Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
Ramy Elshenawy
English 10-7/8
Mr. Storch
March 19 2007
Outline
I. Background on Philoctetes
A. Story
1. Myth
2. Play
B. Painting
1. Description
2. Symbols
1. Quest/Task
2. Fellow Hero
3. Pre-Ordained Fate
A. Purposes of Myth
1. Mystical
2. Cosmological
3. Sociological
4. Pedalogical
B. Meaning of Symbols
III. Utilitarianism
A. Ideals
1. Rightness-Happiness Relation
2. Measurement of morality of action
3. Justifications of morality
B. Supporting Arguments
C. Opposing Arguments
A. Odysseus
1. Pro-Utilitarianism
a. deceive Philoctetes
B. Neoptolemus
1. Anti-Utilitarianism
A. Roles
B. Effectiveness
Mr. Storch
19 March 2007
Philoctetes
The myth of Philoctetes is one that explores the ideals of morality in a way that is
seldom seen in most other stories. Philoctetes is a character that fulfills the archetype of a
hero in several ways, for instance, the oracle’s prophecy of his necessity in the war
against Troy exemplifies the idea of a pre-ordained fate. Also, despite his initial
providing another aspect of a hero. Yet, most importantly, Philoctetes establishes himself
as a hero when he embarks on a quest from Lemnos to Troy, to help the Greeks win the
Trojan War. However, despite his heroic qualities, Philoctetes is also a victim in
Neoptolemus’ and Odysseus’ scheme to steal his bow and arrows. Observing him in this
light illuminates an underlying theme in his story that is ubiquitous throughout history:
In order to truly identify, understand and appreciate the significance of the myth
for the unknown, telling stories that explain the aspects of life that are obscure and
not understood by human beings. On the other hand, the sociological and
myths give insight on the realities and accepted aspects of life and pedagogically,
they, teach us life lessons through symbols, characters and stories. In the story of
Philoctetes, the most significant purposes are both pedagogical and sociological because
the concept of utilitarianism is taught. However, the concept is both supported and
opposed throughout the story, making those that represent it true symbols in the
eyes of Campbell: “… a sign that points itself to a ground of meaning and being that
England. One of its leading advocates, John Stuart Mill, wrote an essay defining it and
explaining its ideals. Utilitarianism is essentially a philosophy that is built around the
Greatest Happiness Principle which states: “actions are right in proportion as they
tend to promote happiness, wrong as they tend to produce the reverse of happiness.”
This principle is the basis of judging the morality of one’s actions: the more
Adams, Samuel. "Sam Adams, Boston Gazette." The Writings of Samuel Adams. Ed.
Collins, Tom. "Mythic Reflections." The New Story 12(Winter 1985/86) 20 Feb 2007
<http://www.context.org/ICLIB/IC12/Campbell.htm>.
<http://www.pbs.org/mythsandheroes/myths_arch_hero.html#content>
<http://utilitarianism.com/mill1.htm>.
North, David.”Weapons of mass destruction in Iraq: Bush’s “big lie” and the crises of
American Imperialism.” World Socialist Web Site. 21 June 2003 27 February 2007
<http://www.wsws.org/articles/2003/jun2003/wmd-j21.shtml>
<http://www.maicar.com/GML/Philoctetes.html>
Sophocles, "Philoctetes." The Complete Plays of Sophocles. Ed. Moses Hadas. 1967: