Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
2012
INTRODUCTION Bret Contreras says Hi readers! Welcome to the first edition of our Strength and Conditioning Research review service. Im very excited about this project as I believe it fills a much needed gap in the industry. Rather than talk about what I learned this month, Im going to take the opportunity to reflect on evidence-based decision making. Though I delve heavily into the research these days, at heart Im a lifter and a strength coach/personal trainer. Im a very curious and intrigued individual when it comes to sports science, but at the end of the day we all need to be practical and confident in our decision- making abilities. Ive noticed an alarming trend in the online strength and conditioning industry as of late - Ive been seeing more and more coaches dissing research. This is utterly reprehensible to me. Perhaps this mind-set has emerged on account of the hundreds of arm-chair experts who give researchers a bad name. The way I see it, if you take any coach who has tons of in the trenches training experience, and you bring him up to speed with the research, it will make him even more effective at what he does. Any coach who doesnt realize this clearly hasnt spent time studying. Considering the surmounting science in the fields of Strength and Conditioning, Biomechanics, Physiology, and Physical Therapy, were learning at a faster rate than ever before, and its highly important to stay up-to- date. Being evidence-based doesnt mean to ignore your own experiences, anecdotes, or practical findings. It doesnt mean you should hit the books and abandon your training and practice. It doesnt mean you should be that fool who quotes some obscure study while dismissing the experiences and opinions of all the top athletes and professionals. Last, it most certainly doesnt mean you should ever abandon common sense. To me, being evidence-based simply means that youre the type who considers and weighs all of the available evidence and understands the quality and limitation of each piece of evidence. An evidence-based practitioner is curious and open- minded, but skeptical. He questions everything. He values what the experts know, he learns the tradition, he understands the scientific theory, he attempts to study the entire body of knowledge before formulating an opinion or hypothesis, he experiments, and he values the scientific method. He realizes that all research has
limitations, that all researchers have biases, and that some types of research are better than others. But he understands that controlled studies are superior to anecdotes, logical thinking, expert opinion, intuition, and trial and error. He knows that the more specific the study, the better, and that what he believes today will likely be much different each year as the field advances. I highly recommend that you find the time to read the following three articles: 1. 2. 3. A Scientific Approach to Fitness: Applying the Hierarchy of Knowledge Brad Schoenfeld Evidence-Based Coaching Sam Leahey Why We Need an Evidence-Based Approach in the Fitness Field Anoop Balachandran
Hopefully these articles will impress upon you the value of the research process. Ive been studying like crazy for the past year and at the risk of sounding cocky, I can now pick apart nearly all of the articles and videos I see online. Most experts are incredible at offering strong opinions, but they usually lack scientific understanding. I will warn you that being well-versed in the literature and becoming scientific doesnt happen overnight. You have to work at it. I cant begin to tell you how much more intelligent I am after one solid year of studying my butt off, and Id like for you to share my experience. I would like for you to subscribe to our research review for an entire year, Id like for you to carefully read our publication each month, and after the year is over Im certain that youll be very proud of the knowledge youve gained, and youll be much more confident in your understanding of sports science. As time goes on, I would like for you to start pondering the various hot-topics in our industry and begin to try to figure out how you could go about solving them (as if you were a researcher). The sports scientist has various tools at his disposal, such as force plates, electromyography, motion capture, goniometers, accelerometers, linear position transducers, GPS, timing lights, radar, tape measurers, dynamometers, ultrasound, MRI, force treadmills, and of course strength training equipment. He can use these tools to investigate claims made by strength coaches or ideas that were sparked from reading the works of other researchers. He does this to refute or support hypotheses, which leads to more questions and subsequent studies. This is the way our field advances. Its time that researchers and practitioners are on the same page. We need to bridge the gap between the lab and the field. Hopefully this service will help. Knowledge is power!
INTRODUCTION continued Chris Beardsley says Hi, and welcome to the first edition of our monthly Strength and Conditioning Research publication. Were starting off as we mean to go on in this issue. Its absolutely crammed full of great research and we had a great time writing it. I hope you enjoy reading it as much. Theres so much in here that I want to talk about and we only have a few short lines here in the introduction to skim the surface. Let me pick out a few of the highlights for me as a strength athlete and as a personal trainer. As a strength athlete As a strength athlete, the study I was most interested in was Strength and neuromuscular adaptation following one, four, and eight sets of high intensity resistance exercise (page 7), in which the researchers concluded that high training volumes are to be preferred over lower or even medium volumes in order to develop strength. However, I was also excited to read about the training habits of international standard powerlifters. In a study called Contemporary Training Practices in Elite British Powerlifters (page 11), it was revealed that 69% of the powerlifters polled used Olympic lifts or derivatives of the Olympics lifts, such as cleans and pulls, in their training. And still on the topic of powerlifting, it was great to read a support of the practice of inhaling before lifts in Musculoskeletal myths (page 48). After all, in nearly every gym (and certainly when I trained as a personal trainer), people are encouraged to breathe out with exertion and told that powerlifters are an accident waiting to happen! (Powerlifters and Olympic weightlifters are taught to inhale prior to the squat in order to increase intra-abdominal pressure in order to protect the spine.) However, recent research suggests that even when there is good abdominal strength, unless there is proper coordination between the abdominals and the diaphragm, spinal instability will be present during challenging activities. So the powerlifters and Olympic lifters were right all along! I was gratified to note that low-level glute exercises as part of a warm-up caused increased glute activation during training, as found in Low Load Exercises Targeting the Gluteal Muscle Group Acutely Enhance Explosive Power Output in Elite Athletes (page 14). I am a big fan of using glute exercises in my own training and have
found them to be significant in creating stability, particularly in my squat. I was intrigued to read in Effects of Unilateral and Bilateral Lower-Body Resistance Exercise on Muscle Activity and Testosterone Responses (page 19) that unilateral squats appear to be as efficacious as bilateral squats at raising testosterone following a workout. I had previously read how some Russian weightlifters had made good use of additional workouts comprising loaded step-ups and similar single-leg lifts but had never been convinced. I may now consider putting them into my routines. As a personal trainer As a personal trainer, I enjoyed learning from the study Kinematic Analysis of Hip and Knee Angles during Landing after Imagery in Females (page 13) how imagery can be used as a coaching strategy to correct faulty movement patterns. It was instructive to see in black and white how coaching cues can have zero impact on performance without imagery. Many people would regard imagery as fluff but this study shows that it has much greater impact than verbal cues. I was also pleased to read in Kettlebell swing, snatch and bottoms-up carry: Back and hip muscle activation, motion, and low back loads (page 34) that the researchers conclude that the kettlebell swing appears to result in unique compression and shear load ratios in the lumbar spine. This unique ratio explains why many people find the kettlebell swing to be particularly irritating to the lower back, when all else can be done pain free. I have certainly seen this in many people. And on a completely different note, I enjoyed reading Physically active men show better semen parameters and hormone values than sedentary men (page 37). It showed that prospective fathers would be advised to include a level of moderate-hard physical activity (c. 1 hour, 3 times per week) to give their partner the best chance of conceiving. Its good to know that staying fit has many different benefits! Thats all Ive got space to talk about this month but Im already looking forward to next months studies. Weve got a great line-up for you again and therell be plenty of eye-opening information for you to use in your training or your business. Until next time enjoy the reviews.
CONTENTS
PAGE
SECTION 1: STRENGTH AND CONDITIONING Effect of Core Strength on the Measure of Power in the Extremities Effect of range of motion on muscle strength and thickness Is power training or conventional resistance training better for function in elderly persons? A meta-analysis Late specialization the key to success in centimeters, grams, or seconds (CGS) sports Relationships between national football league combine performance measures Strength and neuromuscular adaptation following one, four, and eight sets of high intensity resistance exercise The effectiveness of resisted movement training on sprinting and jumping performance The Effects of Treadmill Sprint Training and Resistance Training on Maximal Running Velocity and Power A comparison of the effects of 6 weeks of traditional resistance training, plyometric training and complex training Contemporary Training Practices in Elite British Powerlifters Effect of resistance training regimens on treadmill running and neuromuscular performance in runners Kinematic Analysis of Hip and Knee Angles during Landing after Imagery in Females Low Load Exercises Targeting the Gluteal Muscle Group Acutely Enhance Explosive Power Output in Elite Athletes Positional Relationships Between Various Sprint and Jump Abilities in Elite American Football Players The effects of plyometric training on sprint performance a meta-analysis SECTION 2: BIOMECHANICS Corset hypothesis rebutted Transversus abdominis does not co-contract in unison prior to rapid arm movements Effects of Unilateral and Bilateral Lower-Body Resistance Exercise on Muscle Activity and Testosterone Responses Kinematic changes using weightlifting shoes on barbell back squat Morphological and mechanical properties of muscle and tendon in highly trained sprinters Reality about migration of the nucleus pulposus within the intervertebral disc with changing postures Heel height affects lower extremity frontal plane joint moments during walking Walking on High Heels Changes Muscle Activity and the Dynamics of Human Walking Significantly What is the role of titin in active muscle? Abdominal muscle activation changes if the purpose is to control pelvis motion or thorax motion Calf Stretching in Non-Weight Bearing Versus Weight Bearing Cell phones change the way we walk Direction specific recruitment of rotator cuff muscles during bench press and row Effect of Acute Static Stretch on Maximal Muscle Performance: A Systematic Review Effects of plyometric training on passive stiffness of gastrocnemii Effects of the pullover exercise on the pectoralis major and latissimus dorsi muscles as evaluated by EMG How Neurons Make Us Jump: the Neural Control of Stretch-Shortening Cycle Movements Kettlebell swing, snatch and bottoms-up carry: Back and hip muscle activation, motion, and low back loads SECTION 3: PHYSIOLOGY Insulin sensitivity after maximal and endurance resistance training Physically active men show better semen parameters and hormone values than sedentary men Unraveling the neurophysiology of muscle fatigue Muscle fatigue - from motor units to clinical symptoms Muscle time under tension stimulates differential muscle protein sub-fractional synthetic responses in men 36 37 38 39 40 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 31 32 33 34 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16
CONTENTS
PAGE
SECTION 4: PHYSICAL THERAPY Assessment of the degree of pelvic tilt within a normal asymptomatic population Comparison of hip rotation range of motion in judo athletes with and without history of low back pain Fascia Research - a Narrative Review Fascia Science and Clinical Applications a Clinician-Researcher's Perspectives Hamstring Strain Injuries are we headed in the right direction? Scapular positioning in unimpaired shoulders, shoulder impingement syndrome, and glenohumeral instability Musculoskeletal myths The effects of an isometric knee extension with hip adduction exercise on selective VMO muscle strengthening Using the Functional Movement Screen to Evaluate the Effectiveness of Training 42 43 44 45 46 47 48 49 50
This document is copyright Strength and Conditioning Research Limited, 2012. Bret and Chris both work very hard to bring you this information. Help us to continue our work by not sharing it with your friends, however tempting it may be. Thank you.
Page 1
What were the conclusions? The relationship of the dynamic forward throw to the 1RM squat and bench press was explained by the individuals ability to provide anterior stability while resisting forces of an external load and extremity action. It was noted that the forward and reverse dynamic and static throws did not correlate with each other but the static and dynamic lateral throws did correlate. The researchers concluded that this implied the lateral core muscles were primarily responsible for both static and dynamic actions but that this was not the case for the forward and reverse throws. Correlations were identified between the push press and the static and dynamic left and right throws and the static reverse throw. This was interpreted as support for the idea that the symmetry of the lateral aspects of the core is important In addition, a stepwise regression was run in an attempt to determine which dependent variable(s) best predict push press power. Analysis identified 1RM squat as the only predictor. Practical implications The researchers suggest that the core should be trained dynamically in athletic populations to assist in sports performance and the transfer of power from the lower to the upper body.
In addition, the researchers also tested the push press for power. This test was used so that they could correlate the transfer of power from the lower to the upper body with the various measures of dynamic core strength noted in the medicine ball tests. In addition, the study also measured 1RM squat, bench press, countermovement vertical jump, 40-yard dash and an agility run. The subjects were 25 National Collegiate Athletic Association Division I football players.
This document is copyright Strength and Conditioning Research Limited, 2012. Bret and Chris both work very hard to bring you this information. Help us to continue our work by not sharing it with your friends, however tempting it may be. Thank you.
Page 2
Practical implications The researchers suggest using full ROM for beginner lifters to maximise strength and hypertrophy.
This document is copyright Strength and Conditioning Research Limited, 2012. Bret and Chris both work very hard to bring you this information. Help us to continue our work by not sharing it with your friends, however tempting it may be. Thank you.
Page 3
What were the conclusions? In summary, there was a small-to-medium effect on most functional outcomes in favour of power training compared with strength training. Practical implications The researchers note that power training with moderate resistance at a fast velocity seems to be a feasible method for older persons who are still relatively fit, although safety should be a consideration.
This document is copyright Strength and Conditioning Research Limited, 2012. Bret and Chris both work very hard to bring you this information. Help us to continue our work by not sharing it with your friends, however tempting it may be. Thank you.
Page 4
What are the conclusions? The principle that practice hours are critical for athletic success is upheld. However, it also appears that early specialization makes the total practice hours required more difficult to attain than late specialization. Whether that time is better spent diversifying is not possible to say from this study. Practical implications Practice still makes perfect but it may also be useful to consider when that practice is done in an athletes developmental career. Page 5
This document is copyright Strength and Conditioning Research Limited, 2012. Bret and Chris both work very hard to bring you this information. Help us to continue our work by not sharing it with your friends, however tempting it may be. Thank you.
However, there is strong reason to suspect that there are significant correlational relationships between sprint ability over short distances, between sprint and jump abilities, and between sprint ability and change-of- direction ability. So are the above tests duplicating each other by measuring the same quality several times over? What did the researcher do? Robbins investigated and analysed data on the combine tests that was publicly available for players who attended the NFL combine from 2005 to 2009 and were drafted in the same year. A total of 1,136 players were included in the study, although all combine draftees did not necessarily complete all physical tests making up the combine so not all of the tests have 1,136 data points. And what were the results? Sprint and sprint the correlations between the 9.1m, 18.3m and 36.6m sprint times were nearly perfect, suggesting that these tests are merely duplicating each other Sprint and jump the correlations between the linear sprint times and jump performance were large to very large Jump and jump the correlation between the jump tasks was very large Change of direction the correlation between the change-of- direction tests was nearly perfect Bench press the bench press was positively correlated with all running drills and inversely correlated with the jump tests
This
document
is
copyright
Strength
and
Conditioning
Research
Limited,
2012.
Bret
and
Chris
both
work
very
hard
to
bring
you
this
information.
Help
us
to
continue
our
work
by
not
sharing
it
with
your
friends,
however
tempting
it
may
be.
Thank
you.
Page 6