White Collar Crime

- An Insight into its current state

- Author (Abhilash Panickar)

LLB SEM IV Lords Universal College

Page 2 of 36

Table of Contents
1 INTRODUCTION...................................................................................................... 4 1.1 1.2 Aims and Objectives .......................................................................................... 5 White Collar Crime Relationship to other types of Crime ................................ 5 Blue-collar crime .......................................................................................... 5 Corporate crime ........................................................................................... 5 State-corporate crime .................................................................................. 6 Public a victim of white collar crime ............................................................. 6 How workers/employees of a company can be victims of white collar crime6 Occupational Crime ..................................................................................... 7

1.2.1 1.2.2 1.2.3 1.2.4 1.2.5 1.2.6 1.3

Causes of White Collar Crime ............................................................................ 7 Situational (Opportunity) .............................................................................. 7 Personality ................................................................................................... 8 The Culture of Competition .......................................................................... 8

1.3.1 1.3.2 1.3.3 2 3

WHITE COLLAR CRIME IN INDIA........................................................................... 9 INFAMOUS SCANDALS ........................................................................................ 14 3.1 3.2 The Enron Scandal .......................................................................................... 14 The 2G Scam ................................................................................................... 15

JUDICIAL RESPONSE - LEGISLATION ................................................................ 17 4.1 4.2 4.3 Prevention of Corruption Act ............................................................................ 18 Prevention of Food Adulteration Act................................................................. 23 Other statutes................................................................................................... 24

ANALYSIS OF DATA ............................................................................................. 25

Page 3 of 36 6 CONTROL POLICIES TO BE UNDERTAKEN TO ERADICATE WHITE COLLAR

CRIMES ........................................................................................................................ 32 7 8 CONCLUSION ....................................................................................................... 33 REFERENCES....................................................................................................... 35 8.1 8.2 Webliography ................................................................................................... 35 Bibliography ..................................................................................................... 35

Page 4 of 36

1 INTRODUCTION
Power tends to corrupt and absolute power corrupts absolutely. Where ever law ends, tyranny begins

Within the field of criminology, white-collar crime has been defined by Edwin Sutherland as "a crime committed by a person of respectability and high social status in the course of his occupation" (1939). Sutherland was a proponent of Symbolic Interactionism, and believed that criminal behavior was learned from interpersonal interaction with others. White-collar crime, therefore, overlaps with corporate crime because the opportunity for fraud, bribery, insider trading, embezzlement, computer crime, copyright infringement, money laundering, identity theft, and forgery are more available to white-collar employees.

White-collar criminals are opportunists, who over time learn they can take advantage of their circumstances to accumulate financial gain. They are educated, intelligent, affluent, confident individuals, who were qualified enough to get a job which allows them the unmonitored access to often large sums of money. Many also use their intelligence to con their victims into believing and trusting in their credentials. Many do not start out as criminals, and in many cases never see themselves as such.[1]

This is a non doctrinal research. The Empirical Research Methodology is used and data has been collected by a survey done with approximately 20 people of different age, background and profession. The research is based on actual experience rather than theory or belief. People were asked to give their true opinions and comments. Visits to government establishments and common man interviews like shopkeepers was undertaken to get a first hand picture and opinion and experience of common man with respect to white collar crime.

Page 5 of 36

1.1 Aims and Objectives

The aims and objective of this study is to draw a sketch of the prevailing white collar crime in India and specifically Mumbai and the steps that can be taken to identify and prevent it.

1.2 White Collar Crime Relationship to other types of Crime

1.2.1 Blue-collar crime The types of crime committed are a function of what is available to the potential offender. Thus, those employed in relatively unskilled environments and living in innercity areas have fewer "situations" to exploit (see Clarke: 1997) than those who work in "situations" where large financial transactions occur and live in areas where there is relative prosperity. Blue-collar crime tends to be more obvious and thus attracts more active police attention (e.g. for crimes such as vandalism or shoplifting, where physical property is involved). In contrast, white-collar employees can incorporate legitimate and criminal behavior, thus making themselves less obvious when committing the crime. Therefore, blue-collar crime will more often use physical force, whereas in the corporate world, the identification of a victim is less obvious and the issue of reporting is complicated by a culture of commercial confidentiality to protect shareholder value. It is estimated that a great deal of white-collar crime is undetected or, if detected, it is not reported. 1.2.2 Corporate crime Corporate crime deals with the company as a whole. The crime benefitting the investors or the individuals who are in high positions in the company or corporation. The relationship white-collar crime has with corporate crime is that they are similar because they both are involved within the business world. Their difference is that white-collar crime benefits the individual involved, and corporate crime benefits the company or the corporation.

Page 6 of 36 1.2.3 State-corporate crime The negotiation of agreements between a state and a corporation will be at a relatively senior level on both sides, this is almost exclusively a white-collar "situation" which offers the opportunity for crime. White-collar crime has become a priority of law enforcement; however evidence shows that it continues to be a low priority. When senior levels of a corporation engage in criminal activity using the company this is sometimes called control fraud. 1.2.4 Public a victim of white collar crime Common misconception about corporate crime and white collar time is that its effects are mainly financial. However, they can cause harm to the general public, workers and consumers. For example false claims made by pharmaceutical companies about their products or the dumping of toxic wastes. Another good example includes the Hooker Chemical Company dumping toxic waste into the abandoned Love Canal in Niagara Falls and later selling the land after knowing of the problem but choosing not to warn health officials. It was later sold to a private housing developer in the 1950s and in the 1970s the families starting experiencing major health problems such as miscarriages and birth defects. 1.2.5 How workers/employees of a company can be victims of white collar crime

Some ways that employees of a company can become victims of white-collar crime can be that workers are being exposed to the harms and risks of being involved in a crime. Even if the workers are unaware of the crimes his or her corporation is committing, this poses a threat to their job security. Essentially, if a company is charged with a white-collar crime, such a fraud or embezzlement, and loses copious amounts of money forcing the company to declare bankruptcy, the employees are at risk of losing their jobs. Another harm making employees victims of white-collar crime can be when employers are aware of a physical harm that can affect their employees. An example of this danger can be depicted with miners in Newfoundland who were exposed to Radon gas, which the

Page 7 of 36

company (and the Canadian government) were aware was a danger to peoples health, yet there was nothing done to protect the employees.
1.2.6 Occupational Crime

Individuals who commit crime during the course of their employment roles. The two most common forms are theft and fraud. Examples of occupational thefts are removal by employees of job-related items from the workplace. There are obviously varying degrees of theft ex. from a pencil to furnishings to a car. Most employees do steal and the expense is high. An example of fraud is insider trading. This occurs when an employee uses information not available to the public to gain personal advantage over others in the buying and selling of stock.

1.3 Causes of White Collar Crime

1.3.1 Situational (Opportunity)

As the well known white-collar crime theorist, James Coleman, has noted, all criminal behavior requires that two basic elements -- motivation and opportunity -- must be brought together for a crime to occur. He also claims that this doesn't necessarily create a dividing line between social psychological causes (having to do with motivation), and structural causes (relating to opportunity). The two may be intertwined in the case of white-collar (and other) crimes. That is, an opportunity must somehow become psychologically relevant to a potential offender, and the roots of motivation may be found in the culture of society. Thus where such motivations come from is important. Similarly, the origin of breakdowns in controls that would restrain such behaviors is equally important. In India the breakdown of roles are very important as this is a single and all reaching phenomenon in India.

Page 8 of 36

Individual personalities certainly play a role here, but it is important to understand how persons construct such personal realities that ultimately guide their behavior good or bad. This is quite relevant to the study of white-collar crime, as most people typically see criminals as possessing different personalities from normal or conventional individuals. When the person is a white collar criminal, however, such psychological determinism simply collapses. The criminal seems to have the same conventional lifestyle and personality as the law-abiding individual.

Sutherland pointed out that the psychological normality of white-collar criminals argued against the psychological explanation of any crime. He said, The criminal behavior of businessmen cannot be explained by feeblemindedness or emotional instability. We have no reason to believe that General Motors has an inferiority complex or that Aluminum Company of America has a frustrationaggression complex
1.3.2 Personality

Wheeler argues that such persons may be risk seekers who derive pleasure from adding to their wealth without a real concern over the utility of such marginal gains. The question of, How much is enough? is irrelevant. Their personalities are characterized by greed; the more they have, the more they want. Most persons would probably see this as a general explanation of most white-collar crimes. In contrast, however, Wheeler posits another motivation in some white-collar crimes, which he labels fear of falling. Individuals characterized by this personality trait are not greedy as much as they are afraid of losing their wealth and status, which motivates them to commit white-collar crime.
1.3.3 The Culture of Competition

Most people cite economic reasons, which are tied to what Coleman calls the culture of competition, for the motivations that lead to white-collar

Page 9 of 36

lawbreaking. This replicates in large part the statements of the classical school of criminology (Jeremy Bentham and Cesare Beccaria), in that people will violate the law when they believe that they will receive greater pleasure and less pain than from other courses of action. Moreover, getting rich quick (making a fast buck) may be a motivating factor in many white-collar crimes, but other financial motivations may be present in others (for example, fear of losing what they have legally gained. Competition is seen as a healthy individual pursuit, rather than a negative or selfish activity. Competition is seen as building individual character, and also produces maximum benefits for the entire society. The most capable and hardworking individuals (that is, the most competitive) are seen as the winners and rewarded accordingly. This belief also allows the legitimation of inequality in society: The poor are seen as the losers who occupy their position because they are lazy or incompetent.

2 WHITE COLLAR CRIME IN INDIA

White-collar crimes account for enough violations of law. By comparison, the

instances of white-collar crimes are more then the conventional type of crimes such as theft, burglary, and arson. The loss incurred through white-collar crimes is far higher than that of the conventional type. In the American Context, it has been estimated that losses from such crime may be as high as 200 billion dollars every year. In India also, such type of crime on increase, but no attempts to quantify it have been made, which shows the apathy towards curbing white collar crime. Given the prevalence in India in almost anything and everything, it is likely to be a percentage of the national GDP. That is the enormous amount of white collar crimes committed in India. Let us address the intricacies involved in white-collar crimes. The analysis of White-collar crime will differentiate between individuals who steal, defraud and

Page 10 of 36

cheat in and out of an occupational context and those who commit the variety of offences attributed to business corporations. White collar crimes are to be considered as a global phenomenon to which India is no exception. White collar crimes emerged in India with the advent of the British colonisation during the period of industrial capitalism. Prior to that, instances of men working with the District treasury embezzling with the money kept under his safe custody or bribing practised among the officials were found. Therefore, the white collar crimes were confined to this limit. Thus, the people indulging in the white collar crimes then can to said to be mere grass eaters the people in the modern times have reached the stage of meat-eaters. Thus the white collar crimes become phenomenon to be reckoned with industrial revolution. Modern industrial capitalist economy which evolved with time became complex in nature as it developed a growing commercial nexus among insurance, banking, stocks and related corporate matters. This in turn, gave rise to critical legal intricacies relating to property rights and other legal matters which paved the way for the birth of a new class of professionals of advocates who in the name of providing justice started abetting in the wrong and thereby pursued their own narrow interest. A large number of advocates evolved who forget the pious oath of serving the society and start looking for the legal loopholes and concentrate mainly in helping out the rich entrepreneurs to grow richer. They make extensive study to try out ways for maximum tax evasion for these rich corporate personalities as well as for themselves. The white collar crimes committed by these legal practitioners are not only confines in sorting out illegal methods of tax-evasion. There are very frequent instances of unscrupulous and unethical practises like that of fabricating false evidence, engaging professional witnesses, thereby violating ethical standards of legal profession and dilatory tactics in collusion with the ministerial staff of the courts. Next to the instances of white collar crimes committed in the Indian society by the lawyers, there lie the shameful illustrations of Magistrates and judges involved in committing crimes. They in the name of interpreting the laws often act as the protective shield for the goons having or not-having any political colour and allow

Page 11 of 36

them to go free whereas they should have been subject to deterrence. It is the most unfortunate situation at the same time devastating, because here the crimes are committed by those individuals who are being given by the State the responsibility to ensure justice. In India, the white collar crimes are so wide spread that it does not confine itself in the legal arena. Similar unfortunate instances can be drawn from other professions too, like that of medical practitioners, engineers, educationalists, businessmen, politicians and the list goes on. The medical practitioners are often found involved in issuance of false certificates, carrying out illegal abortions, selling out sample drugs and medicine, even in some cases adulterated drugs and medicines to the patients. Dilatory tactics are often adopted by them in providing treatment to their patients with a mens rea to extract huge amount of money, no matter the person has good practice. Some of the notorious instances are like that of Nithari case, where the medical professionals put up before the society the optimum level of brutal character they can reach for the crave of making money. Misleading and fake advertisement claiming absolute cure is also one of the frequent malpractices being carried out in the medical profession. The problem lies in the fact is, they often escape punishment, since they cannot be said to have violated the letter of law, but, by violating the spirit of law, they commit crimes which are truly anti-social and creates enormous damage to the public health and safely at large. Speaking of the engineers role in having their role to play in white collar crimes, we often find instances of underhand dealing with contractors, suppliers, passing of sub-standard works and maintenance of bogus reports of the labour work. They financially earn more for their low grade works from the contractors, than they can earn for the genuine work. Therefore, many of them, out of the greed of earning more and more, play dangerously with thousands of lives of the individuals. When the matter comes to the white collar crimes educational institutions do come in the league to operate with impunity. A nastier role is played by the private institutions who are least bothered in providing the education, but only

Page 12 of 36

concentrate of making business at the cost of the childrens future. Even rackets operate in these institutions for procuring students to appear in the examinations on the basis of manipulated eligibility certificates, thereby damaging the standard of education in India. When it comes to the Governmental institutions, the teachers and staffs of the institutions are often found to be involved in unscrupulous practices, since they can hardly make fortune from the inadequate salary they receive from the government. Teachers often drag the students for taking private tuitions and even go to the extent of blackmailing them of ruining their future, if they deny doing so. These are only a handful of instances of white collar crimes practised in day to day life by certain professionals in the course of their profession. The major role in committing white collar crimes are played by the business tycoons and politicians, whose greed and wants multiply with the more they acquire. In India, whenever any major scandal comes to the media focus, a though investigation always finds an unlawful involvement of political parties in it. So far as the businessmen are concerned, their acts of white collar crimes go beyond count. They are termed as the corporate criminals who more often than not are involved in illegal contracts, combination and conspiracies of trade restraints, unfair labour practices, selling of adulterated foods and drugs, bribing of public officials so on and so forth. They take advantage of the corporate veil and indulge in a number of crimes. the recent Satyam scam case is one of the worth-mentioning illustrations, where it was seen how an individual, hiding himself in the veil of incorporation, indulge in defrauding crores of money. The white collar crimes are often master minded and are carried out in a planned manner by technocrats in the form of scams, frauds, etc. facilitated by technological advancements. In these types of offences not only the individual is being with pecuniary loss but also, such offences like peddling drugs and narcotic substances, counterfeiting of currency, financial scams are some of the crimes which evoke serious concern and impact to the national security and governance. Violation of foreign exchange regulations, and import and export laws are frequently resorted to for the sake of huge profits.

Page 13 of 36

Another major white collar crime very common among the individuals, no matter he/she belongs to the middle or upper strata of the society is that of evading taxes. The complexity of the taxation laws provided a number of loopholes through which many individuals tried to escape. A tax-evasion has known no professional or class boundary in our country. Be it an engineer, doctor, advocate, a business tycoon or a simple small industry trader-all has learnt the trick of evading taxes. The main difficulty posed before the Income Tax Department is to acquire true information of the real and exact income of these professionals. It is often alleged that only an insignificant amount of their total income is posed a income before the Income Tax Department and the rest therefore goes into the circulation as black money. The frequent modifications in the tax-laws of the country has been able to add very little to put a check on this continuing menace which is throwing a great negative impact in the Governmental revenue and thereby the growth of the country.

The Santhanam Committee Reportin its finding presented a clear picturesque description that in India the white collar crimes so defined, are mostly rampant among the businessmen, industrialists as well as corrupt officials and private practitioners. Highlighting the magnitude of the crimes in India, the Commission on Prevention of Corruption in its report quoted, The advancement of technological and scientific development is contributing to the emergence of mass society with a large rank of file and a small control ling elite, encouraging growth of monopolies, the rise of the managerial class and intricate institutional mechanisms. Strict adherence to high standard of ethical behaviour is necessary for the even and honest functioning of the new social, political and economic processes. The inability of all sections to appreciate this need in full results in the emergence and growth of white collar and economic crimes renders enforcement of all laws, themselves not sufficiently deterrent, more-difficult. Tax evasion and avoidance, share-pushing, malpractices in the share market and administration of companies, monopolistic control, usury, under-voicing or over-voicing, hoarding, profiteering, substandard performance of

Page 14 of 36

contracts of constructions and supply, evasion of economic laws, bribery and corruption, election offences and malpractices are some examples of white collar crime. It was on the basis of the report of this Commission that a new chapter was suggested to include into the Indian Penal Code, 1860 by making amendments to the Act. The motive behind such suggestion was to bring white collar crimes under the purview of the criminal law and at the same time broadly classify the offences that can come under the purview of white collar crimes. The matter was referred to the Law Commission by the Government of India for considering it. However, the Law Commission disagreed with the proposal and observed that such offences which are put under the banner of white collar crimes are to be left to be dealt with by special and self-contained enactments which act as supplement to the basic criminal law. The reason behind that was, as discussed earlier, there have been a lot of debates regarding criminalising acts constituting white collar crimes. However, in the Report of the Vivian Bose Commission of Inquiry highlighted how the industries indulge into white collar crimes such as fraud, falsification of accounts, tampering of records for personal gains, tax evasion, so on and so forth.

3 INFAMOUS SCANDALS
3.1 The Enron Scandal
The first major scandal of the first decade of 21st century is that Enron Corporation, which has been called one of the most intricate pieces of financial chicanery in history and for investors in its stock and its employees. The Enron

Page 15 of 36

sandal did tremendous damage to the company created a crisis of investors confidence the links of which has been seen since the great depression. Enron was a $100 billion corporate empire that had more then 200,000 employees in 40 countries and controlled about one quarter of all trading in natural gas and electricity in the United Status. The company poured millions of dollars into political campaign and lobbyists arguing of further deregulation of energy markets. The Enron hierarchy expected the never-ending innovation and growth from its executive to feed this monster enterprise. In response executives created imaginary markets, paper partnerships and phantom growth that enabled them to report profits that did not exist and to hide debts hat did. Executives were accomplished at cooking the financial books in many ingenious ways, which kept Enrons stock prices rising and thus their own compensation. Because mush of the competition received by Enrons executives was stock based, they had major incentives to make the company look as good as possible to investors by reporting high profits.

3.2 The 2G Scam

This is also a case of political graft along with White Collar Crime where several prominent Industrialists were involved. In 2007-08, when the government issued 122 new telecom licences, several rules were violated and bribes were paid to favour certain firms. Several licences were issued to firms with no prior experience in the telecom sector or were ineligible or had suppressed relevant facts, CAG report said. The violations cost the exchequer $39 billion in lost revenue, the auditor said, equivalent to India's defence budget. The telecom ministry's process of issuing licences "lacked transparency and was undertaken in an arbitrary, unfair and inequitable manner," the auditor said. Police have accused Andimuthu Raja, the then-telecom minister, of having taken bribes from two firms which are now the local joint venture partners of Telenor and Etisalat .

Page 16 of 36

What was the fallout? The report sparked political outrage and the main opposition Bharatiya Janata Party all-but-shut an entire session of parliament demanding a special parliamentary probe. Raja was forced to resign and was arrested over the report. The telecom ministry is considering whether to cancel some 85 licences which the audit report says were issued to firms which were ineligible for them. Many of India's biggest business names have been questioned, including billionaires Anil Ambani, chairman of Reliance ADA group, and Prashant Ruia, chief executive of Essar Group. A parliamentary panel probing the scandal questioned Ratan Tata as well as Anil Ambani.

What does it mean for politics? Singh and the ruling coalition have been weakened by the events, and the BJP is seen as having regained political momentum it had lost after defeat in the 2009 federal elections. The Supreme Court criticised Singh for not acting quickly enough against Raja, a rare censure that was picked up by the BJP to accuse the government of shielding corrupt officials. The attacks have nearly paralysed the government but it is not in danger of collapsing as its slim majority is not expected to see defections by coalition partners and no one, including the BJP, wants a federal election now. The scandal has also touched Raja's regional DMK party, a leading ally of the ruling Congress party. Police say some of the bribes were routed through the DMK's television channel, controlled by the wife and daughter of the DMK party chief. DMK rules the large southern Tamil Nadu state, which goes to polls in April. The corruption cases could affect the electoral performance of the DMKCongress coalition there.

What does this mean for investment in India? While corruption itself has been largely shrugged off by investors, the regulatory uncertainty from the review of past government decisions is a source of concern

Page 17 of 36

to investors. The benchmark Mumbai stock index ended the March quarter as the world's worst performer, weighed down in part by worries over fallout from a spate of scandals. If the telecom ministry does decide to cancel some or all of the 85 licences it is scrutinising, questions will be raised on whether foreign investors can trust Indian government contracts. The licences under review include those now held by Telenor and Etisalat's local ventures. It is too early to know whether licences will be cancelled, but pressure will be on the government not to do so because operators have invested millions of dollars in rolling out networks and cancelling them will inconvenience subscribers. The telecom ministry is also mulling imposing charges for spectrum it granted to telecom firms in the past and has levied fines on newer firms for not rolling out networks quickly enough. For years, India gave operators spectrum beyond contracted levels free of cost as they added subscribers. If the spectrum charges are imposed, market leaders Bharti Airtel and Vodafone would have to pay hundreds of millions of dollars in back-charges. For newer entrants, hefty fines could strain their finances and force them to exit.
Decision : Pending

4 JUDICIAL RESPONSE - LEGISLATION

The judiciary has taken a serious note of the growing intensity of the white-collar crimes. For the sake of convenience the judicial response in this regard can be classified under the following there headings: Judicial response under the Prevention of Corruption Act, 1988, Judicial response under the Prevention of Food Adulteration Act, and Judicial response under other statutes dealing with white- collar crime.

Page 18 of 36

4.1 Prevention of Corruption Act

The strict judicial vigilance over corruption is reflected in various judgments of the Apex Court. In J.Jayalalitha v U.O.I the Supreme Court observed: The legislature has enacted the Act and provided for speedy trial offences punishable under the Act in public interest as it has become aware of rampant corruption amongst the public servants. While replacing the 1947 Act by the present Act, the legislature wanted to make the provisions of the Act more effective and also to widen the scope of the act by giving a wider definition to the term public servant. The reason is obvious. Corruption corrodes the moral fabric of the society and corruption by public servants not only leads to corruption of the moral fabric of the society but is also harmful to the national economy and national interest, as the persons occupying high posts in government by misusing their powers due to corruption can cause considerable damage to the national economy, national interest and image of the country. In State of Maharashtra v Prabhakar Rao the Supreme Court observed that the definition of public servant u/s 21 of I.P.C is of no relevance under the Prevention of Corruption Act. This means that a person may be held liable under the Act even if he is not a public servant within the meaning of section 21 of I.P.C. In Govt of A.P v P.V.Reddy the Supreme Court observed: The Prevention of Corruption Act, 1988 was brought into force with the avowed purpose of effective prevention of corruption and bribery. The said Act, with a much wider definition of public servant was brought into force to purify public administration. Under the repealed Act of 1947, the definition of public servant was restricted to public servant as defined in Section 21 of I.P.C. In order to curb effectively bribery and corruption not only in government establishments and departments but also in other semi-governmental authorities and bodies and their departments where the employees are entrusted with public duties, a comprehensive definition of public

Page 19 of 36

servant has been given in section 2(c) of the Act. When the legislature has given such a comprehensive definition of public servant to achieve the purpose of punishing and curbing growing corruption, it would be appropriate not to limit the contents of the definition clause by construction which would be against the spirit of the statute. The definition of public servant, therefore, deserves a wide construction. The court is required to adopt a purposive approach as would give effect to the intention of the legislature. Employees or servants of a cooperative society, which is controlled or aided by the government, are covered by the Section 2(c) (iii) of the Act and hence are public servant. In Ram Narayan Poply v C.B.I the Supreme Court, defining the object and purpose of the Special Court (Trial of Offences Relating To Transactions in Securities) Act, 1992 observed that the Act was promulgated with a view to recover public monies lost by certain banks and financial institutions in securities where such losses arose as a result of such transactions. The Court further observed: It is equally trite to state the contrary proposition that where there are no losses at all, the institution of the special court was wholly unnecessary and the special court was not to try such transactions even if they amounted to some technical offences. The court further defined the purpose of section 13(2) of the POCA by mentioning that it intends to deal with aberrations of public servants. The court held that he appellant in furtherance of criminal conspiracy, in his capacity as a public servant abused his position by causing and/or allowing MULs funds to be utilized for the wrongful gain of appellant 5. Thus, the court held that the provisions of section 13(1) (c) read with section 13(2) are clearly applicable. Referring to the nature and the adverse affect of white collar crimes, the court observed: The offences in these cases were not of conventional or traditional types, the ultimate objective was to use public money in a carefully planned manner for personal use with no right to do it. The cause of the community

Page 20 of 36

deserves better treatment at the hands of the court in the discharge of its judicial functions. The community or the State is not a persona non grata whose cause may be treated with disdain. The entire community is aggrieved if the economic offenders who ruin the economy of the State are not brought to book. A murder may be committed in the heat of moment upon passions being aroused. An economic offence is committed with cool calculations and deliberate design with an eye on personal profit regardless of the consequences to the community. A disregard for the interest of the community can be manifested only at the cost of forfeiting the trust and faith of the community in the system to administer justice in an even handed manner without fear of criticism from the quarters which view white collar crime with a permissive eye, unmindful of the damage done to the national economy and national interest. Unfortunately in the last few years, the country has seen an alarming rise in the white collar crimes, which has affected the fiber of the countrys economic structure. These cases are nothing but private gain at the cost of public and lead to economic disaster. The Supreme Court, however, preferred to apply reformative theory instead of the punitive theory of punishment in this case. The court observed: Normally, in cases involving offences which corrode the economic stability are to be dealt with sternly. However, considering the fact that the occurrence took place a decade back, and the trial has spread over a few years, and the death of one of the accused, we feel custodial sentence for the period already undergone would meet the ends of justice. While fixing the quantum of sentence, we have duly considered the fact that in the instant case the amount has been paid back. In Vivek Gupta v C.B.I the Supreme Court considered the scope of the jurisdiction of special court dealing with corruption cases. The court held that even if the appellant was not charged under the POCA but under sections 120B/420 of I.P.C, the special judge has the power to try the appellant with other coaccused who, in addition to the said sections, were also charged under section 3 and 4 of POCA. The court, applying the provisions of sections 3and 4 of the Act

Page 21 of 36

and section 220 and 223 Cr.P.C, held that such recourse is available to the special court. In State of M.P v A.K.Gupta the Supreme Court dealt with criminal misconduct committed by the public servant while holding their offices. The court observed: Section 13 of the Act deals with various situations when a public servant can be said to have committed criminal misconduct. Section 13 (1) (e) is applicable when the public servant or any person on his behalf, is in a possession or has, at any time during the period of his office, been in possession for which the public servant cannot satisfactorily account pecuniary resources or property disproportionate to his known source of income. Section 13 (1) (e) corresponds to section 5 (1) (e) of the POCA, 1947 (old Act). But there have been drastical amendments. Under the new clause, the earlier concept of known source of income has undergone a radical change. As per the explanation appended, the prosecution is relieved of the burden of investigating into source of income of an accuse to a large extent. The prosecution cannot be expected to know the affairs of an accused person. These will be matters specifically within the knowledge of the accused, within the meaning of section 106 of the Indian Evidence Act, 1872. The legislature has advisedly used the expression satisfactorily account. The emphasis must be on the word satisfactorily and the legislature has, thus, deliberately cast burden on the accused not only to offer a plausible explanation as to how he came by his large wealth, but also to satisfy the court that his explanation was worthy of acceptance. In R.Sai Bharathi v J.Jayalalitha the Supreme Court observed: The criminal law merely prescribes the minimum standards of behaviour. While in public life, those who hold high offices should not take shelter under the umbrella of criminal law but stand by high probity. Further, criminal law is meant to deal with criminals ordinarily. Persons in public life are expected to maintain very high standards of probity, and, particularly, when there is likely to be even the least bit of conflict of interest between the office one holds and the acts to be done by such person,

Page 22 of 36

ought to desist himself from indulging in the same. Such standards of behaviour were scrupulously observed in the earlier days after independence, but those values have now dwindled and instances of persons holding high elective offices indulging in self-aggrandizement by utilizing government property or in distribution of the largesse of the government to their own favourites or for certain quid pro quo are on the increase. We have to strongly condemn such actions. In this connection it is essential to refer the offence as specified under section 169 of I.P.C. Section 169 specifies that for the completion of offence under section 169 the following conditions must be fulfilled: (1) the person should be a public servant, (2) in such capacity he is legally bound not to purchase or bid for certain property, and (3) either in his name or in the name of another or jointly, or in shares with others. The offence u/s 169 is incomplete without the assistance of some other enactment, which imposes the legal prohibition required. Section 481 of the Cr.P.C, Section 189 of the Railways Act, 1989 and Section 19 of the Cattle Trespass Act, 1871, and instances of that nature in several enactments are available in which persons mentioned therein shall not directly or indirectly purchase any property at a sale under those Acts. It is fairly clear that prohibition should flow from a law as ordinarily understood, that is to say, an enacted law or a rule or regulation framed under such law. The rules and administrative instructions governing the public servants holding the civil posts have no application in this case.

Page 23 of 36

4.2 Prevention of Food Adulteration Act

The object and purpose of the POFAA (Act) are to eliminate the danger to human life from the sale of unwholesome articles of food. It is enacted to curb the widespread evil of food adulteration and is a legislative measure for social defence. It is intended to suppress a social and economic mischief- an evil that attempts to poison, for monetary gains, the very sources of sustenance of life and the well being of the community. The evil of adulteration of food and its effects on the health of the community are assuming alarming proportions. The offence of adulteration is a socio-economic offence. The construction appropriate to social defence legislation is, therefore, one, which would suppress the mischief aimed at by the legislation and advance the remedy. The offences under the Act are really acts prohibited by the police powers of the State in the interests of public health and well-being .The prohibition is backed by the sanction of a penalty. Intention or mental state is irrelevant. In State of Orissa v K.R. Rao the Supreme Court defined the scope of the prohibition against selling of adulterated food. The court observed: In the absence of any provision, express or necessarily implied from the context, the courts would not be justified in holding that the prohibition was only to apply to the owner of the shop and not to the agent of the owner who sells adulterated food. The Act is a welfare legislation to prevent health hazards by consuming adulterated food. The mens rea is not an essential ingredient. It is a social evil and the Act prohibits commission of the offence under the Act. The essential ingredient is sold to the purchaser by the vendor. It is not material to establish the capacity of the person vis--vis the owner of the shop to prove his authority to sell the adulterated food exposed for sale in the shop. It is enough for the prosecution to establish that the person who sold the adulterated article of food has sold it to the purchaser. In Delhi Administration v Manohar Lal the supreme Court held that the High Court, in exercise of its revisional jurisdiction, has no power to itself decide to

Page 24 of 36

commute the sentence imposed under sections 16/7 of the Act and direct the convict to deposit in trial court a specified sum as fine and inform the government of such deposit for formalizing the matter by passing appropriate order u/s 433(d) of Cr.P.C. In State of H.P v Narendra Kumar the Supreme Court observed: The occurrence of adulteration took place nearly two decades back, and the courts below acquitted the accused, though erroneously. Therefore, keeping in view the nature of violation and the peculiar facts and circumstances of the case while sentencing the accused to undergo 6 months RI and fine of Rs 1000, we make it clear that if the accused moves the appropriate government to commute the sentence of imprisonment the same may be considered subject to such conditions or terms as the government may choose to impose. For a period of 3 months the accused need not surrender to undergo sentence. During this period it shall be open to him to move the appropriate government for commutation. The fate of the order of commutation, if any, shall be operative. If no order in the matter of commutation is passed by the appropriate government, the accused shall surrender to serve the remainder of the sentence.

4.3 Other statutes

There are other statutes as well which deal with white collar crimes. For instance, the Conservation of Foreign Exchange and Prevention of Smuggling Activities (COFEPOSA) and Smugglers and Foreign Exchange Manipulators (Forfeiture of Property) Act, 1976(SAFEMA) also deal with white collar crimes. In Safiya v Govt of Kerala the Supreme Court observed that the court could not lost sight of the fact that those who commit economic offences do harm to the national interest and economy. The High Court came to the conclusion that the detenue has violated the provisions of the law (COFEPOSA) and his activities

Page 25 of 36

are not in the larger national interest. The court should be slow to come to the aid off the detenue in such cases. Similarly, in Kesar Devi v U.O.I the Supreme Court while upholding the forfeiture of the properties of the offender observed: The combined effect of section 6(1) and section 8 is that the competent authority should have reasons to believe that properties ostensibly standing in the name of a person to whom the Act applies are illegally acquired properties, he can issue a notice to such person. Thereafter, the burden of proving that such properties are not illegally acquired properties will be upon the person to whom notice has been issued. Under the scheme of the Act, there is no requirement on the part of the competent authority to mention or establish any nexus or link between the money of the convict or detenue and the property sought to be forfeited. In the present case, the appellant is the wife of the detenue and she has failed to establish that she had any income of her own to acquire the three properties. In such circumstances, no other inference was possible except that it was done so with the money provided by the husband.

5 ANALYSIS OF DATA
The Empirical Research Methodology was used and the survey was done with approximately twenty people.

Page 26 of 36

Analysis: A more than ninety percent of the participants have indicated the seriousness of white collar crime in India and the threat it poses to society. This indicates an awareness of society about the extent and consequences of white collar crime.

Analysis: A near overwhelming percent of the participants have indicated the extent of white collar crime in India is more than that of the street crimes. Indicates general populace is aware of the problem it poses to society and the extent to which the problem has spread.

Page 27 of 36

Analysis: Respondents opine that the most frequently overpaying and bribing affect them followed by assault and theft. This also suggests that populace is more generally falling victim to white collar crime than to street crime.

Page 28 of 36

Analysis: Respondents opine overwhelmingly that promoters vanishing after collecting funds from investors cannot be done without the knowledge of regulator. This again strengthens the theory that regulator and unscrupulous promoters are hand-in-glove. This seems to reflect the same story as in question 8 where the authorities themselves are facilitating white collar crime.

Analysis: Police seem to be completely (100%) ineffective in dealing with white collar crime. 100% tells a significant story. This reflects the sentiment in question 8 where participants opine that police is an active participant and facilitator for white collar crimes.

Page 29 of 36

Analysis: Respondents opine that the most frequently overpaying and bribing affect them, followed by assault and theft. This also suggests that populace is more frequently falling victim to white collar crime than to street crime.

Analysis: The net majority overwhelmingly opine that current statutes for punishments and fines are not enough to serve as any deterrent to curb White Collar Crime. An organisation that deals with Crores of Rupees and people holding key positions to deal with organizations money will never find the punishments proportionate to the gains of white collar crime. As such it makes business sense to indulge in white collar crime and pay the paltry fine and punishment if found guilty. This process actually makes people look smart and intelligent to be able to deal in white collar crime thus fuelling the individuals monetary, self actualization and mental needs. The are looked up in society with respect. Fines need to be defined as four to five times the sum involved of notional gain to be of any deterrent

Page 30 of 36

Analysis: Police seem to be hand-in-glove according to an overwhelming majority. This response makes sense and is in line with question 4 where the authorities are themselves participating and facilitating white collar crime.

Analysis: Majority has opined that white collar crime persists in more than 75% of the corporate and an overwhelming majority 87% opines that more than half the corporate commit white collar crimes. These are dangerous signals that convey that our business environment in not trustworthy. Trust is fundamental to the well being of any economy

Page 31 of 36 and these numbers spell doom for business prosperity in the long run. No wonder most of the best recalled brands are foreign brands in India.

Analysis: The near uniform distribution shows how white collar crime is affecting their day to day life. Some of the respondents gave further examples of parking fees, school donations etc to demonstrate the deep extent to which lives are affected by white collar crime.

Survey available online at http://www.surveymonkey.com/s/3T7VP2S

Page 32 of 36

6 CONTROL POLICIES TO BE UNDERTAKEN TO ERADICATE WHITE COLLAR CRIMES

As has been studied so far, white collar crimes are not consequences of any drive of necessity. It is simply greed for multiplying wealth and to retain so called meaningless status in the society by pursuing rivalry with the competitors. These people indulging themselves in these activities are to be considered to the leeches, sucking blood of the society and in turn creating grave hindrances to the progress of the society. Since their acts rarely affect an individual directly, these are often ignored of by a common mass and thereby no single individual takes the pain of prosecuting against the offender. But it must not be forgotten that these crimes and criminals are slowly and steadily spreading their wings towards the society at large and much wrong has already done by now. Therefore, there is an immense need to curb it making no waste of time; otherwise it might totally paralyze and ultimate ruin the society.

The biggest hindrance that lays in the prevention of white collar crimes is the lack of public awareness. Since the individuals involved in these acts, do not generally affect a single individual, an urge of eradicating them, do not usher. Moreover, white collar crimes are yet not considered to be as grave as that of traditional crimes, so to its certain characteristics as mentioned earlier. Though they are likely to take shape of heinous crimes in times to come, yet there lie certain obstacles in considering them at par with traditional crimes. The acts coming under the purview of white collar crimes cannot be termed as crimes in the strict sense of term. Therefore apart from having the stringent penal or regulatory laws for deterring the persons involved in them, there is a first and foremost need of raising public awareness regarding the issues. The government has a comprehensive role to play in doing so through media or by initiating task forces who would act as watch dogs. Proper and methodical string action should

Page 33 of 36

be used randomly so as to catch the individuals involved in the white collar crimes red-handed.

7 CONCLUSION
White collar crime is something nearly everyone has to deal with today in India. The complete ineffectiveness of the police machinery and the judiciary is dealing with white collar crime not only spells doom to the economy but also lowers the quality of life of the average Indian. From the national perspective intelligent and productive children of the soil are sucked up into this grind of corruption, that they cannot bring about innovation and reforms necessary to keep India progressive. Our economies and systems are collapsing & drowning into white collar crime. If the rot is not stemmed early our system will come to a grinding halt like Afghanistan. Fed up with the state of affairs in the country and jobs scene, bright Indians have already made foreign countries their safe haven. Therefore, to conclude, it can be inferred that whatever reasons of justifications are there for the methods used for the control of white collar crimes, the ambivalence of the social response to this sort is so related to wider social factors which have both objective and subjective dimensions. As has been so mentioned a more subjective source of ambivalence in the social response to white collar crimes is the assumption that there is less public concern about these behaviours so termed as white collar crimes, and therefore there is a less support for severe sanctions than in the cases of crimes which are traditional street crimes. But even if there was greater public ambivalence towards white collar crimes in comparison to the traditional crimes, writers such as Box has

Page 34 of 36

regarded this as a further challenge to sensitize people to not seeing processes in which they are victimised disasters or accidents. Therefore, the motto should always be prevention is better than cure. Since the acts involved defrauding public faith and belief, public as a whole mass should come forward to protect the whole society from these greedy people who are destroying the ethics and morality of the society slowly and slowly for their sole aim of pursuing narrow self interest. The general sentiment in India is that if someone indulges in white collar crime, even those people who are aware of it hardly take any steps due to the following 1. The singular loss to them is not significant. 2. If they complain or take action, they will look like fools, while those who adjust and comply in the pretext of duniyadaari appear the smarter lot. It also appears foolish to even support those who fight. The general perception is be stay away and appear smart. This sentiment of appearing smart by refraining from fighting white collar crime should change polarity. The common masses should have the intellect to fathom that it is actually the pinnacle of foolery to comply and participate into the demands to white collar crime.

Page 35 of 36

8 REFERENCES
8.1 Webliography
http://india.indymedia.org http://jurisonline.in/2011/02/white-collar-crimes-in-india/ http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/White-collar_crime http://learn.uci.edu/oo/getDemoPage.php?course=OC0899020&lesson=3&topic=1&page =1

8.2 Bibliography

Indian Penal Code, 140(2010).

Page 36 of 36

*------------------------------------------ Thank You ------------------------------------------*