Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
ISSN 0163-7258197
$32.00
PI1 SO163-7258(97)WO95-8
ABSTRACT. Malaria, one of the most serious diseases transmitted by arthropods, is largely present in tropical and even temperate zones in endemic or epidemic form. More than 40% of the worlds population lives in areas at risk for exposure, and the World Health Orga nization reports that approximately 300 million people are affected by the infection (mostly caused by the species Plasmodium fakipanrm), with 1-2 million deaths per year. These data, and the fact that malaria is becoming increasingly refractory to treatment through resistance of the parasite to antimalarial agents currently in use, e.g., chloroquine, emphasize the need to develop new drugs. The well-known antiparasitic activity of oligopyrrolamidine natural products, such as distamycin and netropsin, suggested the antimalarial evaluation of related compounds obtained by new chemical modifications. Besides possessing antiviral and antitumoural properties, distamycin exhibits interesting in vitro activity against P. @cigarurn. Unfortunately, the high toxicity associated with this product precludes its development as a drug. However, some synthetic analogues of distamycin proved to be highly active against chloroquine-sensitive and -resistant strains of P. falcipa~m, besides showing low toxicity in vitro. PHARMACOL. THER. 76( l-3):125-133, 1997. 0 1997 Elsevier Science Inc. KEY WORDS. CONTENTS 1. INTRODUCTION . . . . . . . . . . . . .
2. ANTIBIOTICPROPERTIES OF 125 Plasmodium fukiparum, malaria, distamycin, pytrole-amidine antibiotics.
125 128
. . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . .
1. INTRODUCTION Distamycin (syn. distamycin A, stallimycin), et al., 1964, 1967), kikumycins a pyrrole-amiis a representacompounds, and antiviruses et al., with 1972; dine oligopeptide isolated from the mycelium of Saeptomyoccurring
DNA sequences
1984; Youngquist and Dervan, 1985; Neidle et studies of DNA complexes have demonstrated of adenine with distaof
al., 1987; Sapse et al., 1993). Crystallographic mycin and netropsin the importance and O(2)
ces distallicus (Arcamone which include netropsin, otic TAN-868 amidinomycin selectively (vaccinia, erentially
hydrogen bonds from the amide NH groups that bridge the strands to the exposed N(3) mine residues. Methylenes van der Waals nonbonded supported by NMR this interaction DNA structure with DNA-protein key biological transcription of thyin and ring CHs are involved
Distamycin
contacts with purine and pyrimet al., 1986). change Because in the In
of different (Verini
idine bases (Kopka et al., 1985). These findings have been studies (Klevit induces a conformational (Low et al., 1985), interactions (Gambari
1976) by binding in the minor groove of duplex DNA prefthus interfering (Zimmer et al., sequences both replication dT)5 and (dA-dT),, tin, and transcription 1986). respectively,
These
are (dAthat
addition, should this occur in genomic regions involved in activities, such as DNA replication is expected to contribute effects. and/or of cellular genes, DNA binding of distamycin greatly to
seems to play a key role in drug-DNA recognition DNA affinity (Pullman, Although (Denny, the biochemical mechanism
1988), recent data suggest that these drugs are caat points in the minor groove
G.
pable of forming reversible complexes with a high degree of selectivity by making contact
1951) and Streptomyces chromogenus (Isono et al., 1955). The antibiotic exhibits an inhibitory effect on the growth
126
P. Lombardi and A. Crisanti No activities against fungi, yeasts, viruses, or parasites have been reported. By contrast, the antibiotic TAN-868 A, isolated from the culture broth of Streptomyces idiomorphus sp. nov., is active against bacteria, fungi, and a protozoan, and has cytotoxic activity against murine tumour cells (Takizawa et al., 1987). The anthelvencins, isolated from the strain Streptomyces wenezuelue (Probst et al., 1965), have only modest activity against a wide spectrum of bacteria and some fungi, but are effective as antiprotozoal and antihelminthic agents against E: histolytica, Syphacia obplelata, Aspicularis tetraptera, Ascaris suum, and Thricuris suis. The antimicrobial effects and the structure-activity relationship of
of several gram-positive and gram-negative microorgan, isms, myco-bacteria, and viruses (Schabel et al., 1953). Nevertheless, the major interest of this compound rests in its trypanocide action, particularly against Trypanosoma congolense (hence the synonym), a parasite resistant to most chemotherapeutic agents active against the two related species Trypanosoma brucei and Trypanosoma equiperdum (Cosar et al., 1952). The compound is an effective antiprotozoal against infections by Entamoeba histolytica. Kikumycins are antibiotics produced by the strain Streptomyces phaeochromogenes R-719 (Kikuchi et al., 1965).. They are effective against gram-positive and gram-negative microorganisms.
Antibiotic TAN-868 A
Antimalarial
FIGURE
2. Structures
of synthetic
N-formimidoyl
analogues (14)
and carbamoyl
analogues (S-7)
of distamycin.
amidinomycin and synthetic stereoisomers have been discussed (Sung et al., 1997). The somewhat high toxicity of the amidine oligopeptide antibiotics did not permit their clinical use, although a top ical preparation of distamycin, named HerperalB, was formulated by Farmitalia (now Pharmacia & Upjohn, Nerviano, Milan, Italy) as an antiherpetic, but was not launched on the market. More recently, the in vitro sensitivity of the malaria parasite P. falciparum to distamycin was reported independently by several groups (Mongelli and Spreafico, 1991; Lee and Inselburg, 1993; Ginsburg et al., 1993).
Malaria is one of the most serious diseases transmitted by arthropods, and is present largely in tropical and even temperate zones in endemic or epidemic form. More than 40% of the worlds population lives in areas at risk for exposure, and the World Health Organisation reports that approximately 300 million people are affected by the infection, with l-2 million deaths per year. Although malaria is no longer present in Europe, the number of cases diagnosed in the Western World is increasing as a consequence of extensive travel and immigration. Such cases of imported ma-
8
V
. 2HCI L V
"zN q;
2
.2HCI
2 HCI
vi, v
2N
i, HN03, acetic anhydride; ii, thionyl chloride, tetrahydrov, Hz, 10% Id/C; vi, 8, diisopropylethylamine.
Antimalarial Activity of Distamycin and Analogues laria are at risk of misdiagnosis sometimes female mosquitoes and delayed treatment, by drugs, hampering effective disease control.
active agents whose structure and mechanism fer from that of drugs currently chloroquine most recent
of the genus Anopheks, and it is caused The parasites infirst in the liver, stages of by feedP. wiuax, infected
by minute parasitic protozoa of the genus Plasmodium, which infect human and insect hosts alternately. mans, the parasites multiply dramatically, development. Other mosquitoes become fect a human while the mosquito is feeding on blood. In huthen in the blood, where they undergo different ing from an infected P. ovale, and P. m&r&
and derivatives, the sulphonamides, and the artemisinine and derivatives, might facilitate of a novel therapeutic arsenal to control
the development
4. NEW
DISTAMYCIN
species of malaria parasites infect humans. Three, rarely fatal, albeit debilitating. The fourth,
causes much more serious and progressive illness, leading to coma and death within a few days. The development of human malaria. Infected surface knobs that contain dothelial cell membrane, erythrocytes a histidine-rich falciparum in the blood differs from that of the other species develop on their protein secreted of the en-
brates) is extremely rich (82%) in dA-dT base pairs (Weber, 1987, 1988), while that of the human host consists of 59% dA-dT. Moreover, during the erythrocytic stage, the parasite has a growth rate, and therefore, rate of DNA synthesis, that is more like malignant than normal human cells. Hence, a ligand possessing a specific dA-dT bias could be more inhibitory to the parasite than to its human host. Nevertheless, the low therapeutic index of distamycin, due to general toxicity caused by degradation products, may once more prevent its development as a drug. We have reviewed the results of screening distamycin against I. falciparum of synthetic that eventually led to identification analogues of of a com-
here. This process, called sequestration, is particularly intense in the brain, causing a measurable reduction flow (Knell, antimalarial 1991). has been the mainstay of chemotherapy, due to its efficacy and low toxFor a long time, chloroquine
icity. Because of the rapid spreading of chloroquine-resistant malaria since the early 1960s in most tropical areas, resulting from the remarkable and the use of antimalarials quate routine treatment areas, the chemotherapy adaptability for prophylaxis of P. falciparum and for inadefevers in endemic and more toxic
pound that may merit specific clinical trials as an antiprotozoal agent (Lombardi et al., 1994; Alfieri et al., 1997). In the course of investigations chemotherapeutic distamycin action and favorable therapeutic analogues l-7 aimed at developing new of agents endowed with high specificity
2 HC3XOOCH3 + CH3NHOH.HCI 1_
. ciq 3 q+
3
... 111 1
H I \
COOCH3
/
=Q
\ COOH AH3 v
vi
X c;y
ix
Q
I\
!Hs
Vlll
...
I -A
t X
\ cocci3
AH3
AH3
130
P. Lombardi and A. C&anti are known (Di Pietro et al., 1996; Alfieri et al., 1997). For compounds 5 and 6, studies have been made of their binding to oligodeoxynucleotide duplexes by two-dimensional, high resolution lH NMR. Both compounds bind strongly to the central dA,dT, sequence of the dodecamer d(CGCAAATTTGCG)z, and 6, particularly, gives rise to a single, stable complex with 2:l stoichiometry (Animati et al., 1995). Extensive DNase I foot-printing experiments revealed that the carbamoyl analogues 5-7 bind to dA-dT-rich sequences and that 5 gives weaker footprints than 6 and 7, whereas few significant differences can be seen between the latter two (Alfieri et al., 1997).
either by a N-formimidoyl moiety (14) or by a carbamoyl group (S-7). More precisely, compounds l-3 bear an additional positively charged amidine group at the N-terminus, whereas compound 4 bears a primary amide group at the Cterminus and an amidine group at the N-terminus. Moreover, compounds 1, 3,6, and 7 present a different number of pyrrole-derived units with respect to distamycin. The synthesis of compounds l-7 entails the preparation of the oligopyrrole backbones with the required number of pyrrolecarboxamido units, which are obtained from 8 by an iterative process (Fig. 3), and the preparation of the carbamoylpyrrole unit 9 (Fig. 4). The oligopyrrole intermediates are then condensed with formamidine hydrochloride or ethyl formamidate to give N-formimidoyl analogues l-4 (Fig. 5, top) or with 9, activated as acyl chloride or with standard condensing agents, to yield carbamoyl analogues 5-7 (Fig. 5, bottom). Data concerning DNA affinity, as well as antiherpetic activity and cytotoxicity of the above described compounds.
5. ANTIPROTOZOAL ACTIVITY
The antiprotozoal activities of distamycin, and of compounds 1-7, against the chloroquine-sensitive IT04 strain of P. falcipurum were measured by incubating unsynchronized cultures of the parasite in erythrocytes with the drugs
b?N
AcjNH2 .2HCl % n
n=3
i t
I
3
-&NH2
.2HCI
HzN
I I
-<.
NH n
2HCI
I
-f,
n
PH2 .2HCl
NH
l-3
n = 1,3,4
HCI
5-7
n = 2,3,4
FIGURE 5. Synthesis of N-formimidoyl analogues (14) and carbamoyl analogues (S-7) of distamycin. Reagents and Conditions: i, NaOH, methanol; ii, formamidine hydrochloride, NaHCO,, methanol, reflex or ethyl formamidate hydrochloride, NaHC03, ethanol; iii, the acyl chloride of 9, diisopropylethylamine.
Antimalarial
Activity
of Distamycin
and Analogues
131
and Calf Thymus DNA-Binding Properties of Distamycin and Distamycin
TABLE
1. Antiprotozoal,
Antiviral,
Cytotoxic
Activities,
($4
HSV-1 11.2 HF Hep-2 32.9 I<, (M-1 26.5
DNA-binding Parameters
x 106)
rb yDD
P. fakiparum
0.7-1.3
(M-1 28.0
x 105)
0.106
>lOO 27 8.6
required to reduce a given biological effect by 50%; K_ intrinsic binding constant; r,,, stoichiometric Q0, inhibition dose, i.e., the drug concentration ing ratio, i.e., number of molecules bound per nucleotide base; K,,,, apparent binding constant, i.e., the product K,> X rh. HSV, herpes simplex virus.
for 20 hr. The frequency of parasitized cells in cultures was determined by microscopic examination of Giemsa-stained fields were culsmears. The data collected separate experiments examined represent average values from 3
1997), and their remarkable antiprotozoal activity prompted further biological I. f&pawn percent inhibition assays against the chloroquine-resistant 2 lists comparative parasitemia and values of chloroquine, (IT04) distamycin, (Kl) strain. Table
in which 50 microscope
curves from which ID50 values were estimated. Control thylsulphoxide) In Table or medium. activities
tures were treated with the same quantity of solvent (dime1, the antimalarial of the compounds
With the resistant strain, both 6 and 7 exhibit a remarkably high inhibition of parasitemia at a dose at which chloroquine and the other compounds tested appear almost ineffective. analogue 7, by The superior activity of the 5-ring carbamoyl
are shown and compared with the respective IDS0 values for their cytotoxicity, viral cytopathic expressed as cell proliferation in Hep2 cells, activity, expressed as reduction of strain HF). The calf bound per the effect on the same cell line infected with parameters, rb (number expressed as K, (intrinof molecules affinity constant, and for their antiherpetic
relative to the 4-ring homolog 6, was further confirmed were synchronized (Lambros and Vanderberg, Data collected
Herpes simplex (herpes simples virus-l, thymus DNA-binding sic binding constant), nucleotide
assaying the two compounds in cultures where the parasites 1979) to the same stage of development. at a single dose
of 1 kg/mL, but at decreasing times (8, 6, 4, 2 hr) of exposure to the drug, indicate for compound 7 a faster inhibiting action. Finally, a comparative compound evaluation of chloroquine against the and the carbamoyl 7 for activities
product K,, * r,,), which is considered as a measure of the binding affinity, are also included. The general picture that emerges from an analysis of the biological tin and the related synthetic larial than antiherpetic affinity further confirm activities is that distamycompounds are better antima-
agents. The data for DNA-binding that the binding process is domiand van der Waals contacts, analogues 5-7 have a series, by the number of pyrroleTABLE2. Antiprotozoal Activity of Distamycin and of Carbamoyl Distamycin Analogues (S-7) against ChloroquineSensitive (IT04) and Chloroquine-Resistant (Kl) Strains of P. fakiparum
IT04 5 Compound Chloroquine Distamycin 5 6 7 100 100 94 100 100 1 (kg/mL) 100 87 54.7 86 100 85 8 11 20.2 64.7 100 100 100 100 100 0.2 5 Kl 1 ( w/mL) 76 78 53.1 94 100 2.7 12 1.5 53 71 0.2
lower affinity for calf thymus DNA than distamycin, indicating that the formylamino group plays a specific role in stabilizing the DNA complex, similar to that of the N-formimidoyl group of analogues 2-4. Nonetheless, the most striking result forthcoming from Table 1 is that the antiprotozoal activity against P. fulcipurum of all the listed compounds units of backbone, irrespective of the type of funcstrictly follows the number of pyrrolecarboxamido the oligopeptide
tional groups present on the termini of the molecule, of their antiviral and cytotoxic activities, or of their calf thymus DNA-binding properties. The very low cytotoxicity of the
Values are expressed as percent parasitemia inhibition, controls, evaluated after 20 hr of exposure to the drug.
with respect to
132
,I
.a !3 .x P
3-
I I
..
*.
chloroquine *. l.
l.
0 - - - - -0
n
i i
0 -.
l.
*..
compound 7
*.
\\
0..
W
-I -.
L O
*c
-.0
FIGURE 6. Comparative evaluation of the activities of chloroquine and carbamoyl diitamycin analogue 7 against the chloroquine-resistant Kl strain of P. fakiparum. Dose effect curves at 4-hr exposure to the drugs. Effect is reported as absolute values of parasitemia (percent of infected cells). M, medium; DMSO, dimethylsulphoxide.
IM
I DMSO
1 0.2
1 1
PglmL
carbamoyl rapid analogue 7. This compound antiparasitic action on the shows a chloroaf-
chloroquine-resistant in synchronized
and
at a 4-hr exposure to the drugs (Fig. 6) demonstrate tent action than chloroquine. 6. CONCLUSIONS Malaria still constitutes AND PERSPECTIVES
quine-resistant
inhibition
4 hr
at 1 FglmL) experiments
and greatly improved the therapeutic which warrants ad7 represents the agents, and in uioo. Compound
quine has been the drug of choice both for treatment bility. Quinine,
use, and because of low cost and good tolerarare and toxic, has been in use only in spemeflohas led and to are expensive and also have very
cialized centers. The new and effective antimalarials quine and halofantrine to the increasing emergence serious side effects. Moreover, development misuse of chloroquine of cross resistance
of new resistant strains of P. fulcipurum, which hopes for ready develfor the
References Alfieri, A., Animati, F., Arcamone, F., Bailly, C., Crisanti, A., Dentini, M., Felicetti, P., Iafrate, E., Lombardi, P., Manzini, S., Rossi, C. and Waring, M. J. (1997) Biological activity and DNA
sequence mycin. Animati, specificity Antiviral of synthetic F. M., Conte, L., Paloma, analogues in the 2:l carbamoyl analogues of distaChem. I., Mayol, Chemother. 8: 243-254. M. R., Felicetti, and their solution P., Galeone, binding Chem. mode as 38: L. G. and Rossi, C. (1995) complexes
opment of a malaria vaccine dictate that the control of this disease will have to rely again on chemotherapy foreseeable future. Many potentially interesting new targets
F., Arcamone,
have been identified in P. fulci~arum in recent years (Murray and Perkins, 1996), and a great part of strategies in malaria control are now focused on how to overcome the problem of resistance (Rasoanaivo et al., 1996). The use of distamycin has been abandoned gopeptide-amidine reason, the antiparasitic as an antiviral or anticancer properties exhibited drug due to its high toxicity. For the same by some oliThe selectivity
to d(CGCAAATTTGCG),
IH-NMR.
J. Med.
P. G., Nicolella,
V. and
Pirelli,
Structure
and synthesis
of distamycin
A. Nature
W., Nicolella,
e struttura
against malarial parasites suggests that distamycin should be now considered as a novel antimalarial with a new mechanism of action. The selective antimalarial effect of distamytin has been greatly improved by chemical modifications, which eventually led to the synthesis and identification of
C., Ninet,
PreudHomme,
antibiotique
streptomices. anti-cancer
W. (1988)
drugs.
Antimalarial
Activity
of Distamycin
133
Di Pietro, G., Giannini, tini, M., Animati, N-formimidoyl Trans. Finlay, (1951)
G., Iafrate, E. M., Monteagudo, P. and Arcamone, J. Chem. of distamycin. F. A., Sobin, Sot.
F., Lombardi,
compounds 20971,1989).
analogues
1 1996: 1333-1335. B. A. and Murphy, Netropsin, a new antibiotic H. J. (1984) produced by a Streptomyces. DNA structural variations
A. C., Hochstein,
E. (1996)
malaria. Neidle,
In: Annual
in Medicinal
J. Am. Chem.
Sot. 73: 341-343. and distamycin as revealed by DNase V., Feriotto, G.,
pp. 141-150,
Bristol, J. A. (ed.) Academic of drug binding. Biochem. M. M. and Woods, with anthelmintic 5: 789-792.
J. V. (1987)
Nucl. Acids Res. 12: 9271-9285. R., Nastruzzi, C., Chirboli, P. and Arcamone, of a nuclear factor HLA-DRa F. (1991) Distamy-
B. L. (1965)
P. G., Giacomini, the binding 41: 497-502. sequence H., Nissani, Selective
inhibits
in nucleic
on Quantum
and Biochemistry,
Jortner, J. (eds.) Kluwer Academic Rasoanaivo, Reversing P., Ratsimamanga-Urverg, agents in the treatment
toxicity
Curr. Med. Chem. 3: l-10. Sapse, A. M., Feng, W., Fugler-Domenico, and Lown, J. W. (1993) Quantum mechanics gopeptide Schabel, studies on the binding antibiotics amidinomycin J. Biomol. L., Kabir, S., Joseph, T. chemical and molecular of the olito the H. E. Proc. synof the
Verlag, New York. Isono, K., Suzuki, S., Sawazaki, T., Nakamura, Yamashita, An antibiotic biot. 8: 19-21. Kikuchi, M., Kumagai, K., Ishida, N., It& Y., Yamaguchi, Isolation, purification, 18: 243-250. B. R. (1986) H NMR A and a symmetProA and B. J. Antibiot. D. E. and Reid, Biochemistry T., Furuand propmai, T. and Okuda, T. (1965) erties of kikumycins Klevit, R. E., Wemmer, produced by Sneptomyces T., Anzai, K., Serizawa, Y. and Sekiyama, Y. (1955)
chromogenus. J. Anti-
Sot. Exp. Biol. Med. 83: l-4. Sung, S. Y., Kist, M. and Frahm, A. W. (1997) thesis and structure antibiotic Takizawa, Pharm. 330: 21-24. M., Tsubotani, S., Tanida, S., Harada, antibiotic S. and HasegTAN-868 A. F. awa, T. (1987) J. Antibiot. Verini, (1976) A new pyrrole-amidine G., Sanfilippo, relationship amidinomycin. Asymmetric of the four stereoisomers
studies on the interaction rical DNA dodecamer. Knell, Kopka, A. J. (1991) H. L., Yoon, gramme of the Wellcome R. E. (1985) netropsin 1376-1380. Lambros, C. and Vanderberg, medium fakipnxm 418420. Lane, H. J., Dabrowiak, specificity J. Malaria,
Part 2. Microbiological
testing. Arch.
25: 3296-3303. of the Tropical Press, Oxford. specificity Sci. USA in 82:
Trust. Oxford University D., Pjura, Natl. origin of DNA-drug Proc. Acad.
C., Goodsell,
P. and Dickerson,
The molecular
M. A., DAmico,
and distamycin.
tions of tissue cultures infected with herpes simplex virus. I1 FarJ. P. (1979) Synchronization of Plas65: mace 10: 705-713. Weber, 109. Weber, J. L. (1988) Molecular biology of malaria parasites. P. B. (1985) Sequence Exp. Parasitol. Youngquist, In vitro sensitivity or inhibit of Plasmodium its synthesis. J. ognition Zimmer, F. and Arcamone, as antimalarials. Italian (Priority: F. (1994) Intemaderivatives Al tools 31-112. M. J. (1985) Echinomycore DNA. Zimmer, Ch., Luck, G., Thrum, H. and Pitra, C. (1972) analogues of the antibiotics distamycin 26: 81-89. native DNA. Eur. J. Biochem. Binding of to induce rotation of nucleosome A and netropsin 66: 143-170. R. S. and Dervan, of B-DNA specific recby oligo(N-methylpyrrole U. (1986) carboxamides). DNAinvestigaBiol. 47: J. L. (1987) genome Analysis of sequences from the extremely 52: 103A+T-rich C. and Voumakis, J. N. (1983) of actinomycin D and netropsin binding to of Plasmodium fafci~or~rn. Gene erythrocytic stages in culture. J. Parasitol.
Sequence pBR322
fulciparum to drugs that bind DNA 79: 780-782. P., Rossi, C., Animati, of distamycin WO 9425436
Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 82: 2565-2569. Ch. and Wahnert, ligands: specificity in biophysical, Non-intercalating and biological Mol. binding of the interaction Prog. Biophys. and their use as
biochemical materials.
Patent Appli-
cation FI83, 1993). Low, C. M. L., Drew, H. R. and Waring, tin and distamycin Nucl. Acids Res. 14: 6785-6801.