Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
Contents
1.0 Investment Banking ..................................................................................................................................... 3 1.1 What is Investment Banking? ............................................................................................................. 3 1.2 Roles as per Investment Banking groups ..................................................................................... 3 1.3 Roles as per job title in Investment Banking ............................................................................... 6 1.4 Typical hierarchy/ ladder in an Investment Bank ................................................................... 8 1.5 Top Investment Banks ........................................................................................................................... 9 1.6 The not-so-secret life of an Investment Banker ...................................................................... 10 1.7 Essentials needed to be an Investment Banker ....................................................................... 11 1.8 Skills and Qualities ................................................................................................................................. 12 1.9 What the banks look for? (Selection criteria) ........................................................................... 13 1.10 What can you expect as a Graduate Analyst? ......................................................................... 13 1.11 Salaries ...................................................................................................................................................... 14 2.0 An Investment Banking Resume .......................................................................................................... 15 2.1 Keywords for Investment Banking resumes ............................................................................. 15 2.2 How Investment Bankers review resume .................................................................................. 16 2.3 How much time is spent on a resume review? ......................................................................... 17 3.1 Interview Dos and Donts ................................................................................................................... 19 3.1.1 Dos: ....................................................................................................................................................... 19 3.1.2 Donts: .................................................................................................................................................. 19 3.2 Interview Questions that an Investment Banker should be prepared for .................. 20 4.0 Interview tips by alumni.......................................................................................................................... 21 4.1 Goldman Sachs Interview tips. ......................................................................................................... 21 4.2 Credit Suisse Interview tips............................................................................................................... 23 5.0 Feedback given by our interviewers.................................................................................................. 25 5.1 Criteria ......................................................................................................................................................... 25 5.2 Feedback Examples ............................................................................................................................... 25 6.1 Examples..................................................................................................................................................... 31 7.0 What next? ...................................................................................................................................................... 32
There are several different groups and areas that investment bankers can specialise in and be a part of:
Industry Coverage This area relates to industry-focused investment banking. The group has a set of senior bankers or managing directors, responsible for maintaining good relationships with client companies in the industry. There is also a group of Directors, VPs, Associates, Analysts and Administrative Assistants who are in-charge of attending client meetings, coming up with ideas for clients, preparing pitch books, executing transactions, writing commitment committee memo's etc. Usually when fresh starting in banking means that you will likely be a part of the coverage group. Corporate finance A corporate finance position is about helping companies raise capital needed for new projects and ongoing operations. It involves determining the amount and structure of fund needs of a client through equity, debt, convertibles, preferred, asset-backs, or derivative securities. As a starting analyst, you would usually work with a client team and have responsibilities like preparing registration statements, attending road shows where investors are sold on securities etc. Mergers & Acquisitions This area involves setting up deals where one company buys another. This is an important source of fee income for many investment banks. Working in this area involves giving advice to a client when they are seeking to buy another firm. The advice may relate to potential target companies, pricing and valuation, as well as how to integrate the firms postacquisition. Here an investment banker needs to work out value transactions, structure creative deals and negotiate favourable terms working in teams. As a starter, your duties could involve analyzing the appropriate form of participation. Expect to start running lots of valuation models on spreadsheets and gradually get more client focus as you progress. Banks, which specialise in this area, are Goldman Sachs, Deutsche Bank, and Morgan Stanley.
Structure Financing Investment bankers provide clients with an alternative to standard business loans. They borrow against a companys cash-flow history. In order to successfully do your work in this area, you must have good spreadsheet, accounting, and legal skills. Equity Capital Markets In this case, investment bankers help clients structure, buy, sell, and issue shares using market insight and intelligence with corporate finance knowledge. What they decide to do with the shares is highly dependent on the financial situation and future estimates of the client firms performance.
Debt Capital Markets When clients have limited access to traditional capital sources, they ask investment bankers to help them raise funds by taking out loans in the form of high yield bonds or investment grade bonds. Investment bankers working in this area will need to interact with other divisions, such as financial strategy, derivatives, and currency trading, in order to be in a position to give sound advice to clients.
Private Wealth Management Investment bankers provide high net worth clients with highly customized and sophisticated investment management and financial planning services. They provide advice on various things including the use of trusts and other estate planning, vehicles, business succession, stock option planning, the use of hedging derivatives for large blocks of stock. It is a service offered by Goldman Sachs and Morgan Stanley.
Presentation are mainly putting together and writing of various PowerPoint presentations including marketing documents like Pitches or Pitch books and documents for live transactions (for example, a presentation to management or the Board of Directors). These PowerPoint presentations are printed in colour and bound with professional covers as they are taken to meeting with the clients. Analytical work involves all the work done in Excel like entering historic company data from public documents, analyzing such data for valuation purposes and projecting a companys financial statements. While administrative tasks are things like scheduling and setting up conference calls and meetings, making travel arrangements and keeping a list of deal team members up to date. Role of an Associate Associates are people who are directly out of a top MBA school or analysts that have been promoted. Before being promoted to the Vice President level, bankers will be at the Associate level for three and a half years at least. Associates also are responsible for supervising over the Analysts and checking their work.
6
In addition to overseeing the Analysts work, Associates will often help write the text for the presentations as well as do much of the modelling work. While dealing with live transactions, the Associate will have significant ongoing interaction with the client and with the opposing investment bank.
Role of a Vice President Main role the Vice President plays is that of being a Project Manager, whether for marketing activities or on a transaction. The VP decides structure of the presentation or pitch book. Dealing with live transactions, the VP is typically the banker running the deal. The VP is in-charge of managing the client, managing the senior bankers and managing the Analysts and Associates that are actually doing the work. It is often at the VP level that bankers begin to form valuable relationships with clients. Depending on the individual and also the bank, some VPs will start to play a role in client development and marketing. Role of a Director or a senior Vice President The Director or SVP acts more like a Managing Director ie managing a high level client development role or acts like a VP playing a project manager role. The role could also depend on specific situation and other deal team members. For Director/SVPs to be promoted to Managing Director level, they need to demonstrate that they can form client relationships and have the ability to market and to bring in new business. Role of a Managing Director Being a senior level banker, the role of the Managing Director (MD) is mostly client development. The MD will likely be the one with the senior level company relationships (CEO, CFO, head of Corporate Development) and is typically responsible for spearheading marketing efforts. On a live transaction, the MD often plays only a minor role, getting involved when difficulties arise in the deal and during high level negotiations.
Sometimes banks do tend to deviate from this typical hierarchy a bit, for example having the Senior Vice President and Director to be separate positions. Other banks, usually have the same hierarchy but with somewhat different names for each position. Associate Director for Associate Director for Vice President Executive Director for SVP However, regardless of the names, the general job functions of each relative position tend to be consistent from bank to bank.
Getting into any of these three requires perseverance and hard work. As a student, you might think of getting ahead of your competition by participating in Spring Weeks organised by the banks or by interning during a Summer Analyst Scheme. Other top investment banks include:
Citigroup Bank of America Deutsche Bank UBS Credit Suisse BNP Paribas HSBC Merrill Lynch Lazard
These investment banks are typically regionally oriented or situated in the middle market. You might come across boutique investment banks, which are oriented toward an industry vertical, bond trading, M&A advisory, technical analysis, or program trading.
10
11
Strong problem solving skills Highly numerate Drive, ambition, flexibility Ability to quickly learn Exceptional networking skills Stamina Ability to work with influential clients
Very good communication skills in order to successfully work with clients A thorough understanding of market trends, the political and macroeconomic environment, and deal mechanics
In order to get a leg up in the recruitment process, you might think of acquiring a CFA certificate as accounting skills are highly valuable in investment banking.
12
13
1.11 Salaries
Salaries will vary with the firm youre working for and the region of the country you are in. However, below are rough estimates of how much you can expect to earn (including bonus) as an investment banker. Job Level First year Analyst Third year Analyst First year Associate Third year Associate Vice President Director/ Principal MD/ Partner Department Head Salary Range $90k 150k $120K - 350K $150K - 250K $300 - 500K $350K - 1MM $400K - 1.5MM $500K - 20 MM $800K - 70MM (Degree/Years experience) Bachelors Bachelors MBA MBA 3-6 years 5-10 years 7-10 years 10+ years (Careers-in-finance.com, 2011) Bonuses greatly vary in size and can reach very high levels; they can end up being between 10% to 50% of your salary. In 2008, due to the severity of the financial crisis, most investment bankers received low and even zero bonuses. You have to be aware of the fact that bonuses are heavily dependent on the state of the current economic climate. In addition, it is important to know that the salary you will receive will include an equity component, which is especially designed for the purpose to limit employees movement between firms. In terms of investment banking areas, due to the new financial forms, salaries in prop trading, institutional equity sales, and securitisation will most likely fall. In contrast, areas such as restructuring, health care M&A/financing, and debt capital markets are growing, and therefore, are expected to have a positive upward effect on salaries.
14
15
Extra curricular Activities: Too often when I reviewed candidate resumes at Credit Suisse people failed to list their extra curricular achievements. Investment banks are highly social institutions and seeing lots of good extra curricular roles suggests that the candidate can fit in. If your leadership roles were elected, you can put (elected) in brackets after your title for the role, this is further proof that you are well-liked and can fit in. Job Locations: This point is particularly important for bank offices outside of New York. These offices will want to know that you have a link to the area. Therefore, if you have ever worked in or near that city be sure to list the location of your jobs on your resume. At a minimum, if you are applying for a role in Charlotte make sure your cover letter indicates why you want to work there.
16
17
18
Analyst/Associate (they really like ambitious people so this type of question so long as you do not come off as arrogant is valuable)?
3.1.2 Donts:
In the interview itself DO NOT come off as arrogant. That is the kiss of death. Be Confident but not arrogant. I would caution against disagreeing with the interviewer unless you are certain you are correct. Unlike consulting interviews, investment bankers view the process as less of a date than a right and wrong answer. Bankers are proud people that generally do not take well to being questioned. DO NOT fake something in your interview. For example do not just pass off that you think the deal will be accretive without knowing what that word means and how to calculate it.
19
Bankers can smell weakness and will likely pounce on it asking follow-up questions that uncover your lack of understanding. Thus, study hard and choose your words and areas of conversation carefully. Do not discuss compensation. The job pays well. You already know that.
20
21
Form small interview focus groups to gather as many Technical questions are you can and quiz each other. This is the best way to get prepared for Technicals - this will expose you to new questions and help you think on your feet Know and understand the sections of a pitch book and what goes into them especially if you are applying for a role in IBD. For markets roles, have defend-able opinions and thesis. Fit / Behavioural Questions This is what is going to get you in the door once you have passed the Technicals round. Working in Banking is tough and working at GS is even harder and they want to see if you have what it takes Someone who is a good cultural fit is someone who is able to demonstrate his/ her fit with each of the business principles. This doesn't mean that you memorize the business principles and regurgitate them in the interview but rather think about examples that will demonstrate that you have those qualities and try and "check off" various principles in the examples / answers you provide One of the things you will likely experience in later rounds is situational questions - GS use this a lot. The key thing to remember here is that there is no right or wrong answer. They want insight into your thought process and often give you very real situations that can occur in the workplace. Some examples are below You are travelling with your MD to a very Sr. Client meeting and pass out the presentation to everyone. Your MD starts speaking and you notice there is a mistake 4 pages into the presentation. What do you do? You are in the elevator with th.... Access the rest of the article. http://www.interviewbay.com/interview_tips/Goldman-Sachs-Interview-tips.php
22
23
24
through.
b. Excellent listening skills - Analytical - Strong macro and consumer trends knowledge
this impacts disposable income and thus consumer spending). 2. Please provide the candidates weaknesses.
a. Pace of speech - slow down and enunciate. b. Your grammatical mistakes should be fewer as a result of slowing down. - You said "I
would say this example." Instead of "Let me give you this example". When I asked you, "Did you meet with the management?", you said "Yes, I do." You could say, "Yes, I did and worked closely with them throughout the process."3.
25
3. Please provide the key areas that candidate needs to improve to address the target companys/business schools requirements.
a. Be more structured in your responses:
For example, when someone asks you, "Which three adjectives would your professors use to describe you? you respond, "One: analytical, Two: industrious and Three: inquisitive". Another good adjective to cite is "collaborative".
b. Interviewer(s) may ask you to cite an example of failure:
You could use an example of how you didn't manage communication effectively but that you learned from this and made a concerted effort to communicate more effectively with your team thereafter.
c. Flexibility and international interest will help you at Goldman Sachs.
IF they ask you to describe your medium or long-term goals, you can say that you'd be very interested working for Goldman Sachs beyond the summer and that you are flexible to work in NY, Hong Kong or other offices where they have GIR teams. 4. Other comments/suggestions/remarks that you want to add to help the candidate in his/her interview preparation.
a. You can mention talking to a GS alumna who worked in four offices including Japan
hone your skills in financial statement analysis and also in corporate finance (M&A, corporate actions, etc).
c. Be sure to mention your having worked with Chinese pharmaceutical companies. d. Do NOT mention anything personal or your personal life/relationship status. GS
(finance, math, economic) as well as you performing financial analyses on your jobs
c. Teamwork/leadership work with large global teams, taking one for the team to
that you will have to learn to delegate as you move up in your career...plus other need to learn as well.
b. Taking too much on your plate accepting too much work just because you want to
learn as much as possible; also you are a people pleaser and rarely say no o Consistent team at being able to prioritize you do everything perfect, but you will reach your maximum capacity 3. Please provide the key areas that candidate needs to improve to address the target companys/business schools requirements.
a. As discussed every story/example that you mentioned try weaving in multiple
competencies. Also, keep in mind that you want to substantiate everything with facts/evidence number of people of the team that you have worked with, number of research published, number of restaurants research QUANTIFY QUANTIFY QUANTIFY! Be sure to know what are your strengths and weaknesses. 4. Other comments/suggestions/remarks that you want to add to help the candidate in his/her interview preparation.
a. A pleasure to work with and I believe she will be a good fit at GS.
27
b. She needs to continue learning from folks with experience in whatever space she is
looking to move into as she learns well from others experiences and can benefit greatly as a result of pursuing this mode of educating herself.
c. Know the facts on GS and have a few questions prepared for your interviewers.
He must gain a stronger knowledge of weighted average cost of capital calculation - to the point where he can deal with theoretical situations thrown at him.
ii.
Secondly - he must speak like a banker when addressing his preparedness for the role. By this I mean - he should improve his vernacular so that he is "speaking more of the same language" when interviewing. The correct use of terms that bankers use will definitely help in his interview.
iii.
Lastly - he must make his story more believable. His attraction and experience in entrepreneurial settings will set alarm bells off and thus he must make it
28
clear that he is committed and passionate to pursue banking as a career and prepared to accept and excel in the lifestyle 3. Please provide the key areas that candidate needs to improve to address the target companys/business schools requirements.
a. As mentioned above, X will benefit from making his story believable, touching up on
his technical knowledge (accounting and valuation readings will help in this regards) and also reading some material that will allow him to make the classic Wall Street banker feel more at ease with his ability to transition into the atmosphere.
b. I suggest that popular books out in the space such as Monkeys business and
Barbarians at the gate be read in order to give him some insight into the minds of people he will be dealing with and the world he will be living in. Although these may seem humorous or outdated as books, they are still different and valued perspectives which he will be able to digest and dwell on. 4. Other comments/suggestions/remarks that you want to add to help the candidate in his/her interview preparation.
a. X and I will follow up with one another as I am interested in viewing his progress. b. Nevertheless - I feel he has a strong resume and story - as he said he is obsessed with
doing - I urge him to tighten, tighten, and tighten some more his preparedness in anticipation of the interview.
c. Reading a few things such as the economist and barrons, as well as hitting the books
on valuation and accounting - will make him a stellar candidate and stand out. Example 4: 1. Please provide the candidat es strengths.
a. The Candidate seems sincere. b. Is qualified well through education and experience.
a. Needs to sharpen understanding of valuation concepts. b. Needs to develop better explanation of his interest in investment banking.
3. Please provide the key areas that candidate needs to improve to address the target companys/business schools requirements.
a. Needs to tighten up answers on preferences for large global banks. b. Needs to have a stronger command of the details of his work at his last summer
internship. 4. Other comments/suggestions/remarks that you want to add to help the candidate in his/her interview preparation.
a. Needs to project his voice and be more confident. b. Doesnt come across as aggressive enough in his presentation.
30
2. A Banker from New York, Harvard Business School, Class of 2011 Well, I have a bit of good news..I'll be attending HBS this coming fall! Thanks for your preparation help.very useful. No feedback on the service, per se, but I will definitely refer to all of my friends applying/interviewing.
3. A consultant from USA joining Oliver Wyman, New York I would like you to thank Julien. I have just accepted an offer at Oliver Wyman. I am grateful for his help. Thank you
4. A graduate from Germany after receiving an internship offer from McKinsey. Thanks again for your great work and feedback! I got the job (internship)! Your suggestions were really helpful and I think they made the difference! Thanks a lot!
5. An undergraduate from France, received a full-time offer from McKinsey I have just passed the last round in Paris and got an offer from McKinsey, Paris! I am so happy about it. Thank you very much for all your help! Thank you very much again!
31
InterviewBay was created for those who have interviews and who wish to prepare for the opportunity through exceptional mock interviews with ALUMNI of the organization. Interviewees can work with alumni to 'perfect' their pitch and prepare for banking, consulting and graduate school admissions interviews.
We conduct interviews with alumni from top firms like Goldman Sachs, J P Morgan, and Morgan Stanley etc.
32