Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
divine, the lived experiences of feminist theologians and laypersons give rise
The Nicene Creed has been particularly selected as the object of our
examination because of its concern for the life of faith as one of communal
kinship and solidarity. Creedal sections, which elicit feminist critique, will
within articles that are not particularly designated for them. Our examination
Page 1 of 17
will reflect this interrelationship in an effort to emphasize the cohesive,
though diverse, nature of the triune God. The purpose of this presentation is
not to reaffirm, reject, or replace the entirety of the Nicene Creed but to open
statements of faith.
We believe in one God, the Father, the Almighty, maker of heaven and
earth, of all that is, seen and unseen. – The Nicene Creed; First
Article
Two aspects of the first article of the Nicene Creed concern feminist
Concern #1) The Nicene Creed confesses belief in God the Father.
The image of father is indeed scriptural, both Old and New Testaments attest
to this image. Isaiah 64:8 says, “Yet, O Lord, you are our Father; we are the
clay, and you are our potter; we are all the work of your hand.” More
directing his disciples to, “Pray then in this way; Our Father in heaven,
hallowed be your name.” One of many scriptural examples using the image
Page 2 of 17
of Father, the Lord’s Prayer has cemented this image into the theological
Used as the principal descriptor for the first person, the image of
time, are less than beneficial. Elizabeth Johnson asserts that, whether
two things;
Page 3 of 17
solely qualified by the wholesome examples with which we may identify.
The Lord’s Prayer is directed to a heavenly father who grants daily bread to
all people, forgives sins, saves from trial, and delivers from evil. However,
“Soon you will lie down with your ancestors. Then this people will
begin to prostitute themselves to the foreign gods in their midst …
they will forsake me, breaking my covenant that I have made with
them. My anger will be kindled against them in that day. I will
forsake them and hide my face from them; they will become easy
prey, and many terrible troubles will come upon them.”
prophetic works, but we must emphasize that such examples are not
“If God in ‘his’ heaven is a father ruling ‘his’ people, then it is in the
‘nature’ of things and according to divine plan and the order of the
universe that society be male dominated. … Within this context, a
mystification of roles takes place: the husband dominating the wife
represents God himself. What is happening, of course, is the familiar
mechanism by which the images and values of a given society are
Page 4 of 17
projected into a realm of beliefs which in turn justify the social
infrastructure.” 2
there are maternal examples as well. The Gospels record Jesus’ parabolic
of the divine identity, even when constrained to the first Trinitarian person,
circulation of the divine vitality to creation and prevents creation from freely
2
Mary Daly, "After the Death of God the Father," Womanspirit Rising: A Feminist Reader in
Religion (1979): 54.
3
Johnson, She Who Is : The Mystery of God in Feminist Theological Discourse, 55.
Page 5 of 17
The feminist critique of the image of Father is not simply one made
against sexist andocentric ideology. It also recognizes the way such imagery
Concern #2) The first article quantifies and qualifies the image of
Father, using almighty to describe the first Trinitarian person. Chiefly this
familiar with systematic abuses of power or physical abuse within the home,
best.
divine’s use of power in order to punish humanity. Here one has only to
Page 6 of 17
recall the radical boycotts of Westboro Baptist Church or the unfortunate
radical sacrifice of God’s own self on the cross, Christians have their
realities transformed by faith, knowing that God is ready, willing, and able
We believe in one Lord, Jesus Christ, the only Son of God, eternally
begotten of the Father, God from God, Light from Light, true God
from true God, begotten, not made, of one Being with the Father.
Through him all things were made. For us and for our salvation he
came down from heaven; by the power of the Holy Spirit he became
incarnate from the Virgin Mary, and was made man. For our sake he
was crucified under Pontius Pilate; he suffered death and was buried.
On the third day he rose again in accordance with the Scriptures; he
ascended into heaven and is seated at the right hand of the Father. He
will come again in glory to judge the living and the dead, and his
kingdom will have no end. – The Nicene Creed; Second Article
Page 7 of 17
In the description of the second Trinitarian person’s distinctive
interest. We shall begin our examination first with the imagery of lordship
work of Christ.
Concern #1) The most troubling aspect of the second article, for
describe Jesus Christ. Jesus Christ is confessed as Lord, one who sits at the
right hand of the Father, and one whose kingdom will have no end. Feminist
of comfort and safety, these images of lordship and kingdom are instantly
Page 8 of 17
communal organizations wherein positions of authority are employed for the
accomplished in and through the incarnation, this question remains open and
valid. The life of Christ is not depicted within the creedal confession, so we
are also left to wonder what sort of kingdom we are confessing here as well.
In the absence of scriptural assurances within the creed itself, to qualify the
societal norms, such images are also received as threatening and treated with
Page 9 of 17
move on the part of divine to connect with and redeem creation, then we
Concern #2) Within the second article, the masculinity of the first
the specific verb in question, describing the manner in which the first
Trinitarian person begets the second. In the composition of the Creed, this
asserted that Jesus Christ was a created being and was not ‘of one being with
the father.’ Feminists are critical of this verb’s use insofar as the divine is
second person as uncreated and begotten from the first, the most useful
metaphor is that of childbirth. The focus of both the word ‘begotten’ and the
coeternity within the Trinity. Simply put, the most effective way of
conceiving the homoousian connection between the first and second persons
of the Trinity is to consider the relationship between mother and child. When
a mother first looks at her child, she identifies and connects with it; her eyes,
nose, or smile have taken form in this new being which, although being
Page 10 of 17
metaphorical use of the female with the verb ‘begotten’ is useful because it
The feminist critique against this metaphorical theology arises as the so-
of the second Trinitarian person “by the power of the Holy Spirit.” Ecclesial
creedal treatment of the third article. The Holy Spirit is therefore regarded
Feminist theologians however, connect the Holy Spirit with the feminine
Therefore, it is by the power of the Holy Spirit, the feminine creative power
of the Shekinah, that the second person is enfleshed in the womb of the
bringing the male into existence. This is fallacious insofar as it represents yet
Page 11 of 17
is nevertheless an acknowledged mutuality of involvement among
theologians. The second article states that the Jesus Christ came down from
heaven “for us and for our salvation” and suffered crucifixion “for our sake.”
The Nicene Creed was not intended to undertake the variety of atonement
theories, but the questions of feminist and global liberation theologians still
stand. What people are included in the ‘us’ for whom Christ became
males. The salvation accomplished through the life, death, and resurrection
of the incarnate Christ was largely constrained to the spiritual realm, the
Page 12 of 17
The Third Article:
We believe in the Holy Spirit, the Lord, the giver of life, who proceeds
from the Father and the Son. With the Father and the Son he is
worshiped and glorified. He has spoken through the prophets. We
believe in one holy catholic and apostolic Church. We acknowledge
one Baptism for the forgiveness of sins. We look for the resurrection
of the dead, and the life of the world to come. Amen. – The Nicene
Creed, Third Article
the Nicene Creed. Whereas the other articles flesh out the theological
nuances of their respective Triune Person, the third article gives passing
are integrally linked to the Holy Spirit, but their focus here raises an
upon the Holy Spirit? One would have valid reasons for asserting such a
proposition. There is no mention of the Holy Spirit within the first article.
conduit through which the preexistent Logos passed into the physical realm.
concerns regarding the third article. First, we shall briefly examine the
Page 13 of 17
concern is the seemingly static portrayal of the third person’s prophetic
work.
addressed this issue twice before, this instantiation requires only a little more
to be said. The Holy Spirit’s activity in and through the prophetic calling,
subjugation.
filioque clause within the third article is, to put it brashly, a necessary evil.
Its inclusion at the First Council of Constantinople in 381 was to combat the
notion that the Holy Spirit was somehow inferior to the first and second
the clarification that, with the first and second Trinitarian persons, the Holy
Page 14 of 17
Greek Orthodoxy hold a high regard for the third person. Within the Western
church however, it is more common for the Holy Spirit to finish out the list
of divine persons to whom the faithful address their prayers and praise. The
feminist concern here is that, given the rich feminine pneumatology within
the Old Testament, more esteem and worship should be ascribed to the many
and various ways through which the Holy Spirit has worked and is working
in the world.
with the third article of the creed. The third article uses the past tense,
describing how the Holy Spirit “has spoken through the prophets.” There is a
theologians and lay persons alike cry out in wonder, “What about now?
Doesn’t the Holy Spirit speak through prophets and prophetesses now?”
The concern for participation here out-sounds any critique against the
careful to note the difference between the literal concern within the Creed
itself and the spiritual concern of feminist theologians who critique it on this
matter. When the Creed speaks with finality of the Holy Spirit’s speech
Page 15 of 17
promise to which those prophets pointed has already arrived in the person of
Jesus Christ. Christ has indeed come and so the feminist concern must be
hope for “resurrection of the dead and the life of the world to come.”
Conclusion:
consolidating the many and various pieces of Christian theology into one
into which we are invited to partake in discerning the nuances and intricacies
of the unfathomable divine. Again, this effort is not intended to replace the
Creed that give us cause for anxiety or joy. This is a humble attempt to re-
Page 16 of 17
We believe in one omnipotent God, who employed divine potency in
the creation of heaven, earth, and all that exists. We confess that all things
have come into being through this same God, those seen and unseen, those
remembered and those forgotten. We praise the omnipotent God who,
through divine benevolence, has and continues to nurture and sustain all of
creation.
Page 17 of 17