Page 1 of 7

mrunal.org

http://mrunal.org/2012/12/polity-ioa-suspension-from-ioc-national-sports-codecontroversy-implications-explained.html

[Polity] IOA Suspension from IOC, National Sports Code: controversy, implications explained
1. What is IOC? 2. What is IOA? 3. Jurisdiction over Sports 4. How can Union Government regulate sport? 5. National Sports Development Code 2011 6. What does National Sports Code say about elections? 7. Delhi High Court verdict on IOA/NSF election 8. Why did IOC ban IOA? 9. Implication of IOAs Suspension? 10. De-recognition by Government ? 11. Why Archery and Boxing Banned? 12. Mock Questions

What is IOC?
International Olympic Committee. It is the supreme authority for organizing Olympic Games. Created by Pierre de Coubertin (the father of Modern Olympics) Motto: Citius, Altius, Fortius (Latin) =Faster, Higher, Stronger. HQ: Switzerland. Next Olympics:

City Winter Olympics Sochi

Country Russia

Year 2014

http://mrunal.org/2012/12/polity-ioa-suspension-from-ioc-national-sports-code-contro... 12/17/2012

Page 2 of 7

(Summer) Olympics

Rio De Janeiro

Brazil

2016

What is IOA?
Indian Olympics Association. IOA is responsible for sending Indian Sportsmen to 1. Olympic Games 2. Commonwealth games 3. Asian Games IOA is also responsible for organizing National Games.

Jurisdiction over Sports

Constitution of India: Seventh schedule provides the separation of legislative powers

Who

What

Total items 100

List I

Union

Only Union (parliament) can make laws in these matters. Only State legislature can make laws in these matters. Both union + state

List II

State

61

List III

Concurrent

52

And only (Union) Parliament can make laws for residuarymatters, i.e. topics that are not covered in Iist I, II and III Sports, cinema, theatre, amusement: these matters fall under jurisdiction of State List (item No. 33). So the first question is

How can Union Government regulate sport?

For long, the National Sports Federations (NSF) and Indian Olympic association

http://mrunal.org/2012/12/polity-ioa-suspension-from-ioc-national-sports-code-contro... 12/17/2012

Page 3 of 7

(IOA) have maintained that theyre autonomous and independent. Theyre only accountable to their respective international bodies for example, BCCI to ICC, IOA to IOC. Therefore, Government shouldnot, cannot and must not interfere with their internal functioning! But in 2010, Delhi High court gave following verdict: 1. Yes, National Sports Federations have autonomy to conduct sports. BUT international sporting events are an essential part of diplomatic relations (Foreign affairs). That matter falls under Union list, 7thSchedule. 2. Although Sports, cinema, entertainment fall under State List, 7thschedule BUT there are issues such as whether we should participate in a sports event held in a particular country or not? Thatd require diplomatic clearance from Union Government. 3. Therefore, Union Government has full jurisdiction to make regulations and laws on National Sports Federations (NSF) and Indian Olympic Association (IOA).

National Sports Development Code 2011

Ministry of Youth and Sports, created National Sports Development Code, 2011 to set out guidelines for election and working of IOA and NSFs. The National Sports Code deals with many things such as 1. Fair and transparent elections for IOA/NSF 2. Age-tenure limit for Office bearers of IOA/NSF 3. Sexual harassment of Women athletes 4. Selection of coaches 5. Anti-Doping rules 6. Making them answerable under Right to Information Act (R.T.I).

What does National Sports Code say about elections?

1. You cannot serve as President of IOA/NSF for more than 12 years. (4 years x 3 terms) 2. If youve already held any of these posts for more than 12 years, you cannot not compete in the elections. 3. If your age is 70 years or above, youre not eligible for the post of President, Secretary General or the Treasurer of IOA/NSF.

http://mrunal.org/2012/12/polity-ioa-suspension-from-ioc-national-sports-code-contro... 12/17/2012

Page 4 of 7

Delhi High Court verdict on IOA/NSF election

A PIL was filed in Delhi High court that most of national sports federations are mismanaged and have become feudal empires of politicians, they donot retire and keep getting elected again and again. This has led to gross mismanagement of Sports. For example For example, Mr Vijay Kumar Malhotra, age 80 (BJP) has been President of the Archery association since 1973. Similarly the infinitely awesome Suresh Kalmadi (Congress) has been President of Indian Olympic Association for last 19 years. In September 2012, Delhi High Court gave judgement on this PIL and ordered IOA and NSFs to conduct elections according to the National Sports Code.

Why did IOC ban IOA?

Indian Olympic Association (IOA) had to conduct elections, according to National sports code (meaning buddha-log cannot compete etc.). If IOA did not follow National sports code, itd amount to contempt (disrespect) to Delhi High courtss order = Jail time for IOA officials. So they conducted elections according to National Sports Code, in Dec 2012. But Internation Olympic Committee (IOC) did not like it. Not one Bit. IOC had repeatedly told the Indian Olympic Association (IOA) not to follow the governments sports code for the elections because it would imply that Government is interfering in sports. Thatll be a violation of the Olympic Charter and compromise of sports autonomy. Therefore when IOA conducted the elections, IOC suspended IOA.

Implication of IOAs Suspension?

It leads to following consequences: 1. International Olympic Committee (IOC) gives about 90,000 dollars per year to every nations Olympic association + other monetary help in training, coaching, scholarships etc. India will no longer receive it. 2. The officials of Indian Olympic Association, will not be invited by the IOC to attend its events like the Olympics and Paralympics.

http://mrunal.org/2012/12/polity-ioa-suspension-from-ioc-national-sports-code-contro... 12/17/2012

Page 5 of 7

3. Indian athletes will not be allowed to compete under the Indian flag. 4. However, Indian athletes can to compete as as Independent Olympic Athletes But that means whatever new medals Sushil Kumar or Mary Kom wins, they will not be counted as medals won by India. This is not the first time. Other countries have been banned in past

Country

Why suspended? for its apartheid policy (i.e. policy of discriminating between black and while people). For Government interference.

1. South Africa

2. Kuwait

3. Netherlands Antilles 4. South Sudan

for not forming their national Olympic Committees.

But then things are sorted out with dialogues and peaceful negotiations.

De-recognition by Government ?
Except BCCI, no sports federation in India gets earns truckload of money. So they depend on Government for ca$h and patronage. If any Sports Federation doesnt fall in line with Government regulations then Government can De-recognize it. Derecognition leads to following outcomes: 1. Those Sport federations will not receive cash from Government. 2. They cannot use word India while sending teams into international sporting events. 3. They cannot claim exemption in custom duty payment while importing sports equipments from abroad. 4. Athletes who win the tournaments organized by such unrecognized NSFs, cannot claim job-reservation in Railways, Income Tax Department etc under Sports Quota.

Why Archery and Boxing Banned?

http://mrunal.org/2012/12/polity-ioa-suspension-from-ioc-national-sports-code-contro... 12/17/2012

Page 6 of 7

After IOC suspended IOA, the Government of India also got in mood and tempo and has derecognized Indian Archery and Boxing associations. But the reason is different. Recently Archery Association held elections for its president and same Mr.Vijay Malhotra (age 80) got re-elected. Similarly Boxing federations election was not held in transparent manner. So this is against the National Development Code. Besides Delhi High Court had ordered Government that if any National sports federation doesnt follow the code then you must deregonize it.

Solution?
Once Archery and Boxing associations will have conduct elections again, and comply with National Sports Code,then theyll be re-recognized (if there such a word in dictionary).

Mock Questions
Q1 Find Correct Statements: 1. Next Winter Olympics = Vancouver, Canada 2. Next Summer Olympics = Madrid, Spain 1. Only 1 2. Only 2 3. Both 4. None Q2. Find Incorrect Statements: 1. International Olympic Committee (IOC) is a specialized agency of UN. 2. Motto of Olympics is Citius, Altius, Latius 1. Only 1 2. Only 2 3. Both 4. None Q3 Which of the following is incorrectly matched?

http://mrunal.org/2012/12/polity-ioa-suspension-from-ioc-national-sports-code-contro... 12/17/2012

Page 7 of 7

1. Union List

Marriage and Divorce

2. State List

Sports

3. Concurrent List

Betting and Gambling

1. Only 2 2. Only 1 and 3 3. Only 2 and 3 4. Only 1 and 2 Q4. Wrong Statements 1. In 2012, Kabaddi World cup was held at Chandigarh, Punjab. 2. The mascot for this game was JAANBAZ, the eagle. 1. Only 1 2. Only 2 3. Both 4. None Q5. Which of the following is not a function of Indian Olympic Association? 1. Sending Indian Athletes to Asian Games. 2. Sending Indian Athletes to Commonwealth Games. 1. Only 1 2. Only 2 3. Both 4. None December 10th, 2012 | Category: polity

http://mrunal.org/2012/12/polity-ioa-suspension-from-ioc-national-sports-code-contro... 12/17/2012