Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
Lead Rubber Bearing or LRB is a type of base isolation employing a heavy damping. It was invented by Bill
Heavy
damping
mechanism
incorporated
in
vibration
control technologies and, particularly, in base isolation devices, is often consider a value source of suppressing vibrations thus enhancing a building's seismic performance. However, isolated for the rather pliant a system such as a base
structures,
with
relatively
low
bearing
stiffness but with a high damping, the so called damping force may turn out the main pushing force at a strong earthquake. It was a uni-axial test in which the bearing was also under a full structure load. Many buildings and bridges, both in New Zealand and elsewhere, are protected with lead dampers and lead and rubber bearings. Te Papa Tongarewa, the museum of New Zealand, and the New Zealand Parliament Buildings have been fitted with the bearings. 1
Laminated Elastomeric Bearings with one or more lead cylinder / plug in the center are named as lead core rubber bearings where these lead plugs facilitates very effective damping during extreme movements of these bearings. Lead core rubber bearings and how they can help reduces damages of a major earthquake is explained here.
Recent devastation of many earthquakes and tidal wave activities around the world has awakened many designers in construction industry and subject that is much looked up is to design structures such a way that even after seismic activates much less damages can be incurred, resulting less human causalities. are design Few of points raised by structural earthquake with
conventional of
approaches providing
buildings; and
building
stiffness great
inelastic to
deformation a given
capacity level of
enough
withstand
Above can be generally accomplished through selection of an appropriate structural configuration and with careful detailing of structural members, such as beams and columns, and connections between them to not etc... above only to Few basic designers approach have for
recommended earthquake
additional resistance,
strengthen
building
structure, but to look at options to reduce earthquakegenerated advanced forces acting of upon it. Among most important design and
techniques
earthquake
resistant
According alternate
to
the of
LRB
isolators
consist
of
layers
vulcanized
reinforcement
steel plates of limited thickness and a central lead core. They allow the of isolation the of the structure by a proper can
selection
horizontal
stiffness
and
they
dissipate energy up to 30% damping due, to the high damping capacity of the lead core. The damping value of 30% is normally the maximum damping to model the device as linear according to the international design standards.
The
Algasism
LRB
isolators
fulfill
the
following
effects;
-Capacity to support horizontal loads due to service load conditions -Capacity to with isolate very the low structure by displacements. shifting the
fundamental vibration period to an optimal and safe level. -Capacity to dissipate energy to reduce the horizontal
LRB isolators assure the following advantages: No damage to the for structure high that remains due to with the no
elastic
response
intensity
earthquakes
interruption of the structural function. This is a primary goal for strategic structures (hospitals, control rooms, etc) - Very well known and used in many application both for building Very simple maintenance for and mainly all limited the to a bridges periodic life
visual
inspection
design
the
structure
with
consequent
simplification
of
the
structure design
A base isolated structure is one, which is supported on a series of isolation supports, which are placed between building and its foundation. Many structural designers have developed different types of base isolation systems around the world and one of them, which are practical and cost effective, are usage of lead-rubber bearings.
A lead rubber bearing is nothing else but a bigger laminated bearing manufactured from layers of rubber,
sandwiched together with layers of steel, except for that in middle of bearing there will be a solid lead "plug." Top and bottom of the bearing is fitted with steel plates, which are used to attach bearing to building through its foundation. These lead rubber bearings are designed in such a way that bearing is very stiff and strong in vertical direction, but flexible in horizontal direction.
Lead rubber bearings were developed as base isolators in the 1970s. They consist of three basic components a lead plug, and rubber and steel, which are generally placed in layers.
2.1.1 Rubber
The rubber provides flexibility through its ability to move but return to its original position. At the end of an
earthquake, if a building hasnt returned to its original position, the rubber bearings will slowly bring it back. This might take months, but it will return to its original position.
2.1.2 Lead
Lead
was
chosen
because
of
its
plastic property
while it may deform with the movement of the earthquake, it will revert to its original shape, and it is capable of deforming many times without losing strength. During an
earthquake, the kinetic (movement) energy of the earthquake is absorbed into heat energy as the lead is deformed.
2.1.3 Steel
Using
layers
of
steel
with
the
rubber
means
the
MLRBs
are
consisting
of
regular
elastomeric
laminated rubber bearing. The rubber compound can be made of natural rubber(NR) or chloroprene were rubber (CR), On while
usually
European
Standards
considered.
request
other standards like SETRA,ASSHTO, etc. can be applied. The shape can be either round, square or rectangular (Fig. 8 and 9).
The MLRBs are generally constructed with low-damping (unfilled) elastomers with shear-moduli of 0,6-1,35 N/mm and lead cores with diameters ranging 15% and 33% of the bonded bearing diameter for round bearings. The surface
relation is kept the same for rectangular bearings. The elastomer provides the isolation and recentring, while the lead core offers the necessary energy dissipation or damping component.
The maximum shear strain value for MLRBs is generally between 125% and 200%.
The inner steel shims do not only grant for good load capacity, but also for a proper confinement of the lead core.
2.3
Basic
Principle
of
Seismic
Isolation
by
Energy
According to the MAURER Lead Rubber Bearings (MLRB) are based on the design principles of the EN1337(Structural Bearings) and the prEN15129(Anti Seismic Devices). The
and it is a seismic isolator for the seismic condition. The bearing plan shape can be round, square or rectangular, whereas the design rules according to the EN standards were applied.
The production of the (MLRB)s is within the DIN ISO 9001 quality management system. (MLRB)s can be applied for buildings and for bridges. The seismic isolation of a
structure is based on the concept of ENERGY MITIGATION and costly strengthening measures are avoided as the resulting forces are mitigated within the structure.
The superstructure gets de-coupled from the ground. The so called seismic-isolation limits automatically the energy to a minimum to enter the superstructure during an earthquake. Due to this fact the natural period of the structure is increased, therefore reduces the spectral
acceleration during a seismic attack. Depending on the type of the employed multidirectional they grant seismic for the isolators vertical in
this
case
(MLRB)s
load
transmission but also for the active re-centring of the superstructure during and after an earthquake. Recentring means that the bridge deck displaced due to the seismic energy input is automatically shifted back by the seismic isolators into its original position.
2.
By
means
of
passive
energy
dissipation
(=
energy
transformation into heat) the seismic rest energy entering into the superstructure will be effectively dissipated by
10
additional relieving
damping
within
the
lead
core
of
the
MLRB
The four fundamental functions of MAURER (LRB)s are: 1. Transmission of vertical loads. 2. Allowance of displacements on the providing the horizontal flexibility. 3. Dissipation of substantial quantities of energy. 4. Assurance of self-re-centring. horizontal plane
The
first
function
means
that
the
MLRB
acts
as
conventional rubber bearing, i.e. transfers vertical loads in the intended location from the superstructure to the substructure. between The second and or function produces and uncoupling reduces energy, allows
foundation forces
thus
transmitted which is
mechanical uncoupling
essentially
horizontal flexibility of the structure. The flexibility is provided by the rubber of the MLRB.
11
The dissipation of energy limits relative displacement of the isolated structural mass and provides better
structural control with bigger safety for the structure. The energy dissipation is realized by the rubber and by the inner lead core of the MLRB.
The
purpose
of
the
self-re-centring
capability
requirement return of the structure to former neutral mid position - is not so much to limit residual displacements at the end of a seismic attack, but rather, prevent
Self-re-centring
assumes
particular
importance
in
structures located in close proximity to a fault, where earthquakes characterized by highly asymmetric
accelerograms are expected (Near Field or Fling effect). The re-centring effect is based on the natural elasticity of the applied rubber.
It
should
be
noted
that
energy
dissipation
and
selfcentring capability (sometimes referred to as restoring force) are two antithetic functions and their relative
Basically the structural designer is providing certain conceptual requirements of the isolation unit, like for
load capacity, damping, stiffness, etc. and the MLRB unit will then be adapted to these requirement by MAURER.
Research on the development of natural rubber bearings for isolating buildings from earthquakes began in 1976 at the Earthquake the Engineering Research Center (EERC) of (now the
PEER,
Pacific
Engineering
Research
Center)
University of California at Berkeley. The initial research program was a joint effort by EERC and the Malaysian Rubber Producers Research Association (MRPRA), U.K. The program was funded by MRPRA through a number of grants over several years, with later funding provided by the National Science Foundation and the Electric Power Research Institute.
Professor James M. Kelly directed the research at EERC, which included considerable theoretical and experimental
Although not an entirely new idea at the timea few methods using rollers or sliders 13 had been proposedthe
concept
of
base by
isolation most of
was the
considered structural
to
be
very
impractical
engineering
profession. The research project began with a set of handmade bearings of extremely low-modulus rubber used with a simple three-story, single-bay, 20-ton model. Shaking table tests showed that isolation bearings could bring about
reductions in acceleration by factors of as much as ten when compared to those of conventional design and that, as predicted, the model would respond as a rigid body with all deformation concentrated in the isolation system. It was also clear that a certain degree of damping was needed in the system and that the scale of the model was too small to allow more practical rubber compounds to be used.
In
1978,
more
convincing
demonstration
of
the
isolation concept was achieved with a more realistic fivestory, three-bay model weighing 40 tons and by using
damping-enhanced bearings made by commercial techniques. A strong interest throughout the EERC research program was in the influence of isolation on the response of equipment and contents in a structure, which tend to sustain more damage when conventional methods of seismic-resistant design are used and which, in many buildings, are much more costly 14
than the structure itself. An extensive series of tests on the five-story frame demonstrated that isolation with
rubber bearings could provide very substantial reductions in the accelerations the the experienced by internal by the when equipment, structure. additional devices,
experienced showed
that
(such
steel
energy-absorbing
frictional systems, or lead plugs in the bearings) were added to the in isolation system to to increase damping, were the not
reductions
acceleration
the
equipment
achieved because the added elements also induced responses in the higher It modes became of the structure, the affecting method the of
equipment.
clear
that
optimum
increasing damping was to provide it in the rubber compound itself. This by method MRPRA was and applied used in later the in the compound
developed
first
base-isolated
Rubber bearings are relatively easy to manufacture, have no moving parts, are unaffected by time, and are very resistant to environmental degradation.
15
The
bearings
are
made
by
vulcanization
bonding
of
sheets of rubber to thin steel reinforcing plates. Because the bearings are very stiff in the vertical direction and very flexible in the horizontal direction, under seismic loading the bearing layer isolates the building from the horizontal vertical relatively components components unchanged. of are the ground movement to the while the
transmitted
structure do
Although
vertical
accelerations
not affect most buildings, the bearings also isolate the building from unwanted high-frequency vertical vibrations produced by underground railways and local traffic. Rubber bearings are suitable for stiff buildings up to seven
stories in height. For this type of building, uplift on the bearings will not occur and wind load will be unimportant.
16
The first base-isolated building in the United States is the Foothill Communities Law and Justice Center, a $30 million legal services center in Rancho Cucamonga San
Bernardino County, about 97 km (60 miles) east of downtown Los Angeles. Completed in 1985, the building is four
stories high with a full basement and sub-basement for the isolation system, which consists of 98 isolators of
multilayer natural rubber bearings reinforced with steel plates. The superstructure of the building has a structural steel frame stiffened by braced frames in some bays.
17
The building is located 20 km (12 miles) from the San Andreas Fault. San Bernardino County, the first in the U.S. to have a thorough earthquake preparedness program, asked that the building be designed for a Richter magnitude 8.3 earthquake, the maximum credible earthquake for that site. The design selected for the isolation system, a which maximum
accounted
for
possible
torsion,
incorporated
horizontal displacement demand of 380 mm (15 in.) in the isolators at the corners of the building. Tests of fullscale sample bearings verified this capacity.
The
highly
filled
natural
rubber,
from
which
the
isolators are made, developed as part of the EERC research program, has mechanical properties that make it ideal for a base isolation system. The shear stiffness of this rubber is high for small strains but decreases by a factor of about four or five as the strain increases, reaching a minimum value at a shear strain of 50 percent. For strains greater than 100 percent, the stiffness begins to increase again, providing a fail-safe action under a very high load. The damping follows the same pattern but less dramatically, decreasing from an initial value of 20 percent to a minimum of 10 percent and then increasing again. The design of the 18
system assumes minimum values of stiffness and damping and a linear response. The high initial stiffness is invoked only for wind load design and the large strain response only for fail-safe action.
This high-damping rubber system was also adopted for the Fire Department Command and Control Facility (FCCF) of Los Angeles County, completed in 1990. (The same type of high-damping rubber bearing was also used for the Italian telephone company, S.I.P., Ancona, Italy, the first modern base-isolated building in Europe.) The FCCF building houses the computer systems for the emergency services of the
19
The decision to use base isolation for this project was reached by comparing conventional and isolation schemes designed to provide the same degree of protection. In most projects, the isolation design costs five percent more. Not only was the isolation design estimate 6 percent less in this case but is less for any building when equivalent levels costs of are protection first are considered. Furthermore, are even these more
costs.
Life-cycle
costs
favorable. Also noteworthy is that the conventional code design requires only a minimal level of protection that the structures not collapse; whereas isolation design provides a higher level of protection.
The Hospital
of Los
California is an
Teaching
eight-story on 68 lead
concentrically
steel
supported
rubber isolators and 81 elastomeric isolators. The building was instrumented by the California Strong Motion
Instrumentation Program soon after its completion in 1991. The foundation system consists of spread footings and grade beams on rock. Because of functional requirements, both the building plan and elevation are highly irregular with
of the building are connected through what is referred to as the "necked-down" portion of the building, and in the original fixed-base design the irregular configuration led to both coupling between the lateral and torsion vibration modes and very large shear force demands in the slender region between the two rings. (Even in the isolated design steel trusses are required to carry the shears in the
necked-down region.) These were two of the main reasons that seismic isolation was eventually chosen for this
structure.
Isolation used in conventional nuclear plants greatly simplifies the expensive and time-consuming design and
qualification of the equipment, piping, and supports for seismic loading. In addition, when seismic design criteria are increased due to the discovery of nearby faults, for example, the plant need not be redesigned; upgrading the isolation system is sufficient.
In an experimental program at EERC isolation bearings were designed, produced, and tested for two types of liquid 21
metal reactor designs. The first, called PRISM, uses highshape factor isolation bearings designed to provide
horizontal isolation only. In the other design, SAFR, the reactor is supported on low-shape bearings that provide
both horizontal and vertical isolation. The results of this test series extended the range of the isolator types with well-understood characteristics.
22
SECTION 3 RESULTS
3.1
To get a basic idea of how base isolation works with lead rubber bearings, let us examine how will an earthquake act up on both base isolated building where super structure is attached to foundations through a sets of lead rubber bearings and a standard conventional fixed base building where super structure is attached direct to its foundation.
As a result of an earthquake, ground beneath building begins to move. Each building responds with movement: which tends toward opposite side of movement of ground. In
reality buildings undergoes displacement towards opposite side of ground movement. This building's displacement in direction opposite ground motion is actually due to
inertia. The inertial forces acting on a building are the most important of all those generated during an earthquake.
The inertial forces by which a building undergoes at time of a major earthquake are proportional to building's 23
acceleration
during
ground
motion
so
buildings
don't
actually shift in not only in one direction but because of complex nature of earthquake ground motion; building tends to vibrate back and forth in varying directions.
In addition to displacing toward one side, the unisolated changing basically earthquake building its (without a lead rubber to bearing) a will be
shape-from the
rectangle
parallelogram, cause by of
deforming damage to
building. is
The
primary
buildings
deformation
which
By contrast, even though building with base isolation too is being displaced, under different directional
movement of ground due to earthquake, building with lead rubber bearing base-isolation retains its original,
rectangular shape and it will be the lead-rubber bearings supporting the building that will be deformed. The baseisolated building itself escapes deformation and damage-which implies that inertial forces acting on base-isolated building have been reduced by the usage of proper lead rubber bearings. 24
Experiments
and
observations
of
base-isolated
buildings in earthquakes have been shown to reduce building accelerations to as little as one fourth of acceleration of comparable to fixed-base buildings, which each building
undergoes as a percentage of gravity as inertial forces increase, and decrease, proportionally as acceleration
increases or decreases. Acceleration is decreased because lead rubber base isolation system lengthens a building's period of vibration, (the time it takes for the building to rock back and forth and then back again). And in general, structures with longer periods of vibration tend to reduce acceleration, while those with shorter periods tend to
Finally, during and after a seismic activities on a building with lead rubber bearing base isolation, what
happens to lead rubber bearings?. Main body of the bearing, rubber being highly elastic, does not suffer any damages, whereas lead plug in middle of bearing will experience the same deformation as rubber but generates heat and reduces in size, or dissipates, energy 25 of motion--i.e., kinetic
energy--by converting that energy into heat, also thus by reducing the energy entering building. This helps to slow and eventually stop the building's vibrations sooner than would otherwise be the case: helping to dampen building's vibrations.
(Damping is the fundamental property of all vibrating bodies, which tends to absorb the body's energy of motion, and thus reduce the amplitude of vibrations until the
body's motion).
Thus, dissipates
lead the
inserted energy of
as
center
core while
of the
bearing rubber,
earthquake
reinforced with steel plates, provides stability, supports structure and isolates vibrations. LRB bearings also
provide excellent base isolation provided there is enough space for bearing and thermal movements are not too extreme.
Lead rubber bearings can, not only be used with new building but also can be incorporated into foundations of existing buildings.
26
The University of Southern California (USC) Teaching hospital was 36 km (23 miles) from the epicenter of the Mw 6.8 1994 Northridge outside the earthquake. building was The 0.49 peak g, ground and the
acceleration
accelerations inside the building were around 0.10 to 0.13 g. In this from earthquake ground to the motions other structure strong buildings from the was enough in USC effectively to cause medical are
isolated
damage records
the
obtained
hospital
particularly encouraging in that they represent the most severe test of an isolated building to date.
27
After development
a in
slow
start,
base
research first
and large
Japan
increased
base-isolated building was completed in 1986. Although such buildings in Japan require special approval from the
Ministry of Construction, as of June 30, 1998, 550 baseisolated buildings had been approved.
Base several
isolation reasons. in
has The
advanced
in
Japan
for and
research a
engineering
designated construction
specifically companies
isolation; market
aggressively
technology; the approval process for constructing a baseisolated building is a straightforward and standardized
process; and the high seismicity of Japan encourages the Japanese to favor the long-term benefits of life safety and building decisions. life-cycle costs when making seismic design
The system most commonly used in the past has been natural rubber bearings with mechanical dampers or lead28
rubber
bearings.
Recently,
however,
there
has
been
an
increasing use of high-damping natural rubber isolators. There are now several large buildings that use these highdamping bearings: an outstanding example is the computer center for the Tohoku Electric Power Company in Sendai, Miyako Province.
Currently the largest base-isolated building in the world is the West Japan Postal Computer Center, located in Sanda, Kobe ft Prefecture. square) This six-story, is 47,000 m square on 120
(500,000
structure
supported
elastomeric isolators with a number of additional steel and lead dampers. The building, which has an isolated period of 3.9 sec, is located approximately 30 km (19 miles) from the epicenter of the 1995 HyogokenNanbu (Kobe) earthquake, and
29
experienced acceleration
severe under
ground the
motion. was
The 400
peak cm/sec
ground square
isolators
(0.41 g) but was reduced by the isolation system to 127 cm/sec square (0.13 g) at the sixth floor. The estimate of the displacement of the isolators is around 12 cm (4.8 in.). A fixed-base building adjacent to the computer center experienced some damage, but there was no damage to the isolated building.
The use of isolation in Japan continues to increase, especially in the aftermath of the Kobe earthquake. As a result of superior performance of the West Japan Postal Computer Center, there has been a rapid increase in the number of permits for base-isolated buildings, including many apartments and condominiums.
30
SECTION 4 CONCLUSION
After
of
several
experimental
analysis
about
lead
rubber bearing it was proven to be an ideal bases isolation system in terms of seismic event in building construction. Seismic occurrence is more dramatically than other natural hazards because it is unpredictable so that engineers
design this kind of isolator to reduce the damages of a certain buildings and protect the human kind.
As a result of an earthquake, movement beneath the ground of a building begins. Building respond with the
movement: which tend towards opposite side of movement of ground. In reality buildings also undergoes displacement towards opposite side of ground movement. Displacement of building is due to inertia. Inertial force by which a
building undergoes of a time of as major earthquake are proportional to building's acceleration during ground
motion so buildings don't actually shift in not only in one direction but because of complex nature of earthquake
ground motion; building tends to vibrate back and forth in varying directions. 31
In addition to displacing towards one side, the unisolated changing basically earthquake building(without its shape-form the a lead rubber to bearing) a will be
rectangle
parallelogram, cause by of
deforming damage to
building. is
The
primary
buildings
deformation
which
Even though building with base isolation too is being displace, under different directional movement of ground due to seismic activity. Building with rubber bearing baseisolation retains its original rectangular shape and it be the lead-rubber bearings supporting the building that will be deformed.
Experiments
and
observations
of
base-isolated
buildings in earthquakes have been shown to reduce building accelerations to as little as one fourth of acceleration of comparable to fixed-base buildings, which each building
undergoes as a percentage of gravity as inertial forces increase, and decrease, proportionally as acceleration
increases or decreases. Acceleration is decreased because lead rubber base isolation system lengthens a building's 32
period of vibration, (the time it takes for the building to rock back and forth and then back again). And in general, structures with longer periods of vibration tend to reduce acceleration, while those with shorter periods tend to
The advantage of lead center core in bearings is it help to slow and eventually stop the building's vibration sooner than would otherwise be the case: helping to dampen building's vibration. Damping is the fundamental property of all vibrating bodies, which tends to absorb the body's energy of motion, and thus reduce the amplitude of
In U.S. Application response due to seismic activity the University of Southern California(USC) Teaching
Hospital was 36 km(23 miles) from the epicenter of the Mw 6.8 1994 North-ridge outside the earthquake. building The peak g ground and the
acceleration
was
0.49
acceleration inside over around 0.10 to 0.13 g. In this earthquake the structure was effectively isolated from
ground motions strong enough to cause significant damage to other buildings in the medical center. 33
Base several
isolation reasons. in
has The
advanced
in
Japan
for and
research a
engineering
designated construction
specifically companies
isolation; market
aggressively
technology; the approval process for constructing a baseisolated building is a straightforward and standardized
process; and the high seismicity of Japan encourages the Japanese to favor the long-term benefits of life safety and building decisions. life-cycle costs when making seismic design
The system most commonly used in the past has been natural rubber bearings with mechanical dampers or leadrubber bearings. Recently, however, there has been an
increasing use of high-damping natural rubber isolators. There are now several large buildings that use these highdamping bearings: an outstanding example is the computer center for the Tohoku Electric Power Company in Sendai, Miyako Province.
34
Currently the largest base-isolated building in the world is the West Japan Postal Computer Center, located in Sanda, Kobe Prefecture.The building, which has an isolated period of 3.9 sec, is located approximately 30 km (19
miles) from the epicenter of the 1995 Hyogoken Nanbu (Kobe) earthquake, and experienced severe ground motion. The peak ground acceleration under the isolators was 400 cm/sec
square (0.41 g) but was reduced by the isolation system to 127 cm/sec square (0.13 g) at the sixth floor. The estimate of the displacement of the isolators is around 12 cm (4.8 in.). A fixed-base building adjacent to the computer center experienced some damage, but there was no damage to the isolated building.
The use of isolation in Japan continues to increase, especially in the aftermath of the Kobe earthquake. As a result of superior performance of the West Japan Postal Computer Center, there has been a rapid increase in the number of permits for base-isolated buildings, including many apartments and condominiums.
35
SECTION 5 REFERENCES
3.Base Isolation: Origins and Development, EERC News, Vol. 12, No. 1, January 1991. Access at <http://nisee.berkeley.edu/lessons/kelly.html> Access on March 7,2012.
36
5.SCIENCE LEARNING sparking fresh thinking,Access at <http://www.sciencelearn.org.nz/Contexts/Earthquakes/Lookin g-Closer/How-do-base-isolators-work> Access on March 8, 2012.
6.MAURER Seismic Isolation System with Lead Rubber Bearing(MLRB), Access at <http://www.maurersoehne.de/files/bauwerkschutzsystem/pdf/de/prospekt/Prospek t_MAURER_Bleikernlager_englisch.pdf> Access at March 7, 2012.
37