Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
QUALITY OF LIFE OF ALCOHOL DEPENDENTS AFTER COMMUNITY BASED CAMP INTERVENTION IN THE TREATMENT OF PERSONS WITH ALCOHOL DEPENDENCE SYNDROME
Authors
UmeshTonse1, Sinu. E2
INTRODUCTION Alcohol consumption is the worlds third largest risk factor for disease and disability; in middle-income countries. Alcohol is a causal factor in 60 types of diseases and injuries. Almost 4% of all deaths worldwide are attributed to alcohol, greater than deaths caused by HIV/AIDS, violence or tuberculosis. Alcohol is also associated with many serious social issues, including violence, child neglect and abuse, and absenteeism in the workplace. Quality of life has become a dominant theme in planning and evaluating services for people with alcohol dependence. It is recognised increasingly as an important component in the evaluation of alcohol treatment processes. Alcohol misuse is a major cause of morbidity and mortality and an important health care burden, the Quality of Life (QoL) of alcohol misusing subjects has been little studied to date. There are few studies of Quality of Life measures (QoL) in alcohol-misusing patients. When the literature was reviewed there were only 24 studies from 1993 2012 related to quality of life of alcohol dependents. These studies have shown that quality of life (Qol) is improved significantly when subjects do not relapse to heavy drinking, and QOL deteriorates significantly on prolonged relapse (Foster, 2000).
Subjects who sustained 30% or greater decrease in drinks per month reported improvement in physical and mental health component and had fewer alcohol-related consequences when compared to those with a <30% decrease (Kraemer 2002). The most important predictors
Corresponding Author: Dr.E.Sinu, Assistant Professor in Psychiatric Social Work, Department of Psychiatry, Kasturba Medical College, Manipal University, Manipal, India -576104. Email: esinu27@gmail.com
of baseline quality of life were severity of alcohol dependence, employment status, psychiatric history, quantity and frequency of alcohol consumption, attendance at Alcoholics Anonymous(AA), global alcohol health status, age, gender, and education (Morgan, 2004). Alcohol dependents attending AA group meetings experiences better quality of life (93.38 12.91) than the Non AA group(75.06 12.08, t=7.323, p<.001)(Savitha et al 2011). Quality of life of alcohol dependents attending AA group meetings was better when compared to patients attending other psychosocial treatments (Singh et al 2004). Frequent heavy drinking or episodic heavy drinking (five or more drinks per occasion) patterns were associated with reduced QoL. Alcohol dependents had significantly lower levels of QoL compared with general population or with other chronic health conditions (George et 2007).. Quality of life appears to be moderated by socio-demographic and client characteristics, such as age, education, gender and co-occurring psychiatric disorders. Alcohol-dependent individuals experience improvements in QoL across treatment with both short-term and long-term abstinence. Despite these improvements, many alcohol dependents QoL is unlikely to exceed that of normative groups. Among hazardous and harmful drinkers, achieving and maintaining a marked reduction in drinking is associated with significant increases in QoL (Dennis et al, 2005). AUDIT-positive patients reported more physical and psychological health problems and poorer QoL (Richard et al 2006). Alcohol dependents found to have lower quality of life due to high state anger, trait anger and high expression and experience of anger than the abstainers and social drinkers (Sharma et al 2012). Alcohol dependents have significantly adverse effects on their spouses in terms of marital satisfaction, family environment and quality of life(Sangeetha et al).
Treatment and Quality of Life of Alcohol Dependents At treatment initiation, alcohol dependent patients had lower QoL total scores and they scored lower on several subscale scores than those without ADS. Contingency Management treatment was associated with improvement in QoL (Andrade, 2012). Extended-release naltrexone 380mg in combination with psychosocial intervention was associated with improvements in QoL, specifically in the domains of mental health, social functioning, general health, and physical functioning (Pettinati, 2009). As an adjunct to medication compliance enhancement treatment, Topiramate (upto 300mg/d) was superior to placebo at not only improving drinking outcomes but increasing overall well-being and quality of life and lessening dependence severity and its harmful consequences (Johnson, 2004; 2008). Combinations of naltrexone and combined behavioral intervention (CBI), and acamprosate and CBI, each predicted significantly improved physical QoL (Prisciandaro 2012). Treatment with acamprosate and psychosocial support, by promoting abstinence, improves the quality of life profile to levels comparable to those observed in healthy individuals.
2. Prisciandaro 2012
Combinations of naltrexone and combined behavioral intervention (CBI) and acamprosate and CBI, each predicted significantly improved physical QOL Alcohol dependence was associated with poorer quality of life in physical, general health and mental health areas of functioning. At treatment initiation, Alcohol dependence patients had lower QOL total scores and they scored lower on several subscale scores Alcohol dependents with PD had lower quality of life over the entire course of the treatment compared to patients without PD. Quality of life and craving at the initiation of the treatment predicted alcohol use during the first 3 months. Patients with personality disorder perceive poorer quality of life in areas such as health status, mood, and social relations. Self-perception of quality of life is affected by psychological adjustment and beliefs about craving Among alcohol-dependent men with lifetime PTSD, a history of childhood emotional abuse contributes to impairment of QoL Female gender, age > 45 yrs, living alone, working as a labourer, somatic co-morbidity were associated with a low physical Component of QOL. psychiatric co-morbidity, smoking and suicidality were associated with a low mental component of QOL. Ex-Drinkers and high-risk drinkers generally had lower life satisfaction and low health-related quality of life.
5.
Martinez et al 2011
6.
Martinez et al 2010
Quality of life in patients with alcohol dependence disorder with personality disorders: relation to psychological adjustment and craving
7.
Evren 2011
et
al
Lifetime PTSD and quality of life among alcohol-dependent men: impact of childhood emotional abuse
Lahmek et al 8. 2009
Quality of life of alcohol-dependents during an inpatient withdrawal programme. N=414; prospective study Effects of alcohol consumption in spousal relationships on health-related quality of life and life satisfaction. n=3110 couples couples living in partner relationships.
Livingston et al 9. 2009
10.
LoCastro et al 2009
Alcohol treatment effects on secondary non-drinking outcomes and quality of life: the COMBINE study
A higher percentage of heavy drinking days, more drinks per drinking day, and lower percentage of days abstinent were associated with lower quality-of-life measures.
11.
Ponizovsky al 2008
et
12.
Saatcioque et al (2008)
Impact of anxiety and depression on quality of life of persons with alcohol dependence syndrome
Cross sectional study on disability and quality of life respondents with alcohol dependence in hospital based deaddiction services. N=60 Role of Social Supports, Spirituality, Religiousness, Life Meaning and Affiliation with 12-Step Fellowships in Quality of Life Satisfaction among Individuals in Recovery from Alcohol & drug problems (N = 353)
Alcohol dependence, other psychiatric disorders, and health-related quality of life N= 127,308
Respondents with a history of alcohol dependence plus one or more other psychiatric disorders had significantly lower HRQoL in domains pertaining to psychological and social functioning than respondents with alcohol dependence only Health-related quality of life is severely impaired in dependent drinkers. The most important predictors of quality of life is abstinence duration QoL improves with abstinence and deteriorates with relapse. QoL in females is worse than in males, for comparable levels of dependency. Disturbed sleep with depression is a particular feature of the impaired QoL in female alcohol misusers Increase in alcohol related problems associated with lower quality of life
16.
Morgan et al 2004
Improvement in quality of life after treatment for alcohol dependence N=1216; 77% male;
17.
Peters et al 2003
SECCAT Survey: II. The Alcohol Related Problems Questionnaire as a proxy for resource costs and quality of life in alcoholism treatment. N=212
Alcohol use disorders, consumption patterns, and health-related quality of life of primary care patients. N=1333
20.
Daeppen et al 1998
Evaluating health-related quality of life in alcohol-dependent patients N=147; 77% males; 26 -78 yrs
Persons with alcohol dependence scored lower (poorer HRQOL) on the mental health component. Binge drinkers and frequent, high-quantity Drinkers showed markedly lower scores in the areas of role functioning and mental Health Severity of alcohol dependence and depression seemed to influence the perception of HRQoL negatively.
TABLE 1: PRE AND POST ASSESSMENT COMPARISON OF QUALITY OF LIFE OF THE RESPONDENTS IN COMMUNITY AND HOSPITAL BASED DE-ADDICTION CAMP
Camp Quality of life Physical Health Psychological Health Social relationship Environment Total Physical health Psychological Health Social relationship Environment Total Test Pre Post Pre Post Pre Post Pre Post Pre Post Pre Post Pre Post Pre Post Pre Post Pre Post Mean 23.4 21.2 19.0 19.4 10.2 10.6 26.2 27.9 82.0 86.2 22.10 20.66 17.40 19.00 10.46 9.73 24.90 27.00 86.56 83.60 S.D 3.82 .88 3.73 1.65 1.87 2.18 3.95 1.78 9.08 5.42 2.57 2.24 2.64 2.08 2.68 2.14 4.11 2.36 11.7 7.82 t value 2.99 .39 .244 1.88 2.22 2.18 2.57 1.47 2.75 1.38 p value .006* .693 .809 .70 .034** .037** .016* .152 .010* .176 Effect size r=0.3 ---r=0.2 r=0.28 r=0.31 -r=0.29 --
CBDC
HBDC
Discussion
Quality of Life of persons with alcohol dependence With regard to quality of life; both group scored less (82 in CBC and 86 in HBC) during preassessment. This finding is in parallel with Andrade et al (2012) where they reported during treatment initiation alcohol dependents had scored low scores in total QOL and subscales of QOL. Present study found that there was no significant difference between both the camp respondents with regard to the overall quality of life before the camp intervention. This is in concordance with Mary & Pandian study (2008) in which they observed that there was no significant difference between respondents who were availing hospital based de-addiction service and community based de-addiction service. There was noteworthy finding from this study that overall quality of life of the respondents increased in community based de-addiction camp during post-assessment but not in Hospital based camp. After the camp intervention both group respondents significantly scored less physical health QOL when compared pre-assessment score. It may be due to their physical withdrawal symptoms. Respondents in HBC showed significant improvement in their psychological, environmental quality of life during post-assessment. Parsimonious the reason could be that they get their family members love and affection; investing their money. In the community based deiJARS Vol. 1(3): Dec 2012: 277 http://www.ijars.in 9
12
13