Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
EXHIBIT D
King&SpaldingLLP 333TwinDolphinDrive Suite400 RedwoodShores,CA94065 Tel:+16505900700 Fax:+16505901900 www.kslaw.com WilliamF.Abrams DirectDial:+16505900703 wfabrams@kslaw.com
DearSteven: WeconsideredyourMay22responsetoGooglesMay1letterattachingadraftRule11motion. GoogleintendstofiletheMotionForRule11SanctionsAgainstSkyhook.YourMay22letterasserting distinctionsbetweentheclaimsofthe657,694,and988patents,doesnotaddressthemore fundamentalpointsintheDraftMotion:(1)thereisexpressdisavowalinthe657Patentspecificationof nonsystematicscanningand(2)SkyhookscounselknewthatGooglestoppedsystematicallycollectingdata usingscanningvehicles.Despiteknowingthosefacts,SkyhookfiledtheAmendedComplaint,assertingthe 657PatentagainstGoogle.ThatviolatesRule11. Thereisanexpressdisavowalofclaimscopeinthespecification,astheCourtrecognizedin construingthetermcalculatedpositioninformationtorequirethatWiFiaccesspointshavebeen collectedsystematically,i.e.,inamannerinwhichallthestreetsinatargetareaarecovered.TheCourt found: [T]hewaytoavoidarterialbiasinthedatasetcollectedistodriveeverysingle streetinthetargetarea.SincetheinventorsdenigratetheRandomModelas introducingarterialbiasintothedatasettheveryproblemwhichthepatentsaim tosolvetheyhavedisavowedtheRandomModelofscanning.Thepatentsinsuit thereforerequirethatthedatabecollectedsystematically,i.e.,bycoveringevery streetinatargetarea. D.I.96at1516(citationomitted).TheCourtalsoconcludedthatdatamustbecollectedinasystematic fashionthroughplannedaudit.Id.at17(citingtheprosecutionhistory).Thedisavowalofclaimscopeis notaltered,andcannotbealtered,bythedifferenceinclaimlanguageyounote(substantiallyallWiFi