Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
TIME
Table
of
Contents
Deni(on
of
Terms Deni(on
of
Acronyms
Chapter
1:
Study
Background,
Objec(ves
and
Scope
Chapter
2:
Evalua(ng
the
Need
for
Elec(ve
Oocyte
Freezing Chapter
3:
Regulatory
Scenarios
of
Selected
Countries Appendix
3
4
5
9
30
36
Deni8ons
of
Terms
Terms
here
are
dened
for
beKer
understanding
of
the
following
report:
Term
Assisted
reproduc(on
technology
(ART)
treatments
Elec(ve
oocyte
freezing
Ever-married
Intracytoplasmic
Sperm
Injec(on
(ICSI)
In-vitro
fer(lisa(on
(IVF)
Medisave
No
Religion
Pre-implanta(on
Gene(c
Diagnosis
(PGD)
Resident
popula(on
Respondents
Deni8on
Clinical
and
laboratory
techniques
that
involve
the
mixing
of
oocytes
and
sperms
outside
the
body
to
enhance
fer(lity
Cryopreserva(on
for
non-medical
purposes
Status
of
having
been
married
at
least
once,
regardless
of
current
marital
status
ICSI
is
a
form
of
Assisted
Reproduc(ve
Technology
(ART)
IVF
is
a
form
of
Assisted
Reproduc(ve
Technology
(ART)
Singapores
na(onal
healthcare
saving
scheme
which
helps
individuals
set
aside
part
of
their
income
to
meet
future
healthcare
expenses
The
status
of
not
being
aliated
to
any
par(cular
religion,
of
which
free
thinkers
are
included
Gene(c
proling
of
embryos
or
oocytes
prior
to
fer(lisa(on
Singapore
Ci(zens
and
Permanent
Residents
Persons
who
had
supplied
informa(on
for
Clearstate
or
BELRIS
surveys
Deni8ons
of
Acronyms
Acronyms
here
are
dened
for
beKer
understanding
of
the
following
report:
Term
ART
ASRM
BELRIS
ESHRE
ICMR
ICSI
IVF
KICs
KOLs
MOH
MSQH
PGD
Deni8on
Assisted
Reproduc(on
Technology
Society
for
Assisted
Reproduc(ve
Technology
Bioethics
Legal
group
for
Reproduc(ve
Issues
in
Singapore
European
Society
of
Human
Reproduc(on
and
Embryology
Indian
Council
of
Medical
Research
Intracytoplasmic
Sperm
Injec(on
In-Vitro
Fer(lisa(on
Key
IVF
Centres
Key
Opinion
Leaders
Ministry
of
Health
Malaysian
Society
for
Quality
in
Health
Pre-Implanta(on
Gene(c
Diagnosis
Photo: TIME
Chapter
1
Study
Background,
Objec8ve
and
Scope
Study
Background
Freezing
oocytes
(also
referred
to
as
freezing
eggs),
or
cryopreserva(on,
is
a
process
which
has
been
used
in
various
parts
of
the
world
for
various
reasons
to
perserve
a
womans
fer(l(y.
The
process
many
(mes
involves
In- Vitro
Fer(lisa(on
(IVF),
and
the
cooling
of
eggs
to
sub-zero
temperatures
(vitrica(on).
In
October
2012,
the
Prac(ce
Commicee
of
the
American
Society
for
Reproduc(ve
Medicine
(ASRM)
and
the
Society
for
Reproduc(ve
Technology
announced
that
oocyte
freezing
should
no
longer
be
considered
experimental.*
However,
notably,
ASRM
did
not
endorse
the
technique
for
rou(ne
elec(ve
use.
Similarly,
the
European
Society
of
Human
Reproduc(on
and
Embryology
(ESHRE)
has
recently
stated
that
arguments
against
using
the
technology
are
not
convincing.**
The
process
of
oocyte
freezing
starts
in
a
similar
manner
as
does
regular
IVF
treatment.
It
involves
the
s(mula(on
of
a
woman's
ovaries
with
fer(lity
medica(on
before
the
oocytes
are
harvested.
However,
instead
of
crea(ng
embryos
immediately,
as
is
in
the
case
in
regular
IVF,
the
oocytes
are
frozen
to
be
used
to
create
embryos
at
a
later
date.***
References: *The Prac(ce Commicee of the American Society of Reproduc(ve Medice and the Society of Reproduc(ve Technology. Mature oocyte crypreserva(on: a guideline. Fer0lity and Sterility 2012 Oct 12.pii: S0015-0282(12)02247-9. **ESHRE Task Force on Ethics and Law, W. Dondorp, G. de Wert, G. Pennings, F. Sheneld, P. Devroey, et al. (2012). Oocyte cryopreserva(on for age-related fer(lity loss. Oxford Journals ***NYU Fer(lity Center. (n.d.). About the Egg Freezing Process. Retrieved March 19, 2013, from hcp://www.nyufer(litycenter.org/egg_freezing/cryopreserva(on_process
Study
Objec8ve:
To understand Singaporeans perspec(ves on elec(ve oocyte freezing To understand regulatory scenarios in selected countries (Malaysia, Thailand, India and Australia) on elec(ve oocyte freezing To iden(fy and compile sta(s(cal informa(on related to elec(ve oocyte freezing
References: *Ministry of Health. (2006). Direc0ves for Private Healthcare Ins0tu0ons Providing Assisted Reproduc0on Services. Singapore: Licensing & Accredita(on Branch, Ministry of Health . See also, The Straits Times . (2012, April 12 ). Freezing the Egg to Delay Motherhood. Retrieved March 19, 2013, from Health Xchange : hcp://www.healthxchange.com.sg/News/Pages/freezing-egg-delay-motherhood.aspx
Source
of
Informa8on
Evalua8ng
the
need
for
elec8ve
oocyte
freezing
in
Singapore
done
through
various
primary
and
secondary
research
methodologies
Clearstate
Quan8ta8ve
Survey
of
Resident
Women:
The
sample
size
for
the
survey
was
410
respondents
aged
between
20
to
45
years
(95%
condence
level
and
5%
condence
interval
for
a
target
popula(on).
Clearstate
prepared
its
own
independent
and
anonymous
contact
list
to
ensure
that
the
anonymity
of
respondents
is
maintained.
BELRIS
Survey
of
Resident
Women
and
Men:
The
sample
size
for
the
survey
was
206
respondents
aged
between
aged
above
18
years.
The
survey
was
conducted
online
at
www.belris.sg.
Clearstate
had
u(lised
the
data
from
this
survey
as
an
addi(onal
data
source
for
analysis
purposes.
Clearstate
Qualita8ve
Interviews
of
Key
IVF
Centres
in
Selected
Countries:
Clearstate
conducted
interviews
with
Key
IVF
Centres
(KICs)
in
Australia,
India,
Malaysia
and
Thailand
to
understand
their
perspec(ves
on
this
topic.
Clinicians
from
approximately
2-4
IVF
centres
were
interviewed
in
each
of
the
above-men(oned
countries.
Clearstate
Qualita8ve
Interviews
of
IVF
Clinics
in
Singapore:
Clearstate
conducted
interviews
with
IVF
clinicians
in
Singapore
to
understand
their
perspec(ves
on
this
topic.
5
of
such
interviews
were
conducted.
Clearstate
Qualita8ve
Interviews
of
Key
Opinion
Leaders
in
Singapore:
Clearstate
conducted
interviews
with
Key
Opinion
Leaders
(KOLs)
in
Singapore
to
understand
their
perspec(ves
on
this
topic.
KOLs
from
diversied
backgrounds,
who
represent
key
womens
organisa(ons,
were
interviewed
for
this
study.
3
of
such
interviews
were
conducted.
Secondary
Sources
Reviews:
Clearstate
also
gathered
informa(on
from
regulatory
reports
and
medical
journals
related
to
oocyte
freezing,
newspaper
ar(cles
on
policies
or
ini(a(ves
undertaken
by
government
bodies,
views
of
KICs
and
KOLs
on
discussion
forums
and
any
sta(s(cal
informa(on
related
to
oocyte
freezing.
Primary Research
Secondary Research
Photo: TIME
Chapter
2
Evalua8ng
the
Need
for
Elec8ve
Oocyte
Freezing
in
Singapore
Photo:
Santa
Monica
Reproduc8ve
Technologies
Rising
median
age
of
marriage,
rising
propor8on
of
singles,
and
decreasing
age-specic
fer8lity
rates
of
women
below
35
are
seen
to
impact
popula8on
trends
in
Singapore
According
to
the
Popula(on
Trends
2012
report
published
by
the
Singapore
Department
of
Sta(s(cs,
a
total
of
27,258
marriages*
were
registered
in
2011,
which
was
12%
higher
than
the
24,363
registered
in
2010.
However,
age-specic
marriage
rates
fell
for
those
below
30
years
of
age
in
2011;
men
aged
25
to
29
years
and
women
aged
20
to
24
years
experienced
the
largest
fall
compared
to
2001
(Chart
1).
Over
the
past
decade,
there
had
been
an
increase
in
the
median
age
for
rst
(me
marriages
for
both
genders.
In
2011,
the
median
age
for
rst
marriage
for
males
was
30.1
years
as
compared
to
28.8
on
2001.
Similarly
for
women,
the
median
age
for
rst
(me
marriage
in
2011
was
28.0,
an
increase
from
26.2
in
2001.*
Sta(s(cs
published
in
the
report
also
indicate
that
in
2011,
the
propor(on
of
singles
among
total
resident
popula(on
had
increased
to
32%
from
30%
in
2001.*
Age-specic
fer(lity
rates
had
fallen
for
resident
women
aged
below
35
years
over
the
past
decade.
In
2011,
those
within
the
age
group
of
25
to
29
years
registered
the
largest
drop
to
73
births
per
1,000
women,
down
from
96
per
1,000
women
in
2001
(Chart
2).
Source:
Popula8on
Trends
2012,
Singapore
##Age-Specic
Fer8lity
Rates
is
dened
as
the
number
of
births
registered
within
a
specic
age
group
during
the
year,
out
of
every
thousand
female
popula8on
in
the
same
age
group
#Age-Specic Marriage Rate is dened as the number of marriages registered within a specic age
group during the year, out of every thousand unmarried popula8on in the same age group
References: *Department of Sta(s(cs, Ministry of Trade & Industry. (2012). Popula0on Trends 2012. Singapore
10
1
Child
2001
31.1%
36.0%
28.4%
24.5%
2001
2011
2011
20.9% 15.3%
6.7% 9.1%
19.4% 15.7%
3.8% 4.4%
12.9% 10.4%
30 - 39 40 - 49 Above 50 Years
15 - 29
30 - 39
40 - 49 Above 50
Years
Chart 4: Age when First Child was Born Men (n=33) Women (n=102) 42% 39% 28% 15% 9% 10%
6% 0%
18 - 25
26 - 30
31 - 35
36 - 40
41 - 45
11
Unmarried
respondents
had
indicated
that
their
ideal
age
to
start
having
children
is
between
31
to
35
years
old,
with
job/nancial
security
as
the
most
men8oned
reason
for
delaying
pregnancy
Of
a
total
of
71
unmarried
respondents
in
the
BELRIS
survey,
50%
of
men
and
41%
of
women
stated
that
their
ideal
age
to
start
having
children
is
between
31
to
35
years
old
(Chart
5).
Of
a
total
of
202
respondents
(both
married
and
unmarried)
in
the
BELRIS
survey,
the
most
men(oned
reason
for
delaying
pregnancy
was
job/nancial
security
which
was
men(oned
by
88%
of
men
and
74%
of
women
(Table
1).
54%
of
men
and
65%
of
women
indicated
looking
for
rela(onship
stability
as
a
reason
for
delaying
pregnancy
(Table
1).
Overall,
34%
of
respondents
indicated
they
would
delay
pregnancy
based
on
their
belief
that
there
will
be
no
problems
having
children
in
the
late
30s
(Table
1).
Chart
5:
Ideal
Age
to
Start
Having
Children
Men
(n=20)
35%
25%
0%
0%
18
-
25
26
-
30
31
-
35
50%
41%
5%
18%
5%
6%
41
-
45
0%
4%
Above
45
Women
(n=51)
36 - 40
12
Table
2:
Reasons
Given
for
Resident
Women
having
Undergone
Oocyte
Freezing
over
the
Past
5
Years
Number
of
Respondents
For
Medical
Reasons
For
Fer8lity
Treatment
Preserving
eggs
prior
to
receiving
cancer
treatment
Either
family
history
of
early
menopause,
endometriosis
or
premature
ovarian
failure
During
IVF
treatment
3
(30%)
1
(10%)
6
(60%)
Marital
Status
2
single
and
1
married
All
married
All
married
13
knowledge
20%
20%
40%
60%
80%
100%
32%
A lot of Knowledge
(Chart 6) Clearstate Survey, C5: Please indicate Yes if you are aware that egg-freezing can be used for each of the following and No if you are not aware (Table 3) Clearstate Survey, C3: On a scale of 1-5, how would you rate your overall knowledge of egg-freezing technology for women? 1 is no knowledge at all and 5 is have lot of knowledge Base, Respondents who have NOT undergone egg freezing n=400
14
An
increasing
number
of
women
in
Singapore
are
seeking
IVF
treatment
in
recent
years
According
to
a
Straits
Times
ar(cle
published
in
July
2011,
sta(s(cs
from
the
Singapore
Ministry
of
Health
showed
that
the
number
of
women
op(ng
for
Assisted
Reproduc(on
Technology
(ART)
treatments
(with
IVF
being
the
most
common)
had
increased
between
2006
and
2009
from
1,933
to
3,271
(Chart
7).*
Propor(onal
to
the
increase
in
number
of
women
seeking
ART
treatments,
sta(s(cs
from
the
Singapore
Ministry
of
Health
also
showed
that
the
number
of
babies
born
via
ART
increased
by
65%
from
717
babies
in
2006
to
1,158
babies
in
2009
(Table
4).*
Chart
7:
Number
of
Women
Op8ng
for
Assisted
Reproduc8on
Technology
(ART)
Treatments
3,271
2,627
1,933
2,179
Table
4:
Number
of
Babies
Born
to
Mothers
through
Assisted
Reproduc8on
Technology
(ART)
Treatment
2006
2007
2008
2009
2009
Fer(lity
specialists
in
Singapore
interviewed
by
Clearstate
had
stated
that
an
increase
in
awareness,
and
women
becoming
more
forthcoming
in
seeking
IVF
and
other
ART
treatments,
have
contributed
to
an
increase
in
the
number
of
babies
born
via
ART.**
It
is
not
a
(social)
s0gma
anymore
in
Singapore
to
seek
fer0lity
treatment.
Once
they
(women)
realized
the
possibility
of
a
fer0lity
issue,
they
are
likely
to
seek
treatment
immediately.
Fer8lity
Specialist,
Singapore
Awareness
level
is
higher
among
more
educated
people
as
they
are
typically
the
ones
making
the
enquires,
the
recent
newspaper
ar0cles
(on
oocyte
freezing)
have
also
helped
raising
awareness
in
Singapore.
Hence
the
demand
of
IVF
is
on
the
rise
in
the
country.
Fer8lity
Specialist,
Singapore
Reference: *Data source from Ministry of Health (MOH), The Straits Times. (2011, July 23). Fer(lity business booming in Singapore. Retrieved March 19, 2013, from Health Xchange, hcp://www.healthxchange.com.sg/News/Pages/Fer(lity- business-booming-in-Singapore.aspx **Clearstate qualita(ve interviews with Singapore KICs
15
Singapore
IVF
rates
are
lower
than
certain
developed
na8ons;
Enhanced
government
support
may
raise
IVF
rates
in
Singapore
According
to
the
ICMART
(Interna(onal
Commicee
for
Monitoring
Assisted
Reproduc(ve
Technologies),
there
is
an
es(mate
of
approximately
1.5
million
ART
cycles
(IVF
inclusive)
performed
globally
each
year.*
In
Singapore,
the
number
of
ART
cycles
is
lower
than
certain
developed
na(ons.
A
comparison
of
gures
from
2009
indicate
that
Singapore
performed
approximately
656#
cycles
per
million
popula(on**
as
compared
to
some
European
na(ons,
such
as
Denmark
and
the
United
Kingdom
which
performed
2,726
cycles
per
million
and
879
cycles
per
million
respec(vely
(Table
5).*
The
number
of
ART
cycles
per
million
popula(on
in
the
United
States
was
approximately
3.5
(mes
higher
than
Singapore
at
2,361
cycles
per
million.***
Prior
to
2013,
the
Singapore
government
had
a
co-funding
limit
of
S$3,000
per
ART
cycle
for
Singaporeans,
up
to
three
cycles
only.****
European
countries
like
Belgium
provide
reimbursement
for
six
ART
cycles
before
the
age
of
43.*****
Star(ng
from
January
2013,
the
Singapore
government
co-funding
limit
has
increased
to
six
ART
cycles
in
public
hospitals.
Couples
are
eligible
for
up
to
three
fresh
(maximum
co-funding
of
S$6,300)
and
three
frozen
cycles
(maximum
co- funding
of
S$3,000)
of
ART
treatments.
Medisave
can
also
be
used
to
reduce
the
out-of-pocket
expense.****
Table
5:
Comparison
of
ART
Cycles
Per
Million
Popula8on
(2009)
Country
Denmark
Belgium
Sweden
Germany
Italy
United
Kingdom
United
States
Singapore
ART
Cycles
Per
Million
Popula8on
2,726
2,562
1,800
830
863
879
2,361
656#
Sources:
European
Society
of
Human
Reproduc8on
and
Embryology's
IVF
Monitoring
Consor8um,
United
States
Assisted
Reproduc8ve
Technology
Surveillance
Report
and
The
Straits
Times
(Data
from
Singapore
Ministry
of
Health)
#Number
of
ART
cycles
per
million
popula8on
for
Singapore
is
obtained
by
number
of
In addi(on to the men(oned enhanced government support, Singaporeans recep(vity to IVF may also raise IVF rates in coming years.
Reference: *European Society of Human Reproduc(on and Embryology's IVF Monitoring Consor(um (2012, July 1). European Society of Human Reproduc0on and Embryology. Retrieved March 19, 2013, from Science Daily: hcp:// www.sciencedaily.com- /releases/2012/07/120702134746.htm **The Straits Times. (2011, July 23). Fer(lity business booming in Singapore. Retrieved March 19, 2013, from Health Xchange: hcp://www.healthxchange.com.sg/News/Pages/Fer(lity-business-booming-in-Singapore.aspx ***Na(onal Center for Chronic Disease Preven(on and Health Promo(on, Division of Reproduc(ve Health. (2012, November 2). Assisted Reproduc0ve Technology Surveillance United States, 2009. Retrieved March 19, 2013, from Centers for Disease Control and Preven(on: hcp://www.cdc.gov/mmwr/preview/mmwrhtml/ss6107a1.htm?s_cid=ss6107a1_e ****Ministry of Health. (2013). Hey Baby. Retrieved March 19, 2013, from Enhanced Co-Funding For Assisted Reproduc(on Technology (ART) Treatment: hcp://www.heybaby.sg/havingchildren/art.html *****The Business Times. (2012, June 02). When 0me is of the essence. Retrieved March 21, 2013, from The Business Times lifestyle: hcp://www.business(mes.com.sg/archive/thursday/lifestyle/wellness/when-(me-essence
16
Yes 71%
No 29%
#Includes respondents that have gone through IVF treatment but have yet successfully
had a child
(Chart 8) Clearstate Survey, A7: Would you consider In vitro fer(liza(on (IVF) if need arises? Base, Respondents who are Single, Never married or Married/Divorced/Widowed/Separated (with no children or children conceived via natural pregnancy) n=407 (Chart 9) Clearstate Survey, A8: How successful do you think IVF treatments are? Base, All respondents n=410
17
IVF
success
rates
(both
live
births
and
clinical
pregnancies#)
are
seen
to
decline
with
the
increase
in
age
in
Singapore
Ms
Tan
Su
Shan,
Nominated
Member
of
Parliament
(NMP),
directed
the
following
ques(on
on
the
live
birth
success
rates
of
IVF
treatment
at
dierent
ages
in
Singapore
to
Mr
Gan
Kim
Yong,
Minister
of
Health
during
a
Sivng
of
Parliament.
Oral
Answer
by
Mr
Gan
Kim
Yong,
Minister
of
Health,
to
Parliamentary
Ques8on
on
Success
Rates
of
IVF
Treatment
NMP:
Ms
Tan
Su
Shan
To
ask
the
Minister
for
Health
what
are
the
success
rates
of
live
births
arising
from
In-vitro
fer(lisa(on
(IVF)
for
Singapore
women
aged
below
35
years
of
age
and
those
above
35
years
of
age.
Answer:
The
success
rate
of
live
births
from
In-vitro
fer(lisa(on
(IVF)
using
fresh
embryos
was
23%
based
on
most
recent
data
from
2010.
In
par(cular,
the
success
rate
of
live
births
from
IVF
for
women
below
35
years
of
age
was
34%,
while
for
women
35
years
of
age
and
older,
the
success
rate
of
live
births
was
14%.
These
rates
have
been
fairly
consistent
over
the
last
ve
years,
from
2006
to
2010.
On
a
similar
note,
the
clinical
pregnancy
success
rate
of
IVF
treatment
for
women
35
years
of
age
and
younger
is
higher
than
that
for
women
older
than
35
years
of
age,
as
observed
in
the
clinical
pregnancy
success
rates
of
IVF
treatment
reported
by
2
clinics
in
Singapore
(Chart
10
and
Chart
11).
Chart
10:
IVF
Clinical
Pregnancy
Success
Rates
Reported
By
A
Private
Clinic
in
Singapore
By
Age
(2011)##
66.7%
43.0%
28.6%
28.6%
Chart
11:
IVF
Clinical
Pregnancy
Success
Rates
Reported
By
A
Public
Clinic
in
Singapore
By
Age
(2012)##
42.0%
38.0%
16.0%
11.0%
20 - 30
31 - 35
36 - 40
41 - 45
20 - 30
31 - 35
36 - 40
41 - 45
#A successful clinical pregnancy is a pregnancy where the fetal sac is seen in the uterus with an ultrasound aner the IVF procedure has taken place ##IVF success rate varies between individual clinic due to factors such as pa8ent volume, health condi8ons of pa8ents etc.
18
IVF
live
birth
success
rates
using
fresh
versus
frozen
embryos
from
pa8ent
oocytes
While
it
has
been
generally
accepted
that
IVF
success
rates
are
seen
to
decline
with
the
increase
in
age
of
a
woman,
a
clinic
summary
report
conducted
on
all
American
Society
for
Assisted
Reproduc(ve
Technology
(SART)
member
clinics
suggests
that
IVF
live
birth
success
rates
also
dier
when
using
fresh
or
thawed
embryos
from
pa(ent
oocytes.*
The
IVF
live
birth
success
rates
for
fresh
embryos
from
pa(ent
oocytes
declined
at
a
faster
rate
with
the
passing
of
age
compared
to
the
IVF
live
birth
success
rates
for
thawed
embryos
from
pa(ent
oocytes
(Chart
12).
Under
35
35
-
37
38
-
40
Chart
12:
IVF
Live
Birth
Success
Rates
Using
Fresh
versus
Frozen
Embryos
from
Pa8ent
Oocytes
(2011)
46.2%
39.3%
38.4%
35.7%
27.4%
30.3%
24.5%
16.6%
6.5%
16.5%
41 - 42
Above 42
Notably, frozen embryo transfers among women aged 38 and over resulted in a higher number of live births that fresh embryo transfers (Chart 12).
Fresh
Embryos
from
Pa(ent
Oocytes
-
Percentage
of
transfers
resul(ng
in
live
births
Thawed
Embryo
from
Pa(ent
Oocytes
-
Percentage
of
transfers
resul(ng
in
live
births
#
Source:
Society
for
Assisted
Reproduc8ve
Technologies
(SART),
the
United
States
#The
ages
of
the
women
at
point
of
embryo
freezing
were
undetermined
Reference: *Society for Assisted Reproduc(ve Technology. (2011). Clinic Summary Report. Retrieved March 19, 2013, from SART: IVF Success Rates: hcps://www.sartcorsonline.com/rptCSR_PublicMultYear.aspx?ClinicPKID=0
19
The
response
in
Singapore
for
providing
single
women
with
the
op8on
of
elec8ve
oocyte
freezing
is
generally
posi8ve
81%
out
of
410
respondents
from
the
Clearstate
survey
support
single
women
being
given
the
op(on
to
undergo
elec(ve
oocyte
freezing
in
Singapore.
Further
analysis
of
the
Clearstate
survey
indicate
that
a
large
majority
of
respondents
across
marital
status,
age,
religion
and
educa(onal
backgrounds
support
elec(ve
oocyte
freezing
for
single
women.
There
is
a
higher
propor(on
of
single,
never
married
respondents
(90%)
suppor(ng
elec(ve
oocyte
freezing
compared
to
ever-married
respondents
(74%)
(Table
6.1).
More
than
80%
of
women
aged
between
20
to
35
support
elec(ve
oocyte
freezing
while
less
than
80%
of
women
aged
above
35
support
elec(ve
oocyte
freezing
for
single
women
(Table
6.2).
Support
for
elec(ve
oocyte
freezing
for
single
women
has
largely
been
consistent
amongst
all
educa(on
levels
(Table
6.3).
Across
religions,
86%
of
Buddhist
respondents,
75%
of
Chris(an
respondents,
64%
of
Hindu
respondents,
74%
of
Muslim
respondents,
84%
of
Taoist
respondents
and
83%
of
respondents
without
religious
alia(on
support
single
women
being
given
the
op(on
to
undergo
elec(ve
oocyte
freezing
in
Singapore
(Table
6.4).
Table
6:
Support
for
Oocyte
Freezing
for
Single
Women
across
Marital
Status,
Age
Groups,
Educa8on
Levels
and
Religions
(n=410)
Table
6.1:
Breakdown
by
Marital
Status#
Marital
Status
#
of
Respondents
Supports
Elec(ve
Oocyte
Freezing
Single,
never
married
172
90%
Married/Divorced/
Widowed/Separated
238
74%
Table 6.2: Breakdown by Age Group# Age Group # of Respondents Supports Elec(ve Oocyte Freezing 20 - 25 71 93% 26 - 30 72 82% 31 - 35 87 84% 36 - 40 94 72% 41 - 45 86 76%
Table 6.3: Breakdown by Educa8on Level# Primary & Post- Secondary Diploma University Educa8on Level lower graduate 4 72 127 175 32 # of Respondents Supports Elec(ve Oocyte Freezing 75% 75% 85% 82% 72%
42 74%
31 84%
107 83%
1 100%
86%
75%
64%
#Representa8ve samples within each category in the Clearstate survey are slightly higher or lower
than in the respec8ve na8onal propor8ons (refer to Appendix) (Table 6) Clearstate Survey, E4: Do you think women who cant nd partners to marry un(l a certain age (say 30) should be given the choice to freeze their eggs for future use? Base, All respondents n=410
20
Respondent
belief
regarding
the
poten8al
implica8ons
of
elec8ve
oocyte
freezing
on
society
With
regard
to
to
the
poten(al
implica(ons
of
elec(ve
oocyte
freezing
on
society,
66%
of
the
Clearstate
survey
respondents
stated
they
believed
that
Singaporeans
would
delay
gevng
married
while
60%
stated
they
believed
there
would
be
an
increase
in
pregnancy
risks
(Chart
13).
48%
of
respondents
believed
that
allowing
elec(ve
oocyte
freezing
would
have
ethical,
religious
or
moral
implica(ons
on
society
(Chart
13).
With
Singapore
women
becoming
more
career
minded,
this
service
might
be
exploited
by
both
the
medical
prac00oners
and
women
who
might
want
to
delay
pregnancy.
Success
rate
is
unknown
and
the
side
eects
on
the
children
is
also
unrepresenta0ve.
Clearstate
quan8ta8ve
survey
respondent
Will
this
eventually
end
up
raising
other
ques0on
as
to
whether
one
can
actually
sell
the
frozen
eggs
to
some
other
want-to-be
mothers
who
are
not
able
to
produce
eggs
even
during
their
younger
days?
Clearstate
quan8ta8ve
survey
respondent
There
will
be
a
lot
of
outcry
from
religious
organisa0on
and
society
on
the
availability
and
how
it
can
encourage
people
to
go
through
it
despite
knowing
that
the
ac0on
would
be
frown
upon
or
even
not
allowed
in
some
religion
Clearstate
quan8ta8ve
survey
respondent
Firstly
I'm
a
Catholic
so
IVF
itself
is
not
an
op0on
Clearstate
quan8ta8ve
survey
respondent
(Chart 13) Clearstate Survey, E2: What implica(ons, if any, do you think egg- freezing will face if it is allowed in Singapore for elec(ve purposes? (Quotes from respondents) Clearstate Survey, E2.1: Could you please elaborate on your answer to the ethical, religious or moral issues that egg- freezing will face if it is allowed in Singapore for elec(ve purposes? Base, All respondents n=410
21
The
belief
that
elec8ve
egg
freezing
has
poten8al
implica8ons
in
society
for
ethical,
religious
or
moral
reasons,
diers
across
age
groups,
educa8on
levels
and
religious
backgrounds
The
31
to
35
age
group
contains
the
greatest
propor(on
of
respondents
(56%)
who
had
indicated
that
ethical,
religious
or
moral
issues
could
be
a
poten(al
implica(on
of
elec(ve
oocyte
freezing
on
society
(Table
7.1).
The
post-graduate
educa(on
level
group
contains
the
greatest
propor(on
of
respondents
(53%)
who
had
indicated
that
ethical,
religious
or
moral
issues
could
be
a
poten(al
implica(on
of
elec(ve
oocyte
freezing
on
society
(Table
7.2).
The
Muslim
respondent
group
contains
the
greatest
propor(on
of
respondents
(76%)
who
had
indicated
that
ethical,
religious
or
moral
issues
could
be
a
poten(al
implica(on
of
elec(ve
oocyte
freezing
on
society
(Table
7.3).
Table
7
:
Belief
that
Ethical,
Religious
or
Moral
Issues
have
Poten8al
Implica8ons
on
Elec8ve
Oocyte
Freezing
in
Society
across
Age
Groups,
Educa8on
Levels
and
Religions
(n=410)
Table 7.1: Breakdown by Age Group# Age Group # of Respondents Indicated 20 - 25 71 34% 26 - 30 72 51% 31 - 35 87 56% 36 - 40 94 49% 41 - 45 86 49%
Table
7.2:
Breakdown
by
Educa8on
Level#
Primary
&
Post- Secondary
Diploma
University
Educa8on
lower
graduate
#
of
Respondents
4
72
127
175
32
25%
46%
44%
52%
53%
Indicated
Table
7.3:
Breakdown
by
Religion#
Religion
#
of
Respondents
Indicated
Buddhism
Chris8anity
Hinduism
Islam
Taoism
No
Religion
Others
127 42%
91 57%
11 27%
42 76%
31 39%
107 42%
1 100%
are slightly higher or lower than in the respec8ve na8onal propor8ons (refer to Appendix)
(Chart 13/Table 7) Clearstate Survey, E2: What implica(ons, if any, do you think egg- freezing will face if it is allowed in Singapore for elec(ve purposes? Base, All respondents n=410
22
The
belief
that
elec8ve
egg
freezing
has
poten8al
implica8ons
in
society
by
increasing
healthcare
cost,
diers
across
age
groups,
educa8on
levels
and
religious
backgrounds
The
31
to
35
age
group
contains
the
greatest
propor(on
of
respondents
(60%)
who
had
indicated
that
an
increase
in
healthcare
cost
could
be
a
poten(al
implica(on
of
elec(ve
oocyte
freezing
on
society
(Table
8.1).
The
secondary
educa(on
level
group
contains
the
greatest
propor(on
of
respondents
(61%)
who
had
indicated
that
an
increase
in
healthcare
cost
could
be
a
poten(al
implica(on
of
elec(ve
oocyte
freezing
on
society
(Table
8.2).
The
Muslim
and
Hindu
respondent
groups
contain
the
greatest
propor(ons
of
respondents
(64%
each)
who
had
indicated
that
an
increase
in
healthcare
cost
could
be
a
poten(al
implica(on
of
elec(ve
oocyte
freezing
on
society
(Table
8.3).
Table
8:
Belief
that
Increase
in
Healthcare
Cost
has
Poten8al
Implica8ons
on
Elec8ve
Oocyte
Freezing
in
Society
across
Age
Groups,
Educa8on
Levels
and
Religions
(n=410)
Table 8.1: Breakdown by Age Group# Age Group # of Respondents Indicated 20 - 25 71 59% 26 - 30 72 58% 31 - 35 87 60% 36 - 40 94 55% 41 - 45 86 53%
Table
8.2:
Breakdown
by
Educa8on
Level#
Primary
&
Post- Secondary
Diploma
University
Educa8on
lower
graduate
#
of
Respondents
4
72
127
175
32
50%
61%
56%
58%
47%
Indicated
Table
8.3:
Breakdown
by
Religion#
Religion
#
of
Respondents
Indicated
Buddhism
Chris8anity
Hinduism
Islam
Taoism
No
Religion
Others
127 57%
91 51%
11 64%
42 64%
31 55%
107 59%
1 100%
are slightly higher or lower than in the respec8ve na8onal propor8ons (refer to Appendix)
(Chart 13/Table 8) Clearstate Survey, E2: What implica(ons, if any, do you think egg- freezing will face if it is allowed in Singapore for elec(ve purposes? Base, All respondents n=410
23
The
belief
that
elec8ve
egg
freezing
has
poten8al
implica8ons
in
society
in
that
people
will
get
married
later,
diers
across
age
groups,
educa8on
levels
and
religious
backgrounds
The
20
to
25
age
group
contains
the
greatest
propor(on
of
respondents
(71%)
who
had
indicated
that
marriage
at
a
later
age
could
be
a
poten(al
implica(on
of
elec(ve
oocyte
freezing
on
society
(Table
9.1).
The
post-graduate
and
primary
&
lower
educa(on
level
groups
contain
the
greatest
propor(ons
of
respondents
(75%
each)
who
indicated
that
marriage
at
a
later
age
could
be
a
poten(al
implica(on
of
elec(ve
oocyte
freezing
on
society
(Table
9.2).
The
Buddhist
respondent
group
contains
the
greatest
propor(on
of
respondents
(69%)
who
indicated
that
marriage
at
a
later
age
could
be
a
poten(al
implica(on
of
elec(ve
oocyte
freezing
on
society
(Table
9.3).
Table
9:
Belief
that
Singaporeans
Will
Be
Gerng
Married
Later
has
Poten8al
Implica8ons
on
Elec8ve
Oocyte
Freezing
in
Society
across
Age
Groups,
Educa8on
Levels
and
Religions
(n=410)
Table 9.1: Breakdown by Age Group# Age Group # of Respondents Indicated 20 - 25 71 76% 26 - 30 72 71% 31 - 35 87 61% 36 - 40 94 62% 41 - 45 86 64%
Table
9.2:
Breakdown
by
Educa8on
Level#
Primary
&
Post- Secondary
Diploma
University
Educa8on
lower
graduate
#
of
Respondents
4
72
127
175
32
75%
64%
65%
66%
75%
Indicated
Table
9.3:
Breakdown
by
Religion#
Religion
#
of
Respondents
Indicated
Buddhism
Chris8anity
Hinduism
Islam
Taoism
No
Religion
Others
127 69%
91 65%
11 64%
42 62%
31 68%
107 64%
1 100%
are slightly higher or lower than in the respec8ve na8onal propor8ons (refer to Appendix)
(Chart 13/Table 9) Clearstate Survey, E2: What implica(ons, if any, do you think egg- freezing will face if it is allowed in Singapore for elec(ve purposes? Base, All respondents n=410
24
The
belief
that
elec8ve
egg
freezing
has
poten8al
implica8ons
in
society
in
that
it
will
increase
pregnancy
related
risks,
diers
across
age
groups,
educa8on
levels
and
religious
backgrounds
The
26
to
30
age
group
contains
the
greatest
propor(on
of
respondents
(64%)
who
had
indicated
that
an
in
pregnancy
related
risks
could
be
a
poten(al
implica(on
of
elec(ve
oocyte
freezing
on
society
(Table
10.1).
Apart
from
the
primary
&
lower
educa(on
level
group,
the
post-graduate
educa(on
level
group
contains
the
next
highest
propor(on
of
respondents
(69%)
who
had
indicated
that
an
in
pregnancy
related
risks
could
be
a
poten(al
implica(on
of
elec(ve
oocyte
freezing
on
society
(Table
10.2).
The
Taoist
respondent
group
contains
the
greatest
propor(on
of
respondents
(77%)
who
had
indicated
that
pregnancy
related
risks
could
be
a
poten(al
implica(on
of
elec(ve
oocyte
freezing
on
society
(Table
10.3).
Table
10:
Belief
that
Increase
in
Pregnancy
Related
Risks
has
Poten8al
Implica8ons
on
Elec8ve
Oocyte
Freezing
in
Society
across
Age
Groups,
Educa8on
Levels
and
Religions
(n=410)
Table 10.1: Breakdown by Age Group# Age Group # of Respondents Indicated 20 - 25 71 59% 26 - 30 72 64% 31 - 35 87 57% 36 - 40 94 63% 41 - 45 86 57%
Table
10.2:
Breakdown
by
Educa8on
Level#
Primary
&
Post- Secondary
Diploma
University
Educa8on
lower
graduate
#
of
Respondents
4
72
127
175
32
100%
60%
56%
61%
69%
Indicated
Table
10.3:
Breakdown
by
Religion#
Religion
#
of
Respondents
Indicated
Buddhism
Chris8anity
Hinduism
Islam
Taoism
No
Religion
Others
127 58%
91 56%
11 64%
42 57%
31 77%
107 61%
1 100%
are slightly higher or lower than in the respec8ve na8onal propor8ons (Chart 13/Table 10) Clearstate Survey, E2: What implica(ons, if any, do you think egg- freezing will face if it is allowed in Singapore for elec(ve purposes? Base, All respondents n=410 (refer to Appendix)
25
Chart
14.1:
Reasons
for
Interest
in
Elec8ve
Oocyte
Freezing
for
Oneself
(n=91)
Preserve
my
fer(lity
with
my
younger
eggs
to
increase
chances
of
pregnancy
later
in
my
life
It
takes
the
pressure
o
to
rush
into
having
children
un(l
I
am
nancially
and
emo(onally
prepared
Freezing
eggs
as
a
form
of
'insurance'
or
'safety
net'
in
case
of
health
problems
in
future
that
may
aect
or
damage
fer(lity'
18%
60%
Ethical/moral reasons
66%
47%
Planning to have children in the near future I do not think I will struggle to conceive naturally
Others
1%
Others
(Chart 14) Clearstate Survey, D3: If egg-freezing for elec(ve purposes is allowed in Singapore, how likely are you to undergo egg-freezing in the future? Base, All Respondents n=410 (Chart 14.1) Clearstate Survey, D4: Why do you think you would undergo egg freezing in the future? Base, Respondents who are likely or somewhat likely to undergo egg freezing n=91 (Chart 14.2) Clearstate Survey, D5: Why are you unlikely to undergo egg-freezing in the future? Base, Respondents who are unlikely or somewhat unlikely to undergo egg freezing n=125
26
Perspec8ve
among
respondents
on
elec8ve
oocyte
freezing
for
themselves
diers
across
marital
status,
age
groups,
educa8on
levels
and
religious
backgrounds
As
indicated
by
the
Clearstate
survey,
there
is
a
higher
propor(on
of
single,
never
married
respondents
(24%)
who
stated
it
will
be
somewhat
likely
or
very
likely
that
they
will
opt
for
elec(ve
oocyte
freezing
for
themselves
as
compared
to
ever-married
respondents
(21%)
(Table
11.1).
Conversely,
there
is
a
higher
propor(on
of
ever-married
respondents
(35%)
who
stated
it
will
be
somewhat
unlikely
or
very
unlikely
that
they
will
opt
for
elec(ve
oocyte
freezing
for
themselves
as
compared
to
single,
never
married
respondents
(24%)
(Table
11.1).
The
propor(on
of
respondents
who
stated
it
will
be
somewhat
unlikely
or
very
unlikely
that
they
will
opt
for
elec(ve
oocyte
freezing
for
themselves
increases
with
each
ascending
age
group
(Table
11.2).
36%
of
women
aged
41
to
45
stated
that
it
will
be
somewhat
unlikely
or
very
unlikely
that
they
will
opt
for
elec(ve
oocyte
freezing
for
themselves
as
compared
to
25%
of
women
aged
20
to
25
(Table
11.2).
The
propor(on
of
respondents
who
stated
it
will
be
somewhat
likely
or
very
likely
that
they
will
opt
for
elec(ve
oocyte
freezing
for
themselves
increases
with
higher
educa(on
level
(Table
11.3).
Notably,
the
propor(on
of
respondents
who
indicated
that
they
are
unsure
decreases
with
the
rise
in
educa(on
level
(Table
11.3).
There
is
a
higher
propor(on
of
Chris(an
and
Muslim
respondents
who
stated
it
will
be
somewhat
unlikely
or
very
unlikely
that
they
will
opt
for
elec(ve
oocyte
freezing
for
themselves
as
compared
to
respondents
of
other
religious
backgrounds
(Table
11.4).
Table
11:
Likelihood
of
Op8ng
for
Elec8ve
Oocyte
Freezing
in
the
Future
for
Oneself
across
Marital
Status,
Age
Groups,
Educa8on
Levels
and
Religions
(n=410)
Table
11.1:
Breakdown
by
Marital
Status#
Marital
Status
Single,
never
married
Married/Divorced/
Widowed/Separated
#
of
Respondents
Somewhat
Likely
and
Very
Likely
Unsure
Somewhat
Unlikely
and
Very
Unlikely
Table
11.3:
Breakdown
by
Educa8on
Level#
Primary
&
Secondary
Educa8on
Level
lower
#
of
Respondents
4
72
0%
15%
Somewhat
Likely
and
Very
Likely
75%
54%
Unsure
25%
31%
Somewhat
Unlikely
and
Very
Unlikely
Table
11.4:
Breakdown
by
Religion#
Religion
#
of
Respondents
Somewhat
Likely
and
Very
Likely
Unsure
Somewhat
Unlikely
and
Very
Unlikely
Islam
Taoism No Religion
Others
127
26%
46%
28%
91
15%
46%
39%
11
46%
27%
27%
42
14%
50%
36%
31
29%
42%
29%
107
21%
53%
26%
1
100%
0%
0%
#Representa8ve samples within each category in the Clearstate survey are slightly higher or
(Table 11) Clearstate Survey, D3: If egg-freezing for elec(ve purposes is allowed in Singapore, how likely are you to undergo egg-freezing in the future? Base, All Respondents n=410
27
The
most
important
reason
selected
by
respondents
for
not
op8ng
for
elec8ve
oocyte
freezing
for
themselves
dier
across
religious
backgrounds
The
most
important
reason
selected
by
Chris(an
respondents
for
not
op(ng
for
elec(ve
oocyte
freezing
for
themselves
was
ethical
and
moral
concerns
(29%)
(Table
12).
On
the
other
hand,
the
most
important
reason
selected
by
Muslim
and
Buddhist
respondents
for
not
op(ng
for
elec(ve
oocyte
freezing
for
themselves
was
the
large
expenses
involved
(34%
for
each
group
of
respondents)
(Table
12).
Meanwhile,
the
most
important
reasons
selected
by
respondents
without
religious
alia(on
for
not
op(ng
for
elec(ve
oocyte
freezing
for
themselves
was
the
belief
that
they
will
not
struggle
to
conceive
naturally
(29%)
(Table
12).
Table
12:
Most
Important
Reason
for
NOT
Op8ng
for
Elec8ve
Oocyte
Freezing
for
Oneself
by
Religion#
(n=125)
Most
Important
Reason
for
NOT
Op8ng
for
Elec8ve
Oocyte
Freezing
for
0neself
Buddhist
Respondents
#
of
Responde nts
%
Distribu8 on
Chris8an
Respondents
#
of
Responde nts
%
Distribu8 on
Hindu
Respondents
#
of
Responde nts
%
Distribu8 on
Muslim
Respondents
#
of
Responde nts
%
Distribu8 on
Taoist
Respondents
#
of
Responde nts
%
Distribu8 on
No
Religion
Respondents
#
of
Responde nts
%
Distribu8 on
Large expenses involved Physical and emo(onal discomfort in retrieving eggs for egg-freezing Health risks involved Ethical/moral reasons Planning to have children in the near future I do not think I will struggle to conceive naturally Others
12 6 4 1 2 5 5 TOTAL 35
5 2 2 10 3 9 4 35
1 0 0 0 0 2 0 3
5 0 2 1 2 3 2 15
2 0 1 0 2 2 2 9
7 3 2 2 2 8 4 28
(Table 12) Clearstate Survey, D5.1: What is the MOST important reason that deters you from undergoing egg-freezing in the future? Base, Respondents who are unlikely or somewhat unlikely to undergo egg freezing n=125
28
There
are
Singaporean
couples
travelling
abroad
to
seek
fer8lity
treatments
such
as
IVF
Based
on
Clearstate
qualita(ve
interviews
with
fer(lity
centres
in
Singapore,
Malaysia,
Thailand,
India
and
Australia,
Singaporean
couples
are
travelling
abroad
to
seek
fer(lity
treatments
such
as
IVF.
In
general,
the
reasons
for
doing
so
are:
o o o Seeking
alterna(ve
IVF
facili(es
overseas
for
treatment
a}er
mul(ple
failed
IVF
cycles
in
Singapore.
Seeking
lower
costs
of
IVF
treatment,
especially
upon
exceeding
government
subsidy
limit.#
For
medical
procedures
that
are
restricted
in
Singapore
such
as
the
use
of
PGD
for
gender
selec(on
during
IVF
treatment.
Table
13:
Overview
of
Singaporean
Couples
Seeking
IVF
treatment
overseas
from
Clearstate
qualita8ve
interviews
with
fer8lity
centres
According
to
fer(lity
clinics
interviewed,
a
large
number
of
Singaporean
couples
travel
to
Johor
Bahru
for
IVF
treatment
due
to
its
closer
proximity
to
Singapore.
Malaysia
A
reputable
IVF
clinic
in
Johor
Bahru
sees
more
than
30
Singaporean
couples
each
year.
On
the
average,
the
interviewed
fer(lity
clinics
in
Bangkok
see
less
Thailand
than
10
Singaporean
couples
each
year.
On
the
average,
the
interviewed
fer(lity
clinics
in
Mumbai,
India
Hyderabad
and
Delhi
see
less
than
5
Singaporean
couples
each
year.
On
the
average,
the
interviewed
fer(lity
clinics
in
Melbourne
and
Australia
Sydney
see
less
than
5
Singaporean
couples
each
year.
Source:
Clearstate
qualita8ve
interviews
with
Singapore
KICs
#Prior to 2013, the Singapore government had a co-funding limit of S$3,000 per ART cycle for Singaporeans, up to three cycles only
29
Photo: TIME
Chapter
3
Regulatory
Scenarios
of
Selected
Countries
Photo:
Santa
Monica
Reproduc8ve
Technologies
30
Australia
Gender
Selec8on
in
IVF
Prohibited
(except
for
medical
reasons)
Regulated
India
Prohibited
Unregulated,
yet
prac(ced
(legisla(on
ini(ated)
Unregulated,
yet
prac(ced
(legisla(on
ini(ated)
Unsubsidised
(pay
out-of-pocket)
Unregulated,
yet
prac(ced
About
SGD
6,000
per
cycle
Malaysia
Prohibited
Unregulated,
yet
prac(ced
(legisla(on
ini(ated)
Unregulated,
not
prac(ced
Unsubsidised
(pay
out-of-pocket)
Unregulated,
yet
prac(ced
SGD4,000
and
SGD
8,000
per
cycle
Thailand
Unregulated,
yet
prac(ced
Unregulated,
yet
prac(ced
Unregulated,
yet
prac(ced
Unsubsidised
(pay
out-of-pocket)
Unregulated,
yet
prac(ced
SGD
6,000
to
SGD
7,500
per
cycle
Singapore
Prohibited
(except
for
medical
reasons)
Regulated
Allowed (altruis(c) Subsidised (~75% covered under Medicare) Allowed SGD2,500 to SGD3,000 per cycle
Prohibited
Subsidised (Medisave) Prohibited (for elec(ve/ single women) SGD 6,000 to SGD 13,000 per cycle
Altruis(c: No monetary compensa(on allowed Medicare: Australias publicly funded universal healthcare system Medisave: Singapores na(onal healthcare saving scheme Pay out-of-pocket: Payment from individual funds
5. 6. 7.
Prohibited: Banned by legisla(on (law) Regulated: Governed by legisla(on (law) Unregulated: Lack of exis(ng legisla(on (law)
31
Australia
Australia
has
regula8ons
in
place
for
fer8lity
treatment
Table
15:
Demographics
of
Australia
Popula8on
size
Birth
rate
Infer8lity
Cost
of
IVF
Treatment
22,015,576
(July
2012
est.)*
1.9
births
per
woman
(2011
est.)*
One
in
six
Australian
couple**
Out-of-pocket
payment
for
an
IVF
treatment
cycle
costs
about
SGD
2,500
to
SGD3,000***
Opinions
of
KCIs
in
Australia
on
Oocyte
Freezing
Cryo-preserva(on
of
oocytes
is
gaining
popularity,
par(cularly
amongst
younger
women
who
freeze
their
eggs
as
a
form
of
insurance
against
age-related
fer(lity
decline.
Embryologist
strongly
believe
allowing
oocyte
freezing
at
an
early
age
has
improved
the
success
of
IVF
rates
in
Australia.
There
have
been
several
studies
both
domes0c
and
interna0onal
which
support
this
hypothesis.
One
of
the
key
reasons
Australia
has
higher
success
rates
in
IVF
is
the
progressive
nature
of
regula0ons
in
this
regard.
Embryologist,
Sydney
***
Regula8ons on IVF and Fer8lity Treatments Australia is said to lead the world in having the highest pregnancy and live birth rates through ART.*** Australians are en(tled to reimbursement from the Na(onal Health Scheme- Medicare for most fer(lity treatments such as IVF and Intracytoplasmic Sperm Injec(on (ICSI).**** Gender selec(on can be done via PGD, for medical reasons (e.g. to prevent the transmission of a gender-linked gene(c disease). **** Elec(ve oocyte freezing is permiced in the Australia.**** Fer(lity clinics adhere to the Na(onal Australian Health Ethics Commicee guidelines when providing any fer(lity treatment.****
Reference: *Central Intelligence Agency. (2013). Australia. Retrieved March 19, 2013, from The World Factbook: hcps://www.cia.gov/library/publica(ons/the-world-factbook/ **Fer0lity Society of Australia. (2013). Retrieved March 19, 2013, from Home Page: hcp://www.fer(litysociety.com.au/ ***IVF Australia. (2012). Retrieved March 19, 2013, from IVF Australia: hcp://ivf.com.au/ivf-fees/ivf-costs ****Na(onal Health and Medical . (2013, February 13). Assisted Reproduc0ve Technology (ART) Research Council. Retrieved March 19, 2013, from Assisted Reproduc(ve Technology (ART)
32
India
India
is
well
known
for
the
provision
of
fer8lity
treatments
but
remains
unregulated
Table
16:
Demographics
of
India
Popula8on
size
Birth
rate
Infer8lity
Cost
of
IVF
Treatment
1,205,073,612
(July
2012
est.)*
2.6
births
per
woman
(2011
est.)*
15
to
20
million
couples
yearly**
One
complete
IVF
cycle
at
an
urban
clinic
about
costs
SGD6,000
Costs
for
freezing
and
storing
the
eggs
will
range
from
SGD600
to
SGD1,000
a
year***
Opinions
of
KOLs
in
India
on
Oocyte
Freezing****
Cryo-preserva(on
of
oocytes
is
currently
oered
by
doctors
mainly
in
Mumbai,
Bangalore,
Hyderabad
and
Delhi
where
there
is
an
awareness
of
the
availability
of
the
service,
although
it
is
s(ll
not
considered
popular
amongst
women
in
India.
Egg-freezing
is
s0ll
rare
(...)
Awareness
is
very
low
in
general
public
and
even
amongst
doctors.
Those
who
make
ini0al
enquiries
are
more
familiar
but
s0ll
require
assurances
about
the
processIndia
s0ll
largely
being
a
conserva0ve
society,
there
is
s0ll
reluctance
for
women
to
step
forward
and
undertake
fer0lity-related
procedures
before
marriage.
Director,
Private
IVF
Centre
in
New
Delhi
Regula8ons on IVF and Fer8lity Treatments Provision of fer(lity services remains unregulated across India (e.g. age limit of IVF pregnancy) although most clinics in major ci(es adhere to interna(onal recognised as well as Indian Council of Medical Research (ICMR) guidelines.***** The ART Regula(on Bill, dra}ed by the ICMR in 2010 to regulate and govern ART procedures, is s(ll under considera(on by legisla(on.***** Fer(lity tourism in India is growing rapidly, with the reputa(on of aordable fer(lity treatments such as IVF and surrogacy driving this growth.**
Reference: *Central Intelligence Agency. (2013). India. Retrieved March 19, 2013, from The World Factbook: hcps://www.cia.gov/library/publica(ons/the-world-factbook/ **Interna(onal Ins(tute of Popula(on Sciences. (2011, June 27). Retrieved March 19, 2013, from Infer(lity: A growing concern: hcp://www.indianexpress.com/news/infer(lity-a-growing-concern/967209 ***The Washington Post. (2010, August 13). The Washington Post. Retrieved March 19, 2013, from In India, age o}en doesn't stop women from seeking help to become pregnant: hcp://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/ content/ar(cle/2010/08/12/AR2010081206876.html?sid=ST2010081300007 ****Clearstate qualita(ve interviews with Singapore KICs *****Indian Council of Medical Research . (2010). Indian Council of Medical Research . Retrieved March 19, 2013, from hcp://www.icmr.nic.in/ & The Assisted Reproduc(ve Technologies (Regula(on) Bill - 2010
33
Malaysia
Malaysias
market
is
presently
unregulated
Table
17:
Demographics
of
Malaysia
Popula8on
size
Birth
rate
Infer8lity
rate
Cost
of
Treatment
29,179,952
(July
2012
est.)*
2.6
births
per
woman
(2011
est.)*
15%**
The
cost
for
one-cycle
of
IVF
in
fer(lity
clinics
ranges
between
SGD4,000
and
SGD8,000***
Opinions
of
KOLs
in
Malaysia
on
Oocyte
Freezing****
No
laws
exist
regula(ng
oocyte
freezing,
thus
cryopreserva(on
of
oocytes
is
currently
oered
for
medical
as
well
as
elec(ve
reasons
by
fer(lity
doctors.
Egg-freezing
and
embryo
freezing
is
currently
not
illegal
in
Malaysia
and
hence
our
IVF
clinic
supports
demand
from
all
over
Malaysia
and
Singapore.
Infer8lity
Specialist,
Private
IVF
Centre
in
Johor
Bahru
Regula8ons on IVF and Fer8lity Treatments Fer(lity treatment remains unregulated in Malaysia although the Ministry of Health has ini(ated legisla(on in 2011 with the proposal of the Assisted Reproduc(ve Technique Services Act.** The act will address issues such as surrogacy, sperm and egg banking, and sperm dona(on to make the Malaysian market more progressive.** Fer(lity centres will have to be licensed once the proposed Na(onal ART Act is passed.** Dra}ing exercise for the proposed legisla(on was expected to be completed in 2012.** Fer(lity centres are accredited by interna(onal bodies (such as the Joint Commission Interna(onal) and Malaysian Society for Quality in Health (MSQH).*****
Reference: *Central Intelligence Agency. (2013). Australia. Retrieved March 19, 2013, from The World Factbook: hcps://www.cia.gov/library/publica(ons/the-world-factbook/ **ASIAONE. ( 2011, February 27). ASIAONE. Retrieved March 21, 2013, from Laws on fer(lity treatment by 2012: hcp://www.asiaone.com/Health/News/Story/A1Story20110227-265537.html ***Borneo Post. (2012, April 25). Retrieved March 19, 2013, from IVF triplets born at Raja Permaisuri Bainun Hospital: hcp://www.theborneopost.com/2012/04/25/ivf-triplets-born-at-raja-permaisuri-bainun-hospital/ cp://www.theborneopost.com/2012/04/25/ivf-triplets-born-at-raja-permaisuri-bainun-hospital/ ****Clearstate qualita(ve survey of key opinion leaders *****Malaysian Society for Quality in Health. (2011). Retrieved March 19, 2013, from Malaysian Society for Quality in Health: hcp://www.msqh.com.my/web/
34
Thailand
Thailand
is
well
known
for
the
provision
of
fer8lity
treatments
but
remains
unregulated
Table
18:
Demographics
of
Thailand
Popula8on
size:
Birth
rate:
Cost
of
Treatment
67,091,089
(July
2012
est.)*
1.6
births
per
woman
(2011
est.)*
Thailand
is
considered
a
major
fer(lity
tourism
hub
in
the
region
with
its
price
compe((veness
for
IVF
being
between
SGD6,000
to
SGD7,500
per
cycle**
Opinions
of
KOLs
in
Thailand
on
Oocyte
Freezing**
Cryo-preserva(on
of
oocytes
is
currently
oered
by
doctors
but
mainly
targeted
foreign
pa(ents
due
to
low
awareness
among
and
aordability
to
local
pa(ents.
Oocyte
freezing
is
quite
a
new
concept
to
Thai
people.
Addi0onally,
IVF
treatments
are
not
reimbursable
for
Thais.
Hence,
there
is
no
demand
for
such
procedures
locally.
We
mainly
get
enquires
from
foreign
pa0ents.
Singaporeans
form
a
small
propor0on
of
these
(foreign)
pa0ents.
Infer8lity
Specialist,
Public
IVF
Centre
in
Bangkok
Regula8ons on IVF and Fer8lity Treatments There are currently no laws governing fer(lity treatment in Thailand but doctors adhere to medical and ethical guidelines set out by the Thai Medical Council and Royal Thai College of Obstetricians and Gynaecologists (RTCOG).*** IVF treatments are largely popular amongst overseas pa(ents as they are typically able to enjoy reimbursement from their individual insurance schemes.** Thailand is one of the few countries in the region that allows gender selec(on treatment via PGD.*** The availability of PGD has acracted pa(ents from countries where gender selec(on is not allowed (including Singapore**** and India*****).
Reference: *Central Intelligence Agency. (2013). Australia. Retrieved March 19, 2013, from The World Factbook: hcps://www.cia.gov/library/publica(ons/the-world-factbook/ **Clearstate qualita(ve survey of key opinion leaders ***Chiang Mai University. (2007). Surveillance of ART and PGD prac0ce in Thailand. Chiang Mai ****Straits Times (2011, August 21). Straits Times. Retrieved March 23, 2013, Gender spenders: hcp://www.healthxchange.com.sg/News/Pages/Gender-spenders.aspx *****The Times of India. (2010, December 27). The Times of India. Retrieved March 19, 2013, from To ensure prized baby boy, Indians ock to Bangkok: hcp://ar(cles.(mesondia.india(mes.com/2010-12-27/india/ 28239140_1_indian-couples-indians-ock-baby-boy
35
Photo: TIME
APPENDIX
36
Married, Men Age Group 26 30 31 35 36 40 41 45 # of Respondents 2 5 10 7 9 33 Married, Women Age Group 26 30 31 35 36 40 41 45 Above 46 TOTAL # of Respondents 6 13 18 42 23 102 % Distribu8on 6% 13% 18% 41% 22% 100% % Distribu8on 6% 15% 30% 21% 28% 100%
Not Married, Women Age Group 18 25 26 30 31 35 36 40 41 45 Above 46 TOTAL # of Respondents 14 11 12 9 2 3 51 % Distribu8on 28% 22% 23% 17%. 4% 6% 100%
Above 46
Married 66%
TOTAL
BELRIS Survey, Ques(on: What is your gender? How old are you? Base, All respondents n=206
37
38
37.1%
58.0%
42.0%
#Latest available data on resident women aged between 20 to 44 from the Singapore Department of Sta8s8cs. Censuses of Popula8on are conducted once in every ten years by the Singapore Department of Sta8s8cs
References: *Department of Sta(s(cs, Ministry of Trade & Industry. (2010). The Census of Popula0on 2010 . Singapore
Clearstate Survey, A5: What is your current marital status? Base, All respondents n=410
39
21.9%
21.4%
22.9%
21.0%
20 - 25 years
26 - 30 years
31 - 35 years
36 - 40 years
41 - 45 years
Respondents
Na(onal Propor(on
References: *Department of Sta(s(cs, Ministry of Trade & Industry. (2012). Popula0on Trends 2012. Singapore
Clearstate Survey, S3: Which age bracket do you fall under? Base, All respondents n=410
40
37.6%
27.9%
50.4%
22.4%
12.2%
17.6%
1.0%
University
&
Above
##
31.0%
Diploma Respondents
Secondary
Na(onal Propor(on
#Latest available data on resident non-student women aged between 20 to 44 from the Singapore Department of Sta8s8cs. Censuses of Popula8on are conducted once in every ten years by the Singapore Department of
Sta8s8cs ##Includes University (42.6%) and Post-graduate (7.8%) respondents References: *Department of Sta(s(cs, Ministry of Trade & Industry. (2010). The Census of Popula0on 2010 . Singapore
Clearstate Survey, A1: What is the highest level of educa(on you have completed? Base, All respondents n=410
41
20.3% 15.0% 22.2% 6.1% 10.2% 2.7% Buddhism Chris8anity Hinduism Respondents Islam
18.7%
31.0%
Na(onal Propor(on
#Latest available data on resident women aged between 20 to 44 from the Singapore Department of Sta8s8cs. Censuses of Popula8on are conducted once in every ten years by the Singapore Department of Sta8s8cs
References: *Department of Sta(s(cs, Ministry of Trade & Industry. (2010). The Census of Popula0on 2010 . Singapore
Clearstate Survey, A3: What is your religious alia(on? Base, All respondents n=410
42
healthcare"
www.clearstate.com
www.eiu.com
43