Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
© 2009 HVS
1
Major Sales Transactions (> $10 Million)
2
Major Hotel Sales Transactions
350 $300,000
300 $250,000
250
$200,000
200
$150,000
150
$100,000
100
50 $50,000
0 $0
90
91
92
93
94
95
96
97
98
99
00
01
02
03
04
05
06
07
YT 4 /3 08
ar
4/ 9
0
D 0 /0
/1
Ye
19
19
19
19
19
19
19
19
19
19
20
20
20
20
20
20
20
20
D 20
30
YT
Number Avg. Price
© 2009 HVS
3
Sales Not Good Indicator of Value
4
3r
d
Q
5.0
6.0
7.0
8.0
9.0
10.0
11.0
12.0
13.0
14.0
1s tr 1
t Q 99
© 2009 HVS
3r tr 1 4
d
Q 99
1s tr 1 5
t Q 99
3r tr 1 5
d
Q 99 6
1s tr 1
t Q 99
3r tr 1 6
d
Q 99 7
1s tr 1
Regional Mall
t Q 99
3r tr 1 7
d
Q 99
Full-Service Lodging
1s tr 1 8
t Q 99
3r tr 1 8
d
Q 99 9
1s tr 1
PWC – Korpacz Investor Survey
t Q 99
3r tr 2 9
d
Q 00 0
1s tr 2
t Q 00
CBD Office
3r tr 2 0
d
Q 00
1s tr 2 1
t Q 00
3r tr 2 1
d
Limited-Service Lodging
Q 00
1s tr 2 2
Quarter
t Q 00
Cap Rate Com parison
3r tr 2 2
d
Q 00 3
1s tr 2
t Q 00
3r tr 2 3
d
Q 00 4
1s tr 2
Luxury Lodging t Q 00
Suburban Office
3r tr 2 4
d
Q 00
Capitalization Rate Comparison
1s tr 2 5
t Q 00
3r tr 2 5
d
Q 00
1s tr 2 6
t Q 00
3r tr 2 6
d
Q 00 7
Apartment
1s tr 2
t Q 00
3r tr 2 7
d
Q 00 8
1s tr 2
t Q 00
tr 8
20
09
5
Investor Survey Data
6
Cap Rates Derived from Key Operating and Balance Sheet
Data for Publicly Traded Hotel REITS - Last 12 Mos.
© 2009 HVS
7
Historical Cap Rates – Select Set of Full
Service Hotels
Cap Rate based on Cap Rate based on Free and Clear Equity
Year Historical NOI 1st Yr. Projected NOI Discount Rate Yield
1988 9.1 9.7 14.7 21.4
1989 9.5 9.4 17.6 28.8
1990 8.0 10.0 15.1 22.4
1991 6.4 8.9 19.4 24.0
1992 4.8 7.7 15.1 21.9
1993 8.5 12.0 20.8 34.3
1994 5.7 8.3 14.8 21.8
1995 7.0 11.1 14.1 20.5
1996 7.0 9.8 13.5 21.4
1997 9.3 10.5 15.4 23.9
1998 8.8 9.7 14.5 22.2
1999 10.3 11.4 15.5 24.9
2000 9.2 10.4 14.0 21.0
2001 8.2 9.8 14.6 22.2
2002 8.9 9.8 13.6 21.0
2003 7.9 8.2 14.0 21.4
2004 5.8 7.4 12.2 19.7
2005 5.2 6.9 11.4 19.7
2006 5.5 5.7 10.8 18.9
2007 6.0 6.8 11.6 21.3
2008 6.6 5.3 11.9 20.0
9
Capitalization and Discount Rates –
Select Set of Full Service Hotels
40.0
35.0
30.0
25.0
20.0
15.0
10.0
5.0
0.0
1988 1989 1990 1991 1992 1993 1994 1995 1996 1997 1998 1999 2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008
Free and Clear Discount Rate Equity Yield Cap Rate based on Historical NOI Cap Rate based on 1st Yr. Projected NOI
3.0
4.0
5.0
6.0
7.0
8.0
9.0
10.0
1s tr 1
t Q 99
4
3r tr 1
d 99
Q 5
1s tr 1
t Q 99
5
3r tr 1
d 99
Q 6
1s tr 1
t Q 99
6
3r tr 1
d 99
Q 7
1s tr 1
t Q 99
7
3r tr 2
d 00
Q 5
1s tr 2
t Q 00
5
Hotel Mortgage and T-Bill Rates
3r tr 2
d 00
Q 6
1s tr 2
t Q 00
6
3r tr 2
d 00
Q 7
1s tr 2
t Q 00
7
3r tr 2
d 00
Q
tr 8
20
08
11
Debt Component More Expensive and Less
Available
12
U.S. CMBS Volume by Year
© 2009 HVS
13
Sample Valuation - Forecast of Income and Expense
© 2009 HVS
14
Valuation of Sample Hotel at Market Peak (2007)
© 2009 HVS
15
Value Based on Current More
Onerous Investment Parameters
© 2009 HVS
16
Change in Value at Current Rates
% Change
Recent Peak Current Recent Peak
Value Available to Current
Valuation Inputs: Mid-2007 Rates Available
Valuation Outputs:
© 2009 HVS
17
Assumed Refinancing in Future Moderates
Value Loss
18
Stabilized Value – Normalized Lending
© 2009 HVS
19
Refinancing Proceeds
© 2009 HVS
20
Reversion at End of Ten Year Holding Period
© 2009 HVS
21
Forecast of Total Cash Flow to Equity
© 2009 HVS
22
Cash Flow to Equity Plus Initial
Mortgage = Value
Net Income Present Worth of $1 Discounted
Year to Equity Factor at 19.0% Cash Flow
10th year net income to equity of $3,696,000 plus sales proceeds of $41,866,000
© 2009 HVS
23
Discount Rate Equating Cash Flow to Value
© 2009 HVS
24
DCR and Cash on Cash Return
Debt Cash on
Coverage Cash
Year Ratio Return
© 2009 HVS
25
Conclusion: Cap Rates Down in 2009 Due to Depressed
NOI, Overall Rates of Return Up, Values Down
Valuation Outputs:
Value Per Room $230,000 $134,000 -41.7% $146,000 -36.5%
Discount Rate 10.6% 15.5% 490 bps 13.5% 290 bps
Implied Cap Rate 7.6% 12.5% 490 bps 10.5% 290 bps
Derived Cap Rate:
Historical NOI 6.6% 10.7% 300 bps 9.9% 270 bps
1st Year Proj. NOI 6.8% 7.1% -40 bps 6.6% -110 bps
© 2009 HVS
26
Suzanne R. Mellen, MAI, CRE, FRICS is the founding principal and Managing
Director of HVS - San Francisco. She also heads up the firm’s Gaming Services
Division, which specializes in the valuation and evaluation of gaming
properties, and HVS’ newest office in Las Vegas. Prior to establishing the San
Francisco office in 1985, Ms. Mellen was Director of Consulting and Valuation
Services for the firm in New York. Her professional experience includes
positions with Morgan Guaranty Trust, Laventhol & Horwath and Helmsley-
Spear and with Harley-Little Associates. She gained her operational experience
with Westin Hotels.
Suzanne R. Mellen, Biography
Ms. Mellen has a BS degree in Hotel Administration from Cornell University and
holds the following designations: MAI (Appraisal Institute), CRE (Counselors of
Real Estate), FRICS (Royal Institute of Chartered Surveyors) and ISHC
(International Society of Hospitality Consultants). She has been appraising
hotels and related real estate for over 30 years, has authored numerous
articles and is a frequent lecturer and expert witness on the valuation of hotels,
casinos and related issues. She developed the Simultaneous Valuation Formula,
a mortgage-equity income capitalization formula for variable income properties,
as well as the refinancing model currently utilized by the firm.
© 2009 HVS
27
HVS
© 2009 HVS
28
Please call with any questions!
Thank You
© 2009 HVS
29