1

MEDICAL COUNCIL OF INDIA NEW DELHI

Minutes of the 3rd meeting of the re-constituted Board of Governors dated 04.06.2013 at 11.00 in the Councils Chamber at Sector-8, Pocket-14, Dwarka, New Delhi 110077, under the Chairmanship of Dr. R.K. Srivastava, Chairman, Board of Governors. The following members of the Board of Governors attended the meeting:1) 2) 3) 4) 5) 6) Dr. Kottilil Mohandas, Member, Dr. Raja Babu Panwar, Member, Dr. A.K. Bardhan, Member, Dr. Manoj K.Singh, Dr. Brijendra Kumar Rao, Member Dr. K.S. Sharma and Dr. R.P. Meena, Member Secretary

At the outset, Dr. K.Mohandas, Member, Board of Governors pointed out that the cases rejected in the meeting of the Board of Governors on 29.05.2013 (Item Nos. 6, 11 & 14) could possibly be given an opportunity of personal hearing before they are rejected. On this, all the Board Members agreed and it was decided to call the Medical colleges for personal hearing on next meeting of the Board. Secretary will intimate the colleges indicating time and date.

Subsequently, following items, as per the table appended below, were discussed and the decision of the Board of Governors were recorded as shown against each item.

2 Items: Status of consideration of inspection Reports for establishment of new medical colleges (for MBBS seats)/Inspection Report for recognition of MBBS seats/Inspection Reports for renewal of permission. UNDERGRADUATE COMMITTEE (I & II) AT ITS MEETING HELD ON 13th & 14th MAY, 2013 CONSIDERED THE FOLLOWING ITEMS:

S. No. 1.

Govt. / Pvt. Govt.

Name of the College

Type of Assessment

Deficiencies as per UG committee Faculty shortage by 18.51%. The department wise shortage is as under: (i) Professor: (a) 01 General Surgery (b) 01 Medicine (c) 01 - OBG (ii) Assistant Professor: (a) 02 Physiology (b) 01 Dermatology (c) 01 Anaesthesia (d) 02 OBG Associate Professor: (a) 01 Anatomy (b) 01 Biochemistry (c) 01 Pathology (d) 01 Community Medicine (e) 01 Surgery (f) 01 Medicine (g) 01 OBG (h) 01 Physiatrist (i) 01 Orthopaedic

BOG decision In view of the major deficiencies pointed out, College be given an opportunity of hearing to explain the deficiencies and shortage of infrastructure.

Establishment of new LOI / LOP for 100 1. medical college at seats Bettiah, West Champaran, Bihar

(iii)

2. (i)

Resident shortage by 66.7%. The department wise shortage is as under: Senior Residents:

3 (a) (b) (c) (d) (ii) (a) (b) (c) (d) (e) 3. 4. (a) (b) (c) 5. 6. 7. 8. 9. 03 Medicine 05 General Surgery 01 OBG 01 ENT Junior Residents: 08 Medicine 02 - ______ 08 Surgery 01 OBG 01 - ENT Inadequate Lecture Theatre (2 x 50 LTs available as against the requirement of 2 x 120). In Central Library: Inadequate area (80 sq. mt. available as against the requirement of 1600 sq. m.). Shortage of Books by 1290 (110 books available as against the requirement of 1400). No information available with regard to Journals. No information available with regard to hostel accommodation for Residents & Nurses. No information available with regard to Residential quarters for teaching & non-teaching staff. Obstetrics ward is on 1st floor without lift. OPD attendance _________________ Bed occupancy - 13035 as a document submitted average of Feb. March, April no OPD figure of the day of assessment is available. Non functional Hospital as per assessment report. No beds available in the department of Skin V.D. and psychiatry. In Clinical Material: Shortage of 02 Major OTs. Shortage of 01 Minor OT. No ICU/ICCU and PICU/NICU beds available. In Radiology Department shortage of : 1 x 500 mA Static x-ray unit. 1 x 30 mA Mobile x-ray unit.

10. 11. (a) (b) (c) 12. (a) (b)

4 (c) No USG machines available, as against the requirement of 02 USG machines. 13. No information about the AERB & PNDT approval. 14. Shortage of Paramedical & Non Teaching staff by 81 (20 available as against the requirement of 101). 15. Shortage of Nursing staff by 25 (150 available as against the requirement of 175). 16. Departmental Labs: 02 Physiology labs are under construction. 17. Inadequate Central Laboratories, as it is outsourced. 18. No transport facility for the staff and students available in RHTC & UHTC. 19. Due to no electricity non functional hospital as per assessors reports. 20. No ECG room in OPD. 2. Govern ment Establishment of new LOI / LOP for 100 1. medical college at seats Azamgarh, U.P. Faculty shortage by 9.25%. The department wise shortage is as under: (i) Professor: (a) Anatomy -1, (ii) Associate Prof. (a) Microbiology 1, (b) Surgery 1, (c) OG 1, (iii) Assistant Prof (a) Radio Diagnosis 1. Resident shortage by 10.41%. The department wise shortage is as under: Surgery 1, Radio-Diagnosis 2 (Declaration Forms TB, Psy. & Derm. not available). In Central Library: Inadequate area (1500 sq. mt. available as against the

Approved subject to undertaking by the state Chief Secretary. Undertaking will contain the following, unless otherwise indicated: 1. An assurance that the shortage of faculty and infrastructure will be rectified before the start of the admissions. 2. Documentary proof of the budget allotment for the proposed projects aimed to rectify the deficiencies pointed out in the Assessors report.

2. (i) (ii)

3. (a)

5 (b) 4. 5. requirement of 1600 sq. m.). Total 35 Journals available, but distribution of Indian + Foreign are not given. Inadequate Bed occupancy (37.45% bed occupancy available as against the requirement of 60%). In Radiology department : shortage of 1 x 30 mA mobile xray unit. Not mentioned in Form A, Form B as well as in the assessors report. AERB & PNDT approval applied for. Paramedical Staff: 64+519 (out sourced) available as against the requirement of 101. Although total number of Nursing Staff is adequate, but no Nursing Supdt., Dy. Nursing Supdt and Asstt. Dy. Nursing Supdt. Blood Bank under construction. Mobile unit 30 mA not available in Form A, Form B assessors report. Approved subject to assurance/undertaking by the ESIC authorities to correct the deficiencies pointed out.

6. 7. 8.

9. 10.

3.

Govern ment (ESIC)

Establishment of new LOI / LOP for 100 medical college at seats Joka Kolkata, West Bengal

1. Faculty : Shortage of 1 AP in pharmacology 2. Resident: Shortage of JRS in Medicine (2) and Surgery (3) 3. In Central Library : (i) seating capacity not mentioned (ii) Shortage of books by 96 (in number). (iii) Inadequate Journals (Indian + Foreign) (college have 09 journals as against the requirement of 14+06 journals (Indian + Foreign) respectively.) 4. Hostel accommodation for students Girls hostel being furnished UG committee remarks. 5. Shortage of 06 hostel accommodation for Residents (UG committee remarks to be furnished shortly). 6. Inadequate Hostel accommodation for Nurses (UG Committee to be furnished shortly). 7. PNDT validity expired. Application for renewal is not

6 attached. 8. Blood Bank License copy not attached 9. Radiology Faculty declaration forms not available 4. Trust Adichunchanagiri Increase of MBBS 1. PNDT Approval No documentary proof. Deferred. Institute of Medical seats from 100 to 150 2. OPD No. of patient and bed occupancy is on average basis. On the day of assessment, OPD number is not mentioned but written Sciences, Bellur, adequate. Karnataka Rangaraya Medical Increase of MBBS College, Kakinada, seats from 150 to 200 & A.P Compliance Verification for Continuance of Recognition Approved subject to undertaking from the Chief Secretary. The undertaking to come within a weeks time.

5.

Govern ment

150 SEATS Lecture Halls 1 x 350 Central library Less by 1062 m2 infrastructure Not capacity Journal (70 + mentioned by assessor& 30) Form A college No foreign journal (shortage 44 + 30)

200 SEATS 1 x 500 Not mentioned by assessor & Form A college Books not purchased for 10 years as per assessor Journals not purchased for 5 years. Shortage 44 + 30

Residential Quarters Minor OT Major OT Casualty beds Radiology

Short by - 46 One Minor OT less Short by - 1 Less by 5 Mobile unit less 30 mA x 1

Short by - 46 One Minor OT less Short by 2 Less by 10 Mobile unit less 30 mA x 1 Fluorosco py unit 2 not available

7 Paramedical staff Less by 49, grossly inadequate as per assessor. Department Forensic Forensic lab Medicine not Medicine not available available Community No No residential & Medicine residential & mess facility as mess facility per assessor as per assessor Faculty list Attached As per 200 Requirement 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6. Central library & Examination Hall is under construction. Shortage of two static x - ray units. Casualty bed shortage by 5. Teaching staff shortage Professor (TB) 1, Assistant Professor (TB) 1. Shortage of Senior residents TB 1, Skin 1. Shortage of Junior Resident Psychiatry 1.

Less by 49

6.

Trust

Sri Devraj Urs Increase of MBBS Medical College, seats from 150 to 200 Kolar , Karnataka & Continuance of Recognition

Personal hearing to be given to the College to explain the deficiencies pointed out by the UG Committees Assessors.

As per 150 Requirement Infrastructure OPD IPD Faculty Residents Staff

Adequate Adequate Adequate Adequate Adequate Adequate

7.

Govern ment

Government Medical Increase of MBBS 1. Faculty Required for 50 recognition 89, for 100 LOP 54. Available 75. College, NDMC seats from 50 to 100 Jagdalpur, Faculty Shortage of Professor Chhatisgarh Physiology, Pharmacology, FMT, General Medicine,

Personal hearing to be given to the College to explain the deficiencies pointed out in the Assessors report.

8 Obs & Gynae, Ophthalmology, ENT, Orthopaedics, Paediatrics, Radio diagnosis (one in each).

Associate Professor
Physiology, Pathology, General Surgery, ENT, Orthopaedics, Anaesthesia

Assistant Professor
Community Medicine -1, Epidemiologist cum Assistant Professor 1, Orthopaedics, Radio diagnosis, TB & Chest, Skin & VD, Anaesthesia.

Tutor
Physiology 4, Biochemistry 1, FMT 1
2. Residents - Required for 50 recognition 91, for 100 LOP 48. Available 24.

Shortage of Residents
SR General Medicine 1, General Surgery 6, Ophthalmology 1, ENT 1, Orthopaedics 1, Radio diagnosis 1, TB & Chest 2, Skin & VD 1, Anaesthesia 3, Psychiatry 1, Dentistry - 1
3. Residential & messing facilities not available at RHTC. 4. OPD% is inadequate for 50 recognition & adequate for 100 LOP. 5. ICCU, ICU inadequate, Nursing staff inadequate. 1. Faculty - Shortage of 1 Epidemologist cum Asst. Prof.

8.

Trust

Krishna Institute of Increase of MBBS Medical Sciences, seats from 150 to 200 Karad, Maharashtra Burdwan Medical Increase of MBBS College, Burdwan seats from 100 to 150

Approved

9.

Govt.

1. 2. 3.

Drug Controller has not given approval to Blood Bank . Deficiencies of 1 Prof. in ENT & 1 JR in TB & Chest. The certificate AERB approval & PNDT approval not available 4. ICU shortage by 2 beds. 100 150 Admissions Admissions (LOP) (Recognition)

Approved subject to assurance to be given by the Chief Secretary, Government of West Bengal to rectify the deficiencies pointed out. Undertaking to come within a weeks time.

9
ural Infrastruct Adequate Journals in Shortage library Bed distribution Casualty Shortage by 10 beds ICU Shortage by 2 Static X- Shortage by 1 Ray unit 500 mA Faculty Adequate Journals inadequate, Foreign journal nil. Intern hostel not available. Minor OT deficient by 1

Adequate Shortage by 2 Adequate Adequate

10.

Govt.

Guru Gobind Singh Medical College, Faridkot

Increase of MBBS 1. 2. seats from 50 to 100

3.

4. Radiology Equipment Mobile Unit - 30 mA x 2

Static Unit 60 mA x 1 500 mA x 1

Approved subject to undertaking by the Chief Secretary Government of Punjab, to rectify the deficiencies.

not functional not functional not available

11.

Govt.

College of Medicine and J.N.M. Hospital, Kalyani, Nadia, West Bengal

Renewal of permission for admission of 4th batch of 100 MBBS students

1. Faculty shortage by 16.49%. The department wise shortage College will be called for hearing of faculty are as under: explain the deficiencies. (a) Professor 6 - 01- Microbiology, - 01 - TB Chest, - 01 - Psychiatry, - 01 - ENT, - 01 - Radio - 01 - Dentistry (b) Assoc. Prof. 8 - 02 - Community Medicine - 02 - Anaesthesia, - 01 - Pathology, - 01 - Microbiology, - 01 - General Medicine - 01 - General Surgery (c) Asst. Prof. 2 - 01 - Anatomy

to

10 01 - Radio Diagnosis

2. Resident shortage by 3.9% shortage. The department wise shortage are as under: (a) Senior Resident 4 - 02 - General Surgery - 02 - Radio Diagnosis 3. Resident hostel capacity is less by 40. 4. Major OT __________ 5. There is no documentary evidence for AERB approval and PNDT approval. 6. Paramedical staff shortage is less by 74. 7. RHTC: hostel facility not available. 12. Govt. Government Medical Renewal of 1. College, Kannauj permission for admission of 2nd batch of 100 MBBS students Faculty shortage by 3.26%. The department wise shortage is as under:
(a) Professor - Anatomy- 1 - Microbiology 1 (b) Assoc. Prof. - Microbiology - 1

Approved subject to undertaking by Chief Secretary Government of Uttar Pradesh to rectify the deficiencies.

2.

3. 4.
5. 6.

In Central Library: (i) Area is less by 796 mt. sq. (804 sq. available as against the requirement of 1600 sq. m.). (ii) Seating capacity not mentioned. (iii) Journals (Indian + Foreign) are not available. Inadequate Bed occupancy (50% available as against the requirement of 60%). Mobile unit of 1x 30 mA not available. Community Medicine transport not available, demand send to State Govt. Blood Bank License expired on 15.02.2013. No detail of renewal application enclosed. 1. There is no documentary proof of PNDT approval. Conditional approval subject to

13.

Trust

Mayo

Institute

of Renewal

of

11 Medical Barabanki, Pradesh Sciences, permission for Uttar admission of 2nd batch of 150 MBBS students 2. Resident shortage by 8.53%. The department wise submission of PNDT & BBL and shortage is as under: rectification of the other deficiencies (i) General Medicine - 03 pointed out in the Assessors report. (ii) General Surgery 1 (iii) Rest are JRs 3. Blood Bank Licenses available but is not functional as the
Blood Bank License is awaited.

14.

Govt.

Chhatrapati Sahuji Renewal of Maharaj Medical Permission for College, Lucknow admission of 3rd batch of MBBS students against the increase intake i.e. from 185 to 250

15.

Trust

K S Hegde Medical Renewal Academy, Mangalore permission

1. Faculty shortage by 8%. 2. Shortage of 1 Lecture theatre of 650 capacity (college have 5 L.T. of 250 capacity and 01 L.T. of 300 capacity is under construction as against the requirement of 07 L.T. of 6x300 & 1 x 650). 3. Inadequate Examination Hall cum Auditorium (5812.54 sq. feet as against the requirement of 2000 sq. m.). 4. In Central Library: (a) Inadequate area (3089 sq. m. available as against the requirement of 4000). (b) No mention of seating capacity & Journals (Form A is not available). 5. Interns accommodation in UG hostel. 6. No mention of hostel accommodation for Nurses. 7. No information available with regard to Residential quarters for teaching & non-teaching staff. 8. Residents majority is Junior Resident. 9. Nursing Staff 629 as against the required 703, less by 74, not as per norms. 10. Shortage of 10 beds in Skin & V.D. department. 11. No mention of Casualty beds _____________________. 12. Shortage of Nursing staff by 74 (629 available as against the requirement of 703). 13. Form A of the college is not available. 14. There are no documentary proof of AERB & PNDT approvals are not available. of Nil deficiency as per UG committee report. for

Approved subject to assurance and Undertaking of Vice-Chancellor/ Chief Secretry to rectify the deficiencies. Undertaking to come within a weeks time.

Approved

12 admission of 3rd batch of MBBS Students against the increase intake i.e. from 100 - 150 MBBS students Dr. Rajendra Prasad Renewal of Government Medical permission for College, Tanda, H.P. admission of 3rd batch of MBBS Students against the increase intake i.e. from 50 to 100 MBBS students

16.

Govt.

1. Faculty - 21.2% shortage

2. Resident - 24.27% shortage
Faculty/ Resident Deficiency Department wise is as follow: Anatomy: Associate Professor - 1, Assistant Professor 1, Tutor 2 Physiology: Professor 1, Associate Professor 1 , Tutor 3 Biochemistry: Tutor 1 Pharmacology: Assistant Professor -1 Pathology: Professor 1, Associate Professor 3, Assistant Professor 1, Tutor 1 Forensic Medicine: Professor 1, Tutor 1 Community Medicine: Epidemiologist cum Assistant Professor 1 General Medicine: SR 1, JR 1 TB & Respiratory Diseases: SR 1, JR - 2 General Surgery: SR 4, JR - 3 Psychiatry: SR 2, JR 2 OB & Gy: ANMO 1 Anaesthesiology: Assistant Professor 2, SR 6 Radio diagnosis: SR 4 Dentistry: Professor - 1

In view of the deficiencies pointed out, college be given hearing to explain the deficiencies and shortages of teaching faculty.

3. Infrastructure - 1 PHC is not there UHTC and PHC is same Total two PHC are these one named RHTC one UHTC. 4. No surgical ICU 5. Shortage of 2 casualty beds 6. AERB Approval Applied for renewal

17.

Govt.

Kilpauk Medical College, Chennai

Renewal of permission for 2nd Batch against the increased intake i.e. from 100 to 150 & Continuance of Recognition

1. Faculty - Department wise shortage - Professor Radiology 1(for 100 recognition), Associate Professor- 02 Anatomy, - 01 Pharmacology 2. Rural Health Training Centre: No hostel and messing facility available.

Approved subject to assurance/undertaking by Chief Secretary Government of Tamil Nadu to rectify the deficiencies.

13 S. No. Govt. / Pvt. Govt. Name of the College Type of Assessment Deficiencies as per minutes of Board of Governors: Comments of UG committee compliance submitted by college. on BOG decision

18.

Establishment of LOI / LOP new medical 100 Seats College at Thiruvannamala i, Tamil Nadu

1.

Lecture theatres, library, hostels for students, Residents, Nurses & Residential quarters for teaching & non-teaching, anatomy deptt. and other preclinical and paraclinical departments under construction. Funds placed by Govt. but nothing mentioned about approximate time of completion. Video CD given on construction. Faculty shortage by 9.25% (a) Anatomy Professor -1 (b) Medicine Professor 1 (c) Community Medicine Associate Prof. 1 (d) Genl. Surgery Associate Prof. 1 (e) Radiology Associate Prof. - 1 Residents shortage by 6.25% (a) Medicine - Sr. Resident 1 (b) Surgery Sr. Resident 1 (c) Radiology Sr. Resident - 1

2.

According to Institution it has been Approved completed but will need physical subject to verification assurance/un dertaking by Partial compliance. Chief Will be ready only after 30.06.2013 Secretary Government of Tamil Nadu Not complied with for rectification of deficiencies by 30.6.2013.

3.

Not complied with

4.

19

Intergral Universit y

Establishment of LOI / LOP new medical college at Lucknow, Uttar Pradesh by Integral University, Lucknow

1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6.

Shortage of hostel accommodation of Nurses by 5. 1. Complied with as per statement. But will need physical verification. Complied with, Photocopy of PNDT approval not available. 2. Annexure attached. Shortage of Nursing Staff by 17. 3. There is a scanned list of 181 Nurses. Blood Bank license applied for license. Institution has appointed another 19 Only 01 defibrillator in the hospital. Nursing staff (Staff Nurses). The SICU not available. joining dates are before 6/5/2013. Will need verification. 4. No change. No Licence has been received as yet. 5. Purchase order of 04 defibrillators attached. 03 defibrillators TEC-5521K purchase

Physical verification of compliance to be carried out immediately.

14 S. No. Govt. / Pvt. Name of the College Type of Assessment Deficiencies as per minutes of Board of Governors: Comments of UG committee compliance submitted by college. on BOG decision

via Invoice No. MME/11-12/150 dated 22/03/2012 01 defibrillators TEC-5521K invoice No. MME/12-13/108 dated 11/02/2013. 6. Currently MSR does not ask for separate SICU, only ICCU / ICU/ NICU/PICU. 20 Trust Travancore Renewal of 1. No mention of Area & Seating capacity in Central Medical College, permission for Library. Kollam, Kerala admission of 5th batch 2. No mention of capacity for hostels for Students, of 100 students Residents, Nurses and Interns. 3. Residential Quarters for non-teaching staff are inadequate. 4. In Radiology IITV not available 5. No mention of PNDT approval validity. 6. UHTC: no mention of UHTC & its accommodation facilities. 7. In casualty only 01 CMO as against required 03. 1. As per Institution area of Central Library 1600 sq. m.t Reading Rooms: 2 x 150 UG 1 x 20 Staff Internet facility of 50 Terminals. Library Layout map attached. There was no A Form submitted as a result, this information was not available before. Needs to be verified. 2. Verified as per Assessors report and Institution report also. Complied with. 3. Complied with. 4. Complied with Order for Fluoroscopy unit P.O. No. 10/12/0934, dated 09.07.2012 attached Service Report cum Invoice also attached. 5. PNDT permission photocopy

Physical verification of compliance be carried out immediately.

15 S. No. Govt. / Pvt. Name of the College Type of Assessment Deficiencies as per minutes of Board of Governors: Comments of UG committee compliance submitted by college. attached. Annexure attached. 6. Complied with There is no Intern batch yet, so not needed. 7. List attached (Signed by M.S.) Complied with 21 Trust Apollo Institute of Medical Sciences and Research, Hyderabad Renewal of permission for admission of 2nd batch of 100 students 1. Faculty shortage of by 17.39% (Total 76 faculty 1. Although, Institution has submitted available as against the requirement of 92). a list of Faculty member and are also claiming that they are not able to However, department wise shortage of Faculty by reconcile the shortage of faculty 27.17%. The department wise shortage is observed department-wise. as under: The presence of faculty will (a) Anatomy 02 Tutors have to be physically verified. (b) Physiology 02 Tutors 2. Needs verification (c) Biochemistry 01 Tutors Although, the institution has 3. (d) Pharmacology 01 Assco. Professor submitted a Lease deed agreement, it 01 Asstt. Professor will need physical verification. 01 Tutors 4. (e) Pathology 02 Assoc. Professor Assessors report Compliance 03 Tutors report (f) Microbiology 01 - Professor Medicine 60 72 01 - Asstt. Professor TB & Resp. 6 8 02 Tutor (g) Forensic 01 Tutors Paediatrics 20 24 Medicine Psychiatry 2 8 (h) PSM 04 Asstt. Professor 01 Tutors Dermatology 4 8 (i) Surgery 01 Asstt. Professor Gen. Surgery 60 90 (j) ENT 01 Assoc. / Asstt. Prof. Personal hearing to be given to the college to explain the deficiencies. Physical verification of compliance be carried out immediately. on BOG decision

16 S. No. Govt. / Pvt. Name of the College Type of Assessment Deficiencies as per minutes of Board of Governors: Comments of UG committee compliance submitted by college. on BOG decision

2. 3.

4.

5. 6. 7. 8. 9.

No mess facility in the students hostel. No information available with regard to Residential Quarters for Teaching & Non-Teaching staff. Shortage of beds by 72 in departments of Medicine & Allied, Surgery & Allied and OBG (total 228 beds available as against the requirement of 300). Shortage of 06 beds in Casualty. AERB approval applied for renewal, but no documentary evidence attached. 02 PHCs not even earmarked, not yet functional. No mention of transport facility for the staff and students in RHTC & UHTC training centre. Marked disparity in average monthly investigation and on the day of assessment.

Orthopaedic 30 Ophthalmology 30 ENT OBG 8 30

30 10 10 40

Although the compliance report gives the requisite number, the beds will have to be physically verified for number as well as patients, since there is a discrepancy. 5. Although the floor plan is there, that does not prove that casualty is functional. Needs physical verification. 6. Documentary proof submitted. Complied with 7. Letter from Principal of College is attached but there is no letter of permission from Government. Not complied with. 8. Complied with 9. Seen and the figures are within average. Complied with.

17 S. No. Govt. / Pvt. Trust Name of the College Type of Assessment Deficiencies as per minutes of Board of Governors: Comments of UG committee compliance submitted by college. on BOG decision

22

of The Board of Governors decided that comments / Gujarat Adani Renewal In process. for clarification on the Assessors Comment may be Institute of permission The total control of G.K. General Medical admission of 5th batch obtained from the college authorities. Sciences, Bhuj, of 150 MBBS students Hospital has still not been handed over Gujrat to GAIMS, although they have initiated

Personal hearing to be given to the college or producing evidence of the process from 2009 onwards. GK General Hospital being They have again urged Govt. to handed over transfer control but still in process. to GAIMS.

23

Govt.

Thiruvarur Govt. Medical College, Thiruvarur Tamil Nadu

Renewal of permission for admission of 4th batch of 100 students

1. Shortage of hostel accommodation for students by 12 (288 available as against the requirement of 300). 2. Shortage of hostel accommodation for Residents by 21 (64 available as against the requirement of 85). 3. Inadequate bed occupancy (only 50% as against the requirement of 75%). 4. Clinical Material: Shortage of one Minor OT. 5. AERB approval applied for renewal. 6. RHTC / UHTC no details available.

1. Photographs showing a building Physical without any signage is attached. verification of compliance be Difficult to say from photograph carried out as to what this building is. immediately. Needs Physical verification 2. Photographs showing a building without any signage is attached. Difficult to say from photograph as to what this building is. Needs Physical verification. 3. Assessors Report IP % - 50% Compliance Report shows almost 120% occupancy.

18 S. No. Govt. / Pvt. Name of the College Type of Assessment Deficiencies as per minutes of Board of Governors: Comments of UG committee compliance submitted by college. Three months As per average, as well as on the annexure day of submitted by inspection. institution 28/1/2013 The IP 449 only, the annexure of March only singed by Principal shows an IPD above 600. Needs physical verification. 4. Complied with 5. Same as earlier. Photographs attached show 6. signages but, inside of Centres cannot be made out. Only 03 PHCs are needed. The institution claims to have 03 RHTCs. A photograph showing a building designated UHTC with on BOG decision

signage. But, it needs verification. 24 Trust

Subbaiah Institute Medical

Renewal of 1. No documentary evidence with regard to AERB of permission for approval. admission of 2nd batch 2. RHTC & UHTC not under the control of Dean /

1. Annexure attached Complied with

Approved

19 S. No. Govt. / Pvt. Name of the College Sciences, Shimoga Karnataka Type of Assessment Deficiencies as per minutes of Board of Governors: Comments of UG committee compliance submitted by college. on BOG decision

of 150 students

Principal (under control of District Health Offices). 3. Hostel for RHTC under construction. 4. No mention of transport facility for staff and students in RHTC & UHTC.

2. Letter issued from District Health & Family Welfare Officer, Shimoga attached. 3. Photographs of accommodation at RHTC attached Complied with 4. Available Complied with 1. Photocopy of permission enclosed Complied with Approved

25

Trust

GMERS Medical College, Sola, Ahmedabad, Gujarat

Renewal of 1. There is no documentary evidence for AERB permission for approval and PNDT approval. admission of 3rd batch of 150 students

26

Govt.

Government Sivgangai Medical College, Sivagangai Tamilnadu

Renewal of 1. Faculty shortage by 22.82% (relaxation as per Gazette permission for Notification dated 16.04.2010). The department wise admission of 2nd batch shortage is observed as under: of 100 students Biochemistry, Professor : Anatomy, Pharmacology, Forensic Medicine, a) Radio-Diagnosis, Dentistry Assco. Prof. : Physiology, Community Chest.

1. No mention of faculty shortage or Resident shortage in compliance report. Not complied with

b)

However, an unsigned list of faculty member titled Available / Deputed / Biochemistry, Deficit is attached. Medicine, TB &

Personal hearing to be given to the college to produce evidence of rectification of the deficiencies.

r.

Asstt. Prof.

Physiology, Biochemistry, Microbiology, Community Medicine-3, Epidemiologist 1, Statistician 1, Gen. Medicine, Dermatology, Radio-Diagnosis

20 S. No. Govt. / Pvt. Name of the College Type of Assessment Deficiencies as per minutes of Board of Governors: Comments of UG committee compliance submitted by college. on BOG decision

Tutor d)

Biochemistry 1, Microbiology 2, Forensic Medicine 1

2. Resident shortage by 43.28%. The department wise 2. No mention of Resident shortage shortage is observed as under: mentioned in compliance report. Sr. Residents Gen. Medicine 2, Paediatric Orthopaedics 2, ENT, Optha a) Not complied with. Diagnosis Jr. Residents Gen. Medicine 6, Paediatrics However, an unsigned list of b) Orthopaedics 1, OBG 3 Faculty member titled Available / Deputed / Deficit is attached. 3. Central Library: (a) Shortage of seating capacity by 90 ( 110 available as Not complied. against the requirement of 200) 3. No mention of seating capacity. (b) Journals (Indian + Foreign) not available (yet to be Not complied with. purchased). 4. SICU, ICCU not available. For 06 Indian Journals and 5. NICU not adequately equipped. 07 Foreign Journals as per Ref. 6. There is no documentary evidence for AERB Proforma Invoice No. 437 / J/13 dated approval. 12/3/2013 is attached but no payment 7. PNDT approval renewal applied for. bill is attached, as Journals need 8. Shortage of Nursing Staff by 23 (152 available as advance payment. 4. & 5. As per photograph it has been against the requirement of 175). created, but needs verification. 9. College website not formed. 6. No document submitted 10. Blood Bank license is on old hospital, valid upto 31.12.2016. For Dr. Sivagangai hospital license has Not complied with. 7. No document submitted to be obtained. 11. Medical Records section not computerized and no Not complied with. 8. Not complied with proper indexing. 9. No Comments 12. College labs not adequately equipped.

21 S. No. Govt. / Pvt. Name of the College Type of Assessment Deficiencies as per minutes of Board of Governors: Comments of UG committee compliance submitted by college. on BOG decision

13. Central sterilization department yet to start functioning. 14. Majority of faculty are not staying in hospital. 15. Main stores is in Administrative building, should be in hospital building. 16. Animal house not yet functional. 17. Department libraries are not yet functioning. 18. Majority of the departments are understaffed and not equipped adequately. 19. OPD / IPD registration not computerized and inadequately staffed. No separate counters for old, new and handicapped patients.

10. A letter stating that Blood Bank application for grant of License in the form 28 C is under process. Partial compliance. 11. No Comments 12. Although 9 order copies from Dean are attached 19/10/2012, but no list of equipment has been given. Partial compliance. 13. & 14. Needs verification. No Proof given. 15. Needs Verification. 16. No Comments 17. Photographs given of one Rack with Books. Needs verification. 18. No Comments 19. Needs verification 1. Documents showing Order / payment proof submitted by institution. Also a grant of Rs.25 Lakhs from Govt. also submitted. In the process of Receiving Complied with. 2. Papers of new construction have been submitted.

27

Govt.

Rajiv Gandhi Institute of Medical Sciences, Ongole, Andhra Pradesh

Renewal of 1. permission for admission of 3rd batch of 100 students 2.

Central Library: No mention of Journal (Indian + Foreign) mentioned in the UG committee report as 65 old, No new subscription. Shortage of hostel accommodation for Residents by 40 (42 available as against the requirement of 82). 3. Shortage of hostel accommodation for Nurses by 15 (20 available as against the requirement of 35). 4. Residential Quarters - Shortage of occupancy in residential quarters (teaching) by 10%, however 5% excess in non-teaching. 5. Bed occupancy on the day of assessment was 50%, however 85% average.

Physical verification of compliance. Be carried out immediately.

22 S. No. Govt. / Pvt. Name of the College Type of Assessment Deficiencies as per minutes of Board of Governors: Comments of UG committee compliance submitted by college. No other document attached Needs Verification. 3. Needs Verification. 4. No document attached. Needs Verification. 5. According to Assessor the bed occupancy is 50% only. This documents is also signed by Dean of the institution. There is no other documentary evidence submitted by college to prove the bed occupancy. Not complied with. 6. No documentary proof Needs verification. 7. Submitted Complied with Submitted Complied with 8. Submitted Complied with 9. No Comments 10. No Comments 11. No Comments 12. Needs verification. 13. a & b Needs verification. c & d No Comments

on

BOG decision

6. Clinical Material : ICU, ICCU & PICU & SICU not functional. 7. AERB approval Approval under process 8. No documentary evidence with regard to PNDT approval. 9. Departmental Labs shortage of 11 beds. 10. Wards are not well equipped with emergency resuscitation measure are not commissioned, do not have doctors duty rooms on pantry or demo room. 11. Animal house is not in working condition. 12. Clinical service lab are 50% functional. 13. OTS are not well equipped, which are as under: (a) Central Oxygen / Nitrous Oxide is not commissioned. (b) No respiratory gas monitor available. (c) No Defibrillators, except in General Surgery 1, which is also not functional. (d) No infusion & Syringe pumps 14. Administrative wing is not functional.

23 S. No. Govt. / Pvt. Name of the College Type of Assessment Deficiencies as per minutes of Board of Governors: Comments of UG committee compliance submitted by college. 14. No Comments 28 Trust Tagore Medical College and Hospital, Chennai Renewal of 1. Central Library: Shortage of Journals (Indian + Permission for 4th Foreign) (14+06 available as against the requirement of 28+12 Indian + Foreign respectively). Batch of 150 MBBS students 2. Shortage of hostel accommodation for students by 105 (347 available as against the requirement of 452). Hostel facility inadequate. 3. Shortage of beds by 115 in the departments of Medicine & Allied, Surgery & Allied & OBG. 4. OPD Attendance most of the patients transported to OPD in college vehicle as per assessor. 5. Bed occupancy Genuiness of admitted patients questionable. 6. Clinical material : Deficiency of 01 Major OT. 7. Clinical Material ICU Genuiness of patients admitted in ICU is questionable. 8. Shortage of Nursing staff by 48 (175 available as against the requirement of 223). 9. As per visual perception on videography, patient influx seems to be quite inadequate. 1. List of Indian International 28 12 has been submitted. A payment details of Rs.1,68,737 has been submitted. This payment has been done on 30.04.2013. Partially complied with 2. As per Institution Boys hostel Block I 170 Block II 76 246 Girls hostel 206 Total 452 A list Room wise has been submitted by the institution Needs Verification. Will need verification. 3. A report of 2011 has been attached which shows requisite bed strength. Currently beds as per assessment report 28th Feb., 1st March 2013 is as follows: General Medicine 72 TB & Respiratory Medicine 08 Paediatrics 24

on

BOG decision

Physical verification of compliance be carried out immediately.

24 S. No. Govt. / Pvt. Name of the College Type of Assessment Deficiencies as per minutes of Board of Governors: Comments of UG committee compliance submitted by college. on BOG decision

Psychiatry 08 Dermatology 08 General Surgery 90 Orthopedics 30 Ophthalmology 10 ENT 10 OB & GYN. 40 4. OPD figure is also less by 28, as per assessors report. Required 750 Present 722

The college has agreed that they are providing a regular shuttle service to reach the patients to hospital 5. Vague explanation. 6. There is no documentary proof that 02 General Surgery OTs are running. Needs physical verification. Available checked as per Assessors Report also. 7. 09 case sheets are available. 8. Unsigned list of Recruited Nursing Staff enclosed. Nursing staff enclosed. Not complied with 9. Needs physical verification. 1. The Institution has submitted a list of

29

Society

GMERS Medical Renewal College, permission

of for

1. Faculty shortage by 38.67%. 2. Shortage of Residents hostel accommodation by 33.

Personal hearing to be

25 S. No. Govt. / Pvt. Name of the College Dharpur, Gujarat Type of Assessment Deficiencies as per minutes of Board of Governors: Comments of UG committee compliance submitted by college. faculty that has joined after last inspection on 22/23rd March 2013 and are declaring 22.64% shortage. This will have to be verified by an assessor. Will have to be verified by an assessor. 2. Will need physical verification. Complied with on BOG decision

Patan admission of 2nd batch of 150 students

given to the college to explain the deficiencies.

30

Trust

31

Trust

Gold Field Institute of Medical Sciences & Research, Ballabgarh, Faridabad, Haryana Hind Institute of Medical Sciences, Barabanki Uttar Pradesh Malla Reddy Institute of Medical Sciences, Hyderabad Andhra Pradesh Indira Gandhi Institute of Medical Sciences,

Renewal of Permission 3rd batch of 100 seats

1. Most building are under construction.

Physical verification of compliance.

Renewal of 1. Although Faculty is adequate, but shortage in the 1. Declaration form submitted. permission for department of Community Medicine admission of 5th batch Epidemiologist & Statistician cum Asstt. Professor Otherwise no faculty shortage. of 100 students one each. 2. Compliance done 2. Blood Bank license applied for renewal. Application for Renewal submitted. Renewal of 1. permission for admission of 2nd batch 2. of 150 students Hostel accommodation for students exact 1. As per Assessors report. capacity not mentioned. Complied with Form A not signed by the Dean. 2. Complied with

Approved

32

Society

Approved

33

Govt.

Renewal of 1. Faculty shortage by 35.45%. permission for 2. Resident shortage by 53%. admission of 3rd batch 3. Lecture theatre of 2x125 available, but not of 100 students furnished and no gallery type.

1. & 2. Extra faculty members in other departments cannot be counted towards faculty calculation.

Personal hearing to be given to the college to

26 S. No. Govt. / Pvt. Name of the College Sheikhpura Patna Bihar Type of Assessment Deficiencies as per minutes of Board of Governors: Comments of UG committee compliance submitted by college. on BOG decision

34

Govt.

Not complied with 4. Not complied with 5. Not complied with Rajiv Gandhi Recognition for 100 1. Inadequate seating capacity in Examination Hall cum 1. Not complied with Auditorium [college have two examination hall cum Institute of seats Auditorium of 700 + 900 (Area), with seating capacity Medical of 150 + 250 respectively, and required 800 sq. mt. with Sciences, seating capacity is 500 700 sq. mt.]. Adilabad 2. Shortage of hostel accommodation for students by 39. 2. Although work has started, but 3. In Radiology Department : Not complied with a) Shortage of Static Unit of 1x300 mA. b) Shortage of Mobile units of 1x30 mA & 2x60 mA. 3. c) Shortage of 01 USG machine. 30 mA x 2 60 mA x 1 4. No information provided regarding AERB & PNDT approval in the Assessment Form as well as in the Form A. 5. Shortage of Paramedical & Non-Teaching staff by 12. 6. UHTC Name of place & distance has not been mentioned in Assessors Report or in Form A. 7. Blood bank License expired on 31.12.2012. No information provided regarding renewal of Blood Bank Static Unit 600 mA x 1 500 mA x 2 800 mA x 1 with IITV

4. Inadequate area of Central Library [8998.69 sq. ft. (835.94 sq. mt.) available as against the requirement of 1600 sq. mt.]. 5. It has been noted that the college is utilizing Obstetrics facility at Gardanibag hospital, Patna, Lok Nayak Jai Prakash Narayan, Shastri Nagar, Patna and Guru Gobind Singh Hospital, Patna City for the purpose of Obstetrical training and teaching of Undergraduate students. You are advised to ensure that the department is developed at the earliest, as per Minimum Standard Requirement.

explain the Each department has to have a deficiencies requisite number of faculty and Senior and shortage residents. of teaching faculty and Not complied with. infrastructure 3. Process has been started but it is in pointed out in nascent stage. Will take some time for the Assessors completion. report. So not complied with.

Personal hearing to be given to the college to explain the deficiencies.

27 S. No. Govt. / Pvt. Name of the College Type of Assessment Deficiencies as per minutes of Board of Governors: Comments of UG committee compliance submitted by college. on BOG decision

License in the UG Committee Report. & Fluoroscopy 8. The allegations in the complaint have been scrutinised. It appears to be a case of Govt. transfers to this Institute CT Spiral 1 as verified from transfer orders annexed alongwith USG 3 (2 Grey Scale & 1 declaration forms. colour). Higher mA machine available, so complied with 4. AERB not present. Attached, complied with 5. No document attached. Not complied with. 6. Institution has agreed that this information was neither in Form A or Assessors Report. Although video is attached, but all pictures video are unnamed. Will need physical verification. 7. Application dated 18.03.2013,

seeking renewal attached. 8. No Comments 35 Trust Melmaruvathur Recognition Adiparasakthi seats Instt. Medical Sciences and Research 150 1. 2. Shortage of Residents is 8.45%. As per Assessors report there are 700 beds out of which 350 are teaching and 350 are paying beds. Therefore, the deficiency is of 350 beds. On checking assessment reports of 2012-13 & 2013-2014 differences were observed regarding Experience of Dean as well as teaching/ paying beds, which are as under: 1. The institution agrees to the shortage but invokes Notification 16.04.2010, Item No. 3 2. As per Assessors Report there are 350 paying beds and 350 teaching beds. Whereas Form A 2013-14 mentions 700 total beds. Even previous assessment report shows Deferred in view of pending CBI/Legal issues of the College.

3.

28 S. No. Govt. / Pvt. Name of the College Type of Assessment Deficiencies as per minutes of Board of Governors: Comments of UG committee compliance submitted by college. 700 beds (teaching) 3. Declaration from Dean Sr. Resident 03 years. A.P. 09 years. Associate Professor 04 years. Professor 05 years. Dy. DME 03 years & 06 months Dean - 11 months (Chengalpet) on BOG decision

1)

Dr. J. Mohana Soundaran, Dean Year Teaching Administrative Experience Experience 2012 25 7 2013 33 18 2) Number of beds Year 2012 2013 4. Total Beds 765 700 Teaching Beds 700 350 Paying Beds Nil 350

5. 6.

7.

From-A mentions bed occupancy 85% calculated on teaching beds. However, as per Assessors Dean - 10 months report it is 76% and it is not clear whether bed (Stanley) occupancy is calculated on teaching beds or on total beds (teaching+paying). Dean - 1 years. Nursing staff is inadequate. Less by 2. (M. Medical College) RHTC : Assessors report is incomplete. No information provided regarding population Total teaching Exp. 25 approx. covered by RHTC, Students & Interns posted in Adm. = 7 years. batches, Residential & messing facilities, cold chain, posting of interns etc. There is no mention of transport facility for RHTC There is a letter from managing trustee declaring that there are 700 free & UHTC. teaching beds. 4. Even 76% is adequate. 5. Appointment of joining report is attached. Complied with. 6. Annexures and photographs are

29 S. No. Govt. / Pvt. Name of the College Type of Assessment Deficiencies as per minutes of Board of Governors: Comments of UG committee compliance submitted by college. available, attached. Will need physical verification. 8. Complied with List of student on BOG decision

posting

36

Rajiv Gandhi Recognition Institute of seats Medical Sciences, Srikakulam

100

1. Residents hostels are not available & inadequate 1. As per Institution accommodation for Interns as per assessors report. 48 Male 2. AERB approval is not yet available. Residen 42 Female t 3. Paramedical & non-teaching staff is inadequate. Less by 44. Accommodation have been 4. Blood Bank license renewal is awaited (letter of provided. Drug Inspector, Drug Control Administration 78+78 (Intern) accommodation enclosed). allocated Will need physical verification. 2. Complied with Photocopy of the certificate attached. 3. Not complied with No list indicating paramedical staff. Only a statement in the letter. 4. Complied with Photocopy of certificate 18/08/2016 AERB approval applied for renewal on 18.01.2013 Photocopy of the letter attached. no letter of application or receipt of application. Complied with 1. The situation remains the same. Not complied with. the

Physical verification of compliance be carried out immediately.

upto Approved

37

Trust

JSS Medical Increase of seats from 1. College, Mysore 150 to 200

38

Govt.

Madras Medical LOI / LOP Increase 1. Faculties shortage Associate Professor Anatomy 2 College, Chennai of seats from 165 to Community Medicine -2 250 u/s 10 A of the

Approved subject to the undertaking

30 S. No. Govt. / Pvt. Name of the College Type of Assessment Deficiencies as per minutes of Board of Governors: Comments of UG committee compliance submitted by college. on BOG decision

IMC Act, 1956

Forensic Medicine -2 Asst. Professor Community Medicine 4 Forensic Medicine 2

2. Residents quarters short by 80.

2. Not complied with Will need physical verification.

by Chief Secretary Government of Tamil Nadu to rectify the deficiencies.

39

Govt.

Osmania Increase of Seats from 1. Inadequate area of Central library. 2. Number of hostel accommodation for students are Medical College, 200 to 250 adequate but partially furnished. Hyderabad 3. Annexure not available with regard to AERB & PNDT approval. 4. Blood Bank license valid upto 31.12.2011 renewal applied for.

1. In the process sanction letters attached. But Not Complied With In the process sanction letters 2. attached. But Not Complied With Photocopy of AERB & PNDT 3. approval attached. Complied with 4. Photocopy of letters attached Valid upto 31.12.2016

Approved subject to undertaking by Chief Secretary Government of Andhra Pradesh to rectify the deficiencies.

40

Trust

Meenakshi Medical College & Hospital, Chennai

41

Trust

Renewal of 1. Permission for admission of 5th Batch of MBBS students against the increased intake i.e. from 100 to 150 J N Medical Renewal of 1. College, Swangi, Permission for Wardha admission of 3rd 2. Batch of MBBS students against the increased intake

Blood Band license valid upto 31.10.2012- applied for Photocopy renewal. attached.

of

permission

letter Approved

Blood Bank License upto 31.10.2017 Complied with Shortage of Nursing staff by 19 (684 available as against the requirement of 703). Department Labs: post-mortem facilities not available. 1. A list of 25 staff nurses who have Approved joined in March April 2013, alongwith date of Joining singed by Dean of the college is attached. 2. As per rules.

31 S. No. Govt. / Pvt. Name of the College Type of Assessment Deficiencies as per minutes of Board of Governors: Comments of UG committee compliance submitted by college. Complied with on BOG decision

42

Govt.

i.e. from 150 to 200 & Continuance of Recognition Sardar Patel Renewal of Medical College, Permission for 3rd Bikaner Batch of MBBS students against the increased intake i.e. from 100 to 150 & Increase of seats from 150 to 250

1. 2.

1. A chart showing the Approved Proportion of Sr. Resident Central Library: requirement (for 250) and available (i) Inadequate area (College have 100 x 50 Sq. ft. Senior Resident & Junior Resident is as ground floor & 100 x 50 Sq. ft. first floor). follows: Senior Resident (ii) Inadequate Setting capacity (College have 50-UG & 30 PG as against the requirement of 300 (150+150). Required Available 3. No information available with regard to Hostel accommodation for Nurses. 4. Shortage of hostel accommodation for Interns by 54 7 General 15 Medicine (46 available as against the requirement of 100). 5 Paediatric 8 5. OPD Separate registration counters for OPD/IPD not available. Registration not computerized. No dark rooms in ophthalmology. Condition in OPD and Wards are dirty. No utility rooms. No separate 1 TB & Chest 3 toilets for male & female patients. 1 Dermatology 3 6. OBG OT does not have Central O2 and no OT has ventilator except surgery OT. 1 Psychiatry 3 7. Departmental Labs: 2 General 15 i) No embalming machine in Anatomy Department Surgery (ii) Clinical physiology lab inadequate. 1 Orthopaedics 8 (iii) No. research lab in Pathology. 4 3 iv) Microbiology Museum inadequate + no Ophthalmology cataloguing 2 ENT 2
OBG Anaesth esia Radio 8 2 8 14 2 2

32 S. No. Govt. / Pvt. Name of the College Type of Assessment Deficiencies as per minutes of Board of Governors: Comments of UG committee compliance submitted by college.
Diagnosis

on

BOG decision

Still not complied with 2. The college has accepted that the area of library is less. They have written to Govt. of Rajasthan for starting construction. Not complied with. 3. & 4. Partial Compliance 5. Not complied with Will need verification Will need verification 6. Will need verification 7. (i) Partial compliance (ii) Will need verification (iii) Partial Compliance 43 Pt. J N M Renewal of Medical College, permission against Raipur increase intake from 100 to 150 seats 5th batch
1. 2. (c) 3.

4. 5.

(iv) Will need verification Resident shortage by 14%. 1. An advertisement of 22/1/2013 In Central Library Walk-in-interview is attached. Inadequate area (1600 sq. m. available as against the The assessment has been done on 19th & requirement of 2400 sq. m.) 20th Feb. 2013, so the appointments Shortage of 02 Indian Journals (40 Indian Journals should have been done. available as against the requirement of 42 Indian Not Complied with Journals). 2. Partial compliance. Shortage of hostel accommodation for Residents by 3. The order of 02 Indian Journals has 15 (100 available as against the requirement of 115). been placed Shortage of hostel accommodation for Interns by 10 Complied with (90 available as against the requirement of 100). 4. Still to be built.

Approved subject to assurance/ undertaking by Chief Secretary Government of Chhatisgarh to rectify the deficiencies.

6.

Inadequate Bed occupancy (69% as against the

33 S. No. Govt. / Pvt. Name of the College Type of Assessment Deficiencies as per minutes of Board of Governors: Comments of UG committee compliance submitted by college. on BOG decision

required 75%). Not complied with RHTC & UHTC under control of Director Health 5. Will need physical verification. Services. 6. Bed Occupancy 2012 8. Renewal of Blood Bank License awaited. Jan. 70.92 Feb. 71.66 Mar. 75.17 April 70.39 May 71.17 July 71.48 As per Aug. 69.47 Annexure Sept. 70.96 Oct. 64.54 Nov. 76.20 Dec. 76.21
7.

As per Records, the IPD is marginally less. 7. Complied with Letter from Chief Medical Officer, giving permission to use UHTC for students and Interns. 8. Letter of Renewal attached. As per FDA Raipur, they are Recommended for renewal for a period 2012-2016. Complied with

44

Govt.

Karnataka

Renewal

of 1.

Inadequate hostel accommodation for Interns.

1. Will need physical Verification

Approved

34 S. No. Govt. / Pvt. Name of the College Type of Assessment Deficiencies as per minutes of Board of Governors: Comments of UG committee compliance submitted by college. on BOG decision

Institute of Permission for 2. Medical admission of 5th Batch 3. Sciences, Hubli of MBBS students against the increased intake i.e. from 100 to 150 & Continuance of Recognition 45 Trust Rohilkhand Medical College & Hospital, Bareilly Renewal of Permission for 2nd Batch of MBBS students against the increased intake i.e. from 100 to 150

Clinical Material: IITV machine not working. 2. Complied with AERB & PNDT approval mentioned as Yes but But, will need physical verification. there is no documentary evidence for AERB 3. Complied with approval & PNDT approval. AERB approval photocopy attached. PNDT approval valid upto 11/2/2017 photocopy attached

subject to assurance/un dertaking by Chief Secretary Government of Karnataka to rectify the deficiencies. Approved

1. No deficiency recorded as per requirements for 150 Has higher version of machine. admission (1st renewal). However, one 60 mA 100 mA machine instead of 60 mA. mobile unit is deficient for recognition for 100 batch as per MSR. Accepted & Complied with No deficiency Higher version of machine available Application for Renewal attached Request to renew upto 31/12/2017, have also requested for an inspection. Under process and also from Drugs Controller that the license No. KTK/28c-25/1996 is under process and they are deemed valid till further decision.

46

Trust

Father Mullers Institute of Medical Education and Research, Mangalore, Karnataka

Renewal of 1. permission against increase intake from 100 to 150 seats 2nd batch

No mention for Blood Bank License renewal.

Approved.

35

Dr. R.P. Meena, Member Secretary

Dr. Kottilil Mohandas, Member, BOG

Dr. Raja Babu Panwar, Member, BOG

Dr. A.K. Bardhan, Member, BOG

Dr. Manoj K. Singh, Member, BOG

Dr. Brijendra Kumar Rao, Member, BOG

Dr. K.S. Sharma, Member, BOG

Dr. R.K. Srivastava, Chairman, Board of Governors