Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
Agenda
Background Central Counterparty Clearing Central Settlement Derivatives Collateral Management Credit Derivatives Standardisation Trade Reporting & Transparency
2
2009 JPMorgan Chase & Co. All rights reserved. JPMorgan Chase Bank, N.A.
Background
17 Sep 2009 Weekly recording of CDS trades in a centralised regulated repository: represents 17 July for Signatories + 60 days** 30 Sep 2009 All eligible new trades & novations must be confirmed on DTCC or other electronic platform Dec 2009 90% T+0 submission, and 94% T+2 matching for electronically eligible transactions (31 Dec) Latest date for Buy-side access to CDS Clearing (15 Dec)
Credit
30 Nov 2009 All eligible credit derivatives backloaded onto DTCC TIW 96% of settlements on DTCC-eligible trades to be centrally settled via TIW / CLS
Jun 09
Jul 09
Aug 09
Sep 09
Oct 09
Nov 09
Dec 09
Jan 10
Feb 10
Mar 10
Apr 10
May 10
Jun 10
Jul 10
Equity
30 Sep 2010 Universal recording of equity trades in a centralised regulated repository: represents 31 Jul 10 for signatories + 60 days**
30 Sep 2009 Strategic road map for cash flow recs, central netting & settlement
28 Feb 2010 Universal recording of IRD trades in a centralised regulated repository: represents 31 Dec 09 for signatories + 60 days**
Rates
30 Sep 2009 Marketwide solution for improved resolution of disputed margin calls (DR protocol), implementation schedule to follow
Collateral
31 Oct 2009 Feasibility study on market-wide portfolio reconciliation (undertaken by the ISDA Collateral Committee)
4
2009 JPMorgan Chase & Co. All rights reserved. JPMorgan Chase Bank, N.A.
be traded on a regulated (CFTC, SEC) exchange or alternative swap execution facility (ASEF)
Encourage Greater Standardisation through
in broader take-up of standard contracts, electronic confirmation services, central storage, payment automation and collateral management processes
Central Data Repositories to improve
transparency and improve operational efficiency (e.g., DTCCs Trade Information Warehouse); the EU will act upon the findings of a CESR review
Central Clearing industry commitment to achieve
regulators to the specific OTC transactions and positions of participants; also public access to aggregated data Also:
CCP clearing in Europe by 31 July 09; further incentivise the broader use of CCPs (e.g., through regulatory capital rules)
Move to Public Trading Venues the EC will
Extended regulation of dealers and major participants Robust and comprehensive regulation Position limits Protection of unsophisticated investors
examine how to arrive at a more transparent and efficient trading process for OTC derivatives
5
2009 JPMorgan Chase & Co. All rights reserved. JPMorgan Chase Bank, N.A.
Trade Cleared
Party A
CCP
Party B
2009 JPMorgan Chase & Co. All rights reserved. JPMorgan Chase Bank, N.A.
Example Offerings:
ICE (ICE Trust, ICE Clear) Contract type Full ISDA CME Future on commodity under Clearing Agreement referencing ISDA Language $300mn of ANC/Tier 1 capital $5m CDS security deposit, with fall-back to wider fund Stress-based IM Credit CDX IG, HVOL, XO iTraxx HVOL, XO 3, 5, 7, 10 yr tenors Latest 4 series SN constituents Key Infrastructure Full Support of DTCC, TIW, Icelink(T Zero), auctions TIW bronze entry, Clearport, CMDX Planned connectivity to DTCC EUREX SwapClear
ISDA language within ISDA Annex standard Clearing Conditions EUR 1bil of Tier 1 capital or higher Min $50m security deposit, risk adjusted FTD and liquidity based IM EU Domicile Credit iTraxx HVOL, HY, XO Latest 3 series Rates Vanilla IRS up to 30 years Euribor/Libor, 14 currencies Further products under development MarkitWire $5bil minimum capital Swap portfolio of $1trn+ A credit rating or above Required to bid in auctions
Membership requirements
$5bil of Tier 1 capital, A Credit $50m CDS security deposit Var/Monte Carlo-based IM Operational competence
Product Scope
Credit CDX IG, HVOL, HY, XO, iTraxx HVOL, HY, XO Latest 4 series Single names in testing
8
2009 JPMorgan Chase & Co. All rights reserved. JPMorgan Chase Bank, N.A.
1 2
Client
6 3
Dealer
2 6
4
Acceptance for Clearing
Middleware
5
Legal Confirmation
6a 6
Submission to TIW
DCM
CCP
6a
Transaction and Position Reporting
TIW
8 7
Settlement
CLS
(fees, coupons)
CCP
(margin)
Trade executed Dealer submits trade executed bilaterally to middleware for matching CCP is specified, this is a matching field Client Agrees trade in middleware (at this point legally binding bilateral trade) Client specifies the DCM, this is not a matching field Client specifies allocations if applicable Middleware will send a notification of the matched trades to DCM for acceptance DCM completes limit/eligibility checks and accepts/rejects trade for clearing Once all three parties have affirmed (client, dealer, DCM), middleware submits the trades to the CCP for clearing CCP determines if the trades are accepted for clearing and sends a message back to middleware If the trades are cleared middleware sends a message to all parties, with all trades DCM v client DCM v CCP (DCM client account) Dealer v CCP (dealer house account trade) DCM sends a message back to middleware with their references on the booked trades Either the dealer or client may also add IDs for submission to TIW, but assume they could have added these on initial submissions Middleware submits all trades on an individual (gross) basis to TIW as matched trades Settlement of fees and coupons via CLS, margin settles via CCP and clearing members, and between DCM and client
Legend:
Initial trade agreement and acceptance Trade notification (and enrichment)
Key Considerations Agreed trade between client and dealer should be a legally binding bilateral trade until cleared (potentially only for minutes but that state should exist) If trades not accepted for clearing then fallback to being bilateral If a trade is not affirmed then it cannot process through to clearing but is still legally binding between client and dealer based on execution Trades submitted on individual (gross) basis, netting/compression process to be completed separately from clearing submission Confirmation process unchanged initially, strategic goal to have affirmation = confirmation within middleware
2009 JPMorgan Chase & Co. All rights reserved. JPMorgan Chase Bank, N.A.
FUNCTION
Valuation Move to CCPs as source of MTM valuations on cleared trades Need to review and approve CCP valuation methodology by pricing committees? Comparison of CCP valuation to independent source
Confirmation CCP becomes a matching field, DCM to be determined/specified More aggressive timing (e.g., 30 mins following execution) Tracking of DCM and CCP acceptance, management of exceptions Access to Middleware workflow required (e.g., MarkitWire, ICE Link) Maintenance of CCP-related static data in middleware Backloading requirement
Counterparty Reconciliation Reconciliation of cleared positions to DCM and non-cleared positions to executing broker Reconciliation of eligible positions to DTCCs TIW
Collateral Management Management of initial margin and daily variation margin to & from DCMs Verification of margin amounts per CCP algorithm and clearing agreement with DCM no recourse to challenge Additional documentation (e.g., ISDA appendix, clearing agreements, compensation agreements)
Settlement Potential netting of daily cash flows to a single payment (i.e., coupon and fee settlements + daily margin requirement) Central settlement via CLS remains a goal for the buy side
Other (Credit) Processing impact of credit events (Rates) Impact of novation event: requires a declear and reclear process
10
2009 JPMorgan Chase & Co. All rights reserved. JPMorgan Chase Bank, N.A.
CCP checklist
9 Choice of CCP Are you making an assessment of the various CCP provider offerings? 9 Selection of Clearing Broker(s) Are you reviewing clearing broker capabilities?
Who would be your backup broker?
9 Timeline Are you aiming for implementation in 2009? 9 Middleware Are you live on the necessary workflow tools? 9 Process Flows Do your current process flows support the timeliness objectives for clearing? 9 Margin Have you considered the impact on your collateral requirements and process? 9 Backloading What is your existing population of eligible deals to be backloaded? 9 Additional Legals What additional legal documentation will you need to review and sign? 9 Administrator / Outsourced Provider Is your service provider ready to support procedural changes? 9 Commercials Are you clear on the costs of Clearing? What rate of interest will your DCM pay on
margin posted to them?
11
2009 JPMorgan Chase & Co. All rights reserved. JPMorgan Chase Bank, N.A.
Central Settlement
Benefits Benefits Certainty of settlement elimination of unexpected cash breaks and compensation claims Operational risk reduction through move from bilateral settlement to automated netted settlement Reduction in need for presettlement matching across multiple counterparties DTCC cash flow record is golden Netting across FX and OTC has the potential to reduce funding costs Impact Impact Move from bilateral (SWIFT, fax, file) instruction to custodian/PB, to automatic settlement messaging via TIW and CLS No match, dont pay settlement depends upon timely completion of confirmation process (by 12:00 ET on VD-1) Settlement netting by fund, counterparty, currency and value date Bifurcation of settlement processing based on instrument, currency, legal entity and position certainty status
13
2009 JPMorgan Chase & Co. All rights reserved. JPMorgan Chase Bank, N.A.
9 Backloading Have you backloaded all of your eligible positions into DTCC TIW (30 Nov 2009 target) 9 CLS Settlement Member Do you have access to a CLS settlement provider (direct, custodian, third
party)?
9 Custodian Readiness Have your custodians implemented central settlement capability? 9 Onboarding Notification Have you notified DTCC of your implementation plans? 9 Implementation Window Have you considered the implementation blackout periods around the
quarterly rolls?
9 Legal Documentation Have you signed the incremental documentation required by DTCC and your
custodian(s)?
9 User Acceptance Testing have you planned UAT with all participants (custodian, CLS,
counterparty)?
9 Outsourced Provider Is your provider ready to support the necessary changes to their OTC
settlement process flows?
14
2009 JPMorgan Chase & Co. All rights reserved. JPMorgan Chase Bank, N.A.
Benefits Benefits
Dispute Resolution Will set out roles and obligations during a dispute, set up escalation timelines and procedures Portfolio Reconciliation Will set out best practice guidelines around frequency, timelines and escalations during a reconciliation Independent Amounts Will set out possible solutions to issue of collateral held as an independent amount, and ways to implement Best Practice Collateral Guidelines Will set out an industry best practice around valuations, calculations, messaging and settlements
Impact Impact
Reconciliations and dispute resolution will create tighter standards of performance and remediation that will require training and infrastructure in order to comply Independent amount solutions may necessitate the bifurcation of initial and variation margin, create more segregated accounts at custodians, more tri-party agreements, and more infrastructure links between the sell side and custodians Best practice guidelines will tighten up procedures around grey areas in the market, and provide more guidance on standard practice and electives
16
2009 JPMorgan Chase & Co. All rights reserved. JPMorgan Chase Bank, N.A.
9 Wait and See Some of the developments around CCPs, especially around buy-side participation
and scope, are still being worked through. Some of the more immediate recommendations from ISDA are just that, and intended for large sell-side firms, although using them as a yardstick to view appropriateness is useful.
9 Technology and Operational Impact The impact of the changes being discussed may mean
more collateral accounts, with different margin practices (around accruals and upfront margin), so some form of mapping change will need to be implemented once confirmed, and SOPs (standard operating procedures) updated.
9 Outsourced Provider make sure that your outsourced provider has a view on all the upcoming
recommendations and changes, and that you are in regular discussion to ensure adherence to those changes. Futureproofing from potential changes is a key benefit of outsourcing.
17
2009 JPMorgan Chase & Co. All rights reserved. JPMorgan Chase Bank, N.A.
Impact Impact Changes to CDS contract terms: applicable to full open population - Big/Small Bang Protocols; applicable to new transactions only standardized CDS Changes to operations: existing responsibilities and procedures may need to be adapted (e.g., restructuring event processing on CDS indices requires additional bookings); Determination Committees activity requires monitoring Change management: rollout of multiple initiatives throughout the year has meant that timeframes may be compressed for planning, analysis, build (if applicable) and implementation
19
2009 JPMorgan Chase & Co. All rights reserved. JPMorgan Chase Bank, N.A.
9Adherence Did you adhere to the Big/Small Bang Protocols in April and July 2009? Did
you check whether your counterparties have adhered?
9Operational Impact Do you have the right tools to identify your trades impacted by
specific events that Determination Committees opine on?
9System Impact Can you differentiate between nonstandard and standard CDS? Do you
need to enhance any of your messaging to external parties?
9Outsourced Provider Is your provider ready to support the necessary changes: trade
processing, reporting, settlements, confirmations?
9Residual Population Are you trading any nonstandard CDS? 9Recouponing Has your front office considered whether potential liquidity reduction
might warrant recouponing of your legacy nonstandard trades?
20
2009 JPMorgan Chase & Co. All rights reserved. JPMorgan Chase Bank, N.A.
22
2009 JPMorgan Chase & Co. All rights reserved. JPMorgan Chase Bank, N.A.
23
2009 JPMorgan Chase & Co. All rights reserved. JPMorgan Chase Bank, N.A.