Sie sind auf Seite 1von 2

EvaluationCriteriaUsedbyTextbookReviewCommittee

SectionI:CorrelationwiththeStandardsofLearning Determinethedegreetowhichcontentfoundinthesetextbooksiscorrelatedwith theStandardsofLearningandtheCurriculumFrameworkforthissubject. Adequate Limited NoEvidence A L N (Note:Provideexamplesto (Note:Provideexamplesto supportthisrating.) supportthisrating.)
Lessonsarealignedwiththe Limitedconnectionsbetween standards. thestandardsandthelessons arenoted. Contentappearsaccurate,clear, Contentappearstocontain someinaccuraciesorisnot andinsequentialorder. alwaysclear. Essentialunderstandings, Mostoftheessential understandings,knowledge,and knowledge,orskillsarenot sufficientlyaddressed. skillsaresupported. Thereislimitedopportunityfor Manyopportunitiesare providedforstudentstopractice studentstopracticeessential skills. essentialskills. Commentsorconcernsrelatedtocontentaccuracy,bias,orediting: Nocorrelationbetweenthe standardsandthelessons. Alogicalsequenceofcontent cannotbeidentifiedand/orthere appeartobesignificantcontent inaccuracies. Essentialunderstandings, knowledge,orskillsarenot addressed. Opportunitiestopracticeessential skillsarenotincluded.

ApprovedbytheVirginiaBoardofEducation,March24,2011

EvaluationCriteriaUsedbyTextbookReviewCommittee
SectionII:RubricforInstructionalDesignandSupport (Reportedandmaybeusedincorrelationandapprovalconsiderations.)
Limited NoEvidence L N (Note:Provideexamplestosupport (Note:Provideexamplestosupport thisrating.) thisrating.) Criterion1Textbookispresentedinanorganized,logicalmannerandisappropriatefortheage,grade,andmaturity ofthestudents. Textbookislogicallyorganizedand Textbooklacksconsistencyin Textbookisnotreasonablyorganized grade/ageappropriateforstudents. organizationandappropriatenessfor andisinappropriateforthe thegrade/ageofstudents. grade/ageofthestudents. Criterion2Textbookisorganizedappropriatelywithinandamongunitsofstudy. Scopeandsequenceiseasytoread Scopeandsequenceisconfusingand Scopeandsequenceisdifficultto andunderstand. noteasytounderstand. readandunderstand. Criterion3Formatdesignincludestitles,subheadings,andappropriatecrossreferencingforeaseofuse. Organizationalpropertiesofthe Organizationalpropertiesofthe Organizationalpropertiesofthe textbookassistinunderstandingand textbookofferlimitedassistancein textbookdonotassistin processingcontent. understandingandprocessing understandingandprocessing content. content. Criterion4Writingstyle,syntax,andvocabularyareappropriate. Readabilityisappropriateforthe gradelevel.Writingstyleandsyntax arevariedandappropriateto enhancestudentunderstanding. Vocabularyconsistsofbothfamiliar andchallengingwords. Readabilitymaybeappropriatebutis inconsistentthroughoutthetext. Writingstyleandsyntaxmaybe inappropriateorlackvariety,offering limitedsupportforstudent understanding.Vocabularymaybe toochallengingortoofamiliar. Readabilityisnotappropriateforthe gradelevel.Writingstyleandsyntax areofteninappropriateandlack varietytoenhancestudent understanding.Vocabularyistoo challengingorunfamiliar. Adequate A

Criterion5Graphicsandillustrationsareappropriate. Visualsaresomewhatunclear and Visualsareinaccurate,donot offerlimitedsupportforthetextand supportthetext,anddonotenhance studentunderstanding. studentunderstanding. Criterion6Sufficientinstructionalstrategiesareprovidedtopromotedepthofunderstanding. Materialsprovidestudentswith Materialsprovidestudentswith Materialsprovidestudentswithno opportunitiestointegrateskillsand limitedopportunitiestointegrate opportunitiestointegrateskillsand concepts. skillsandconcepts. concepts. Visualsareaccurate,supportthetext, andenhancestudentunderstanding.

Note:Anysubjectareacriteriathatarerequiredinstatestatutewillbeincludedaspartofthestate review.TheDepartmentofEducationmayestablishcriteriaindicatorsthataresubjectareaspecific.

ApprovedbytheVirginiaBoardofEducation,March24,2011

Das könnte Ihnen auch gefallen