Sie sind auf Seite 1von 6


Ted Cruzs Remarks from his Colloquy on Defunding Obamacare with Sens. Mike Lee and Marco Rubio RUSH TRANSCRIPT

Mr. Cruz: I want to thank the Senator from Utah for his leadership on this issue. I am proud to stand with Senator Lee, with Senator Rubio and with so many others. I can tell you in the state of Texas, Texans overwhelmingly understand that Obamacare isn't working, that this legislation is failing and it's hurting the American people. If you look at jobs, there is no legislation currently in effect that is damaging the economy more or damaging jobs more than Obamacare. In response to the law 41% of small business owners have held off hiring employees. The U.S. chamber of commerce reports 71% of small businesses say Obamacare makes it harder to hire workers. Beyond that, one of the most pernicious aspects of this law is it is forcing more and more employees to be moved to part-time employment, moved to working 29 hours a week or less to get under the Obamacare 30-hour threshold. In 2013 employers added more part-time employees, averaging 93,000 a month seasonally adjusted than full-time workers. It is important to understand who it is hurt the most by Obamacare. It is not the C.E.O.'s, not the wealthy. It is young people, Hispanics, African-Americans, single moms. According to the most recent census data in 2011 the poverty rate for those who worked full time was 2.8%. The poverty rate for those working less than full time year round was 16.3%. Mr. President, I'm reminded of earlier in this year when we were debating the issue of Obamacare and I read from a newspaper article out of the state of Oklahoma that quoted a single mom working in a fast-food restaurant and she and all of her coworkers had her hours forcibly reduced to 29 hours a week or less, and this single mom said, I got two little kids at home. I can't feed my kids on 29 hours a week, and neither can the other single moms struggling to make ends meet. Beyond the impact on jobs, on the economy, beyond those being forced into part-time work, we also have the compliance costs. According to federal agency estimates, Obamacare will add paperwork burdens totaling nearly 190 million hours or more every year. And, Mr. President, to put that

in perspective, Mount Rushmore, which took 14 years to build, could be instructed 1,547 times with the paperwork Obamacare requires in one year. Not only do we see jobs being hurt, hours being reduced, paperwork going up, but we're seeing premiums going up, premiums going up far too high. And it's hitting those who are suffering the most. On Monday Florida's insurance commissioner told the palm beach post that insurance rates will rise by 5% to 20% in the small-group market and by 30% to 40% in the individual market. Mr. President, to those who are at home in Florida watching what's happening, as they're seeing their insurance rates go up, they're going up because of the impact of this failed law. The Ohio Department of Insurance announced that Obamacare in Ohio will increase the individual market health premiums by 88%. Mr. President, if you're in Ohio right now and seeing your premiums go up, you can thank the men and women of the U.S. congress. According to the Wyman firm looking at young people, young people in particular are hurt by Obamacare. The Wyman firm estimates that 80% of Americans age 21 to 29 earning more than $16,000 will pay more out of pocket for coverage under Obamacare than today. Mr. President, if young people at home are watching this today and wondering about are they going to get a job, how are they going to climb the economic ladder? How are they going to achieve the American dream? Obamacare is driving up their health care premiums right now. And we all know that the President promised the American people at the time Obamacare was being debated if you like your health care plan, you can keep it. Mr. President, the facts have conclusively proven that wrong. According to a February 2013 report by the Congressional Budget Office, seven million people will lose their employer-sponsored insurance. Mackenzie and Company, a very well- regarded accounting firm found 30% of employers will definitely or probably stop offering health insurance in the years after 2014. Mr. President, this bill isn't working, and I would note that there is a growing bipartisan consensus on that front. As the facts have come in, the American people have kept an open mind, have looked at this bill and have seen that as it's being implemented, it is not working. It's hurting the economy, hurting jobs. According to an ABC/Washington Post poll, in 2010, 74% of moderate and conservative democrats, there are a significant number of democrats that describe themselves as moderate or conservative, in 2010, 70% supported Obamacare. In July just 46% supported Obamacare. Not only that we have seen the lead Senate author of Obamacare, a senior Democrat in this body describe Obamacare as headed towards a -- quote -- "huge train wreck." 2

We have seen over and over against unions -- which initially supported Obamacare turning as they realized the consequences. In April the united union of roofers and allied workers called for -- quote -- "repeal or complete reform of the affordable care act to protect our employers, our industry and our most important assets: our members and their family." Mr. President, if you listen to the voice of unions, unions are saying Obamacare is failing, it's not working. The international brotherhood of electrical workers released a white paper in July explaining that Obamacare -- quote -- "threatens to harm our members by dismantling multiemployer health plans." and then really quite striking, James Hoffa Jr., the President of the Teamsters union, wrote a letter to Senator Reid and Nancy Pelosi saying -- quote -- "Obamacare will destroy the well- being of our members along with other hardworking Americans." why? Mr. Hoffa explained Obamacare is destroying the 40-hour work week that has been the backbone of the working middle class." Mr. President, if you have a concern of the American middle class, listen to the bipartisan voices that are rising up saying Obamacare isn't working. And most strikingly, Mr. President, with President Obama himself who just a few weeks ago was forced to unilaterally and without legal authority delay implementation of Obamacare for large corporations, with companies for more than 50 employees he unilaterally moved the employer mandate until after the next election. Mr. President, I would suggest there are at least two things we can derive from President Obama's decision to do that. Number one, if Obamacare were a good thing, if it were working, we can be sure President Obama would want it to go into full effect before the next election. He would want to take credit with the American people for the benefits of this signature bill. The fact that the President was forced to concede the wheels are coming off and to move the employer mandate until after the next election, I would suggest is highly, highly revealing. But number two, Mr. President, it raises the obvious follow-up question. Why is President Obama willing to grant a waiver for giant corporations but not for hardworking American families? Not for the men and women who are struggling to make ends meet, who are climbing the economic ladder, who want like our parents and grandparents before them to achieve the American dream. Obamacare is standing in their way. So what are we to do about it? Well, Mr. President, the most important constitutional check and balance that congress has on an overreaching executive is the power of the purse. And the framers of the Constitution wisely gave authority over expenditures of money to the United States Congress, and that is why the Senator from Utah, the Senator from Florida and I, along with many others, are standing together and saying this isn't working, and Congress should defund it. 3

In 62 days the continuing resolution which funded the federal government will expire. Each of the three of us along with a number of others have publicly stated under no circumstances will we support a continuing resolution that funds one penny of Obamacare. If 41 members of this body stand together and make that same statement, or if 218 members in the House of Representatives stand together and take that same position, we can do something different than we've seen this year. The past couple of years we've seen 39, 40, 41 votes to repeal Obamacare, all of which have been effectively symbolic because none of them had a real chance of passage. Mr. President, with a continuing resolution, we have a chance to successfully defund Obamacare. Now right now we don't have the votes in this institution. If the vote were held today, we would not hold 41 Senators to defund Obamacare. But we've got 62 days until September 30, and every one of us takes very seriously our obligation to represent our constituents. And if in the next 62 days we see what I believe we're going to see, which is the American people rising up en masse, hundreds of thousands, millions of Americans standing up saying it isn't working, it's hurting our jobs, it's hurting our economy, it's hurting our health care, it's making our lives worse. Stand up and defund it. If enough Americans speak out and demand of their elected officials that we do the right thing, Mr. President, I'm confident we will. I'm confident republicans will. And I am hopeful that members of the Democratic Party will as well. That every one of us, Mr. President, I believe the American people should hold their elected officials accountable and that most assuredly includes me. It includes all of us. We should be held accountable by our constituents. And the American people know this bill isn't working. There's bipartisan agreement on it. And we have a potential in the next 62 days to show real leadership. Not to give a speech. Not to give a meaningless symbolic vote. But if we stand together to actually defund it. And let me make one final point, which is those who disagree with the position that is being taken by Senator Lee and Senator Rubio and myself say that taking this stand will mean that Republicans will be blamed for a government shutdown. Let me be clear what I think should happen. I believe the House of Representatives should pass a continuing resolution, should fund the entirety of the federal government except for Obamacare, and should explicitly prohibit further funding of Obamacare, should adopt the legislation that I've introduced as a condition to the continuing resolution. 4

Now the next step, there will be partisan critics who immediately charge Republicans with threatening to shut down the government. Mr. President, I would suggest that we then take the argument to the American people. That it is the American people that should decide if there are members of this body who are willing to shut down the American government in order to force Obamacare down the throats of the American people, in order to say President Obama will grant a waiver to giant corporations but not to hardworking American families, let's take that argument to the American people because I think the American people want economic growth back. That should be our top priority. Nothing is killing jobs more. Nothing is hurting the American economy more than Obamacare. There's bipartisan agreement on that, and I am hopeful that members of this body will stand and lead. And I thank the Senator from Utah for taking the lead on what I believe is the most important battle that this congress will confront. Mr. Cruz: Mr. President, I do indeed share those thoughts and feelings. And I would ask the Senator from Utah if he would yield for a series of three short questions? Mr. Cruz: The first question is, there has been much talk of a shutdown and am I correct that we don't have to hypothesize what a shutdown would look like. We have in fact seen that in 1959 with two temporary partial shutdowns that occurred when republicans in the house stood up to President Clinton. When that occurred in 1995 we saw several things. Number one, we saw the parade of horrors that is brought out, did not occur. Social security checks continued to flow. The military continued to be funded. Interest on the debt continued to be paid. Planes didn't fall out of the sky. And indeed what occurs if Democrats decide to block a continuing resolution and force a temporary shutdown in order to force Obamacare on the American people is a partial, temporary shutdown where nonessential government services get suspended for a period of time, not a shutdown of essential services such as paying for the men and women who are fight for the military and providing social security checks. We have seen that in the past, is that correct?

Mr. Cruz: A second question I would ask is this week we saw the rather -- stunning news that the IRS employees unions shall, the men and women at the IRS charged with enforcing Obamacare are asking not to be made subject to Obamacare. Indeed, the union leaders have sent to their union members draft letters to send members of this body saying we, the IRS employees' union, do not want to be subject to Obamacare. Likewise, Obamacare subjects members of this body and their staffs to Obamacare. And I am not aware of a single senate office that is not deeply concerned about that, that is not faced with staff quitting the office because the harms of Obamacare are so significant and there has been many a panicked discussion among Democrats and Republicans about what to do about subjecting members and their staff to Obamacare. My second of three short questions is what does it say to you that the IRS employees union is asking, let us out from Obamacare and that members and congressional staff are deeply concerned about the harms Obamacare is going to do to that them? Mr. Cruz: And my third, brief question is for those in this body who have chained at home, who have told their constituents they're opposed to Obamacare, on January 1 the exchanges going up and you running, the subsidies begin, and the history of the modern entitlement state is that any time a subsidy has been put in place, it has proven politically virtually impossible to undo. Indeed, no major entitlement has that has been implemented in modern times has ever been undone. For those who say they oppose Obamacare, what is the alternative to defunding Obamacare with the continuing resolution? And let me ask it a separate way. If we do not defund it, am I correct that come January 1, Republicans will essentially be surrendering that in all likelihood Obamacare will be a permanent feature of the economy, hurting the economy, hurting jobs, hurting low-income workers, hurting our health care system? And if that's correct, has any reasonable alternative been proffered by anyone on this side of the senate to stop that harm other than what you and Senator Rubio and I and remembers are trying to do?