Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
Third Party Administrators (TPAs) are the intermediaries who bring all
the components of health care delivery - hospitals, physicians, clinics, long-term
care facilities and pharmacies - into a single entity. They extend quality health
care and services at reasonable costs. It is important to take an overview of the
health insurance scenario in India before taking a detailed look at the
functioning of TPAs. IRDA has defined TPA's as "An insurance intermediary
licensed by the Authority who, either directly or indirectly, solicits or effects
coverage of, underwrites, charges premium from an insured, or adjusts or settle
claims in connection with health insurance, except as an agent or broker or an
insurer."
1
(iii) TPAs insist on standardization of fee structure of medical
services/procedures across providers;
(iv) healthcare providers do experience substantial delays in settling of
their claims by the TPAs;
(v) hospital administrators perceive significant burden in terms of effort
and expenditure after introduction of TPA and
(vi) no substantial increase in patient turnover after empanelling with
TPAs. However, there is an indication that hospital administrators
foresee business potential in their association with TPA in the long-run.
There is a clear indication from the study that the regulatory body
needs to focus on developing mechanisms, which would help TPAs to
strengthen their human capital and ensure smooth delivery of TPA
services in emerging health insurance market.
2
INTRODUCTION
TPAs were introduced by the IRDA in the year 2001. The core service of
a TPA is to ensure better services to policyholders. Their basic role is to function
as an intermediary between the insurer and the insured and facilitate cash less
service at the time of hospitalization. A minimum capital requirement of Rs.10
million and a capping of 26% foreign equity are mandatory requirements for a
TPA as spelt by the IRDA. License is usually granted for a minimum period of
three years.
3
Ideally, the TPA functions by collaborating with the hospitals in order for
the patient to enjoy hospitalization services on a cashless basis. The job of TPA s
is to maintain a database of policy holders and issue identity cards with unique
identification numbers to them. They also handle all the policy- related issues,
including claim settlements for the policy holders.
Once the policy has been issued, all the records will be passed on to the
TPAs and all further correspondence of the insured will be with the TPAs and
not with the insurance companies. The TPA's are expected to provide value-
added services to the consumers, like arranging ambulance services, medicines
and supplies, guiding policy holders for specialized consultation, and providing
information about 24- hour help lines, health facilities, bed availability,
organization of lifestyle management and well- being programs. With the advent
of TPA, the insurance companies aim at ensuring higher efficiency,
standardization of charges, greater awareness and penetration of health
insurance to a larger section of the people.
4
Emergence of Third Party Administrator
The Indian health care system, one of society’s largest and most
influential institutions, is on the threshold of profound cultural and structural
changes because large buyers of services are wresting partial control from
providers in order to restrain escalating costs. Major corporations and insurers
have been rudely awakened from the spiraling of medical expenses paid by them
and are aggressively pursuing methods to curtail medical costs from continuing
to rise at about twice the general rate of inflation.
5
By the end of the 20th century, however, more and more businesses with
none of these special needs also began to contract on a competitive basis for the
health care of their employees. Commercial insurance companies of the day also
got involved, putting together packages of services for a flat amount per person
per year (capitation) or for a discounted fee schedule.
More widespread than early corporate health care plans are rapid
comprehensive health care services offered for a flat subscription price per year
to members of a group. This concept has proliferated rapidly in the recent past.
Informal reporting attests to the prevalence of such plans and of "contract
practice", as competitive health care. Practically all the large cities are fairly
honeycombed with nursing homes, steadily increasing in number, with a
constantly growing membership. The government has also become involved in
organized buying near the turn of the century. Municipal and state agencies are
thinking of putting out for bid service contracts for the poor, and also for civil
employees.
6
Third Party Administrators have had a tremendous impact on the hospital
industry and on the health care system in general. Hospital administrators seem
so concerned that they quickly cut staff, reduce inventory, and have briefing
sessions with physicians to encourage shorter stays.
They establish internal monitoring systems to weed out or re-educate those
providers who run up expenses with too many tests or procedures. Secondary
industries arise around maximizing payments and around clinical management
systems. Profits (or surpluses) subsequently reach an all-time high, but the era of
dehospitalization has begun. Insurers responded to the profits by paying less.
They do not give the insurers an increase as large as overall medical inflation.
As a result, profits and surpluses have dropped to razor-thin levels, and many
hospitals run deficits. Admissions and length of stay continue to decline.
Such integrated delivery systems bring all the components of health care
delivery - such as physicians, hospitals, clinics, home health long-term care
facilities and pharmacies into a single entity – and takes upon financial risk.
Insurers expect the TPAs to deliver high quality health care and services at less
cost; balance cost of treatment with the need to provide more comprehensive
health promotion and disease prevention. The utilization of such a system
encourages appropriate treatment, discourages over treatment, encourages
preventive care, and attempts to promote cost containment and quality health
care delivery.
7
Third Party Administrators for
Health Insurance
While call center facilities and personalized financial planning tools are
some of the innovative trends, experienced in the products front, the best thing
to happen on the service front is the introduction of third party administrators as
they serve as a vital link between insurance companies, policyholders and health
care providers
8
TPAs were introduced by the IRDA in the year 2001. The core service of a TPA
is to ensure better services to policyholders. Their basic role is to function as an
intermediary between the insurer and the insured and facilitate cash less service
at the time of hospitalization. A minimum capital requirement of Rs.10 million
and a capping of 26% foreign equity are mandatory requirements for a TPA as
spelt by the IRDA. License is usually granted for a minimum period of three
years. Ideally, The TPA functions by collaborating with the hospitals in order for
the patient to enjoy hospitalization services on a cashless basis.
9
FUNCTIONING
TPAs sort out health care providers by setting up a network with hospitals,
general practitioners, diagnostic centres, pharmacies, dental clinics etc. They
sign a memorandum of understanding with insurance companies under which
they let policyholders know about the various health care delivery facilities and
the methods for settling claims.
10
The agreement between TPA's and health care facilities includes the
collection of documents and bills concerning the treatment. Documents are
assessed and sent to the insurance company for reimbursement. TPA's also
procure reimbursements from the insurance company and pay the healthcare
provider. TPA's usually have in-house specialists comprising of medical
practitioners, insurance consultants, legal experts and IT professionals. The
mainstay of TPA's is information management system.
11
SERVICES
The TPA undoubtedly aims to give the health insurance industry the required
boost in India.
12
The specialized functions of the TPA include:
[[[
• The TPA keeps and maintains all the records of medical insurance policies
of an insurer.
• The TPA issues identity cards to all the policyholders. The policyholders
will have to show the identity cards to the hospital authorities before
availing any services from the hospital.
• TPA pays for the treatment; they issue an authorization letter to the
hospital for the admission of the policyholder in the hospital.
• At the point of discharge, all the bills will be sent to the TPA while they
are tracking the case of the insured at the hospital.
13
• TPA sends all the documents necessary for consideration of claims, along
with the bills to the insurance company.
14
Third Party Administrators Regulations
Presently TPA licenses are issued to render health services. It is hoped that
effectively this will lead to cash less hospitalisation services. In contrast to
earlier scenario where the insured is reimbursed all the hospitalisation expenses,
in the present scenario TPA would tie-up with the hospitals and all the
hospitalisation services would be on cash less basis. Below is an overview of the
activities of TPA
15
To offer their services TPAs, after getting license have to forge alliances with
insurers. To this extent TPAs have no role to play if they are not empanelled by
Insurers. As discussed earlier TPAs will be remunerated by insurers and
remuneration shall be fixed on a mutually agreeable terms. However IRDA has
laid down a maximum ceiling on the commission that can be given to a TPA,
which presently stands at 15% of premium amount. TPAs shall also have to tie-
up with hospitals, which offer hospitalisation services. Further each TPA may
tie-up with any number of insurers and like wise each insurer can empanel any
number of TPAs.
16
Responsibility of the insurer: The insurer will be responsible for determining
the benefits, premium rates, underwriting criteria and claims payment
procedures that shall be followed by the TPA. Additionally, any reinsurance
requirements for this line of business carried on by it will be arranged by the
insurer.
Agreement:
(1) No TPA shall act as such without a written agreement between the TPA
and the insurer, and such an agreement shall be retained as part of the
official records of both the insurer and the TPA for the duration of the
agreement and for five years thereafter.
(2) The written agreement shall include a statement of duties which the TPA
is expected to perform on behalf of the insurer, and the types of policies of
insurance which the TPA is authorized to administer.
(3) The agreement shall make provisions on underwriting or other standards
pertaining to the policies underwritten which the TPA will adopt while
acting so.
(4) The insurer or TPA may, by written notice, terminate the agreement for
causes provided in the agreement. The insurer may suspend the
underwriting authority of the TPA during the pendency of any dispute
between them.
(5) The insurer shall fulfill all lawful obligations with respect to the policies
covered by the written agreement, regardless of any dispute between it
and the TPA.
17
Conditions and Procedures for Licensing of TPA
• Only a Company with a share capital and registered under the Companies
Act, 1956 can function as a TPA.
• The main or primary object of the company shall be to carry on business
in India as a TPA in the health services, and on being licenced by the
Authority, the company shall not engaged itself in any other business.
• He shall not be:
a) A person of unsound mind,
b) An undischarged insolvent ,
c) A person who had been subjected to a term of imprisonment for a
period of three months by a court of competent jurisdiction on
grounds of misconduct, misfeasance, forgery, etc.
18
CODE OF CONDUCT FOR TPA
A third party administrator licenced under insurance regulations shall act in the
best professional manner as underlined in the licence. In particular and without
prejudice to the generality of the provisions contained above, it shall be the duty
of every TPA, its Chief Administrative Officer and its employees or
representatives to:
• Ascertain its identity to the public to the insured and that of the insurance
company with which it has entered into an agreement.
• Make known its licence to the insured.
• Disclose the details of the services it is authorized to render in respect of
health insurance products under an agreement with an insurance company.
• Bring to the notice of the insurance company with whom it has an
agreement, any adverse report or inconsistencies or any business.
• Obtain all the requisite documents pertaining to the examination of an
insurance claim arising out of insurance contract concluded by the
insurance company with the insured.
• Render necessary assistance specified under the agreement and advice to
policyholders or claimants or beneficiaries in complying with the
requirements for settlements of claims with the insurance company.
• Conduct itself / himself in a courteous and professional manner.
• Refrain from acting in a manner, which may influence directly or
indirectly insured of a particular insurance company to shift the insurance
portfolio from the existing insurance company to another insurance
company.
19
• Refrain from trading on information and the records of its business.
• Maintain the confidentiality of the data collected by it in the course of
agreement.
• Abstain from including an insured to omit any material information, or
submit wrong information.
• Desist from demanding or receiving a share of the proceeds or indemnity
from the claimant under an insurance contract.
• Pursue the guidelines / directions that may be issued down by the
Authority from time to time.
20
What is Mediclaim Cashless Settlement
The insurance company settles the bill directly. The aim behind it to
reduce the direct financial burden on insured at the time of hospitalization.
Insurance company will directly settle the bill through TPA.
21
co. & a hospital. It verifies the policy details of the beneficiary, on behalf of the
insurer, & provides clearance for cashless services.
PLANNED HOSPITALISATION
The TPA needs the prescription with the details of the medical history along
with the following particulars:
22
• The process will take 3-5 hours.
EMERGENCY HOSPITALISATION
Benefits:
23
Precautions:
24
ROLE OF THIRD PARTY ADMINISTRATOR
25
Before IRDA allowed the TPAs to formally enter the market, there were
intermediaries who were acting on behalf of the corporate and playing a very
similar role to that of present-day TPAs. Corporate were utilizing these agencies
to help them make the process of claim reimbursement easier and smoother for
their employees. Also, these agencies were helping to market the insurance
products available – mainly Mediclaim – to corporate.
26
Market for TPAs in India
Health insurance premiums in India have risen from Rs 531 crore in
2000-01 to Rs 1,045 crore in 2002-03, which includes overseas medical policies
(IRDA Journal 2003). The four public sector insurance companies have hiked
premium by 6 per cent since January 2003, apparently to factor in cost
escalation as a result of the appointment of TPAs as mandated by IRDA.
However, this revision comes on the heels of another hefty hike of 15 per cent
implemented exactly a year earlier (Business Line, December 31, 2002). The
TPAs are being paid 5.5 per cent of gross premium as commission. Based on a
figure of over Rs 1,000 crore of premiums, this means that the total business for
TPAs in India is about Rs 50 crore. Some business is, however, being conducted
without TPAs. Based on the rate of growth of insurance premiums in just one
year, it is possible that health insurance will grow much more in coming years,
giving more business to the TPAs.
Given the current business of about Rs 50 crore, it may seem that even
these 23 TPAs are probably too many. The market is already divided among
some that have cornered the major part of the business. However, while bigger
TPAs are more effective, for pan-Indian operations, some of the smaller TPAs
are also doing well in terms of quality of service, in their limited areas of
operation. Success or lack of it depends on a fine balance of essentially three
parameters: (a) share of total business, (b) availability of capital, and (c)
geographic spread of operations. As in any market, the unsuccessful players are
expected to exit the business. In the TPA market, the inefficient players, who are
not able to satisfy their main customers, would in theory exit the market;
however, as will be discussed below, this has not really happened in India.
27
The reason ultimately is that the TPA market is not really like any other
market: neither the entry nor the exit of TPAs from the market is really free. As
mentioned above, the entry of TPAs was based on rationing of the total business
and not a natural entry based on market considerations. Similarly, the exit of
inefficient TPAs is also not due to market forces and, in fact, has not taken place
at all.
To illustrate how the system works, let us assume that the claims ratio of
Mediclaim is 100 per cent. This means that for a premium of Rs 1 crore (Rs 100
lakh) per annum, the claim would also be Rs 100 lakh. Let us also assume that
the turnaround time – the time taken from the time of service delivery to the
payment by the insurance company to the TPA – for a claim on average is 15
days (presuming efficient turnaround time). For a 15-day period, the claim
amount would be around Rs 4 lakh on an annual claim of Rs 100 lakh. Hence if
the insurance company insists on bank guarantees, and the turnaround time for
claims is on average 15 days, then for each Rs 1 crore of business, the TPA has
to arrange for a bank guarantee of Rs 4 lakh. The bank would charge a
commission while issuing the bank guarantee. Further, it would also insist on a
cash margin. If the margin requirement were 50 per cent of the bank guarantee,
then Rs 2 lakh cash margin would have to be provided for the issuance of a bank
guarantee of Rs 4 lakh for business worth Rs 1 crore. For business worth Rs
1,000 crore, bank guarantees worth Rs 40 crore would have to be provided. This
would require a cash margin of Rs 20 crore, assuming 50 per cent margin.
28
Thus the requirement of working capital for TPAs goes up substantially.
This example clearly indicates that pan-Indian operations would require a
substantial amount of working capital for TPAs and of bank guarantee in
proportion to the size of the business. Initially, some TPAs could not make the
reimbursements to the hospitals and/or the customers on time, with resultant
confusion and frustration on the part of all the stakeholders. Even now, some
hospitals continue to complain about not receiving payment on time.
As for the basic design of the new system of cashless payment, it is clear
that the entire system is not as yet cashless; a significant portion of the
Mediclaim business is still in the form of reimbursement to the policyholder.
One TPA mentioned a 30-70 split between cashless and reimbursement;
however, this may vary widely among TPAs. The reason for not moving over to
the cashless system could be both a preference of consumers who like to visit
their selected hospitals that are not on the TPA network, or the hospitals, who
prefer to be paid by patients directly rather than wait for settlement. A third
reason is an emergency situation where the consumer does not have much of a
choice.
29
Benefits of TPAs
30
Secondly, the cashless system is definitely an improvement over the
reimbursement scheme, and the choice set for such cashless transactions
expanded when the TPAs succeeded in enlisting many more hospitals and
nursing homes on the approved list eligible for cashless facility. From the
perspective of the insurance companies, the TPAs benefit them by bringing
down the claims ratio, by reducing false claims as well as standardizing
treatment costs.
Finally, the TPAs can play a huge role in making appropriate data
available for actuarial calculations, because they are the recipients of morbidity
data that are linked with individual characteristics such as age. From a research
and policy perspective too, the availability of such data is of immense value.
31
Poor hospital network of TPAs dents Mediclaim Cashless
Service plan
Mediclaim cashless service introduced by general insurance companies is
yet to take off. It has been six months since the four public sector insurance
companies - New India Assurance, United India Insurance, National Insurance
and Oriental Insurance - launched the Mediclaim cashless service, but 80 per
cent of claims still continue to be reimbursed. In other words, cashless service
has been effective in only 20 per cent of the claims.
The Insurance Division of the Ministry of Finance has cited the weak
hospital network of Third Party Administrators (TPAs) as the main reason for
cashless Mediclaim not taking off as proposed. ‘‘In big cities, the numbers of
hospitals under the TPA network are inadequate. As a result, 80 per cent of
policy holders go to small and medium hospitals for treatment and these
institutions are not in the network. This is the main reason for such high levels
of reimbursements,’’ S K Mahapatra, secretary general, General Insurance
Public Sector Association (GIPSA), told Express Healthcare Management.
The Finance ministry is now calling for expansion of the TPA hospital
network by inviting more hospitals to get empanelled with TPAs. Last month,
the Division appointed four nodal TPAs (one for each region) to process new
applications. The four nodal TPA appointed include Paramount Health Services
for the Western region, Medicare for East and North, and TTK and Family
Health Plan in the South. These nodal TPAs would also take upon the task of
improving the system by exploring options of grading and standardizing hospital
procedures like billing and admission procedures.
32
General Insurance Public Sector Association (GIPSA) is planning to
convene a meeting this month to review the service levels of 10 TPAs appointed
by public sector insurance companies to discuss and implement steps suggested
by the finance ministry, S K Mahapatra said.
Besides weak network, infrastructure at the TPA level is also blamed for
high number of reimbursements. The primary complaint is delay in issuing
identity cards to policy holders. ‘‘Policy holders have been complaining that
they have not got their cards. Without identity cards, hospitals refuse to provide
cashless service to the patients,’’ says Subhash Wasnikar, divisional manager,
New India Assurance. Subir Bhattacharya, manager, United India, admits that
they have received complaints on delay in issuance of identity cards, delay in
claim settlements, etc against TPAs.
But TPAs say patients are not yet used to the system of cashless service
and it will take some time. ‘‘Patients do not carry identity cards or there are
instance where patients do not furnish sufficient medical details for pre-
authorization by TPAs. Patients also do not go through the information brochure
sent by TPAs leading to inconveniences, says Dr Nayan Shah, managing
director, Paramount Health Services.
TPA service is another sore point among policy holders. ‘‘My TPA sent
me the list of hospitals only after I called and fired them,’’ says Dr Rao.
Mediclaim subscribers feel that they should also have the choice of TPAs.
Another policy holder said despite his TPA mentioning a name of a particular
hospital in Mumbai in its panel, treatment was refused to the policy holder. The
reason offered was that the particular TPA was not recognized by the hospital.
‘‘If I had the choice of TPA, I could have ensured that this does not happen,’’ he
says.
33
The problems facing effective implementation of cashless service extend
to hospitals as well, say experts.
Both insurance companies and TPAs say these are early days and
problems are bound to exist, which will be sorted out soon. ‘‘It is true that most
TPAs have failed to issue identity cards. But, these are due to teething problems,
which will be sorted very soon. Adds Mahapatra, ‘‘It is too premature to review
and judge the TPAs. It is a learning process for them too and also for insurance
companies and policy holders.’’
Another problem is the surge in patient base. Earlier, TPAs used to pay
deposits to the hospitals for cashless service. But, with increasing patient base, it
is not possible to do so, say TPAs. ‘‘For a hospital, the number of cashless
service has increased five times after Mediclaim began offering cashless
service,” says Dr Nayan Shah.
Insurance companies and TPAs assure that they are working towards
building an efficient system. GIPSA plans to launch awareness campaigns on
TPA services, while TPAs plan to hold seminars to educate the stake holders on
the evolving changes in the health insurance sector and on how to gear up to
meet the challenges.
But, experts say, public sector insurance companies need to gear up pretty
fast to match consumer expectations. How serious are insurance companies in
building up an efficient system remains a question mark as Bhattacharya says,
‘‘we can always fall back on the old one if this fails.’’
34
Insurance Companies Working on Measures to Speed Up
There have been widespread complaints that TPAs do not issue cheques to
claimants on time. They divert the claims funds for other activities, delaying
payments to hospitals and policyholders. There have also been instances where
cheques issued by TPAs have bounced.
35
Do's and Don'ts For Policy Holders
Do's
36
Don'ts
The bottom-line is that before undergoing any treatment check all the facts with
TPA's to avoid disappointment.
37
TPA-related Challenges
38
Future role
In the fast developing health insurance sector the TPAs have crucial roles to
play in the future. Some of them are
39
CONCLUSION
Third party administrator in health service will also play an important role in
insurance sector but Health insurance is not very popular in India as people are
not taking Health Insurance because it is a costly proposal. Furthermore there is
lack of awareness amongst people about the benefit they can derive from Health
Insurance. At present, Health Insurance is purchased by those people who are
affluent and can afford to pay the medical bills whereas it is actually required by
those who can ill afford the costly medical treatment. With the entry of the TPAs
this concept will spread and more people will go in for Health Insurance.
40