Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
2013
STUDY GUIDE
Chair: Kritika Lama Vice Chair: Biswash Adhikari Moderator: Biraj Koirala
CONTENTS
INTRODUCTION ....................................................................................................................... 3 HISTORY OF THE COMMITTEE ............................................................................................... 4 OVERVIEW OF THE SECURITY COUNCIL .............................................................................. 5 CUBAN MISSILE CRISIS STATEMENT OF THE PROBLEM ....................................................... 6 CURRENT SITUATION....................................................................................................................... 11 QARMQARMA: QUESTIONS A RESOLUTION MUST ANSWER.............................................15 POSITION PAPER REQUIREMENTS ......................................................................................16 BLOC POSITIONS ....................................................................................................................17 CONCLUSION ..........................................................................................................................19 REFERENCES .........................................................................................................................20
INTRODUCTION
The Historical Security Council has on its docket one issue to center on for the duration of this conference: the Cuban Missile Crisis. Before leaping into the matters at stake, I want to outline my vision for the committee. The HSC is all about deciding global events of a world past. I envision that the committee will function as a blend of a standing and crisis committee. Every session as a committee you must be able to produce a resolution advocating actions, radical and reforming. The year is 1962, delegates, and world peace is a meager dream for the leaders of the globe. It is a perilous time; one that is filled with political tension, turmoil, and a looming nuclear holocaust on the cards. The nations of earth are innocent bystanders as the USA and USSR fight it out in in proxy wars. The Cuban Missile Crisis, however, is unlike any other. The first documented instance of the threat of mutual assured destruction, it was perhaps the closest the world ever came to nuclear war. The committee begins on October 22, as Kennedy announces the discovery of the missile installations to the public and his decision to quarantine the island. He decrees that any nuclear missile launched from Cuba would be regarded as an attack on the United States by the Soviet. As delegates your challenge will be to overcome the deadlock which might result from the spirit of the Cold War, the ability of the Great Powers to veto and still find a solution for the most dangerous crisis which the world has ever faced.
Historic Security Council is granted the ability to take enforcement measures so as to sustain or reinstate international peace and security. Such measures encompass sanctions, either economic or others, as well as other methods which do not involving the use of armed forces in case of international military action. With five permanent members: UK, USA, China, France, and Russia, it contains many of the worlds most significant and influential voices. This year, the Historical Security Council committee will have to undertake challenges which will push the committee to its limits. With new challenges and perspectives, the Historical Security Council will have to attempt to quickly and resolutely solve the entrancing issues which once had the world on edge. HSC will give you an opportunity to model a conflict from the past, pondering over different outcomes, perhaps even different from the ones in the past. In the conference, the HSC will look upon history from the perspective of the year 1994. However, from that moment onward, the HSC members exercise freedom based on the series of all the choices within the capabilities of them and their governments. Effective role playing for an HSC Member State will not just be a replay of the nationwide decisions as they once evolved in 1994. Indeed, the problems of the age may not emerge as they once did. While role replays must be in character, it is not a sure that, given a second chance to look at events in the past, any given national government would do things exactly the same way. The delegates are responsible to make use of their countries national policies to solve the proble ms and issues. The conference will follow a timeline based on the actions as they occurred, modified by the delegates policy decisions in the committee. As their nations voice, the delegates have the freedom to make any declarative statements they like. The Historic Security Council thus holds a great responsibility as it has to address questions that can change the course of history.
when USSR tried to keep the mission a secret. The Cuban government however did not want to surpass any International Law.
On October 16, an American U2 spy plane photographed nuclear missile site built by the USSR in Cuba. The President of USA, John F. Kennedy, did not show any reaction to this event recently. He made a secret group where he discussed the matter for several days. The American bloc did not want the opponent to know about their discovery. However on October 22, President Kennedy announced about the secret mission during his speech on TV where he claimed naval blockade would be imposed to Cuba. He
specified that any attack to USA from Cuba would mean an attack from USSR and were warned to remove the entire Soviet Army from the nation. On the other hand the Soviet Army was instructed to use the missile and forces in any case of emergency. On the 23rd Kennedy ordered six Crusader jets to fly a low level reconnaissance mission. On the same day, the Organization of American States (OAS) unanimously approved of the quarantine against Cuba. President Kennedy used the word quarantine instead of blockade. This sugges tion, made by George Ball, Under Secretary of State, was an important one. A blockade, as defined under international treaties is an act of war. Quarantine, on the other hand, is merely an attempt to keep something unwanted out of a particular area. In sum, the U.S. could have its blockade but the international community would not consider it an act of war. The trusted unofficial assembled groups of President Kennedy known as the Executive Committee of the National Security Council or EX-COMM held a meeting to sum up the situation to three possible actions that the USA could take which are as follows: The political course of action. To engage Castro and Khrushchev on the diplomatic stage in a gamble to resolve the crisis openly an option which most members of EX- COMM deemed unlikely to succeed. A course of action that would involve declaration of open surveillance combined with a blockade against offensive weapons entering Cuba. Military action directed against Cuba, starting with an air attack against the missiles, and then followed by an invasion.
National security must come first...we cant negotiate with a gun at our head... if they wont remove the missiles and restore status quo ante, we will have to do it ourselves. -President John F. Kennedy The USA bloc was ready for war. Defensive Readiness Condition (DEFCON) was on high alert. Two plans, OPLAN 316 and OPLAN 312 were considered. On 26 October USA espionage CIA reported no halt in the missile development of the sites. Rather the Soviet armies were trying to camouflage it. The next day on 27 October was one of the most crucial days of this 13 day event. One U-2 was shot down. Another flew off course over Russia; a low-level reconnaissance mission was shot at over Cuba. Secretary of Defense McNamara had stated This means war with the Soviet Union. The EXCOMM finally came to know that the shorter range missile of the USSR could only target small countries of Europe but the missile of USA could target the entire Russia. However with new missile in Cuba they could easily target the USA. However the Soviets feared the American Nuclear attack. To secure them Russian started stockpiling more missiles in Cuba. In 1961, President Kennedy told that the missile gap was in their favor. The USA has started building new warhead and missiles. By the end of the time, USA had more than ten times as many as the USSR. After the EXCOMM decided the naval blockade the Rio Treaty was invoked for legal justification. The treaty emphasized the collective defense that was such an integral part of the American States. (Treaty can be read for further information). A new draft was sent to Ambassador Stevenson highlighting the precipice the world was on and overlooking the abyss of Nuclear War.
A series of letter was exchanged between Premier Nikita Khrushchev and President John F Kennedy. Some important experts that show the heat of the situation can be read below: This government, as promised, has maintained the closest surveillance of the Soviet military buildup on the island of Cuba. Within the past week unmistakable evidence has established the fact that a series of offensive missile sites is now in preparation on that imprisoned island. The purpose of these bases can be none other than to provide a nuclear strike capability against the Western Hemisphere.... I have directed that the following initial steps be taken: First, to halt this offensive build up, a strict quarantine of all military equipment under shipment to Cuba is being initiated. Second, I have directed the continued and increased close surveillance and its military buildup. Third, it shall be the policy of this nation to regard any nuclear missile launched from Cuba against any nation in the Western Hemisphere as an attack by the Soviet Union on the United States, requiring a full retaliatory response on the Soviet Union. President John F Kennedy I must say frankly that the measures indicated in your statement constitute a serious threat to peace and to the security of nations...We reaffirm that the armaments which are in Cuba, regardless of the classification to which they may belong, are intended solely for defensive purposes... I hope the United States Government will display wisdom and renounce the actions pursued by you, which may lead to catastrophic consequences for world peace. Premier Nikita Khrushchev You, Mr. President, are not declaring quarantine, but rather are advancing an ultimatum and threatening that if we do not give in to your demands you will use force.... No Mr. President, I cannot agree to this, and I think that in your own heart you recognize that I am correct. I am convinced that in my place you would act the same way. Therefore the Soviet Government cannot instruct the captains of Soviet vessels bound for Cuba to observe the orders of the American naval forces blockading that Island.... Naturally we will not simply be bystanders with regard to piratical acts by American ships on the high seas. We will then be forced on our part to take the measures we consider necessary and adequate to protect our rights. We have everything necessary to do so. Premier Nikita Khrushchev
Esteemed Mr. President: I have received your message of October 27, 1962. I express my satisfaction and gratitude for the sense of proportion and understanding of the responsibility borne by you at present for the preservation of peace throughout the world... In order to complete with greater speed the liquidation of the conflict... the Soviet Government... in addition to previously issued instructions on the cessation of further work at building sites for the weapons, has issued a new order on the dismantling of the weapons which you describe as offensive, and their crating. . Premier Nikita Khrushchev
I welcome Chairman Khrushchevs statesmanlike decision to stop building bases in Cuba, dismantling offensive weapons and returning them to the Soviet Union. . . I think that you and I, with our heavy responsibilities for the maintenance of peace, were aware that developments were approaching a point where events could have become unmanageable. So I welcome this message and consider it an important contribution to peace President John F Kennedy.
10
CURRENT SITUATION
1962 began with the USA designing a second scheme to cripple Castros regime. Operation Mongoose intended to stir up socio-political discontent in Cuba, which, of course, the USA would clandestinely support to unbridle a full-scale insurgency, finally leading to an armed intervention by the United States. Members of the OAS (Organization of American States) conference, held in Uruguay, effectively suspended Cuba from the Organization as well as from the collective defense mechanisms deliberated at the time. Selling artillery to the Cuban Government was also forbidden. In late April, Khrushchev, severely fretful about the missing superiority of the Soviet long-range missiles, is exacerbated when he finds out about United States bases in Turkey. He presents the idea to carry out a similar plan in Cuba, facing rigid disapproval from his own Deputy Prime Minister. The Soviet contingent suggested entailed 24 Medium Range Ballistic Missile bases and 16 Intermediate Range bases along with four elite combat regiments, 24 SA-2 surface to air missile batteries, 42 MIG 21 interceptors, 42 IL 21 bombers, 12 Komar-class missile boats and coastal defense cruise missiles. On the 30th of May, Castro makes the historic announcement, claiming that Cuba was now newly equipped with the means to repel any and all impending invasions by an intimidating USA. Throughout August, the United States received scattered reports on the growing presence of Soviet armaments in Cuba. In tandem with these reports, demands for a more antagonistic Operation Mongoose grew in incidence and confidence. However, Kennedy firmly stayed put on moderation from any unswerving martial intervention. On September 11th, the Telegraph Agency of the USSR responded to recurrent censures and rebukes by the USA, claiming that the armaments were positioned for purely defensive purposes. 9 days later, the American Senate passed a decisive bill, formally sanctioning the use of military force against The Cuban regime, declaring it a threat to American Safety. In the House of Representatives an additional bill is passed with the purpose of cutting of aid to countries militarily backing the Cuban Government. September 15th sees the first MRBMs deployed to the Cuban Island. Matters spiraled on October 14th morning when American U-2 aircrafts captured images of Medium Range Ballistic Missiles. The first occurrence of concrete evidence had its expected effect. The next morning, President Kennedy was notified. On Monday, October 22, and preparations are made for Kennedys 7:00 address to the nation. The State Department informs American allies around the world of Kennedys decision. U.S. Senate leaders are called to Washington for a briefing. They come out of the briefing surprised and doubting the effectiveness of quarantine many want an airstrike. About 300 Navy ships set sail, thus
11
far not having received the orders for quarantine. Military vigilance was raised to DEFCON 3 and directions were given to be ready to launch missiles within minutes of Kennedys speech. 20 airplanes equipped with nuclear bombs were also in the air prepared to strike the Soviet Union. At 7:00 p.m., exactly as Kennedy is beginning his speech, fighter jets take off from bases in Florida and head towards Cuba. If Castro decided to react militarily, they would be prepared. In answer to Kennedys speech Castro marshals all of Cubas armed forces. The public phase had begun. Timeline: January 1, 1959 Fidel Castro assumes power after the Cuban Revolution. October 19, 1960 The Unites States stops all exports to Cuba December 19, 1960 Cuba openly aligns itself with the Soviet Union and their policies. January 3, 1961 The U.S. ends all diplomatic relations with Cuba. April 12, 1961 President Kennedy states that the U.S. will not intervene militarily to overthrow Castro. April 17th -19th , 1961 Cuban exiles, assisted by U.S forces, invade Cuba at the Bay of Pigs in an attempt to overthrow Castro. This anti-Castro rebellion fails and numerous Cuban rebels are captured by Castro's forces. June 4th, 1961 Kennedy and Khrushchev meet at Vienna to discuss international relations. It is said that during this meeting Khrushchev and Kennedy had differing viewpoints. January 21, 1962 January 31, 1962 At the Organization of American States meeting of ministers of foreign affairs, the United States convinces the other Western Hemispheric countries to expel Cuba from the OAS.
12
February 3, 1962 Economic, financial and commercial embargo of Cuba announced by the U.S. May 13, 1962 May 20, 1962 This is the time at which Khrushchev decided to place nuclear missiles in Cuba. He informed members of the Politburo of his plans soon after. May 29, 1962 Khrushchev remitted a delegation from the Soviet Union to discuss the placement of nuclear missiles in Cuba. This was accepted by Castro a day later. July 27, 1962 Castro announces that with the help of the Soviet Union, Cuba is taking measures to protect itself against any direct U.S military attack. August 10, 1962 CIA Director John McCone expresses his fear of the presence Soviet medium-range ballistic missiles (MRBMs) in Cuba, to Kennedy. August 31, 1962 Senator Keating tells the Senate that there is evidence of Soviet missile installations in Cuba. Keating urges Kennedy to take action. September 15th, 1962 The first Soviet vessel carrying missiles (mostly MRBMs) arrive in Cuba. October 9, 1962 A U-2 reconnaissance flight over western Cuba is ordered. October 10, 1962 Senator Keating claims that 6 intermediate-range ballistic missile bases are being built in Cuba. October 14, 1962 The U-2 flight discovers missile sites. Photographs obtained by this flight provide evidence that the Soviets have missiles in Cuba.
13
October 15, 1962 The National Photographic Intelligence Center studies the photos and identifies the MRBM components. McGeorge Bundy decides not to inform Kennedy of the missile discovery till the next day. McNamara is shown the photographic evidence of the MRBMs. October 16, 1962 Kennedy is told of the news and a meeting of ministers is called, later came to be known as the EXCOMM. At that meeting Kennedy and his advisors discuss possible diplomatic and military courses of action. October 17, 1962 The Joint Chiefs of Staff and the Air Force urge for an air strike. The military discovers intermediate range (IRBMs) SS-5 nuclear missiles as a result of another U-2 flight that takes place at night on the 17th. October 21, 1962 General Maxwell Taylor tells the U.S President that an air strike cannot guarantee destruction of all Soviet missiles in Cuba. Kennedy decides on a quarantine of Cuba in the interim period. Another U-2 flight reveals bombers and cruise missile sites being built on Cuba's northern shore. October 22, 1962 Congressional leaders who assemble at the White House are shown pictorial evidence of the Soviet missiles. The President addresses the nation, announcing the presence of offensive missile sites in Cuba. U.S. military forces go to DEFCON 3. The base at Guantanamo Bay is fortified by the U.S. Marines.
14
15
Current Situation What are your national interests in the situation and briefly explain the stance on the topic? What is your country doing to support or condemn the topic? What past resolutions or treaties have the country supported regarding the topic?
Solution What does your nation believe needs to be done to solve the problem? What would your country want to be included in the committees resolution?
16
BLOC POSITIONS
1. United States of America (USA): The intense mistrust between Nixon and Castro was mirrored by their country policies. After The Bay of Pigs invasion, their bilateral relations were always strained by their opposing policies. The main fear of the United States was that the crisis would spillover, first priority being Berlin. Khrushchev had ignited a spark once during the Berlin Blockade and again by the construction of the Berlin Wall. Based on that, Kennedy considered the implementation of missile sites in Cuba as the preparation of a confrontation regarding Berlin. 2. Cuba: Having declared its political goals during the revolution, the USA tried every tactic to suppress the revolution or overthrow the Communist leader, Castro. Hence, fearing an American invasion, Cuba, an avid Marxist Communist-Socialist state, received financial, military and psychological support from the USSR. Cuba had initiative to begin stockpiling Nuclear weapons and secretly did so, until the USA caught it through reconnaissance photographs, throwing the World into panic. The Western Bloc believed it was likely that the USSR was stockpiling these weapons in Cuba to attack the USA, whereas Cuba and the Eastern Bloc claimed to have done it for defense purposes only. 3. Czechoslovak Socialist Republic (CSR): An archetypal satellite state of the USSR, CSR was signatory to the Warsaw Pact as well as COMECON, and subject to unconditional agreement with Stalins, and then later, Khrushchevs demands. The absence of both, democracy, as well as strong Communist leaders, left the country with not such a strong foothold in global affairs at the time. With Antonin Novotny as General Secretary of the nation, CSR was at Khrushchevs beck and call 5. France: A significant member of the Western Bloc, France was one of the first nations to accept the quarantine suggested by the Kennedy administration, and was keen to restore peace in the world. However, determined to be on an equal footing as the USA and UK, after receiving an unsatisfactory response to a memorandum on the issue, it withdrew its Mediterranean Fleet from the NATO, and began to construct its Defense Force. Furthermore, France banned the stationing of Nuclear Weapons in their territory.
6. United KingdomAmericas oldest and strongest ally, the UK was vital and thoroughly instrumental in reaching a state of peace after the Cuban Missile Crisis. Having dubbed Castro as stubborn in a letter to the Cuban External Affairs Department from the British Ambassador to Cuba, the UK warned Cuba that the Americans would consequently not give them a formal guarantee against invasion. Being one of only 3 Nations with working Nuclear Missiles, the UK had as many as the USSR as well as was looking after American Nuclear
17
Bombers and Submarines stationed in British territories. Playing a pivotal role with NATO, the UK was prepared to retaliate like for like to any Soviet attack on the USA.
8. India: Though by policy Non Aligned, Indias position during the Cold War remained absolutely ambivalent only for a couple of decades after its independence. Great support was shown to India by the USSR and received more aid than China by 1960. Nehru and Castro also showed signs of strong friendship and mutual appreciation for Socialism. Delegates must note that India was neck deep in the Sino - Indian War at this time. Also, remaining somewhat true to her Non Aligned nature, India never shows any hostility to the Capitalist Bloc. 9. China: China also, obviously, was warring with India at this point in time. The conflict over the Mcmahon Line is something the two concerned delegations might want to look into. China is placed in a strange situation in this committee, due to the timing. Owing to Maos belligerent absolutism, China had aggressive foreign policy towards the Capitalist bloc and was also two years into the Sino Soviet split, owing to differing ideas on Communism itself. However it is very important to note that China was one country that openly and loudly voiced its utter disgust at Khrushchev compromise and decision to demilitarize Cuba, after the Cuban Missile Crisis. 10. Italy Italy was fully a member of the Capitalist bloc at this time, having also severed diplomatic ties with Cuba over an unrelated event. Italy held several US missile bases too, a point of comparison for the USSR. However, there were, very obvious Communist elements in Italy, who had to struggle to keep them out of the government. Italy also had a slightly anti American national policy, which was given the backseat during these critical years of the Cold War.
18
CONCLUSION
Thus the committee ensues on October 22nd, 1962. The Security Council has just congregated. News of Kennedys speech has just been broadcast. Delegates, prepare yourselves for existing in a world of espionage and war, diplomacy and debate. Everything you say or do has a consequence. Use your time wisely to research and make debate worthwhile and exciting. If the committee is to fail, then the consequences will be severe and Armageddon will be the catastrophic result. It is your duty, delegates, to determine a comprehensive and far reaching solution to the crisis at hand.
19
REFERENCES
Cuban Missile Crisis. History.A & E Television Networks, LLC.Web. February 5, 2013. http://www.history.com/topics/cuban-missile-crisis Fulgencio Batista. Encyclopedia Britannica. Encyclopedia Britannica, Inc. 2013.Web. February 5, 2013. http://www.britannica.com/EBchecked/topic/56027/Fulgencio-Batista Fulgencio Batista. Spartacus Eduational. Spartacus Educational Publishers Limited.Web. February 5, 2013. http://www.spartacus.schoolnet.co.uk/COLDbatista.htm Quotation Details.The Quotations Page.Quotations Page.com and Michael Moncur. 2012. Web. February 5, 2013. http://www.quotationspage.com/quote/24962.html The Bay of Pigs.John F. Kennedy Presidential Library and Museum. John F. Kennedy Presidential Library and Museum. Web. February 5, 2013. http://www.jfklibrary.org/JFK/JFK-in-History/The-Bay-of-Pigs.aspx The Cold War.AtomCentral.com: the atomic bomb website. Web. February 5, 2013. http://www.atomcentral.com/the-cold-war.aspx Truman Doctrine. Yale Law School, Lillian Goldman Law Library.Lillian Goldman Law Library. 2008. Web. February 5, 2013. http://avalon.law.yale.edu/20th_century/trudoc.asp Ramcharan, B.G. (retrieved on 3 August, 2013). U Thants preventive diplomacy during the Cuban missile crisis. Retrieved from http://www.unspecial.org/UNS680/t23.html
rd
20