Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT _____________________________________________________________ I
ABSTRACT ________________________________________________________________________II
FINANCIAL SYSTEM..................................................................................................................................4
1. MONEY.......................................................................................................................................................4
2. FINANCIAL INSTRUMENTS...............................................................................................................................4
3. FINANCIAL MARKETS....................................................................................................................................4
4. FINANCIAL INSTITUTIONS...............................................................................................................................4
5. CENTRAL BANKS..........................................................................................................................................4
FINANCIAL INSTITUTIONS......................................................................................................................4
INTERNATIONAL FINANCIAL INSTITUTIONS...................................................................................4
Definition................................................................................................................................................4
Explanation ............................................................................................................................................5
TYPES OF INTERNATIONAL FINANCIAL INSTITUTIONS.............................................................................................5
Bretton Woods institutions......................................................................................................................5
Regional development banks..................................................................................................................5
Bilateral development banks...................................................................................................................5
Other regional financial institutions.......................................................................................................5
HISTORY ........................................................................................................................................................6
Need for the IFIs.....................................................................................................................................6
Bretton woods conference.......................................................................................................................6
HOW IFIS WORK?............................................................................................................................................7
THE IMF.........................................................................................................................................................7
PURPOSES........................................................................................................................................................8
SOURCE OF FUNDING........................................................................................................................................8
1. The Quota system................................................................................................................................8
2. Gold holdings......................................................................................................................................8
3. Borrowing arrangements....................................................................................................................9
4. Interest charges and Fees ................................................................................................................10
FUNCTIONS....................................................................................................................................................10
Surveillance .........................................................................................................................................10
Technical Assistance.............................................................................................................................10
Lending .................................................................................................................................................11
QUOTAS........................................................................................................................................................14
Definition..............................................................................................................................................14
Quotas of some Member: [Table] .........................................................................................................15
The Multifaceted Role of Quotas..........................................................................................................15
SPECIAL DRAWING RIGHTS (SDRS).................................................................................................................16
SDR Valuation.......................................................................................................................................16
How is SDR calculated?.......................................................................................................................16
SDR Interest Rate..................................................................................................................................17
SDR Interest rate calculation...............................................................................................................17
PAKISTAN AND IMF..................................................................................................................................18
LENDING HISTORY:.........................................................................................................................................18
IMF’S ATTITUDE TOWARDS US..........................................................................................................................20
THE WORLD BANK...................................................................................................................................21
HISTORY.......................................................................................................................................................21
Page 2 of 42
Money & Banking International Financial Institutions
OBJECTIVE....................................................................................................................................................21
WORLD BANK: A BANK?................................................................................................................................21
PURPOSES......................................................................................................................................................21
DIFFERENCE BETWEEN WORLD BANK AND THE IMF...........................................................................................22
MILLENNIUM DEVELOPMENT GOALS (MDGS)...................................................................................................23
WORLD BANK GROUP....................................................................................................................................25
International Bank for Recosruction and Delopment. (IBRD).............................................................25
The International Development Association (IDA)..............................................................................26
WORLD BANK’S AREAS OF OPERATION..............................................................................................................27
PROJECTS OF WORLD BANK IN PAKISTAN .........................................................................................................27
ASIAN DEVELOPMENT BANK...............................................................................................................30
ORGANIZATION...............................................................................................................................................30
LENDING.......................................................................................................................................................31
NOTABLE PROJECTS........................................................................................................................................31
MEMBERS.....................................................................................................................................................31
ISLAMIC DEVELOPMENT BANK..........................................................................................................31
ESTABLISHMENT.............................................................................................................................................31
PURPOSE ......................................................................................................................................................32
FUNCTIONS....................................................................................................................................................32
MEMBERSHIP.................................................................................................................................................32
HEAD OFFICE AND REGIONAL OFFICES ............................................................................................................32
RESOURCE MOBILIZATION ...............................................................................................................................33
CRITICISM ON IMF AND THE WORLD BANK...................................................................................33
1. CONDITIONALITIES......................................................................................................................................33
2. IMPACT ON PUBLIC HEALTH.........................................................................................................................34
3. DEVALUATIONS...........................................................................................................................................35
4. CRITICISM FROM FREE MARKET ADVOCATES....................................................................................................35
5. IMF/WORLD BANK SUPPORT OF MILITARY DICTATORSHIPS ...............................................................................35
6. IMF & WB : SECRETIVE INSTITUTIONS WITH NO ACCOUNTABILITY....................................................................36
7. DEMOCRACY IS BEING TORN APART BY A FINANCIAL OLIGARCHY (MIGHT IS RIGHT)...............................................36
8. VIOLATION OF ISLAMIC PRINCIPLES...............................................................................................................37
9. IMF POLICIES HURT THE ENVIRONMENT.........................................................................................................38
11. OTHER CONTROVERSIES............................................................................................................................38
SOME IRONIC FACTS ABOUT THE IFIS:...............................................................................................................38
CRITICISM BY SOME FAMOUS PERSONALITIES......................................................................................................39
WHY DO COUNTRIES SIGN AGREEMENTS WITH THE IFI’S IF THE CONSEQUENCES ARE ULTIMATELY NEGATIVE? ...............39
IMF & THE 3RD WORLD................................................................................................................................39
RESPONSE TO CRITICISM .....................................................................................................................41
SUGGESTIONS............................................................................................................................................42
CONCLUSION.............................................................................................................................................42
Page 3 of 42
Money & Banking International Financial Institutions
Financial System
These are the five main parts that together make up financial system:
1. Money
To pay for purchases and store wealth
2. Financial Instruments
To transfer wealth from savers to investors and to transfer risk to those best equipped to
bear it.
3. Financial Markets
Buy and sell financial instruments
4. Financial Institutions.
Provide access to financial markets (a finical intermediary)
“A financial institution is an institution that provides financial services for its clients
or members.”
Financial institutions are often regulated be Government bodies
5. Central Banks
Monitor financial Institutions and stabilize the Economy
Financial Institutions
Financial Institutions are one important pillar of the financial system. Their main
functions include:
• Reduce transactions cost by specializing in the issuance of standardized securities
• Reduce information costs of screening and monitoring borrowers.
• Issue short term liabilities and purchase long-term loans.
Page 4 of 42
Money & Banking International Financial Institutions
Explanation
Their owners or shareholders are generally national governments, although other
international institutions and other organisations occasionally figure as shareholders. The
most prominent IFIs are creations of multiple nations, although some bilateral financial
institutions (created by two countries) exist and are technically IFIs. Many of these are
multilateral development banks.
The best-known IFIs are the World Bank, the IMF, and the regional development banks.
Some of the IFIs are considered UN agencies.
Page 5 of 42
Money & Banking International Financial Institutions
History
Our main focus of our project is on the Bretton-Woods sister IFIs the International
Monetary Fund (IMF) and the World Bank so we added a brief history of these
institutions too.
Countries’ economies were adversely affected by WWII . There was a need for
reconstruction in well-developed nations. And also need for development in the lesser
developed nations
The World Bank and the International Monetary Fund were created in the aftermath of
World War II, to direct investments to the neediest countries of the world, the Bank, and
to ensure international monetary cooperation, the Fund.
However, these International Financial Institutions (IFIs) have changed their roles over
the last few decades, becoming international advocates of controversial economic
policies in developing countries. The governance of the Bank and the Fund is severely
skewed towards rich countries which dominate decision-making in these institutions.
The location of the meeting - in the plush Mount Washington Hotel in rural Bretton
Woods, New Hampshire - was designed to ensure that the delegates would have no
distractions, and no pressure from lobbyists or Congressmen, as they worked on their
plans for post-war reconstruction.
The meeting was born out of the determination by US President Franklin D Roosevelt
and UK Prime Minister Winston Churchill to ensure post-war prosperity through
economic co-operation, avoiding the economic conflicts between countries in the 1930s
that they believed contributed to the drift to war.
The principal negotiators at the meeting were the US, represented by the US Treasury's
Harry Dexter White, and the UK's John Maynard Keynes, who was serving as UK
Treasury adviser despite declining health.
Page 6 of 42
Money & Banking International Financial Institutions
And chairing the proceedings was Henry Morgenthau, the US Treasury Secretary, from
the only country that was likely to emerge from the war with a strengthened economy.
President Roosevelt told the conference: "The economic health of every country is a
proper matter of concern to all its neighbors, near and distant.”
At the outset it signs a so-called Letter of Intent which lays out the elements of the
recovery plan and in return the Fund commits itself to grant loans in stages as and when
economic targets specified in the Letter are achieved. These will include cutting budget
deficits and inflation.
But today there are other components in IMF programs that have become more
important. In East Asia the Fund demanded the reform of the banking system in Thailand
and Indonesia and the introduction of proper formal accounting systems in South Korea.
Similarly the Bank now looks more at the long-term strategic goals of an economy than
at traditional development schemes such as new highways and dams.
One of the World Bank's priorities is therefore its commitment to achieve the Millennium
Development Goals (as agreed upon in Monterrey), which were designed to significantly
reduce the indebtedness of developing countries. These new approaches are gradually
taking hold as the influence of globalization becomes more apparent. The emphasis is on
providing better guiding and flanking measures whilst at the same time providing greater
coherence with the objectives pursued by other UN organizations. In addition, developing
countries want to have a greater say regarding the make-up of the IFI's structures, despite
their limited contribution to these bodies.
The IMF
The International Monetary Fund (IMF) is an international organization that oversees the
global financial system by following the macroeconomic policies of its member
countries, in particular those with an impact on exchange rates and the balance of
payments. It is an organization formed to stabilize international exchange.
The IMF was formally organized on December 27, 1945, when the first 29 countries
signed its Articles of Agreement. Now, the IMF has huge influence in the world economy.
It is a specialized agency of the United Nations but has its own charter, governing
structure, and finances. Its members are represented through a quota system broadly
based on their relative size in the global economy.
Page 7 of 42
Money & Banking International Financial Institutions
IMF’s unit of account is SDR (-SDRs will further be elaborated later in this
report-).
The current Managing Director of IMF is a French Jew named Dominique
Strauss-Kahn .
Balance of payments difficulties or to assist with poverty reduction. The IMF works with
other international organizations to promote growth and poverty reduction. It also
interacts with think tanks, civil society, and the media on a daily basis. [or at least that’s
what they say,- in the later half ( the critical review part) of this report you’ll see the
what the IMF is really doing-]
Purposes
Following are the main Articles of Agreement of the IMF:
i) promote international monetary cooperation
ii) expansion and balanced growth of international trade
iii) promote exchange rate stability
iv) help establish multilateral system of payments and eliminate foreign exchange
restrictions
v) make resources of the Fund available to members
vi) Shorten the duration and lessen the degree of disequilibrium in international balances
of payments
However, the real undisclosed purposes that the critics argue upon are highly
controversial and completely different from the above articles.
Source of Funding
Where does IMF get it’s money? The IMF gets the funding for the loans from the
following sources:
2. Gold holdings
Total gold holdings 103.4 million ounces (3,217 metric tons). IMF is the third largest
official holder of gold in the world.
The IMF’s total gold holdings are valued on its balance sheet at SDR 5.9 billion (about
$8.7 billion) on the basis of historical cost. As of March 31, 2009, the IMF's holdings
amounted to $94.8 billion (at then current market prices).
Page 8 of 42
Money & Banking International Financial Institutions
IMF is prohibited from buying gold or engaging in other gold transactions.85% majority
(of total voting power) needed for sale and purchase of gold.
3. Borrowing arrangements
If necessary, the IMF may borrow from a number of its financially strongest member
countries to supplement the resources available from its quotas. It has done so on several
occasions when borrowing countries needed large amounts of financing and a failure to
help them might have put the international monetary system at risk.
The IMF maintains two standing multilateral borrowing arrangements
1. the New Arrangement to Borrow (NAB)
2. the General Arrangements to Borrow (GABs)
Page 9 of 42
Money & Banking International Financial Institutions
GAB
“Line of credit set up with several governments and banks throughout the world”
Functions
The work of the IMF is of three main types:
Surveillance
Technical Assistance
Lending
in addition to these three IMF also plays an important role in the fight against money-
laundering and terrorism
Surveillance
IMF’s regular monitoring of economies and associated provision of policy advice known
as surveillance.
The IMF oversees the international monetary system and monitors the financial and
economic policies of its members. It keeps track of economic developments on a
national, regional, and global basis
Technical Assistance
To assist mainly low- and middle-income countries in effectively managing their
economies, the IMF provides practical guidance and training on how to upgrade
institutions, and design appropriate macroeconomic, financial, and structural policies.
Page 10 of 42
Money & Banking International Financial Institutions
Lending
The IMF provides loans to countries that have trouble meeting their international
payments and cannot otherwise find sufficient financing on affordable terms.
A country in severe financial trouble, unable to pay its international bills, poses potential
problems for the international financial system, which the IMF was created to protect.
Any member country, whether rich, middle-income, or poor, can turn to the IMF for
financing if it has a balance of payments need—that is, if it cannot find sufficient
financing on affordable terms in the capital markets to make its international payments
and maintain a safe level of reserves.
About four out of five member countries have used IMF credit at least once. But the
amount of loans outstanding and the number of borrowers have fluctuated significantly
over time.
In the first two decades of the IMF's existence, more than half of its lending went to
industrial countries. But since the late 1970s, these countries have been able to meet their
financing needs in the capital markets.
The oil shock of the 1970s and the debt crisis of the 1980s led many lower- and lower-
middle-income countries to borrow from the IMF.
In the 1990s, the transition process in central and Eastern Europe and the crises in
emerging market
economies led to a further
increase in the demand
for IMF resources.
In 2004, benign economic
conditions worldwide
meant that many
countries began to repay
their loans to the IMF. As
a consequence, the
demand for the Fund’s
resources dropped off
sharply (see graph).
Page 11 of 42
Money & Banking International Financial Institutions
to countries hit by the financial crisis and high food and fuel prices. In late 2008 and early
2009 the IMF lent $60 billion to emerging markets affected by the crisis.
While the financial crisis has sparked renewed demand for IMF financing, the decline in
lending that preceded the financial crisis also reflected a need to adapt the IMF's lending
instruments to the changing needs of member countries. In response, the IMF conducted
a wide-ranging review of its lending facilities and terms on which it provides loans.
In March 2009, the Fund announced a major overhaul of its lending framework,
including modernizing conditionality, introducing a new flexible credit line, enhancing
the flexibility of the Fund’s regular stand-by lending arrangement, doubling access limits
on loans, adapting its cost structures for high-access and precautionary lending, and
streamlining instruments that were seldom used. It has also speeded up lending
procedures and redesigned its Exogenous Shocks Facility to make it easier to access for
low-income countries.
Article I of the IMF's Articles of Agreement states that the purpose of lending by the IMF
is "...to give confidence to members by making the general resources of the Fund
temporarily available to them under adequate safeguards, thus providing them with
opportunity to correct maladjustments in their balance of payments without resorting to
measures destructive of national or international prosperity."
In practice, the purpose of the IMF's lending has changed dramatically since the
organization was created. Over time, the IMF's financial assistance has evolved from
helping countries deal with short-term trade fluctuations to supporting adjustment and
addressing a wide range of balance of payments problems resulting from terms of trade
shocks, natural disasters, post-conflict situations, broad economic transition, poverty
reduction and economic development, sovereign debt restructuring, and confidence-
driven banking and currency crises.
1. First, it can smooth adjustment to various shocks, helping a member country avoid
disruptive economic adjustment or sovereign default, something that would be extremely
costly, both for the country itself and possibly for other countries through economic and
financial ripple effects (known as contagion).
2. Second, IMF programs can help unlock other financing, acting as a catalyst for other
lenders. This is because the program can serve as a signal that the country has adopted
sound policies, reinforcing policy credibility and increasing investors' confidence.
3. Third, IMF lending can help prevent crisis. The experience is clear: capital account
crises typically inflict substantial costs on countries themselves and on other countries
through contagion. Today, IMF lending serves three main purposes.
Page 12 of 42
Money & Banking International Financial Institutions
The Stand-By Arrangement is a key lending facility established in 1952. Although its use
has been declining in recent years, it has remained the most popular facility for middle-
income countries that seek financial assistance. Under its structure, financing is provided
in support of adjustment to a balance of payments need and disbursed in tranches based
on conditions spelled out in the program. The IMF's largest loans have traditionally been
provided under SBAs.
Page 13 of 42
Money & Banking International Financial Institutions
8. The IMF has introduced a new Flexible Credit Line (FCL) for countries with very
strong fundamentals, policies, and track record of policy implementation.
Quotas
Definition
The IMF is working on wide-ranging reforms to make sure it meets the needs of its
member countries. One of the most important elements is governance reform, which
involves adjusting quota shares to better reflect the relative weight of member countries
in the world economy and enhancing the voice and participation of low-income members
within the institution.
IMF decides on the quota for each member, richer countries have larger quota. Each
member country of the IMF is assigned a quota, based broadly on its relative size in the
world economy and characteristics .Quotas are denominated in Special Drawing Rights
(SDRs), the IMF's unit of account. US, having largest economy, provides 44% of the total
quota US has largest voting power 17.09%.
Quotas are reviewed every 5 years by the IMF. They are calculated by a formula. Quotas
also determine how much each member can borrow from the IMF when in need of aid.
Page 14 of 42
Money & Banking International Financial Institutions
Basically 25% of the country’s quota may be used. If this still is not sufficient, then
members can borrow up to 3 times the amount of its quota. In order to do so the country
Page 15 of 42
Money & Banking International Financial Institutions
(in need) present plans for reform to Executive Directors. If these plans are sufficient for
the Executive Directors, the IMF grants the member a loan.
The SDR is an international reserve asset, created by the IMF in 1969 to supplement the
existing official reserves of member countries. SDRs are allocated to member countries in
proportion to their IMF quotas. The SDR also serves as the unit of account of the IMF
and some other international organizations. Its value is based on a basket of key
international currencies.
The SDR is neither a currency, nor a claim on the IMF. Rather, it is a potential claim
on the freely usable currencies of IMF members. Holders of SDRs can obtain these
currencies in exchange for their SDRs in two ways: first, through the arrangement of
voluntary exchanges between members; and second, by the IMF designating members
with strong external positions to purchase SDRs from members with weak external
positions.
SDR Valuation
The value of the SDR was initially defined as equivalent to 0.888671 grams of fine gold
—which, at the time, was also equivalent to one U.S. dollar. After the collapse of the
Bretton Woods system in 1973, however, the SDR was redefined as a basket of
currencies, today consisting of the euro, Japanese yen, pound sterling, and U.S. dollar.
in November 2005, the weights of the currencies in the SDR basket were revised based
on the value of the exports of goods and services and the amount of reserves denominated
in the respective currencies which were held by other members of the IMF. These
changes became effective on January 1, 2006.next revision will be in 2010.
With effect from January 1, 2006, the IMF has determined that the four currencies that
meet both selection criteria for inclusion in the SDR valuation basket will be assigned the
following weights based on their roles in international trade and finance: U.S. dollar (44
percent), euro (34 percent), Japanese yen (11 percent), and pound sterling (11 percent).
Page 16 of 42
Money & Banking International Financial Institutions
Total 0.4180
SDR Interest Rate 3 0.42
Note: SDR per currency rates are based on the representative exchange rate for each
currency.
Page 17 of 42
Money & Banking International Financial Institutions
• The current SDR is a relatively small basket of currencies; this is both a strong
point and weak point of the SDR.
• The US Dollar, Euro and UK Pound are contained in the SDR -- these currencies
have been losing value against a larger basket of secondary reserve currencies since the
late 2000s recession started in 2007.
• The SDR does not contain Chinese Yuan, Indian Rupee, Australian Dollar or
Canadian Dollar, which are important benchmark or secondary global reserve currencies.
• The lack of global banking support for consumers (that is to say private persons
and businesses) for the SDR.
Pakistan gets loans from IMF for the following main purposes:
Page 18 of 42
Money & Banking International Financial Institutions
[* this graph is taken from IMF’s official site=== the first column shows the lending
instruments (explained earlier) used]
o Six loan arrangements were made during the regime of Benazir Bhutto.
o One IMF loan is made in current regime. (It was a hard step for a newly formed
government to ask for IMF’s aid, just shortly after coming to power)
o 44% of the total lending amount has been drawn from the original 100% agreed
upon lending amount.
Page 19 of 42
Money & Banking International Financial Institutions
As we all know that IMF attitude towards developing nations has always been
humiliating so same is the case with Pakistan as this report also shows:
Article from the News about the latest (24th Nov 2008) loan :
“In view of the IMF demand, the Pakistani currency will also be devalued after slight changes
in the discount rate and exchange rate will be decreased officially by six to seven per cent,” an
official in the Ministry of Finance disclosed, wishing to remain anonymous.
Moreover, the official said the release of 60 per cent funds for the next three quarters of the
current financial year, under the Public Sector Development Program (PSDP), would be
reviewed downward to 45 per cent.
According to the official, the foreign assistance flow had already declined by 40 per cent
because donors have refused to provide funds for new projects at the federal and provincial
levels under the PSDP against the ongoing projects funded by the Japan-IBRD, the World
Bank, the Islamic Development Bank and the Asian Development Bank.
The IMF proposal received by the federal government in the last week of October contained
16 conditions having 180 points that were discussed in four meetings between Pakistani and
IMF officials in Dubai, 1 the official disclosed.
The official said that major conditions accepted by the Pakistan government included changes
in the Islamic Development Bank loans and differentiation between loans and grants,
devaluation of rupee, freezing of non-development expenditure under the defense budget for
the last three quarters of the current financial year, non-provision of supplementary grants to
government departments, ending subsidy on gas and electricity, 20 per cent reduction in non-
development expenditure of civil departments and federal ministries, increase in markup rate
of banks and on inter-bank transactions, uniformity in the inter-bank and open market dollar
exchange rate and stoppage of government financial intervention in stock markets.
Under the conditions accepted by the government, the IMF will be informed at the time of the
issuance of credit line by any international financial institution, including the World Bank or
immediately after it, I the official said.
The matters on which the government and its financial managers have differed with the IMF
include release of $1.5 billion to$2 billion for the current financial year under the annual
assistance package, I he said.
The government wants the IMF to provide $3 billion and another $1.5 billion to $2 billion for
adjustment of the loan installments and maintenance of the balance of payments during the
current financial year, said the official.
Page 20 of 42
Money & Banking International Financial Institutions
History
World bank came lnto existance on 27th December, 1945. it is the part of the United
Nations with different governance structure.
The World Bank is one of two major financial institutions created as a result of the
Bretton Woods Conference in 1944. The International Monetary Fund, a related but
separate institution, is the second. Delegates from a wide variety of countries attended the
Bretton Woods Conference, but the most powerful countries in attendance, the United
States and Britain, mainly shaped negotiations.
World Bank conceived during World War II at Bretton Woods, New Hampshire, the
World Bank initially helped rebuild Europe after the war. Its first loan of $250 million
was to France in 1947 for post-war reconstruction. Reconstruction has remained an
important focus of the Bank's work, given the natural disasters, humanitarian
emergencies, and post conflict rehabilitation needs that affect developing and transition
economies. The first president of World Bank was Eugene Meyer (June 1946–December
1946) and current president is Robert Zoellick.
Objective
The World Bank provides over $20 billion in assistance to developing and transition
countries every year. The Bank's projects and policies affect the lives and livelihoods of
billions of people worldwide - sometimes for the better, but very often in controversial
and problematic ways.
Purposes
World Bank background and objectives have expanded and evolved over the years. The
original purpose and objectives as the International Bank for Reconstruction and
Development was a facilitator role in post-war reconstruction. Since 1944, this role has
expanded and World Bank's objectives have grown to develop its current mandate to
Page 21 of 42
Money & Banking International Financial Institutions
alleviate worldwide poverty. They work closely with their affiliate, the International
Development Association.
With all this expansion and growth, World Bank's original focus has not changed. Today,
reconstruction remains a top priority in such situations as:
• Natural disasters
• Needs affecting developing economies
• Post conflict rehabilitation
• Needs affecting a transitioning economy
Most people have only the vaguest idea of what these institutions do, and very few people
indeed could, if pressed on the point, say why and how they differ. Even John Maynard
Keynes, a founding father of the two institutions and considered by many the most
brilliant economist of the twentieth century, admitted at the inaugural meeting of the
International Monetary Fund that he was confused by the names: he thought the Fund
should be called a bank, and the Bank should be called a fund. Confusion has reigned
ever since.
Both international organizations are known as the Bretton Woods Institutions. The actual
differences between the two organizations, in reality, can be somewhat mixed. However,
by principle, the IMF concerns itself with macroeconomics issues, such as balance of
payment issues, international trade policy, and exchange rates. The founding idea was
that there was a need for collective action on the international level for financial stability.
The World Bank, ideally, is to deal with issues more related to structure within a country,
such as how and what the government spends money on, financial institutions, labor
markets and trade policies. The World Bank concerns itself more with development
projects, which have been controversial in the past, such as dam construction.
Both institutions are major advocates of neo liberal concepts such as the ability of the
free market to solve many global economic problems.
We’ve listed down the main differences in a tabular form. So they could be understood
with a minimum time and effort:
Page 22 of 42
Money & Banking International Financial Institutions
5 Source of Funding
draws its financial resources principally acquires most of its financial resources by
from the quota subscriptions of its borrowing on the international bond
member countries market
Page 23 of 42
Money & Banking International Financial Institutions
In light of the enormous challenge facing the global community to eradicate poverty --
which affects nearly half of the world’s population living on less than $2 dollars a day --
the international development community in 2000 adopted specific targets for poverty
reduction, now known as the Millennium Development Goals (MDGs). The MDGs
constitute 8 basic poverty reduction goals ranging from access to social services and
gender equity to environmental sustainability. The overarching goal is to halve income
poverty worldwide by 2015.
Goal 1: Eradicate extreme poverty and hunger
Goal 2: Achieve universal primary education
Goal 3: Promote gender equality and empower women
Goal 4: Reduce child mortality
Goal 5: Improve maternal health
Goal 6: Combat HIV/AIDS, malaria, and other diseases
Goal 7: Ensure environmental sustainability
Goal 8: Develop a global partnership for development
Page 24 of 42
Money & Banking International Financial Institutions
Purpose
It was founded in 1944 as a way to finance reconstruction projects in war-ravaged
countries despite their poor creditworthiness.
Functions
The main functions of the bank are :
To assist in process of reconstruction, development and restoration of countries destroyed
by war.
To promote long term balanced growth all around the world.
To encourage international investments for development of the member countries.
To encourage private foreign investments by means of gurantees.
To help member countries in maintenances of equilibrium of BOP.
To play a role so that smooth transition may take place from war time to peace time
economies.
Mode of funding
The IBRD gets its money from regular subscriptions paid by member governments and
by borrowing money on international markets (through selling World Bank bonds). The
Bank then lends that money to borrowing governments at a lower rate than commercial
banks would. Although the IBRD still concentrates on development it operates primarily
in mid-middle-income developing countries; in FY 1994, the IBRD was funded at about
$17 billion.
Loans
The IBRD offers loans to developing country governments for a variety undertakings:
Sectoral loans support reform or infrastructure improvement in a specific economic
sector, i.e., mining, transport, energy, banking, etc.; project loans support the completion
of a specific project, such as a dam, highway or power plant; and macroeconomic loans
assist governments in achieving the economic objectives detailed in a structural
Page 25 of 42
Money & Banking International Financial Institutions
adjustment program (more on structural adjustment programs, below). IBRD loans can
cover the entire cost of a project, but Bank clout attracts many other sources of financing,
especially from the private sector. Recently, the Bank has also started offering support for
private investors themselves, in an effort to attract development money to Southern
countries. Finally, IBRD also offers a host of technical assistance programs to its
developing country members for "capacity building" and "technology transfer."
Membership
To be eligible for IBRD loans, governments must be a member the World Bank, and
comply with Bank-imposed Structural Adjustment Programs (SAPs), which have been
severely criticized by NGOs worldwide as an unnecessarily harsh set of macroeconomic
policies. SAPs are aimed at reducing government budget deficits by decreasing
government expenditure (particularly on social programs), increasing export production,
privatization, and liberalizing trade and investment policies. The purpose of these reforms
is to help countries become more economically robust, creditworthy and able to pay off
its debts. These policies are prerequisites for loan eligibility and often include provisions
for reduced government spending on social services. The Bank offers advice and loans to
help implement SAPs
Orign
In 1959, the US made the resolution for the articles of agreement for IDA and in
September 1960 the IDA was established.
Loans
IDA's funding priorities are poverty alleviation, environmental protection, and
sustainable development. Its loans, however "soft" they might be, are conditioned by
harsh structural adjustment requirements. IDA and IBRD are often lumped in the same
category, because they lend for the same purposes and focus primarily on government
Page 26 of 42
Money & Banking International Financial Institutions
borrowers. However, IDA funding is considerably lower than that of the World Bank,
amounting to $5.6 billion (about 34% that of IBRD's) in FY 1994.
IDA is considering the establishment of two new financing services to enhance the
private sector. The rationale is that through foreign investment, IDA countries could gain
much-needed infrastructure. The first is a guarantee program that would encourage the
penetration of foreign capital and multinational corporations. The second program is the
IDA Private Investment Fund which would be IDA money managed by the International
Finance Corporation
Page 27 of 42
Money & Banking International Financial Institutions
Working with Pakistan Poverty Alleviation Fund to bring difference in the lives of
poor.
The World Bank funded Pakistan Poverty Alleviation Fund Project (PPAF) is designed to
reduce poverty and empower the rural and urban poor in Pakistan through the provision
of resources and services to the poor, especially women. This is being achieved through
an integrated approach that includes building institutions of the poor and then providing
them with micro-credit loans; grants for small scale infrastructure projects; training and
skill development and social sector interventions. The program is impacting over 10
million people and has mobilized over 66,000 community organizations (COs) in 27,000
localities across 111 districts in the country. More than 13,000 small scale village-based
projects have been identified, constructed and maintained by communities’ right across
the country benefiting nearly 6 million people. PPAF has issued 1.5 million micro-credit
loans, (average loan-size US$ 150), benefiting nearly 9 million people. Over the last 7
years PPAF has driven the microfinance sector growth from 60,000 borrowers to more
than 1.25 million active borrowers in the sector.
The October 2005 earthquake in Pakistan destroyed or damaged around 575,000 rural
houses, leaving more than 73,000 dead, and rendering over 3 million people without
shelter in North West Frontier Province (NWFP) and Azad Jammu and Kashmir (AJ&K).
In response, the government created the Earthquake Relief and Reconstruction Authority
(ERRA) and launched an ambitious US$1.5 billion owner-driven rebuilding program -
largely suited to the mainly rural affected population. Under ERRA’s Rural Housing and
Reconstruction Program (RHRP), partially funded by the World Bank, homeowners are
given around US$3,000 in installments to build quake-resistant homes - with routine
visits by inspection teams to ensure compliance to agreed seismic-resistant standards.
Owner driven reconstruction and rehabilitation of an estimated 463,000 houses have
begun and is at various stages of completion. The RHRP has disbursed over $1.1 billion
to program beneficiaries or 75 percent of the overall $1.5 billion estimated cost.
Page 28 of 42
Money & Banking International Financial Institutions
measures student achievement and uses the findings to address gaps in student learning.
NEAS has established, piloted and improved assessment mechanisms and instruments,
which are now being regularly administered.
The HIV-AIDS situation is changing rapidly in Pakistan; the latest data indicate a
concentrated epidemic among injecting drug users in several cities. The key challenge
facing the country is to expand and improve quality of HIV preventive services to
vulnerable groups that are most at risk of contracting and transmitting the disease. These
include sex workers and injecting drug users. The Bank is supporting the Government
efforts to control AIDS through the HIV/AIDS Prevention Project designed to prevent the
disease from becoming established in these populations, while at the same time working
to protect these groups from stigmatization. A key focus of the project is delivery of HIV
preventive services to high risk populations through public-private partnerships. A total of
17 service delivery packages for injecting drug users (IDUs), sex workers, truckers and
jail inmates have been contracted out to NGOs by the National and Provincial AIDS
Control Programs covering most major cities across the country.
Around 90 percent of our staff in Islamabad office, plus additional staff in our
Washington office are Pakistanis. While a large part of World Bank’s value is it’s global
experience and expertise, local knowledge is indispensable to effective development. We
also work closely with the Pakistan government, civil society and communities in
designing our support for the country. Most importantly our overall assistance to the
country is specifically designed to support its own development goals. We have periodic
client satisfaction surveys through which we assess how our services are perceived by a
cross section of society including the government, private sector, civil society, academia,
and media etc. These polls are carried out globally by reputed international firms.
Evaluating Results
It’s one thing to set goals and objectives, but without an effective way to measure the
results it's difficult to know if they are effectively being met.
Page 29 of 42
Money & Banking International Financial Institutions
Aim: The work of the Asian Development Bank (ADB) is aimed at improving the
welfare of the people in Asia and the Pacific, particularly the 1.9 billion who live on less
than $2 a day. Despite many success stories, Asia and the Pacific remains home to two
thirds of the world's poor.
The bank was conceived with the vision of creating a financial institution that would be
"Asian in character" to foster growth and cooperation in a region that back then was one
of the world's poorest. ADB raises funds through bond issues on the world's capital
markets, while also utilizing its members' contributions and earnings from lending. These
sources account for almost three quarters of its lending operations.
The primary human capital asset of the bank is its staff of professionals, encompassing
academic and/or practical experts in the areas of agriculture, civil engineering,
economics, environment, health, public policy and finance. Professional staff are drawn
from its member countries and given various incentives to relocate to Manila.
It is conceivable that once all of Asia-Pacific reaches a certain level of living standard the
bank will be wound down or reconfigured to operate as a commercial enterprise.
Organization
The highest policy-making body of the bank is the Board of Governors composed of one
representative from each member state. The Board of Governors, in turn, elect among
themselves the 12 members of the Board of Directors and their deputy. Eight of the 12
members come from regional (Asia-Pacific) members while the others come from non-
regional members.
The Board of Governors also elect the bank's President who is the chairperson of the
Board of Directors and manages ADB. The president has a term of office lasting five
years, and may be reelected. Traditionally, and because Japan is one of the largest
shareholders of the bank, the President has always been Japanese. The current President
is Haruhiko Kuroda.
The headquarters of the bank is at 6 ADB Avenue, Mandaluyong City, Metro Manila,
Philippines, and it has representative offices around the world. The bank employs
approximately 2,400 people, coming from 55 of its 67 member countries, and with more
than half of the staff being Filipino.
Page 30 of 42
Money & Banking International Financial Institutions
Lending
ADB's annual project lending amounts to about US$7 billion per year with typical
lending per project being in the $100 million range.
Notable Projects
Afghan Diaspora Project
Funding Utah State University led projects to bring labor skills in
Thailand
Earthquake and Tsunami Emergency Support Project in Indonesia
Greater Mekong Subregional Program
ROC Ping Hu Offshore Oil and Gas Development
Solar energy development funds in India
Strategic Private Sector Partnerships for Urban Poverty Reduction in the
Philippines
Trans-Afghanistan Gas Pipeline Feasibility Assessment
Loan of $1.2 billion to bail it out of an impending economic crisis in
Pakistan
Members
ADB has 67 members (Georgia being the 67th member joined in 2007)
Establishment
The Islamic by the Conference of Finance Ministers of Muslim Countries held in Jeddah
in Dhul Q'adah 1393H, corresponding to December 1973. The Inaugural Meeting of the
Board of Governors took place in Rajab 1395H, corresponding to July 1975, and the
Bank was formally opened on 15 Shawwal 1395H corresponding to 20 October 1975.
On the basis of paid-up capital, the main shareholders of the Bank are from these
countries:
Saudi Arabia UAE
Sudan Iran
Kuwait Egypt
Libya Indonesia
Turkey Pakistan
Page 31 of 42
Money & Banking International Financial Institutions
Purpose
The purpose of the Bank is to foster the economic development and social progress of
member countries and Muslim communities individually as well as jointly in accordance
with the principles of Shari'ah i.e., Islamic Law.
Functions
The functions of the Bank are to participate in equity capital and grant loans for
productive projects and enterprises besides providing financial assistance to member
countries in other forms for economic and social development.
The Bank is authorized to accept deposits and to mobilize financial resources through
Shari'ah compatible modes. It is also charged with the responsibility of assisting in the
promotion of foreign trade especially in capital goods, among member countries;
providing technical assistance to member countries; and extending training facilities for
personnel engaged in development activities in Muslim countries to conform to the
Shari'ah.
Membership
The present membership of the Bank consists of 56 countries. The basic condition for
membership is that the prospective member country should be a member of the
Organization of the Islamic Conference, pay its contribution to the capital of the Bank
and be willing to accept such terms and conditions as may be decided upon by the IsDB
Board of Governors.
Page 32 of 42
Money & Banking International Financial Institutions
Resource Mobilization
In order to meet the future funding requirements of the Bank, it is planned that IDB will
tap the international market some time during 2008 to raise additional resources through
issuance of Sukuk. The size and the currency of the Sukuk issues will be decided close to
the time of issuance.
1. Conditionalities
On giving loans to countries, the IMF makes the loan conditional on the implementation
of certain economic policies.
These policies tend to involve:
o Reducing government borrowing - Higher taxes and lower spending
o Higher interest rates to stabilize the currency. Allow failing firms to go
bankrupt.
o Structural adjustment. Privatization, deregulation, reducing corruption and
bureaucracy.
Critics of the World Bank and the IMF are concerned about the conditionalities imposed
on borrower countries. The World Bank and the IMF often attach loan conditionalities
based on what is termed the 'Washington Consensus', focusing on liberalisation—of
trade, investment and the financial sector—, deregulation and privatisation of
nationalised industries. Often the conditionalities are attached without due regard for the
borrower countries' individual circumstances and the prescriptive recommendations by
the World Bank and IMF fail to resolve the economic problems within the countries.
Page 33 of 42
Money & Banking International Financial Institutions
It is claimed that retard social stability and hence inhibit the stated goals of the IMF,
while Structural Adjustment Programs lead to an increase in poverty in recipient
countries.
The main problem is that these policies of structural adjustment and macro economic
intervention make the situation worse; we’ll take these two cases for an example to
support this point:
Case I: (Asian Crisis), in the Asian crisis of 1997, many countries such as Indonesia,
Malaysia and Thailand were required by IMF to pursue tight monetary policy (higher
interest rates) and tight fiscal policy to reduce the budget deficit and strengthen exchange
rates. However, these policies caused a minor slowdown to turn into a serious recession
with mass unemployment.
A Case II (Argentina): In 2001, Argentina was forced into a similar policy of fiscal
restraint. This led to a decline in investment in public services which arguably damaged
the economy
Argentina, which had been considered by the IMF to be a model country in its
compliance to policy proposals by the Bretton Woods institutions, experienced a
catastrophic economic crisis back in year 2001, which some believe to have been caused
by IMF-induced budget restrictions — which undercut the government's ability to sustain
national infrastructure even in crucial areas such as health, education, and security — and
privatization of strategically vital national resources. Others attribute the crisis to
Argentina's mis-designed fiscal federalism, which caused sub-national spending to
increase rapidly. The crisis added to widespread hatred of this institution in Argentina and
other South American countries, with many blaming the IMF for the region's economic
problems. The current (as of early 2006)trend towards moderate left-wing governments in
the region and a growing concern with the development of a regional economic policy
largely independent of big business pressures has been ascribed to this crisis.
Page 34 of 42
Money & Banking International Financial Institutions
be insufficient. In the 2005 Massey Lecture, entitled "Race Against Time", Stephen Lewis
argued that the structural adjustment policies of the World Bank and the International
Monetary Fund have aggravated and aided the spread of the AIDS pandemic by limiting
the funding allowed to health and education sectors.
3. Devaluations
The IMF has also been criticized for allowing inflationary devaluations. Currency
devaluation is recommended by the IMF to the governments of poor nations. E.g
As a part of conditions (for the last loan by IMF, Nov 2008) The Pakistani currency was
devalued after slight changes in the discount rate and exchange rate decreased officially
by 6-7% .
Complaints are also directed toward International Monetary Fund gold reserve being
undervalued. At its inception in 1945, the IMF pegged gold at US$35 per Troy ounce of
gold. In 1973 the Nixon administration lifted the fixed asset value of gold in favor of a
world market price. Hence the fixed exchange rates of currencies tied to gold were
switched to a floating rate, also based on market price and exchange. This largely came
about because Petrodollars outside the United States were more than could be backed by
the gold at Fort Knox under the fixed exchange rate system. The fixed rate system only
served to limit the amount of assistance the organisation could use to help debt-ridden
countries. Current IMF rules prohibit members from linking their currencies to gold.
Page 35 of 42
Money & Banking International Financial Institutions
Case I (Brazil) : In the 1960s, the IMF and the World Bank supported the government of
Brazil’s military dictator Castello Branco with tens of millions of dollars of loans and
credit that were denied to previous democratically-elected governments.
They support military dictators just for their own interests and to make their policies
imposed on such countries.
Case II (Pakistan) :For instance, In Pakistan, the IMF used a military government to
impose the General Sales Tax (GST), a national sales tax on most consumer items. At the
same time, they pressured the government to eliminate the Wealth Tax. The most ironic
twist in IMF tax policy is that the IMF itself is exempt from all taxes, along with its sister
institutions, the World Bank and the Inter-American Development Bank, in spite of the
fact that the trio of institutions own $1.4 billion worth of property in Washington DC.
“Evidently, the IMF exempts itself from the requirement of paying taxes to ensure
adequate governmental revenues,”
These agencies are not accountable to anyone but top financial officials of the wealthiest
nations, they make decisions in closed meetings, and they fail to produce the desired
results.
The IMF is funded with taxpayer money, yet it operates behind a veil of secrecy. In case
of designing a loan package for a country the members of affected communities do not
participate in designing loan packages.
The IMF works with a select group of central bankers and finance ministry staff to decide
polices without input from other government agencies such as health, education and
environment departments. Furthermore, the IMF has resisted attempts to open up to
public scrutiny and independent evaluation. The IMF has made elites from the Global
South more accountable to First World elites than their own people.
Page 36 of 42
Money & Banking International Financial Institutions
Undemocratic System
Unlike a democratic system in which each member country would have an equal vote,
rich countries dominate decision-making in the IMF because voting power is determined
by the amount of money that each country pays into the IMF's quota system. It's a system
of one dollar, one vote. The U.S. is the largest shareholder with a quota of 17 percent.
Germany, Japan, France, Great Britain, and the US combined control about 38 percent.
The disproportionate amount of power held by wealthy countries means that the interests
of bankers, investors and corporations from industrialized countries are put above the
needs of the world's poor majority.
Amercanization
Many critics and economists consider IMF & World Bank: an instrument for the
promotion of US or Western interests in certain regions of the world
US has a veto on major constitutional decisions with just over 16% of the shares in the
bank. The U.S. is the largest shareholder with a quota. The headquarters of both these
IFIs is in Washington D.C., (US capital), too. Further more the President of the World
Bank is has always been a US national.
In short, the IMF mainly serves wealthy countries and Wall Street
Page 37 of 42
Money & Banking International Financial Institutions
Moreover, reduction in government social spending in health and education means poor
no longer can afford these services. Liberalists backed by IMF maintain that poverty as
unfortunate or even unfair but not unjust, even if people die of hunger.
Page 38 of 42
Money & Banking International Financial Institutions
Page 39 of 42
Money & Banking International Financial Institutions
Here are some articles (/ selective extracts from articles) concerning the cruel attitude of
IMF and WB concerning the poor countries.
The IMF and the World Bank: protectors of capitalism
By Daniel Vila, People’s Weekly World, 17 January 1998
Imagine applying for a loan at a bank and being told that in order to receive the money
you must agree to being hit in the face by Mike Tyson, in the stomach with a bat
swung by Jose Canseco and kicked in the rear by a soccer player every morning for
the rest of your life. Paying the money back is not as difficult as surviving the
humiliating conditions of the loan.
There exists a double standard which allows richer countries to use fiscal expansion in
the face of recession while poorer nations are forced into stricter economic restraints.
Under the guise of helping economic distraught countries, the IMF is really bailing out
foreign investors and multinational corporations. They have further fueled chaos and
instability in some of the poorest regions in the world.
The International Monetary Fund (IMF) has been described as one of the enforcers of
globalization. Nations who receive IMF assistance are often forced to surrender more
sovereignty and further open up their borders to international banks and multinational
corporations. Much of their wealth is then sucked dry by foreign predators with its
resources and population essentially becoming the collateral for such financial aid. As a
result of the global economic crisis, many more nations are having to turn to the IMF for
help. At the recent G-20 Summit in London, the IMF’s role was expanded and its
powers enhanced. There was little mention of its failed policies and its less then stellar
record of effectively promoting development and democracy around the world. While
some talk of reform, the IMF continues to rape the world, one poor nation at a time.
Some IMF conditions that countries have been forced to comply with can only be
described as harsh and undemocratic. Often the devaluation of a nation’s currency has
been a precondition for IMF assistance. In order to qualify for IMF loans, some nations
have also been forced to lower tariffs, restrict governmental subsidies and spending,
balance budgets, as well as sell-off state institutions to foreign interests. In some cases,
the IMF has even prohibited wage increases as some countries have tried to do so, in
order to compensate for a sharp rise in food prices and other commodities.
Environmental and labor rights have also taken a hit as a result of IMF policies. Under
the guise of helping economic distraught countries, the IMF is really bailing out foreign
investors and multinational corporations. They have further fueled chaos and instability
in some of the poorest regions in the world.
Page 40 of 42
Money & Banking International Financial Institutions
Response to Criticism
Here is what IMF and it’s supporter say in response to all the critics:
3. Confidence
The fact there is a lender of last resort provides an important confidence boost for
investors. This is important during current financial turmoil
What we Think: Though there might be some (next to negligible) truth about these
counter arguments. But we can surely see that the stated objectives are totally
contradicting what these organizations really do.
Page 41 of 42
Money & Banking International Financial Institutions
Suggestions
IMF and World Bank should use their power in the positive sense, to help the third world
not to create problems for them. The government of developing countries who is
successful in getting funds from the IFIs, they must use it in efficiently and sincerely. The
IMF should be accountable to all of its members (even if they have a 0.001% share)
There is so much criticism about IFIs and we think most of the critics are true.
The IMF requires deep, comprehensive, structural reforms. it should start by deciding
whether it wants to be a main player in the international financial architecture, or whether
it wishes to remain only a trusted advisor. If it wants to be a key player, it must greatly
increase its independence, boost its financial capacity and adopt an automatic insurance
facility. Otherwise its influence will be dependent on the political skills of its managing
directors. As regards its function as facilitator in the multilateral surveillance process, it
will be critical to craft political agreement, which will solve thorny issues. Moreover
unless emerging markets are provided with the viable insurance facility, it will be very
difficult to induce the needed changes in the incentive structure that lead these countries
to accumulate massive foreign reserves. Global imbalances and national financial crises
that can spill over into global markets are best addressed by a global institution like IFIs.
The IMF can work to try to insure that financial and current account imbalances are
addressed rather than ignored, and that they are addressed by policies that are not
destructive of global prosperity. The World Bank country offices should be autonomous
in designing policies and implementation strategies on the basis of a certain nation’s
needs. We can’t apply the same policy in all countries. The country offices should
identify problems of a certain country and then formulate policies to solve those. Instead
of focusing on growth-based development, it should pay attention on involvement of the
poor in their efforts for sustainable development. As Prof. Muhammad Yunus founder of
Grameen bank said “I told them you have forgot the people, who should be the centre of
any development program. Yes, infrastructure can also help in eradicating poverty. But it
will be successful only when the poor have ownership in that infrastructure, The World
Bank should lend at least 5 percent of its total lending money for micro credit programs.”
Conclusion
In short, the world can turn into a much better place to live in, for everyone. If only the
IMF and World Bank use their enormous authority and the immensely great economic
power in a healthier way.
Page 42 of 42