22/09/2013

Israel has no Roger Waters - Opinion Israel News | Haaretz

SUBSCRIBE T O HAARET Z DIGIT AL EDIT IONS

Haaretz.com

TheMarker

TheMarker Caf
Hel l o y t r You hav e v iewed 7 of 1 0 articles. Sunday, September 22, 2013 Tishrei 18, 5774 Search Haaretz.com

ISRAEL MINT
Pr ofile Log ou t
su bscri be n ow

World

Is Merkel good for the Jews?

NEWS

OPINION JEWISH WORLD

Attack in Keny a Sukkot

BUSINESS
Sy ria

TRAVEL

CULTURE

WEEKEND BLOGS

ARCHAEOLOGY NEWS BROADCAST

Like 81k Follow

ISRAEL NEWS BREAKING NEWS

Home Opinion

Nuclear Iran

Word of the Day

1:40 PM Iran's president: Country is 'loyal' to its pledge not to seek nuclear weapons (AP)

More Breaking News

Israel has no Roger Waters

Those who have attacked, poisoned, uprooted and burned will be coming this evening to applaud Ehud Banai, a singer representing Israel's heart and soul.
By Gideon Levy | Sep. 22, 2013 | 2:12 AM |
1 Tw eet 9

HAARETZ SELECT

6
Send Marius Berntsen and 56 others recommend this.

Recommend

EU settlement guidelines do not victimize Israel or endanger peace

The EU would lose all international credibility if it acceded to Israel's dem and to water down its settlem ent guidelines - and it would also be in breach of international law. By Willem-Gert Aldershoff , Michel Waelbroeck | Opinion | 15

Analysis || Murder in the West Bank: A thin line between terror and crime
By Amos Harel | Diplom acy and Defense | 13

T he ancient road to Jerusalem: the work of Romans, or Jewish pilgrims?

By Eli Ashkenazi | National | 12

Pink Floy d co-founder and bass guitarist Roger Waters perform s his 'The Wall' liv e concert in Bucharest, August 2 8, 2 01 3 . Photo by Reuters

Behind the scenes: How the nuclear resolution on Israel was defeated
By Barak Ravid | Diplom acy and Defense | 3

There's a show on tonight. Hundreds will put on their holiday finest, maybe dressing in white. They'll grab their weapons and kids, and off theyll go. Theyll park their cars in the parking lot that was especially arranged (without permission, of course) on land owned by the Shraytah family, and in theyll go to the West Bank site that was once the Palestinian village of Sussia. Until 1986, it was home to hundreds of residents who lived in caves and niches there. They were expelled by Israel in an "expropriation for public use," with the administration of the site turned over to the nearby Jewish settlement (also called Sussia) as an additional source of income - "for public use," of course. At the rear of the site, the settlers had set up several huts, where the Palestinians became squatters. They were evicted from their new location twice, until the High Court of Justice ruled in 2001 that a "mistake" had been committed. That happens, but the threat of eviction is again hovering over the Palestinians. Throngs of people will be coming to Sussia this evening. Some will be people who have poisoned Palestinians' wells, attacked Palestinian shepherds, and uprooted their trees and burned their fields. People from Sussia, the Lucifer farm, the Maon farm, Mitzpeh Yair, Avigayil, Mitzpeh Asahel, and elsewhere. A popular singer will be performing in this violent no-man'sland, this apartheid district. Ladies and gentlemen, please welcome that

Tex t size Comments (6) Print Page Send to friend Share on Facebook Share on Twitter Share
THIS STORY IS BY

T he devil wears (Jewish) history: Dive into the world of dybbuks

Dr. J.H. Chajes, researcher of Jewish culture in the early m odern era, Univ ersity of Haifa, talks about the Jewish definition of the karm a concept and whether he believ es in the spirit world. By Ayelett Shani | Magazine

Gideon Levy

RELATED TAGS Israel settlers West Bank opinion

Departures / Arrivals: Forget beaches and shopping: Marguerite visited checkpoints and refugee camps
By Liat Elkayam | Departures/Arrivals

T roubled waters || Israel Navy commander sees prominent role for fleet in future land battles
By Amos Harel | National | 22

O PI NI O N
EU settlem ent guidelines do not v ictim ize Israel or endanger peace
By Willem-Gert Aldershoff, Michel Waelbroeck | 12:50 PM |

www.haaretz.com/opinion/.premium-1.548120

1/4

22/09/2013
performer of strong opinions, Ehud Banai.

Israel has no Roger Waters - Opinion Israel News | Haaretz

15

Banai was evasive on his Facebook page: "I wanted to come to perform at Sussia despite my views to convey a message that we should come together in the spirit of the Sukkot holiday," he wrote. He apologized to the "residents" - meaning, of course, just the settlers - for his previous, premature notice that his show was being canceled. He had come to an agreement with the head of the local settlement council, Zviki Bar-Hai, that his concert would not take place - "due to the not-good atmosphere that developed around it" - but immediately backed down, for reasons that are not clear. A resident of the Palestinian village of Sussia, Nasser Nawaj'a, responded to Banai, also on Facebook. "When you perform at the site, Mr. Banai, look around you. You will still be able to see remnants of the village, the caves where we used to live, and the water holes that we drank from." Nasser was just 4 when he was evicted from his home, a site that is now the location where Banai will be performing this evening. And for the information of a singer who expressed the wish to bring people together, Banai should know that Nasser's elderly father, Mohammed, attempted to visit the site. A documentary film immortalized the occasion. The father was expelled by the settlers, to his tearful chagrin. In his song "Aharei has'ara" ("After the storm"), Banai sang: "Just for one woman / whose home the winds took away / it's as if time stopped." He should think about that lyric this evening. And in an entirely different context, Banai once sang, in his song "Zmancha avar" ("Your time has passed"), "We are guests here for the moment / look around / that is not our bus." And, again in a different context, "Bluz kna'ani" ("Canaanite blues"), he sang about how "hahosheh gover kan" ("darkness is taking over here"). Darkness is indeed taking over. And this evening it will extend its reach even further. Banai will give the settlers a good time with his music, which, of course, is his prerogative - although he should have boycotted them. The man should have performed somewhere else this evening. In Khirbet Makhoul, in the Jordan Valley, for example, where dozens of Palestinians remain without a roof over their heads after the Israeli army demolished their village. But performing at such a place would never occur to an Israeli singer. Banai could also have performed at Sussia but invited the Palestinians who were evicted from there, in an effort to bring people together. Instead - because he is "opposed to boycotts" - he opted to perform at a Sussia where, as a practical matter, Palestinians are denied admission. He opted to perform there "despite his views," which remain unknown. I would have had more respect for him if he had declared allegiance to the right wing. He is no Roger Waters, the singer who opted to boycott Israel. We and he don't have a single, brave and honest performer like Waters. Not one. I once met an elderly shepherd, Khalil Nawaj'a, and his wife, Tamam, at Sussia. The two had been attacked twice, by settlers with clubs. I also once saw dead and poisoned sheep in nearby Khirbet Tawani, and also saw a red jeep leave the settlement of Sussia. The occupants of the vehicle stole their olive harvest by force. Those who have attacked, poisoned, uprooted and burned will be coming this evening to applaud Banai, a singer representing Israel's heart and soul.

What about battered wiv es' freedom ?

By Moshe Negbi | 02:27 AM

Better liv ing without chem icals

By Amir Oren | 02:24 AM

Legally m andated destruction

By Haaretz Editorial | 02:19 AM | 3

MO RE FRO M THE WEB

For Migrant s, New Land of Opport unit y Is Mexico (The New York Times) Europes Least Likely t o Succeed Could Soon St art (The Financialist) Here Are t he Four Missiles That May Fly Over Sy ria (Business Week)
Recommended by

FACEBO O K
ACTIV ITY
Recent Activity Guy Butavia recommends EU tells Israel to explain seizure of Palestinian aid - Diplomacy and Defense.
12 hours ago

RECOMMENDATIONS

Joe Bauers recommends What 'equality under the law' means to Israeli police in the West Bank Diplomacy & Defense.
about a month ago

Kim Marie recommends Bill to raise Israel's electoral threshold passes first reading - National.
about a month ago

F acebook social plugin

MORE FROM HAARETZ.COM

Report || Swiss police raid home of world's richest Israeli
(Haaretz | Business)

FROM AROUND THE WEB

Let s Be Honest About Israels Nukes
(The New York Times)

Top 10 Jewish Holly wood moment s of 57 7 3

(Haaretz | Jew ish World)

Indias Undersea Nuclear Det errent Poses Proliferat ion Challenges

(World Politics Review )

www.haaretz.com/opinion/.premium-1.548120

2/4

22/09/2013

Israel has no Roger Waters - Opinion Israel News | Haaretz

Time for a t arget ed killing in Sy ria

(Haaretz | Opinion)

Adult ery as Aperit if, Served by 6 Amat eurs and a Pro

(The New York Times)

George Soros marries 42y ear-old in st ar-st udded ceremony

(Haaretz | Jew ish World)

Israel is rat ed 2nd in t he most educat ed count ries in t he world

(TIME)
Recommended by

COMMENTS
Name Subject Comment
Your comment here

By adding a comment i agree to this sites Terms of use

LATEST

MOST VIEWED

HIGHEST RATED

Open All
7 1

04

Banais heart & soul searching ly rics are a luxury denied t o ot hers, while we sing & search our souls,,
By Zigzag Yashar 22 Sep 2013 05:25PM

03

Pick up a bass, Gideon, don't y ou see t hat Y OU are t he Israeli Wat ers?
By Nemesis 22 Sep 2013 04:03PM

And it f t hey are at t acked t hey will cry t errorism ? 02 By Freedomfighter 22 Sep 2013 01:09PM This is why y ou suffer.
By Sergey 22 Sep 2013 01:56PM 1

15

14

Polacks must be at t acked t hen,t hey occupy Breslau,Pomern,Schlesien

By Absolute Sw eden 22 Sep 2013 01:56PM

01

Thank y ou ...
By Tamar 22 Sep 2013 11:58AM

14

NEWS: Diplomacy and Defense | National | World | Middle East | Features | Opinion | Israel weather | Maccabiah 2013 JEWISH WORLD: News | Rabbis' Round Table | The Jewish Thinker CULTURE: Books | Food and Wine | Arts & Leisure HAARETZ.COM BLOGS: A Special Place in Hell | West of Eden | Diplomania | Routine Emergencies | Eyes Wide Open | Jerusalem Vivendi The Axis | East Side Story | Strenger than Fiction | Modern Manna | The Fifth Question HAARETZ.CO.IL: | | | | | | | | | FAQ | Contact us | Terms and Conditions | Privacy Policy | Management | Editorial | Employment Opportunities | Advertise on Haaretz.com | Haaretz News Widget

Design by Roni Arie | Accelerated by cotendo

www.haaretz.com/opinion/.premium-1.548120

3/4

22/09/2013

Israel has no Roger Waters - Opinion Israel News | Haaretz

Haaretz.com, the online edition of Haaretz Newspaper in Israel, and analysis from Israel and the Middle East. Haaretz.com provides extensive and in-depth coverage of Israel, the Jewish World and the Middle East, including defense, diplomacy, the Arab-Israeli conflict, the peace process, Israeli politics, Jerusalem affairs, international relations, Iran, Iraq, Syria, Lebanon, the Palestinian Authority, the West Bank and the Gaza Strip, the Israeli business world and Jewish life in Israel and the Diaspora. Haaretz Daily Newspaper Ltd. All Rights Reserved

www.haaretz.com/opinion/.premium-1.548120

4/4