Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
Carlyle A. Thayer
Vietnam Update
The Australian National University
November 6-7, 2008
2008
Year of Economic Calamity
Outline
1. Framing Political Analysis
2. Formal Politics
3. Informal Politics
4. Party-State Response
5. Reconsidering Political Analysis
Indicators
Index Ranking Organisation
12th legislature
• 3rd Session
(6 May-7 June)
• 4th Session
(16 October-15 November)
8th Plenum (2-4 October)
• Considered a report on socio-economic
development and 2008 budget spending
plus major tasks for 2009 by Nguyen Sinh
Hung.
• 2009 top priority to achieve single digit
inflation rate by 2010, thus gradually
stabilizing the macro-economy with growth
rate kept at an appropriate and
sustainable level
③ Informal Politics
• Pro-Democracy Activism
• Labour Strikes
• Media Reporting of Corruption
• Catholics Land Protests in Hanoi
• Ethnic Minorities and Religious Freedom
in the Central Highlands
Pro-Democracy Activism
Source: Kerkvliet 2008b and Vietnam Investment Review, August 25, 2008
Labour Strike Da Nang, 30th January
Thai Ha Parish
Former Vatican Embassy 178 Nguyen Luong Bang
42 Nha Chung
Catholic Church-State Land Disputes
Supporters of
Supporters of
Party Secretary
Prime Minister
General
Five Deputy
Prime Ministers
PM Nguyen
Tan Dung
8th
Pre-date PM
Congress 5
Dung
1996
9th
PM Dung’s
Congress 7
cohorts
2001
10th New comers
Congress 10 to spearhead
reforms
2006
⑤ Reframing Political Analysis
• Bring the party back in
• Leaders and role conflict
• Factions and factionalism
• Sectoral politics
• Political economy
• Patron-client relations
• Beyond workers and peasants
– the role of intellectuals and clergy
• The media
– journalists, Internet, blogs, Bishop’s
letters, New Horizon Radio
Vietnam’s Power Elite
Secretary
General
State
Prime Minister
President
?
Leninist, Mono-organisational Socialism,
Market-Leninism, Soft Authoritarian?
Armed Mass
The State
Forces Organisations
Political Overview: Vietnam in 2008
Abstract & Bibliography
Carlyle A. Thayer
Paper presented to Vietam Update 2008, The Australian
National University, Canberra, November 6-7, 2008
2
Abstract
This paper presents an overview of the major political developments in
Vietnam during 2008. The paper opens with a brief consideration of how
political scientists have framed their analysis of politics in Vietnam.
The main body of the paper is divided into three parts. Part one considers
“formal politics”, that is, decision-making by the Vietnam Communist
Party and the National Assembly. In particular, the paper analyses the
main outcomes of the sixth, seventh and eighth plenary sessions of the
party Central Committee, held January, July, and October, respectively.
Next, the paper discusses the legislative outcomes of the third and fourth
sessions of the National Assembly that met in May-June and October-
November.
Part two of the paper explores “informal politics” in Vietnam during the
year. In particular, the paper discusses public protest in a number of issue
areas. Five case studies are discussed: pro-democracy activism; labour
strikes in the garment and textile industries; media reporting of corruption
scandals; Catholic protests over property claims in Hanoi; and ethnic
minorities and religious freedom in the Central Highlands
Part three presents an analysis of how Vietnam’s party-state responded to
the rapid rise in inflation. This section considers tensions between party
and state over how to demarcate responsibility for dealing with this issue.
The paper concludes with a reconsideration of frameworks for analysing
the Vietnamese political system in light of developments in 2008.
*
Professor of Politics, School of Humanities and Social Sciences, University College, The
University of New South Wales at the Australian Defence Force Academy. Professor Thayer is
currently on sabbatical leav as Visiting Fellow, Strategic and Defence Studies Centre, The
Australian National University.
3
Bibliography
Agenzia Fides (2005). History of the Catholic Church in Vietnam. Vatican City:
Dossier, November 26.
Amnesty International (2008a). ‘Viet Nam’, Amnesty International Report 2008,
May.
Amnesty International (2008b). ‘Viet Nam: Time to Live Up to Human Rights
Commitment’, Public Statement, ASA 41/001/2008, June 30.
Amnesty International (2008c). ‘Viet Nam: Growing Fear, Growing
Discrimination’, Public Statement, ASA, October 9.
Asian Development Bank (2008). Asian Development & Viet Nam: A Fact Sheet.
Manila: Asian Development Bank.
Ban Chap Hanh Trung Uong Dang Cong San Viet Nam (2008a). ‘Xay dung to
chuc co so Dang thuc su tro thanh cau noi giua Dang voi nhan dan’, Quan Doi
Nhan Dan, February 2, 1-2.
Ban Chap Hanh Trung Uong Dang Cong San Viet Nam (2008ab). ‘Thong bao Hoi
nghi lan thu bay Ban chap hanh Trung uong Dang (khoa X)’, Quan Doi Nhan Dan,
July 18, 2.
Ban Chap Hanh Trung Uong Dang Cong San Viet Nam (2008c). ‘Thong bao Hoi
Nghi [lan thu bay]’, Tap Chi Cong San, 790: 3-7.
Ban Chap Hanh Trung Uong Dang Cong San Viet Nam (2008d). ‘Thong bao Hoi
nghi lan thu bay Ban chap hanh Trung uong Dang (khoa X)’, Quan Doi Nhan Dan,
July 18, 1-2.
Ban Chap Hanh Trung Uong Dang Cong San Viet Nam (2008e). ‘Tang cuong su
lanh dao cua Dang doi voi cong tac thanh nien thoi ky day manh cong nghiep
hoa, hien dai hoa’, Quan Doi Nhan Dan, August 15, 1-2.
Ban Chap Hanh Trung Uong Dang Cong San Viet Nam (2008ef. ‘Nghi quyet Hoi
nghi lan thu bay Ban chap hanh Trung uong khoa X ve xay dung doi ngu tri thuc
trong thoi ky day manh cong nghiep hoa, hien dai hoa dat nuoc’, Quan Doi Nhan
Dan, August 16, 1-2.
Ban Chap Hanh Trung Uong Dang Cong San Viet Nam (2008g). ‘Nghi quyet Hoi
nghi lan thu bay Ban Chap hanh Truong uong khoa X ve nong nghiep, nong dan,
nong thon’, Quan Doi Nhan Dan, August 17, 1-2.
Ban Chap Hanh Trung Uong Dang Cong San Viet Nam (2008h). ‘On dinh kinh te
vi mo, bao dam an sinh xa hoi va tang truong ben vung’, Quan Doi Nhan Dan,
October 5, 1-2.
Berteslmann Stiftung ed. (2008). Bertlesmann Transformation Index 2008. Gütersloh:
Verlag Bertlesmann Stiftung.
Bingham, B. (2008). ‘Remarks to Vietnam: Informal Mid-Year Consultative
Group Meeting’, Sapa City, Vietnam, June 5-6.
Brassard, C. (2008). ‘The Employment Agenda in Vietnam: What’s in it for the
Poor?’, Paper presented to Remaking the Vietnamese State: Implications for Viet
4
Nam and the Region, Viet Nam Workshop, City University of Hong Kong, Hong
Kong, August 21-22.
Clarke, S. (2006). ‘The Changing Character of Strikes in Vietnam’. Post-Communist
Economies, 18:3, 345-361.
Clarke, S. Change-Hee Lee and Do Quynh Chi (2007) ‘From Rights to Interests:
The Challenge of Industrial Relations in Vietnam’. Journal of Industrial
Relations, 49:4, 545-568.
Committee to Protect Journalists (2008a). ‘Vietnam: Award-Winning Journalist
Released’, News Alert 2008, February 4.
Committee to Protect Journalists (2008b). Letter from Joel Simon, Executive
Director, to President Nguyen Minh Triet, Protest Letter 2008, May 13.
Committee to Protect Journalists (2008c). ‘Vietnamese Authorities Revoke Seven
Journalists’ Press Credentials’, Protest Letter 2008, August 5.
Committee to Protect Journalists (2008d). ‘Vietnam: Critical Blogger Given 30
Months in Prison’, News Alert 2008, September 11.
Committee to Protect Journalists (2008e). ‘Police Detain, Beat Associated Press
Reporter in Vietnam’, News Alert 2008, September 19.
Committee to Protect Journalists (2008f). ‘Vietnam: Graft-Busting Reporter Jailed
for Two Years’, News Alert 2008, October 15.
Crispin, S.W. (2008). ‘Vietnam’s Reforms on the Line’, Asia Times Online, June 28.
Dao Viet Dung (2008). ‘Vietnam’, in Asian Development Outlook 2008. Manila:
Asian Development Bank. 229-233.
Dixon, C. (2004). ‘State, Party and Political Change in Vietnam’, in Duncan
McCargo, ed., Rethinking Vietnam. London: RoutledgeCurzon. 15-27.
Do Quy Don (2008). ‘Hoat Dong Bao Chi, Xuat Ban Va Cong Tac Quan Ly Nha
Nuoc Ve Bao Chi, Xuat Ban Hien Nay [Press and Publication Activities Current
State Management of Press and Publication Activities]’, Tap Chi Cong San, 788:
20-24.
Dosch, J. and Alexander L. Vuving (2008). The Impact of China on Governance
Structures in Vietnam. Discussion Paper 14. Bonn: Deutsches Institut für
Entwicklungspolitik.
Fforde, A. (2008). ‘Economic Transformation: Some Implications of Vietnam’s
Economic Growth Pattern or Reflections on the Economics of Vietnamese
Capitalism and Possible Political Implications’, Paper presented to Remaking the
Vietnamese State: Implications for Viet Nam and the Region, Viet Nam
Workshop, City University of Hong Kong, Hong Kong, August 21-22.
Fosberg, L.T. and Ari Kokko (2007). ‘The Role of Donors in Vietnamese
Development Planning’. Working Paper 238. Stockholm, Stockholm School of
Economics.
Freedom House (2007). ‘Vietnam (2007)’, Freedom in the World. Accessed February
20, 2008.
5
Freedom House (2008). ‘Vietnam’, Freedom of the Press 2008. April 29.
Gainsborough, M. (2003). Changing Political Economy of Vietnam: The Case of Ho
Chi Minh City. London: RoutledgeCurzon.
Gainsborough, M. (2004). ‘Ho Chi Minh City’s Post-1975 Political Elite:
Continuity and Change in Background and Belief’ in Benedict J. Tria Kerkvliet
and David G.Marr, eds., Beyond Hanoi: Local Government in Vietnam. Singapore:
Institute of Southeast Asian Studies, 2004.
Gainsborough, M. (2007). ‘From Patronage to “Outcomes”: Vietnam’s
Communist Party Congresses Reconsidered’, Journal of Vietnamese Studies, 2:1, 3-
26.
Gainsborough, M. (2008a). ‘Privatisation As State Advance: Private Indirect
Government in Vietnam”. Unpublished manuscript.
Gainsborough, M. (2008b). ‘States and Global Forces Reconsidered: Some
Theoretical and Empirical Pointers From Vietam’. Unpublished manuscript
Hansson, E. (2003). ‘Authoritarian Governance and Labour: The VGCL and the
Party-State in Economic Renovation’, in Ben Tria Kerkvliet, Russell Heng and
David Koh, eds., Getting Organized in Vietnam: Moving In and Around the Socialist
State. Singapore: Institute of Southeast Asian Studies.
Harvard Vietnam Program (2008). Choosing Success: The Lessons of East and
Southeast Asia and Vietnam’s Future – A Policy Framework for Vietnam’s
Socioeconomic Development, 2001-2020. Cambridge: Asia Programs, John F.
Kennedy School of Government , Harvard University.
Hayton, B. (2007). ‘Tensions since the Xth Congress and Current Political
Situation and Problems’, Commentary (Adam Fforde & Associates), 1, 13-18.
Hayton, B. (2008). ‘Dissent’, Paper presented to EuroViet 6, Asien-Afrika Institüt,
Universität Hamburg, Hamburg, Germany, June 6-8.
Hong Kong and Shanghai Banking Corporation (2007). ‘Economics & Strategy’,
Vietnam Monitor, August 29, 5: 1-15.
Hong Kong and Shanghai Banking Corporation (2008a). ‘Economics & Strategy’,
Vietnam Monitor, January 8, 9: 1-13.
Hong Kong and Shanghai Banking Corporation (2008b). ‘Vietnam Economics’,
Vietnam Monitor, June 3, 1-13.
Hong Kong and Shanghai Banking Corporation (2008c). ‘Economics & Strategy’,
Vietnam Monitor, October 3, 18: 1-17.
Human Rights Watch (2002). Repression of Montagnards: Conflicts Over Land and
Religion in Vietnam’s Central Highlands. New York: Human Rights Watch.
Human Rights Watch (2006). No Sanctuary: Ongoing Threats to Indigenous
Montagnards in Vietnam’s Central Highlands. 18;3(C), June.
Human Rights Watch (2008a). ‘Vietnam Country Summary’, January.
Human Rights Watch (2008b). ‘Vietnam: Eight Vietnamese Writers Receive
Prestigious Human Rights Prize’, Press Release, July 22.
6
Lai Hong Khanh (2008). ‘Tu Do Ton Giao Phai Gan Lien Voi Chap Hanh Nghiem
Phat Luat’ , Tap Chi Quoc Phong Toan Dan, 10:54-58.
Landau, I. (2008). ‘Law and Civil Society in Cambodia and Vietnam: A
Gramscian Perspective’, Journal of Contemporary Asia, 38:2. 244-255.
Le, L.S. (2008). ‘Vietnam in Denial Over Economic Woes’, Far Eastern Economic
Review, 171(8), 45-49.
Le Dang Doanh. (2008). ‘Market Economy with Socialist Orientation and The
Role of the State in Vietnam’, Paper presented to Remaking the Vietnamese State:
Implications for Viet Nam and the Region, Viet Nam Workshop, City University
of Hong Kong, Hong Kong, August 21-22.
London, J. (2008). ‘Viet Nam and the Making of Market-Leninism’, Paper
presented to Remaking the Vietnamese State: Implications for Viet Nam and the
Region, Viet Nam Workshop, City University of Hong Kong, Hong Kong,
August 21-22.
London J. (2008b) ‘The Market-Leninist Welfare Regime’, Paper presented to
Remaking the Vietnamese State: Implications for Viet Nam and the Region, Viet
Nam Workshop, City University of Hong Kong, Hong Kong, August 21-22.
Malesky, E. (2008). ‘Why Do Single-Party Regimes Hold Elections? An Analysis
of Candidate-Level Data in Vietnam’s 2007 National Assembly Contest, Paper
presented to Remaking the Vietnamese State: Implications for Viet Nam and the
Region, Viet Nam Workshop, City University of Hong Kong, Hong Kong,
August 21-22.
Manthorpe, J. (2008). ‘American Meltdown Worsens Vietnam Turmoil’,
Vancouver Sun, October 13.
Masina, P. (2008). ‘Industrial Policy, Labor and Strategic Planning: Vietnam After
the WTO Accession’, Paper presented to Remaking the Vietnamese State:
Implications for Viet Nam and the Region, Viet Nam Workshop, City University
of Hong Kong, Hong Kong, August 21-22.
McCool, G. (2008). ‘Vietnamese Struggle with High Inflation’, International Herald
Tribune, January 29.
Mitton, R. (2008a). ‘For Hanoi, Protests are Okay – Up to a Point’, The Straits
Times, March 14.
Mitton, R. (2008b). ‘Viet Papers Blast Gov’t for Arrests Over Graft Expose;
Perception of Party Rift Reinforced by State-Owned Papers’ Criticism’, The
Straits Times, May 15.
Mitton, R. (2008c). ‘Chronicle of a Death Untold’, The Straits Times, June 22.
Mitton, R. (2008d). ‘Economic Waves Imperil Vietnam’s Leader’, Asian Sentinel,
August 4.
Mitton, R. (2008e). ‘Vietnam Faces Political Turbulence as Economic Woes
Worsen’, The Asia Sentinel, October 7.
Mitton, R. (2008f). ‘Vietnam: Behind the Journalists’ Jailings’, The Asia Sentinel,
October 24.
8
Thayer, C.A. (2006a). ‘Political Dissent and Political Reform in Vietnam, 1997-
2002’, in Claudia Derichs and Thomas Heberer, eds. The Power of Ideas: Intellectual
Input and Political Change in East and Southeast Asia. NIAS Studies in Asian Topics
No. 36, Copenhagen S: Nordic Institute of Asian Studies Press. 115-132.
Thayer, C.A. (2007a). ‘Mot bai viet ve dang Viet Tan (Report on the Viet Tan
Party)’, Written commentary for BBC World Service, Vietnamese Service, 4 May.
Thayer, C.A. (2007b). ‘Vietnam: The Tenth Party Congress and After’, in Daljit
Singh and Lorraine C. Salazar, eds., Southeast Asian Affairs 2007. Singapore:
Institute of Southeast Asian Studies. 381-397.
Thayer, C.A. (2008a). ‘Hanoi Party Tricks’, The Wall Street Journal, Editorials &
Opinion, June 19, 15.
Thayer, C.A. (2008b). ‘One-Party Rule and the Challenge of Civil Society in
Vietnam’, Paper presented to Remaking the Vietnamese State: Implications for
Viet Nam and the Region, Viet Nam Workshop, City University of Hong Kong,
Hong Kong, August 21-22.
Thayer, C.A. (2008c). ‘Vietnam’, in Stuart Farson, Peter Gill, Mark Phythian, and
Shlomo Shapiro eds., PSI Handbook of Global Security and Intelligence: National
Approaches, Vol. 1, The Americas and Asia. Westport, CT and London: Praeger
Security International. 300-317.
Thayer, C.A. (2008d). ‘Vietnam’, in Karen J. Sparks, ed., Encyclopaedia Britannica
2008 Book of the Year. Chicago: Encyclopaedia Britannica, Inc. 490-491.
Thayer, C.A. (2008e). “Vietnam: One-Party Rule and the Challenge of Civil
Society,” Paper presented to Surveying the Paradigm Shifts in Asia, Regional
Outlook Forum, sponsored by the Institute of Southeast Asian Studies,
Singapore, Shangri-La Hotel, January 8.
Thayer, C.A. (2008f). ‘Vietnam’s Defence Policy and its Impact on Foreign
Relations’, Paper presented to EuroViet 6, Asien-Afrika Institüt, Universität
Hamburg, Hamburg, Germany, June 6-8.
Thayer, C.A. (2008g). ‘Vietnam People’s Army: Development and
Modernization’, Paper presented to Sultan Haji Bolkiah Institute of Defence and
Strategic Studies, Ministry of Defence, Bolkiah Garrison, Bandar Seri Begawan,
Brunei Darussalam, July 24.
Thayer, C.A. (forthcoming). ‘Military Politics in Vietnam’, in Marcus Mietzner.
ed., Military Politics in Contemporary Southeast Asia. London: Routledge.
Thayer, C.A. (forthcoming). ’Vietnam’, in Karen J. Sparks, ed., Encyclopaedia
Britannica 2009 Book of the Year. Chicago: Encyclopaedia Britannica, Inc.
Thayer, C.A. (forthcoming). ‘Vietnam’, in Bogdan Szajkowski, ed., Political
Parties of the World. 67h Edition. London: John Harper Publishing.
Tran, A.N. (2007a), ‘Alternatives to the “Race to the Bottom” in Vietnam:
Minimum Wage Strikes and Their Aftermath’. Labor Studies Journal, 32:4, 430-451.
11
Tran, A.N (2007b). ‘The Third Sleeve: Emerging Labor Newspapers and the
Response of the Labor Unions and the State to Workers’ Resistance in Vietnam’.
Labor Studies Journal, 32:3, 257-279.
Transparency International (2006), Corruption Perceptions Index 2006.
Transparency International (2007), Corruption Perceptions Index 2007.
Transparency International (2008), Corruption Perceptions Index 2008.
Uy Ban Bao Ve Quyen Lam Nguoi Viet Nam (2008). ‘Political Stability vs
Democratic Freedom? Economic Crisis and Political Repression in Vietnam’.
Submission to Hearing on Cambodia, Laos and Vietnam, Sub-commission on
Human Rights, European Parliament, Brussels, August 25.
United States Commission for International Religious Freedom (2008). Policy
Focus: Vietnam.
United States Department of State (2008). ‘Vietnam’, Country Reports on Human
Rights Practices 2007. Washington, D.C.: Bureau of Democracy, Human Rights,
and Labor, March 11.
Vasavakul, T. (1997). ‘Sectoral Politics and Strategies for State and Party Building
fro the VII to the VIII Congress of the Vietnamese Communist Party (1991-1996)’.
In Adam Fforde, ed., Doi Moi: Ten Years After the 1986 Party Congress. Political
and Social Change Monograph 24. Canberra: Department of Political and Social
Change, Research School of Pacific and Asian Studies, The Australian National
University. 81-135.
Vasavakul, T. (2003). ‘From Fence-Breaking to Networking: Interests, Popular
Organizations, and Policy Influences in Post-socialist Vietnam’, in Ben J. Tria
Kerkvliet, Russell H. K. Heng and David W. H. Koh, eds., Getting Organized in
Vietnam: Moving in and around the Socialist State. Singapore: Institute of Southeast
Asian Studies. 25-61.
Vasavakul, T. (2008). ‘Recrafting State Identity: Corruption and Anti-Corruption
in Doi Moi Vietnam from a Comparative Perspective’, Paper presented to
Remaking the Vietnamese State: Implications for Viet Nam and the Region, Viet
Nam Workshop, City University of Hong Kong, Hong Kong, August 21-22.
Viet Nam Resident Mission, Asian Development Bank (2008). ‘Viet Nam: Staying
the Course in Storms’, Presentation to Launch of Asian Development Outlook 2008,
Hanoi, April 2.
Vietnam Venture Group (2008). Economic Indicators, September 18.
Vo Van Ai (2008). Presentation to Hearing on Cambodia, Laos and Vietnam, Sub-
commission on Human Rights, European Parliament, Brussels, August 25.
Vuving, A. (2006). ‘Strategy and Evolution of Vietnam’s China Policy: A
Changing Mixture of Pathways’, Asian Survey, 46(6), 805-824.
Vu Van Ninh (2008). ‘Mot so giai phap kiem che lam phat, on dinh kinh te vi mo
Some Solutions for Restraining Inflation and Stabilizing the Macro-Economy’,
Tap Chi Cong San, 789: 3-7.
12