IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT FOR THE DISTRICT OF DELAWARE

ALEX IS THE BEST, LLC, Plaintiff, v. SAMSUNG ELECTRONICS CO. LTD., SAMSUNG ELECTRONICS AMERICA, INC., and SAMSUNG TELECOMMUNICATIONS AMERICA, LLC Defendants. C.A. N!. """"""""""""""""""" TRIAL BY JURY DEMANDED

COMPLAINT FOR PATENT INFRINGEMENT Plaintiff Ale# is t$e Best, LLC. %&AITB' , () and t$*!+,$ its +nde*si,ned -!+nsel, (*in,s t$is a-ti!n a,ainst Sa.s+n, Ele-t*!ni-s C!. Ltd., Sa.s+n, Ele-t*!ni-s A.e*i-a, In-.,, and Sa.s+n, Tele-!..+ni-ati!ns A.e*i-a, LLC %-!lle-tivel), &Sa.s+n,' and &Defendants' . In s+//!*t !f t$is C!./laint, AITB alle,es as f!ll!0s1 NATURE OF THE SUIT 2. T$is is an a-ti!n f!* /atent inf*in,e.ent +nde* t$e Patent La0s !f t$e United

States !f A.e*i-a, 34 U.S.C. 55 2 et seq., in-l+din, 34 U.S.C. 5 672. THE PARTIES 6. Plaintiff AITB is a li.ited lia(ilit) -!./an) !*,ani8ed +nde* t$e la0s !f t$e state

!f Ne0 9!*: 0it$ its /*in-i/al /la-e !f (+siness at 74 ;6nd St., B*!!:l)n, Ne0 9!*: 226<=. 3. On inf!*.ati!n and (elief, Sa.s+n, Ele-t*!ni-s C!., Ltd. is a -!*/!*ati!n

!*,ani8ed and e#istin, +nde* t$e la0s !f S!+t$ >!*ea 0it$ its /*in-i/al /la-e !f (+siness ?2@ MaetanA3d!n,, 9e!n,t!n,A,+, S+0!nACit), G)e!n,,iAd!, >!*ea ??3A7?6. U/!n inf!*.ati!n

and (elief, Sa.s+n, Ele-t*!ni-s -!nd+-ts (+siness in t$e United States t$*!+,$ its 0$!ll) !0ned s+(sidia*ies, t$e *elevant !nes !f 0$i-$ a*e als! na.ed as defendants in t$is a-ti!n. ?. On inf!*.ati!n and (elief, Sa.s+n, Ele-t*!ni-s A.e*i-a, In-. is a Ne0 9!*:

-!*/!*ati!n 0it$ its /*in-i/al /la-e at ;4 C$allen,e* R!ad, Rid,efield Pa*:, Ne0 Be*se) <7@@<. SEA -an (e se*ved 0it$ /*!-ess t$*!+,$ its a,ent CT C!*/!*ati!n S)ste., 222 ;t$ Aven+e, Ne0 9!*:, Ne0 9!*: 2<<22. 4. On inf!*.ati!n and (elief, Sa.s+n, Tele-!..+ni-ati!ns A.e*i-a, LLC is a

Dela0a*e li.ited lia(ilit) -!./an) 0it$ its /*in-i/al /la-e at 23<2 E. L!!:!+t D*ive, Ri-$a*ds!n, Te#as 74<;6. STA -an (e se*ved 0it$ /*!-ess t$*!+,$ its a,ent C!*/!*ati!n Se*vi-e C!./an), 6722 Cente*ville R!ad, S+ite ?<<, Cil.in,t!n, Dela0a*e 2=;<;. Defendant STA is a 0$!ll) !0ned s+(sidia*) !f Defendant SEA. @. Defendants a*e in t$e (+siness !f .a:in,, +sin,, sellin,, !ffe*in, t! sell andD!*

i./!*tin, net0!*:Aena(led i.a,e -a/t+*in, devi-es and s)ste.s in-!*/!*atin, t$e sa.e. JURISDICTION AND VENUE 7. T$is C!+*t $as s+(Ee-t .atte* E+*isdi-ti!n !ve* t$is a-ti!n /+*s+ant t! 6;

U.S.C. 552332 and 233;%a (e-a+se t$e a-ti!n a*ises +nde* t$e /atent la0s !f t$e United States, 34 U.S.C. 55 2 et seF. ;. T$is C!+*t $as /e*s!nal E+*isdi-ti!n !ve* Defendants () vi*t+e !f t$ei*

s)ste.ati- and -!ntin+!+s -!nta-ts 0it$ t$is E+*isdi-ti!n, as 0ell as (e-a+se !f t$e inE+*) t! AITB and t$e -a+se !f a-ti!n AITB $as *aised, as alle,ed $e*ein. =. Defendants a*e s+(Ee-t t! t$is C!+*tGs s/e-ifi- and ,ene*al /e*s!nal E+*isdi-ti!n

/+*s+ant t! d+e /*!-ess andD!* t$e Dela0a*e L!n,AA*. Stat+te, d+e t! at least t$ei* s+(stantial (+siness in t$is f!*+., in-l+din,1 %i at least a /!*ti!n !f t$e inf*in,e.ent alle,ed $e*einH

and %ii *e,+la*l) d!in, !* s!li-itin, (+siness, en,a,in, in !t$e* /e*sistent -!+*ses !f -!nd+-t, andD!* de*ivin, s+(stantial *even+e f*!. ,!!ds and se*vi-es /*!vided t! individ+als in t$is Dist*i-t. 2<. Defendants $ave -!nd+-ted and d! -!nd+-t (+siness 0it$in t$is Dist*i-t,

di*e-tl) !* t$*!+,$ inte*.edia*ies, *eselle*s, a,ents, () !ffe*in, t! sell, sellin,, andD!* adve*tisin, %in-l+din, t$e +se !f inte*a-tive 0e( /a,es 0it$ /*!.!ti!nal .ate*ial /*!d+-ts in t$is Dist*i-t t$at inf*in,e t$e Asse*ted Patents. 22. In additi!n t! Defendants -!ntin+!+sl) and s)ste.ati-all) -!nd+-tin,

(+siness in t$is Dist*i-t, t$e -a+ses !f a-ti!n a,ainst Defendants a*e -!nne-ted %(+t n!t li.ited t! DefendantsG /+*/!sef+l a-ts -!..itted in t$is Dist*i-t, in-l+din, DefendantsG .a:in,, +sin,, i./!*tin,, !ffe*in, t! sell, !* sellin, /*!d+-ts 0$i-$ in-l+de feat+*es t$at fall 0it$in t$e s-!/e !f at least !ne -lai. !f t$e Asse*ted Patents. 26. Ien+e lies in t$is Dist*i-t +nde* 6; U.S.C. 5523=2 and 2?<<%( (e-a+se,

a.!n, !t$e* *eas!ns, Defendants a*e s+(Ee-t t! /e*s!nal E+*isdi-ti!n in t$is Dist*i-t, and $ave -!..itted and -!ntin+e t! -!..it a-ts !f /atent inf*in,e.ent in t$is Dist*i-t. J!* e#a./le, Defendants $ave +sed, s!ld, !ffe*ed t! sell, andD!* i./!*ted inf*in,in, /*!d+-ts in t$is Dist*i-t. JOINDER 23. Defendants a*e /*!/e*l) E!ined +nde* 34 U.S.C. 56==%a %2 (e-a+se a *i,$t t!

*elief is asse*ted a,ainst t$e /a*ties E!intl), seve*all), and in t$e alte*native 0it$ *es/e-t t! t$e sa.e t*ansa-ti!ns, !--+**en-es, !* se*ies !f t*ansa-ti!ns !* !--+**en-es *elatin, t! t$e .a:in,, +sin,, i./!*tin, int! t$e United States, !ffe*in, t! sell, andD!* sellin, t$e sa.e a--+sed /*!d+-ts. S/e-ifi-all), as alle,ed in detail (el!0, Defendants a*e alle,ed t! inf*in,e t$e

Asse*ted Patents 0it$ *es/e-t t! t$e sa.e /!*ta(le -!./+tin, devi-es in-l+din,, (+t n!t li.ited t!, t$e Sa.s+n, Gala#) N!te II .!(ile /$!ne. 2?. Defendants a*e /*!/e*l) E!ined +nde* 34 U.S.C. 56==%a %6 . K+esti!ns !f fa-t

0ill a*ise t$at a*e -!..!n t! (!t$ defendants, in-l+din, f!* e#a./le, 0$et$e* DefendantsG /*!d+-ts $ave feat+*es t$at .eet t$e feat+*es !f !ne !* .!*e -lai.s !f t$e Asse*ted Patents, and 0$at *eas!na(le *!)alt) 0ill (e adeF+ate t! -!./ensate t$e !0ne* !f t$e Asse*ted Patents f!* its inf*in,e.ent. 24. Defendants +se, .a:e, sell, !ffe* t! sell andD!* i./!*t /!*ta(le -!./+tin,

devi-es t$at, 0$en +sed, inf*in,e !n t$e Asse*ted Patents. 2@. At least !ne *i,$t t! *elief is asse*ted a,ainst t$ese /a*ties E!intl), seve*all),

!* in t$e alte*native 0it$ *es/e-t t! !* a*isin, !+t !f t$e sa.e t*ansa-ti!n, !--+**en-e, !* se*ies !f t*ansa-ti!ns !* !--+**en-es *elatin, t! t$e .a:in,, +sin,, i./!*tin, int! t$e United States, !ffe*in, t! sell, !* sellin, !f t$e sa.e a--+sed /*!d+-t andD!* /*!-ess. THE PATENTS-IN-SUIT 27. T$e*e a*e f!+* /atents at iss+e in t$is a-ti!n1 United States Patent N!s. 7,@33,46?

%t$e &G46? Patent' H 7,=<7,276 %t$e &G276 Patent' H ;,23?,@<< %t$e &G@<< Patent' H and ;,?77,2=7 %t$e &G2=7 Patent' %-!lle-tivel), t$e &Asse*ted Patents' . The 524 Patent 2;. On De-e.(e* 24, 6<<= t$e United States Patent and T*ade.a*: Offi-e

%&USPTO' d+l) and le,all) iss+ed t$e G46? Patent, entitled &Inte,*ated Inte*net Ca.e*a S)ste.' afte* a f+ll and fai* e#a.inati!n t! invent!*s J*an: Cle.ente and Ted Jease*. AITB is /*esentl) t$e !0ne* () assi,n.ent !f t$e G46? Patent, $avin, *e-eived all *i,$ts, title, and inte*est in and t! t$e G46? Patent. AITB /!ssesses all *i,$ts !f *e-!ve*) +nde* t$e G46? Patent,

in-l+din, t$e e#-l+sive *i,$t t! *e-!ve* f!* /ast inf*in,e.ent. A t*+e and -!**e-t -!/) !f t$e G46? Patent is atta-$ed t! t$is C!./laint as E#$i(it A. The 172 Patent 2=. On Ma*-$ 24, 6<22 t$e USPTO d+l) and le,all) iss+ed t$e G276 /atent, entitled

&Inte,*ated Inte*net Ca.e*a S)ste.' afte* a f+ll and fai* e#a.inati!n t! invent!*s J*an: Cle.ente and Ted Jease*. AITB is /*esentl) t$e !0ne* () assi,n.ent !f t$e G276 Patent, $avin, *e-eived all *i,$ts, title, and inte*est in and t! t$e G276 Patent. AITB /!ssesses all *i,$ts !f *e-!ve*) +nde* t$e G276 Patent, in-l+din, t$e e#-l+sive *i,$t t! *e-!ve* f!* /ast inf*in,e.ent. A t*+e and -!**e-t -!/) !f t$e G276 Patent is atta-$ed t! t$is C!./laint as E#$i(it B. The 600 Patent 6<. On Ma*-$ 23, 6<26 t$e USPTO d+l) and le,all) iss+ed t$e G@<< Patent, entitled

&Inte*net Di*e-t Devi-e' afte* a f+ll and fai* e#a.inati!n t! invent!*s J*an: Cle.ente and Ted Jease*. AITB is /*esentl) t$e !0ne* () assi,n.ent !f t$e G@<< Patent, $avin, *e-eived all *i,$ts, title, and inte*est in and t! t$e G@<< Patent. AITB /!ssesses all *i,$ts !f *e-!ve*) +nde* t$e G@<< Patent, in-l+din, t$e e#-l+sive *i,$t t! *e-!ve* f!* /ast inf*in,e.ent. A t*+e and -!**e-t -!/) !f t$e G@<< Patent is atta-$ed t! t$is C!./laint as E#$i(it C. The 197 Patent 62. On B+l) 6, 6<23 t$e USPTO d+l) and le,all) iss+ed t$e G2=7 /atent, entitled

&Inte*net Di*e-t Devi-e' afte* a f+ll and fai* e#a.inati!n t! invent!*s J*an: Cle.ente and Ted Jease*. AITB is /*esentl) t$e !0ne* () assi,n.ent !f t$e G2=7 Patent, $avin, *e-eived all *i,$ts, title, and inte*est in and t! t$e G2=7 Patent. AITB /!ssesses all *i,$ts !f *e-!ve*) +nde* t$e G2=7 Patent, in-l+din, t$e e#-l+sive *i,$t t! *e-!ve* f!* /ast inf*in,e.ent. A t*+e and -!**e-t -!/) !f t$e G2=7 Patent is atta-$ed t! t$is C!./laint as E#$i(it D.
4

DESCRIPTION OF THE ACCUSED PRODUCTS 66. DefendantsG net0!*:Aena(led i.a,eA-a/t+*in, devi-es %$e*einafte*, &I.a,eA

-a/t+*in, Devi-es' , in-l+din, (+t n!t li.ited t! t$e Sa.s+n, Gala#) N!te II, a*e -!nfi,+*ed t! ta:e still and vide! i.a,es and t*ans.it and *e-eive t$!se i.a,es t! and f*!. !t$e* I.a,eA -a/t+*in, Devi-es, as 0ell as a 0e(site a//li-ati!n, !n 0$i-$ still and vide! i.a,es -a/t+*ed () t$e I.a,eA-a/t+*in, Devi-es -an (e st!*ed and .ana,ed, +sin, a va*iet) !f -!nne-ti!ns, in-l+din, (+t n!t li.ited t! CiAJi and va*i!+s 3G and ?G -ell+la* net0!*:s. 63. J!* e#a./le, t$e Sa.s+n, Gala#) N!te II in-l+des (+iltAin a//li-ati!ns t$at

all!0 a +se* t! .a:e vide! -alls !ve* CiAJi !* -ell+la* t! an!t$e* Inte*net di*e-t devi-e, and all!0 still and vide! i.a,es -a/t+*ed () t$e devi-e t! (e +/l!aded t! an inte*netAa--essi(le a*-$ive t! (e st!*ed and .ana,ed. T$e Sa.s+n, Gala#) N!te II als! all!0s a +se* t! a--ess t$e Inte*net t$*!+,$ a va*iet) !f -!nne-ti!ns, in-l+din, (+t n!t li.ited t! CiAJi and va*i!+s 3G and ?G -ell+la* net0!*:s. A--!*din,l), t$e Sa.s+n, Gala#) N!te II is an Inte*net di*e-t devi-e 0it$ an i.a,in, s)ste. t! -a/t+*e still !* vide! i.a,es and is a -!./!nent !f an inte,*ated Inte*net -a.e*a s)ste.. COUNT I (INFRINGEMENT OF THE 524 PATENT) 6?. Plaintiff *ealle,es and in-!*/!*ates () *efe*en-e t$e alle,ati!ns set f!*t$ in

/a*a,*a/$s 2A63. 64. In vi!lati!n !f 34 U.S.C. 5 672, Sa.s+n, is n!0, and $as (een di*e-tl)

inf*in,in,, -!nt*i(+t!*il) inf*in,in,, andD!* ind+-in, inf*in,e.ent !f t$e G46? Patent. 6@. Defendants $ave $ad :n!0led,e !f inf*in,e.ent !f t$e G46? Patent at least as !f

t$e se*vi-e !f t$e /*esent -!./laint.

67.

Sa.s+n, $as di*e-tl) inf*in,ed and -!ntin+es t! di*e-tl) inf*in,e at least -lai.

27 !f t$e G46? Patent () .a:in,, +sin,, i./!*tin,, !ffe*in, t! sell, andD!* sellin, inte,*ated inte*net -a.e*a s)ste.s 0it$!+t a+t$!*it) in t$e United States, and 0ill -!ntin+e t! d! s! +nless enE!ined () t$is C!+*t. As a di*e-t and /*!#i.ate *es+lt !f Sa.s+n,Gs di*e-t inf*in,e.ent !f t$e G46? Patent, Plaintiff $as (een and -!ntin+es t! (e da.a,ed. 6;. Sa.s+n, $as indi*e-tl) inf*in,ed and -!ntin+es t! indi*e-tl) inf*in,e at least

-lai. 27 !f t$e G46? Patent () a-tivel) ind+-in, t$ei* *es/e-tive -+st!.e*s, +se*s, andD!* li-ensees t! di*e-tl) inf*in,e () +sin,, sellin,, !ffe*in, t! sell andD!* i./!*tin, an inte,*ated inte*net -a.e*a s)ste.. Sa.s+n, en,a,ed !* 0ill $ave en,a,ed in s+-$ ind+-e.ent $avin, :n!0led,e !f t$e G46? Patent. J+*t$e*.!*e, Sa.s+n, :ne0 !* s$!+ld $ave :n!0n t$at its a-ti!n 0!+ld ind+-e di*e-t inf*in,e.ent () !t$e*s and intended t$at its a-ti!ns 0!+ld ind+-e di*e-t inf*in,e.ent () !t$e*s. J!* e#a./le, Sa.s+n, sells, !ffe*s t! sell and adve*tises inte,*ated inte*net -a.e*a s)ste.s in Dela0a*e s/e-ifi-all) intendin, t$at its -+st!.e*s (+) and +se said /*!d+-ts. As a di*e-t and /*!#i.ate *es+lt !f Sa.s+n,Gs indi*e-t inf*in,e.ent () ind+-e.ent !f t$e G46? Patent, Plaintiff $as (een and -!ntin+es t! (e da.a,ed. 6=. Sa.s+n, $as -!nt*i(+t!*il) inf*in,ed and -!ntin+es t! -!nt*i(+t!*il) inf*in,e at

least -lai. 27 !f t$e G46? Patent () sellin, andD!* !ffe*in, t! sell an inte,*ated inte*net -a.e*a s)ste., 0$i-$ is a -!./!nent !f a /atented inventi!n and is n!t a sta/le a*ti-le !f -!..e*-eH 0it$ :n!0led,e !f t$e G46? Patent and :n!0led,e t$at t$is -!./!nent -!nstit+tes a .ate*ial /a*t !f t$e inventi!n -lai.ed in t$e G46? Patent. Sa.s+n, en,a,ed !* 0ill $ave en,a,ed in s+-$ -!nt*i(+t!*) inf*in,e.ent $avin, :n!0led,e !f t$e G46? Patent. As a di*e-t and /*!#i.ate *es+lt !f Sa.s+n,Gs -!nt*i(+t!*) inf*in,e.ent !f t$e G46? Patent, Plaintiff $as (een and -!ntin+es t! (e da.a,ed.

3<.

T! t$e e#tent t$at fa-ts lea*ned in dis-!ve*) s$!0 t$at DefendantsG inf*in,e.ent

!f t$e G46? Patent is !* $as (een 0illf+l, AITB *ese*ves t$e *i,$t t! *eF+est s+-$ a findin, at t$e ti.e !f t*ial. 32. As a *es+lt !f DefendantsG inf*in,e.ent !f t$e G46? Patent, AITB $as s+ffe*ed

.!neta*) da.a,es and is entitled t! a .!neta*) E+d,.ent in an a.!+nt adeF+ate t! -!./ensate f!* DefendantsG /ast inf*in,e.ent, t!,et$e* 0it$ inte*ests and -!sts. 36. AITB 0ill -!ntin+e t! s+ffe* da.a,es in t$e f+t+*e +nless DefendantsG inf*in,in,

a-tivities a*e enE!ined () t$is C!+*t. As s+-$, AITB is entitled t! -!./ensati!n f!* an) -!ntin+in, !* f+t+*e inf*in,e.ent +/ +ntil t$e date t$at Defendants a*e finall) and /e*.anentl) enE!ined f*!. f+*t$e* inf*in,e.ent. COUNT II (INFRINGEMENT OF THE 1 2 PATENT) 33. Plaintiff *ealle,es and in-!*/!*ates () *efe*en-e t$e alle,ati!ns set f!*t$ in

/a*a,*a/$s 2A36. 3?. In vi!lati!n !f 34 U.S.C. 5 672, Sa.s+n, is n!0, and $as (een di*e-tl)

inf*in,in,, -!nt*i(+t!*il) inf*in,in,, andD!* ind+-in, inf*in,e.ent !f t$e G276 Patent. 34. Defendants $ave $ad :n!0led,e !f inf*in,e.ent !f t$e L276 Patent at least as !f

t$e se*vi-e !f t$e /*esent -!./laint. 3@. Sa.s+n, $as di*e-tl) inf*in,ed and -!ntin+es t! di*e-tl) inf*in,e at least -lai. 2

!f t$e G276 Patent () .a:in,, +sin,, i./!*tin,, !ffe*in, t! sell, andD!* sellin, inte,*ated inte*net -a.e*a s)ste.s 0it$!+t a+t$!*it) in t$e United States, and 0ill -!ntin+e t! d! s! +nless enE!ined () t$is C!+*t. As a di*e-t and /*!#i.ate *es+lt !f Sa.s+n,Gs di*e-t inf*in,e.ent !f t$e G276 Patent, Plaintiff $as (een and -!ntin+es t! (e da.a,ed.

37.

Sa.s+n, $as indi*e-tl) inf*in,ed and -!ntin+es t! indi*e-tl) inf*in,e at least

-lai. 2 !f t$e G276 Patent () a-tivel) ind+-in, t$ei* *es/e-tive -+st!.e*s, +se*s, andD!* li-ensees t! di*e-tl) inf*in,e () +sin,, sellin,, !ffe*in, t! sell andD!* i./!*tin, an inte,*ated inte*net -a.e*a s)ste.. Sa.s+n, en,a,ed !* 0ill $ave en,a,ed in s+-$ ind+-e.ent $avin, :n!0led,e !f t$e G276 Patent. J+*t$e*.!*e, Sa.s+n, :ne0 !* s$!+ld $ave :n!0n t$at its a-ti!n 0!+ld ind+-e di*e-t inf*in,e.ent () !t$e*s and intended t$at its a-ti!ns 0!+ld ind+-e di*e-t inf*in,e.ent () !t$e*s. J!* e#a./le, Sa.s+n, sells, !ffe*s t! sell and adve*tises inte,*ated inte*net -a.e*a s)ste.s in Dela0a*e s/e-ifi-all) intendin, t$at its -+st!.e*s (+) and +se said /*!d+-ts. As a di*e-t and /*!#i.ate *es+lt !f Sa.s+n,Gs indi*e-t inf*in,e.ent () ind+-e.ent !f t$e G276 Patent, Plaintiff $as (een and -!ntin+es t! (e da.a,ed. 3;. Sa.s+n, $as -!nt*i(+t!*il) inf*in,ed and -!ntin+es t! -!nt*i(+t!*il) inf*in,e at

least -lai. 27 !f t$e G276 Patent () sellin, andD!* !ffe*in, t! sell an inte,*ated inte*net -a.e*a s)ste., 0$i-$ is a -!./!nent !f a /atented inventi!n and is n!t a sta/le a*ti-le !f -!..e*-eH 0it$ :n!0led,e !f t$e G276 Patent and :n!0led,e t$at t$is -!./!nent -!nstit+tes a .ate*ial /a*t !f t$e inventi!n -lai.ed in t$e G276 Patent. Sa.s+n, en,a,ed !* 0ill $ave en,a,ed in s+-$ -!nt*i(+t!*) inf*in,e.ent $avin, :n!0led,e !f t$e G276 Patent. As a di*e-t and /*!#i.ate *es+lt !f Sa.s+n,Gs -!nt*i(+t!*) inf*in,e.ent !f t$e G276 Patent, Plaintiff $as (een and -!ntin+es t! (e da.a,ed. 3=. T! t$e e#tent t$at fa-ts lea*ned in dis-!ve*) s$!0 t$at DefendantsG inf*in,e.ent

!f t$e G276 Patent is !* $as (een 0illf+l, AITB *ese*ves t$e *i,$t t! *eF+est s+-$ a findin, at t$e ti.e !f t*ial.

?<.

As a *es+lt !f DefendantsG inf*in,e.ent !f t$e G276 Patent, AITB $as s+ffe*ed

.!neta*) da.a,es and is entitled t! a .!neta*) E+d,.ent in an a.!+nt adeF+ate t! -!./ensate f!* DefendantsG /ast inf*in,e.ent, t!,et$e* 0it$ inte*ests and -!sts. ?2. AITB 0ill -!ntin+e t! s+ffe* da.a,es in t$e f+t+*e +nless DefendantsG inf*in,in,

a-tivities a*e enE!ined () t$is C!+*t. As s+-$, AITB is entitled t! -!./ensati!n f!* an) -!ntin+in, !* f+t+*e inf*in,e.ent +/ +ntil t$e date t$at Defendants a*e finall) and /e*.anentl) enE!ined f*!. f+*t$e* inf*in,e.ent. COUNT III (INFRINGEMENT OF THE !"" PATENT) ?6. Plaintiff *ealle,es and in-!*/!*ates () *efe*en-e t$e alle,ati!ns set f!*t$ in

/a*a,*a/$s 2A?2. ?3. In vi!lati!n !f 34 U.S.C. 5 672, Sa.s+n, is n!0, and $as (een di*e-tl) inf*in,in,

andD!* ind+-in, inf*in,e.ent !f t$e G@<< Patent. ??. Defendants $ave $ad :n!0led,e !f inf*in,e.ent !f t$e G@<< Patent at least as !f

t$e se*vi-e !f t$e /*esent -!./laint. ?4. Sa.s+n, $as di*e-tl) inf*in,ed and -!ntin+es t! di*e-tl) inf*in,e at least -lai. 2

!f t$e G@<< Patent () .a:in,, +sin,, i./!*tin,, !ffe*in, t! sell, andD!* sellin, I.a,eA-a/t+*in, Devi-es 0it$!+t a+t$!*it) in t$e United States, and 0ill -!ntin+e t! d! s! +nless enE!ined () t$is C!+*t. As a di*e-t and /*!#i.ate *es+lt !f Sa.s+n,Gs di*e-t inf*in,e.ent !f t$e G@<< Patent, Plaintiff $as (een and -!ntin+es t! (e da.a,ed. ?@. Sa.s+n, $as indi*e-tl) inf*in,ed and -!ntin+es t! indi*e-tl) inf*in,e at least

-lai. 2 !f t$e G@<< Patent () a-tivel) ind+-in, t$ei* *es/e-tive -+st!.e*s, +se*s, andD!* li-ensees t! di*e-tl) inf*in,e () +sin,, sellin,, !ffe*in, t! sell andD!* I.a,eA-a/t+*in, Devi-es. Sa.s+n, en,a,ed !* 0ill $ave en,a,ed in s+-$ ind+-e.ent $avin, :n!0led,e !f t$e G@<<
2<

Patent. J+*t$e*.!*e, Sa.s+n, :ne0 !* s$!+ld $ave :n!0n t$at its a-ti!n 0!+ld ind+-e di*e-t inf*in,e.ent () !t$e*s and intended t$at its a-ti!ns 0!+ld ind+-e di*e-t inf*in,e.ent () !t$e*s. J!* e#a./le, Sa.s+n, sells, !ffe*s t! sell and adve*tises I.a,eA-a/t+*in, Devi-es in Dela0a*e s/e-ifi-all) intendin, t$at its -+st!.e*s (+) and +se said /*!d+-ts. As a di*e-t and /*!#i.ate *es+lt !f Sa.s+n,Gs indi*e-t inf*in,e.ent () ind+-e.ent !f t$e G@<< Patent, Plaintiff $as (een and -!ntin+es t! (e da.a,ed. ?7. T! t$e e#tent t$at fa-ts lea*ned in dis-!ve*) s$!0 t$at DefendantsG inf*in,e.ent

!f t$e G@<< Patent is !* $as (een 0illf+l, AITB *ese*ves t$e *i,$t t! *eF+est s+-$ a findin, at t$e ti.e !f t*ial. ?;. As a *es+lt !f DefendantsG inf*in,e.ent !f t$e G@<< Patent, AITB $as s+ffe*ed

.!neta*) da.a,es and is entitled t! a .!neta*) E+d,.ent in an a.!+nt adeF+ate t! -!./ensate f!* DefendantsG /ast inf*in,e.ent, t!,et$e* 0it$ inte*ests and -!sts. ?=. AITB 0ill -!ntin+e t! s+ffe* da.a,es in t$e f+t+*e +nless DefendantsG inf*in,in,

a-tivities a*e enE!ined () t$is C!+*t. As s+-$, AITB is entitled t! -!./ensati!n f!* an) -!ntin+in, !* f+t+*e inf*in,e.ent +/ +ntil t$e date t$at Defendants a*e finall) and /e*.anentl) enE!ined f*!. f+*t$e* inf*in,e.ent. COUNT IV (INFRINGEMENT OF THE 1# PATENT) 4<. Plaintiff *ealle,es and in-!*/!*ates () *efe*en-e t$e alle,ati!ns set f!*t$ in

/a*a,*a/$s 2A?=. 42. In vi!lati!n !f 34 U.S.C. 5 672, Sa.s+n, is n!0, and $as (een di*e-tl) inf*in,in,

andD!* ind+-in, inf*in,e.ent !f t$e G2=7 Patent. 46. Defendants $ave $ad :n!0led,e !f inf*in,e.ent !f t$e G2=7 Patent at least as !f

t$e se*vi-e !f t$e /*esent -!./laint.

22

43.

Sa.s+n, $as di*e-tl) inf*in,ed and -!ntin+es t! di*e-tl) inf*in,e at least -lai. 2

!f t$e G2=7 Patent () .a:in,, +sin,, i./!*tin,, !ffe*in, t! sell, andD!* sellin, I.a,eA-a/t+*in, Devi-es 0it$!+t a+t$!*it) in t$e United States, and 0ill -!ntin+e t! d! s! +nless enE!ined () t$is C!+*t. As a di*e-t and /*!#i.ate *es+lt !f Sa.s+n,Gs di*e-t inf*in,e.ent !f t$e G2=7 Patent, Plaintiff $as (een and -!ntin+es t! (e da.a,ed. 4?. Sa.s+n, $as indi*e-tl) inf*in,ed and -!ntin+es t! indi*e-tl) inf*in,e at least

-lai. 2 !f t$e G2=7 Patent () a-tivel) ind+-in, t$ei* *es/e-tive -+st!.e*s, +se*s, andD!* li-ensees t! di*e-tl) inf*in,e () +sin,, sellin,, !ffe*in, t! sell andD!* i./!*tin, I.a,eA-a/t+*in, Devi-es. Sa.s+n, en,a,ed !* 0ill $ave en,a,ed in s+-$ ind+-e.ent $avin, :n!0led,e !f t$e G2=7 Patent. J+*t$e*.!*e, Sa.s+n, :ne0 !* s$!+ld $ave :n!0n t$at its a-ti!n 0!+ld ind+-e di*e-t inf*in,e.ent () !t$e*s and intended t$at its a-ti!ns 0!+ld ind+-e di*e-t inf*in,e.ent () !t$e*s. J!* e#a./le, Sa.s+n, sells, !ffe*s t! sell and adve*tises inte,*ated I.a,eA-a/t+*in, Devi-es in Dela0a*e s/e-ifi-all) intendin, t$at its -+st!.e*s (+) and +se said /*!d+-ts. As a di*e-t and /*!#i.ate *es+lt !f Sa.s+n,Gs indi*e-t inf*in,e.ent () ind+-e.ent !f t$e G2=7 Patent, Plaintiff $as (een and -!ntin+es t! (e da.a,ed. 44. T! t$e e#tent t$at fa-ts lea*ned in dis-!ve*) s$!0 t$at DefendantsG inf*in,e.ent

!f t$e G2=7 Patent is !* $as (een 0illf+l, AITB *ese*ves t$e *i,$t t! *eF+est s+-$ a findin, at t$e ti.e !f t*ial. 4@. As a *es+lt !f DefendantsG inf*in,e.ent !f t$e G2=7 Patent, AITB $as s+ffe*ed

.!neta*) da.a,es and is entitled t! a .!neta*) E+d,.ent in an a.!+nt adeF+ate t! -!./ensate f!* DefendantsG /ast inf*in,e.ent, t!,et$e* 0it$ inte*ests and -!sts. 47. AITB 0ill -!ntin+e t! s+ffe* da.a,es in t$e f+t+*e +nless DefendantsG inf*in,in,

a-tivities a*e enE!ined () t$is C!+*t. As s+-$, AITB is entitled t! -!./ensati!n f!* an)

26

-!ntin+in, !* f+t+*e inf*in,e.ent +/ +ntil t$e date t$at Defendants a*e finall) and /e*.anentl) enE!ined f*!. f+*t$e* inf*in,e.ent. DEMAND FOR JURY TRIAL 4;. a-ti!n. PRAYER FOR RELIEF CHEREJORE, AITB /*a)s f!* t$e f!ll!0in, *elief1 A. T$at Defendants (e adE+d,ed t! $ave inf*in,ed t$e Asse*ted Patents, di*e-tl) AITB de.ands a t*ial () E+*) as t! all iss+es t$at a*e t*ia(le () a E+*) in t$is

andD!* indi*e-tl), () 0a) !f ind+-e.ent andD!* -!nt*i(+t!*) inf*in,e.ent, lite*all) andD!* +nde* t$e d!-t*ine !f eF+ivalentsH B. T$at Defendants, t$ei* !ffi-e*s, di*e-t!*s, a,ents, se*vants, e./l!)ees, att!*ne)s,

affiliates, divisi!ns, (*an-$es, /a*ents, and t$!se /e*s!ns in a-tive -!n-e*t !* /a*ti-i/ati!n 0it$ an) !f t$e., (e /e*.anentl) enE!ined f*!. inf*in,in, t$e Asse*ted PatentsH C. An a0a*d !f da.a,es /+*s+ant t! 34 U.S.C. 56;? s+ffi-ient t! -!./ensate AITB

f!* t$e DefendantsG /ast inf*in,e.ent and an) -!ntin+in, !* f+t+*e inf*in,e.ent +/ +ntil t$e date t$at Defendants a*e finall) and /e*.anentl) enE!ined f*!. f+*t$e* inf*in,e.ent, in-l+din, -!./ensat!*) da.a,esH D. An assess.ent !f /*eAE+d,.ent and /!stAE+d,.ent inte*est and -!sts a,ainst

Defendants, t!,et$e* 0it$ an a0a*d !f s+-$ inte*est and -!sts, in a--!*dan-e 0it$ 34 U.S.C. 56;?H E. T$at Defendants (e di*e-ted t! /a) en$an-ed da.a,es, in-l+din, AITBGs

att!*ne)sG fees in-+**ed in -!nne-ti!n 0it$ t$is la0s+it /+*s+ant t! 34 U.S.C. 56;4H and

23

J. /*!/e*.

T$at AITB $ave s+-$ !t$e* and f+*t$e* *elief as t$is C!+*t .a) dee. E+st and

O-t!(e* 3<, 6<23

BA9ARD, P.A. /s/ Stephen B. Brauerman Ri-$a*d D. >i*: %*:<=66 Ste/$en B. B*a+e*.an %s(?=46 Ianessa R. Ti*adentes %vt43=; Sa*a E. B+ssie*e %s(4764 666 Dela0a*e Aven+e, S+ite =<< P.O. B!# 6423< Cil.in,t!n, DE 2=;== *:i*:M(a)a*dla0.-!. s(*a+e*.anM(a)a*dla0.-!. vti*adentesM(a)a*dla0.-!. s(+ssie*eM(a)a*dla0.-!. %3<6 @44A4<<< Attorneys for Plaintiff Alex is the Best, LLC

2?