Verification Control

SAP2000 Steel Frame Design Verification Examples

Filename:

Verif manual version:

16.0.0

Solver:

Path to SAP2000.exe:

C:\Program Files (x86)\Computers and Structures\SAP2000 16\Sap2000.exe

Delete Files: Yes

Path to data files:

C:\Temp\Verification\Design Examples\Steel Frame

32 Bit:

Default

Process:

Default

Last checked:

Code Region
American
American
American
American
American
American
American
American
American
American
American
American
American
American
American
American
Australian
Australian
Australian
British
British
British
British
Canadian
Canadian
Canadian
Canadian
Canadian
Canadian
Eurocode
Eurocode
Eurocode
Eurocode
Eurocode
Eurocode
Indian
Indian
Indian
Italian
Italian
New Zealand
New Zealand
New Zealand
Norwegian
Norwegian
Norwegian

Code & Example Number

AISC 360-05 Ex001
AISC 360-05 Ex002
AISC 360-10 Ex001
AISC 360-10 Ex002
AISC ASD-01 Ex001
AISC ASD-01 Ex002
AISC ASD-89 Ex001
AISC ASD-89 Ex002
AISC LRFD-93 Ex001
AISC LRFD-93 Ex002
AISC LRFD-99 Ex001
AISC LRFD-99 Ex002
UBC ASD-97 Ex001
UBC ASD-97 Ex002
UBC LRFD-97 Ex001
UBC LRFD-97 Ex002
AS 4100-1998 Ex001
AS 4100-1998 Ex002
AS 4100-1998 Ex003
BS 5950-1990 Ex001
BS 5950-1990 Ex002
BS 5950-2000 Ex001
BS 5950-2000 Ex002
CISC 95 Ex001
CISC 95 Ex002
CSA S16-01 Ex001
CSA S16-01 Ex002
CSA S16-09 Ex001
CSA S16-09 Ex002
EN 3-1993 Ex001
EN 3-1993 Ex002
EN 3-1993 Ex003
EN 3-2005 Ex001
EN 3-2005 Ex002
EN 3-2005 Ex003
IS 800-2007 Ex001
IS 800-2007 Ex002
IS 800-2007 Ex003
NTC 2008 Ex001
NTC 2008 Ex002
NZS 3404-1997 Ex001
NZS 3404-1997 Ex002
NZS 3404-1997 Ex003
NORSOK N-004-2004 Ex001
NORSOK N-004-2004 Ex002
NORSOK N-004-2004 Ex003

Example Title
Wide Flange Member Under Bending
Built Up Wide Flange Member Under Compression
Wide Flange Member Under Bending
Built Up Wide Flange Member Under Compression
Wide Flange Member Under Bending
Wide Flange Member Under Compression
Wide Flange Member Under Bending
Wide Flange Member Under Compression
Wide Flange Member Under Bending
Wide Flange Member Under Combined Compression & Biaxial Bending
Wide Flange Member Under Bending
Wide Flange Member Under Combined Compression & Biaxial Bending
Wide Flange Member Under Bending
Wide Flange Member Under Compression
Wide Flange Member Under Bending
Wide Flange Member Under Combined Compression & Biaxial Bending
Wide Flange Member Under Compression
Wide Flange Member Under Bending
Wide Flange Member Under Combined Compression & Bending
Wide Flange Section Under Bending
Square Tube Member Under Compression & Bending
Wide Flange Section Under Bending
Square Tube Member Under Compression & Bending
Wide Flange Member Under Bending
Wide Flange Member Under Compression & Bending
Wide Flange Member Under Bending
Wide Flange Member Under Compression & Bending
Wide Flange Member Under Bending
Wide Flange Member Under Compression & Bending
Wide Flange Member Under Combined Compression & Bending with Shear Limit State
Wide Flange Member Under Combined Compression & Bending with Flexural Buckling Limit State
Wide Flange Member Under Combined Compression & Bending with LTB Limit State
Wide Flange Member Under Combined Compression & Bending
Wide Flange Section Under Bending
Wide Flange Section Under Combined Compression & Bending
Wide Flange Member Under Compression
Wide Flange Member Under Bending
Wide Flange Member Under Combined Compression & Biaxial Bending
Wide Flange Section Under Combined Compression & Bending
Wide Flange Member Under Combined Compression & Bending
Wide Flange Member Under Compression
Wide Flange Member Under Bending
Wide Flange Member Under Combined Compression & Bending
Round Tube Member Under Compression
Round Tube Member Under Bending
Round Tube Member Under Combined Compression & Bending

Run This
Example
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes

#VALUE!

User Switches (Overrides Cells E2 thru E5):

Default

Check This Example

Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes

Page 1 of 145

(Applies to analysis files only, not input or output files)

Max % Diff From

Version 16.0.0
Not Checked
Not Checked
Not Checked
Not Checked
Not Checked
Not Checked
Not Checked
Not Checked
Not Checked
Not Checked
Not Checked
Not Checked
Not Checked
Not Checked
Not Checked
Not Checked
Not Checked
Not Checked
Not Checked
Not Checked
Not Checked
Not Checked
Not Checked
Not Checked
Not Checked
Not Checked
Not Checked
Not Checked
Not Checked
Not Checked
Not Checked
Not Checked
Not Checked
Not Checked
Not Checked
Not Checked
Not Checked
Not Checked
Not Checked
Not Checked
Not Checked
Not Checked
Not Checked
Not Checked
Not Checked
Not Checked

Version

Level

Time Checked

Applies to
Ultimate
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes

Applies to
Advanced
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes

Applies
to Plus
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes

Applies
to Basic
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes

Comments

C:\Verification\v14.0.0_I\go32_oop_adv_xls\Example 5-008c.sdb
Analysis successful with 0 warnings (4/19/2009 10:07:54 PM)
Data exported to Example 5-008c.mdb
C:\Verification\v14.0.0_I\go32_oop_adv_xls\Example 5-008d.sdb
Analysis successful with 0 warnings (4/19/2009 10:08:03 PM)
Data exported to Example 5-008d.mdb
C:\Verification\v14.0.0_I\go32_oop_adv_xls\Example 5-008e.sdb
Analysis successful with 0 warnings (4/19/2009 10:08:13 PM)
Data exported to Example 5-008e.mdb
C:\Verification\v14.0.0_I\go32_oop_adv_xls\Example 5-008f.sdb
Analysis successful with 0 warnings (4/19/2009 10:08:25 PM)
Data exported to Example 5-008f.mdb
C:\Verification\v14.0.0_I\go32_oop_adv_xls\Example 5-009a.sdb
Analysis successful with 0 warnings (4/19/2009 10:08:42 PM)
Data exported to Example 5-009a.mdb
C:\Verification\v14.0.0_I\go32_oop_adv_xls\Example 5-009b.sdb
Analysis successful with 0 warnings (4/19/2009 10:08:52 PM)
Data exported to Example 5-009b.mdb
C:\Verification\v14.0.0_I\go32_oop_adv_xls\Example 5-010.sdb
Analysis successful with 0 warnings (4/19/2009 10:09:04 PM)
Data exported to Example 5-010.mdb
C:\Verification\v14.0.0_I\go32_oop_adv_xls\Example 5-011.sdb
Analysis successful with 0 warnings (4/19/2009 10:09:16 PM)
Data exported to Example 5-011.mdb
C:\Verification\v14.0.0_I\go32_oop_adv_xls\Example 5-012a.sdb
Analysis successful with 0 warnings (4/19/2009 10:10:19 PM)
Data exported to Example 5-012a.mdb
C:\Verification\v14.0.0_I\go32_oop_adv_xls\Example 5-012b.sdb
Analysis successful with 0 warnings (4/19/2009 10:13:47 PM)
Data exported to Example 5-012b.mdb
C:\Verification\v14.0.0_I\go32_oop_adv_xls\Example 5-012c.sdb
Analysis successful with 0 warnings (4/19/2009 10:14:46 PM)
Data exported to Example 5-012c.mdb
C:\Verification\v14.0.0_I\go32_oop_adv_xls\Example 5-012d.sdb
Analysis successful with 0 warnings (4/19/2009 10:18:09 PM)
Data exported to Example 5-012d.mdb
C:\Verification\v14.0.0_I\go32_oop_adv_xls\Example 5-013.sdb
Analysis successful with 0 warnings (4/19/2009 10:18:36 PM)

Data exported to Example 5-013.mdb

C:\Verification\v14.0.0_I\go32_oop_adv_xls\Example 6-001.sdb
Analysis successful with 0 warnings (4/19/2009 10:21:28 PM)
Data exported to Example 6-001.mdb
C:\Verification\v14.0.0_I\go32_oop_adv_xls\Example 6-002.sdb
Analysis successful with 0 warnings (4/19/2009 10:21:41 PM)
Data exported to Example 6-002.mdb
C:\Verification\v14.0.0_I\go32_oop_adv_xls\Example 6-003a.sdb
Analysis successful with 0 warnings (4/19/2009 10:25:18 PM)
Data exported to Example 6-003a.mdb
C:\Verification\v14.0.0_I\go32_oop_adv_xls\Example 6-003b.sdb
Analysis successful with 0 warnings (4/19/2009 10:28:41 PM)
Data exported to Example 6-003b.mdb
C:\Verification\v14.0.0_I\go32_oop_adv_xls\Example 6-004.sdb
Analysis successful with 0 warnings (4/19/2009 10:28:51 PM)
Data exported to Example 6-004.mdb
C:\Verification\v14.0.0_I\go32_oop_adv_xls\Example 6-005a.sdb
Analysis successful with 0 warnings (4/19/2009 10:41:38 PM)
Data exported to Example 6-005a.mdb
C:\Verification\v14.0.0_I\go32_oop_adv_xls\Example 6-005b.sdb
Analysis successful with 0 warnings (4/19/2009 10:41:48 PM)
Data exported to Example 6-005b.mdb
C:\Verification\v14.0.0_I\go32_oop_adv_xls\Example 6-006.sdb
Analysis successful with 0 warnings (4/19/2009 10:55:46 PM)
Data exported to Example 6-006.mdb
C:\Verification\v14.0.0_I\go32_oop_adv_xls\Example 6-007.sdb
Analysis successful with 0 warnings (4/19/2009 11:14:16 PM)
Data exported to Example 6-007.mdb
C:\Verification\v14.0.0_I\go32_oop_adv_xls\Example 6-008.sdb
Analysis successful with 0 warnings (4/19/2009 11:16:45 PM)
Data exported to Example 6-008.mdb
C:\Verification\v14.0.0_I\go32_oop_adv_xls\Example 6-009.sdb
Analysis successful with 0 warnings (4/19/2009 11:17:23 PM)
Data exported to Example 6-009.mdb
C:\Verification\v14.0.0_I\go32_oop_adv_xls\Example 6-010.sdb
Analysis successful with 0 warnings (4/19/2009 11:21:18 PM)
Data exported to Example 6-010.mdb

C:\Verification\v14.0.0_I\go32_oop_adv_xls\Example 6-011a.sdb
Analysis successful with 0 warnings (4/20/2009 12:27:24 AM)
Data exported to Example 6-011a.mdb
C:\Verification\v14.0.0_I\go32_oop_adv_xls\Example 6-011b.sdb
Analysis successful with 0 warnings (4/20/2009 1:42:42 AM)
Data exported to Example 6-011b.mdb
C:\Verification\v14.0.0_I\go32_oop_adv_xls\Example 6-012.sdb
Analysis successful with 0 warnings (4/20/2009 1:43:05 AM)
Data exported to Example 6-012.mdb
C:\Verification\v14.0.0_I\go32_oop_adv_xls\Example 7-001.sdb
Analysis successful with 0 warnings (4/20/2009 1:43:14 AM)
Data exported to Example 7-001.mdb
C:\Verification\v14.0.0_I\go32_oop_adv_xls\Example 7-002.sdb
Analysis successful with 0 warnings (4/20/2009 1:43:24 AM)
Data exported to Example 7-002.mdb
C:\Verification\v14.0.0_I\go32_oop_adv_xls\Example 7-003.sdb
Analysis successful with 0 warnings (4/20/2009 1:43:50 AM)
Data exported to Example 7-003.mdb

Problem Number
AISC 360-05 Ex001
AISC 360-05 Ex002
AISC 360-10 Ex001
AISC 360-10 Ex002
AISC ASD-01 Ex001
AISC ASD-01 Ex002
AISC ASD-89 Ex001
AISC ASD-89 Ex002
AISC LRFD-93 Ex001
AISC LRFD-93 Ex002
AISC LRFD-99 Ex001
AISC LRFD-99 Ex002
UBC ASD-97 Ex001
UBC ASD-97 Ex002
UBC LRFD-97 Ex001
UBC LRFD-97 Ex002
AS 4100-1998 Ex001
AS 4100-1998 Ex002
AS 4100-1998 Ex003
BS 5950-1990 Ex001
BS 5950-1990 Ex002
BS 5950-2000 Ex001
BS 5950-2000 Ex002
CISC 95 Ex001
CISC 95 Ex002
CSA S16-01 Ex001
CSA S16-01 Ex002
CSA S16-09 Ex001
CSA S16-09 Ex002
EN 3-1993 Ex001
EN 3-1993 Ex002
EN 3-1993 Ex003
EN 3-2005 Ex001
EN 3-2005 Ex002
EN 3-2005 Ex003
IS 800-2007 Ex001
IS 800-2007 Ex002
IS 800-2007 Ex003
NTC 2008 Ex001
NTC 2008 Ex002
NZS 3404-1997 Ex001
NZS 3404-1997 Ex002
NZS 3404-1997 Ex003
NORSOK N-004-2004 Ex001
NORSOK N-004-2004 Ex002
NORSOK N-004-2004 Ex003

Access Database File

AISC 360-05 Ex001.mdb
AISC 360-05 Ex002.mdb
AISC 360-10 Ex001.mdb
AISC 360-10 Ex002.mdb
AISC ASD-01 Ex001.mdb
AISC ASD-01 Ex002.mdb
AISC ASD-89 Ex001.mdb
AISC ASD-89 Ex002.mdb
AISC LRFD-93 Ex001.mdb
AISC LRFD-93 Ex002.mdb
AISC LRFD-99 Ex001.mdb
AISC LRFD-99 Ex002.mdb
UBC ASD-97 Ex001.mdb
UBC ASD-97 Ex002.mdb
UBC LRFD-97 Ex001.mdb
UBC LRFD-97 Ex002.mdb
AS 4100-1998 Ex001.mdb
AS 4100-1998 Ex002.mdb
AS 4100-1998 Ex003.mdb
BS 5950-1990 Ex001.mdb
BS 5950-1990 Ex002.mdb
BS 5950-2000 Ex001.mdb
BS 5950-2000 Ex002.mdb
CISC 95 Ex001.mdb
CISC 95 Ex002.mdb
CSA S16-01 Ex001.mdb
CSA S16-01 Ex002.mdb
CSA S16-09 Ex001.mdb
CSA S16-09 Ex002.mdb
EN 3-1993 Ex001.mdb
EN 3-1993 Ex002.mdb
EN 3-1993 Ex003.mdb
EN 3-2005 Ex001.mdb
EN 3-2005 Ex002.mdb
EN 3-2005 Ex003.mdb
IS 800-2007 Ex001.mdb
IS 800-2007 Ex002.mdb
IS 800-2007 Ex003.mdb
NTC 2008 Ex001.mdb
NTC 2008 Ex002.mdb
NZS 3404-1997 Ex001.mdb
NZS 3404-1997 Ex002.mdb
NZS 3404-1997 Ex003.mdb
NORSOK N-004-2004 Ex001.mdb
NORSOK N-004-2004 Ex002.mdb
NORSOK N-004-2004 Ex003.mdb

Example AISC 360-05 Ex001

American
Wide Flange Member Under Bending
Results Published in the Current Verification Examples
Case
Lb = 5 ft
Lb = 11.67 ft
Lb = 35 ft

Output
Parameter
Compactness
Cb

bMn (k-ft)
Cb

bMn (k-ft)
Cb

bMn (k-ft)

SAP2000
Independent
Compact
Compact

Percent
Difference
0.00%

1.004

1.002

0.20%

378.750

378.750

0.00%

1.015

1.014

0.10%

307.124

306.657

0.15%

1.138

1.136

0.18%

94.377

94.218

0.17%

Results From Current Analyses

SAP2000 Result

Number of Decimal
Places
-

Result for
Comparison
0.0

% Diff From
Version 16.0.0
Not Checked

0.000

Not Checked

0.000

Not Checked

0.000

Not Checked

0.000

Not Checked

0.000

Not Checked

0.000

Not Checked

#VALUE!

Example AISC 360-05 Ex002

American
Built Up Wide Flange Member Under Compression
Results Published in the Current Verification Examples
Output
Parameter
Compactness

cPn (kip)

Percent
SAP2000
Independent
Difference
Slender
Slender
0.00%
506.1

506.1

0.00%

Results From Current Analyses

SAP2000 Result

Number of Decimal
Places
-

Result for
Comparison
0.0

% Diff From
Version 16.0.0
Not Checked

0.0

Not Checked

#VALUE!

Example AISC 360-10 Ex001

American
Wide Flange Member Under Bending
Results Published in the Current Verification Examples
Case
Lb = 5 ft
Lb = 11.67 ft
Lb = 35 ft

Output
Parameter
Compactness
Cb

bMn (k-ft)
Cb

bMn (k-ft)
Cb

bMn (k-ft)

SAP2000
Independent
Compact
Compact

Percent
Difference
0.00%

1.004

1.002

0.20%

378.750

378.750

0.00%

1.015

1.014

0.10%

307.124

306.657

0.15%

1.138

1.136

0.18%

94.377

94.218

0.17%

Results From Current Analyses

SAP2000 Result

Number of Decimal
Places
-

Result for
Comparison
0.0

% Diff From
Version 16.0.0
Not Checked

0.000

Not Checked

0.000

Not Checked

0.000

Not Checked

0.000

Not Checked

0.000

Not Checked

0.000

Not Checked

#VALUE!

Example AISC 360-10 Ex002

American
Built Up Wide Flange Member Under Compression
Results Published in the Current Verification Examples
Output
Parameter
Compactness

cPn (kip)

Percent
SAP2000
Independent
Difference
Slender
Slender
0.00%
506.1

506.1

0.00%

Results From Current Analyses

SAP2000 Result

Number of Decimal
Places
-

Result for
Comparison
0.0

% Diff From
Version 16.0.0
Not Checked

0.0

Not Checked

#VALUE!

Example AISC ASD-01 Ex001

American
Wide Flange Member Under Bending
Results Published in the Current Verification Examples
Output
Parameter
Compactness
Fb (ksi)

fb (ksi)

SAP2000

Percent
Independent Difference

Non-Compact Non-Compact

0.00%

32.70

32.70

0.00%

30.74

30.74

0.00%

n Examples

Results From Current Analyses

SAP2000 Result

Number of Decimal
Places

Result for
Comparison

% Diff From
Version 16.0.0

0.0

Not Checked

0.00

Not Checked

0.00

Not Checked

#VALUE!

Example AISC ASD-01 Ex002

American
Wide Flange Member Under Compression
Results Published in the Current Verification Examples
Output
Parameter
Compactness
Fa (ksi)

fa (ksi)

SAP2000

Independent

Percent
Difference

Compact

Compact

0.00%

16.47

16.47

0.00%

15.86

15.86

0.00%

Results From Current Analyses

SAP2000 Result

Number of Decimal
Places

Result for
Comparison

% Diff From
Version 16.0.0

0.0

Not Checked

0.00

Not Checked

0.00

Not Checked

#VALUE!

Example AISC ASD-89 Ex001

American
Wide Flange Member Under Bending
Results Published in the Current Verification Examples
Output
Parameter
Compactness
Fb (ksi)

fb (ksi)

SAP2000
Independent
Non-Compact Non-Compact

Percent
Difference
0.00%

32.70

32.70

0.00%

30.74

30.74

0.00%

Results From Current Analyses

SAP2000 Result

Number of Decimal
Places
-

Result for
Comparison
0.0

% Diff From
Version 16.0.0
Not Checked

0.00

Not Checked

0.00

Not Checked

#VALUE!

Example AISC ASD-89 Ex002

American
Wide Flange Member Under Compression
Results Published in the Current Verification Examples
Output
Parameter
Compactness
Fa (ksi)

fa (ksi)

SAP2000

Independent

Percent
Difference

Compact

Compact

0.00%

16.47

16.47

0.00%

15.86

15.86

0.00%

Results From Current Analyses

SAP2000 Result

Number of Decimal
Places

Result for
Comparison

% Diff From
Version 16.0.0

0.0

Not Checked

0.00

Not Checked

0.00

Not Checked

#VALUE!

Example AISC LRFD-93 Ex001

American
Wide Flange Member Under Bending
Results Published in the Current Verification Examples
Case

Lb = 4.375 ft
Lb = 11.67 ft
Lb = 35 ft

Output
Parameter
Compactness
Cb

bMn (k-ft)
Cb

bMn (k-ft)
Cb

bMn (k-ft)

Percent
SAP2000
Independent
Difference
Compact
Compact
0.00%
1.008

1.002

0.60%

294.000

294.000

0.00%

1.010

1.014

-0.39%

211.975

212.703

-0.34%

1.136

1.136

0.00%

50.599

50.599

0.00%

Results From Current Analyses

SAP2000 Result

Number of Decimal
Places
-

Result for
Comparison
0.0

% Diff From
Version 16.0.0
Not Checked

0.00

Not Checked

0.00

Not Checked

0.00

Not Checked

0.00

Not Checked

0.00

Not Checked

0.00

Not Checked

#VALUE!

Example AISC LRFD-93 Ex002

American
Wide Flange Member Under Combined Compression & Biaxial Bending
Results Published in the Current Verification Examples
Output
Parameter
Compactness

cPn (kips)
bMnx (k-ft)
bMny (k-ft)
D/C Ratio

SAP2000

Independent

Percent
Difference

Compact

Compact

0.00%

1937.84

1937.84

0.00%

1200

1200

0.00%

600.478
0.974

600.478
0.974

0.00%
0.00%

Results From Current Analyses

SAP2000 Result

Number of Decimal
Places

Result for
Comparison

% Diff From
Version 16.0.0

0.0

Not Checked

0.00

Not Checked

0.00

Not Checked

3
3

0.000
0.000

Not Checked
Not Checked

#VALUE!

Example AISC LRFD-99 Ex001

American
Wide Flange Member Under Bending
Results Published in the Current Verification Examples
Case

Lb = 4.375 ft
Lb = 11.67 ft
Lb = 35 ft

Output
Parameter
Compactness
Cb

bMn (k-ft)
Cb

bMn (k-ft)
Cb

bMn (k-ft)

SAP2000

Independent

Percent
Difference

Compact

Compact

0.00%

1.008

1.002

0.60%

294.000

294.000

0.00%

1.010

1.014

-0.39%

211.973

212.703

-0.34%

1.136

1.136

0.00%

50.599

50.599

0.00%

Results From Current Analyses

SAP2000 Result

Number of Decimal
Places

Result for
Comparison

% Diff From
Version 16.0.0

0.0

Not Checked

0.00

Not Checked

0.00

Not Checked

0.00

Not Checked

0.00

Not Checked

0.00

Not Checked

0.00

Not Checked

#VALUE!

Example AISC LRFD-99 Ex002

American
Wide Flange Member Under Combined Compression & Biaxial Bending
Results Published in the Current Verification Examples
Output
Parameter

SAP2000

Independent

Percent
Difference

Compactness

Compact

Compact

0.00%

cPn (kips)
bMnx (k-ft)
bMny (k-ft)

1937.844

1937.844

0.00%

1200.000

1200.000

0.00%

600.478
0.974

600.478
0.974

0.00%
0.00%

D/C Ratio

Results From Current Analyses

SAP2000 Result

Number of Decimal
Places

Result for
Comparison

% Diff From
Version 16.0.0

0.0

Not Checked

0.000

Not Checked

0.00

Not Checked

3
3

0.000
0.000

Not Checked
Not Checked

#VALUE!

Example UBC ASD-97 Ex001

American
Wide Flange Member Under Bending
Results Published in the Current Verification Examples
Output
Parameter
Compactness
Fb (ksi)

fb (ksi)

SAP2000

Independent

Percent
Difference

Non-Compact

Non-Compact

0.00%

32.70

32.70

0.00%

30.74

30.74

0.00%

Results From Current Analyses

SAP2000 Result

Number of Decimal
Places

Result for
Comparison

% Diff From
Version 16.0.0

0.0

Not Checked

0.00

Not Checked

0.00

Not Checked

#VALUE!

Example UBC ASD-97 Ex002

American
Wide Flange Member Under Compression
Results Published in the Current Verification Examples
Output
Parameter
Compactness

Fa (ksi)
D/C Ratio

SAP2000

Independent

Percent
Difference

Compact

Compact

0.00%

17.503
0.987

17.503
0.987

0.00%
0.00%

Results From Current Analyses

SAP2000 Result

Number of Decimal
Places

Result for
Comparison

% Diff From
Version 16.0.0

0.0

Not Checked

3
3

0.000
0.000

Not Checked
Not Checked

#VALUE!

Example UBC LRFD-97 Ex001

American
Wide Flange Member Under Bending
Results Published in the Current Verification Examples
Case
Lb = 4.375 ft
Lb = 11.67 ft
Lb = 35 ft

Output
Parameter
Compactness
Cb

bMn (k-ft)
Cb

bMn (k-ft)
Cb

bMn (k-ft)

SAP2000
Independent
Compact
Compact

Percent
Difference
0.00%

1.008

1.002

0.60%

294.000

294.000

0.00%

1.010

1.014

-0.39%

211.975

212.703

-0.34%

1.136

1.136

0.00%

50.599

50.599

0.00%

Results From Current Analyses

SAP2000 Result

Number of Decimal
Places
-

Result for
Comparison
0.0

% Diff From
Version 16.0.0
Not Checked

0.000

Not Checked

0.00

Not Checked

0.000

Not Checked

0.00

Not Checked

0.000

Not Checked

0.00

Not Checked

#VALUE!

Example UBC LRFD-97 Ex002

American
Wide Flange Member Under Combined Compression & Biaxial Bending
Results Published in the Current Verification Examples
Output
Parameter
Compactness

cPn (kips)
bMnx (k-ft)
bMny (k-ft)
D/C Ratio

SAP2000
Independent
Compact
Compact

Percent
Difference
0.00%

1937.844

1937.844

0.00%

1200.000

1200.000

0.00%

600.478
0.974

600.478
0.974

0.00%
0.00%

Results From Current Analyses

SAP2000 Result

Number of Decimal
Places
-

Result for
Comparison
0.0

% Diff From
Version 16.0.0
Not Checked

0.00

Not Checked

0.00

Not Checked

3
3

0.000
0.000

Not Checked
Not Checked

#VALUE!

Example AS 4100-1998 Ex001

Australian
Wide Flange Member Under Compression
Results Published in the Current Verification Examples
Output
Parameter
Compactness
Ns (kN)
Nc (kN)

SAP2000

Independent

Percent
Difference

Results From Current Analyses

SAP2000 Result

#VALUE!
Number of Decimal
Places

Result for
Comparison

% Diff From
Version 16.0.0

Compact

Compact

0.00%

0.0

Not Checked

6275

6275

0.00%

Not Checked

Not Checked

4385

4385

0.00%

Example AS 4100-1998 Ex002

Australian
Wide Flange Member Under Bending
Results Published in the Current Verification Examples
Output
Parameter
Compactness
Ms33 (kN-m)
Mb (kN-m)

Percent
SAP2000
Independent
Difference
Compact
Compact
0.00%
837.5

837.5

0.00%

837.5

837.5

0.00%

Results From Current Analyses

SAP2000 Result

Number of Decimal
Places
-

Result for
Comparison
0.0

% Diff From
Version 16.0.0
Not Checked

0.0

Not Checked

0.0

Not Checked

#VALUE!

Example AS 4100-1998 Ex003

Australian
Wide Flange Member Under Combined Compression & Bending
Results Published in the Current Verification Examples
Output
Parameter
Compactness
Mr33 (kN-m)

Percent
SAP2000
Independent
Difference
Compact
Compact
0.00%
837.5

837.5

0.00%

Mi33 (kN-m)

823.1

823.1

0.00%

Mo (kN-m)

837.5

837.5

0.00%

Results From Current Analyses

SAP2000 Result

Number of Decimal
Places
-

Result for
Comparison
0.0

% Diff From
Version 16.0.0
Not Checked

0.0

Not Checked

0.0

Not Checked

0.0

Not Checked

#VALUE!

Example BS 5950-1990 Ex001

British
Wide Flange Section Under Bending
Results Published in the Current Verification Examples
Output
Parameter
Compactness
M33 (kN-m)
Fv (kN)

SAP2000

Independent

Percent
Difference

Class 1

Class 1

0.00%

585.4

585.4

0.00%

292.3

292.3

0.00%

Mc (kN-m)

649

649

0.00%

Pv (kN-m)

888.4

888.4

0.00%

Results From Current Analyses

SAP2000 Result

Number of Decimal
Places

Result for
Comparison

% Diff From
Version 16.0.0

0.0

Not Checked

0.0

Not Checked

0.0

Not Checked

0.0

Not Checked

0.0

Not Checked

#VALUE!

Example BS 5950-1990 Ex002

British
Square Tube Member Under Compression & Bending
Results Published in the Current Verification Examples
Output
Parameter
Compactness
Pc (kN)
Mc (kN-m)

SAP2000

Independent

Percent
Difference

Class 1

Class 1

0.00%

773.2

773.2

0.00%

68.3

68.3

0.00%

Results From Current Analyses

SAP2000 Result

Number of Decimal
Places

Result for
Comparison

% Diff From
Version 16.0.0

0.0

Not Checked

0.0

Not Checked

0.0

Not Checked

#VALUE!

Example BS 5950-2000 Ex001

British
Wide Flange Section Under Bending
Results Published in the Current Verification Examples
Output
Parameter
Compactness
M33 (kN-m)
Fv (kN)

SAP2000

Independent

Percent
Difference

Class 1

Class 1

0.00%

Mc (kN-m)

585.4
292.25
649.0

585.4
292.25
649.0

0.00%
0.00%
0.00%

Pv (kN-m)

888.4

888.4

0.00%

Results From Current Analyses

SAP2000 Result

Number of Decimal
Places

Result for
Comparison

% Diff From
Version 16.0.0

0.0

Not Checked

1
2
1

0.0
0.0
0.0

Not Checked
Not Checked
Not Checked

0.0

Not Checked

#VALUE!

Example BS 5950-2000 Ex002

British
Square Tube Member Under Compression & Bending
Results Published in the Current Verification Examples
Output
Parameter
Compactness
Cr (kN)
Mrx (kN-m)

SAP2000

Independent

Percent
Difference

Class 1

Class 1

0.00%

773.2

773.2

0.00%

68.3

68.3

0.00%

Results From Current Analyses

SAP2000 Result

Number of Decimal
Places

Result for
Comparison

% Diff From
Version 16.0.0

0.0

Not Checked

0.0

Not Checked

0.0

Not Checked

#VALUE!

Example CISC 95 Ex001

Canadian
Wide Flange Member Under Bending
Results Published in the Current Verification Examples
Case
W410x54
W410x60
Lb = 0 m w/
W410x54
Lb = 2 m w/
W410x54
Lb = 4 m w/
W410x60

Output
Parameter
Compactness
Compactness
Mf (kN-m)
Mr (kN-m)
Mr (kN-m)
Mr (kN-m)

SAP2000

Independent

Percent
Difference

Class 1
Class 1

Class 1
Class 1

0.00%
0.00%

250.0

250.0

0.00%

283.5

283.5

0.00%

283.5

283.5

0.00%

264.2

264.1

0.04%

Results From Current Analyses

SAP2000 Result

#VALUE!

Number of Decimal
Places

Result for
Comparison

% Diff From
Version 16.0.0

0.0
0.0

Not Checked
Not Checked

0.0

Not Checked

0.0

Not Checked

0.0

Not Checked

0.0

Not Checked

1
1
1

Example CISC 95 Ex002

Canadian
Wide Flange Member Under Compression & Bending
Results Published in the Current Verification Examples
Output
Parameter
Compactness
Cr (kN)
Mr33 (kN-m)

SAP2000

Independent

Percent
Difference

Class 1

Class 1

0.00%

3797.3

3797.3

0.00%

583.2

583.2

0.00%

Results From Current Analyses

SAP2000 Result

#VALUE!

Number of Decimal
Places

Result for
Comparison

% Diff From
Version 16.0.0

0.0

Not Checked

0.0

Not Checked

0.0

Not Checked

Example CSA S16-01 Ex001

Canadian
Wide Flange Member Under Bending
Results Published in the Current Verification Examples
Case
W410x46
W410x60

Output
Parameter
Compactness
Compactness
Mu (kN-m)

Lb = 0 m w/
W410x46
Lb = 2 m w/
W410x46
Lb = 4 m w/
W410x60

Mr (kN-m)
Mr (kN-m)
Mr (kN-m)

SAP2000
Independent
Class 1
Class 1
Class 1
Class 1

Percent
Difference
0.00%
0.00%

250.0

250.0

0.00%

278.775

278.775

0.00%

268.57

268.42

0.06%

287.69

287.64

0.02%

Results From Current Analyses

SAP2000 Result

#VALUE!

Number of Decimal
Places
-

Result for
Comparison
0.0
0.0

% Diff From
Version 16.0.0
Not Checked
Not Checked

0.0

Not Checked

0.000

Not Checked

0.00

Not Checked

0.00

Not Checked

3
2
2

Example CSA S16-01 Ex002

Canadian
Wide Flange Member Under Compression & Bending
Results Published in the Current Verification Examples
Output
Parameter
Compactness
Cr (kN)
Mr33 (kN-m)

SAP2000

Independent

Percent
Difference

Class 2

Class 2

0.00%

3849.5

3849.5

0.00%

605.5

605.5

0.00%

Results From Current Analyses

SAP2000 Result

#VALUE!

Number of Decimal
Places

Result for
Comparison

% Diff From
Version 16.0.0

0.0

Not Checked

0.0

Not Checked

0.0

Not Checked

Example CSA S16-09 Ex001

Canadian
Wide Flange Member Under Bending
Results Published in the Current Verification Examples
Case
W410x46
W410x60
Lb = 0 m w/
W410x46
Lb = 2 m w/
W410x46
Lb = 4 m w/
W410x60

Output
Parameter
Compactness
Compactness
Mf (kN-m)
Mr (kN-m)
Mr (kN-m)
Mr (kN-m)

SAP2000
Independent
Class 1
Class 1

Percent
Difference
0.00%

Class 1

Class 1

0.00%

250.0

250.0

0.00%

278.775

278.775

0.00%

268.97

268.83

0.05%

292.10

292.05

0.02%

Results From Current Analyses

SAP2000 Result

#VALUE!

Number of Decimal
Places
-

Result for
Comparison
0.0

% Diff From
Version 16.0.0
Not Checked

0.0

Not Checked

0.0

Not Checked

0.000

Not Checked

0.00

Not Checked

0.00

Not Checked

3
2
2

Example CSA S16-09 Ex002

Canadian
Wide Flange Member Under Compression & Bending
Results Published in the Current Verification Examples
Output
Parameter
Compactness
Cr (kN)
Mr33 (kN-m)

SAP2000

Independent

Percent
Difference

Class 2

Class 2

0.00%

3849.5

3849.5

0.00%

605.5

605.5

0.00%

Results From Current Analyses

SAP2000 Result

#VALUE!

Number of Decimal
Places

Result for
Comparison

% Diff From
Version 16.0.0

0.0

Not Checked

0.0

Not Checked

0.0

Not Checked

Example EN 3-1993 Ex001

Eurocode
Wide Flange Member Under Combined Compression & Bending with Shear Limit State
Results Published in the Current Verification Examples
Output
Parameter
Compactness
Nb,Rd22 (N)

SAP2000
Class 1

Results From Current Analyses

Percent
Independent
Difference
Class 1
0.00%

SAP2000 Result

#VALUE!
Number of
Decimal Places Result for Comparison
0.0

% Diff From
Version 16.0.0
Not Checked

600531

600531

0.00%

Not Checked

Nb,Rd33 (N)

608864

608864

0.00%

Not Checked

Nc,Rd (N)

600531

600531

0.00%

Not Checked

Mc,Rd22 (N-m)

9528

9528

0.00%

Not Checked

Mc,Rd33 (N-m)

47214

47214

0.00%

Not Checked

Mv,Rd22 (N-m)

9528

9528

0.00%

Not Checked

Mv,Rd33 (N-m)

44815

44815

0.00%

Not Checked

Mb,Rd (N-m)

47214

47214

0.00%

Not Checked

C1

1.880

1.880

0.00%

0.000

Not Checked

k22

0.955

0.955

0.00%

0.000

Not Checked

k33

0.965

0.965

0.00%

0.000

Not Checked

kLT

1.000

1.000

0.00%

0.000

Not Checked

D/CAxial

0.345

0.345

0.00%

0.000

Not Checked

D/CBending

1.116

1.116

0.00%

0.000

Not Checked

Example EN 3-1993 Ex002

Eurocode
Wide Flange Member Under Combined Compression & Bending with Flexural Buckling Limit State
Results Published in the Current Verification Examples
Output
Parameter

SAP2000

Percent
Difference

Independent

Compactness
Nb,Rd22 (N)

Class 1

Class 1

0.00%

174551

174551

0.00%

Nb,Rd33 (N)

571558

571558

0.00%

Nc,Rd (N)

174551

174551

0.00%

Mc,Rd22 (N-m)

9528

9528

0.00%

Mc,Rd33 (N-m)

47214

47214

0.00%

Mv,Rd22 (N-m)

9528

9528

0.00%

Mv,Rd33 (N-m)

47214

47214

0.00%

Mb,Rd (N-m)

37594

37594

0.00%

C1

1.880

1.880

0.00%

k22

1.500

1.500

0.00%

k33

1.014

1.014

0.00%

kLT

0.671

0.671

0.00%

D/CAxial

1.203

1.203

0.00%

D/CBending

0.924

0.924

0.00%

ng Limit State
Results From Current Analyses

SAP2000 Result

Number of
Decimal Places Result for Comparison

% Diff From
Version 16.0.0

0.0

Not Checked

Not Checked

Not Checked

Not Checked

Not Checked

Not Checked

Not Checked

Not Checked

Not Checked

0.000

Not Checked

0.000

Not Checked

0.000

Not Checked

0.000

Not Checked

0.000

Not Checked

0.000

Not Checked

#VALUE!

Example EN 3-1993 Ex003

Eurocode
Wide Flange Member Under Combined Compression & Bending with LTB Limit State
Results Published in the Current Verification Examples
Output
Parameter
Compactness
Nb,Rd22 (N)

SAP2000
Class 1

Percent
Independent
Difference
Class 1
0.00%

24977

24977

0.00%

289941

289941

0.00%

24977

24977

0.00%

Mc,Rd22 (N-m)

9528

9528

0.00%

Mc,Rd33 (N-m)

47214

47214

0.00%

Mv,Rd22 (N-m)

9528

9528

0.00%

Mv,Rd33 (N-m)

47214

47214

0.00%

Mb,Rd (N-m)

18609

18609

0.00%

C1

1.880

1.880

0.00%

k22

1.500

1.500

0.00%

k33

1.249

1.249

0.00%

kLT

5.879

5.879

0.00%

D/CAxial

8.408

8.408

0.00%

13.585

13.585

0.00%

Nb,Rd33 (N)
Nc,Rd (N)

D/CBending

Results From Current Analyses

SAP2000 Result

Number of
Decimal Places Result for Comparison
0.0

% Diff From
Version 16.0.0
Not Checked

Not Checked

Not Checked

Not Checked

Not Checked

Not Checked

Not Checked

Not Checked

Not Checked

0.000

Not Checked

0.000

Not Checked

0.000

Not Checked

0.000

Not Checked

0.000

Not Checked

0.000

Not Checked

#VALUE!

Example EN 3-2005 Ex001

Eurocode
Wide Flange Member Under Combined Compression & Bending
Results Published in the Current Verification Examples
Output
Parameter
Compactness
D/CAxial
D/CBending

SAP2000

Independent

Percent
Difference

Class 1

Class 1

0.00%

0.334

0.334

0.00%

0.649

0.646

0.46%

Results From Current Analyses

SAP2000 Result

Number of Decimal
Places

Result for
Comparison

% Diff From
Version 16.0.0

0.0

Not Checked

0.000

Not Checked

0.000

Not Checked

#VALUE!

Example EN 3-2005 Ex002

Eurocode
Wide Flange Section Under Bending
Results Published in the Current Verification Examples
Output
Parameter
Compactness
Vpl,Rd (kN)

SAP2000
Independent
Class 1
Class 1

Percent
Difference
0.00%

689.2

689.2

0.00%

Mc,33,Rd (kN-m)

412.8

412.8

0.00%

Mv,33,Rd (kN-m)

386.8

386.8

0.00%

Results From Current Analyses

SAP2000 Result

Number of Decimal
Places
-

Result for
Comparison
0

% Diff From
Version 16.0.0
Not Checked

0.0

Not Checked

0.0

Not Checked

0.0

Not Checked

#VALUE!

Example EN 3-2005 Ex003

Eurocode
Wide Flange Section Under Combined Compression & Bending
Results Published in the Current Verification Examples
Output
Parameter
Compactness
Npl,Rd (kN)

SAP2000
Independent
Class 2
Class 2

Percent
Difference
0.00%

2937.5

2937.5

0.00%

Mpl,y,Rd (kN-m)

524.1

524.5

-0.08%

Mn,y,Rd (kN-m)

341.9

342.2

-0.09%

Results From Current Analyses

SAP2000 Result

Number of Decimal
Places
-

Result for
Comparison
0.0

% Diff From
Version 16.0.0
Not Checked

0.0

Not Checked

0.0

Not Checked

0.0

Not Checked

#VALUE!

Example IS 800-2007 Ex001

Indian
Wide Flange Member Under Compression
Results Published in the Current Verification Examples
Output
Parameter
Compactness
Pd (kN)

SAP2000
Independent
Plastic
Plastic
733.85

734.07

Percent
Difference
0.00%
-0.03%

Results From Current Analyses

SAP2000 Result

Number of Decimal
Places
-

Result for
Comparison
0.0

% Diff From
Version 16.0.0
Not Checked

0.00

Not Checked

#VALUE!

Example IS 800-2007 Ex002

Indian
Wide Flange Member Under Bending
Results Published in the Current Verification Examples

Results From Current Analyses

Output
Percent
Parameter
SAP2000
Independent
Difference
Compactness Plastic
Plastic
0.00%
Msd (kN-m)
152.71
152.97
-0.17%
Vd (kN)
603.59
603.59
0.00%

SAP2000 Result

#VALUE!
Number of Decimal
Places
-

Result for
Comparison
0

% Diff From
Version 16.0.0
Not Checked

0.00

Not Checked

0.00

Not Checked

Example IS 800-2007 Ex003

Indian
Wide Flange Member Under Combined Compression & Biaxial Bending
Results Published in the Current Verification Examples
Output
Percent
Parameter
SAP2000
Independent
Difference
Compactness Plastic
Plastic
0.00%
Nd (kN)
6564
6564
0.00%
Pd,z (kN)
6555
6555
0.00%
Pd,y (kN)
5324.01
5324.01
0.00%

Results From Current Analyses

SAP2000 Result

#VALUE!
Number of Decimal
Places
-

Result for
Comparison
0

% Diff From
Version 16.0.0
Not Checked

Not Checked

Not Checked

0.00

Not Checked

Mdz (kN-m)

897.46

897.46

0.00%

0.00

Not Checked

Mdy (kN-m)

325.72

325.72

0.00%

0.00

Not Checked

MdLTB (kN-m)

882.11

886.76

-0.52%

0.00

Not Checked

VPz (kN)

1009.2

1009.2

0.00%

0.0

Not Checked

VPy (kN)

2961.6
1.218

2961.6
1.048

0.00%
16.22%

1
3

0.0
0.000

Not Checked
Not Checked

D/C Ratio

Example NTC 2008 Ex001

Italian
Wide Flange Section Under Combined Compression & Bending
Results Published in the Current Verification Examples
Output
Parameter
Section
Nc,Rd (N)

SAP2000
Class 2

Independent
Class 2

Percent
Difference
0.00%

2797619

2797619

0.00%

Vc,Rd,y (N)

719157

719157

0.00%

Mc,y,Rd (N-m)

499095

499095

0.00%

MV,y,Rd (N-m)

481276

481276

0.00%

MN,y,Rd (N-m)

310772

310772

0.00%

0.644

0.644

0.00%

D/CRatio

Results From Current Analyses

SAP2000 Result

Number of Decimal
Places
-

Result for
Comparison
0.0

% Diff From
Version 16.0.0
Not Checked

Not Checked

Not Checked

Not Checked

Not Checked

Not Checked

0.000

Not Checked

#VALUE!

Example NTC 2008 Ex002

Italian
Wide Flange Member Under Combined Compression & Bending
Results Published in the Current Verification Examples
Output
Parameter
Section
Nc,Rd (N)

SAP2000
Class 2

Independent
Class 2

Percent
Difference
0.00%

2797619

2797619

0.00%

Vc,Rd,y (N)

719157

719157

0.00%

Vc,Rd,z (N)

984733

984733

0.00%

Mc,y,Rd (N-mm)

499095238

499095238

0.00%

Mc,z,Rd (N-mm)

84823810

84823810

0.00%

MV,y,Rd (N-mm)

481275859

481275859

0.00%

MN,y,Rd (N-mm)

310771539

310771539

0.00%

MN,z,Rd (N-mm)

82263377

82263377

0.00%

Nbyy,Rd (N)

2797619

2797619

0.00%

Nbzz,Rd (N)

2797619

2797619

0.00%

499095238

499095238

0.00%

2.044

2.044

0.00%

Mb,Rd (N-mm)
D/CRatio

Results From Current Analyses

SAP2000 Result

Number of Decimal
Places
-

Result for
Comparison
0.0

% Diff From
Version 16.0.0
Not Checked

Not Checked

Not Checked

Not Checked

Not Checked

Not Checked

Not Checked

Not Checked

Not Checked

Not Checked

Not Checked

Not Checked

0.000

Not Checked

#VALUE!

Example NZS 3404-1997 Ex001

New Zealand
Wide Flange Member Under Compression
Results Published in the Current Verification Examples
Output
Parameter
Compactness
Ns (kN)
Nc (kN)

SAP2000
Compact

Independent
Compact

Percent
Difference
0.00%

Results From Current Analyses

SAP2000 Result

#VALUE!
Number of Decimal
Places
-

Result for
Comparison
0.0

% Diff From
Version 16.0.0
Not Checked

6275

6275

0.00%

Not Checked

4385

4385

0.00%

Not Checked

Example NZS 3404-1997 Ex002

New Zealand
Wide Flange Member Under Bending
Results Published in the Current Verification Examples
Output
Percent
Parameter
SAP2000
Independent
Difference
Compactness Compact
Compact
0.00%
Msx (kN-m)
837.5
837.5
0.00%
Mb (kN-m)
837.5
837.5
0.00%

Results From Current Analyses

SAP2000 Result

Number of Decimal
Places
-

Result for
Comparison
0.0

% Diff From
Version 16.0.0
Not Checked

0.0

Not Checked

0.0

Not Checked

#VALUE!

Example NZS 3404-1997 Ex003

New Zealand
Wide Flange Member Under Combined Compression & Bending
Results Published in the Current Verification Examples
Output
Parameter
Compactness
Mrx (kN-m)

SAP2000
Independent
Compact
Compact

Percent
Difference
0.00%

837.5

837.5

0.00%

Mix (kN-m)

823.1

823.1

0.00%

Mo (kN-m)

837.5

837.5

0.00%

Results From Current Analyses

SAP2000 Result

Number of Decimal
Places
-

Result for
Comparison
0.0

% Diff From
Version 16.0.0
Not Checked

0.0

Not Checked

0.0

Not Checked

0.0

Not Checked

#VALUE!

Example NORSOK N-004-2004 Ex001

Norwegian
Round Tube Member Under Compression
Results Published in the Current Verification Examples
Output
Parameter
Nc,Rd (kN)
Ncl,Rd (kN)
D/CAxial

SAP2000

Independent

Percent
Difference

Results From Current Analyses

SAP2000 Result

#VALUE!
Number of Decimal
Places

Result for
Comparison

% Diff From
Version 16.0.0

849.846

849.846

0.00%

0.000

Not Checked

1100.980

1100.980

0.00%

0.000

Not Checked

0.235

0.235

0.00%

0.000

Not Checked

Example NORSOK N-004-2004 Ex002

Norwegian
Round Tube Member Under Bending
Results Published in the Current Verification Examples
Output
Parameter
MRd (kN-m)
D/C

SAP2000
74.098
0.540

Independent
74.098
0.540

Percent
Difference
0.00%
0.00%

Results From Current Analyses

SAP2000 Result

Number of Decimal
Places

Result for
Comparison

% Diff From
Version 16.0.0

3
3

0.000
0.000

Not Checked
Not Checked

#VALUE!

Example NORSOK N-004-2004 Ex003

Norwegian
Round Tube Member Under Combined Compression & Bending
Results Published in the Current Verification Examples
Output
Parameter
D/CAxial
D/C

SAP2000
0.182
0.785

Independent
0.182
0.785

Percent
Difference
0.00%
0.00%

Results From Current Analyses

SAP2000 Result

Number of Decimal
Places

Result for
Comparison

% Diff From
Version 16.0.0

3
3

0.000
0.000

Not Checked
Not Checked

#VALUE!