Book Review - The Greater Journey - Americans in Paris - By David Mc...

http://www.nytimes.com/2011/05/29/books/review/book-review-the-grea...

Reprints
This copy is for your personal, noncommercial use only. You can order presentation-ready copies for distribution to your colleagues, clients or customers here or use the "Reprints" tool that appears next to any article. Visit www.nytreprints.com for samples and additional information. Order a reprint of this article now.

May 27, 2011

How Paris Created America

By STACY SCHIFF

David McCullough has stressed Frances pre-eminent role in American history for years. We would not, he Americans in Paris has argued, have a country without the French, who By David McCullough have permanently and profoundly shaped us. If anyone Illustrated. 558 pp. Simon could get away with suggesting that room be made on & Schuster. $37.50 Mount Rushmore for Astrix it is McCullough. He seems to have had something else in mind, however. With The Greater Journey: Americans in Paris, he explores the intellectual legacy that France settled on its 19th-century visitors. The result is an epic of ideas, as well as an exhilarating book of spells. The tradition began very much as a case of Lafayette, nous voici. The first pilgrims were nearly all single, wealthy men in their 20s, serious of purpose and ambitious by nature. A number of them had played a role in the French generals triumphant return to America. They were provincial and inexperienced. They had never before sailed. They knew little French literature. They did not yet suspect that one could be seduced by breakfast. Following a tradition established years earlier by John Adams, they came to Paris to do their homework. Oliver Wendell Holmes, James Fenimore Cooper, Charles Sumner and Samuel F. B. Morse looked to the city as library and laboratory rather than as liberation. The idea was to settle in Paris to study hard, a concept that would put most junior-year-abroad programs out of business. In two panoramic chapters, McCullough introduces us to the travelers as they prepare for their adventure. Emotions ran high on the eve of departure, he writes. Melancholy and second thoughts interspersed with intense excitement were the common thing. The trip was arduous, the French drizzle constant, and bureaucracy evidently dates to Vercingetorix. But it was a fine time to make the game-changing discovery that the Old World really was old. There were probably fewer than a thousand Americans in the city through the 1830s.
1 of 4

THE GREATER JOURNEY

5/27/2011 2:22 PM

Book Review - The Greater Journey - Americans in Paris - By David Mc...

http://www.nytimes.com/2011/05/29/books/review/book-review-the-grea...

All were struck by the civility of their hosts. Wine was cheaper than milk. Though the Louvre opened to the public only on Sundays, foreigners could visit throughout the week. One American who could reliably be found there was Samuel Morse. At his side for several hours each day was his dear friend James Fenimore Cooper, whose Last of the Mohicans graced every Parisian bookstore window. (As Cooper noted, the French understood that novel to be the only book published in America since the time of Ben Franklin.) McCullough devotes a chapter to Morse and Cooper the two had met at the White House in the course of Lafayettes visit who attest to the transformative, transfiguring power of Paris. Morse arrived as a painter and left as an inventor. He took home with him in 1832 the germ of what would become the telegraph. With a second visit, he imported Daguerres ideas on photography. For most of McCulloughs travelers, Paris represented a great awakening the blood-tingling beauty of it all! but also an education, an invitation to see the world anew. Any doctor worth his salt hoped to study there. Charles Sumner was struck by the science but also by the black medical students. He would go on to crusade for abolition. Americas first female physician, Elizabeth Blackwell, returned to New York to found a hospital run entirely by women. (In the plus a change department, teeth were already an American specialty. The foremost Parisian dentist in the 19th century was a Philadelphian.) By definition McCulloughs grand tour is impressionistic and discursive, proceeding by way of crossed paths and capsule biographies. This is history to be savored rather than sprinted through, like a Parisian meal. It amounts to a meaty collection of short stories, expertly and flavorfully assembled, free of gristly theory. McCullough has his favorites, and displays a marked preference for the visual artists. Generally he describes Paris with a painters eye: It was not just that they had never known a city of such size or variety, or with so much history, but they had never known one where the look and mood could be so strikingly different in different light. Only an ingrate would question his casting decisions. As he points out, often the minor characters tell a story best. Mark Twain would not be pleased. Occasionally McCullough pauses to pit one national treasure against another. So Harriet Beecher Stowe spends a spellbound hour before The Raft of the Medusa: She was sure, he writes, no more powerful piece had ever been painted. It was as though this one picture had been worth the whole trip to

2 of 4

5/27/2011 2:22 PM

Book Review - The Greater Journey - Americans in Paris - By David Mc...

http://www.nytimes.com/2011/05/29/books/review/book-review-the-grea...

France. The New York sculptor Augustus Saint-Gaudens plays a leading role in The Greater Journey. He began as a cameo-cutter, an apprenticeship to which McCullough devotes several pages. And like every dual national, his narrative maintains a foot in two places. McCulloughs is as much the splendid story of a nation growing up as it is that of a city coming into its own. In the course of these pages, Paris acquires bateaux-mouches , the grands magasins , the Folies Bergre and Haussmans avenues. The two histories combine most powerfully in his account of the FrancoPrussian War and Elihu Washburne, Americas minister to France between 1869 and 1877. A reliable topic of conversation in Paris, food was the principal one during the German siege, when cat meat revealed itself be a delicacy and Paris solved its rat problem. By the time German troops marched down the Champs-lyses, on March 1, l871, more than 65,000 Parisians had died. The only prominent diplomat to do so, Washburne valiantly refused to budge even through the months of the Commune, one of the bloodiest chapters in French history. His was no paradisiacal Paris; as the atrocities mounted, the distraught Washburne noted that the city was a hell upon this earth. At one point the Seine ran red with blood. A team of 60,000 masons would be required to put Paris back together again. On Mary Cassatts arrival shortly afterward, the Htel de Ville looked like a Roman ruin. The making of art is inherently less dramatic than the making of history, and the Paris Commune exerts a power that John Singer Sergeants painting of Madame Gautreau or Saint-Gaudenss casting of Admiral Farragut may not. Saint-Gaudens brilliantly proves McCulloughs point, however; here was American history literally forged in France. The colossal bronze statue of the Civil War hero was shipped back to New York, all 900 pounds of him, to be unveiled in May 1881. During a later Parisian stay, Saint-Gaudens cast the Sherman on horseback that stands today on the edge of Central Park. Among the reasons to visit Paris, Saint-Gaudenss son recognized one that would migrate with the times: Only in France could an artist measure himself with his contemporaries, place his work before the worlds most critical audience, and learn, once for all, wherein it was good and wherein bad. McCullough takes us from Oliver Wendell Holmes to Isadora Duncan, which is to say that The Greater Journey ends before Theodore Dreiser spilled the beans. Its history and art were all very well and good, but Paris was about something else altogether. That something else was sex. No one in The Greater Journey seems to have noticed Twains delightfully immoral
3 of 4

5/27/2011 2:22 PM

Book Review - The Greater Journey - Americans in Paris - By David Mc...

http://www.nytimes.com/2011/05/29/books/review/book-review-the-grea...

working girls. Instead, John Singer Sargents father waxed on about probity and the domestic virtues of Parisian life. Saint-Gaudens would draw a blank when asked later to recall any amorous adventure abroad, although, as is clear from these pages, the sculptor had a selective memory. Very possibly much of what happened in 19th-century Paris stayed in Paris. What McCulloughs Americans took home with them were less sentimental educations than artistic and intellectual ones; the finishing school and the movable feast came later. These years were about shaping art and principles, tasks with which France assisted by dispatching the Statue of Liberty and Tocqueville in the opposite direction. It bestowed a greater gift as well. Coming here has been a wonderful experience, surprising in many respects, one of them being to find how much of an American I am, Saint-Gaudens wrote. Pining for all that had once seemed unremarkable, he returned home a burning hot-headed patriot. That lesson too endures. Paris is the city to which good Americans go to learn that they really do love peanut butter.
Stacy Schiffs most recent book is Cleopatra: A Life.

4 of 4

5/27/2011 2:22 PM