REPORTE FINAL ANALISIS DE RACKS

SERVICIOS DE INGENIERIA Y CONSULTORIA ESIME AZCAPOTZALCO

De Ing. Gerardo Minutti Pilloni e Ing. Francisco Rodrguez Lezama

Para: Ing. Jos Jaime Carmona Trejo
CLIENTE: Industrias de Refrigeracin Plafer

SAP2000 and Solid Works Analysis Report

Prepared by

SICEA
Model Name: RACKS DE CARGA

4 febrero 2013

ESIME
Contents

SAP2000 v14.0.0 AND SOLID WORKS - License #DEA5647

04 febrero 2013

Contents
1. Model geometry ................................................................................................................................................................. 4
1.1. Joint coordinates ....................................................................................................................................................... 5
1.2. Joint restraints ........................................................................................................................................................... 6
1.3. Element connectivity .................................................................................................................................................. 7
2. Material properties ............................................................................................................................................................. 8
3. Section properties .............................................................................................................................................................. 9
3.1. Frames....................................................................................................................................................................... 9
4. Load patterns ................................................................................................................................................................... 10
4.1. Definitions ................................................................................................................................................................ 10
5. Load cases ...................................................................................................................................................................... 11
5.1. Definitions ................................................................................................................................................................ 11
5.2. Static case load assignments .................................................................................................................................. 11
5.3. Response spectrum case load assignments ........................................................................................................... 11
6. Structure results............................................................................................................................................................... 12
6.1. Mass summary ........................................................................................................................................................ 12
6.2. Modal results ........................................................................................................................................................... 13
6.3. Base reactions ......................................................................................................................................................... 14
7. Joint results ...................................................................................................................................................................... 14
8. Frame results ................................................................................................................................................................... 15
9. Material take-off ............................................................................................................................................................... 17
10. Design preferences ....................................................................................................................................................... 18

List of Figures
Figure 1: Finite element model .............................................................................................................................................. 4
Figure 2: Deformed shape ................................................................................................................................................... 12

List of Tables
Table 1: Joint Coordinates, Part 1 of 2 .................................................................................................................................. 6
Table 1: Joint Coordinates, Part 2 of 2 .................................................................................................................................. 6
Table 2: Joint Restraint Assignments .................................................................................................................................... 6
Table 3: Connectivity - Frame, Part 1 of 2 ............................................................................................................................. 7
Table 3: Connectivity - Frame, Part 2 of 2 ............................................................................................................................. 7
Table 4: Frame Section Assignments.................................................................................................................................... 7
Table 5: Material Properties 02 - Basic Mechanical Properties ............................................................................................ 8
Table 6: Material Properties 03a - Steel Data, Part 1 of 2..................................................................................................... 8
Table 6: Material Properties 03a - Steel Data, Part 2 of 2..................................................................................................... 8
Table 7: Material Properties 03b - Concrete Data, Part 1 of 2 .............................................................................................. 8
Table 7: Material Properties 03b - Concrete Data, Part 2 of 2 .............................................................................................. 9
Table 8: Frame Section Properties 01 - General, Part 1 of 7 ................................................................................................ 9
Table 8: Frame Section Properties 01 - General, Part 2 of 7 ................................................................................................ 9
Table 8: Frame Section Properties 01 - General, Part 3 of 7 ................................................................................................ 9
Table 8: Frame Section Properties 01 - General, Part 4 of 7 ................................................................................................ 9
Table 8: Frame Section Properties 01 - General, Part 5 of 7 .............................................................................................. 10
Table 8: Frame Section Properties 01 - General, Part 6 of 7 .............................................................................................. 10
Table 8: Frame Section Properties 01 - General, Part 7 of 7 .............................................................................................. 10
Table 9: Load Pattern Definitions ........................................................................................................................................ 10
Table 10: Load Case Definitions, Part 1 of 2 ....................................................................................................................... 11

DEASA

Page 2 of 26

ESIME
List of Tables

SAP2000 v14.0.0 AND SOLID WORKS - License #DEA5647

04 febrero 2013

Table 10: Load Case Definitions, Part 2 of 2 .......................................................................................................................

Table 11: Case - Static 1 - Load Assignments ....................................................................................................................
Table 12: Function - Response Spectrum - User ................................................................................................................
Table 13: Assembled Joint Masses .....................................................................................................................................
Table 14: Modal Participating Mass Ratios, Part 1 of 3 ......................................................................................................
Table 14: Modal Participating Mass Ratios, Part 2 of 3 ......................................................................................................
Table 14: Modal Participating Mass Ratios, Part 3 of 3 ......................................................................................................
Table 15: Base Reactions, Part 1 of 3 .................................................................................................................................
Table 15: Base Reactions, Part 2 of 3 .................................................................................................................................
Table 15: Base Reactions, Part 3 of 3 .................................................................................................................................
Table 16: Joint Displacements ............................................................................................................................................
Table 17: Joint Reactions ....................................................................................................................................................
Table 18: Element Forces - Frames, Part 1 of 2 .................................................................................................................
Table 18: Element Forces - Frames, Part 2 of 2 .................................................................................................................
Table 19: Material List 2 - By Section Property ...................................................................................................................
Table 20: Preferences - Steel Design - AISC-LRFD93, Part 1 of 2 ....................................................................................
Table 20: Preferences - Steel Design - AISC-LRFD93, Part 2 of 2 ....................................................................................
Table 18: Element Forces - Frames, Part 1 of 2 .................................................................................................................
Table 18: Element Forces - Frames, Part 2 of 2 .................................................................................................................
Table 19: Material List 2 - By Section Property ...................................................................................................................
Table 20: Preferences - Steel Design - AISC-LRFD93, Part 1 of 2 ....................................................................................
Table 20: Preferences - Steel Design - AISC-LRFD93, Part 2 of 2 ....................................................................................
Table 24: Preferences Revision Solid Works AA-ASD 2000 ...........................................................................................
Table 25: Preferences Recomendaciones y resultados ...................................................................................................
Table 26 Preferences - Conclusiones .................................................................................................................................

DEASA

11
11
11
12
13
13
14
14
14
14
15
15
15
16
17
18
18
15
16
17
18
18
11
23
24

Page 3 of 26

ESIME
1. Model geometry

SAP2000 v14.0.0 AND SOLID WORKS - License #DEA5647

04 febrero 2013

1. Model geometry
This section provides model geometry information, including items such as joint coordinates, joint restraints, and
element connectivity.

Figure 1: Finite element model

DEASA

Page 4 of 26

ESIME
1. Model geometry

DEASA

SAP2000 v14.0.0 AND SOLID WORKS - License #DEA5647

04 febrero 2013

Page 5 of 26

ESIME
1. Model geometry

SAP2000 v14.0.0 AND SOLID WORKS - License #DEA5647

04 febrero 2013

1.1. Joint coordinates

Table 1: Joint Coordinates, Part 1 of 2
Joint

CoordSys

1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12

GLOBAL
GLOBAL
GLOBAL
GLOBAL
GLOBAL
GLOBAL
GLOBAL
GLOBAL
GLOBAL
GLOBAL
GLOBAL
GLOBAL

Table 1: Joint Coordinates, Part 1 of 2

CoordType
XorR
Y
cm
cm
Cartesian
0.000
121.000
Cartesian
0.000
121.000
Cartesian
0.000
0.000
Cartesian
0.000
0.000
Cartesian
121.000
0.000
Cartesian
121.000
0.000
Cartesian
121.000
121.000
Cartesian
121.000
121.000
Cartesian
121.000
0.000
Cartesian
121.000
121.000
Cartesian
0.000
121.000
Cartesian
0.000
0.000

Z
cm
0.000
660.000
0.000
660.000
0.000
660.000
0.000
660.000
330.000
330.000
330.000
330.000

SpecialJt
No
No
No
No
No
No
No
No
No
No
No
No

GlobalX
cm
0.000
0.000
0.000
0.000
121.000
121.000
121.000
121.000
121.000
121.000
0.000
0.000

Table 1: Joint Coordinates, Part 2 of 2

Joint
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12

Table 1: Joint Coordinates, Part 2 of 2

GlobalY
GlobalZ
GUID
cm
cm
121.000
0.000
121.000
660.000
0.000
0.000
0.000
660.000
0.000
0.000
0.000
660.000
121.000
0.000
121.000
660.000
0.000
330.000
121.000
330.000
121.000
330.000
0.000
330.000

1.2. Joint restraints

Table 2: Joint Restraint Assignments
Joint

U1

1
3
5
7

Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes

DEASA

Table 2: Joint Restraint Assignments

U2
U3
R1
Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes

Yes
Yes
Yes
Yes

No
No
No
No

R2

R3

No
No
No
No

No
No
No
No

Page 6 of 26

ESIME
1. Model geometry

SAP2000 v14.0.0 AND SOLID WORKS - License #DEA5647

04 febrero 2013

1.3. Element connectivity

Table 3: Connectivity - Frame, Part 1 of 2
Frame

JointI

1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12

1
3
5
7
4
6
8
2
9
10
11
12

Table 3: Connectivity - Frame, Part 1 of 2

JointJ
IsCurved
Length
CentroidX
cm
cm
2
No
660.000
0.000
4
No
660.000
0.000
6
No
660.000
121.000
8
No
660.000
121.000
6
No
121.000
60.500
8
No
121.000
121.000
2
No
121.000
60.500
4
No
121.000
0.000
10
No
121.000
121.000
11
No
121.000
60.500
12
No
121.000
0.000
9
No
121.000
60.500

CentroidY
cm
121.000
0.000
0.000
121.000
0.000
60.500
121.000
60.500
60.500
121.000
60.500
0.000

CentroidZ
cm
330.000
330.000
330.000
330.000
660.000
660.000
660.000
660.000
330.000
330.000
330.000
330.000

Table 3: Connectivity - Frame, Part 2 of 2

Table 3: Connectivity - Frame, Part 2 of 2
Frame
GUID
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12

Table 4: Frame Section Assignments

Frame

SectionType

1
2
3
4
5
6
7

Angle
Angle
Angle
Angle
Angle
Angle
Angle

DEASA

Table 4: Frame Section Assignments

AutoSelect
AnalSect
N.A.
N.A.
N.A.
N.A.
N.A.
N.A.
N.A.

L2X2X1/8
L2X2X1/8
L2X2X1/8
L2X2X1/8
L2X2X1/8
L2X2X1/8
L2X2X1/8

DesignSect

MatProp

N.A.
N.A.
N.A.
N.A.
N.A.
N.A.
N.A.

Default
Default
Default
Default
Default
Default
Default

Page 7 of 26

ESIME
2. Material properties

SAP2000 v14.0.0 AND SOLID WORKS - License #DEA5647

04 febrero 2013

Frame

SectionType

8
9
10
11
12

Angle
Angle
Angle
Angle
Angle

Table 4: Frame Section Assignments

AutoSelect
AnalSect
N.A.
N.A.
N.A.
N.A.
N.A.

L2X2X1/8
L2X2X1/8
L2X2X1/8
L2X2X1/8
L2X2X1/8

DesignSect

MatProp

N.A.
N.A.
N.A.
N.A.
N.A.

Default
Default
Default
Default
Default

2. Material properties
This section provides material property information for materials used in the model.

Table 5: Material Properties 02 - Basic Mechanical Properties

Material
4000Psi
A36
A992Fy50

Table 5: Material Properties 02 - Basic Mechanical Properties

UnitWeight
UnitMass
E1
G12
U12
Kgf/cm3
Kgf-s2/cm4
Kgf/cm2
Kgf/cm2
2.4028E-03
2.4501E-06
253456.36
105606.82
0.200000
7.8490E-03
8.0038E-06
2038901.92
784193.04
0.300000
7.8490E-03
8.0038E-06
2038901.92
784193.04
0.300000

A1
1/C
9.9000E-06
1.1700E-05
1.1700E-05

Table 6: Material Properties 03a - Steel Data, Part 1 of 2

Material
A36
A992Fy50

Fy
Kgf/cm2
2531.05
3515.35

Table 6: Material Properties 03a - Steel Data, Part 1 of 2

Fu
EffFy
EffFu SSCurveOpt SSHysType
Kgf/cm2
Kgf/cm2
Kgf/cm2
4077.80
3796.58
4485.58
Simple
Kinematic
4569.95
3866.88
5026.95
Simple
Kinematic

SHard

SMax

0.020000
0.015000

0.140000
0.110000

FinalSlope

FAngle
Degrees
0.000

Table 6: Material Properties 03a - Steel Data, Part 2 of 2

Table 6: Material Properties 03a - Steel
Data, Part 2 of 2
Material
SRup
FinalSlope
A36
A992Fy50

0.200000
0.170000

-0.100000
-0.100000

Table 7: Material Properties 03b - Concrete Data, Part 1 of 2

Material
4000Psi

DEASA

Fc
Kgf/cm2
281.23

Table 7: Material Properties 03b - Concrete Data, Part 1 of 2

LtWtConc
SSCurveOpt SSHysType
SFc
SCap
No

Mander

Takeda

0.002219

0.005000

-0.100000

Page 8 of 26

ESIME
3. Section properties

SAP2000 v14.0.0 AND SOLID WORKS - License #DEA5647

04 febrero 2013

Table 7: Material Properties 03b - Concrete Data, Part 2 of 2

Table 7: Material
Properties 03b - Concrete
Data, Part 2 of 2
Material
DAngle
Degrees
4000Psi
0.000

3. Section properties
This section provides section property information for objects used in the model.

3.1. Frames
Table 8: Frame Section Properties 01 - General, Part 1 of 7
SectionName
FSEC1
L2X2X1/4
L2X2X1/8

Table 8: Frame Section Properties 01 - General, Part 1 of 7

Material
Shape
t3
t2
cm
cm
A992Fy50
I/Wide Flange
30.4800
12.7000
A36
Angle
5.0800
5.0800
A992Fy50
Angle
5.0800
5.0800

tf
cm
0.9652
0.6350
0.3175

tw
cm
0.6350
0.6350
0.3175

I22
cm4
330.13
14.48
7.91

AS2
cm2
19.35
3.23
1.61

R33
cm
12.4145
1.5471
1.5914

R22
cm
2.7823
1.5471
1.5914

Table 8: Frame Section Properties 01 - General, Part 2 of 7

SectionName
FSEC1
L2X2X1/4
L2X2X1/8

Table 8: Frame Section Properties 01 - General, Part 2 of 7

t2b
tfb
Area
TorsConst
I33
cm
cm
cm2
cm4
cm4
12.7000
0.9652
42.65
9.65
6572.42
6.05
0.83
14.48
3.12
0.12
7.91

Table 8: Frame Section Properties 01 - General, Part 3 of 7

SectionName
FSEC1
L2X2X1/4
L2X2X1/8

Table 8: Frame Section Properties 01 - General, Part 3 of 7

AS3
S33
S22
Z33
Z22
cm2
cm3
cm3
cm3
cm3
20.43
431.26
51.99
491.19
80.72
3.23
4.05
4.05
7.29
7.29
1.61
2.15
2.15
3.85
3.85

Table 8: Frame Section Properties 01 - General, Part 4 of 7

SectionName

ConcCol

FSEC1
L2X2X1/4
L2X2X1/8

No
No
No

DEASA

Table 8: Frame Section Properties 01 - General, Part 4 of 7

ConcBeam
Color
TotalWt
TotalMass
Kgf
Kgf-s2/cm
No
Yellow
0.00
0.00
No
Yellow
0.00
0.00
No
Gray8Dark
88.43
9.017E-02

FromFile
No
Yes
Yes

AMod
1.000000
1.000000
1.000000

Page 9 of 26

ESIME
4. Load patterns

SAP2000 v14.0.0 AND SOLID WORKS - License #DEA5647

04 febrero 2013

Table 8: Frame Section Properties 01 - General, Part 5 of 7

SectionName
FSEC1
L2X2X1/4
L2X2X1/8

Table 8: Frame Section Properties 01 - General, Part 5 of 7

A2Mod
A3Mod
JMod
I2Mod
I3Mod
1.000000
1.000000
1.000000

1.000000
1.000000
1.000000

1.000000
1.000000
1.000000

1.000000
1.000000
1.000000

1.000000
1.000000
1.000000

MMod

WMod

1.000000
1.000000
1.000000

1.000000
1.000000
1.000000

Table 8: Frame Section Properties 01 - General, Part 6 of 7

SectionName

Table 8: Frame Section Properties 01 - General, Part 6 of 7

SectInFile
FileName

FSEC1
L2X2X1/4

L2X2X1/4

L2X2X1/8

L2X2X1/8

GUID

c:\program files\computers and

structures\sap2000 14\aisc.pro
c:\program files\computers and
structures\sap2000 14\aisc.pro

Table 8: Frame Section Properties 01 - General, Part 7 of 7

Table 8: Frame Section Properties 01 - General, Part 7 of
7
SectionName
Notes
FSEC1
L2X2X1/4
L2X2X1/8

Added 01/02/2013 06:06:18 p.m.

Imported 01/02/2013 06:09:24 p.m.
from AISC.PRO
Imported 01/02/2013 06:09:38 p.m.
from AISC.PRO

4. Load patterns
This section provides loading information as applied to the model.

4.1. Definitions
Table 9: Load Pattern Definitions
LoadPat

DesignType

DEAD

DEAD

DEASA

Table 9: Load Pattern Definitions

SelfWtMult
AutoLoad
GUID

Notes

1.000000

Page 10 of 26

ESIME
5. Load cases

SAP2000 v14.0.0 AND SOLID WORKS - License #DEA5647

04 febrero 2013

5. Load cases
This section provides load case information.

5.1. Definitions
Table 10: Load Case Definitions, Part 1 of 2
Case

Type

DEAD
MODAL

LinStatic
LinModal

Table 10: Load Case Definitions, Part 1 of 2

InitialCond
ModalCase
BaseCase
DesTypeOpt
Zero
Zero

Prog Det
Prog Det

DesignType

AutoType

DEAD
OTHER

None
None

Table 10: Load Case Definitions, Part 2 of 2

Case

RunCase

DEAD
MODAL

Yes
Yes

Table 10: Load Case Definitions, Part 2 of 2

CaseStatus
GUID

Notes

Finished
Finished

5.2. Static case load assignments

Table 11: Case - Static 1 - Load Assignments
Case
DEAD

Table 11: Case - Static 1 - Load Assignments

LoadType
LoadName
Load pattern

DEAD

LoadSF
1.000000

5.3. Response spectrum case load assignments

Table 12: Function - Response Spectrum - User
Table 12: Function - Response Spectrum - User
Name
Period
Accel
FuncDamp
Sec
UNIFRS
0.000000
1.000000
0.050000
UNIFRS
1.000000
1.000000

DEASA

Page 11 of 26

ESIME
6. Structure results

SAP2000 v14.0.0 AND SOLID WORKS - License #DEA5647

04 febrero 2013

6. Structure results
This section provides structure results, including items such as structural periods and base reactions.

Figure 2: Deformed shape

6.1. Mass summary

Table 13: Assembled Joint Masses
Joint
1
2
3
4
5
6
7

DEASA

U1
Kgf-s2/cm
4.124E-03
7.148E-03
4.124E-03
7.148E-03
4.124E-03
7.148E-03
4.124E-03

Table 13: Assembled Joint Masses

U2
U3
R1
Kgf-s2/cm
Kgf-s2/cm
Kgf-cm-s2
4.124E-03
4.124E-03
0.00
7.148E-03
7.148E-03
0.00
4.124E-03
4.124E-03
0.00
7.148E-03
7.148E-03
0.00
4.124E-03
4.124E-03
0.00
7.148E-03
7.148E-03
0.00
4.124E-03
4.124E-03
0.00

R2
Kgf-cm-s2
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00

R3
Kgf-cm-s2
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00

Page 12 of 26

ESIME
6. Structure results

Joint
8
9
10
11
12

U1
Kgf-s2/cm
7.148E-03
1.127E-02
1.127E-02
1.127E-02
1.127E-02

SAP2000 v14.0.0 AND SOLID WORKS - License #DEA5647

04 febrero 2013
Table 13: Assembled Joint Masses
U2
U3
R1
Kgf-s2/cm
Kgf-s2/cm
Kgf-cm-s2
7.148E-03
7.148E-03
0.00
1.127E-02
1.127E-02
0.00
1.127E-02
1.127E-02
0.00
1.127E-02
1.127E-02
0.00
1.127E-02
1.127E-02
0.00

R2
Kgf-cm-s2
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00

R3
Kgf-cm-s2
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00

6.2. Modal results

Table 14: Modal Participating Mass Ratios, Part 1 of 3
OutputCase

StepType

MODAL
MODAL
MODAL
MODAL
MODAL
MODAL
MODAL
MODAL
MODAL
MODAL
MODAL
MODAL

Mode
Mode
Mode
Mode
Mode
Mode
Mode
Mode
Mode
Mode
Mode
Mode

Table 14: Modal Participating Mass Ratios, Part 1 of 3

StepNum
Period
UX
UY
UZ
Sec
1.000000
0.842266
1.082E-08
0.99
0.00
2.000000
0.842266
0.99
1.082E-08
0.00
3.000000
0.840142
1.781E-19
4.778E-19
0.00
4.000000
0.197166
5.055E-10
8.140E-03
0.00
5.000000
0.197166
8.140E-03
5.055E-10
0.00
6.000000
0.195742
0.00
0.00
0.00
7.000000
0.044798
0.00
0.00
0.00
8.000000
0.035791
0.00
0.00
0.00
9.000000
0.006692
1.252E-20
0.00
0.96
10.000000
0.006664
3.053E-08
1.881E-08
7.863E-14
11.000000
0.006664
1.881E-08
3.053E-08
1.927E-13
12.000000
0.006637
2.541E-20
1.385E-20
1.523E-13

SumUX

SumUY

1.082E-08
0.99
0.99
0.99
1.00
1.00
1.00
1.00
1.00
1.00
1.00
1.00

0.99
0.99
0.99
1.00
1.00
1.00
1.00
1.00
1.00
1.00
1.00
1.00

RZ

SumRX

SumRY

0.25
0.25
0.50
2.036E-03
2.034E-03
3.903E-03
0.00
0.00
0.00
3.531E-10
2.432E-08
0.00

0.91
0.91
0.91
0.97
0.97
0.97
0.97
0.97
0.98
0.99
1.00
1.00

9.947E-09
0.91
0.91
0.91
0.97
0.97
0.97
0.97
0.98
0.99
1.00
1.00

Table 14: Modal Participating Mass Ratios, Part 2 of 3

OutputCase

StepType

MODAL
MODAL
MODAL
MODAL
MODAL
MODAL
MODAL
MODAL
MODAL
MODAL
MODAL
MODAL

Mode
Mode
Mode
Mode
Mode
Mode
Mode
Mode
Mode
Mode
Mode
Mode

DEASA

Table 14: Modal Participating Mass Ratios, Part 2 of 3

StepNum
SumUZ
RX
RY
1.000000
2.000000
3.000000
4.000000
5.000000
6.000000
7.000000
8.000000
9.000000
10.000000
11.000000
12.000000

0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.96
0.96
0.96
0.96

0.91
9.947E-09
4.394E-19
5.825E-02
3.617E-09
0.00
0.00
0.00
1.449E-02
5.431E-03
8.816E-03
1.235E-14

9.947E-09
0.91
1.638E-19
3.617E-09
5.825E-02
0.00
0.00
0.00
1.449E-02
8.816E-03
5.431E-03
1.784E-14

Page 13 of 26

ESIME
7. Joint results

SAP2000 v14.0.0 AND SOLID WORKS - License #DEA5647

04 febrero 2013

Table 14: Modal Participating Mass Ratios, Part 3 of 3

Table 14: Modal Participating Mass Ratios, Part 3 of 3
OutputCase
StepType
StepNum
SumRZ
MODAL
MODAL
MODAL
MODAL
MODAL
MODAL
MODAL
MODAL
MODAL
MODAL
MODAL
MODAL

Mode
Mode
Mode
Mode
Mode
Mode
Mode
Mode
Mode
Mode
Mode
Mode

1.000000
2.000000
3.000000
4.000000
5.000000
6.000000
7.000000
8.000000
9.000000
10.000000
11.000000
12.000000

0.25
0.50
0.99
0.99
1.00
1.00
1.00
1.00
1.00
1.00
1.00
1.00

6.3. Base reactions

Table 15: Base Reactions, Part 1 of 3
OutputCase

CaseType

DEAD

LinStatic

GlobalFX
Kgf
8.882E-16

Table 15: Base Reactions, Part 1 of 3

GlobalFY
GlobalFZ
GlobalMX
Kgf
Kgf
Kgf-cm
0.00
3670.03
222036.77

GlobalMY
Kgf-cm
-222036.77

GlobalMZ
Kgf-cm
-1.137E-13

GlobalX
cm
0.000

XCentroidF
Y
cm
-1.137E-13

YCentroidF
Y
cm
-655.467

ZCentroidF
Y
cm
0.000

Table 15: Base Reactions, Part 2 of 3

OutputCase

DEAD

GlobalY

GlobalZ

cm
0.000

cm
0.000

Table 15: Base Reactions, Part 2 of 3

XCentroidF
YCentroidF
ZCentroidF
X
X
X
cm
cm
cm
-7.380E+17
0.000
0.000

Table 15: Base Reactions, Part 3 of 3

Table 15: Base Reactions, Part 3 of 3
XCentroidF
YCentroidF ZCentroidFZ
OutputCase
Z
Z
cm
cm
cm
DEAD
60.500
60.500
0.000

7. Joint results
This section provides joint results, including items such as displacements and reactions.

DEASA

Page 14 of 26

ESIME
8. Frame results

SAP2000 v14.0.0 AND SOLID WORKS - License #DEA5647

04 febrero 2013

Table 16: Joint Displacements

Joint

OutputCase

CaseType

1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12

DEAD
DEAD
DEAD
DEAD
DEAD
DEAD
DEAD
DEAD
DEAD
DEAD
DEAD
DEAD

LinStatic
LinStatic
LinStatic
LinStatic
LinStatic
LinStatic
LinStatic
LinStatic
LinStatic
LinStatic
LinStatic
LinStatic

Table 16: Joint Displacements

U1
U2
U3
cm
cm
cm
0.000000
0.000000
0.000000
0.000124
-0.000124
-0.070916
0.000000
0.000000
0.000000
0.000124
0.000124
-0.070916
0.000000
0.000000
0.000000
-0.000124
0.000124
-0.070916
0.000000
0.000000
0.000000
-0.000124
-0.000124
-0.070916
0.000098
-0.000098
-0.047347
0.000098
0.000098
-0.047347
-0.000098
0.000098
-0.047347
-0.000098
-0.000098
-0.047347

R1
Radians
-0.003047
0.008553
0.003047
-0.008553
0.003047
-0.008553
-0.003047
0.008553
-0.006099
0.006099
0.006099
-0.006099

R2
Radians
-0.003047
0.008553
-0.003047
0.008553
0.003047
-0.008553
0.003047
-0.008553
-0.006099
-0.006099
0.006099
0.006099

R3
Radians
-1.356E-16
-2.739E-16
-1.356E-16
-2.739E-16
-1.356E-16
-2.739E-16
-1.356E-16
-2.739E-16
-1.356E-16
-1.356E-16
-1.356E-16
-1.356E-16

M1
Kgf-cm
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00

M2
Kgf-cm
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00

M3
Kgf-cm
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00

V3
Kgf
2.71
2.71
13.00
13.00
-2.71
-2.71
-13.00
-13.00
-2.71
-2.71
-13.00
-13.00
2.71
2.71
13.00
13.00

T
Kgf-cm
0.00
0.00
-4.103E-14
-4.103E-14
0.00
0.00
-4.103E-14
-4.103E-14
0.00
0.00
-4.103E-14
-4.103E-14
4.920E-20
4.920E-20
-4.102E-14
-4.102E-14

M2
Kgf-cm
0.00
-893.82
2024.77
-2264.58
0.00
893.82
-2024.77
2264.58
0.00
893.82
-2024.77
2264.58
1.137E-13
-893.82
2024.77
-2264.58

Table 17: Joint Reactions

Joint

OutputCase

CaseType

1
3
5
7

DEAD
DEAD
DEAD
DEAD

LinStatic
LinStatic
LinStatic
LinStatic

Table 17: Joint Reactions

F1
F2
Kgf
Kgf
2.71
-2.71
2.71
2.71
-2.71
2.71
-2.71
-2.71

F3
Kgf
917.51
917.51
917.51
917.51

8. Frame results
This section provides frame force results.

Table 18: Element Forces - Frames, Part 1 of 2

Frame
1
1
1
1
2
2
2
2
3
3
3
3
4
4
4
4

DEASA

Station
cm
0.000
330.000
330.000
660.000
0.000
330.000
330.000
660.000
0.000
330.000
330.000
660.000
0.000
330.000
330.000
660.000

OutputCase
DEAD
DEAD
DEAD
DEAD
DEAD
DEAD
DEAD
DEAD
DEAD
DEAD
DEAD
DEAD
DEAD
DEAD
DEAD
DEAD

Table 18: Element Forces - Frames, Part 1 of 2

CaseType
P
V2
Kgf
Kgf
LinStatic
-917.51
-2.71
LinStatic
-909.42
-2.71
LinStatic
-458.75
-13.00
LinStatic
-450.67
-13.00
LinStatic
-917.51
-2.71
LinStatic
-909.42
-2.71
LinStatic
-458.75
-13.00
LinStatic
-450.67
-13.00
LinStatic
-917.51
2.71
LinStatic
-909.42
2.71
LinStatic
-458.75
13.00
LinStatic
-450.67
13.00
LinStatic
-917.51
2.71
LinStatic
-909.42
2.71
LinStatic
-458.75
13.00
LinStatic
-450.67
13.00

Page 15 of 26

ESIME
8. Frame results

Frame
5
5
5
5
6
6
6
6
7
7
7
7
8
8
8
8
9
9
9
9
10
10
10
10
11
11
11
11
12
12
12
12

SAP2000 v14.0.0 AND SOLID WORKS - License #DEA5647

04 febrero 2013

Station
cm
0.000
40.333
80.667
121.000
0.000
40.333
80.667
121.000
0.000
40.333
80.667
121.000
0.000
40.333
80.667
121.000
0.000
40.333
80.667
121.000
0.000
40.333
80.667
121.000
0.000
40.333
80.667
121.000
0.000
40.333
80.667
121.000

OutputCase
DEAD
DEAD
DEAD
DEAD
DEAD
DEAD
DEAD
DEAD
DEAD
DEAD
DEAD
DEAD
DEAD
DEAD
DEAD
DEAD
DEAD
DEAD
DEAD
DEAD
DEAD
DEAD
DEAD
DEAD
DEAD
DEAD
DEAD
DEAD
DEAD
DEAD
DEAD
DEAD

Table 18: Element Forces - Frames, Part 1 of 2

CaseType
P
V2
Kgf
Kgf
LinStatic
-13.00
-225.33
LinStatic
-13.00
-75.11
LinStatic
-13.00
75.11
LinStatic
-13.00
225.33
LinStatic
-13.00
-225.33
LinStatic
-13.00
-75.11
LinStatic
-13.00
75.11
LinStatic
-13.00
225.33
LinStatic
-13.00
-225.33
LinStatic
-13.00
-75.11
LinStatic
-13.00
75.11
LinStatic
-13.00
225.33
LinStatic
-13.00
-225.33
LinStatic
-13.00
-75.11
LinStatic
-13.00
75.11
LinStatic
-13.00
225.33
LinStatic
10.29
-225.33
LinStatic
10.29
-75.11
LinStatic
10.29
75.11
LinStatic
10.29
225.33
LinStatic
10.29
-225.33
LinStatic
10.29
-75.11
LinStatic
10.29
75.11
LinStatic
10.29
225.33
LinStatic
10.29
-225.33
LinStatic
10.29
-75.11
LinStatic
10.29
75.11
LinStatic
10.29
225.33
LinStatic
10.29
-225.33
LinStatic
10.29
-75.11
LinStatic
10.29
75.11
LinStatic
10.29
225.33

V3
Kgf
2.862E-16
2.862E-16
2.862E-16
2.862E-16
5.291E-16
5.291E-16
5.291E-16
5.291E-16
4.510E-16
4.510E-16
4.510E-16
4.510E-16
3.626E-16
3.626E-16
3.626E-16
3.626E-16
-3.261E-16
-3.261E-16
-3.261E-16
-3.261E-16
-3.504E-16
-3.504E-16
-3.504E-16
-3.504E-16
-2.793E-16
-2.793E-16
-2.793E-16
-2.793E-16
-4.007E-16
-4.007E-16
-4.007E-16
-4.007E-16

T
Kgf-cm
4.174E-14
4.174E-14
4.174E-14
4.174E-14
3.819E-14
3.819E-14
3.819E-14
3.819E-14
4.086E-14
4.086E-14
4.086E-14
4.086E-14
4.174E-14
4.174E-14
4.174E-14
4.174E-14
4.086E-14
4.086E-14
4.086E-14
4.086E-14
4.263E-14
4.263E-14
4.263E-14
4.263E-14
4.086E-14
4.086E-14
4.086E-14
4.086E-14
4.174E-14
4.174E-14
4.174E-14
4.174E-14

M2
Kgf-cm
1.987E-14
8.328E-15
-3.216E-15
-1.476E-14
2.609E-14
4.750E-15
-1.659E-14
-3.793E-14
3.331E-14
1.512E-14
-3.076E-15
-2.127E-14
1.965E-14
5.028E-15
-9.595E-15
-2.422E-14
-2.032E-14
-7.163E-15
5.991E-15
1.914E-14
-2.176E-14
-7.627E-15
6.506E-15
2.064E-14
-1.654E-14
-5.278E-15
5.987E-15
1.725E-14
-2.365E-14
-7.485E-15
8.677E-15
2.484E-14

Table 18: Element Forces - Frames, Part 2 of 2

Frame
1
1
1
1
2
2
2
2
3
3
3
3
4
4
4

DEASA

Table 18: Element Forces - Frames, Part 2 of 2

Station OutputCase
M3
FrameElem
cm
Kgf-cm
0.000
DEAD
0.00
1-1
330.000
DEAD
893.82
1-1
330.000
DEAD
-2024.77
1-2
660.000
DEAD
2264.58
1-2
0.000
DEAD
0.00
2-1
330.000
DEAD
893.82
2-1
330.000
DEAD
-2024.77
2-2
660.000
DEAD
2264.58
2-2
0.000
DEAD
0.00
3-1
330.000
DEAD
-893.82
3-1
330.000
DEAD
2024.77
3-2
660.000
DEAD
-2264.58
3-2
0.000
DEAD
0.00
4-1
330.000
DEAD
-893.82
4-1
330.000
DEAD
2024.77
4-2

ElemStation
cm
0.000
330.000
0.000
330.000
0.000
330.000
0.000
330.000
0.000
330.000
0.000
330.000
0.000
330.000
0.000

Page 16 of 26

ESIME

Frame
4
5
5
5
5
6
6
6
6
7
7
7
7
8
8
8
8
9
9
9
9
10
10
10
10
11
11
11
11
12
12
12
12

SAP2000 v14.0.0 AND SOLID WORKS - License #DEA5647

04 febrero 2013
Table 18: Element Forces - Frames, Part 2 of 2
Station OutputCase
M3
FrameElem
cm
Kgf-cm
660.000
DEAD
-2264.58
4-2
0.000
DEAD
-2264.58
5-1
40.333
DEAD
3794.37
5-1
80.667
DEAD
3794.37
5-1
121.000
DEAD
-2264.58
5-1
0.000
DEAD
-2264.58
6-1
40.333
DEAD
3794.37
6-1
80.667
DEAD
3794.37
6-1
121.000
DEAD
-2264.58
6-1
0.000
DEAD
-2264.58
7-1
40.333
DEAD
3794.37
7-1
80.667
DEAD
3794.37
7-1
121.000
DEAD
-2264.58
7-1
0.000
DEAD
-2264.58
8-1
40.333
DEAD
3794.37
8-1
80.667
DEAD
3794.37
8-1
121.000
DEAD
-2264.58
8-1
0.000
DEAD
-2918.59
9-1
40.333
DEAD
3140.35
9-1
80.667
DEAD
3140.35
9-1
121.000
DEAD
-2918.59
9-1
0.000
DEAD
-2918.59
10-1
40.333
DEAD
3140.35
10-1
80.667
DEAD
3140.35
10-1
121.000
DEAD
-2918.59
10-1
0.000
DEAD
-2918.59
11-1
40.333
DEAD
3140.35
11-1
80.667
DEAD
3140.35
11-1
121.000
DEAD
-2918.59
11-1
0.000
DEAD
-2918.59
12-1
40.333
DEAD
3140.35
12-1
80.667
DEAD
3140.35
12-1
121.000
DEAD
-2918.59
12-1

ElemStation
cm
330.000
0.000
40.333
80.667
121.000
0.000
40.333
80.667
121.000
0.000
40.333
80.667
121.000
0.000
40.333
80.667
121.000
0.000
40.333
80.667
121.000
0.000
40.333
80.667
121.000
0.000
40.333
80.667
121.000
0.000
40.333
80.667
121.000

9. Material take-off
This section provides a material take-off.

Table 19: Material List 2 - By Section Property

Section
L2X2X1/8

DEASA

Table 19: Material List 2 - By Section Property

ObjectType
NumPieces TotalLength TotalWeight
cm
Kgf
Frame
12
3608.000
88.43

Page 17 of 26

ESIME
10. Design preferences

SAP2000 v14.0.0 AND SOLID WORKS - License #DEA5647

04 febrero 2013

10. Design preferences

This section provides the design preferences for each type of design, which typically include material reduction
factors, framing type, stress ratio limit, deflection limits, and other code specific items.

10.1. Steel design

Table 20: Preferences - Steel Design - AISC-LRFD93, Part 1 of 2
THDesign

FrameType

Envelopes

Moment
Frame

Table 20: Preferences - Steel Design - AISC-LRFD93, Part 1 of 2

PatLLF
SRatioLimit
MaxIter
PhiB
PhiC
0.750000

0.950000

0.900000

0.850000

PhiT

PhiV

0.900000

0.900000

Table 20: Preferences - Steel Design - AISC-LRFD93, Part 2 of 2

PhiCA

0.900000

Table 20: Preferences - Steel Design - AISC-LRFD93, Part 2 of 2

CheckDefl
DLRat SDLAndLLR
LLRat
TotalRat
at
Yes

120.000000

120.000000

360.000000

240.000000

NetRat

240.000000

11. REVISION SOLID WORKS

N
1

DEASA

Nombre de slido
Slido 2(Saliente-Extruir30)

Material
ASTM A36 Acero

Masa
69.9603 kg

Volumen
0.00891214 m^3

Page 18 of 26

ESIME
11. REVISION SOLID WORKS

SAP2000 v14.0.0 AND SOLID WORKS - License #DEA5647

04 febrero 2013

1. Informacin de cargas y restricciones

Sujecin
Fijo-4 <Racks>

activar 4 Cara(s) fijo.

Carga
Presin-1
<Racks>

activar 1 Cara(s) con presin 7300

N/m^2 a lo largo de la direccin normal a
la cara seleccionada

2. Propiedad del estudio

Informacin de malla

DEASA

Tipo de malla:

Malla slida

Mallador utilizado:

Malla estndar

Transicin automtica:

Desactivar

Superficie suave:

Activar

Verificacin jacobiana:

4 Points

Tamao de elementos:

27.703 mm

Tolerancia:

1.3851 mm

Page 19 of 26

ESIME
11. REVISION SOLID WORKS

SAP2000 v14.0.0 AND SOLID WORKS - License #DEA5647

04 febrero 2013

Calidad:

Alta

Nmero de elementos:

23213

Nmero de nodos:

52091

Tiempo para completar la malla (hh;mm;ss):

00:00:32

Nombre de computadora:

KIKE25

Informacin del solver

Calidad:

Alta

Tipo de solver:

Solver tipo FFEPlus

3. Resultados
3a. Tensiones

Nombre

Tipo

Mn.

Ubicacin

Mx.

(1085.31
mm,
Stress

VON: Tensin de von

Mises

116.467
N/m^2

1648.5
mm,
1099.21
mm)

DEASA

Ubicacin
(1050.37
mm,

2.6596e+007
N/m^2

-1628.63
mm,
-22.2893
mm)

Page 20 of 26

ESIME
11. REVISION SOLID WORKS

SAP2000 v14.0.0 AND SOLID WORKS - License #DEA5647

04 febrero 2013

Fallan columnas por fatiga

DEASA

Page 21 of 26

ESIME
11. REVISION SOLID WORKS

SAP2000 v14.0.0 AND SOLID WORKS - License #DEA5647

04 febrero 2013

3b. Desplazamientos

Nombre

Tipo

Mn.

Ubicacin

Mx.

(1159.69
mm,
Displacement

URES: Desplazamiento
resultante

0
mm

1650 mm,
-31.7945
mm)

DEASA

Ubicacin
(1065.46
mm,

1.17534
mm

-1325.4 mm,
559.886
mm)

Page 22 of 26

ESIME
12. Recomendaciones de resultados

SAP2000 v14.0.0 AND SOLID WORKS - License #DEA5647

04 febrero 2013

12. Recomendaciones de resultados

DEASA

Nombre de material:

ASTM A36 Acero

Descripcin:

Fallan elemento verticales por pandeo

recomendacin

Cambiar configuracin de perfil o bien aumentar el

calibre

Tipo de modelo del material:

Isotrpico elstico lineal

Criterio de error
predeterminado:

Tensin mxima de von Mises

Nombre de propiedad

Valor

Unidades

Mdulo elstico

2e+011

N/m^2

Coeficiente de Poisson

0.26

NA

Mdulo cortante

7.93e+010

N/m^2

Densidad

7850

kg/m^3

Lmite de traccin

4e+008

N/m^2

Lmite elstico

2.5e+008

N/m^2

Page 23 of 26

ESIME
13. Conclusiones

SAP2000 v14.0.0 AND SOLID WORKS - License #DEA5647

04 febrero 2013

13. Conclusiones
De acuerdo al anlisis obtenido; debe cambiarse el espesor del perfil que se usa como
columna a ; o bien cambien la geometra de la seccin ya que dicha seccin es muy dbil;
pudiera someterse a cargas y no fallar en el instante; sin embargo el colapso puede llegar
despus de un determinado tiempo que es impredecible, para este caso las columnas fallan
por pandeo; el hecho de que se les cargue por primera vez y no colapsen, no exime de la
cantidad de esfuerzo a que estn sometidos y de acuerdo a la memoria de clculo el pandeo y
posterior colapso vendr con el tiempo; el pandeo no indica que el material fallo; pero si lo
deja ms vulnerable y con peligro a colapsar; as mismo la manufactura debe apegarse ms a
las especificaciones del (AISC; American Institute Steel Construction); ya que la soldadura
est incompleta; as mismo los cortes no son los correctos y muchos cordones de soldadura
tienen poros, socavados y faltas de fusin; se recomienda que sean apegados a las normas
de calidad y revisados por un inspector certificado o una Institucin acreditada; as mismo las
vigas aunque en menor medida tambin presentan problemas por la falta de material; ojala
hubiera una memoria de calculo que respalde el diseo para compararlo con la presente y
darnos cuenta los criterios de diseo. Los racks no son adecuados para la cantidad de
carga a soportar debe cambiarse el espesor del material o bien cambiarse la geometra
de la seccin; as como mejorar en mucho la manufactura

DEASA

Page 24 of 26

ESIME
13. Conclusiones

DEASA

SAP2000 v14.0.0 AND SOLID WORKS - License #DEA5647

04 febrero 2013

Page 25 of 26

ESIME
13. Conclusiones

DEASA

SAP2000 v14.0.0 AND SOLID WORKS - License #DEA5647

04 febrero 2013

Page 26 of 26