IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT FOR THE DISTRICT OF DELAWARE DATA SPEED TECHNOLOGY LLC, Plaintiff, v.

MINDJET LLC, Defendant. ) ) ) ) ) ) ) ) )

C.A. No. ________________ JURY TRIAL DEMANDED

COMPLAINT FOR PATENT INFRINGEMENT T i! i! an a"tion fo# $atent inf#in%e&ent in ' i" Plaintiff Data S$eed Te" nolo%( LLC &a)e! t e follo'in% alle%ation! a%ain!t Defendant MindJet LLC. BACKGROUND *. +ennet H. Conne# i! a life,lon% "o&$-te# en%inee# 'it )no'led%e and

e.$e#ien"e 'it

&an( te" nolo%ie! in"l-din%/ &ainf#a&e "o&$-te#!, a$$li"ation !oft'a#e, T i! e.$e#ien"e "o&e! f#o&

o$e#atin% !(!te&!, "ell-la# "o&&-ni"ation!, and net'o#)in%.

'o#)in% 'it te" nolo%( %iant! in"l-din% Di%ital E0-i$&ent Co#$o#ation, A#%onne National La1o#ato#(, 2ell La1!, Moto#ola, and L-"ent. In ea#l( *334, M#. Conne#, alon% 'it Ja&e!. G H-nte#, G#e%o#( P. S$a# and 2#-"e Ande#!on invented a ne' info#&ation &ana%e&ent and !to#a%e !(!te& t at ena1led &-lti$le "o&$-te#! to inde$endentl( #ead and '#ite to a &a!! !to#a%e devi"e in a #elativel( i% !$eed &anne# on a fi#!t "o&e, #eal ti&e 1a!i!. 5o# e.a&$le, t e "o&$-te# fi#!t a""e!!in% a $a#ti"-la# &e&o#( add#e!! !$a"e o# file 'o-ld ave t e e."l-!ive a1ilit( to '#ite to t at file and t e file 'o-ld 1e lo")ed to !-1!e0-ent "o&$-te#! atte&$tin% to '#ite to it, ' i" allo'ed &-lti$le "o&$-te#! to -!e a &a!! !to#a%e devi"e in a i% !$eed &anne# 'it o-t "onfli"t. 2( t e !-&&e# of *334, t e tea& ad develo$ed a 'o#)in% f-n"tional $#otot($e of t ei# invention. On Nove&1e# 3, *334, t e tea& filed an a$$li"ation fo# $atent on

t e invention, and on 5e1#-a#( 6, *333, t e 7.S. Patent and T#ade&a#) Offi"e i!!-ed 7.S. Patent No. 8,9:;,:9: <t e =Conne# Patent>). PARTIES 6. Plaintiff Data S$eed Te" nolo%( LLC <=Data S$eed Te" >) i! a Dela'a#e li&ited

lia1ilit( "o&$an(. 4. On info#&ation and 1elief, MindJet LLC. <=Defendant>) i! a Califo#nia

"o#$o#ation, avin% an add#e!! at **:? 2atte#( St., @t 5loo#, San 5#an"i!"o, Califo#nia 3@***. JURISDICTION AND VENUE @. T i! a"tion a#i!e! -nde# t e $atent la'! of t e 7nited State!, 48 7.S.C. A *, et

seq., in"l-din% A 6;*. T i! Co-#t a! !-1Be"t &atte# B-#i!di"tion $-#!-ant to 69 7.S.C. AA *44* and *449<a). 8. T i! Co-#t a! !$e"ifi" and %ene#al $e#!onal B-#i!di"tion ove# Defendant 1e"a-!e,

a&on% ot e# #ea!on!, Defendant a! availed it!elf of t e #i% t! and 1enefit! of Dela'a#e 1( in"o#$o#atin% -nde# Dela'a#e la', Defendant a! done 1-!ine!! in t i! Di!t#i"t, a! "o&&itted and "ontin-e! to "o&&it a"t! of $atent inf#in%e&ent in t i! Di!t#i"t, and a! a#&ed and

"ontin-e! to a#& Data S$eed Te" in t i! Di!t#i"t, 1(, a&on% ot e# t in%!, -!in%, !ellin%, offe#in% fo# !ale, and i&$o#tin% inf#in%in% $#od-"t! and !e#vi"e! in t i! Di!t#i"t. :. Cen-e i! $#o$e# in t i! di!t#i"t -nde# 69 7.S.C. AA *43*<1),<d) and *@??<1)

1e"a-!e, a&on% ot e# #ea!on!, Defendant i! in"o#$o#ated in t i! di!t#i"t, Defendant i! !-1Be"t to $e#!onal B-#i!di"tion in t i! Di!t#i"t, and Defendant a! "o&&itted and "ontin-e! to "o&&it a"t! of $atent inf#in%e&ent in t i! Di!t#i"t. On info#&ation and 1elief, fo# e.a&$le, Defendant a! -!ed, !old, offe#ed fo# !ale, and i&$o#ted inf#in%in% $#od-"t! in t i! Di!t#i"t.

COUNT I INFRINGEMENT OF U.S. PATENT NO. 5,867,686 ;. Data S$eed Te" i! t e o'ne# 1( a!!i%n&ent of t e Conne# Patent, entitled =Hi%

S$eed Deal,Ti&e Info#&ation Sto#a%e S(!te&.> A t#-e and "o##e"t "o$( of t e Conne# Patent i! atta" ed a! E. i1it A. 9. Defendant a! 1een and no' i! di#e"tl( inf#in%in% t e Conne# Patent, lite#all( and

-nde# t e do"t#ine of e0-ivalent!, in t i! B-di"ial Di!t#i"t and el!e' e#e in t e 7nited State! 1(, a&on% ot e# t in%!, &a)in%, -!in%, i&$o#tin%, offe#in% fo# !ale, andEo# !ellin% ele"t#oni" info#&ation &ana%e&ent and !to#a%e $#od-"t! and !e#vi"e! t at -!e a &et od of $#ovidin% &e&o#( a""e!! to a &e&o#( &a!! !to#a%e devi"e 1( a $l-#alit( of "o&$-te#!, ea" f-n"tionin% -nde# an inde$endent o$e#atin% !(!te&, and !-" &et od "o&$#i!in% t e !te$! of/ #e"eivin% a '#ite a""e!! #e0-e!t identif(in% a &e&o#( !$a"e f#o& a #e0-e!tin% "o&$-te# of t e $l-#alit( of "o&$-te#! 1( t e &e&o#( &a!! !to#a%e devi"eF %#antin% a""e!! and #e!e#vin% t e &e&o#( !$a"e fo# t e e."l-!ive -!e of t e #e0-e!tin% "o&$-te# and den(in% '#ite a""e!! to t e &e&o#( !$a"e 1( an( ot e# "o&$-te# of t e $l-#alit( of "o&$-te#! fo# t e d-#ation of t e a""e!! %#ant to t e #e0-e!tin% "o&$-te#F and #e"eivin% a '#ite a""e!! #e0-e!t and a #e0-i#ed &e&o#( !iGe f#o& a !e"ond #e0-e!tin% "o&$-te# of t e $l-#alit( of "o&$-te#!. In addition and alte#nativel(,

Defendant i! inf#in%in% 1(, a&on% ot e# t in%!, &a)in%, -!in%, i&$o#tin%, offe#in% fo# !ale, andEo# !ellin% ele"t#oni" info#&ation &ana%e&ent and !to#a%e $#od-"t! and !e#vi"e!, "o&$#i!in%/ a &e&o#( &a!! !to#a%e devi"eF a $l-#alit( of "o&$-te#!, ea" f-n"tionin% -nde# an inde$endent o$e#atin% !(!te&, o$e#a1l( "onne"ted to t e &e&o#( &a!! !to#a%e devi"e t #o-% an e.te#nal 1-!F a "o&&-ni"ation $#o"e!!o# of t e &e&o#( &a!! !to#a%e devi"e o$e#a1l( "onne"ted to t e $l-#alit( of "o&$-te#! t #o-% t e e.te#nal 1-! fo# #e"eivin% an a""e!! #e0-e!t f#o& a #e0-e!tin% "o&$-te# of t e $l-#alit( of "o&$-te#! identif(in% a &e&o#( !$a"e of t e &e&o#( &a!! !to#a%e
4

devi"eF a "ont#olle# of t e &e&o#( &a!! !to#a%e devi"e o$e#a1l( "onne"ted to t e "o&&-ni"ation $#o"e!!o# fo# %#antin% e."l-!ive '#ite a""e!! to t e identified &e&o#( !$a"e 1( t e #e0-e!tin% "o&$-te# fo# a d-#ation of t e a""e!! %#ant to t e #e0-e!tin% "o&$-te#F and a d(na&i" &e&o#( &a$ "ontainin% a li!tin% of t e identified &e&o#( !$a"e. T e inf#in%in% $#od-"t! and !e#vi"e! in"l-de, fo# e.a&$le, DefendantH! $#o%#a& entitled MindJet MindMana%e#. 3. 2( en%a%in% in t e "ond-"t de!"#i1ed e#ein, Defendant a! inB-#ed Data S$eed

Te" and i! t -! lia1le fo# inf#in%e&ent of t e Conne# Patent $-#!-ant to 48 7.S.C. A 6;*<a). *?. **. Defendant "o&&itted t e!e a"t! of inf#in%e&ent 'it o-t li"en!e o# a-t o#iGation. A! a #e!-lt of DefendantH! inf#in%e&ent of t e Conne# Patent, Data S$eed Te"

a! !-ffe#ed &oneta#( da&a%e! and i! entitled to a &one( B-d%&ent in an a&o-nt ade0-ate to "o&$en!ate fo# DefendantH! inf#in%e&ent, 1-t in no event le!! t an a #ea!ona1le #o(alt( fo# t e -!e of t e invention 1( Defendant, to%et e# 'it inte#e!t and "o!t! a! fi.ed 1( t e Co-#t. Data S$eed Te" 'ill "ontin-e to !-ffe# da&a%e! in t e f-t-#e -nle!! DefendantH! inf#in%in% a"tivitie! a#e enBoined 1( t i! Co-#t. *6. Data S$eed Te" a! !-ffe#ed and 'ill "ontin-e to !-ffe# !eve#e and i##e$a#a1le

a#& -nle!! t i! Co-#t i!!-e! a $e#&anent inB-n"tion $#o i1itin% Defendant, it! a%ent!, !e#vant!, e&$lo(ee!, #e$#e!entative!, and all ot e#! a"tin% in a"tive "on"e#t t e#e'it , f#o& inf#in%in% t e Conne# Patent. PRAYER FOR RELIEF Data S$eed Te" #e!$e"tf-ll( #e0-e!t! t at t i! Co-#t ente#/ A. PatentF A B-d%&ent in favo# of Data S$eed Te" t at Defendant a! inf#in%ed t e Conne#

2.

A $e#&anent inB-n"tion enBoinin% Defendant and it! offi"e#!, di#e"to#!, a%ent!,

!e#vant!, affiliate!, e&$lo(ee!, divi!ion!, 1#an" e!, !-1!idia#ie!, $a#ent!, and all ot e#! a"tin% in a"tive "on"e#t t e#e'it f#o& inf#in%e&ent of t e Conne# Patent, o# !-" ot e# e0-ita1le #elief t e Co-#t dete#&ine! i! 'a##antedF C. A B-d%&ent and o#de# #e0-i#in% Defendant to $a( Data S$eed Te" it! da&a%e!,

"o!t!, e.$en!e!, and $#eB-d%&ent and $o!t,B-d%&ent inte#e!t fo# DefendantH! inf#in%e&ent of t e Conne# Patent a! $#ovided -nde# 48 7.S.C. A 69@, and an a""o-ntin% of on%oin% $o!t,B-d%&ent inf#in%e&entF D. A B-d%&ent and o#de# findin% t at t i! i! an e."e$tional "a!e 'it in t e &eanin%

of 48 7.S.C. A 698 and a'a#din% to Data S$eed Te" it! #ea!ona1le atto#ne(!H fee! a%ain!t DefendantF E. A B-d%&ent and o#de# #e0-i#in% Defendant to $#ovide an a""o-ntin% and to $a(

!-$$le&ental da&a%e! to Data S$eed Te" , in"l-din% 'it o-t li&itation, $#eB-d%&ent and $o!t, B-d%&ent inte#e!tF and 5. An( and all ot e# #elief to ' i" Data S$eed Te" &a( 1e entitled. DEMAND FOR JURY TRIAL Data S$eed Te" , -nde# D-le 49 of t e 5ede#al D-le! of Civil P#o"ed-#e, #e0-e!t! a t#ial 1( B-#( of an( i!!-e! !o t#ia1le 1( #i% t.

Dated/ Jan-a#( *@, 6?*@ Of Co-n!el/ Ale. C.D. GiGa Ma#" A. 5en!te# Do#ian S. 2e#%e# D7SS A7G7ST I +A2AT *6@6@ Jil! i#e 2o-leva#d, *6t 5loo# Lo! An%ele!, CA 3??68 <4*?) 96:,;@;@ a%iGaK#a)la'."o& &fen!te#K#a)la'."o& d1e#%e#K#a)la'."o&

2AYADD, P.A. /s/ Stephen B. Brauerman (sb4952) Di" a#d D. +i#) <#)?366) Ste$ en 2. 2#a-e#&an <!1@386) Cane!!a D. Ti#adente! <vt8439) 666 Dela'a#e Aven-e, S-ite 3?? P.O. 2o. 68*4? Jil&in%ton, DE *3933 <4?6) :88,8??? #)i#)K1a(a#dla'."o& !1#a-e#&anK1a(a#dla'."o& vti#adente!K 1a(a#dla'."o&

Attorneys for Plaintiff Data Spee !e"hnolo#y $$%