REPUBLIC OF THE PHILIPPINES NATIONAL CAPITAL JUDICIAL REGION METROPOLITAN TRIAL COURT OF QUEZON CITY Quezon City, Bran

! "#

BERNARD E. ROQUE Plaintiff, #ve s$s# PEDRO %. &ANTO&, Defen'ant. (##########################( COMPLAINT

Civil Case No. Fo ! E"ECTMENT

P$ainti%%, &y t!e un'er(i)ne' oun(e$ an' unto t!i( Honora&$e Court, re(*e t%u$$y (tate( t!at+ ,- P$ainti%% i( o% $e)a$ a)e, .arrie' an' *re(ent$y re(i'in) at No- "# /a$i)aya St- Br)y- 0ati*unan Quezon City1 2- De%en'ant i( $i3e4i(e o% $e)a$ a)e, Fi$i*ino an' *re(ent$y re(i'in) at No- ""# Na5y Roa', 6eteran( 6i$$a)e, Br)y- Ho$y S*irit, Quezon City, 4!ere !e .ay &e (er5e' 4it! (u..on( an' ot!er ourt *ro e((e(1 "- P$ainti%% i( t!e re)i(tere' o4ner o% a *ar e$ o% $an' $o ate' at No- ""# Na5y Roa', 6eteran( 6i$$a)e, Br)y- Ho$y S*irit, Quezon City, ontainin) an area o% #77 (8 .eter(, .ore or $e((, 4it! TCT No- RT9 ":;2< =,>##7,?, o*y o% 4!i ! i( !ereto atta !e' an' .ar3e' a( Anne( A1 #- De%en'ant i( o u*yin) t!e (u&@e t *ro*erty %or %ree an' &y .ere to$eran e o% !erein *$ainti%%, 4!i ! a tua$ *o((e((ion &y to$eran e 'i' not in any .anner a%%e t t!e ri)!t o% an' to *o((e((ion &y *$ainti%%1 <- P$ainti%% no4 nee'( t!e (u&@e t *ro*erty, !en e, on January 2<, 27,", !e (ent a 'e.an' $etter, Anne( B an' B#), to !erein 'e%en'ant, %or t!e $atter to 5a ate t!e (ai' *ro*erty1

San /i)ue$ Gar ia A A((o aiate( ,2229A Ta.&untin) St-, Sta- Cruz, /ani$a 2< Enero 27," G- Pe'ro Santo( ""# Na5y Roa' 6eteran( 6i$$a)e, Br)y- Ho$y S*irit Quezon City G- Santo(+ An) a.in *on) 3$iyente na (i G- Bernar' Ro8ue ay $u.*ait (a a.in) tan))a*an at 3inu!a an) a.in) (er&i(yo &i$an) .ananan))o$ 3au)nay (a inyon) *aninira!an (a $u*an) 3anyan) *a)9aari na .atata)*uan (a ""# Na5y Roa' 6eteran( 6i$$a)e Br)y- Ho$y S*irit, Quezon CityNai( na.in) i*a&ati' (a inyon) 3aa$a.an na 3ai$an)an na n) na&an))it na 3$iyente an) $u*an) inyon) *ino*o(i(yonan- Da!i$an 'ito, 3ayo ay &i&i&i)yan na.in n) $a&in$i.an) =,<? ara4 .u$a (a *a)3atan))a* n) (u$at na ito u*an) $i(anin an) $u*an) na&a))it- 0un) !in'i, i3ina$u$un)3ot na.in) (a&i!in na .a*i*i$itan 3a.in) .a)(a.*a n) 3au3u$an) 'e.an'a (a !u3u.an u*an) .a*an)a$a)aan an) 3ara*atan at intere( n )a.in) 3$iyenteBBB Atty- A$e@a'ro A- San /i)ue$ Certi%i ation 'ate' /ar ! <, 27," erti%ie' &y Ro.eo D- O$i5e, C!ie% o% Re or'( Se tion o% P!i$i**ine Po(ta$ Cor*- QC Centra$ Po(t O%%i e De.an' $etter 4a( (ent &y *o(t.an E.i$io C!a5ez on Fe&ruary <, 27,"- T!e (a.e 4a( re ei5e' &y Pe'ro G- Santo(:- Ho4e5er, to 'ate, 'e%en'ant %ai$( an' re%u(e( to 'o t!e (a.e, to t!e 'a.a)e an' *re@u'i e o% !erein *$ainti%%1 ;- T!e &aran)ay on i$iation *ro ee'in) (ou)!t at Br)y- Ho$y S*irit %ai$e' to (ett$e t!e 'i(*ute, t!u( a Certi%i ate to Fi$e A tion , Anne( C, 4a( i((ue' &y t!e Baran)ay Se retary Lu y Reye(, (i)ne' &y Baran)ay Ca*tain Fre'eri o An)e$e(1

C- By 5irtue o% 'e%en'antD( a'a.ant re%u(a$ to 5a ate t!e *re.i(e( an' %ai$ure to (ett$e t!e 'i(*ute a.i a&$y at t!e &aran)ay on i$iation *ro ee'in), *$ainti%% 4a( on(traine' to en)a)e t!e $e)a$ (er5i e( o% t!e un'er(i)ne' oun(e$ %or an a)ree' attorneyD( %ee( in t!e a.ount o% P27,777-771 >- Li3e4i(e, a( a re(u$t o% 'e%en'antD( i$$i it o u*an y o% t!e *ro*erty, *$ainti%% %ai$e' to rea$ize in o.e in t!e a.ount o% P#,777-77 a( rea(ona&$e o.*en(ation %or t!e (ue o% (ai' *re.i(e(PRAYER *+EREFORE, *re.i(e( on(i'ere', it i( .o(t re(*e t%u$$y *raye' o% t!i( Honora&$e Court t!at @u').ent &e ren'ere' in %a5or o% *$ainti%% an' a)ain(t 'e%en'ant an' a$$ *er(on( $ai.in) ri)!t( un'er !i.+ ,- 6a ate t!e *re.i(e( an' (urren'er *ea e%u$ *o((e((ion t!ereon in %a5or o% *$ainti%%, in $u'in) a$$ *er(on( $ai.in) ri)!t( un'er !i.1 2- P$ay t!e *$ainti%% t!e a.ount o% P#,777-77 .ont!$y a( rea(ona&$e o.*en(ation %or t!e u(e an' o u*ation o% t!e (u&@e t *ro*erty (tartin) Ju$y 27,7 an' (u&(e8uent$y t!erea%ter, unti$ t!e ti.e t!e 'e%en'ant an' a$$ ot!er *er(on( $ai.in) ri)!t( un'er !i. (!a$$ !a5e %u$$y an' o.*$ete$y 5a ate' t!e (u&@e t *re.i(e(1 "- Pay t!e *$ainti%% t!e (u. o% P27,777-77 &y 4ay o% attorneyD( %ee(1 #- Pay t!e o(t o% (uitCity o% Quezon- P!i$i**ine(- January ,7, 27,#ATTY. RO&ALIE FLORE& Coun(e$ %or P$ainti%% Ro$$ No- #7727 IBP OR No- >7272:E7292;927,"E/ani$a PTR No- ,C7"#<<E7#9,;927,"E/ani$a /CLE EBe.*tion III No- 77,2,<E7#92:927,7
=A4aitin) I((uan e Certi%i ate o% Co.*$ian e %or /CLE EBe.*tion I6?

,##< /a)in!a4a St- Quezon City

CERTIFICATION OF NON#FORUM &+OPPIN% I, Be na ' E. Ro,$e, o% $e)a$ a)e an' a re(i'ent o% No. -. Mali/a0a &t. Ba an/a0 1ati2$nan Q$e3on Cit0, un'er oat! 'e $are t!at+ ,- I !a5e not ear$ier o..en e' a (i.i$ar a tion a)ain(t t!e 'e%en'ant %or t!e (a.e au(e 4it! any ot!er ourt, tri&una$ or 8ua(i9@u'i ia$ a)en y1 2- No (u ! a tion or *ro ee'in) i( *en'in) 4it! any ot!er ourt, tri&una$ or 8ua(i9@u'i ia$ a)en y1 "- I% I (!ou$' $earn t!at a (i.i$ar a tion or *ro ee'in) !a( &een %i$e' or i( *en'in) &e%ore any ot!er ourt, tri&una$ or 8ua(i9@u'i ia$ a)en y, I !ere&y un'erta3e to noti%y t!i( Honora&$e Court 4it!in %i5e =<? 'ay( %ro. (u ! noti e-

Be na ' E. Ro,$e "URAT &UB&CRIBED AND &*ORN to &e%ore .e, in t!e City o% Quezon, t!i( ,7t! 'ay o% January, 27,#, t!e a%%iant eB!i&itin) !i( Dri5erD( Li en(e NoN2<97,2"#<: i((ue' &y t!e Lan' Tran(*ortation O%%i e on Ju$y <, 27,2ATTY. RO&ALIE FLORE& Notary Pu&$i Ro$$ No- #7727 IBP OR No- >7272:E7292;927,"E/ani$a A**oint.ent No- ,2", Unti$ De e.&er ",, 27,# PTR No- ,C7"#<<E7#9,;927,"E/ani$a /CLE EBe.*tion III No- 77,2,<E7#92:927,7
=A4aitin) I((uan e Certi%i ate o% Co.*$ian e %or /CLE EBe.*tion I6?

Seria$ No- o% Co..i((ion /9,2" ,##< /a)in!a4a St- Quezon City

Do - No- ,,1

Pa)e No- 221 Boo3 No- 61 Serie( o% 27,#