Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
www.fuelfirst.com
Abstract
A membrane-based gas– liquid contacting process was evaluated in this work for CO2 removal from flue gases. The absorption of CO2
from a CO2 – N2 mixture was investigated using a commercial hollow fiber membrane contactor and water or diethanolamine as absorbing
solvents. Significant CO2 removal (up to 75%) was achieved even with the use of pure water as absorbent. By using aqueous amine solutions
and chemical absorption, mass transfer improved, and CO2 removal was nearly complete (, 99%). A mathematical model was developed to
simulate the process and it was validated with experimental data. Results show that membrane contactors are significantly more efficient and
compact than conventional absorption towers for acid gas removal.
q 2003 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
Keywords: Membrane contactor; CO2 removal; Modeling
With these assumptions, the CO2 concentration profile in is considered, the effective mass transfer coefficient is
the lumen can be estimated from the differential mass balance reduced by a factor, which denotes the fraction of the pores
wetted by the liquid phase, x; according to:
›Cig 1 › ›Cig
uz ¼ Dig r ð5Þ 1 ð1 2 xÞtlm xtlm
›z r ›r ›r ¼ þ ð11Þ
ki;membrane Dig 1 Dil 1
where Dig is the diffusion coefficient in the lumen fluid
(cm2/s), considered here independent of concentration and In pure water, absorption of CO2 is accompanied by the
derived from Chapman –Enskog theory [23], and uz the gas following reaction:
velocity inside the lumen (cm/s). This velocity profile is þ
given by CO2 þ 2H2 O $ HCO2
3 þ H3 O
" 2 # Because the value of equilibrium constant of the reaction is
r
uz ¼ u 1 2 ð6Þ very small, the formation of bicarbonate is very small [12].
ri
Therefore, CO2 is absorbed physically.
where u is the maximum velocity inside the fiber lumen (cm/ For absorption in an aqueous DEA solution, chemical
s) and ri the inner fiber radius (cm). reaction should be considered. The zwitterions-mechanism
The initial condition for CO2 in the lumen is specified as [25] was adopted for this theoretical study:
k1 =k21
in
Cig ¼ Cig ; for z ¼ 0 and all r ð7Þ CO2 þ R2 NH $ R2 NHþ COO2
in k2
where Cig is the inlet concentration of CO2 in the gas R2 NHþ COO2 þ R2 NH ! R2 NCOO2 þ R2 NHþ
2
phase (mol/cm3).
In the radial direction, symmetry is assumed at the axis of The mechanism consists of two steps, the formation of the
the cylindrical fiber: zwitterions followed by the removal of a proton by the amine.
The physicochemical properties, such as diffusivities of
›Cig CO2 in gas phase and in aqueous solutions, and solubilities
¼ 0; for r ¼ 0 and all z ð8Þ
›r were obtained from the literature [23,25,26]. In the case of
At the gas –liquid interface, the conservation of mass with chemical reaction, the enhancement factor E in Eq. (10), was
respect to CO2 is expressed as evaluated from the classical solution of gas absorption
accompanied by a chemical reaction [27].
›Cig
Dig ¼ 2Kext ðCig 2 ms Cil Þ; for r ¼ ri and all z ð9Þ The set of partial differential Eqs. (5) –(11) was solved
›r using the method of lines. A finite difference scheme in
where ms is the distribution coefficient between gas and dimensionless r direction was applied to convert the set of
liquid phase and Kext the external (membrane wall and shell partial differential equations into a system of ordinary
side) mass transfer coefficient (cm/s), calculated by Eq. (10): differential equations (ODE). The latter gives an ODE initial
1 Hi 1 value problem, which was solved by the explicit ‘hybrid’
¼ þ ð10Þ method [28].
Kext ki;membrane Eki;liquid
The shell side mass transfer coefficient, ki;liquid ; is calculated
by an engineering correlation developed for this type of cross 3. Experimental
flow membrane contactors [24]. The membrane mass
transfer coefficient, ki;membrane depends on the diffusivity of A gas mixture containing 15% CO2 – 85% N2 (procured
absorbed gas in the gas-filled, Dig ; or liquid-filled pores, Dil ; and certified by Air Liquid Hellas S.A.G.I.) was selected as
and the thickness lm ; porosity 1; and tortuosity t of the feed gas. This mixture simulates a typical composition
the membrane wall. When partial wetting of the membrane (in major components) of flue gases from a coal combustion
2156 M. Mavroudi et al. / Fuel 82 (2003) 2153–2159
Fig. 5. Effect of chemical reaction on membrane-based CO2 absorption. Fig. 6. Removal of CO2 in various absorbents. Feed gas: 100 N cm3/s.
Feed gas: 100 N cm3/s. Simulation: partially wetted mode (solid curves). Simulation: partially wetted mode (solid curves).
2158 M. Mavroudi et al. / Fuel 82 (2003) 2153–2159
can be regenerated, their use is generally more economic with Raschig rings of diameter dr ¼ 25 and 50 mm. The
than other liquid absorbents, which are discarded after use. height of transfer unit based on liquid phase, HTUL, was
This indicates that DEA is suitable as an absorbent for CO2 plotted in Fig. 7(a) for the case of CO2 absorption in water,
removal in a membrane contacting process. However, while the height of transfer unit based on gas phase, HTUG,
comparison of theoretical and experimental results for all demanded for a gas phase controlled process, was plotted in
gas/liquid systems studied indicate that the membrane is Fig. 7(b) for the case of CO2 absorption in DEA. The values
operated somewhere between the limits of gas-filled and of HTU for packed contactors were calculated with the use
liquid-filled pores. The penetration of the liquid into of empirical correlations [33]. The HTUs for membrane
the pores, as explained by the necking phenomenon, technology were based on the experimental results pre-
depends on the gas – liquid system and on the characteristics sented in this work.
of the fiber used. In order to prevent this wetting, research Under the same operating conditions, the experimentally
efforts should focus on new membrane materials having a obtained HTU values for the membrane contactor were
high degree of hydrophobicity [16,32], and/or on new liquid significantly lower than those of a conventional packed
absorbents with improved surface tension properties [31]. contactor, for CO2 absorption both in water and in DEA.
In order to evaluate the membrane-based technology This leads to lower specific area requirements and, hence, to
efficiency, the absorption performance of the hollow fiber a reduction in absorber investment costs compared to
membrane contactor needs to be compared with that of a packed towers. Thus, a significantly higher amount of CO2
conventional packed absorber. For this, the classical removal can be achieved with a relatively small module and
measure of absorption technology efficiency was used, i.e. low flow velocities. Another benefit of using membrane
the height of a transfer unit (HTU) required for CO2 technology instead of conventional absorption equipment is
absorption in an absorbent (here pure water and DEA). In that membrane operation can be scaled-up linearly, so that
Fig. 7, the required HTUs for physical and chemical an increase in capacity is achieved simply by adding
absorption of CO2 under the same operating conditions are membrane modules.
plotted as a function of superficial velocity for the case of
the tested membrane contactor and for packed contactors
5. Conclusions
Acknowledgements
References [17] Al-Saffar HB, Ozturk B, Hughes R. A comparison of porous and non-
porous gas–liquid membrane contactors for gas separation. Trans
[1] Freund P. Abatement and mitigation of carbon dioxide emissions from IchemE 1997;75(A):685–92.
power generation. IEA GHG Programme. Available at: http://www. [18] Chun MS, Lee KH. Analysis on a hydrophobic hollow-fiber
ieagreen.org.uk/; 1998. membrane absorber and experimental observations of CO2 removal
[2] Wuebbles DJ, Jain AK. Concerns about climate change and the role of by enhanced absorption. Sep Sci Techol 1997;32(15):2445– 66.
fossil fuel use. Fuel Process Technol 2001;71:99–119. [19] Li K, Teo WK. Use of permeation and absorption methods for CO2
[3] Herzog H, Drake E, Tester J. A research needs assessment for the removal in hollow fibre membrane modules. Sep Purif Tech 1998;13:
capture, utilization and disposal of carbon dioxide from fossil fuel- 79–88.
fired power plants. MIT Report No. DE-FG02-92ER30194.A000, [20] Feron PHM, Jansen AE, Klaasen R. Membrane technology in carbon
Cambridge, MA; 1993 dioxide removal. Energy Convers Mgmt 1992;33(5 –8):421–8.
[4] IEA Greenhouse Gas R&D Programme. Carbon dioxide capture from [21] Jansen AE, Klaasen R, Feron PHM, Hanemaaijer JH, ter Meulen BPh.
power stations. Final report, London, http://www.ieagreen.org.uk Membrane gas absorption processes in environmental applications.
[5] Rao AB, Rubin ES. A technical, economic, and environmental In: Crespo JG, Böddecker KW, editors. Membrane processes in
assessment of amine-based CO2 capture technology for power plant separation and purification. The Netherlands: Kluwer Academic;
greenhouse gas control. Environ Sci Technol 2002;36(20):4467–75. 1994.
[6] Ho WWS, Sirkar KK. Membrane handbook. New York: Van [22] Kim BS, Harriott P. Critical entry pressure for liquids in hydrophobic
Nostrand Reinhold; 1992. membranes. J Colloid Interface Sci 1987;115(1):1 –8.
[7] Gabelman A, Hwang ST. Hollow fiber membrane contactors. J Membr [23] Reid RC, Prausnitz JM, Sherwood TK. The properties of gases and
Sci 1999;159:61–106. liquids. New York: McGraw-Hill; 1977.
[8] Zhang Q, Cussler EL. Microporous hollow fibers for gas [24] Schöner P, Plucinski P, Nitsch W, Daiminger U. Mass transfer in the
absorption: I. Mass transfer in the liquid. J Membr Sci 1985;23: shell side of cross flow hollow fiber modules. Chem Engng Sci 1998;
321– 32. 53(13):2319 –26.
[9] Zhang Q, Cussler EL. Microporous hollow fibers for gas [25] Versteeg GF, van Dijck LAJ, van Swaaij WPM. On the kinetics
absorption: I. Mass transfer across the membrane. J Membr Sci between CO2 and alkanolamines both in aqueous and non-aqueous
1985;23:333–45. solutions. An overview. Chem Engng Commun 1996;144:113–58.
[10] Yang MC, Cussler EL. Designing hollow-fiber contactors. AIChE J [26] Versteeg GF, van Swaaij WPM. Solubility and diffusivity of acid
1986;32(7):1910–6. gases (CO2, N2O) in aqueous alkanolamine solution. J Chem Engng
[11] Cooney DO, Jackson CC. Gas absorption in a hollow fiber device. Data 1988;33:29 –34.
Chem Engng Commun 1989;79:153–63. [27] Danckwerts PV. Gas– liquid reactions. New York: McGraw-Hill;
[12] Karoor S, Sirkar KK. Gas absorption studies in microporous 1970.
hollow fiber membrane modules. Ind Engng Chem Res 1993;32: [28] Ashour SS, Hanna OT. A new very simple explicit method for the
674–84. integration of mildly stiff ordinary differential equations. Comput
[13] Kreulen H, Smolders CA, Versteeg GF, van Swaaij WPM. Chem Engng 1990;14(3):267–72.
Microporous hollow fibre membrane modules as gas-liquid con- [29] Sengupta A, Peterson PA, Miller BD, Schneider J, Fulk Jr CW. Large-
tactors; Part 1. Physical mass transfer processes. A specific scale application of membrane contactors for gas transfer from or to
application: mass transfer in highly viscous liquids. J Membr Sci ultrapure water. Sep Purif Tech 1998;14:189 –200.
1993;78:197–216. [30] Mahmud H, Kumar A, Narbaitz RM, Matsuura T. A study of mass
[14] Kreulen H, Smolders CA, Versteeg GF, van Swaaij WPM. transfer in the membrane air-stripping process using microporous
Microporous hollow fibre membrane modules as gas–liquid con- polypropylene hollow fibers. J Membr Sci 2000;179:29– 41.
tactors; Part 2. Mass transfer with chemical reaction. J Membr Sci [31] Kumar PS, Hogendoorn JA, Feron PHM, Versteeg GF. New
1993;78:217–38. absorption liquids for the removal of CO2 from dilute gas streams
[15] Rangwala HA. Absorption of carbon dioxide into aqueous solutions using membrane contactors. Chem Engng Sci 2002;57:1639 –51.
using hollow fiber membrane contactors. J Membr Sci 1996;112: [32] Feron PHM, Jansen AE. CO2 separation with polyolefin membrane
229–40. contactors and dedicated absorption liquids: performances and
[16] Nishikawa N, Ishibashi M, Ohta H, Akutsu N, Matsumoto H, Kamata prospects. Sep Purif Tech 2002;27:231–42.
T, Kitamura H. CO2 removal by hollow-fiber gas–liquid contactor. [33] Perry RH, Green DW. Perry’s chemical engineers’ handbook. New
Energy Convers Mgmt 1995;36(6– 9):415–8. York: McGraw-Hill; 1984.