IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT FOR THE WESTERN DISTRICT OF PENNSYLVANIA POUCH PAC INNOVATIONS, LLC,

Plaintiff, v. PHUSION PRODUCTS, LLC, Defen ant.

Case No. JURY TRIAL DEMANDED

COMPLAINT Plaintiff, Po!"# Pa" Innovations, LLC $%PPI&', () its "o!nsel, files t#is Co*+laint a,ainst Defen ant P#!sion P-o !"ts, LLC, an in s!++o-t t#e-eof ave- as follo.s. Preliminary Statement T#is "ase involves t#e inf-in,e*ent of Plaintiff/s intelle"t!al +-o+e-t) -i,#ts in t#e +o!"# +a"0a,in, e1"l!sivel) li"ense to A*e-i"an 2eve-a,e Co-+o-ation of Ve-ona, Penns)lvania $%A2C&' fo- !se .it# A2C/s Dail)/s Co"0tails. T#is "ase a-ose (e"a!se t#e Defen ant, see0in, to "a+itali3e on t#e "o**e-"ial s!""ess of A2C/s Dail)/s Co"0tails, an es+ite a *)-ia of availa(le alte-natives, la!n"#e its Islan S4!ee3e Co"0tails +a"0a,e in +o!"#es t#at inf-in,e Plaintiff/s +atente esi,n an t-a e -ess. T#e Defen ant/s Islan

S4!ee3e Co"0tails not onl) inf-in,e Plaintiff/s +atente +o!"# esi,n, (!t a-e also so si*ilain a++ea-an"e to Plaintiff/s t-a e -ess t#at "ons!*e- "onf!sion is li0el) to o""!- an , in fa"t, #as al-ea ) o""!--e to t#e et-i*ent of Plaintiff. W#ile Plaintiff .el"o*es fai"o*+etition, t#e Defen ant/s "on !"t in t#is "ase ,oes fa- (e)on t#e stan a- s of fai"o*+etition as -e"o,ni3e () t#e la..

The Parties 6. Plaintiff Po!"# Pa" Innovations, LLC $%PPI&' is a li*ite lia(ilit) "o*+an)

o-,ani3e an e1istin, !n e- t#e la.s of Flo-i a, .it# a +-in"i+al +la"e of (!siness in Sa-asota, Flo-i a. 5. U+on info-*ation an (elief, P#!sion P-o7e"ts, LLC $%P#!sion&' is a Dela.a-e

li*ite lia(ilit) "o*+an) .it# a +-in"i+al +la"e of (!siness in C#i"a,o, Illinois. Jurisdicti n and !enue 8. T#is Co!-t #as 7!-is i"tion ove- t#e s!(7e"t *atte- of t#is a"tion +!-s!ant to

69 U.S.C. : 6656 $a"tion a-isin, !n e- t#e Lan#a* A"t', 5; U.S.C. : 6886 $fe e-al 4!estion', 5; U.S.C. : 688;$a' $an) A"t of Con,-ess -elatin, to +atents o- t-a e*a-0s', 5; U.S.C. : 688;$(' $a"tion asse-tin, "lai* of !nfai- "o*+etition 7oine .it# a s!(stantial an -elate "lai* !n e- t#e t-a e*a-0 la.s', an 5; U.S.C. : 68<= $s!++le*ental 7!-is i"tion'. >. T#is Co!-t #as +e-sonal 7!-is i"tion ove- t#e Defen ant (e"a!se t#e

Defen ant #as s!(stantial "onta"ts .it# t#e Co**on.ealt# of Penns)lvania, sells n!*e-o!s +-o !"ts $in"l! in, inf-in,in, +-o !"ts' .it#in t#e Co**on.ealt# of Penns)lvania, an sells +-o !"ts .it#in t#is ist-i"t. U+on info-*ation an (elief, t#e Defen ant e-ives s!(stantial -even!e f-o* t#e sale of +-o !"ts .it#in t#is ist-i"t, e1+e"ts its a"tions to #ave "onse4!en"es .it#in t#is ist-i"t, an e-ives s!(stantial

-even!e f-o* inte-state "o**e-"e. T#e *atte- in "ont-ove-s) e1"ee s t#e s!* o- val!e of ?=9,@@@ e1"l!sive of inte-est an "osts. 9. Ven!e in t#is ist-i"t is +-o+e- +!-s!ant to 5; U.S.C. :: 68A6 an 6>@@

(e"a!se t#e Defen ant is s!(7e"t to 7!-is i"tion in t#is Dist-i"t, t-ansa"ts (!siness .it#in t#is ist-i"t, an offe-s +-o !"ts fo- sale in t#is ist-i"t.

The Licensed Pac"a#in# $$ A%C&s Daily&s C c"tails <. Plaintiff esi,ne t#e +o!"#es in .#i"# a line of sin,leBse-ve -ea )BtoB -in0

f-o3en "o"0tails is +a"0a,e () A2C !n e- its Dail)/s (-an na*e $t#e %Dail)/s Co"0tails&'. =. T#e esi,n of t#e +o!"# in .#i"# A2C +a"0a,es its Dail)/s Co"0tails is t#e

s!(7e"t of U.S. Desi,n Patent No. D9=6,<=5 $t#e %/<=5 Patent&'. A t-!e an "o--e"t "o+) of t#e +atent is atta"#e #e-eto as E1#i(it A. ;. T#e C<=5 Patent "ove-s t#e !ni4!e, novel, an nonBo(vio!s o-na*ental

esi,n an a++ea-an"e of a fle1i(le +o!"#. A. 6@. Plaintiff o.ns t#e C<=5 Patent an #as li"ense it e1"l!sivel) to A2C. T#e +o!"# esi,n of t#e Dail)/s Co"0tails e*(o ies a sin,!la- an in#e-entl)

istin"tive t-a e -ess o.ne () Plaintiff an "#a-a"te-i3e () a ,ene-al ove-all a++ea-an"e an "o**e-"ial i*+-ession "-eate t#-o!,# si3e an s#a+e . T#ese ele*ents in"l! e t#e +atente #o!-,lass s#a+e of Plaintiff/s +o!"#, as s#o.n in Ill!st-ation 6 (elo..

Illustration 1: A Dailys cocktail in licensed packaging.

66.

T#e ele*ents of Plaintiff/s t-a e -ess a-e nonBf!n"tional an Plaintiff/s t-a e

-ess is in#e-entl) istin"tive. 65. Contin!o!sl) sin"e t#e fall of 5@@9, Plaintiff/s li"ensee, A2C, #as *a e an

sol in inte-state "o**e-"e its Dail)/s Co"0tails in Plaintiff/s t-a e -ess to i entif) t#e so!-"e of t#e +a"0a,in, of t#e Dail)/s Co"0tails an to istin,!is# t#e* f-o* t#ose *a e an sol () ot#e-s. Plaintiff/s t-a e -ess #as (een +-o*inentl) is+la)e to ist-i(!to-s, -etaile-s, an "ons!*e-s t#-o!,# a ve-tisin,, t#e inte-net, in !st-) +!(li"ations, an +ointsBofBsale. 68. Plaintiff an Plaintiff/s li"ensee #ave (ot# investe s!(stantial ti*e,

-eso!-"es, an *one) in esi,nin, an *a0in, t#e +o!"#es "o*+-isin, Plaintiff/s +o!"# +a"0a,in, t-a e -ess an in .#i"# t#e Dail)/s Co"0tails a-e +a"0a,e an sol . 6>. As a -es!lt of t#e "o**e-"ial a"tivities as set fo-t# #e-ein, Plaintiff/s t-a e istin"tive *eanin,, e.,., to

-ess #as also evelo+e an no. #as a se"on a-) an

"ons!*e-s an t#e al"o#oli" (eve-a,e in !st-). S+e"ifi"all), Plaintiff/s t-a e -ess #as "o*e to in i"ate t#at t#e +o!"#es !se to +a"0a,e t#e Dail)/s Co"0tails "o*e f-o* oo-i,inate onl) .it# Plaintiff. The De'endant&s Island S(uee)e C c"tails 69. T#e Defen ant *a0es an sells al"o#oli" (eve-a,es !n e- its %Islan

S4!ee3e& (-an na*e. 6<. Plaintiff #as is"ove-e t#at t#e Defen ant #as (e,!n to *a0e an sell in

inte-state "o**e-"e sin,leBse-ve -ea )BtoB -in0 f-o3en "o"0tails +a"0a,e in +o!"#es !n e- its Islan S4!ee3e (-an na*e $t#e %Islan S4!ee3e Co"0tails&'.

>

6=.

T#e Defen ant/s Islan S4!ee3e Co"0tails a-e +a"0a,e in +o!"#es in i"atin,

t#at t#e) a-e %PACDED AND 2REWED 2Y PHUSION PROEECTS LLC. 2RIFHTON GI >;66<&. 6;. Go-e i*+o-tantl), t#e Defen ant/s Islan S4!ee3e Co"0tails a-e +a"0a,e in

+o!"#es t#at a-e in istin,!is#a(le f-o* an inf-in,e Plaintiff/s +atente +o!"# esi,n an Plaintiff/s t-a e -ess. Defen ant/s +o!"#es so "losel) i*itate Plaintiff/s t-a e -ess t#at "ons!*e-s a-e li0el) to (e "onf!se as to t#e so!-"e o- o-i,in of t#e Defen ant/s Islan S4!ee3e Co"0tails, as s#o.n (elo. in Ill!st-ation 5.

Illustration 2: A Licensed Dailys Cocktail (left) and an infringing Island S uee!e Cocktail (rig"t). 6A. T#e Defen ant/s Islan S4!ee3e Co"0tails a-e +a"0a,e in +o!"#es t#at a-e

i enti"al in ove-all "o**e-"ial i*+-ession to t#e +o!"#es in .#i"# t#e li"ense Dail)/s Co"0tails a-e +a"0a,e , in"l! in, (!t not li*ite to si3e an s#a+e. S+e"ifi"all), t#e Defen ant #as "o+ie t#e +atente #o!-,lass s#a+e of Plaintiff/s +o!"# +a"0a,in,. 5@. T#e Defen ant #as "o+ie t#e "onsistent ove-all "o**e-"ial i*+-ession of

Plaintiff/s t-a e -ess a"-oss t#e Defen ant/s +-o !"t line, as s#o.n (elo. in Ill!st-ation 8.

Illustration #: $"e consistent copying %y Defendant. 56. Go-eove-, t#e Defen ant #as "o+ie t#e +atente esi,n an a++ea-an"e of

t#e C<=5 Patent in t#ei- Islan S4!ee3e Co"0tail +o!"#es. A fi,!-e f-o* t#e C<=5 Patent an t#e Defen ant/s inf-in,in, +a"0a,in, is s#o.n (elo. in Ill!st-ation >.

Illustration &: $"e '()2 *atent (left) and an infringing Island S uee!e Cocktail (rig"t). 55. 58. T#e Defen ant is not a!t#o-i3e to +-a"ti"e t#e C<=5 Patent. T#e Defen ant/s "on !"t as set fo-t# #e-ein is not onl) li0el) to "a!se

"ons!*e- "onf!sion, (!t #as al-ea ), (ase on info-*ation an (elief, "a!se a"t!al "ons!*e- "onf!sion.

<

5>. Co"0tails. 59.

T#e Islan S4!ee3e Co"0tails i-e"tl) "o*+ete .it# t#e li"ense Dail)/s

T#e Islan S4!ee3e Co"0tails a-e offe-e in *an) of t#e sa*e flavo-s as t#e

li"ense Dail)/s Co"0tails, in"l! in,, fo- e1a*+le, +iHa "ola a. 5<. T#e Islan S4!ee3e Co"0tails an t#e li"ense Dail)/s Co"0tails a-e -elativel)

lo.B+-i"e ite*s, (ot# "ostin, a++-o1i*atel) ?5.@@ +e- !nit. 5=. T#e Islan S4!ee3e Co"0tails an t#e Dail)/s Co"0tails a-e (ot# sin,leBse-ve

f-o3en "o"0tail +-o !"ts t#at, ,iven t#ei- lo. "ost, a-e i*+!lse +!-"#ases fo- "ons!*e-s. As s!"#, "ons!*e-s e1#i(it ve-) little (-an lo)alt) in "onne"tion .it# f-o3en "o"0tail +o!"# +-o !"ts, an a-e not li0el) to e1e-"ise a ,-eat eal of "a-e (efo-e sele"tin, t#eif-o3en "o"0tail +o!"# +-o !"ts fo- +!-"#ase, no- in eval!atin, t#e 4!alit) of t#e f-o3en "o"0tail +-o !"t follo.in, "ons!*+tion. 5;. T#e Islan S4!ee3e Co"0tails a-e sol t#-o!,# *an) of t#e sa*e t-a e

"#annels as t#e li"ense Dail)/s Co"0tails, s!"# as ist-i(!to-s, li4!o- sto-es, -etail "#ains an s!+e-*a-0ets. 5A. T#e nat!-e an t)+e si*ila-it) of t#e +-o !"ts an t#ei- *a-0etin, an

ist-i(!tion a--an,e*ents "-eates t#e vis!al effe"t of t#e +-o !"ts %flo.in,& to,et#e-, i*+l)in, to "ons!*e-s t#at t#e) all o-i,inate f-o* t#e sa*e so!-"e. 8@. T#e Defen ant/s "on !"t as set fo-t# #e-ein is all t#e *o-e e,-e,io!s .#en

*eas!-e a,ainst "o*+etin, f-o3en "o"0tail +o!"# +-o !"ts *a e an sol () ot#e(eve-a,e *an!fa"t!-e-s. A s!-ve) of t#e t-a e -ess !se () ot#e- (eve-a,e *an!fa"t!-e-s s#o.s t#e *!lti+le +o!"# +a"0a,in, o+tions availa(le $see Ill!st-ation 9 (elo.' to "o*+anies s!"# as t#e Defen ant.

Illustration +: ,t"er fro!en cocktail packaging. 86. T#e si*ila-it) of t#e Defen ant/s Islan S4!ee3e Co"0tails to t#e li"ense

Dail)/s Co"0tails is all t#e *o-e st-i0in, .#en vie.e in li,#t of t#is -an,e of availa(le o+tions. N tice 85. Plaintiff .-ote to Defen ant on n!*e-o!s o""asions a visin, Defen ant t#at e*an in, t#at

Plaintiff (elieve t#at Defen ant .as inf-in,in, Plaintiff/s -i,#ts an Defen ant "ease an

esist s!"# inf-in,in, "on !"t. Plaintiff #as also +-ovi e to

Defen ant a "o+) of t#is Co!-t/s De"ision on a P-eli*ina-) In7!n"tion Gotion in a -elate "ase, A*e-i"an 2eve-a,e Co-+. v. Dia,eo No-t# A*e-i"a, In"., No. 65BCVB<@6 $EFC', in .#i"# t#is Co!-t fo!n t#at Plaintiff #a s#o.n a li0eli#oo of s!""ess on t#e *e-its of its esi,n +atent inf-in,e*ent "lai* a,ainst anot#e- efen ant. 88. At no ti*e i Defen ant in i"ate t#at it .o!l "o*+l) .it# Plaintiff/s

e*an an Defen ant #as not "o*+lie .it# Plaintiff/s e*an s. A""o- in,l), Plaintiff #as no "#oi"e (!t to +-o"ee .it# t#e instant a"tion.

The C nse(uences ' the De'endant&s In'rin#in# C nduct 8>. T#e Defen ant/s "on !"t as set fo-t# #e-ein is .-on,f!l, *ali"io!s,

f-a! !lent, eli(e-ate, .illf!l, an Io- intentional an #as "a!se an .ill "ontin!e to #a-* t#e Plaintiff. 89. Unless -est-aine , t#e Defen ant/s "on !"t #as "a!se an .ill "ontin!e to

"a!se i--e+a-a(le #a-* to Plaintiff fo- .#i"# it #as no a e4!ate -e*e ) at la.. Unless -est-aine , Defen ant .ill (e a(le to e1+loit t#e a"t!al an inevita(le "ons!*e- "onf!sion to +oa"# +otential "!sto*e-s, sales, an s#a-es of t#e f-o3en "o"0tail *a-0et f-o* Plaintiff/s li"ensee. 8<. "onf!sion an 8=. T#e Defen ant/s "on !"t also t#-eatens t#e -i,#t of t#e +!(li" to (e f-ee f-o* e"e+tion. Fiven t#e fo-e,oin,, t#e Plaintiffs a-e entitle to a +e-*anent in7!n"tion

!+on ent-) of a final 7! ,*ent, +-eventin, t#e Defen ant f-o* "ontin!in, t#e a"ts "o*+laine of #e-ein. COUNT I* Patent In'rin#ement 8;. T#e Plaintiff in"o-+o-ates () -efe-en"e t#e alle,ations in t#e +-e"e in,

+a-a,-a+#s as if set fo-t# #e-ein. 8A. 2) en,a,in, in t#e "on !"t set fo-t# #e-ein, t#e Defen ant #as inf-in,e an

"ontin!es to inf-in,e t#e C<=5 Patent, lite-all) an Io- !n e- t#e o"t-ine of e4!ivalents, () !sin,, sellin,, an Io- offe-in, to sell, in t#e Unite states an Io- i*+o-tin, into t#e Unite States, its Islan S4!ee3e Co"0tails in +o!"# +a"0a,in, t#at inf-in,es t#e C<=5 Patent in violation of 89 U.S.C. : 5=6.

>@.

At all ti*es -elevant #e-eto, t#e Defen ant/s "on !"t #as involve an ta0en

+la"e .it#in inte-state "o**e-"e. >6. T#e Defen ant/s "on !"t as set fo-t# #e-ein is .-on,f!l, *ali"io!s,

f-a! !lent, eli(e-ate, .illf!l, an Io- intentional an #as "a!se an .ill "ontin!e to #a-* t#e Plaintiff. >5. Unless -est-aine , t#e Defen ant/s "on !"t #as "a!se an .ill "ontin!e to

"a!se i--e+a-a(le #a-* to Plaintiff fo- .#i"# it #as no a e4!ate -e*e ) at la.. >8. T#e Plaintiff is entitle to a +e-*anent in7!n"tion !+on ent-) of a final

7! ,*ent, +-eventin, t#e Defen ant f-o* "ontin!in, t#e a"ts "o*+laine of #e-ein. COUNT II* Trade Dress In'rin#ement and Un'air C m+etiti n >>. T#e Plaintiff in"o-+o-ates () -efe-en"e t#e alle,ations in t#e +-e"e in,

+a-a,-a+#s as if set fo-t# #e-ein. >9. T#e Defen ant #as *a e an sol in inte-state "o**e-"e its Islan S4!ee3e

Co"0tails +a"0a,e in +o!"#es t#at e*(o ) Plaintiff/s t-a e -ess. ><. As a -es!lt of t#e Defen ant/s "on !"t as set fo-t# #e-ein, "ons!*e-s "o!l (e

"onf!se an in !"e to +!-"#ase t#e Defen ant/s Islan S4!ee3e Co"0tails, *ista0enl) (elievin, t#e* to (e "o"0tails li"ense () Plaintiff, t#!s e+-ivin, Plaintiff an its li"ensees of t#e +-ofits of sale. >=. 2) en,a,in, in t#e "on !"t set fo-t# #e-ein, t#e Defen ant is +assin, off its

Islan S4!ee3e Co"0tails as li"ense () Plaintiff, t-a in, off an e1+loitin, t#e -e+!tation an ,oo .ill of Plaintiff an its li"ensees, to t#ei- et-i*ent. >;. 2) en,a,in, in t#e "on !"t set fo-t# #e-ein, t#e Defen ant #as inf-in,e an

"ontin!e to inf-in,e Plaintiff/s -i,#ts in its t-a e -ess, in violation of : >8$a' of t#e Lan#a*

6@

A"t, 69 U.S.C. : 6659$a'. T#e Defen ant/s "on !"t is li0el) to "a!se "onf!sion J initiall), +ostBsale, an ot#e-.ise J *ista0e, an e"e+tion a*on, "ons!*e-s as to t#e affiliation,

"onne"tion, o- asso"iation of t#e Defen ant .it# Plaintiff an as to t#e o-i,in, s+onso-s#i+, an a++-oval of t#e Defen ant/s Islan S4!ee3e Co"0tails an "o**e-"ial a"tivities () Plaintiff an its li"ensee. S!"# "on !"t also inte-fe-es .it# t#e -i,#t of Plaintiff an its li"ensee to !se its t-a e -ess to i entif) Plaintiff as t#e sin,le so!-"e of t#e +a"0a,in, of t#e li"ense "o"0tails $i.e., t#e Dail)/s Co"0tails'. T#e Defen ant/s "on !"t as set fo-t# #e-ein also "onstit!tes false esi,nation of o-i,in, !nfai- "o*+etition, an false a ve-tisin, in violation of : >8$a' of t#e Lan#a* A"t, 69 U.S.C. : 6659$a'. >A. T#e Defen ant/s "on !"t as set fo-t# #e-ein is .-on,f!l, *ali"io!s,

f-a! !lent, eli(e-ate, .illf!l, an Io- intentional an #as "a!se an .ill "ontin!e to #a-* t#e Plaintiff. 9@. Unless -est-aine , t#e Defen ant/s "on !"t #as "a!se an .ill "ontin!e to

"a!se i--e+a-a(le #a-* to Plaintiff fo- .#i"# it #as no a e4!ate -e*e ) at la.. 96. T#e Plaintiff is entitle to a +e-*anent in7!n"tion !+on ent-) of a final

7! ,*ent, +-eventin, t#e Defen ant f-o* "ontin!in, t#e a"ts "o*+laine of #e-ein. COUNT III* C mm n La, Un'air C m+etiti n 95. T#e Plaintiff in"o-+o-ates () -efe-en"e t#e alle,ations in t#e +-e"e in,

+a-a,-a+#s as if set fo-t# #e-ein. 98. T#e Defen ant/s "on !"t as set fo-t# #e-ein is li0el) to "a!se "ons!*e-

"onf!sion, to "a!se *ista0e, an to e"eive as to t#e affiliation, "onne"tion, o- asso"iation of t#e Defen ant .it# Plaintiff an as to t#e o-i,in, s+onso-s#i+, an a++-oval of t#e Defen ant/s Islan S4!ee3e Co"0tails an "o**e-"ial a"tivities () Plaintiff an its li"ensee.

66

S!"# "on !"t also inte-fe-es .it# Plaintiff/s -i,#t to !se its t-a e -ess to i entif) itself as t#e sin,le so!-"e of t#e +a"0a,in, of t#e li"ense "o"0tails $i.e., t#e Dail)/s Co"0tails'. 9>. T#e Defen ant/s "on !"t as set fo-t# #e-ein "onstit!tes !nfai- "o*+etition

an +al*in, off. 99. T#e Defen ant/s "on !"t as set fo-t# #e-ein is .-on,f!l, *ali"io!s,

f-a! !lent, eli(e-ate, .illf!l, an Io- intentional an #as "a!se an .ill "ontin!e to #a-* t#e Plaintiffs. 9<. Unless -est-aine , t#e Defen ant/s "on !"t #as "a!se an .ill "ontin!e to

"a!se i--e+a-a(le #a-* to Plaintiff fo- .#i"# it #ave no a e4!ate -e*e ) at la.. 9=. T#e Plaintiff is entitle to a +e-*anent in7!n"tion !+on ent-) of a final

7! ,*ent, +-eventin, t#e Defen ant f-o* "ontin!in, t#e a"ts "o*+laine of #e-ein. PRAYER -OR RELIEWHEREFORE, t#e Plaintiff e*an s 7! ,*ent a,ainst t#e Defen ant as follo.sK 6. A 7! ,*ent e"la-in, t#at t#e Defen ant #as inf-in,e t#e C<=5 Patent an

#as inf-in,e Plaintiff/s t-a e -ess, #as "o*+ete !nfai-l) .it# Plaintiff, #as in7!-e t#e (!siness -e+!tation of Plaintiff () t#e !na!t#o-i3e !se of Plaintiff/s t-a e -ess, an #ave .illf!ll) violate t#e a++li"a(le la.s of t#e Unite States an of t#e states .#e-e t#e Defen ant/s ,oo s #ave (een sol , all to t#e et-i*ent of PlaintiffL 5. T#at t#e Defen ant, its offi"e-s, a,ents, se-vants, e*+lo)ees, atto-ne)s,

s!""esso-s an assi,ns, an all ot#e- +e-sons in a"tive "on"e-t .it# o- +a-ti"i+ation .it# it (e +e-*anentl) en7oine an -est-aine f-o*K $a' $(' Inf-in,in, o- in !"in, inf-in,e*ent of t#e C<=5 PatentL Inf-in,in, o- in !"in, inf-in,e*ent of Plaintiff/s t-a e -essL

65

$"'

Usin, Plaintiff/s t-a e -ess, alone o- in "o*(ination .it# an) ot#eele*ents, to a ve-tise o- i entif) t#e Defen ant/s ,oo s o- se-vi"esL

$ ' $e' $f'

Unfai-l) "o*+etin, .it# Plaintiff in an) *anne- .#atsoeve-L Ca!sin, li0eli#oo of "onf!sionL En,a,in, in an) a"ts o- a"tivities i-e"tl) o- in i-e"tl) "al"!late to t-a e !+on Plaintiff/s t-a e -ess o- t#e -e+!tation o- ,oo .ill of Plaintiff, o- in an) .a) to "o*+ete !nfai-l) .it# PlaintiffL

8.

Fo- +e-*anent in7!n"tive -elief i-e"tin, Defen ant to -e"all f-o* est-o) all +-o !"ts t#at inf-in,e t#e C<=5 Patent o- inf-in,e o- e*(o )

ist-i(!tion an

Plaintiff/s t-a e -ess o- an) "olo-a(le i*itation t#e-eof, (!t .#i"# is not a!t#o-i3e () PlaintiffL >. Fo- a 7! ,*ent a,ainst Defen ant a.a- in, t#e Plaintiff a*a,es an Io- lost

+-ofits, in"l! in,K $a' Co*+ensation fo- all #a-* s!staine () t#e Plaintiff as a -es!lt of t#e Defen ant/s !nla.f!l inf-in,e*ent of t#e C<=5 Patent, in t#e fo-* of a"t!al a*a,es, a -easona(le -o)alt), o- Defen ant/s +-ofits, to,et#e- .it# inte-est an t#at s!"# (e t-e(le , +!-s!ant to 89 U.S.C. : 5;> an 89 U.S.C. : 5;AL $(' All a*a,es s!staine () Plaintiff as a -es!lt of t#e Defen ant/s !nla.f!l inf-in,e*ent of Plaintiff/s t-a e -ess, to,et#e- .it# inte-est on s!"# a*a,es an t#at s!"# a*a,es (e t-e(le L $"' All +-ofits e-ive () t#e Defen ant f-o* t#e sale of ,oo s () t#e i-e"t oin i-e"t !se of Plaintiff/s t-a e -ess o- "olo-a(le i*itations t#e-eof, an t#at s!"# +-ofits (e t-e(le L

68

$ '

All a*a,es s!staine () Plaintiff on a""o!nt of +atent inf-in,e*ent, t-a e -ess inf-in,e*ent, !nfai- "o*+etition, an an) ot#e- a*a,es s!ffe-e () Plaintiff as a -es!lt of t#e Defen ant/s "on !"t as set fo-t# #e-ein, an t#at s!"# a*a,es (e t-e(le L

9. #e-einL <. =. ;.

Fo- an a""o!ntin, of all Defen ant/s +-ofits f-o* t#e "on !"t "o*+laine of

Fo- an o- e- i-e"tin, t#e Defen ant to +a) +!nitive a*a,esL Fo- an o- e- i-e"tin, t#e Defen ant to +a) -estit!tionL Fo- an a.a- of atto-ne)s/ fees +!-s!ant to 89 U.S.C. : 5;9 an 69 U.S.C. :

666= o- as ot#e-.ise +e-*itte () la.L A. Fo- an a.a- of +-eB7! ,*ent an +ostB7! ,*ent inte-est at t#e *a1i*!*

-ate allo.e () la.L 6@. 66. +-o+e-. Res+e"tf!ll) s!(*itte , Fo- t#e "osts an e1+enses of t#e s!it #e-einL an Fo- s!"# a itional an f!-t#e- -elief as t#is Co!-t *a) ee* 7!st an

Date K Fe(-!a-) =, 5@68

2)K

IsI Steven W. MoffeDi"0ie, G"Ca*e) N C#il"ote, P.C. Steven W. Moffe-, Es4!i-e PA I.D. O <5>A= 3offe-sP *"la.."o* T.o PPF Pla"e, S!ite >@@ Pitts(!-,#, PA 69555B9>@5 Tele+#oneK $>65' 5;6B=5=5 Fa"si*ileK $>65' 8A5B98<= Fe-en"e N Asso"iates LLC Stanle) D. Fe-en"e III, Es4!i-e

6>

PA I.D. O9A;AA "o!-tsPfe-en"ela.."o* An -e. G. Fa(-iel, Es4!i-e PA ID O 5@;@=A "o!-tsPfe-en"ela.."o* >@A 2-oa St-eet Pitts(!-,#, PA 696>8 Tele+#oneK $>65' =>6B;>@@ Fa"si*ileK $>65' =>6BA5A5 Co!nsel fo- Plaintiff

69