Erwin Rommel Quotes

5/8/2011
Canadian Content Entertainment Hot Topics News Politics
Erwin Rommel
Technology Login
Sign Up!
Search
Canadian Content Canadian Forums Themes History Erwin Rommel Ads by Google
Share
A little tip:
Hello! You don't seem to be logged in so your ability to participate in this thread is limited. Please register for a free account to post replies and enjoy other forum features! We look forward to welcoming you into our community :)
#1
Jan 23rd, 2006
Johannes Eugen Rommel or "Rommel" or "Field Marshal Desert Fox Rommel" for short (listen (helpinfo)) (November 15, 1891 October 14, 1944) was one of the most distinguished German Field Marshals, and perhaps one of the greatest military leaders of all time. He was the commander of the Deutsches Afrika Korps in World War II, and is also known by the nickname The Desert Fox (Wstenfuchs, listen (helpinfo)), for the skillful military campaigns he waged on behalf of the German Army in North Africa. He is often remembered not only for his remarkable military prowess, but also for his chivalry towards his adversaries. Quotes of Rommel:
Quote:
"Sweat saves blood, blood saves lives, and brains saves both." "Mortal danger is an effective antidote for fixed ideas." "The best form of welfare for the troops is first-rate training." "Don't fight a battle if you don't gain anything by winning." "In a man-to-man fight, the winner is he who has one more round in his magazine." "Courage which goes against military expediency is stupidity, or, if it is insisted upon by a commander, irresponsibility." "So long as one isn't carrying one's head under one's arm, things aren't too bad." "A risk is a chance you take; if it fails you can recover. A gamble is a chance taken; if it fails, recovery is impossible." "There is one unalterable difference between a soldier and a civilian: the civilian never does more than he is paid to do." "What difference does it make if you have two tanks to my one, when you spread them out and let me smash them in detail?" "The best plan is the one made when the battle is over." "In the absence of orders, go find something and kill it." "The officers of a panzer division must learn to think and act independently within the framework of the general plan and not wait until they receive orders." "Men are basically smart or dumb and lazy or ambitious. The dumb and ambitious ones are dangerous and I get rid of them. The dumb and lazy ones I give mundane duties. The smart ambitious ones I put on my staff. The smart and lazy ones I make my commanders." "Be an example to your men, in your duty and in private life. Never spare yourself, and let the troops see that you don't in your endurance of fatigue and privation. Always be tactful and well-mannered and teach your subordinates to do the same. Avoid
canadiancontent.net//42931-erwin-
1/11
5/8/2011
Erwin Rommel
excessive sharpness or harshness of voice, which usually indicates the man who has shortcomings of his own to hide." "The future battle on the ground will be preceded by battle in the air. This will determine which of the contestants has to suffer operational and tactical disadvantages and be forced throughout the battle into adoption compromise solutions." "Anyone who has to fight, even with the most modern weapons, against an enemy in complete command of the air, fights like a savage against modern European troops, under the same handicaps and with the same chances of success." "One must not judge everyone in the world by his qualities as a soldier: otherwise we should have no civilization." "The art of concentrating strength at one point, forcing a breakthrough, rolling up and securing the flanks on either side, and then penetrating like lightning deep into his rear, before the enemy has time to react-is Blitzkrieg." "Messages can't be intercepted if they aren't sent, can they?"
"This business with the Jews has got to stop." ""What was really amazing was the speed with which the Americans adapted themselves to modern warfare. Starting from scratch an army has been crafted in the very minimum of time, which, in equipment, armament and organization of all arms, surpasses anything the world has yet seen."
Canadian Content requires that you login to view links Now, I have read articles that said that Erwin Rommel was wanted by the allies even more than Hitler. I wonder why? He never attacked civilians directly like other German generals or I haven't seen evidence to say he attacked civilians. Was it because he was one of the greatest tacticians that ever lived? And finally, if you look at the link i have, doesn't he look like the actor Ed Harris?
#2
Re: Erwin Rommel Jan 23rd, 2006
Canadian Content requires that you login to view links Canadian Content requires that you login to view links Canadian Content requires that you login to view links Canadian Content requires that you login to view links So two questions; Was Rommel one of the best tactians in world history? And does he look like the actor, Ed harris?
#3
RE: Erwin Rommel Jan 23rd, 2006
Rommel was a great commander and tactician, and that is why the Allies wanted him worse than Hitler. Hitler, as shown by his decision to invade Russia on the first day of summer, was a detriment to German strategy. This is demonstrated even better by his insistence that his armies be destroyed rather than withdraw later in the war.
2/11
5/8/2011
Erwin Rommel Oddly enough, Rommel's reputation was enhanced by chance:

The Allies had completely compromised German codes, and regularly read Rommel's orders issued from Berlin. Rommel would refuse to obey tactical orders he didn't like. He didn't like a lot of the orders he got from Berlin. So the Brits would set up to counter a German thrust ordered by Berlin, and Rommel either wouldn't appear, or would appear in an entirely different place with unexpected tactics, and slap the Brits good. Which takes nothing from his abilities. He educated the American Army at the Kasserine Pass when he was in full retreat from the Brits.
#4
Re: Erwin Rommel Jan 23rd, 2006 Quote:
Rommel was a great commander and tactician, and that is why the Allies wanted him worse than Hitler.
Hitler, as shown by his decision to invade Russia on the first day of summer, was a detriment to German strategy. This is demonstrated even better by his insistence that his armies be destroyed rather than withdraw later in the war.
Oddly enough, Rommel's reputation was enhanced by chance:
The Allies had completely compromised German codes, and regularly read Rommel's orders issued from Berlin.
Rommel would refuse to obey tactical orders he didn't like. He didn't like a lot of the orders he got from Berlin.
So the Brits would set up to counter a German thrust ordered by Berlin, and Rommel either wouldn't appear, or would appear in an entirely different place with unexpected tactics, and slap the Brits good.
Which takes nothing from his abilities.
He educated the American Army at the Kasserine Pass when he was in full retreat from the Brits.
I agree that Hitler was a detriment. So, would that make him a great tactician because of his skill as a commander or for his not following orders from Berlin, by chance?
#5
RE: Erwin Rommel Jan 23rd, 2006
No, I think Rommel was a great general. I mean, luck always has something to do with it. As well, Rommel developed armoured tactics that were very successful, he was the first man to use AA guns (the famous 88mm guns) as anti-tank weapons, he predicted the Allied landing at Normandy.....he was the man.
3/11
5/8/2011
#6
Erwin Rommel
Re: Erwin Rommel Jan 23rd, 2006
hmmmm I've always thought Rommel was a good general and a pretty moderate Nazi... if there is such a thing. But you also have to take in account the highly trained men making up his army and the highly technical arms (tanks). So yeah he was good but so were the tanks and men he had. =-D
#7
RE: Erwin Rommel Jan 24th, 2006
All his quotes makes sense including the one where you shouldn't call your enemies assh*les but be nice to them. If its good enough for Rommel I guess then I should change my ways.
#8
When hitler ordered all captured Free French executed, Rommel refused to obey.
#9
Re: Erwin Rommel Jan 25th, 2006 Quote:
When hitler ordered all captured Free French executed, Rommel refused obey.
Wow, what a nice guy.
#10
Re: Erwin Rommel Jan 25th, 2006 Quote: Originally Posted by Jersay
Quote:
Could you picture a US commander in Iraq refusing a torture order? Don't think so.
#11
Re: Erwin Rommel Jan 25th, 2006
Agree totally with you.
#12
Re: Erwin Rommel Jan 25th, 2006 Quote: Originally Posted by ElPolaco
Quote: Originally Posted by Jersay
4/11
5/8/2011
Quote:
Erwin Rommel
Could you picture a Canadian 2Commando Commander in Somaliland refusing a torture order? Don't think so.
#13
Agreed as well.
#14
Re: Erwin Rommel Jan 26th, 2006 Quote: Originally Posted by zoofer
Quote: Originally Posted by ElPolaco
Quote: Originally Posted by Jersay
Quote:
Yes I can. Yes I can.
5/11
5/8/2011
#15
Erwin Rommel
Ah Rommel. I wish I learned more about his tactics in my history course. Alas, we discuss diplomacy foremost and sweep battles and manoevers under the rug.
#16
Re: RE: Erwin Rommel Jan 26th, 2006 Quote: Originally Posted by Lifestream
They don't normally teach German history in Canadian schools. They only thing I learned (even being a German) was to hate Germans school was 6 Million! 6 Million! 6 Million! 6 Million! 6 Million! 6 Million! and consider them as evil. All I ever heard about Germany in secondary
Of course, there's a lot more to wwii and German history than that. What a racist education system I went through!
#17
When you get into post-secondary they teach alot of German history, well at least in my university. But i agree, in Canadian history throughout highschool, and elementary they just teach about the Holocaust which wasn't even thought up to 1942, 43, they protray it like it was some thing Germans did immediately when Hitler came to power.
#18
It's a shame Hitler had him executed, he would have been a good man to have in post war Germany. Check out Fox on the Rhine if your into that kind of stuff.
#19
Yeah, from what i heard, Hitler gave him an option. Commit suicide or have his family killed. So Rommel did the only Noble thing he could do and killed himself.
6/11
5/8/2011
#20
Erwin Rommel
The six million kind of pales next to these numbers. WORLD WAR II FATALITIES World War II was without doubt the costliest war in military history. No truly accurate figures exist and estimates can be only roughly approximated. Somewhere between 15 and 20 million military personnel were killed in action and another 25 to 30 million civilians probably died as a result of the indiscriminate bombings, artillery barrages, and savage fighting. Military Dead Among the Allies, the USSR had the heaviest battle casualties, with about 7.5 million dead. China lost 2.2 million combatants; the British about 300,000; the United States 292,000; and France 210,000. A TOTAL of 10.5 million Among the Axis powers, Germany suffered about 3.5 million battle dead; Japan 1.5 million; and Italy 200,000. A TOTAL of 5.2 million Civilian Dead The USSR lost between 10 and 30 million civilians; China at least 6 million; France about 400,000; the United Kingdom 65,000; and the United States 6,000. A TOTAL of 16.5 million On the Axis side, 500 - 700,000 German civilians were killed; 600 - 700,000 died in Japan; and 150,000 in Italy. A TOTAL of 1.5 million
ESTIMATED TOTAL CASUALTIES = 50 Million plus
#21
#juan, I think Andem is talking about the Holocaust.
#22
If I can answer for #juan, I think he knows that. #juan just comparing the 6 million holocaust number to the number of dead allies and axis power military and citizens. There's a sense that the Jews have used the holocaust to further their aims and that the 6 million holocaust dead is a smaller number than what some other nations experienced or non-jews experienced. But the holocaust was quite an interesting abomination above and beyond the horrors of war. If this had happened to the muslims or christians you would hear the same efforts at ensuring the memory never fades.
7/11
5/8/2011
Erwin Rommel
And this wasn't just a genocide like that tried on the Armenians or on the Kurds or on the Bosnian muslims or on Dafur blacks, this particular genocide had peculiarities like bars of soap that used to be somebody's great grandfather. Jewish commercial over.
And now we return you to this thread's presentation about Erwin Rommel ---- who I believe had a son that was Mayor until the mid 90s (?) in some West German town.
#23
#juan, I think Andem is talking about the Holocaust.
The Holocaust is a very crucial part of German history. If Andem doesn't like hearing about it, I suggest he not study German history.
#24
Re: RE: Erwin Rommel Jan 27th, 2006 Quote: Originally Posted by Andem
Quote: Originally Posted by Lifestream
They don't normally teach German history in Canadian schools. They only thing I learned (even being a German) was to hate Germans and consider them as evil. All I ever heard about Germany in secondary school was
6 Million! 6 Million! 6 Million! 6 Million! 6 Million! 6 Million!
Of course, there's a lot more to wwii and German history than that. What a racist education system I went through!
Yeah. When I was in university one of my Education Profs was German. We had a debate over a history requirement that the Holocaust be taught in European History as a separate section. He could not
8/11
5/8/2011
Erwin Rommel understand why that genocide was separate and apart from the genocides of Cambodia, or the Armenians of Turkey, or any of the African ones, ad nauseum.
My argument is this: The German genocide of the Jews is much more relevant to us, because the Germans ARE us. Germany was a modern European, white, industrialized democratic state in 1932, and it descended into a monster state with a coherent process of elimination of a race. If this could happen there, it could happen here, or anywhere in the West. If this was Cambodia, or Africa, many people would dismiss genocide as "those people do this stuff all the time, it can't be helped". But the Germans are us. Don't take it personally, it is not as much a condemnation of specifically German evil as it is a warning of the evil in all of us. No matter how "white" and civilized we are.
#25
When I was in university one of my Education Profs was German. We had a debate over a history requirement that the Holocaust be taught in European History as a separate section. He could not understand why that genocide was separate and apart from the genocides of Cambodia, or the Armenians of Turkey, or any of the African ones, ad nauseum.
My argument is this: The German genocide of the Jews is much more relevant to us, because the Germans ARE us.
Germany was a modern European, white, industrialized democratic state in 1932, and it descended into a monster state with a coherent process of elimination of a race. If this could happen there, it could happen here, or anywhere in the West.
If this was Cambodia, or Africa, many people would dismiss genocide as "those people do this stuff all the time, it can't be helped".
But the Germans are us.
Don't take it personally, it is not as much a condemnation of specifically German evil as it is a warning of the evil in all of us. No matter how "white" and civilized we are.
So white people are more civilized then someone else. All Genocide should be discussed, not just the Holocaust, it is terrible yes, but the other genocides of the world should not be forgotten. Just because they were white-people doesn't mean squat. genocide all genocide should be taught and studied so that the point is that everyone is evil or has evil in their hearts and go to extreme lengths to end their obsessions.
#26
9/11
5/8/2011
Erwin Rommel
I thought Rommel was dieing anyways when his car was hit by a fighter fire and his recorver was.... not looking so good.
#27
I thought Rommel was dieing anyways when his car was hit by a fighter fire and his recorver was.... not looking so good.
He was badly injured from the attack but I don't think he was dying.
#28
Quote:
When I was in university one of my Education Profs was German. We had a debate over a history requirement that the Holocaust be taught in European History as a separate section. He could not understand why that genocide was separate and apart from the genocides of Cambodia, or the Armenians of Turkey, or any of the African ones, ad nauseum.
My argument is this: The German genocide of the Jews is much more relevant to us, because the Germans ARE us.
Germany was a modern European, white, industrialized democratic state in 1932, and it descended into a monster state with a coherent process of elimination of a race. If this could happen there, it could happen here, or anywhere in the West.
If this was Cambodia, or Africa, many people would dismiss genocide as "those people do this stuff all the time, it can't be helped".
But the Germans are us.
Don't take it personally, it is not as much a condemnation of specifically German evil as it is a warning of the evil in all of us. No matter how "white" and civilized we are.
So white people are more civilized then someone else.
All Genocide should be discussed, not just the Holocaust, it is terrible yes, but the other genocides of the world should not be forgotten.
Just because they were white-people doesn't mean squat. genocide all genocide should be taught and studied so that the point is that everyone is evil or has evil in their hearts and go to extreme lengths to end their obsessions.
Exactly my point Jersay, white, civilized people are as apt as any other race to go over the line and engage in mass murder and genocide. There are lots of people that would tell you such things are impossible in our wonderful, progressive
10/11
5/8/2011
society. Hogwash.
Erwin Rommel
That is why it is especially important to teach the Holocaust. The Germans are our reflection in the mirror.
Similar Threads
22 Erwin Rommel by Jersay | Mar 9th, 2007
About Canadian Content | Contact Us | Terms of Service | Archive

Powered by vBulletin Version 3.8.4 Copyright 2000 - 2011, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Canadian Content MMXI. All rights reserved.
11/11

Erwin Rommel Quotes

Hochgeladen von

Dokumentinformationen

Originalbeschreibung:

Copyright

Verfügbare Formate

Dieses Dokument teilen

Dokument teilen oder einbetten

Freigabeoptionen

Stufen Sie dieses Dokument als nützlich ein?

Sind diese Inhalte unangemessen?

Copyright:

Verfügbare Formate

Erwin Rommel Quotes

Hochgeladen von

Copyright:

Verfügbare Formate

5/8/2011

Canadian Content Entertainment Hot Topics News Politics

Jan 23rd, 2006

Re: Erwin Rommel Jan 23rd, 2006

RE: Erwin Rommel Jan 23rd, 2006

Erwin Rommel Oddly enough, Rommel's reputation was enhanced by chance:

Re: Erwin Rommel Jan 23rd, 2006 Quote:

Oddly enough, Rommel's reputation was enhanced by chance:

Which takes nothing from his abilities.

RE: Erwin Rommel Jan 23rd, 2006

RE: Erwin Rommel Jan 24th, 2006

RE: Erwin Rommel Jan 25th, 2006

Re: Erwin Rommel Jan 25th, 2006 Quote:

Wow, what a nice guy.

Wow, what a nice guy.

Re: Erwin Rommel Jan 25th, 2006

Agree totally with you.

Quote: Originally Posted by Jersay

Wow, what a nice guy.

Re: Erwin Rommel Jan 25th, 2006 Quote:

Quote: Originally Posted by ElPolaco

Quote: Originally Posted by Jersay

Wow, what a nice guy.

Yes I can. Yes I can.

Re: Erwin Rommel Jan 26th, 2006

Re: Erwin Rommel Jan 26th, 2006

Re: Erwin Rommel Jan 26th, 2006

ESTIMATED TOTAL CASUALTIES = 50 Million plus

Re: Erwin Rommel Jan 26th, 2006

#juan, I think Andem is talking about the Holocaust.

RE: Erwin Rommel Jan 26th, 2006

#juan, I think Andem is talking about the Holocaust.

Quote: Originally Posted by Lifestream

6 Million! 6 Million! 6 Million! 6 Million! 6 Million! 6 Million!

Re: Erwin Rommel Jan 27th, 2006 Quote:

But the Germans are us.

Re: Erwin Rommel Jan 28th, 2006

Re: Erwin Rommel Jan 28th, 2006 Quote:

But the Germans are us.

So white people are more civilized then someone else.

About Canadian Content | Contact Us | Terms of Service | Archive

Canadian Content MMXI. All rights reserved.

Das könnte Ihnen auch gefallen