You are on page 1of 8

BENNETT C.

JAFFE
SE MA LEGAL ASSISTANT CORP.
231 MAIN STREET, STE. 201
BROCKTON, MA 02301
Name: COUTINHO, JOAO
U.S. Department of Justice
Executive Ofce fr Immigration Review
Board of Immigration Appeals
Ofce of the Clerk
5107 Leesbur
g
Pike, Suite 2000
Fa/ Church, Vir
g
inia 20530
OHS/ICE Ofice of Chief Counsel - BOS
P .0. Box 8728
Boston, MA 02114
A 098-236-13
Date of this notice: 2/11/2014
Enclosed is a copy of the Board's decision and order in the above-refrenced case.
Enclosure
Panel Members:
Creppy, Michael J.
Sincerely,
D/ c t
Donna Carr
Chief Clerk
yungc
Userteam: Docket
For more unpublished BIA decisions, visit www.irac.net/unpublished
I
m
m
i
g
r
a
n
t

&

R
e
f
u
g
e
e

A
p
p
e
l
l
a
t
e

C
e
n
t
e
r

|

w
w
w
.
i
r
a
c
.
n
e
t
Cite as: Joao Coutinho, A098 236 413 (BIA Feb. 11, 2014)
.'
U.S. Department of Justice
Executive Ofce fr Immigration Review
Decision of the Board oflmmigration Appeals
Falls Church, \:irginia 20530
File: A098 236 413 - Boston, MA
In re: JOAO COUTINHO
I REMOVAL PROCEEDINGS
APPEAL
Date:
ON BEHALF OF RESPONDENT: Bennett C. Jafee, Esquire
APPLICATION: Adjustment of stats
FEB 11 2014
The respondent, a native and citizen of Cape Verde, appeals the Immigration Judge's
October 5, 2011, decision denying his application fr adjustment of status under section 245 of
the Act, 8 U.S.C. 1255. The record will be remanded.
We review fr clear error the fndings of fct, including the determination of credibility,
made by the Immigration Judge. 8 C.F.R. 1003. l (d)(3)(i). We review de novo all other issues,
including whether the paries have met the relevat burden of proof, and issues of discretion.
8 C. F.R. 1003.l(d)(3)(ii).
As the respondent's application fr relief was fled afer May 11, 2005, it is govered by the
provisions of the REAL ID Act. Matter of A-S-B-, 24 l&N Dec. 493 (BIA 2008).
The Immigation Judge denied the respondent's application fr adjustment of status solely as
a mater of discretion, based upon fnding that the respondent and his United States citizen wif
had lied to the Court regarding the nature and circumstances of an alleged physical altercation
between the two in which the police were called and the respondent was arrested (l.J. at 3). The
Immigration Judge fund that their testimony was in contradiction to the police report, which
stated tat the respondent's wif told the offcers that the respondent had slapped her thee or
fur times, and which stated that the ofcers had observed red maks on the respondent's wife's
fce and neck.
The Immigration Judge's decision, however, lacks any fndings of fct related to the
respondent's positive equities, as well as any other adverse fctors, including whether the alleged
physical altercation resulted in a criminal conviction. The decision also lacks any analysis or
indication that the Immigration Judge careflly considered and balanced all favorable and
adverse fctors presented in determining whether the respondent warrants relief as a matter of
discretion. See Matter of Sotelo, 23 I&N Dec. 201, 204 (BIA 2001); Matter ofC-V-T-, 22 l&N
Dec. 7, 10-11 (BIA 1998); see also Matter of S-H-, 23 I&N Dec. 462, 465 (BIA 2002) (because
the Board has limited fct-fnding authoriy, there is a heightened need fr Immigration Judges to
include clea and complete fndings of fct in their decisions). In light of this very limited record,
we are precluded fom meaingflly reviewing de novo the Immigration Judge's discretionary
denial. See generally Matter ofS-H-, 23 I&N Dec. 462, 463-65 (BIA 2002).
I
m
m
i
g
r
a
n
t

&

R
e
f
u
g
e
e

A
p
p
e
l
l
a
t
e

C
e
n
t
e
r

|

w
w
w
.
i
r
a
c
.
n
e
t
Cite as: Joao Coutinho, A098 236 413 (BIA Feb. 11, 2014)
,.
A098 236 413
Accordingly, the record will be remanded to the Immigration Judge fr additional fct
fnding and fr a new determination a to whether te respondent warrants adjustment of status
as a matter of discretion based upon a balancing of the respondent's equities and adverse fctors.
On remand, the paries should be given te opportuity to submit additional relevant evidence
and to make additional arguments. By remanding, we make no deterination regarding the
ultimate outcome of this case; rather, that decision rests in the frst instance with the Immigration
Judge. See Mater oJL-0-G-, 21 I&N Dec. 413, 422 (BIA 1996). The fllowing order will be
entered.
ORDER: The record is remanded fr frther proceedings consistent with the fregoing
opinion and fr the entry of a new decision.
2
I
m
m
i
g
r
a
n
t

&

R
e
f
u
g
e
e

A
p
p
e
l
l
a
t
e

C
e
n
t
e
r

|

w
w
w
.
i
r
a
c
.
n
e
t
Cite as: Joao Coutinho, A098 236 413 (BIA Feb. 11, 2014)
,.
C.

'
UL P LkPHMN LV L
ZLV LVVL VLH MMHPLN HVW
NL P MHLN LLH
LLN MPLH
V3O' Pobo LCCOOOI 5, U
D CDO MBCCO1 O1
LPL LLNL N HMLVPL kHLLLN
HkLNLN
LHPH' \B} |} |} 1O0B3DOO 3D CDO D3COO IBCOB 1O1
B O13OO O1 C30O 1OD@O1 IOBD _O1m3CCOO
PkkLLPLN' PO_UBCmODC O1 BCBCUB |~}
LN HLV LV H1LNLN NN PVV
LN HPLV L LH HNPHL MNNLZ
L LLLN LV H MHLN L
OO 1OBODOODC 3B B _OB1OO DBC3VO BDO C3C32OD O1
LBO VOIOO DO OVO1D0ODC OBB CDBI@OO CDO LOBODOODC 3D CDO
NOC3CO CO P_OBL BB 1O1OLODCOO BOOVO BBOO U_OD LOV3Ow O1 B
OV3OODCO 3D IDO 1OCOIO O1 1OCOOO3D@ COO LOU1C 13DOB O_ COB1
CODV3DC3D@ BDO UDOQU3VOCB OV3OODCO COBC CDO IOBODOODC 3B
1O0OVBOO BDO O31OCCB CDO COUDC1_ O1 LBO VO1OO BB COO COUI1_
O1 IO0OVB DO 1OBODOODC OBB B3OO 1O1 1O3O1 1D COO 1O1m
I
m
m
i
g
r
a
n
t

&

R
e
f
u
g
e
e

A
p
p
e
l
l
a
t
e

C
e
n
t
e
r

|

w
w
w
.
i
r
a
c
.
n
e
t

O1 BO_UB0OOI O1 BCBIUB U1BUBOI IO BO B1OVOO oU V3BB


OC3C3OO 131OO OO D3B OODB11 O_ D3B O3OO IBIOB C3C32OO w31O
w3D wDO0 DO DBB 1BDO1OO ID1OO O3IOO IBOB C3I32OO CD3O1OO.
DO B13OB BOB1 IO OO OO@B@OO 3D B OOOB 13OO
0B113B@O DO BUO1I B113OBV3IB 1OBOOIOO O_ CDO 1OBODOOO
BOO D3B GODBO1 0OOI CDO BCBIUO1_ BOO 1O@UBCO1_ @U3OO3OOB
BOO DO 1OBOOOOO`B 0OO3CB OB03DB3OO 3B COB1 HOwOVO1
OU13O@ IDO COO1BO O1 DO 0O13B DOB13O@ w3ID 1O@B1O IO D3B
0BO1 DO LOU1I 1OV3OwOO IDO 3O1OTB3OO CODCB3OOO 3O XD3O3I
9 wD3CD 3B B O3CO 1OO1C w3CD 1O@B1O CO BO 3OC3OOOI OCCU113O@
OO O1 BOOU VOO1UB1_ 3O IDO C3I_ O1 1OCKIOO
JDO 1OU1 B1B@1BD OB11B3VO wD3CD DO LOU1 0B1KB BB
D3O3C 9P OOBC13OOB CD3B 3OC3OOOC kB1I3CUB1_ 3C
OOGC13OOG CDO 1OCKCOO kO13CO LOB1I0OOI 1OCO3V3O@ B
O0O1@OOC_ CB1 11O0 B 1O0B1O BCBI3O@ CDBI DO1 DUBOBOO wBB
BBBBUI3D@ DO1 JDO CB1 QU3CK_ OOOOO WDOO CDO O113CO1B
wODI O DO 1OBODOOO`B BB1I0OOI CDO_ OOK B BCBCO0ODI 11O0
OOD IDO 1OBOOOODC BOO D3B w11O OBO13OB DO 1OBODOOO
BCBIOO CDBT DO BDO OBO13OB UBDOO OBCD OCDO1 B 13ICO O3C
DO 1OBOOOOO DOO 1O1UBOO IO IBK CO IDO O3CO O113CO1B
1U1IDO1 JDO O113CO1B DOO 3OIO1V3OwOO CDO 1OBOOOODB w31O
OBO13OB wDO BIBCOO "IDB OBO BBOO DO1 CD1OO O1 1OU1
I30OB JDO 1OBOOOODC wBB BCOO UDOO1 B11OB D DO 1BBC
B1B@1BD O1 DO O3CO 1OO1I DO O113CO1B OOBO1VOO B 1OO
0B1K OO DO O1C B3OO O1 DO1 1BCO BOO B 1OO 0B1K OD CDO 13@DI
PUob9o LCCOOO1 5, U
I
m
m
i
g
r
a
n
t

&

R
e
f
u
g
e
e

A
p
p
e
l
l
a
t
e

C
e
n
t
e
r

|

w
w
w
.
i
r
a
c
.
n
e
t

'-
B3O O1 DO1 DOCK 1O1O113D@ CO CDO 1OBODOOOC`B w31O OBO13OB
LU13D@ CDO31 COBC30OD_ COOB_ BC CDO 0O13CB DOB13D@
f . -
w3ID 1O@B1O CO CD3B 0BCCO1 OOCD 1

OOD3O CDBC BD_
BO1C O1 D_B3CB BCO1CBC3OD DBO CBKOD BCO OOCwOOD CDO
B1I3OB kB1C3COB1_ CDO 1OBODOODC OOD3OO CDBC DO DBO
BBOO OBO13DB OBO13DB wBB BOB0BOC CDBC BDO DBO DOC OOOD
BBOO OCD CDO 1OBODODC BDO D3B w31O COOK CDO OB3C3OO
CDBC CDO O3CO O113CO1B w13C3D@ CDO 1OO1C DBO OOOD UDI1UCD1U
3D IDO31 1OO1C HOwOVO1 DO3IDO1 wBB BOO CO O11O1 BD_
1BI3OOBO 1O1 wD_ CDOBO 1OCKCOD O3CO O113CO1B OO3D@ CBOO CO
CD3B O0O1@OOC_ CB wOUO 0BDU1BCCU1O CD3B O3CO 1OO1C BDO
CO 0BKO U CDO OOBO1VBC3ODB O1 CDO 1OO 0B1XB OD CDO 1OBODOODC`B
w31O DO1 CBD CDO LOU1C 13DO BD_ OBB3OO 1OBBOD wD_ CDO O3CO
O113CO1B wOUO 0BKO U CDOBO OOBO1VBC3ODB BB wO BB 0BKO U
CDO BCBCO0ODCB wD3CD CDO_ 1OO1C 11O0 OBO13OB CDBC BDO DBO OOOD
BBO O_ CDO 1OBODODC
JDO LOU1C 13DB CDBC OOCD CDO 1OBODOODC BDO D3B w31O
DBMO OOOD UDClUCD1U w3CD CDO LOU1C 3D CDO31 COBC30OD_ IOB_
OCBUBO O1 CD3B CDO LOU1I 13DB CDBC CDO_ 3O DOC DODO1 CDO31
OOJ3_BI3OD CO IOBC31_ C1UCO1U_ B1CO1 OO3O@ BO03D3BCO1OO CDO
OBID 1OQU313D@ CDO0 CO OO BO DO LOU1C 13DOB CDBC CDO_ DBVO
13G UDOO1 OBD 3D3G lG B VO1_ GO13OUB 0BCCO1 3D CDO LOO1C`B
COIB3OO1BC3OD BDO 3C 1B B 0BCCO1 O1 O3BC1OC3OD OCBUBO O1
CD3B CDO LOU1I w3 OOD_ BDO DO1OO_ OOOB OOO_ CD3B B3CBI
_
OD
1O1 BO_UBC0ODC O1 BCBIUB PB CDO 1OBOOOOOC DBB DO OCDO1 0OBDB
Pbb4 LCCOOO1 5, J
I
m
m
i
g
r
a
n
t

&

R
e
f
u
g
e
e

A
p
p
e
l
l
a
t
e

C
e
n
t
e
r

|

w
w
w
.
i
r
a
c
.
n
e
t

'
O1 1O3O CDBC DO B BOOK3O@ O1 CB303D@ DO 3B DO1OO_ O1OO1OO
1O0OVOO CO CDO COUDC1_ O1 LB_O NO1OO
DO 1OOw3O@ O1OO1 BDB OOCO1
LH
DO 1OB_OOOODCB B_3CBC3OD O1 BO_UBC0ODI O1 BCBCUB
3B DO1OO_ OOO3OO
DO 1OB_OOODC 3B O1OO1OO 1O0OVOO CO CDO COUDC1_ O
LB_O NO1OO
kPL M LPLNLN
D3CO CBCOB 003@1BC3OO UO@O
PobJo LCCOOO1 5, JJ
I
m
m
i
g
r
a
n
t

&

R
e
f
u
g
e
e

A
p
p
e
l
l
a
t
e

C
e
n
t
e
r

|

w
w
w
.
i
r
a
c
.
n
e
t
CERTIFICATE PAGE

`
I hereby certify that the attached proceeding before JUDGE
PAUL M. GAGNON, in the matter of:
JOAO COUTINHO
A098-236-413
BOSTON, MASSACHUSETTS
is an accurate, verbatim transcript of the recording as provided
by the Executive Office for Imigration Review and that this is
the original transcript thereof for the file of the Executive
Office for Imigration Review.
. .
.' .
ANGELINA BECERRA {Transcriber)
DEPOSITION SERVICES, Inc.
DECEMBER 16, 2011
(Completion Date)
I
m
m
i
g
r
a
n
t

&

R
e
f
u
g
e
e

A
p
p
e
l
l
a
t
e

C
e
n
t
e
r

|

w
w
w
.
i
r
a
c
.
n
e
t