Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
Psychosocial Functioning and Health-related Quality of Life in Paediatric Inflammatory Bowel Disease
ABSTRACT
Objectives: The present systematic review examined the literature focusing on psychosocial functioning and health-related quality of life (HRQOL) in young people with inammatory bowel disease (IBD). It aimed to critique the methodological quality of the identied studies, discuss the implications of their ndings, and make recommendations for future research. Patients and Methods: Relevant articles (January 1990December 2009) were subject to strict inclusion and exclusion criteria. Identied papers were rated for methodological quality using SIGN 50 and Critical Appraisal Skills Programme guidelines before data extraction. Results: Of 2141 articles initially identied, 278 were screened in detail, leaving 12 articles for inclusion in the review: 3 having acceptable and 9 having goodquality rating scores. These 12 studies yielded a combined total of 5330 participants including 790 with IBD and 4540 controls (ages 418 years). Five main outcomesself-esteem, HRQOL, anxiety and depression, social competence, and behavioural functioningwere examined. Three of the 4 controlled studies addressing self-reported HRQOL found it to be signicantly lower in the participants with IBD. The evidence for lowered self-esteem, self-reported symptoms of depression and anxiety, impaired social competence, and behavioural problems were conicting. Methodological heterogeneity was noted in terms of areas of functioning addressed, measures used, sample size, and use of control groups. Conclusions: HRQOL is lower in patients with IBD, but conicting results and methodological aws limit conclusions on other aspects of psychosocial functioning. Future research should present data on effect sizes, avoid confounding ndings by not combining across age groups or disease severity indices, and consider investigating body image disturbance. Key Words: adolescents, children, health-related quality of life, inammatory bowel disease, psychosocial functioning
nflammatory bowel disease (IBD), comprising Crohn disease (CD) and ulcerative colitis (UC), is commonly diagnosed in childhood or adolescence. Around 15% to 25% of individuals with IBD are diagnosed in childhood (1) and the incidence of paediatric IBD is reported to be increasing in Europe and North America, although reasons for this remain unknown (2). IBD is characterised by an unpredictable illness course and includes symptoms of abdominal pain, diarrhoea, nausea, fatigue, delayed puberty, and weight loss. These symptoms, in addition to treatment (including surgery, corticosteroids, and having a stoma), can be embarrassing, socially limiting, and can lead to changes in physical appearance. This may have a negative effect on body image, self-esteem, and mood (35). The social constraints of the disease, in addition to the considerable amount of school often missed because of illness and hospital appointments, may therefore have effect on social functioning (3,4). This could result in the children having fewer opportunities to develop autonomy as they grow older.
Received March 11, 2011; accepted July 17, 2011. From the Academic Unit for Mental Health and Wellbeing, School of Medicine, University of Glasgow, and the yDepartment of Paediatric Gastroenterology, Royal Hospital for Sick Children, Glasgow, UK. Address correspondence and reprint requests to Dr S.L. Wilson, Academic Unit for Mental Health and Wellbeing, University of Glasgow, Admin. Building, Gartnavel Royal Hospital, 1055 Great Western Rd, Glasgow G12 0XH, UK (e-mail: Sarah.Wilson@glasgow.ac.uk). This work was carried out in partial fullment of the requirements for the degree of DClinPsy and was funded by NHS Education Scotland. R.K.R. has received support from a Medical Research Council PICTS grant (G0800675). The IBD team at Yorkhill, Glasgow is supported by the Catherine McEwan Foundation. The authors report no conicts of interest. Copyright # 2011 by European Society for Pediatric Gastroenterology, Hepatology, and Nutrition and North American Society for Pediatric Gastroenterology, Hepatology, and Nutrition DOI: 10.1097/MPG.0b013e31822f2c32
480 JPGN Volume 53, Number 5, November 2011 Copyright 2011 by ESPGHAN and NASPGHAN. Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited.
JPGN
Psychosocial Functioning and Quality of Life in Paediatric IBD was conducted in addition to searching each database individually using subject headings. The results of the subject-heading search informed the final text-word search. The references of the most recent review (12) were examined to ensure no appropriate studies had been missed.
allow judgments to be made about the clinical significance of a young persons difficulties. Generic measures of HRQOL (eg, PedsQL) (9), which compare children with IBD to healthy peers and children with other conditions, have been used. Although these allow easy comparison across illness groups, they may not be specific enough to reflect impaired functioning in young people with IBD. Researchers in Canada and the Netherlands have collaboratively developed and validated IMPACT, a paediatric IBD-specific questionnaire measuring 6 domains: bowel symptoms, systemic symptoms, social/functional concerns, body image, emotional concerns, and test and treatment concerns (10,11). In addition to these broad HRQOL measures, questionnaires that focus on specific symptoms (eg, depression) or areas of functioning (eg, social functioning) also are popular. Mackner and Crandall (12) highlight the benefits of including a comparison group when assessing psychosocial functioning/ HRQOL. A control group (healthy age-matched peers or those with another chronic illness) can identify problems that are specific to young people with IBD. Although normative reference data are often used in place of matched control groups, these data cannot account for cohort effects, geographical location, and socioeconomic factors that may be specific to the population being studied.
Inclusion Criteria
All of the studies retrieved by the database search were examined using the following inclusion criteria. Those not meeting these criteria were excluded from the review. Published in a peer-reviewed journal Study examined data from original research Study is written in English Study uses quantitative methods Participants aged 18 years or younger Participants have a medically conrmed diagnosis of CD, UC, or IBD unclassied 7. Outcome measures include HRQOL or aspects of psychosocial functioning (eg, social/behavioural functioning, self-esteem, body image, depression, anxiety) 8. Established or standardised questionnaires are used 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6.
OBJECTIVES
This is a growing area of research in which various aspects of psychosocial functioning have been examined using a range of different measures. Although the most recently published review (12) summarises the literature up to 2006, it was not performed in a systematic fashion. Because several articles have been published in the intervening years, it is timely for a systematic review to be conducted to evaluate this research literature in greater depth. With increasing recognition that populations with IBD may be experiencing difficulties, intervention trials are already under way to evaluate the efficacy of psychological treatments such as cognitive-behavioural therapy (13). A thorough examination of the evidence to date is therefore clinically relevant. The present review summarises the relevant literature, focussing on psychosocial functioning and HRQOL in young people with IBD (up to age 18 years), to critique the methodological quality of this literature, discuss the implications of the findings, and make recommendations for future research and clinical practice.
RESULTS
The database search identified 2141 articles. Of these, 1863 were either duplicates or were not deemed relevant to the present review and were excluded on the basis of the title. Abstracts of the remaining 278 articles were examined using full inclusion criteria, resulting in the exclusion of a further 252 articles; this left 26 potentially appropriate articles, 14 of which were excluded after reviewing the full text (10,11,1627) (Fig. 1). The 12 remaining articles were deemed suitable to be included in the review and are discussed in detail below (4,5,2837).
481
Copyright 2011 by ESPGHAN and NASPGHAN. Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited.
Ross et al
JPGN
Databases searched using search terms: Ovid medline EMBASE PsychInfo British nursing index HMIC EBSCO CINHAL WOK web of science between the dates 1990 Dec 2009 Articles identified n = 2141
Table 1 provides a summary of each study in its entirety for reference. In interpreting psychosocial functioning/HRQOL scores, larger or increasing scores indicate better functioning unless otherwise stated.
Self-esteem
Excluded n = 1863 Duplicates removed and articles excluded on the basis of title
Titles and abstracts screened n = 278 Excluded n = 252 Not child or adolescent sample Not original journal article Not published in peer reviewed journal Not in available in English Medical rather than psychological focus Focus on parent rather than child
Full copies of potentially appropriate articles retrieved and reviewed using full inclusion/exclusion criteria n = 26
Excluded n = 14 Secondary data from another included study n = 5 Primary outcome not HRQOL or psychosocial function n = 1 No clear outcome data n = 3 Not standardised measures n = 2 Other = 3
FIGURE 1. Flowchart of the study selection process. Eleven of the studies were cross-sectional observational studies and 1 used a prospective longitudinal design (36). Four studies (33%) did not have a control group (5,28,36,37); 5 (42%) used either matched controls recruited at the time of the study (4,29,35), another illness group (32), or illness groups or healthy controls (31). Three studies (25%) used previously collected reference group data (30,33,34). Time since diagnosis varied widely between studies from 0 months (5,36), >1 to 2 months (28), 3 months (35), 6 months (30,33,34), and >1 year (4). From the information available (4 studies did not report time since diagnosis), the mean duration of disease was 2.74 years. Only 6 studies reported disease severity in categories that could be compared among studies (4,5,33,34,36,37). In these studies (n 539), 36% had mild, 45% had intermediate/moderate, and 19% had severe disease activity. A wide range of standardised assessments were administered via questionnaires and clinician-led interviews. The majority of studies included both self- and parent-report questionnaires (4 used self-report measures only). Four studies conducted standardised diagnostic interviews with either the child (31) or the child and parent (5,28,37). Quality rating revealed that 3 articles (5,28,30) scored in the acceptable range (>50%), whereas the remaining 9 papers scored in the good range (>75%). Methodological shortcomings are discussed below in relation to the results as they arise.
Self-esteem was measured using standardised, validated selfreport questionnaires in 5 studies (4,3033). Only one of these studies, using a measure of self-esteem, I think I am, developed in Sweden (38), found that young people with IBD had significantly lowered self-esteem compared with healthy controls (Fr 8.46, P < 0.04) (31). T scores were not provided, making it difficult to determine whether the reduction in self-esteem was clinically significant. Additionally, the present review used 20 outcome measures in a small sample (n 20) without adjusting significance levels for multiple comparisons. Another study using I think I am as the only outcome measure (33) found no significant difference in self-esteem between young people with IBD (n 71) and a previously assessed healthy reference group. Two studies using the Piers-Harris Childrens Self-Concept Scale (39), a more commonly used measure yielding T scores, also found no significant difference in self-esteem between young people with IBD and healthy controls (4,32). Indeed, Gold et al (32) found that young people with IBD actually had a significantly better self-concept than the normative group; however, participants in both of these studies had mild disease activity. In line with these findings, De Boer et al (30), using the Dutch version of the SelfPerception Profile for Adolescents (Harter) (40), did not find that young people with IBD had lowered self-esteem. They did demonstrate that self-esteem was a good predictor of all of the domains of HRQOL, but they were unable to make any assumptions about the direction of causality.
HRQOL
Five articles assessed HRQOL (29,30,3436). The 2 studies that administered generic multidimensional HRQOL instruments (29,30) had somewhat conflicting results. Using the Child Health Questionnaire (41,42), Cunningham et al (29) found that although parents reported their children with IBD to be more impaired than healthy controls in the overall areas of physical health (F 50.17, P < 0.001) and psychological health (F 5.789, P < 0.05), young people themselves did not report more difficulties except on the general health subscale. In contrast, using the Dutch Childrens AZL/TNO Quality of Life Questionnaire (DUCATQOL) (43), De Boer et al (30) found that adolescent boys with IBD self-reported significantly worse overall HRQOL than the reference group (P < 0.01). The age range of the reference data, however, did not match that of the participants, resulting in unsatisfactory analyses (girls with IBD could not be compared with controls in 2 of the 4 domains of the DUCATQOL) (30), and although the 25-item version of the DUCATQOL administered was reported to be internally consistent and reproducible (43), no validation studies had been published at that time. (Validity testing of the DUCATQOL has subsequently been reported (44).) Two studies using an IBD-specific HRQOL measure, the IMPACT Questionnaire (10,11), and generic HRQOL questionnaires found that HRQOL was significantly lower in young people with IBD (34,35). Loonen et al (34) analysed their data by 2 age strata in accordance with the normative data for the generic HRQOL measure (TNO-AZL Childrens Quality of Life questionnaire) (45). They found that although adolescents (1218 years, n 65) had significantly lower HRQOL than healthy peers on 4 domains (body www.jpgn.org
Psychosocial Functioning
The 5 main outcomes (self-esteem, HRQOL, anxiety and depression, social competence, and behavioural problems/functioning) identified will be considered separately so that comparisons can be made between studies (Table 2). An average of 4 outcome assessments were used in each study, and therefore the same studies are discussed in relation to different outcomes. For this reason,
482
Copyright 2011 by ESPGHAN and NASPGHAN. Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited.
JPGN
www.jpgn.org
1018 y; mean age 14.96 y IBD, no further info No info; mean duration no info
Study
Country
Burke et al (28)
US
Cunningham et al (29)
US
De Boer et al (30) 1218 y; mean age 15.2 y DUCATQOL, Dutch version SPPA, Dutch version STAI, CBCL Self-report x3, parent completed CBCL CD, UC, or IBDU >6 months; mean duration 3.8 y HRQOL, self-esteem, anxiety (trait), behaviour problems
The Netherlands IBD 40; healthy children 1359 (reference data DUCATQOL)
718 y; mean IBD 20; headache age 16.5 y control 20; diabetes control 20; healthy control 20 CBCL frisk well-being scale, Rotter sentence completion test, ITIA, CDI, RCMAS, Raven matrices, CAS
UC or CD
No info; mean Psychological adjustment, duration 4.2 y social competence, (range 1.08.2 y) well-being, emotional adjustment, psychiatric disorders, self-esteem, depression, anxiety, cognitive abilities No info; mean duration: 2 y Depression, self-concept, social adjustment CBCL, CDI, Piers-Harris Childrens Self-Concept Questionnaire developed by researchers ITIA
Gold et al (32) 818 y; Mean age 13.31 y UC or CD, excluded if had a colectomy
Canada
IBD 36; functional gastrointestinal complaints controls 26 1016 y; mean age 14.6 y CD, UC, or IBDU >6 mo; mean duration 2.9 y Self-esteem
Lindfred et al (33)
Sweden
Self-report
14% met diagnostic criteria for major depression, 28% for atypical depression; 10 children had a history of anxiety. The depressed group was less severely ill than the nondepressed group (P 0.006). Parent report: IBD group signicantly impaired HRQOL compared with controls (physical health score P < 0.000, psychosocial score P < 0.05); child report: no signicant differences in HRQOL compared with controls (except in general health) Boys with IBD had signicantly worse HRQOL (P < 0.01) and more behavioural problems (P < 0.05) and internalising behaviour (P < 0.01) compared with healthy peers. Girls had more internalising behaviour (P < 0.05) only. No signicant differences in state anxiety or self-esteem compared with controls. On most variables, children with IBD had highest levels of psychiatric disturbance, that is, IBD is higher than that in healthy children for behaviour problems (P < 0.03), social competence (P < 0.04), emotional adjustment (P 0.001), psychiatric disorders (P 0.01), self-esteem (P < 0.01), and depression (P < 0.02) IBD group was less depressed and had fewer behaviour problems than controls (P 0.03). No scores were in the clinical range. Children with IBD have a higher than average self-concept. No signicant difference in self-esteem between IBD group and comparison or normative group
Loonen et al (34) 818 y; mean age 14.3 y CD, UC, or IBDU >6 mo; mean duration no info HRQOL
IBD 71; previously collected healthy reference group 1037; normative data from ITIA 2662 The Netherlands IBD 83; Dutch schoolchildren controls 1810 1117 y; mean age 14.69 y CD, UC, or IBDU >1 y; mean duration 3.53 y
Self-report
YSR, CDI, RCMAS, PHSCS, coping strategies inventory, social support questionnaire Psychosocial functioning, behavioural/emotional functioning, social competence, self-esteem, coping strategies, social support HRQOL fatigue Peds-QL multidimensional fatigue scale, Peds-QL 4.0 IMPACT III, CDI-SF
Self-report
Adolescents with IBD had signicantly lowered HRQOL on 4 domains (P < 0.05). Younger children had comparable or better HRQOL than healthy peers. No signicant differences on any measures
Marcus et al (35)
US
Otley et al (36)
US and Canada
0 mofollowed up to 1 y
HRQOL
IMPACT III
Self-report
IBD group had signicantly lower generic HRQOL than healthy controls (P < 0.0001). No signicant difference in depressive symptoms between IBD and controls. Signicant improvement in HRQOL scores 1 y postdiagnosis (P < 0.05)
483
Copyright 2011 by ESPGHAN and NASPGHAN. Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited.
484
Age range No info (appears CD or UC to be 4.9215 y); mean age 11.6 y 0 mo Diagnosis (CD, UC, or IBDU) Outcomes assessed Assessments Self-report or parent report Signicant results Time since diagnosis 1117 y; mean age 14.7 y CD or UC No info; mean duration 2.4 y (range 09.7 y) Psychopathology of child K-SADS-P interview, AAI, Mostly parent report or 73% had DSM-III diagnoses (predominantly and parent, maternal CBCL, MCMI, Lockeinterview with parents; separation anxiety and major depression), attachment, attachmentWallace mental scale, some interview/assessment a signicant number showed internalising related disorders in FILE, IOF, COBI, of child but no self-report behaviour (P < 0.01) children (separation anxiety, Irvine sentence completion measures dysthymia/depression), test, WISC-R, TAT OCD disorder children Depression (and its relation CDI, SADS-PL if scored Self-report, clinical High rates of clinically signicant depressive with disease factors) >12 on CDI interview with child symptoms in older children and adolescents and parent with IBD. Twenty-ve percent had depressive symptoms (>12 CDI) and 16 of 19 psychiatrically interviewed had clinically signicant depressive disorder. No. studies nding young people with IBD were signicantly impaired compared with controls No. studies nding no difference compared with controls Conclusions
Ross et al
TABLE 1. (Continued )
Study
Country
Szajnberg et al (5)
US
Szigethy et al (37)
US
AAI Adult Attachment Interview; A-SADS-L Adult Schedule for Affective Disorders and Schizophrenia, lifetime version; CAS Childrens Assessment Schedule; CBCL Child Behaviour Checklist; CD Crohn disease; CDI-SF Child Depression InventoryShort Form; COBI Clinicians Objective Burden Index; DSM Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders; DUCATQOL Dutch Childrens AZL/TNO Quality of Life; FILE Family Inventory for Life Events; FRI Family Relationship Index Scale; HRQOL Health-Related Quality of Life; IBD inammatory bowel disease; IBDU inammatory bowel disease unclassied; IOF Impact of Events Scale; IMPACT III IBD-Specic HRQOL Instrument; ITIA I think I am; K-SADS-P Kiddie Schedule for Affective Disorders and Schizophrenia; MCMI Millon Clinical Multi-Axial Inventory; OCD obsessive-compulsive disorder; Peds-QL Pediatric Quality of Life Inventory; PHSCS Piers Harris Childrens Self-Concept Scale; RCMAS Revised Childrens Manifest Anxiety Scale; SADS-PL Schedule for Affective Disorders and Schizophrenia for School-Aged ChildrenPresent and Lifetime Versions; SPPA Self-Perception Prole for Adolescents (Dutch version); STAI State-Trait Anxiety Inventory for Children (Dutch version); TACQOL TNO-AZL Child Quality of Life Questionnaire; TAT Thematic Apperception Test; UC ulcerative colitis; WISC-R Weschler Intelligence Scale Revised; YSR Youth Self-Report.
Outcome
No. studies
Self-esteem HRQOL
5 4
131 (IBD: 20, healthy controls: 20) 2 using generic HRQOL measures (parent report29) (self-report, boys only30), (IBD: 89, healthy controls: 1408) 2 using IBD-specic HRQOL measures34,35 (IBD: 133, healthy controls: 1852) 0
44,30,32,33 (IBD: 197, healthy controls: 2438, other: 26) 1 (self-report29) (IBD: 49, healthy controls: 49)
Inconclusive evidence for lowered self-esteem HRQOL lowered in young people with IBD compared with healthy controls
Self-report
Contradictory ndings between methods Young people with IBD have higher levels of depression and anxiety than do healthy controls Young people with IBD do not appear to be more depressed or anxious than do healthy controls
45,28,31,37 (IBD: 153, normative data used31; IBD: 20, healthy controls: 20, headache: 20, diabetes: 20) Depression: 131 (IBD: 20, healthy controls: 20, headache: 20, diabetes: 20) Anxiety: 0
Social competence
Anxiety: 24,31 (IBD: 70, healthy controls: 20, headache: 20, diabetes: 20) 24,32 (IBD: 86, healthy controls: 43, other: 26) 24,32 (IBD: 86, healthy controls: 43, other: 26)
Inconclusive evidence for impaired social competence Inconclusive evidence for increased incidence of behavioural difculties
Behavioural difculties
1 parent report31 (IBD: 20, healthy controls: 20, headache: 20, diabetes: 20) 231 (IBD: 20, healthy controls: 20, headache: 20, diabetes: 20) Signicant for boys only30 (IBD: 19 boys, 21 girls, healthy controls: 1359)
www.jpgn.org
Copyright 2011 by ESPGHAN and NASPGHAN. Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited.
JPGN
Psychosocial Functioning and Quality of Life in Paediatric IBD with mixed results (4,31,32,35). Although Engstrom (31) found that young people with IBD reported significantly more depressive symptoms than healthy controls (Fr 10.00, P < 0.02), the other 3 studies did not find evidence of increased symptoms of depression in comparison with healthy controls (4,35) or another illness group (32). Two of these studies (4,31) also assessed anxiety using a self-report measure: the Revised Childrens Manifest Anxiety Scale (51); they both failed to find increased symptoms of anxiety in the IBD group compared with controls.
complaints, motor functioning, autonomy, and negative emotions) (P < 0.05), younger children (811 years, n 18) had comparable or better HRQOL than controls (the small sample of younger children had mainly inactive or mild disease). Marcus et al (35) found that young people reported significantly lower HRQOL than matched healthy controls on both the IBD-specific IMPACT (P < 0.001) and on a well-established generic measure of HRQOL (PedsQL 4.0) (9) (P < 0.001). The second IMPACT was a large multisite prospective cohort study that administered the questionnaire to 218 young people with IBD; mean HRQOL scores significantly improved from baseline during the first year postdiagnosis (P < 0.05) (36).
Social Competence
Three studies examined social competence as an outcome (4,31,32). Engstrom (31) and Gold et al (32) used a parentreport questionnaire, the Child Behaviour Checklist (52), whereas Mackner and Crandall (4) administered the self-report version, the Youth Self-Report (53). Both measures have a social competence scale in which an increasing score indicates better social functioning. Although 2 studies (4,32) found social competence to be in the normal range and comparable with controls, Engstrom (31) found that mothers rated their children with IBD as significantly less socially competent than healthy children (Fr 7.86, P < 0.04). Given the small sample size and large number of measures used in the present review, however, it would be prudent to interpret these results with caution (eg, by adopting a more conservative significance level).
Behavioural Problems/Functioning
Four studies examined behavioural functioning using either the Child Behaviour Checklist (3032) or Youth Self-Report (4). These measures yield a total behavioural problems score as well as internalising behaviour (withdrawn, somatic complaints, and anxious/depressed) and externalising behaviour (rule-breaking and aggressive behaviour) scores. For these domains, an increasing score indicates greater levels of behavioural problems. Engstrom (31) found that young people with IBD had significantly more total behavioural (x2 Fr 9.34, P < 0.03) and internalising behaviour (x2 Fr 9.83, P < 0.02) problems than healthy controls. De Boer et al (30), comparing young people with IBD to a healthy reference group, found significant differences on the total behavioural problems (P < 0.05) and internalising behaviour subscales (P < 0.01) for boys, whereas for girls, the only significant difference was found for internalising behaviour (P < 0.05). In contrast, Gold et al (32) and Mackner and Crandall (4) found mean scores in the normal range and no significant differences between young people with IBD and controls; a subset of 20% of participants with IBD did, however, report clinically impaired levels of behavioural/emotional functioning (4).
DISCUSSION
The reviewed studies present a somewhat mixed picture of psychosocial functioning/HRQOL in children and adolescents with IBD, although the evidence for decreased HRQOL and increased incidence of psychiatric disorders (eg, anxiety and depression, assessed using structured diagnostic interviews) seems fairly consistent across the included studies. In the 2 studies in which parental/family functioning also was assessed, all of those who showed psychiatric caseness came from families with other psychological problems. Children and young people with an emotional disorder are at least twice as likely as those without to have a parent with a mental health disorder (54). The evidence for lowered self-esteem, symptoms of depression and anxiety
Self-report Questionnaires
Four studies administered the Childrens Depression Inventory, a self-report measure of depression, to young people www.jpgn.org
485
Copyright 2011 by ESPGHAN and NASPGHAN. Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited.
Ross et al (measured by self-report measures), impaired social competence, and behavioural functioning is less clear because of conflicting results. To make sense of these findings, confounding factors that may have influenced outcomes are considered and placed in the context of other relevant research.
JPGN
people from more stable family backgrounds are more likely to have their IBD diagnosed and treated. Studies have also reported that children with CD proportionately are more likely to come from affluent backgrounds (57,58).
Disease Severity
Disease severity also may contribute to the variation in results. Increased disease severity was found to correlate with increased depression (37), lowered self-esteem (33), and decreased HRQOL (29,35,36). It seems intuitive that young people experiencing more severe symptoms would report lower HRQOL than those in remission. Most of the studies reviewed had large proportions of participants categorised with either mild or moderate disease severity. Therefore, information about the difficulties experienced by individuals with more severe symptoms may be missing. The underrepresentation of this group also may make correlations between severity and psychosocial functioning more difficult to appreciate; however, a number of studies found no association between disease severity and psychopathology (4,17,18,28). There is, however, some evidence that psychosocial factors are more predictive of emotional and behavioural functioning than disease factors (24,28). Low socioeconomic status has been found to correlate with increased depression (32) and decreased selfesteem (33), whereas parental separation correlated with reduced self-esteem (33). This is consistent with research in the general population, where these factors are considered to increase risk for psychological difficulties (56). Interestingly, children with IBD have a consistently higher proportion of cohabiting or married parents than those in healthy control groups (31). Parents perhaps stay together to care for their sick child, or alternatively, young
486
Copyright 2011 by ESPGHAN and NASPGHAN. Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited.
JPGN
Psychosocial Functioning and Quality of Life in Paediatric IBD needs to be considered given the increased awareness of body image and appearance that is typical of teenage development. Developing a clearer understanding of the effect of IBD on HRQOL and psychosocial functioning would be beneficial for clinical staff working with this illness group because it would allow early interventions to be targeted to those most at risk. This may prevent the development of more serious mental health problems such as depression, which has been linked to difficulties with medication adherence (61), and anxiety, which may exacerbate future disease activity (8). In addition to the individual benefits associated with improved emotional and physical health, there could be financial benefits and associated savings for the health system in terms of reduced hospital admissions; also, there is a likelihood of reducing school absences, which in turn will have positive effects on the childs or teenagers social, emotional, and academic development. Acknowledgment: The authors thank Dr Kimberly Ross, who co-rated the papers included in the review.
calculated effect sizes for their results (30). The majority of studies included participants from a wide age range with varying disease severity and disease durations. The present review indicates that these factors may have an influence on HRQOL and as such should be considered carefully in the study design and analysis. Inclusion and exclusion criteria were often not reported in sufficient detail. All of the studies except for one used a cross-sectional design, which means causality cannot be determined. More recently published studies, however, appear to be addressing some of the limitations outlined above. Otley and colleagues (36) ongoing longitudinal study will provide valuable information about HRQOL over time. Since the validation of an IBD-specific HRQOL measure (the IMPACT score), a growing number of studies have reported robust results that allow easy comparison. HRQOL is frequently used as an outcome in clinical studies of patients with IBD. There also has been an increase in the use of objective, standardised disease severityrating questionnaires (eg, the Paediatric Crohn Disease Activity Index (59), the Pediatric Ulcerative Colitis Activity Index (60)), allowing for more accurate disease severity recording and better comparison between studies.
REFERENCES
1. Kim SC, Ferry GD. Inammatory bowel diseases in pediatric and adolescent patients: clinical, therapeutic, and psychosocial considerations. Gastroenterology 2004;126:155060. 2. Benchimol EI, Fortinsky KJ, Gozdyra P, et al. Epidemiology of pediatric inammatory bowel disease: a systematic review of international trends. Inamm Bowel Dis 2011;17:42339. 3. Engstrom I. Inammatory bowel disease in children and adolescents: mental health and family functioning. J Pediatr Gastroenterol Nutr 1999;28:S2833. 4. Mackner LM, Crandall WV. Long-term psychosocial outcomes reported by children and adolescents with inammatory bowel disease. Am J Gastroenterol 2005;100:138692. 5. Szajnberg N, Krall V, Davis P, et al. Psychopathology and relationship measures in children with inammatory bowel disease and their parents. Child Psychiatry Hum Dev 1993:23; 21532. 6. Drossman DA, Patrick DL, Mitchell CM, et al. Health-related quality of life in inammatory bowel disease: functional status and patient worries and concerns. Dig Dis Sci 1989;34:137986. 7. Hommel KA, Denson LA, Crandall WV, et al. Behavioral functioning and treatment adherence in pediatric inammatory bowel disease: review and recommendations for practice. Gastroenterol Hepatol 2008;4:78591. 8. Mittermaier C, Dejaco C, Waldhoer T, et al. Impact of depressive mood on relapse in patients with inammatory bowel disease: a prospective 18-month follow-up study. Psychosom Med 2004;66:7984. 9. Varni JW, Seid M, Kurtin PS. Reliability and validity of the pediatric quality of life inventory version 4.0 generic core scales in healthy and patient populations. Med Care 2001;39:80012. 10. Grifths AM, Nicholas D, Smith C, et al. Development of a quality-oflife index for pediatric inammatory bowel disease: dealing with differences related to age and IBD type. J Pediatr Gastroenterol Nutr 1999;28:S4652. 11. Otley A, Smith C, Nicholas D, et al. The IMPACT questionnaire: a valid measure of health-related quality of life in pediatric inammatory bowel disease. J Pediatr Gastroenterol Nutr 2002;35:55763. 12. Mackner LM, Crandall WV. Psychological factors affecting pediatric inammatory bowel disease. Curr Opin Pediatr 2007;19:54852. 13. Szigethy E, Carpenter J, Baum E, et al. Case study: longitudinal treatment of adolescents with depression and inammatory bowel disease. J Am Acad Child Adolesc Psychiatry 2006;45:396400. 14. Sign 50: A Guideline Developers Handbook, Methodology Checklists. Edinburgh: Scottish Intercollegiate Guidelines Network; 2004. 15. Critical Appraisal Skills Programme. Public Health Resource Unit. New York: Oxford University Press; 2004. 16. Burke P, Kocoshis SA, Chandra R, et al. Determinants of depression in recent onset pediatric inammatory bowel disease. J Am Acad Child Adolesc Psychiatry 1990;29:60810.
487
Copyright 2011 by ESPGHAN and NASPGHAN. Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited.
Ross et al
17. Cotton S, Kudel I, Humenay Roberts Y, et al. Spiritual well-being and mental health outcomes in adolescents with or without inammatory bowel disease. J Adolesc Health 2009;44:48592. 18. Engstrom I, Lindquist BL. Inammatory bowel-disease in children and adolescentsa somatic and psychiatric investigation. Acta Paediatr Scand 1991;80:6407. 19. Engstrom I. Family interaction and locus of control in children and adolescents with inammatory bowel disease. J Am Acad Child Adolesc Psychiatry 1991:30;91320. 20. Janicke DM, Gray WN, Kahhan NA, et al. Brief report: the association between peer victimization, prosocial support, and treatment adherence in children and adolescents with inammatory bowel disease. J Pediatr Psychol 2009;34:76973. 21. Loonen HJ, Grootenhuis MA, Last BF, et al. Measuring quality of life in children with inammatory bowel disease: the IMPACT-II (NL). Qual Life Res 2002;11:4756. 22. Loonen HJ, Derkx BHF, Koopman HM, et al. Are parents able to rate the symptoms and quality of life of their offspring with IBD? Inamm Bowel Dis 2002;8:2706. 23. Mackner LM, Crandall WV. Brief report: psychosocial adjustment in adolescents with inammatory bowel disease. J Pediatr Psychol 2006; 31:2815. 24. MacPhee M, Hoffenberg EJ, Feranchak A. Quality-of-life factors in adolescent inammatory bowel disease. Inamm Bowel Dis 1998;4:6 11. 25. Moody G, Eaden JA, Mayberry JF. Social implications of childhood Crohns disease. J Pediatr Gastroenterol Nutr 1999;28:S435. 26. Perrin JM, Kuhithau K, Churhtai A, et al. Measuring quality of life in pediatric patients with inammatory bowel disease: psychometric and clinical characteristics. J Pediatr Gastroenterol Nutr 2008;46:16471. 27. Van Der Zaag-Loonen HJ, Grootenhuis MA, Last BF, et al. Coping strategies and quality of life of adolescents with inammatory bowel disease. Qual Life Res 2004;13:10119. 28. Burke PM, Neigut D, Kocoshis S, et al. Correlates of depression in newonset pediatric inammatory bowel-disease. Child Psychiatry Hum Dev 1994;24:27583. 29. Cunningham C, Drotar D, Palermo TM, et al. Health-related quality of life in children and adolescents with inammatory bowel disease. Childrens Healthcare 2007;36:2943. 30. De Boer M, Grootenhuis M, Derkx B, et al. Health-related quality of life and psychosocial functioning of adolescents with inammatory bowel disease. Inamm Bowel Dis 2005;11:4006. 31. Engstrom I. Mental health and psychological functioning in children and adolescents with inammatory bowel diseasea comparison with children having other chronic illnesses and with healthy children. J Child Psychol Psychiatry 1992;33:56382. 32. Gold N, Issenman R, Roberts J, et al. Well-adjusted children: an alternate view of children with inammatory bowel disease and functional gastrointestinal complaints. Inamm Bowel Dis 2000;6:17. 33. Lindfred H, Saalman R, Nilsson S, et al. Inammatory bowel disease and self-esteem in adolescence. Acta Paediatr 2008;97:2015. 34. Loonen HJ, Grootenhuis MA, Last BF, et al. Quality of life in paediatric inammatory bowel disease measured by a generic and a diseasespecic questionnaire. Acta Paediatr 2002;91:34854. 35. Marcus SB, Strople JA, Neighbors K, et al. Fatigue and health-related quality of life in pediatric inammatory bowel disease. Clin Gastroenterol Hepatol 2009;7:55461. 36. Otley AR, Grifths AM, Hale S, et al. Health-related quality of life in the rst year after a diagnosis of pediatric inammatory bowel disease. Inamm Bowel Dis 2006;12:68491. 37. Szigethy E, Levy-Warren A, Whitton S, et al. Depressive symptoms and inammatory bowel disease in children and adolescents: a crosssectional study. J Pediatr Gastroenterol Nutr 2004;39:395403.
JPGN
38. Ouvinen-Birgerstam P. Jag tycker jag ar. Stockholm: Psykologiforlaget; 1985. 39. Piers EV, Harris DB. Age and other correlates of self-concept in children. J Educ Psychol 1964;55:915. 40. Treffers DA, Goedhart AW, Veerman JW, et al. Competentiebelevingsschaal voor Adolescenten. Amsterdam: Swets & Zeitlinger BV; 2002. 41. Landgraf JM, Abetz L, Ware JE. The CHQ Users Manual. 1st ed. Boston: The Health Institute, New England Medical Centre; 1996. 42. Landgraf JM, Abetz LN. The physical and psychosocial well-being of children representing three cultural groups: initial self-reports using the Child Health Questionnaire (CHQ-CF87). Psychol Health Qual Life: Recent Adv Theory Methods 1997;12:116. 43. Kolsteren MM, Koopman HM, Schalekamp G, et al. Health-related quality of life in children with celiac disease. J Pediatr 2001;138:5935. 44. Cremeens J, Eiser C, Blades M. Characteristics of health-related selfreport measures for children aged three to eight years: a review of the literature. Qual Life Res 2006;15:739754. 45. Vogels T, Verrips GHW, Koopman HM. TACQOL Manual: Parent Form and Child Form. Leiden: Leiden Centre for Child Health and Pediatrics; 2000. 46. Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders, 3rd ed, rev. Washington, DC: American Psychiatric Association; 1987. 47. Hodges K, Kline J, Fitch P, et al. The child assessment schedule: a diagnostic interview for research and clinical use. Cat Selected Documents Psychol 1981;11:56. 48. Orvaschel H, Puig-Antich J, Chambers W, et al. Retrospective assessment of pre-pubertal major depression with K-SADS-E. J Am Acad Child Psychiatry 1982;21:3927. 49. Kaufman J, Birmaher B, Brent D, et al. Schedule for Affective Disorders and Schizophrenia for School Age Children: Present and Lifetime Version (K-SADS-PL). Pittsburgh, PA: Department of Psychiatry, University of Pittsburgh School of Medicine; 1996. 50. Kovacs M. Childrens Depression Inventory (CDI). New York: Multihealth Systems; 1992. 51. Reynolds CR, Richmond BO. Revised Childrens Manifest Anxiety Scale Manual. Los Angeles: Western Psychological Services; 2000. 52. Achenbach TM. Manual for the Child Behaviour Checklist (CBCL). Burlington, VT: University Associates of Psychiatry; 1988. 53. Achenbach TM. Manual for the Youth Self-report. Burlington: University of Vermont, Department of Psychiatry; 1991. 54. National Institute for Health and Clinical Excellence Depression in Children and Young People. National Clinical Practice Guideline Number 28. London: British Psychological Society and Royal College of Psychiatry; 2005. 55. Canning EH. Mental disorders in chronically ill children: case identication and parent-child discrepancy. Psychosom Med 1994;56:1048. 56. Carr A. The Handbook of Child and Adolescent Clinical Psychology: A Contextual Approach. 2nd ed. London: Routledge; 1999. 57. Armitage EL, Aldhous MC, Anderson N, et al. Incidence of juvenileonset Crohns disease in Scotland: association with northern latitude and afuence. Gastroenterology 2004;127:10517. 58. Green C, Elliott L, Beaudoin C, et al. A population-based ecologic study of inammatory bowel disease: searching for etiologic clues. Am J Epidemiol 2006;164:61523. 59. Hyams JS, Ferry GD, Mandel FS. Development and validation of a pediatric Crohns disease activity index. J Pediatr Gastroenterol Nutr 1991;12:43947. 60. Turner D, Otley AR, Mack D, et al. Development, validation, and evaluation of a pediatric ulcerative colitis activity index: a prospective multicenter study. Gastroenterology 2007;133:42332. 61. Mackner LM, Crandall WV. Oral medication adherence in pediatric inammatory bowel disease. Inamm Bowel Dis 2005;11:100612.
488
www.jpgn.org
Copyright 2011 by ESPGHAN and NASPGHAN. Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited.