Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
OF THE
university:
OF
d/./FO R^>b/
2007
witii
funding from
IVIicrosoft
Corporation
littp://www.arcliive.org/details/appliedpsycliologOOmclericli
APPLIED PSYCHOLOGY.
AN INTRODUCTION
TO THE
A.
Normal Schools for Ontario. Author of "Mental " lements of Algebra." Etc.
Prof.
Of Michigan
Learn
to
Do
by
Knowmg and
to
Know
by Doing.
uB^
VA
o'o\
N'^
7^
PEEFACB
This volume has been
teachers
tures
many
lec-
and Inspectors
some of
my
which have been given from time to time before Teachers* Associations.
It
room
for
one which
of these
more
directly
Some
works are too abstract and deal with philosophical questions that
very remotely concern the science of education
too superficial,
i.e.y
;
others are
easy,
in their attempts to
make psychology
they have
made
it
student of philosophy.
declare that
but
it
must be confessed
even
be specially pre-
pared for teachers, tans to see tne aurect bearing of the subject
What
who have
ears, is
the worth ot
a more practical
one that
will
show
clearer
and more
principles
methods of
instruction.
It
VI
PREFACE.
this
volume
will fully
but
it is
hoped
some
now
generally held
by
educationists,
and
tersely expressed
by Herbert
a knowledge of
psychology
and
Attention
1.
may be called to certain features of the book The general mode of treatment in the part on mental
is
science
that of Professor
me
with his
**
own
ideas
on the
subject, specially
recommended
Dewey's
lectures
Psychology."
On the
tions
not too
much
deep
a
interest
fair test
of
The book
is
The
If
*'
education
is
the hardest
its
and most
science cannot be
method
an introduction
to
subject,
is
will
and
certainly to
any student of
common
industry and
abilitv
PRSFACB.
3.
Vll
As
intimated,
to
gives a clear
Basis,
Instruction, as
chology.
4.
on the Method of
Interro-
gation will
show
still
more
and prove
helpful to the
teacher
who
skill in
of his calling.
5.
The
chapter on Kindergarten
Work and
Self-Instruction
in Public Schools,
abounds,
it is
thought, in hints
and suggeswork
of
tions
which
will
be found of
the school-room.
The
;
and
greatly increase
The
outline
methods
on
based on
will,
perhaps, prove
more
ical "
7.
volume of empir-
The
full
volume
that
he
will
be
fairly
by distinguished inventors.
To
bpok on Psychology,
already
mentioned
should
vm
I
PREFACE.
must express
my
obligations for
in
For the
on Kindergarten work
J.
Suddaby,
who
is
whose work
Berlin
which
^has
placed the
Model School
For nearly
has been
pirical
Professional
and
method of
training
made
is
" teaching
the sorriest of
all
professions."
But
it
on a knowledge
make
professional
it
on a
'
a word, to substitute
I sincerely
for
hope
book
will help, in
some
that wise
and
far-seeing oolicy.
CONTENTS.
CHAPTER
Psychology
I.
and
its
It is the Science of
Mind
to
be Educated
....
It
a. Definition of
h.
c.
n.The
I.
As a Science
viduals
is
4
while Teaching
is
a. It is Theoretic,
Practical
m. The
B.
..
A. Discussion of
Raw
Material or Basis.
Of Processes. Of Products.
CHAPTER
These Bases are Three
II.
it is t
6 6
7
r. Sensation.
I.
Definition
8.
As an element in Knowledge
a.
5.
Immediate
Presentative
CONTENTS.
.
Characteristics
Definitions of each.
Conditions:
m. Physical Condition
{i.)
9
9
10
Dependence of Quality upon Velocity Illustrated by Sound and Color (w.) Dependence of Quality upon Kinds of Vibration, Illustrated by Timbre of Sound and Shades of Coloi
(.)
lo
ii
{it.)
are
to
vague
are
first
appear.
(i.) Specific
Sensations ha e Quality
;
predominating)
;
are definite
ap(
pear later in
Psychical Condition
(/)
is
Consciousness.
1
(m)
5.
to Consciousness
:
12
I^
t.
Used to Test Reports of other Senses. Most Closely Connected with Muscular Activity, Hearing, and Sight the Senses of Highest Development 13-14
(.)
(V.)
(.)
They Make
Hearing
is
Space Sense.
the
Time
Sense.
and Auditory.
14
15
6.
Educational Principles
a.
External Objects in
k.
Since Sensation
is
Act upon
c.
it
Instruction Should be
CONTSMTS.
id
ILInterest.
X.
Meaning of Interest
Distinctions of Interest from Information
a. It is
i.
c.
i6
17
8.
EmotionaL
Subjective.
Individual.
,
3.
4.
Importance of Interest
Educational Principle
17
18
O. -Impulse.
1.
Definition of Impulse
19
19
3.
3.
20 20
21
4.
Impulses of Sensation
Impulses of Perception
Imitative Impulses
21 21
d.
Impulses to Expression
Gesture Language
Speech
22
5.
Educational Principles.
a.
k. Instruction
Development
^.
22
Instruction should
make
pulses
2324
CHAPTER
Introduction.
III.
14
idi
CONTENTS.
of Processes Corresponding to these
aj^
Il.Classification
Contents
Non- Voluntary
Association.
Attention,
Voluntary Attention.
The
s^V-i-^-^
Processes.
lL,asr onI.
Definition
. .
.'
i'.VA
.'.V. ;
^fTTT, .^d
I
'^^'^
a.
U>-^*^'^
36
37
37
Quantity
(.)
i.
Tone
Familiarity
Acquired Interest
(/.)
{it.)
37
Novelty
37 38 38
Negative Effect
Positive Effects
(/. )
39
30 30
30
31
{it.)
Uniting Elements in
(1)
(2)
May
4. Educational Principles:
a.
i.
Must be some Activity of Attention Teacher must not only Present Material, but must Induce
this Activity
33 33 34
c.^lt
d.
e.
must be Induced Indirectly by Arousing Interest ...,,. Interest Accompanies all Mental Activity
34
35 35 36
/.
g.
Also the Exercise of Play-Impulse Also Dependent upon Relations of Novelty and Familiarity
Suggestions as to Cultivating Non- Voluntary Attention..
-
IL Association.
I.
Definition
'*''^*^37
;
3.
3.
Conditions
38
a.
38
('.)
Spatial.
{ii.)
Temporal.
CONTENTS.
Xlll
Similarity Internal
Includes Contrast
39
(^^u.
40 40
41
,
jj
^ ,,
4. Results a.
k.
41
'
c.
Formation of Habits
(.)
/^
Definition of Habit.
M^rn^^.^?^^^
U.
^-^^^uLAy^"^
(.) Actire
[}ii.)
42
Functions of Habit
(i) (2)
^^^~<l^
43
'^^-i^^f
"),,-*'
^^^-6^ "^^
44
$.
Educational Principles
(/.)
44
45
its
(.)
(mi.)
Based on Repetition
Has
Discipline
(which
is
object)
Meaning of Discipline
(w.) Relation of
45 46
to
Knowing
Doing, in Mechanical
; .
Stage
h.
46
47
Is Stage of
(*,)
(,)
{Hi.)
Or between Ideas
Sensuous Associations Should be Subordinate....
47 48
Mean49 49 49 50
ing
(v.)
r.
Is Stage of Culture
Voluntary Attention,
Introduction
1.
.... 5052
50
51
2.
3. 4.
Early Forms
Later and More Complex
52
Forms
52
53
XIV
I.
CONTENTS.
Adjusting Activity
(,)
:
Mind more
Others
53
Stretches
iU.)
Hence,
Interest
out to
what
will
Satisfy this
54
(Hi.
And
tion
fixes Certain
(iv.)
This
is
55
t. Selecting Activity
(.)
Selects
what Meets
is
its
Interests
..
55
56
56
Law
Mind
of Permanent Interest
56
3, Relating Activity
(i.)
{ii.)
57 58
(M.)
(t>.)
(v.)
{zfi.)
58
58
59 59
Goal of Attention
Principles.
m.Educational
1.
2.
3.
4. 5.
6.
Need of Activity to Prevent Mind Wandering 60 Need of Permanence or Continuity of Interest 60 Need of Store of Ideas in Mind akin to Object of Attention. 61 Need of Arousing this Store of Ideas 61 Failures in real Attention when these Conditions are not met 62 Need that the Mind move along Related Points 63 When the Mind Notices or discovers Relations, it is paying
.
Attention
7.
63
Suggestions as to
Ways
of gaining Attention
64
Mind and
affect Material
Known ....
Illustration of Apperception.
Illustration of Retention
65 66
66
67
Mutual Relations
I.
Retention:
a.
Nature
67
k Forms
c.
68
68
GONTENT&
Apperception t
a.
b.
Wt
Nature
Basis of
Growth of Knowledge
:
Of 69
70
7
71
Educational Principles
a.
h.
End
But
of Education
this occurs
is
Mental Development
perception
t.
and Character
ft
CHAPTER
(First Division of
IV.
Idealizing Activity
a. Educational Principles
a. Necessity of Interpretation
b.
76 76
Necessity of Assimilation
2.
Meaning of Particular and General The Definite and Universal Constituted by Relations
. Necessity of Defining
77 78
79
3. Educational Principles
Knowledge
and Definite Know-
80
80
ledge
{1^.)
Definite
after Indefinite
81
8a
XVI
i.
CONTENTS.
Necessity of Connecting Knowledge.
83
?3
Re*
83
4L
84
^.\
Perception which
(i)
(2)
(3)
is
85
85
8$
_
(ji.)
More Representative than Peception More Ideal and Expresses more Relations
is
;
86 86
86
(*w.)
Imagination whi ch
{I) iJasea
(2) (3)
upon Jkemory more Representative and Ideal And Involves Wider Relations
But
is
87 88
88
'\i)
(2)
(3)
Most Representative or Symbolic of all Stages. Most Ideal and Expresses Most Relations
Hence, the Educational Principle
all
is
89
89
90
90
to
Develop
by Same Methods
I 2.
Stages
1.
L Considered
2. 3.
92 92
IL Considered
I.
Hence
That
all
tions ...
94
CONTENTS.
,
XVI
Odierwise
(t)
(it)
What
is
Learned
is
Meaningless
Uninteresting
94 94
(i)
Productive of
Mind Wandering
95
L Learning
General Principle
:
95
Train
Memory by
are Appropriated
95
This Principle
I.
may be
applied
a.
To Memorizing T Memorizing
m. Evils of
(I)
96
96
97
/.
Memorizing by Sheer Force of Repetition are Employs only Sensuous Association {jU.) It Leaves the Mind Passive. (tt.) It Burdens the Mind (iv.) It Leads to Mind Wandering. Proper Methods of Memorizing rely :
It
(.)
(it.)
97
97
97
98
98
99
3.
To Memorizing
Repetition.
Complex Ideas
n. RecollectingDepends upon
1.
loo
Reviews.
a. Attention to
Connected Ideas
100
/L ^
2.
loi
102
102
3. Because of
Unconscious Growth
n.This
I.
Indirect Training is Brought About 102 Through Cultivation of Expression of Imagination S. Through Cultivation of the Feelings that Stimulate Imagination:
.
b.
Due
103
103
Xrffi
CONTENTS.
Through Providing Material
. Natural Scenes
i.
r.
to
be Worked Upon t
.. I04
104
104
Study of Literature
6Stages
LIndirect
Illustrated
I.
Lower Stages
by
Generalization involved in Perception
I05
..
S. 3.
106
107
The Grouping
Given
.
nDirect Training.
I.
1:^
Language
107
Words
108
108
k. Structure of Sentences a
t.
Product of Thought.
109
109
1.
Given by Science.
.
Physical
109
MatbematioaL
109
CHAPTER
(Second Division of
V.
Mental Products.)
LConditions
1.
of Interest.
. Iio .* lie
Ill
2.
3.
Ill
4.
Harmony
of Activities
.. Ii^
117
OONTENTt.
1.
UX
I13
113
Widening of Feelinj a. Through Transference i. Through Unconscious Sympathy c. Through Conscious Sympathy
:
I14
2.
Deepening of Feeling
a.
b.
\,,
1 14 I14
Intellectual
115
:
0.
Wonder
)
115
(w.
i.
Curiosity
116
Acquisition of Knowledge,
Resulting from
Feeling of
Freedom, or of Self-Command
.Aesthetic
a.
116 117
Adaptation
117
118 116
(w.)
i.
Freedom
;
..118
Ideality
and
119
119
|.
Personal
a. Social.
()
(m)
19 120
120
120
Sympathy
(1)
Origin of Sympathy
120
121
(2)
b.
Development of Sympathy
Moral.
()
Contents:
Rightness, Obligation, Approbation
121
(l)
Origin
is
122
the Formation of Moral Groups or
(m) Result
Com122
munities
The School
(1) Is Continuation of
Family
123
123
CONTENTS.
fjh.)
Tmimng:
(1)
(2)
123
at
Development of Moral
124
124
(3)
Religious
(.)
Dependence
Peace
Faith
124
124 125
(It.)
^)
CHAPTER
Forms of
Introduction.
Volitional
VI.
Volitional Development.
(Third Division of
or Psychical Products.)
Aiialysis of Volitional
is
Act
125
127
125
Act
is
Intelligent
126
The Reasop
that
it
has an
End End
126
127
LFactors
1.
of Volitional Development.
127 127
Beginning of Idea
Completion of Idea 128 Subjection of Impulses to Idea, or Training of Impulses 129 (t.) Impulses Trained through Development of Intellect 129
.
(m.) Training of
(tti.)
129
129
130
(to.)
When
Render131
(.)
(r.)
rest
And
consists in
132
1 33
(t;i,)
And
has
its
end
in Self-Control or
Freedom
133
CONTENTS.
a.
Vd
Formation of Desire.
(Desire
a.
t.
t.
is
134
Origin of Desires
134
135
:
Object of Desires.
Training of Desires
(.)
(. )
135
1
By
Satisfying or
Thwarting them
36
(.)
(<v.)
Awakening Idea of Possibilities 136 Through Cultivation of Imagination 137 Imagination Widens and Strengthens ........... 137
138
its
J.
Simple Case
End Suggests
by
Means by
Association..
i.
Complex Cases
138
138
Conflict Settled
(*.) {it.)
(tit.)
Deliberation
Effort
138
Choice
139 140
4. Realization of Desired
a.
i.
t.
Self- Control..
140 140
Character
is
Choice
is
140
140
141
Through Influence of Educator upon Habits (tti.) Through Self- Reliance {iv. ) Through Recognition of Law
(.)
(v.)
142
142 143
Th rough
. ,
144
.
Development or of Self-Control.
144
Physical
m.
t.
Relation to
Its
MoraL
:
145
Process
(.)
(t.)
Differentiation of Impulses
....... 146
146
146
146
Interconnection of Impulses
t.
Its Results
(i.
)
(it.)
146
147
{iu. )
Amount
Lessened
bA
a.
CONTENTa,
Prudential
.
Contrd t
Definition
Results.
(i.)
.. 147
Action
is
more Deliberate
(.)
More Unified {/iii. ) More Determined and Persevering (.) More Intense or Energetic ,
149
J.
Moral Control
m.
#.
Definition
149
150
to Motives of
150
is
Constituted by Motive....
151
151
Acts do not
152
|lv.)
152
152
Growth of
d.
Sense
Moral Action
(.)
Secured
153 153
.. 154
154
154 154
Moral Control
Generic Choice
Automatic Decision
Regulation of Desires
(tit. )
(i.) Effective
Execution
..^
155
CHAPTER
Mind and
LImportance
1.
VII.
Body,
155
of
Body
for Soul
2.
3.
156
156
IS7
In Brain
CONTENTS.
xxiii
Man
158
158
m.
158 158
.
Initablity or Excitability
2.
Conductibility
158
159 I59
3.
Summation
Masticity
P'acilitation,
>
4. Inhibition
5.
159
Accommodation.
IV. Pwychological
1.
Equivalents.
is
Of Excitability
Of
Inhibition
is
Sensation, etc.
160
160
2.
3.
Of Plasticity
is
Habit &c
160
v.Lo\calization
Principles
1.
of Function.
161
Are
from Use
Original Indifference.
2. localization Resulting
3.
161
161 161
4.
5.
Sensory and Motor Organs have Vague Centres .,,.,. Powers have no Definite Centres
all
162
6.
162
VI. Educational
1.
Principles.
Necessity of Care of
Body
in all
Education
62
2. Physical Basis of
3.
Organization of Faculty
163
No
163 163
4.
CHAPTER
Summary of
I. Bases of Instruction.
1.
VIII.
Principles.
Activity of Pupil
Interest of Pupil
m 163
164
,
2. 3.
164
CONTENTS.
II.Ends of InstructioH.
I.
,,.
164
164
164
165
165
a.
3.
b secured When right Habits are Formed When New Faculties are Organized When Fundamental Psychical Powers
Beveloped
166 166
m.Methods
I.
of Instruction
167
167
Illustration
Teach one Thing at a Time a. What Makes a Proper Method, with i. This Gives the Analytic Method t. Advantages of Analytic Method :
(.)
167
i68
(n.) Defines
{Hi.
)
168
,
169
169
169
(.)
Way
for
Memory
(v.)
169 170
8.
Teach
in a
170
170
Graded Instruction
Side of the Pupil
it
170
Upon the
.
Demands
1 70
all
171
171
(u.)
Two
Factors in Perception.
172 172
CONTENTS.
XXV
172 172
1 73
Acquisition of
173
Frequent Reviews
174
(n.)
Mental Preparation
174
174
177
177
IV. -Relation of Knowledge, Feeling and Will 1. Mind as Organic Unity, Hence . The Dependence of Knowledge ^, The Dependence of Knowledge r. The Dependence of Will
2.
178
179
179
affect the
whole Personality
180
v. Criticism
1.
of Maxims.
its
Maxim
own Kind
of
180
181
2.
3.
Maxim
Learning to
Do
by Doing
182
to the
4.
5. 6.
Known
Unknown
,
182
183
The Order
Teadiing what
is
understood
8.
184
185 185
Words Introduce Representative Factor Words Make Knowledge General and Definite Words Concentrate Knowledge ....
9.
185
XXVI
CONTENTS.
CHAPTER
Introduction
IX.
187
187 188
188
What
Ejcperience Really
is.
,
Division of Subject
189 190
A. Objects of Questioning
of Material.... 109
190
presented
Knowledge
is
This
(.)
is
Missed
if
(or Questioning)
190
stimulate
Such Questions
fail to
191
2.
And
192
Illustrated
(&'.)
by
Drill.
is
Too
difficult
:
pre-
sented
192
h.
Such Questions Fail to Aid Assimilation .... 193 This is Secured if Teacher Finds out what Pupil knows and horw he knows it 194 Such Questioning Connects the old and the new 194
.
S.
195
195
Law
(/.
)
is
peated
195 196
(iV.)
Forming A nalytic and Synthetic Habit Forming Definite Perceptions Habits of Rea:
soning
r.
196
Illustrations.
(. )
Getting Knowledge of
Numbers
196
(/.)
Numbers
197
(V.) Getting
CONTENTS.
4,
XXVll
Power
to
Think
Illustration
198
199
of Drill
199
Improper Repetition Dwells too "Concrete" (iV.) Drilling aside from the Real Point (^V.) Drilling on Unimportant Points :
Sense of Proportion
much on
200
201
201
3,
203 203
204
realize for
Him204
205 206-207
b.
(m.) Illustrations from Arithmetic 208 Extends by Imparting New Knowledge 209 Questioning Should Lead Pupil to Institute new Relations
{i. )
209
from Pronouncing Words
Illustration
From Naming Numbers {iti.) From Elementary Arithmetic {iv.) From Solution of Problems {v.) From Algebraic Formulae
{it.)
209 2io
21
212
213-214
215
1.)
4.
Fourth Object
is
to Cultivate
Power of Expression
tM5.--This
a. Relation of
(1.)
21
(V.)
Words are Chaotic Words Define and Make Permanent {Hi.) Thought is Not Complete Till Objectified
Language
216
in
217
.
k.
Hence Thought Lessons Must be Language Lessons Each Reacts upon the Other C Method of Training Expression and Thereby Thought (1. ) Question Pupil to Clear Thought (iV.) Then to Clear Oral Statement of the Thought (iU,) Then to Clear Written Statement
.
217 218
219 220
220
221
XVUl
d, B'justration of
(.)
{it. )
CONTENTS.
Rule
:
Elementary
Illustrations
Illustrations
222
CHAPTER
A. Objects of Questioning C^w/iVwfl/.
X.
Continued.
224
225 225 226
To
This
Excite Interest
is
secured by
a. Clear Presentation
Time
r.
requisite for
Development
Self- Education
226
227 228
Sympathy
(i)
in
Teacher
292
close to
(it)
Mind of Teacher
Teacher
Personality involves
Enthusiasm
(*)
Method of Personality
Method
for Per-
Power
233
243
.
To
arouse Attention
234
adjust
it
upon
234-235
New
{ii)
Illustration
235
3.
To direct
(1)
Attention
236
(0
Mind in Ordeiiy Movement 236 Thus develop Power of Analyns and Synthesis 236
337
(&'i) Illustrations
CONTENTS.
4.
XXIX
338 338
239
To Cultivate
(t)
(ti)
Habit of Self-Questioning
Goal of Attention
Gives Independence of
Mind
L Acquired
I.
Qualifications
.
240
Thorough Knowledge 240 {t) Requires Knowledge of Kindred Subjects and 24c Advanced Branches ,
{it)
{it't)
24
241
As
well as in higher
work
3.
Preparation of Lessons
242 343
,...,...
3. Analytic
4.
5.
343
.,.,,.,
344 344
345
n. Natural Endowments
Force of Personality
Its
Spirit
345
0-
345
L As to Matter,
1.
Questions should be
246
Definite
Illustrations.
2.
3.
Connected
In Logical Sequence
Adapted
to Capacity
347 348
249
4.
And
Put
n.
As to Form,
1.
in
249
249
,
2.
3.
Varied
Given in Questioner's
Own Words
249
4.
5.
350
ni.
Mode
of Questioning
350
Various Suggestions
D. Matter
Various Suggestions
Class
.
^Answering.
eto.
......
351-252
XJU
CONTENTS.
CHAPTER XL
Kindergarten
Work and
Self-Instruction in
Public Schools,
Introduction
Grounds
1.
Work
a5a 253
Physical Education
2.
3.
Moral Education
Intellectual Education
254
is
4.
5.
Kindergarten Instruction
Rational
255 256
256
257 258
..
2.
3.
Value of
this
259 260
Blocks
261-62
6. 7.
263-64 264-67
267-62F
m.
The
1.
Description of
268-69
269-71
,.
2. 3. 4.
271-72
Constructive Exercises
yniiEk
275
275
2.
Kindergarten Drawing
Slat Interlacing
8.
3.
Paper Folding
278-79 280-83
*
Mat Weaving
Kindergarten
4.
Work aid
283-84 284-86
286
VL
Results Manifested
CONTENTS.
1XX
Vn.
I.
Self-Instruction in
Common Work.
286
287
.. 287
Principle of Reproduction
a. 3.
Prepare Self-Instruction
Work
4.
5.
Reading
Arithmetic
2S7-88
i... 288
CHAPTER
.Outline
I.
XII.
Methods
in
Special Subjects,
289-96
296-304
305-11
Geography n. Arithmetic in. Primary Reading IV. Training Language Power V. Qxammax
312-15
315-17
PRINCIPLES
AND PRACTICE
OF
EDUCATION
CHAPTER L
PSYCHOLOGY AND
ITS
On
may
reasonably ask
it
What
is
relation does
essential
subject ?
If
it
is
it
so,
in order to
educator?
To
Psychology Defined.
question
is
What
is
psychology?
For the
this
that
it is
whom he
has to teach
on the whole, with the body, the physical nature of the pupil, only on account of its close connection with moral and
intellectual habits,
it
is
plain that
this
definition
is
almost
is
equivalent to saying
the
is
mind that the educator must reach, of the nature of mind and of the laws^ principles and results of its activity.
PSYCHOLOGY.
tedinical
definition of
that
it is
phenomena
is
of
self.
By
meant
that the
mind
conscious of
its
own
self
recognizes itself as Ijn distinction from things and from other persons.
as generally used, suggests the close relation
Sotd
its
organ,
the body.
Subject
it
lies
over against
self.
The term
moral and
reli-
methods used
for invest-
and explaining psychical facts. A person may set himself to study his own mind ; may watch the origin and progress of his own thoughts may analyze them as they come and go and note the ties that seem to conIn other words, he may observe himself as he would observe nect them.
any phenomena. This is the method of introspection of looking within. Many of our ideas come to us primarily through the connection of soul with body in the form of sensations, and many of our states, as our desires, express We may, therefore, experiment with our themselves through the body. This is the experimental sense organs as a means of changing our ideas. method. We may also study the minds of others. We may observe (l)
chiW-';n with a view to ascertaining the original forms and gradual development of what we know introspectively only as finished products. Or we may study {2) animals, with a view to learning about instincts, and
the lower stages of psychical
life
j
mind
we may
study
its
products
and then
reason
back
to those
Language, the growth and religious institutions, we may consider and study as manifestations, embodiments of intelligence, and hence infer some laws of intelligence itself This is the objective method.
of mind necessary to produce such results.
art, political
of science and of
particu-
psychology
mind works.
should
an account of the various ways in which the Some of these ways are what constitute the prois
cess of learning,
and
it is
know them.
In
all his
ITS
will
harmful.
activity
native to the learner's mind, either hangs " in the air " utterly
development.
is
;
doubtless go on whether he
is
taught well or
or indeed
whether he
taught at
all
or not
but
left
to themselves
or
:
to
never .reached.
the
instinctive
evolution of the
human powers
in
is
find
their
place
stimulating
movement, in and progressing upon that line in the simplest, most economical and most vital way. They must rest, therefore, upon knowledge of the This activities of the mind and of the laws governing them.
into
ever-renewed
line,
keeping them
directed
in
the right
to give.
Value of Method.
does not detract
that the
is
The position
its
thus given to
method
high,
from
high
value
value
its is
so
practical side,
a question of method.
this
high value.
of the mind.
Methods
giving them this subsidiary function, but by making them mere mechanical devices which the teacher is required to
method
is
at
and
lifeless,
and at
mere
deadening to the
4
pupil,
PSYCHOLOGY.
and degrading
to the teacher.
assumed educational
rule,
some
activity
work of the
effectiveness,
It
vitality
and
and makes the teacher an qrtist rather than a tradesman. should ever be remembered that the servile imitation of what
the hands of another
in
may be
not educational method in any True educational methods are ways of approach to the learner's mind, and ways of directing its
adherence to empirical
true sense of the term.
rules, is
activities
They
but
subject
fact
who
this
is
self. (
Upon
this
and
alone
importance of psychology. )
Limitations of Psychology. But it is important to know what psychology cannot do as well as what it can do. The following limitations are accordingly to be noticed. In the
first place
teaching
That
is
to say, as a science,
it
it
mind
in general,
but
life
in general,
and
that
and that boy and girl yet it is just with boy and girl that the teacher has continually to do.
is
theoretical,
practical.
That
is
teacher knowledge ol
the laws of
ITS
mind; but
it
and
insighl
in
physiology
may know the laws of the and pathology of the human body and yet be a poor
with pupils will often give the teacher a power of insight into
their
mental processes, and thus enable him to adjust his teachwith good
;
ing methods
theoretical
effect,
knowledge
in
this
sympathy
is,
in part, a
after
all,
and
partly
on
much
in teaching as in every-
The best
teacher will be he
personal
knowledge of the theory of his subject which has been perfected by experience; for "studies perfect nature and are perfected by experience."
qualities with
Mode
of Treatment.
article
We
may
by comparison of a finished
manufactured
made
psychical
raw
material which
in order to
The
become a know
something about each of these, something about the capacities which are the beginnings, the raw material something about
material,
and something
I.
SENSATION.
Life.
II.
The Processes of
Psychi-
cal Life, and III. The three forms of psychical development, viz., the Intellectual, the Emotional, and the Volitional, with something about the various classes of facts coming undei
each head.
Note.
Regarding
L
Psychology and
its
chology, Chapter
V
As
just said, the
CHAPTER
II.
LIFE,
its
origin from
certain capacities
once the stimulus to further progress and the raw material out of which the more complex
which are
Sensations
tional,
These bases are, upon the intellectual upon the emotional. Interests ; upon the
side.
voli-
Impulses.
We
1.
cerning
SENSATION.
Sensation
arises from
Q^et
may be defined as any Mental State which a bodily stimulus, and upon the basis of which we knowledge of the world around us. few examples will
make
this
clear.
;
sensation of odor
sensation of taste
an orange, and get the we put a part of it in our mouth, and get the we look at it, and get the sensation of color \
smell of
get the sensation of
;
We
we
contact, of pressure,
and and of temperature If we apply these the sensation of sound. finition we see (i) That smell, taste, si^
explore
its
we drop
it,
and get
changed as soon
ear,
hand,
etc.,
together with
\
and
(3)
states
we
we
see
how
the
first
step in
know-
ledge
of this
world
is
taken.
is
meant
is
directed
by the mind upon this fruit. The mind does not have to remember, or imagine or think in order to have these feelings. But, if the eye falls upon the figures, 7, 9, 8, 6, 5, 4, the intellect must go through a series of processes and come to a conclusion before discovering that the
is
sum is
39.
Such knowledge
is,
ate processes,
and
is
opposed to sensation.
We may
illustrate
comprehending the meaning of the words uttered. The sound is heard as soon as the stimulus reaches the brain ; the meaning of the words is not apprehended until certain processes of interpretation, to be studied hereafter, are brought to bear.
The term
presentative has'
significance
it is
as immediate.
A sensation
is
my
me, and
a sensation, while
the
memory
representative,
The
sensation, in a word,
presentative
because
8
affecting the
SENSATION.
organ of sense
;
Sensation, to sum up, is primary and original, not secondary and derived, and has no antecedent excepting the physical
Sensation
is,
and elementary material out of which knowledge of the world about us is built up, and hence our account of how the mind gains its knowledge must begin with a study of sensations.
considerations
Characteristics of Sensations. From these general we must turn to a study of the particular characterWe may continue to illustrate by the sensaistics of sensation. tions occasioned by the orange say the visual sensation of
color.
every
other,
is
possesses
quality^
extensity, intensity ^
and
tone.
By
quality
in this case,
and not a sound or taste, and furthermore that it is yellow Extensity refers to the extent color, and not green nor red.
its
of impression produced, to
voluminousness.
A small portion
impression
make
this as
so extensive an
nor
The
latter,
as just said,
But any
light which produces This intensity would be nothing in pitch darkness, and
to
the
amount of
noonday
light,
while at twilight
would be
feeble,
etc
sound may
may be more
it
is
may be
pleasant
The
LIFE.
excites,
whether agree-
able or disagreeable.
of these charac
partly
(i) physical
and
upon
(2)
physiological conditions.
studied.
(1)
V sion
of sensation
Of
taste
and
visible particles
of air or
the stimulus
ether.
vibrations of an imponderable
medium
called
The
intensity,
hung by a string to be struck a blow \ blow the wider will be the swing of the ball That is, the amplitude of a vibration depends upon the impetus Now if we imagine the swinging ball of the moving particle.
to
come
in
contact with a
is
drum head,
it is
moving
its
amplitude) the
this illustration
From
may
depends
upon the strength of the motion which stimulates it, and, if this motion is in the form of a vibration, upon the amplitude
of the vibration.
all
By
velocity
is
meant
the
number of swings
The
produced by a rate of from twelve to twenty vibrations per second ; the highest tone, by vibrations at the rate of about forty
thousand per second.
<^ JOP
THK.
aNiyERSlTYj
lO
various octaves of pitch.
SENSATION.
I'here
is
however, almost
four
hundred and
rapid, seven
the five
most hundred and eighty five billions per second, while other spectral colors occupy the interval.
far
we have been
But
if
of
of a
number
colors.
of series,
we have mixed
This
is
produced what
is
that quality in
sound which
distinguishes
exactly the
an organ tone from a piano or violin tone of same pitch and intensity, or from a human voice,
In the sphere of colors,
this
union,
which we
call
shades;
etc.
for
scarlet,
The proper
This
is,
perhaps,
all
that
rela-
(2)
to
turn
now
to the
from
brain
and
third,
The organs
that are
classified as special
The
some
special
specific
to receive
and react upon the waves of ether. ^\iQ general organs are those the main business of which is not the iDeception
fitted to receive
LIFE.
like
breathing,
or circulation.
The
nerves
which
tell
us
how
the respiratory
going on.
tions. This
Differences
difference
a corresponding
and
specific.
The
main
1.
In the
is
qucUity
so
From
results
and
So
one another by
3.
indistinct blendings.
The
own
and
and smell
of our
ledge.
own
body,
theoretical
On
the subjective
4.
and the
One
standpoint,
At
birth
and
vails
The
infant
is
at
first
i2
sensations of hunger
SENSATION.
etc
Even
taste
and thirst, comfort, or fatigue and pain, and smell do not seem to convey much idea
substanca
tasted, but
only of
its
But
in time
and more
after
no
between
The development begins, in other words, and the vague^ and advances towards the
and
the intellectual.
The
hearing and touch, since they are the senses which give the
most information about the surrounding world, are those of most importance to the teacher.
psychical
it
is
a state of con;
The changes
all
physical
they are
They
no con-
spatial.
left,
But the sensation is not material nor no quick or slow motion. It simply
Materialism attempts to regard the sensjust as heat
exists as
a psychical occurrence.
force
changed into
may be But heat, light and electricity may all be considered as forms of -fiiotion, and hence as conEven rertible into one another ; while sensation is not a form of motion.
changed into another form,
light, this into electricity
and so oi^
the materialist
is
is
Nervous Change
lion.
is
We
cannot re-
There
is
is
may
This
call
the soul
acts as
soul,
an excitation
a stimulus to
sensation.
soul,
ar'^
The
while the affection of the sense and the change in the nerve and brain
Sensation
may
;
thus be regarded
ar the
13
and
is
of remaining a
mono-
And
comes
itself
in connection
mechanically
__
is
important
and because
it is
most closely
the
of the will
may be called
from
of
it
;
it ;
upon it for and confirmation. Touch gives the most intimate and detailed knowledge of any sense. To be in contact with anything is synonymous with having relations of closest ac
and, secondly^ because the other senses rest
assistance
quaintance with
it.
We
and ears
may
deceive us,
we attempt
of certainty.
and by handling
it,
to get a sense
The
other reason
is its
close
the
muscular
Touch
is
Touching
is
Contact
not
The hand,
touch.
that
never contented until he has the object he " perceives in his hands, and turns it over and over, and " tries through comes senses the The first real education of it for himself
child
touch,
and wherever the senses are largely concerned, the teacher must continue to rely upon it
importance
it
and hearing
in
knowledge
is
14
is
SENSATION.
call attention to
is
unnecessary to
One
no
of these points
almost
ible.
They
and most
is,
It is further to
for space,
and
The range
is
so great that
it
its
capacity for
fit
complex
subject.
Hence
and
all
graphic representations.
The
that follow
on the other hand, is the sense for time and of events one another, and hence should be appealed to wherever a subject is to be learned in which the relation of
ear,
sequence predominates.
tion
may make
whom
may
is
and
for recalling.
is
This prominence
are generally
Draughtsmen, geometers and chess players of unusual ability Artists have been known pronounced visualists. to paint accurately portraits from the vividness of their mental
vision without the presence of the person represented.
Persons
of this type
when
and
to read from
it.
LIFE.
exists in terms
received.
is
most easily
The same
to
be said of the
auditory
and motor
types,
Those of
memor-
most
easily
Upon
repeating
Those of the they seem to hear a voice reading to them. motor type will articulate to themselves when reading, studying, or engaged in reflection ; and when recalling they depend upon
a repetition of
writing.
this silent articulation.
hense
is
10 the pupil
by discovering
to
this study
from the
The
it is
impossible to have
There
in
some way from sensation than a blind man can tell how colors Hence the necessity of constant appeal to the pupil's look.
own
thing to be known.
Seeing
is
education
it is
imply that no knowledge can be had excepting knowledge of just that which has been presented to the senses. On the contrary,
the
imagination
erecting large
and
but
real
it
superstructures
of sensation
basis.
is
meant
years
necessary in
INTERESTS.
may be
The
mind
the limitations of
it,
sensation.
is
and material
The mental
must
not
upon the
that
sense-material.
It
be
forgotten, therefore,
is
the development of
of^he pupil irl putting Into motion those promind which will apprehend the sensations, and in strengthening the processes so that they will grow naturally into memory, imagination and thought.
cesses of the pupil's
3.
The
teacher should
remember the
necessity of a propel
may
under
instruction.
Note.
Regarding
chapter III.
2.
TBCB INTERESTS.
infor-
We
and events with the beginnings of knozvledge. But we have had occasion to notice that sensations possess 'tone' in greater or less degree, that is, that
mation about
they have
effect.
certain
is
agreeiftble
or
disagreeable
emotional
This
It arises
now
to
be discussed.
Interest cannot be described, it can only be felt. But every one knows what he means by saying that something interests him ; he means that it bears such a relation to him as renders
LIFE.
attractive,
fixes the
mind's attention.
While
an analytic
may be
Interest
it
is
That
is
to
say,
mind
itself.
It is usually
Interest
is subjective,
while knowledge
is objective.
The
world
is individual, while knowledge is universal. By we mean belonging to a world which is open to all minds alike. That seven and nine make sixteen is a universal fact; it holds for all minds under all circumstances. By individual we mean being the unique and peculiar possession of some one mind. Others may have an interest similar to mine
3.
Interest
universal
in, say,
in
my
interest.
of
it,
or,
They cannot even know that it by some other external act, make
speak
itself
known.
In
it is
but a fact
as
much
sensation
sensation,
is.
It is
and, like
an
indispensable
cultivated
higher
development.
While
ject in
it
may be
and
indifferent or repulsive,
than a
new
Importance of Interest.
INTERESTS,
is found in the fact that it is the means by which mind is drawn to any subject, and led to exercise itself upon it. Whatever does not interest the mind, that the mind is indifferent to ; and whatever is indifferent is for that mind as if it had no existence. The problem of teaching an intelligent savage some technical scientific matter would not be chiefiy a problem of how to give him sensations regarding it, nor how to give him mental capacity enough to understand it, but how to arouse his interest in such a way that he would set his mind to work upon it. Interest is, therefore, as much a necessary source
of interest
the
of knowledge as
is
sensation.
all
the
and yet if they failed the mind would pass them over and they would
now
Educational Principle.
ciple
is clear.
The
While
it is
made a matter of play; while, indeed, education as the direction of the mind by methods supplied from without, is opposed
to theveryidea of play,
it is
appeal to some
interest^
and,
the subject
is
not intrinsically
it
should be
made
to gather about
That
there
is,
In teaching children
but
little difficulty
elements of knowledge.
be done
it
is
^a
power almost wholly due to sympathy which is, in the emotional Under the world, what attention is in the intellectual world. influence of this power the teacher is interested in the subject for the sake of the pupil ; interest begets interest, and the pupil
often
becomes interested
teacher.
The
mind
the individual
LIFE.
19
Note.
On
d seq,
3.
IMPULSE.
intellectual
Having
of the
volitional
studied
the
life,
psychical
basis.
we have
are
to take
Impulses
activities
from
of that want, lead to some physical change. For illustration, we may take the impulse for food. This arises from the organic
feeling,
satisfy
and
it
movements
Impulse
outward
The
litter begins in
and then becomes a psychical state. But impulses begin in a psychical state, and this, by means of the brain and motor nerves,
IS transformed into outward motion. and impulse outwards.
Importance of Impulse.
the lowest to the highest,
and
call to
excepting the purely physiological, are only the outward expressions of impulse.
Impulse, in short,
it
the basis of
will.
It is
requires to be regulated,
it
a true act of
sition of
will
movements
in
which purpose
clearly displayed
head
to
IMPULSE.
in order to
be changed into
Impulses
its
Indeed, an instinct
may be
defined as an im
proper end.
Instinct, in
an impulse which leads one to do, without any knowledge of the reason why, just what one would do, if he had complete knowledge of the circumstances. The impulse
for food, for
example
instinct,
is,
in
in
man
in his
infancy, as
it
an
feels the
it,
secure
and does
want of food, takes just the measures needed to this without being guided by previous ex-
perience.
Impulses
Classified.
Impulses may be A
sensation
it
classified, accord-
ing to the stimulus which arouses the sense of want, as impulses of sensation^ oi perception^ of imitation^
I.
and of
not
expression.
Impulses
of Sensation.
only
reports
excites a tendency
it.
Thus
hold of something external and to make it a part of the organism, arise in needs which are excited by organic affections, that
But the special senses have also corby general sensations. There is a hunger of the sense of responding impulses. touch for contact with bodies, of the sense of hearing for
is
sounds,
etc.
off,
as
by sickness,
that
the
act freely.
hunger of these senses. The impulses are now permitted to There is such a thing as starving the mind by not
satisfying the sense-imptilses, as well as starving the
body by
not satisfying
its
hunger-impulse.
LIFE.
SI
These are such as arise directly S. Impulses of Perception. from the mere perception of an object. They come under the head of impulses to grasp something or, in some way,
to
continue
the
exploration
of
it.
An
infant
begins
to
them.
This impulse
is
play impulse.
The
for himself,
and
tries to
do with
them.
3.
Impulses
to
Imitation.
As
is
He does
why he endeavors
but
the very perception of the action renders the child, for the time baby " reads " when he takes a newsbeing, an automaton.
This
early
tendency to imitation
wise be effected,
4.
is
education, enabling the child to learn easily what would otherif at all,
Impulses
to
Expression.
These
states.
Thus the
infant cries,
acts
draws back in
fright, etc.
These outward
may be
comes
used
them.
After
the expression
of inward
feeling
the
The
at
interests
him, and thus there gradually arises the whole class of gestures.
Among
those in
whom
is
articulate speech
it
unnecessary there
This
is
it
IMPULSE.
found
tribes
who
are in
So and unconventional is this mode of expression that it has been found that North American Indians and deafmutes have no difficulty in understanding one another when The highest class they come together, even for the first time. of ^impulses of expression is that of the communication of ideas. This manifests itself, for the most part, in spoken
instinctive
language.
In civilized mankind, at
least, there is
an impulse
Educational Principles. The educational bearing of what has been said regarding the impulses is evident.
(i)
The
mind the
close connection of
active
senses, care
must be taken
upon the
Willi
things.
of
training of the
the
regulation
see^
An
no
as
at
first,
on
its
retina,
no
fixity of
gaze,
The baby
learns to see,
by regulating and combining such afterwards it The teacher's work in training the senses must be impulses.
ftn
The
mind the
great importance of
the instincts.
It is
appeal to
some natural
and that
it
instinct.
It is of
equal im-
EDUCATIONAL PRINCIPLES.
tj
It has been well said that the pedagogical equivalent ihc child. of " strike while the iron is hot " is " seize every instinct at the
height of
its
development."
In early
life,
each instinct as
it
it
appears
is
so imperious that
it is
should
unconsciously
taught
during
which
the
child
subtle and involved, there is greater need of the teacher's and control. Before an instinct in a given direction has shown itself, it is hopeless to educate a child in that direction ; after that instinct has given way to another, interest dies out and the teacher, instead of availing himself of the tide
more
tact
of energy setting
activity
naturally in
that
direction, has
to
evoke
by
artificial aids.
(3)
Let the teacher, then, make the most of the impulses that
It follows
from the
perception-\vix^\!\%^%
undai
at
a' judicious
and
the
is
same time
wasted, or
He
can be
led
quite without
power
to
unless
etc.,
the teacher
so-called
take an interest in
many
by which he
soon leads to the desire and the power to But more especially this impulse is a powerful co-factr with the *' environment " in educating the
and
skilful imitation
child.
At
first
he unconsciously imitates the actions, the tones, whole demeanor of those about him ; but unto, or
rather
is
strengthened by
formed between
his
bond of sympathy has been teacher and himself, the child makes a
the
When
24
conscious
grow
There
posessed
is
an intense
of superior
love-
charm
in
imitating
him
to
whom,
as
fear
blended with
in all
He
feels that
he
is
manly
qualities,
with so
when he is growing like his teacher whom he regards much deference. Thus it is that the characteristics of
gestures, his
self-control, his
energy,
etc.,
have a
The impulse
neglected.
of expression
is
equally important
and equally
impulse
who
will
and
in
in fact, a lesson in
expression because
it is
Note. XVII.
Regarding
the
Dewey's Psychology,
Chapter
CHAPTER
Three
III.
We
Ways
in
and impulses are worked up If we examine what makes up the contents of our minds, we shall see that the complex forms whose mode of production we have to discover,
material
sensations, interests
into the forms
of actual experience.
may be
(t) In the
made up
of coexistI
ent members.
For example, as
look out of
my window
PSYCHICAL PROCESSES.
25
do not get disconnected and fragmentary color sensations, but I see a diversified landscape with its many features, and all are present at about the same instant of time. The first group
is
composed of
simultane-
under
call
The
up Tennyson,
so on indefinitely.
Here we have a
trai7t
members
(3) Finally
we might be
In
this case,
House
of
we would compare
political causes
the history of
and effects, weigh and sift evidence, reject all that did not seem to bear upon the case in hand, and arrange the remaining facts to meet the desired end. Here the result, as in the second case, would be a train of ideas, consisting of successive members, but yet differing from the second group. It is not a series whose parts suggest one another at haphazard, but a controlled and regulated series.
different nations,
examine
The order
is
trains o\
members
in
allowed to suggest
just as
may happen,
to
up
some end.
by which the elements are speaking in a rough and
voluntary Attention
call the
is
now
Still
we may say
in
that
Non
the
power active
group
;
simultaneous
group of successive
a6
NON-VOLUNTARY ATTENTION.
meant
prominence.
is
The term
this
non-voluntary,'
mind
turned upon
by reason of any intervention on the part of the will an act of attention when a student keeps his mind fixed
his lessons in spite of all distracting circumstances
if it
;
upon
effect
of
voluntary ^XX^XiixovL
it,
of non-voluntary
It is evident that
non-voluntary attention
'
must always precede voluntary. A baby notices ' (and this noticing is precisely what is meant by attention) not because any appeal is made to his reason and will to keep his mind di*
'
is
We
of non-voluntary attention.
1.
tion
Conditions. The condition under which any presentaawakens noiv voluntary attention is that it be interesting.
attention
is
The
some
We may
if
possibly give
we
force ouris,
by power of
will to
do so
volition
apart from
all
connection with
may
itself,
interest
pleasing in
or because
^^-^v
NON-VOLUNTARY ATTENTION.
7
are quantity
and
same
color.
is
The
the
mean
it.
The
etc.,
organic
sensations, hunger,
thirst,
fatigue,
satisfaction,
of the
To
knows
when he
is
hungry,
simply to
when
its
nothing else
will
do
is
freed from
bondage
and
to organic affections.
The
pleasures that go
along
mind
five
which are
gateways of knowledge.*'
may
(2) Acquired Interest,As suggested, a presentation acquire value in virtue of its surroundings. The sight of
first
perhaps
brightly
satis,
not nearly so
much
interest for
him
its
as
other
more
an attractiveness ot We may reduce the conditions which lead to the its own. acquisition of interest to two \i^z.^% familiarity and novelty.
Familiarity. Originally
influence of quantity
all
experiences
aside
from the
and tone stand upon the same level, all are equally noticed and hence equally unnoticed. There is no perspective, no foreground and no background. We have a
somewhat
similar experience
when we
SS
ings wholly new.
PSYCHICAL PROCESSES.
Everything looks alike to us
;
about us seem
all
where to begin,"
"We
do not know
stands out so as to
We
Those
factors
The
familiar occurrences
become
lifts
Similarly
we may suppose
life
which
of an infant
and
etc.
They become
centres of interest,
and
gain distinctness.
Novelty.
and draws us
where
it
While
to
itself,
in general
it is
yet familiarity
may be
Those who
live
Similaiiy,
we do not
notice
clothing
us.
to strike a stranger
It is
we nevernotice
proverb that
common
familiarity
deadens and
dulls.
Now
change
its
noise, let the mill stop, let the clock cease tick-
ing, let the unnoticed feature of our friend alter, and at once we are all attention. Familiarity and Novelty in Connection.The truth
it is
itself,
new
bears his
own language
in a foreign country
traveller
in the
NON-VOLUNTARY ATTENTION.
midst of the customary
f9
strange
as when that
we
we hear a
tongue
attracts attention.
That which
so habituated
we have become
find nothing in
it
which seems
Effects of
is
workings.
That
is
to
mind dwells upon some presentations only because Imagine a light equally diffused it draws away from others. over a room, then imagine all the light focussed in some one point. It is evident that the rest of the room will grow dark as
the
this
bright.
So
it is
with attention.
Attention
has
Effects of
that
Withdrawal of Attention.It
is
follows
what
is
not attended to
affects
Not everything that comes before the senses, or even that them strongly, comes to be knowledge. There is an
indefinite throng of
stimuli
sights, sounds,
pressures, etc.,
knocking
within
its
gates,
is
because, the
no
mental activity
We
are almost
our minds.
One may
sit
before an
and
going on.
The
withdrawal of attention
may go
so
far
that the
Soldiers,
Archimedes so engaged
to
30
PSYCHICAL PROCESSES.
is
attend to a presentation
to hold
it
il
and thus
show
it
in clearest light.
said to distinguish
half-a
in in
steel
what
is
to say,
by the
tasters,
bring to
tea
escapes
others.
Similarly,
perceive
a great number
of differences,
where
would get only one impression. A trained botanist will more in a casual glance through a microscope than one untrained would discover by careful searching. The power of
others
see
is
only does
it
of
all
ever,
is
and
the
same act of
one idea.
grasped by another movement of attention, and hence become another idea. In other words, a single idea a single concrete
state of consciousness
means
It
makes no
parts
are
many
Illustration that a
We
Capable 0/
a simple exam-
very irregularly.
The mind
them
in
may
be
NON-VOLUNTARY ATTENTION.
obliged to pay attention to one at a time
this case, there will
3I In
to count them.
Now
Here we
shall
ed by four acts of attention, and hence with four resulting ideas. If these four groups are now formed into one symmetrical
will
apprehend
all
in
one
idea, although
there
really just as
much
there to be seen, as
when
the act
This
makes no
in
it,
an
idea,
in
how much
act of
there
is
provided only
can
all
be taken
by one
attention.
tration
abstract
illus-
between these
Twenty
apprehend them and hence But group the facts under one law as various astronomical facts are connected m the law of gravitation and the mind at once binds them together into
require as
will
many
acts of attention to
produce as many
distinct ideas.
same
and carried in one act. The when no law is known, if any kind of connection can be made out between the various facts. Just as the mind, for the sake of ease in apprehending and economy in carrying impressions, will attempt to form some kind of grouping among the twenty dots, even where none is apparent, so it will strive to unite separate ideas by making connections, even This brings us to the second if none exist upon the surface. fact mentioned, that elements having no actual coherence will
result occurs
if
in one idea.
It
may be
it is
PSYCHICAL PROCESSES.
ever
among them.
At a
This
is
ence in time.
and
rejects
For
component
it is
only by
all)
but
we
call really
may
reverse his
first
act of con-
there
whenever no obstacle offered, the mind connects whatever it can connect, even upon so slight a basis as occurrence at the same Many of the popular fallacies and superstitions point of time.
is
The
that
is
have arisen from a tendency to give a real connection to events which are only casually connected; in this we have an explanation
of the
common
"
fallaries
moon
comets portend
of
St.
disaster, etc.
men
assigned
many
the
why
At
last
it
occurred to some
bold thinker that the arrival of the ship might not be the cause
of the distemper, but that bothvcii^X. be the effect of a
cause,
common
and then
it
BDUCATIO^AL PRINCIPLES.
Purther Illustrations.
33
Two or three simple examples may make French psychologist tells of a little boy who when going under a railway bridge happened to think of a toy horse which had been given him, and said "my horse." For a long time after that he never went under anything whatever without saying ** my horse." Although
the principles clearer.
there
was absolutely no
real connection
facts,
they were
connected for him in one idea simply because he had attended to both at
the same time.
Another example
window of
the car,
th
These examples, trivial as they are, serve none the less kj illustrate the law upon which all mental acquisition is originally founde<!4 namely, that whateve^ sensations occur at the same time can be attend7i to by one and the same act unless there is some actual opposition bel -^een them, and. since they are grasped in one act of attention, they b.'come
window
catch.
Thus it is that sensations in themselves fraguientary of one idea. and separate become united into the simultaneous wholes of ca existent parts, which constitute so large a part of our actual experience. , hEESF ^77
members
Educational Principles.
(t)
The
Necessity
of
Activity.
is
Perhaps
V ^-Tv,
the chief point
^y^^
of^
mind
the necessity of
some
activity
on the part of the child from the very first and in every operation. No amount of presentation, however skillful no amount of repetition, however persistent ; no amount of explanation, however clear is of any avail, unless the child's ^tentiony the one condition of learning which cannot be dispensed with, is secured. That there is attention, simply means that the child's mind is working upon the subject attended to and that the child is non-attentive, simply means that there is In the no connection between his mind and the subject. latter case, the teacher and pupil might as well be in different
worlds
relation
between them
is
concerned.
(2) Possible Errors.
There
is
a tendency at present to
emphasize the need of sense presentation, of intuition and of This is Well ; the need cannot be object lessons in teaching.
34
PSYCHICAL PROCESSES.
it be remembered that placing the no more insures their being appre-
over-emphasized, provided
objects before the senses,
than
of
its
activity proceeding
from
the
mind;
this
but cannot be produced by another. Here, we have occasion to renew the caution referred to in the first chapter against the error
of over-estimating the part
important as
it
undoubtedly
is
There
is
a dis-
on the part of some teachers to substitute the work of and explanation of material for the more difficult, because less mechanical and more personal task, of getting the pupils' mind at work upon the material. This 3. Non-voluntary Attention must be Secured Indirectly. attention cannot be gained however by the mere directing of the child "to pay attention." Such an injunction, at the stage of development now considered, must be meaningless. Attention must be attracted^ not forced. The subject matter, in other words, must be made of interest. This interest once obtained, attention follows naturally and even inevitably. The teacher
presentation
again
4.
is
the test
and condition
-of
intellectual
development.
It
can hardly need repeating that interesting does not mean amusing.
It
does not mean that the subject must be surrounded with factitious
some
Such Every
as
mind
rely
he
does in the activity of his body, and to render a subject interesting meani only to
make
it
To
is
upon
such sources of interest, as are directed, not to the native and simple delight
in
mental
activity, but to
like think-
make him
eat appro*
EDUCATIONAL PRINCIPLES.
Two wrongs
left in
35
powers are
The
artificial
created.
Use of the Play-impulse. On the other hand, in early good use may be made of the "play-impulse" by a proper selection of work which the child will take delight in
5.
training
for
garten.
is an methods clearly The principles of the kindergarten, and some of its proves. methods- or at least modified forms of them may be applied
in
all
primary education.
Why
not
awaken attention
by
gratifying the
of the eye
He
hand for doing? There is scarcely a become deeply interested in Building, Folding,
will therefore give the
what he is doing, and thus begin to form habits both mental and physical which must
Methods of Awakening Normal
is
tion
such as naturally
calls forth in
No
can
here be given^ense,
That belongs
and
still
more
to the
But
notice
largely
may
and
their intermixture in
due proportion.
take
child, and no pains to bring out points of likeness between this new subject and those already somewhat familiar, is to repel attention. To continue to dwell upon a topic or illustration worn threadConnections should be made bare will give the same result. between matters and interests familiar outside of school, and those taken up within, as well as between various school subjects. A boy may sometimes be interested in arithmetic by connecting
To
thrust
^6
PSYCHICAL PROCESSES.
Interest in history or
geography
may be
contempor
to have
may be made
all
a great mistake in
more than
Further Suggestions.
(dj)
The
<?^d!//V^ aspect of
attention,
of impressions which
would
call
away the
Before
mind from
and
if
this
In
this
may be noticed
depending on the
child's health
his surroundings.
Attention, even in
this,
mind-tension,
and
;
again,
early stage,
nervous energy
it
show much
activity of attention
is
even
for a
a feeling of
extremely
it
difficult
to arouse
fixed in a
definite direction,
The
a successful
mode
of
young mind
is
same
time,
Finally,
it
may be
its
\vzs,
a certain justification as a
its
power of arousing
attention
and
ASSOCIATION.
37
is
keeping
it
rightly
directed.
question
a challenge
to
attention.
And, while disconnected, mechanical, unprepared questions gradually weaken what power of attention originally exists, orderly, progressive and suggestive questions infallibly
it.
strengthen
The
the
chief thing to be
aimed
at, in
fact, is
to
cultivate in
pupil the
in
other words)
is
secured.
voluntary attention
to lead
up
to
wg
may
2.
ASSOCIATION.
has
is
What
is
means by which a
not
after
meant simply
ideas,
that
presentations
follow
one another.
succession of
at-
What
is
meant,
is
rather that
some presentation or idea, another idea, and so on, the whole process going on This is without the intervention of any new presentation.
and out of
this a third,
standard
illustra-
Hobbes, (born 1588) one of the first to call In a company, when the conversaattention to the subject. tion turned upon the subject of the civil war in England
that of
between the Stuarts and the Puritans, some one asked the
value of a
Roman
upon
:
Denarius.
reflection,
abrupt, but
associations
who sum of
\^
money
results.
received,
its
value.
We
shall take
its
up
\
ditions of Association
second,
varieties
and
third,
3^
(i) Conditions
PSYCHICAL PROCESSES.
of Association.
is
Why
is
it
that ideas
enter
The answer
a general way
together
is
have the power of calling one another up. Association thus seen to depend upon non-voluntary attention. In the
latter, as
one.
we have learned, as many parts as possible are made Now, if one of these parts is presented, there is a
for
it
by suggesting the parts not be re-presented. Suppose, to take a very simple example, that I have heard a celebrated orator deliver a speech ; by my acts of attention
actually presented.
tendency
to complete itself
These
Now, years afterward, I read this oramy mind the idea of the speaker as he
is
;
delivered it
pendent idea in
evident
the speech
is
not an inde-
it is
and
it
completes
by suggesting
called
other member.
acts of presentation
are sometimes
integration
The term
was a whole formed out of parts ; red-integration is a second upon the first. Thus, when the sight of a flower recalls the place where it was picked, when the perception of some tokeu suggests the person who gave it, when a Latin word calls up its English
presentation
equivalent in
completing
ed.
It
all
these cases
calling
we have
itself
by
may be
piirt
original union in
of one
parts.
2.
Varieties
of Association.
There
ation,
know
as association
by the principle
and by
and internal association. meant that whatever ideas or objects have been conjoined in ipau or in time have the power of redintegrating one aaotheK
ASSOCIATION.
J9
one
in
calls
up another.
By
similarity
appearance, in meaning, in
mode
Examples of Contiguity.An
in space
is
instance of contiguity
office, I
the following
If
may
may
I
suggest
and so
all its
on.
Were
1 sufficiently
whole
called
might go on
had
before
me
buildings.
Contiguity in time
is
illustrated
by
the fact that a note of music will suggest a bar, the bar the the air the entire tune, etc.
the next and so on;
air,
One
letter of
an alphabet suggests
a line of a familiar
succeeding
line, this
We
visiting
Irish
boy
his age,
; seven years old, the day the pig died " evidently what to him
had occurred
the original.
at the
same
time.
Examples of
One
The apple-blossom
etc.
Similarity.
Seeing
a portrait
calls
up
which
it
resembles.
calls up the rose ; the locust flower the pea, Napoleon the Great may suggest Julius Caesar; while The idea of a straight line may Cicero calls up Demosthenes.
suggest rectitude; a
frater will call
hammer call up a hatchet. The word up the words Brudcr and brother, etc. In some
is
No
limits
can
summoning
fft
PSYCHICAL PROCESSES.
Association
by Contrast. A
is
remarkable extensioc
of
call
each other up; so vice suggests virtue, night day, joy sorrow,
a dwarf a giant, a valley a mountain,
etc.,
etc.
It
may seem
absurd to
call this
clearly
is.
etc
there
is
common
already
mentioned,
by conii^uity
is
The
reason
is
as follows.
suggesting and the suggested idea have been parts of one idea, but the
bond
i.e.^ it
When,
e.g.^
where
first I
read
a certain idea brings into consciousness it, the idea and place are connected,
Each would be unchanged if this connection had not The union does not affect the internal structure of either. Not
by
similarity.
so in association
When
is
followed in
is
its original,
bond of union
just the
and without
nor
it
i&
The connecting
Results of Association.
first result
Mental
rule.
dom. The
is
some semblance,
into psychical
at least, of order
and of
come
life.
sequences having some common bearing, some unity. While in non-voluntary attention the mind is always called into action from without and thus is subject to whatever is presented,
into
in association, the
mind forms a
series of ideas
from within.
The
upon the
internal
us, but
upon the
ASSOCIATION.
train of suggestion.
It
41
may
is
fairly
be
said,
therefore,
that
to free the
and
to allow
a certain inde-
pendence of
ation based
own.
Superiority of Association by Similarity. Associupon internal similarity assists the development of mental power and freedom much more than that based upon accidental conjunction in space or time. One might associate
for
a book.
common
ation
structure of both.
case (associ-
no reason in the association ; it might just as well have happened between other ideas ; while in the latter case (association by similarity) there is meaning in the association and it may lead to something beyond itself to a scientific comprehension of the relation of the two animals. Similarly an historical event may be associated with some by
contiguity) there
some
historical law.
Pormation of Habits.
and freedom
This
is
far is that
mind an order
ideas
and
activities
is
meant such a thoroughly formed train of associations that if one member of the train comes into consciousness the other members follow almost inevitably and ivithout any intervention on the part of will or of
often repeated that a habit
formed.
By a
habit
is
consciousness.
erect
For example, we now have the habit of standing and of walking. We do not need to pay careful attention
43
to every detail
in these acts.
rest
PSYCHICAL PROCESSES.
and stage of the complex movements involved It is enough that we begin the movement, the
itself.*
goes on of
But
it
so.
One need
successive move-
ments of
his
muscles
associations carefully
and an
indefinite
once
performed automatically,
without the
as active
are distinguished
is
meant simply
that
we are habituated or accustomed to anything. It implies no more than ability to hold our own so that we are not conquered by external impressions or
activities.
Active habit
is
more than
this.
impression, to
trained ability in
habit
is
illustrated
by the binding force of a custom upon us ; active habit, by the dexterity, quickness and accuracy of a well-trained mechanic.
Function of Habit.
mental
life.
in
In the first place^ it forms a psychical mechanis or piece of machinery by means of which the soul both holds its
own and
cumstances
it
and the Will time and opportunity mastery of new and higher acts.
the
First End. In the early period of psychical existence, mind is at the mercy of its impressions. It can understand nothing of its surroundings, and can execute no purposes,
it is
indeed,
tion
this
It is xhQ forma-
intellectual habit
\s
ASSOCIATION.
given
43
in
him
there
he
is
at least
one respect
which he stands
above the chaos which in other regards overpowers him. H he forms a habit of will say of walking, of controlling the
movements of
culate speech
arti-
by them.
Habit
mode
said,
is Self-Oontrol.
A
it
habit, in other
It
words,
is,
is
a
so
as
is
often
is,
is
mode
of self-control
and with
is any occasion for its use. It is by body becomes a fit and accurate instrument for
itself
upon
its
the body,
and
is
master.
executed
as when
one
talks, or walks,
some problem.
The
influence of habit is seen most clearly in body to perform certain complicated acts
ways of thinkartist
ing or of feeling, as
we
The
has one
scientific
man
and so
is little
on.
Each has
falls
certain kinds of
naturally
and spontan-
or
no
effort to
keep thinking,
fairly said
as suggested, a habit
may be
itself,
requiring intelligence
and
will
merely to
start
then
clearly, the
the necessity of
free to
devote
itself to
any supervision of such actions and leaves it other matters. For example, when a
is,
child
is
when he
is
forming an associ-
44
ation
it;
EDUCATIONAL PRINCIPLES.
between certain impulses) he must give his entire mind to mental processes cannot occupy themselves with anything
his
else.
it
seems
to be taken entirely
much
as
if
on
at all
perfection.
If
etc.,
itself specially to
the
power
the idea
origin-
down
to assist
and
regulate
it
mind,
is
demand
and
in every stage
Their use is fundamental of mental growth and hence they may be helpfully
and the
higher.
is
Mechanical.
It
it is
come
most
into play.
part,
That
is
to say, the
made,
for the
machine would
act, without consciousness of any reason for making the association, while the result is mainly to give the mind a machine-like power of performing the same operation
in the future.
The
child
who
really
doing, of the
activity, or
acquiring.
From
merely
And
is
culturing
eflfect
comes from
later reading
it is
simply the
EDUCATIONAL PRINCIPLES.
acquisition of a
45
it
new capacity or
habit,
making
more easy
to
of
the
Mechanical Stage,
The
mechanism, the capacity for performing the act spontaneously and without effort, is built up through repetition. There is
in
thing again
and
again.
The
of appeal to the
mind
is
is,
therefore,
t ^
facts,
acquired in this
pedagogy whichi u?uier proper limitations^ finds its application here Learn tp This principle is by no means co-extensive with do by doing. the whole of education, and is in fact much abused by some
is
:
There
one dictum of
modem
it is
the basis of
all
early training.
Reading can be learned only by reading; spelling only by spelling; writing only by writing; the fundamental operations of number only by performing them, and so on. The teacher must aim, therefore, at thoroughness and continuity of repetition, and while having constantly in view the dawning intelligence oi the child, must avoid undue reliance upon the rationale of the
subject-matter,
3.
to a reason as yet
undeveloped.
The teacher
its
value
is
in
what
it
can do.
is
To make
even
early
as
if
a weaver were to
loom in motion wholly While the process of irrespective of making any cloth. early education must be largely mechanical, its spirit must be intelligent and rational There is a temptation in the practical work of teaching to forget this, and to allow the whole work to become one of dead routine. How shall the teacher avoid this and yet not make premature appeal to an immature reason ?
regard
as his sole business to
keep
his
46
PSYCHICAL PROCESSES.
that the
By remembering
discipline.
training
is
What is Meant by Discipline- Discipline, like habit, has its active and its passive side. It aims to make the mind at once capable of resistance and capable of positive effort. A mind is disciplined just in the degree in which it can hold its own against both the pressure and the distracting solicitations of sensations and impulses, and in the degree in which it has the power of systematically acting upon them, so as to shape them for its own
ends.
The
effect
of discipline, in short,
is
to give the
mind
tAe capacity of
accomplishment of some definite worky while at the same time it gives power to act in new and untried ways^
acting steadilyt easily
and
efficiently to the
The
is
to give ability
number easily, quickly and accurately, and at the same time, to enable the mind to act with greater strength and Now, if this end is kept in mind, there is no efficiency in all directions.
to ascertain the simpler relations of
spirit will
how
Learn
to
do by Knowing.
It
may be
well
to
warn the
" learn
is
maxim
doing.'
to
do by
chiefly applicable in
arisen educa-
who preach
as a universal principle.
And
what
is
comes a
positive error in
advanced
stages.
speaking "
no
formal
grammar.
Learn
to
science of arithmetic
by teaching " therefore no science of educa no professional training of teachers, and so on thiough a long list of *' practical " inferences, which are plainly " Let eye. at variance with a sound philosophy of education. and ear, and hand, be thoroughly trained," by all means ; but is there not Something behind these organs that makes the seeing eye, the hearing ear and the forming hand ? Is the pro" Learn to teach
tion
and
first
mind,
brain, hand?
Even
in
EDUCATIONAL PRINCIPLES.
the elementary
47
It
may be
but from
before
the
is
actual.
*'
aiming at
Bain, we must clearly conceive what is aimed at.*' And so, as we have already intimated, the teacher must constantly keep in view the growing intelligence of the child, helping him to form clear ideas of the new " constructions " aimed at, and teaching
can
be
Where we have a very distinct and intelligible model before us, we are in a fair way to succeed in proportion as the ideal is dim and wavering, we stagger and miscarry." It appears, then, that the maxim, " learn to do by doing," is, after all, but the complement of a
of power.
:
"
to
do by knowing.
Connections.
is
one of
Forming
is
While
the
example) there
is
This
is
able to recite
upon
it,
When a pupil geography or history lesson so as to be he is intentionally forming certain conof teaching
nections of ideas.
The work
now changes
its
aspect somewhat and the main emphasis should be put n^^on presenting the proper connections of ideas^
and upon
assisting the
pupil to re-make
6.
them
in his
own mind.
may be Sensuous or Ideal may be forming associations
visible
The Associations
in this Stage
As a pupil
He may
49
PSYCHICAL PROCESSES.
This
it
is
may
is
this
Of course
it is
Idiots
of
On
book which one had read without some knowledge of the look and sound of the successive sentences.
7.
Sensuous
Associations
should be Subsidiary.
When
and
calls
upon one to stop in the middle of a sentence and the next to take it up at that point, he is doing his utmost to induce the
pupil to form only sensuous
associations.
activity of intelligence,
and
alone con-*
are
Children's
sense-organs
exceed-
ingly sensitive ;
way
no
adult.
The
ment or organ
8.
*'
for
Teach only
What
is
Understood."
It
is in
this
second stage
of
child should learn only the development of association that the precept ** what he understands " has its application. In the earlier, mechanical stage,
it
all
and
in this
second stage,
it
its
true
mean:
It
does not
mean what
literally says
what he comprehends.
To
understand implies
know
scientifically
this of
and
it
is
absurd
demand
yet undeveloped.
In
fact,
the learn-
number of
means
is
that
whose relations are not understood is the them at a later time. What the dictum the pupil should learn only that which has some nuan'
facts
EDUCATIONAL PRINCIPLES.
i^ which
appeals to him, which conveys something to him.
It
49
means
that he should connect ideas, the significance of things, rather than associate meaningless
sounds or
sights.
When
this
arithmetic
is
numbers,"
it is
impossible that
he should
that
fully
understand what
means.
But
it is
definition should
it
And
this
it
does, if there be
Importance of Habit.
It is
much
tion
first act,
of good habits good habits of body and of mind. The mental or bodily is the starting point of habit ; it leaves
is
first,
and so on,
In
and
tendency to follow
are measured by the frequency with which the acts involved have
been repeated.
all
education
it
works with
special
Assuming
that in his
kingdom those
it
and
Such a man
will
teach not by
:
lazi-
etc, are not to be found in his pupils because they are not to be
found in him.
On
become
of the
teacher.
is
One of
Culture.
As the
first
stage
is
50
PSYCHICAL PROCESSES.
is
one of culture.
Associations are
formed on the principle of similarity, and thus ideas are grouped about a common centre. The tie in the case of association by similarity
is
natural
and
intrinsic
While ideas
associ-
ated by
coTitigiiity
may be
mind
to hold
them
together,
compared
and
;
digested,
the one
it.
may be
a strain
upon mental
similarity
fibre,
Rational comprehen-
and
is finally
seen in
its
by
it
Note.
VOLUNTARY ATTENTION.
Relations to Non-Voluntary.
based upon movement directed with
end,
differs
Voluntary attention
from
it
is
non-voluntary,
but differs
as a
mental
future
some
simply
by
chance
attraction
of
the
moment.
For
example,
we may suppose a
botanist's attention
called spon-
taneously to a flower by
the next
so on.
He may be attracted its vivid colouring. moment to the contrasting colour of the foliage, and Or, he may observe something peculiar say an appa-
Now
He
He
scientifically to see
mechanism and
of the
with other
that are
mode
;
of
operation.
it
observes
the
structure
;
flower
compares
He
already caught and speculates upon the mode aad purpose of He sets himself to watch the plant and see the their capture.
VOLUNTARY ATTENTION.
exact
insect
is
entangled.
Non-volun
he no longer notices
but because of
trait
in the flower,
to reach,
directed in
refer-
something, with
Relation to AssOCia.tion. Voluntary attention can It can deal only with the presentacreate no new material.
tions afforded
tions given
goes on at
to
by non-voluntary attention and the representaby association. But while association by itself hap hazard, one idea suggesting another according
any accidental bond of contiguity or of similarity, voluntary and manipulates, controls it for
own
end.
It
compels the
train in
one direction
it
shuts
which do not appear to lead towards Ideas which the mind feels to be helpful
Association
when
some fundamental
a
one another not by any accidental bond, but by characteristic, some unity which gives them
common
Example.
Take
;
who
then of the
it
some
coal
;
he had
often
Thus one
53
PSYCHICAL PROCESSES.
minutes before.
The
fei^
on.
But voluntary attention prevents a succession of ideas having no common significance. It keeps the suggested ideas of our
botanist, e.g. in
harmony with
the
end desired
knowledge of the
structure of such
velopment.
an apparatus, and of the process of its deVoluntary attention is a train of associations con'
of forming
finds interesting.
Ideas no
to this end-
longer
come and go
at
At
first,
voluntary attention
For example, a boy forms making a kite. As soon as he has this idea, his thoughts and activities at once get a certain unity. They are controlled by the end which he desires to reach, and the end suffices of itself to suggest those ideas which lead to it, and to expel others. So, too, a boy may wish to find how a story "turns out," and the interest in this end will keep his mental processes engaged in reading, while otherwise they would be straying here and there. There is simply an extension of non-voluntary attention by interest in some future occurrences.
interest.
Higher Forms.
ests but yet
But
does not
suffice
of
itself to
ideas.
The
who
has
made a
afterwards
Here the matter is so complicated that the intermediate steps must be separately studied and their relations to one another and to the whole, made The end is forgotten for the time being, and attention is out. So with a pupil solving given to all the steps leading up to it. While the whole process is directed with a problem in algebra. a view to reaching the end (finding the value of x\ yet it is the
sets himself to
making a steam-engine.
YOLUNTARY ATTENTION.
successive operationo to
53
itself,"
so to
speak; the mind need only be fixed upon the end and the
means
is
to
it
in the higher
required. Ai Hie power of attention more and moie comprehensive until it requires the cooperation of almost evciy process of the intellectual life. Thus we may
Activities Involved in Attention. Attention may, be defined as a movement of ideas unified and controlled by the conception of some end. There are various activities involved in this movement, of which three may be particularly Attention is (i) an adjusting^ (2) a selecting and mentKjned.
therefore,
(j)
a relating
activity.
I.
IS,
Atte7iiion as
in
whom
come and go. Its extreme form is reverie; the mind drifts on from one topic to another. If we ask why this happens, we see that it is because the mind lets ideas take their It is not filled before-hand with some idea by which course.
.
it
tests,
in
is
it
But
It
not indifferent
it is
hardly impartial.
has a controlling
It
and compelling
ful, alert for
has a predisit
Hence
is
watch-
passed over.
consider a biologist
Illustration. By way of
engaged
in studying the life
illustration,
history of an
animal under
microscope.
He
train
54
PSYCHICAL PROCESSES.
tff Ueas that suggests itself; he must be indifferent to all sights and sounds unconnected with the animal observed. He must notice the slightest change there; must connect this with what
after.
The mind
it,
at-iends,
is
coming, to anticipate
the fatigue
more than
follow their
half-way.
Hence
own
to react
on the new
Why
Called Adjusting ? It
is
is
clear, therefore,
why
the activity
An empty mind
cannot
attend to anything
a mind empty in a given direction canIt must have some idea, however
is
coming, of what
of
is
to be looked
a certain
subject, the
new
in that
subject.
Attention
is
in the
Attention
is
dejl/iite
having points of community with the group. The adjusting power of attention consists in getting to the foreground of the mind and
holding there, those ideas allied to the object-matter attended
to.
A pupil
knowledge of numbers
it
to the
life
new case.
nature of
is is
mental
may be
illus-
An
individual
in a dark
he
is
unacquainted.
This room
lighted
up
VOLUNTARY ATTENTION.
by an
electric spark.
55
first
Now, previous
to the
illuminarion
no preparatory activity of the mind. It doe not know what to look for, and hence cannot get ready. But at the first spark, it obtains some dim idea of the room, and this makes a
there can be
basis for attention at the
Being
slightly
give/
prepared,
greater
flash,
it
now
sees
more
second
flash.
This
power
and so
flash during
ward presentation, the better it can attend, and, of course, the more it can become conscious o
Attention and Past Experience. It
the
is
power of voluntary
upon
We cannot
form adjustments, where we have no ideas. In every fact learned, in every process of knowing, therefore, we are deciding our future knowledge as well as our present, for we are deciding in what directions we may be able
to
form adjustments, to pay attention. The difference between a child and a man, between an uncultured and an educated man, is largely that ono has definite groups of ideas, or instruments of adjustment, ready to bring to
bear upon presentations, while the other has not.
considering the
Thus far we have been mind in attention ; the preNow we shall paration necessary in order to give attention. suppose that adjustment has been secured, and ask what is The primary the eff^ect upon the subject matter attended ta The mind emphasizes ^i- slurs, brightens iPt effect is selective. JBB*dims, according to the end it wishes to reach. Attention has the same efifect upon any mental content that a lens has
2.
upon
and
indistinct
Attention, as adjust-
ment, has been called " asking questions of the future," and the
question once asked, the
mind must
select
material fitted to
answer it
56
PSYCHICAL PROCESSES.
Basis of Selection.
cross-examining attitude.
The
It
is
in a
come, but inquires into their value, and makes use of them ac-
on which some are chosen and others are mind takes in it. A flower will produce the same sensations in the mind of an artist, a farmer and a man of science ; but the artist will notice
cordingly.
basis
The
rejected
is
make
seem
to testify to a
weed
or
may
scientific
of the
One
the
perceives, or selects,
one
thing,
in
and
others
who
neglect
it.
And
any
case,
is
mind wishes
it,
which
it
brings
with
and
as just
varying things.
But
all
minds, have a
common
interest in knowledge,
and a common
end
there
would be no knowledge. Thus we may suppose a thousand persons reading a book and each underlining what
A large number of
would vary according to the various ages, tastes, stages of But there might be a number of culture, etc., of the readers. passages in the book which would appeal to all, and which all would emphasize. So with the book which the world presents
lined
to
The
Law
of
Common
Selection.
it
laid
down
in
when
may
be, there
is
selects those
and
impulses
VOLUNTARY ATTENTION.
that are signs of something else
;
57
that point to
Elements having no meaning outside their own occurrence, are neglected. For example, although muscular sensations are of great importance to us,
we
them
in themselves, unless
it
be when
we
are
tired.
what they
signify
We move
strain,
is
of persons
years.
who became
blind in
and are not conscious of the muscular measured by it. There are instances one eye and yet did not know it for
to,
being unchanged, they never noticed the change in the sensations themselves.
Each of us has
is
tirely either
no reference
reference
so
that alone.
J. Atteniion as
noticed, ideas
may be connected
something
The
relations
which
And
aims
that
it
at penetrating
superficial,
con-
and which
distinguish
Ordinary
experience,
no classification. Objects might forever thrust themselves upon the mind, and if the mind did not react upon them with
the idea of a system according to which they might be grouped, a
Example.
If
in
which our ideas present themselves or suggest one another, what kind of Zoology, for example, should we have ? It would
consist simply of a continuous description of animals taken in
58
tion
PSYCHICAL PROCESSES.
ciation
and co-ordination, no principle of classification. Assoby similarity would suffice, doubtless, to give some larger
divisions
birds,
insects,
quadrupeds,
etc.,
might
fall
into
groups by themselves.
used to
called
test
classification
birds,
and
whales
fishes.
Finer classification
and
knowledge of the
wholly lacking.
that
would be almost
For zoological
we examine
just as they
some hidden
unity,
them some
in ap-
common
principle or cause
among
facts the
most diverse
Comparison.
we
This
by which
and
termed comparisoiu
We
compare when we hold two ideas together in the mind, and from one to the other in order to see It is association, without in what points they agree or differ. doubt, which originally brings the two ideas together; but
is
attention
required to
keep them from being displaced by further suggestions, and attention, the idea of an end, and the direction of our thought
by it
is
Comparison
;
it
unifies
and
discriminates.
Unffication- When we say that attention aims at unifiying ideas, it must not be thought that two ideas zxt/used into one. The tw o ideas stiU remain separate in their existence, it is only their meaning that is identified.
Both are seen to signify the same thing. Thus the fall of the apple, th path of the cannon ball in the air, the revolution of the moon, the rise of the tide, facts separate in themselves, are unified by the lavi^ of gravitation.
Voluntary attention, then, sets out with the idea of a law, a relation, a prin*
VOLUNTARY ATTENTION.
ciple
59
common to
different facts,
;
and
it
it
seeks for
it
everywhere
it
tries
this
and
that
procedure of a
is
scientific
man, endeavoring
to discover or to verify
it
Discrlmlliatioil. When speaking of non- voluntary attention, we noticed that one of its effects is to bring whatever receives attention more clearly
into consciousness.
In voluntary attention
we have an
extension of the
same
principle.
The mind
another property.
one object and another, between one feature or quality of the object and It is through this process that knowledge ceases to be
vague, and gains clearness.
tree before
he recognizes any particular kind of tree. The elm, the oak, the maple, But he notices, say, the difference in the leaves are all simply trees to him.
; he then compares the two trees with a view to ascertaining in what other respects they differ. Each difference as it is noticed makes knowledge of the tree known more distinct, or definite. Thus, also, the child begins with a vague idea of meat, which by noticed differences,
of two trees
beef, veal,
mutton,
etc.
The
undefin-
ed in every case precedes the distinct, and the vague becomes the definite,
upon
differences.
and
discriminating,
knowledge becomes
at
once
unified
and
definite.
While, at
first,
and these few vague, with growand larger wholes, and the details of these larger wholes are better and better defined. The mind takes in more at one grasp, and the details stand out more For example, a child just learning to read has before clearly. him a printed page \ the unit of attention is necessarily small say the single word, or at most the sentence. And the members
idea,
details in
ing culture
takes in larger
or, if
he can
recognize the meaning of a sentence at one act of attention, he will not know the relations of the different parts of the sentence,
the value of each of
its
members.
after,
he
will
and
at the
6o
EDUCATIONAL PRINCIPLES.
will
same time he
factors,
of
each of
its
laboriously
one
at a time.
The
attention
is,
and
at the
same
part of
this
whole
reached, there
is
economy
and
facility in
of securing atten-
is
depends upon the patience, tact, interest and skill of the teacher. But there are certain psychological principles upon
which he must build either consciously or unconsciously,
his best energies
1.
if
even
to be of
any
avail.
Voluntary Attention
if left
Demands Mental
Effort.
The
It
train
of ideas,
ation.
to
itself, will
go on by the principle of
associ-
And when
all
by
therefore, a certain
it
were, with
and
to control them, to
compel
it
them
It requires
;
no
positive effort or
to allow
to
mind wander
This
we have simply
easy,
follow
its
own
course.
is
and so mental
laziness
the student
association of ideas,
and
2.
to
must be awakened from the inertia natural to the and made to exercise his mental powers, assume an active, energetic habit of mind.
Voluntary Attention
Interest.
Dissipation
of
of interest
lazi-
Watch an inattentive schoolboy; one moment he studies one lesson, the next moment, another lesson, then he must write upon his slate, then sharpen his pencil, then speak to a fellow-pupil, and so on in a conness, the great foe of attention.
PSYCHICAL PROCESSES.
stantly interrupted
interest
The
pupil
may have had good powers of nonis to say, objects may have attracted
long as the
attrac-
him
tion
readily
and kept
if
endured, but
the
successive
attractions
were nevel
welded into a
result
is
series, if
disconnected habit of
in
diverse subjects
mind.
interest
attention.
akin
is
to the
Subject to be attended
to.
we have
seen,
focussing
upon
to
the subject
To
tion
require a
young
pay attention
mode
of revolu-
whether
may
and
interpret the
new
no
statements,
is
to
commit a
pedagogical blunder.
or the ear
A certain
may be
secured, but
To
demand
him to
to
to ask
fix his
demand an
tion, attention
havmg some
4.
)e
not
hand
stored away,
it
62
it
EDUCATIONAL PRINCIPLES.
If mental effort
failure
must have them ready to seize upon whatever is presented and unity of interest exist, and yet there is
of attention,
it
is,
Of
course, training in
^is
easily secured.
5.
Counterfeit Attention.
It follows
from
this,
that there
may be
the
outward
form and
attitude
of attention
is
the
utterly
forms
of
such spurious
all
;
attention
futile.
as
already^
intimated,
but equally
its
to a lesson
facts
hended while
lesson to
never grasped.
may
und yet
whole
is
;
fail
wanting
no
a pupil
it, through not giving the higher and power of attention necessary to such mastery. Or, again, a
yet
fail
to master
student
topic
may
and
still
old
he does not revive and hold in readiness the groups of ideas bearing on the subject ; he fails in the adjusting power ol
;
ff
y^
OF THK
'
r^
VOLUNTARY ATTENTION.
attention,
UNIVLP,:3ITY o^ ^^^= 6^ ^
ol
and the
result
is
neither
permanent increase
that the
Mind move
kept moving.
along
may
Let
the
met
mind is aroused to active effort, it has continuous interest ; it has had knowledge of matters analogous to that to be attended to, and this knowledge has been stirred up and called to the And now the subject is put before the pupil, and he surface. A most lame and imis told by the teacher to pay attention. The pupil is now waiting and anxious to potent conclusion pay attention ; how to pay it is the essential point, and the If he tries to point on which he is too apt to get no help. keep his mind resting, to keep it literally fixedy one result is the mind must move in one way or another ; it inevitable cannot rest without consciousness ceasing; some association So, with the suggests itself, this suggests another, and so on. firm purpose to pay attention, the pupil finds his mind
!
wandering.
How
the
Attention
is
movement of
by the
relations of identity
The process of paying attention is, therefore, and difference. In the early one of naticitig and discovering these relations. stages, this work must, of course, be performed largely by the teacher ; he must arrange the material, he must arrange his
questions so as to
ject,
make
prominent.
;
Unimportant and
must be
salient
excluded
must be made
mind
ally
and of
64
PSYCHICAL PROCESSES.
When
this point
is
no
attention
itself,
need be paid to
attention.
Attention
takes care of
for this
lations is Attention.
V^
7.
Further
Suggestions.
{a)
In infancy
is, it
and
childhood
attracted
must be
by some
power,
by the personality
grows into
of
to.
of the teacher
etc.
But
as
non-voluntary
voluntary,
may be
effectively
appealed
itself,
com-
mands
attention
through
its
association
(J?)
prospect " of
some
desired end.
As
to his thinking;
mind
in
conquering
The
difTerent
tastes
pupil
may have
it.
little
native
or,
may have
acquired a thorough
In either
on
tremely
difficult.
He
specific direction,
to attend with no groups of ideas which are related to the new subject and without which he cannot seize upon it for, once more, a mind empty in a given
direction,
In such a
case,
if
the
teacher
it
flows from
many a youth
6$
is
"
The boy
of perhaps equal importance in the moral is father of the man ;" if, in the school, the
habit of attention
is
and
unstable as water."
(says
Compayr6)
is
the
synonym
of
To
be habitually attentive
sciences,
effective prayer
itself
may bestow
to the
is
also
one of the most precious means of moral perfection, the surest means of shunning mistakes and faults, and one of the
virtue.
8 4.
We
attention,
which
elaborate
it
ence or aspect.
the
They
acts
affect
mind which
;
they
the subject.
the processes of attention and association workupon them, form the idea of a flower. This is the outward objective effect But the mind now has knowledge of this
by an object
ing
flower
its
own
store of ideas
is
is
increased
its
structure
is
en-
This
effect.
latter effect it
66
PSYCHICAL PROCESSES.
Apperception
may be
sented to
ial
Retention
is
the action
when
apprehended.
Apperception
the
mind {apprehending^ of
Retention
is
giving
it
the material,
itself.
when taken
Illustrations.
These
An
all,
abstract definitions
may be made
It
clearer by examples.
infant,
produces
same
effect
upon
supposing that
all
And
no
mingled feelings
The savage also has these feelings, some qualities; its immense size, the peculiarities of its form, some analogies of appearance and perof movement with those of animals that he has known haps he calls it an " iron-horse." The ordinary man perceives
and
in addition recognizes
;
the locomotive
that
is,
this object,
knows
its
that
it is
structure.
The mechanic
;
the
bearing'
to
and
relation of it
;
He perof it
means
an end
member
;
Whence come
Not from
attitude
the engine
the
of
mind towards
Apperceiving power
acts
from the
may
from
dififerent
ways
in
upon the
sensations.
On
tion.
The
baby,
it
he
will
67
his
of recognition.
The
structure
of
mind,
in
The savage
he notices how
levers, etc.
it
how
it is
governed by
The
know
his
mind
itself.
supplies
them from
after van-
ishing, left
some
trace,
some
of
that the
engine
he imparts
It is
own
knowledge.
attitude of
mind of
changed.
He
is
new facts told him, but mind and enlarged its powers.
is
Knowledge
possession.
illustrated.
a permanent
fact of Retention
Mutual Relations.
processes depends
It
is
of these
upon the
other.
We
we have once apprehended, so much, at least, is clear. Furthermore, what we retain from one experience is that with which we apprehend ever afterwards. If the baby, or the savage, or the ignorant man apperceives more the second time
he sees a locomotive than he did the
experience were "writ in water,"
first,
it
is
because of
If every
left
no
trace of itself
no such thing as retenwe should always remain infants would be no growth in apperceiving
if
there were
power.
student
is
not to infer
stored
com
are stored
in
a bin.
68
PSYCHICAL PROCESSES.
;
but such
The
idea, as
an
moment
that
it
leaves consciousness.
Nor can we
it is left
say in
strict
behind.
which the experience makes upon the mind is retained. The apprehending activity of the mind may be compared to the reception and assimilation of food by a living organism. As the tree, for example, does not absorb surrounding gases, moisture and mineral substances and " store them up " unaltered, but as these act and react upon the living tissues of the tree until they themselves are changed into living tissues so the mind deals with its experiences. They are not passively received into the mind, to be preserved there unchanged, but they are worked over into the strengthening of old powers and tendencies and into the germination of new ones.
the
effect
;
Educational Illustration.Suppose
a column of
figures.
If
he
do
this
without assistance.
But
add.
it is
his
its
mind,
action
and
to perceive
and
to construct rela-
A
its
when he
f/u
may form
retained
is
some-
"dynamical association." By this is meant thai retention consists in an active tendency to form connections.
69
The mind which has joined objects or ideas by attention or by making similar connections more easily in the future, but it has a tendency^ a predisassociation, has not only the capacity of
position, to
make them.
it is
Long
memory
each of his
in
is
experiences and
power, that
it
by this retention that his mind grows develops and matures. If we examine what
retained before
the
memory
exists,
we
see that
it is
Nature of Apperception. We
are
.,'
more clearly what constitutes apperception. // is bringing to bear what has been retained ofpast experiences in such a way as to interpret, to give meaning to, the new experience. Without this
act of bringing to bear what
is
^fiHi\
-~^
is
no
knowledge of what
that in a certain
is
presented.
all
may be
is
its
said, therefore,
sense
cognition
re-cognition.
Knowre-
ledge of what
lations to
is
meaning upon
the perception.
An
if
objected that
this
advance in mental
theory, if a
The
new
fruit,
But
this objection
know it at all, since he could not recognize it may be met so as to bring out the very point
tastes the fruit
; ;
desired.
The person
his
mind from
its
previous
and other
By
its
relations
of
In relating
it
to similar things
his past
experiences.
into a
He
new
combinations,
new
objects.
From
and
differences
PSYCHICAL PROCESSES.
On
the
is
he recognizes what he
identifies
sort of
;
an object
presented to him,
the object
on the
basis of
known.
an idea of something different from what was previously And in either case, it is only by the results of his past
that there
is
experiences
amined.
Educational Principlea
r.
As
to Retention.
keep
in
mind
that
the retention
it
of
what
learned
it
consists not
in preserving
unchanged, but in
working
over
into
mental
capac-
end of instruction is not so much the acquisition of a given amount of information as the production of powers and tendencies, of abilities and
ities
and tendencies, he
tastes.
Not what
is
perceived so
much
as
is
power
the
to perceive
*'
and
interest
end of
object
lessons."
Not what is remembered so much as capacity to remember, and a fixed tendency to seize upon the salient
memory
lessons
is
not what
the
is
thought about so
much
end to be sought
it
Knowledge
that education
facts,
of what
viz.,
but in
the development
of the whole
be observed, there is often too broad a contrast made between knowledge and mental power as ends of eduYet,
it is
to
cation.
The
fact
is,
that the
of acquiring knowledge.
correlative.
gains
power
in the
act
no other
EDUCATIONAL PRINCIPLES.
is
made
it
is
elements of know-
As
to
Apperception.
is
The
perception
precisely
" learning."
The
he apperceives.
mind
to
(with
its
into
its
structure)
bear
the
upon
is
evident
to
upon
relation
of the mind
what
presented.
is,
The
on the^one hand, to secure the presentation of material of such a kind and in such a manner that the mind can be brought into relation with It ; and on the other hand, to secure such a preparation and attitude of mind that it may easily be brought to bear upon what is presented. Proper presentation of material on the one si&Q, proper preparation of mind on the other are the two conditeacher's office, therefore, in relation to learning
tions of learning.
we
shall
meet with
3-
Organization of Faculty.
The mind
faculties
inheriting certain
tively,
There are no apperceptive organs formed, no groups of ideas ready to seize upon and assimilate new There is simply a bundle of dormant capacities which material.
definite directions.
activity
Every mental experience leaves behind by some residuum an effect^ which tends^to reproduce the experience, and the accumulation of such traces mind-function of a creates special power and tendency
a trace
called
kind.
definite
Moreover,
is
from
the
known connection
of
mind with
brain, there
no doubt
72
EDUCATIONAL PRINCIPLES.
in
groups of brain
cells,
and
of
the brain.
first.
facility to act
right or wrong,
iiito
good or
evil
in
the struc-
body and mind, and will give a coloring to all future thoughts and actions, just as the food-elements absorbed by the tree, become part of its living tissue and affect the assimilation of all material afterwards absorbed. Now, the
ture of both
teacher
faculty
is
not
of
into account
but
no doubt
in
that,
under conceivably
responsible.
favourable circumstances, he
no small degree,
He
can make the child love what he himself loves, and hate
hates.
It is difficult to over-rate the far-reaching influ-
what he
of
stirred
from
that
it
what he was
before ;
will
forever.
In
in his
this
hand the
and
intellectual
child,
e.g.,
of volatile
hands
his
till
he gets from the child one act of attention suitable to feeble capacity, then a second act, then a third, and so on
;
fair
is
and the whole psychical life thereby influencfound to possess no " faculty " for literature,
;
INTELLECTUAL DEVELOPMENT.
to develop faculty, ability, taste for
73
ac-
cording to
the special
his
apperceptive
been developed in
the law
is
own mental
life.
On
equally effective.
of
a selfish disposition
does
?
meanest of
all
passions
No, he watches
kindly act
a generous
make
this effective in a
;
he
now
;
it
will
to lead to
selfish
becoming
is
the by the
till
self-sacrificing
formed
new
creation
may
sing
for,
*'
to
make some
blessed>
human
more
less accursed, is a
work
for a
God."
Dewey*s Psy-
Note.
Further
;
CHAPTER
We
have studied the
IV.
Raw
Material of psychical
life,
and the
briefly
I.,
Wc
have now
As
stated in Chap.
p. 6,
these
may be arranged
of
feehng),
and the
its
In
this
chapter
in
we
shall discuss
Development, taking up
the
first
section
general principles,
stages, par-
74
INTELLECTUAL DEVELOPMENT.
1.
VBLOPMBNT.
1.
The Development of
Representative.
Intelligence is
to the
Sensation,
the
from
the Presentativi
beyond
is
its
its
own
occurrence.
to
But the
its
test of value of
a sensation
it
;
power
merge
own
fills
existence in what
represents.
it
A
own
sensation of hunger
mind with
its
itself
thrusts out of
own
sensation of color,
its
beyond
own
suggests
these sensations
when they are not present, and thus becomes a sign or symbol it represents them. As I look at a rose, for example, of them all I see, strictly speaking, is certain shades of color. Were
my knowledge to stop short with this presentative factor, it would never occur to me that a rose was before me. But
and shape, etc. up other sensations not now present, but experienced in the past ; they call up also associated sensations of touch, And from all these factors the most of them of smell, etc.
these shades of color stand for a certain size
They
call
being
rose.
now
suppose
All that
present
is
it
as
such,
it is
it is
not a song,
It
is
it
is
not music
sound.
it
But by what
symbolizes,
gains successively
meaning.
The Development of
Intelligence is
from
the Sensuous to
the Ideal.
This,
INTELLECTUAL! DEVELOPMENT.
already laid down.
75
s^j^'||^ifln
]
The presented
elem<*nf
is
the
represented
element can
onW be
itself,
images, ideas.
mind
a nd
is
Consider the perception, for example, of some particular object, this pen, this paper, this book, as now present in space. It might
seem
at first as
if,
no
if
book
is
actually present.
But
we simply look at the book, the only elements presented to the mind are the color-sensations with which the mind is affected. The color-sensations do not make up an idea of the book.
This contains not only color-element, but also those ot weight,
size,
forms,
of
all
number of pages, printed and meant to be read. Now, these elements, the only one that can be seen, as matter
and
also the notion of a
is
of sensation,
^are
color.
The
mind
itself.
Idealizmg Activity.
portance,
it
Since
the
ideal factor,
is
which
is
of so
much
is
im-
The
ideal factor
due
for-
to retention.
It is
its
the sensuous
presentation.
The development
results
to
bear upon
it
new
ex-
periences^
The
is
affects
the senses
all
Whether this sensation comes to mean or signify anything beyond its occurrence, depends first, upon whether the mind has had similar experiences in the past ; secondly upon whether these experiences have taken root in the mind and produced fruit there, and thirdly, upon whether they are brought Certain principles of great to bear upon the new presentation.
y
f6
EDUCATIONAL PRINCIPLES.
Educational Principles.
1.
T?ie development
of knowledge
is
the result
preting process.
interpreted
ideal
;
The
of an intermust be
in
order to
in a word, in order to
show him natural objects which he is to understand, to lecture From the point of view of to him upon laws and relations.
the pupil, the important thing
lesson, the object, the lectures.
pretation^
itself,
is
the
material,
is
so
much mere
and color
signifying nothing.
2.
//
is the result
of an assimilating process.
The
tation
1
/
The
is
min lind,
The
is
process
of interpreting
with what
is
presented
of great
It is
work
a.
in such a
way
as
Not To
to load the
mind with
receive
dencies, organs,
b.
which may
material.
shall
create centres
of
interests
be on
new
presented shall
as-
similated
c.
by them.
as careful,
To be
material, to arouse
and
d.
Always
to utilize past
There
INTELLECTUAL DEVELOPMENT.
is
77
instruction.
the
same subject be
by proper grading, by
overlapping of ideas,
centre.^
and geography,
to treat
and aid one another, instead of and separate groups of interests and To present four subjects isolated from one another is the pupil as having four minds ; it is almost to quad-
One
subject
is
out
it.
The Development of Intelligence is from the Vague to tht and from the Particular to the Universal. Its End Knowledge, in its is, thereforeyto be both Specific and General first stages, is both indefinite or vague, and limited or nonA child's knowledge of, say, a horse, as general in character. compared with a man's, possesses no sharply defined features or qualities, and is lacking in recognition of the relations which
Definite,
this
horse has in
common
with others.
all
The
other animals
with which he
somewhat similar. If the horse is the animal is most familiar, the dog will be to him a small
Taine
in
tells
of a child
who
it
for
And
;
this
example
is
is
typical
of
re-
There
all is
no
defniteness,
it
no
vague, and, as
were,
generality
evident that early knowledge has a certain kind of The word " mamma," the generality of vagueness.
78
INTELLECTUAL DEVELOPMENT.
the
This
is
no
The
child
may
every round object, from a circle drawn on his slate to the moon, " plate," but this is not because he grasps the identity of
relation (in the matter oi
form)
It is
differ-
Knowledge
In
is
it is
not
individualized.
general.
isolation
;
reality,
limited^ not
Immature
each
is
intelligence
always
it
takes facts. in
their
its
taken to be what
appears to be on
De-
and
is
laws,
do not appeal
to a
young
child
in
fact,
he cannot
of
internal connections, of
ways
in
which one
third
depends upon
limitation
is
another, or
is
some
removed.
Generality.
it
An idea
It
its
is
stands
for,
its
own
existence.
in the
degree in
which
facts
it is
taken out of
isolation,
from other
like
and
it
is
meaning.
To
may be
simply
all
what
appears to be in
one
object, separate
from
others, with
an individuality of
its
it
own.
But a
scientific
man
He
sees
through
chemical actions
and
reactions.
He may
finally rise,
through
the discovery of the law of interdependence of all things, to the statement that if the pebble were otherwise than as it is,
now become
INTELLECTUAL DEVELOPMENT.
stgnificantoi to
79
wide
relations^ instead of
be in themselves.
is
Relations, as
ve saw when
its
experiences;
it
has
it
presentation
is
ledge
is
limited.
The
discriminafuig,
activity
of
its
The
develops
relations of unity
between various
common
law or aspect.
fact,
Every
its
fact, as
is
con-
widens
meaning, for
fact.
has added
On
every
as
it
is
defines its
meaning, for
it is
Illustration.
plate,
circle
If we return to the child who confuses a and the moon, we shall find him, as he grows
He
will notice
the
moon
the abstract
in individuality.
is
a geometrical
it it
He identifies a surface, curvilinear, etc. other figures the plate, etc., and learns that
with these
has certain
it
qualities in
common
with
them
thus his
knowledge of
He
learns also to
know
the
So
EDUCATIONAL PRINCIPLES.
as a heavenly body, as not a fixed
it
moon
star,
as a satellite, etc.
and
in identifying
it
the qualities
Then
too,
moon
the
moon ceases
member by moon is now
its
of a vast
Knowledge
and
of the
some
however
different in
appearance they
may
Educational Principles.
education of intelligence,
The
down
the
at in
generality^
and the means by which these ends are to be reached, namely, analysis and synthesis.
I.
to
make Knowledge
Definite.
It is
some-
times said that knowledge begins with the concrete and advances
to the abstract,
particular,
and from
deduced
that
definite,
objects, should
his
be presented to the
pupil,
and afterwards
mind be
false
it
qualities.
However
it
may
is
be,
if it is
rightly
interpreted,
is
thoroughly
first
meant
to imply that
knowledge
is
at
concrete,
and
knowledge may be used as the basis for further knowledge. So far ought the teacher to be from assuming that objects have the
Illustra.tions. pose
it is
It is
an extremely
itselfi is
common
definite
is
error to sup-
tliat,
because an object, in
and
in
concrete,
itself,
so to the mind.
triangle, for
example,
per
INTELLECTUAL DEVELOPMENT.
fectly
8
properties
definite
it
has just
child's
such
idea
and such
of
it
and
con-
no
others.
But a
has no
such
creteness.
the triangle
definiteness.
only beginning.
A
it
triangle
has to be made
in
a.
triangle, as
he learns that
it
has three
sides,
distinction
is
bounded by
Primary
straight instead of
curved
as
circle,
etc.
same way,
mind on
from some definite idea which the pupil already has, but to wg him definite ideas, corresponding to the concrete individual
character of the object.
2.
first,
first Outlines,
The
growth* of knowledge in a
mind has been well compared to the growth of his repreThe child, at first draws upon his of, say, a man. slate two circles, one for the head, another for the body, and After a time, arms are puts under the body two lines for legs.
child's
sentation
dowed
process
lashes
feet.
Then
the
same
The eye
;
gains eye-brows,
and
Then perhaps
one
;
So
it is
it
in character.
same general kind are examined with a view to seeing individual differences, and thus knowledge becomes gradually spe.
8i
cific
EDUCATIONAL PRINCIPLES.
and concrete.
The
this
natural
psychological order.*
3.
rely
To
reach his end, the educator must be able to excite the dis-
He
;
cannot present
but he can call
these qualities.
in
That
is
to say, he
can
set
the
pupil's
mind working
This process of
there-
recognizing differences
fore,
is
The
teacher
and
rely
upon
it,
it.
If suitable material
presented, the
it
mind
will
properly,
will
be sure
it
how
to
do
The awakening and developing of mental appetites or interests^ and preparing apt material for them to work upon, give wide
enough scope to the teacher's ability without his attempting to show the pupil's mind just how it must work. The right use of object lessons, of definite and precise statements in text-books,
of talks and lectures by the teacher, etc., etc., are all covered
interest^ of
presenting material
The
trusted
mind must be
the
rest,
and
if
the teacher
The mind
sense.
it
is
always
is
seizing
upon whatever
is
in
a spatial
really
geography
child's
it
mind
it
naturally begins.
Or because
it
the sentence
a grammatical
first
whole,
is
the
psychological outline
in
child's mind.
INTELLECTUAL DEVELOPMENT.
presented,
noticing
differences, subdividing,
It
83
comparing, and
all
cannot work at
is
without going
Discrimination
a fundamental
mental capacity.
4.
tion
awakens a genuine methods at his command, presents material so that this appetite is/<f^, and noX pampered on the one hand, or repressed on the other, the pupil's mind will instinctively work towards the underlying relations of things. Ideas grow together in the mind ; centres of psychical gravitation are formed about which ideas of a like kind gather ; and
definiteness.
If the teacher
The Teacher mustdependy similarly upon the Synthetic FuncThe mind naturally works towards unity, as it
^
and
reasons,
and by
all
these centres
in the future.
along the
when
it
become organs for the apperception of like ideas If the mind works upon facts of like kind and lines which connect them, the time will surely come will notice these connections and the similarities.
growth towards unifying or grouping facts, then
Firsts unconscious
conscious recognition
of
and
laws,
is
the order
of nature,
5.
should be Taught.
least, that it is
It is
now
mass of isolated
reasons.
It
regarded simply as
facts,
may be
some
and whether
For example, many teachers require pupils that are little more than beginners in arithmetic, to write out examples in addition,
subtraction, etc., with a statement of the exact reason for every
operation performed.
the
84
difference
INTELLECTUAL DEVELOPMENT.
between a
common and
a proper noun
If
florist
all
it
necessary
to
produce
upon analyzing the flower in order to find the seed within it, he would be acting on precisely the same principle.
fruit naturally,
but should
insist
Facts, in
relations to
one another^ or
explain^ that
also has
furnish
reasofis for
one another.
The mind
for
an
and search
reasons.
Now,
facts
interest
the
in
it
would, a
final
The
teacher must
^
mind
first,
unconscious appropriation
it.
If
he
will
not try himself to take the place both of the facts and of
The
so-called
Faculties of
Mind
These
They
are
sometimes
same
being.
progressive
growth of intelligence
character.
all,
representative,
and related
The same
activities,
some particular
Perception. This may be defined as the recognition of object now present in space, as, for example, this
of grass, this particular
etc.,
pebble,
such knowledge
is
INTELLECTUAL DEVELOPMENT.
(i)
S$
presentative,
representative.
It is
It is representative,
because
stands
for.
tree.
As
stand here,
see
it
at
a distance
it
The
get from
now
are,
and the muscular sensations which I have as my eye turns from one point of light to another. The representative elements are the form, size, height and distance of the tree ; the feeling it would give if I had power to touch it ; its wider, unseen, structure and arrangement ; the kind of tree, as e. g. a maple, and all the scientific knowledge that I have of its
therefore, those of color
etc.,
etc.
The
very few
which
(2) // is Largely
ideal.
Ideal.
^These
is
representative
factors are
in
They
are
the
mind
The mind, on
the basis
own
made up of Relations. ^The relations which prominent in perception are those of space. The most are
object
surface
is
is
at a certain
Each of these qualities is relative. Distance measured from my body or from some other object ; posiand
bulk.
is
tion
its
form
bound it,
it
etc.
We
perceive
to other objects.
all.
body absolutely
isolated
cannot be perceived at
Such
46
INTELLECTUAL DEVELOPMENT.
relation of
The
in space
may be changed
without changing
2.
own
nature.
in its
Memory, This,
not
mind but
time.
now
so,
with a
refereiice
of
it to its proper
place in
remembrance of a railway accident, for example, is complete when I can reproduce all its details, and also tell when it occurred, that is, place or date it with reference to preceding and to succeeding events. Such reproductions are
(i) Largely
My
Representative.
The
representative element
is
made
present,
if
only
we
But
in
bered event and the time in which it occurred have vanished, and we could not make them present if we wished. We represent not what we could experience, but what we have
experienced.
(2) It is
Largely Ideal.
is
not
itself
a
of
is
pain
the
memory
the
memory
in
of Relations.
In "memory,
we extend
the
We
that
come
after.
An
It is the extent
of relations
so difficult for
young children
*hey occurred.
INTELLECTUAL DLVELOPMENT.
3.
that
Imagination.
any
of
instead
Imagination
ideas without
reference to
recalling
experience.
it
ourselves have
selves.
experienced,
we attempt
to picture
to ourof
We
trains,
and
this
of incidents.
Here we have
imagination.
It
is
evidently
In the first place, we must even in memory, picture or image, what is not present, and In the second place, we very thus use a kind of imagination.
closely allied to
memory
in
two ways.
happened
we
portant details,
plan or system,
tions of facts,
selves.
we we
re- arrange
some
them-
we
are imagining.
Persons
events
recollections of important
happened years before, are often startled upon coming upon an actual description of the experience (perthat
it
occurred, to see
and
The
and this has happened simply by the natural laws of the development of reproduction, without any intention on the part of the person concerned to
has
fancy,
alter or distort.
become a work of
and
insignifi-
Imagination
has lost
its
memory which
own
Thus
art,
the world's
memory
of things."
&S
INTELLECTUAL DEVELOPMENT.
The productions
(i)
The
inr^age
which we
make
it
ourselves need
not correspond
to
anything
now
Or,
may correspond
if
to what indeed
is
would be present
real
Professor Tyn-
ment of science.
It
may
if
what
is
capable of
if
be present,
we
we could
ideals^
come guides
to conduct.
(2) // Involves
Wide
Relations.
Imagination, as
with
it is
more
than
representative
and
ideal,
deals
wider
relations
memory and
tions of place
i-ersal
perception.
not
confined to
limita-
Indeed,
time,
frees
its
and of
in their uni-
significance.
fall
Take
and the
the
fall
of the apple.
of this particular
the falling of
many
material bodies, of
all
enced.
By
of this apple as
one another ; he
to
saw embodied
This
forms.
in
it,
relations as
working of imagination in
particular fact or idea,
facts
;
higher
it
some
and makes
typical of a
idea.
whole group of
it
4.
Thinking.This may
universalfactors or of relations in their connections with, one anWhile we perceive, or rememother and with particular facts.
INTELLECTUAL DEVELOPMENT.
ber, or
89
event, or person,
we
think what
is
general.
In thinking, we do
not deal, for example, with any particular rose or geranium, but
with the class of roses or of geraniums
;
make
ities
it is
which any one individual rose may happen to possess. may have before him a particular
tions
drawn on a certain blackboard, yet his demonstrado not concern this triangle, but deal with triangles in
general,
when he proves
that
the
three
degraded to be simply a
of
no value
in
itself,
but
representative, ideal
and
re-
They
has no value of
own ;
its
worth
It is
;
is
entirely in
its
capacity to
stand
braist,
of the alge-
and having
termined by what
discovered to stand
for.
The universal has (2) That which is thus signified is ideal. no existence as a separate thing in time or space. It is the significance or meaning which is general, and meaning is ideal.
When we
this
does not
mean
is
that
existing,
which
a universal rose.
we
of
qualities
liar to
common to all roses, and excluding all each. Any idea we frame must be of a
form, etc.
;
qualities pecu-
rose of certain
size, color,
triangle
must be particular. It is just like the drawn on the board ; we can make only some parit
What
for,
is
general
is
the
or symbolizing, a
go
relation or
INTELLECTUAL DEVELOPMENT.
group of
relations.
some one
in the significanct
of a particular idea.
an Explicit Promss of Grasping Relations. memory and imagination, but thinking deals expressly and openly with the relations and with nothing else. The mind discriminates and
(3)
is
Thinking
and
in
thinkmg
it
;
simply aimi
the whole
synthesis.
keep in
Teacher
should always
Much
as
is
harm has
resulted in peda-
gogy from treating these stages of development as if they were independent faculties, having no connection with one another.
When
trained
this
is
laid
down
is
then
by separate methods. There is one process to train perception, another to train memory, another for thinking, etc. The inevitable result is so great a number of " methods " that both teacher and pupil are burdened. Again, this separation
is
fact.
The
all
methods employed
merous.
too nu
Above
ineflficient
in
each
*'
faculty"
is
but a stage
in
knowledge
No
much
less
TRAINING OF PERCEPTION.
the right education of perception
of memory^
correct
9I
is at the same time a training and the proper education of memory insures the development of imagination and of thought. Any right
method trains
These topics
now occupy
2.
us in more detail.
PERCEPTION.
by the
and, (2) in
its
The
stages,
teacher both
in
itself,
reference to other
a preparation
is
is
for
them.
all
Perception
the stages of
There can be no perception except when there is an object affecting the senses, and the richness of the perception will depend on the degree in which the senses are exercised. What has been said regarding sensation should, therefore, be
again rpfered
to.
(1)
in Itself.This
(2)
(i)
To
what
is
perceived
To
the
render the
habit
of
perception
observation.
I.
independent,
To form
what
is
using the
To
avoid
hazy perceptions, those which slur over the object and report
in a dim way, or only partially, the mind must be active. There must be mental alertness instead of indolence and In the earlier stages of life, this alertness and the correinertia.
it
the
to get hold of
to
and
in carrying out
is
any course of
action, in
there
gether^
and putting
to*
which
analysis
and
synthesis.
These
activities,
as previously sug-
92
gested,
INTELLECTUAL DEVELOPMENT.
may be
all
carried
int6
the school.
Folding, weaving,
drawing, modelling,
etc., all
of them
make
perception accurate,
because
new
whole.
Such
as the senses.
Principle further Applied. ^The teacher should strive to have the same spirit of enquiry into sul)jects where chiefly mental analysis and synthesis are required. The student's mind should always what feitures has this object, this event ? be in a questioning attitude How do they go together to make the whole ? What have I known like it ? What of the same kind, and yet different ? and so on. It is a mistake to its primary end should carry on a recitation simply as a test of memory be to test the original perception ; to discover what the student has grasped, and should (without confusing him) leave him with such a sense of imper. feet perception as to stimulate him to renewed perceptive activity.
pupil carry the
; :
2.
Independence.
In
mean
But
it
make
original discoveries,
what no one
is
does
is
mean
that
he
that, so far as
he
to be a discovery, whether
it is
is
repre-
by others
to
actually
presented.
Agassiz was accustomed to put his pupils at a microscope, and giving them no idea of what was to be seen, compel them to look for themselves Whether this is the best until they had observed everything possible. method of accomplishing the result or not, there is no doubt about the desirability of the pupil's
using his
perception, rather
Habit of Observation.
number
no matter how
ac-
TRAINING OF PERCEPTION.
curate
93
is
be,
the formation
of a habit of observation.
look-out, with his senses
pupil
who
leaves school
for
on the
is
whatever
employ them, has the most perfect equipment the teacher can provide him with, so far as perception is concerned. The traming of the ^ower
presented,
to observe should
observation of a certain
three elements
:
number of
for
things.
amounting them ; (2) An attention which is both alert and under control ; and (3) Ability to use the senseorgans, especially the eye, the ear and the hand, as instruments^ just as one would use the microscope or the pencil
(i)
An
to
(2)
Perception in
stages of
its
The other
therefore,
germ.
Unless,
is
rightly educated,
memory
suffers,
not
^^T
merely because
are
feeble
is
So, too,
there
will
for
training of per-
necessary not only for knowledge of and may be perceived, but for the sake of knowledge of what may never be, or perhaps cannot be, under actual observation. For example, a child will learn about many things in his geography and history lessons which, from the nature of the case, he cannot perceive ; foreign countries and their productions ; past epochs and their customs. Now,
things which are
mean nothing
The
till
pupil
they seem
94
to
INTELLECTUAL DEVELOPMENT.
convey to him the required
:
idea.
We
portant principle
itself
matter of
only as so translated
d into perceptions already familiar, and will it have any 7neaning. The teacher
sufficiently
must absolutely
see, therefore,
demand
representative
and
(b) That the child connects ideas which are given to him in
actual
perception,
that
is,
there
must be
and the teacher must take care appeal to clear and adequate perceptions.
Possible Errors. It is easy to blame a pupil for ideas seem ridiculous and absurd, when really his having such ideas shows that he is doing his best to translate unknown
that
topics into
what
is
familiar
and
significant.
That
his transla-
tion
is
inadequate or erroneous,
It
is
make over into perceptions previously experienced, is to burden And the evil does not stop the mind with what is meaningless. In the with loading the mind with this mass of dead matter. It is interested meaningless, the mind cannot take any interest. only in what has some connection with itself; interest has even
been defined as the relation of an impression to a group of ideas If, therefore, there is no connection between in the mind.
what
is
its
own
finally,
store of expe-
riences, interest
an
impossibility.
And,
attetition.
TRAINING OF MEMORY.
95
is
who
interested
in everything with
which they come in contact, become and listless in all that concerns their
is
that so
them which thej cannot "apperceive," that is, which thay cannot really bring their minds to bear upon. And the reason they cannot bring their minds to bear, cannot interpret and assimilate, is the lack
translated.
Thus
of previous experiences into which the new material can be studies become unreal and artificial, belonging to a realm
is
learned.
MEMOEY.
power ofgetling afty thing into the mind so that it can be got out One factor then concerns the original again when wanted.
getting
of
it
of a thing into the mindy or learning, the other, the getting Each of these factors depends
chiefly
itself
upon
depends upon
(1)
Learning.
is
keep
in
mind
in
It may be laid down as a at training memory directly, but indirectly, through the training of the apperceiving powers. The attitude of the pupil's mind should be I
what
is
to be
remembered.
Do not aim
must perceive
remember
this just as
it is
and
;"
not, I
must
is
this.
other words,
what
it
memory may be
first
itself.
For the
If this
step in
remembering anything
is
to get
it
it
and apperception
is
step in
memory
its
it
already taken,
and
own.
We may now
make
more
specific.
90
I.
INTOLLBQT&AI. SSYBLOPMENT.
A certain
rivers
has, in
itself,
no meanlarge
ing,
always has
memorized.
This
includes,
to a
names of counto
teaching, rudimentary
arithmetical
wrong method of training, that which insists memory, would pay small attention, or none, to the original perception of these facts, but would endeavor by the force of repetition to get them impressed upon
on the
direct training of
Now,
the mind.
interest
is
remember.
it
If
he
is
not to do
by a mechanical
one after another till they are graven memory, but by a perception of them, based on interest in the form and structure of the the word, and by holding the mind in strong tension to see just what should be seen and nothing else. If the child performs this act of interested and lively perception, and if he is occasionally called upon to
reproduce his knowledge, there
will
is
not
much danger
that he
forget
the
word.
And
other
classes
of facts mentioned.
The
memory by
tense,
resulting
perception.
2.
consists in the
consecutive statement
of matters offact.
class in that
it
It differs
included in the
first
has meaning of
own
It
but
it
studies,
original
" Learning
by
mind by
It
may
TRAINING OF MEMORY.
be necessary to learn
97
many
but the
literal
to the appre-
and not
memory.
it
"
"
Learning by Heart."
This, as a process of
till
is
fixed in
tions,
it
no association
mind passive.
What
is
learjied
is
activity.
The
out,
mind
always that the various impressions blur and blot out one
wax
is
worn
is
and there
is
left
only a
memory
fii
fails
largely
memory,
childhood there
of the senses.
The mind
is
plastic
The
result is
less
power of sensuous associations is greatly impaired. (3) The mind being passive, only receiving impressions,
-juhat it
burdened by
is
remembers.
for
it
;hus
a load
to carry.
may be
it
;
laid
down
as an
is
The
senses^
is
vjandering
pi-oduced.
rather than the mind, being engaged, the habit of mindOne of the commonest sources of inability to con*
and keep it fixed, is that the pupil has been accustomed to memorize by the mere repetition of sense impressions while his mind was really occupied with something else.
centrate attention
It is to
be-bome in iliind
learning-by-heart
includesas
it
ought to include
;
an
appeal to the
'
intelligettcet it
it is
accordingly to be
TTNIVERSITY
98
INTELLECTUAL DEVELOPMENT.
mere rote learning, there is a memory and especially to eliminate
educating practice of intelligently
literature.
from
"modern" methods
by heart
selections
the
truly
learning
mean
employed
On
the
and
should be
utilised.
The
and full
and no
further.
Association of Ideas.
not of sensations.
On
it
may be
ideas,
what the sensations mean, what they convey to the mind, should be connected ; and, so far as possible, the kinds of connection, whether of contiguity or of
is,
That
similarity,
should be noticed.
It will
be found a great
aid,
even
facts
in teaching
young
way
in
which
are connected.
The
constant employment
first
reading
that
interpreting
it
by
his
similating
making
the
Thus he will gain a him go over the subject various parts of the whole definite, and getting
then
let
to
one another.
If the material
is, if
is
suited
its
he can grasp
it,
erally
prehended the material as a whole and in its be found that no special draft upon the
will gen-
specific capacity
ri
memory
is
requisite
in taking
it
in,
he has memorized it
TRAINING OF MEMORY.
3.
99
There
is
material
to be
complex Ideas.
political
This includes
by
tural
economy, psychology, the more advanced stages of naSuch material has meaning in itself, and also science, etc.
implication, reasons for the facts, as
principle, that
still
apprehension,
Such material must be understood and the process of understanding it, of developing relations and tracing their connections with one another, is a process of making it over
into
fulfils
the
first
requisite
of
memory.
To memory in
this third
and highest
that
is
memory should be
particularly applicable.
lie
when taken
into the
itself,
Forgotten Knowledge-
It is
to
answer the question often asked as to the benefit of studies, such e. g., as Greek Grammar and the Calculus, whichj are often forgotten after leaving There is not only the/orma/ benefit, school, by one who never uses them.
the discipline of the mental powers employed in learning these subjects,
but there
just
While the person may not be able to recall is a material benefit. what he learned, he yet remtmbers it in the sense that it has been transformed into new mental growths. It has been changed into assimilating
power
or drawing
it
forth
when
desired.
and correct
it
easy
and almost necessary for the mind to pass from one idea already If the present to another which it wishes to make present.
association
is
is
nothmg
inter*
00
recollection
may
be broken
tion
off at
any
point.
Aside from
however, recollec-
depends upon
(i) Repetition
and
(2) Attention,
If the original act of apprehension has been 1. Repetition. an interested and an attentive one, difficulty of recollection will generally be found to be due to the multiplicity of associations
that arise.
The
idea that
is
already in
the
mind, instead
of
it will be found that seems to have a better memory than an educated one, or a child than an adult, is that the child and the illiterate have,
Thus,
is
less difficulty in
When
best
number
The
mind
acts
more
of other associations.
Each
Reviews.
repetition
is
said, it will
be un^derstood that
is
That
is, it
not to be a
the
impression
is
will
be found
that mastery of a subject depends less upon its first reception into the mind than uponthefrequent going over of what was then learned. To use the com. parison of a recent writer, just as a military officer must daily review his
troops to see that they are in proper condition for battle, so a student must constantly review his ideas to keep them fresh and ready for use.
2.
Attention.
In
this connection,
we do not
is
The machinery
in the
of recollection
either
as follows
There
an idea
idea
we wish
to recall, or
similar to it
By
PERCEPTION.
ciation, therefore, the present idea will suggest
101
what But
is
wanted
of
fail
When we
to
say
we
recollect,
it
is
really
may
pontaneously.
It is
then necessary to
to re-
is
wanted.
In
in recollecting, but
It is these
working by contiguity or
If,
similarity, bring
about
we wish to recall some one's name, we think of where we met him, who introduced him, what was said, etc.; we go over the letters of the alphabet, to try whether the name will be suggested by its initial letter. Thus we start by attention a number of converging associations to prothe recollection.
for example,
duce what
is
wanted.
was
this pro-
4.
IMAGINATION.
Imagination
its
Of
all
is
the least
As reasons
its
may be
and
mentioned, (i)
its
individual nature
mode
is
of
growth.
it is
Imagination
free in that
not boufid
down
by any
external laws.
It is not, like
like think-
Objects of perception
the resulting tan be directed as to Lessons to memoperceptions can be tested by questioning. rize may be given the student, and he can be examined to find
pupil
and he
down
for
him
to follow, cannot
be examined on the
of imagination puts
straint
The
free nature
re-
I02
2.
IMAGINATION.
Imagination
is
its
spring in
feeling
and
it is
it
desire rather
cesses.
itself
;
Its birthplace is in
what
is
and admiration.
Thus
greatly stimulated
feelings.
it
from without;
child's imagination
or guidance
3.
but by unconscious
child in
steps.
power of
feeling
and desiring;
it
underlying forces of
feeling.;,
human
taneity
and which, if forced into consciousness, lose their sponand value. Thus a child questioned about his imaginaoften conceal his real fancies entirely, or will pro-
tion, will
The
indirect.
(i)
Through
cultivation of
modes of expression
(2)
Through
cultivation
of the feelings that find their outlet in imagination, and (3) Through presentation of material scenes of nature, works of
art,
fine
literature
fitted
at
once
to
imagination.
I.
It
is
natural
for the
its
imagination to project
itself;
to
attempt to
embody
These
out-
ward modes of expression may be very largely guided and controlled without interfering unduly with the inward moods and Drawing, modelling, designing, dispositions whence they flow.
IMAGINATION.
even
plaiting, sticklaying
103
only means of training the impulses, the sense organs and the
functions of intelligence, but also the imagination.
neglected
The
may be
treated under
two heads.
(1)
is
higher forms.
one who
is
wholly interested in
and in their satisfaction, will not be able to get outside of himself, and hence will not be able either The emotions and the to produce or to notice external beauty. mood, which predispose to imagination, must be left largely to The the vital influence and personal sympathy of the teacher. enthusiasm and the devotion of the teacher for whatever is worthy of admiration, will go further than any set methods.
appetites
(2)
The imagination
them
It
attempts to clothe
to find
its
significant of ideals.
mind beyond
into
own
memory
what
is
general,
Imagination
mind beyond
to. religious
rent
Hence
its
kinship
the
most
influential
once the product of the imagination and means of forming it Religious emotions,
reverence,
and
I04
imagination;
else,
Imagina-
tion
unless these
it
will
be defective or unobjects,
upon outward
scenes and
emotions
imagination to work on
(
may be
classified as follows
lakes
Natural Scenes. Taking children into the wodds, to and mountains, calling their attention to sunsets, clouds and all the forms of animate and inanimate nature, are highly
1)
important.
The
are
with works of
beautiful,
art, etc.,
is
means
with
great
is
effect.
An
im-
is
beautiful*
own
needs.
one
in the direction of
They should be
taught almost as
means of widening and deepening the imagination, as of furnishing the mind with information.
much
as
(3) The Study of Literature.The products of the imagination of the race, as embodied in literature, are perhaps
For the most influential means of training the imagination. young children, that literature is the best which is the unconscious product of races and of peoples rather than of the conscious invention of individuals.
historic epics,
ts
Fairy
tales, folk-lore,
myths
and
and
healthy.
There
TRAINING OF THINKING.
individual that
10$
makes such
dren
whom
Shelley
or
Wordsworth
than
to
leave
untouched.
Upon
produced as
THlNKXtra.
The
nation
thinkmg.
It is
may be
that
of
may be by means whose specific end is the development reasoning power, or it may be by methods, which in themtoward the development of other powers,
Indirect Training.
Thinking,
since
it
is
not an
iso-
implied within
attention), the
Generalization.
it
Thinking
the
is,
as previously shown,
factor.
generalizing;
is
dealing with
universal
The
I06
general factor
is
TRAINING OF THINKINO.
implied or involved in the lower stages.
It is
one
When we perceive
we
now
before us
is
a book,
generalize or classify.
We
class possesses.
There
is
involved, there-
else.
This generalization
is
We
conclude, or
something
tain similarities
tion of book.
(2) Relation.
scious analysis
Thinking
is
and
conscious synthesis.
in thinking as induction
and as deduction
common
law to
some
particular
as a case
coming under
it.
Induction
as
some
particular
under
it,
as
when we
gravitation applies to
all
heavenly bodies,
must apply to
some newly discovered comet, although we have not dis covered Now, since all as matter of observation, that it does apply. knowledge requires the functions of discrimination and identification, and induction and deduction are only the higher de. velopments of these functions, all knowledge is, to some degree,
A preparation for reasoning.
TRAINING OF THlNKINa
(3)
centre
I07
Retention.
There
facts about some common and according to some common principle. Every one has had the experience of learning some branch of study, as algebra, without having comprehended all of it ; but a year or two later, upon returning to this subject, it appears clear and even simple. The facts seem to have fallen into their right In other words, relations, and to be just what they should be. the results of thinking have been obtained, and this without the This would not have occurred, conscious exercise of thought. indeed, had the algebraic knowledge lain inert in the mind, but the use of it, the employment of relations similar to those
groups
once appropriated,
afterwards used.
The
relations implied
explicit ;
into reason.
From
and
law
:
and organically
as-
involved in
this
The power of reasoning is a natural and necessary growth from the powers ofperception, memory and imagination, provided
*hese
is
principles.
2.
to the
Direct Training. Not all subjects, however, calbforth, same extent, the processes of generalizing and relating,
and the power of organic assimilation. Among the subjects which call them forth the most, and thus give the best training of thought, may be mentioned language and science.
There is a common educational precept that I. Language. needs careful interpretation, namely, " Teach things, not words."
Its only
proper meaning
is
not be taught, but that with the word, the meaning for which
io9
it
TRAINING OF THINKINa
So
seems to
as for
importance, for the sake of the knowledge qf things^ as well Proper trainits own account, the principle is erroneous.
is,
ing in words
in
and of
itself,
effective
me-
This
with regard
with regard to
bination of sentences.
(i)
class
Words.
Every
getieral ;
common noun
quality
is
is
general ;
it
names a
quality,
and not an
is
individual.
and
quality
upon which
'
classes
are constJucted.
being,
and
this
general
to be,'
to run,'
'
to study,'
When
a child learns
is
necessarily
When
the thing,
become more
definite,
because he has
now a means
He
all
(2) Sentences.
Grammar
is
is
Every
unit
structure
in
is
language
objectified
The
of
sructure
the sentence,
and
is
this
of thought, the
firmed,
judgment.
In a judgment a relation
af-
or an act of thought
stated.
sentence but
if
understood,
it
requires,
same
functions of analysis
however imperfectly, the action of the and synthesis that are involved in
judgaieot
TRAINING OF THINKING.
(3) Combination
cally, discourse.
I09
is
of
Sentences.
is
Reasoning
/j,
termed,
logi-
This
the consecutive
employment of
senof
tences
upon some
subject,
and
in substance, a process
reasoning.
none the
there
order,
upon
is,
logical principles.
There
is
is classification,
group-
end.
If a pupil really
in
reads, that
is, if
2. Science.
Scientific
knowledge
thought
is,
conscious and
refer-
ence of
fact to law,
and law to
fact.
description, classification^ If
explanation, reasoning
concerned.
is
it
if
he
really reproduces
means,
he
is
even the
If,
train-
on the one side, the scientific material is properly presented, and if, on the other side, the pupil really appropriates it, or makes it his
own, the education of the
attained.
ytic or inductive
or deductive.
no
CHAPTER
V.
We have completed our study of intellectual development, and turn now to the growth of Feeling. Since the same processes of attention and association underlie it, and since its development
is
intellec*;, it
may be
treated with
comparative brevity.
may
is
also
be mentioned
at the outset
must be
left
his
own knowledge
ently treated
The subject may be conveniunder the head of I., Conditions of Interest^ or oj Emotional Development; II., The Principles of Growth; III., The Resulting Forms.
I,
Conditions of Interest.
is
The
interest
is
excitation,
to
and implies, accordingly, stimulation and response If the activity is free and unimstimulus in some activity.
if
it
peded,
urable.
fects,
If the activity
decreases the
amount
of
energy that
feeling
may be put
activity,
Since
accompanies
of the
nature
and
this
discussed.
I.
Spontaneity.
It
is
As
that
activity.
aspects
and
in
its
itself.
It
has an
this is stimulated
by every
impression
made upon
it,
it.
Whatever
whatever increases
interests
by that very
Interest
is
Ill
of the
child.
all
The
child's
within and
own
activity called
he
is
to be interested in
any
subject
All materials of study, regarded 2. Strength of Activity. from the standpoint of the pupil, are a stimulus, a challenge to
his
own
powers.
The
stimulus
Too weak
do
it
that
is,
too easy
mind cannot respond to. Very slight mind ; each seems to call for activity,
loud enough to get an answer.
Slight,
and yet
does not
call
and
finally
exhaust
it.
Strength of
stimulus
is
power of response.
The
is
much
it,
of
is
of
Change of
activity,
it
Activity.
to,
stimulus which
the
wholly responded
ceases to be a stimulus,
interest.
and
calling forth
mind has no
the need
more
awakens no more
is
Hence
monotonous means
that
the
itself
a teacher detects signs of monotony, him to vary something. He must appeal to the mind from a new side, and, awakening new activity, call
is
it
When
is
time
for
the
new interest. Constant activity in one direction, also, if mind does not succeed in answering the challenge of the stimulus, produces mental fatigue, and thus lowering disposable
out
It is
if
the eye
gazes
for
to green,
It
the green
The
the
al-
This law
prevails in
it
education,
for
teacher should
avail himself of
;
by providing
like
and due
ternation of activities
first
an
one
of memory, then of
bodily
impulses,
gymnastics, etc,
Harmony of
Activities.
Activity
it
is
is
harmonious.
Harmony
is
made up of a
variety.
no unity interrupts and distracts the mind ; unity which has no variety within it is, as just seen, monotonous and dead. But the co-operation of various factors, having some common end and meaning, calls forth one activity, and yet an activity which manifests itself in a great many directions. Each activity supports and stimulates every other. Hence there, arises a permanent and ever-growing interest. There is no more practical problem in the school-room than how to attain the due adjustment of unity in variety. The subjects must be brought into relation with one another, and the various facts and principles of the same subject must be united, but yet the mind must not be kept dwelling too long upon bare
The best method, in general, of solving the problem and thus keeping interest awake and increasing, is to start from some centre and then develop facts, principles, subjects from
unity.
that.
The common
the various
Principles
is
of Emotional
Growth.The
de-
velopment of the
plex productSj
from their original form into comanalogous to the inlellectual development alinterests
It begins with immediate sensuous states, and advances by idealizing them into more universal, and at the
ready traced.
distinct forms.
What
II3
good very
largely of
cmo
we
need only
I.
call attention to
some of
their aspects,
Feeling
early
is
originally limited in
The
feelings spring
from the
in
their value
which
who
has them.
is
personal in the
terra.
But gradually
Transference.
This
widening
the
of
feeling
occurs
of
first,
through what
may be
called
transference
feeling.
associated with
The who
pleasure
his
food
is
and
to the
gives
the
The
interest
widened into
first
The pleasure which a child takes in mere and mental, becomes transferred to the obactivity
is
jects
exercised.
(^)
The widening
a child
becomes
him
The
and thereby widens his interest to the games generally follow the business of his parents. Almost all children play " keep house ** and " school." These plays simply witness to the fact that the child's feelings are being colored by his contact with others, and that he is desirous of making their wider life his.
horizon of others.
child's
114
(e)
Sympathy or Love.
The
life,
This
is
he
is
perforce inter-
them
to be interested
in.
This
is
not the
due more
largely to their
power to make
communicate
force.
2.
And
Deepening of Feeling.
Interests at
first
and
unstable.
Their development
;
making them
deep, instead
of superficial.
{a) Repetition.
repetition^
This
deepening
the
results
coming
under
general
law
it.
that
exercise
A feeling
;
con-
restrained
from expression
is is
starved
one always
allowed to give
itself
outward form,
deepened.
feeling
may be
that will
this
developed,
first,
evoke
it,
to act
upon
material
is
whenever present.
Thus,
the
sentiment for
beautiful objects are always at hand and when the sentiment is allowed and encouraged to re-act upon the stimulus. On the other hand, the disposition to anger dies out when persons and objects that
beauty
deepened when
it,
to stimulate
would excite
it,
are kept
child, or
when, although
Co-operation.
co-operation
Besides
of
the teacher
may
rely
upon
feelings.
Feelings
of
similar
kind
115
like
diffi-
On
generally
any
feeling
by acting upon
feeling
alone.
Another and
The
habit of anger
it
is
desired to displace.
easily corrected
by getting the
by negative
moods
intellife
way
to anger.
formation oidispositions^
There
is
character.
The
of feeling.
III.
be
acter)
I.
and of increasing
universality
and
Intellectual Feelings.
These
A
is
positive acquisition.
The
are
wonder and
Wonder
mind always has unknown. It is the feelbefore the mind calling upon
presented.
It is thus
lor action.
a peractive
It is
an
that
is,
it
and master what evo^^ wonder has been termed the " mother of science and p*^^^*^ophy.*
been said that while the customary
it
anj* is^. .Amiliar cease to exdr* a mark <* genius that it wonders at the familiar as well as at the novel. It should be one result of education
is
It has
keep
is,
in every experience,
something won*
derful,
Il6
-^
Curiosity.
This
is
When
mind takes
it
it
something
there
is
is
to
be otherwise,
an explanation
good
and a bad
sense.
desire of investigation,
it is
to discover
what the
desire of ininterest.
allies of
it
In
its
good
sense, curiosity
is
the teacher.
that
it
The
and disinterestedness of mind. Some minds seem shut to all new ideas and hard and rigid in structure, others are flexible and open to new ideas, and hence
pass into openness
may
As the two relations implied in Feelings of Acquisition. knowledge are identity and difference, there are two corresponding emotions which
apparently diverse,
faction
:
arise.
Every
identification
of ideas
a feeling
and light in These feelings together give a sense of self-command, of power and of intellectual freedom. It has been said that the great advantage of education is not so
tinction is
accompanied by a
feeling of clearness
much
the information
it
it
affords that
we
True education, in other words, gives a sense of control over ideas and objects, instead of a sense of being at The educated mind feels that it has the power their mercy. to deal with facts, to discover the relations of identity and difare not deceived.
ference
among them
The
is
allies
of the teacher.
It
shows
itself
II7
the
earliest stages.
The child who has learned to put make simple numerical combinations
rewards Kim for past and stimulates him to new activity. Studies which are too difficult or which are meaningless do not permit the pupil to master them, and thus deprive the teacher of this ally.
has gained a sense of capacity which
effort
n. Aesthetic Feelings.
some form of reality.
presentation,
and the ideal There is and there is representation, for embodied in the presentation is an ideal value or signifiIt differs from an object of scientific knowledge because cance. in the latter the presentation serves only as a symbol to suggest
some
sensible object,
the idea
is
so embodied
no
distinction can
be made between
them.
It requires activity
;
must be excluded from a recognition of beauty. The beautiful an object of perception^ not of con-
Factors of the Beatdiful Object. It is impossible to tell beforehand just what particular qualities an object which
awakens aesthetic feeling will possess, for the very reason that this object is an embodiment of imagination in perceptual form,
in
a symbol.
But
I.
Adaptation.
By adaptation
parts as expresses
is meant such inter-relation of some one meaning, or serves some one end.
There may be either external or internal adaptation. In eocternal adaptation, the arrangement of parts is such as to render
the object useful for something
outside purpose
;
beyond
itself.
It serves
is
an
sub-
ri8
servient to something
So, too, a
poem which
is
meant to convey some moral lesson, is adapted to this exIn internal adaptation no outside purpose is traneous end. In every living being, there is complete adaptation subserved.
of parts to one another
is
and
to the whole.
But
this
adaptation
with
its
being
itself; it is identical
own
structure;
it
serves
its
own
is
outside.
So
far as
;
adaptation
useful
it
when
it
is
internal,
however useful
may
beautiful.
There is another method of stating the same some one end is reached by the co-operation Where principle. members co-operate to bring about the the and members of richest end with the least waste and in the simplest way, there
Economy.
is
beauty.
Economy
It
is
sparseness.
that
nothing superfluous.
of action, always means that the result is reached with the slightest expenditure of means, with no perceptible effort;
while clumsiness, awkwardness, always shows that the result not easily and economical!) reached,
3.
is
Harmony.
This
signifies
many members
always
constituting a
unity.
regular form,
poem
or statue
or painting,
there
is
is
there
is
there
perspective, etc.
Freedom.
The very
some
of
adjustment or harmony
free or unconstrained.
;
serves Life
find
no is more
it is
inanimate
indeed,
it
when we
nature or
forms beautiful,
is
because we
II9
them a
life
;
of their own.
even the most irregular and apparently capricious piece of music is based upon mathematical and physical laws ; but the law is internal ; the beautiful object appears as living law, not as a lifeless object obeying some law
in the beautiful object
outside itself
On
account of
;
this
it is
which has
its
end
own
manifestation.
turn from the beautiful obthat aesthetic
feeling has a
it
certain universality
From
these characteristics
follows that
Tasting and (1) The lower senses do not have any important place in art. smelling may produce agreeable sensations, but not emotions of beauty. Such presentations have no universal value ; they are of worth only to the organism that has them, and only while it has them. They are sensuous and particular,
(2) Aesthetic feeling
object
must exclude
its
The beautiful
witness the
beauty.
thetic
who
object.
III.
Personal Feelings.
from the They may be
relations
These
of
may be
defined to be
such as arise
other.
classified as Social,
Social Feelings.
These
come under
self.
These are not necessarily although, of course, they may become so. But reis
a social feeling, as
much
no
because the
self
An
The
recog-
nition of "
me " and
for
"
mine
'*
and
"thine."
(a) Feelings
Self.
The root of
all
own
Love
oi
I20
others
feelings of
or what one
and humility
the desire
in the self
self-respect
all
sides of self
The
love of pro-
and thus
is
indirectly over
others.
The
love of power
and
influence
personality
the deeds
beyond the limits of the body, and to realize it and thoughts of others. In itself this desire
to
own being
its
is
may become
ments of humanity, or of
friendly or hosis
In both, there
an
identi-
fication,
with our
own ;
in
one
case,
own.
the
origin in
" catching."
or even
A person
if
is
if
Children
constantly manifesting such sympathy. Babies in their second year cry or " make believe " to cry when they see others
are
first
year there
is
a smile, that
reflex,
is
may
to
younger
pupils.
It is also the
121
school
treatment.
class
this
The
has
results
teacher
its
knows
that every
and
a child that has refused to study or learn when trained alone at home has " taken a start " as soon as he went to
school through
the influnce of his fellow
pupils
Many
upon him.
disciplined,
may be
and then
it
becomes
a help to the
teacher as to the
officer.
however,
Is
active
We
must
first,
it
indeed,
make
make
another's.
To
man
suffering
in
somewhat as he feels, but we must also realize that factually has those feelings, those sufferings, and the latter factor is practically much more important than the former.
ourselves
Many
who
are
most
sensitive in reproducing
The fact that we have taken out from sympathy with sorrows should not mislead
sympathy
is
the student
it is
Moral Feelings.
be-
They
are, psychologically,
an outgrowth of social
feelings, particularly of
sympathy.
They
and of
approval or disapproval.
take
up
first
the contents
Contents of
Moral
Feelifig.
The
feeling of rightness
the
122
a personal
fore,
because
it
mind and
felt
of
acts to personality.
An
act
felt
to be right
is
also
to be
obligatory.
ideally
Thus the
be.
feeling
that
is
one may
Something
one
is
make
it
real,
and
hence
acts contributing to
its
A right
is
the act
is
and
ideal
upon
perceiving the
harmony of
real
and
ideal in
an
object.
it
As already
said,
grows out
interest in
Sympathy
is
;
it is
unity
of interest, the realization that a group of persons has a common relation to a common good, and that this good is, therefore, to
be shared by
all.
It thus
becomes
is
love,
feels
actively interested in
is
making
good.
way, begin-
is
a physical basis, arises an ethical sympathy. the source of moral groups or communities.
Love becomes
The
family, for
example, while
dren, has a
made up
common
common
interest
and
to
purpose.
moral community
in
one
in
which there
is felt
be some
common
it
end, or good,
need of realizing
felt
the
and
23
It is
both historically and philosophically, the preparation for tht community and the state.
ethical basis
and function
of
its
The
its
school
is
good
of
each of
members ;
It
it
and order imposed from members for membership in a larger community, where each takes charge of his own development or training, and where he comes in contact with external
end by
definite training, authority
without
prepares each of
its
power.
The
the family^ must train with reference to free citizenship in the state. This is the principle which underlies, ethically, the disciplinary
Training of Moral Feeling. A few specific principles may be mentioned, (i) It is generally useless to give abstract
and didactic moral teaching.
It
life,
is
It is
it
what
it
is
that
is
right.
may be made
the
own
ed
to,
His interest in business, in politics, may be appealand thus he may be interested in the rights and duties
of such relations.
that
spring out
instruction
However
it
may be
punishment
in the school
is
124
own moral
nature.
aim
is
the development
and capacity, through the formation of habits, for self-control and self-government.
and application of this principle would
The
thorougli recognition
for
do more
The
vital
our schools than any one can easily imagine. (3) motives as interest, sympathy and love, are much more
conduct than
It
fear,
worst of
best of
men probably know as much of what men can do. The practical problem is,
right as the
therefore, the
relied
cultivation of feelings
upon
3.
Religious Feeling.
As
is
con-
The
feeling of a synthesis or
of
factor con-
and unconsciously,
this,
in
religious senti-
ment.
And
this factor is
supplied originally, at
controlling
imagination.
Fused with
and content, should be factors supplied by moral motives. As the result of this fusion there come feelings of dependThe feeling of depefidcnce, of peace, and of trust or faith. ence has as its intellectual element, the feeling that we are only a part of a whole, much wider, more powerful than ourselves. As its moral element, it contains the feeling that the source of all good, in ourselves and in the world, is a Being upon whom we are dependent for power to think and attain
the
good.
The
feeling of peace,
as the
factor
supplied by
to,
the
feel-
is
The
who
perfect Goodness.
I25
Through the intellectual feeling of our oneness we feel that we can trust it, that we are borne
is
that the
Being who
is
is
perfect
Goodness
is
which we should
made known to the senses, but is to be apprehended by faith. No specific methods of cultivating religious emotions can be laid down
here.
As a general
keep
in
mind
that a vague
work
is
But to a certain degree this feeling of unity, and desire for it, and so far the teacher can assume It as a basis. His then to give this feeling a moral and personal turn and filling.
Note.
pp. 326-346.
CHAPTER VL
FORMS OF VOLITIONAL DEVELOPMENT.
As already
will is
stated, in
impulse.
and association working upon it There are no new functions, no new laws to be met with in the subject of will. Analysis and synthesis play as great part here as they do in the intellect ; development is here, as there, from the immediate, the particular and the indefinite From the fact, howto the ideal, the general and the definite.
cesses of attention
activities,
no new
impulses,
material, the
certain
new
Contrast of Impulsive and Volitional Action. The characteristics of an act of will may be seen by comparing
it
Action
originating
in
impulse
is
126
blind ;
that
its
way
it
it
clear to
any end.
li
occurs
this
its
from a tendency
to act, but
is
bird builds
knowing the purpose to be reached ; a child when hurt strikes wildly about him without having any end in view. When we say that such and such a person acts from the impulse of the moment, we mean that that person is inclined to act out any impulse that occurs to him without looking beyond the moment in which the impulse takes
impulse, without
him.
action
Its
is
end
is
Impulsive
Uncontrolled.
tion
is
Another
When we
distinction
is
uncontrolled.
a creature of
impulse,
that
it
we mean
apparently unregulated;
Action
is
unconan
In
trolled
its
when
the impulse
is
is
impulse
is
controlled
will
own
value,
and
motive for action. Every imnone is suppressed, none is checked, none is guided towards any end. Every impulse expresses itself, and But if the impulses are directed towards an end all only itself.
this intrinsic value is sufficient
pulse
is
followed,
this is
changed.
far as it
is
not valuable in
If
it
itself,
but
only so
suppressed
if it
may
it is
it
whose law
In other words,
controlled.
what makes the difference between impulsive and volitional Impulse is blind, because it action is the conception of an end.
la)
has no purpose, no end in view ; it is uncontrolled for the same reason. Volitional action has an end in view, and this end controls and subordinates all the steps of the activity. ^ ***/*" ^'^^ rnfifrnJIpA and harmnni7.f>d hy the concfption JMjjjnn
^'
In studying will, we have to study the development qf an end. of the idea of an endy and the ways in which the idea becomes
actual.
niustration.
place, there
Take
building of a house.
This
In the
first
must be an idea of
or the
architect
the
more
be the work.
idea
clearer and the more definite, more orderly and eflftcient will stage, the end is only an idea. The
The
must be changed
into
an actuality ;
is
it
must be
realized.
The execution of a
take
purpose,
We
shall (i)
is
up
the
way
in
Beginning of Idea of End. While an impulsive action A does not aim at an end, it none the less reaches an end. child grasps after a bright-colored ball, not because he has any
purpose, but because an impulse has been aroused by the excitation of the retina of his eye
;
but
if
of the
ball,
of
its
feeling,
and
especially of
what can
be done
it,
with
itf is
formed.
The
can
bound
it,
etc
action that he
The
01
redintegrates
accordingly
performed.
IiL.iStrations Continued. No one can watch a baby of the age of from one to two years and not be convinced that, to the child's mind, the qualities of an object are mostly made up of what he can do with the object
.
hai
is
a whip something to
128
Strike
etc.
with ; a drawer is something to be drawn out and pushed back, etc.j His own actions about or with the object constitutes his ideas of the object ; his knowledge exists in terms of his actions with reference to the
thing.
The
rather
is
to
him
of
an object passes
naturally, or
transition to
ex-
The
action
The
the connecting
is
link
It
volition,
however, because the action does not occur for the sake
many
do with an
object,
and
that
some
when he
comes to distinguish between the do with it. Thus the idea of what he can do becomes a distinct idea to him, and so an end in itself. He learns that a whip is not something to strike with always and under all circumstances ; and he learns also that the act of
independent of his actions, he
striking
is
This
act, dis-
therefore,
tinct
becomes a
;
end
it
Suramaiy. At first, as Professor James very truly says, we do not know what we are going to do until after we have
done
is
it
;
is
it
has executed
But the act once done the idea of the act ever afterwards associated with the impulse, and hence there
to that impulse for the future.
if
is
an end supplied
Thus
the im-
pulses gradually
and normally,
we now come.
TRAINING OF IMPULSES.
If
Training of Impulses.
The development of the impulses depends upon the developThere can be no volitional activity until there is an idea of an end. The child cannot do until he knows.
1.
To
we might
as well ask a
man
Choctaw equivalent of some English word, as to ask him to perform some action corresponding to which he has no equivalent in the way of a mental notion. If, for example, a child is to pronounce the word cat,' or is to write the word, he iCiMs\. first have a mental image and th^n express it
to give the
*
2.
the intellect.
Every development of the impulses results in a training of While the foregoing principle is true, it is also
is
The
d, for
made
it.
At
first
own
activities
he has the
truly
and now for the first time he recognizes or knows the sound in the future, as well as
thrill
of identification,
know how
First,
to
make
it.
And
this
the
end and
end ; then
of an
idea, in a more and complete way, and the idea is further enriched. This, in turn, supplies a still more definite end to impulse, and so on indefinitely. Thus the development of intellect and
manifests
definite
itself,
of impulse
3.
is
reciprocal.
processes,
be trained by the
same
We
are
now
able to
130
do by knowing."
The
principles
when
rightlj
Unless
we cannot understand the ideas involved in action^ much And unless we know^ we cannot act in a significant way, in a way which is really expressive of ideas. Apply
we
do^
less
act
this to the
teaching of arithmetic.
A child
will
never under*
until
he has embodied
it
it
in arithmetical operations
he
will
until
upon
it,
thoroughly master of
will
But, on the
for the sake of forming a blind habit of " doing sums," but in order to
principle.
He
is,
do sums," not
and
to
he
is
and the
principles, not
power
upon them,
There
is
a similar
in
relation
grammar.
action of which, indeed they are only the abstract statement The child must " do," must speak and write in order to know
the laws.
is
brought
rational basis.
Language
to
him
will
be a mere meaningless
tool.
4.
Such a reciprocal training of the Impulses and the Intellect There is no need of saying that
not
to
merely
being applied
money>making.
or capable of
it
mean
is
that
be capable of
direct application to
still
upon
the spot,
TRAINING OF IMPULSES.
into action.
I3I
But no education
ability
is
practical
;
in
will
in giving
knowledge, give
to act.
No
is
not
of
term
practical.
A course
intellect,
fit
one
defective,
is
regarded
for
knowledge
sonal,
remains imper-
yet
activities of its possessor, and it is on the moral side, for he who is not trained to rational activity has no preparation for a moral life. We have now seen what is the goal of the training of the impulses such a development of them as subordinates them to ideas, while ideas are, at the same time, employed to control We may now briefly discuss the means at the comimpulses.
more
mand
5.
and
The
School
life
is
a develop-
new and arThis is a common-place, and yet it may be tificial ones. doubted whether any pedagogical precept is more frequently The artificial atmosviolated, or with more harmful results. phere of some schools, the dislike of pupils for their studies (and perhaps lor their teachers), the stupidity of some children,
ment of the instinctive
activities,
not a creation of
and the
up
study has
Pleasure in Training.
impulses,
it
Since education
is
mass of pupils do
There
hereditary,
f3
home and
activity
;
do not seem
to
re-
garding the
6.
**
great
mass" remains
This again
the impulses.
tends to subordinate
itself in
the future to
The
principle.
He
employs
it
in a systematic
way
by overseeing the end tow^ards which the impulses work, and by taking care that they work regularly toward these ends.
The
defec-
because there
highest
is
reaches
its
and fullest
it
and
secondly,
because there
is
Surtendency to work towards the end shall become a law. rounding influences preclude the impulse manifesting itself to
and they preclude anything more than a activity of it. The teacher supplies ends which call out the fullest manifestation of the impulses, and he supplies regular and constant means for working towards these ends. This may almost be said to exhaust the work of the teacher.
its
highest capacities,
fitful
and intermittent
7.
ments.
is left
to the
na.tura.\ force
of the impulses
is
and
child in school
and
The
is
child
is
to take
and
to
in school
he
to be present at a
certain hour
TRAINING OF IMPULSES.
Order
is
I33
Punctuality as to time-re-
lations,
and
regularity as to
place-relations are
demanded
of
the pupil.
All that
and
includes,
is
of the pupil
it is
8. A portion of the discipline is internal. external means accompany and render efficient instruction in certain subjects. There is a regular recurrence of studies; a fixed
^The
The
nishes the ends best fitted to guide the impulses into complete ac-
he gives them orderly and regular exercise. To go into upon the ways in which these studies afford discipline, would be to repeat all that has been said upon the training of association, attention and the various faculties, and to anticipate all that will be said in the next part upon educational
tivity, and
details
praxis.
9. Discipline accomplishes its
purposes when
it results
control.
The
in Selfis
training, to
to
which
The training is to result in a law inherent and when this is done there is self-control,
It
^2X\%, freedom.
is
must be repeated
not
for
When
disci-
had
this result,
The impulses have again, and in a true and lasting sense, become a law unto themselves because they have embodied disci^
134
pline,
pulse
law within themselves. The person acts both from imand from principle. This ideal may never be reached, but it is none the less the teacher*s function and duty to aim
at its realization.
Idea and Desire. Aristotle sa3rs that volition, or the power of originating action, constitutes a man, and that volition may be termed either reason that desires or desire that reasons.
feeling of
As impulse is blind action, so it is blind desire. want or lack, but it does not know what
want thus aims blindly
impulse
;
It
is
includes
wanting
Desire
the
at
its
own
satisfaction.
is
its
intelligent
it is
own
Thus
volition
is
desire
itself.
But, on the
The
idea
move
to action if the
mind
is
satisfied with
present condition.
stir
before there
idea.
is
any tendency
/olition
is
for
it
to
Thus
and impersonal, and become emotional and interested So far we have studied only the rational side, the idea ; we must now take up the emotional side, the desire.
abstract
Origin of Desires.
In
there
is
contained a tendency
to satisfy
As
is
manifested,
extent.
some end
is
reached which
want to some
The
The
child
who
that
it
satisfies his
it is
play-
ing with
ball
and
The
idea,
pleasurable
in comparison with
The
TRAINING OF DESIRE.
I35
ball than
is
do what he
;
is
doing.
pleais
this
tension
there
:
is
end
is
is
found satisfactory
there
opposed to the
idea.
TAis
of an idea felt
to be satisfactory^
is
desired
is
not
tiie
thing
or
the
nor
yet
the
pleasure afforded
of the self.
is
satisfied
satisfaction.
What is wanted is the satisfaction by them. The thing is desued only because through it the self pleasure is wanted only so far as it testifies to Pain is an object ot desire when it is considered
The
desires are developed,
self is developed.
which the
When
the self
and many
interests,
are
correspondingly
its
complex.
When
city
of a
is
SE^
a desire
awakened.
\Xl jsj-j
an
t/'^
^'"^
-2t|
made
and quick
is
intellectually,
is
well-
of the
will.
We
notice then
trained through a
is
desired.
The development
development of and desire is so
;
of interests
will
is,
as of intellect.
The connection of
love
are identified
and
there
is
this
Sympathy
is
a powerful coadjutor
136
in training desire.
The
awaken
it
in another.
As soon
it
too,*'
even though
it
was previously
to in order
eflfective-
Rivalry
desire,
to
awaken
more
reflect-
ing his
own
and controlling
school.
a.
on
shows
itself in
the
pulsetent.
Impulses
Desires are trained by satisfying or failing to satisfy imthat are always thwarted die out to
is
to recur in the
On
The
practical
to search out
some impulse which has never been allowed to express itself. This done, definite desire is produced, and the boy is quickened into the exertion of his own powers to gain satisfaction in the
future
;
fruits
of gratification, he never
falls
There is a moral as well as an intellectual application of this same principle. A selfish child should be made to feel the gratification of satisfying what generous impulses he does possess \ an untruthful child, the satisfaction of stating things as they are, etc. While moral action is not constituted
back into
gratification,
it
is
often
none
its
by experiencing
is
gratification
from moral
own
3.
sake.
Desire
is
at-
tainments
for
and
There
is
desire
satis-
To
TRAINING OF DESIRE.
actual state has, therefore, the
to increase the satisfaction
137
same
result in
awakening desire as
Though a
child can-
not be
made
may
selfish-
not yet
made
actual.
if,
Once make a
Hardly anything
do
it
will
be awakened.
own
capacities
person to
whom
It
before him.
a new possibility is open, has a new world may be questioned if the transforming influence
is
gives in
new and
Real belief
efficient
in the possibility it
of an achievement
is
4.
Desire
widens
because
it
creates
new conceptions
desires
is
for
honor, fame
for, to
it
or
wealth, etc.
allow the
mind
to dwell
to endear
it
to the mind.
and wish, in some degree to make it real. If imagination habitually dwells upon some idea, this idea is apt to become the controlling desire of the mind. An artist imagines beautiful forms and
as real,
When we
is
realities
By
mind
is
is
actions
stirred to corres-
activity.
The
more
he
l$S
may have
most of
one/'
II.
beauty in
the
this insures al
itself that
the "outward
at
step in volition
its
accompanying
We
in
have
now
it
the
want way
which
is
an actual
fact.
changed from an idea into a presentation, into If there is but one desired end, the manner
illustrated as follows
:
of realization
may be
The
child forms
that of reaching out the arm and and thus the end is reached. In other words, the idea of the end suggests, by association, the means necessary for reaching the end. In more complex ends, attention is active, rather than association, and first analyzes the end into the means or steps which lead up to it, and then combines them In either case, there is no factor so as to reach the end.
contiguous
association,
;
Conflict of
case
is
Ends and of
There
is
Desires.
not so simple.
own
The
child
who wishes
may have been told not to play with it, and he desires to obey this command. One cannot have his cake and eat it too. In case of
ball
may
conflict
it
is
decided, and
end of
action.
The
may be stated
as
deliberation, effort
Dliberation.
checking, or,
out of action.
The
I39
or
degree
in
He
upon
all
The
it
process in a child
is
and con,
arrests
regarding an action.
attention, and, the
But the
conflict
between desires
the conflict,
various
Effort
In
is
some
He
wishes to play
is
desired
and what
desirable
do not
is
coincide.
desirable, different
from what
to
is
no
if
conflict.
He
is
continues
do
as
he
wishes to do.
(that
is
is,
Or,
the act
if
satisfaction
go together) there
But
in
no
conflict
many
action, while
Here
effort is required.
;
it
re-
True effort consists in reinforcing by additional ideas, desires and motives^ the side felt to be the weaker. It may be true that action follows the strongest desire, but it is also true that we have the power to call up considerations and feelings that strengthen and that weaken the force of a desire. The idea of
obligation
itself, if it
ideas,
gradually
and action
140
Choice
effort, is
FORMATION OF CHARACTER.
The
choice.
end of
Choice
conflict, following
deliberation
and
may be
certain
end of
action
and
self.
the identification
the
act
strength of the
of self with it. In one desire, and gives that all While desire manifests a possible
aflftrms
or state of
real,
self,
choice
that this
possibility shall
be made
and
be
realized.
By
to
or desires corresponding
character
or character of a
man
is
he continually tends to
tion.
tions.
shown by what he can do, plus what do. Character is formed by retenresiduum or
result of all past ac-
It is
the organized
the These are acted upon ; some are encouraged end of some is consciously adopted as motive to action. Each activity leaves behind an effect which renders it easier to act in that way again. The accumulation of such In the same way effects creates a tendency to act in that way. something is retained from each desire, and this leads desire m
pulses.
the
same paths
the future.
Character
is
dency and
Choice
tion.
desire.
and Apperception.
it is
Choice
Indeed,
and assimilation of some course of action. In knowledge, appert:eiving is bringing the mind to bear through itJi organized centres of experience, upon presented sensations. In will, it is bringing to bear the organized centres of ability and
selection
desire
is
The
result in
both cases
results
of past experience.
a reciprocal one.
Character
the
is
organized de-
choices.
Choice
is
expression of character
141
in
manifested
Every choice enters into the building up of an organ of choice and thus decides future decisions.
Control.
trolled
when
Every
of
When an
is
in so far controlled,
and
it
is
controlled in the
totality
highest degree
when
a
it is
of such groups
tact only with
with
character.
desire
may come
in con-
superficial
desires
tendencies
and and
Here the conflict is prolonged, for each of these groups must be allowed due consideration; effort is severe, for the conflicting claims of these groups must be reconciled, and choice is important, influencing the entire
future of the
self,
for
it
it
affects
is.
make the
self
what
no such thing as
groups 0/ fixed tendencies, ideas and desires, it must be remembered that however unimportant any one choice may be (since
affecting only
one
centre), yet
is
it is
each centre
built
But
further points.
I.
Character
is is
built
up through
successive acts.
From each
sum and
act something
in controlling
future activity.
Character
is
the
14a
activities.
FORMATION OF CHARACTER.
It is
significant
that our
words
"ethical**
and
" moral
habits.
'*
good nor
Day by
Then
as his
is
right.
The
that
acts are
is,
now
right,
they have a right motive and purpose, as well as conhabits is largely under
is
The formation of
thus self-control
the control of
others:
once
is
it
his
Character
in his
hands to aid
in-
when
it is
and
cer-
so great that
its
stands in
no need of exaggeration.
ture has
its
Nature contributes
"
part
also.
The
virtues," says
Aristotle,
" come
against
nature,
them and
Self control
is
While the
highly susit
is
should
is
I43
only by
seen,
is
The
habit
repeated
personal
decisions.
we have
desire.
No
self,
there-
can choose.
One can do much for another, but he canThe teacher may and should supply all
;
of
choice
therefore,
no opportunity
fact that
for decision
given,
if
the edu-
cator does everything for the child, as soon as this external prop
is
removed the
reveals itself in
streets
no habit of choice has been formed weak and in wrong action. The child of the
favoured
Self control
is
and
have already seen that impulses work towards an end, and that this end once reached
strengthening regard for
We
;
Law
many
But
in
intelligence
he frames the
ideas of larger
inclusive laws.
and more comprehensive ends, and thus of more Finally he rises to the generalization of law
There
is
of law in general, not merely a particular law for each particular impulse.
set
conformity to law
by which
that
measured
and
it
if
correspondingly
developed,
is
felt
their standard.
The conception
for
is
felt
that there
is
some law
The
144
5.
FORMATION OF CHARACTER.
Self-control is trained through the conception
self,
perfect
of an
ideal or
child in intelligence
is
and
in
It
enlarged.
and
actions, but
an
ideal
There
self;
it
is
nothing mystical
and above actual attainments, the idea of capacities or possibilities not yet realized. Desires are measured not merely by
their reference to the actual state of character as the organized
result of past experiences, but by their reference to the deve lopment of possibilities of character in the future. Desires in line
with
in
the
development of
these
possibilities,
however
much
a completed character
a character with
is
capacities realized.
When
such an ideal
made
and by reference
ments.
Such
self-control is freedom.
Kinds of Control.
be rendered more
The
foregoing considerations
may
specific
soemwhat
moral.
arbitrarily,
first
be
classified as physical^
In the
enabled to use
body
as
an instrument
in executing
any
volition, walking,
able to control his speech, his actions, and even his thoughts
and feelings with reference to his own welfare. And finally, he must be able to control himself, with regard to what is demanded of him by the obligations of morality first as they are embodied in the requirements of others, and afterwards as he recognizes his own obligations to his own and *o others* personality.
I45
Physical Control.
its
This
is
by
it.
own sake, and for the discipline The necessity of a child's being able
to
But
it
and his muscles is so evident as not to need must also be remembered that in learning
is
to control
them he
he
exercising kind.
all
He
pulses to law
is
he
is
cm-
It is thus
is
obvious that
a very importtrain-
all
put
to.
when
necessary, to prepare
and
and
is
he forms habits of
self-control,
which,
when subordinated
There
therefore, a decided
moral as well as
intellectual side to
the training of the eye, the ear, the tongue and the hand.
" Kin-
dergarten " and " manual " training are tributary to specifically
ethical culture.
It is said that in a certain reformatory, part of
the prisoners were subject to definite physical training, gymnastic exercises, etc.,
and
and
in personal appearance,
this is
And
No new
control.
upon
in
the impulses
and
instincts
In particular,
place, all iminstincts,
In the
first
An
in-
fant has very early the impulse to walk, but the impulse instead
146
of being distinct
itself
FORMATION OF CHARACTER.
and confined
the muscles.
through
all
So, a child
his
when
learning to
write
moves
his
tongue.
Learning
perform some
physical
and
of the impulse.
And
in the
second place,
it
consists in the
To
walk
is
to
series or succession of
distinct
muscular impulses.
series of ideas.
That
control
sounds which he
to
make
and
if
mean
Similar complex
combinations are involved in writing, playing musical instruments, reading aloud, etc
Results of Control.
becomes more exte?ided
i.
The
idea
and more
is is
definite.
Not only
of what can
is
be done
the act
more definite, for, as we have when an end has been reached A baby has no definite idea that we know what the end is. either of what a word sounds like or how to speak it, until he And the idea becomes more has succeeded in pronouncing it. extensive '^wsX in proportion as the act combines more impulses. An infant lives in the present because his actions do not extend their significance beyond the present. Compare with an Here all actions have infant a youth who is learning a trade.
more
definite,
previously noticed,
only
at,
and comprehensiveness.
Abilities
and tetidencies are created. We come again upon Movements become organized into the
147
effect that
is
since easier,
tends to
more energy ; being become powcf acts have Isolated repeated, habit is formed. to act. That which has been acquired by hard labor becomes spontaneous function, becomes play. These abilities become
be repeated
in preference to acts requiring tendencies
\
that
is,
acts according
to
them unconsciously or
effort,
and unless he
exercises
he
falls
to control him.
He
he has created.
3. The amount of stimulus and effort required is This follows from the two principles already stated.
lessened.'-^
When,
it
in
is
is
most of
it is
wasted.
When
it
is
confined to the
required.
In an
an excitement of the
whole organism.
organism
affections
There are chance and random movements, to an end occur only when the whole
stirred
by a demand
for
food.
of a single sense
Then
strong
^as
a bright
light,
or a loud
stimulus to repeat
the
sound.
Then a
the
child
suggestion or in-
junction from
told to do.
another suffices;
does what he
in
is
Then, at
is
last,
an
/^ifa originating
his
own
con-
sciousness
sufficient
stimulus
to
action.
Thus
there are
And, of
effort is
amount of necessary
it
may
act
II. Prudential Control. As soon as physical control b made a means to something beyond itself, the stage of pruden-
148
tial
FORMATION OF CHARACTER.
control
is
reached.
When
the
thus begins at
a very early
action
for
the sake
moral end.
already
some recognized
character.
Accordingly we turn
in the formation
1.
at
once to the
and development of
deliberate.
it
Action
is
more
Since
some
recognized satisfaction,
is
The
child cannot
upon them to see which will reach the most useful end, and what steps he must take to reach the end he decides upon. In this way character becomes
must
reflect
thoughtful ox
2.
reflective.
The
in a
day
it is
or even in a year.
remote satisfaction
is
desired,
evident that
all
acts
realiza-
end.
must be controlled with reference to the one For example, consider a person studying a profession
or learning a trade.
very inclusive
it
may
be health, or wealth, or
or author.
indefinite
a teacher
number of minor acts of restraint, Thus character gains unity and continuity,
3.
Action
is
While only a
"esolute
or determined person
likely to
be persevering, the
I49
definitely
and
he knows what he
wants and
settled
Having
upon
he
is
now
persevering in attempting to
reach
it.
persevering person
it
is
end because
is
Resolution
permanent
stability.
As
prudential
control
creased power.
not mea-
A person who
appears
very intense
is
often, like
is
Physical energy
tional
defined as power to
is
energy or intensity,
for
measured by
capacity
doing,
not
A
in
teacher
ac-
mere
going through
is
a set of motions
or performances
the
value
in
what the
effective.
accomplishes.
Energy
renders character
said,
it
If
liberation
making
and
energy using
III.
all
appropriate
means
for realising
it.
Moral Control-
There are no new processes involved in moral control It differs from physical and prudential control only in the end to which the volitional processes are subject. It aims at controlling the impulses
acter,
and the desires by the law of good charand not by the law of physical action or of personal
welfare.
150
Relation
to
FORMATION OF CHARACTER.
physical
It is
of great im-
portance to the teacher to realize that moral control considered simply upon the side of volitional factors that enter into
it,
namely, desire,
the
same
as physical
dif-
and prudential
fers.
control,
and
end or motive
This
fact gives
two principles
1.
Every
act
of
will^
may
It
be
Moral
Character.
faculties,
is
was
that their
memory,
is
for example,
trained
moral training
that such
is
and
and pupil
the case.
sitting quietly
when
neces-
satis-
same
moral conduct
requires,
and
tion of habits.
If the teacher's
if
methods and
an ethical
his
own purpose
spirit
animates him,
development of character
directly
moral in
themselves,
when
mbordinated
to right motives,
become moral.
In
other words, in
some new
tinct
processes, to
all
from
employed
Moral
right
and
make
motive of
his actions.
The
teacher
who
MORAL CONTROL.
methods to give the and of his mental activities, and who. at the same time, by example, by sympathy, by correction, by awakening admiration of good characters and good acts, and, if
is
making use of
all
possible
necessary,
by
is
direct precept,
is
love of
the right,
character.
doing
all
that
Relation of motive
to
moral
action.
A
}
few examples
will
make
and
moral action.
acts,
Both lying
truth-telling,
considered as external
and considered
They
differ in the
The
The
was performed.
it
moral,
originates.
Motive and
Resp07isibility,
This
is
the reason
why persons
hold themselves, and are held byothers, responsible or accountable for moral action,
sult is often,
and not
The
re-
the motive
never.
For example, a man wishes to become rich. His depending upon his own industry,
depends also upon forces of nature and
so-
ciety
These
forces
may
defeat his
result,
best plans,
and
a
thus, considered
Yet he does not blame himself for the his act is But failure, so far as it depends solely upon outside agencies. when one is untruthful, one recognizes that the failure lies not His choice or motive was with outside forces, but in himself.
failure.
own
act,
he holds himself
l$9
It is also
In
and physical
character.
make
character.
But a man's
will is
When,
in
therefore, a
man
in so far g'^od.
The The
this set or
bent
Character and the Sense of Obligation. We have seen before and choice is reciprocal. This
in
is,
holds
makeSf
moral action.
upright
A
;
constant choice
of
the
right
character
and
this,
in turn leads
to a
We
cannot overestimate
;
heartening yet
is
the sense of obligation, and thus lessen the force of good motives.
that
is,
not
that
bad
seems to have
no idea of obligation of duty. The well-spring of moral is dried-up, and good deeds come, if they come at all, only by impulse or by accident. The Growth of Idea of Obligation. To a child the sense
action
of
obligation
can come
particu-
lar acts.
first
right or wrong.
That
is,
And
restraint
is
forbidden to do
The
impulse
is
met by a
restraining power,
and
in the conflict of
MORAL CONTROL.
child gets his
first
153
positive in-
moral experiences.
Then come
do certain things which his impulses, if left to themselves, would not do. Gradually the experience is generalized. There comes the idea of law^ of something always obligatory
junctions to
it
both by arresting
and by guiding
it.
the obligation
But there are other forces which act along with the force of obligation, and which re-act upon it to
motive or moving power.
strengthen
it.
There
is,
first,
mentioned.
done tends
called in
to be repeated,
independent of
rightness.
may be
by the educator;
moral motives,
the desire for reward, to escape punishment, for future gratification, for the approval of others, etc., while not
may be
judiciously
as forces co-oper-
especially
with younger
And,
motives which,
slight
development.
These are
es-
sympathy and
in the
love.
Such
him
first
the
wider relations
of
society.
This
identification
makes
these claims, the rights of others, are not mere abstract obligations,
he
is
own interests. He is interested in them as own wants and desires. This identification also
;
what-
whom
154
nizes,
he ought to recognize.
And
finally
wrong conduct, selfishness, namely. It takes the beyond his own personal gratification and widens his
Only that can
satisfy
him which
satisfies
This
feeling, if
finally
cause
the
person
to recognize, practically if
identity of interests
sons,
and purpose with those of all other perand must change the bare feeling of obligation into a
i.
Generic or
first,
Immanent
It creates
child
who
have to exercise specific choice in each case; but has a general governing intention or purpose which controls all cases. It implies,
no immediate cause
for action.
A temperate
is
not
;
satisis,
some
appetite.
The
choice
is
immanent
in
him
that
fixed
An
also,
in intuitive
recognition
of what
is
right
and wrong.
its
An immature
what
is
decision at once.
The formation of desires is, if we 3, Regulation of Desires, omit moral considerations, as natural as the origin of impulses
the desires are the direct result of the psychical constitution.
I55
is
seen that
obli-
may be
what
be per-
what acts
shall
formed.
the person.
4.
Effective Execution.
An immature
is
may choose
There
realization.
temptations.
character may desire to do and yet be overcome by opposing not enough force back of the choice to
guarantee
its
person
and
acts,
leads
which he has,
CHAPTER VIL
MIND AND BODY.
The mind must be developed as completely as possible. The mind must also be able to use its developed powers in an effective way, so as to
accomplish as
much
To
well-trained.
The
for the mens sana, and that he may be able to infer something as to methods to be employed in bringing about the ideal relation between them.
soul of a
human
fact
not pure
spirit,
This one
makes
156
It is
which make up body connects the soul with material universe in two ways on the one hand, it makes the soul a recipient of the influences coming from it ; on the other hand, it makes the soul an a^ent, a power capable of affecting or influencing nature. All that comes to the soul from without, comes through the body ; all that the soul can
with
this
and
also
minute
whole universe.
And
the
it
In more
all
to the
sense-
organs ;
system ;
all activity
of will
is
memory
accompanied by activities in the brain and nervous system. The body is, therefore, not only an instrument of mind, but its processes enter, as an integral factor^ into mental processes and results. If a sense-organ is defective or is
and thinking
diseased, the corresponding sensation
if
is
absent or abnormal
is
entirely wanting,
it is
evidently cut
off ; if
distorted, resulting
knowledge
is
abnormal.
Indeed,
it.
demons, or as the voice of one commanding him to do some This hallucination, in turn, becomes an " apperceiving deed.
organ,'* that
it
;
it
is, other perceptions and ideas are assimilated to becomes a centre about which many ideas gather and are
correspondingly distorted.
On
if
the sense-
organ
is
to the will.
The same may be said of the relation The muscular system is not
of carrying out the decisions of the soul, but 'its culture or non-
I57
will.
development of the
Un-
mean
of soul
and
choice.
its
The dependence
The
and
nutrition of
the
body
will reflect
in the staie of the brain. Hence, the culture of the whole body is as necessary as that of any special organ. The health of the body as a whole seems to be intimately connected with the emotional condition. The organic or common sensations com-
of the body,
form,
it
is
probable,
the
every
of the organism
is
reflected in a
air,
Fresh
exercise,
to the emotions, as
much
as of physical
Brain. Less is known, of course, of the direct mind and brain than of the direct relations of mind and sense-organs, and muscular system. But there is good reason
relations of
Mind and
to
is
accompanied with
it
an alteration
Lesions
accompanied
is
The
of
the
in the
mental
body and of the nerve-centres, manifests themselves Mental over-work, lack of change, or states.
On the other hand, statistics show that and thorough mental activity is conducive to good health and long life, through the correct habit that it
well-balanced
158
Man.
The
details of this
it
may be
well
some leading
or
facts.
is
which
masses
bundles,
so
as
nerve-centres^
and
aggregated
into
known
form
as
the nerves.
In
man
to
the
cerebro-spinal
system,
including
the
and the nerves going from the brain and These the spinal-cord to the various organs of the body. The motor nerves are generally classified as motor or sensory.
brain, the spinal cord
is,
the brain-centres
light
is
reflected
is
stimulus
and thus occasion sensation. For example, upon the retina of the eye; the resulting transmitted by the optic nerve to the brain ; nerits
vous changes take place there corresponding to the assimilation of the sensation, to
and
an orange; other cerebral changes occur corresponding to a determination to get the orange
nerve, the muscles of the
is
; an impulse goes out along a motor hand are stimulated, and the orange
grasped.
The
is,
capable
is
also capable
its
capable of transmitting
own
excitation to
some other
point.
The
fibres
are
much
and hence
IfIND
AND
BODY.
1 59
power of summation^ that is, it is number of separate, continuous more prolonged stimuinto one and shocks minute By It also has the powers of inhibition^ and of plasticity. lus.
Nerve
tissue also has the
inhibition
is
meant
is
capable of arrest-
If a neural organ
it
property
of excitability,
would use up
it,
all
energy in
answer to a
on hand.
Indeed,
and by antagonizing
it,
arrests the
outflow of energy.
By
plasticity is
meant
structure
that has
before.
nerve organ
also
way once,
acts that
way more
future.
it
way
in
This property
is
termed accommodation.
This
fact that
becomes
specially
accommodated or adjusted
It is
to that kind
of stimulus or process.
The more a
to act in
will offer
to
all
Psychological Equivalents,
interest,
It
is
evident
that
to the
sensation,
in
some way
the
soul
property
either
of
excitability.
They
all
stir
to
action,
And
as the physiological
stimulus
is
controlled
inhibition exercised
by
the central organs, so the psychological excitations are brought under the control of the less superficial " apperceptive organs."
lOO
That
to say,
physiological
gical sides,
we
that,
by the manner of
their re-
And
it
is
physiological or psychological,
it
becomes effective or of any value The sensation is controlled by the intellectual capacities that connect and interpret
it
;
the impulse
it is
is
and choice
with which
or psychical
inertia,
is
activity.
laziness,
lack of incentive
without inhib-
there
is
There
no
self-control, physical or
mental
excites activity to
relatively
more
So
fatigue
and often by
brain centres
irritation of
is
temper.
The
stronger. Hence the evil effects, mental and physical, of over work and over pressure in school. Some psychologists think the different temperaments are due to the mutual relations of the stimulating and the inhibiting power. The psychological equi-
valent of plasticity
is,
There
is
And
retention, in building
charinhi-
Localization of Function.
l6l
To
what
do
correspond to definite
details of this
The
:
question
much
of opinion
1.
points
There
That
is,
prior
no
2.
localization.
Every part
of the nervous
structure
is
As
Use depends not so much on the structure of a part as upon motor, sensory and cerebral connections. 3. The more mechanical iht function, the more rea y (and hence perfectly) it is localized. Thus the processes ordinarily
its
li
The
spinal-cord
parts of
to be
Walking
Ar-
hemisphere.
Mental capacities^ whether intellectual or volitional, have That is to say, the capacities ill-defined and changeable centres.
of assimilating and of recognizing various kinds of sense-impressions,
of
in the brain.
The
centres have
no
By
calling
and probably overlap one another. them changeable we mean that if a centre in one
is
hemisphere
sumed by a corresponding
this
is
If
also destroyed,
it is
may be
substituted.
62
5.
Memory,
There
etc.,
ization.
retention
experiences.
were.
Hence
the
centre of
memory
original idea.
active in
tion.
supposed to be the same as that of the In other words, the same parts of the brain are
is
remembering
cept
is
The agreement of this physiological fact with the prelaid down for training memory will be noticed. Thinking
and
ideas.
It
cannot have
and
in the images,
must be active
is
in
no
memory
what
6.
is
remembered, what
is
thought about.
Some have
written as
if
each
with other
ideas.
cells,
by
fibres
This cannot be
true,
the result
itself,
of associations
is
and
relations.
an entity in
processes.
but
idea
the
a complex result of
'
many
factors
and
The
of a
coming from
all
senses
word dog; involves, in an educated person, words corresponding to the same idea in several languages ; and involves all the manifold knowledge a person has about the habits, varieties, Almost every kind of idea may be thus involved etc of dogs.
,
in
an
idea, apparently as
All portions
when we have
the idea.
Educational Principles.
convinced
he
may
SUMMARY OF
PRINCIPLES.
63
see that the idea of organization of faculty, through retention of the result of every experience, which has been so
sized, has a
Secondlyj he
see that
it is
any one
faculty.
The
faculty
and the
fundamental
and
synthesis,
memory, thinking, etc., will take care of themselves. Thirdly^ as no cell or fibre has originally any particular function in itself,
but
acquires
functions
only
through
its
connections,
so,
and by attention
itself.
isolated sensation
CHAPTER
SUMMARY OF
VIIL
PRINCIPLES.
We
shall
now go
we may,
and rearrange them under appropriate maxims for the guidAfter having done this we shall be in a position to ance of the teacher. criticise some of the current maxims, recognizing both their value and their
heads, that
as far as possible, derive general
limitations.
The
II.
Ends
at
III.
I.
I.
Methods which
Bases of Instruction.
Always
base instruction upon some activity of the pupiL
164
This
is
SUMMARY OF
PRINCIPLES.
;
from the
pri.
mary stage
Education
is
the development
of the psychical activities, and must, therefore, begin with some spontaneous
manifestation of the activity to be educated.
in the
This activity
may
effort,
appear
form of an impulse, an
interest,
a habit, an exercise of
an asdevelopment, but
be.
Always
of
the pupil.
upon which
is
exercised, to
it is
object, but
it may not have originally belonged to the activity or to it may have been transferred to it from something else interesting,
or
it
knowledge, of progress,
3.
Always
^s
the pupil
mind.
In the current phrase, knowledge must proceed from the " known to the
unknown."
by any
possibility
some idea already there. Insome idea already in the mind so as to make it grow into a larger and more accurate idea, rather than in There are two forcing or pouring something into the mind from without. principles which we have repeatedly had occasion to notice which strengthen that just laid down one b that we always learn with what we have already learned ; the other is that an idea (however vague) of what is to be done must precede any doing.
gain entrance only by being taken hold of by
struction consists in supplying nutriment to
:
II.
I.
Ends of
subject^
Instruction.
instruction significant.
Aim at making
make each
There
as a whole significant,
and
make
everj
is
no
evil in
teaching them as
if
from that obtained spontaneously out of school, is one of the on his guard against. Children
SUMMARY OF
may
PRINCIPLES.
165
study geography and not find out that they are simply extending and
classifying the
that they
since they
were
bom
they
may
knowledge of
men and
deeds
they
may
is
study
grammar without
and anaAll
of.
None
more important
than that in primary methods which has connected studies with ordinary
2.
Aim
at
making
instruction definite.
Every lesson should have a point, and every question upon that lesson should have a point, precise, salient, unambiguous. Irrelevant matter
should be excluded
:
examples or analogies.
point desired
j
if
and
many
lait'
knowledge
Finally the teacher should and the idiosyncracies. of the pupil permit. remember that knowledge is naturally anything but definite. Vague and cloudy ideas come first, and they will in many minds remain vague to the
is
3.
and action
\f3iXXi%
countsy and
life,
when he
his
is
learning
in his
namely
first five
doing.
through action.
got
this
ideal
l66
not be physical)
is
SDMMARY OF
continued through
PRINCIPLES.
all
school years,
it.
md is
joined to
when
it
Uads
to
the formation of
The
right under-
is
There must be
drill,
but
it is all
proper place
the training
ful
own
influence in building
up
most power-
of the forces at work in severing school work from the real world, and
in
and
and unreal. Imagine a child out of school drilled upon some facts he has gathered in conversation or in reading, as he too often is upon facts learned in school ; drilled as if the sole value of the facts consisted in the extent to which they lent themselves to purwould not the result be that these facts would become unreal poses of drill and distasteful ; that interest would die out ; that the sense of proportion, of the difference between the important and the unimportant, would be destroyed, and that, by dwelling on what is familiar to the degree of tedious* But when drill is used ness, habits of mind-wandering would be formed ? simply as means and as means to forming right habits in the subject studied, whatever it be, these evil results are avoided, and the proper union of
it artificial
making
redrilled
is systematically secured.
no need
that
if
instruction is
effect
new capacities and powers ; that, inand dead facts in the mind, there will be an assimilation and digestion of them, by which they will be worked over into centres of new activity and apprehension.
mind,
it
(Hi) Instruction
psychical powers^
Retention.
is
practical
when
it
develops the
fundamental
Association
and
Attention, Apperception
e<^
SUMMARY OF
Iv
PRINCIPLES.
67
specific
knowledge acquired, nor upon the upon the specific powers gained,
rely after
most to
he leaves school,
It
its
is
most depend.
the
fundamental capacities,
powers
concen-
and
and
is
person
educated for
The
best
also the surest to develop right habits of dealing with arithmetical relations,
form
rigflt
are surest to
mind, and to
mental faculties. And the methods and organize new powers are also the methods which discipline, cultivate and develop the fundamental powers of give association and attention ability to deal with whatever
habits
III.
I.
Methods of
Instruction.
to
be taught
is
at to
one time,
be so pre-
and so on.
It
means
may be
energies concen-
at a time.
become so habitual
one
is
necessary for
them
in logical order,
and
is
drill
them
separately.
When
the question
as to the special
methods
to
what mental operations the mind must go through in grasping that subject ; the next step is to arrange ways by which the child's attention may be confined successively to each
one of these constituent operations, beginning, of course, with the simplest.
Example.
matter.
Reading aloud
is
to
an educated adult a comparatively simple in use, went upon the principle that it
was a correspondingly simple matter to a child, and, therefore, endeavoured to make the child's mind work in three or four directions at once. The
t69
resnit, naturally,
SUMMARY OF
PRINCIPLES.
slighted,
and
that
and economi-
For, consider how complex the operation really is. must be paid to the visual sensations in order to recognize the written word ; then there must be the mental operation of combining the letters and words then of paying attention to the ideas symbolized by the words ; then, in order to pronounce the words with expression, attention must be paid to the auditory sensations represented by the words then to their association with the motor impulses required to make the sounds ; and then to the proper inflection, pitch, emphasis, etc., that will give the fall meaning of what is written. The analysis could be carried farther, but here we have six distinct operations, to each of which separate attention musf be paid if the child is to learn to read well. How much better, therefore, the methods which select the various operations and train the child in them, one by one, than the methods that present all in a mass and compel the pupil to pick out the processes for himself.
cally performed.
First, attention
; ;
Every
right
method
is
a way
of assisting some normal psychical process (page 4), and this method of " teaching one thing at a time " finds its justification in its relation to the
the neces-
could
it
would need no
it.
instruction.
But
it is
It is the function of
the
his teacher is makwork analytically. A ing, and then attempts to reproduce them, is performing mental analysis. There is one thing presented to him, and all his attention is concentrated upon that one thing. An analytic method in education always consists in resolving a subject into its component members^ and in presenting these mem'
bers,
and analyze the material, that the pupil who notices the sounds that
pupil's
mind shall
one at a time,
to the
mind's
activities to
work upon.
Advantages of Analytic Method. Its main advantage is, of course, that based upon and aids a fundamental function of mind, one which must be used if knowledge is to be gained. But there are minor advantages
it is
is
called
upon
to
pay
it is
factors,
upon
to attend to that
is
The
at
result
is
diffused, scattered
There
greater strain
a time,
but
less is
Mccoviplishtd,
SUMMARY OF
(ii) It defines
PRINCIPLES.
distinct
169
Is
menial Products.
mental product
one which
Paying atten-
one thing
to.
makes
distinct
what
is
at
tended
it
On
when
were, everything
to asso-
whatever
is
should be connected
thing and
fix
attention
upon
that, the
mind
is
much
it is
When
a pupil
tells
knew
the earth was round because he balanced an egg on the table ;"
easy, to
laugh at him
two statements had such juxtaposition amid a jumble of facts that his
is
that these
It
repeated that
memory
is
memory
When
one thing
is
attended to at a
met
that
remem-
When we
that
say that a
man
he
is
its
im-
them clearly, and hold them firmly, no matter how complicated and confused the subject upon its surface. This means that he has acquired one of the
portant
points, to distinguish
best, if
an analytic
principle
habit of
and
principles.
here laid down, the inducement to form this habit is strong. Paying attention to " one thing at a time," the mind is gradually led to look for the " one thing " which underlies a varied mass
of facts
;
it
feels irritated
and
ill
at ease
is
until this
unity
is
17
3.
SUMMARY OF
PRINCIPLES.
This principle bears the same relation to the Synthetic Function of mind that the one just given does to the analytic function. The method based upon it may be termed, therefore, the synthetic method. This method de-
mands
of
the teacher. It
does not have, in every detail of his school work, a purpose larger than that detail, must not only fall into a mechanical way of
teacher
teaching, but must teach in a disconnected dispersive manner.
who
There
is
no one end which runs through his class-work, course with pupils, etc., welding them into a unity.
of a practical ideal, that of forming good habits of
inter-
mind
by
this ideal
connect
all
details,
themselves.
(ii)
That
The
He
laid for
is
an educa-
He
going to ac-
So
quires
(i)
far as
:
the pupil
is
That knowledge
This
is
for two
of the mind are trained^ and, because representative knowledge must be capable of translation into presentative.
That knowledge should be connected
be connected
if
is
It
cannot
SUMMARY or
translation into presentations.
less.
PRINCIPLES.
isolated
I71
and meaningnecessity of
Nor
cf*.n it
an orderly development or
The
and concepts
and so
This
is
v/e shall
sometimes stated
ment,
such a
first,
perception, then
memory and
:
way
grow from it. For the first stateimply that memory, imagination, etc., come after come
after,
only be-
Qom^from
perception.
In other words,
all
mental
activities are
way
and
as affording material
shall act.
be attended to, must be associated, must be idealized and retained to become knowledge.
involved in
up
numbers.
as
, : :
Here and as
and
he
useless. For the time must come when have to grasp the relations involved, and experiencing sensations any number of times, would not give any preparation for the apprehension of
method would be
will
relations.
, ,
But in reality, the child relates the sensations of , and of , and only because he relates them does he perceive anything.
institutes the relation,
the
or the consciotis grasping of the relation. He performs, without recognizing its full significance, a kind of relating identical
any
subject,
In order
its
to establish a
training,
172
particular, to
SUMMARY OF
PRINCIPLES.
be looked after. One is identifying the presentation with what has already been presented, recognition ; the other is the discovery of something implied in the perception, but not apparent on the surface, its
differentiation.
The
is
that
what
is
now
perceived
assimilated to what
This en-
new
its
exercise.
is evi-
by which the child sees that c-a-t spells cat, and is also involved in that by which the older student identifies a botanical species, perceives the principle which covers a
dently involved in the simplest perception, as
g. that
mathematical problem, or sees that the form of some given Greek word
illustrates
perception a
new
factor as well as
an
old.
and is the same as 'jl I sees it only by putting together the first two number-forms and taking apart the last. He perceives the identity by discovering it, by making it. So when a child
child
sees that
.
The
who
...
but he discovers.
In higher education
make the word, he not only recognizes, we have clearly the factor of dis-
covery in scientific experiment, in the demonstration of original propositions, in the analysis of unfamiliar plants, in the dissection of animals, etc.
But
it is
a mistake
to
and physical
They are involved to some degree in every which gives new knowledge, and education should be so ploy in all stages this acquisition of new knowledge by
is
act of perception
directed as to
em-
perception.
New
knowledge
only through an cut of construction, or synthesis^ an act of discovery. It should be noticed that the new combination of these two factors of recognition and discovery renders knowledge connected. The old is made the basis of apprehending the new,
obtained
and
this
is,
in reality,
while the
{ii)
new
is
made
the
old.
The
synthetic
cted to-
and by
and
or groups of
An
there
pressing
is
by the pupil only through sheer force of imon his mind. Both brain and mind are plastic in childhood, and no doubt that the child can store avvay multitudes of comparatively
facts.
unconnected
But
this
train
mental power;
it
gives no
Further*
SUMMARY OF
PRINCIPLES.
;
173
the facts are
by expenditure of force ; But facts learned by associations and in both ways, the mind is burdened. relations, strengtnen and form faculty in the very process of making Further, the mind gains the connections, or appropriating the material.
instead of losing in carrying power by its assimilation of facta so learned. These connected ideas serve as centres about which allied ideas gather thus they carry others, instead of having to be carried by the energy of the
tfiind.
Training of Connection of Ideas, It is impossible here to lay down deconnecting ideas in various studies. There are, however, lome facts bearing upon the subject which may be called to mind. First,
connecting activity
it
this
whenever
terial
can,
so that
is normal to the mind ; the mind strives to connect and the teacher can accomplish much by presenting mathe child's mind is drawn on naturally from one point to an-
other.
Again, a unity of
feeling, or
otherwise diverse.
The
who began by
building houses in a
sand
pile,
facturing, railway
and went on graAuaHy to the development of agricultural, manuand commercial establishments, comprehending in all a
different activfties.
it
vast
number of
unity of interest
made
the transi-
tions.
ing,
And
so
will
be
in scfiools.
writing,
composition,
history
of
all
and geography may undoubtedly be have hitherto been. Indeed, earlier years, arithmetic is the only one
inevitably, to union with other
is
and almost
once grasped.
_.~,-^
new knowledge.
'
This principle has two sides. A pufil who has learned, for example, the simple arithmetical operations must, on Ine one hand, constantly use them ; must add, subtract, etc.; and, on the other hand, must gain new arithmetical
knowledge
as an
expansion or development of
in gaining
these
operations.
Old
new
presentations,
Old knowledge
new
present-
new
ledge.
174
SUMMARY OF
PRINCIPLES.
first,
Applications of Principle.
of former knowledge.
frequent reviews
Reviews have as
classifying.
It is
merely repeating
grouping and
under
to
its
form the habit of re-arranging what he has learned ; of bringing it proper heads, and of placing these heads in their proper relations
In reviews, therefore, the serial order should often be
for a topical order.
one another.
changed
facts,
many
mind
meaning of the
are trained
facts
but
it
trains thought
and memory.
is
with them.
The memory
;
be remembered
them
as instances or illustrations.
The
takes
That is, before a pupil enters upon mind must be prepared for it before he principle, his mind must be prepared, and learn any lessons there must be preparatory
his
:
adjustment of mind.
and
in calling
them
into activity
how these
Without
this
preparatory activity
no attention can be given (pages 6i and 62), and hence what is studied has previously been learned, and there is no is not connected with what
assimilation nor comprehension.
thirdly, that old knowledge be exercised. There two injunctions of equal importance to the teacher. One is that new knowledge be not simply impressed upon the mind the other is that old knowledge be not simply stowd or passively retained in the mind. Constantly employing what has been learned guards against both these errors.
are
To
and
new sentences, etc., enlarges and organizes these principles, same time causes what is learned to gather about them, and to Old knowledge and new facts are thus so con|;ain meaning from them. Kept apart, both are dead. nected together that both are made vital. Just as the body must have nourishment in order to keep itself living, and just as food by becoming nourishment is itself transformed from dead to Unless the mind living material, so with the mind and its food-studies. constantly uses what it has gained to gain more, it loses what it has possessed ; and unless what is gained is connected with mental power already
constructing
at the
existing,
it is
SUMMARY OF
PRINCIPLIt.
175
facts.
methods are only applications to particular branches of the analytic and synthetic methods. 2. These two methods do not exclude, but supplement, each other. 3. They are not to be confused with physical division and composition.
All
special
1.
mind
is
are
analysis
and
synthesis, since
all
that
is
ever learned
learned
ideas,
these
follows
that
must
rest
upon
powers.
appeal, to
Any method
some
and the unifying and the best method is that which appeals to them in the most systematic way, and which stimulates them to the fullest and most intense activity. In his knowledge of these powers every teacher has an instrument by which he may test for himself the value of any special method
extent, to the discriminating
functions of intelligence,
which
2.
is
proposed,
synthesis are
it
not separate,
functions of mind,
and
synthetic educational
Indeed,
method,
upon
failure to
understand the
some
unperformed.
What
is
usually
and making
divisions of land
and
water
known from
it,
is, it
in reality,
It is synthetic,
because
176
SUMMARY OF
knows
;
PRINCIPLES.
begins with presentations and
it
for,
But it is also analytic, by such operations the vague outline-knowledge of the world which the child has is transformed into knowledge of the defitranslates representative ideas into them.
and
make
it is.
When
that
a lake
a lake has
the analysis
The
fact
may
make
by noticing a pond
own
And
is
While
in
some
far
method
justifiable, it
The
erally arises
functions
with
opposed
to physical
Thus, in geo-
graphy, that
known
to the pupil,
down
But
this
misapprehends the
meaning of mental
Mental
mental
analysis
and
synthesis.
The terms do
any difference
analysis
definite,
clear,
how
common
meaning.
SUMMARY OF
PRINCIPLES.
177
purposes of mental analysis and synthesis, and these not of material objects,
but of knowledge.
Illustration
from Reading.
many
be found as the
the unit
is
basis,
discussed whether
the
letter,
that he
in
what the pupil must begin with is the whole toass of sounds makes use of in pronouncing words. While these sounds
themselves are distinct, to his mind they have no such defi-
His first act must, therefore, be to notice some of these sounds, and through attention dwelling upon them make them distinct. He performs an act of analysis. But at the same time, he must
notice
how
these sounds go
together 10
synthesis^ or combination. By knowledge of the primary sounds of speech becomes definite ; by the other, his knowledge becomes connected^ By both acts, his fundamental mind functions are trained, and the habit of defining and unifying ideas is formed.
the
one act
Will
While in the previous chapters knowledge, feeling and will have been discussed separately, nothing has been said about This subject is, however, imtheir relations to one another. from Partly the necessity of the case, teacher. the portanc to
partly from surrounding circumstances,
and
our schools
is
It
is
important to
know
and
in
what degree
this involves
will,
and
what degree it needs supplementing. The Mind an Organic Unity. The fact is that knowledge, fcelin<y and will are so closely interconnected that it is imposalso in
178
sible
SUMMARY OF
to educate
PRINCIPLES.
one without
at
and retention underlie all these, that the functions of analysis and synthesis enter into them all, and that the main principles of development (from the presentative and immediate to the representative and mediate, etc.) are alike in all, the mind is a unity, and primarily it is mind that is affected by education and not knowledge, feeling or will. There is but one mind, and knowledge, feeling and will are not three departments of mind, but three phases of its manifestation. Just as it would be impossible for the digestive organs to digest food
without the aid of the circulatory, the respiratory and the nervous
must re-act upon mind cannot know without the support of feeling and of will, and without the re-action of knowledge upon the emotional disposition and the volitional
processes,
all
and
capacities.
While
in a material or spatial
the whole
ture of
may
exist side
one another,
an
it
it.
what
by
members
that influence
Dependence of Knowledge.
at work.
will
;
In
all
knowledge which
is
is
got by
evidently
that
all
controls
the processes
end before it, and which and ideas so as to lead up to this end. there be control, physical and prudential,
pupils,
and
generally, in
many
sometimes
in all pupils,
will,
moral
control
the obtaining of
knowledge
is a practical impossibility. Knowledge is also dependent upon feeling. Interest is a condition of attention,
after
is
superficial
SUMMARY OP
atid counterfeit
PRINCIPLES.
realize the
79
knowledge.
To
it,
meaning of anyit
thing, to
be acquainted with
feelings.
means
to see
in its bearings
upon the
The
internal appropriation
and
assimila-
be joined to
the heart
that they be
known by
as well as
by the head.
Dependence of Feeling,
attention to
activity, the
^When
discussing feeling
is
we
called
two
facts
one that
feeling
an accompaniment of
aesthetic
and personal, depend upon the kinds of objects or ideas about which feelings gather that the distinction between them is not so much in difference in them as feelings^ as in that These two facts mean, in substance, about which they cluster. that feeling is dependent upon will and upon knowledge, using will in a broad sense to include all psychical activity, and knowledge as the presentation of all sorts of objects and ideas. The education of perception and of thought, the training of attention and association must develop the intellectual emotions ; the growth of imagination must bring about a development of the aesthetic feelings. Growth in personality, in recognition of other persons, in the recognition and practice of duty, carries along with it growth of the personal and moral
feelings.
The
religious
to ideas,
and on the
ex-
may
be cultivated
and
of ideas. Feeling of any kind that does not arise from internal acquaintance with ideas, from becoming at home with them,
and
Will
one
involves, as
its
two
essential cova-
and
^i5jw>(tf,
emotional
l8o
SUMMARY OF
PRINCIPLES.
is
Without the
action
having no stimulus.
is
Without the
knowledge,
of
blind,
unregulated,
capricious.
Every growth
some motive
to action
and
in
it
a broader end or
ideal,
more
deliberate
both in the
if we go back to its ultimate foundaupon some impulse ; and, as learning advances, this impulse is controlled by being brought into connection with ideas, and by being subjected to desire and choice. The process oi learning is a volitional one from beginning to end, and as the facts of will are exercised, will must be trained. The knowledge acquired makes a basis for new activities of will ; it reveals new possibilities, and gives new laws by which to control conduct.
Education of Feeling and of Will. It is evident from what has been said that the objection sometimes brought against
present systems of education that they are purely intellectual,
is
Any
must
system
perfect,
we now havp
and, furthermore, that this training will give a better training of intellect than that
now
secured.
But
this will
not involve
any departure from the precepts already laid down. So far as present methods are what they should be, even as training the intellect, they rest upon the normal interests and impulses of
childhood, and train these by subjecting them to association
and
attention, analysis
and
emo-
tional
and
Further
more
fully
interests
and
impulses are, and will find better methods for calling out, ex-
SUMMARY OF
ercising
PRINCIPLES.
I^i
and developing the impulses, better methods for oil and satisfying the interests. In a word, education is primarily of the whole personality, and only secondarily of the
turing
intellect, the feelings,
or the will.*
Criticism of Maxims.
discuss briefly
1.
Having
maxims, we may
which
precepts.
Faculties, each of
The
Intellect is
Sum of Different
Requires
its
own Kind of
This
always, or
formulated,
assumed as
violates the
the basis
much
pedagogical discussion.
It
two fundamental functions or powers, analysis and synthesis, both of which are forms o^
All faculties must, therefore,
functions,
relating activity.
(Pages
train
84 and
90.)
which attempt to
memory and
First
Form
it
This maxim
:
is
sus-
ceptible of
it
substantially conect,
Form
faculty by
furnishing
it.
The
a more import-
It
is
incorrect, so far as
it
be formed apart from the activity of the mind in acquiring knowledge, and apart from the reaction of knowledge upon the mind, " For organizing mental faculty
faculty can
* See Chap,
vi.,
See also
82
SUMMARY OF
PRINCIPLES.
Menial there is no other means than organized knowledge." power and knowledge are not to be opposed, or even separ(See page 70). ated, for they are correlative.
3.
Learn
to
do by Doing.
This
all
discussed.
in so far as
129).
The
principle
is
true,
pupil
must
be appealed to in
and
that
it
is
is
through
apprehended.
sight of the
for
The
principle
becomes
false
when
it
loses
knowledge required
supplement
habitual or mechanical.
therefore, requires a
do by knowing.
to
We
4.
Known
to
to the
Unknown.
is
This maxim,
basis
is
make what
is
familiar the
unfamiliar,
in line with
Some
all
new element,
and
this
new element
or vague into the familiar and definite, instruction really adBut the words are vances from the unknown to the known.
not used in the same sense in the two maxims. The maxim, '* proceed from the known to the unknown," means utilize old
knowledge
unknown unknown
new;" while the maxim, "from the known," certainly does not mean " make the It means that the basis of acquiring the known." the presentation of the unknown that what is through it was previously known is enlarged and strengthened, or that
in acquiring
to the
the
presentation
of the unfamiliar
is
necessary to
the deve-
corresponds to
to retention.
From the known to the unknown From the unknown to the known apperception.
is,
That
SUMMARY OF
pon
the presentation
;
PRINCIPLES.
83
sentation has
5.
This
Taken
precept
literally
also has
it
(Page 80).
is
impossible,
which to begin.
ledge
is
Nor
is it
difficult,
requires as
much
preparation, as
much mental
energy,
and as much maturity of mind, to make a clear distinction as to make broad generalization. Both processes, in fact, occur
together as
different
aspects of comparison.
To
transform
knowledge from hazy into definite, and from isolated into connected forms, are both ends of instruction, and the educator cannot safely assume that either process has been already accomplished before his work begins.
but this
Develop representations
presentations.
There are two maxims apparently wholly opposed to each works " Follow the order of na:
order of the
and
then analysis^
and Proceed from the whole to the part" Regarding the first prin" If in language, or in grammar we begin ciple one author writes
:
with
grammar and pass to its divisions, learn of what each treats, take up parts of speech, and the properties of each, etc, we teach by analysis. If we begin with words, learn that they are of different kinds, as names, action-words, quality-words,
their properties,
etc.,
then learn
subject,
grammar,
we teach by synthesis. It is evident tiiat is the method of nature, while the analytic
the subject."
But, what
is
is
the synthetic
method
method
It
just as
much
analytic as synthetic.
is
synthetic, because
it
most
familiar to the
his present a*
child,
and advances
to that
184
tainments
;
SUMMARY OF
it is
PRINCIPLES.
it
analytic because
upon
differences of function
and
and thus
knowledge.
fact
that the
Thus we get another illustration of the two methods cannot be separated. The other
is
correct, if
it
be
clearly
whole
'
does not
the whole as
it
exists apart
from the
child's
if
each be under
stood as
7.
should be.
Teach Only What is Understood. The maxim, in its meaning is identical with the precept already laid down. Make instruction significant. It must be remembered that a great many things are both interesting and significant to a child that are not so to an adult for example, the forms of letters and of words, the sounds of speech simply as sounds, etc,
true
8. " Teach Ideas before Words^ or as some give " Teach things not names." In its latter form the precept
it,
is,
till
taken
literally,
meaningless.
And
In the
a
language
other
is
and
textual
and
yet leaves
subjects.
them with no recognition of the meaning of the But the maxim, so far as it seems to underrate the
SUMMARY OF
PRINCIPLES.
is,
185
as already
We may
notice a few
First,
consciousness which
is
meaningless.
Language
is
and most
efficient
-What
it
means can be
in
seen by comparing the knowledge of deaf mutes with that of speaking people
;
and by
is
calling to
educating deaf-mutes
Secondly, words
to give
make knowledge of objects both general and They make it general by fixing attention upon the They class-qualities, upon the generic properties of the object. make it definite by seizing upon some quality of the object and making that a handle, as it were, by which the object may The mind is always restless till it knows always be grasped. the name of an object; if there is no recognized name, one is
definite.
This
is
to one's
self.
It fixes
it
it
an individuality of
own.
The development
child,
salient or
shows clearly that names, at first, simply express the most prominent quality of the object. Indeed, to a baby,
is
the
name
repeats the
name
attention of others to
but to
re-zzSS.
it.
own
mind ;
language
Decause
it is
not generalized.
Thirdly,
knowledge.
fullness
names are condensations, concentrations of past They introduce the immature mind at once into and richness of knowledge which it would take the
r86
SUMMARY OF
PRINCIPLES.
Sir Isaac
Newton
the race.
had.
The reason
is
found in language.
Words sum
civiHzation of
is
up and condense
and
teaching, therefore,
necessary to
Much
This precept
But in spite of
rest
is
so vague
that
might be dismissed
at once.
its
vagueIts
ness
true
it is
only
meaning
and
is
that educational
methods should
upon psy-
chical processes
late
normal to the
It is
child's
train them.
there
of
or,
itself,
some force called Nature which will carry on education and which should not be interfered with by educators
Nature lays
that
down
need not have special knowledge or art of his own ; or that Nature provides models so distinct that no one can err in following them, and so perfect that the teacher cannot improve upon them. All this is either mythology robing itself in the
garb of science, or
it is
a vague
way
of covering
up ignorance
the
The
know
him
ality
the
He
must,
Great
Teacher,
for
know what
in
man
in order that
he may educate
has need
is
manhood,
man
is
what
he
in actu-
and
in possibility.
MifaiUUi^
\J*
U^lti,M.*\sjsiAliUM
IS7
CHAPTER
IX.
QUESTIONIiro.
nn
special
Geii^ral Method. We have seen (page 167, et se^) that methods of instruction rest upon Analysis and Synthesis, and that the Analytic and Synthetic Methods in education are
not independent but complementary^ being in fact but different
aspects of the one psychological
in
all
normal
instruction.
therefore, with a
minute
only
we may appeal to the Analytic and Synthetic functions of mind chiefly in two ways, viz. by direct, continuous Exposition (the Expository Method) or by Interrogation (the Socratic Method) ; /. e.^ we may by Questioning,
necessary to state that
:
172).
The
is
Of
all
the qualifications
teacher, ability to
method we shall now study. that go to make the successful question well is probably the most important.
that
is
The prime
himself.
object of teaching
in the
proper attitude
and
properly presented.
These
conditions secure a
the
structure of knowledge,
and
its
acquisition
the
may be
tioning
is
l88
METHOD OF INTERROGATION.
Natural enteach well ; whoever fails in this point fails in all. dowments, accurate scholarship, professional knowledge and experience, are required for excellence in this method of instrucValuable as the method is, no great prominence has tion.
hitherto
been given to
It
its
tra;r.ing
if
;
of teachers.
granted that
upon
it
well
an
knowledge of a subject
is
teach
nised.
it.
The
fallacy of this
assumption
now
generally recog-
and
calling.
Principles
ing
is
and
Practice,
acquired, by
;
one
by questioning.
Mere
word
;
maxim has its place By knowing, learn make experience in the true sense
:
to do.
of the
must be
intelligent practice.
Rules of
from principles of science, and unless the "doer "has a cleir knowledge of rules and of their underlying principles, he is not
likely to acquire artistic skill in their practical application.
is
It
it
common
On
is
many a
is con" experi-
practical "
man
is
cerned
so
far as
that
many an
enced " one quite without experience. An experience which is not the result of sound principles and their wise application, gives special powers and tendencies to work in the wi^ong direction, a fatal facility for
METHOD OF INTERROGATION.
It is
1 89
not an
uncommon
who
his
account of
in his actual
every principle of scientific method, and who, in consequence It may of his " experience," is beyond hope of improvement.
be
little
more
may
be, such
may
and
continue
right,
waste of
time and power, to attain that true experience which comes from
right doing guided
by right knowing
It
and learning
are based
Apperception
and Retention the effect which the material when apprehended, has upon the mind itself. These two processes are, as we have seen, mutually dependent there can be no retention without clear apprehension ; and, on the other hand, every new apprehension modifies mind, and so has its effect in inter-
mind
the
preting
new
experiences.
The
mind
proper presentation of material^ and on the other hand, proper In the light of this principle, we may conpreparation of mind.
The Objects of Questioning, or what may be accomit (II) The Qualifications of the Questioner; (III) The Form and Matter of Questions; (IV) The Form and
sider (I)
plished by
Matter of Answers.
deduced.
If the
first
topic
is
fully discussed, it is
may be
easily
it
definitely to
be convenient to
one process rather than to the other. But it classify them roughly under these heads,
will
/>.,
IpO
METHOD OF INTERROGATION.
Purposes, of Questioning as
we
(a) concerned with the Presentation of Material, or with the Testing of Retention ; (b) as concerned with the Preparation of
Mmdy
follow-
i.
To
;
To
3.
To
;
tual
Knowledge
the vague
made
made
Power
accurate,
and
4.
To
Cultivate
Training Apperception,
following purposes
:
Under
To
?>.,
(b)
may be
;
considered the
2.
i.
Excite
;
Interest
4.
To Arouse
Attention
3.
To
Direct Attention
To
Cultivate Habit of
Self-Direction of Attention,
Habit of Self-Questioning.
(a) Testing
I.
Retention
Presentation of Material
To Discover
This
is
one of the
For the new lesson must have some logical connection with what was previously taught ; it can be interpreted only by what has been
first
new
lesson.
it is
impossible effectively
the old, unless
new with
we
know what
If this
is
and how it stands in the learner's mind. not known we may waste time in two ways.
the old
is
Presenting too Easy Stimulus. (See page m.) In We may dwell upon what is already perfectly first place known to the learner, and thus, by monotonous repetition of
the
:
what has
interest.
lost all
The tendency
in this direction.
charm of novelty, quench rather than excite of certain modern methods is strongly Ingenious minds have long been in travail
;
dis-
METHOD OF INTERROGATION.
covered
it
I91
difficulties
It
in-
appears to
be thought that the teacher can take the place of the learner by properly preparing the material, that
ledge,
is
by atomizing knowit
the
in
homoeo-
admitted that
that leads to
it
and
skill,
the ladder,
is
thought,
all its
anyone thinks
this is
too
him open almost any educational journal or recent educational work, and he will find abundant proof of the " develop strength by making things prevalence of the theory
;
easy."
"model"
number
mob "
of
recommended
to ask
on
common
which can never enter into organized knowledge nor have any
effect
in
organizing faculty.
Witness
the
trivial
"develop-
ment
" questions
recommended
which
mental growth.
it
necessary,
is
it
on the
as
number two ?
e.g.^
hand ? How many on the left ? ? John had one apple and his sister Two birds are gave him another, how many had he then ? sitting on a tree, if one bird flies away how many will be left ? How many eyes has Willie ? If he shuts one how many will remain open? And so on, if not ad infinitum, certainly <id
right
192
METHOD OF INTERROGATION.
modicum of
brains.
power to stimulatey and the answers become simply an exercise in " dead vocables." Merely
at last loses all
Such questioning
and so drill
men may
be carried to a point
where
it is
In primary schools, perhaps in all schools, incalculable time wasted in a wearisome monotony of drills, tending to form merely sensuous associations, and continued long after such associations have been actually formed. Let the teacher be on
is
his
feed
guard against the atomic method in questioning a cutmethod which may be, presumably, suited to the capacity
is
a positive hindrance to an
intel-
is
mind
where there
mind
there
is
activity of
of normal power, and that this selfmind works with effect, because it works with interest when operating upon material that challenges effort. There is
for self-active direction
little
interest
presented as mental pabulum, and is pronounced "dull" when he is only disgusted and " inattentive " when he is but attentive
to his
own more
is
:
The
conclusion of
the matter
many
questions
it,
and end
in the
*'
and hence
and
disqualify the
elaboration
Teaching too
The
Matter. In
is
beyond the
child's
power
This error,
is
in
METHOD OF INTERROGATION.
Canadian Schools, more
going paragraph, and
is
193
foreis
common
Learning
presented to-day.
is
There
past
*'
is
when
is it
there
bringing to bear
is
experiences upon
learner's
above the
material.
If this material
assimilation ? If A, B,
and
into
the learner
is
in possession of
A
his
but not of B,
it is
worse than
useless to present
relation with C.
position,
to
him
There may be
and apposite
is
illustration,
on the
part of the
learner there
wonder how so " excellent a lesson " Even gaod the pupil words and nothing more.
to
this error of
are prone to
he
is
no
re-
which
is
a thing of growth
sulting only
from the
self-activity
;
he
on
test fully
been
fairly
taken
in,
all
has been
appropriated,
logically
and
so,
when he proceeds
last,
to give a
depending on the
he
finds, after
energy and
much discouragement
exist.
True Assimilation
apprehension
the
It
that the
interpretation
of
the
that
is
the true
assimilation,
occurs not
capacity in
'94
METHOD OF INTERROGATION.
in acquiring such ideas. If, for example, a young pupil has mastered the number five, he is not only in possession of certain ideas concerning the number
(such as 4 and
ideas his
are
5,
5 less
is 4,
number-relations in general.
to teach the
also, if
a teacher attempts
number 7 before the pupil has a clear apprehension of the number 6, he is not only appealing to ideas not yet in the child's mind for 6 is a thought in 7 but he is as-
What
exactly
Is
is
clear, therefore,
i.e.,
how
he has acquired
(verbal
association
cally in the
memory) in which case the ideas are held mechanimind and have no interpreting power or by true
assimilatioM, in
there, but
to test
is,
what
how he knows
it ;
that
the
The thoughtful teacher probut not a test of power developed. poses to act on the maxim " From the Known to the related
:
Unknown."
is
What
He
endeavors
new
mind
he
he carefully analyzes
the
and
new
he
"known"
in the
it ;
stimulates
known
;
tc
new and
the old.
Thus
there
is
real assimilation
METHOD OF INTERROGATION.
and retention
;
I95
in organ-
there
is
ized knowledge.
pleasure to the
To Fix Knowledge:
is
Retention by
in
all
Repetition.
;
The
it
law
of Retention
fundamental
education
operates
in the acquiring of
labour-saving
Law
of Repetition which
is
stage of education,
and so useful
For example
tentatively produces
a certain
power
make
still
sults ability to
without the
This
illustration is typical
all
shows how
*'
forms of physical and mental growth ; how " knowing " helps
and how both aid Retention, the process by which the mais wrought over into powers and capacities, tendencies and tastes.
doing,
terial
of instruction
mental
of apprehension that
to
be due to merely sensuous association, or rote learning. Even in what we have termed the mechanical stage, discipline is
to be the aim, that
is,
there
is
opening intelligence.
The law
in brief, not
impression
and
Self-activity and Repetition of Self-activity. Self-activity is to be awakened and guided chiefly by the method of Interrogation. The teacher makes a preparatory analysis of the subject; he prerepetition of impression, but rather
196
METHOD OF INTERROGATION.
point by point;
by
skilful
mind of
in
in identifying^ />.,
in
working synthetically
he continues
this
method of educais
tion until
formed,
analysis
and
the presenta^
clearer with
becomes
each repetition, and the dim and vague mental outline with
started,
idea.
So,
facts,
and
and
course.
he
is
comprehend the
;
the solution
the relations
and
Illustration.
intuition of the
By means
five ;
first
number
one presentation
will
not
suffice,
even
act.
if
Herein,
may be
first
observed,
lies
the source of
many
**
a sad
mistake.
there
must
be
objective
into the
falls
concrete
is
first
idea
vague, indefinite
that the
mind
METHOD OF INTERROGATION.
the child must be
I97
must ar/ on the material, and frequently repeat the act; that made to think from the vague to the welldefined the concrete :' and that the mental processes ou^ht to be aided by proper presentation of objects. For example,
'
number five, we do not begin with five disand unarranged objects this would be to commit two blunders. We begin with similar objects, symmetrically
in teaching the
similar
arranged, as thus
"
But even with this symmetrical number-form, one presentation is not enough On the basis of the several familiar forms, which the child has already learned, he must be questioned through clear perceptions into clear conctp lions. Every presentation becomes clearer until there results a definite idea of the number five, through a conscious recognition of its relations to Thus, in the foreo;oing number-form, the lower numbers. 1= 4, i.e. by questioning, 5=4 the relations 5=4+1,5 + ?, 5 I =? can be presented in five difl^erent (though related) ways. It seems plain that if the child is led by clear intuitions to think the relations as presented in these number.
forms, the
**
Similarly, from the same numberform can be presented various intuitions of the relations 5 = 3 +2, 53=2, /.(?., by questioning, 5=3-!-?, 53=?; 5=2+3, (See chap, on teaching arithmetic.) 5 = 2+?, etc., etc.
Again
a proposition as
first clearly apprehend so simple " Things which are equal to the same thing
as
e.g..,
the line
AB is equal to
the line
CD, the
line
EF
is
also equal to
CD,
nol
which
is
The The
price.
price -f $20.
198
METHOD OF INTERROGATION.
yet
fail
And
axiom
will at
The
will
many
con-
and he
tioned
upon the
principle
and
its
it,
all
applies.
Once more
he
cost
when a
number
:
six,
offhand
such, a question as
If 2 apples
4 cents what will 3 apples cost ? Much less will he be able comprehend its solution by the " Rule of Three," since the general idea of ratio and the complex idea of the equality of ratios, are quite beyond his grasp. But he can be led to solve the problem by taking its two steps, one at a time. By clear intuitions, he can be led first to perceive^ and then to conceive that if 2 apples cost 4 cents, one apple will cost 2 cents ; and then by
to
similar means, to see that
if
cost
^ cents
As,
e.g.
Apple Apple
cents
cents
etc.
Thus forming
clear
visible objects.
is
Not only
is
as has
main
even here,
is
There can
be, of course,
no
this
severe
is
METHOD OF INTERROGATION.
the law of similiarity.
lysis
It
is
I99
child
brought to think
He
;
facts
but
some
this rationality
carefully kept in
in
their
unconscious appropriation
will
rationality,
which
in
good time
grow
Illustration. If, for example, the facts of six have been presented in clear intuitions will be a gradual, but J J J there sure growth of clear perceptions into a conscious thinking
of the relations between
is
i
and
6, 2
and
;
6,
etc; 6
is
is
6 times
i,
one-sixth of 6
is
three times 2
one-third of
(first
6, etc.
passes, easily
by
intuition,
is
new
9
facts
--
=8=4
6 times
times
2,
2, 2
one-
fourth of
8,
and so
;
on, to 5 times
2,
etc
So, too, 6
9,
= two
and so
grow
times 3
on.
=6+3=
is,
three times
3,3 = one-third of
from the right presentation of objects, the child forms clear perceptions which almost unconsciously
into a firm grasp of the relations of
That
numbers
in the Multi-
plication
Table
he
and
thus, learning
how
for himself,
left to memorize it by merely mechanThere must be repetition, of course; the table must be so thoroughly memorized that any pair of factors instantly suggests the right product But, if there are a few repetitions of the acts of apprehension by which the several prois
not
ical associations.
ducts are formed, the task of mastering the table will be im-
mensely
lighter
than
if left
to the
symbol-memory
It is clear
is
alone.
Drill.
and
necessary for
goo
METHOD OF INTERROGATION.
work
accumulation of
in all stages
but there
is
a point at which
repetition,
knowledge, or
ful.
skill,
Unintelligent
strengthen
details,
intelligence,
re-
ceaseless questioning
callings of
on unimportant
monotonous
mere sensuous
what
seen,
is
already well
known
destroy
interest,
which, as
on we have
is
essential to attention^
Dealing
if
all in all
as
" from
the concrete to the abstract " means to begin, continue and end
is
only means to
defeats
its
ment.
The
re-action against
equally imperfect
Formerly
Now,
and
is
to
possibly,
this
tangible that so
tion
many teachers are deficient in power of abstracand analysis. The trained mind of a trainer of minds
As
are not B's^ therefore, some H's are not A's, \/ithout the
e.g.,
necessity of resorting to a concrete case, as, things are not men, therefore,
some
living
some men
IVkat
is
the
of the
METHOD OF INTERROGATION.
whose
length
201
A
is
is
Ct
ten feet ?
is
not unfre-
"to
inter-
is,
When
tion
on a lesson
to the fatigue-point,
story," or illustration, in
supposed to be repeated,
and thus " more drill " secured. But the real interest is in the illustration and not in the thought it is supposed to illusChildren have been " drilled," say on the number two, trate. ringing changes on one and one? nothing and two? two less one? two less two ? till under the monotonous repetition interest and
attention die out
;
is
for
more
drill,
and so
interesting stories, of
cats, or
Unin the
doubtedly there
but
it is
not in the
two
it is
no attention
is
amuseCollege
ment
or
attention
even in
That advanced
sort
of
spurious
classes.
It
possible to
tak
veying
" A.
much information or developing much power ^just as Ward, the American humorist," interested many an intelligent audience by his lecture on The Babes in the Wood,
while giving but
little
Sense of Proportion. In
fore, the
there-
aOl
METHOD OF INTERROGATION.
and to give due Sense of Proportion, i.e., so as to repeat the great principles, leading thoughts, rather than subordinate details.
By the majority of
sight of.
teachers this important point is lost In questioning, they make no distinction between the
trivial
points
and
prominent
facts
and
their relations.
Lessons
in reading, geo-
number of questions
child
is
value depended on the be asked upon them. The questioned and re-questioned and cross-questioned,
if their
that can
drilled
and
of
little
value.
times on the equally unimportant details of a lesson in itself of Take the following interesting lesson " The rat sat on
:
a mat, the cat ran to the mat, the rat ran into the box." What are we to think of the model lesson that gives twenty-five or
thirty questions
on such
stuff?
model and a half pages of questions on seven and a half lines of an ordinary reading lesson ? Suppose a child were to be subjected to such a " drill " on every fairy talc
?
an ordeal
pygmy What
size" that
are
is
ruthlessly sub-
we
to think of a
he reads, or every interesting story or biography, how long before fairy tale and story would become an utter abomination
to
him ?
is
ordinarily given
it,
in utter dis-
The
inevitable result
is
attention
and instead of assimilated knowledge and strengthened faculty, there is left a medley of vague notions and disconnected facts, whose only end is to be speedily forflags,
By such
the teacher
mechanisms
after his
own
likeness.
METHOD OF INTERROGATION.
3.
aoj
questioning,
By
vague ideas
nothing
may be made
definite,
misapprehensions removed,
It is
common maxim
able to
that
make out for himself. What he acquires by the exercise of his own powers will remain with him in more enlarged or more accurate knowledge, or at least in increased power of apperception. Of
to be told the learner that he
is
and
needed.
For, while
it
may be
true that
not so
much what
it
is
him unless something is first put into him. It is almost a common-place that* " Telling is not teaching." The truth of this depends on the mental attitude of the taught, and this again, depends chiefly on the kind of telling and the spirit and ability of the teller.
right time
is
Telliug; Questioning. Telling the right thing at the and in the right way, is teaching. Very often time
worse than wasted in a
futile
pupil what has never been questioned into him, and what he cannot by any possibility evolve from his " inner consciousness."
It is one of the best characteristics of a good teacher that he knows exactly when and what to telly as well as when and what The *' telling not teachto impart or to elicit by questioning. protest against the method ing" maxim is thoroughly sound as a
of continuous lecturing.
It is
easy to lecture
it
is difficult
to
good lecturers but not good teachers. With clearness of thought and fluency of speech, they seem to expect that lucid exposition on the part of the teacher will prove an effective substitute for attention and self-activity on
teach; thus,
instructors are
many
The
may have
little
its
though
even there a
desirable
Socratic questioning
now and
then seems
but the method is nearly worthless in the primary and the secondary school The object lesson, the exposition,
04
METHOD OF INTERROGATION,
and assimilated only by
what
is
it
is
and can
But,
and
as
lucid exposition
text-book.
we have
may aid
enting the
by questioning
make
for
and may lead him and to himself the mental connection between the new and
in its proper relations, to see the old
new matter
knowledge
in clearer light,
the old.
Vague made Definite. It has been said that the first ideas got by a child no matter by what process of instruction are necessarily hazy j his mental growth is from the vague to the definite
And
by analysis and synthesis, either conscious or unconscious. as these mental functions are undeveloped in the young
it is
learner,
mind made
ledge
into analytic
definite,
is
Thus
the vague
is
both
it
clarified
is
with which
and enlarged by new growths of material If a pupil, by an errohim the correct answer.
is
we do not
forthwith
tell
made
Guided by a and
Socratic Questioning.
assumed,
The
truth of his
wrong answer
he
dis-
he
is
led
by Socratic
lies,
questioning to a reductio
ad absurdum
argument
he makes the needed corrections ; and thus, ; an active co-worker in the process, he is sure to retain somewhat of real value, both in knowledge and mental discipline. The teacher must guard against the mistake of thinking that because he is using objects in teaching, the child's
METHOD OF INTERROGATION.
ideas cannot
205
will suffice.
No
matter
fully
how well a lesson may be given, no matter how skilthe maxim " from concrete to abstract " may be applied,
knows
is
the
that
;
there
are
some
is
points
that,
though there
a con-
mind there
mind, and he
questions, to
will
make
Illustrations.
of a straight
pupil
may have
line, for
it
He
that a line has not breadth but " position only," yet
he
will re-
to
his eyes,
he
to
describe an equilateral
on the side of
all,
DE
on
(a line) ''remote
from
A?"
"
If
he
thinks at
he
is
somewhat perplexed by
class
this proposition
this
" remote
side.
and suspecting that some '* remote side," etc., put a few questions Has DE, then, two sides ? // has. On which side is the equilateral triangle to be described ? It is to be described on the side reviote from A, If one side of DE is remote from A, what may you say about the other -side? // is near or next to A. Then, how much further from A is the remote %\^t, than the near side? // depends on the width of the line I This was the answer of an eager but perfectly sincere member of the class, and two or three others were quite ready to agree with him. It is not improbable that scores of pupils who have crossed the *' Pons" in triumph, have very misty notions concerning the meaning and reason of construction
examiner testing a
of the class had but crude ideas of "straight line;"
:
An
in this proposition.
mark of a
even axioms and definitions are on their first presentation, clear to the minds of beginners. By examination and cross-examination they are to
be guided in thinking
till
their
vague outlines
beginner in
become
clear
Many a
206
METHOD OF INTERROGATION.
affirm that
when
three lines
;
lips. Some have been known to AD, BD, CD meet in D, only two
if
the
angle
ADB
CD
will
remain. 'Not
is
the
little
tom of
the page
may be
the base, as in
g.
the figure
vi.
A
The
little
pupils clearer ideas of triangle, base, vertical angle, " the other
two sides,"
that
etc.
concrete
knowledge
aid teacher
and pupil
Further Illustrations.
It
minimum
remain
Ideas
obscure
at
first,
obscure
by exercise of the mental functions by which they were apprehended, and by which they may be at once extended and defined. A pupil may have been taught the parts of speech, and the doctrine of grammatical equivalency ; he will have to apply his knowledge many times He must himself corbefore he apprehends it in its fullness. given topic till he reaches on thinkings a imperfect rect his
there
is
a growth into
clearness
perfect thought.
to be confuted,
Take the sentence " The charge is too trifling and deserves to be mentioned only that it may
be despised
A
He
pupil
probably
parse
is
it
He
should be led by
:
METHOD OF INTERROGATION.
ao^
What is only ? If is an adverb modifying mentioned. What does only mean? It means this one thing and nothing more. Hut doiS the speaker mean that the charge deserves to be only mentioned, i.e., that the bare menwould lead to its being despised ? No, that is not the meaning. meaning where should only be placed ? // should be placed Well, what is only ? It is an adverb modifying bifore the verb mentioned. despised. Is the meaning, then, that the charge should be despised and Omitting only, what have we ? nothing more ? That is not the meaning. The charge deserves to be mentioned that it may be despised. Does the charge deserve to be mentioned ? // does. For what reason, or purpose ? That it may he despised. Is there any other reason ? There is no other reason. How do you learn that ? From the word '* only.** Then what is the part of only in the sentence ? It affects the meaning of the clause^ ** That it may
tion of
it
be despised.**
Again, a pupil
is
in
the line
"
The
Reflecting for a
is
moment,
probably
is
therefore,
Now,
nounce the answer wrong, give the correction, and pass on without further concern, and his " teaching," for any lasting effect it can have on the minds of the learners, might as well be But a few questions will enable addressed to the idle winds.
the pupil to correct his
own
errors,
firmly
hold what he has thought out for himself, he has also increased
The paths
lead whither f
is
How do you gather this from the word *^ but," Then, what word or words does but affect ? // affects the meaning of the words, ** to the grave.** And, grammatically, what is the phrase to the grave ? It is an adverbictl phroH
ination ?
line ?
There
is
no other destination.
We gather
it
from
the
modifying lecuU
etc.
OK THK
'^
2o8
METHOD OF INTERROGATION.
to imperfect
many
pupils
really
e.
done
in
finding the
Propose to a
ft.
class
g.,
wide,
work and
its
result
Does
that answer
feet. feet^
How
What
Many
word
length
is
prominent
of the class will give this anin the " rule," and by repe-
of length.
Now, the
else,
something
the correct answer and pass on to and so the pupils who gave the wrong answer
this correction of errors
will retain nothing.
-have apper-
and of course
The
gets
care-
by a few Socratic
minds
to
make
He
them
all
simply
etc.
there are,
is
an
"abstract**
number,
He
draws a
is
figure
on the board
whose area
to be found, performs
Then
1
What
is
What What
JVb, fifteen
others
who having
The
trusty eye
on the
observers that
it
is
not permitted
play
such
fantastics
METHOD or INTERROGATION.
tricks with quantities- -that
209
feet in the
operation,
What have we
15-
done ?
result
5x3 =
Can
the
be got
in
another way
thne
ation
an addend, thus 5ft. +^ft. + j[//. = ij//. Does this operwork any change on the quantity which 5 represents ? It makes no change. Then what is the sum of 5cts + cts + 5cts 1 And of 5 linear ft. + 5 linear ft. + 5 linear ft. Fifteen cents.
times as
But what
is
the area
And
so,
by a few
is
and misconceptions corrected, but also new knowledge is acquired and assimilated with the old. By the principles of the synthetic method {p. 173) ideas are connected into groups, and these groups are used to interpret and assimiOld knowledge is to be brought into vital late new groups. connection with new facts \ and this vital union at the same time gives meaning to the new and strengthens and enlarges the old. To this end the analytic-synthetic method is employed
definite
made
in self-education.
Even
he has to do something
letters to start with, the
for himself.
many
Havmg
word
at,
/,
and
to form the
For inhim and he pronounces the word cat ; the word is then written on the board ; the pupil recognizes the familiar part at, and recalls its sound ; he discriminates the forms of at and cat^ and their sounds^ and
he
discover the sounds of
is
may
b, c,
f,
h, etc.
before
aiO
METHOD OF INTERROGATION.
of
r,
as well as
power
etc.,
to produce
it
letters, ^, f, h,
m,
reading.
When
he has learned to
words, of which at forms a part, he will quickly learn to pronounce when written, and to write when pronounced, all the new
him
will
words which can be formed with the letters now familiar to ; as, e.g.^ pronounce cab, can, etc., and he will write them,
or point
them ol^ on
pronounce them.
In
all this,
questioning directs
him
in
identifying
and discovering.
naming numbers, the
example, he
is
is
Even
activity
pupil's self-
for
10 (3 + 10)
named
teen), and of 4 and i^n, fourteen. Then, name the number composed of 5 and 10 ? 6 and 10 ? etc. What then, does teen mean ? And, similarly, a number composed of two tens is named
twenty (twain-ty
= two-ty),
of
three
tens, thirty
three-ty)
name, then, the number made up of 4 tens ? of 5 tens ? What then does ty mean ? So, in notation, when a pupil etc.
has learned through intuitive teaching, the relation between the
tens
and the
units,
i, 2,
3, etc., it is
is
only necessary to
tell
him
and no
units
and no
units, eta;
and one
unit,
and two
units,
etc
Arithmetic.)
Illustrations.
(i)
We
work
in the school-room.
When
method number-forms the child, very early gains the idea of division of a number into equal
METHOD OF INTERROGATION.
parts,
Ill
which
first
is,
And by
have no great
For example
6,
8, etc.,
Divide
2, 4,
3, 6,
9, 12. etc.,
4, 8, 12, 16,
by 2 ? by 3? etc., by 4?
2, 4,
6, etc. 9, etc.
etc, etc.
Now
of of
"
third
3, 6,
"
" fourth of
tell
4, 8, 12,
etc ?
it
will
be only necessary to
take the half of third of
it,
him
that to divide
a number by
3, is to
2, is
to
it ; i.e.,
to divide a
that there
is
number by
take the
etc,
idea.
change of
It
may
not, indeed,
make even
this explanation.
An
He
know how
:
to take the
He put a
series of questions
in division,
which
all
9 by 3? 12 by 3?
etc.
And
then, without
asked a bright
little fellow: what is the third of 6? After a moment's thought the child replied two; and then answered
one-third of 9
12? etc., and one-fourth of 4? of 8? of 12? etc The other members of the class soon caught the clew, and answered similar questions with equal readiness.
cation
The
inspector
identifi-
what
fix,
is
did you find out what I meant by the question, one-third of 6 ? He replied, " There are three twds in
How
and I thought you meant one of them.^' At the end of the lesson, the class were able to answer such questions as these How do you find the half of a number ?
:
211
METHOD OF INTERROGATION.
third ?
The -th ? How many halvei The fourth ? number ? How many thirds ? How many fourths how many -ths ? What is one-third of 6 ? /zw-thirds ? threethirds ? What is ^//^-fourth of 8 ? two-iownhs ? Mr^^-fourths ? One-ihixd of a number is 4, what is the number ? four-fo\ix\hs ? One-iourth of a number is 5, what is the number? etc., etc.
The
has a
And
ber ?
(2.)
the following
Two-\h\xds of a number
is 6,
v/hat
7%r^^-fourths of a
number
is 9,
what
is
the
numfirst ?
bers in
and 10 per
left
;
cent, of the
remainder
second
battle,
the
army at
What
part of a
number
10 per cent of
it
One-tenth.
is lost,
Nine- tenths
One-tenth of this remainder is lost what part of it reof it. What part of the whole army now mains? Nine-tenths of it.
remains
If 81
hundredths
?
is
one-
hundredth
200 men.
army
e.,
men
/.
20,000 men.
had the horse
cost
$36 more,
there
How many
TwOy
mentioned
What
How many
What
One
selling price.
it
part of a
relation
number
is
10 per cent, of
selling price
cost.
One-tenth.
?
What
between the
Selling price
H cutual
METHOD OF INTERROGATION.
fj
And
Selling price
= -^ supposed
What
What
Ni? answer.
^^^j"'f^ =
AnsweTy
^}
inference?
B=
C.
is
inferred ?
other.
Things which are equal to the same thing are equal to each
two
=^
is
.^
^^ =
y = if of actual
cost.
The
difference is f of actual
cost
f actual
cost
= $36, ^
= $18, and
entire cost
$162.
the expression
are they
of
(3.)
aH"^
+ 3V +
?
What
letters are
involved
a,b,.
How
involved
They
ab + bf^ca.
It is not.
it
make any
difference in your
argument? It
vjill
a + by
will.
still
b + c, c + a^ or
make no difference. If for a,^,r, there be substituted p-q, r-s, t-u, will your answer still be valid? //
for a,b,Cf
When
hold
?
// does.
{X -.v) (y
- z)^ + (y - )
It
is ;
Now,
separately,
{z
- x) -{ {z - x) {x-f).
It
is not.
Compare the
Is (y
with
cU>-\-hc
+ ca,
ab-\-bc-{-ea the
Then
is
(-
-)
- 2)' + etc.?
// is not.
it.
214
At
in
METHOD or INTERROGATION.
this declaration the class
were
gjreatly astonished.
the reasoning?
amined the reasoning again and again ; there was a general marshalling of all the ideas bearing on the matter, there was in a word, some close thinking It would have been hard to condone, before the fallacy was discovered. vince that class, that Mathematical reasoning '* condemns to a minimum of
thought
;
"
that
it is
*'
because
Socratic Questioning, Positive The following is an example of knowledge by questioning. A class had been led discover the two rational factors of
and were now to apply the result to the resolution of certain similar forms, rhe teacher told nothing. What about the symmetry of this question 1 It is symmeiricalin -ha, +^.
+<.
What
is its
linear factor ?
a+3+r
cfl-\-b^-\-c'^
-ab-bcca^
)'
rhich can
^ [{a - *)* + (^ - f
+ (f - df\.
(I).
Now
let
us
what quantities is this symmetrical T No correct answer. How may this be derived from the expression already factored ? No correct The teacher then proceeded to give a few questions leading up to answer.
With
respect to
How may a-\-c be got from a-^-bl A few answer correctly, others incorrectly.
What
shall
we do
\-b.
with a-\-b
'va
order to get
a?
Takeaway
What
shall
we do
is
Add
By By By
+r.
Then how
taking
shall
a + * changed
-^b
away
by
substitutit^ -^c
for +&,
How
a-bl
+b.
Now
what
is
It is derived
State, then,
// differs
from the primitive by substituting - < for^t. how form (l) differs from the primitive? only in having c for +c.
METHOD OF INTERROGATION.
Well,
21$
what can you
infer
we proved
Then what
They can be got from the facts of the primitive by substituting is the linear factor in form (i) t
factor ?
- for +6
a^->fb^\^-ab-{-bc->tca, etc.
How may other forms similar By substituting - b for +^ we for +a we get a third form.
For
the first case
and by
substituting
-m
we have
4:
<z^
^ ea.
the primitive
?
second case
-a-\-b-irc zsAa'^-{-b'^-Vc^-\-ab-bc-\-ca,
Can you suggest how other forms may be derived from For \-b and +^, substitute -b and -c respectively.
What
a* - fi
is
the result?
yibc.
- (* -
The
factors?
a-b-c9L\i6. a-\rb^+(^-\-ab-be-^M.
?
May
for ^r c +a, and again for ^-a + b. And so at the conclusion of the lesson which lasted about 2o minutes the class were able, without a moment's hesitation, to write down the
YeSt by substituting
six derived
factors.
4.
To
Cultivate
and
Retention.
As intimated,
In
fact, it is
Power of Expression ;
this
Effect on Apperception
tains
Apperception.
of
expression
it
is
of Questioning.
The thought
because
power ought
to
be a prominent aim
in all instruction.
Belittling
learning, there
Words.
is
the re-action against mere rote^ " Words, a strong tendency to belittle words.
is
In
filling
the
memory
with
l6
tvords
METHOD OF INTERROGATION.
and making
little
or
no appeal
to the intelligence.
it is
The
plan
is
an easy plan,
we have seen,
little
is
it
But
it is
txracher to check,
or to rather properly
He must
this
see, indeed,
but equally
it is
his
How
is
this to
be done ?
Not by
teaching
definite
teaching
words
alone,
nor things
alone, but
by
and defining them in words. While, therefore, the teacher must be on his guard against teaching empty words, he must be equally on his guard against imparting empty ideas ; for if the word without the idea is empty, the idea without the word is little better than an airy nothing without a local habitation and a name. and
this
by
fixing
Relation of
" The
learner's
Words and
Ideas to Knowledge.
writer, " consists
facts
in ideas gained
by
his
consciously possessed
not
in words.
to him."
if it is
if its
The
learner's
knowledge,
of an organized structure,
con-
clearer^
made more
definite,
made more
comprehensive,
true that if
finally
a child were to
made incarnate in words. It is quite memorize a series of words by sound-sensations, making the connecwords would
But
it
is
symbols of some
sort,
IIEIHOD OF INTERROGATION.
217
f/eld his sense-impressions into definite and permanent forms, and that such wordless mental experiences would not be knowledge in any true sense of the word. The truth appears
to
(if
and that this act of embodiment is a factor and is an essential part of the process of Let the organizing mental faculty by organizing knowledge. teacher remember that, even in the primary stage, " to learri the name of a thing, and to learn how to use this name, involves much more mental action than is required in forming
embodied
words
;
sense-peceptions about
it.**
Words and
only the instruments for the expression of thought, they are also
the instruments of the thinking process
is
Human
speech
the complement of
human
reason, the
gift
without which
it is. Words and the condition of the cultivation of readeserving of the name son, that is, there can be no thinking without words, and no explicit proof that the thinking process
is
its
For the
oh
expression, oral
expression, oral
expression.
and written; and of clear thinking, is cleai and written. Definite thought means definite Vague expression means equally vague thought.
No
have been
this is
act of thinking is complete till its products set forth in words. And the manner in which
done marks the character of the thinking and the
eflfeo-
fol-
should be
lesson
it is
in
language.
It
a lesson in thought,
is
it
and only so
far as
it
is
a language lesson
an
effective
2l8
thought lesson.
to
METHOD OF INTERROGATION.
Every lesson,
in all stages of learning,
is
given
awaken the self-activity of the child, to cause thinking. It is only by questioning that we can determine the matter and manner of his thinking ; it is only by questioning that we can determine
whether the
final step
is
been taken,
and completed
when he has
and promptly. If we give a lesson which demands the thinking of relations we know that the act of thought has been
properly
performed when
mental product
it
is
So,
shown
elicit
in the character of
by the Socratic
art.
We
is
necessary to
The
intended to convey.
If a pupil
teacher
his
may be
mind. The teacher must not be deceived by the earnest This means nothing except, plea, " I know, but I cannot tell."
perhaps, that the
mind
is
more
The
thought-elements, mental
and discriminating laws of Intelligence are to act still further, before distinct and finished forms appear. Let the thing be clearly seen, says Horace, and the willing words will foicow.
nebulae, are there, but the unifying
and Expression.
it
From down
may be
laid
is
sound principle
that direct
and
clear expression
effort to
speak with
di-
METHOD OF INTERROGATION.
rectness
SI
and
precision reacts
maxim akin
to that con-
Knowing
As knowing
and doing
on knowing, so think-
and speaking
it, 1.^.,
on thinking.
A man
is, till
much
less
he has clothed
in words.
it
in
spoken
in
The
thought
trained
master of
the word-embodied comes forth, whether in oral or in written speech, a thing of strength and beauty. But the immature mind of the learner is far below such power A thought, as it first appears in his of thought and speech. mind, is vague, and, in its expressed form, it bears the marks of But it is now before him in audible and in this vagueness.
thoughts at
is
it
visible
form
this objectified
thought
as
it
tioning of his teacher, and aided by the visible (or audible) form before him, he turns the thought over and over in his
mind, each successive mental act being aided by the verbal expression of the preceding one
as the expression of
it,
till
is
as perfect as he
can make
is
:
it.
The
therefore,
First the
Thought, then the Oral Expression of the thought, then the Written Expression of it. Thus the interaction between thought
and expression
mind
in
its
ous Explanation
manifest
220
METHOD OF INTERROGATION.
is
secondary schools
pupil too
little.
much and
and
it is
the
talk
It is easier
And
common
of the
teacher,
ensure
clear
the thought,
self-activity
oral
The
may
lesson in which
done all the talking is nearly worthless. A lesson during which the class have- been questioned into clear and direct expression, and which ends with reducing to written forms the best that has been thought and said, is of permanent value, because it enlarges knowledge and strengthens and dethe teacher has
velops faculty.
Course to be followed.
wise teacher follow
ing,
?
What
As
of learn-
in correct expression.
By
and correct language in his explanations and suggestions, and by clearly and definitely expressed questions, he stimulates the pupil to a similar clearness and distinctness of thought and speech. At the beginning of the lesson he has the pupils correctly express the groups of ideas bearing upon the subjectclear
matter of the
new
lesson.
the outward form of imperfect thought, and with an apt suggestion or a brief but lucid explanation, he questions the class
and well-defined thought clothed in chosen words. mere verbal memory is at work in rule or formula, or reproduced expression, and questions and cross-questions the reciter till his empty words are filled with Point by point he presents his solid and connected thoughts.
into clear
He
METHOD OF
expression of the several
insists
INTERROGATlbllCi^/
Of-
^-T^tft^
Concluding the lessSnTlJc parts. on a connected summary, and what was grasped and
is
now reproduced
is
in
connected
form
test
its
instruction
and
for
of
value in discipline.
to each
member
the
that
If
said.
such a course as
to
followed
and
it
can be followed
studies
will
in all stages,
mere
picture,
advanced
class
that
an imnot be
portant point
in the
much need
knowledge.
doubted growth
Illustrations. The rule to be followed is : in a// classes, from the lowest primary to thehighest class, no thought without If a child has had a lesson in which an idea has expression.
been developed, as that of an angle, or of the color violet, or of weight, the idea has not been clearly grasped, the lesson is
incomplete, unless the word and the idea are so closely associated that the one instantly recalls the other.
If
an easy
thought has been acquired, as that a cube has six faces, the
of the value of the lesson.
and written expression of the thought is the proof If by the use of objects and practice 1 examples, the facts about the number /our have been taught and learned, there must be facility in expressing the facts, and ability to use them in making and rightly expressing applied examples ; as e. g, three and one are four, four less one is three, etc; Charlie has four cents, if he gives Susie one, and spends one for a pencil, how many has he left ? Suppose a lesson on
prompt
oral
the text,
223
METHOD OF INTERROGATION.
Politeness is to do
and say
in the kindest
way :
play-ground
thing said in the kind way, are illustrated in the concrete value of the lesson depends
the
on the exact
A
;
water
presses
directions,
is
etc
the lesson
not complete
From
struction
the
end
is
when
all
that can
be expressed
is
reproduced
and
beautiful speech.
is
More than
lost
Train power
and
Too
membra
We
is
have
known
consid-
ered the greatest of orators ; they had done much construing, had done much of the author's work into a kind of English ; his
first
clumsy garb
rendered a solitary
meagre vocabulary; they had never paragraph from the majestic Greek into
What
is
power?
if we may be pardoned the perversion of language, without ever having caught a note of his lyric music To such unfortunates, even if
Thus, too,
many
METHOD OF INTERROGATION.
the intellect fairly grasped the
27^
read,
may
well be applied
It is
To understand, not feel, his lyric flow, To comprehend, yet never love, his verse.
Of course
meaning and end
lines of
there
by fragments
till
the
in
Take
the
Horace
dissociabili
lish possible
grammar is simple ; there could not well Where then is the value of the consists in rendering the thought into the best Engby the combined efforts of teacher and learner. If,
the
patching together the fragments with which he began, the student ends with " the prudent god has cut off lands in vain by
the unsociable sea,'' the lesson is all but worthless. But the work may be made of lasting value, if he be questioned and cross-questioned, on the poetic adequacy of different words, till by the united effort of master and scholar, something approacJiing Conington's fine lines
is
reached
Has
224
METHOD OF INTERROGATION.
CHAPTER
X.
Method of Interrogation.
we
Continued,
as concerned
now
consider such
(b)
Mind.
Since the two processes are correlative,
been
fore,
said,
under the
first
we
shall, there-
The purposes
(4)
to be studied
under
this
head are:
(3)
To
To Arouse
Attention
To
Direct Attention
To
Questioning.
To Excite Interest. ^We have seen (page 164) that inThis prinstruction must be based on the interest of the pupil.
I.
ciple
is
What
in,
the
miud
it
is
will
attend
is
to,
i.e.y
it
will
exercise
its activity
upon
it
not interested
has for
practically
activity
no existence.
itseit,
it is
tal
There may be interest in the menin the object upon which it works, in desired to reach, and interest may be exor
rational
motives.
if this
All instruction
is
an appeal to some
it is
activity,
and
activity
free
and
unimpeded,
naturally pleasureable.
movement
is
as spontaneous as piiysicai
right conditions,
both ought to be equally a source of delight. It is the function of the teacher to appeal to these spontaneous activities so as to increase rather than diminish the pleasure
METHOD OF INTERROGATION.
naturally arising from them.
free activity
925
We may
briefly consider
how
thii
may be
sented to
the first place: by and connected questions the matter may be prethe pupil's mind in a way best suited to his capacities
In
and attainments.
in
less likely to
is
is
led to
His progress is one of invention and discovery ; his curiosity is kept on the alert ; he unexpectedly perceives the old in the new, he identifies ; what was dim
acquisitions for himself
make
into a
luminous thought,
he discriminates ; he pursues, in short, a method of investigation differing only in degree from that of the greatest thinkers
and discoverers
thrill
in philosophy
life.
and
science,
and
is
of healthful menial
Thus, there
produced the
self-activity
effort,
and
de-
of investigation.
clear teaching
The Clear
*'
Teacher.
On the importance of
as opposed to merely
we
it was easy to be dear in teaching ; in fact want more constant attention, and even preparaTo make his own words precise and clear-cut ; to put complicated tion. things in lucid order and simple language to search out for the point and
sight as if
to avoid
formulae as
much
as
may
be,
and constantly
;
to use
words by
rote
:
when
there
are difficulties, to
shew exactly where the difficulties are to lead on confused answers till the confusion, and the exact point of the confusion, become apparent to cross-question neatly and succintly half knowledge, so
:
as at once to expose
its
to define
exactly in a
226
muddle
:
METHOD OF INTERROGATION.
these are
is
and such
clearness
excessively stimulating.
Interest.
In
The
potent
allies
of the teacher
(p. 1 16).
In
this consists
one of the
lecturing
art.
Where
there
is
much
by the comes
ies as
teacher, there
to feel that
is
is
little
real thinking
by the
pupil.
He
he
is
the lecturer
by one, and each successful effort brings a glow of satisfaction and a sense of growing pow^r. Inspire a boy with confidence in his ability to do a thing, and the thing is already half done ;
all his
all his
ideas bearing
on the subject will be brought to the front, and used by the To know quickened mind in assimilating the new material. when to tell, and when not to tell, to evoke the maximum of energy with the minimum of telling, is the mark of a teacher as compared with a mere expositor. There is, in general, too much talkmg by the teacher, and too little talking and thinking by the
.
learner.
This
isf
no doubt,
partly
many
But,
to enable
it is
them to make the best of very imperfect conditions. due to popular ignorance of the nature of education, which demands of the teacher more than he can possibly accomplish, and almost forces him to follow the exposialso partly
tory
method
in the vain
hope
that
what
is
clearly explained
fiictor in
in Culture. It is foi^otten that time is a necessary b an organic growth, the growing organism being And so, from a spirit of false a living soul in union with a growing body. economy, a double burden is imposed on the teacher. In proof of this, con-
Time a Factor
education which
METHOD OF INTERROGATION.
sider the
227
number of pupils a single teacher is expected to " educate ;'* the number of branches, disciplinary and practical, he is supposed to handle as
educating instruments
;
is
allotted
him
is
work.
Consider the
Divisions,"
swarms of
where,
if
little
"Primary
to
our psychology
required
the part
no won-
der that even the earnest and able teacher, in presence of such a task
is
own
is,
self-activity
that ought to
It
be done
perhaps, vain
hope that the multitudinous writers and speakers who are so ready with nostrums for the " improvement of the teachers and the schools," may devote a portion of their energies to the removing of certain disabilities
their
which make impossible the task now assigned to the teacher. And the watch-word of the first campaign in behalf of needed reforms, might well
be
:
for the
For
double
the higher grades, double the time or half the snbjects^ox better
the time
AND
half the
subjects.
Law
he
to
is
of Self-Education.The
teacher, then,
is
to use as
;
much
He
is
awaken
Happily
this
drawn upon
ceeded
in
Every teacher has seen on the face of the little child who has sucdoing what had threatened to baffle him. It may be
in all stages of instruction.
mak.ng of a
letter,
or
it
may be
the combination of
known
letters into
three
in
is
a challenge to
class
effort,
and
of conscious power.
With but
little
can be led to a
fair
they
will
228
selves, fractions
METHOD OF INTERROGATION.
and
this
all
is
science.
And
school curricula.
teacher
who
explains much,
who
anticiin.
and
is
trusts
more than half his power. This is the tendency of things today. There is too much coddHng demanded by indulgent parents; the teacher is expected to do everything for the pupil, who is to do little or nothing for himself Against this tendency, the able and faithful teacher must be on his guard ; he must arouse and deepen interest by developing conscious power. Tfu boy must
shorn
educate himself.
dependent investigation,
Sjnupathy, and
Interest.
In
the
third place
It
has
been seen again and again that sympathy (pp. 113, 120) and Where interest are great mental forces in the work of educating.
there
is
sympathy there
is
is
interest,
with
all
it.
Sympathy
pathy
is
;
Sym-
in the
is
in the
world of
matter
worlds,
by the one
maintained unity
among
the systems of
by the other
In the school-room
put
it is
To
teach well,
the
weak;
become a
child."
This relation
between teacher and taught, can be created by sympathy, For, it is impossible to get near and by sympathy alone. a child, to win his affection and his confidence, without know-
and
ing him, without a clear insight into the workings of his mind And this is the gift of sympathy. The seventh heart.
beatitude of the Divine Teacher is as sound in philosphy as it " Blessed are the pure in Heart is deep in spiritual significance :
for
they
shall
see
God
" that
is.
syjnpathetic in heart,
eya.
METHOD OF INTERROGATIOW.
fl29
A man
little
in
is
word
lacking the
gift
of insight, he
he may be a hearer of
recitations,
an ex-
positor of subjects, a
martinet of discipline,
an enforcer of
he has no and through the heart, to fashion mind into a form of blended strength and beauty. On the other hand, there is not a more beautiful sight than strong brain and kindly heart working on the plastic mind of childhood. It is hard
spurious attention, a prince of rule
routine, but
and
power
it
is
pathy.
is
presence
felt;
by the mterrogative
itself
He
for
feels
he
is
and they become interested in it for his sake \ he questions their minds into a communion with his, till the strong "sympathy of love unites their thoughts."
Mind
mind
first,
to Mind.
The
knows when
;
his
is
he has
;
at
he has
his error
and
fertile in
resources
feels,
he quickly touches the responand the children feel, that teacher and
There
;
is
perhaps no greater
her knows that bond of sympathy has been formed through which alone Through it, he becomes a true educating power can pass. rather increasing his manly child in heart without losing He moves down from his superior plane strength of intellect. pf learning and power ; step by step he comes, till he reaches
the
te
230
the lowly plane
METHOD OF INTERROGATION.
where children stand, and with a portion of
that
It is
hem
of
garment, and that with every touch there goes forth a quick-
Now, while the entire atmosphere of the school is one of sympathy, and thus influences the general school life, it is in actual teaching, especially by the Method of Interrogation^ that it works
with personal power.
There
is
a concentration of the
inel
depends, in no
small degree,
upon
the former.
Under
its
this
condition effective
teaching
is
possible.
The
mind
to
normal action
and
breathless interest
is
and brightening
e} e,
not in vain.
Arousing the
Dull.
The
questioning
by which
the
members
is
some sem-
deepened by the
teacher's interest
The
who learn
with difficulty
it is
the
heavy-laden ones
for the
whom
he
likes to
burden.
The measure
his
Clever pupils
even
the
and the teacher shows but little and especially the " slow of heart,*' can be aroused only by the touch of a master hand Now, to the highest mental activity of which they are capable.
matter
is
imperfectly presented,
ability,
33
whole
class
is
deepened.
The
ability are
on the
is
alert,
and
acts
ot
Mind
bom
cer-
tain
newness of
life.
Nor does
fail
to put questions
there
this,
is
something within
tMr grasp,
and under the vitalizing impulse, unwonted energy, and the teacher
whom
It often
happens,
all
as
when
a student
who
and
vice versa ;
or, occasionally
one who
is
literature.
:
Personality, and
pathy,
In
The
the
fourth place
Symhe
we have
and
sympathy
may
sympathy which
which
is
way
He
i?
With the
clearei
comes from human sympathy, he has constantly him the intricate points with which the child is wrestling, and affectionately aids the struggling mind into And so, the child feeling again and again, the clearer light.
before
comes from conquest of difficulty, turns with blended and reverence to his inspiring leader. In this way is created a vital relation between the learner and the teacher, and everything that the one shows a deep interest in, becomes a source of interest to the other.
thrill
that
feelings of gratitude
9^
personality.
METHOD OF INTERROGATION.
Sympathy united with enthusiasm constitutes a powerful More than anything else, it is this personality Learning and method will that makes the successful teacher.
little
be of
is
interest,
enthusiasm in the
work, for this alone can arouse the interest and stimulate the
powers of the
ality
child.
The fundamental
itself,
principle
is
that person-
communicates
that there
is
intellectual
If a subject has
interest
for
can
have
no
but
sympathy,
make
all
under
the
still
work of mental and moral development. He takes will ; he makes an attractive subject
attractive
; ;
more
ered charms
for
He
of
The
despiser of classics
becomes an
enthusiastic student
Homer and
geometry
Method
It is the power and permanent effect to all les ongiving; and especially is it this that moulds the character of More than knowledge, it imparts lo /e of knowledge the pupil. and ability to acquire it ; more than mere information about right and wrong, it forms character^ which shows itself in a spon-
METHOD OF INTERROGATION.
33
In the interminable discussions about "methods," therefore, it should be remembered that the true method for the Educator, is not to be found among the scores of ways, plans, devices,
Erudition, knowledge of
have their place, a high place. But the highest place must be given to Personality, It is almost impossible to over-rate the influence of a strong personality.
influences
history has known, or perhaps will know, may be traced to its forming and transforming power. It operates in the schoolroom,
re-
spects infinitely the nature of the child, and comprehends the laws Too much reliance on methods as methods, of its development.
dull,
deadening,
benumbmg,
This
is
and
pupil.
due
the
teacher
and
it
its
Give the
by putting
Personality, not
a machine which you yourself have modelled. method, is the only power to produce per-
sonality;
formally
the true
method based on recognition of personality both and m its contents, gives the mesmeric energy of In this informing spirit, sympathy united with teacher.
enthusiasm,
is
John Morley,
we watch the voyagings of humanity from the " wide, depths " of time. Those have been greatest in lampless grey,
out as
thought
pathy,
2.
best
endowed with
faith,
hope, sym-
and the
of effort
To Arouse Attention.
attention
/>.,
r^ferred to
(page 37).
A question
a challenge
to attention
and
If there is to
be any true
learn-
234
ing
METHOD or INTERROGATION.
true relation between the
any
mind and
the object-mai
ter,
Questioning
is
is
the only
maintained.
it
what does
It
implies
it
forming an app^jrceiving
be brought to the
mind shall
made
fresh
and
new
and related groups may be so grafted upon them organic growth takes place.
In the
early
that an
stages
of learning
this
can be secured by
If the teacher simply
in the dark as to
how
the
is
mind of
no
the pupil
is
dealing
witii
the explanations.
There
real attention,
no
in
mind
move from
is
point
to
point
discovering relations.
The
first
clearly
necessary to enable
calls
up
that
knowledge
and then, by a
it
lesson
between the matter of the new and the freshened knowledge of the old.
Illustration.
If,
for
example, a master
is
going to give a
first lesson on compound addition, he asks himself what is the relation between the new rule and the rules the pupil has already learned ? What ideas must be clear and fresh in the child's mind that he may firmly grasp the connection, />., recognize in the (apparently) new the familar features of the old ? What are the resemblances, what the differences ? The only difference of
METHOD UF INTERROGATION.
course,
is
335
in the
mode
of notation
compound
rule.
He
calls
mind
that
etc.;
make one
make
and the
this
under
sum number of tens to be carried as, e.g.^ when the aggregate of the units' column is 57, and we consider this as 5 tens and 7 units^ we really divide 57 by 10 ; etc Thus, by recalling vividly to the learner's mind
the units' column
;
(3)
in
doing
we
all
common
is
to the
two
no new
principle
and are
easily
apprehended
of the old.
the new
is
number
a number has
fourths, etc.
that
one of
its
;
halves
equal
that three of a
a necessity in
all
adjustment, the
There must be preparatory mental revivified, must be made ready, then there follows the process of attention, of making right connections, till the goal of the unknown is reached and found to
the
to the
known
unknown.
known must be
be the
known made
larger
and
clearer.
first
reads
its
meaning.
This serves as a
may be
said,
come from further study and teaching. In other words, though this general idea may be vague, it is his starting point, it is what he will use when he goes over the lessen again, in acquiring a clearer idea of the whole
by getting clearer ideas of its parts. whole is thoroughly assimilated*
And
till
th
236
3.
METHOD OF INTERROGATION.
To Direct
Attention.
Concentration
After the
its
of
act of attention,
mind with
follows ?
towards
by questioning.
His untrained mind cannot make the right preparatory adjustment of ideas, much less can it seize upon resemblances, notice differences and discover the law of connection which comprehends variety
in
unity.
He
is
of
No matter how
may
be presented by text-book or lecturer, his immature powers cannot make the needed analysis, exclude the irrelevant, seize
upon the
salient points,
right connections.
Thus,
make
the material,
related ideas
and
till
skilfully
of
This
orderly
Whatever may be the subject matter of a lesson, there is an way of presenting it, which tends to form the habit of
Illustrations.
If
a lesson
is
to
on the Least Common before him the central truths, that the Least Common Multiple of several numbers must contain all the different (diCioxs found in the several numbers, and each of these in the highest power in
Multiple, the teacher will keep clearly
METHOD OF INTERROGATION.
which
it
237
occurs.
He
form
;
will
not at
first,
in this abstract
the principle.
up to a clear conception of For the Least Common Multiple of 6 and 8, e.g., he proceeds somewhat as follows :
The
factors oi 6 ?
and
3.
What,
then,
?
(l).
and
2.
3, .^.,
The
factors of
8?
What What
//
therefore must
?
(2).
8, viz.^
then must a
common
must contain
and
(2).
(2) suffice ?
factor in (l).
The
Is
it
result is
2?
No, for 2
the foregoing
simply
under consideration,
must
Again
Pons)
tion,
:
Take
the famous
fifth
proposition of Euclid,
I.,
(the
if
a boy of
common
is
ability fails to
master
this proposi-
it is
fourth proposition
and
if
this
is
arise ?
fourth proposition,
will
is
in his hands.
He
hardly stumble,
much
less
fail,
when he
of
all,
attacks the
fifth.
is
first
preparatory adjusting
boy is tested upon his knowledge ot the fourth proposition ; his knowledge must be practical, .r., capable of ready application to easy cases ; a few easy exercises leading up to the pons, are given,
etc
Then
there
is
a directing of attention
there
is first
of
all attention
to
238
METHOD OF INTERROGATION.
;
:
then to
part
in
two
triangles
which the
is proved; then part second, in which the on the base is proved ; lastly, part thirds in and second parts are used, and the conclusion
is
formally inferred.
Thdt
is,
sub.livided, analyzed,
in
its
With such a
direction of
oi
famous proposition
assured.
is
of universal application.
In a
litera-
common
ture, in
gem
of
a chapter of history,
there must be
some
unity, a
And
To
this unity
in
of
attention
at the
wholes in one
act,
and to give
is
same
This goal
reached
analytic
and discriminating, that is, by the exercise of the mind's and synthetic functions, which are best trained through
of Interrogation.
the
Method
The
questioning
which condiffer-
tendency to notice
test
of the
development of attention.
this habit.
^)oints
I perceive,
what
is it ?
What
are the
?
which connect
is
it
Wherein
like,
they?
These facts that are before me what relation have These relations are they comprehended in a wider law ? In this problem what are the facts or conditions given ? What is the thing sought ? Are any of these conditions irrel^-
known ?
METHOD OF INTERUOGATION.
rant?
139
What
spirit
its
relations are
explicitly given,
all
what impHctly
powers
Such a
the activities of
attention,
and
relating
^and
be formed by
difficult,
logical questioning
and by
with a
The pouring
or by teachers
who
The wordy teacher has been referred to ; the wordy annotator deserves a passing notice. He is more to be dreaded than The young learner will sometimes venture to question the wordy teacher. the scientific or literary accuracy of the oral instructor ; but he receives
with unquestioning reverence the printed statements of the annotator.
we have
rarely
found a
to question a statement
made by
lines
:
In the
Yet e'en these bones from insult to protect, frail memorial still erected nigh. With uncouth rhymes and shapeless sculpture decked
Some
known
is
and both teachers and learners had accepted itly, the famous Elegy had not been considered in its unity, nor had there been any
it,
its
related parts.
Take
the well
*
known
si,
lines of
Horace
Hunc,
sa^^ds of students
*
This joys,
wind
rise."
Through
triple
240
for
METHOD OF INTERROGATION.
to ask whethei
fiction.
We
amazement of a
" after
all.
certain class
and the
indig-
might be no
ing, of
**
Graecism
The
habit of self-question-
independent thought,
is
Study
the
II.
We may
Ao
Endowments.
Under
indis-
good teaching
Thorough Knowledge.
Clear
teaching
is
necessary and
is
to this,
What a teacher does not know he cannot teach; what he does not know well, he cannot teach well. To know a subject well, it must be known in its relations to kindred subjects. A single, isolated fact, or principle, as we have seen,
essential.
; to become knowledge, to have any effect on must be grasped in its relations. It follows, then, that an instructor must know of a subject far more then he inIf, in mathematics, for example, he is ignorant tends to teach.
is
not knowledge
it
intelligence,
if
he were a
If
name of teaching.
scholarship
is,
Indeed, since
knowledge
is
one,
it
may
knowledge.
iti
He
;
relations
he
will
know know
he
will see
;
it
in
he
will
be
more
art
;
fertile in illustration
and
he
will
METHOD OF IRTERROGATION.
lessons.
24
take the ground
is
They are
who
going
is
The primary
and
sometimes argued,
to
cipher, he
is
minimum
of knowledge
maximum
feebly
comprehends
vigorous effort ?
little
culture-value,
the
more necessary
well as the
have a
liberal
culture, as
power of
insight into
all
human
others,
it
nature.
is
the
is
of greatest value.
The beginnings
*'
The
child
is
manhood
and
his
his
sides,
far as
time
and circumstances permit.*' This view of primary work is not an ideal one which we may imagine but never hope to realize. The standard aimed at is easily within the reach of the earnest cultivated teacher ; it is far beyond the crude empiric whose fitness for the teacher's high vocation is an imperfect knowledge of the mechanical trivium, reading, writing and arithmetic.
In the more advanced work,
is
it is
The
his
command
character
and admiration
for
Thoroughly
master of his subject, he moves along with conscious, yet unpretentious power,
and
his
242
METHOD OF INTERROGATION.
Briefly, in all
an able leader.
dergarten
teaching,
to the
University, wherever
is
to
be true
wherever power
to
be organized by
perative condition is To organize faculty, the teacher must have organized knowledga
(2) preparation of Lessons. should be thoroughly prepared.
It
follows
that
every lesson
However conversant a teachei may be with the subject-matter of a lesson, he will know better for teaching purposes, if he makes special preparation.
ii
He may
is
if
he
about to teach
to a
new
class,
it
will
have a
fresh interest
for him.
strong
same
while interest
pathy.
be broadened and freshened by increasing knowledge, is still further deepened by the power of sym-
felt
the
thrill
that
comes
in teaching
ele-
ments he
is
mind of
the child
is
to the awakening of
new
life
and
strength.
The
teacher
what to him
is
On
the
comes from
half
imperfect
effect
preparation of a lesson.
what he has thoroughly prepared ; what, from want of prepara Instead tion is only half knowledge, leads to feeble teaching.
of
moving
step
is
and keen eyes are quick to see that he is in a maze without a clue. To be ready in resource, to have freshness of mind, to possess and to inspire confidence, to arouse
feebly wavering,
METHOD OF INTERROGATION.
843
and develop mind, the golden rule to be followed in all teaching, from a lesson on the cube to one on Differential
Equations,
is
:
Make Thorough
Power.
Preparation of the
trained in-
Lesson.
(3) Analytic
tellect
;
at
he should possess analytic power. ** Present one thing This implies a time," is one of the soundest of maxims. been analyzed, the connection
of
presented
If the
and
at
teacher
is
his questions
his pupils
apprehend
one thing
at a time ?
*'
Once more,
in order to
muddled
it
brain.
is
And
if
that
is
the teacher,
in
its
right connection,
so that the pupil re-thinking the related things, in the end re-
the intellect.
The
analytic habit of
mind
is,
perhaps, three-
A fruitful
;
source of failure
is
method
in teaching.
logical
Speaking generally, the untrained mind cannot be and the illogical mind cannot teach. The mechanical
and
show
that a
Knowledge of Mind. All our previous study goes to knowledge of psychology is indispensable to the
It
is
true educator.
mind
that the
skill is
His method
is
good, his
244
great,
METHOD OF INTERROGATION.
only so
far as
He may have
and methods and maxims, about ** how to teach and how not to teach," but if he knows little or nothing of the laws, principles, and results of mental activity, his methods and his devices are likely to be only crude experiments, knowing
no law, or unity, or definite aim. know the laws of mind, and make
its
The teacher,
all
then, should
questioning, tributary to
spontaneous
he should
empiric
is
is
questioning a mind.
is
The
to question about
mind
But the
Artist^
by which
it
subordinates
method and
all
its
instruments, to
mind and
its
development.
Questioner of Mind.
(5) Practice
in
Questioning.
The
reciprocal
action
be-
tween knowi?7g and doing has been frequently pointed out. Long and intelligent practice is necessary to skill in any art. Let the
In seeking the
the
way
is
to excellence let
him
remember
alone,
By
way
doing alone,
is
way
endless
by knowing
the
long;
the
way
(6)
is
Personal Endowments.
Under
this
head but
little
need
It has been seen be added to what has already been advanced. of the qualifications in the element vital the personality is that Energy, enthusiasm, decision of character, sympathy teacher.
and the
insight
it,
no method, mechanical
METHOD OP INTERROGATION.
rational,
145
can be a substitute
himself.
no
slight
degree communicates
ing with
follow-
numb rigidity
meanmg he has
and moral
never grasped, drags his pupils through a dull and dreary routine of unprofitable facts, touching the intellectual
who
also
is
human
spirit, will,
pupils, plant in
sal
them moral
spirit
love of man.
he touches the
intellect
indeed, but touches also the moral and religious nature, inspires a reverence for the divine spirit of the Gospel, " which is
on the
destinies of
mankind."
He who
teacher
Great, with
would
well
all
may
keep
in
work of the school is concerned, school-masters are earnestly reminded above everything to prepare themselves for teaching by heartfelt prayer for themselves, and ask from the Giver of all good gifts, wisdom, and patience,
Prussian teachers
*'As far as the
that their exertions
blessed.
In particular
pater-
them a heart
may
discharge the
on them as teachers, willingly and without grudge, remembering that they can accomplish nothing, not even gain the hearts of the children, without the divine aid and Spirit of
duties lying
Jesus, the friend of children."
III.
Matter and
Form
of Questions,
What
is
will suffice to
246
give a short
METHOD OF INTERROGATION.
summary of the
characteristics of questioning as to
Matter,
{a)
As
We may
Questions should be perfectly definite, i.e. (i.) Z>e^mteness. unambiguous, precise, and corresponding to some assigned pan
of the subject.
questions,
i.e.,
questions which
(page
167.)
definite
and
in clear, terse
and
precise language.
Both of these
rules
life,"
may be
Jerusalem
given
Qlustration.
?
"
"What occurred in Palestine after the destruction of To answer that question would require on the part of the
student an extraordinary gift of mind-reading. **If you ip\a.ce a over b what does it mean ? " The teacher had in mind a way of representing
division
;
but, a
the meaning of
**
boy would have been quite right in respectfully asking for ** over," and ** it." What influence do you draw from the
till
a certain temperature
is
reached,
and then begins to expand?" " What sort of quantity is a' + a^-r6'?" "In this poem, explain the devices of contrast and contiguity." And so on.
A teacher in
nership."
training
trial
lesson
on "Part-
ceeded as follows
"
A man comes to the city to begin a certain business and finds that
answer being given, the teacher said
'*
it
will
?
take $2,000 to start the business, but he has only $1,000, what will he do
"
some of you can answer," and repeated the question, stating the supposition and ending with " Wnat ** After another solemn pause, one boy said Please, sir, he will he do? " would borrow a thousand dollars." This was a very good answer, but not The teacher was plainly taken aback, but said "No, the required answer. the man wa a stranger in the city, and could not borrow a thousand dollars. What would he do, think a moment?" "After another pause, a thoughtful boy who was perfectly sincere said Please, sir, if a man had a thousand dollais of his own, and had a good character, couldn't he borrow another
surely
:
No
METHOD UF INTERROGATION.
thousand?"
247
Which was a perfectly correct and business-like view of the The showing considerable thought on the part of the answerer. teacher was now driven to answer his own vague questions ; in other words, at the end of the lesson, the boys had learned that, in the opinion
case,
man
with
**
another
man
minute
effort to
a twenty
The
is
Vague questions have an exceedingly mischievous tendency. thoughtful boy honestiy endeavouring *' to pay attention," bewildered, and is likely to become inattentive to what he
cannot understand.
questions are a
To
the
less
conscientious boys,
such
premium on " guessing ; " they often hit upcn^^ the answers expected by the teacher, and so gain so6e <9feSS^ iig^^
through dishonesty.
-^^^^t?
(2) Logical Sequence. In the Second Place : Froril Sdl^j^Qg^ has been already said upon the necessity of presenting facts in ~^-;
their relations,
it
follows
that questions
should be connected,
already said,
mind
into
conscious
more that, in all grades of instruction, there can be clear thinking, and actual assimilation on the part of the learner, only when there are clear thinking (analysis and synthesis) and connected instrucThe most fruitful source of tion on the part of the teacher. weak and ineffectual teaching to-day is, without doubt, the lack
thinking of the relations.
It
may be
stated once
all
the preposterous
made
do duty in exposing the weakness of educational work. But there is no doubt that dispersive and discursive teaching and questioning are partly responsible. It seems impossible th9^
248
all
METHOD OF INTERROGATION.
the absurd answers are
due
stupidity.
The
candidates
must,
suffered
from immethodical
questioning.
Of such
who gave
?
the
What
Ife wrote
Of course some
familiar topic
license
may be allowed
on
a
"
In review-questions, a
little
skipping round
may be
in all
In
should give place to the topical (page 174) reviews for testing the thorough mastery of the work.
When
them
method
demands
of
facts,
now be
To
lead
to
Capacity.
In order to
interest,
stimulate, questions
must be
skillfully
is,
and mind-wandering
As a
will
{c)
In the
many
safe,
exceptions, especially
But the
guiding principle
is
METHOD OF INTERROGATION.
(4)
facts
349 mportant
Due
Proportum,
As the
all
excluded.
similar
ers.
minds of the
learn-
Question upon the points of the lesson according to their importance, (page 202.)
{b)
As
to the
Form
of Questions.
What
has been
said
as to their form.
(i)
few of these
may be
and
noticed.
Good Language.
wordy, obscure,
Comteachers
fairly successful
would be astonished
in written form.
racy of the
**
report."
final
Muddled
to avoid
Varied.
monotony, and
Some
(
the
same forms,
etc).
in fact-subjects,
Elementary Geography,
g.,)
in thought-subjects
e.
Interest.
(3)
Questioner's
250
METHOD OF INTERROGATION.
interest.
Do
not be the
of the
set
It
Sunday-school Guide.
may be remarked
is
not to be a blind
follower of the limited rule " teach only what the child underis
words "
may be
wisely used.
them ; "
using them.
(4) Elliptical
Questions.
This
It
is
all
possible
forms,
(5)
and should be
Topical
rarely used.
and
Serial.
by the
topical
method.
Mode
the mode of putting questions, (i) Effective class questioning the result of a judicious use of the individual
and the
class
the
methods, (2) In general, the questions should be addressed to clasSy the answers given by the individual. (3) Unless the
is
teacher
at fault, a question
is
As
to
At the beginning
may
rapidly
forming relations,
Finally, in reasonable time should be allowed for the answer. a review of the lesson, and in general reviews, question and
(5) Mutual questionan excellent test and stimulu?,. To put a good question upon a subject, one must know it well A pupil, knowing he will be called on to put a question, is kept on the alert, he is
attentive;
and
METHOD OF INTERROGATION.
habit of self-questioning, the attitude
2$\
of the thinking
mind
(page 238).
(6)
IVritten
written examinations.
tion of thought
There should be frequent From what has been said upon the relaAnswers.
it
and language,
tions are
IV.
Under
brief
this
little
to be said that
is
not given
;
summary
or,
(i)
Good
answering,
results.
in
other
expression.
thererore,
The
that
it
is,
(2)
is
the rule,
Class-
(or
sumultaneous) answering,
exception.
answering
may sometimes be
may,
at
times,
dull.
it
be useful in
But, for other
method
is
misleading,
is
and
extensively used,
says
exceedingly
harmful.
"It
astonishing,"
Gladman,
" with what readiness boys can take their cue from one another,
common
such
knowledge.
The
apparently wide-spread
fallacious,
knows and he
it
that
will rarely
employ a method
pretation."
in his teaching
(3) If
an answer
is
proof oi
imperfect teaching,
that
little
an answer
is
and the wise teacher will not hastily decide In some subjects there is but wholly wrong.
others there
is
room
great
room.
Consider a question as to the force of a word in a given The teacher who has his stereotyped answer, to sentence, etc
which
all
I'he pupil
is fallible
the teacher
252
is
not
(4) If
an answer
is
is
partly right,
and
partly
wrong,
thinking,
and the
teacher, by
(5)
Random
answers
but
cannot
"
answer.
(6)
Almost as rare will be the "Know " Cannot tell," The rule is
:
Oral examination
not enough
must be frequent written examinations, (page 220). Not that They are an indispensable element in training.
there
which goes into the eyes and ears of a student educates, but
that which
in oral
and
especially in written
form.
ject
till
No
he has reproduced
This reproduction
is
the test of
demand
mind, and
"
train to
They
are," said
means of
Examination
is
Education.
CHAPTER XL
KINDERGARTEN WORK AND SELF-INSTRUCTION
IN PUBLIC SCHOOLS.
Grounds
cises.
for Establishing
Kindergarten Exer-
When
at
efficient
known, to secure an
all-sided
means Wherever it is
253
We
have
an organic unity
independent much
less antagonistic
"
that
but
faculties/*
but thai
all
psychical development.
There
is
not one
set
for
set
of prin-
the
Kindergarten,
another
the
Primary
schools, etc.
The
sound
under
specially
circumstances, to
a certain stage of human development. In an ideal system of education, there would be a Kindergarten deIt
is
likely,
however, that
the
fully equip-
ped Kindergartens,
duction except in
will
cities
and towns.
Kindergarten exercises, or at least exercises embodying Kindergarten principles, be imported into the public schools as at
present constituted ?
May
is
not
all
calculated to
make
Can provision be made in Public Schools for the working of Kindergarten Principles and Methods ?
In order to answer this question, we must ascertain upon what distinctive methods the Kindergarten mainly depends to
secure the aims of education in
Physical, Moral and
Intellectual.
its
We
may
adaptability of such
ditions presented
1.
Physical Education.
254
elaborate
of various
and
grace-
In addition to
this,
weaving,
room
required for this training, nor has the teacher the necessary time at his dis-
doubtful whether
much
for
common in the best Public Schools. In cities and towns, however, by adopting the " Half-Time " system, time may be had for all the most valuable Kindergarten methods for physical education.
2.
Moral Education.
it
cation,
any method
ever,
how-
many marked advantages, as, e. g, {a) Before evil habits have become fixed, the child comes under the influence of a
society
psychology and
training,
experience show
{jb)
how important
is
this early
(p. 72).
for devel-
oping sympathy which not only goes out in kindly acts towards
others, but
{c)
is
power is greatly strengthened by the constant employment of hand and brain in accomplishing the various kinds The importof work proposed for intellectual development. ance of this hand training in educating the will, is very great.
will
For, the child, in controlling hand-movements, in fact all bodily movements, is exercising the elements that enter into the Train eye, ear, hand, tongue, and highest kind of self-control.
in the process
The
development of intelligence
degree, to moral culture
the
slight
it
no
(p. 145).
The
pupil
is
inspired by
9$^
of order
;
patience
is
are acquired
He
is
all
the
With the exception of this strengthening of the will-power and general development of the ethical nature by the employment of hand and brain an advantage peculiar to the exercises for intellectual
development,
it
will
department of moral education, the superiority of the Kindergarten over the school
peculiarity of
is
method.
development,
be so
much
gain to moral
In
fact, at this
stage of develop-
ment,
intellectual, moral,
and physical
culture,
may be
almost
considered as one.
3. Intellectual Education. In the intellectual field, assuming development of power to be the chief work of the Kindergarten, what is really the principle, which working by means
of the various exercises, draws forth
and
On reflection, it will be found that it is the close attention which the child is obliged to give in order to perform the necessary movements in various pleasing constructive employments, that sets the mechanism of the senses in motion and thus secures the development of power. The attempt to do under such circumstances that each forward step
powers?
furnishes the necessary pleasurable stimulus for deeper attention
and further effort, will be found to be the source of most of the good which characterizes the Kindergarten. The operation of the same principle, secures skill, itself one of the ends of education, since
it
is
a product of intelligence.
doing,
pupil learns to
know by
and
to
f5*
Instruction
is
is
;
based upon
the correla-
gratified
laws of knowing and doing are in continuous operation there is interest, natural and acquired, which secures non-vol-
untary attention
good
habits result
the law of association works with effect, and the constant working for some end develops
;
and development of the essential functions of mind, analysis and synthesis ; in brief, since there is, under assumed favourable conditions, the best possible means for the training of Sensation, Interest,
is
in
that very fact, the best possible preparation for securing the
t/ie
faculties, includ-
ing reasoning, are the natural outgrowth of perception,or intuition^ Train the observing powers, it is urged, because (page 171).
But
also,
and
all
this training so
touches
remembering and thinking, that they will afterwards appear as naturally as blossom from plant and fruit from blossom.
"
Teach a
see,
and he
will
To
in
the
efficiency
depends on the
is
weak
in this,
weak
Clearly, then,
the principles
157
be
introduced as
far as
is
Training perception
therefore, let
aH the mental powers ample provision be made for the best possible
training
in
the Beginning of Wisdom every System of Education. (Page 130.) Happily, many of the Kindergarten exercises which are
skill,
and which
moral culture,
(page 145) readily lend themselves to the modifications neceslary to their introduction into Public Schools.
The
^insig-
compared with the good that is sure to follow. The time taken for direct instruction need not exceed half an hour a day for first and second classes, and about three half-hour lessons a week for the other classes. There cannot be a doubt that the common branches will be learned with greater facility, and will have a far higher educative value. Lastly, if a teacher has had no special training for this work, he can easily qualify himself with the help of a good Kindergarten guide.
nificant
The
now
to be describ-
ed, have
Under
The
important
consideration
is
is
to
keep up the
interest,
and
for this
purpose
it
best to have
variety (page
no).
and matweavingy the teacher is at first work. This will, however, be speedily
corrected by experience.
I.
In dealing with the blocks, prepare for each pupil two boxes
of thin material one
5^
inside
nate
(a),
(^),
put 24
found that the various kinds of blocks here mentioned can be furfive cents each.
Expense of material,
it
is
the close
type.
power of the Kindergardo somg work of the ordinary " object-lesson " For example, having put into the hands of each pupil
well to
box {d) let the teacher select eight cubes from his own box, and form them into a large cube. At a signal from the This is the T/iird Gift of teacher the pupils do the same.
the Kindergarten.
By
faces, the
number of corners,
the
The terms
also,
be learned
as a whole, divide
it
into
two
By
questions, the
before.
Make
The
its
elements.
object-lessons with the cube
may now be
*
applied
*
to
half,'
quarter,*
A brick !s a block 2 X i X J^
i is
inch.
is
The
the half-cube
pieces.
into
two equal
triangular
259
and
to
make
:
The whole equals two halves. The whole equals four quarters. The whole equals eight eighths,
(d)
(e)
{(/)
A quarter
Illustration.
1^
possession
^^
*
'
in the
in
hands
one
your own
This
is
By
questions, lead
it
this closely,
to
compare
Lead
How many
26o
How many
Each
face
is
an oblong.
Each
face
is
the
hands of
select
each pupil,
let
the
teacher
his
own
hands,
Now form
these
cube thus
is
This
garten.
As
by questhis form,
tioning, to
make
the
same
close observation
it is
upon
composed.
'
'
in
the
hands of each
in your
pupil, select
own
possession
eighteen bricks,
six pillars
and twelve
squares.
:
Now
of
form
This
the blocks of which
cated.
forms
the
Sixth
Gift
the
Kindergarten.
it is
composed
in
Value of the Object Lesson Phase of Kindergarte?t Work. These object-lessons on the material, are not very interesting.
If the lessons be
made
It
may
would be a great mistake to give a long course of such lessons before entering upon the constructive Short lessons, however, given occasionally will be exercises.
become irksome.
26
They lead to a practical acquaintance with a number of geometrical forms and terms^
large
(d)
{e)
They They
Constructive Exercises with Blocks. mittmg the pupils to see how he does it, let the
upon the table some such object as
stead
:
^Without
per-
teacher build
this,
representing a bed-
Their attention
after
will
be
still
further deep-
looking at the
it
object a
make
(page no.)
When
some such means as this, excited a deep the object, and when he knows their fingers are
is
contemplated in perfect
silence.
Knowing
same
swiftly
compares the length with the breadth, notes the number and the kind of blocks used for the head and for the foot,
marks the kind of divided blocks used,
tion of a short time, sharply give the
etc.
command
" Work," at
the
screen.
point,
it
will
be with a
thrill
has been spent in attempting to form the object, the teacher While the pupils are should give the signal to " Stop work.
" in position," the teacher should pass along
work.
It will
failed.
have
262
observations were,
attention
too
careless,
and
that
closer
umst be
given.
Those who have failed should have an opportunity to re-examine the object but the time given for this purpose should be Having a keen sense of their former shorter than before.
;
failure,
is
raised, will
make
the
which caused
b3 remedied.
to shew that they are now able to do the proposed work. The teacher gives the command "Work," at the same time replacing the screen. This time they do not fail. It is obvious
that exercises of this nature, repeated
cultivate
faculties.
difficult
class,
How many
seat?
How many
The
seat
is
is
how many
blocks high
? ?
The back
how many
blocks high
foi.-
What kind
the
foot rests?
What kind
arms?
After the object has been thoroughly examined as a whole, it should be reduced to its constituent blocks, and then rebuilt by
the teacher
and
263
'ITie
whole
Then on the command, " Work," the pupils take The pupils resume position, and observe the the same step. next step. This may consist in forkning the take the teacher
back.
On
the
command
The
pupils again
come
to position
and observe the teacher take the next step, which may be placing At the command " Work," the pupils take the same the arms.
step, etc.
etc
work of placing the
material in position will be
by marking
This
is
handle.
most readily done by means of a little toothed wheel fixed in a It can be made by any blacksmith, and will cost but a few cants.
Language Training.
form,
it
For
this purpose,
tell
made
to play
an important
This effort pupils should be successively called upon to relate the story. on the part of the pupil at once lays bare the defects in his language. A very gentle criticism by the teacher should be followed by a renewed effort,
and so on.
After the pupils can tell the given story fairly well, they should be encouraged to "make up " stories in connection with the object under conAttempts of this nature have an educative value distinct from sideration.
those just described.
imagination.
the product of
Desk Work, or
Ones.
little
children
usefully
in full view.
264
(c) They
or printed
may
upon the
boai,
-,,
on a
large sheet.
left
(d)
They may be
own
fancy as to forms.
may
may
write
some of
invent stories.
The
pupils
become too deeply absorbed in these pleasant occupations, and thus, much of the school-room worry disappears.
to give trouble
The number
of forms that
may be
thus treated
is
unlimited.
illustrations
given in "
The Kinsug-
Kraus.
gestion
:
way of
the
Forms
pupils
may
in a great
measure be
left
to
They may
be led
:
to
apprehend
the
What form
is
this ?
it
shall
now
:
place a
at the top)
We now
balance
have
this
form
Where should we
the
form?
The
that there
The
teacher
may now
say "
shall
place
side
a brick in
the
middle on the
right
SELF- INSTRUCTION.
265
266
267
When
pupils,
will
be found
u
r
1
J:hat
J
They
will
of balance of parts.
ing:
sym metrical
By way
ally place
will
a new design before them for imitation. Thus, it be found, that forms such as some of those on pages 272-3, (See also Kindergarten Guide) thrown in by the teacher, will
^rove very stimulating
Value of Exercises.
power of
attention.
(i)
They
268
(2)
They are
and quickness
They
are
The
imagination.
The
imagination corrects
all
defects in
mind,
strengthens
the will-
(6)
(7)
power. * The attempt to do while the mind is stimulated on so many sides, imparts skill or manual dexterity, The practice of connecting the object built, with interesting stories, can be made the means of cultivating
both the constructive and the creative phase of imagination.
(8)
The
telling
The Fom
aesthetic culture.
IL The Tablets.
The
(i)
(2) (3)
wood
well
seasoned.
following forms:
side.
side.
The
The
The
equilateral triangle,
one inch to a
one
inch.
The
one of the sides contwo inches and the other one inch
The
.5
and 6
will
be evident upon
si
slight
examination of
those kinds of
work more
weaving, papcr-rclJllij,
etc.
OF TH r^'jps
isosceles
triangle, the
side opposite
The
(i)
(2)
colours.
on the
(3)
other.
right angled issoceles triangle, red
other indigo.
Remark.
purposes,
It is
found that
all
For Public School recommended that a sufficient number be procured to furnish each pupil with about 40 of each kind. A little paste-board box is all that is required to hold the tablets used by each pupil.
cabinet-maker at the rate of sixteen cents per hundred.
it is
As
in the case of
an object
lesson.
The
ideas repreetc.,
should
be
elicited.
The
different kinds
of angles
should be con-
sidered, etc.
beyond the
can
be made with
270
The
trapezoid
may
be- considered
and the
pupils called
upon
to form
this figure
The
rhomboid with four, etc., etc. Again supposing the right angled scalene triangle to have been carefully considered, the pupils may be called upon to form an oblong with two of these triangles.
A rhomboid
with two.
A trapezum
with two.
i
:
An
j^^
27
trapezoid with
tliree.
rhomboid with
four.
^
etc
A large
A hexagon
It is evident that work of this kind will make the pupils very familiar with the forms dealt with in elementary geometry. The teacher must not forget, however, that the chief value of Kindergarten work centres in the
constructive exercises.
The
mode
of dealing with the tablets will naturally follow the same general
the
pupils
upon a
vertical
surface
better than
The
following simple
upon a method
(i) Hang against the wall a board 2)% ft. x 2.% ft., painted of a light drab color, and ruled or pricked into inch squares like the tops of the pupils'
desks.
72
(2)
own
ject
use,
brads.
pro-
In order to
make
provision for the different colors, half of each kind of tablet should
other.
The
teacher can
now with
The
children
may repeat
taught,
their
This change of work, without is found most valuable in the intervention of the teacher,
by the
teacher, or dictated
own
fancy.
When
such forms
tablets, they
should be drawn^ as
mentioned
the
Rem xRK. Of
work with the
be described hereafter.
The forms
that
may be
The
3,
"
No.
273 are suggestive. In dealing with the Forms of Beauty, those on page 274 are
given by way of suggestion
:
III
The
Sticks.
Each
sticks
child
Some
of these
should be one inch long, some two inches, some three, some
four,
and some
five.
They
Such
will
pupils, if colored.
and may be
how
tablets
may be
used, as the
/,
74
r:^
Sl^^.<^^B
frt*
*^^iglr
aT3 fr^*
tf$
The
instruction.
Thus, the
hexagons,
etc
The
same care
to
becoming irksome.
The
method
is
order
have a
ruled into
seen
by
all
Upon
may
by means of the ordinary blackboard crayon, any form which he desires the pupils to produce by means of sticks upon the lines forming the checkered surface of their desks.
easily exhibit
The following forms are suggestive See page 276. Teachers should examine " The Kindergarten Guide,*' No. 4, by Maria
:
Kindergarten Drawing.
It is
lines.
The
mode
of dealing with part of the work, therefore, needs no explanation. The following forms are suggestive See page 277.
:
Hand
Training.
For Public School purposes, perhaps the most valuable employments are Slat Interlacing, Paper Folding, and Mat Weaving.
276
^-
^
^k
'
t^
J.
it
z<^'
\ A-nV.
/C "^ r
I r_ V!
"^
-
.m^.
.
v^
^^
-
V 1
1^&
\^
.^^? ^
.1
-r
^^^i/ S^'
4-^^
/:
277
a;8
They
are, at the
same
time, fully
making For the purpose here contemplated, those ten inches long and twoA number sufficient to supply fifths of an inch wide, are best. They are each pupil with about sixteen, should be provided. inexpensive and may be obtained from any dealer in Kinder-
interlacing
consists
in
thin elastic
wooden
slats.
garten material.
These
slats
it is
best to proceed
for hand-training.
In dealing with
method
is
The
use,
teacher, having
made
own
to
spection.
lected,
have imitated, distributes them among the pupils for inAfter the lapse of a short time, these should be col-
" to work."
Those who
fail
should have another opportunity, but the time allowed for ex-
etc.
difficult
forms, the
The
ments)
teacher will be in a
much
better position
to give in-
struction in this
if
department of work,
he
will
some of
the
little
(Number 4 of the Kindergarten works on Slat Interlacing " Kindergarten Guide " by M. Kraus-Bolte and J. Kraus will
give
all
that
is
required.)
are
offered
The
following forms
by way of suggestion.*
teacher
is
one of the best forms of " desk work" for the pupils while the engaged with other classes. It should consist in imitating forms distributed by
Since in this case they are at liberty to look at the specimens as often as
the teacher.
may
be somewhat
difficult.
279
fr
250
Paper Folding. For the older First Book pupils, the employments of Slat Interlacing, Paper Folding, and Mat Weaving are peculiarly appropriate. They make a greater
demand upon
the
exercises
and
reflection,
than do
give
The
named
for securing
ercises permit of
any desired gradation in point of difficulty. may be performed by a child while the more dificult forms fairly tax the powers
square.
For Paper Folding, the teacher should provide sheets of paper four inches Manilla paper which is tough and of various colors is best for the
purpose.
paper.
Any
The
The
much
"
Steiger's
PAPER-FOLDING.
Having placed
in the hands of each child one of the small folding-sheets,
its
the teacher takes a sheet of the same form, but so large that
foldings
may be
readily seen
by
all
Having secured
movements, the teacher brings two of the opposite At the command "work" the and smooths the paper. The teacher now brings the opposite sides pupils take the same step.
close attention to her
sides together
At
the
command
**
work," the
stage.
When opened,
mr^-
Eig. I.
281
bringing the opposite comers over each other and smoothing, the
:
^;
/\
Fig. 2.
The
creases
exercises
till
shown
in Fig. 2.
creased their papers, she takes her large sheet creased in the
have same way, turns the comers upon the centre, and smooths the paper. At the command "work," the pupils do the same with their sheets. All, now, have
First Basis.
iTom
forms are
made
in endless variety.
form from
is
called a basis.
i.
all
No
in their hands.
282
comers back on the middle of the four sides of square and smooths the paper. At the command "work," the pupils do the same. This gives us the following form
No.
i.)
Let
in their hands.
Now,
At
the
command "work,"
:
"he
pupils
do the same.
Fig.
5,
(Derived
Form No.
2.
Forms, Endless in Variety. This system or" producing new forms by modifying old forms, may be carried on indefinitely. As other bases may be assumed each as prolific as the one we have denominated
slightly
First Basis,
it
is
is
as
rich in
the
matte- of
283
Basb are
First
given by
Harmonious Blending of
tice in
Colors. After the pupils have had some praC producing forms from a single sheet, they should be directed to take
different,
if
one sheet.
the beauty of the forms and th erefore to the interest in the exercises.
Paper- Folding
to
opens up a magnificent
Pupils
may be
permitted
taught.
(2)
to invent
new
forms.
(3)
particular forms
demanded by
by
all
the teacher.
For
this
purpose the teacher should make the required forms, with large sheets,
that they
may be
readily seen
the pupils.
pupils
Note. Permissions to blend colors, should always be granted the when engaged in Desk-work.
Mat-Weaving.
This occupation
of weaving
is
strips
For
purpose the
leaf,
and the
weaving
tion.
below
teacher's
power of apply-
ing this admirable means of training will be greatly increased by examining " Steiger's Designs for Mat-Weaving.
284
passed
Mat- Weaving furnishes an occupation for Seat Work unsurm excellence, by any of the other departments of work.
following diagrams are given
The
by way of suggestion
See
page 285.
is
present school
arrangements at
is
Without any change whatever in the least some of them may be introduced.
still
Where
utility
the teacher
as
much
be found of great
"Desk Work."
much
better plan
found,
schools a
tO
make room
system,
the
for
them
by adopting the
First
Half-Time
System.
By
this
pupils in
the
Book
in the
down
Public School programme, leaving the remaining part for other exercises.
To
illustrate
how
garten
work
Book work, each department provided with a teacher employed solely upon the regular work of the programme. Now, for the pupils of these two departments, let us suppose a Kindergarten room with
partments doing First
a teacher capable of doing Kindergarten work. Let us suppose the pupils of the two departments first mentioned divided into two sections, a junior
and a senior
section.
In the morning, the juniors of both rooms pass into the Kindergarten After department, and the seniors into the rooms for ordinary work. intermission, a change takes place, the seniors passing into the Kindergarten room, and the juniors into the
room
for ordinary
work.
It is found that this arrangemen' gives time, not only for the employments described in the foregoing pages, but for those Kinrlergarten exercises The teacher of the Kindergarten designed for physical and moral training.
department, not being held responsible for the pupils' ability to pass the promotion examination, turns kindly to those subjects on the Public
School programme which are too often neglected. Thus the culiivation of the voice by simple songs, object lessons, and oral composition receive
due
attention.
285
v<<->w.w
Vb"bVbvI"v
S'"i?i?
BT^^M^B
V
1 1 1
C^aVay" ?-----
1 1
1
ViViWiV.'.
1 1
1 1
n 1mnii
286
Results Manifested.
In schools in which these modified forms of Kindergarten
results
have been
clearly-
The
pupils have a
much
intelli-
gence.
(b)
{c)
They have a greater power of concentration. They have a much better command of language.
(d)
They do
and
first
ideas
more
readily,
{e) They learn more easily the forms of letters and words, and hence reading comes easier. (/) The exercises have completely dispkced the inveterate
is
The
little
interest of parents
awakened
and the
make
the school."
Common Work.
Reproduction. With the kindergarten exercises maybe wtroduced much desk-work in connection with the ordinary lessons. The importance of " doing " in primary education has been often pointed out. Reproduction
is
And
made, as
of the utmost
classes
akould be always at
definite work. In a properly managed rural school, as good results can be produced as in any graded school : because^, from the force of circumstances, the law of self-education has a chance to operate ; pupils must help
themselves, and self-reliance must, to
some
extent,
be cultivated.
In a
graded school, where each teacher has but one class, there is, in general, too much teaching and too little independent work. The teacher is most of
the time teaching
with the
ever-present help of the teacher they lose, or never fully acquire, the spirit
of self-help.
instruction, or
But
schools
either
be given to
self-
wasted in idleness.
make
provision for having all his pupils always at work, and. in real educa-
tional results,
287
Preparation of Lesson Provides for Self-Instruction. The advanced classes can easily be kept employed. But for all classes, sclf-instraction
work should be carefully considered and properly prescribed. Hap-hazard suggestions given on the spur of the moment, are all but use-
Definite work should be assigned for a definite purpose. Work given merely as " busy " work, from a vague idea that youthful hands ought to be
less.
doing
**
something,"
is
But work
In
educative results
fore,
it is
work done
There-
for
every lesson
will
and
the
self-instruction exercises.
The
little difficulty in
assigning such
work on
to
the
ordinary lessons of the day, and so interspersing them with the kindergarten exercises which have been described that they will not
esting, and, therefore,
1.
fail
be
inter-
profitable.
Children should
panying the primary readers, and easy sketches of familiar things, will
supply
much desk-work.
is
The sooner a
all
some
facility in writ-
ready to reap
Reading.
letter,
the
child should
it
make
word when
r, /,
the letters of
fixes their
cai.
He
and
forms in his mind by writing them separately and together in the word
Even
3.
letters and theii which form the names of objects For example, from the picture of a pan, he may presented in pictures. be asked to select the letters and write as neatly as he can the word, pan.
When
powers, he
may be
4.
The
possible, should
5.
new words of a lesson, and, as soon as have practice in forming easy sentences from given words.
He should
etc.,
upon which
copy short sentences, especially proverbs, gems of poetry, interesting lessons have been given, and which it is wise
to
^it
affords
good practice
own
288
7.
a valuable exercise.
useful exam< For example 1. There may be practice in making and varying the number-forms with blocks, or other counters, and on slates, e.g.^ different forms for five,
pies for desk-work.
sixy etc.
2. There may be practice in writing down the sums of pairs of numbers and the differences of pairs, first in words, then in figures ; e.g., X X \ four and two are six. Then 4 + 2 = 6, 6-2=4, ^^c. Also in forma\
'>
additions, of numbers,
by means of
figures, e.g.^
2+1+3 = 6,
the addenda
Deing arranged as in
3.
common
addition.
forms, there
may be
;
practice in
as
the
for
example
sells
how much has he left ? Willie has six turkeys and two of them for three dollars, and the rest at a dollar a pair, how much money does he receive altogether? Several columns of numbers may be given, the sum of no column exceeding 6 : e.g..
a pencil for his sister,
I
2 2
I
5
I
2
I
3
I
2
3
2 tens 3 tens
I
=
=
20
10
= 30
4
tell all
tens
6 tens
4.
60
the
Similarly, pupils
:
maybe asked to
six,
e.g.,
num-
ber six
etc.
five
(5
+ 1=6);
;
sue (2
in six
there are
;
two
+ 4 = 6), And so
for larger
fives ?
numbers
as, e.g.,
twenty represented by
How many
How many
may
fours ?
How many
twos, etc.
^44
The
teacher,
Once 3 is 3. Twice 3 is 6,
etc., etc.
The
thoughtfu.
who
The
rule
is
al-
Guide (which has been referred to) ought to & Co., from whom all
can be had at reasonable
rates.
289
CHAPTER
L
1.
XIII.
Apart from
its
practical utility
Geography
when properly
general culture.
an excellent means of mental discipline and appeals to the imagination, strengthens the memory,
and stimulates the reasoning powers by inducing the habit of discriminating It supplies invaluable information about facts and forming real relations. innumerable familiar objects and aspects of nature, and excites an interest in these that gives a new charm to every country walk.
2.
plants, ani-
mals and minerals, should be begun as soon as the pupil enters school, and
may be
An
graphical purposes
(imparting fact-lore).
fication of
Hot Region,
Those
Draw atten(i) Sun at Noon. noon and inform the pupils that when we face the sun at that hour, we look toward the South, and that our backs, are to the Norths the left hand to the East and the right hand to the West,
3.
(2)
Sun
at Rising
and
Setting.
Inform
in the East
(3)
and
sets in the
West.
Shadow
of Stick.
Set up a stick about four feet long in a vertical At noon the shadow points North a.nd South.
Draw upon the floor a long line pointing (4) Diagram upon Floor. North and South. Bisect this by another of the same length, pointing East and West. Causing a pupil to take the centre, give directions "Go North,"
"Go
South,"
"Go
Now,
ii^ermediate
directions
and
proceed as before.
Again
Place
map
Now,
after resting
towards the
an instant the end of the pointer upon the central part of the map, move it sides, the pupils describing the movement as N, S, E, &c. &c.
,
it is
for convenience
we hang
the
290
4.
(l)
Boundaries.
Let
the teacher
secure the assistance of the class in drawing a plan of the school-room floor,
etc.
it
This plan
may be drawn
first
upon the floor, then the pupils should draw he school yard in the same manner.
I
upon
their slates.
Deal with
line about two feet " Let us call tins the North side of the room." " Who will come to the board and draw lines for the other sides ? " The sides being drawn, the teacher calls upon others to mark the places for the
(3) Scale
in Maps.
The
and
says,
" Let us
teacher then draws a horizontal line one North side of the room ; " ** Who
come to the board and put in the other sides ? " Proceeds as before. Next a liae /our inches long is drawn and the teacher calls this the North side and proceeds as in ike other case. The pupils thus see that the school room can be represented by pictures of different sizes.
(3) The teacher hands a boy a foot rule and asks him to measure the North side and the East side of the room. Supposing it is found that the measurements are 20 feet and 24 feet, the teacher says " If I call every foot
one inch,
how many
"
Let these be drawn upon the board, foot rule and find the length of the
to
Now
it
let
teacher's desk.
will take
Supposing
it
proves
to
be 5
feet,
it
represent
The
school yard
may now be
represented, taking
(These processes employ child's own one inch to represent a yard. they define fundamental ideas, pp. 80-81 ; they ;
base representation on presentation, pp. 93-94
the old, p. 171.)
6.
:
new
with
(l)
form
Definitions.
Be
thoroughly understood, and that the pupils as far as possible form the definitions for themselves.
(Page 49.
From
well
adjacent
hill
From
known
pressed by
(3)
**
river."
(Page 74.)
Moulding-Board Representations,
sea,
Letting
Lead
29
Map
Notation.
The
map
as
Many
may
feel at
home
The
the
cal features of
each country.
This
will
to self-activity
and 105.)
7.
Shape.
of the Earth.
Let
Holding the marble and the pea up to view, "In what do they resemble each other? " (Shape). " In what respect do the orange and the ball resemble each other ? " The marble and the orange ?
spherical bodies.
respect
shape. (Page
58.)
How
of the Earth. How long would it take a man to walk around long would it take a train running forty-five miles an hour to
it,
run around
8.
etc. ?
Poles,
Axis,
Equator, Latitude,
pupils to
to spin, call
on
draw a
points
line
move
most quickly.
" What
The line drawn through those points represents the equator. move most slowly ? " These two points are the poles.
is
The
All points
between the equator and the South Pole are said to be in South Latitude.
Lead the pupils to see the necessity of lines of latitude and lines of longiby asking them to describe the position of points made with the crayon upon the surface of the black globe.
tude,
(2)
Show
Why does
earth
become so
hot,
we
move towards
9.
the poles ?
Map and
point to
The
teacher says
"On
will
this
map
of the
(Hsra
map
and
find the
same?"
Again
" On
**
Who
come
to the globe
this
map
292
this
the
same
island
on the
globe?
10.
Interest in Map Work. Connection between Places and CharacAnimals and Plants. In dealing with a map of the world, the grand divisions should be connected with such people and with such proteristic
ductions as
ter of
may be
fairly
characteristic.
The
'*
teacher should
make
maps
glow with
interest.
Pointing to a
map
Here
is
the
home
of the Negro."
will secure the
'*
closest attention.
When
;
the attention
is rivetted,
This
country
is
called
it till
do not
to pro-
pronounce
will
all
have looked
word.
at
it.
If
pronounced
at first,
the pupils
nounce and
the
The
teacher
in
upon
*'
It is also
h9me
be made familiar
place.
(a)
(b)
{e)
Distance from the Equator, Height upon the continents the pupils should with the principal causes determming the climate of a
Before
entering
(d)
(e)
The distance from the equator. The height above the sea-level. The nature of the winds sweeping over it Slopes towards or away from the equator.
The
nature of the currents
(
(warm or
cold) washing
its shores.
12.
The Continents.
I)
Topical
should be followed.
and pupils. The pupils must have access to the best books of reference and also to the best books of The books of reference will be especially useful as giving recent travel. information for the ordinary recitation in geography ; and an hour should be set apart each week for the reading by the pupils of interesting items
requires wide reading on the part of teacher
The
prarticular
division or country,
may be
pictures of
art,
its
works of
will also
The
all
Specimens of productions
293
Mrill
(Page 76.)
is
largely determined
by
physical conditions,
learned.
tures,
follows that
first
The
would be
(i)
(2) Surface,
moun-
(4)
People.
Map-work in
Oejteral.
The
map,
is
most
effective
to practise
from memory.
(Page 91.)
means
not as an end.
It is
maps of
the
The
Although
be accurate.
it
is
maps from which the pupils learn geography should drawn upon the board by the teacher is almost certain to give erroneous ideas of relative position and of proportion. A true outline painted in some bright color upon the ordinary blackboard, or better still, upon a movable blackboard of slate-cloth, is almost indisFor a similar reason the pupils should use pensable in teaching maps. The true form of the boundary pasteboard outlines of the continents.
An
being thus retained, the pupils are not ^likely to go far astray in putting in
map- work. Whenever possible life should be thrown into the dead matter of maps, by connecting the places with something of permanent interest, as for example : Trafalgar, with the naval engagement The Bay of Fundy, with Maps should be so taught as tc enkindle the imaits wonderful tides, etc.
the other
'
gination and
stir
the feelings.
Map-Drawing as Desk Work. Map-drawing furnishes one of the (3) most useful forms of Desk work. This arises from the following considerations
:
(a) It
{h)
by changing
classes,
be brought to a speedy
(r)
By
this
means the
teacher, while
can
work already
memory.
Map- Drawing as a means of Education in Geography. Map-drawiog one of the most speedy and effective means of examinigg the pupils either
294
for the
When
used as an instrument
political
the animals,
may be
work
of
it
as readily indicated
on the map,
as can
(5)
be
towns, &c.
Coast Features.
As
in the
drawing the
follows, that
these should be
etc., are
is
element
dealt
It is
For work we require raised mz.'^'s,. The raised maps offered for sale are rather expensive ; but by means of the ordinary moulding board* such maps may be easily made by teacher and pupils. In the work of forming the sand-maps on the moulding board, the teacher would be greatly assisted by having on his desk the " Royal Relief Atlas," published by
Messrs. Sonnenschein and Allen, LonJon.
While looking
at the
cribe the position of the great highland regions, give the boundaries of
This
The
to
way
Ideas.)
(Pages 95 and 129. Doing defines For this purpose, each should be supplied with a pan and a small
quantity of putty.
map, and then the work should be done entirely from memory. The description of a Highland Region should include an enumeration of its mountain chains, rivers, and lakes ; and the description of a Lowland
the connection in which the
Region should include an enumeration of its rivers and lakes. Now this is names of the mountains, rivers, and lakes
is,
and
Productions.
The
be given.
(See Guyot'a
Common
*A board
School Geography).
4
will
answer
vrvery purpose.
The
front edge should be provided with a hinged leg so that the hoard
OXJTLINE
METHODS
IN SPECIAL SUBJECTS.
map-work, the
295
political
As
divisions should
(9)
be fixed
in the
Great Towns.
outcome of some
flourish, as
it
obvious natural cause, the attention of the pupils should be directed to the
fact
is
by
qtiestionSf
Para
is
likely to
Amazon
Basin.
Towns should be
is
Coupling what a town name, makes the work more interesting and useful.
13. Political
Geography.its
(i) Interest;
desire of
by exhibiting pictures of
by exhibiting
speci-
is
study of a country.
few words as to the history of the people, citing especially any great
prove interesting.
country should, as far as
is
possible,
be
This
eliciting
now
perfectly
division
is
of.
The
pupils.
Climate
and
Productions.
In
A little information
by way
that
is
required.
people should be
(5)
Commerce; Great
good pictures
Journeys.
will
Commercial Towns
cities,
Foreign or Domestic Exports, Imports, Routes of Commerce. In learning about the great
Cities.
be helpful
should be
in
many
ways.
interesting
(6)
These
made very
by
pictures.
Solar
Camera of
great value.
Comparison should be carried out in every subject (7) Comparison. The continents drawn on the same scale should be always before the pupils. The pupils should be constantly exercised upon these, and also upon the chart, showing the comparative volume of trade of different countries, the
comparative wealth, the comparative population, military strength, etc
The
ia
296
some family
attention, pages
58 and 59.)
for teachers
:
Note.
Geikie's
Teaching of Geography, MacMillan & Co.; Dr. King's, Aids and Methods in Geography, Lee and Sheppard, Boston.
It is strictly in line
with
psychology
1.
It begins
is,
Number
concrete.
in the
method here
outlined, the
pupil begins not only with concretes, but with intuitions that
make them
That is, the arrangement of each number- form is an analyzed one which makes relations distinct. Present seven things in a row, say, and the resulting idea is vague ; it will have to be made definite by analysis and Symmetrical arrangement, with different intuitions of the same synthesis.
form, leads to clear perception^ and so aids the higher mental processes.
2.
and
re- combination
of things
call
Sice nHmber
is
not so
much a
method gives
mathematics
number
an idea which
made
explicit.
The
child
different.
He
is
and abstracting
and
unconsciously.
He
is
5.
common
interest
Giving the symbol as soon as the idea is mastered, is justified by There is variety and therefore sense as well as by psychology.
dealing with the objects too long, becomes monotonous ; ; symbols open up a new field. There comes also a feeling oi power, of There is economy of time and power for both teacher and advance, etc.
In short, the justification is on -instruction. It affords means oi self same ground for the child as for the race. The human mind always economizes by means of some condensed symbol as soon as the idea is familiar. It is worse than useless to be always going back to beginnings ;
pupil
the
this
UTLINE METHODS IN
SPECIAI. SUBJECTS.
297
GENERAL SUGGESTIONS.
1.
Arithmetic
is
its
ralue in discipline,
(t) its
value as knowledge,
2.
study
be a training in thinking ; all merely mechanical work is to be banished. There must indeed be mechanical drill, but this must be founded
to
%n miuitions.
3.
For
to last,
is
absolutely indispensable.
is
Mental Arithmetic.
op to Written Arithmetic.
Aritmetic alone,
Mental Arithmetic,
As compared with the effectiveness of written may be fairly said that with the systematic teaching */ twice the Knowledge and twice the Power will
correct language,
at.
In mental work,
rapidity,
and
logical order ol
6. In mental Arithmetic it is desirable that the teacher should follow the sequence of some book. Otherwise the " course " is likely to be without logi-
method ; disconnected problems are of but little use in mental training. At the outset, children need no book ; when they have advanced to division, and its applications, they may prepare assigned lessons in some text -book. But a book supplies only type-questions ; many similar questions should be framed by teacher and pupils.
cal
7.
and white) with faces a centimetre them are represented by a rectangular prism (units, black and white alternately, ) which makes a convenient ten-unit. For making the number-forms, a blackboard may be used having holes bored two inches apart in horizontal and vertical lines. With this are roo white (wood or bone) buttons with short stems for inserting in the holes. The number forms can be built up, for teaching, or copying by the pupils.
8. Grood counters are cubes (black
j
ten of
to Five,
I. The numbers i to 5, inclusive, taught intuitively by Number-Forms and by counting these "forms" being presented through (a) dots or
298
points
(e)
arrangement of
used as counters.
Number-forms are
is
;
to
be
clear
and
comparatively easy
if
there
is
a symmetrical arrangement
e.g.^
the per-
ception and ultimate conception of five are easier from this arrangement
2.
It
will
eight, or
be found useful to run over the number forms from one to even ten, to give a general idea of the numbers represented ; then
begin to
make
making
5 the
first
stage.
It is
not
of
all,
in learning to count.
That
5, e.g.,
6, is seen
is
little, if
any
formal
3.
drill in
counting
necessary.
after
reasonable
From principles which have already been set forth, it will be well, drill on one form, to make other presentations of a
^^., of /hv
Number Form,
4.
. I
Practice
is
to be
had
number
(a)
is to
taketi up.
Number Forms
in various ways
into pairs
numbers
similar means,
(c)
e.g.,
Note.
{c)
May
be
left till
to 10 are learned.
Of course,
:
number-forms, on board,
slate,
etc
For example
6.
"
*
I
"
etc
is
clearly
grasped.
7.
When
sufficient practice
example
how much
did he spend
etc,
etc.
;
When drilling
when
in
on addition,
let
sub-
Then, problems
299
B)
operations.
So with
using the number-forms the operation can be seen, and thb leads to undei
sfanJing.
8.
5-1+2-1+3
exer-
2, etc.
9.
Have
and symbol)
cises as
For example
*
3
I
5.
in words, two
five
in
symbols,
to Ten.
The numbers 6
given in the
(1)
first
to 10, inclusive, to
be taught
sum is not
greater than
ten
(2) Subtraction.
Practical problems.
(3)
limits.
The
(a)
before)
{b)
The multiplication table of numbers from i to 10 much "drill," but drill grounded on intuitions.
this
supposes (as
; :
(b)
in
is
be rendered visible
there
must be
intuitions
through number-pictures.
{c)
in the sense of
e.g.,
is
contained in 4,
in the corresponding written exercises as soon as the children (4) Practice Practice, also, in solving and in have mastered the processes mentally.
may be
run over
twen-ty,
etc., etc.
i
is
The
to 20,
following table, which exhibits all combinations of number from shews substantially the work to be done in these two stages, and
all
the basis of
combinations.
300
C
I.
to
Twenty.
i
to
20.
%
l+l
\%
3
2+1
1
4
3+1 2+2
1
5
4+
1
6
S
7
i
8
7 5
9
8+
7
1
10
3+2
2
11
+2
4+2 3+3
2
+1 +3
6+2
+2 6+3
5
\\\ 7+3
6+4
5+5
+3
+3 +4 1 + 5
+4 +5
4+4
+6
3+5 2+ 6
1
lO+I
9+2 8+3
7
13
10 + 2
1+4
14
+4
4+ 5
3+6 2+7
9+3
8+4
7+
5
10
+4
+6
6+5
5
4+6
3 +7 2 +8
16
IT
10 + 7
+7
18
1+8
19
6+6
+6
84-6
7+7
9 8
+ 6 10+6 +7 9+7
1+9
4+7
8+8 6+ 7 9+8 10 + 8 5+7 3-r8 4+8 5 + 8 6 + 8 7 + 8 9 + 9 10+9 2+9 4+9 5 + 9 6 + 9 7 + 9 8 + 9 3+9 I + 10 2+10 3 + 10 4+10 5 + 10 6+10 7+10 8+10 9 + 10
2.
^0
10+10
to
The upper
;
numbers
ten iuclusive
20 inclusive.
The ways
and
3,
4 and
I,
related forms, 2
ations,
and
different
The and no more. ways of expressing some of these as e.g.y 3 and 2 are 5, may be also In the table, the equivalent forms are separated expressed by 2 and 3 are 5. from the fundamental forms by wider spacing, e.g.^ i + 2, so separated
from
and
4.
In
all,
2+1.
as that of the preceding stages.
The plan to be followpd b the same Number forms of all the numbers from 1 1
balls
on Frame,
dots, etc.
to 20 are to be given by means of and by means of these the partitions and recom-
Take,
e.g.^
the
number
eleven.
i,
From
2,
the
3.
9 and
8 and
all
and
4,
6 and
unit-forms of
Then with the following number-form for eleven, which are now familiar to the child, we have
5.
104-1
= 11
h2
""
=
8
th
+3 =
^7+4
6+5
301
moving
^ne of the
And
forms up to 20.
Making
and
these partitions
figures, afiford
(a)
: i
all
plus 2,
3, 4, etc.
2 plus
2, 3, etc.
it
3 plus
I, 2, 3, etc.
intuitive-
teaching,
{6)
will
primary work.
e.^,,
combinations of numbers,
take
those of
2
+ 23,
leads to
21+3,
1.
The
to 100, inclusivethe
method of intui-
Make
the combination of
4+ 1 = 5,
so,
4 tens+ 1
ten
=5
tens
this
by
visible
is
and tangible
tens
;
objects.
= three- ty,
forty is four-ty,
intuitions)
3.
4 tens, etc. In fact, practice on the may be had as soon as ten is learned.
tens (using
Teach the intermediate numbers, e.g.^2i2 tens+ I ; 22 = 2 tens + 2, Give practice in counting backwards 31 = 3 tens + 1, 32=3 tens +2. and forwards by 2's, by 3's, etc. 2, 4, 6, etc. 3, 6, 9, etc. Give notation and numeration to 100, inclusive. Throughout, keep prominent the composite character of the numbers, viz. tens and units ; e.g., 35 = 3 tens
etc.;
: ;
and 5
4.
units.
in the addition of a number of one digit to one of two number to be exhibited as so many tejis and units. Form of numbers, e.g., give two or three terms, and have the children con;
Give practice
the higher
digits
series
As
such cases as 43
6.
+ 7,
62 + 9,
etc.
till the pupils have obtained a ready knowledge of it, but, in every instance give by intuition a clear insight into the meaning of each combination ; e.g., the meaning of 4 times 7 is 28, must
NoTK.Call
4
attenrion to the
&ct
The
pupil
may run
that thirteen is three-teen, ut., 3 and ten. ; fourteen, over the numbers from xi to 30, to get a general idea
them by
analysts
and synthesis.
302
be
made
etc.
But
this clear
the
an
efforf
of thought.
The
pupil may be taught to construct and by means of the balls, the counters, dots,
etc
/^.,
etc.,
one two
three
yt
3's
etc
In written work the order should be (a) multiplication by a number of one digit ; {b) do,, by lo ; (<) do., by a multiple of lo (</) do., by a number formed of units and tens.
7.
in
Stage B,
Give practice in the division of the products of the multiplication (as i b), {a), by an abstract divisor, i.e.^ division in the sense of
;
measurement of the products, i.e.y division in the In written work the order will be (a), division by a number of one digit ; (b) by 10 ; (f ), by a multiple of 10 ; {d), by a number consisting of tens and units.
distribution
and
(b),
8.
two or more numbers {c), the G. C. F., of do. ; and (a) with the multiples of a number ; {b), a multiple of two or more numbers, and (f ), the L. C. M. of two or more numbers.
of a
are
now
(a),
the factors
;
the factors
common
to
The
course of
whole course
subsequent work.
'K.^Fi/th Stage.
This stage
is
mainly a continuation of the preceding stages, which cover first seven sections of Mental Arithmetic, Pt. I. Details,
Children must understand the value of numbers before they use them.
is
This
has the
place.
is
number should be
a. In written work with large numbers mental operations, note the following points
for
NoTK.- If the intuition-method has been intelligently followed, most children will understand the reason of " borrowing and carrying ; " but time need not be wasted and tke brighter pupils kept back till the " dull " members of the class master the rationmlt.
OUTLINE METHODS
(a)
in
IN SPECIAL SUBJECTS.
303
Do not
drudgery.
Long mechanical
little
operations,
especially of multiplication
practical value.
Who
needs to multiply
by
millions, or
many
questions of
rapidity.
To
As
logical
in written
accuracy, rapidity.
(d)
Some
made of them
in
"
Practical Problems."
F.
I.
1.
Sixth
now
by 3
**
Stage.
Fractional Arithmetic,
NUMBER
intu
all
Vulgar
II.
Decimal.
familiar idea of the division of a
teaching of fractions.
pose 6.
Show
;
that
is
to take one-third of
6"
is
the
same as
" to divide
by
three
" there
tion.
2.
of a number.
Lead
four
fourths, etc
3.
The
any kind,
is
two units of the same kind ; three times one unit of any kind is three units of the same kind, etc. They are, therefore, now prepared to find |, \, ^,
etc, of a
number
e.g.,
2,
thirds of 6 to be 4.
4.
Lead
| of a number
the
same as
to
take one-quarter of three times the number, i.e., to divide 3 times the numLead to the facts 3 lbs. divided by 4 is 12 ounces, $3-1-4=75 ber by 4.
cents, etc.
5.
Show
etc.
;
that ^ of a
of
it,
and that
|^
of a
24
I of24^
NoTB.
Vulgar
fractions form
Mentol Arithmetic.
Both from
experience and from operations in the preceding stages, the children have become familiar with some of the ideas and nomenclature of Fractional Arithmetic. The formal and systematic instruction is now to begin. Give the notation as soon as the con-
common
304
6.
Now
single thing
intuitions,
proceed to show that not only a number of things, but also a may be divided into equal parts. Base the instruction on
h'ne,
by a divided
Apply
how to change a whole number into the form of a how inexact division gives rise to a mixed number and {c) conversely how a mixed number may be changed into an indicated division, i.e.y an *' improper fraction " (d) how the quotient of one number divided
7.
Show
;
{a)
fraction
{b)
of the dividend
by
1
4
i_
_
4,
etc.,
and conversely.
different
4
8.
Use ideas of
5,
above, to show
10.
The Teaching
in
its
Guard again&t
rule-
of-thumb work
G.
Seventh Stage.
**
Commercial Arithmetic.'*
The
1.
unitary method, which has been followed in the simple analysis <A
is
to be followed here.
It is to
be applied to
Solution of
**
2. 3.
"
and
"cases."
4.
6.
desirable that the pupils should pass as soon as possible to the abstract
For method and type-questions under these heads see McLellan's Higher Mental
/Arithmetic
Note.
tions,
In
thi;.
may
be given.
305
Methods.
but
difficult
one
some
It requires
no great
learn-
indictment.
viz.:
name
^
the alphabetic^
^t phonetic
little
As
the alpha-
betic
bet,
method
is
now but
we may
word and
it
method, as practised, begins with teaching words connects familiar spoken words with their written or printed
generally not
is
soon enough
its
to
phonic
that
is,
the spoken
word
resolved into
printed word.
the
1.
The
so-called
**
whole to part."
It is
un-
word-method
tention /* the
it
is
analytic
^proceeding
As pure
vague idea of sound is made definite by calling his at* sound of the word. The whole that the child starts from is the vague idea of sound ; the "part " is the articulate, i.e., the definite sound.
fact that the child's
2.
It claims to
known
to the
unknown,"
i.e.^
the
as spoken) to the
unknown form-word
is
^word
is
from
as written or printed.
an arbitrary symbol
that
having no significance of
the
How
The
ethod awakens some interest by showing the child that written words, like spoken, are means of expressing his ideas of things. It is pure assumption that because the form-word is before the child he knows the word. He no more knows the word till he has made his vague idea definite by analysis, than he knows the number ten before lie has made his vague idea definite by
partitions
and recombinations of the objects before him. word only through analysis into its element.
He
knows the
as word-method ^is mechanical ; there must be a vast 3. The method amount of telling, and a vast amount of guessing. For vague perceptions lead to feeble memory. The mind is, therefore, driven to form merely sen-
nous
associations.
And
thus,
when
is
too faith-
30t
ply recites
4,
when he seems
This perpetual telling tends to produce a mere passive as opposed to an active and energetic habit of mind. He is not taught to use the knowledge acquired yesterday to gain
new knowledge
:
to-day
e.g.^
told about
tlie
word mat
him
with to-day's.
Is not this
6.
It is
is
to
from
If he
it
or whetlier he shall be
to himself, there
is left
etc.,
in order to acquire
even moderate
power of word-recognition,
of the art of reading.
7.
i,e.^
in order to learn
In reading, as in
all
left
to his
power of word-recognition
gained, and
is
may be
power.
the sounds^ or powers of the letters, and then combines It is, therefore, commonly called a " synthetic " method.
I.
them
into words.
It
is,
in fact,
metho
1.
The
an analytic
act.
tion
is
called to
;
what he has
the result
is
tion, analyzes
It is here, as
in this
ideas of
sound
those which he
has
made
led
imitation,
aad
307
There
is
one of analysis.
word.
3.
attention,
The phonic (analytic-synthetic) method best obeys the law of unity of "one thing at a time." The child's attention is fixed first upon
one kind of sensations, the auditory^ and then upon the corresponding visual sensations. In the word method, attention is divided between the look, the
sound and the meaning of the word, and in some cases the distraction is increased from the attempt to associate the form of the word immediately with
the "object," (See page 168.)
been said that this method is without interest because the isohave no meaning. This is pure theory, l^t forms of letters are interesting to children, then why not sounds ? Besides, there is (a) in3.
It has
lated sounds
own
(c)
activity in
in elementary education
is
scarcely possidoes,
what he himself
from the exercise of the analytic function, (d) Interest from the sense of new power, or capacity, and this is of the Left to his own hap-hazard inductions from the wordhighest value. method, the pupil must spend a long time before gaining the power and
sense of power, to recognize
new
words,
the child
is
are learned
as
soon as he has mastered a few sounds, and the letters which represent them, he is set to work to use his knowledge. In the very first lesson he learns
df
and
these,
4.
experiences the thrill of discovery when, combining /, and r, and he recognizes the sound cat^ with which he has long been familiar.
objection has been
The
made
to this
;
method
that
it is
impossible to
isolate the
do so they are
(a) In the case
In the
partially vocalized,
of c in caty
it
becomes
To
answer
e.g.^
is
of a
final
consonant there
a slight vocalization,
is
the / in cat.
This
is
a slight vowel-element.
;
Besides (b) It
is
not neis
it
is
The difficulty arising from the same letter standing for several sounds much magnified. Besides, this is not peculiar to the phonic method. The word method /nvA^ to analysis, and, therefore, has to face the difficulty.
308
well,
sounds,
is
not nearly so
difficult
" hard" sound of c (as in cat)^ has he to make a very wide induction in order to know where it has the " soft " sound?
the child has learned, say, the
is
available for
many
**
cases.
j,
and comes
to the sentence,
the cat
at
first,
**
pronounce
is **iss ;" if
he does so
The
analytic-synthetic (phonic)
method
is,
therefore, psycholc^cally
justifiable.
Indeed,
it
into the
words,
is
Finally, the
test
been used
used in the
Toronto schools where the results may challenge comparison with those of any other schools or any other methods.
Suggestions.
1. The teacher should remember that much drill \& necessary, no matter which method of teaching reading may be used. The aim is to gain ability When to recognize and pronounce words without conscious mental effort.
a child has mastered the multiplication table the symbols 6x8 suggest the result without mental effort ; so, in primary reading, the association of
sounds and symbols must h^ perfect. There must be no stopping to think, e.g., what sound any letter in band stands for, or what sound they all together So long as any such thinking has to be done, there cannot be represent. good reading ; the mechanical association between sign and sound is not complete, and the reader has to take time and expend energy in re-making such association. So long as this is the case there cannot be expressive
reading.
2.
From
the
banning,
writing
Imitating the is to go with reading. sound of a (as in cat) j the teacher makes
;
on blackboard, etc
letters are
One
thing at a time
Indeed,
it
be neces*
309
nd
4.
it
will
tario Readers)
be found that by the time the Second Part of First Book (Onis reached, the pupils know the names 0/ the Utters.
made with
little effort.
If the
blackboard and tablets (or primers) are used together from the
print-form will
start
the
come with
the script-form.
it
When
a word
is
written on the
Show
the word on
it,
etc.
first,
pression.
As
sentence is necessary.
and answers.
With simple
tablets,
etc), the
of objects.
class.
;
Of
some words
that
wholes.
8.
It is unnecessary
rather
:
it is
unwise
words.
is,
The
order
is
perfect association
is
perfect association
written form.
To
at-
(object)
and
form
is
The following
suggestions
may be
useful to
Choose some element, say at, as starting point. Give sound of a in and have children repeat the sound individually and collectively. Make the letter on blackboard and have children make it on slates, etc., helping
rt/,
them
to easiest
letter
way of doing
call
/.
this.
Drill to associate
call
Make
more
and
till
for sound,
for letter. at
first
Proceed
(at the
a,
/,
slowly, then
the word at
produced.
Illustrate
meaning of at
door, etc.)
2.
Have
Show
picture of a cat.
so as to separate into
sented by
c-at.
Sound a/?
(or
Children pronounce the word cat ; then slowly two sound-elements (a known and an unknown) repreWrite word cat on blackboard. Call attention to the parts what does a/ say, etc.) Sound the whole word? Then
:
3IO
make
the
letter.
makes at into cat ?) Have chiland sound. For desk-work and the word^ on properly ruled
the letters can be best formed.
cat, fat, hat,
how
vat.
3.
which are
Cqnstant exercise in using acquired knowledge to gain new words, significant, or which can easily be made significant, to the child.
:
For example
pronounce
it.
He pronounces
the
(3)
word pan, and asks the pupil to wordyaw (or gives picture of the thing) He leaves them to discover new words,
In such
way may be
can be taught
;
bit, fit,
mit, pit,
sit,
9r
in, bin,
fin, pin,
;
sin, tin,
spin
*r
;
men,
ten,
pen
The
other consonants
may be
^ba-d, ha-d,
pa-d, po-d, ho-d, so-d, bi-d, hi-d, di-d, d-in, din-ner, etc., ba-g, na-g, ra-g, bo-g, fo-g, do-g, g-ad, g-ap, g-un, big, pig, gig, etc.; 1-ad, b-ag, 1-ap,
let-ter, etc.
;
let,
Of course
*.^.,
He
sinner,
summer,
etc
pepper, supper, rub-ber, rob-ber, red-der, lad-der, man-net, ban-ner, picnic, sis-ter, riv-er, nev-er, cutter butter,
6.
As
:
the
silent
long
bat, bate
mat, mate,
etc.
cane, lane, mane, sane, vane ; made, glade, blade ; came, same, tame, lame, name, blame, Fin, fine ; din, dine, etc. ; fine, line, mine, fame, dame, game, flame, etc ine, pine, vine, wine ; time, grime, lime, crime, clime ; hide, ride, tide, Mole, stole, dole, bole, sole, poke, woke, broke, side, glide, pride, etc yoke, spoke ; bone, tone, lone, alone, crone, drone, cone Met, mete ; pet, pete ; cede, re-cede, im-pede. Tun, tune, cub, cube, etc
hate, late, grate, skate, slate, grated, plated
fade, jade,
mute,
lute,
fume, tune,
clue, blue
;
latest,
plated,
3II
classi-
It will
be convenient to have
for use
of
Long a
<ii,
siil)
bail, fail, jail, mail, nail, pail, rail, sail, wail, fail,
air,
etc.;
aim,
hair,
chair, pair,
lair,
AyAs
ey
:
bay, day, gay, hay, jay, lay, may, nay, pay, play, ray, say,
gfray,
Also a few in
Long e
etc., etc.
doubled
(e e), as
tree,
six-teen,
In the combination
a>, as
mead,
read, beak, leak, heap, leap, each, peach, teach, reach, etc., etc.
Long
Oa^ as
loan,
:
<nOt
as
bow, low, mow, sow, tow, blow, flow, glow, grow, etc. goal, shoal, foam, roam, loam,
etc.
Oi sounds as : oil, boil, coil^ foil, soil, toil, broil, spoil, noise, voice, Sonu in oy^ as : boy, coy, joy, toy, annoy, destroy, con-join, appoint, etc
oyster.
The
And
The
mind
he is power of word-
recognition, ability
to
pronounce
words without a
conscious effort of
may
But of course he is not to drill simply on isolated words till the forty sounds and their representatives are learned. He should have the vstords as fast as It requires skill to form learned used in sentences and easy stories. No lesson requires more careful preparation by the teacher these properly.
than the primary reading lesson. Let no teacher follow any plan which takes from four to eight months
by the " word-method," ** some two hundred words." The school By life of the child b too short and too precious to be thus frittered away. *^ from four follffwing the analytic-synthetic (phonic) method his pupils in to eight months** will have acquired the ability to pronounce at once any orto learn
is.
The main
difficulty in
primary reading
To
help in sentence and story reading, the teacher should have different primary
readers.
$ J
IV.TRAINING
I.
OF LANGUAGE POWER.
of language has been
dwdt on
2.
(a) It records
{c) It
analyzes thought,
It reacts
on thinking.
3. Language, is, therefore, the complement of reason that without which reason would not and could not be what it is. Progress in thought,
upon language.
It follows that
language
is
of reason
{a)
{b) {c)
In judg-
must be propositions,
In
relat-
5. Hence every lesson should be a lesson in language. () Power ot expression is test of thinking ; clear expression means clear
thought,
(b)
not
(d^
sufficient,
l.
Indirect Influ-
2.
3.
Original
Work.
Indirect Influences.
(1)
Gutques-
school-room influences
In
all
by the
good grammar, {b) correct pronunciation, {c) educated accent, or cadences of voice, which are "the commentary of the emotions on the propositions
of the intellect"
(2) Insist
on Correct Forms.
No
writers.
the scrappy
book
To become
lit-
good
readers,
lovers of English
313
There ou^ht to be There is not half enough and the power to read well and love
liter-
for
good
literature will
ature.
(4)
Pay no
syntax."
There
is
no
There
every-day speech and writing, and habits of right speaking must come
In
this connection,
because
2.
(1)
it is
Reproduction.The importance
write
The primary pupil is (^) Make new sentences in which given words are to occur, such as new words, irregular verbs (go, went, etc.) on which lessons have been given, {c) Copy maxims
All lessons supply material for such exercises.
to
(tf)
and proverbs which are worth remembering. (</) Give substance of what has been said in lessons on such proverbs and maxims, {e) Give Sentences expressing observed facts.
(2) Silent
Reading,
beginning.
and then have them close books and reproduce the thought.
all classes.
Power of concentration
(3) Stories, From pictures, and reproduction of stories told by teacher. Train children to " translate " pictures (orally) as well as they can, to tell
and
finally to write
they can.
etc.
Advanced
(4)
Object lessons,
Perceptive.
{a) Perceptive
{b) Reflective.
size,
(m)
mon
objects, etc.;
fiices,
comer, edges,
etc., these
314
pressed.
OUTLINE METHODS IN
Lesson on
table, e.g.,
S]^ECIAL SUBJECTS.
and in writing. If a lesmeans of pieces of wood, stone, wool, etc. ) has been given to develop ideas of hardness and sofitess^ the results should be expressed in " Because such language as rtone does not yield easily to the touch, it
son, e.g. , (by
:
be hard, to have (or possess) the quality of hanijtess ;" similar sentences about the wood, &i ; then expression of the generalization, {b) Lessons on txu^hfulness, justice, charity, industry, patriotism, Reflective.
is
said to
etc.
Such
lessons
(subjective)
**
lessons,
literary, gems, etc., to be the subject-matter of Such lessons can be made more interesting than external object nd are *if the highest value in education. For example, lessons
:
"
A soft
**
Kind hearts are the gardens. Kind thoughts are the roots, Kind words are the blossoms.
Kind deeds
" All
**
you do, do with your might, Things done by halves are never done right**
things that
Dare to be
need a
all
lie.*
Be good dear
child,
and
let
who
will
be clever.
Do
And
**
day long.
make
life,
One grand
**
sweet song."
from
the heartJ*
be honest, to be gentle, to be generous, to be brave, to be wise, and, possessing all these qualities, to exercise them in the most graceful manner."
is
it
What
to be a
gentleman
It is to
can
!"
etc.,
etc
Memorizing.
Selections
in
Poetry and
Prose.
is
The
a
Intelligent
effective
most
means of education; now greatly neg'ected owing to re-action against mere r^/<f-leaming. Should be in every school ; part of the work oj every
(kus.
315
the
beautiful thoughts
which
will tell
(d) It
powerfully on character,
It
tends to develop a taste for good literature, one of the highest results the
Something
in this line
and
every week
The work being graded according to the stage of 3. Original Work. advancement of class, there should be : (l) Letters and Business Forms.
(2)
Narratives of
personal
experiences,
descriptions
(4)
of
journeys,
etc.
and
historical narratives.
Accounts of cur-
rent events.
(5) Criticisms
(6)
Formal Essays.
(General
called
value,
'*
Remarks.
tkought'subjeets of the
school course.
than
Arithmetic to be
its
common
make
schools."
But beside
disciplinary
it
The
of thought),
study helps to
The
Grammar and
says,
Analysis.
General Method.
Begin with
is
and
their offices
noun (pronoun)
the two kinds of qualifying words (adverb and adjective) and the two con-
familiar language,
be thoroughly comprehended. Dealing as we do with a known and we can accomplish all this before we proceed to take up
is
This the true method, and the preliminary work indicated can be done in almost the lowest classes. The child begins to form judgments before he is
two years
he is three. Bemust be understood, i.e., there must be analysis of it, conscious or unconscious. Begin then with the sentence, and let the process be one of analysis and synthesis. For public school work the following points should be kept ia view
old,
(in propositions) before
it
/.
Classification
1.
Word-functions
Subject or noun.
Predicate or verb.
S.
3l6
3.
Pronoun.
Adjective.
4.
5.
The
Predicate-modifier
Adverb.
Preposition,
6.
7.
The Noun-connector
The Sentence-connector The Emotion-word
is
Conjunction.
Interjection.
8.
Tn this
\Ahich
is
necessary to
The noun,
**
e.g.,
may be
its
object
of a verb,
or with a preposition
acter
is to
may make a
modifier
" but
distinguishing char-
name
;
The examples,
up
to accurate
Examples[a)
Leaves
learn.
fall
Plants grow.
flutter
Flowers fade.
Birds sing,
Flowers bloom.
fly,
rustle.
chirp.
Boys
play, run,
jump,
Grass grows.
Time
{b) Little
men
die,
iead leaves
{c)
etc
Birds sing sweetly, boys run fast, roses fade quickly, etc
(d)
{e)
The
little
child
weeps
bitterly, the
The yellow
)
bird sings in the tree, the boy writes with a poor pen, etc.
(/
The
she
is
dis-
persed, etc.
By
"
parts of speech."
fact that the use of
it is.
Keep prominently
view the
a word in a sen-
Walking
is
a healthful exercise,
hand
me my
walking
stick.
There
is
rest for
III.
Grammatical Equivalency
:
make
this also
prominent.
For
ex-
ample
{a)
An
;
adjective, or
an adverb, or an
infinitive,
or a prepositional phrase,
may
fill
:
the office of a
noun
e.g..
is
me
doth appear in
this
From fame
to
infamy
{b)
a beaten track,
office of
etc
filled
The
adverb
may be
OUTLINE Mi^THODS
{c)
IN SPECIAL SUBJECTS.
317
The "
adjective "
may be
preposition, etc.
Inflexions, Number^ Gender^ etc, A good many inflexions will be Teamed incidentally, but there should be many lessons and copious exerOKes on the subject.
Ol&SSification of the
This "diagramming"
"compartments,"
etc.
There ought
much
LOAN
This book is due on the
DEPT.
date stamped below, or on the dace to which renewed. Renewed books are subject to immediate recall.
last
?.G
'm
i^4S
W^
KtChilVEiD
MAR 14*68 -7 HM
,-.
jNTER-LlBRAR^
LOAN
APR1
1 1^BR_
,
^\;5
!R.
MAY
Z6 75
LD
21A-60?n-2,'67
(H241slO)476B
YC 8424
^s
!
V
i.t
'
is