Third Party Research

March 12, 2013

VIX As A Leading Indicator

eResearch Corporation is pleased to provide an article, authored by Adam Warner, Analyst, writing for Schaeffers Investment Research, in which Mr. Warner looks at the returns on the SPDR S&P 500 ETF every time the VIX closes at least 10% above its 10-day Simple Moving Average. His conclusion: Crashes are low-probability events. So I would suggest that VIX pops in the middle of otherwise placid markets are more likely than not good entry points on the long side. The article begins on the next page and is entitled: Is An Overbought VIX Good News For Stocks?.
Schaeffers Investment Research Inc. offers real-time option trading services to investors, as well as a full array of print and multi-media educational offerings, including daily, weekly and monthly newsletters. The SchaeffersResearch.com website provides financial news and commentary, as it happens, throughout the market day, plus stock screeners, filters, and many other option tools to give investors an edge.

Schaeffers monthly Option Advisor, the nation's leading options newsletter and the company's flagship publication, has been published since 1981. Every month, Bernie Schaeffer and his team of analysts provide subscribers with 10 new suggested option trades, with commentary accompanying each trade. Option Advisor also includes a monthly column by Mr. Schaeffer, in which he comments on the news and discusses longer-term market trends.

You can learn about Schaeffers Investment Research at: http://www.schaeffersresearch.com. eResearch was established in 2000 as Canada's first equity issuer-sponsored research organization. We are a primary source for professional investment research, focused primarily on small- and mid-cap companies. Our research and analysis is of institutional quality, and has the potential to reach millions of global investors through our extensive electronic distribution network. Bob Weir, CFA, Director of Research
Note: All of the comments, views, opinions, suggestions, recommendations, etc., contained in this Article, and which is distributed by eResearch Corporation, are strictly those of the Author and do not necessarily reflect those of eResearch Corporation.

eResearch Corporation
100 Adelaide Street West, Suite 407 Toronto, Ontario M5H 1S3 Telephone: 416-703-6258 Toll-Free: 1-877-856-0765 www.eresearch.ca

March 11, 2013

Is An Overbought VIX Good News For Stocks?

By Adam Warner

I recently decided to play with some VIX numbers. I used the CBOE Market Volatility Index (INDEXCBOE:VIX) more than 20% above its 10-day simple moving average (SMA) as a proxy for overbought. This is not some magical number or anything it is just a level that the VIX does not attain all that frequently, so a good breaking point. Anyway, here is what I did. I looked at the SPDR S&P 500 ETF Trust (NYSEARCA:SPY) returns one month and three months out every time the VIX closed more than 10% above its 10-day SMA. Once the VIX hit the 20% threshold, I ignored any further violations until that time period passed, so as to not over-count the same samples. I went back to the listing of SPY in February 1993, and found 46 distinct occurrences where VIX closed "overbought." Again, it happened more than 46 times -- I just eliminated subsequent occurrences within a month. Of those 46 times, SPY was higher one month later 31 times. It averaged a 1.6% rally, with a median of a 1.8% rally. That is far from cosmic, but it is considerably better than the 0.9% average rally the market saw in a typical month, according to Hulbert's work. It was not without its "accidents." If you went long on the Sept. 15, 2008 overbought VIX signal, you got Lehman-ized to the tune of a 24.8% one-month hit. Then again, one of the better buy signals this indicator delivered occurred not much later. A SPY buy on Nov. 20, 2008 netted a nice 15% return in a month. The best, however, was a 20.9% pop one month after the overbought VIX signal on July 23, 2002. In other words, this is more evidence that numbers from the fall of 2008 were the definition of outliers. Lop both these off, though, and it doesn't change the picture much. Going long for a month when the VIX got overbought was a value-added strategy. The VIX-di-cater added value going long for three months as well. There were 30 distinct instances of overbought VIX, and the SPY was higher three months later 23 times. The mean gain was 3.3% and the median gain was 4.4%, versus an average three-month gain of 2.9% on a "normal" day. That same signal on Sept. 15, 2008 was the disaster, producing a 23% loss over three months. The best gainer was a 15% pop after the Oct. 27, 1997 VIX-Fest.

eResearch Corporation

~ 2 ~

www.eresearch.ca

I did not go further out because, frankly, six months later is an awful long time to read much into a VIX lift. I have said this before and I will say it again. The experience of 2008 changed how many view the VIX. Prior to that, the VIX was considered a contra-tell. High VIX meant too much fear, which meant the selling was at an extreme. Post 2008, the VIX suddenly became a leading indicator. None of this is to say you should go long every time the VIX explodes. Yes, it is a sign of an oversold market, but oversold markets are the ones that crash. Not all oversold markets crash, but all crashes start from oversold conditions. 2008 was essentially a market crash, just not one that played itself out in one session. Crashes are low-probability events. So I would suggest that VIX pops in the middle of otherwise placid markets are more likely than not good entry points on the long side. Disclaimer: The views represented on this blog are those of the individual author's only, and do not necessarily represent the views of Schaeffer's Investment Research.

eResearch Corporation

~ 3 ~

www.eresearch.ca