Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
March 2014
The FOCUS Group, Inc. 521 A1A Beach Blvd St. Augustine, FL 32080 800.324.9117 office 800.324.8816 fax www.tfgrp.com
March 11, 2014 Juan Galloway President New York City Relief 295 Walnut Street Elizabeth, NJ 07201 Dear Juan, Thank you for partnering with The FOCUS Group to conduct the feasibility study for New York City Reliefs capital campaign. This Feasibility Study Setup Manual will serve as a guide for the feasibility study associate and the staff to prepare for the study. The feasibility study report will include specific recommendations for moving forward to plan and conduct your capital campaign. Our pledge to you is that our research and recommendations will be at the highest professional level available in fund raising today. While the strictest level of confidence will be maintained with the interviewees, you will receive specific documentation that serves as the basis for our analysis and recommendations. I want to assure you and the leadership at New York City Relief, that as we meet with major donors and others in your constituency, we are keenly aware that we represent you. We will do everything we can to encourage the respondents interest in and support for your mission. From time to time we will give you periodic reports on how the study is proceeding. However, if you have questions or need any additional information at any time, please do not hesitate to contact me. Sincerely yours,
TABLE OF CONTENTS
4-6
7-10
11-12
13-16
17-23 18 19 20-23
24-25 26-27
GLOSSARY OF TERMS
NYCR New York City Relief
TFG
Leadership Team
FSA
CA
TFG Consultants
Brad Layland blayland@tfgrp.com (m) 904.687.7876 Ame See asee@tfgrp.com (m) 407.492.0215 Steve Godfrey sgodfrey@tfgrp.com (m) 804.502.5025
Priority designations: Priority 1 Priority 2 Priority 3 Priority 4 Most highly preferred Next level of preference Candidates for a focus group Leadership Team
Complete Case Statement and Research. Using Research results, complete the list of fifty prioritized respondents.
Leadership Team calls priority 1 prospective respondents to personally invite their participation. Then, invitation letters are sent. FSA calls respondents after invitation calls are made to schedule an interview. FSA sends interview confirmation letter and case statement draft at least one week in advance of interview.
FSA sends completed Interview Fact Sheet for each respondent to the CA one week in advance of interview. FSA updates any changes to the Interview Schedule in Google docs & notifies CA via email by the end of the day of the change.
3
12. Update the Interview Schedule in Google docs and email the CA each time something changes. This information includes: total interviews scheduled, interviews completed, and interviews yet to schedule. These updates are important to ensure that the contracted number of interviews is completed and to maintain clear communication between NYCR and TFG.
TIMING CONSIDERATIONS
In general, each interview should last approximately one hour. When scheduling interviews, there are a few considerations to keep in mind that will help ensure consultants enough space to travel between interviews in a timely manner and to honor the respondents that agree to participate in the feasibility study. 1. Consider travel time, parking and additional situations, and commuter traffic in scheduling appointments. Allow at least fifteen minutes as a buffer, in addition to travel time, for traffic, parking, etc. 2. When scheduling an interview over a meal, please allow for one and a half hours for the interview. 3. When scheduling an interview with a couple in their home, please allow for one hour and fifteen minutes for the interview.
As you consider these four factors, focus on the people and constituencies from whom NYCR can recruit leaders and raise major gifts. Once you have determined the very best people to interview regarding these four factors, make sure the selection is balanced in terms of covering the various influence groups across the NYCR constituencies. The process. TFG will be conducting approximately twenty-five to thirty individual interviews or focus group interviews. In light of this, approximately fifty respondents should be identified to offset lack of availability of some respondents due to travel or personal reasons. Most of the individual/couple interviews will be approximately an hour. Interviews will take place at NYCR or in offices, restaurants or in homes of the interviewees. Interviews may be scheduled over a meal when appropriate. The interview fact sheet. Each interview must be approached with goals in mind related to the factors noted above. Each respondent will be asked to comment on all four, but the consultants need to know beforehand in which areas the respondent can best contribute. This information should be noted on the Interview Fact Sheet. Major donors and potential leaders. A minimum of eighty percent of the interviews should be with priority one people who are targeted as major donors ($100,000 or higher pledged over three years) and major donors who have the stature and experience to be leaders in the campaign. Hopefully there will be major donors among the other twenty percent. This latter group is important, nevertheless, since by virtue of their association with NYCR, they will be able to give good insight on the case for the campaign and recommendations for leadership. The best examples of this latter group are executive leadership and current or former board members. Focus groups. Where appropriate there could be several focus groups. A focus group is equal to one individual interview and is appropriate for respondents who are not major donor prospects.
8
Selecting Respondents. When selecting respondents, plan as many interviews as possible keeping the following three critical factors in mind: Connection/interest: Select people who have a history of relationship to NYCR and/or a board member and/or someone on staff. Ability: Have clear evidence that they are individuals with substantial net worth. "Substantial" should be defined as individuals worth multiple millions, not simply millionaires. Inclination: Have evidence that these individuals have a reputation for giving in the six and seven figure range.
Keep in mind that people should be selected who are not only major donor prospects, but also people to whom you can look for active leadership in the campaign. Identify people who have networks with peers with similar financial capabilities. Sometimes these networks will be geared to a particular business or a type of business. In other cases the network will relate to family and social ties. In terms of networks, we are not talking simply about relationships, but about people who have used their networks to help benefit a nonprofit organization in a substantial way. We are looking for major donors who have a generous heart and have experience in giving and inviting others to do what they have done at the level at which they have participated. Categorizing respondents. With these thoughts in mind, the categories of respondents are as follows: (80% of potential interviewees should fall in categories 1 and 2.) 1. Major donors (current or lapsed) and prospective campaign leaders These should be individuals who are known to have assets in the multiple millions and have used their resources to give gifts to nonprofits totaling in the high five or mid-to upper six figures. Hopefully, a few have given seven-figure gifts. This category should include individuals who not only are substantial givers but have the reputation for going to their peers and inviting them to do what they have already done themselves. Of the top donor categories, this one should have the majority of respondents.
9
2.
Major donors (current or lapsed) These are donors who give very substantial gifts, but are not known to take leadership or participate in asking their peers to give.
3.
Influential friends and prospective friends This category includes individuals who are not major donor prospects, but who are influential as community, church or civic leaders and/or who serve on foundation or corporate boards.
4.
Foundation administrators/trustees and key "competitors" Here TFG is looking for some insight on what is happening in the related philanthropic marketplace over the next few years. We will also get their reactions on the compelling nature of the NYCR case.
5.
Focus Groups These should be affinity groups that have a stake in the success of the campaign (alumni, staff, and other must interviewees with limited financial capacity).
6.
Leadership Team It will be important to interview Juan Galloway and Claudia Wittel as part of the Feasibility Study.
10
11
12
13
Comments/Assignments
NYCR TFG NYCR NYCR staff prepare case draft with TFG counsel TFG NYCR makes revisions in preparation for interviews TFG NYCR
II. Respondents Selection & Invitation (Using compiled interviewee list, schedule 5 interviews per day)
Ongoing Ongoing FSA NYCR Leadership Team Build mailing list, FSA send out invitation letters.
14
TASK
III.
March
April
May
June
Comments/Assignments
Interview Schedule (Consultants need to schedule flights at least two weeks in advance.) Schedule interviews: Call five business days after the invitation letters are sent. Once interview is set, the CA will confirm all interviews with FSA. FSA sends letter to confirm interview date, time and place, along with case statement draft. Send one week before interview. Call to confirm receipt of materials and to confirm interview 3 days prior to visit. Complete Interview Fact Sheet for each respondent before the interview and send to the CA one week in advance of interview. Interviewing approximately 25-30 respondents personally, averaging five interviews per day and preparing the data for analysis. FSA compiles list of respondents then emails invitation for the online survey.
Ongoing
Ongoing
Ongoing
Ongoing
FSA
Ongoing
Ongoing
TFG
NYCR
15
TASK
IV. Institutional Data Gathering Complete Institutional Data Reports using electronic forms for: Giving by board members, Organization three year giving history, Foundation Giving Submit Institutional Data Reports electronically to TFG
March
April
May
June
Comments/Assignments
FSA
FSA
V.
Follow Up to Interviews
Ongoing Ongoing TFG Consultants CA FSA to send out letters following interviews. President and other NYCR Leadership with TFG Consultants
TFG Consultants report when interviews are completed. CA notifies FSA to send thank you letter. Send thank you letter, with promise of Executive Summary Report after boards review and action. VI. Report Review Conference Call VII. Submission of Feasibility Study Report Present FS report to NYCR Board. Following presentation of the report to board Send each respondent an Executive Summary Report with cover letter.
Ongoing
Ongoing
TFG Representatives TFG advises on preparation of Executive Summary Report TBD FSA to send out Executive Summary Report with cover letter announcing board action to respondents
16
17
Time
8:00 AM 9:30 AM 3:00 PM 5:30 PM 8:15 AM
Consultant
Ame Ame Steve Steve Steve
Name
Bill and Barbara Jones Joe Smith George and Jillian Clark Bob Hampton Valarie Johnson
Location
Starbucks Coffee 123 Sesame Street, Anytown, IN 32788 His office: Sears Building 658 12th Ave, Suite A, Anytown, IN 32788 Their home: 5 Sparrow Lane, Chicago, IL 55590 Dinner @ The Chart House: 314 Towns Drive, Chicago, IL 55590 Panera Coffee shop: 678 1st Ave, Chicago, IL 47859
Contact info
Cell: 677-345-0000 Email: bjones@gmail.com Office: 677-345-9293 Assts name is Joan Home: 589-990-7676 Jillians cell: 589-993-0988 Restaurant: 589-098-0045 Cell: 589-444-9821 Cell: 674-987-0321 Panera: 589-234-0986
Notes
Priority (1-4)
1
1 1 2 1
Letters
Invitation
personal call by President Jones 3/15 personal call by Mike Smith, Dir of Develop 3/14 personal call by President Jones 3/20 personal call by President Jones 3/20 personal call by Mike Smith, Dir of Develop 3/25
Confirm
Sent 3/22 Sent 3/22 Sent 4/4 Sent 4/4 Sent 4/4
Thank You
Sent 3/30 Sent 3/30 Sent 4/12 Sent 4/12 Sent 4/14
Summary
Delivered 4/15 Delivered43/15 Delivered 5/15 Delivered 5/17 Delivered 5/17
18
FEASIBILITY STUDY
Date: Respondents Name: Interview Time: Interview Date: INTERVIEW FACT SHEET The FOCUS Group Consultant: ........... Phone at Interview: Cell phone:
Interview Address (If a business or restaurant, include name and/or name of building. If a home, please note):
Interview Category: (Please Bold) Key information/ comments about respondent: priority, closest contact, history with organization, etc. History of giving: 2013 2012 2011
Board Alumni
Pastor/Church Foundation
Amount
Designation(s)
Giving capability to proposed campaign: (Please project gift range below & any specific details) High Projection over 3 years $ ___________ Low projection over 3 years $ ___________ Details
Has this interviewee documented a planned gift to your institution: If so, When or currently in process: Describe type of planned gift: Estimated Value: Known major gifts to other nonprofits, current or past, especially to similar organizations/projects: Projected campaign leadership role:
19
S
[Date]
Dear Mr. Smith: [Introductory paragraph with ministry highlights]. The Board has approved a feasibility study for a capital campaign to I want to personally invite you, along with a few others, within the next four weeks to review a confidential draft of our case statement outlining the proposed campaign for New York City Relief. After you receive and review these materials, I am asking you to take an hour to participate in a formal interview setting and confidentially discuss New York City Reliefs proposed campaign. I believe it is important to emphasize two things. First, this is not a meeting at which you will be asked to make a gift; however, the interviewer will confidentially discuss your potential level of support for this new effort. Second, your comments and views on New York City Relief and its proposed campaign will be kept confidential, and the results of the meetings with you and others will be reported anonymously. Our [leadership -- use appropriate term, i.e. Board and Administration] have asked The FOCUS Group, Inc. to conduct these interviews and then to prepare a report with recommendations. [Someone representing NYCR] will be calling you to invite your participation in this very important interview process and to schedule your individual interview. Your taking the time to advise New York City Relief through this feasibility study will be extraordinarily helpful. Your insight and advice will be invaluable to us as we plan what is best for New York City Relief. Cordially yours [or preferred sign-off], [Appropriate NYCR Staff Member] Title
20
[Date] Dear Mr. Smith: Thank you for agreeing to participate in the feasibility study for New York City Reliefs proposed capital campaign. Enclosed is a draft of the Case Statement. Please review this material in detail in preparation for your interview. Your interview is scheduled to take place [date] [time] at [place] with [consultant name]. I would like to re-emphasize two things. First, this is not a meeting at which you will be asked to make a gift; however, the interviewer will confidentially discuss your potential level of support for this new effort. Second, your comments and views on New York City Relief and its proposed campaign will be kept confidential. The results of the meetings with you and others will be reported anonymously. Our Board has asked The FOCUS Group, Inc. to conduct these interviews and prepare a report with recommendations. I am very grateful to you for taking your valuable time to advise New York City Relief through this interview process. Cordially yours [or preferred sign-off],
[Appropriate NYCR Staff Member] Title P.S. If there is a last minute change to your schedule, please contact The FOCUS Group consultant [place consultants name and cell phone number here]
21
[date]
Dear Mr. Smith: Thank you for participating in the feasibility study for New York City Reliefs proposed capital campaign. Your input into this study is invaluable, and I personally would like to thank you for investing your time to participate. Once the feasibility study report has been completed and submitted to the New York City Relief Board, you will be receiving an Executive Summary of the report outlining the findings and recommendations of the study. At any point during this process, I would like to encourage you to call me with questions or additional input that you may have. It is very important that we keep an open dialogue with you as we contemplate the capital campaign. Thank you again for taking your time to advise the board and administration of New York City Relief through this feasibility interview process. Cordially yours [preferred signoff],
Note: It is a good idea to have the president personally sign this letter and include a brief personal handwritten note at the bottom of the letter, ex: We really appreciate your participation and time. I look forward to seeing you and your family soon.
22
[date]
Dear Mr. Smith: This [winter] you shared your time generously with New York City Relief by participating in our feasibility study for our proposed campaign. Your gift of time and interest is greatly appreciated, and I would like to take this opportunity once again to thank you for your insights and ideas regarding our proposed campaign. As promised, I am pleased to share with you the Executive Summary of the feasibility study report, prepared for us by The FOCUS Group. Since you care deeply about New York City Relief, I am sure you will find this Executive Summary to be encouraging. If, while reading this report, you find that you have questions or additional comments that you would like to share, please call me at xxx-xxx-xxxx (direct line if appropriate). I would appreciate hearing from you. You will also be pleased to know, [or,] as you already know the board has voted to Thank you again for your time and your support. It is an exciting time for all of us at New York City Relief. [signoff],
[President]
23
24
Development Personnel
1. Please list all development department personnel and attach job descriptions for each. 2. Please include a copy of the development departments organizational chart.
Donor Research
1. Briefly describe the current donor research program, including both formal and informal methods, sources and systems. 2. Please provide a typical/sample report that is produced from the donor research program.
Planned Giving
1. Please briefly describe the strategy that is in place to secure planned gifts. 2. Briefly describe the procedures used to document donor intent. 3. Please also provide copies of gift acceptance policies and institutional policies or protocols for receiving planned gifts. Also indicate when these policies were approved by the governing board.
25
Endowment Gifts
Please include a copy of the policies that are in place regarding the receiving, managing and reporting for endowment gifts.
26
3. Provide the giving history for any previous capital campaigns in the past ten years.
27
28
10. Prepare and mail Interview Confirmation Letters to respondents when interviews have been confirmed, including a copy of the draft of the Case Statement for their review.
(Note: It is a good idea to check with the respondents regarding how they would prefer to receive this material. Faxing or emailing has worked in the past as an alternative to sending a hard copy in the mail, if this is what the respondents prefer. Occasionally, the respondents will accidentally toss materials that are sent via regular mail, especially if they are not specifically looking for them.)
11. Arrange for Institutional Data Forms to be completed and sent to TFG staff. 12. Make follow up calls to respondents a few days before each interview is to take place. Confirm receipt of Confirmation Letter and draft of the Case Statement, and confirm the details of the interview appointment. If respondents make ANY change in interview details, contact CA immediately. Encourage respondent to contact the consultant directly if time is of the essence and give them the consultants cell number. 13. Prepare and mail the Thank you Letters to respondents on a weekly basis as soon as interviews are completed. 14. Prepare and send the Follow up Letters which will include the boards actions to respondents and enclose copies of the Executive Summary from the feasibility study report.
29