Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
285
LIS Laboratory, Electronics Department, Engineering Faculty University of Setif, 19000, Setif, Algeria.
Summary
The diagnosis of gearbox faults based on the Fourier analysis of the vibration signal produced from a gear reductor system has proved its limitations in terms of spectral resolution. In this paper, we propose a method for the fault diagnosis of a gear reductor made of two toothed wheels operating at constant conditions. This technique is based on Prony method. The good performances of the proposed method relatively to the synchronous cepstral technique are demonstrated on the basis of experimental data of the vibration signal delivered from the gear reductor system under study. We show that the fault diagnosis of the considered system can be performed by observing the evolution of the power spectrum of the vibration signal during the observation days of the reductor.
Key words:
Diagnosis, Power Spectrum, Prony, Gears, Vibration Signal.
efficient to describe the non stationarities introduced by faults in the vibration signal. The second limitation and the most important one is the frequency resolution, which is the ability to distinguish the spectral responses to two or many harmonics. Another limitation is due to the windowing of data which appears during the FFT processing [9]. In order to overcome these performance limitations inherent to the FFT approach, many modern spectral estimation techniques have been proposed during the last two decades [10 - 23]. In this paper, we propose and analyse a spectral approach, based on the Prony method, to the diagnosis of faults in gear reductors. A comparison between the proposed method and the synchonous cepstrum technique will be performed by using the vibration signal delivered by gear reductors.
1. Introduction
The gear reductors are present in all mechanical machines. We find them in most industrial sectors such as the speedbox in automobile industries. Researchers are still very interested in the study of gear reductors because of their relative weakness [1 - 7]. The analysis of vibration signals was often based on the fast Fourier transform [3, 8, 9]. This approach suffers from some limitations. Among these limitations, the FFT is not
CETIM: Centre dEtudes Techniques des Industries Mcaniques, 52 av. Felix Louat, 60300 Senlis.
286
IJCSNS International Journal of Computer Science and Network Security, VOL.7 No.10, October 2007
Motor
Reductor under test ratio 20/21 Fig. 2 Tooth 2 in the 10th day.
Height of the tooth Fig. 3 Tooth 16 in the 11th day. a : Meshing beginning. c: End of the contact. d: End of the meshing.
Measuring point
Gear
The system characteristics are: *The number of teeth is respectively 20 teeth on the first wheel and 21 teeth on the second wheel. *The rotation speed of the input tree of the reductor is Rpm= 1000 turns/min, thus a rotation frequency of fr=16.67 Hz and 15.87 Hz on the output tree. *The meshing frequency is fe=333.33 Hz. A measure has been recorded every day during a period of 12 days. The machine has turned permanently during the 12 days. Each measure is composed of approximately 60000 samples, thats about 50 rotation periods. The sampling frequency is 20 kHz. During experimentation, the testing gear goes from the well operating state to the deteriorated gear state.
Tooth spalling No evolution Tooth 1/2 no evolution, tooth 15/16 spalling beginning Spalling evolution of tooth 15/16 // // // //
IJCSNS International Journal of Computer Science and Network Security, VOL.7 No.10, October 2007
287
with:
wheel 1 (pinion of 20 teeth), f r1 : the rotation frequency of wheel 1 and N 1 : the number of teeth of wheel 1.
Tr 2 = 1 / f 2 = N 2 .Te With: Tr 2 : the rotation period of wheel 2, f r 2 : the rotation frequency of wheel 2 and N 2 : the teeth number of wheel 2. The Fourier transform (TF) of the signal se (t ) is:
Se( f ) = Xc ( f ).( f nfe) + Xc ( f ) ( f nfe) *Sr1( f ).
n= m + +
( f f
=
r1
) + Xc ( f ) ( f nfe ) * Sr 2 ( f ). ( f ifr 2 )
n i =
(2)
x en =
i =1
b i Z in for n=0,1,.,N-1
(5)
X c ( f ) = TF[xc (t)] S r 1 ( f ) = TF [ s r 1 ( t )]
S r 2 ( f ) = TF[s r 2 (t )]
Zi = [exp(i + j 2fi)t ]
(7)
i the
4. Presentation Techniques
of
Vibratory
Analysis
and t the sampling period in seconds. To estimate the polynomial coefficients and the model order, we use one of the estimation algorithms for the AR model parameters. In our work, we have used the RLS (recursive least square) algorithm. To determine the frequencies and the damping coefficients, we use the following equations:
x e (t ) = E[ xe (t )]
Generally, this mean is a function of time. It is constant for a stationary signal; it is periodic for a cyclostationary signal [8]. The first order cyclostationarity is one means for the diagnosis of gear reductor faults. For the kind of reductor under study including a pinion of period T1 and a wheel of period T2 [2, 8], it is shown that the signal is cyclostationary at the periods T1 and T2 [3, 24]. It is possible to estimate, in our application, the synchronous mean relatively to one of these periods as follows:
p ( ) = 1 / N
F (Z ) = (Z Z k ) =
k =1
i=0
aiZ
P i
,a0=1
(8) (9)
(10) fi =tg 1[Im( Z i ) / Re( Z i )]/ 2 t The determination of amplitudes and phases is based on equations (9) et (10). The approximation function becomes then:
X e (n) = Ai exp( i it ) exp[ j (2f i it + i )] (11)
i =1 P
i = ln Z i / t
N 1 k =0
s ( + k . motif )
(3)
motif
samples.
288
IJCSNS International Journal of Computer Science and Network Security, VOL.7 No.10, October 2007
Amplitude relative
S e Pr ony ( f ) = X e ( f ) X e ( f )=
0 .3
Day (08)
Ai exp( j i ) 2 + [2 ( mf f
i =1 i
(12)
i
0 .2
) ]2
0 .1
The temporal and spectral processing of data, using the investigated techniques, will be presented in the following section.
- 0 .1
- 0 .2
- 0 .3
- 0 .4 0 0 .0 5 0 .1 0 .1 5 0 .2 0 .2 5
of
Data
and
1
The synchronous cepstre method and the Prony based technique proposed in this work have been applied to the vibration signal emitted by the gear system under study. The order of Prony model is estimated with the optimal criterion of Akaike (AIC) [9, 27]. The spectral analysis methods proposed in this paper have been simulated using an amplitude modulated signal composed of a white gaussian noise and three sinusoids of respective normalised frequencies 0.1, 0.2 and 0.21 and amplitudes 0.1, 1, and 1 (already available mechanical model [9]). The technique based on Prony algorithm and synchronous cepstre method are then applied to the recorded vibration signal emitted by the gear system under study.
Day (06)
0 .4
Amplitude relative
0 .8 0 .6 0 .4 0 .2 0 - 0 .2 - 0 .4 - 0 .6 - 0 .8 -1 0 0 .0 5 0 .1 0 .1 5 0 .2 0 .2 5
Time (s) Fig. 5 Vibrations recorded during days 6, 7,8 and 12. Displaying over 4 periods of rotation relative to the pinion.
0 .3 0 .2 0 .1 0 - 0 .1 - 0 .2 - 0 .3 - 0 .4 - 0 .5 0 0 .0 5 0 .1 0 .1 5 0 .2 0 .2 5
We notice, in figure 5, that the temporal representation of signals observed each day presents oscillations caused by teeth meshing and a modulation of long duration corresponding to the period of the two wheels (pinion of 20 teeth and wheel of 21 teeth). The vibration signal keeps this shape until the 12th day during which the fault is supposed to appear. We observe a very high increase of signal amplitude around modulations relative to oscillations between these last ones. These observations allow the diagnosis of a fault in the 12th and 13th days.
Amplitude relative
Amplitude relative
0 .3 0 .2 0 .1 0 - 0 .1 - 0 .2 - 0 .3 - 0 .4 0 0 .0 5 0 .1 0 .1 5 0 .2 0 .2 5
Time (s)
IJCSNS International Journal of Computer Science and Network Security, VOL.7 No.10, October 2007 the wheel (with 21 teeth) during the 12 days of experimentation. We observe, according to figure 5, from the 2nd to the 7th day the presence of a relatively weak change in amplitude of peaks of the wheel with 21 teeth and of the pinion with 20 teeth. This change is due to many phenomena such as the level and quality of the lubricant. At the 8th day, we observe the appearance of a fault on the pinion in an obvious manner by an increase of the peak characterising it. These observations can be valuable for the diagnosis of the fault and its localisation through the synchronous cepstre.
Day 06
289
Day 12
Amplitude relative
Time (s)
Fig. 6 The cepstre of the signal recorded during days
Amplitude relative
6,7,8 and 12. A: peak of wheel with 21 teeth. B: peak of wheel with 20 teeth.
0.35
Peak amplitudes
Time (s)
0.3
0.25
0.2
0.15
0 .2
0.1
0.15
0.05 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13
0 .1
Days
0.05
-0.0 5
Time (s)
0.15
0.2
0 .25
0 .2
0.15
0 .1
0.05
Time (s)
The power spectral density is estimated each day of the experimentation by the proposed Prony based technique. The vibration signal recorded each day is filtered between the third and the fifth meshing harmonics, where there is a higher energy with a bandwidth equals to two times the meshing frequency. The filtered passeband signal is modulated, and then it is lowpass filtered to eliminate the meshing peak in the purpose of observing the information contained in the lateral bands. Figure 8 shows the spectrum of the vibration signal recorded at the 4th day over 20 rotation periods of the pinion before and after the demodulation and the lowpass filtering.
290
IJCSNS International Journal of Computer Science and Network Security, VOL.7 No.10, October 2007
In the next part, we will present the experimental results, in the frequency domain, that are obtained from the Prony based method after the synchronous mean, the demodulation and the lowpass filtering.
(Day 07)
170
160
D S P (dB)
150
140
Amplitude
130
120
Frequency (Hz)
2
(Day 08)
170
1 00 0
2000
3 00 0
4000
5 00 0
6000
7 00 0
8000
9 00 0
160
150
140
130
120
110
20
40
60
80
1 00
120
1 40
160
180
200
190
180
170
D S P (dB)
160
150
140
130
120
(Day 06)
110
A
1 70 1 60
Frequency (Hz) Fig. 9 Spectrum of the recorded signal estimated from Prony based technique at days 6, 7, 8 and 12. A: peak of 21 teeth wheel B: peak of 20 teeth wheel
D S P (dB)
1 50
1 40
1 30
1 20
1 10
1 00 20 40 60 80 1 00 12 0 1 40 1 60 1 80
Frequency (Hz)
This spectral analysis technique detects the fault, its localisation and its evolution. We can conclude that Prony based technique is an efficient means for the diagnosis of gear reductor faults.
IJCSNS International Journal of Computer Science and Network Security, VOL.7 No.10, October 2007
291
0.35
0.3
Peak Amplitudes
0.25
0.2
0.15
0.1
0.05 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13
Days
10. Comparative Study of the Proposed Method Relative to the Expertise Report [3]
Table 2 presents the day of fault detection using the investigated techniques according to the evolution of peaks corresponding to the rotation frequencies of the 21 teeth wheel and the 20 teeth pinion.
vibration signal emitted from the gear system under study have revealed that the cepstral method shows clearly the presence of two modulations, whereas in the temporal signal, it seems that there exists only one modulation. Moreover, this method permits to precisely measure the peaks corresponding to the 21 teeth wheel and the 20 teeth pinion. It detects well the fault at the 8th day according to the change in the vibrations nature, whereas the temporal signal does not present yet characteristic particularities on the appearance of a fault until the 12th day only. Furthermore, the Prony based technique detects the fault appearance at the 6th day in the gear reductor system through a simple visual interpretation and consequently a simple observation of the presence or the absence of gear faults. In summary, this study demonstrates, relatively to the expertise report, that the proposed Prony based method is more performant than the cepstre synchronous method. It can be interesting in the supervision of complex gear reductors. In this case, we must follow carefully the evolution of particular peaks, both in amplitude and frequency, in the purpose of detecting faults.
11. Conclusion
In this paper, a gear box diagnosis technique based on Prony model has been proposed. The performances of this technique in the gear system diagnosis have been compared to those of the synchronous cepstre method and the expertise report. The application of this technique to the vibration signal emitted by the gear reductor system permits to conclude that it can play an important role in the study of gear vibrations. In fact, the use state of a reductor is strongly related to modulation phenomena that present the vibrations relative to the meshing signal. We have shown that vibration analysis through the Prony based technique permits to detect the fault presence and determine the deteriorated wheel at the 6th day, whereas the synchronous cepstre detects the fault at the 8th day. Consequently, this technique is very efficient for the diagnosis of faults in gears reductors.
// // // //
References
[1] Isa Yesilyurt Fault detection and location in gears by the smoothed instantaneous power spectrum distribution NDT&E International 36 (2003) 535 542 [2] M. El Badaoui, Cahouet V., Guillet F., Danire J., Velex P., "Modelling and detection of localized tooth defects in geared systems", ASME Journal of mechanical design, Vol. 123, sept. 2001, p 422-430.
The proposed Prony based technique and the synchronous cepstre method that we have applied to the
292
IJCSNS International Journal of Computer Science and Network Security, VOL.7 No.10, October 2007 [16] L. B. Jack, A.K. Nandi, Fault detection using support vector machines and artificial neural network augmented by genetic algorithms, Mechanical Systems and Signal Processing 16 (2002) 373- 390. [17] Tim Toutountzakis, Chee Keong Tan, David Mba Application of acoustic emission to seeded gear fault detectionT. Toutountzakis et al. / NDT&E International 38 (2005) 2736 [18] S.J. Loutridis Instantaneous energy density as a feature for gear fault detection, Mechanical Systems and Signal Processing 20 (2006) 12391253. [19] D. Chen, W. J. Wang Classification of Wavelet Map Patternsusing Multi-Layerneural Networks For Gear Fault Detection Mechanical Systems and Signal Processing (2002) 16(4), 695704. [20] B. Samanta Artificial neural networks and genetic algorithms for gear fault detection Mechanical Systems and Signal Processing 18 (2004) 12731282. [21] B. Samanta, K. R. Al- Balushi, Artificial neural network based fault diagnosis of rolling element bearings using time- domain features, Mechanical Systems and Signal Processing, 2002. [22] P. D. McFadden, Detection of gear faults by decomposition of matched differences of vibration signals, Mechanical Systems and Signal Processing 14 (2002) 805- 817. [23] J. Antoni, R. B. Randall, Differential diagnosis of gear and bearing faults , Transactions of the ASME, Journal of Vibration and Acoustics 124 (2002) 165171. [24] J. Antoni, J. Danire, F. Guillet., Effective Vibration Analysis of IC Engines using Cyclostationarity Part 2 New Results on the reconstruction of the cylinder Pressures., Journal of Sound and Vibration, volume 257 issue 5. 7 novembre 2002, page 839-856. [25] ElBadaoui M, Guillet F, Danire J. Contribution de cepstre dnergie au diagnostic des de rducteur complexe engrenages . 3me Confrence Internationale Mthodes de Surveillances et Technique de Diagnostique Acoustique et Vibration, Senlis, France, 13-15 Oct. 1998. [26] Haloui, N. Chikouche, D. Benidir, M. Application of spectral parameters analysis methods for the detection of gear faults in rotating machines IEEE CCECE02 Proceedings; vol. 1, pp. 190-194, 13-15 mai 2002. [27] H. Akaike, A new look at the statistical model identification, IEEE. Transactions on automatic control, vol. AC-19, No . 6, Dec. 1974. [28] A. Apostoliouk, Amlioration de la mthode de Prony dans le problme didentification des systmes dynamiques, Proc, Frrst. Int. Conf on Electronics end Automatic Control. Mai. 1994.
[3] Noureddine Haloui, Djamel Chikouche, Messaoud Benidir, and Rais Elhadi Bekka , Diagnosis of Gear Systems by Specral Analysis of Vibration Signals Using Synchronous Cepstre Technique , GESTS Internationl Transactions on Communication and Signal Processing, August 2006, Vol 8, N 1, p 27 36. [4] Mcfadden P. D, Detecting fatigue cracks en gears by amplitude and phase demodulation of the meshing vibration , Journal of vibration, Acoustics, stress, and Reliability in Design, avril 1986, Vol. 108, p. 165 170. [5] Antoniadis I. Glossiotis G, Cyclostationnary analysis of rolling element bearing vibration signals Journal Sound of Vibration, Dc 2001, Vol. 248, N 5, p 829 845. [6] Shiroishi J., L I Y., Liang S., Kurfess T., Danyluk S. Bearing condition diagnostics via vibration and acoustic emission measurements Mechanical Systems and Signal Processing, Sept 1997, Vol. 11, N 5, p 693 705. [7] W. J. Wang, P. D. Mcfadden, Application of wavelets to gearbox vibration signals for fault detection, Journal of sound and vibration (1996), 192(5), pp. 927- 939. [8] H. Akaike, A new look at the statistical model identification, IEEE. Transactions on automatic control, vol. AC-19, No . 6, Dec. 1974. [9] S. M. Kay, Modern spectral estimation, Printice hall signal processing series, Englewood cliffs, New Jersey 07632, 1988. [10] J.A. Cadzow, Spectral estimation: An Overdetermined Rational Model Equation Approach, Proc. IEEE, vol.70, N 9, Sep. 1982, pp. 907-937. [11] R. H. Jones, Identification and autoregressive spectrum estimation, IEEE. Transaction on automatic contrl, vol. AC 131, No . 13, Dec. 1974. [12] R. E. Bekka, D. Chikouche, Pouvoir de dtection et de rsolution de la mthode AR : Application aux signaux courts, Revue Sciences &c Technologie, Univ. Constantine, N12, Dec. 1999, pp. 49- 53. [13] S . Kay, S. L. Marpele, Spectrum Analysis: A modern perspective , Proc. IEEE, vol. 69, N 11, Nov 1981, pp.1380-1419. [14] B. Samanta Gear fault detection using artificial neural networks and support vector machines with genetic algorithms Mechanical Systems and Signal Processing 18 (2004) 625644. [15] K. R. Al- Balushi, B. Samanta, Gear fault diagnosis using energy- based features of acoustic emission siganals, Proceedings of institution of Mechanical Engineers, Part I: Journal of Systems and control Engineeing 216 (2002) 249- 263.
IJCSNS International Journal of Computer Science and Network Security, VOL.7 No.10, October 2007 [29] W. M. Steedly, C. J. Ying, A Modified TLS-Prony Method Using Data Decimation, IEEE, Trans. Sig. Proc., vol. 42, N 9, Sept. 1994, pp. 2292- 2303.
293
Biography
Name: Chikouche Djamel Address: Electronics Department, Engineering, Faculty, University of Setif, Postal Code 19000, Setif, Algeria. Education & Work experience: Professor at the Electronics Department, Engineering Faculty, University of Setif, Algeria. I got my MS degree in Electrical Engineering from Ohio State University, USA in 1984 and my PhD in Signal Processing from the University of Setif, Algeria in 2000. My research interests are: Signal processing, spectral analysis, fast algorithms, diagnosis of gearbox faults, and parallel processors.
Name: Benidir Massaoud Address: Laboratory of the Signals and Systems, College of Electricity, University of Paris- South, 3, Street JoliotCurie, Postal Code 91192, Gif- Sur-Yvette, Cedex, France. Education & Work experience: Professor of signal processing and Dean of the Doctoral education, University of Paris-South, France. Name: Haloui Noureddine Address: 2, Avenue of Savigny Postal Code 93600, Aulnay Sous Bois, France. Education & Work experience: I got my MS degree in Signal Processing from the University of Setif, Algeria in 2002. My research interests are: Signal processing, spectral analysis and diagnosis of gearbox faults.