STATE OF SOUTH CAROLIA )

)
COUNTY OF JASPER )
Sout Caolina Deaent of )
Health and Environmenta Contol, )
)
Plaintif )
)
vs. )
)
Salvatore Arzillo, )
)
Defedat. )
IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS
FOURTEENTH JUDICIAL CIRCUIT
Civil Action No: 2014-CP-27-

SUNONS
(on-Jury-Enforcement Acton)
TO: SALVATORE ARZILLO OR COUSEL THERETO:
YOU ARE HERBY SUMMONSED and required to answer te Complaint in ts
action, a copy of which is heewith seed upon you, to fle a copy of said Answer with the
Jasper County Clerk of Court, ad to see a copy of your aswer to the said Complant on te
subscribe at te South Caolina Deaet of Healt and Environmeta Contol, Ofce of
General Counsel, R.R. Aycock Building, 2600 Bull Steet, Colubia, South Caolina 29201,
within (30) days afer seice hereof, exclusive of the day of seice. If you fail to answer te
Complant witn te time aforesad, the Plaintif in this acton will apply to te Cour for te
relief demaded in te Complant.
April 2014
Columbia, South Caolina
Respectflly submitted,
ra
S.C. Ba No. 75117
Assistat Geeral Counsel
South Caolina Deaent of Health
ad Environmetal Contol
2600 Bull Steet
Columbia, SC 29201
Tel.: (803) 898-3349
Fax: (803) 898-3367 (not for seice)
tra ec.sc.gov (not for service)
STATE OF SOUTH CAROLINA
COUNTY OF JASPER
South Carolina Deaent of
Health and Environmetal Contol,
Plantf
vs.
Savatore Arzillo,
Defendant.
)
)
)
)
)

)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS
FOURTEENTH JUDICIAL CIRCUIT
Civil Action No: 2014-CP-27-
COMPLAT
(on-Jury)
(nforcement Acton)

The Plantif South Caolina Deaet of Healt and Environmetal Contol

("SCDHEC" or the "Depament"), complainng of and aganst Defendat Salvatore Arillo
would respectflly show tis Honorable Court that:
1. Plantif SCDHEC is an agecy of the State of Sout Caolina vested wit all te
powes, fnctions, and dutes ganted to it, its ofcers, ad agets by statute. The Deaent is
charged with impleentaton of the Sout Carolina Polluton Contol Act, S. C. Code P &
48-1-110 et . (2008), te Wate Polluton Contol Peits, 24 S.C. Code P a Regs.
61.9.122.26 (2011) and NPDES Geneal Permit for Stor Wate Discharges.
2. Tis is a civil acton pursuat to S.C. Code P 48-1-110 of te South Caolina
Pollution Contol Act for the enforceent of a Consent Order.
3. Defendant Salvatore Arzillo is an individual responsible for lad-disturbing
acvities locate at Tax Map. No. 029-43-04-003 in Jasper County, South Caolina; theefore,
ts Cou has jusdicion over tis action ad veue is proper in tis Cou.
1
4. On Ocobe 29, 2009, the Deartent issued NPDES Pet SCR10L286 to
Defedant Azillo, authorizing stor water dischages fom the Site to wates of te State in
accordace wit the efuent limitations, monitoring requremets and oter conditions as set
fort in the peit.
5. The Dearent conducted inspections of te Site on March 3 and March 31,
2010, noting numeous violatons of Defedant's perit on bot occasions. (See Attachment
A).
6. Following numerous attempts to bring the Site into compliace ad resolve te
violatons, te Deaent and Defedat Arzillo eteed into Consent Order 12-03 7-W on
Octobe 4, 2012.
7. Defendat Azillo kowingly ad voluntarily ageed to perfor the following
activities in Consent Orde 12-037-W:
a. Within thirty (30) days fom the execution date of this Orde,
respond to staf commets i the Depaent letter dated May 19,
2010. Provide inforaton as necessary to complete te peit
application ad obtan pet coveage for the aea desigated in
te NOI submitted on AprilS, 2010;
b. Witin tirty (30) days fom te execution date of tis Orde,
peanently stabilize all aeas of te Site, outside of ay curently
peitte aea, excluding ay delineate wetlands.
c. Within sixty (60) days of te issuance of the NPDES Peit,
submit to te Dearent a report, compleed ad staped by te
S.C. Regstere Professional Engneer that develope te SWPPP,
certifing tat all stor wate and seiment contol devices ae
installed ad fnctioning propery as specife i te Site's
approved SWPPP.
d. Witn trty (30) days fom the executon date of tis Orde,
submit a Notice of Intent to the Deartent, for the puose of
obtaining coveage for the Site unde the NPDES Geneal Peit
2
for Stor Wate Discharges Associated with Industal Activities
SCROOOOOO.
e. Pay to te Dearet a civil penalty in the amount of four
thousad dollas ($4,000.00) in accordace wit te following
schedule. Te penalty shall be paid in eleven (11) equal paymets
of tree hundred t-tree dollas ad thirty-three cents
($333.33) begn ing on Octobe 15, 2012 (subseuet payets
being due on te ffeet (15
t
) day of each mont) ad a fnal
payet of tree hundred t-tree dollars ad thirty-seven
cents ($333.37) being due on Septembe 15, 2013.
8. Defendat Arzillo siged a Promissory Note ageeing to te payet scheule as
set forth above (Attachment B). Defendant has submitted te inital paymet of tee hundre
t-tree dollars and ty-tree cets ($333.33), but has not submitted te reaining
paymets according to the schedule detale in te Promissor Note.
9. Defedant Aillo kowingy, voluntaily and without coecion ageed to te
reureents of Consent Order 12-037-W, as well as to te payet scheule outined in te
Promissory Note.
3
PRAYER
WHEREFORE, having flly set fort its Complaint, the Dearent prays for a order
requiring Defendat Aillo to immediately comply with Consent Orde 12-037-W; and gating
such other and fhe relief d tis Court may de appropriate.
April _ 2014
Columbia, Sout Caolina
Respectflly submitted,
--
S.C. Ba No. 75117
Assistant General Cousel
Sout Caolia Deaent of Heat
and Environmenta Contol
2600 Bull Steet
Columbia, SC 29201
Tel.: (803) 898-3349
Fax: (803) 898-3367 (Not for Seice)
tayhms@dhec.sc.gov (Not for Seice)
4
Attachment A
STATE OF SOUTH CAROLIA
BEFOR 1 DEPARTNT OF HALTH A ENONNAL CONTROL
RE,: SALVATORAILLO
. .. :.:_, ,.. (:~. >s+ > .:.., , ;x~ .

.... aaa
..wwvx,,: ==:.. .. .; ). . , ..
_CONSEN ORER

` r
IZwT-W
. "

Salvatore A o ,=ad Hrspnsible for l-sbing av1e lote

. '
at 1MNo. 02<J++wJ(s|wjmJas Cou, Sout C|| mMWof te Sie is
eleven an net-fou bw&0(1.4)aWsg wth apprxately MX(6}W.
Te Respndet failed-t compywt te Naional Pollutt Dishge Elimnaon Syst
(DES) PWit Ndintate lad-disrbing activt on te s|aouide of the WWdesignate in
the Depaent apprved somWatr Polluton Prveton Pla (SWPP).
=upn dscusions mte Rpondent on !w!,202,te pies WQt te
issuce of Oer to inclu te followng Findings of Fat a Coluions of Law.
1

- 4
IINGS OF FAC
+~ .
. Te Respondnt ow mHnsible fOtlad-disting aivit mte Site mJaper

_
_

_
C
o
ut, Sou Cro
t
i
ni:) " .+

_

2. On Octobr 2,2w,0cDeent ise NUbP= t bK1LoWKpu4
_1 s
.
autorizng sor =.mUblNto wate oft Stte macrdc wt te
_ . . .
_
cUBculliton mammgtequment ad ot conditons set for Qm.
J. UmUbJ, !,DQentconducted |a|asolmcSite. Te Rendent
Wpresent. Te folloWing wa noted:
a) Te Stor Water PoJJuon Prevention Pla (SWPP) Wnot available;
'`.
.

.
t

.':`:
< "

_
__ `-

`
.

"
'

$-_
_
b) TDHC -cvee}et Wulalale;
c) Io wmWUotavaale;
d) mmWmt bng pfore b qied pnel;

__ _ _
-
, ,..... ...
_
' --
.

- _ __
___

e) Lm,cton bmsld w (vehicle p) we oi, moi cone,

u t a-oil MwWg

Sit fe R.Wprt W i neof r

g Sit a ot Mt ad esion UNmtmile MMM
`'
h) Tcton woWmlmlmg0QgmSWPP;
i) ml0foue(14) dy mlben Wm,
_ -
_

:
)
I
Cleg a

mwouid of RW qSWPPP;
Te Sit rve a ,rtng. Ptg WMN.mq
` .-
_
ste Rl Waon euld m comple by Mah 26,2010. 1 npW
. .
prvidd to te xawtseenc .
4. N 31,2010, Dact sconucted a follo-up iton oft Site. Te
Rnt Wt.defciece idtfed the prou io NlM
J.
co
a) Cleag, ,-,N fll avit cntue oa:of the W t aprved
v
SWPP, Ms1mW

b) sdimet :not ben med gte apv SWPPP.

.
'`
Te Sit reived a "Uitsftz' rng. Phogp Wten.
Te ition nor uto te Pmowced ml ad eletnc W
>
:
_
A 1 2010. Te e mlad-sbi acvtes oO outide of

2
`I ? 1

I
|
|
l
'

0o0m00Q mvcqgt|orSite. lHrmdmdImcKp00mtk

wNvr Mmcot Mm 0o0a mtwof MWk
`t .
x
NM0tI8W0qMcJ@m@ .

- - ---

.c\,z:it,LmtmVcJaNN0cu| mu|t0rSl0mwDr
Uwm4.,MWSit .
. ',-
7. mal mM).9, 2010,DtStfpvded Mc&u4mtobo0&c
NUlNQI00.WlmpaWofm0lmmMbcN0Mw
&cgtmJb i$. To

Dmtm00tmW.WmmQW
WMy 19, 2010 mwi
May Z,2011, Stnw&McRpmM0cDet's ofce MBw
MMCol k&clMatSite. Hcgt do wh mMm
-Skm|ommgm.
e
. May 30, 2012, pstfmR t00w-Qion o0 Sit. T

`
&JtWt.Md0mWmN
''

8} TcSwmF0o0WdoaPla (SWPPP) w0ol=ai.:i-,

_
b) TDHC wve!:a=W0ot~i-,
_
c) Ispton rawmaale;
d) Ito --:bg g=mmmpc|;
c} r-iW,pep,au,omcbmdbs, bdw[vcwcIcp},W
oi, woIlcteled W, J00WkMWQl,

Si|t|c0cromrmmtJ=8000mbmtmW cJmd|W
. .
rqu b 0SWPPP;_
"
g TmmoWa0til e gte aprvd SWPPP;
/
'

i
&
.

b) c|,,,,mondoude olWWB te apve SWPPP,

iclu i BwJW8Wnot in pou ie ton.
i) Did WmaotWfoW{14) das efNVQ.

,..+ 4'l4 "*

q~~~ ^
)
) Wmwmlwp.
1Site re Wart. Phoths WWN
10. ma |mM31, 2012, Det stnted t QNM0
N efte ken.DeletNm wte Resndt W crtv aton
Nts|wcce b Ju 8, 2012.
II. W 19, 2012,. sted W N W W0 00

Ret tod e nTisc of 8mutemcng a dw
pqWwmW.
coNOUtONsOrW
Bad gO00bcFmgolmVDmMte followg Concluion of
LW`
1. TRpndet viola VIL/S.C. Co A. 48-l-llO(aXI}
(2008) W ZQ 24 S.C. Ce A. R. 61-9.122.26 (a) (Sup.

~
20\1)N [SCRI 000 i tt b fe
>
`.
to c0mgwmhs NES mt Nmmmlad-si avit prior wobt
.
NDES Perit cv
r
e for W4mMtDet.

. *
2. cPoluton gscCode An. 48-1-330 (8), prvde for 0mp
, -
notWexced Nmmdo($1 0,000.00) gjOYom0Bfor gN0vel
+ e - .
- -
0Act or ay re, mgep,pit coton mdenton or Lof c
.
!.
Dpmt

.
+
.
e "
4
+'
W,IS Wmo,LNWTO A Aput to M
0lI0 A@5.C.C0A .48-50(208)}48--lw(0Q,M0Rn
sh:
_ ~ ' ' ' ~ ^ " `
) ,eLN,mNmmm
'.

`
.
.
cDqlmmMy 19,2010. WwcmwMmWp:
~
ptQ l00moNgIcovmrf0tMW(4.5)dgMMN
W0nAplJ,16.
-
Z. WW(J0}'of meeon d of t O, pet WUNN0
mr5k,omdr0fcwdyymNecug NWWW
^
3. W"r m(60) atM0of0NDF(tto0Oplapq
:mimaN m5.L. KrgMko&mtWtdq0
5WFF, = mt wmW N Mlmaml am:W MK J
:. '
.
`

fco ppry @xMw0s|w's8@WSWPP.

& ' o
4. Wit tr (0) dy at&cmaaofMO, Wmt&N0dw0flNVM
.

Deet rnm,aratwmwr:rs|t:wNNDES
?mlf0r5t0mWa | :PmNWMAwm5CK00W.
. Fzyt0&cDmO|Wpqmcl0ff0wmowddoll(M,0.0)m
accdmcrw& mr m|amsue. 1 pqshlmpd c|cvm(1 l]equ
.
.
pyent wWhud mWd0llmdt-tecnt (333.33) bgg 0D
Ocl0,20I2(moutpbeing due on te fnt (IS dy 0fmm)
B mgl 0fmdW-cchmad MQ-MWW ($33.37

-:
beig OOStmb 15, zG1.
.
`.

J
-
-
T
.
- `
_
*
. , !-
l
.
J
e&
`*:-'
. ``
IATOORWc0c0ngW8Nad it ret N
m08f0II0w8
FY.Wi
,, , ...
`
.bLJ *`*`` ""^ """ ''`:
*

*

*

Uwuof Wae
Wa P0IIuuClO0n
260bm ,.

C0Imb0um2920!
TcDmnwb sud b

wdwONUmaw8payet 0mc0Wpq.
bT OR8RWwW mmgw0Np 0R Nm
@wMl0rNWNlyMte @O @b.C.CA48-
-30(208)Mu0Icmc|of 0Mpad 0mc0t0f 4Uti te
qppakmw.
11 OR8RAU&|0CtLg0ony Svr
Alo's liailit Mmcmt0tcv|0b080gm0WMI0mMN
!
cote t etr QmmMUc0tbzIwm ,w0m00lK0
:*
m0Iub0uad wcmt 0fm wf0Mmw Tc W m|rlyi uon ay
.

.
rprtton, prms, UCt U@mmUmcq8mmIyfW008
H.
`
:
` 4 [gF@cF0II0wj
\
+

"
.
.
.

.-
e*

-1
. :

-
-v
= 1
mR1m.....D&ATN
.MW.........
W
UwCmc[B0f@
A
`

* '
.v
!


. `
".
.' .
mwof
"

e

....
s
r .~.<. . :t:.......: ....t

. .
Sa
- -

;o

~

4
2 .7

.
.
.
1
Da: g/L
J D
OW
Attachment B
State 0b0RlbLsms
.

1
Cout of Japer L0Mnq ]
BOMbbUHYNO1
-mo7(.-q)
pay 0 M0Otd0tofmc b00@ LaWmaDepamet 0Mfb sod Envnment LoRU0I
N 8B0080I aenc mmfmmW "ot holdr") at20 Hw b0 l Colmia
Sout Lm 21, u UmwSt % N 0I by a negotable itent edec:
ba by te euvent mi Unte Stts % cy, te M of Four Thousad U0m
(M,M.00)payab|om acmcc m&te follow seue. Te pnty m p6m
eleven {11) eu pb 0 W hundre thi-e dm ad U-fbM rmN
($333.33) bgg on Omber5,2012(mqwp=ubdue on Wcfe t (is
dy of ea mont) s Mm @ yent offbtw bw0M W-fbtcc 0oam d W-
seven cent (MJ3.3J0won September 15, 2013 .
.
rjO| be. me t te orer of tc bom Lolm L0gMc0l 0 Het ad
Envronet LO0U0MUto ( aenton of

.
PamW|

wuolWae
Sout LM0mDepaent of Het dmwmOML0000l
ZBull Ml
Colubia SoU LmZZ0
WkDRit is o|ag dccwcJ ml mt not is gve t sm t
Oblige's prmise t pay te ,0 boadDoUr ($,000.00), t0cNON0dN.
+

.~
. .

.
'
.
U

`
*` .
3
`: ^
....,.,...

:
Page o2

.
Witess to the sigtue o(the Obhge.
:
.
Swor to before me tis . .
/ J8y0_ 212
via
f00I
My C0ission Expires: c/,
.'
-

. `l
'
' .
'
Page2of2
'
. 't