Kimberlin v. NBC Tracked Redline Redacted

1
0NITEB STATES BISTRICT C00RT

F0R TBE BISTRICT 0F NARYLANB
uREENBELT BIvISI0N

BRETT KINBERLIN,
Plaintiff,

v. No. PWu 1S SuS9

NATI0NAL BL0uuERS CL0B,
ALI AKBAR,
PATRICK FREY,
ERICK ERICKS0N,
NICBELLE NALKIN,
uLENN BECK,
AAR0N WALKER,
WILLIAN B0uE,
LEE STRANABAN,
R0BERT STACY NCCAIN,
}ANES 0'KEEFE,
NANBY NAuY,
BREITBART.C0N,
BB CAPIT0L STRATEuIES,
!"# %"&'()*
TBE FRANKLIN CENTER,
SIN0N&SCB0STER INC.,
+,## -./0"1 232 KINBERLIN0NNASKEB,
NERC0RY RABI0 ARTS,
TBE BLAZE,
ACE 0F SPABES,
REBSTATE,
-45-&.,*
-.( "0()5&"# 16(&-"-/)*
Befenuants.

1(&/#! "0(#!(! &/06+"5#- 7/) !"0"8(1
95/+"-5/# /7 &595+ )58.-1* )5&/ "#! 1-"-( +"4 -/)-1

5#-)/!:&-5/#

1. Plaintiff Biett Kimbeilin ("Kimbeilin") heieby biings this 1;<=>? Amenueu
Complaint to iecovei uamages inflicteu by Befenuants, uefineu below, @=A ;>B2BC>B
C> 2 DEFGCGE?; =@ G=AGC=EH 2<GH, incluuing a ciiminal iacketeeiing enteipiise that
Justice Through Music 14331 18:40
Deleted: TWITCBY,
Formatted: Font color: Black
Deleted: .
Formatted: Font color: Black, Pattern:
Clear (White)
Deleted: ... [1]
Formatted: Font color: Red
Deleted: complaint
Formatted: Font:Bold

2
;>B2B;? C> wiuespieau mail fiauu, wiie fiauu, money launueiing, intimiuation,
assault, extoition, 2GG;DIG;? extoition, obstiuction of justice, anu gang activity foi
the puipose of haiming 6F2C>GC@@JH KEHC>;HH 2>? IA=I;AGL C>G;A;HGH anu uepiiving
him of his civil iights. Specifically, the Befenuants (1) cieateu false anu uefamatoiy
naiiatives stating that Plaintiff engageu in, oiueieu, uiiecteu anuoi facilitateu the
ciiminal swatting of inuiviuuals, (2) <A;2G;? =GM;A @2FH; >2AA2GCN;H 2K=EG 6F2C>GC@@
C> =A?;A G= K=FHG;A GM; @2FH; HO2GGC>B >2AA2GCN;P (S) pioviueu false infoimation to
meuia outlets, politicians anu law enfoicement officials accusing Plaintiff of
involvement in saiu swattings, (S) iepeateuly publisheu uefamatoiy statements that
Plaintiff committeu swattings, (4) <=>HG2>GFL KEFFC;? 6F2C>GC@@ OCGM <ACDC>2F
<=>NC<GC=>H D=A; GM2> GMA;; ?;<2?;H =F? C> =A?;A G= ?;D=>CQ; MCD, anu then
(S) eniicheu themselves by fiauuulently iaising ME>?A;?H =@ thousanus of uollais
anu incieasing tiaffic on theii websites baseu on those false naiiatives. Some of the
Befenuants conspiieu to anuoi uiu assault Plaintiff anu then useu gang activity to
thieaten him against exeicising his iight to ieuiess thiough access to the couits.
The Befenuants useu online anu offline gang activity to thieaten, haiass anu
intimiuate otheis who iejecteu theii false naiiatives about Plaintiff, incluuing
jouinalists, juuges anu Naiylanu State's Attoineys. -M;H; GMA;2GH =@ M2AD 2>?
?;2GM O;A; D;2>G G= 2>? ?C? C>GCDC?2G; 6F2C>GC@@ @A=D H;;3C>B A;?A;HH @=A
D=A; GM2> =>; L;2AR These toits weie intentional anu causeu Plaintiff physical
haim anu emotional uistiess.
Deleted: violateu his civil iights anu which
incluues
Deleted: thieat of
Deleted: Plaintiff
Deleted: anu then (
Deleted: tens

S
2. Swatting is the calling of the police using a falsifieu phone numbei anu telling
the police that a majoi ciime occuiieu at the auuiess associateu with that auuiess in
oiuei to cause a laige police iesponse.
S. Befenuants iepeateuly maue the false, slanueious anu uefamatoiy
statements about Plaintiff's involvement in swatting month aftei month foi moie
than a yeai, causing the publication of thousanus of aiticles, blog posts, Twittei
tweets anu iauio anu television bioaucasts attiibuting the swattings to Plaintiff.
4. None of the Befenuants evei contacteu Plaintiff foi comment oi iesponse to
these false, slanueious anu libelous statements piioi to oi aftei theii publication.
S. Plaintiff asseits claims against Befenuants aiising fiom violations of (1) the
Racketeeiing Influenceu anu Coiiupt 0iganizations Act (RIC0), 18 0SC 1962(c); (2)
conspiiacy unuei RIC0, 18 0SC 1962(u); (S) the Civil Rights Act, 42 0SC 198S, (4)
conspiiacy unuei the Ku Klux Klan Act, 42 0SC 198S, (S) assault, (6) uefamation; (7)
fiauu, (8S @2FH; FCBMG C>N2HC=> =@ IACN2<L* TUS C>G;A@;A;><; OCGM KEHC>;HH
A;F2GC=>HMCIH* TVWS C>G;A@;A;><; OCGM IA=HI;<GCN; 2?N2>G2B;* TVVS <=>HICA2<L*
TVXS K2GG;AL* 2>? TVYS intentional infliction of emotional uistiess.
Z:)51!5&-5/# "#! 9(#:(
6. This Couit has juiisuiction ovei this action puisuant to 28 0SC 1SS1 (feueial
question), 28 0SC 1SS2 (uiveisity of citizenship), anu 18 0SC 1964(c) (RIC0).
7. This Couit has supplemental juiisuiction ovei the HG2G; causes of action
baseu on state law puisuant to 28 0SC 1S67(a), as the state law claims aiise out of
the same nucleus of opeiative facts which suppoit the feueial claims.
Deleted: anu (

4
8. venue is piopei in the Bistiict of Naiylanu unuei 18 0SC 196S anu 28 0SC
1S91, in that Plaintiff iesiues in Naiylanu, many of the actions of Befenuants took
place in Naiylanu, the injuiy occuiieu in Naiylanu, anu a substantial poition of the
communications, tiansactions, events oi omissions occuiieu in Naiylanu.
6")-5(1
9. Plaintiff Kimbeilin is the Biiectoi of }ustice Thiough Nusic, a Naiylanu baseu
Su1(c)(S) non-piofit that uses music to inspiie anu euucate young people to get
involveu with civic paiticipation. Plaintiff has helu that position foi ten yeais anu
iesiues anu woiks in Nontgomeiy County Naiylanu. 6F2C>GC@@ CH 2FH= 2 DEHC<C2>*
D2>2B;A* DEHC< IA=?E<;A* 2>? <=DI=H;A ;>B2B;? C> GM; KEHC>;HH =@ DEHC<R
1u. At all ielevant times, GM; )5&/ Befenuants aie a "peison" within the
meaning of that teim as uefineu by RIC0, 18 0SC 1961(S).
11. At all ielevant times, Befenuants weie engageu in inteistate
commeice oi in the piouuction of goous oi seivices foi sale oi use in inteistate
commeice.
12. Befenuant }ames 0'Keefe iesiues at 1214 W. Boston Post Roau #14S,
Namaioneck, New Yoik 1uS4S who poitiays himself as a "citizen jouinalist" anu
book authoi. Be iecently publisheu a book entitleu, "Bieakthiough: 0ui uueiilla
Wai to Expose Fiauu anu Save Bemociacy," publisheu by Befenuants Simon &
Shustei, anu ieleaseu thiough its Thiesholu Bivision. Simon & Shustei has its
coipoiate heauquaiteis at 12Su Avenue of the Ameiicas, New Yoik, New Yoik
1uu2u.

S
1S. Befenuant Aaion Walkei is an unemployeu attoiney who iesiues at
7SS7 Remington, Ru, Nanassas, viiginia. 2u1u9.
14. Befenuant Lee Stianahan is a bloggei who iesiues at 1S824 Nethuen
uieen Stieet, Ballas, Texas 7S24u.
1S. Befenuant Nanuy Nagy is a bloggei who iesiues at 1u Sussex Ct,
Beuminstei, New }eisey u7921.
16. Both Befenuants Stianahan anu Nagy wiite =A OA=G; foi Befenuant
Bieitbait.com, a meuia gioup locateu at 149 South Baiiington #7SS, Los Angeles,
Califoinia 9uu49.
17. Befenuant Robeit Stacy NcCain is a bloggei who iesiues at 21819
Acauemy Teiiace, Bageistown, Naiylanu 2174u. XU[ %EA>HC?; !AR 72FFC>B 42G;AH*
49 X\[VU
18. Befenuant William Boge is a bloggei who iesiues at 2u Riuge Roau,
Westminstei, Naiylanu 211S7.
19. Befenuant Ali Akbai iesiues at 2uu Capstone Biive, #1u8, Lynchbuig,
viiginia 24Su2, anu is the self pioclaimeu heau of the Befenuant National Bloggeis
Club, which is O2H locateu at 8116 Beiitage Place Biive, Ft. Woith, Texas 761S7.
2u. Befenuant ulenn Beck is a iauio anu television peisonality OM=H;
<=AI=A2G; 2??A;HH CH iesiues at 127u Avenue of the Ameiicas, 9th Flooi New Yoik,
New Yoik 1uu2u.
21. Nichelle Nalkin is a bloggei anu F0X News commentatoi OM=H;
<=AI=A2G; 2??A;HH CH iesiues at 44SC E. Cheyenne Nountain Blvu. #1u4, Coloiauo
Spiings, Coloiauo 8u9u6.
Formatted: Strikethrough
Deleted: who
Deleted: who

6
22. Befenuant Eiick Eiickson is a bloggei anu television commentatoi
who iesiues at 7S6 Waveily Pt, Nacon, ueoigia S121u.
2S. Befenuant Ace 0f Spaues is a blog cieateu A;BCHG;A;? by Nichelle
Keii anu is locateu at S1S1 Bomesteau Roau, #SE Santa Claia, Califoinia 9SuS1 anu
it is wiitten by an anonymous bloggei.
24. Befenuant Patiick Fiey is a bloggei who iesiues at SS47 Seaglen
Biive, Rancho Palos veiues, Califoinia 9u27S. Be is employeu as an Assistant
State's Attoiney foi Los Angeles.
2S. Befenuant Twitchy is a blogging platfoim owneu oi opeiateu by
Befenuant Nichelle Nalkin thiough Twitchy LLC to piomote stoiies cieateu by hei
anu othei membeis of Twitchy. It is heauquaiteieu at 44SC E. Cheyenne Nountain
Blvu. #1u4, Coloiauo Spiings, Coloiauo 8u9u6. 5G O2H A;<;>GFL IEA<M2H;? KL
12F;D &=DDE>C<2GC=>H F=<2G;? []]W 12>G2 )=H2 )=2? &2D2ACFF=* &" UYWVXR
26. Befenuant The ulenn Beck PiogiamNeicuiy Rauio Aits, is a meuia
company cieateu to piomote Befenuant ulenn Beck anu is locateu 127u Avenue of
the Ameiicas, 9th Flooi New Yoik, New Yoik 1uu2u.
27. Befenuant The Blaze Inc, Is a meuia company owneu by Befenuant
ulenn Beck anu cieateu to piomote Befenuant ulenn Beck anu his woiluview, anu is
locateu at 11SS Avenue of the Ameiicas, S4th Flooi, New Yoik, New Yoik 1uuS6.
28. Befenuant ReuState is a meuia company owneuoi uiiecteu by
Befenuant Eiick Eiickson anu is locateu at 1 Nassachusetts Avenue, NW Ste 6uu,
Washington, BC, 2uuu1 2>? O2H A;<;>GFL IEA<M2H;? KL 12F;D &=DDE>C<2GC=>H
OMC<M CH F=<2G;? 2G []]W 12>G2 )=H2 )=2? &2D2ACFF=* &" UYWVXR
Deleted: .

7
29. Befenuant BB Capitol Stiategies is a law fiim locateu at 717 King
Stieet, Suite Suu Alexanuiia, viiginia 22S14, anu is heaueu by Attoiney 2>?
!;@;>?2>G Ban Backei.
Su. The Fianklin Centei foi uoveinment anu Public Integiity is a non-
piofit oiganization locateu at 1229 King Stieet, S
iu
Flooi, Alexanuiia, viiginia
22S14, with a mission of feiieting out B=N;A>D;>G coiiuption.
S1. -M; "D;AC<2> 1I;<G2G=A CH 2 IEKFC<2GC=> =@ GM; "D;AC<2>
1I;<G2G=A 7=E>?2GC=> F=<2G;? 2G V^VV #R ';>G 1GA;;G* 1ECG; UWV* "AFC>BG=>* 9"
XXXWUR
S2. Befenuant +L>> -M=D2H 232 Kimbeilin0nmaskeu CH 2 bloggei
whose mission is to smeai I;=IF;* C><FE?C>B Plaintiff. -M; 'CDK;AFC>:>D2H3;?
2<<=E>G O2H <A;2G;? KL !;@;>?2>G -M=D2H EHC>B GM; ;D2CF
<2EH2F>;_EHRB;=AB;`BD2CFR<=DR

1-"-(0(#- /7 7"&-1
SS. 5> XWWU* GMA;; DCFCG2AL C>G;FFCB;><; <=>GA2<G=AH* .% 82AL* %;AC<=
-;<M>=F=BC;H 2>? 62F2>GCA <A;2G;? 2 H;<A;G BA=EI <2FF;? a-;2D -M;DCHb G=
?;HGA=L IA=BA;HHCN; =AB2>CQ2GC=>H 2>? GM;CA HG2@@ => K;M2F@ =@ <=AI=A2G;
<FC;>GH 2>? @;?;A2F 2B;><C;H* C><FE?C>B GM; :>CG;? 1G2G;H &M2DK;A =@
&=DD;A<; 2>? 7%5R -M;H; 2<GCNCHGH 2>? =AB2>CQ2GC=>H O;A; G2AB;G;? @=A
;_;A<CHC>B GM;CA <=>HGCGEGC=>2F ACBMGH G= @A;; ;_IA;HHC=> 2>? @A;;?=D =@
2HH;DKFLR 1=D; =@ GM; BA=EIH 2>? I;=IF; G2AB;G;? O;A; 4C3CF;23H*
">=>LD=EH* -MC>36A=BA;HH* 8F;>> 8A;;>O2F?* &M2DK;A 42G<M* &M2>B; G=
Deleted: n anonymous
Formatted: Normal, Indent: Left: 0"
Deleted: <#>In Septembei 2u1u,
Anuiew Bieitbait, the foimei ownei of
Bieitbait.com, a meuia company,
contacteu Befenuants Patiick Fiey anu
Nanuy Nagy anu otheis, anu conspiieu
with them to taiget Plaintiff foi a smeai
campaign. Ni. Bieitbait was closely
associateu with Befenuant Fiey anu
chose him because of his position as a
Los Angeles Assistant Bistiict Attoiney
anu as the ownei of the blog, Patteiico's
Pontifications. ... [2]

8
4C>* "7+c&5/* 0=N;/>R=AB* %A;GG 'CDK;AFC>* %A2? 7AC;?D2>* ZEHGC<; -MA=EBM
0EHC<* 1G=I -M; &M2DK;A 2>? 9;FN;G );N=FEGC=>R 62F2>GCA ;DIF=L;; 02GGM;O
1G;<3D2> C> 2 7;KAE2AL ]* XWWU ;D2CF G= .% 82AL ;DIF=L;; "2A=> %2AA
?;H<ACK;H GM; D;GM=?=F=BL =@ -;2D -M;DCH GMCH O2Ld
7A=D c -E; 7;K W] WUdW^d[] XWVV 7A=Dd 02GGM;O 1G;<3D2>
eDHG;<3D2>`I2F2>GCAR<=Df -=d .%8"),c"2A=>R%2AA
e22A=>`MKB2ALR<=Df !2G;d 7AC* Y !;< XWVW W\dV\d\U cW]WW 1EKg;<Gd
)(d @CAHG <EG 7;;? GM; @E;F K;GO;;> GM; @;E?C>B BA=EIHR !CHC>@=AD2GC=>R
&A;2G; D;HH2B;H 2A=E>? 2<GC=>H G= H2K=G2B; =A ?CH<A;?CG GM; =II=HC>B
=AB2>CQ2GC=>R 1EKDCG @23; ?=<ED;>GH 2>? GM;> <2FF =EG GM; ;AA=AR h
&A;2G; <=><;A> =N;A GM; H;<EACGL =@ GM; C>@A2HGAE<GEA;R &A;2G;
;_I=HEA; HG=AC;HR 5@ GM; IA=<;HH CH K;FC;N;? G= >=G K; H;<EA; GM;L 2A;
?=>;R h &LK;A 2GG2<3H 2B2C>HG GM; C>@A2HGAE<GEA; G= B;G ?2G2 =>
?=<ED;>G HEKDCGG;AHR -MCH O=EF? 3CFF GM; IA=g;<GR 1C><; GM; H;AN;AH
2A; >=O C> 1O;?;> 2>? 7A2><; IEGGC>B 2 G;2D G=B;GM;A G= B;G 2<<;HH CH
D=A; HGA2CBMG@=AO2A?R h 0;?C2 <2DI2CB> G= IEHM GM; A2?C<2F 2>?
A;<3F;HH >2GEA; =@ OC3CF;23H 2<GCNCGC;HR 1EHG2C>;? IA;HHEA;R !=;H
>=GMC>B @=A GM; @2>2GC<H* KEG <A;2G;H <=><;A> 2>? ?=EKG 2D=>BHG
D=?;A2G;HR h 1;2A<M @=A F;23HR :H; H=<C2F D;?C2 G= IA=@CF; 2>? C?;>GC@L
ACH3L K;M2NC=A =@ ;DIF=L;;HR i5G CH GMCH F;N;F =@ HEII=AG O; >;;? G=
2GG2<3R -M;H; 2A; ;HG2KFCHM;? IA=@;HHC=>2FH GM2G M2N; 2 FCK;A2F K;>G*
KEG EFGCD2G;FL D=HG =@ GM;D C@ IEHM;? OCFF <M==H; IA=@;HHC=>2F
IA;H;AN2GC=> =N;A <2EH;i

S4. 4M;> "2A=> %2AA C> 7;KAE2AL XWVW KA2BB;? G= GM; !"#$#%"$&
(")*+ GM2G M; M2? I;>;GA2G;? ">=>LD=EH 2>? O2H B=C>B G= G23; ?=O> GM;CA
F;2?;AH* ">=>LD=EH A;HI=>?;? KL IEKFCHMC>B D=A; GM2> \W*WWW =@ .% 82AL
;D2CFH GM2G ;_I=H;? GM; ;_CHG;><; =@ -;2D -M;DCHR 1;N;A2F =@ GM; ?=<ED;>GH
2>? ;D2CFH HM=O;? 2 DEFGCcDCFFC=> ?=FF2A =I;A2GC=> G= ?;HGA=L 6F2C>GC@@* MCH
;DIF=L;A 2>? =GM;A =AB2>CQ2GC=>H 2>? 2<GCNCHGHR -MCH =I;A2GC=> O2H =A?;A;?
KL GM; &M2DK;A =@ &=DD;A<;* 2>? CGH 42HMC>BG=>* !& F2O @CAD .E>G=> j
4CFFC2DH O2H GM; <=>?ECG K;GO;;> GM; &M2DK;A 2>? -;2D -M;DCHR -;2D
-M;DCH B2GM;A;? D2HHCN; 2D=E>GH =@ ?2G2 2K=EG 6F2C>GC@@* OMC<M O2H HM2A;?

9
OCGM F2OL;AH 2G .E>G=> j 4CFFC2DH 2>? NC<; N;AH2R -;2D -M;DCH CFF;B2FFL
H<A2I;? H=<C2F D;?C2 HCG;H 2HH=<C2G;? OCGM 6F2C>GC@@ HE<M 2H 72<;K==3 2>?
IA;I2A;? ?=HHC;AH => 6F2C>GC@@ 2>? MCH 72<;K==3 @AC;>?H 2>? =GM;AHR -M;L
IA=I=H;? G= H;<A;GFL C>HG2FF CFF;B2F D2FO2A; => <=DIEG;AH* G= <A;2G; 2
?CHC>@=AD2GC=> <2DI2CB>* G= <A;2G; @2FH; ?=<ED;>GH* 2>? G= ?;HGA=L GM;
@E>?C>B =@ 6F2C>GC@@JH ;DIF=L;AR 0AR %2AAJH ?=HHC;A kE=G;? @A=D 2> /<G=K;A VV*
XWVW 2AGC<F; KL !;@;>?2>G 02>?L #2BL IEKFCHM;? KL !;@;>?2>G %A;CGK2AGR<=D
?;@2DC>B 6F2C>GC@@R
SS. "@G;A -;2D -M;DCH CFF;B2F <2DI2CB> O2H ;_I=H;?* <=>BA;HHC=>2F
C>N;HGCB2GC=>H O;A; F2E><M;? 2>? GM; D;?C2 ;_G;>HCN;FL <=N;A;? GM; HG=ALR
S6. "<<=A?C>B G= #1" ?=<ED;>GH A;F;2H;? KL (?O2A? 1>=O?;> C>
7;KAE2AL XWV[ 2>? A;I=AG;? => KL 8F;>> 8A;;>O2F?* GM; G2<GC<H =EGFC>;? KL
GM; -;2D -M;DCH <2DI2CB> O;A; >=G A;F;B2G;? G= GM; GMA;; A=BE; C>G;FFCB;><;
<=>GA2<G=AHR 5>HG;2?* GM;L 2A; I2AG =@ 2> #1" IA=BA2D G= ?CHAEIG 2>? ?;HGA=L
2<GCNCHGH O=AF?OC?;R -MCH a?CAGL GAC<3Hb BA=EI 3>=O> 2H Z-)58 cc GM; Z=C>G
-MA;2G );H;2A<M 5>G;FFCB;><; 8A=EI O=EF? H;;3 G= C>@CFGA2G; ?C@@;A;>G BA=EIH
=>FC>; 2>? ?;HGA=L I;=IF;lH A;IEG2GC=>H cc B=C>B @2A K;L=>? gEHG G2AB;GC>B
G;AA=ACHG BA=EIH 2>? GMA;2GH G= >2GC=>2F H;<EACGLR
,)-#. /0* %-1* +*&23"4*#/"2"*4 5615-+*+ -2 7(89: $1* /;- /$%/"%+< =>? /-
"#@*%/ $&& +-1/+ -2 2$&+* )$/*1"$& -#/- /0* "#/*1#*/ "# -14*1 /- 4*+/1-A /0*
1*56/$/"-# -2 "/+ /$1.*/+B $#4 =C? /- 6+* +-%"$& +%"*#%*+ $#4 -/0*1
/*%0#"D6*+ /- )$#"56&$/* -#&"#* 4"+%-61+* $#4 $%/"E"+) /- .*#*1$/*
-6/%-)*+ "/ %-#+"4*1+ 4*+"1$F&*G (- +** 0-; *H/1*)"+/ /0*+* 51-.1$)+
$1*I @6+/ %-#+"4*1 /0* /$%/"%+ /0*A F-$+/ -2 6+"#. /- $%0"*E* /0-+* *#4+<
J2$&+* 2&$. -5*1$/"-#+K =5-+/"#. )$/*1"$& /- /0* "#/*1#*/ $#4 2$&+*&A

1u
$//1"F6/"#. "/ /- +-)*-#* *&+*?I 2$L* E"%/") F&-. 5-+/+ =51*/*#4"#. /- F*
$ E"%/") -2 /0* "#4"E"46$& ;0-+* 1*56/$/"-# /0*A ;$#/ /- 4*+/1-A?I $#4
5-+/"#. J#*.$/"E* "#2-1)$/"-#K -# E$1"-6+ 2-16)+G
mMGGIdnn<2>>=>@CA;RKF=BHI=GR<=DnXWV[nWXnDC>?cKF=OC>BRMGDFo

S7. 0n oi about Septembei 2u1u, Anuiew Bieitbait, the >=O ?;<;2H;?
ownei of !;@;>?2>G Bieitbait.com, a meuia company, ?;<C?;? G= G23; EI 2
I2A2FF;F <2DI2CB> HG2AG;? KL -;2D -M;DCH G= ?;HGA=L 6F2C>GC@@ 2>? MCH
FCN;FCM==?R /> /<G=K;A p* XWVW* M; H;>G =EG 2 GO;;G H2LC>B GM2G M; O2H B=C>B G=
D23; 6F2C>GC@@JH 2HH=<C2G; %A2? 7AC;?D2>JH aFC@; 2 F=G D=A; ?C@@C<EFGRb />
/<G=K;A VV* XWVW* M; H;>G 2>=GM;A GO;;G G;FFC>B MCH F;BC=> =@ @=FF=O;AH GM2G
6F2C>GC@@ 2>? GO= 2HH=<C2G;H a>;;? ;_I=HEA;Rb -MCH O2H 2 <=?; IMA2H; @=A MCH
@=FF=O;AH G= ;>B2B; C> GM; GLI; =@ ?;HGAE<GC=> %A;CGK2AG EH;? 2B2C>HG "&/)#
2>? 1MCAF;L 1M;AA=?q@2FH; >2AA2GCN;H* ;?CG;? NC?;=H* =>FC>; B2>B 2<GCNCGLR
m"&/)# HG2@@;AH 2>? 1MCAF;L 1M;AA=? HE;? %AC;GK2AG 2>? !;@;>?2>G /J';;@;
=N;A GM2G G=AGC=EH <=>?E<G C> H;I2A2G; HECGHR />; =@ GM; "&/)# HECGH O2H
A;<;>GFL H;GGF;? C> GM; ;DIF=L;;JH @2N=A 2>? GM; 1M;AA=? HECG CH <EAA;>GFL
I;>?C>B C> 42HMC>BG=> !& @;?;A2F <=EAGoR .; contacteu Befenuants Patiick Fiey,
+;; 1GA2>2M2> anu Nanuy Nagy anu otheis, anu conspiieu with them to taiget
Plaintiff foi a smeai campaign =@ I;AH=>2F 2>? IA=@;HHC=>2F ?;HGAE<GC=>R Ni.
Bieitbait was closely associateu with Befenuant Fiey anu chose him because of his
position as a Los Angeles Assistant Bistiict Attoiney anu as the ownei of the
<=>H;AN2GCN; blog, Patteiico's Pontifications.
S8. /> /<G=K;A VV* XWVW* !;@;>?2>G #2BL* E>?;A GM; ?CA;<GC=> =@ 2>?
C> <=>HICA2<L OCGM 0AR %A;CGK2AG* OA=G; 2> 2AGC<F; HD;2AC>B 6F2C>GC@@ GM2G

11
2II;2A;? => %A;CGK2AGR<=DR MGGIdnnOOORKA;CGK2AGR<=Dn%CBc
Z=EA>2FCHDnXWVWnVWnVVn6A=BA;HHCN;Hc(DKA2<;c&=>NC<G;?c-;AA=ACHG /> GM;
H2D; ?2L* !;@;>?2>G 7A;L @=FF=O;? GM2G 2AGC<F; OCGM 2 HCDCF2A HD;2A 2AGC<F; =>
MCH 62GG;AC<=JH 6=>GC@C<2GC=>JH KF=BR .--6dnn6"--()5&/R&/0nXWVWnVWnVVn%)"!c
7)5(!0"#1c6")-#()c"#!c%:!!,c"c&/#95&-(!c%/0%()c6()Z:)()c"#!c!):8c10:88+()c
1:16(&-(!c0:)!()()c"#!c(+(&-5/#c5#-(8)5-,c.()/n
S9. 0n 0ctobei 1S, 2u1u, Plaintiff sueu a bloggei nameu Seth Allen foi
uefamation in the Ciicuit Couit foi Nontgomeiy County Naiylanu. 0n Novembei
16, 2u11, the Ciicuit Couit enteieu juugment in Plaintiff's favoi, anu issueu an
injunction against Ni. Allen. 5> GM2G <2H;* 0AR "FF;> @CF;? 2 D=GC=> @=A GM; <=EAG G=
@C>? GM2G 6F2C>GC@@ O2H 2 aIEKFC< @CBEA;*b KEG ZE?B; rECA3 @=E>? =GM;AOCH; 2>?
?;>C;? MCH D=GC=>R
4u. In 2u11, Befenuant Walkei was co-hosting Befenuant Fiey's
62GG;AC<= blog using the name, Aaion Woithing, a supposeu attoiney fiom
Nanassas, viiginia. Befenuant Fiey supeiviseu Befenuant Walkei in that capacity.
41. 0n oi about August 17, 2u11, Seth Allen sent an email to Anuiew
Bieitbait, anu Befenuants Walkei, Fiey anu Nagy telling them that he was planning
to come to Naiylanu anu "muiuei" Plaintiff. Befenuant Fiey, an Assistant Bistiict
Attoiney, uiu not contact Plaintiff oi law enfoicement officials to iepoit the muiuei
thieat. Befenuant Nagy uiu contact the authoiities 2>? 0AR "FF;> O2H 2AA;HG;? C>
0=>GB=D;AL &=E>GL 02ALF2>?R
42. In Becembei 2u11, Befenuant Walkei, using his pseuuonym Aaion
Woithing, contacteu Seth Allen anu offeieu pio bono to file post-juugment motions

12
in Naiylanu to oveituin the juugment enteieu against Ni. Allen. Befenuant Walkei,
still using the pseuuonym, then piepaieu anu fileu numeious pleauings foi Ni. Allen
attacking Plaintiff anu the juuge who issueu the juugment. .; ?C? GMCH ;N;> GM=EBM
GM; GCD; @=A 2II;2F 2>? @=A A;<=>HC?;A2GC=> M2? ;_ICA;?R
4S. -MA=EBM=EG GM; D=>GM =@ !;<;DK;A XWVV* !;@;>?2>GH 42F3;A*
7A;L 2>? #2BL <=DDE>C<2G;? OCGM ;2<M =GM;A => M=O GM;L <=EF? ?;HGA=L
6F2C>GC@@ KL B;GGC>B MCD 2AA;HG;? => @2FH; <M2AB;HR !;@;>?2>G 7A;L EH;? MCH
I=HCGC=> 2H !;IEGL !CHGAC<G "GG=A>;L @=A +=H ">B;F;H G= BCN; <A;?CKCFCGL G= GM;
@2FH; >2AA2GCN;H 2>? 2<<EH2GC=>H M; 2>? =GM;AH D2?; 2B2C>HG 6F2C>GC@@R
!;@;>?2>G 7A;L EH;? MCH I=HCGC=> G= F2E><M C>N;HGCB2GC=>H =@ 6F2C>GC@@ KL MCH
HEI;ANCH=AH 2G GM; +=H ">B;F;H &=E>GL !CHGAC<G "GG=A>;LJH /@@C<; 2>? OCGM GM;
7%5R 5> @2<G* !;@;>?2>G 7A;L D;G OCGM K=GM =@ GM=H; F2O ;>@=A<;D;>G 2B;><C;H
2>? @2FH;FL G=F? GM;D GM2G 6F2C>GC@@ O2H C>N=FN;? OCGM HO2GGC>BR
44. /> Z2>E2AL ^* XWVX* !;@;>?2>G 7A;L <=E>H;F;? !;@;>?2>G 42F3;A
=> M=O G= @CF; 2>? IA;I2A; F;B2F @CFC>BH 2B2C>HG 6F2C>GC@@ G= D23; MCD 2II;2A
=?C=EHd a#=* ,=E M2N; G= HG2AG OCGM G;> H;<=>?H =@ F2K;FC>B MCD 2 <=>NC<G;?
K=DK;A 2>? <=>NC<G;? I;AgEA;A* 2>? H2L GMCH CH ;HG2KFCHM;? KL D2g=A D;?C2
HG=AC;H 2>? KL IEKFCHM;? <=EAG ?;<CHC=>HR -M;> H2L M; =KG2C>;? GM; C>gE><GC=>
KL A;I;2G;?FL I;AgEAC>B MCDH;F@ 2>? GM2G L=E <2> IA=N; CGR s (GM=H @CAHGR -M;>
F=B=HR -M;> I2GM=HRb
4S. 5> 2> ;D2CF @A=D !;@;>?2>G 7A;L G= !;@;>?2>G 42F3;A =>
!;<;DK;A XX* XWVV* !;@;>?2>G 7A;L <=DIFCD;>G;? 42F3;A => 2 IF;2?C>B 2>?
GM;> H2C?* a-MCH 3C<3H 2HHR -M;L 2A; B=C>B G= B= 2I;HMCGR 4M;> L=E KF=B CG* 9M&&

1S
+*#4 "/ /- :&*## 8*A#-&4+ $#4 /*&& 0") /0$/ 9 /0"#L /0"+ "+ /0* .6A ;0- +;$//*4
)*sRb T;DIM2HCH 2??;?SR 0AR );L>=F?H CH 2 O;FFc3>=O> <=>H;AN2GCN; 2EGM=A*
IA=@;HH=A 2>? KF=BB;AR !;@;>?2>G 7A;L O2H <=>HICAC>B OCGM !;@;>?2>G 42F3;A
G= <A;2G; 2 HCGE2GC=> GM2G !;@;>?2>G 7A;L <=EF? EH; G= @2FH;FL 2<<EH; 6F2C>GC@@ =@
HO2GGC>BR
46. 5> 2>=GM;A ;D2CF ;_<M2>B; OCGM !;@;>?2>G 42F3;A* 42F3;A G;FFH
7A;L* a#=O M; t'CDK;AFC>u CH B=C>B G= F;2A> >=G G= @E<3 OCGM D; ;CGM;ARb -=
OMC<M 7A;L A;IFC;?d a,;2M* KEG M; CH v@E<3C>BJ OCGM D;R ZEHG >=G C> <=EAGR .;
H;>?H KEFFHMCG C>G;AA=B2G=AC;H GM2G M; M2H G= 3>=O OCFF >;N;A B;G 2>HO;A;?R
%EG D=HGFL M; CH GALC>B G= D23; D; DCH;A2KF;* IEKFCHMC>B DL 2??A;HH* 0"1"#.
5*-5&* /- +;$/ )*I 8==BF; K=DKC>B D;* ?;@2DC>B D;* D=<3C>B D; 2>? H= =>R
sR 5 gEHG O2>G L=E G= E>?;AHG2>? GM2G 'CDK;AFC> CH K;MC>? 2FF GM; GMC>BH GM2G
M2N; M2II;>;? G= D;* 2>? GM2G M; CH GAEFL ?2>B;A=EH 2>? 2 IHL<M=I2GMRb
T;DIM2HCH 2??;?SR 6F2C>GC@@ >;N;A MCA;? 2>L=>; G= HO2G !;@;>?2>G 7A;L* 2>?
>;N;A ;N;> IEKFCHM;? =>FC>; 2 HC>BF; O=A? =A GO;;G 2K=EG !;@;>?2>G 7A;LR
47. 5> =GM;A ;D2CFH G= !;@;>?2>G 42F3;A 2>? H=D; =@ GM; =GM;A
!;@;>?2>GH* !;@;>?2>G 7A;L HG2G;H GM2G MCH =@@C<; 2G GM; +" &=E>GL !CHGAC<G
"GG=A>;L CH aC>N;HGCB2GC>Bb 6F2C>GC@@ 2>? M2? 2H3;? !;@;>?2>G 42F3;A G= 3;;I
kEC;G OMCF; GM; C>N;HGCB2GC=> IA=<;;?;?R
48. 5> 2>=GM;A ;D2CF ?2G;? !;<;DK;A VU* XWVV* M; HG2G;Hd a!=>JG
N=FE>G;;A OM;A; L=E B=G GMCH HGE@@R ZEHG K;<2EH; =@ GM; C>N;HGCB2GC=>R %EG @=A
GM2G* 5 O=EF? K; HM=EGC>B 2FF GMCH @A=D GM; MCFFG=IH* F6/ 9 +/"&& /0"#L ;* %$# 56/
/0*+* .6A+ "# 51"+-#* H= 5 M2N; G= HG2L kEC;GRa T;DIM2HCH 2??;?SR

14
49. 5> 2> ;D2CF ?2G;? Z2>E2AL X\* XWVX* !;@;>?2>G 7A;L G=F?
!;@;>?2>G 42F3;A OMCF; O2CGC>B @=A 2 gEAL C> 2 <2H; M; O2H GALC>BR a5JD M2NC>B
@E>R -MCH CH OM2G 5 ?=d IA=N; GMC>BHR 5 M2N; 2 gEAL =EG H= 5 M2N; 2 FCGGF; GCD;
G=>CBMG tG= A;NC;O GM; IF;2?C>B 42F3;A IA;I2A;? A;B2A?C>B 6F2C>GC@@uR b
Su. 5> H;N;A2F ;D2CFH => !;<;DK;A XV* XWVV* !;@;>?2>G 7A;L
?CH<EHH;? MCH IF2>>;? D;;GC>B OCGM GM; 7%5 GM; @=FF=OC>B ?2L 2>? H;GGC>B EI 2
HGC>B =I;A2GC=> OCGM F2O ;>@=A<;D;>G G= 2AA;HG 6F2C>GC@@R a5 ?=>JG HEBB;HG FLC>B
E>F;HH CGJH ?=>; E>?;A HEI;ANCHC=> =@ F2O ;>@=A<;D;>G 2H I2AG =@ 2 HGC>BR s %EG
CG =>FL D23;H H;>H; 2H I2AG =@ 2 D=>CG=A;? HGC>BRb
S1. /> Z2>E2AL \* XWVX* !;@;>?2>G 7A;L 2H3;? !;@;>?2>G 42F3;A G= H;>?
MCD 2 F;GG;A 2K=EG 6F2C>GC@@ G= HM2A; OCGM MCH HEI;ANCH=AH 2G GM; +" &=E>GL
6A=H;<EG=AH /@@C<; 2>? =GM;A F2O ;>@=A<;D;>G =@@C<C2FHR
S2. 0n oi about Becembei S1, 2u11, Plaintiff uiscoveieu that "Aaion
Woithing" was not a ieal attoiney but that Aaion Woithing was actually Befenuant
Aaion Walkei, an attoiney licenseu in viiginia.
SS. Plaintiff also uiscoveieu that Aaion Woithing was the publishei of a
blog ueuicateu to attacking, smeaiing, mocking anu insulting the Nuslim faith anu
the Piophet Nohammeu. That blog was calleu "Eveiyone Biaw Nohammeu," anu it
soliciteu vile, poinogiaphic anu insulting uepictions of the Piophet fiom people all
ovei the woilu. In Becembei 2u11, Befenuant Walkei hau publisheu moie than 8uu
insulting uepictions of the Piophet.

Formatted: Indent: Left: 0", First line:
0.5"

1S
S4. 0n oi about }anuaiy S, 2u12, Plaintiff, by motion, auviseu the
Nontgomeiy County Naiylanu Ciicuit Couit }uuge in the Seth Allen case that the
attoiney assisting Ni. Allen was not Aaion Woithing but iathei was Aaion Walkei.
SS. 0n }anuaiy 9, 2u12, at a heaiing on a Notion foi Contempt against Ni.
Allen, Befenuant Walkei appeaieu uninviteu anu inteiiupteu the pioceeuings fiom
the viewing aiea. Be uemanueu that the }uuge seal the pioceeuings because Plaintiff
hau iuentifieu him as Aaion Walkei, anu eveiyone woulu know that he was the
publishei of the Nuslim hate blog.
S6. Aftei the heaiing was concluueu, Befenuant Walkei followeu Plaintiff
out of the couitioom in Nontgomeiy County Naiylanu, assaulteu 2>? K2GG;A;? MCD
KL IMLHC<2FFL HGAC3C>B MCD C> GM; @2<;* 2>? OA;HGF;? his iPau fiom him.
Couithouse secuiity iesponueu, ietiieveu the iPau anu uigeu Plaintiff to seek
meuical assistance. Petitionei fiist went to a neaiby meuical clinic, which oiueieu
him to immeuiately go to the Emeigency Room at Subuiban Bospital in Bethesua,
Naiylanu. wheie -M;A;* he was evaluateu, tieateu anu given meuicines foi his
physical injuiies, incluuing contusion to the eye, possible concussion, anu back pain.
.; O2H F2C? =@@ @A=D O=A3 @=A H;N;A2F ?2LH GM;A;2@G;AR The assault 2>? K2GG;AL
was in ietaliation foi Plaintiff exeicising his iight to ieuiess anu access to the couits,
anu it was meant to intimiuate him.
S7. 0n }anuaiy 12, 2u1S, Befenuant Walkei was teiminateu fiom his
employment as an attoiney foi Piofessional Bealth Caie Resouices 2@G;A !;@;>?2>G
42F3;A G=F? CG C> OACGC>B the employei uiscoveieu that he was the publishei of the
Nuslim hate blog. that he was publishing the blog uuiing woik houis, anu that he
0.5"
0.5", Tabs: 0.69", Left
Deleted: him
Deleted: took
Deleted: ,
Deleted: ,

16
was incompetent. 0utsiue counsel foi the company notifieu Befenuant Walkei in
wiiting GM2G M; O2H G;ADC>2G;? @=A OACGC>B GM; M2G; KF=B IF2<C>B MCH <=cO=A3;AH
2G ACH3* @=A OACGC>B GM; M2G; KF=B 2G O=A3 2>? @=A K;C>B C><=DI;G;>Gd these
ieasons foi his teimination:
,+ 2-1 /0* 1*$+-#+ 2-1 A-61 /*1)"#$/"-#I ;0"&* NO89 ;-6&4 0$E* F**#
@6+/"2"*4 "# /*1)"#$/"#. A-6 2-1 A-61 .1-++&A "11*+5-#+"F&* $%/"-#+
1*&$/*4 /- A-61 F&-.."#.I *+5*%"$&&A -# %-)5$#A /")* =)$#A -2 A-61
5-+/+ F*$1 /")* +/$)5+ 461"#. #-1)$& ;-1L"#. 0-61+? /0* $%/6$&
1*$+-# 2-1 A-61 /*1)"#$/"-# "+ /0* "#%1*4"F&A "11*+5-#+"F&* ;$A /0$/ A-6
5*12-1)*4 &*.$& +*1E"%*+ 2-1 NO89 =-1 2$"&*4 /-? -E*1 /0* 5$+/ 2-61 A*$1+I
F-/0 $+ $# -6/+"4* $//-1#*A $#4I +"#%* 76&A -2 CP>>I $+ $# *)5&-A** -2
NO89G ,+ 9 )*#/"-#*4 /- A-6 -# !1"4$AI /0* +/$/* -2 A-6 -22"%* "+ $&)-+/
F*A-#4 4*+%1"5/"-#G Q-+/ -2 /0* &*.$& 4-%6)*#/+ "# A-61 -22"%* $1* 5"&*4
0$50$R$14&A "# #- &*++ /0$# 2"E* &*.$& +"H* 5$5*1 F-H*+I ;"/0-6/ 1*.$14
/- $#A L"#4 -2 -1.$#"R$/"-#I 2"&"#.I %01-#-&-.AI */%G (0* 2*; 2"&*+ /0$/
;*1* $%/6$&&A +/-1*4 "# A-61 2"&* %$F"#*/ $1* #-/ 2"&*4 $&50$F*/"%$&&A -1
+6F@*%/ )$//*1G SE*# /0-+* $55*$1 /- F* "#%-)5&*/* $#4 51-E"4* #-
F$+"+ 2-1 4*/*1)"#"#. ;0$/ $%/"-#+ ;*1* /$L*# -1 1*)$"# /- F* /$L*# /-
%-#%&64* /0* )$//*1G 9/ "+ $&+- -FE"-6+ /0$/ )-+/ -2 /0* ;-1L /0$/ A-6
4"4 "# /0$/ -22"%*I $+ 1*E*$&*4 FA /0* +/$%L+ -2 4-%6)*#/+ "# /0* /-5 -2
A-61 4*+LI 1*&$/* /- 5*1+-#$& F6+"#*++I "#%&64"#. A-61 E$1"-6+ F&-.
$%/"E"/"*+G 9# 2$%/I "/ "+ 4"22"%6&/ /- 4*/*1)"#* ;0$/ A-6 ;*1* ;-1L"#. -#
2-1 NO89 -E*1 /0* &$+/ 2*; ;**L+I "2 $#A/0"#.G =T-61 %0$1$%/*1"R$/"-# -2
A-61 -22"%* $+ J)*++AK "+ F*&"*4 FA /0* 50-/-.1$50+ /0$/ ;* /--L /-
4-%6)*#/ /0* $%/6$& %-#46%/"-# -2 /0$/ 1--)?G (0* 2*; 4-%6)*#/+ /0$/
4"4 1*&$/* /- NO89 F6+"#*++ 4- #-/ "#4"%$/* /0* %611*#/ +/$/6+ -2 /0*
)$//*1+ /- ;0"%0 /0*A 1*&$/*4 $#4 NO89 "+ #-; "# /0* 5-+"/"-# -2
1*/1$%"#. +/*5+ $#4 %-#/$%/"#. #6)*1-6+ /0"14 5$1/"*+ /- 4*/*1)"#*
;0*1* /0"#.+ +/$#4G UFE"-6+&AI /0-+* *22-1/+ ;"&& %-+/ NO89 +".#"2"%$#/
+6)+I "#%&64"#. /0* %-+/ 2-1 -6/+"4* %-6#+*& /- %-))6#"%$/* ;"/0 /0"14
5$1/A %-6#+*& $#4 %-#/"#6* 1*51*+*#/$/"-# -2 NO89I $+ #*%*++$1AG :"E*#
/0-+* %"1%6)+/$#%*+I "/ +**)+ %&*$1 /0$/ A-6 2$"&*4 /- 5*12-1) A-61
46/"*+ $+ %-6#+*& /- NO89I "# 2$E-1 -2 561+6"#. A-61 5*1+-#$& "#/*1*+/+I
;0"&* F*"#. 5$"4 FA NO89G (06+I NO89 "+ *#/"1*&A @6+/"2"*4 /- /*1)"#$/*
A-61 *)5&-A)*#/ 2-1 %$6+* 1*&$/*4 /- A-61 2$"&61* /- 5*12-1) "#
$%%-14$#%* ;"/0 /0* *H5*%/$/"-#+ $#4 ;"/0 A-61 -F&".$/"-#+ $+ $
)*)F*1 -2 /0* V"1."#"$ W/$/* X$1G UFE"-6+&AI *E*# "2 NO89 0$4 $
+*E*1$#%* 5-&"%AI ;0"%0 "/ 4-*+ #-/I A-6 ;-6&4 #-/ F* *#/"/&*4 /- 1*%*"E*
$#A +6%0 %-)5*#+$/"-# 6#4*1 /0* %"1%6)+/$#%*+G 8$/0*1I NO89 ;-6&4
F* @6+/"2"*4 "2 "/ +-6.0/ 1*")F61+*)*#/ 21-) A-6 2-1 $)-6#/+ 5$"4 2-1
+*1E"%*+ /0$/ A-6 4"4 #-/ 5*12-1) 461"#. 5*1"-4+ 461"#. ;0"%0 A-6 4"4
#-/ 5*12-1) +*1E"%*+G
Deleted: .

17

9# &".0/ -2 $&& /0* $F-E*I $#4 "# /0* %-#/*H/ -2 A-61 $%/"-#+ -6/+"4* /0*
+%-5* -2 A-61 *)5&-A)*#/I "2 A-6 )6+/ %-#+"4*1 A-61+*&2 /- F* $ E"%/")I
"/ "+ -#&A -2 A-61 -;# "11*+5-#+"F&* $%/"-#+G NO89 4-*+ #-/ 0$E* $
1*+5-#+"F"&"/A /- 51-E"4* A-6 ;"/0 $ J+-2/ &$#4"#.K 21-) /0-+* $%/"-#+ "#
/0* 2-1) -2 6#*$1#*4 %-)5*#+$/"-#G YG

YG T-6 %0-+* /- 5-L* $/ $ .1-65 /0$/ "+ L#-;# 2-1 E"-&*#/ 1*51"+$&+I
$55$1*#/&A "# /0* #$)* -2 $++*1/"#. 2"1+/ $)*#4)*#/ 1".0/+ =*E*#
/0-6.0 /0* ZGWG :-E*1#)*#/ "+ #-/ "#E-&E*4 "# +6551*++"#. %$1/--#+ -2
Q-0$))*4?G ,#4 A-6 ;*1* 2*$126& *#-6.0 -2 A-61 $4E*1+$1"*+ /- $&*1/
/0* 5-&"%* "# /;- %-6#/"*+G W- "/ ;-6&4 F* 6#1*$+-#$F&* 2-1 A-6 /-
%-#4*)# %-))-# +*#+* *22-1/+ /- 51-/*%/ /0-+* ;0- 0$E* #-/0"#. /- 4-
;"/0 A-61 $%/"E"/"*+ $+ JF*A-#4 $&& 1$/"-#$&"/AG 9# 0"#4+".0/I 4- A-6 +/"&&
%-#+"4*1 A-6 JSE*1A-#* [1$; Q-0$))*4K F&-. /- F* 1$/"-#$&\ 92 +-I 9
;-6&4 #-/ %-#+"4*1 A-6 /- F* $ %1*4"F&* $551$"+*1 -2 1$/"-#$&"/AG
http:www.sciibu.comuoc176869717Letteis-conceining-Aaion-
Walkei-s-ieal-ieasons-foi-being-teiminateu
S8. In }anuaiy 2u12, Befenuants Walkei, Fiey, anu Nagy, in conceit,
concocteu a false naiiative that Plaintiff (1) causeu Befenuant Walkei's job
teimination, (2) was not assaulteu, anu (S) falsifieu his hospital iecoius.
S9. In Febiuaiy 2u12, Anuiew Bieibait tolu Befenuant Stianahan anu
othei Befenuants that they shoulu uestioy taiget Plaintiff at all costs. Befenuant
Stianahan stateu that he took this as an oiuei fiom Anuiew Bieitbait to put all
available iesouices into a ?;<F2A2GC=> =@ O2A 2B2C>HG 6F2C>GC@@R Befenuant
Stianahan wiote: "This woulu have been a big ueal: putting ieal jouinalistic
iesouices anu a huge platfoim into the Kimbeilin stoiy. It's what Anuiew wanteu."
https:twittei.comStianahanstatusesS819SSSS18897u496u
6u. In Febiuaiy anu Naich the spiing of 2u12, Befenuants Walkei, Fiey,
Nagy, Akbai anu Stianahan, in conceit, planneu ways to push theii false naiiative
into the meuia in oiuei to (1) uemonize Plaintiff, (2) cieate a witch hunt, (S) cause
Formatted: Indent: Left: 0.63", No bullets
or numbering
Formatted: Font color: Blue
0.5"
Deleted: this.

18
maximum haim to Plaintiff, (4) poitiay Befenuant Walkei as a victim, anu (S) iaise
significant funus fiom people who believeu the false naiiative. Befenuant Walkei
maue many tiips to Naiylanu in fuitheiance of that conspiiacy.
61. In }anuaiy 2u12, Befenuant Akbai C> <=>HICA2<L OCGM Befenuants
Walkei, Fiey, Nagy, Stianahan, anu otheis that was launching a F2E><M;? a new
entity calleu the National Bloggeis Club to biing togethei Republican @2A ACBMG
bloggeis to collectively cooiuinate theii messaging about specific issues, anu taiget
specific inuiviuuals. !;@;>?2>G "3K2A A;BCHG;A;? -M; #2GC=>2F %F=BB;AH &FEK 2H
2 -;_2H >=>cIA=@CG <=AI=A2GC=>R 4M;> GM;H; !;@;>?2>GH 2BA;;? G= 2>? ?C?
IEKFCHM GM; @2FH; >2AA2GCN;H =@ GM; #2GC=>2F %F=BB;AH &FEK A;B2A?C>B 6F2C>GC@@
2>? GM; &FEKJH @A2E?EF;>G \WVT<STYS HG2GEH* GM;L g=C>;? GM; )5&/ (>G;AIACH;R
Befenuant Akbai latei stateu that he can oiuei bloggeis in the National Bloggeis
Club to taiget people oi not taiget people. Befenuant Akbai has stateu that he is in a
supeivisoiy position ovei the othei bloggeis in the Club. Befenuant Akbai has been
to Naiylanu seveial times in fuitheiance of the conspiiacy.
62. -M; #2GC=>2F %F=BB;AH &FEK CH 2 <ACDC>2F ;>G;AIACH; ;>B2B;? C>
CFF;B2F 2<GCNCGL @=A D=A; GM2> GO= L;2AHR 5G M2H ?;@A2E?;? <CGCQ;>H =EG =@
ME>?A;?H =@ GM=EH2>?H =@ ?=FF2AH KL <A;2GC>B @2FH; >2AA2GCN;H* D=HGFL EHC>B
6F2C>GC@@JH >2D;* 2>? KL @2FH;FL HG2GC>B GM2G CG CH 2 \WVT<STYS >=>cIA=@CGR 5> @2<G*
CG M2H >;N;A @CF;? 2>L A;kECA;? KEHC>;HH @CFC>BH HC><; CGH C>CGC2F A;BCHGA2GC=>R
6S. -M; @A2E? <=DDCGG;? KL -M; #2GC=>2F %F=BB;AH &FEK CH
;_GA2=A?C>2AL C> CGH H<=I; K;<2EH; CG F2HG;? =N;A 2 I;AC=? =@ L;2AH* H<2DD;?
ME>?A;?H =@ ?=>=AH* <=>>;? D2g=A >2D;H C> GM; <=>H;AN2GCN; <=DDE>CGL* 2>?
Deleted: Febiuaiy
Deleted: auviseu
Deleted: he

19
O2H <=><;CN;? KL 2 <=>NC<G;? @;F=> @A=D GM; 1G2G; =@ -;_2H OM= O2H =>
IA=K2GC=> @=A @A2E?R &F;2AFL* GMCH @A2E? O2H ;_G;>?;?* OC?;HIA;2? 2>?
I2AGC<EF2AFL ?2>B;A=EHR
64. !;@;>?2>G 0C<M;FF; 02F3C> g=C>;? -M; #2GC=>2F %F=BB;AH &FEK =>
CGH K=2A? =@ ?CA;<G=AH 2>? EH;? M;A I=HCGC=> 2>? A;IEG2GC=> G= BCN; GM; &FEK
<A;?CKCFCGLR 1M; g=C>;? GM; )5&/ (>G;AIACH; 2>? <=>HICA2<L OM;> HM; 2BA;;? G=
2>? ?C? IEKFCHM GM; @2FH; >2AA2GCN;H =@ -M; #2GC=>2F %F=BB;AH &FEK A;B2A?C>B
6F2C>GC@@R
6S. Befenuants Akbai, Walkei, Fiey, Stianahan, Nagy anu otheis ueciueu
that Plaintiff woulu be the fiist smeai taiget of The National Bloggeis Club. They
ueciueu to have an "Eveiyone Blog About Biett Kimbeilin Bay" on Nay 2S, 2u12
wheie scoies of bloggeis woulu wiite smeai stoiies about Plaintiff, post them
online, anu tweet about them on Twittei. Seveial of those bloggeis aie fiom
Naiylanu, anu all the blog posts about Plaintiff weie vieweu on the Inteinet in
Naiylanu. 5> @2<G* 6F2C>GC@@ CH GM; =>FL I;AH=> G2AB;G;? KL -M; #2GC=>2F
%F=BB;AH &FEK @=A 2 HD;2A <2DI2CB> K2H;? => @2FH; >2AA2GCN;H* 2>? M; CH GM;
=>FL I;AH=> GM; &FEK EH;? G= A2CH; @E>?H @=A CGH @A2E?EF;>G >=>cIA=@CGR -M;
#2GC=>2F %F=BB;AH &FEK ;>B2B;? C> <LK;A KEFFLC>B =@ 6F2C>GC@@ => 2 BA2>? H<2F;R
66. In Nay anu }une 2u12, the National Bloggeis Club bloggeis geneiateu
hunuieus of posts anu tens of thousanus of tweets smeaiing Plaintiff. Buiing that
time anu continuing until the piesent, Befenuant Akbai soliciteu uonations on his
anu othei websites foi the Befenuant National Bloggeis Club, anu falsely tolu uonois
that theii uonations weie tax ueuuctible anu that National Bloggeis Club was a
0.5"
Deleted: the

2u
F;BCGCD2G; Su1(c)(S) oiganization. https:www.lsnewsgioup.comwp-
contentuploaus2u1Su1NBC-Feb-9-2u12-Lettei.puf Befenuant National
Bloggeis Club 2>? GM; =GM;A !;@;>?2>GH iaiseu tens of thousanus of D=A; GM2> 2
ME>?A;? GM=EH2>? ?=FF2AH baseu on those fiauuulent iepiesentations. Even aftei
people askeu foi pioof that Befenuant National Bloggeis Club was gianteu
Su1(c)(S) status, anu Befenuant Akbai faileu to pioviue that pioof, Befenuants
continueu to solicit uonations foi Befenuant National Bloggeis Club. As of 0ctobei
17, 2u1S, 02A<M p* XWV[* The National Bloggeis Club continues to iaise money on a
uonate page stating falsely: "National Bloggeis Club, Inc. is a Su1(c)(S) -- status
penuing" https:secuie.piiyx.comuonatec97AfwvcRemembeiing-Bieitbait
5G CH HGCFF A2CHC>B @E>?H G= G2AB;G 6F2C>GC@@ => CGH OOOR%=DK;A1E;H%F=BB;AH I2B;
GMA=EBM 2 )2FFL*=AB @E>?A2CHC>B I2B;R -M2G D=>;L CH K;C>B A2CH;? =>FC>; C>
C>G;AHG2G; <=DD;A<;* 2>? IF2<;? C>G= 2 @;?;A2FFL C>HEA;? K2>3R
67. !;@;>?2>G #2GC=>2F %F=BB;AH &FEK >=G =>FL >;N;A @CF;? @=A
\WVT<STYS HG2GEH OCGM GM; 5)1* CG >;N;A @CF;? 2>L 5)1 UUW L;2AFL A;GEA>* 2>?
>;N;A ;N;> @CF;? 2>L =@ GM; D2>?2G=AL KEHC>;HH @CFC>BH =A G2_ A;GEA>H OCGM GM;
1G2G; =@ -;_2HR /> /<G=K;A V]* XWVY* GM; &=DIGA=FF;A =@ 1G2G; =@ -;_2H
@=A@;CG;? GM; ACBMG =@ -M; #2GC=>2F %F=BB;AH &FEK G= GA2>H2<G KEHC>;HH K;<2EH;
=@ GM;H; @2CFEA;H G= @CF;R ">? => 7;KAE2AL XV* XWV[* GM; 1G2G; =@ -;_2H A;N=3;?
GM; <M2AG;A =@ -M; #2GC=>2F %F=BB;AH &FEK G= 2<G 2H 2 <=AI=A2GC=>R
68. -M; !;@;>?2>GH OM= 2A; D;DK;AH =@ -M; #2GC=>2F %F=BB;AH &FEK
<A;2G;? CG 2H 2 HM;FF <=DI2>L G= ?;@A2E? D=A; GM2> =>; ME>?A;? GM=EH2>?
?=FF2AH @A=D BEFFCKF; <CGCQ;>H KL D23C>B EI @2FH; >2AA2GCN;H 2K=EG 6F2C>GC@@R
Deleted: the

21
-M;L >;N;A C>G;>?;? G= 2>? >;N;A ?C? AE> GM2G =AB2>CQ2GC=> C> 2>L F;BCGCD2G;
D2>>;AR 5> @2<G* -M; &FEK M2H >=G IA=NC?;? 2>L @=AD2F =A C>@=AD2F
2<<=E>G2KCFCGL =A GA2>HI2A;><L 2H A;kECA;? @=A \WVT<STYS >=>cIA=@CGHR
69. -M;A; 2A; H;N;A2F 2<GCN; C>N;HGCB2GC=>H C>G= GM; @A2E?EF;>G
2<GCNCGC;H =@ -M; #2GC=>2F %F=BB;AH &FEK E>?;A !;@;>?2>G "FC "3K2A* 2>? 2
@=AD2F A;kE;HG M2H K;;> @CF;? OCGM GM; 5)1 @=A 2 <ACDC>2F C>N;HGCB2GC=> =@ GM;
&FEK 2>? !;@;>?2>G "3K2A @=A @A2E?R
7u. "@G;A -;_2H @=A@;CG;? -M; #2GC=>2F %F=BB;AH &FEK => 7;KAE2AL XV*
XWV[* 6F2C>GC@@ %A;GG 'CDK;AFC> A;BCHG;A;? 2>? C><=AI=A2G;? -M; #2GC=>2F
%F=BB;AH &FEK C> GM; 1G2G; =@ -;_2H* 2>? => 02A<M p* XWV[* >=GC@C;? !;@;>?2>G
"FC "3K2A GM2G M; M2H >= F;B2F ACBMG G= EH; GM2G >2D; =A ;>GCGL G= A2CH; @E>?H =A
@=A 2>L =GM;A IEAI=H;R
71. The Befenuants National Bloggeis Club anu Ali Akbai soliciteu 2>?
i;<;CN;? ?=>2GC=>H @A=D <CGCQ;>H =@ 02ALF2>? 2>? GMA=EBM=EG GM; :>CG;?
1G2G;H K2H;? => GM;CA @A2E?EF;>G A;IA;H;>G2GC=>HR
72. !;@;>?2>G !2> %2<3;A g=C>;? GM; )5&/ (>G;AIACH; OM;> "FC
"33K2A O2H ;_I=H;? C> 2AGC<F;H 2H 2 <=>NC<G;? @;F=> 2>? @A2E?HG;A @A=D GM;
1G2G; =@ -;_2H 2>? -M; #2GC=>2F %F=BB;AH &FEK O2H ;_I=H;? 2H 2 @A2E?EF;>G
\WVT<STYS >=>cIA=@CGR !2> %2<3;A M2H 2 A;IEG2GC=> 2H 2 F2OL;A OM= <A;2G;H
6=FCGC<2F "<GC=> &=DDCGG;;H =A =GM;A ;>GCGC;H* A2CH;H F=GH D=>;L C> ?=>2GC=>H*
2>? GM;> EH;H GM; D=>;L 2H M; H;;H @CG OCGM=EG OCGM=EG ?CHI;AHC>B GM; @E>?H C>
2> ;GMC<2F D2>>;AR 7=A ;_2DIF;* M; 2>? -=?? &;@@2A2GC H<2DD;? ME>?A;?H =@
GM=EH2>?H @A=D -;2 62AGL 2<GCNCHGH KL @2FH;FL I=AGA2LC>B -;262AGLR>;G 2H 2>
0.5"

22
=AB2>CQ2GC=> GM2G O=EF? M;FI IA=D=G; -;2 62AGL <2>?C?2G;HR
MGGIdnn<=>H;AN2GCN;c=EGF==3HR<=DnXWVVnW[nW\n;NC?;><;cD=E>GHc2ACQ=>2c
G;2cI2AGLcCHc2c@23;n 5> @2<G* M=O;N;A* >=>; =@ GM; @E>?H A2CH;? O;>G @=A GM;
IEAI=H;H A;IA;H;>G;? KL !;@;>?2>G %2<3;AR !;@;>?2>G %2<3;A M2H A2CH;?
DCFFC=>H =@ ?=FF2AH GMA=EBM ?=Q;>H =@ ;>GCGC;H GM2G ?= >=G @E>? GM; 2<GCNCGC;H
2?N;AGCH;?R "<<=A?C>B G= 7(& ;_I;>?CGEA; @CFC>BH* !;@;>?2>GH %2<3;A 2>? !%
&2ICG=F 1GA2G;BC;H M2? K;;> connected to Defendant Akbar for several years, and
had been paying Defendant Akbars Vice & Victory Agency for various things.
7S. As a iesult of these smeai blogs anu aiticles, Plaintiff, while in
Naiylanu, ieceiveu many thieats of injuiy anu ueath by people who ieau anu
believeu the false naiiatives. These weie ieceiveu by email, phone anu blog posts.
Seveial ieaueis calleu 2>?n=A <=>G2<G;? =>FC>; Plaintiff, his family, his neighbois
anu his chiluien thieatening, intimiuating anu smeaiing Plaintiff. Seveial othei
ieaueis came to Plaintiff's home in Naiylanu anu took photogiaphs of the home anu
of him anu his chilu. This causeu Plaintiff anu his family extieme emotional uistiess.
74. Examples of these thieats aie:
I'll be biinging the stiaw foi you. It's now not a mattei of if.
Biett Kimbeilin, neck bioken by 11ulbs Female Naiine.
Biett Kimbeilin is uone....... the huntei is the hunteu
We know who you aie. We'ie coming foi you. You will pay.
I uon't get intimiuateu & get on my bau siue & you'll get
the full wiath. Not just fiom but. (sic) I have my own. The extieme
wing of the TP has aiiiveu. This message is foi Ni. K. It woulu not suit
the best inteiests of all people involveu in youi movement to shut the
F&*K up & that incluues you. .

Formatted: Font:Times New Roman, Bold
Formatted: Bulleted + Level: 1 + Aligned
at: 0.75" + Indent at: 1", Tabs:Not at 0.5"
Formatted: Space Before: 0.01 line,
After: 0.01 line, Bulleted + Level: 1 +
Aligned at: 0.75" + Indent at: 1", Tabs:Not
at 0.5"
0.5", Space Before: 0.01 line, After: 0.01
line

2S
7S. Seveial of the thieats that Plaintiff ieceiveu stateu that he woulu be
haimeu oi killeu if he appeaieu in couit in Naiylanu oi coopeiateu with the police
theie. Foi example,
If Biett uoes not stait to act like a giown up anu quit calling the police on
people like a little punk. Theie will be hell to pay.
Aimy 0f Bavius sent a message.. Bon't show up in couit Tuesuay oi you
aie ueau. This is youi only waining.

76. 6F2C>GC@@ M2H K;;> E>?;A HC;B; KL GM; !;@;>?2>GH @=A D=A; GM2>
GO= L;2AHR -M;L M2N; K;;> ;>B2B;? C> <=>HG2>G <LK;A KEFFLC>B 2>? <LK;A
HG2F3C>B =@ MCD 2>? MCH @2DCFL KL EHC>B C>@=AD2GC=> 2>? <=DDE>C<2GC=>
G;<M>=F=BC;H G= HEII=AG ?;FCK;A2G;* A;I;2G;?* 2>? M=HGCF; K;M2NC=A G= M2AD
6F2C>GC@@R .; FCN;H C> <=>HG2>G @;2A @=A MCDH;F@ 2>? MCH @2DCFL K;<2EH; =@ GM;
KEFFLC>B 2>? GMA;2GH 2B2C>HG MCDR 9CAGE2FFL ;N;AL GCD; 6F2C>GC@@ 2II;2AH C>
&=EAG* !;@;>?2>GH 42F3;A 2>? .=B; M2N; HG2F3;? MCD* 2>? 6F2C>GC@@ @;2AH GM2G
!;@;>?2>G 42F3;A OCFF 2HH2EFG MCD 2B2C>R %=GM !;@;>?2>GH 42F3;A 2>? .=B;
<=>HG2>GFL OACG; KF=B I=HGH* H=D; OCGM IM=G=H =@ GM;CA HM=GH 2G GM; HM==GC>B
A2>B;* HG2GC>B M=O GM;L 2A; 2AD;? 2>? ?2>B;A=EH 2>? OCFF >=G M;HCG2G; G= EH;
GM;CA O;2I=>H 2B2C>HG 6F2C>GC@@R 6F2C>GC@@ M2H OCG>;HH;? !;@;>?2>GH 42F3;A*
"3K2A* 0<&2C>* 7A;L 2>? .=B; 2GG2<3 2>L=>; =>FC>; OM= kE;HGC=>H GM;CA
<=>?E<G* 2>? 2G F;2HG =>; A;I=AG;A M2H A;<;CN;? D2>L ?;2GM GMA;2GH 2@G;A
OACGC>B 2K=EG GM; !;@;>?2>GHR
77. !;@;>?2>GH "3K2A* .=B;* 42F3;A* -M=D2H 232
'CDK;AFC>:>D2H3;? 2>? 0<&2C> M2N; <=>GC>E;? G= ?;@2D; 2>? IEKFC<FL
2GG2<3 6F2C>GC@@ 2@G;A GM; @CFC>B =@ GMCH &=DIF2C>G OCGM GM=EH2>?H =@ GO;;GH 2>?
0.5"
After: 0.01 line, Bulleted + Level: 1 +
Aligned at: 0.5" + Indent at: 0.75",
Tabs:Not at 0.5"
After: 0.01 line, Line spacing: single

24
KF=B I=HGH @2FH;FL <2FFC>B 6F2C>GC@@ 2 HO2GG;A 2>? HG2GC>B GM2G M; <2EH;?
!;@;>?2>G 42F3;AJH G;ADC>2GC=>R 5> NCAGE2FFL ;N;AL I=HG 2>? GO;;G* GM;H;
!;@;>?2>GH EH; 6F2C>GC@@JH >2D; 2F=>B OCGM 2 <ACDC>2F 2<<EH2GC=> G= M2N; GM2G
GCGF; FCHG;? => 5>G;A>;G H;2A<M ;>BC>;H C> =A?;A G= <2EH; GM; D2_CDED ?2D2B;
G= 6F2C>GC@@* MCH A;IEG2GC=>* MCH @2DCFL* MCH KEHC>;HH;H 2>? MCH FCN;FCM==?R
78. !;@;>?2>G "3K2A OA=G; => GM; @A=>G I2B; =@ -M; #2GC=>2F
%F=BB;AH &FEK O;KHCG;* OMC<M O2H HGCFF GM;A; => 02A<M p* XWV[* GM; @=FF=OC>B
@2FH; >2AA2GCN;d

Kimbeilin wants moie than the $1 NILLI0N he is seeking in his fiivolous
lawsuit -- he wants silence. Kimbeilin's 2 yeai campaign of haiassment has
leu to bloggeis losing jobs, thieats of violence, police "SWATTings" anu one
jouinalist even hau to move homes with his family. Fiankly, this all costs
money anu Kimbeilin knows it. Youi help is necessaiy.
www.BombeiSuesBloggeis.com

79. As pait of Befenuant Walkei's fiauuulent plan to poitiay himself as a
victim of Plaintiff, Befenuant Walkei fileu numeious false ciiminal chaiges, Peace
0iueis anu civil suits against Plaintiff in 2u12 anu 2u1S in Naiylanu. Each of these
filings maue false claims anu allegations against Plaintiff, anu the juuges anuoi the
State's Attoiney in Nontgomeiy County Naiylanu, Piince William County viiginia,
anu the 0niteu States Bistiict Couit in uieenbelt, Naiylanu iejecteu each. Bespite
these iejections, Befenuants continueu to iepeat theii false naiiatives as concocteu
by Befenuants Walkei, Fiey, Nagy, Stianahan anu otheis. Ni. Walkei anu othei
Befenuants have continueu to iepeat GM;H; @2FH; >2AA2GCN;H ;N;> G= GMCH ?2LR
0.5"

2S
8u. 1;N;A2F =@ GM; Befenuants conspiieu to intimiuate State Attoineys in
Nontgomeiy anu Bowaiu County Naiylanu, anu }uuge Richaiu }oiuan anu }uuge
Coinelius vaughey in Nontgomeiy County aftei they iejecteu Befenuants' false
naiiatives. Specifically, Befenuant Walkei uefenueu Seth Allen's online attacks of
}uuge }oiuan, anu then Befenuant Walkei, using the pseuuonym Aaion Woithing,
fileu pleauings foi Ni. Allen uefenuing those attacks. Be uiu this aftei Seth Allen
sent him an email saying that he might come to Naiylanu to muiuei Plaintiff.
Befenuants Walkei, Boge, Fiey anu Stianahan conuemneu }uuge vaughey online
which iesulteu in the juuge being taigeteu by having his home phone numbei anu
auuiess posteu online, causing the heau of couithouse secuiity to pioviue special
secuiity foi him. Befenuants Walkei anu Boge calleu on theii followeis to contact
Nontgomeiy County States Attoiney }ohn NcCaithy anu uemanu that he aiiest anu
piosecute Plaintiff baseu on theii false naiiatives. In Naich 2u1S, Befenuants Boge,
Walkei, NcCain anu Stianahan launcheu "Eveiyone Blog About Bowaiu County
(Naiylanu) State's Attoiney Bay," which iesulteu in thieats by phone anu email to
the State's Attoiney ovei a peiiou of seveial weeks.
http:theotheimccain.com2u1Su4u8e-mail-fiom-a-foimei-maiylanu-
iesiuent-to-howaiu-county-mu-states-attoiney
http:alleigic2bull.blogspot.com2u1SuSeveiyone-blog-about-howaiu-county-
mu.html
http:hogewash.com2u1SuS2Seveiyone-blog-about-the-howaiu-county-
states-attoiney-uay
Formatted: Indent: Left: 0"

26
81. At some point between Becembei 2u11 anu Nay 2u12, Befenuants
Walkei, Fiey anu otheis concluueu that they hau to cieate a moie sinistei false
naiiative against Plaintiff that woulu iesult in ciiminal anu Congiessional
investigations. Theiefoie, they ueciueu to veiy publicly falsely accuse Plaintiff of
"swatting conseivative bloggeis in oiuei to silence them."
82. Befenuant Fiey was allegeuly swatteu on }une Su, 2u11 at his home in
Califoinia. At the time, he tolu the police that he thought it was because he was
wiiting about Congiessman Anthony Weinei. Bowevei, HG2AGC>B C> !;<;DK;A
XWVV, 2u12, Befenuant Fiey, in conceit with otheis, incluuing Befenuants Walkei,
Nagy anu Stianahan, began publicly implying anu stating that Plaintiff hau him
swatteu. Some of these statements weie in wiiting anu otheis weie oial. Foi
example, http:alleigic2bull.blogspot.com2u12uSbieaking-anothei-ciitic-of-
convicteu.html. 5> @2<G* C> 2> ;D2CF G= !;@;>?2>G 42F3;A => !;<;DK;A VV* XWVV*
!;@;>?2>G 7A;L H2C? GM2G M; O=EF? <2FF KF=BB;A 8F;>> );L>=F?H 2>? G;FF MCD
GM2G 6F2C>GC@@ HO2GG;? MCDR
8S. Befenuants quickly iealizeu that theii allegations of swatting against
Fiey one yeai eailiei weie not believable B;GGC>B ;>=EBM GA2<GC=> so they
concocteu a plan to get the swatting smeai into the mainstieam meuia, anu they uiu
that by ieciuiting Befenuant Eiick Eiickson, who bloggeu at the highly tiaffickeu
ReuState anu was a paiu commentatoi at CNN. 0n oi about Nay 1S, 2u12, Befenuant
Eiickson joineu the RIC0 Enteipiise by contacting his local police anu tolu them that
he was going to wiite about Plaintiff on Befenuant ReuState anu might be swatteu.
Anu, as pieuicteu, on Nay 27, 2u12, Eiickson was swatteu anu the police he hau
0.5"
Deleted: contacteu

27
eailiei tolu to expect the swatting came to his home in ueoigia. Befenuant Nagy
wiote about the swatting inciuent foi Bieitbait.com anu posteu the viueo fiom the
CNN bioaucast, which weie vieweu in Naiylanu. -MCH <=>G2C>;? GM; ?;@2D2G=AL
CDIFC<2GC=> GM2G 6F2C>GC@@ O2H C>N=FN;? OCGM GM; HO2GGC>BHR
http:www.bieitbait.comBig-uoveinment2u12u6u8Eiickson-CNN-SWATting
84. Befenuant Eiickson anu many othei Befenuants anu membeis of the
National Bloggeis Club wiote extensively about Befenuant Eiickson's swatting anu
falsely blameu Plaintiff foi uoing it, both uiiectly anu by implication. Foi example,
http:www.examinei.comaiticlebloggeis-obseive-uay-of-silence-to-uige-
congiessional-action-ovei-swatting
!;@;>?2>G );?1G2G; IEKFCHM;? GO= 2AGC<F;H CDIEGC>B GM2G 6F2C>GC@@ O2H
C>N=FN;? OCGM aI=FCGC<2F G;AA=ACHDb GMA=EBM HO2GGC>BR
http:www.ieustate.comeiick2u12uS29one-metiic-on-impact-swatting
http:www.ieustate.comeiick2u12uS2Suaily-koss-neal-iauhausei-bombei-
biett-kimbeilin-anu-political-teiioiism
8S. Befenuant Eiickson appeaieu on CNN Television on }une 8, 2u12 anu
imputeu that Plaintiff was iesponsible foi the swatting thiough "his fan club."
Befenuant Eiickson even pusheu back against the iepoitei's piotests that theie was
no eviuence of Plaintiff's involvement, saying that "the same fact pattein" applieu
wheie the bloggeis wiote about Plaintiff anu within weeks they aie swatteu. "
NC?;= =@ GMCH 2II;2A2><; O2H I=HG;? OC?;FL => GM; 5>G;A>;G 2>? => ,=E-EK;R
http:www.youtube.comwatch.v=T1Suf46AwIN
0.5"

28
86. 0n }une 2S, 2u12, Befenuant Walkei was allegeuly swatteu at his
home in viiginia. Be anu othei Befenuants stateu publicly in piint anu on iauio that
Plaintiff was iesponsible foi the swatting. Befenuant Walkei appeaieu on Buff Post
Live, imputing that Plaintiff swatteu him.
http:live.huffingtonpost.comisegmentswatting-
lapuS166cb7SfeS4442u7uuuuS9u. Anu he posteu on his Twittei account.
"As foi TSu anu stack, they weie at least the tools of Kimbeilin anu Rauhausei, who
hau a hanu in 14"-GC>B him, too."
https:twittei.comAaionWoithingstatusS42499727444688896
87. 0n oi about Nay 2S, 2u12, Befenuant ulenn Beck g=C>;? GM; )5&/
(>G;AIACH; 2>? pioviueu a platfoim on his 8F;>> %;<3n0;A<EAL )2?C= "AGH
6A=BA2DH iauiotelevision bioaucast foi Befenuants Walkei anu Fiey to accuse
Plaintiff of swatting. Specifically, Befenuant Beck alloweu Befenuants Walkei anu
Fiey to appeai via auuio on his iauiotelevision piogiam anu impute, imply anu
state that Plaintiff taigeteu Befenuant Fiey with swatting anu causeu Befenuant
Walkei to be fiieu. Befenuant Fiey stateu on the piogiam that he is a "Beputy
Bistiict Attoiney." These piogiams weie vieweu in Naiylanu anu acioss the globe.
Befenuant Fiey specifically stateu that the swatting "happeneu to anothei guy
wiiting about the same stoiy," anu Befenuant Fiey stateu that Plaintiff "coulu have
gotten me killeu." http:www.youtube.comwatch.v=o8FugXl8b0E
88. 0n Nay 2S, 2u12, Befenuant The Blaze publisheu an aiticle entitleu,
"Bo You Know What 'Swatting' Is. victims Tell Beck Bow They Weie Taigeteu By
Teiioiist Biett Kimbeilin," anu saiu title anu aiticle imputeu that Plaintiff swatteu
0.5"

29
conseivative bloggeis. This was vieweu in Naiylanu anu publisheu on the Inteinet.
http:www.theblaze.comstoiies2u12uS2Suo-you-know-what-swatting-is-
victims-tell-beck-how-they-weie-taigeteu-by-teiioiist-biett-kimbeilin
89. 0n Nay 2S, 2u12, Befenuant ulenn Beck publisheu an aiticle on his
ulennBeck.com site titleu "ulenn Talks To Bloggeis About Biett Kimbeilin
Teiioiism" in which he imputes that Plaintiff swatteu Befenuant Fiey. This was
vieweu globally on the Inteinet. http:www.glennbeck.com2u12uS2Sglenn-
talks-to-bloggeis-about-biett-kimbeilin-teiioiism
9u. /> 02L X\* XWVX* !;@;>?2>G -M; %F2Q; IEKFCHM;? 2> 2AGC<F; GCGF;?
a0;;G 1=A=Hc7E>?;? !=D;HGC< -;AA=ACHG %A;GG 'CDK;AFC>* 4M=H; vZ=KJ 5H
-;AA=ACQC>B %F=BB;AH 5>G= 1CF;><;*b OMC<M @2FH;FL 2>? D2FC<C=EHFL HG2G;H GM2G
6F2C>GC@@ M2H @CF;? =N;A VWW @ACN=F=EH F2OHECGH 2>? CH NC<C=EHFL 2GG2<3C>B
KF=BB;AHR MGGIdnnOOORGM;KF2Q;R<=DnHG=AC;HnXWVXnW\nX\nA;2?LD;;GcH=A=Hc
@E>?;?c?=D;HGC<cG;AA=ACHGcKA;GGc3CDK;AFC>cOM=H;cg=KcCHcG;AA=ACQC>BcKF=BB;AHc
C>G=cHCF;><;n
91. +2G;A GM2G ?2L* 8F;>>%;<3R<=D* 8F;>>%;<3-9* -M;%F2Q;-9 E>?;A
GM; K2>>;A =@ !;@;>?2>G 0;A<EAL )2?C= "AGH* IEKFCHM;? 2>=GM;A 2AGC<F; GCGF;?
a8F;>> -2F3H -= %F=BB;AH "K=EG %A;GG 'CDK;AFC> -;AA=ACHD*b OMC<M @2FH;FL 2>?
D2FC<C=EHFL CDIEG;H GM2G 6F2C>GC@@ HO2GG;? !;@;>?2>G 7A;L 2>? !;@;>?2>G
42F3;AR -M2G 2AGC<F; M2H GO= NC?;=H =@ !;@;>?2>G %;<3 C>G;ANC;OC>B
!;@;>?2>GH 7A;L 2>? 42F3;A C> OMC<M GM;L CDIFL 2>? CDIEG; GM2G 6F2C>GC@@
HO2GG;? GM;DR !;@;>?2>G %;<3 HG2G;H GM2G -M; %F2Q; 2AGC<F; 2K=EG 6F2C>GC@@ CH
a=>; =@ GM; D=HG CDI=AG2>G ;_I=H;H GM2G GM;L M2N; ;N;A ?=>;Rb .; @2FH;FL
0.5", Tabs: 0", Left
Formatted: Font color: Blue,
Strikethrough
Deleted: 0n }une 8, 2u12, Befenuant Ace of
Spaues publisheu "National Bay of Bloggei
Silence" to focus attention on the false
naiiative that Plaintiff was iesponsible foi
swattings. In the aiticle, Befenuant Ace of
Spaues imputeu that Plaintiff was involveu
with the "ciime" of swatting: "They aie
liteially going to "#$ %&'#&(# )*++#,- That is
theii enugame heie." This was vieweu in
Naiylanu.
Unknown
Field Code Changed
Deleted: http:ace.mu.nuaichivesS2
9849.php
Deleted: ... [3]

Su
HG2G;? GM2G 6F2C>GC@@ O2H K;C>B I2C? G= aIEG <=>H;AN2GCN; KF=BB;AH =EG =@
KEHC>;HHRb http:www.glennbeck.com2u12uS2Sglenn-talks-to-bloggeis-
about-biett-kimbeilin-teiioiism -MCH O2H NC;O;? BF=K2FFL => GM; 5>G;A>;GR
92. "G 2K=EG GM; H2D; GCD;* !;@;>?2>G %;<3 2FH= IEKFCHM;? 2
?;@2D2G=AL BA2IMC< OMC<M M; M2>? OA=G; OMC<M M2H 6F2C>GC@@ C> GM; <;>G;A =@ 2
M=HG =@ <ACDC>2F 2<GCNCGL C><FE?C>B HO2GGC>B* G2_ ;N2HC=> 2>? HG2F3C>BR -MCH 2>?
GM; =GM;A ?;@2D2G=AL HG2G;D;>GH KL !;@;>?2>G %;<3 2>? GM; <=DI2>C;H M;
<=>GA=FH O;A; ?=>; D2FC<C=EHFL G= <2EH; D2_CDED M2AD G= 6F2C>GC@@R
!;@;>?2>G %;<3 3>;O =@ HM=EF? M2N; 3>=O> GM;L O;A; @2FH;* 2>? M; ?C? >=G
<=>?E<G 2>L ?E; ?CFCB;><; =A 2H3 6F2C>GC@@ @=A <=DD;>G K;@=A; D23C>B GM;
D2FC<C=EH HG2G;D;>GHR -M;H; HG2G;D;>GH IF2<;? 6F2C>GC@@ K;@=A; GM; IEKFC< C>
@2FH; FCBMG C> 2 MCBMFL =@@;>HCN; D2>>;A* 2>? !;@;>?2>G %;<3 2<G;? OCGM 2
A;<3F;HH ?CHA;B2A? @=A GM; GAEGM K;<2EH; M; ?C? >=G @=FF=O g=EA>2FCHGC<
HG2>?2A?H GM2G A;kECA; GM2G GM; HEKg;<G =@ 2 HG=AL K; BCN;> GM; =II=AGE>CGL G=
A;HI=>? G= 2> 2FF;B2GC=> =@ OA=>B?=C>BR
9S. 0n }une 4, 2u12, Befenuant Ace of Spaues joineu the RIC0 Enteipiise
anu publisheu "National Bay of Bloggei Silence" on his blog to focus attention on the
false naiiative that Plaintiff was iesponsible foi swattings. In the aiticle, Befenuant
Ace of Spaues imputeu that Plaintiff was involveu with the "ciime" of swatting:
"They aie liteially going to "#$ %&'#&(# )*++#,- That is theii enugame heie." "s%A;GG
'CDK;AFC> 2>? MCH HG2F3;A <A;OsRb This was vieweu in Naiylanu.
http:ace.mu.nuaichivesS29849.php .; IEKFCHM;? @=EA =GM;A ?;@2D2G=AL
2AGC<F;HR

S1
5> GM; @CAHG* 2AGC<F;* MGGIdnnDC>_R<<nwI=HGxYXU\^U M; A;IEKFCHM;? 2
I=HG @A=D 62GG;AC<= OMC<M 2<<EH;H 6F2C>GC@@ =@ HO2GGC>B 2>? GM;> M;
H2LHd
a5GlH 2H F=>B 2H 2> "<; =@ 1I2?;H D=NC; A;NC;O* KEG CG CH 2 HM=<3C>B
;_I=HCGC=> =@ gEHG M=O >;@2AC=EH 'CDK;AFC> 2>? MCH M;><MD;> 2A;
2FF;B;? G= K;Rb

5> GM; H;<=>? 2AGC<F;* MGGIdnn2<;RDER>En2A<MCN;HnYXU[U[RIMI M;
G2AB;G;? 6F2C>GC@@JH ;DIF=L;A* H2LC>B GM2G GM; >=> IA=@CG B;GH ?=>2GC=>H
G= HEKHC?CQ; 6F2C>GC@@JH aM2A2HHD;>G 2>? 2KEH;RRRRb ">? GM;> M; @2FH;FL
2<<EH;H 6F2C>GC@@ =@ M2A2HHD;>G* 2>? GM;> M; <2FFH MCD 2 aGMEBRb ">?
GM;>d a,=E <2> K; 2 GMEB C@ L=E FC3;R X6/ A-6 %$# 4- "/ -# A-61 -;#
.-44$)#*4 4")*G />; F2HG GMC>B O; <2> ?=d 4; <2>
EAB;nA;kE;HGn4*)$#4 =EA A;IA;H;>G2GCN;H 1*$4 X1*// ]")F*1&"#^+
%1")"#$& 0"+/-1A "#/- /0* Z#"/*4 W/$/*+ _-#.1*++"-#$& 8*%-14G
4MLw #=G @=A IE>CGCN; A;2H=>HR )2GM;A* G= 2>HO;A GM; kE;HGC=> 5 I=H;?
C> GM; M;2?FC>;R !C? GM; :1 &=>BA;HH HGACI "D;AC<2> <CGCQ;>H =@ GM;CA
ACBMG G= HG2G; ?;D=>HGA2KFL GAE; @2<GH OCGM=EG E>;>?C>B M2A2HHD;>GHw
!C? O; F=H; GM2G ACBMG HCDIFL K;<2EH; %A;GG 'CDK;AFC> M2H ?;<C?;?* 2H
2 &=>BA;HH =@ />;* GM2G O; HM=EF? >= F=>B;A M2N; CGwb

5> GM; GMCA? 2AGC<F;* MGGIdnn2<;RDER>En2A<MCN;HnYXUUppRIMI* M;
;>B2B;H C> OC?;HIA;2? ?;@2D2GC=>R
a-O= I;=IF; M2N; 2FA;2?L K;;> HCF;><;?R />; D2> M2H K;;> $11*+/*4 cc
2AA;HG;?* @=A KF=BBC>B 2K=EG GM; <ACDC>2F MCHG=AL =@ %A;GG 'CDK;AFC>*
2>? @=A ?;H<ACKC>B MCH =>B=C>B =A?;2F 2G 'CDK;AFC>lH M2>?HR :>F;HH
&=>BA;HH 2<GH cc 2>? 2<GH HOC@GFL cc GM;A; OCFF K; HGCFF @EAGM;A C>>=<;>G
<CGCQ;>H HEKg;<G;? G= %A;GG 'CDK;AFC>lH F2OF;HH NCBCF2>GCHDRb
.; GM;> A;IEKFCHM;H 2> 2AGC<F; 2<<EHC>B 6F2C>GC@@ =@ AE>>C>B 2 >;O
<ACDC>2F aH<2DRb
-M;> M; CDIEG;H GM2G 6F2C>GC@@ O2H C>N=FN;? OCGM HO2GGC>BH* 2>? C>
G;AA=ACHDR a4MCF; 5* 2>? 'CDK;AFC>lH =GM;A G2AB;GH* 2A; M;2AG;>;? KL
&=>BA;HHl F;GG;A G= (AC< .=F?;A G= F==3 C>G= GM; 14"-GC>B D2GG;A* OM2G
2 A;2?C>B =@ &CGCQ;> ' ?;D=>HGA2G;H CH GM2G &=>BA;HH CGH;F@ >;;?H G= 2<G
C> =A?;A G= @C>2FFL IEG 2> ;>? G= %A;GG 'CDK;AFC>lH =>B=C>B ?CBCG2F T2>?
A;2FcFC@;S G;AA=ACHDRb
a6ACH=> ?C? >=G HG=I MCH <ACD;HR 6ACH=> =>FL G2EBMG MCD >;O H3CFFHRb
a">? GM; 2N2F2><M; =@ @ACN=F=EH* N;_2GC=EH* 2>? =EGACBMG D2FC<C=EH
F2OHECGH K;BC>H 2>;O* 2H O;FF 2H D=A; 2F2ADC>B M2A2HHD;>GHRb
a5 2D OACGC>B G= L=E* 0;DK;AH =@ &=>BA;HH* G= 2F;AG L=E =@ GM; @EFF
D;>2<; GM2G %A;GG 'CDK;AFC> HGCFF I=H;H G= H=<C;GLR .; HM=EF? >;N;A
M2N; K;;> F;G =EG =@ IACH=>P M2NC>B FCN;? >;2AFL GM; ;>GCA;GL =@ MCH FC@;
HC><; MCBM H<M==F 2H =>;cD2> <ACD; O2N;* CG <2> M2A?FL M2N; K;;>
K;FC;N;? GM2G M; M2? GAEFL A;@=AD;? KL XWWWRb

S2
a5G CH 2 KEA?;> G= FCN; OCGM 2 <ACDC>2F <=>NC<GC=> @=A 2 G;AAC@LC>B
?=D;HGC<cG;AA=ACHD K=DKC>B HIA;;* 2H %A;GG 'CDK;AFC> O;FF 3>=OHR
.=O;N;A* %A;GG 'CDK;AFC> M2H ?;<C?;? GM2G KEA?;> HM2FF >= F=>B;A @2FF
EI=> MCH HM=EF?;AH* KEG EI=> GM; HM=EF?;AH =@ 2>L=>; OM= D;>GC=>H
MCH ;_G;>HCN;* A;D=AH;F;HH* A;F;>GF;HH <ACDC>2F MCHG=ALR %A;GG
'CDK;AFC> M2H I;AH=>2FFL ?;<C?;? GM2G CG CH H=<C;GL 2G F2AB;* A2GM;A
GM2> MCDH;F@* OM= HM2FF K;2A GM; KEA?;> =@ MCH <ACD;HRb
a4CFF &=>BA;HH <=>HC?;A ;>2<GC>B I=HCGCN; F;BCHF2GC=> G= FCDCG %A;GG
'CDK;AFC>lH A;F;>GF;HH ?;G;ADC>2GC=> G= HE; =N;A 2>L >;B2GCN;
D;>GC=> =@ MCH I2HGwb
a"G H=D; I=C>G* GM; =>B=C>B <2H; =@ %A;GG 'CDK;AFC> NR -M; 4=AF? "G
+2AB; DEHG @C>2FFL* 2"#$&&A ;>?Rb
a" <ACD; CH C> IA=BA;HHR 5G CH =>B=C>BR 4CFF &=>BA;HH IF;2H; 2<G G= HG=I
CGwb
a5@ L=E 2A; A;2?C>B GMCH* IF;2H; <=>G2<G &=>BA;HH G= 2H3 GM;D G= >=G
=>FL G23; 2> C>G;A;HG C> GMCH D2GG;A* KEG G= H;AC=EHFL <=>HC?;A ;>2<GC>B
I=HCGCN; HG2GEG=AL F2O G= FCDCG %A;GG 'CDK;AFC>lH =>B=C>B 2KEH; =@ GM;
F;B2F HLHG;D 2>? <=AAEIGC=> =@ gEHGC<;Rb
a&=>BA;HH 2FH= ?=;H>lG 2IIA;<C2G; GM; EAB;><L =@ GM; HCGE2GC=>R 5@
GM;A;lH =>; GM;D; =@ %A;GG 'CDK;AFC>lH FC@;* CGlH ;H<2F2GC>B ACH3cG23C>B
OM;> 2FA;2?L C> 2 ACH3L HCGE2GC=>Rb
a-M; 1I;;?O2L %=DKC>BH* =@ OMC<M M; O2H <=>NC<G;?* O;A; <=>?E<G;?
;N;> 2H M; O2H E>?;A C>N;HGCB2GC=> @=A GM; DEA?;AcKLcMCA; =@ 2>
C>>=<;>G BA2>?D=GM;AR -M; GM;=AL O2H GM2G %A;GG 'CDK;AFC> H;G GM;
K=DKH G= <2EH; <M2=H 2>? IA;N;>G 2 IA=I;A C>N;HGCB2GC=> =@ GM;
;_;<EGC=>cHGLF; DEA?;A =@ ZEFC2 1<LIM;AHRb
aS+%$&$/"-#G GGGG S+%$&$/"-#G ">? GMCH F;2?H G= GM; F2HG I=C>G GM2G 5 ?=>lG
3>=O C@ &=>BA;HH CH 2O2A; =@d %A;GG 'CDK;AFC> CH 2 ?2>B;A=EH D2>R
-M2G CH >=G DL =IC>C=>P GM2G CH GM; @C>?C>B =@ GM; :>CG;? 1G2G;H @;?;A2F
<=EAGHR -MCH CH >=G H=D; KF=BO2A KEFFHMCGR -MCH CH >=G 2 <2H; =@ M;
<2FF;? D; 2 ?CAGL >2D; => GM; C>G;A>;G 2>? 5lD 2>BALR -MCH CH ?CBCG2F
G;AA=ACHD* HGA2CBMG EIR 4CGM <=>H;kE;><;H GM2G B= @2A K;L=>? OM2G
H=D;=>; H2C? 2K=EG L=E => -OCGG;AR 1=D; I;=IF; 2A; M;2AG;>;? GM2G
GMCH D2FC<C=EH =>B=C>B G= GMA;2G G= H=<C;GL CH @C>2FFL B;GGC>B H=D;
D;?C2 <=N;A2B;* 2>? H=D; :>CG;? 1G2G;H B=N;A>D;>G =@@C<C2FH 2A; >=O
I2LC>B <F=H; 2GG;>GC=>R 5lD >=GR %;<2EH; 5 3>=O OM2G M2II;>;? F2HG
GCD; %A;GG 'CDK;AFC> K;B2> B;GGC>B H=D; H;AC=EH H<AEGC>Ld %=DKH
K;B2> B=C>B =@@R S+%$&$/"-#GK

">? C> GM; @=EAGM 2AGC<F;* MGGIdnn2<;RDER>En2A<MCN;HnYYWY\\RIMI* M;
@2FH;FL HG2G;H GM2G 6F2C>GC@@ M2H K;;> ;>B2B;? C> aMCH ;>?F;HH <2DI2CB>
=@ M2A2HHD;>G* C>GCDC?2GC=>* 2>? F2O@2A;Rb .; GM;> kE=G;H N;AK2GCED
@A=D !;@;>?2>G !2> %2<3;A 2>? !% &2ICG=F 1GA2G;BC;HJ ?;@2D2G=AL
I=HG 2<<EHC>B 6F2C>GC@@ =@ HO2GGC>BR

SS
94. 0n }une 2S, 2u12, Befenuant Stianahan wiote an aiticle on
Bieitbait.com, implying that Plaintiff was iesponsible foi the swatting of Aaion
Walkei. This was available to citizens of Naiylanu. http:www.bieitbait.comBig-
uoveinment2u12u62SBloggei-Aaion-Walkei-Swatteu
9S. 0n }une 2S, 2u12, Befenuant Fiey wiote an aiticle on Patteiico's
Pontifications implying that Plaintiff was iesponsible foi the swatting of Befenuant
Walkei, anu even tolu othei bloggeis to call the police if they planneu to wiite about
Plaintiff because they coulu be swatteu. All of Befenuant Fiey's blog posts aie
viewable in Naiylanu. http:patteiico.com2u12u62Saaion-walkei-swatteu
96. 0n Nay 27, 2u12, Befenuant Eiick Eiickson joineu the RIC0
Enteipiise anu publisheu an aiticle on Befenuant ReuState, which was vieweu in
Naiylanu, implying that Plaintiff was somehow involveu with swatting him:
Last week we spent a lot of time wiiting about Biett Kimbeilin anu the
inciuent involving bloggei Patteiico wheie someone spoofeu his phone
numbei anu tolu 911 he hau shot his wife.
Tonight, my family was sitting aiounu the kitchen table eating uinnei when
sheiiffs ueputies pulleu up in the uiiveway.
Someone calleu 911 fiom my auuiess claiming theie hau been an
acciuental shooting.
It wasn't neaily the tiauma that Patteiico suffeieu, but I guess the Eiickson
householu is on somebouy's iauai.
Luckily it was two sheiiffs ueputies who knew me anu I hau alieauy, last
week, auviseu the Sheiiff's Bepaitment to be on the look out foi something
like this. http:www.ieustate.comeiick2u12uS27swatting-the-
eiicksons

97. 0n }une 2S, 2u12, Befenuant Twitchy joineu the RIC0 Enteipiise anu
publisheu an aiticle titleu, "Aaion Walkei Swatteu," which compileu uozens of
tweets that togethei impute that Plaintiff committeu the swatting. Twitchy posts
0.5"
0.5"

S4
aie viewable in Naiylanu. http:twitchy.com2u12u62Saaion-walkei-swat-
teu
98. !;@;>?2>G -M; "D;AC<2> 1I;<G2G=A IEKFCHM;? >ED;A=EH
?;@2D2G=AL 2AGC<F;H KL !;@;>?2>G 0<&2C> 2>? GM;> A;D=N;? GM;DR !;@;>?2>G
0<&2C> <=DIF2C>;? G= GM; ;?CG=A 2>? GM; 2AGC<F;H O;A; GM;> A;IEKFCHM;? C>
7;KAE2AL XWV[ OCGM ?C@@;A;>G EAFHR -M; HM;;A >EDK;A =@ 2AGC<F;H IEKFCHM;? KL
GM; "D;AC<2> 1I;<G2G=A 2K=EG 6F2C>GC@@ ?;D=>HGA2G;H D2FC<; 2> C>G;>G G= M2AD
MCD 2>? MCH KEHC>;HH IA=HI;<GHR 7=A ;_2DIF;* C> =>;* GCGF;? a-;AA=A %L ">L
/GM;A #2D;*b !;@;>?2>G 0<&2C> CDIEG;H GM2G 6F2C>GC@@ O2H C>N=FN;? OCGM
HO2GGC>BH 2>? OACG;Hd a
0<M;FF; 02F3C> M2H <2FF;? %A;GG 'CDK;AFC> 2> i=>FC>; G;AA=ACHG
AC>BF;2?;A*i OMCF; KF=BB;A ZCDDC; %CH; ZAR IA;@;AH GM; IMA2H; iFLC>B
@;F=>*i KEG 'CDK;AFC>lH I=FCGC<2F 2FFC;H <2FF MCD 2 iIA=BA;HHCN; 2<GCNCHGRi
!EAC>B GM; I2HG O;;3* 'CDK;AFC>lH KCQ2AA; D;GM=?H =@ i2<GCNCHDi M2N;
D2?; MCD GM; @=<EH =@ C>G;>H; H<AEGC>L @A=D <=>H;AN2GCN; KF=BB;AH*
2A=EHC>B GM; C>G;A;HG =@ D2g=A >;OH =AB2>CQ2GC=>H* H= GM2G GM;
<=>NC<G;? @;F=> =><; >=G=AC=EH 2H GM; i1I;;?O2L %=DK;Ai CH FC3;FL G=
K;<=D; ;N;> D=A; >=G=AC=EH C> GM; >;2A @EGEA;R
1C><; XWVW* 'CDK;AFC> M2H K;;> HEC>B* HD;2AC>B* M2A2HHC>B* 2>?
=GM;AOCH; 2GG;DIGC>B G= C>GCDC?2G; KF=BB;AH OM= OACG; 2K=EG MCH
<ACDC>2F MCHG=ALR 5G H;;D;? M; O2H C>G;>G => HCF;><C>B GM; GAEGM 2>? cc
2FGM=EBM 5 M2? >;N;A ;N;> M;2A? =@ MCD E>GCF 02L Vp cc OCGMC> @=EA
?2LH =@ DL K;BC>>C>B G= A;I=AG 2K=EG MCD => DL I;AH=>2F KF=B*
'CDK;AFC> K;B2> G2AB;GC>B D; OCGM MCH GMEB G2<GC<HR /> 0=>?2L* 02L
XV* 5 F;@G DL 02ALF2>? M=D; 2>? ?;I2AG;? G= 2>=GM;A HG2G; OM;A;* @=A
GM; I2HG O;;3* 5lN; <=>GC>E;? 2 H;AC;H =@ A;I=AGH 5lN; <2FF;? i-M;
'CDK;AFC> 7CF;HRi -M;H; =>FC>; ?CHI2G<M;H M2N; K;;> @CF;? @A=D 2>
E>?CH<F=H;? F=<2GC=>* DL OM;A;2K=EGH <=><;2F;? C> =A?;A G= IA=G;<G
DLH;F@ 2>? =GM;AH @A=D GM; D;>2<; =@ 2 ?2>B;A=EH D2> OM= KL 2FF
ACBMGH HM=EF? HGCFF K; K;MC>? K2AHR
http:spectatoi.oigaiticlesS767Steiioi-any-othei-name
99. Befenuants Eiickson, Walkei, Fiey anu otheis contacteu Nembeis of
the Bouse anu Senate, telling them that Plaintiff was iesponsible foi the swatting
0.5"

SS
anu uiging them to uemanu a ciiminal investigation by the Bepaitment of }ustice.
As a iesult Senatoi Saxby Chambliss anu 87 Bouse Nembeis signeu letteis uiging
the Bepaitment of }ustice to investigate anu piosecute the peison who swatteu
"conseivative bloggeis." These letteis in conjunction with the false statements by
Befenuants imputeu that Plaintiff was involveu in the swattings. Foi example,
Befenuant Robeit Stacy NcCain, 2 D;DK;A =@ GM; #2GC=>2F %F=BB;AH &FEK 2>?
I2AG>;A =@ !;@;>?2>G "FC "3K2A* iepoiteu about the letteis anu uigeu mainstieam
iepoiteis to "peel. that big onion" aiounu Plaintiff's connections to the swattings.
http:theotheimccain.com2u12u611floiiua-iep-sanuy-auams-leaus-8S-
house-iepublicans-in-swatting-lettei
1uu. Two FBI agents came to Plaintiff's home in Naiylanu on oi about }uly
1, 2u12, anu inteivieweu Plaintiff about the swattings. 0n oi about August 2u, 2u1S,
anothei FBI agent inteivieweu Plaintiff's wife aftei Befenuant Walkei contacteu the
agent anu tolu him to suipiise hei at a location in Naiylanu known to Befenuant
Walkei.
1u1. In 2u12 anu 2u1S, Befenuant Walkei iepeateuly contacteu state anu
feueial law enfoicement officials anu falsely tolu them that Plaintiff committeu the
swattings anu uemanueu that they aiiest himR 5> XWVV 2>? XWVX* !;@;>?2>G 7A;L
A;I;2G;?FL <=>G2<G;? HG2G; 2>? @;?;A2F =@@C<C2FH 2>? G=F? GM;D GM2G 6F2C>GC@@
O2H C>N=FN;? OCGM GM; HO2GGC>BHR -M;H; !;@;>?2>GH D2?; GM;H; @2FH;
HG2G;D;>GH OCGM=EG 2>L ;NC?;><; GM2G 6F2C>GC@@ O2H C>N=FN;? OCGM GM;
HO2GGC>BH 2>? GM;L ?C? H= C> =A?;A G= M2N; 6F2C>GC@@ 2AA;HG;? =A M2A2HH;? KL
F2O ;>@=A<;D;>G 2B;>GHR

S6
1u2. Befenuant Walkei GMA=EBM !;@;>?2>GH !2> %2<3;A 2>? !% &2ICG=F
1GA2G;BC;H attempteu to use uiscoveiy in his fiivolous viiginia civil lawsuit to
uemanu uocuments fiom Plaintiff to bolstei his false swatting allegations. The juuge
in the case uenieu those uiscoveiy iequests. 6AC><; 4CFFC2D 9CABC>C2 &CA<ECG &=EAG
ZE?B; 6=GG;A @=E>? GM2G GM2G <2H; O2H OCGM=EG D;ACG* K=GM F;B2FFL 2>? @2<GE2FFL*
2>? O2H KA=EBMG @=A 2> CDIA=I;A IEAI=H;. Plaintiff was iequiieu to tiavel fiom
Naiylanu to viiginia to uefenu against that malicious suit.
1uS. Befenuant Walkei thiough !;@;>?2>GH !2> %2<3;A 2>? !% &2ICG=F
1GA2G;BC;H fileu a feueial lawsuit in the Bistiict of Naiylanu asking the feueial couit
to piohibit Plaintiff fiom seeking ieuiess in State of Naiylanu couits baseu on the
false naiiative that Plaintiff engageu in ciiminal anu unethical conuuct. Befenuant
Walkei came to Naiylanu fiom viiginia to piosecute that malicious suit.
1u4. Befenuants Walkei anu BB Capitol Stiategies attempteu to use
Befenuant Walkei's fiivolous feueial lawsuit to extoit a settlement that woulu
iequiie the teimination of Plaintiff's employment at the non-piofit, anu the
uisclosuie of piotecteu infoimation fiom his employei. Attoiney 2>? !;@;>?2>G
Ban Backei wiote an email to that effect anu it was ieceiveu in Naiylanu. .;
C><FE?;? 6F2C>GC@@JH ;DIF=L;A C> GM; HECG C> K2? @2CGM 2>? ?C? >=G ;N;> 2FF;B;
GM2G GM; ;DIF=L;A ?C? 2>LGMC>B ;_<;IG ;DIF=L 6F2C>GC@@R
1uS. 4M;> 6F2C>GC@@ A;@EH;? !;@;>?2>G %2<3;AJH ;_G=AGC=>2G; ?;D2>?
2>? @CF;? 2 0=GC=> G= !CHDCHH* 0AR %2<3;A A;HI=>?;? KL H;>?C>B 2 ?;@2D2G=AL
?=<ED;>G M=F? F;GG;A G= GM; >=>cIA=@CGHJ F2AB;HG C>HGCGEGC=>2F @E>?;A* 2>?

S7
@2FH;FL G=F? GM2G @E>?;A GM2G 6F2C>GC@@ 2>? GM; >=>cIA=@CGH O;A; ;>B2B;? C>
<ACDC>2F 2<GCNCGL => 2 BA2>? H<=I;R -M; F;GG;A HG2G;H C> I2AGd
-MCH F;GG;A CH G= C>@=AD L=E =@ GM; <EAA;>G 2K=N;cHGLF;? F2OHECG
I;>?C>B 2B2C>HG 0AR %A;GG 'CDK;AFC>* ZEHGC<; -MA=EBM 0EHC< 6A=g;<G*
2>? 9;FN;G );N=FEGC=> :1 TaGM; /AB2>CQ2GC=>HbS* C> OMC<M 5 A;IA;H;>G
6F2C>GC@@ "2A=> 42F3;AR ,=EA =AB2>CQ2GC=> M2H <=D; EI ?EAC>B GM;
?;N;F=ID;>G =@ GMCH FCGCB2GC=> 2H 2 ?=>=A G= =>; =A K=GM =@ GM;H;
=AB2>CQ2GC=>H* 2>? 2H HE<M I=G;>GC2FFL ;>2KFC>B GM; G=AGC=EH 2>?
I=G;>GC2FFL E>F2O@EF <=>?E<G =@ 0AR 'CDK;AFC> 2>? GM;
/AB2>CQ2GC=>HR 7=A L=EA K;>;@CG* 5 M2N; ;><F=H;? GM; &=DIF2C>G 2>? 2
)EF; VV D=GC=> 0AR 'CDK;AFC> @CF;? 2B2C>HG D; C> 2 ?;HI;A2G;
2GG;DIG G= C>GCDC?2G; D; @A=D IEAHEC>B GMCH <2H; 2>? FCGCB2GC>B CG
GMA=EBM GAC2FR 5 M2N; 2FH= C><FE?;? DL A;HI=>H; 2>? 5 BCN; L=E DL
2HHEA2><; GM2G 5 OCFF K; IA;<;?C>B THC<S C> HGAC<G 2<<=A?2><; OCGM GM;
7;?;A2F )EF;H =@ &CNCF 6A=<;?EA; 2>?* C> HM=AG =A?;A* OCGM ?CH<=N;AL
OMC<M OCFF H;;3 C>@=AD2GC=> => ;N;AL 2HI;<G =@ GM; /AB2>CQ2GC=>HJ
C><FE?C>B ?=>=A 2>? @E>?A2CHC>B 2II2A2GEH;HR %;<2EH; =@ L=EA
=AB2>CQ2GC=>JH C>N=FN;D;>G OCGM 0AR 'CDK;AFC> 2>? GM;
/AB2>CQ2GC=>H* 2>? K;<2EH; =@ GM;CA I=G;>GC2FFL G=AGE=EH 2>?
I;AM2IH ;N;> CFF;B2F 2<GCNCGL* 5 2D H;>?C>B L=E GMCH F;GG;A 2H 2
A;kE;HG G= IA;H;AN; I=G;>GC2F ;NC?;><; C> GMCH D2GG;AR sR

-O= ?2LH 2@G;A !;@>?2>G %2<3;A H;>G GM; ?;@2D2G=AL F;GG;A* ZE?B; 0=GQ
?CHDCHH;? GM; <2H; 2B2C>HG 6F2C>GC@@ 2>? GM; >=>cIA=@CGHR
1u6. Befenuant BB Capitol Stiategies posteu on its website that it was
suing Plaintiff in feueial couit to uefenu bloggeis fiom "swatting," imputing that
Plaintiff was iesponsible foi those swattings.
http:bloggeisuefenseteam.com.about !;@;>?2>GH !2> %2<3;A 2>? BB Capitol
Stiategies wiote on its blog that Plaintiff's "victims" weie "swatteu," implying that
Plaintiff was involveu with the swattings. "Kimbeilin 'associates' aie suspecteu in
fai moie sinistei foims of haiassment - incluuing the 'SWATting' of an Assistant BA
in Califoinia." http:bloggeisuefenseteam.com.naiiative These aie still viewable
Formatted: No bullets or numbering
0.5"
Deleted: Befenuant
Formatted: Font color: Custom
Color(RGB(80,98,111))
Color(RGB(80,98,111))

S8
>=O =>FL NC;O2KF; NC2 I2HHO=A? C> 02ALF2>? KEG O;A; NC;O2KF; @=A D=A; GM2>
=>; L;2AR
1u7. Befenuant BB Capitol Stiategies iaiseu tens of thousanus of uollais
baseu on this false naiiative anu is still iaising <=>GC>E;? G= A2CH; funus even
though }uuge Notz uismisseu its fiivolous suit against Plaintiff on Novembei 26,
2u12.
1u8. Befenuant Walkei's attoiney in the state anu feueial lawsuits,
Befenuant Ban Backei, who is the uiiectoi of BB Capitol Stiategies, iefuseu
Plaintiff's iepeateu iequests to iemove the false anu uefamatoiy infoimation fiom
the BB Capitol website. 7C>2FFL* C> 7;KAE2AL XWV[* GM=H; I=HGH O;A; IF2<;?
E>?;A I2HHO=A? IA=G;<GC=>R
1u9. Befenuant Nichelle Nalkin useu hei blog anu Twittei compilei,
!;@;>?2>G Twitchy, to iepeateuly state that Plaintiff committeu the swattings. Foi
example, on Nay Su, 2u12, she wiote a blog post titleu "Bieakthiough: Fox News
Coveis Biett KimbeilinPatteiico Swattings."
http:michellemalkin.com2u12uSSubieakthiough-fox-coveis-biett-kimbeilin-
patteiico-swatting-bloggeis-continue-piessing-the-stoiy
11u. 0n Apiil 8, 2u1S, Befenuant Nichelle Nalkin publisheu an aiticle on
hei blog titleu, "Noie Celebiities Swatteu, Neanwhile Anti-Biett Kimbeilin Bloggeis
Still 0nuei Fiie." http:michellemalkin.com2u1Su4u8moie-celebiities-swat-
teu-meanwhile-anti-biett-kimbeilin-bloggeis-still-unuei-fiie Befenuant Nalkin
imputeu that Plaintiff was iesponsible foi the swatting of Befenuants Fiey anu
Deleted: .
Color(RGB(80,98,111))
Deleted:
0.5", Tabs: 0.63", Left

S9
Walkei. The fiist commentei to the aiticle saiu: "Biett Kimbeilin neeus to wake up
with a hoise's heau in his beu."
111. Befenuant Fiey is an Assistant Bistiict Attoiney in Los Angeles,
Califoinia by uay anu by night he blogs as Patteiico. Befenuant Fiey has iepeateuly
stateu, uiiectly anu by implication, that Plaintiff swatteu him. Foi example, on Nay
2S, 2u12, Befenuant Fiey heaulineu an aiticle about swatting with Plaintiff's name
piominently uisplayeu saiu in the aiticle HG2GC>B that he coulu have been killeu, anu
imputeu that Plaintiff was iesponsible foi the swatting.
http:patteiico.com2u12uS2Sconvicteu-bombei-biett-kimbeilin-neal-
iauhausei-ion-biynaeit-anu-theii-campaign-of-political-teiioiism
112. Befenuants Fiey, Walkei, Stianahan, Nagy, NcCain anu otheis have
useu Befenuant Fiey's job uesciiption - "Assistant Bistiict Attoiney" - to
give cieuibility to theii statements smeaiing Plaintiff as a swattei. This
job uesciiption has been publisheu in aiticles, in tweets, in emails, anu in
letteis. Foi example,
Befenuant Fiey wiote "I am that L.A. County Piosecutoi."
http:patteiico.com2u12uS2Sconvicteu-bombei-biett-
kimbeilin-neal-iauhausei-ion-biynaeit-anu-theii-campaign-of-
political-teiioiism
"Los Angeles County Beputy Bistiict Attoiney Patiick Fiey has an
unusual night job."
http:www.laweekly.com2u12-11-u8newspatiick-fiey-
swatting-patteiico-ueauly-gamefull
Color(RGB(66,71,74))
0.5"
at: 0.88" + Indent at: 1.13", Tabs:Not at
0.5"

4u
"It's a phone call that coulu have gotten me killeu," Patiick Fiey,
a ueputy uistiict attoiney at Los Angeles County Bistiict Attoiney's
0ffice.."
http:www.foxnews.compolitics2u12uSS1conseivative-
bloggeis-say-theyie-being-haiasseu-foi-postings
"LA Weekly iecounts the stoiy of Beputy Bistiict Attoiney Patiick
Fiey, the well-known conseivative bloggei Patteiico, being
SWATteu last summei" http:www.bieitbait.comBig-
uoveinment2u1211u8LA-Weekly-Inteiviews-Patteiico-About-
Bis-SWATting
"Anothei bloggei who was SWAT-teu, Patiick Fiey, a Los Angeles
assistant uistiict attoiney, went thiough the teiiifying expeiience in
}uly of 2u11"
http:www.washingtontimes.comblogwateicoolei2u12jun1u
picket-fla-congiesswoman-leaus-effoit-uemanuing-sw
"In 0ctobei of 2u1u, I was contacteu by }. Patiick Fiey, a.k.a.
"Patteiico" of Patteiico's Pontifications. Patiick is a Beputy Bistiict
Attoiney in Los Angeles in the haiu coie gang unit."
http:alleigic2bull.blogspot.com2u12uShow-biett-kimbeilin-
tiieu-to-fiame-me_17.html
11S. Befenuant Fiey ielies on his job as Assistant Bistiict Attoiney to
maintain a leaueiship anu supeivisoiy position in the conseivative blogging
hieiaichy anu in the instant iacketeeiing enteipiise. Bis oiueis aie followeu, his
0.5"
0.5"
at: 0.75" + Indent at: 1"
0.5"

41
uiiectives aie heeueu, his legal analysis is unquestioneu, anu his statements aie
believeu.
114. !;@;>?2>G 7A;L A=EGC>;FL A;@;AH G= MCDH;F@ => MCH KF=B 2H
a62GG;AC<=*b 2 aIA=H;<EG=A C> +=H ">B;F;H &=E>GLsRb
MGGIdnnI2GG;AC<=R<=Dn2K=EGI2GG;AC<=R );2?;AH* <=DD;>G;AH 2>? A;I=AG;AH 2FF
K;FC;N; GM2G 7A;LJH O;FFc3>=O> =>FC>; 2FG;A ;B= a62GG;AC<=b CH 2 ?CBCG2F
;_G;>HC=> =@ Z=M> 62GAC<3 7A;L* GM; +=H ">B;F;H &=E>GL !;IEGL !CHGAC<G
"GG=A>;LR 5> @2<G* !;@;>?2>G 7A;L C?;>GC@C;H MCDH;F@ 2H a62GG;AC<=b 2>?
?;H<ACK;H a62GG;AC<=b 2H 2 IA=H;<EG=A C> +=H ">B;F;H &=E>GL OM= IA=H;<EG;H
<ACDC>2FHR 5> MCH KF=B I=HGH* !;@;>?2>G 7A;L M2H D2?; <F;2A GM2G a62GG;AC<=JH
6=>GC@C<2GC=>Hb CH GM; IA=?E<G =@ 2 !;IEGL !CHGAC<G "GG=A>;LR 7A;L M2H C>?C<2G;?
GM2G a62GG;AC<=JH 6=>GC@C<2GC=>Hb CH FC>3;? G= MCH I=HCGC=> 2H 2 IA=H;<EG=AR 5> 2
1;IG;DK;A U* XWWU KF=B I=HG ;>GCGF;? a62GG;AC<= %2>>;? 2G GM; +R"R -CD;Hwww*b
7A;L OA=G; at2uA; GM;L K2>>C>B 2FF !;IEGL !CHGAC<G "GG=A>;LHw /A gEHG GM; =>;H
GM2G D23; GM;D F==3 FC3; @==FH => 2 ?2CFL K2HCHwb 5?R 7A;LJH I=HG HM=OH GM2G M;
I;A<;CN;H 2>L IEAI=AG;? K2> => a62GG;AC<=b G= K; A;F2G;? G= 7A;LJH I=HCGC=> 2H
!;IEGL !CHGAC<G "GG=A>;LR 5?R !E; G= 7A;LJH A;I;2G;? A;@;A;><;H G= MCH I=HCGC=>
2H 2 IA=H;<EG=A* =GM;A D;?C2 =EGF;GH M2N; NC;O;? a62GG;AC<=JH 6=>GC@C<2GC=>Hb
2H C>;_GAC<2KFL FC>3;? G= MCH I=HCGC=> 2H 2 ?;IEGL ?CHGAC<G 2GG=A>;LR 0=A;=N;A*
7A;L @A;kE;>GFL C>N=3;H MCH I=HCGC=> 2H 2 IA=H;<EG=A G= F;>? HEKHG2><; 2>?
O;CBMG G= MCH =IC>C=>H* C><FE?C>B <F2CDC>B GM2G aO; !;IEGL !"JH 2A; HEHIC<C=EH
KL >2GEA;Pb ?CHI2A2BC>B 2 <=DD;>G;AJH <ACGCkE; => MCH KF=B I=HG KL HG2GC>B
atCu> L=EA O=AF?* ;N;AL IA=H;<EGC=> CH =@ 2> C>>=<;>G I;AH=> R R R L=EA O=AF? M2H

42
>=GMC>B G= ?= OCGM GM; O=AF? 5 3>=O* 2>? L=E 2A; <F;2AFL VWWy CB>=A2>G =@ GM;
>2GEA; =@ GM; IA=<;HH L=E 2A; ?CH<EHHC>Bb 2HH;AGC>B GM2G atKu;C>B 2 IA=H;<EG=A
CH 2K=EG IA;H;>GC>B GM; GAEGMb T5?RSP 2>? ?CH<EHHC>B C>HC?; C>@=AD2GC=> @A=D
GM; !"JH /@@C<;R a62GG;AC<=JHb C>N=<2GC=> =@ MCH 2EGM=ACGL 2H 2 IA=H;<EG=A CH
HEKGF; 2>? 7A;L M2H C>G;>GC=>2FFL <A2@G;? a62GG;AC<=b G= BCN; GM; CDIA;HHC=>
GM2G a62GG;AC<=b HI;23H <2HE2F* =@@M2>?* 2>? CH 2FD=HG 2FO2LH @=FF=O;? KL 2
a?CH<F2CD;ARb %EG OM;> a62GG;AC<=b <=>GC>E=EHFL 2>? ;_G;>HCN;FL C?;>GC@C;H
MCDH;F@ 2H 2 IA=H;<EG=A* OM;> M; EH;H MCH IEKFC< I=HCGC=> G= ;_;AG C>@FE;><;
2>? F;>? <A;?CKCFCGL G= MCH =IC>C=>H* 2>? OM;> M; GMA;2G;>H <ACDC>2F
IA=H;<EGC=>* 7A;L M2H GA2>H@=AD;? a62GG;AC<=b C>G= GM; NCAGE2F* =>FC>;
I;AH=>C@C<2GC=> =@ GM; !;IEGL !CHGAC<G "GG=A>;L Z=M> 62GAC<3 7A;LR -MEH* OM;>
a62GG;AC<=b HI;23H* M; HI;23H OCGM GM; 2EGM=ACGL 2>? IA;HGCB; =@ GM; /@@C<; =@
GM; !CHGAC<G "GG=A>;LR %L <F=23C>B MCDH;F@ OCGM GM; I=O;A =@ MCH B=N;A>D;>G
I=HCGC=>* a62GG;AC<=b IF2<;? A;2?;AH 2>? 5>G;A>;G =KH;AN;AH => >=GC<; GM2G MCH
;_IA;HHC=>H <2AAC;? GM; O;CBMG 2>? BA2NCG2H =@ 2 IA=H;<EG=AC2F =@@C<; =@ GM;
HG2G; B=N;A>D;>GR +C3; GM; =@@c?EGL I=FC<; =@@C<;A OM= @F2HM;H MCH K2?B; 2>?
EH;H 2 ?;I2AGD;>G CHHE;? M2>?BE>* a62GG;AC<=b =I;>FL ?CHIF2LH MCH <A;?;>GC2FH
2H 2 IA=H;<EG=AR 4M;> a62GG;AC<=b CHHE;? MCH GMA;2G G= C>N;HGCB2G; 2>?
CDIACH=> 6F2C>GC@@ @=A HO2GGC>BH* GM; HG2G;D;>G O2H EGG;A;? OCGM GM; @=A<; =@
2EGM=ACGL <=>@;AA;? => 7A;L KL NCAGE; =@ MCH I=HCGC=> 2H 2 IA=H;<EG=A => 2
D2GG;A C> OMC<M 7A;L O2H E>CkE;FL ;>?=O;? G= 2<GR
11S. Nany of the Befenuants anu othei non-uefenuant bloggeis anu
iepoiteis believeu that Plaintiff was involveu with the swattings because of
0.5"

4S
Befenuant Fiey's position as Beputy Bistiict Attoiney. The accusations anu
implications by Befenuant Fiey weie so cieuible because of his position as a
piosecutoi, anu he capitalizeu on that position to make suie that no one questioneu
that Plaintiff committeu the swattings. Be anu othei Befenuants also useu that
position to maximize the publicity about the swattings, anu to misleau the FBI anu
Congiess about the swattings.
116. Plaintiff has iepeateuly infoimeu the Los Angeles County Bistiict
Attoiney's 0ffice 2>? 5>G;A>2F "@@2CAH about the toitious conuuct of Befenuant Fiey
but his supeivisois have tolu Plaintiff that they have given Befenuant Fiey
peimission to act that way as long as he uoes not uo it while physically at the
Bistiict Attoiney's 0ffice.
117. /> 02L XY* XWVX* 6F2C>GC@@ A;<;CN;? 2 GMA;2G => MCH >=>cIA=@CG
O;KHCG; <=>G2<G I2B; H2LC>Bd a+("9( .50 "+/#(R !/#J- 8/ -.()(Rb 6F2C>GC@@
C>G;AIA;G;? GMCH 2H 2 GMA;2G G= F;2N; 0AR 7A;L 2F=>; 2>? >=G G= <=>G2<G MCH
HEI;ANCH=AHR 4M;> 6F2C>GC@@ <M;<3;? GM; <=>G2<G F=BH => @=A GM2G GCD; 2>? GM2G
O;KHCG;* M; ?CH<=N;A;? GM2G GM; ;D2CF <2D; @A=D GM; a+=H ">B;F;H &=E>GL
1M;AC@@JH !;I2AGD;>G*b 2G 56 "??A;HH V[^RXYYRWRXWX C> 4MCGGC;A* &2FC@=A>C2R
/>FL 2 I;AH=> 2<GC>B E>?;A <=F=A =@ F2O <=EF? <=>NC><; 2> ;DIF=L;; =@ GM; +"
&=E>GL 1M;AC@@JH /@@C<; G= OACG; 2 GMA;2G FC3; GM2GR -M; I;AH=> OM= OA=G; CG
O=EF? M2N; G= @;;F GM2G M; O=EF? K; aIA=G;<G;?b KL !;@;>?2>G 2>? !;IEGL
!CHGAC<G "GG=A>;L 7A;L 2B2C>HG 2>L KF=OK2<3R
0.5"

44
118. Befenuant Fiey acts unuei coloi of the law of the State of Califoinia,
which has given him full authoiity anu peimission to smeai Plaintiff, falsely accuse
Plaintiff of swatting, anu uefame Plaintiff.
119. Befenuant Fiey, as an official of the State of Califoinia, has useu his
position to intimiuate, haiass, stalk, thieaten anu haim Plaintiff, uiiectly anu
thiough otheis. Befenuant Fiey masqueiaues as a law abiuing state official by uay,
anu then by night he calls on his ieaueis to haiass his taigets, incluuing Plaintiff. All
the while, Befenuant Fiey anu his employei maintain official plausible ueniability by
asseiting that he is acting alone anu off uuty, yet he weais the title of Assistant
Bistiict Attoiney by uay anu by night anu uses it on his blog, in talking to meuia, anu
to bolstei his statuie, cieuibility anu stanuing.
12u. Befenuant Fiey has stateu that Plaintiff shoulu be aiiesteu anu jaileu
foi vaiious ieasons. Because these statements come fiom an Assistant Bistiict
Attoiney, they caiiy much gieatei weight than woulu such calls coming fiom a
iegulai citizen. These statements have been vieweu in Naiylanu.
121. Befenuant Fiey secietly contacteu GM; HI=3;HI;AH=> @=A GM;
M2<GCNCHG BA=EI ">=>LD=EH Baiiett Biown anu sought his help anu the help of the
hackei gioup Anonymous to intimiuate Plaintiff. Befenuant Fiey useu his position as
Beputy Bistiict Attoiney to make that contact anu implieu to Ni. Biown that
because of his position, he may be able to pioviue a quiu pio quo to help Ni. Biown
with his legal pioblems in exchange foi Ni. Biown helping Befenuant Fiey.
http:pastebin.comWuuuScBB Ni. Biown iefuseu that iequest anu posteu his
chat logs with Befenuant Fiey.

4S
122. Befenuant Walkei has wiitten many letteis to people anu officials
using Befenuant Fiey's job position in oiuei to enhance the cieuibility of his false
statements against Plaintiff. Befenuant Walkei has useu Befenuant Fiey -"Assistant
Bistiict Attoiney"as a iefeience, anu uigeu people to contact Assistant Bistiict
Attoiney Fiey to veiify Befenuant Walkei's false statements about Plaintiff.
http:alleigic2bull.blogspot.com2u1112i-iesponu-to-biett-kimbeilins-
motion.html
12S. "H >=G;? C> GM; ;D2CFH @A=D !;@;>?2>G 7A;L 2K=N;* Befenuant Fiey
uses the legal tiaining, legal contacts, anu legal iesouices he has uevelopeu as an
Assistant Bistiict Attoiney to taiget Plaintiff with smeais, false naiiatives anu legal
analysis.
124. Befenuants have iepeateuly stateu that theii goal is to have Plaintiff
aiiesteu anu jaileu, anu uestioy his ability to iaise funus foi his non-piofit
employei.
12S. Befenuants' business mouel is to cieate false naiiatives about Plaintiff
in oiuei to iaise funus foi themselves while uiiving theii blogs to highei iankings of
Inteinet seaich engines such as uoogle.
126. 0n }une 26, 2u12, Befenuant The Fianklin Centei joineu The RIC0
Enteipiise anu publisheu a piess ielease that was vieweu in Naiylanu, anu helu a
webinai, which stateu:
Convicteu uomestic teiioiist Biett Kimbeilin anu his associates have
iepeateuly teiioiizeu bloggeis anu otheis who highlight his stoiy with ovei
1uu fiivolous lawsuits anu 4 SWATting attacks. SWATting is a uangeious
tactic that involves calling a police uepaitment to iepoit a false ciime to get
a SWAT team uispatcheu to the victim's house. The attacks have incluueu

46
bloggeis Patteiico, Eiick Eiickson, anu as iecently as last night, Aaion
Woithing.
http:fianklincenteihq.oigS8SSfianklin-centei-joins-lee-stianahan-
popehat-aaion-walkei-manuy-nagy-anu-otheis-to-uiscuss-piotection-of-
the-fiee-piess T-MCH KF=B I=HG O2H N=FE>G2ACFL A;D=N;? KL GM;
7A2>3FC> &;>G;A => =A 2K=EG 7;KAE2AL V* XWV[S

127. -M; 7A2>3FC> &;>G;A M;F? 2 O;KC>2A* OMC<M C><FE?;? !;@;>?2>GH
42F3;A* #2BL 2>? 1GA2>2M2> OMC<M HG2G;? 2>?n=A CDIEG;? GM2G 6F2C>GC@@ O2H
C>N=FN;? OCGM HO2GGC>B 2>? M2? B=GG;> !;@;>?2>G 42F3;A G;ADC>2G;? @A=D MCH
;DIF=LD;>G za"2A=> 4=AGMC>B O2H HO2GG;? F2HG >CBMG 2>? CH 2 N;AL MCBM
IA=@CF; NC<GCD =@ %A;GG 'CDK;AFC>Rb -M2G O;KC>2A O2H I=HG;? KL -M; 7A2>3FC>
&;>G;A => ,=E-EK; OM;A; CH A;<;CN;? OC?;HIA;2? NC;O;AHMCI @A=D 2<A=HH GM;
BF=K; 2>? CG CH HGCFF 2N2CF2KF; => ,=E-EK; 2H =@ 02A<M ]* XWV[R
MGGIdnnOOORL=EGEK;R<=DnO2G<MwNx#UrVN4k#p(]
128. /> 02L X\* XWVX* -2KCGM2 .2F; OA=G; 2> 2AGC<F; => -M; 7A2>3FC>
&;>G;A O;KHCG; GCGF;?* a.=F?C>B 6=FCGC<2F -;AA=ACHG %A;GG 'CDK;AFC>
"<<=E>G2KF;b OMC<M @2FH;FL HG2G;? GM2G 6F2C>GC@@ CH 2 <MCF? D=F;HG;A* 2HH2HHC>*
OM= M2H @CF;? =N;A VWW @ACN=F=EH F2OHECGH* 2>? 2GG2<3;? a2>L KF=BB;A OM=
?2A;? D;>GC=> MCH >2D;sRb -M; 2AGC<F; EAB;H A;2?;AH G= G2AB;G GM; 1G2G;
!;I2AGD;>G @=A O=A3C>B OCGM 6F2C>GC@@JH ;DIF=L;AR
http:fianklincenteihq.oigSS46holuing-political-teiioiist-biett-kimbeilin-
accountable
129. -M; 7A2>3FC> &;>G;AJH HGA=>B A;F2GC=>HMCI OCGM GM; @A2E?EF;>G #2GC=>2F
%F=BB;AH &FEK 2>? @EAGM;A ;NC?;><; GM2G CG g=C>;? -M; )5&/ (>G;AIACH; CH @=E>?
C> GM; @2<G GM2G -M; &;>G;A O2H 2 6A;DC;A 1I=>H=A 2>? .=HG /AB2>CQ;A =@ GM;
Deleted: ... [4]
Deleted: above piess ielease on his
blog unuei the heauline, "
Unknown
Field Code Changed
Deleted: #TC0T #BiettKimbeilin
#SWATting Impoitant Event 9:Su p.m. ET
Tonight!
Deleted: "

47
XWV[ #2GC=>2F %F=BB;AH &FEK %F=B %2HM M;F? => 02A<M ^* XWV[R -MCH ?;HICG;
GM; @2<G GM2G GM; &;>G;A M2H 3>=O> =@ -M; &FEKJH @A2E?EF;>G 2<GCNCGC;H @=A D=A;
GM2> 2 L;2AR http:www.blogbash.oigsponsois 5><A;?CKFL* 2G F;2HG =>; =@ GM;
KF=BB;AH K;C>B <=>HC?;A;? @=A 2O2A?H 2G %F=B%2HM CH 2 !;@;>?2>G C> GMCH HECG
2>? GM; 2O2A? CH @=A 2> 2GG2<3 => 6F2C>GC@@ 2>? MCH @2DCFL.
1Su. 0n }une 26, XWVX* Befenuant Robeit Stacy NcCain publisheu The
above 7A2>3FC> &;>G;A piess ielease on his blog unuei the heauline, "#TC0T
#BiettKimbeilin #SWATting Impoitant Event 9:Su p.m. ET Tonight!"
http:theotheimccain.com2u12u626tcot-biettkimbeilin-swatting-impoitant-
event-9Su-p-m-et-tonight "G GM; GCD;, Befenuant NcCain A;HC?;? in Naiylanu
anu this post was vieweu in Naiylanu.
1S1. Noie than 1S,uuu iesults come up on uoogle when paiiing "Biett
Kimbeilin with Swatting."
1S2. Befenuant }ames 0'Keefe publisheu a book in }une 2u1S, calleu
"Bieakthiough," which was publisheu by Befenuant Simon & Shustei thiough its
Thiesholu Bivision. In that book, Befenuant 0'Keefe publisheu the following
?;@2D2G=AL HG2G;D;>GHd
"Kimbeilin ueseives his own book. Be's the scaiy uuue who pioneeieu the
ait of 'swatting' - that is convincing the police of a uomestic inciuent seveie
enough to tiiggei a SWAT iesponse at the home of a political opponent. 0f
late, he has focuseu his uemonic eneigy on citizen jouinalists." page 2Su.

That book was solu anu available in Naiylanu. !;@;>?2>G /J';;@; O;>G => 2 K==3
G=EA @=FF=OC>B GM; A;F;2H; =@ GM; K==3 2>? A;I;2G;? MCH ?;@2D2G=AL HG2G;D;>GH
2K=N;R
0.5"
Deleted: iesiues
Color(RGB(6,157,213))
Formatted: Indent: Left: 0", Line spacing:
double

48
1SS. 0n Apiil 8, 2u1S, Befenuant Nichelle Nalkin, who was on the boaiu of
-M; #2GC=>2F %F=BB;AH &FEK, wiote an aiticle foi hei blog implying that Plaintiff
was iesponsible foi swatting conseivative bloggeis:
"Conseivative bloggeis anu activists iallieu behinu the victims of left-wing
convicteu uomestic teiioiist Biett Kimbeilin anu his cabal. A yeai latei, the
suivivois of those SWATting attacks aie still fighting foi theii secuiity anu
fiee speech iights." http:michellemalkin.com2u1Su4u8moie-
celebiities-swat-teu-meanwhile-anti-biett-kimbeilin-bloggeis-still-unuei-
fiie

That blog post was viewable in Naiylanu.

1S4. 0n 0ctobei 1, 2u1S, Befenuant -M=D2H 232 Kimbeililn0nmaskeu
stateu the following on the About page of his blog which is still was viewable in
Naiylanu:
"This blog is foi the puipose of fuithei exposing anu highlighting the sick
pathologies anu actions of Biett Kimbeilin anu his associates, ... This blog is
an attempt to uocument theii actions on behalf of the many people they've
taigeteu anu continue to taiget online anu in peison. The most teiiifying
methouology they've useu against theii iueological foes is SWATting, which
is why many people aie keeping theii heaus uown, hoping that not
mentioning them will make them stop."
http:kimbeilinunmaskeu.blogspot.compabout.html

1SS. !;@;>?2>G -M=D2H 232 'CDK;AFC>:>D2H3;? I=HG;? ME>?A;?H =@
KF=B I=HGH 2>? GM=EH2>?H =@ GO;;GH @A=D Z2>E2AL XWVY GMA=EBM !;<;DK;A
XWV[ ?;@2DC>B* 2GG2<3C>B* KEFFLC>B 2>? M2A2HHC>B 6F2C>GC@@* C><FE?C>B D2>L
GM2G 2<<EH;? 6F2C>GC@@ =@ HO2GGC>B 2>? =GM;A <ACD;HR 8==BF; HEHI;>?;? M;A
KF=BHI=G 2<<=E>G @=A NC=F2GC>B G;ADH =@ H;ANC<; OCGM GM;H; 2GG2<3H 2>? -OCGG;A
HEHI;>?;? GO= =@ M;A 2<<=E>GH @=A GM; H2D; A;2H=>R 1M; D=N;? M;A
'CDK;AFC>:>D2H3;? KF=B =@@HM=A; EHC>B D2H3;? 9CAGE2F 6ACN2G; #;GO=A3H
Deleted:
0.5"
Formatted: Indent: Left: 0.63"
0.13"
0.5"
Color(RGB(59,59,59)), Strikethrough
Formatted: Pattern: Clear
Formatted: Line spacing: single

49
<=>GA=FF;? KL <LK;A <ACDC>2FH* KEG ;N;> CG M2H K;;> A;D=N;? @A=D GM; 5>G;A>;GR
OOOR'CDK;AFC>:>D2H3;?R<=D 1M; D=<3;? GMCH HECG 2>? 6F2C>GC@@JH 2GG;DIGH
G= C?;>GC@L M;A GM=EBM <=EAG =A?;AH C> 2 1G2G; =@ 02ALF2>? F2OHECGR
1S6. 0n }une 26, 2u12, Befenuant Robeit Stacy NcCain, iesiuing in
Naiylanu, wiote an aiticle on viialReau that implieu that Plaintiff swatteu Aaion
Walkei.
"This latest attack follows similai tactics useu against Patiick Fiey anu Eiick
Eiickson aftei they became inteiesteu in the ongoing Kimbeilin saga."
http:www.viialieau.com2u12u626aaion-walkei-swatteu

1S7. 0n }une 12, 2u12, Befenuant Robeit Stacy NcCain, posteu an aiticle
on his blog that imputeu anu stateu that Plaintiff committeu swattings.
0f couise, since the B0} is leu by the coiiupt anu iacist Eiic Boluei, anu the
victims of the Biett Kimbeilin SWATing aie Conseivatives anu the
peipetiatois aie Libeial political activists.
http:theotheimccain.com2u12u6u6sen-saxby-chambliss-iequests-
uoj-investigate-swatting

1S8. 1C><; GM; =ACBC>2F @CFC>B =@ GMCH &=DIF2C>G* !;@;>?2>G 0<&2C> M2H
A;I;2G;?FL ?;@2D;? 2>? 2GG2<3;? 6F2C>GC@@ => MCH KF=B* <2FFC>B MCD NCF;*
HM2D;F;HH* 2>? CDIEGC>B GM2G 6F2C>GC@@ O2H C>N=FN;? OCGM HO2GGC>B K;<2EH;
I;=IF; 6F2C>GC@@ 3>=OH ?CH<EHH;? GM; @CAHG HO2GGC>B NC<GCD 2G H=D; I=C>G C>
GM;CA FCN;HR MGGIdnnGM;=GM;AD<<2C>R<=DnXWV[nWYnWXn3;NC>cQ;;H;c>;2Fc
A2EM2EH;Ac2>?cGM;c=<<EILcC>@CFGA2G=Ac@A2D;cEIn
1S9. 0n }une 8, 2u12, Befenuant Boge, who lives in Naiylanu, wiote a
lettei to a Congiessman in Naiylanu anu imputeu that Plaintiff was involveu with
swattings, that he shoulu be investigateu by the FBI anu sent to piison. Befenuant
0.5"
0.5"
Formatted: Pattern: Clear
Formatted: Indent: Left: 0.63"
0.5"

Su
Boge publisheu that lettei along with a blog post.
http:hogewash.com2u12u6u8national-uay-of-bloggei-silence
14u. 1C><; GM; @CFC>B =@ GM; =ACBC>2F <=DIF2C>G C> GMCH <2H;* !;@;>?2>G
.=B; M2H IEKFCHM;? ME>?A;?H =@ KF=B I=HGH 2>? GO;;GH ?;@2DC>B 6F2C>GC@@ 2>?
2<<EHC>B MCD =@ <ACD; 2@G;A <ACD;R 5> @2<G* GM; D2g=ACGL =@ MCH .=B;O2HMR<=D
KF=B CH ?;?C<2G;? G= 2GG2<3C>B* <LK;A HG2F3C>B 2>? M2A2HHC>B 6F2C>GC@@* MCH @2DCFL
2>? 2>L=>; OM= HEII=AGH 6F2C>GC@@* C><FE?C>B A;I=AG;AH* gE?B;H 2>?
IA=H;<EG=AHR
141. 0n }une 7, 2u12, Befenuant Akbai gave an inteiview to The Examinei
in which he imputeu that Plaintiff was iesponsible foi swattings 2>? M2A2HHC>B
<=>H;AN2GCN; KF=BB;AHR http:www.examinei.comaiticleaclj-to-uefenu-
conseivative-bloggeis-taigeteu-ovei-biett-kimbeilin-coveiage
142. 0n 0ctobei 14, 2u1S, Befenuant Akbai launcheu a new funuiaising
campaign baseu on the false naiiatives that Plaintiff swatteu anu causeu Befenuant
Walkei to lose his job. www.bombeisuesbloggeis.com. When a peison clicks the
B0NATE button, it ieuiiects to the same National Bloggeis Club uonate site that
Befenuant Akbai pieviously useu to iaise money baseu on his false claim that
Plaintiff is a swattei. "Kimbeilin's 2 yeai campaign of haiassment, has leu to
bloggeis losing jobs, thieats of violence, anu police 'SWATTings'.." "G GM; K=GG=D
=@ GM; HCG;JH M=D; I2B;* CG HG2G;H* a#2GC=>2F %F=BB;AH &FEK* 5><R <=ILACBMG XWVYRb
0n the same uay, Befenuant Ali sent tweets to many of the Befenuants in this suit to
gainei theii help in iaising moie money baseu on false naiiatives about Plaintiff.
0.5"
Deleted: .

S1
14S. Nembeis of Befenuant National Bloggeis Club ieau aiticles wiitten by
Befenuants Fiey, Walkei, Ace 0f Spaues, Stianahan, Eiickson, anu NcCain, anu then
publisheu theii own aiticles linking to those aiticles specifically stating that Plaintiff
swatteu conseivative bloggeis. Foi example,
http:www.bob-owens.com2u12u6anothei-conseivative-
bloggei-swatteu-by-leftist-uomestic-teiioiists
http:www.youtube.comwatch.v=T1Suf46AwIN "CNN Biscusses
Biett Kimbeilin Swatting Cases With Eiick Eiickson"
http:newsbusteis.oigblogstom-blumei2u12uS28biett-
kimbeilin-anu-swatting-wheie-establishment-meuia-u
http:neoseculaiist.comtagbiett-kimbeilin-swatting
http:legalinsuiiection.com2u12uSa-biett-kimbeilin-situation-
coulu-happen-to-you
http:ameiicanpoweiblog.blogspot.com2u12uSbiett-kimbeilin-
anu-swatting-wheie-is.html
http:gianitegiok.comblog2u12uSthe-kimbeilin-files-continue-
swatting-the-eiicksons
http:www.usmessageboaiu.compolitics22S8S8-biett-kimbeilin-
stiikes-again-anothei-swatting-attack-against-conseivatives.html
http:patuollaiu.com2u12uSswatting-patteiico-alleges-
campaign-of-teiioi-attempteu-muiuei-by-neal-iauhausei-ion-
biynaeit-anu-biett-kimbeilin

144. Befenuants NcCain, Walkei, Fiey, Stianahan, .=B;* BB Capitol
Stiategies, anu Akbai iaiseu anu continue to iaise money on theii websites baseu on
theii false naiiative about the swattings. They soliciteu those funus in inteistate
commeice thiough the use of the Inteinet, the telephone anu mail. Those funus
weie tiansfeiieu anu ieceiveu thiough inteistate commeice anu placeu in banks
insuieu by the Feueial Beposit Insuiance Coipoiation.
14S. Befenuants' solicitation of funus baseu on the false swatting naiiative
constitutes wiie, mail, anu bank fiauu in inteistate commeice.
0.5"
0.5", Tabs: 0.13", Left + 0.75", Left

S2
146. Befenuant Akbai's solicitation of funus baseu on the false asseition
that Befenuant National Bloggeis Club is a Su1(c)(S) non-piofit anu all uonations to
Befenuant National Bloggeis Club aie tax ueuuctible constitutes fiauu.
147. /> 02A<M p* XWVY* !;@;>?2>G "3K2A GO;;G;? GM; @=FF=OC>Bd
a{%A;GG 'CDK;AFC> IC<3;? 2 @CBMG OCGM ">?A;O %A;CK2AG GM2G O;JA; B=C>B G=
@C>CHMR .;JFF B= G= g2CF GMCH GCD; {%F=B%2HMRb -MCH ?;D=>HGA2G;H GM2G -M;
#2GC=>2F %F=BB;AH &FEK 2>? CGH F;2?;AHMCI O;A; C>G;>G => ?;IACNC>B 6F2C>GC@@ =@
MCH FCK;AGL K2H;? => @2FH; <ACDC>2F <M2AB;HR
148. -M; !;@;>?2>GH ;>B2B;? C> 2 <=><;AG;? <2DI2CB> =@ =>FC>;
?;@2D2GC=>* @2FH; FCBMG* @2FH; >2AA2GCN;H* K2GG;AL* C>GCDC?2GC=>* GMA;2GH* @A2E?*
GM; @CFC>B =@ BA=E>?F;HH <CNCF HECGH 2>? <ACDC>2F <M2AB;H* <LK;A KEFFLC>B 2>?
2<GC>B E>F2O@EFFL* C> =A?;A G= C>G;A@;A; OCGM 6F2C>GC@@JH KEHC>;HH A;F2GC=>HMCIH
2>? MCH IA=HI;<GCN; 2?N2>G2B; K=GM 2H 2> ;DIF=L;; =@ ZEHGC<; -MA=EBM 0EHC<
2>? 2H 2 DEHC<C2>R
149. -M; <=>?E<G =@ GM; !;@;>?2>GH O2H ;_G;>?;?* OC?;HIA;2? 2>?
I2AGC<EF2AFL ?2>B;A=EH K;<2EH; CG =<<EAA;? =N;A 2 I;AC=? =@ L;2AH 2>?
C>N=FN;? H= D2>L NC<GCDH =@ GM; @A2E? OM= O;A; <=>>;? KL GM; !;@;>?2>GHR 5>
@2<G* GM; @A2E? O2H H= OC?;HIA;2? GM2G <=EF? A;HEFG C> <ACDC>2F IA=H;<EGC=>R
/>; O=EF? K; M2A? IA;HH;? G= @C>? 2>=GM;A C>HG2><; C> A;<;>G MCHG=AL OM;A;
2> =>FC>; D=K ;>B2B;? C> 2 DEFGCcL;2A ?;@2D2GC=> <2DI2CB> OMC<M @2FH;FL
2<<EH;? 2 I;AH=> =@ 2 M=AACKF; <ACD; <=DKC>;? OCGM D2HHCN; @A2E? @A=D
GM=EH2>?H =@ NC<GCDHR -MCH <ACDC>2F (>G;AIACH; <=>HGCGEG;H 2 aGMA;2G G= H=<C2F
O;FFcK;C>BRb
0.38"

SS
1Su. -M; !;@;>?2>GHJ <=>?E<G 2>? 2<GCNCGC;H 2@@;<G;? C>G;AHG2G;
<=DD;A<; K;<2EH; GM; @A2E?H* ;_G=AGC=>* =KHGAE<GC=> =@ gEHGC<; 2>? K2GG;AL
<A=HH;? HG2G; FC>;HR -M; !;@;>?2>GH 3>=OC>BFL 2>? C>G;>GC=>2FFL 2BA;;? OCGM
;2<M =GM;A =A 2G F;2HG =>; =GM;A I;AH=> G= <=DDCG 2G F;2HG GO= IA;?C<2G; 2<GHR
5> @2<G* GM; )5&/ !;@;>?2>GH 2FF 3>;O GM2G -M; #2GC=>2F %F=BB;AH &FEK O2H
<=DDCGGC>B @A2E? KL G;FFC>B ?=>=AH GM2G CG O2H 2 \WVT<STYS 2>? GM2G GM;CA
?=>2GC=>H O;A; G2_ ?;?E<GCKF;R
1S1. !;@;>?2>G 02F3C> M2H =N;A ^^W*WWW -OCGG;A @=FF=O;AH 2>? HM; EH;?
M;A -OCGG;A 2<<=E>G 2>? M;A -OCGG;A <=DICF;A* !;@;>?2>G -OCG<ML G= 2DIFC@L
M;A ?;@2D2G=AL HG2G;D;>GH 2K=EG 6F2C>GC@@ K;C>B C>N=FN;? OCGM HO2GGC>BR
"<<=A?C>B G= 2 7;KAE2AL ]* XWV[ 2AGC<F; C> N-&"/"%- 2K=EG !;@;>?2>G 02F3C>*
a-OCGG;A CH 02F3C>JH O;2I=> =@ <M=C<;R %2GGF;H OCGM M;A 2FD=HG 2FO2LH ?;N=FN;
C>G= O2AHs-2E>GC>B kECIH @A=D @=;H KAC>B =EG GM; @EFF @=A<; =@ M;A -OCGG;A
2AH;>2F* OCGM H>2IIL A;IFC;H* <2G<ML M2HMG2BH 2>? GM; D=KCFCQ2GC=> =@ 2 F;BC=>
=@ ;>;ABCQ;? @=FF=O;AHRb
MGGIdnnOOORI=FCGC<=R<=DnHG=ALnXWV[nWXnDC<M;FF;cD2F3C>cXWV[c;F;<GC=>Hc
A;IEKFC<2>HcVWYX][RMGDF
1S2. -M; !;@;>?2>GH* E>?;A GM; F;2?;AHMCI =@ -M; #2GC=>2F %F=BB;AH
&FEK* => OM=H; %=2A? !;@;>?2>G 02F3C> HCGH* M2N; B;>;A2G;? FCG;A2FFL G;>H =@
GM=EH2>?H =@ KF=B I=HGH* GO;;GH 2>? =GM;A 2AGC<F;H @2FH;FL 2<<EHC>B 6F2C>GC@@ =@
HO2GGC>BH 2>? =GM;A <ACD;HR -M;L M2N; EH;? GMCH @2FH; >2AA2GCN; G= ICFF=AL*
M2A2HH* HG2F3* ?;@2D; 2>? =HGA2<CQ; 6F2C>GC@@ C> 2 DEFGCcL;2A <LK;AHG2F3C>B
<2DI2CB>R !;@;>?2>G 02F3C> M2H EH;? M;A <A;?CKCFCGL 2>? BA2NCG2H 2H 2 K=2A?

S4
D;DK;A G= HCB> =@@ => GM; @A2E? KL -M; &FEK* GM;A;KL ?;@A2E?C>B 2 DEFGCGE?;
=@ E>HEHI;<GC>B NC<GCDHR !;@;>?2>G 02F3C> 2>? =GM;A !;@;>?2>GH 3>;O =@ GM;
@A2E?* @2FH; >2AA2GCN;H* 2>? D=>;L F2E>?;AC>B 2>? 2BA;;? OCGM =GM;A
!;@;>?2>GH* C><FE?C>B !;@;>?2>G "3K2A G= I2AGC<CI2G; C> GM; 2@@2CAH =@ GM;
<=>HICA2<LR 5> GMCH <2H;* GM;A; O;A; >=G D;A;FL GO= IA;?C<2G; 2<GH KEG A2GM;A
GM=EH2>?H HC><; ;2<M D=>;L GA2>H2<GC=> OCGM =A KL -M; #2GC=>2F %F=BB;AH
&FEK <=>HGCGEG;? 2 H;I2A2G; 2<G =@ D2CF @A2E?* OCA; @A2E? =A D=>;L F2E>?;AC>BR
1SS. -M; !;@;>?2>GH @2FH; >2AA2GCN;H M2N; M2AD;? 6F2C>GC@@JH KEHC>;HH
A;F2GC=>HMCI 2H 2> ;?E<2G=A OM= @=A GMA;; L;2AH IAC=A G= XWVX O=A3;? OCGM GM;
1G2G; !;I2AGD;>GJH 9#/*1#$/"-#$& `*$4*1+0"5 N1-.1$) G= G;2<M 2<GCNCHGH @A=D
2A=E>? GM; O=AF? M=O G= EH; H=<C2F D;?C2 2>? GM; 2AGH G= ;@@;<GE2G; <M2>B; C>
GM;CA A;HI;<GCN; <=E>GAC;HR 6F2C>GC@@* 2H !CA;<G=A =@ ZEHGC<; -MA=EBM 0EHC<*
M=HG;? 2<GCNCHGH @A=D 5A2>* -EA3;L* '2Q23MHG2>* (BLIG* ,;D;>* +CKL2* 12E?C
"A2KC2* -E>CHC2* %2MA2C>* Z=A?2> 2>? ;FH;OM;A; G= F;2A> 2K=EG H=<C2F D;?C2R
4M;> GM; !;@;>?2>GH F;2A>;? 2K=EG GMCH O=A3* H=D; =@ GM;D <=>G2<G;? GM;
1G2G; !;I2AGD;>G 2>? OA=G; ?;@2D2G=AL 2AGC<F;H 2K=EG GM; O=A3 <=DIF2C>C>B
2K=EG CG 2>? <2FFC>B 6F2C>GC@@ 2 <ACDC>2F 2>? G;AA=ACHG OM= O2H ;?E<2GC>B
2<GCNCHGHR 7=A ;_2DIF;* !;@;>?2>G -M; %F2Q;* <=>GA=FF;? KL !;@;>?2>GH 8F;>>
%;<3 2>? 0;A<EAL )2?C= "AGH* IEKFCHM;? 2> 2AGC<F; GCGF;?* a4ML CH GM; 1G2G;
!;I2AGD;>G 62AG>;AC>B OCGM 1I;;?O2L %=DK;A %A;GG 'CDK;AFC>Rb
MGGIdnnOOORGM;KF2Q;R<=DnHG=AC;HnXWVXnW\nX\nOMLcCHcGM;cHG2G;c?;IGc
I2AG>;AC>BcOCGMcHI;;?O2LcK=DK;AcKA;GGc3CDK;AFC>n !;@;>?2>GH 02F3C> 2>?
-OCG<ML GM;> D2B>C@C;? GM2G 2GG2<3R MGGIdnnGOCG<MLR<=DnXWVXnW\nX\nHG2G;c

SS
?;I2AGD;>GcI2AG>;AC>BcOCGMcI=FCGC<2FcG;AA=ACHGc2>?cK=DK;AcKA;GGc3CDK;AFC>n
">? !;@;>?2>G (AC<3H=> GO;;G;? G= &=>BA;HHD2> !2AALF 5HH2 G= C>N;HGCB2G;
GM; 1G2G; !;I2AGD;>G =N;A CGR 5?R ">? 2H 2 A;HEFG* GM; 1G2G; !;I2AGD;>G >=
F=>B;A KAC>BH GM;H; 2<GCNCHGH G= ZEHGC<; -MA=EBM 0EHC<* 2>? GM; 2<GCNCHGH >=
F=>B;A 3>=O GM2G GM;L M2N; 2> 2?N=<2G; @=A GM;CA <2EH; =@ @A;;?=D 2>?
?;D=<A2<L* 2>? GM;L ?= >=G 3>=O GM2G GM;L <2> A;FL => 6F2C>GC@@ 2>? ZEHGC<;
-MA=EBM 0EHC< G= I=HG GM;CA NC?;=H OM;> GM;CA =O> B=N;A>D;>GH G2AB;G GM;DR
1S4. 6F2C>GC@@ M2? 2 IA=I;AGL C>G;A;HG C> <=>GC>EC>B MCH O=A3 @=A
ZEHGC<; -MA=EBM 0EHC<* OMC<M C><FE?;? L;2AFL GA2C>C>B =@ @=A;CB> 2<GCNCHGHR -M;
!;@;>?2>GH <2EH;? C>gEAL G= 6F2C>GC@@JH KEHC>;HH A;IEG2GC=> 2>? <EHG=D;A
B==?OCFF KL ;>B2BC>B C> GM;CA IA;?C<2G; 2<GH 2>? A2<3;G;;AC>B 2<GCNCGLR
1SS. !;@;>?2>G #2GC=>2F %F=BB;AH &FEK O2H 2 @=AD2F =AB2>CQ2GC=> GM2G
@E><GC=>;? 2H 2 <=>GC>EC>B E>CG OCGM 2 HM2A;? IEAI=H; 2>? C?;>GC@C2KF;
HGAE<GEA;R -M; !;@;>?2>GH =N;A 2 F=>B I;AC=? =@ GCD; IEAHE;? GM; 2 <=DD=>
IEAI=H; =@ ?;@A2E?C>B NC<GCDH C> =A?;A G= ;>AC<M GM;DH;FN;H 2>? M2AD GM;
KEHC>;HH 2>? IA=I;AGL =@ 6F2C>GC@@R -M; !;@;>?2>GH 2FF M2? A;F2GC=>HMCIH*
@AC;>?HMCIH* KEHC>;HH ?;2FC>BH* 2>? GM;L 2FF HM2A;? C> GM; F2AB;HH @A=D GM;
@A2E? GM;L I;AI;GA2G;?* ;CGM;A KL @C>2><C2F ;>AC<MD;>G =A C><A;2H;? 1(/ >
8==BF; 2>? =GM;A HCG;HR 5> HM=AG* GM;L @E><GC=>;? 2H 2 E>CG 2>? GM;L B=G
G=B;GM;A G= @=AD 2H 2 OM=F;* ;N;> OCGM 2 >2D;* 2>? =AB2>CQ2GC=>2F HGAE<GEA;*
<2FF;? -M; #2GC=>2F %F=BB;AH &FEKR
1S6. !;@;>?2>G 7A;L G=F? !;@;>?2>G 42F3;A C> 2> ;D2CF ?2G;?
!;<;DK;A XX* XWVV* GM2G M; O=EF? <2FF g=EA>2FCHG a8F;>> );L>=F?Hb G= G;FF MCD

S6
GM2G 6F2C>GC@@ O2H aGM; BEL OM= HO2GG;? D;Rb ">? 8F;>> );L>=F?H CH => GM;
%=2A? =@ #2GC=>2F %F=BB;AH &FEK* 2>? CH 2FH= GM; I;AH=> OM= I=HG;? 2
GMA;2G;>C>B IM=G= =@ MCDH;F@ OCGM 2 HM=GBE> 2??A;HH;? G= a!;2A %A;GG
'CDK;AFC>Rb -MCH ?;D=>HGA2G;H GM2G GM; !;@;>?2>GH ;>B2B;? C> <=>HICA2<L*
C>GCDC?2GC=>* GMA;2GH* =KHGAE<GC=> =@ gEHGC<;* 2>? NCBCF2>G; 2<GC=> G= M2AD
6F2C>GC@@R
1S7. 0=HG =@ GM; !;@;>?2>GH OM= M2N; GM;CA =O> KF=BH 2>? OM= @2FH;FL
2<<EH;? 6F2C>GC@@ =@ HO2GGC>B* M2N; <=DD;>G H;<GC=>H OM;A; GM;L ;>B2B; OCGM
GM;CA <=DD;>G;AH 2>? GM;L M2N; -OCGG;A 2<<=E>GH GM2G ;>B2B; OCGM GM;CA
@=FF=O;AHR -M;H; !;@;>?2>GH* C><FE?C>B 02F3C>* .=B;* 42F3;A* "<;* -M=D2H*
0<&2C>* "3K2A 2>? 7A;L* ;BB => GM;CA <=DD;>G;AH 2>? 2H3 GM;D G= B;G
C>N=FN;?* I=HG <=DD;>GH 2>? GO;;GH* ?;D2>? GM2G 6F2C>GC@@ K; C>N;HGCB2G;?
2>? C><CG; GM;CA A;2?;AH G= ;>B2B; C> NCBCF2>G; 2<GC=> ?CA;<G;? 2G 6F2C>GC@@ C>
02ALF2>?R
75)1- &+"50 7/) )(+5(7
)"&'(-(() 5#7+:(#&(1 "#! &/)):6- /)8"#5|"-5/#1 "&- :#!()
V] :1& VU^XT<S 2>? V] :1& VU^XT?S
(All Befenuants)
T!;@;>?2>GH "3K2A* 42F3;A* .=B;* 02F3C>* 0<&2C>* %2<3;A* !% &2ICG=F
1GA2G;BC;H* 7A;L* #2BL* 7A2>3FC> &;>G;A* "<; =@ 1I2?;H* 1GA2>2M2>*
-M=D2H* (AC<3H=> 2>? -OCG<MLS

1S8. Plaintiff ie-alleges anu incoipoiates eveiy paiagiaph above.
1S9. Plaintiff's claims unuei the Racketeeiing Influenceu anu Coiiupt
0iganizations Act, 18 0SC 1961-68 ("RIC0") aie biought against all GM;
2K=N; >2D;? Befenuants.

S7
16u. Plaintiff is a peison with stanuing to sue within the meaning of 18 0SC
1964(c).
161. Each of the nameu Befenuants is a "RIC0 peison" within the meaning
of 18 0SC 196S(1).
162. All Befenuants anu unnameu peisons constitute an association-in-
fact, anu theiefoie an enteipiise ("The RIC0 Enteipiise"), within the
meaning of 18 0SC 1961(4).
-M; )5&/ (>G;AIACH;
16S. At all ielevant times fiom Novembei 2u11 thiough Febiuaiy 27. 2u14,
The RIC0 Enteipiise was an ongoing ielationship, business anu ciiminal,
among all GM; >2D;? Befenuants, with the common puipose of cieating
false naiiatives, publishing false naiiatives, using thieats, extoition,
intimiuation, haiassment, assault, K2GG;AL* fiauu, anu misuse of
goveinment agencies to smeai anu haim Plaintiff.
164. At all ielevant times, The RIC0 Enteipiise was engageu in inteistate
commeice in that its activities anu tiansactions ielating to its @A2E?EF;>G
2>? <ACDC>2F activities as ielateu above affecteu inteistate commeice
anu fiequently iequiieu tiavel, communications anu financial
tiansactions acioss state lines.
16S. At all ielevant times, the membeis of The RIC0 Enteipiise functioneu
as a continuing unit.
166. At all ielevant times, GM; >2D;? Befenuants conuucteu oi paiticipate
in, anu conspiieu to conuuct oi paiticipate in, the affaiis of The RIC0
Deleted: the piesent uay

S8
Enteipiise thiough a pattein of numeious acts of iacketeeiing in
violation of 18 0SC 1962(c) anu 1962(u), ielateu by theii common goal to
use false naiiatives about Plaintiff to fiauuulently anu ciiminally iaise,
?;I=HCG 2>? HI;>? funus, inciease ieaueiship, anu sell piouucts anu
seivices.
167. Specifically, GM; >2D;? Befenuants conuucteu oi paiticipateu in anu
agieeu to conspiie to conuuct the affaiis of The RIC0 Enteipiise by
engaging in the following pieuicate acts of iacketeeiing unuei 18 0SC
1961(1):
Nail fiauu to fuithei theii unlawful scheme in violation of 18 0SC
1S41;
Wiie fiauu to fuithei theii unlawful scheme in violation of 18 0SC
1S4S;
0bstiuction of justice to fuithei theii unlawful scheme in violation
of 18 0SC 1SuS;
0bstiuction of ciiminal investigation to fuithei theii unlawful
scheme in violation of 18 0SC 1S1u;
0bstiuction of state anu local law enfoicement to fuithei theii
unlawful scheme in violation of 18 0SC 1S11;
Retaliation against a witness anu victim to fuithei theii unlawful
scheme in violation of 18 0SC V\VX 2>? 1S1S;
Extoition to fuithei theii unlawful scheme in violation of 18 0SC
19S1;
0.5"

S9
Noney launueiing to fuithei theii unlawful scheme in violation of
18 0SC 19S7.
168. -M; >2D;? Befenuants' engagement in the above listeu pieuicate
acts in the conuuct of affaiis of The RIC0 Enteipiise iesulteu in the
inuiviuual financial gain of each Befenuant, thiough actual funus,
auveitising anu incieaseu tiaffic to theii publications, at the expense of
business, piopeity anu peisonal injuiy to Plaintiff.
169. 6F2C>GC@@JH KEHC>;HH C>G;A;HGH O;A; M2AD;? KL GM; 2<GC=>H =@ GM;
>2D;? !;@;>?2>GH 2>? GM; )5&/ (>G;AIACH;R 6F2C>GC@@ M2? 2
aIA=I;AGL C>G;A;HGb C> <=>GC>EC>B MCH ;DIF=LD;>G 2H GM; ?CA;<G=A =@ 2
>=>cIA=@CG GM2G M; M2? O=A3;? 2G @=A GM; IA;NC=EH ;CBMG L;2AHR .;
M2? 2 aIA=I;AGL C>G;A;HGb C> K;C>B 2KF; G= A2CH; @E>?H @=A GM2G
KEHC>;HH G= I2L MCH H2F2AL 2>? GM; =GM;A H2F2AC;H 2>? ;_I;>H;H =@ GM;
KEHC>;HHR ,;G !;@;>?2>GH 2GG;DIG;? 2>? ;>B2B;? C> <=>?E<G
C>G;>?;? G= ?;IACN; 6F2C>GC@@ =@ GM=H; IA=I;AGL C>G;A;HGHR -M;L M2N;
HG2G;? D2>L GCD;H GM2G GM;L O2>G G= ?;HGA=L GM; >=>cIA=@CGH KL
HG=IIC>B GM;CA @E>?C>B 2>? EAB;? =GM;AH G= ?;D2>? GM; H2D;R -MCH
2D=E>GH G= <=>HICA2<L 2>? 2GG;DIG G= M2AD 6F2C>GC@@JH IA=I;AGL
C>G;A;HGHR
6A;?C<2G; "<GH
02CF 7A2E?* V] :1& VY[V
17u. -M; >2D;? Befenuants thiough The RIC0 Enteipiise, soliciteu,
enticeu, peisuaueu, anu inuuceu citizens to senu money thiough the
Deleted:
Deleted: Befenuants thiough

6u
0niteu States Postal Seivice to GM; >2D;? !;@;>?2>GH Befenuants
National Bloggeis Club, Backei, BB Capitol Stiategies, Akbai, NcCain,
Nalkin, Walkei, Fiey, Stianahan anu Boge baseu on the false naiiatives
that Plaintiff was involveu in oi iesponsible foi swattings 2>? <2EH;? GM;
G;ADC>2GC=> =@ !;@;>?2>G 42F3;AR
171. -M; >2D;? Befenuants thiough The RIC0 Enteipiise, soliciteu,
enticeu, peisuaueu, anu inuuceu citizens to senu money thiough the
0niteu States Postal Seivice to Befenuants National Bloggeis Club anu
Akbai baseu on the false statements that Befenuant National Bloggeis
Club is a Su1(c)(S) non-piofit anu that uonations to it weie tax
ueuuctible. In fact, the National Bloggeis Club O2H 2 <ACDC>2F
=AB2>CQ2GC=> GM2G nevei hau Su1(c)(S) status 2>? >;N;A @CF;? 2>L
A;kECA;? KEHC>;HH ?=<ED;>GH 2@G;A CG A;BCHG;A;? 2H 2 -;_2H
<=AI=A2GC=>R
172. -M; >2D;? Befenuants .&(%/*0#, thiough The RIC0 Enteipiise, to
solicit, entice, peisuaue, anu inuuce citizens to senu money thiough the
0niteu States Postal Seivice to GM; >2D;? !;@;>?2>GH Befenuants
National Bloggeis Club, BB Capitol Stiategies, Akbai, NcCain, Walkei,
Fiey, Stianahan anu Boge baseu on the false naiiative that Plaintiff was
involveu in oi iesponsible foi swattings 2>? <2EH;? GM; G;ADC>2GC=> =@
!;@;>?2>G 42F3;A.
17S. -M; >2D;? Befenuants .&(%/*0#, thiough The RIC0 Enteipiise, to
solicit, entice, peisuaue, anu inuuce citizens to senu money thiough the
Deleted: to
Deleted: naiiative
Deleted: .
Deleted: cS
Deleted: .

61
0niteu States Postal Seivice to Befenuants National Bloggeis Club anu
Akbai baseu on the false statements that Befenuant National Bloggeis
Club is a Su1(c)(S) non-piofit anu that uonations to it weie tax
ueuuctible.
174. -M; >2D;? Befenuants thiough The RIC0 Enteipiise willfully,
knowingly anu intentionally committeu anu conspiieu to commit
multiple pieuicate acts of mail fiauu in violation of 18 0SC 1S41, as set
foith in Plaintiff's Fiist Claim foi Relief.
4CA; 7A2E?* V] :1& VY[Y
17S. -M; >2D;? Befenuants thiough The RIC0 Enteipiise, soliciteu,
enticeu, peisuaueu, anu inuuceu citizens to tiansmit money thiough
telecommunications anu wiie anu Inteinet seivices to GM; >2D;?
!;@;>?2>GH Befenuants National Bloggeis Club, Backei, Nalkin, BB
Capitol Stiategies, Akbai, NcCain, Walkei, Fiey, Stianahan anu Boge
baseu on the false naiiative that Plaintiff was involveu in oi iesponsible
foi swattings.
176. -M; >2D;? Befenuants thiough The RIC0 Enteipiise, soliciteu,
enticeu, peisuaueu, anu inuuceu citizens to senu money thiough
telecommunications anu wiie anu Inteinet seivices to Befenuants
National Bloggeis Club anu Akbai baseu on the false statements that
Befenuant National Bloggeis Club is a Su1(c)(S) non-piofit anu that
uonations to it weie tax ueuuctible.
Deleted: cS
Deleted: cS

62
solicit, entice, peisuaue, anu inuuce citizens to senu money thiough
telecommunications anu wiie anu Inteinet seivices to GM; >2D;?
!;@;>?2>GH Befenuants National Bloggeis Club, Backei, BB Capitol
Stiategies, Nalkin, Akbai, NcCain, Walkei, Fiey, Stianahan anu Boge
baseu on the false naiiative that Plaintiff was involveu in oi iesponsible
foi swattings.
solicit, entice, peisuaue, anu inuuce citizens to senu money thiough
telecommunications anu wiie anu Inteinet seivices to Befenuants
National Bloggeis Club anu Akbai baseu on the false statements that
Befenuant National Bloggeis Club is a Su1(c)(S) non-piofit anu that
uonations to it weie tax ueuuctible.
179. -M; >2D;? Befenuants thiough The RIC0 Enteipiise willfully,
knowingly anu intentionally committeu anu conspiieu to commit
multiple pieuicate acts of wiie fiauu in violation of 18 0SC 1S4S, as set
foith in Plaintiff's Fiist Claim foi Relief.
/KHGAE<GC=> =@ ZEHGC<;P V] :1& V\WY* V\VW* V\VV
18u. -M; >2D;? Befenuants thiough The RIC0 Enteipiise coiiuptly anu
by thieats oi foice, anu by communication, influenceu, obstiucteu,
impeueu, anu enueavoieu to influence, obstiuct, oi impeue, the uue
auministiation of justice obstiucteu justice, obstiucteu a ciiminal
investigation anu obstiucteu local, state anu law enfoicement effoits by
Deleted: cS
Deleted: ... [5]
Deleted: obstiucteu justice, obstiucteu
a ciiminal investigation anu obstiucteu
local

6S
falsely accusing Plaintiff of swatting, anu pioviueu false eviuence to the
FBI anu state anu local law enfoicement officials asseiting that Plaintiff
was involveu in the swattings. This false infoimation causeu feueial,
state anu local law enfoicement officials to waste valuable time anu
iesouices chasing false infoimation pioviueu by GM; !;@;>?2>GH C> The
RIC0 Enteipiise.
181. -M; >2D;? Befenuants thiough The RIC0 Enteipiise fuitheieu theii
obstiuction of justice by pioviuing false eviuence anu infoimation about
Plaintiff to 0niteu States Senatois anu Congiess Nembeis with the
knowleuge that saiu false infoimation woulu be pioviueu to the Attoiney
ueneial of the 0niteu States anu to the Feueial Buieau of Investigation.
obstiuction of justice by pioviuing false infoimation to the Nontgomeiy
anu Bowaiu County Naiylanu State's Attoiney baseu on theii false
naiiative that Plaintiff committeu ciiminal acts.
18S. -M; >2D;? Befenuants thiough The RIC0 Enteipiise fuitheieu theii
obstiuction of justice by thieatening Plaintiff anu causing thieats of
injuiy anu ueath to be uiiecteu at Plaintiff in oiuei to intimiuate him fiom
coopeiating with law enfoicement officials anu fiom exeicising his iight
to seek legal ieuiess C> 2 <=EAG =@ F2OR
obstiuction of justice by causing thieats to be maue to the Nontgomeiy
anu Bowaiu County Naiylanu State's Attoineys anu to }uuges Richaiu
Deleted: .

64
}oiuan anu Coinelius vaughey because they iejecteu the false naiiatives
biought to them by GM; !;@;>?2>GH C> The RIC0 Enteipiise.
18S. These willful, knowing anu intentional acts constitute obstiuction of
justice in violation of 18 0SC 1SuS(a). anu obstiuction of a ciiminal
investigation in violation of 18 0SC 1S1u. anu obstiuction of state anu
local law enfoicement in violation of 18 0SC 1S11.
);G2FC2GC=> =@ 2 4CG>;HH 2>? 9C<GCDP V] :1& V\VX 2>? V\VY
186. -M; >2D;? Befenuants thiough The RIC0 Enteipiise have engageu in
a multi-yeai campaign of ietaliation against Plaintiff in oiuei to
intimiuate him fiom being a witness, 2>? G= A;G2FC2G; 2B2C>HG MCD @=A
IA=NC?C>B C>@=AD2GC=> G= F2O ;>@=A<;D;>G =@@C<C2FH A;B2A?C>B
@;?;A2F =@@;>H;H <=DDCGG;? KL =>; =A D=A; =@ GM; !;@;>?2>GHR foi
being a victim. This ietaliation came in the foim of thieats of ueath,
batteiy anu injuiy causeu by false naiiatives cieateu anu publisheu by
Befenuants poitiaying Plaintiff as causing Befenuant Walkei's job
teimination anu swatting conseivative bloggeis. 0thei foims of
ietaliation weie the assault batteiy of Plaintiff by Befenuant Walkei; the
filing of false ciiminal chaiges, peace oiueis anu fiivolous civil suits
against Plaintiff by Befenuants Walkei anu Boge; attempting to extoit a
settlement fiom Plaintiff in exchange foi uismissing a malicious feueial
lawsuit by Befenuants Walkei, %2<3;A anu BB Capitol Stiategies;
publishing uefamatoiy stoiies accusing Plaintiff of swatting; iepeateuly
Deleted: ,
Deleted: ,
Deleted:
Deleted: anu

6S
thieatening Plaintiff with impiisonment baseu on false naiiatives; anu
thieatening Plaintiff's family.
187. !;@;>?2>GH 42F3;A* %2<3;A 2>? !% &2ICG=F 1GA2G;BC;H A;G2FC2G;?
2B2C>HG 6F2C>GC@@ KL G23C>B M2AD@EF 2<GC=> 2B2C>HG 6F2C>GC@@* C><FE?C>B
2GG;DIGC>B G= C>G;A@;A; OCGM 6F2C>GC@@JH F2O@EF ;DIF=LD;>G 2>?
FCN;FCM==? K;<2EH; 6F2C>GC@@ <=>G2<G;? F2O ;>@=A<;D;>G =@@C<C2FH
2K=EG TVS 2> C>G;HG2G; DEA?;A GMA;2G 2B2C>HG 6F2C>GC@@ KL 1;GM "FF;>
GM2G O2H <=DDE>C<2G;? G= !;@;>?2>GH 42F3;A* #2BL* 7A;L 2>?
2>=GM;A I;AH=>* HC><; ?;<;2H;?* TXS GM; 2HH2EFG 2>? K2GG;AL KL
!;@;>?2>G 42F3;A 2B2C>HG 6F2C>GC@@ C> GM; 0=>GB=D;AL &=E>GL
&=EAGM=EH;* TYS GM; @2FH; 2FF;B2GC=>H =@ HO2GGC>B* T[S 2>? GM; <CNCF
ACBMGH NC=F2GC=>H 2B2C>HG 6F2C>GC@@ KL !;@;>?2>G 7A;LR
188. These willful, knowing anu intentional acts constitute ietaliation of a
witness anu a victim in violation =@ V] :1& V\VXT?S 2>? V\VYTKS 2>?
T;SR
189. The Befenuants also engageu in a conspiiacy to thieaten, assault anu
intimiuate Plaintiff anu theiefoie theii conuuct is piohibiteu by 18 0SC
1S12(k).
(_G=AGC=>* &=>HICA2<L 2>? "GG;DIG;? (_G=AGC=>P V] :1& VU\V
19u. -M; >2D;? Befenuants thiough The RIC0 Enteipiise engageu in
extoition by filing a malicious feueial lawsuit against Plaintiff anu two
non-piofits, one of which employs Plaintiff, to limit his Fiist Amenument
iight to ieuiess anu then uemanuing that his employei fiie him anu tuin
Deleted: .
Formatted: Font:Not Bold

66
ovei piotecteu business uocuments in exchange foi a settlement of the
case against the non-piofits.
191. !;@;>?2>GH 42F3;A* %2<3;A 2>? !% &2ICG=F 1GA2G;BC;H ;>B2B;? C>
<=>HICA2<L G= ;_G=AG 2>? 2GG;DIG;? ;_G=AGC=> E>?;A V] :1& VU\VT2S
KL 2BA;;C>B G= EH; GM; @;?;A2F HECG G= B;G 6F2C>GC@@ @CA;?* 2>? GM;>
H;>?C>B 2 F;GG;A ?;D2>?C>B GM2G @CAC>B C> ;_<M2>B; @=A ?CHDCHHC>B 2
D2FC<C=EH F2OHECGR
192. These willful, knowing anu intentional acts constitute extoition in
violation of 18 0SC 19S1.
0=>;L +2E>?;AC>BP V] :1& VU\p
19S. -M; >2D;? Befenuants thiough The RIC0 Enteipiise engageu in
money launueiing by cieating an entity calleu the National Bloggeis Club
anu then falsely poitiaying it as a non-piofit opeiating unuei the
authoiization of the Inteinal Revenue Seivice, Section Su1(c)(S).
Befenuant National Bloggeis Club uiu not apply foi Section Su1(c)(S)
status piioi to stating publicly that the National Bloggeis Club was a
Su1(c)(S) non-piofit. Befenuants thiough The RIC0 Enteipiise posteu
online, thiough a lettei anu thiough woiu of mouth, that uonations maue
to Befenuant National Bloggeis Club weie tax ueuuctible unuei Section
Su1(c)(S). Those uonations, in excess of $1u,uuu, weie funneleu by
vaiious means in inteistate commeice to a bank account contiolleu by
Befenuant Ali Akbai, anu launueieu foi his own puiposes, without any
accounting anu without filing any Section 99u ietuins with the Inteinal
Deleted: Befenuants thiough

67
Revenue Seivice. Befenuant Akbai iefuseu all iequests maue to him anu
Befenuant National Bloggeis Club to pioviue a copy of any Section
Su1(c)(S) ueteimination issueu by the IRS foi the National Bloggeis Club.
Befenuant Akbai iefuseu all iequests maue to him anu the National
Bloggeis Club foi an accounting of the funus he ieceiveu anu uisbuiseu
fiom his false naiiatives about Plaintiff. -M; #2GC=>2F %F=BB;AH &FEK
>;N;A @CF;? 2>L A;kECA;? KEHC>;HH @CFC>BH C> GM; 1G2G; =@ -;_2H 2@G;A
CGH C>CGC2F A;BCHGA2GC=>* 2>? CG <=>GC>E;? G= A2CH; @E>?H ;N;> 2@G;A CGH
<=AI=A2G; ;>GCGL O2H HMEGG;A;? 2>? CGH >2D; @=A@;CG;?R
194. -M; >2D;? Befenuants thiough The RIC0 Enteipiise knew oi hau
ieason to know that Befenuant National Bloggeis Club was not a
Su1(c)(S) non-piofit anu that uonations maue to the National Bloggeis
Club weie not tax ueuuctible, anu that Befenuant Akbai anu the National
Bloggeis Club weie committing fiauu by soliciting anu ieceiving funus
baseu on those fiauuulent iepiesentations anu on Befenuants' false
naiiative that Plaintiff was involveu with swattings.
19S. -M; >2D;? Befenuants thiough The RIC0 Enteipiise engageu in
these monetaiy tiansactions ueiiveu thiough fiauu in a value gieatei
than $1u,uuu in inteistate commeice. These monetaiy tiansactions
incluueu ueposits, withuiawals, tiansfeis anu exchanges to, fiom anu
thiough financial institutions in the 0niteu States.

68
196. These willful, knowing anu intentional acts constitute engaging in
monetaiy tiansactions in piopeity ueiiveu fiom specifieu unlawful
activity in violation of 18 0SC 19S7.
62GG;A> =@ );F2G;? )2<3;G;;AC>B "<GH
197. -M; >2D;? Befenuants engageu in the iacketeeiing activity anu
commission of pieuicate acts as uesciibeu in this Complaint, G2AB;GC>B
6F2C>GC@@ beginning in August 2u1u anu continuing until the piesent time.
198. As set foith above, GM; >2D;? Befenuants have committeu at least
two pieuicate acts of iacketeeiing activities in the past 1u yeais. 5> @2<G*
GM;L M2N; <=DDCGG;? ME>?A;?H =@ IA;?C<2G; 2<GH =@ @A2E? K;<2EH;
;2<M ?=>2GC=> G= -M; #2GC=>2F %F=BB;AH &FEK CH <=>HC?;A;? 2
H;I2A2G; 2<G =@ @A2E?R
199. -M; >2D;? Befenuants implementeu the iacketeeiing acts uesciibeu
in this Complaint as a business mouel foi The RIC0 Enteipiise.
2uu. -M; >2D;? Befenuants' iacketeeiing acts have oi hau similai
puiposes; to piofit fiom the fiauuulent naiiatives about Plaintiff, to piofit
fiom the money launueiing schemes, anu to inciease the value of theii
websites anu meuia opeiations thiough the use of those false naiiatives.
2u1. As set foith above, GM; >2D;? Befenuants' iacketeeiing acts have oi
hau similai paiticipants; some in supeivisoiy ioles such as Befenuants
Fiey anu Akbai, anu otheis in suppoit ioles such as the othei >2D;?
Befenuants.

69
2u2. As set foith above, GM; >2D;? Befenuants, thiough The RIC0
Enteipiise, uiiecteu theii activities at Plaintiff. -M; >2D;? Befenuants
cieateu The RIC0 Enteipiise as a business mouel to iaise funus thiough
fiauuulent means: cieate false naiiatives about Plaintiff such as
swattings, uemonize him with those false naiiatives, falsely poitiay
Plaintiff as victimizing Befenuants anu violating theii iights, bieathlessly
solicit uonations it oiuei to fight Plaintiff, falsely piomise uonois that
theii money will go to a Su1(c)(S) non-piofit, ieceive tens of thousanus in
uonations, launuei that money with no accountability, anu spenu oi
pocket that money while incieasing tiaffic anu value to theii websites
anu meuia sites.
2uS. -M; >2D;? Befenuants' acts have oi hau similai methous of
commission, such as common false naiiatives against Plaintiff, consistent
piactices with iespect to collecting uonations foi a non-existent Su1(c)(S)
non-piofit, anu the use of stonewalling anu lies when askeu foi
tianspaiency anu accountability.
5>gEAL
2u4. As a uiiect anu pioximate iesult of GM; >2D;? Befenuants' willful,
knowing anu intentional IA;?C<2G; acts, as set foith above, Plaintiff has
suffeieu injuiy to his name, piopeity anu businesses, incluuing, but not
limiteu to: having his name falsely associateu with swatting anu othei
ciimes anu false naiiatives; having his employei uefameu baseu on those
false naiiatives; having to spenu untolu houis, uays, weeks, D=>GMH 2>?
Deleted:
Deleted: anu

7u
L;2AH uefenuing against the false naiiatives; having to spenu money
uefenuing against the false naiiatives; losing employment anu funuing
oppoitunities, M2NC>B 2GG;DIG;? C>G;A@;A;><; OCGM MCH KEHC>;HH
A;F2GC=>HMCIH 2>? MCH <=>GA2<G G= A;D2C> ;DIF=L;? KL MCH ;DIF=L;A*
M2NC>B C>G;A@;A;><; OCGM IA=HI;<GCN; KEHC>;HH 2?N2>G2B;* M2NC>B
C>G;A@;A;><; OCGM MCH KEHC>;HH 2H 2 DEHC<C2>* <=DI=H;A 2>?
D2>2B;A, anu othei pecuniaiy anu losses to ieal oi peisonal piopeity.
2uS. Plaintiff is entitleu to an awaiu of uamages in an amount to be
ueteimineu at tiial, incluuing tieble uamages anu othei fees anu costs
associateu with this action.
1(&/#! &+"50 7/) )(+5(7
95/+"-5/# /7 -.( &595+ )58.-1 "&- /7 V]^^* [X :1& VU]Y
T!;@;>?2>G 7A;LS

2u6. Plaintiff-ie-alleges anu incoipoiates eveiy paiagiaph above.
2u7. Plaintiff asseits this claim unuei 42 0SC 198S foi ueclaiatoiy ielief
anu uamages against Befenuant Fiey.
2u8. As set foith above, the actions of Befenuant Fiey -- such as cieating
false naiiatives about Plaintiff committing ciimes, incluuing swattings,
planning =>FC>; gang attacks on Plaintiff baseu on false naiiatives
knowing that such attacks woulu iesult in thieats of injuiy anu ueath,
failing to contact law enfoicement when a peison thieateneu to muiuei
Plaintiff, attempting to get the gioup Anonymous to ietaliate against
Plaintiff 2H 2 kEC? IA= kE=* 2GG;DIGC>B G= M2N; 6F2C>GC@@ 2AA;HG;? =>
@2FH; <M2AB;H* IA=NC?C>B @2FH; C>@=AD2GC=> G= GM; 7%5 2>? +" &=E>GL

71
F2O ;>@=A<;D;>G =@@C<C2FH 2K=EG 6F2C>GC@@* anu uiiecting othei
Befenuants to cieate false naiiatives anu make false ciiminal accusations
against Plaintiff in oiuei to haim him -- weie uone unuei coloi of state
law, specifically as an Assistant Bistiict Attoiney foi Los Angeles,
Califoinia, with the knowleuge anu peimission of his supeivisois in the
Los Angeles Bistiict Attoiney's 0ffice.
2u9. Befenuant Fiey knowingly, willfully, maliciously, intentionally anu
without legal justification planneu anu acteu to uepiive Plaintiff of his
civil anu constitutional iights.
21u. Befenuant Fiey knowingly, willfully, maliciously, intentionally anu
without legal justification acteu to uepiive Plaintiff of his civil iights.
211. As a iesult of the unlawful acts of Befenuant Fiey, Plaintiff suffeieu
uamages.
212. Plaintiff seeks all appiopiiate ielief, incluuing ueclaiatoiy, fees, costs,
anu uamages, incluuing compensatoiy anu punitive, in an amount to be
ueteimineu at tiial.
-.5)! &+"50 7/) )(+5(7
95/+"-5/#1 /7 -.( ': '+:} '+"# "&- /7 V]pV* [X :1& VU]\
T!;@;>?2>GH 42F3;A* .=B;* 0<&2C>* "3K2A* (AC<3H=>* 02F3C>* %2<3;A* -M=D2H*
%;<3* "<; =@ 1I2?;H* 1GA2>2M2>* #2BL* 2>? !% &2ICG=F 1GA2G;BC;HS

21S. Plaintiff-ie-alleges anu incoipoiates eveiy paiagiaph above.
214. Plaintiff asseits this claim puisuant to 42 0SC 198S(2) anu (S) foi
ueclaiatoiy ielief, anu uamages against GM; >2D;? Befenuants.
21S. As set foith above, GM; >2D;? Befenuants conspiieu, agieeu, planneu
anu cooiuinateu with Befenuant Fiey, acting unuei coloi of law, foi the

72
puipose of uepiiving Plaintiff of his constitutional anu civil iights,
incluuing his Fiist Amenument iight to seek ieuiess fiom the couits, his
Fifth Amenument iight to uue piocess, his constitutional iight to piivacy,
his Fiist Amenument iight to speech, MCH @E>?2D;>G2F ACBMG G= FCK;AGL*
anu his oveiaiching iight be safe in his eveiyuay activities.
216. -M; >2D;? Befenuants conspiieu to uetei Plaintiff, by foice,
intimiuation, oi thieat, fiom attenuing couit, oi fiom testifying to any
mattei penuing theiein, fieely, fully, anu tiuthfully, anu to injuie Plaintiff
in his peison oi piopeity on account of his having so attenueu oi testifieu.
217. -M; >2D;? !;@;>?2>GH <=>HICA;? G= ?;IACN; 6F2C>GC@@ =@ MCH ACBMG
G= A;?A;HH KL =>FC>; B2>B 2<GCNCGL* GMA;2GH* C>GCDC?2GC=>* <LK;A
KEFFLC>B* 2GG2<3H 2B2C>HG MCH @2DCFL* @2FH; >2AA2GCN;H* 2>? K2GG;ALR
218. -M; >2D;? Befenuants knowingly, willfully, maliciously,
intentionally, anu without justification planneu anu acteu to uepiive
Plaintiff of his iights.
219. As a iesult of the unlawful acts of GM; >2D;? Befenuants' conspiiacy
to violate his iights, Plaintiff has suffeieu uamages.
22u. Plaintiff seeks all appiopiiate ielief, incluuing ueclaiatoiy, fees, costs,
anu uamages, incluuing compensatoiy anu punitive, in an amount to be
ueteimineu at tiial.
7/:)-. &+"50 7/) )(+5(7
7)":! "#! #(8+58(#- 051)(6)(1(#-"-5/#

221. Plaintiff ie-alleges anu incoipoiates eveiy paiagiaph above.
Deleted:

7S
222. As set foith above, Befenuants maue mateiially false anu untiue
statements anu iepiesentations iegaiuing Plaintiff's involvement in
swattings, anu iegaiuing the Su1(c)(S) status of Befenuant National
Bloggeis Club.
22S. As set foith above, Befenuants knowingly oi negligently faileu to
uisclose mateiial anu tiuthful facts iegaiuing the swattings anu the
Su1(c)(S) status of Befenuant National Bloggeis Club.
224. Befenuants intenueu that theii false statements woulu inuuce otheis
to believe theii false naiiatives anu woulu inuuce them to senu money to
Befenuant National Bloggeis Club.
22S. Nany people ielieu on Befenuants' fiauuulent iepiesentations anu
uonateu moie than $1u,uuu to Befenuant National Bloggeis Club,
incluuing many who uiu so believing that they woulu get a tax ueuuction
foi theii uonation.
226. Nany people ielieu on Befenuants' fiauuulent iepiesentations about
swattings, anu then wiote blog posts anu aiticles baseu on those false
iepiesentations uefaming Plaintiff as being involveu with the swattings.
227. Befenuants fuithei maue false iepiesentations anuoi omissions with
the intent of obtaining favoiable meuia exposuie foi theii false
iepiesentations, piessuiing the 0niteu States Congiess anu FBI to
investigate Plaintiff, anu to haim Plaintiff.

74
228. As a uiiect, pioximate anu foieseeable iesult of Befenuants' knowing,
willing, intentional anuoi negligent actions, Plaintiff has been injuieu,
incluuing significant pecuniaiy, ieputational, anu othei uamages.
229. Plaintiff is entitleu to iecovei compensatoiy anu punitive uamages in
an amount pioven at tiial.
7/:)-. &+"50 7/) )(+5(7
!(7"0"-5/#
T"3K2A* 42F3;A* .=B;* -M=D2H* #2GC=>2F %F=BB;AH &FEK* 0<&2C>* "D;AC<2>
1I;<G2G=A* /J';;@;* 1CD=>j1<MEHG;AS

2Su. Plaintiff ie-alleges anu incoipoiates eveiy paiagiaph above.
2S1. /N;A GM; I2HG L;2A* GM; >2D;? Befenuants have intentionally,
knowingly anuoi iecklessly publisheu, A;IEKFCHM;? anu uisseminateu
the false anu uefamatoiy statements iuentifieu above iegaiuing swattings
2>? =GM;A D2GG;AH on the Inteinet, on television, on iauio anu in piint
wheie they have been easily accessible, anu weie accesseu my many
people, incluuing Plaintiff's family, chiluien, fiienus, business associates
anu actual anu piospective paitneis, clients anu otheis.
2S2. -M; >2D;? Befenuants' uefamatoiy statements iegaiuing Plaintiff's
involvement in swattings anu othei matteis have causeu anu continue to
cause substantial injuiy to Plaintiff, his business anu peisonal well-being.
2SS. The statements have causeu anu continue to cause ueep
embaiiassment, humiliation, oppiobiium, emotional uistiess anu mental
suffeiing to Plaintiff.
2S4. -M; >2D;? Befenuants' false anu uefamatoiy statements anu the
implications uiawn fiom them conceining Plaintiff aie uefamatoiy /#0 %#
Deleted: 757-.

7S
because they allege ciimes anu make Plaintiff appeai ouious, infamous,
anuoi fiightening.
2SS. Befenuants publisheu these false anu uefamatoiy statements to thiiu
paities who ieasonably unueistoou the publisheu statements to be
uefamatoiy.
2S6. -M; >2D;? Befenuants weie awaie of the uefamatoiy implication of
theii statements about Plaintiff, anu intenueu anu enuoiseu the
uefamatoiy implication.
2S7. -M; >2D;? Befenuants publisheu these false anu uefamatoiy
statements about Plaintiff even though they knew that they weie not
baseu on fact oi tiuth.
2S8. -M; >2D;? !;@;>?2>GH IEKFCHM;? GM; ?;@2D2G=AL HG2G;D;>GH
OCGM=EG <=>?E<GC>B 2>L ?E; ?CFCB;><; =A <=>G2<GC>B 6F2C>GC@@ G=
?;G;ADC>; C@ GM;L O;A; C> @2<G GAE;R
2S9. -M; >2D;? Befenuants publisheu these false anu uefamatoiy
statements about Plaintiff with knowleuge of theii falsity anuoi ieckless
uisiegaiu foi theii tiuth.
24u. Alteinatively, GM; >2D;? Befenuants publisheu these false anu
uefamatoiy statements about Plaintiff negligently as the tiuth oi falsity of
what they weie saying.
241. Each of the >2D;? Befenuants was uiiectly involveu anu iesponsible
foi the false anu uefamatoiy statements that weie publisheu about
Plaintiff.

76
242. -M; >2D;? Befenuants publisheu these false anu uefamatoiy
statements with both common law anu actual malice, anu with the intent
of haiming Plaintiff.
24S. 02>L =@ GM; >2D;? Befenuants publisheu these false anu uefamatoiy
statements uay aftei uay, week aftei week, month aftei month anu yeai
aftei yeai with the attacks K;C>B <==A?C>2G;?* 2BBA;HHCN; 2>?
HEHG2C>;? G= <2EH; D2_CDED M2AD G= 6F2C>GC@@R becoming moie
cooiuinateu, aggiessive anu nastiei as time piogiesseu.
244. -M; >2D;? Befenuants' uefamatoiy statements weie iepeateu anu
iepublisheu by othei meuia anu bloggeis, theieby compounuing the haim
to Plaintiff.
24S. None of the />FL =>; =@ GM; !;@;>?2>GH* -M; 7A2>3FC> &;>G;A, has
ietiacteu 2>L =@ theii uefamatoiy statements oi iemoveu them fiom
theii websites, blogs oi meuia outlets, ?;HICG; 6F2C>GC@@JH A;kE;HGH G= ?=
H=R !;@;>?2>G !% &2ICG=F 1GA2G;BC;H ?C? D23; GM;CA ?;@2D2G=AL
IEKFC<2GC=>H I2HHO=A? IA=G;<G;?R
246. -M; >2D;? Befenuants also publisheu these uefamatoiy anu false
statements in oiuei to inciease tiaffic to theii blogs anu to iaise money
fiom unsuspecting ieaueis who believeu theii statements.
247. -M; >2D;? Befenuants' false anu uefamatoiy statements have
causeu Plaintiff to sustain uamages.
Deleted:
Deleted: .

77
248. -M; >2D;? Befenuants' actions against Plaintiff weie willful, wanton
anu malicious, weie intenueu to uelibeiately haim Plaintiff, anu weie
maue with a callous inuiffeience to Plaintiff.
249. Thus, in publishing the numeious false anu uefamatoiy statements
about Plaintiff, GM; >2D;? Befenuants acteu with an impiopei anu
outiageous motive oi callous inuiffeience to Plaintiff's iights anu
inteiests. As a iesult of GM; >2D;? Befenuants' outiageous anu iepeateu
conuuct, Befenuants shoulu be oiueieu to pay substantial compensatoiy
anu punitive uamages.

15}-. 757-. &+"50 7/) )(+5(7
7"+1( +58.- 5#9"15/# /7 6)59"&,
T42F3;A* "3K2A* .=B;* 0<&2C>* (AC<3H=>* 02F3C>* -OCG<ML* );?HG2G;*
%;<3* -M=D2H* /J';;@;* 1CD=>j1<MEHG;A* -M; %F2Q;* -M; "D;AC<2>
1I;<G2G=A* "<; =@ 1I2?;H* 0;A<EAL )2?C= "AGH* 7A;L* 1GA2>2M2>* #2BL*
%A;CGK2AGR<=D* %2<3;A* !% &2ICG=F 1GA2G;BC;H* -M; 7A2>3FC> &;>G;A*
#2GC=>2F %F=BB;AH &FEKS

2Su. Plaintiff ie-alleges anu incoipoiates eveiy paiagiaph above.
2S1. -M; >2D;? Befenuants' statements, book, webinai anu aiticles above
containeu false statements, iepiesentations oi imputations about Plaintiff
that place him K;@=A; GM; IEKFC< in a false light.

78
2S2. As stateu above, GM; >2D;? Befenuants poitiayeu Plaintiff as being
involveu with swatting, a seiious ciime, 2>? <2EHC>B !;@;>?2>G
42F3;AJH G;ADC>2GC=>R
2SS. The false light in which GM; >2D;? Befenuants placeu Plaintiff woulu
be consiueieu highly offensive to a ieasonable peison.
2S4. -M; >2D;? Befenuants weie each complicit in anu iesponsible foi
casting Plaintiff in a false light anu violating his piivacy.
2SS. -M; >2D;? Befenuants uisseminateu theii aiticles on the Inteinet,
television, iauio anu in piint wheie they weie wiuely available to anu
accessible by membeis of the geneial public acioss the globe.
2S6. -M; !;@;>?2>GH ;>B2B;? C> =EGA2B;=EH 2>? ;_GA;D; <=>?E<G KL
@2FH;FL IEKFCHMC>B GM; ?;@2D2G=AL HG2G;D;>GH 2<<EHC>B MCD =@ <ACD;H
2>? >;@2AC=EH <=>?E<G* ?;D2>?C>B GM2G M; K; C>N;HGCB2G;?* 2AA;HG;?
2>? CDIACH=>;? @=A HO2GGC>BH* IEKFCHMC>B G;>H =@ GM=EH2>?H =@
GO;;GH 2>? KF=B I=HGH HD;2AC>B 6F2C>GC@@ 2>? 2<<EHC>B MCD =@ <ACD;H*
@CFC>B GMA;; @ACN=F=EH 2>? D2FC<C=EH F2OHECGH 2B2C>HG MCD* H;>?C>B 2
?;@2D2G=AL F;GG;A G= 2> C>HGCGEGC=>2F @E>?;A @2FH;FL 2<<EHC>B MCD =@
<ACD;H* 2GG;DIGC>B G= ;_G=AG MCH ;DIF=L;A C>G= @CAC>B MCD* A2FFLC>B
;_GA;DCHGH OCGM @2FH; >2AA2GCN;H G= 2GG2<3 MCD* @CFC>B @=A H2><GC=>H C>
GM; 2D=E>G =@ G;>H =@ GM=EH2>?H =@ ?=FF2AH 2>? CDIACH=>D;>G* 2>?
2H3C>B 2 @;?;A2F <=EAG G= ?;>L MCD 2<<;HH G= GM; <=EAGHR -MCH
2KM=AA;>G <=>?E<G M2H 3;IG 6F2C>GC@@ E>?;A HC;B; @=A L;2AH* 2>?
<2EH;? ;_GA;DCHGH G= <=D; G= MCH M=D;* G23; IC<GEA;H =@ MCD 2>? MCH
Deleted: .

79
?2EBMG;A* 2>? D23; GMA;2G;>C>B <2FFH G= MCD* MCH @2DCFL 2>? MCH
>;CBMK=AHR #= I;AH=> C> 2 <CNCFCQ;? H=<C;GL HM=EF? K; D2?; G= ;>?EA;
HE<M <=>?E<GR
2S7. 0=A;=N;A* !;@;>?2>GH <=>HICA;? OCGM GM; =GM;A !;@;>?2>GH G=
CDIACH=> 6F2C>GC@@ K2H;? => GM;CA @2FH; >2AA2GCN;H GM2G 6F2C>GC@@ O2H
C>N=FN;? OCGM HO2GGC>BHR -MCH <=>HGCGEG;H ;_GA;D;FL =EGA2B;=EH
<=>?E<G GM2G C>G;>GC=>2FFL C>@FC<G;? ;D=GC=>2F ?CHGA;HH => 6F2C>GC@@R
-M;A; 2A; >=G D2>L GMC>BH C> GMCH <=E>GAL O=AH; GM2> K;C>B @2FH;FL
2<<EH;? =@ <ACD;H 2>? GM;> M2NC>B GM=H; @2FH; 2<<EH2GC=>H C><CG; 2
FL><M D=K G= 2GG2<3 A;F;>GF;HHFL 2>? ?2CFL OCGM G;>H =@ GM=EH2>?H =@
GO;;GH 2>? I=HGH 2>? 2AGC<F;H* 2>? HG2F3;AH =N;A 2 I;AC=? =@ L;2AHR
-MCH CH 2GA=<C=EH 2>? M2H 2KH=FEG;FL >= IF2<; C> 2 <CNCFCQ;? H=<C;GLR
2S8. #=G 2 ?2L B=;H KL OM;A; 6F2C>GC@@ CH >=G 2GG2<3;?* =>FC>; =A C>
I;AH=>* KL =>; =A D=A; =@ GM; !;@;>?2>GHR !;@;>?2>G 42F3;A <2D;
G= 2 <=EAG M;2AC>B C> 0=>GB=D;AL &=E>GL &CA<ECG &=EAG 2>?* 2@G;A GM;
IA=<;;?C>B G= OMC<M M; O2H >=G 2 I2AGL* @=FF=O;? 6F2C>GC@@ =EG =@ GM;
<=EAGA==D 2>? K2GG;A;? MCD H= H;N;A;FL M; ;>?;? EI C> GM;
(D;AB;><L )==D 2G 1EKEAK2> .=HICG2FR -MCH A;HEFG;? C> ?2LH =@@ =@
O=A3 2>? 2 @;2A GM2G !;@;>?2>GH OCFF 2B2C> 2HH2EFG 6F2C>GC@@ =A MCH
@2DCFLR !;@;>?2>GH 42F3;A* .=B;* 0<&2C> 2>? "FC M2N; HG2F3;?
6F2C>GC@@ C> IEKFC< IF2<;HR !;@;>?2>GH 42F3;A* .=B; 2>? !% &2ICG=F
1GA2G;BC;H M2N; @CF;? >ED;A=EH @2FH; <ACDC>2F 2>? <CNCF 2<GC=>H
2B2C>HG 6F2C>GC@@ =N;A 2 GO=cL;2A I;AC=?* 2FF OMC<M M2N; K;;>

8u
?CHDCHH;? =A ?;>C;?R !;@;>?2>GH .=B;* 42F3;A 2>? H=D; =@ GM;
=GM;A !;@;>?2>GH IEKFCHM ?2CFL G2E>GH 2B2C>HG 6F2C>GC@@ 2>? D=<3 GMCH
HECG OCGM ?2CFL I=HGH => GM;CA KF=BH* 2>? <=>GC>E2FFL 2HH;AG GM2G GM;L
2A; B=C>B G= B;G 6F2C>GC@@ CDIACH=>;?R -M;L M2N; 2GG2<3;? 6F2C>GC@@JH
;DIF=L;A 2>? GM=H; OM= ?=>2G; G= GM2G >=>cIA=@CGR -M; !;@;>?2>GH
M2N; GAC;? G= B;G 6F2C>GC@@ @CA;?R -M;L M2N; 2GG2<3;? 6F2C>GC@@JH OC@;
2>? G;;>2B; ?2EBMG;A 2>? ;N;> A;I=AG;AH OM= M2N; OACGG;>
@2N=A2KFL 2K=EG 6F2C>GC@@R -M;L M2N; ;N;> 2GG2<3;? IA=H;<EG=AH OM=
M2N; A;@EH;? GM;CA @ACN=F=EH <M2AB;H* !;@;>?2>G 42F3;A M2H ;N;>
CDIEG;? C> 2 A;<;>G KF=B I=HG GM2G 6F2C>GC@@JH G;;>2B; ?2EBMG;A CH @2CA
B2D; @=A ?;HGAE<GC=> K;<2EH; =@ a<=AAEIGC=> =@ KF==?Rb
2S9. "FF =@ GMCH M2H K;;> C>G;>?;? G= C>@FC<G D2_CDED ;D=GC=>2F
?CHGA;HH => 6F2C>GC@@R 6F2C>GC@@ M2H M2? G= C>HG2FF A=KEHG H;<EACGL
?;NC<;H 2>? NC?;= <2D;A2H 2G MCH M=D; 2>? =@@C<;* 2>? G23;
IA;<2EGC=>H @=A MCH @2DCFL GM2G >= L=E>B <MCF? HM=EF? M2N; G= K;
HEKg;<G;? G=* 2FF K;<2EH; GM; !;@;>?2>GH M2N; <A;2G;? 2 FL><M D=K
K2H;? => @2FH; >2AA2GCN;H G= G;AA=ACQ; 6F2C>GC@@ 2>? MCH @2DCFL => 2
<=>GC>E=EH DEFGCcL;2A K2HCHR -MCH <F;2AFL ?;D=>HGA2G;H GM2G GM;
!;@;>?2>GH* C>G;>GC=>2FFL <2HG;? 6F2C>GC@@ C> @2FH; FCBMGR
26u. -M; >2D;? Befenuants knew that theii actions anu statements hau
the effect of casting Plaintiff in a false light but neveitheless continueu to
uo so week aftei week, aiticle aftei aiticle anu tweet aftei tweet. -M;L

81
M2? 3>=OF;?B; =@ =A 2<G;? OCGM A;<3F;HH ?CHA;B2A? 2H G= GM; @2FHCGL =@
GM; IEKFC<CQ;? D2GG;A 2>? GM; @2FH; FCBMG C> OMC<M CG IF2<;? 6F2C>GC@@R
261. -M; >2D;? !;@;>?2>GH IEKFCHM;? GM; ?;@2D2G=AL HG2G;D;>GH
OCGM=EG <=>?E<GC>B 2>L ?E; ?CFCB;><; =A <=>G2<GC>B 6F2C>GC@@ G=
?;G;ADC>; C@ GM;L O;A; C> @2<G GAE;R
262. Alteinatively* GM; >2D;? Befenuants weie negligent in the
publication of theii statements about Plaintiff, the effect of which was to
poitiay Plaintiff in a false light.
26S. -M; >2D;? Befenuants' poitiayal of Plaintiff in a false light, as stateu
above, causeu substantial injuiy to Plaintiff's ieputation, business
inteiests, anu mental well-being.
264. -M; >2D;? Befenuants' placing Plaintiff in a false light has causeu
Plaintiff to sustain substantial uamages.
26S. -M; >2D;? Befenuants' actions against Plaintiff weie willful, wanton
anu malicious, anu weie intenueu to uelibeiately haim Plaintiff.
266. Thus, GM; >2D;? Befenuants acteu with an impiopei anu outiageous
motive oi caieless inuiffeience to Plaintiff's iights anu inteiests.
Befenuants' outiageous conuuct waiiants the imposition of significant
compensatoiy anu punitive uamages.
15}-. &+"50 7/) )(+5(7
5#-()7()(#&( 45-. %:15#(11 )(+"-5/#1
T!% &2ICG=F 1GA2G;BC;H* %2<3;A* 42F3;A* #2GC=>2F %F=BB;AH &FEKS

267. 6F2C>GC@@ A;c2FF;B;H 2>? C><=AI=A2G;H ;N;AL I2A2BA2IM 2K=N;R
Deleted: 1(9(#-.
Deleted: 5#-(#-5/#"+ 5#7+5&-5/#
/7 (0/-5/#"+ !51-)(11

82
268. !;@;>?2>GH !% &2ICG=F* %2<3;A* 42F3;A 2>? #2GC=>2F %F=BB;AH
&FEK D2FC<C=EHFL 2>? OA=>B@EFFL C>G;A@;AC>B OCGM 6F2C>GC@@JH
;<=>=DC<* =A IA=HI;<GCN;* A;F2GC=>HMCIHR 1I;<C@C<2FFL* 6F2C>GC@@ M2H
O=A3;? 2H ?CA;<G=A =@ ZEHGC<; -MA=EBM 0EHC< @=A G;> L;2AH 2>? M2H 2>
2BA;;D;>G G= <=>GC>E; GM2G O=A3R -M; >2D;? !;@;>?2>GH 3>=O =@
GM; ;_CHG;><; =@ GM2G ;DIF=LD;>G A;F2GC=>HMCI 2>? GM;L
C>G;>GC=>2FFL 2GG;DIG;? G= C>G;A@;A; OCGM CG KL D23C>B @2FH; <F2CDH
2B2C>HG 6F2C>GC@@ 2<<EHC>B MCD =@ <ACD;H* H;>?C>B 2 ?;@2D2G=AL F;GG;A
G= 2 D2g=A @E>?;A* @CFC>B 2>?n=A IA=D=GC>B 2 D2FC<C=EH F2OHECG
2B2C>HG 6F2C>GC@@ 2>? MCH ;DIF=L;A C> =A?;A G= EH; GM2G F2OHECG G=
@=A<; 6F2C>GC@@JH ;DIF=LD;>G G;ADC>2GC=>R
269. !;@;>?2>GH @EAGM;A <=>G2<G;? 2 D2g=A C>HGCGEGC=>2F @E>?;A =@
6F2C>GC@@JH >=>cIA=@CG ;DIF=L;A 2>? @2FH;FL H2C? GM2G 6F2C>GC@@ O2H
C>N=FN;? OCGM <ACD;H* OMC<M <2EH;? GM2G @E>?;A G= HG=I @E>?C>B
6F2C>GC@@JH ;DIF=L;AR -M; >2D;? !;@;>?2>GH 2>? =GM;A E>>2D;?
!;@;>?2>GH M2N; HG2G;? GM2G GM;CA B=2F O2H G= @=A<; =AB2>CQ2GC=>H
2>? =GM;AH G= HG=I @E>?C>B 6F2C>GC@@JH >=>cIA=@CG ;DIF=L;AR -M;L
M2N; KA2BB;? GM2G GM;L M2N; HE<<;;?;? C> HG=IIC>B GM2G @E>?C>BR
27u. 6F2C>GC@@ M2H K;;> ?2D2B;? KL GM; >2D;? !;@;>?2>GHJ D2FC<C=EH
2<GC=>HR " <2EH; =@ 2<GC=> @=A G=AGC=EH C>G;A@;A;><; OCGM 2> ;_CHGC>B
<=>GA2<G CH K2H;? => 02ALF2>? F2OR

8S
271. -M; >2D;? !;@;>?2>GHJ 2<GC=>H 2B2C>HG 6F2C>GC@@ O;A; OCFF@EF*
O2>G=> 2>? D2FC<C=EH* 2>? O;A; C>G;>?;? G= ?;FCK;A2G;FL M2AD
6F2C>GC@@R
272. -MEH* GM; >2D;? !;@;>?2>GH 2<G;? OCGM 2> CDIA=I;A 2>?
=EGA2B;=EH D=GCN; =A <2A;F;HH C>?C@@;A;><; G= 6F2C>GC@@JH ACBMGH 2>?
C>G;A;HGHR -M; >2D;? !;@;>?2>GHJ =EGA2B;=EH <=>?E<G O2AA2>GH GM;
CDI=HCGC=> =@ HCB>C@C<2>G <=DI;>H2G=AL 2>? IE>CGCN; ?2D2B;HR

1(9(#-. &+"50 7/) )(+5(7
5#-()7()(#&( 45-. 6)/16(&-59( (&/#/05& "!9"#-"8(
T"FF !;@;>?2>GHS

27S. 6F2C>GC@@ A;c2FF;B;H 2>? C><=AI=A2G;H ;N;AL I2A2BA2IM 2K=N;R
274. !;@;>?2>GH* C>G;>GC=>2FFL 2>? OCFF@EFFL ;>B2B;? C> 2 <=><;AG;?
<2DI2CB> =@ =>FC>; ?;@2D2GC=>* @2FH; FCBMG* @2FH; >2AA2GCN;H* K2GG;AL*
C>GCDC?2GC=>* GMA;2GH* @A2E?* GM; @CFC>B =@ BA=E>?F;HH <CNCF HECGH 2>?
<ACDC>2F <M2AB;H* <LK;A KEFFLC>B 2>? 2<GC>B E>F2O@EFFL* C> =A?;A G=
<2EH; ?2D2B; G= 6F2C>GC@@ C> MCH F2O@EF KEHC>;HH;H* K=GM 2H 2>
;DIF=L;; =@ ZEHGC<; -A=EBM 0EHC< 2>? 2H 2 DEHC<C2>R
27S. !;@;>?2>GH 3>;O GM2G 6F2C>GC@@ O2H ;>B2B;? C> KEHC>;HH 2>?
;>B2B;? C> <=>?E<G G= ?CHAEIG GM2G KEHC>;HH 2>? ?;IACN; 6F2C>GC@@ =@
@EGEA; KEHC>;HH 2>? GM;L ?C?R
276. -M;H; 2<GC=>H KL !;@;>?2>GH O;A; ?=>; OCGM D2FC<; C> =A?;A G=
<2EH; 2<GE2F ?2D2B;H 2>? F=HH G= 6F2C>GC@@JR
277. 6F2C>GC@@ M2H HE@@;A;? 2<GE2F ?2D2B; 2>? F=HHR

84
278. -MEH* GM; !;@;>?2>GH 2<G;? OCGM 2> CDIA=I;A 2>? =EGA2B;=EH
D=GCN; =A <2A;F;HH C>?C@@;A;><; G= 6F2C>GC@@JH ACBMGH 2>? C>G;A;HGHR
!;@;>?2>GHJ =EGA2B;=EH <=>?E<G O2AA2>GH GM; CDI=HCGC=> =@
HCB>C@C<2>G <=DI;>H2G=AL 2>? IE>CGCN; ?2D2B;HR
1(9(#-. &+"50 7/) )(+5(7
%"--(),
T!;@;>?2>G 42F3;AS

279. 6F2C>GC@@ A;c2FF;B;H 2>? C><=AI=A2G;H ;N;AL I2A2BA2IM 2K=N;R
28u. /> Z2>E2AL ^* XWVX* !;@;>?2>G 42F3;A E>F2O@EFFL EH;? @=A<;
2B2C>HG 6F2C>GC@@ GM2G A;HEFG;? C> GM; =@@;>HCN; G=E<MC>B =@ 6F2C>GC@@ G=
HE<M 2 ?;BA;; GM2G 6F2C>GC@@ O2H A;@;AA;? G= GM; (D;AB;><L )==D 2G
1EKEAK2> .=HICG2F @=A ;N2FE2GC=> 2>? GA;2GD;>G @=A <=><EHHC=>*
<=>GEHC=> =@ GM; ;L;* K2<3 I2C>R 6F2C>GC@@ O2H ;N2FE2G;? GM;A; 2>?
IA;H<ACK;? D;?C<C>; 2>? =A?;A;? G= A;HG @=A H;N;A2F ?2LHR
281. -MCH K2GG;AL =@ 6F2C>GC@@ KL !;@;>?2>G 42F3;A O2H C>G;>GC=>2F 2>?
D2FC<C=EH* 2>? ?=>; C> =A?;A G= M2AD 6F2C>GC@@* C>GCDC?2G; MCD 2>?
A;G2FC2G; 2B2C>HG MCD @=A ;_;A<CHC>B MCH ACBMG G= A;?A;HH 2>? 2<<;HH G=
GM; <=EAGR
282. 6F2C>GC@@ M2H HE@@;A;? 2<GE2F ?2D2B; 2>? F=HHR
28S. -MEH* !;@;>?2>G 42F3;A 2<G;? OCGM 2> CDIA=I;A 2>? =EGA2B;=EH
D=GCN; =A <2A;F;HH C>?C@@;A;><; G= 6F2C>GC@@JH ACBMGH 2>? C>G;A;HGHR .CH
=EGA2B;=EH <=>?E<G O2AA2>GH GM; CDI=HCGC=> =@ HCB>C@C<2>G
<=DI;>H2G=AL 2>? IE>CGCN; ?2D2B;HR
1(9(#-. (58.-. &+"50 7/) )(+5(7
5#-(#-5/#"+ 5#7+5&-5/# /7 (0/-5/#"+ !51-)(11

8S
T"FF !;@;>?2>GHS

284. Plaintiff ie-alleges anu incoipoiates eveiy paiagiaph above.
28S. Befenuants' uefamatoiy anu false statements, intentional
misiepiesentations, @2FH; FCBMG* NC=F2GC=> =@ IACN2<L* C>G;A@;A;><; OCGM
MCH ;DIF=LD;>G, anu wiue publication of false statements about
Plaintiff's involvement in swatting 2>? =GM;A <ACD;H constitute extieme
anu outiageous conuuct.
286. Befenuants' causal anu in conceit ielationship to the assault of
Plaintiff by Befenuant Walkei, the many thieats of ueath anu injuiy to
Plaintiff anu his family, anu the uemanus foi Plaintiff's aiiest anu
impiisonment on the basis of false statements about swattings 2>? =GM;A
<ACD;H uemonstiates malice with an intent to cause maximum haim to
Plaintiff.
287. Befenuants' actions weie uone intentionally anuoi iecklessly in
conscious uisiegaiu of the high piobability that Plaintiff's mental uistiess
woulu follow.
288. -M;A; O2H 2 <2EH2F <=>>;<GC=> K;GO;;> GM; G=AGC=EH 2<GH =@
!;@;>?2>GH 2>? GM; ;D=GC=>2F ?CHGA;HH HE@@;A;? KL 6F2C>GC@@R 5G CH
C>G=F;A2KF; C> 2 <CNCFCQ;? H=<C;GL G= OA=>B@EFFL 2<<EH; H=D;=>; =@ 2
M=AACKF; <ACD; 2H ?C? D=HG =@ GM; !;@;>?2>GHR 5G CH C>G=F;A2KF; G=
M2A2HH 6F2C>GC@@ OCGM @2FH; 2FF;B2GC=>H =@ <ACDC>2F 2<GCNCGL @=A L;2AH
=> ;>?R 5G CH C>G=F;A2KF; G= <LK;A KEFFL 6F2C>GC@@ @=A <ACD;H GM2G
=<<EAA;? D=A; GM2> YW L;2AH 2B=R
Deleted: ,

86
289. As a iesult of Befenuants' actions, Plaintiff has suffeieu seveie
emotional uistiess anu mental anguish.
#5#-. &+"50 7/) )(+5(7
&/#165)"&, -/ &/005- 1-"-( +"4 -/)-1
T"FF !;@;>?2>GH (_<;IG 1CD=>j1<MEHG;AS

29u. Plaintiff ie-alleges anu incoipoiates eveiy paiagiaph above.
291. The Befenuants conspiieu with each othei to commit the state law
toitious acts allegeu above.
292. As a iesult of Befenuants' actions, Plaintiff has suffeieu haim anu
uamage.

6:#5-59( !"0"8(1
29S. The actions oi omissions of Befenuants set foith in this Complaint
uemonstiate malice, egiegious conuuct, insult, anu a peiveise
giatification fiom haim causeu to Plaintiff. Such actions oi omissions by
Befenuants weie unueitaken with eithei (1) maliciousness, spite, ill will,
vengeance oi uelibeiate intent to haim Plaintiff, oi (2) ieckless uisiegaiu
of the piofounu wiongfulness of theii actions oi omissions, anu theii
haimful effects on Plaintiff. Accoiuingly, Plaintiff iequests an awaiu of
punitive uamages beyonu anu in excess of those uamages necessaiy to
compensate Plaintiff foi injuiies iesulting fiom Befenuants' conuuct.

6)",() 7/) )(+5(7
WBEREF0RE, Plaintiff iequests the following ielief:
Deleted: ... [6]
Formatted: Centered, Line spacing:
single

87
Compensatoiy uamages anu consequential uamages in an amount
exceeuing $7S,uuu, that is $2,uuu.uuu.
Punitive uamages as applicable to punish Befenuants' iepiehensible
conuuct anu to uetei futuie occuiience;
Tieble uamages as authoiizeu by RIC0, 18 0SC 1964(c);
Beclaiatoiy ielief in the foim of an 0iuei finuing that Plaintiff hau no
involvement in any swattings;
An oiuei enjoining Befenuants fiom engaging in futuie toitious
conuuct against Plaintiff;
An oiuei iequiiing Befenuants to iemove any uefamatoiy statements
about swatting anu othei unchaigeu ciimes by Plaintiff fiom blogs,
book oi meuia ovei which they have contiol;
Foi equitable ielief as appiopiiate puisuant to applicable law,
incluuing but not limiteu to issuing a tempoiaiy iestiaining oiuei, a
pieliminaiy injunction anu a peimanent injunction that bais
Befenuants fiom ietaliating against Plaintiff in any way foi biinging
this action;
7=A@;CGEA; =@ 2FF @E>?H A2CH;? KL GM; !;@;>?2>GH K2H;? => GM;CA
@2FH; >2AA2GCN;H* @A2E? 2>? G=AGC=EH <=>?E<GP
Costs anu fees incuiieu in the piosecution of this action, anu
Fuithei ielief as this Couit ueems just anu appiopiiate.

Z:), !(0"#!
Deleted: ;
Deleted: .
Deleted:
Deleted:
Formatted: Font:Not Bold

88
Plaintiff Kimbeilin heieby uemanus a juiy tiial of all issues in this action
tiiable as of iight by a juiy.
Respectfully submitteu,
_________________________________________
Biett Kimbeilin-pio se

Naich 7, 2u14

Deleted: 0ctobei 17, 2u1S ... [7]

Kimberlin v. NBC Tracked Redline Redacted

Hochgeladen von

Dokumentinformationen

Copyright

Verfügbare Formate

Dieses Dokument teilen

Dokument teilen oder einbetten

Freigabeoptionen

Stufen Sie dieses Dokument als nützlich ein?

Sind diese Inhalte unangemessen?

Copyright:

Verfügbare Formate

Kimberlin v. NBC Tracked Redline Redacted

Hochgeladen von

Copyright:

Verfügbare Formate

1

0NITEB STATES BISTRICT C00RT

Das könnte Ihnen auch gefallen