Sie sind auf Seite 1von 452

DOT/FAA/AR-01/46

Office of Aviation Research


Washington, D.C. 20591

Full-Scale Testing and Analysis of


Fuselage Structure Containing
Multiple Cracks

John Bakuckas
Federal Aviation Administration
William J. Hughes Technical Center
Airport and Aircraft Safety
Research and Development Division
Atlantic City International Airport, NJ 08405

July 2002
Final Report

This document is available to the U.S. public


through the National Technical Information
Service (NTIS), Springfield, Virginia 22161.

U.S. Department of Transportation


Federal Aviation Administration

NOTICE
This document is disseminated under the sponsorship of the U.S.
Department of Transportation in the interest of information exchange. The
United States Government assumes no liability for the contents or use
thereof. The United States Government does not endorse products or
manufacturers. Trade or manufacturer's names appear herein solely
because they are considered essential to the objective of this report. This
document does not constitute FAA certification policy. Consult your local
FAA aircraft certification office as to its use.

This report is available at the Federal Aviation Administration William J.


Hughes Technical Center's Full-Text Technical Reports page:
actlibrary.tc.faa.gov in Adobe Acrobat portable document format (PDF).

Technical Report Documentation Page


1. Report No.

2. Government Accession No.

3. Recipient's Catalog No.

DOT/FAA/AR-01/46
4. Title and Subtitle

5. Report Date

FULL-SCALE TESTING OF FUSELAGE STRUCTURE CONTAINING


MULTIPLE CRACKS

July 2002

7. Author(s)

8. Performing Organization Report No.

6. Performing Organization Code

John Bakuckas
9. Performing Organization Name and Address

10. Work Unit No. (TRAIS)

Federal Aviation Administration


William J. Hughes Technical Center
Airport and Aircraft Safety
Research and Development Division
Materials and Structures Branch
Atlantic City International Airport, NJ 08405

11. Contract or Grant No.

12. Sponsoring Agency Name and Address

13. Type of Report and Period Covered

U.S. Department of Transportation


Federal Aviation Administration
Office of Aviation Research
Washington, DC 20591

Final Report
14. Sponsoring Agency Code

ANM-100

15. Supplementary Notes

16. Abstract

An experimental and analytical study was conducted to determine the effects of multiple cracks on the fatigue crack growth and
residual strength of curved fuselage panels. Four panels were tested, two panels with a longitudinal lap splice and two with a
circumferential butt joint. For each joint configuration, one panel contained only a lead crack and the other contained a lead crack
with multiple cracks located along the outer critical fastener row of the joints. The panels were tested in the Full-Scale Aircraft
Structural Test Evaluation and Research (FASTER) facility. First, strains were measured under quasi-static load conditions to
ensure proper load introduction into the panels. Second, fatigue crack formation and growth were monitored and recorded in real
time using the Remote Controlled Crack Monitoring (RCCM) system under constant amplitude loading up to a prescribed amount
of fatigue crack growth. Third, the crack growth and residual strength were measured during quasi-static loading to failure.
Geometric nonlinear finite element analyses were conducted to support the tests. The strain distributions and fracture parameters
governing crack formation and growth were determined. Comparisons with strain-gage data verified the finite element models.
For fatigue crack growth predictions, the corresponding mixed mode stress-intensity factors were calculated using the Modified
Crack Closure Integral (MCCI) method. Results include comparisons of strain distributions, fatigue crack growth characteristics,
and the damage growth process during residual strength test for the two joint configurations. In general, results show that
multiple cracking did not have an effect on the overall global strain response. However, the number of cycles to grow a fatigue
crack to a predetermined length was reduced by 37% and 27% for the longitudinal lap joint and circumferential butt joint panels,
respectively. In addition, the presence of multiple cracks reduced the residual strength of the panels with a longitudinal lap joint
by approximately 20%. For the circumferential butt joint panels, the effect of multiple cracking on the residual strength could not
be quantified due to premature failures at the load application points in the baseline panel. However, it was observed that the
growth of lead crack into the first fastener directly ahead was more rapid for the panel containing multiple cracks.

17. Key Words

18. Distribution Statement

Fatigue crack growth, Residual strength, Longitudinal lap


joint, Circumferential butt joint

This document is available to the public through the National


Technical Information Service (NTIS) Springfield, Virginia
22161.

19. Security Classif. (of this report)

Unclassified
Form DOT F1700.7

20. Security Classif. (of this page)

Unclassified
(8-72)

Reproduction of completed page authorized

21. No. of Pages

452

22. Price

TABLE OF CONTENTS
Page
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY

ix

INTRODUCTION

FULL-SCALE AIRCRAFT STRUCTURAL TEST EVALUATION AND RESEARCH


(FASTER) FACILITY

Mechanical Loading Mechanisms


Hydraulic and Pneumatic Systems
Control and Data Acquisition Instrumentation
Remote Controlled Crack Monitoring (RCCM) System
EXPERIMENTAL PROCEDURE

2
4
4
6
7

Panel Configurations

Longitudinal Lap Joint Panel Configuration


Circumferential Butt Joint Panel Configuration
Strain Gage Locations
Test Conditions
Verification of Test Results

8
9
9
10
10

ANALYSIS

11

Description of Models
The Modified Crack Closure Integral (MCCI) Method
RESULTS AND DISCUSSION

11
11
12

Strain Survey

13

Longitudinal Lap Joint Configuration


Circumferential Butt Joint Configuration
Fatigue Crack Growth

13
14
15

Longitudinal Lap Joint Configuration


Circumferential Butt Joint Configuration
Comparisons With Other Data
Residual Strength

15
17
19
20

iii

Longitudinal Lap Joint Configuration


Circumferential Butt Joint Configuration
Comparison With Other Data
Posttest Observations and Analysis

20
21
22
22

Longitudinal Lap Joint Configuration


Circumferential Butt Joint Configuration

22
23

CONCLUDING REMARKS

23

REFERENCES

24

APPENDICES
APanel Engineering Drawings
BLocation of Strain Gages
CBoeing Full-Scale Strain Survey Test Results
DAnalysis of Full-Scale Panels
ERaw Strain Gage Data
FReduced Strain Gage Data
GFatigue Crack Growth Data
HBoeing Full-Scale Fatigue Test Results
IResidual Strength Data

iv

LIST OF FIGURES
Figure

Page

Full-Scale Aircraft Structural Test Evaluation and Research (FASTER) Fixture

27

Schematic of Longitudinal and Hoop Loading Mechanism

27

Schematic of Shear Loading Mechanism

28

Schematic of Frame Loading Mechanism

28

Schematic of the Hydraulic and Pneumatic System

29

Schematic of the Proportional Integral Derivative (PID) Closed-Loop Error


Correction Process

29

Photographs of FASTER Facility and RCCM System

30

CVP1 and CVP2 Panel Configuration and Strain Gage Locations

30

Dimensions of Frames, Stringers, Shear Clips, and Intersect of Stringer and Frame

31

10

Photographs of Panel CVP1 Showing the Inner and Outer Surfaces and the Initial
Crack-Like Slit

31

11

Joint Configuration for Panels CVP1 and CVP2

32

12

Initial Damage Configurations for Panels CVP1 and CVP2

32

13

CVP3 and CVP4 Panel Configurations and Strain Gage Locations

33

14

Photographs of Panel CVP3 Showing the Inner and Outer Surfaces and the Initial
Crack-Like Slit

33

15

Joint Configuration for Panels CVP3 and CVP4

34

16

Initial Damage Configurations for Panels CVP3 and CVP4

34

17

Boeing Aft Fuselage Section Test Article

35

18

Location of Strain Gages in Aft Fuselage Section Test Article

35

19

Finite Element Model of CVP3 Showing Full Assembly and Substructure


Components

36

Definition of Four Stress-Intensity Factors and Crack Tip Elements and Nodes for
Computing the Rate of Work Done to Close a Crack Using the MCCI Method

36

20

21

Hoop Strain in Gage Located at Skin Mid-Bay in Panels CVP1 and CVP2 and
Boeing Full-Scale Test Article

37

Forty-Five Degree Strain in Gage Located at Skin Mid-Bay in Panels CVP1 and
CVP2 and Boeing Full-Scale Test Article

37

Longitudinal Strain in Gage Located at Skin Mid-Bay in Panels CVP1 and CVP2
and Boeing Full-Scale Test Article

38

Hoop Strain at Outer Cap of Frame in Panels CVP1 and CVP2 and Boeing FullScale Test Article

38

Longitudinal Strain at Outer Cap of Stringer in Panels CVP1 and CVP2 and
Boeing Full-Scale Test Article

39

Hoop Strain at Inner Cap of Frame in Panels CVP1 and CVP2 and Boeing FullScale Test Article

39

Longitudinal Strain at Flange of Stringer in Panels CVP1 and CVP2 and Boeing
Full-Scale Test Article

40

28

Hoop Strain Distribution in the Skin Mid-Bay in Panels CVP1 and CVP2

40

29

Longitudinal Strain in Gage Located at Skin Mid-Bay in Panels CVP3 and CVP4

41

30

Longitudinal Strain Distribution in the Skin Mid-Bay in Panels CVP3 and CVP4

41

31

Longitudinal Strain Distribution in the Stringers of Panels CVP3 and CVP4

42

32

Photographs of Crack Growth in CVP1 During Fatigue Loading Using RCCM


System

42

Photographs of Crack Growth in Panel CVP2 During Fatigue Loading Using


RCCM System

43

Stress-Intensity Factor Range as a Function of Half Crack Length for Panels


CVP1 and CVP2

43

Half Length of the Lead Crack as a Function of Number of Fatigue Cycles for
Panels CVP1 and CVP2

44

36

Crack Tip Position as a Function of Fatigue Cycles for Panel CVP2

44

37

Strain Redistribution in Panel CVP2

45

38

Photographs of Crack Growth in Panel CVP3 During Fatigue Loading Using


RCCM System

45

22
23
24
25
26
27

33
34
35

vi

39

Photographs of Crack Growth in Panel CVP4 During Fatigue Loading Using


RCCM System

46

Stress-Intensity Factor Range as a Function of Half Crack Length for Panels


CVP3 and CVP4

46

Half Crack Length as a Function of Number of Fatigue Cycles for Panels CVP3
and CVP4

47

42

Crack Tip Position as a Function of Fatigue Cycles for Panel CVP4

47

43

Strain Redistribution in Panel CVP4

48

44

Comparison of Fatigue Crack Growth Data Showing Effect of Multiple Cracks on


Lead Crack Growth

48

45

Crack Extension During Residual Strength Tests for Panels CVP1 and CVP2

49

46

Crack Tip Position of Lead Crack and Multiple Cracks as a Function of Applied
Pressure for Residual Strength Test of CVP2

49

47

Photographs of Tab Failure After First Residual Strength Attempt for Panel CVP3

50

48

Photographs of Tab Failure After Second Residual Strength Attempt for Panel
CVP3

50

Photographs of Reinforcements Made to all Tab Ends for the Longitudinal Load
Application Points for Panel CVP3

51

Crack Extension, as a Function of Applied Pressure, Recorded for Residual


Strength Tests of Panel CVP3

51

Crack Extension, as a Function of Applied Pressure, Recorded for Residual


Strength Tests of Panels CVP3 and CVP4

52

Crack Tip Position of Lead Crack and Multiple Cracks as a Function of Applied
Pressure for Residual Strength Test of CVP4

52

Comparison of Data Showing the Effect of Multiple Cracks on the Residual


Strength

53

Photographs of the Final State of Damage Showing Crack Bulging and Damaged
Frames in Panel CVP1

53

55

Strain in Frame F5 Prior to Failure of Panels CVP1 and CVP2

54

56

Photographs of the Final State of Damage in Panel CVP3 Showing Skin Failure

54

40
41

49
50
51
52
53
54

vii

57
58

Photographs of the Final State of Damage in Panel CVP3 Showing the


Substructure Failure

55

Strain in Stringer S5 Prior of Failure of Panels CVP3 and CVP4

55

LIST OF TABLES
Table
1
2
3
4
5

Page
Test Matrix
Sequence of Loading Conditions Applied to Panels CVP1 and CVP2
Sequence of Loading Conditions Applied to Panels CVP3 and CVP4
Stress-Intensity Factor Range Calculations for Panels CVP1 and CVP2
Stress-Intensity Factor Range Calculations for Panels CVP3 and CVP4

viii

56
56
56
57
58

EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
An experimental and analytical study was conducted to determine the effects of multiple cracks
on the fatigue crack growth and residual strength of curved fuselage panels. Four panels were
tested, two panels with a longitudinal lap splice and two with a circumferential butt joint. For
each joint configuration, one panel contained only a lead crack and the other contained a lead
crack with multiple cracks located along the outer critical fastener row of the joints. The panels
were tested in the Full-Scale Aircraft Structural Test Evaluation and Research (FASTER)
facility. First, strains were measured under quasi-static load conditions to ensure proper load
introduction into the panels. Second, fatigue crack formation and growth were monitored and
recorded in real time using the Remote Controlled Crack Monitoring (RCCM) system under
constant amplitude loading up to a prescribed amount of fatigue crack growth. Third, the crack
growth and residual strength were measured during quasi-static loading to failure.
Geometric nonlinear finite element analyses were conducted to support the tests. The strain
distributions and fracture parameters governing crack formation and growth were determined.
Comparisons with strain-gage data verified the finite element models. For fatigue crack growth
predictions, the corresponding mixed mode stress-intensity factors were calculated using the
Modified Crack Closure Integral (MCCI) method. Results include comparisons of strain
distributions, fatigue crack growth characteristics, and the damage growth process during
residual strength test for the two joint configurations. In general, results show that multiple
cracking did not have an effect on the overall global strain response. However, the number of
cycles to grow a fatigue crack to a predetermined length was reduced by 37% and 27% for the
longitudinal lap joint and circumferential butt joint panels, respectively. In addition, the
presence of multiple cracks reduced the residual strength of the panels with a longitudinal lap
joint by approximately 20%. For the circumferential butt joint panels, the effect of multiple
cracking on the residual strength could not be quantified due to premature failures at the load
application points in the baseline panel. However, it was observed that the growth of lead crack
into the first fastener directly ahead was more rapid for the panel containing multiple cracks.

ix/x

INTRODUCTION
Since the 1988 Aloha Airlines accident in which a large portion of the fuselage crown of a
Boeing 737 tore apart due to the linkup of small cracks emanating from rivet holes in the lap
joint, much effort has been placed on developing methodologies to predict the reduction in
residual strength of aircraft fuselage structure due to various multiple-site cracking scenarios.
Research efforts sponsored by the Federal Aviation Administration (FAA), National Aeronautics
and Space Administration (NASA), and the Department of Defense (DoD) include the
development of various analytical tools that address this complex problem at several levels.
Both rigorous numerical methods and simplified engineering approaches have been developed to
predict crack initiation, growth, and linkup, and residual strength [1-9]. In general, the
development of each tool has been focused on analyzing different aspects of the process, such as
crack initiation, crack growth, crack linkup, or residual strength of the fuselage structure. When
fully validated, the combination of the tools should be able to predict the entire process and
could be used in the current fleet of aircraft to predict the effect of multiple-site cracks on the
residual strength or in future aircraft designs to prevent the occurrence of multiple-site cracking
within the design life of the structure.
As part of the FAA research program, a research effort was conducted at the FAA William J.
Hughes Technical Center to assess the effects of multiple-site cracking on the fatigue crack
growth and residual strength of fuselage structures. One focus of the research effort is on
developing computational methods to determine fracture parameters governing the onset and
growth of cracks and the residual strength of fuselage structure with multiple cracks. These
methods will be used to predict strain distributions, crack growth, and residual strength.
The second focus is on conducting tests to understand the damage mechanics and guide the
model development. A state-of-the-art facility, the Full-Scale Aircraft Structural Test Evaluation
and Research (FASTER) facility, was developed to apply realistic flight load conditions to large,
full-scale, curved sections of fuselage structure [10 and 11]. Both quasi-static and spectrum
loadings can be applied, including differential pressure, longitudinal load, and hoop load in the
skin and frames, and shear load. The test data will be used to validate analytical methodologies
developed by the FAA and NASA [9]. The FASTER facility is located at and operated by the
FAA William J. Hughes Technical Center.
This document reports on tests and analyses that were conducted to verify the predictive
methodologies. The curved panels used in the test program are similar to a typical narrow-body
fuselage structure consisting of skin, frames, shear clips, stringers, and either longitudinal splice
or circumferential joints. A total of four panels were tested, two panels with a longitudinal lap
splice and two with a circumferential butt joint. For each joint configuration, one panel
contained only a lead crack and the other contained a lead crack with multiple cracks. A strain
survey was conducted under quasi-static loading conditions on a test panel to verify proper load
transfer from the load application points to the panel. Comparison with an independent full-scale
test conducted by Boeing Aircraft Company on an aft fuselage section of an actual aircraft with
similar structural details to the panels tested in this program and comparisons with detailed finite
element analysis results confirmed appropriate applied load conditions. Crack growth under
fatigue loading conditions was measured and recorded up to a predetermined crack length.
Finally, crack extension and residual strength were measured under quasi-static loading
1

conditions. In the following sections, a brief description of the FASTER test fixture is presented
followed by the analytical and experimental results, including strain distributions, damage
growth process, and residual strength characteristics. These findings provide experimental and
analytical procedures for testing curved panels containing multiple-site cracking scenarios.
FULL-SCALE AIRCRAFT STRUCTURAL TEST EVALUATION AND
RESEARCH (FASTER) FACILITY
The FASTER test fixture, shown in figure 1, features a unique adaptation of mechanical, fluid,
and electronic components and is capable of applying internal pressurization, longitudinal, hoop,
frame, and shear loads to a curved panel. As shown in the exploded view in figure 1, the fixture
consists of a base structure, hoop load assembly, longitudinal load assembly, fuselage pressure
box, frame load assembly, and shear fixture assembly. The FASTER facility also includes a
computerized instrument control and data acquisition system and a remote-controlled video
system that are not shown in figure 1.
In general, the test fixture is capable of dynamically cycling the internal pressure as well as
performing a static pressurization. The hoop and longitudinal stresses are simulated by the
controlled application of distributed loads around the perimeter of the test panel. Hoop forces
are distributed by individual loading linkages using a two-tier coaxial whiffle tree assembly,
which generates four equal forces from each controlled load point. A total of seven load points
are used on each side of the specimen, creating a total of 28 attachment points. Longitudinal
forces are applied using similar loading devices on each end of the panel, consisting of four load
control points and 16 attachment points. Similar devices are available to apply hoop tension
loads at each end of a frame.
An innovative shear load application system was developed that uses two load distribution points
in the longitudinal direction at the edges of the specimen. The force is applied as a couple and is
reacted by a couple in the hoop direction. A unique feature of the shear loading system is the
elastomeric coupling between the loading mechanisms and the test specimen. The elastomer,
which has a soft shear modulus, creates a close approximation to uniform shear distribution in
both the applied and reacted couples.
All forces are generated using water and air as the fluid medium. The external loads are
generated by applying water pressure to bladder type actuators, which are controlled by pressureactivated dome valves. The dome valves are automatically controlled by electro/pneumatic (E/P)
control valves. The E/P valves are driven by a computer control system in a closed-loop
configuration. The operator can control the loads, speed, and type of test. Data from strain
transducers, load transducers, pressure transducers, etc., are displayed on color monitors in real
time and stored for off-line analysis.
MECHANICAL LOADING MECHANISMS.
Water actuators with a lever arm construction are used to apply loads to the curved panel. The
water actuators used are air-water springs. An air-water spring is an elastomeric rubber fabric
bellow with metal-end closures which contains a column of compressed air or water. In the
FASTER test fixture, water is used. The compressed water provides the force or supports the
2

load. Air-water springs have wide industrial applications, including vibration isolation, truck
suspension, and actuators. They are highly durable, rugged, and reliable. The water actuators
used for the FASTER test fixture are more cost-effective than the standard oil-based hydraulic
cylinder actuators. The initial purchase cost is much less and no maintenance or lubrication is
required. There is no internal rod or piston or sliding seals, as in conventional cylinders. Since
there are no moving parts in the water actuator, it is maintenance free, friction free and the
response is immediate.
A schematic of the general loading mechanism for the longitudinal and hoop load assemblies is
shown in figure 2. The loading mechanism consists of a water actuator, lever arm, fulcrum pivot
point, a load cell, and a whiffle tree. The lever arm is connected to the water actuator at one end
and to the load cell at the other and rotates about the fulcrum pivot point. The distance from the
water actuator to the fulcrum is l1, and the distance from the top of the lever arm to the fulcrum is
l2. As the water actuator inflates, the bottom of lever arm will displace an amount u1, rotate at
the fulcrum pivot point, causing the top of the lever arm to displace an amount u2. There are
eight loading mechanisms to apply longitudinal load, four attached to each end of the specimen
as shown in figure 1. There are 14 loading mechanisms to apply the hoop load, 7 on each side of
the specimen. The load is distributed to the edge of the specimen through four links in the
whiffle tree for each loading mechanisms as shown in figure 2.
Although the application of shear loading was not included in this test program, a brief
description of this capability is described herein for the sake of completeness. The shear load
assembly consists of the shear fixture and four counter balance poles and baskets as shown in
figure 3. The shear fixture consists of a rigid reaction structure and pairs of water actuators,
shear lever arms, pivot points, longitudinal skis, and hoop skis. The longitudinal and hoop skis
are attached to the curved panel using elastic polyurethane strips 1 thick by 4 wide with a
Shore A durometer scale hardness rating of 90. The strips are a hard rubber material on the
Shore A scale compared to rubber bands at 40, tire treads at 50, and shoe heels at 70. As the
water actuator inflates, the shear lever arm will displace downward, u1, and will rotate about the
shear arm pivot point. As a result, the lever arm keyway, which is attached to longitudinal ski,
will displace amount u2 as shown in figure 3. The displacement u2 will deform the polyurethane
strip, which will distribute the point force at the keyway into a uniform shear force distributed
along the entire length of the longitudinal ski. By inflating the two water actuators, which are
located at diagonal corners of the reaction structure, the shear loads are applied through the
longitudinal skis in equal magnitude but opposite direction. The shear couple is reacted by the
rigid support structure, which is attached to the hoop skis. The entire shear load fixture weighs
approximately 3800 lbs. To insure this weight is not applied to the panel, the fixture is counter
balanced using four weights attached to the fixture through four cable support columns as shown
in figure 3.
The frame load assembly loading mechanism is shown in figure 4. The figure shows a cut-away
view through a frame loader. The frame-loading mechanism consists of a water actuator, a
frame lever arm, a fulcrum pivot point, a radial reaction link, and a frame load link. As the water
actuator inflates, the end of the frame lever arm will displace an amount u1 and will cause a
displacement of the frame load link in the hoop direction, u2. The radial reaction link ensures
that the frame attachment point is displaced only in the hoop direction. There are 12 loading
mechanisms for the frame load assembly.
3

The curved panel can be pressurized using either air, water, or a combination of both. The panel
skin is attached to the pressure box using an elastomeric rubber seal as shown in figure 4. The
seal is bonded to the panel skin and bolted to the pressure box.
HYDRAULIC AND PNEUMATIC SYSTEMS.
All forces are generated using water supplied by a stand-alone water system. The water supply
system consists of a 1050-gallon reservoir, a 40-hourspower (HP) pump capable of discharging
water at 140-psi pressure. A radiator on the water return line acts as a heat exchanger to keep the
water temperature below 105F. The water supply line and supply manifold is constructed from
3 schedule 80 CPVC pipe. Under normal operating conditions, 60 psi is sufficient operational
pressure. The water return line and manifold are constructed from 4 schedule 80 CPVC pipe.
A schematic of the hydraulic and pneumatic system for a single loading mechanism is shown in
figure 5. The pressure regulator dome valves are attached to the water supply and return
manifolds with a 3/4 flexible hose. The high-precision pressure regulator dome valves control
the water outlet pressure to inflate the water actuators of the loading mechanisms. When the
water actuator deflates, the water exits to the water return manifold through a constant flow
orifice valve. The pressure regulator dome valves use air pressure applied above the valve
diaphragm controlled by E/P valves to accurately regulate water outlet pressure. The water
outlet pressure is identical to the air inlet pressure applied to the dome above the diaphragm. The
E/P valves convert a 0- to 10-volt control input signal to a proportional 0.7 to 127 psi pneumatic
air pressure inlet signal sent to the pressure regulator dome valves. Air supply pressure to the
E/P valves is set to 130 psi supplied by an air compressor. Plastic tubing having 1/4 diameter is
used to connect the E/P valves to the supply from an air compressor and inlet to the pressure
regulator dome valves. The E/P valves are computer controlled in a closed-loop configuration as
discussed in the next section.
CONTROL AND DATA ACQUISITION INSTRUMENTATION.
The computer control and data acquisition instrumentation integrates the various mechanical
load assemblies of the FASTER test fixture. The control and data acquisition instrumentation
uses the VXIbus (VMEbus eXstenions for Instrumentation) standard. The VXIbus standard is
based on the VMEbus (versa modular European) architecture, a recognized standard that offers
an excellent computer backplane for high-speed digital data transfer and communication between
devices. The VMEbus standard was originally designed for digital communication and is too
noisy for precise low-level analog measurements of test instrumentation. The VXIbus standard
enhanced the VMEbus standard by specifying interference shielding requirements on the
backplane and between modules and by increased spacing between modules. The VXIbus
standard provides the architecture to allow low-level analog signals to coexist on the backplane
with high-speed digital signals resulting in state-of-the-art test and measurement instrumentation
with high throughput and versatility.
The control and data acquisition instrumentation contains a six-slot VXI mainframe (HP 1421B).
In the current configuration, five slots are used for control and data acquisition, with one
reserved for expansion. The zero slot contains a UNIX-based VXI-embedded controller

(HP V732/100) with a 100-MHz RISC processor. The next four slots of the mainframe contain
VXI multifunction measurement and control (HP E1419A) modules having 16-bit measurement
resolution and 56,000 samples per second maximum reading rate. The HP E1419A module can
be configured for a specific measurement and control application by using up to eight signalconditioning plug-on (SCP) cards. The SCP cards can accommodate up to eight input or output
channels and can provide various analog and digital input or output functions. In the first slot,
the E1419A module is designed for control of the longitudinal load assemblies, internal fuselage
pressure, the shear load assemblies, and system hydraulic supply. In the second and third slots,
the E1419A modules have similar configurations, each designed for the control of the hoop and
frame load assemblies on both sides of the system. In the fourth slot, the E1419A is designed for
64 channels of data acquisition with 56 low-level signals with a gain of 64 used for strain and
crack propagation gages, and eight high-level signals for pressure transducers.
The scanning rate of the control and data acquisition process is 150 times per second. There are
64 channels dedicated to data acquisition from strain gages, load transducers, pressure
transducers, crack gages, etc. There are 40 channels to control the FASTER test fixture. The
control channels include operation of the E/P valves, using a full proportional integral derivative
(PID), closed-loop feedback error control process as shown in the block diagram in figure 6. In
the figure, lines indicate the path of a signal, the sign of the signal, within a circle designates
a summation junction of signals, and the boxes represent a process done to the signal. The
controlling signals shown in the figure are the command signal, Cmd, the feedback signal from
the loading system, Fbk, and the error signal Err, which is the difference in the Cmd and Fbk
signals. The error signal is used to adjust the response of the load system using proportional
error correction, integral error correction, and derivative error correction processes. The
proportional error correction process scales the error by parameter Pgain to obtain a quick
response. The integral error correction process takes the history of the error and integrates over
time and scales to parameter Igain to reduce steady-state error of the response. The derivative
error correction process takes the rate of change of the error and scales to parameter Dgain to
help damp the response. The final control input signal, Cin, is the summation of the Cmd signal,
and the signals from the proportional, integral, and derivative error correction processes given
by:
Cin = Cmd + Pgain Err + Igain

sign( Err )dt + Dgain

d ( Err )
dt

(1)

This signal is then used as input to the E/P value of a loading system as shown, for example, in
figure 5. Limit parameters are used to ensure that the system does not run unstable or
inadvertently overload the system. These parameters include maximum and minimum limits on
the command signal, Omax and Omin, a limit range on the integral error correction, Ilim. In
addition, a limit is set to shut the system down if the error exceeds parameter Dumpl.
A target signal specifies the level the command signal must obtain over a certain time interval
called the end point, EP, and time (figure 6). The three ramping functions, which are used to
define the path the command signal follows to get to the target level, are a haversine (half
sinusoidal wave), linear, and step. To synchronize the loading mechanisms, two other control
parameters are used: the static hold, Shold, and the dynamic hold, Dhold. The Shold and Dhold
5

parameters are limits on the amount of error between the command signal and the feedback
signals at the target signal end point and between the target signal end points, respectively. If the
Shold or Dhold limits are exceeded, a hold is placed on all control channels until the feedback
control adjusts itself to within these limits.
The graphic programming language, HP-Visual Engineering Environment (VEE) was used to
develop the graphical user interface (GUI) and the control and data acquisition system. The HPVEE software is designed for use with the HP VXI-based instrumentation. It can access and
load any driver for standard VXI instrument cards. The driver then provides a procedural
interface to the instrument for programmatic control. The user-friendly GUI of HP-VEE allows
a user to efficiently develop code necessary for controlling instruments, acquiring data, display
data in real time, analyze and reduce data in real time, or store data to buffers and files for
posttest analysis and data reduction. A graphical interface program developed using HP-VEE
allows the operator to control the loads, speed, and type of test desired. Data acquisition from
strain transducers, load transducers, pressure transducers, etc., are displayed on color monitors in
real time and stored for off-line analysis.
REMOTE CONTROLLED CRACK MONITORING (RCCM) SYSTEM.
The Remote Controlled Crack Monitoring (RCCM) system, shown in figure 7, tracks and
records multiple crack formation and propagation during loading in real time. The RCCM
system is a stand alone, computer-based video data acquisition system capable of monitoring the
entire fuselage panel test surface at several levels of magnification with a field of view ranging
from 0.05 up to 14. The system consists of cameras mounted to two computer remotecontrolled, high-precision translation stages and provides accurate and repeatable length
measurements.
The RCCM system is comprised of three main components: a mechanical frame assembly, a
motion control assembly, and a video data acquisition system. The mechanical frame assembly
is used to mount and place the motion control assembly over the test section of the panels while
in the fixture. A large rectangular frame made from 4 square aluminum tubing is mounted on
top of the four counterbalance columns of the fixture. A second section sits within the
rectangular frame and can slide to provide longitudinal positioning of the motion control
assembly. The third component fits within the second section for lateral positioning of the
motion control assembly.
The motion control assembly is comprised of three bidirectional and two single-directional
translation stages each having a 0.078 lead screw. A bidirectional translation stage provides 24
of overall travel in each direction. Two more bidirectional translation stages are mounted
underneath the 24 bidirectional stage, each providing 36 of travel in longitudinal direction and
12 of travel in the lateral direction. Periscope stages are mounted to the two 36 by 12
bidirectional translation stages to provide translation in the z direction of 10.
The motion of the stages are remotely controlled by a computer via a joystick, mouse, and
keyboard, which sends step and direction commands through a 50-pin ribbon cable to each of the
eight motor driver modules. The stages are powered by 24 volt, 4 ampere, and four-phase

stepper motors that provide 200 full steps per revolution. The stepper motors driver modules
further divide the step to ten increments, providing motion resolution of 0.000039. The
accuracy of the lead screws is 0.0039 per 10 inches of travel and bidirectional repeatability is
0.000236.
The video data acquisition assembly contains two black and white RS-170 format analog
cameras operating at 30 frames per second with high-resolution 768- by 493-pixel chips. The
two cameras are mounted to each of the two periscope stages. A high magnification zoom lens
(narrow-field-of-view (NFOV) lens) is attached to the first camera and provides a field of view
ranging from 0.05 up to 0.5. The NFOV lens was modified to accommodate a simple beltdriven motor to control the zoom ring remotely. In addition, a fiber-optic ring light is attached to
the end of the NFOV lens to provide localized lighting that also can be controlled remotely.
A zoom lens (wide-field-of-view (WFOV) lens) is attached to the second camera with a focal
length range of 0.45 to 2.71, having complete motorized zoom, focus, and iris controls built-in.
A +1 diopter and +2 diopter were added to the WFOV lens end to provide a field of view ranging
from 2 up to 14.
Video data acquisition and reduction software provides real-time crack length measurement
capabilities from the cameras on each stage. Using a cross-hair on the image as a reference,
accurate measurements of crack length can be obtained through the control of the translation
stages. Up to 360 of the 768- by 493-pixel digital images can be captured continuously and
stored in bitmap format at a rate up to 30 frames per second. The software can playback the
stored images. In addition, direct hookup to monitors and video control recording (VCR)
equipment is provided for continuous real-time monitoring and recording.
EXPERIMENTAL PROCEDURE
The test matrix for the four curved panel tests is shown in table 1. Panel CVP1 contains a
longitudinal lap splice with a lead crack. Panel CVP2 has the same configuration and lead crack
as CVP1 with the addition of multiple small cracks emanating from rivet holes ahead of the lead
crack. Panel CVP3 has a circumferential butt joint with a lead crack. Panel CVP4 has the same
configuration and lead crack as panel CVP3 with the addition of multiple small cracks emanating
from rivet holes ahead of the lead crack. These panels were subjected to a sequence of three
loading functions: (1) initial monotonic, quasi-static loading to a predetermined load level; (2) a
constant amplitude cyclic loading; and (3) a postfatigue monotonic, quasi-static loading up to
fracture.
PANEL CONFIGURATIONS.
Detailed engineering drawings for the four panels tested are presented in appendix A. The
selected panel configurations represent generic fuselage structure from a narrow-body aircraft,
fabricated according to original equipment manufacturing (OEM) specifications. It was decided
in this program to test panels that were generic instead of aircraft specific, since the purpose of
this study is to provide experimental data to support and verify analysis methodologies to assess
the effects of multiple cracks applicable to all aircraft types. The panel size was selected so that

the test section will contain large damage such as a two-bay crack with central frame severed.
The test section of the panel was sized in order to minimize the effect of the test fixture
attachment points along the perimeter.
Typical panel dimensions are 120 in the longitudinal direction, 68 in the circumferential
direction, with a radius of 66 as shown in figure 8. For all four panels, the skin was 2024-T3
aluminum with a thickness of 0.063. Each panel had six frames with a 19 spacing and seven
stringers with a 7.5 spacing. The cross-sectional properties of the substructure are shown in
figure 9. The frames and shear clips were 7075-T6 aluminum with thicknesses of 0.071 and
0.063, respectively. The stringers were also 7075-T6 aluminum with a thickness of 0.063,
except for S4 where the thickness is 0.071. As shown in the photographs, the shear clip is
connected to skin using NAS1097AD6 rivets with a pitch of 1.0. The stringer is connected to
skin using NAS1097AD6 rivet with a pitch of 1.25. The frame and shear clips are connected
using MS20470AD6 rivets with a pitch of 1.0, and the shear clips and stringers are connected
using HL518-6 Hi-Lok pin fasteners.
The edges of the curved panels, where loads are applied, were reinforced by bonding six layers
of 0.045~0.065-inch-thick aluminum alloy doublers to the skin to ensure a uniform load transfer.
Along the perimeter of the panel, reinforcing doublers with a length of 112 on the longitudinal
sides and 56 on the hoop sides were added. Holes with a diameter of 0.5 were spaced
approximately 4 apart along each side and 3.5 apart along each end to attach the whiffle tree
assemblies which apply the load. There were 28 load application points on each longitudinal
side and 16 load application points on each end. Doublers were also added to the frame ends
where they attach to the frame loaders.
LONGITUDINAL LAP JOINT PANEL CONFIGURATION. Figure 8 shows a schematic of
the longitudinal lap joint test panels CVP1 and CVP2 as well as the dimensions and location of
the strain gages. Details can be found in appendix A. Photographs of the CVP1 panel are shown
in figure 10. As shown in figure 8, there are six frames, F1 through F6, in the circumferential
direction and seven stringers, S1 through S7, in the longitudinal direction. A longitudinal lap
joint is located along stringer S4 as shown in figure 11. The joint consist of two layers of the
2024-T3 panel skin with a thickness of 0.063 and two layers of 2024-T3 finger doublers with a
thickness of 0.025. Four rows of fasteners, A, B, C, and D, are used to connect the skin and
doublers. For rows A and D, MS20470AD5 rivets were used with a pitch of 1.5. For row C,
MS20470AD6 rivets were used with a pitch of 0.813, and for row B, NAS1097AD6 rivets were
used with a pitch of 0.813. The distance between rows A and B and rows C and D is 0.875,
and the distance between rows B and C is 1.25.
The initial damage configuration for the two longitudinal lap joint panels is shown in figure 12.
For both panels CVP1 and CVP2, a crack-like slit representing a lead crack was placed
symmetrically across frame F4, machined in the skin along the critical rivet row A in the
longitudinal lap splice. The total length of the lead crack was 7.0 long. Between rivet holes 2L
and 2R, the crack-like slit was saw cut with a width of 0.012. The tips of the lead crack
emanated 0.5 from the centerline of rivet holes 2L and 2R where it was wire cut to a width of
0.008. For panel CVP2, small multiple cracks were machined in the first 18 rivets to the left
8

and right of the lead crack centerline rivet designated 0. The nominal length of each crack is
indicated in figure 12. The nominal width of all the cracks was 0.008.
CIRCUMFERENTIAL BUTT JOINT PANEL CONFIGURATION. Figure 13 shows a
schematic of the circumferential butt joint test panels CVP3 and CVP4 as well as the dimensions
and location of the strain gages. Photographs of the CVP3 panel are shown in figure 14. The
structural details of CVP3 and CVP4 test panels were similar to those in the longitudinal lap joint
panels and can be found in appendix A. Both CVP3 and CVP4 test panels have a butt joint in
the circumferential direction between frames F3 and F4 as shown in figure 15. The joint consists
of two layers of the 2024-T3 panel skin with a thickness of 0.063, a 2024-T3 finger doubler
with a thickness of 0.025, and a tapered doubler with a thickness of 0.071, which tapers to a
thickness of 0.025 along the edge. Eight rows of fasteners, A through H, are used to connect
the skin and doublers. For rows A and H, MS20470AD5 rivets were used with a pitch of 1.5.
For rows B, C, F, and G, NAS1097AD6 rivets were used with a pitch of 0.75, and for rows D
and E, S4931919-6 Hi-Lok pin fasteners were used with a pitch of 0.75. The distance between
rows A and B and rows G and H is 0.875, and the distance between rows B and C, C and D, F
and G, and E and F is 0.625. The distance between rows D and E is 1.0.
The initial damage configuration for the two circumferential lap joint panels is shown in figure
16. For both panels, CVP3 and CVP4, a crack-like slit representing a lead crack was placed
symmetrically across stringer S4, machined in the skin along the critical rivet row A in the
circumferential butt joint. Stringer S4 was cut to simulate a broken stringer. The total length of
the lead crack was 7.0 long. Between rivet holes 2L and 2R, the crack-like slit was saw cut to a
width of 0.012. The tips of the lead crack emanated 0.5 from the centerline of rivet holes 2L
and 2R where it was wire cut to a width of 0.008. For panel CVP4, small multiple cracks were
machined in the first 12 rivets to the left and right of the lead crack centerline rivet designated 0.
The nominal length of each crack is indicated in figure 16. The nominal width of all the cracks
was 0.008.
STRAIN GAGE LOCATIONS.
Strain gages were placed on all four panels to monitor the strain distribution and to ensure proper
load introduction. The precise location of the strain gages and types of strain gages, coatings,
cables, and adhesives are provided in detail in appendix B. For the longitudinal lap joint panels
CVP1 and CVP2, the approximate locations of the stain gages on the skin, frames, and stringers
are shown in figure 8. In general, 20 axial strain gages were located on both the inner and outer
flanges of the frames. The stringers were instrumented with eight axial strain gages on the
flange and hat section (see detail in figure 8). The skin was instrumented with eight strain gage
rosettes. At one location on the skin, two back-to-back 45 strain gage rosettes (gages 31 and 32)
were installed to provide a measure of bending of the skin.
For the circumferential lap joint panels CVP3 and CVP4, the approximate locations of the strain
gages on the skin, frames, and stringers are shown in figure 13. Panels CVP3 and CVP4 were
instrumented with 9 strain gage rosettes (45o) in the skin and 31 axial strain gages in the frames
and stringers. At two locations on the skin, namely at gages 36 and 37 and at gages 39 and 40,
two back-to-back 45 rosette gages were installed to provide a measure of bending of the skin.
9

TEST CONDITIONS.
The longitudinal lap joint and circumferential butt joint panels were subjected to the sequence of
loadings listed in tables 2 and 3, respectively. Three different quasi-static loadings were applied,
followed by fatigue loading and postfatigue residual strength loading.
Three quasi-static loadings were applied, as shown in tables 2 and 3, to determine the strain
distribution and insure proper introduction of load into the panels. In load condition 1a, each
panel was subjected to an internal pressure; 10.1 psi for longitudinal lap joint panels and 8.8 psi
for the circumferential butt joint panels. Hoop and frame loads were applied as reactive loads
from the internal pressure. In load condition 1b, only longitudinal load was applied. Load
conditions 1a and 1b were superimposed for load condition 1c. For the longitudinal lap joint
panels, load condition 1c simulates the cylindrical pressurization that a section of the fuselage
along the neutral axis would experience. For the circumferential butt joint panels, load condition
1c simulates a fuselage down-bending condition that a fuselage section along the crown of the
aircraft would experience, where the longitudinal stress is 50% higher than the hoop stress.
In load sequence 2, shown in tables 2 and 3, the same load conditions as in load sequence 1c was
applied at constant amplitude and a frequency of 0.2 Hz with an R-ratio (minimum to maximum
load) of 0.1. Crack growth of the lead crack and small multiple cracks were continuously
monitored and recorded using the RCCM system.
The postfatigue residual strength test was performed using loading condition 3 as listed in tables
2 and 3. Frame F4 in longitudinal lap joint panels, which was intact prior to the residual strength
test, was saw cut midway between stringers S4 and S5 to simulate a broken frame. The panels
were statically loaded until catastrophic failure. For the longitudinal lap joint panels, the applied
loading consisted of internal pressurization with reactive hoop and frame loads with a
longitudinal stress that was 50% less than hoop stress. For the circumferential butt joint panels,
the applied loading consisted of internal pressurization with reactive hoop and frame loads, with
a longitudinal stress that was 50% higher than the hoop stress.
VERIFICATION OF TEST RESULTS.
The test results from a full-scale test conducted on an aft fuselage section of an actual narrowbody aircraft by Boeing Aircraft Company in Long Beach, CA, were compared to the FASTER
test results. The aft fuselage test article is shown in figure 17. The test article was mounted on a
strong back fixture and pressurized quasi-statically from 0 to 7.8 psi for three tests. A section of
aircraft, from frame station 1269 to 1288 and stringer L4 to L5, was instrumented with strain
gages as shown in figure 18. The instrumented section of the aft fuselage test article has a
structure which is similar to the four curved panels tested in the FASTER facility with a similar
radius, skin thickness, and substructure detail. A 45 rosette gage was placed near skin mid-bay
location A, and uniaxial gages were placed in the cap and flange of stringer L4, locations B and
C, and the inner and outer frame cap at frame station 1269, locations E and F. The strain gage
data from the three tests are listed in the tables of appendix C. Strains measured from these
locations were compared with the strains measured at similar locations in longitudinal lap joint
panels CVP1 and CVP2.

10

ANALYSIS
Geometric nonlinear finite element analyses were conducted using the commercial finite element
code ABAQUS 5.8 [12]. A full description of the analysis procedures and results are provided in
appendix D. A brief description is provided herein. In general, two analyses were conducted for
each panel: the first to predict the strain distributions and the second to compute the stressintensity factor (SIF) solutions. The SIF solutions were used to predict the fatigue crack growth
of the curved panels and the predictions were compared with test results.
DESCRIPTION OF MODELS.
The panels were modeled using two-dimensional shell elements with each node having six
degrees of freedom. Figure 19 shows the global view of a typical finite element model of panel
CVP3. Four-noded shell elements were used throughout to model the skin, frames, shear clip,
stringers, and intercostals, except near the crack tips. In the immediate vicinity of the crack tips,
eight-noded shell elements were used. The major geometric details of the panels were modeled,
including the cross-section properties of the substructure (frames, stringers, shear clip, and
intercostals), the dimensions of finger doublers, and the load attachment doublers. Beam
elements were used to model the rivets that connected the substructures with the skin and the
substructures to one another. The semiempirical equation developed by Swift [13], shown
below, was used to calculate the shear stiffness of the beams as:

k shear =

E' d
d d
5 + 0.8 +
t1 t2

(2)

where E' = 10.5106 psi is the effective modulus, d = 0.1875 is the fastener diameter, and t1 =
0.063, and t2 = 0.063 are the thickness of the skin and substructure (shear clip or stringer),
respectively. To simplify the global panel modeling, the rivet holes were not modeled. The
typical finite element model of a panel had 250,000 degrees of freedom.
The load conditions specified in tables 2 and 3 were simulated in the analysis. For the hoop,
frame, and longitudinal loads, nodal point forces were applied at the load application points in
the actual test, as shown by the arrows in figure 19. Internal pressure was applied to the inner
surface of the skin.
THE MODIFIED CRACK CLOSURE INTEGRAL (MCCI) METHOD.
In the MCCI approach [14-16], it is assumed that the energy released during crack extension is
the same as the work that would be needed to close the crack, and that the energy released can be
related to the four components of SIF. The four components of SIF are the Mode I SIF caused
by tensile load, K1, the Mode II SIF cause by in-plane shear load, K2, the SIF due to symmetric
bending loads, k1, and the SIF due to out-of-plane shear and twist loads, k2, as shown in
figure 20.

11

The MCCI method approximates the rate of work needed to close a crack using the local crack
tip displacements and forces. The displacements and forces at the nodes of the four elements
surrounding the crack tip were obtained from the finite element results for each crack length, as
shown in figure 20. The work (Wi) done to close a crack of length, a, for each nodal degree of
freedom is given by [16]:

Wi =

)]

1
Fi Close u itop u ibot , i = 1,L,6
2ta

(3)

where t is the thickness of the panel, F is the force needed to close the crack surfaces, u is the
displacement component on each surface of the crack, and i denotes the degree of freedom
(DOF). The total amount of work done to close a crack of length, a, is numerically equal to the
total amount of strain energy released during a crack growth increment of a, and the
components of strain energy release rate can be related to the stress-intensity factors. Thus, the
work done to close the crack is related to the SIFs as:
W 2 + W6 =

W1 =

W4 =

k12
3E

K 12
E

(4)

K 22
E

(5)

1 +

3 +

(6)

and
W3 + W5 =

k 22
3E

1 +

3 +

(7)

where E = 10,500 ksi and = 0.3 are the Youngs modulus and Poisons ratio of the panel skin
material and K1, K2, k1, and k2 are the SIFs described earlier. Only the Mode I SIF, K1, was used
to predict the fatigue crack growth behavior because, as will be shown, it was found to be the
dominant SIF compared to the other modes.
RESULTS AND DISCUSSION
The effects of a lead crack and multiple cracking on the strain distribution, fatigue crack growth,
and postfatigue residual strength for both the longitudinal lap joint panels (CVP1 and CVP2) and
the circumferential butt joint panels (CVP3 and CVP4) were studied. In the following sections,
strain survey test results and analytical predictions are first discussed, followed by the fatigue
crack test results, and lastly, the residual strength test results.

12

STRAIN SURVEY.
The strain distribution was measured and predicted at ten equal load increments up to the
maximum values for load sequences 1a through 1c in tables 2 and 3 for the longitudinal lap joint
and circumferential butt joint panels, respectively. The strain gage locations for each joint
configuration are shown in figures 8 and 13 and appendix B. Details of the predicted strains are
provided in appendix D.
The strain survey test was repeated twice using water and twice using air for each panel to verify
the repeatability of the results and determine the effect of the pressurizing media. The raw data
from the strain survey for the strain gages on each panel are listed in the tables in appendix E. In
the tables, for each test condition (1a, 1b, and 1c) and run (Air 1 and 2, Water 1 and 2), applied
loads and strains measured at each gage at each of the ten equal load increments up to the
maximum loads are listed.
The raw data was reduced to remove the strain offset that occurred due to preloading after the
panel was installed in the fixture. In the strain gage data reduction, the first three data points
were removed to minimize the effects of preloading and free play. A linear regression using a
least squares method was used to curve-fit the remaining data set to the following first order
polynomial:

= A + B

(8)

where is the dependent strain variable, the independent load increment variable, A the slope,
and B the ordinate intercept. Parameter B was used to define the zero load offset used to shift all
data in the set. The reduced strain gage data is listed in appendix F at the ten equal load
increments up to the maximum loads for each load sequence. Cross-reference tables in appendix
E list the corresponding values of the applied loads.
In general, for all panels tested, strain gage results from the four runs were repeatable for gages
measuring strain in the principle loading direction. In particular, strains measured in the skin, the
stringer cap, and outer cap of the frames had the least amount of scatter. Strains measured in the
inner frame cap had the most scatter. Complete results are given in appendix F. Representative
results are discussed for each joint configuration in the subsequent sections.
LONGITUDINAL LAP JOINT CONFIGURATION. The hoop strain at a rosette strain gage
located in the skin mid-bay, as a function of applied pressure, is shown in figure 21 for panel
CVP1 (lead crack only) and panel CVP2 (lead crack and multiple cracks). The load was applied
in ten equal increments up to the maximum values listed for test condition 1c (table 2), which
simulates a cylindrical pressurization. For each panel, the test was repeated twice using water
and twice using air. As shown in the figure, the strains are nearly identical for both panels for all
four runs, indicating that small multiple cracks have no effect on the global strain response at the
given load level. As expected, there were no differences in the results when air or water was
used to pressurize the panel.

13

In addition, the three sets of results from the Boeing full-scale test (appendix C) measured from a
rosette strain gage in the skin mid-bay location are plotted in figure 21. The Boeing full-scale
test results are repeatable and match the results from CVP1 and CVP2 panels up to the maximum
pressure of 7.8 psi. This indicates that the loading applied using the FASTER facility closely
resemble the pressurization of a fuselage structure.
Also shown in figure 21 is a plot of the results predicted using the ABAQUS finite element
analysis as described in detail in appendix D. The prediction from analysis shown by the solid
curve in the figure is in good agreement with the experimental data validating the finite element
analysis.
Similar results are shown in figures 22-27 for other strain gage locations for test condition 1c
(table 2). In general, strain gage results from panels CVP1 and CVP2 were repeatable and in
close agreement with the Boeing full-scale test results for the skin mid-bay location (figures 22
and 23) for the outer fame cap (figure 24) and the stringer cap (figure 25). For strain gage results
from the two panels measured at the frame inner cap (figure 26) and the stringer flange (figure
27), the agreement with the Boeing full-scale test results is not as good due to more scatter.
Overall, trends in the results show good agreement with the Boeing full-scale test and provide
confidence that the applied loads were introduced into the panels correctly.
The hoop strain in the skin for panels CVP1 and CVP2 for test condition 1c (table 2) is shown in
figure 28. The data shown for each panel is the average of the four tests conducted. As shown in
the figure, the magnitudes of the measured strains in both panels were similar and the
distributions were nearly uniform in the middle of the panels. Thus, multiple cracking did not
effect the overall strain response.
CIRCUMFERENTIAL BUTT JOINT CONFIGURATION. The longitudinal strain in the skin
mid-bay, as a function of load step, is shown in figure 29 for panel CVP3 (lead crack only) and
panel CVP4 (lead crack and multiple cracks). The load was applied in ten equal increments up
to the maximum values listed for test condition 1c (table 3), which simulates a fuselage down
bend condition. For each panel, the test was repeated twice using water and twice using air. As
shown in the figure, the strains are nearly identical for both panels for all four runs indicating
that small multiple cracks have no effect on the global strain response at the given load levels.
As expected, there were no differences in the results when air or water was used to pressurize the
panel. Predictions from analyses, shown by the curves, were in excellent agreement with the
experimental data.
The longitudinal strain in the skin for panels CVP3 and CVP4 for test condition 1c (table 3) is
shown in figure 30. In addition, the distribution of longitudinal strain in the stringer is shown in
figure 31 for both panels for test condition 1c (table 3). The data shown in both figures for each
panel is the average of the four tests conducted. As shown in the figures, the magnitudes of the
measured strains in both panels were similar.
In general, similar trends in strain gage data were obtained at the other gage locations in the both
joint configurations. That is, experimental results were very repeatable and the analytical
predictions were in good agreement with the test results. Measured strains were nearly uniform

14

in the middle of the panel. This provides confidence that the applied loads were introduced
properly and the models have enough fidelity to capture the mechanical response. In addition,
the small multiple cracks had no effect the global strain response.
FATIGUE CRACK GROWTH.
The fatigue crack growth was measured during the constant amplitude loading, defined by load
sequence 2 in tables 2 and 3 for the longitudinal lap joint and circumferential butt joint panels,
respectively. The growth of the lead crack and the multiple cracks was monitored and recorded.
Details of the analysis procedure and results are provided in appendix D. All experimental
fatigue crack growth data is provided in the tables of appendix G. Representative results are
presented for each joint configuration.
LONGITUDINAL LAP JOINT CONFIGURATION. Photographs of crack extension under
fatigue loading obtained from the RCCM system are shown in figures 32 and 33 for panels
CVP1 and CVP2, respectively. The photographs illustrate the damage growth process from the
original slit to the first neighboring rivet (3R and 3L). The block size of the grid paper on the top
of each photograph is 0.05. In general, for both panels, the crack extension was symmetric and
collinear indicating a symmetric load in the region of the crack. As the crack length increased,
the in-plane crack opening displacement increased indicating Mode I crack growth. Some Mode
III crack growth was assumed to occur where out-of-plane (bulging) deflection of one of the
crack faces occurred opposite to the lap joint along stringer S4. There was little deflection of the
crack face reinforced by the lap joint.
For panel CVP1, the crack growth rate of the lead crack increased as the crack tip approached the
rivet directly ahead. In the test shown in figure 32, after 3850 cycles, the lead crack on the righthand side grew 4.2575 inches and the tip was approximately 0.2 from rivet hole 3R. In the next
40 cycles, the crack grew 0.15 and the tip was only 0.05 from the rivet hole. Shortly
afterwards, at 3916 cycles (an additional 26 cycles) the lead crack grew into rivet hole 3R. A
large number of cycles were required to reform the crack on the opposite side of the rivet hole
(an additional 909 cycles) for a total of 4825 cycles.
For panel CVP2, the crack growth rate of the lead crack and the small crack increased as they
grew closer together. As shown in figure 33, fatigue cracks formed from the small crack notches
at rivets 3L and 3R when the lead crack tip was approximately 0.25 from the small crack notch
tip after 2852 and 3000 cycles, respectively. The lead crack and the smaller crack then grew
faster when at approximately 0.15 apart, the lead crack and the small crack linked up within
four cycles, as shown in the photographs taken on the left side at 2884 and 2888 cycles. The
crack reformed on the opposite side, as shown, after 3000 cycles.
The predicted stress-intensity factor ranges for the lead crack in panels CVP1 and CVP2 are
listed in table 4 and shown in figure 34. The numbers inside the circles along the x axis
represent the location of rivets. As shown in the figure, K1, which governs Mode I crack
growth, is the dominant SIF range. The next highest SIF range, k2, which would cause Mode
III crack growth, was not significant. Thus, as stated earlier, only the Mode I SIF was used to
predict the crack growth. For short crack lengths, the values of the SIF were similar for both
15

panels. For CVP2, the SIF increased compared to CVP1 as the lead crack tip approached the
rivet directly ahead due to the small cracks at the rivet hole.
The half length of the lead crack, as a function of number of fatigue cycles, is shown in figure 35
for panels CVP1 and CVP2. The initial half-crack length prior to loading was 3.5. Loading
condition 2 (table 2) was used to simulate a cylindrical pressurization. In figure 35, the circular
and square symbols represent the measured crack lengths at both the left and the right crack tips,
respectively, for each panel. The numbers inside the circles along the y axis represent the
location of rivets. For panel CVP1, indicated by the open symbols, the vertical jumps indicate
crack extension across a rivet hole. When this happened, the crack length increased
instantaneously by the diameter of the rivet hole. The rate of crack growth increased as the crack
tips approached the rivet holes. The horizontal segments shown in the plot indicate the number
of cycles before the crack reformed on the opposite side of the rivet hole. As the crack length
increased, the delay in crack reformation (incubation period) decreased due to the larger crack
driving force. For panel CVP2, which contained multiple cracks, the vertical jumps in the
experimental data indicate linkup of the lead crack and a small multiple crack. When this
happened, the crack length increased instantaneously by the diameter of the rivet hole plus the
lengths of the small cracks at that rivet. There was no crack reformation. The length of the lead
crack front instantaneously grew the length of the small cracks located in the rivets directly
ahead. As a result, the number of cycles needed to grow the lead crack to the final length
(~12.5 inches) in panel CVP2 was approximately 37%, less than that in panel CVP1.
The Mode I SIF range, K1, (figure 34) and the crack growth data for 2024-T3 aluminum [1719] were used in a cycle-by-cycle crack growth analysis program to predict the fatigue crack
growth in panels CVP1 and CVP2, also shown in figure 35. A complete description of the
analysis procedure is provided in appendix D. Briefly, the rivet holes were not explicitly
modeled in the finite element analysis. For panel CVP1, crack growth across rivet holes,
indicated by the vertical jumps in the curve, was modeled by instantaneously increasing the
length of the crack by the diameter of the rivet hole when the crack reached the rivet. For panel
CVP2, crack growth across the rivets was modeled by instantaneously increasing the length of
the crack by the diameter of the rivet plus the length of the small cracks at the rivet when the lead
crack reached the first small multiple crack. It is important to note that only K1 was used to
predict crack growth since it was the dominant SIF. There were indications of other loading
modes, specifically the Mode III from the k2, calculated from analysis and from the crackbulging deflection observed during the test. Mode III crack growth was not included in the crack
growth analysis due to the lack of experimental crack growth data. Good agreement was
obtained between experiments and predictions relying on K1. For CVP2, the growth of the
small multiple crack in the rivet ahead of the lead crack was not accounted for in the analysis.
In figure 36, the crack tip positions of the lead crack and the small cracks at the rivet holes ahead
of the lead crack are plotted as a function of the number of cycles for panel CVP2. The labeled
circles on the x axis denote the rivets directly ahead of the lead crack on the left and right hand
sides. In general, fatigue cracks formed from the small crack notches when the lead crack tip
was an average distance of 0.426 from the small crack notch tip. The average length of
observable cracks formed from the notches was 0.019. The rate of crack growth of the lead
crack and the small crack increased as their tips grew closer together. Sudden linkup of the lead
16

crack and small crack occurred within an average of four cycles when the average distance of
their tips reached 0.238. In general, this process repeats itself. On one occasion, at rivet 4R, the
lead crack and the small crack grew past each other, as shown in the inset of figure 36.
As the damage grew during fatigue loading, the strain distribution changed as shown in figure 37
for panel CVP2. In this figure, the hoop strain at a gage located in the mid-bay of the skin,
SG35T, and a gage located in a frame, SG10, is plotted as a function of the lead crack length
normalized with respect to the distance of the strain gages from the crack centerline. When this
ratio is equal to one, the crack tip and the strain gage location coincide. For a value less than
one, the crack is growing towards the gage, and for a value greater than one, the crack has grown
past the gage. As shown in the figure, the value of strain in gage SG35T increased as the crack
grew and reached a maximum value when the crack tip and gage location coincided. The value
of strain decreased as the crack grew past the gage SG35T. For gage SG10, the value of strain
increased as the crack grew closer to the gage. The fatigue test was stopped before the crack tip
reached SG10.
CIRCUMFERENTIAL BUTT JOINT CONFIGURATION. Photographs of crack extension
under fatigue loading obtained from the RCCM system are shown in figure 38 and figure 39 for
panels CVP3 and CVP4, respectively. The photographs illustrate the damage growth from the
original slit to the first neighboring rivets on either side (3R and 3L). The block size of the grid
paper on the top of each photograph is 0.05. For panel CVP3, the lead crack growth rate
increased as the crack approached the rivet directly ahead. As shown in figure 38, after 4715
cycles, the lead crack tip was approximately 0.15 from rivet hole 3R. Shortly afterwards, at
4918 cycles, the lead crack grew into rivet hole 3R. An additional 1307 cycles were required for
the crack to reform on the opposite side of the rivet hole.
The crack growth of the lead crack and small crack directly ahead is shown in figure 39 for panel
CVP4. In general, it was observed that when the path of lead crack projected above or below the
rivet directly ahead, the lead crack and adjacent small crack grew past each other. This is shown
in the photographs on the left side of figure 39. If the path of the lead crack was in a direction to
intersect the rivet directly ahead, the crack tips coalesced as shown in the photographs on the
right side of figure 39.
The predicted stress-intensity factor ranges for the lead crack in panels CVP3 and CVP4 are
listed in table 5 and shown in figure 40. The numbers inside the circles along the x axis
represent the location of rivets. As shown in the figure, K1, which governs Mode I crack
growth, is the dominant SIF range. The next highest SIF range, k2, which would cause Mode
III crack growth, was not significant. Thus, as stated earlier, only the Mode I SIF was used to
predict the crack growth. For short crack lengths, the values of the SIF were similar for both
panels. For CVP4, the SIF increased, compared to CVP3, as the lead crack tip approached the
rivet directly ahead due to the small cracks at the rivet hole. In both cases, for crack lengths
longer than the stringer spacing of 7.5, the SIF range reduced due to the stiffening of stringers
bridging the crack.
The fatigue crack growth behavior of panels CVP3 and CVP4 is shown in figure 41. The initial
half crack length prior to loading was approximately 3.5. Loading condition 2 (table 3) was
17

used to simulate a narrow-body fuselage down bending where the longitudinal stress was 50%
higher than the hoop stress. In figure 41, the circular and square symbols represent the measured
crack lengths of the left and the right crack tips, respectively, from both panels. The numbers
inside the circles along the y axis indicate the locations of the rivets. For panel CVP3, crack
growth across a rivet hole is indicated by a vertical jump in the data, where the crack length
instantaneously increases by a length equal to the hole diameter. The horizontal segments shown
in the plot indicate the incubation period or the number of cycles for the crack to reform on the
opposite side of the rivet hole. For panel CVP4, which contained multiple cracks, the vertical
jumps in the experimental data indicate the point when the lead crack and small multiple crack
linked up. When this happened, the crack length increased instantaneously by the diameter of
the rivet hole plus the lengths of the small cracks at that rivet. There was no crack reformation.
The small crack at the rivet hole on the opposite side became the new lead crack front. As a
result, the number of cycles to grow the lead crack to the third rivet hole in panel CVP4 was
approximately 27% less than that in panel CVP3. At the third rivet holes, 5R and 5L, the crack
tips had just reached the first intact stringers (S3 and S5), increasing the incubation period for
panel CVP3 and decreasing the subsequent crack growth rate for both panels.
The Mode I SIF range, K1, (figure 40) and the crack growth data for 2024-T3 aluminum [1719] were used in a cycle-by-cycle crack growth analysis program to predict the fatigue crack
growth in panels CVP3 and CVP4, also shown in figure 41. Details of the analysis procedure are
provided in appendix D. Briefly, the analysis based on K1 was in good agreement with the test
data for crack growth in both panels until the crack reached the third rivet hole. Little crack
bulging was observed during the test, indicating that the crack growth was primarily due to Mode
I loading.
The crack tip positions of the lead crack and the small cracks at the rivet holes ahead of the lead
crack is plotted as a function of the number of cycles for panel CVP4 in figure 42. In general,
fatigue cracks formed from the small crack notches when the lead crack tip was an average
distance of 0.283 from the small crack notch tip. The average length of observable cracks
formed from the notches was 0.0115. The crack tips coalesced at rivets 3R and 4R while they
grew past each other at rivets 3L, 4L, 5L, and 5R, as shown in the inset of figure 42. Cracks
typically reformed from the notch tip of the crack on the opposite side once linkup occurred or as
soon as the two cracks grew past each other.
Strain redistribution occurred as fatigue cracks formed and grew in panels CVP3 and CVP4 as
shown in figure 43. In this figure, the longitudinal strain at a gage located in the mid-bay of the
skin, SG36L, and a gage located in a stringer, SG26, is plotted as a function of the lead crack
length normalized with respect to the distance of the strain gages from the crack centerline for
both panels. When this ratio is equal to one, the crack tip has grown to the strain gage location.
For a ratio value less than one, the crack is growing towards the gage, and for a ratio value
greater than one, the crack has grown past the gage. As shown in the figure, the strain measured
in gage SG36L in both panels reaches a maximum when the crack tip and gage location
coincided. The value of strain decreased as the crack grew past gage SG36L. For gage SG26,
the measured strain increased as the crack grew closer to the gage and is maximum when the
crack grew up to the gage. Note that the trends of the results for both panels are nearly identical.
This provides confidence that the applied loadings, data acquisition characteristics, and test

18

procedure were the same for both panels, that the test data is repeatable and reliable, and that the
small multiple cracks had no effect on the global strain response.
COMPARISONS WITH OTHER DATA. The fatigue crack growth data generated in this study
was compared with similar data previously generated by Boeing Aircraft Company [20] on widebody panels using a full-barrel test fixture. Similar to the damage in the CVP1 and CVP2 panels,
the initial damage configuration for the Boeing wide-body panels consisted of a two-bay crack in
the outer rivet row of a longitudinal lap joint with (test 2) and without (test 1) smaller, collinear
multiple cracks approximately 0.05 long. Unlike the CVP1 and CVP2 panels representing a
narrow-body aircraft fuselage structure, the Boeing panels represented wide-body aircraft
fuselage structure having a radius of 127. Other differences include the joint configuration,
substructure details, and the loading fixture. The raw data for the Boeing full-scale test is shown
in table H-1 of appendix H for a baseline panel containing only a lead crack, test 1, and a second
panel containing the same lead crack configuration with the addition of multiple cracks, test 2.
For panel test 1, a 5 saw cut was made in the central tear strap and the outer rivet row of the
skin placed symmetrically across a frame. The lead crack tips terminated at fastener holes.
Consequently, no cracks developed after 1170 cycles. Similar phenomena was observed in panel
CVP1 after the lead crack grew into a fastener hole, a number of cycles were required to reform
a crack on the opposite side of a hole. For test 1, the lead crack tips were saw cut 0.25 beyond
the fastener holes to a length of 5.71, and the test was resumed. Stable fatigue crack growth
occurred up to 3101 cycles, where the total crack length was 36.91, at which fatigue loading
was terminated.
For panel test 2, small multiple cracks were saw cut in the outer rivet row of the skin. In
addition, a 5 saw cut was placed symmetrically across a frame in the outer critical rivet row of
the skin. The tips of the lead crack extended 0.05 beyond the fastener holes. Unlike panel test
1, the central tear strap was intact prior to testing panel test 2. After 281 cycles, no crack growth
was observed in panel test 2 and the tear strap was cut to match the initial condition in panel
test 1. The test was then resumed. Stable crack growth occurred up to 1231 cycles, where the
total crack length was 17.20. At 1233 cycles, dynamic crack extension occurred, where the
total crack length was 37.44, at which fatigue testing was terminated.
To compare the results from panel test 1 and panel test 2, the raw data was reduced (appendix H)
so that the initial damage configurations and corresponding cycle counts in both panels
matchedan initial crack length of 5.71 with the central tear strap severed. For panel test 1, the
cycle count data was shifted by 1171 cycles corresponding to a crack length of 5.71. For test 2,
the cycle count data was shifted by 451 cycles corresponding to a crack length of 5.71, which
was approximated using a linear interpolation. In addition, the final crack lengths used were
matched to correspond to stable fatigue crack growth. For panel test 1, the final crack length
assumed in the comparison was 17.20, which was selected to best compare with that in panel
test 2, where the final crack length for stable cracking was 17.30. The reduced data is shown in
table H-2 in appendix H for panel tests 1 and 2.
A comparison of the fatigue crack growth data generated for CVP1 and CVP2 panel with the
Boeing full-scale barrel panels, test 1 and test 2, is shown in figure 44. The circular symbols are
19

the data set from the CVP1 (baseline) and the CVP2 (multiple crack) panels. The square
symbols are the data set from the Boeing test for the baseline panel containing only a lead crack
(test 1) and for the second panel containing the same lead crack configuration with the addition
of multiple cracks (test 2). For each data set in the figure, the crack length data and the cycle
count data were normalized with respect to the final crack length and final cycle count for the
baseline panel. As shown in figure 44, the normalized fatigue crack growth data from both sets
have similar rates. In addition, both data sets show that small multiple crack caused a reduction
in the number of cycles to grow the crack to a predetermined length. For the current study, a
37% reduction was measured; and for the Boeing full-scale barrel tests, a 54% reduction was
measured.
RESIDUAL STRENGTH.
After the fatigue loading, each panel was loaded quasi-statically to failure to measure the crack
growth and residual strength. The lead crack length for the longitudinal lap joint panels (CVP1
and CVP2) was approximately 25 and for the circumferential butt joint panels (CVP3 and
CVP4) was approximately 19. For longitudinal lap joint panels, the frame directly underneath
the crack centerline, frame F4, was cut prior to the residual strength test to simulate a broken
frame. For the circumferential butt joint panels, stringer S4 had already been cut to simulate a
broken stringer. All the residual strength data is provided in the tables of appendix I.
Representative results are presented for each joint configuration.
LONGITUDINAL LAP JOINT CONFIGURATION. Results from the residual strength test of
panels CVP1 and CVP2 are shown in figure 45, where the square and circular symbols represent
the crack extension for the left and right crack tips, respectively. The numbers inside the circles
along the x axis indicate a rivet location. During the test, cylinderical pressurization was applied
quasi-statically, and the crack extension measured up to panel failure. In the initial stages of
loading, slow stable crack extension was observed in both panels up to 10.25 psi pressure for
panel CVP1 and 8.5 psi pressure for panel CVP2. The crack grew rapidly through rivets 9
through 11 on both the right and left side to the first intact frames (F3 and F5) for both panels,
and then were arrested. An increase of pressure was required to grow the cracks past the frames
in both panels, and stable crack extension continued until catastrophic failure occurred at 11.14
psi for panel CVP1 and 9.16 psi for panel CVP2. The presence of multiple cracks reduced the
residual strength by approximately 20%.
The position of the lead crack tip and the small multiple crack tips at rivets 9R through 18R are
plotted as a function of the applied pressure in figure 46 for the right side of panel CVP2. In the
figure, the point at which the lead crack and small crack directly ahead of it coalesced is called
the linkup position and is indicated in the plot by the two arrowheads in contact. The direction
of crack growth, right or left, is indicated by the arrowheads. Initially, stable crack extension of
the lead crack occurred where an increase in applied pressure to 8.44 psi was required to grow
the crack. At 8.44 psi, the lead crack and the small crack at rivet 9R linked. The crack at rivet
9R had grown during the loading, so the new crack front was at approximately 14. The applied
pressure was increased to 8.57 psi, where the lead crack and small cracks at rivets 10R through
15R suddenly merged. Crack growth was then arrested due to the intact frame located at rivet
13R. With increase in the applied pressure to 8.60, 8.8, and 9.019 psi, linkup occurred between

20

the lead crack and small multiple cracks at rivets 15R, 16R, and 17R, respectively. At an applied
pressure of 9.16 psi, panel CVP2 failed catastrophically. It was observed that the lengths of the
small multiple cracks at linkup were nearly constant with an average length of 0.3697.
CIRCUMFERENTIAL BUTT JOINT CONFIGURATION. The load application points failed
prematurely during the residual strength test of panel CVP3. A tab end failed first at the
longitudinal load application point as shown in figure 47. During the original fatigue loading of
CVP3, a fatigue crack initiated from a manufacturing flaw at the stop-drill hole at the end of a
load transfer slot. The fatigue crack grew and caused the end tab to break during the first
residual strength test attempt. The tab end was repaired and the residual strength test was
resumed. The tab ends at several longitudinal load application points then failed as shown in
figure 48. At these locations, the tab ends delaminated, resulting in bearing failures of the tab
ends. All tab ends were then reinforced with several layers of 4130A steel doublers as shown in
figure 49. The doubler layers were cold bonded using EA9309.3NA and bolted together using
NAS 6204 and 6205 steel bolts. After reinforcing all tab ends at the longitudinal load
application points, the residual strength test was resumed and the panel failed in the test section
during the third test attempt.
Results from three residual strength tests for panel CVP3 are shown in figure 50, where each of
the three runs is shown using different symbols. Crack growth began at a pressure of 17 psi in
the first run. Stable tearing then occurred up to a pressure of 19.1 psi. At this point, one of the
load attachment points failed and the test was stopped. The broken load attachment point was
repaired and the test was restarted from zero load. During the second run, the panel was loaded
monotonically up to a pressure of 18.4 psi, then stringer S3 broke causing a large amount of
crack extension at the left crack tip. One of the longitudinal load application reinforcement
doublers delaminated at one of the load application points. After repairing the panel a second
time, the panel was loaded again. In the third run, stringer S5 failed at an applied pressure of 17
psi, causing the crack to extend to the next intact stringers S2 and S6. The panel then failed
catastrophically at a pressure of 17.9 psi. Note that after each attempt of residual strength, the
maximum load reduced.
The effect of multiple cracking on the residual strength of the circumferential butt joints cannot
be accurately quantified since the final residual strength of panel CVP3 could not be determined.
However, the effect of multiple cracking on the damage growth process can be seen using the
first test done for the residual strength. Figure 51 shows the results from the first residual
strength test for panel CVP3 and the residual strength test for panel CVP4. In this figure, the
numbers inside the circles along the x axis indicate the location of rivets. For panel CVP3,
growth of the lead crack was slow and stable up to rivet 7. A continuous increase in load was
required to extend the crack. However, the load attachment point failed prematurely. For panel
CVP4, once the lead crack started to grow, the subsequent growth was very rapid through rivet 7.
Catastrophic failure of panel CVP4 occurred at a pressure of 20.75 psi.
The position of the lead crack tip and the small multiple crack tips at rivets 6L through 12L is
plotted as a function of the applied pressure in figure 52 for the left side of panel CVP4. In the
figure, the point at which the lead crack and small crack directly ahead coalesce is called the
linkup position and is shown in the plot by the two arrowheads in contact. The direction of crack

21

growth, left or right, is indicated by the arrowheads. At an applied pressure of 20 psi, the lead
crack and the small crack at rivet 7L linked up. The crack from rivet 7L continued to grow on
further increase in applied pressure. At an applied pressure of 20.75 psi, panel CVP4 failed
catastrophically. The lengths of the small multiple cracks at linkup were nearly constant, with an
average length of 0.4374.
COMPARISON WITH OTHER DATA. The residual strength data generated in this study was
compared with similar data previously generated by the Boeing Aircraft Company [20 and 21]
on wide-body panels, using a full-barrel test fixture, and by Foster Miller [22] on narrow-body
panels, using a panel pressurization fixture. The Boeing panels tested [20 and 21] represented
wide-body aircraft fuselage structure having a radius of 127. For the panels tested in reference
20, a floating frame construction was used and for the panels tested in reference 21, a shear-tied
frame construction was used. Similar to FAA longitudinal lap joint panels CVP1 and CVP2, the
Boeing panels had an initial damage configuration of a two-bay crack in the outer rivet row of a
longitudinal lap joint with and without smaller, collinear multiple cracks with a length of
approximately 0.05. In addition, the central frame was severed.
The Foster Miller (FM) panels tested [22] represented narrow-body fuselage structure having a
radius of 75. Different from the two-bay crack configurations for the FAA and Boeing tests, the
FM panels had an initial damage configuration of a single-bay crack in the outer rivet row of a
longitudinal lap joint with and without smaller, collinear multiple cracks with a length of
approximately 0.05. Other differences among the FAA, Boeing, and FM tests include the joint
configuration, skin thickness, substructure details, and the loading fixture employed.
The reduction of residual strength due to multiple cracks measured in these tests is compared in
figure 53. As shown in three of the four tests, an approximate 20% reduction in the residual
strength was measured. For the shear-tied panels tested by Boeing [21], the residual strength
was reduced by ~10% due to multiple cracks.
POSTTEST OBSERVATIONS AND ANALYSIS.
After the residual strength tests, all panels were examined to determine the extent of damage. In
general, the final state of damage was similar for the two panels of each joint configuration.
Posttest analysis of the strains was conducted to interpret the observed damage.
LONGITUDINAL LAP JOINT CONFIGURATION. The final state of damage in panel CVP1
is shown in the photographs in figure 54 (the final state of damage in panel CVP2 was similar).
As shown in the figure, the skin crack grew to a length of approximately 68. A large amount of
permanent bulging of the crack faces occurred. A considerable amount of damage occurred to
the substructure as frames F3 and F5 were fractured (frame F4 was cut prior to the residual
strength test).
Analysis of the residual strength test data of panels CVP1 and CVP2 shows that frames F3 and
F5 fractured due to load transfer from the skin to the frame as the crack grew. In both panels, the
frame failure occurred from the hi-lok connecting the outer flange of the frame to the stinger as
shown in the photograph in figure 55 for CVP1. In both panels, a strain gage was located in the

22

frame approximately 3 from this crack site. The strain measured by the strain gage and the
crack length is plotted as a function of applied pressure for panels CVP1 and CVP2 in the graph
in figure 55. As shown, the value of strain increased gradually with pressure. When the crack
reached frame F5 there was an abrupt increase in the strain. Values of strain of 4958 and
5219 were measured in frame F5 at failure for panels CVP1 and CVP2, respectively.
CIRCUMFERENTIAL BUTT JOINT CONFIGURATION. The final state of damage in panel
CVP3 is shown in figures 56 and 57 (the final state of damage in panel CVP4 was similar). The
photographs in figure 56 show the crack path along the original rivet row, the change in crack
path from the original rivet row, and the fractured doublers at the load transfer slots. Once the
doublers fractured, the panel was broken completely in half. A considerable amount of damage
occurred to the substructure where all seven stringers fractured during the residual strength test
as shown in the photographs in figure 57.
The maximum strain measured in stringer S5 is plotted as a function of applied pressure in figure
58 for both panels. Data plotted for panel CVP3 is from the first residual strength test attempt.
As shown, the value of strain increased linearly as the pressure increased. Values of strain of
3710 and 3992 were measured in frame S5 at failure for panels CVP3 and CVP4,
respectively.
CONCLUDING REMARKS
An experimental and analytical investigation was undertaken to assess the effects of multiple
cracking on the fatigue crack growth and residual strength characteristics of curved panels with
either a longitudinal lap splice or a circumferential butt joint. The Full-Scale Aircraft Structural
Test Evaluation and Research (FASTER) facility was used to apply realistic loading conditions
to curved panels representing fuselage sections. Both quasi-static and constant-amplitude fatigue
loadings were applied to the panels. A geometrically nonlinear finite element analysis was used
to determine the strain distribution in the panels and the fracture parameters necessary for
predicting the fatigue crack growth behavior of the panel were calculated.
A total of four panels were tested, two panels with a longitudinal lap splice and two with a
circumferential butt joint. For each joint configuration, one panel contained only a lead crack
and the other contained a lead crack with small multiple cracks. Strains were measured under
quasi-static loading conditions to ensure proper load introduction to the panels. The strain
measurements were highly repeatable and were in good agreement with the finite element
analyses. The presence of multiple cracks did not affect the overall global strain response.
In general, symmetric, collinear crack propagation was observed under constant-amplitude
fatigue loading for the four panels tested. Reasonable agreement was obtained between
experimental fatigue crack growth data and predictions relying on the Mode I stress-intensity
factors calculated from finite element analyses of the test panels. The number of cycles to grow
a fatigue crack to a predetermined length was reduced by approximately 37% due to the presence
of multiple cracks for the longitudinal lap joint panels and 27% for the circumferential butt joint
panels.

23

Residual strength tests were conducted on each panel after the fatigue loading. For the curved
panels with the longitudinal lap splice, the initial damage consisted of a two-bay crack with a
length of approximately 25 with the central frame cut. The presence of multiple cracks reduced
the residual strength of the panels with a longitudinal lap joint by approximately 20%. For the
curved panels with the circumferential butt joint, the initial damage consisted of a four-bay crack
with a length of approximately 19 with the central stringer cut. The residual strength of the
baseline panel containing only a lead crack was not measured due to premature failures at the
load application points. Consequently, the effect of multiple cracks on the residual strength of
the circumferential butt joint configuration could not be quantified. However, it was observed
that the growth of lead crack into the first rivet was more rapid for the panel containing multiple
cracks.
REFERENCES
1.

Newman, J.C., Jr., A Crack-Closure Model for Predicting Fatigue Crack Growth Under
Aircraft Spectrum Loading, American Society for Testing and Materials, USA, Special
Technical Publication 748, 1981, pp. 53-84.

2.

Newman, J.C., Finite Element Analysis of Crack Growth Under Monotonic and Cyclic
Loading, American Society for Testing and Materials, USA, Special Technical
Publication 637, 1977, pp. 56-80.

3.

Harris, C.E., Newman, J.C., Piascik, R.S., and Starnes, J.H., Analytical Methodology for
Predicting the Onset of Widespread Fatigue Damage in Fuselage Structure, Proceedings
of FAA-NASA Symposium on Continued Airworthiness of Aircraft Structures,
DOT/FAA/AR-97/2, July 1997.

4.

Atluri, S.N. and Nishioka, T., Engineering Fracture Mechanics, Vol. 20, 1984, pp. 209244.

5.

Wang, L., Brust, F.W., and Atluri, S.N., Predictions of Stable Growth of a Lead Crack
and Multiple-Site Damage Using Elastic-Plastic Finite Element Alternating Method
(EPFEAM), Proceedings of FAA-NASA Symposium on Continued Airworthiness of
Aircraft Structures, DOT/FAA/AR-97/2, July 1997.

6.

Broek, D., Effects of Multi-Site Damage on the Arrest Capability of Aircraft Fuselage
Structures, FractuREsearch, Inc., USA, TR 9302, 1993.

7.

Swift, T., Widespread Fatigue Damage MonitoringIssues and Concerns, Proceedings


of 5th International Conference on Structural Airworthiness of New and Aging Aircraft,
Federal Republic of Germany, DGLR-Bericht 93-02, 1993, pp. 133-150.

8.

Bakuckas, J.G., Nguyen, P.V., and Bigelow, C.A., Bulging Factors for Predicting
Residual Strength of Fuselage Panels, Proceedings of the 19th Symposium of the
International Committee on Aeronautical Fatigue, ICAF 97, Edinburgh, United
Kingdom, 1997, pp. 179-196.

24

9.

Tan, P.W, Bigelow, C.A., and Bakuckas, J.G., Jr., Widespread Fatigue Damage
Assessment, Applied Vehicle Technology Panel (AVT), Life Management Techniques
for Aging Air Vehicles, Manchester, UK, 8-11 October 2001.

10.

Bakuckas, J.G., Jr., Bigelow, C.A., and Tan, P.W., The FAA Full-Scale Aircraft
Structural Test Evaluation and Research (FASTER) Facility, Proceedings from the
International Workshop on Technical Elements for Aviation Safety, Tokyo, Japan, 1999,
pp. 158-170.

11.

Bakuckas, J.G., Jr., Akpan, E., Zhang, P., Bigelow, C.A., Tan, P.W., Awerbuch, J., Lau,
A., and Tan, T.M., Experimental and Analytical Assessments of Multiple-Site Cracking
in Aircraft Fuselage Structure, Proceedings of the 20th Symposium of the International
Committee on Aeronautical Fatigue, Seattle, Washington, USA, July 14-15, 1999.

12.

ABAQUS Version 5.8, Hibbitt, Karlsson, and Sorensen (HKS), 1080 Main Street,
Pawtucket, RI 02860, USA, 1998.

13.

Swift, T., Development of the Fail-Safe Design Features of the DC-10, American
Society for Testing and Materials Special Technical Publication 486, 1970, pp. 164-214.

14.

Rybicki, E.F. and Kanninen, M.F., A Finite Element Calculation of Stress-Intensity


Factors by a Modified Crack Closure Integral, Engineering Fracture Mechanics, Vol. 9,
1977, pp. 931-938.

15.

Potyondy, D.O., Ph.D. Thesis, School of Civil and Environmental Engineering, Cornell
University 1993.

16.

Viz, M.J., Potyondy, D.O., and Zehnder, A.T., Computation of Membrane and Bending
Stress-Intensity factors for Thin, Cracked Plates, International Journal of Fracture, Vol.
72, 1995, pp. 21-38.

17.

Hudson, C.M., Effect of Stress Ratio on Fatigue Crack Growth in 7075-T6 and 2024-T3
Aluminum Alloy Specimens, NASA TN D-5390, 1969.

18.

Phillips, E.P., The Influence of Crack Closure on Fatigue Crack Growth Thresholds in
2024-T3 Aluminum Alloys, ASTM STP 982, 1988, pp. 505-515.

19.

Dubensky, R.G., Fatigue Crack Propagation in 2024-T3 and 7075-T6 Aluminum Alloys
at High Stress, NASA CR-1732, 1971.

20.

Gruber, M.L., Mazur, C.J, Wilkens, K.E., and Worden, R.E., Investigation of Fuselage
Structure Subjected to Widespread Fatigue Damage, DOT/FAA/AR-95/47, 1996.

21.

Miller, M., Gruber, M.L., C.J, Wilkens, K.E., and Worden, R.E., Full-Scale Testing and
Analysis of Fuselage Structure, FAA/NASA International Symposium on Advanced

25

Structural Integrity Methods for Airframe Durability and Damage Tolerance, NASA
Conference Publication 3274, Part 1, pp. 481-496, 1994.
22.

Samavedam, G. and Hoadley, D., Fracture and Fatigue Strength Evaluation of Mutiple
Site Damaged Aircraft Fuselages Curved Panel Testing and Analysis, DOT/FAA/CT94/10, 1994.

26

Full Assembly

Exploded View
Shear Fixture
Test Specimen

Pressure Box and


Frame Load
Assembly
Base Structure, Hoop
and Longitudinal Load
Assemblies

FIGURE 1. FULL-SCALE AIRCRAFT STRUCTURAL TEST EVALUATION AND


RESEARCH (FASTER) FIXTURE
Load Cell

Displacement, u2

Length, l2
Whiffle Tree
Assembly
Fulcrum
Pivot Point
Length, l1

Lever Arm

Displacement, u1

Water Actuator

FIGURE 2. SCHEMATIC OF LONGITUDINAL AND HOOP LOADING MECHANISM


27

Counter Balance Support


Poles

Reaction Structure

Displacement, u2

Counter Balance Weights

Water Actuator
Shear Arm Lever
Shear Arm Pivot

Displacement, u2

Hoop Ski

Keyway

Longitudinal Ski

FIGURE 3. SCHEMATIC OF SHEAR LOADING MECHANISM


Stringer
Curved Panel Skin

Frame Load Link

Frame

Elastomeric
Rubber Seal
Pressure Box
Displacement,
u2

Radial Reaction Link


Frame Lever Arm

Displacement, u1

Fulcrum Pivot Point

Water Actuator

FIGURE 4. SCHEMATIC OF FRAME LOADING MECHANISM

28

Load Link

Feedback Signal
Specimen

Lever Arm
Fulcrum
Water Actuator

Control Input Signal


(0 - 10 volts)
Air Supply Pressure, 130 psi
E/P Valve
Air Inlet Pressure
(0.7 to 127 psi)

Water Outlet Pressure

3 Water Supply Manifold

Pressure Gage

Water Supply Pressure, 60 psi


Constant Flow
Orifice Valve

Pressure Regulator
Dome Valve

Water Exit

4 Water Return Manifold

FIGURE 5. SCHEMATIC OF THE HYDRAULIC AND PNEUMATIC SYSTEM


Signal

Target
Shold

Cmd
Proportional Error
Correction

Dhold

Fbk

Cmd

Pgain Err

Omax
Cmd
Omin

+Dumpl
+

Err

-Dumpl

Integral Error +I + +
lim
Correction
Ecor Load System
+
Igain d ( Err ) dt
-Ilim
+

EP

Time

Derivative Error
Correction
Dgain

d ( Err )
dt

Fbk

FIGURE 6. SCHEMATIC OF THE PROPORTIONAL INTEGRAL DERIVATIVE (PID)


CLOSED-LOOP ERROR CORRECTION PROCESS
29

Mechanical Frame Assembly


Motion Control Assembly
4 Square
Aluminum Tube
24 by 24
Translation Stage
4 Square
Aluminum Tube

36 by 12
Translation Stages

10 Periscope
Stages

WFOV Lens
NFOV Lens

FIGURE 7. PHOTOGRAPHS OF FASTER FACILITY AND RCCM SYSTEM

Stringer Detail

Frame Detail

Crack Location

22

23

1
a

F1

F2

F3

F4

F5

F6

S1
b

S2
S3
66

S4

45 T
L 29

45 T
L 30

23

45 T 31 6
L 32

34

22
21

b
24
3

26

T
5 45
L 33

25 45

T 12
9 L 35 28
45 T 27

10

S5

11

45

7
14

L 34

56 68

13

L 36

S6

15

16

18

17

20

19

7.5

3.5

S7
19

60
112
120

FIGURE 8. CVP1 AND CVP2 PANEL CONFIGURATION AND STRAIN GAGE


LOCATIONS
30

Intersect of Stringer and Frame

Frame and Shear Clip


Dimensions

Left View

Right View

0.75

MS20470AD6

0.063

NAS1097AD6

1.0
1.375

Stringer

1.75
HL518-6

2.25

1.25
0.071

Shear Clip

1.0
Frame

0.375
0.875
F6

F5

F4

Stringer Dimensions
F3

F2

F1

0.625

S7
S6
S5

0.875

S4

0.063 for all stringers except S4


0.071 for S4

S3
S2

0.1875

S1

0.625

FIGURE 9. DIMENSIONS OF FRAMES, STRINGERS, SHEAR CLIPS, AND INTERSECT


OF STRINGER AND FRAME
Inner Surface

Outer Surface

Crack-Like Slit

FIGURE 10. PHOTOGRAPHS OF PANEL CVP1 SHOWING THE INNER AND OUTER
SURFACES AND THE INITIAL CRACK-LIKE SLIT

31

F6

F5

F4

F3

F2

F1

0.063

S7

0.025

S6
S5

Fastener Row A:
MS20470AD5

S4
S3
S2

A (2 : 1)

S1

0.063
Fastener Row B:
MS20470AD6

Outer Skin
AA

0.025

1.5

Outer Finger
Doubler

A
0.875

Fastener Row C:
NAS1097AD6

1.250

0.813

C
Stinger

B (2 : 1)

0.875

0.071
C (2 : 1)

Fastener Row D:
MS20470AD5

AA

Inner Skin

AA-AA
D (2 : 1)

Inner Finger Doubler

FIGURE 11. JOINT CONFIGURATION FOR PANELS CVP1 AND CVP2

Rivet Row A

Multiple Cracks (CVP2 Only)

Lead Crack
(CVP1 & CVP2)

F5

F4
0.1"

18L 17L 16L 15L 14L 13L 12L 11L 10L 9L 8L 7L 6L 5L 4L 3L 2L 1L

0.15"

0.05"

0.1"

00 1R 2R 3R 4R 5R 6R 7R 8R 9R 10R 11R 12R 13R 14R 15R 16R 17R 18R

7"
0.1"

0.05"

0.15"

19

0.1"

Multiple Cracks (CVP2 Only)

CL

F3

AA

A
B

0.012"
Saw Cut

0.008"
Wire Cut

0.008"
Wire Cut

0.5"

D
AA

Rivet Row Designation

AA-AA

Lead Crack Tip


Configuration, Rivets 2R
and 2L

Multiple Crack Length


Configuration, Rivets 3R
and 3L to 18R and 18L

FIGURE 12. INITIAL DAMAGE CONFIGURATIONS FOR PANELS CVP1 AND CVP2
32

Crack Location

F1

F2

S1

F3

10

S2
S3
66

19

17

S4
3

18

S5
S6
S7

31
19

20

F4

Stringer Saw-Cut

F5

F6

34

11
1 13 32 12
15
14
33 16
2
21

23
7 24

5 22 36, 37
25
27
28
26
8 9 39, 40 29
30

34, 35 6

56 68

38

7.5

3.5

60
112
120

FIGURE 13. CVP3 AND CVP4 PANEL CONFIGURATIONS AND STRAIN GAGE
LOCATIONS
Inner Surface

Outer Surface

Crack-Like Slit

FIGURE 14. PHOTOGRAPHS OF PANEL CVP3 SHOWING THE INNER AND OUTER
SURFACES AND THE INITIAL CRACK-LIKE SLIT

33

0.063

0.025

AA
Skin

Fastener Rows
A and H:
MS20470AD5

1.500

Finger
Doubler

A (2 : 1)

C
D
Tapered
Doubler

Fastener Rows
B, C, F and G:
NAS1097AD6

0.75

CL

0.625

0.75

B (2 : 1)

0.625

0.75

0.875

0.071

Skin

AA

Fastener Rows
D and E:
S4931919-6
Hi-Lok Pin

AA-AA
D (2 : 1)

FIGURE 15. JOINT CONFIGURATION FOR PANELS CVP3 AND CVP4

Lead Crack
(CVP3 & CVP4)
S2

S3

Stringer Saw Cut


(CVP3 & CVP4)
S4

Multiple Cracks (CVP4 Only)


S5
0.05"

0.1"
Rivet Row A

12L 11L

10L

9L 8L 7L 6L

5L

4L 3L 2L 1L

00 1R 2R 3R 4R

5R

7"
0.05"

6R 7R 8R 9R

10R

11R 12R

7.5

0.1"

Multiple Cracks (CVP4 Only)

S6

CL

A
B
C
D

0.008"
Wire Cut

0.012"
Saw Cut

E
F
G
H
Rivet Row Designation

0.008"
Wire Cut

0.5"

Lead Crack Tip


Configuration, Rivets 2R
and 2L

Multiple Crack Length


Configuration, Rivets 3R to
12R, and 3L to 12L

FIGURE 16. INITIAL DAMAGE CONFIGURATIONS FOR PANELS CVP3 AND CVP4

34

FIGURE 17. BOEING AFT FUSELAGE SECTION TEST ARTICLE

Location B, Stringer Cap


Location C, Stringer Flange

Location F, Frame Outer Cap


Location E, Frame Inner Cap

Location A, Skin Mid-Bay

FIGURE 18. LOCATION OF STRAIN GAGES IN AFT FUSELAGE SECTION TEST


ARTICLE
35

Full Assembly

Skin

Longitudinal Load

Hoop Load

Finger Doubler

Stringer
Detail

Substructure

Crack Area

Frame - Shear Clip


Detail

Frame Load

8-noded elements

FIGURE 19. FINITE ELEMENT MODEL OF CVP3 SHOWING FULL ASSEMBLY AND
SUBSTRUCTURE COMPONENTS

u~ top =

top
i

i =1

KI

KII

u~ bot =

uibot

~
F close =

close

i =1

i =1

2
5

k1

k2

6
D.O.F

FIGURE 20. DEFINITION OF FOUR STRESS-INTENSITY FACTORS AND CRACK TIP


ELEMENTS AND NODES FOR COMPUTING THE RATE OF WORK DONE TO
CLOSE A CRACK USING THE MCCI METHOD
36

Strain Gage Location


Load Cond. 1c
Pressure

1000

Max. Load
10.1 psi

Hoop Load

554.6 lb/in

Frame Load

111.9 lb/in

Long. Load

333.3 lb/in

800
600

Hoop
Strain ()

Boeing Full-Scale Test


Test 1
Test 2
Test 3

400

CVP1

Air, Run 1
Air, Run 1
Air, Run 2
Air, Run 2
Water, Run 1
Water, Run 1
Water, Run 2
Water, Run 2
FAA-TC Panel Analysis

200
0

-200

CVP2 (Multiple Cracks)

10

12

Applied Pressure (psi)


FIGURE 21. HOOP STRAIN IN GAGE LOCATED AT SKIN MID-BAY IN PANELS CVP1
AND CVP2 AND BOEING FULL-SCALE TEST ARTICLE
Load Cond. 1c

Max. Load

Pressure

600

10.1 psi

Hoop Load

500

554.6 lb/in

Frame Load

111.9 lb/in

Long. Load

333.3 lb/in

Strain Gage Location

400

Boeing Full-Scale Test

45o Strain ()

Test 1
Test 2
Test 3

300
200

CVP1

100
0
-100

CVP2 (Multiple Cracks)


Air, Run 1
Air, Run 2
Water, Run 1
Water, Run 2

Air, Run 1
Air, Run 2
Water, Run 1
Water, Run 2

10

12

Applied Pressure (psi)

FIGURE 22. FORTY-FIVE DEGREE STRAIN IN GAGE LOCATED AT SKIN MID-BAY IN


PANELS CVP1 AND CVP2 AND BOEING FULL-SCALE TEST ARTICLE

37

Load Cond. 1c
Pressure

250
200

Max. Load
10.1 psi

Hoop Load

554.6 lb/in

Frame Load

111.9 lb/in

Long. Load

333.3 lb/in

Strain Gage Location

150

Longitudinal
Strain ()

Boeing Full-Scale Test


Test 1
Test 2
Test 3

100
50

CVP1

0
-50

CVP2 (Multiple Cracks)

Air, Run 1
Air, Run 2
Water, Run 1
Water, Run 2
0

Air, Run 1
Air, Run 2
Water, Run 1
Water, Run 2

10

12

Applied Pressure (psi)


FIGURE 23. LONGITUDINAL STRAIN IN GAGE LOCATED AT SKIN MID-BAY IN
PANELS CVP1 AND CVP2 AND BOEING FULL-SCALE TEST ARTICLE
Load Cond. 1c

600

Hoop L oad

500

Frame Hoop
Strain ()

Max. Load

Pressure

10.1 psi
554.6 lb/in

Frame Load

111.9 lb/in

Long. Load

333.3 lb/in

400

Boeing Full-Scale Test


Test 1
Test 2
Test 3

300
200

Strain Gage Location

CVP1

Air, Run 1
Air, Run 2
Water, Run 1
Water, Run 2

100
0
0

CVP2 (Multiple Cracks)


Air, Run 1
Air, Run 2
Water, Run 1
Water, Run 2

10

12

Applied Pressure (psi)


FIGURE 24. HOOP STRAIN AT OUTER CAP OF FRAME IN PANELS CVP1 AND
CVP2 AND BOEING FULL-SCALE TEST ARTICLE
38

Load Cond. 1c

350

Max. Load

Pressure

300

10.1 psi

Hoop Load

554.6 lb/in

Frame Load

111.9 lb/in

Long. Load

333.3 lb/in

250

Longeron
Strain ()

Boeing Full-Scale Test

200

Test 1
Test 2
Test 3

150

Strain Gage Location

100
Air, Run 1
Air, Run 2
Water, Run 1
Water, Run 2

0
-50

CVP2 (Multiple Cracks)

CVP1

50

Air, Run 1
Air, Run 2
Water, Run 1
Water, Run 2
10

12

Applied Pressure (psi)

FIGURE 25. LONGITUDINAL STRAIN AT OUTER CAP OF STRINGER IN PANELS


CVP1 AND CVP2 AND BOEING FULL-SCALE TEST ARTICLE

Load Cond. 1c

800

10.1 psi

Hoop Load

600

Frame Hoop
Strain ()

Max. Load

Pressure

554.6 lb/in

Frame Load

111.9 lb/in

Long. Load

333.3 lb/in

Boeing Full-Scale Test


Test 1
Test 2
Test 3

400

Strain Gage Location

200

CVP1

Air, Run 1
Air, Run 2
Water, Run 1
Water, Run 2

-200

CVP2 (Multiple Cracks)


Air, Run 1
Air, Run 2
Water, Run 1
Water, Run 2

10

12

Applied Pressure (psi)

FIGURE 26. HOOP STRAIN AT INNER CAP OF FRAME IN PANELS CVP1 AND CVP2
AND BOEING FULL-SCALE TEST ARTICLE

39

Load Cond. 1c
Pressure

120

Hoop Load

100
80

10.1 psi
554.6 lb/in

Frame Load

111.9 lb/in

Long. Load

333.3 lb/in

Boeing Full-Scale Test


Test 1
Test 2
Test 3

60

Longeron
Strain ()

Max. Load

40
20

Strain Gage Location

-20
-40
-60

CVP2 (Multiple Cracks)

CVP1

Air, Run 1
Air, Run 2
Water, Run 1
Water, Run 2

Air, Run 1
Air, Run 2
Water, Run 1
Water, Run 2

10

12

Applied Pressure (psi)

FIGURE 27. LONGITUDINAL STRAIN AT FLANGE OF STRINGER IN PANELS CVP1


AND CVP2 AND BOEING FULL-SCALE TEST ARTICLE
Strain Gage Locations

1000

800

600

Hoop
Strain ()

Load Cond. 1c
Pressure
Hoop Load

400

200

Max. Load
10.1 psi
554.6 lb/in

Frame Load

111.9 lb/in

Long. Load

333.3 lb/in

CVP1
CVP2
29T

30T

32T

33T

34T

Strain Gage

FIGURE 28. HOOP STRAIN DISTRIBUTION IN THE SKIN MID-BAY IN


PANELS CVP1 AND CVP2
40

CVP3
Air, Run 1
Air, Run 2
Water, Run 1
Water, Run 2

1000
800

CVP4 (Multiple Cracks)


Air, Run 1
Air, Run 2
Water, Run 1
Water, Run 2

Analysis
600

Longitudinal
Strain ()

Strain Gage
Location

400
200

Load Cond. 1c

Max. Load

Pressure

0
-200

8.8 psi

Hoop Load

483.2 lb/in

Frame Load

97.6 lb/in

Long. Load

875.7 lb/in

10

Load Step
FIGURE 29. LONGITUDINAL STRAIN IN GAGE LOCATED AT SKIN MID-BAY IN
PANELS CVP3 AND CVP4

Pressure
Hoop Load

Max. Load

Strain Gage Locations

8.8 psi
483.2 lb/in

Frame Load

97.6 lb/in

Long. Load

875.7 lb/in

S1 S2S3S4 S5 S6S7

Load Cond. 1c

1000

800

Longitudinal
Strain ()

600

400

CVP3
CVP4

200

SG35L

SG32L

SG39L

SG38L

Strain Gage

FIGURE 30. LONGITUDINAL STRAIN DISTRIBUTION IN THE SKIN MID-BAY IN


PANELS CVP3 AND CVP4
41

Load Cond. 1c

Max. Load

Strain Gage Locations

8.8 psi

Hoop Load

483.2 lb/in

Frame Load

97.6 lb/in

Long. Load

875.7 lb/in

S1 S2S3S4 S5 S6S7

Pressure

1200

13

20

24

1000
800

Longitudinal
Strain ()

26

600
CVP3
CVP4

400
200
0

SG20

SG13

SG26

SG24

Strain Gage

FIGURE 31. LONGITUDINAL STRAIN DISTRIBUTION IN THE STRINGERS OF


PANELS CVP3 AND CVP4
Left Side

0.05 inch

Right Side

3L

3650
Cycles

3850
cycles

3R

3L

3L

3890
cycles

3R

3L

3916
cycles

3R

3L

5000
Cycles

3R

3L

5600
Cycles

3R

FIGURE 32. PHOTOGRAPHS OF CRACK GROWTH IN CVP1 DURING FATIGUE


LOADING USING RCCM SYSTEM

42

Left Side

0.05 inch

Right Side

3L

2852
cycles

3L

2884
cycles

3R

3L

2888
cycles

3R

3L

3000
cycles

3R

3R

3024
cycles

3L

3R

FIGURE 33.. PHOTOGRAPHS OF CRACK GROWTH IN PANEL CVP2 DURING FATIGUE


LOADING USING RCCM SYSTEM
CVP1
K

K1

100

80

Stress-Intensity
Factor Range
ksi in

CVP2 (Multiple Cracks)


K

K1

K2
K
kk1

K2
K
kk1

kk2

kk2

Initial Crack
Length, ao ~ 3.5 in
F1

60

F2

F3

F4

F5

F6

S7
S6
S5
S4
S3

40

S2
S1

20

10

12

14

Half Crack Length, a (in)

FIGURE 34. STRESS-INTENSITY FACTOR RANGE AS A FUNCTION OF HALF CRACK


LENGTH FOR PANELS CVP1 AND CVP2

43

Initial Crack
Length, ao ~ 3.5 in

Frequency = 0.2 Hz
R = 0.1
Load Cond. 2

Max. Load

Pressure
Hoop Load

14

12

10

111.9 lb/in

Long. Load

333.3 lb/in

F3

F4

F5

F6

S2
S1

CVP1
Right Crack Length
Left Crack Length
Analysis - KI

F2

S6
S5
S4
S3

554.6 lb/in

Frame Load

Lead Crack
Half Length (in) 6

F1
S7

10.1 psi

CVP2 (Multiple Cracks)


Right Crack Length
Left Crack Length
Analysis - KI

64

3000

6000

9000

Number of Cycles

FIGURE 35. HALF LENGTH OF THE LEAD CRACK AS A FUNCTION OF NUMBER OF


FATIGUE CYCLES FOR PANELS CVP1 AND CVP2
Frequency = 0.2 Hz
R = 0.1
Load Cond. 2
Pressure

4800

4250 Cycles

Max. Load
10.1 psi

Hoop Load

554.6 lb/in

Frame Load

111.9 lb/in

Long. Load

333.3 lb/in

3R

4R

Crack Growth Direction

4400

Number of
Cycles

4000

Initial Crack
Length, ao ~ 3.5 in
F1

F3

F4

F5

F6

S6
S5
S4
S3
S2
S1

3200

2800
-15

F2

S7

3600

8L 7L 6L 5L 4L 3L

3R 4R 5R 6R 7R 8R

15

Crack Tip Position (in)


FIGURE 36. CRACK TIP POSITION AS A FUNCTION OF FATIGUE CYCLES FOR
PANEL CVP2
44

F3

F4
Crack Tip and Strain Gage
Location Coincide

9.5
a

1800
1600

Strain Gage 35T - Skin


Strain Gage 10 - Frame 3

1400

SG10

1R 2R 3R 4R 5R 6R 7R 8R 9R 10R 11R 12R 13R

19

CL

1200

Hoop
Strain ()

SG35T

1000
800
600
400

Crack Growth Past Strain


Gage

Crack Growth
Towards Strain Gage

200
0
-200
0.0

0.5

1.0

1.5

Crack Length/Distance From Centerline

FIGURE 37. STRAIN REDISTRIBUTION IN PANEL CVP2

Left Side

Right Side
4715
cycles
4918
cycles

3R

5500
cycles

3R

3L

6125
cycles

3R

3L

6700
cycles

3L

0.05 inch

3R

3R

FIGURE 38. PHOTOGRAPHS OF CRACK GROWTH IN PANEL CVP3 DURING FATIGUE


LOADING USING RCCM SYSTEM

45

Left Side

Right Side
2000
cycles

3L

0.05 inch

3L

2200
cycles

3L

2300
cycles

3L

2712
cycles

3R

3R

3R

3R

FIGURE 39. PHOTOGRAPHS OF CRACK GROWTH IN PANEL CVP4 DURING FATIGUE


LOADING USING RCCM SYSTEM

CVP3
K

K1

50

40

Initial Crack
Length, 2ao ~ 7 in

CVP4 (Multiple Cracks)


K
K 1

K2

K2

k1

k1

k2

k2

Stress-Intensity 30
Factor Range
ksi in

1st Intact
Stringer (S3, S5)

20

S1 S2 S3 S4 S5 S6 S7

10

Saw-Cut
Stringer

10

Half Crack Length, a (in)


FIGURE 40. STRESS-INTENSITY FACTOR RANGE AS A FUNCTION OF HALF CRACK
LENGTH FOR PANELS CVP3 AND CVP4

46

Frequency = 0.2 Hz
R = 0.1
Load Cond. 2

Max. Load

Pressure

10

8.8 psi

Hoop Load

483.2 lb/in

Frame Load

97.6 lb/in

Long. Load

875.7 lb/in

Initial Crack
Length, 2ao ~ 7 in

Intact
Stringer (S3, S5)

8
5

Half Crack
Length, a (in)

7
6

CVP3
Right Crack Length
Left Crack Length
Analysis - K1

CVP4 (Multiple Cracks)


Right Crack Length, CVP4
Left Crack Length, CVP4
Analysis - K1

4
3

S1 S2 S3 S4 S5 S6 S7

4000

8000

12000

16000

20000

24000

Saw-Cut
Stringer, S4

Number of Cycles

FIGURE 41. HALF CRACK LENGTH AS A FUNCTION OF NUMBER OF FATIGUE


CYCLES FOR PANELS CVP3 ANDCVP4
Frequency = 0.2 Hz
R = 0.1
Load Cond. 2
Pressure

2712 Cycles

3L

16000

8.8 psi

Hoop Load

Lead Crack

Max. Load
483.2 lb/in

Frame Load

97.6 lb/in

Long. Load

875.7 lb/in

Crack Growth Direction

Initial Crack
Length, 2ao ~ 7 in

12000

Number of
Cycles

8000

4000

S1 S2 S3 S4 S5 S6 S7

0
-10

5L

4L

3L

3R

Crack Tip Position (in)

4R

5R

10

Saw-Cut
Stringer

FIGURE 42. CRACK TIP POSITION AS A FUNCTION OF FATIGUE CYCLES FOR


PANEL CVP4

47

S5

S4
Crack Tip and Strain Gage
Location Coincide

3.75
SG36L

1200

1R

1000

CL

600

3R

4R

5R

CVP3
SG36L - Skin
SG26 - Stringer
CVP4 (Multiple Cracks)
SG36L - Skin
SG26 - Stringer

400
200
0
-200

2R

8.25

800

Longitudual
Strain ()

SG26

Crack Growth
Towards Strain Gage

Crack Growth Past Strain


Gage

Crack Length/Distance From Centerline

FIGURE 43. STRAIN REDISTRIBUTION IN PANEL CVP4


1.00

0.75

Normalized Crack
Length

0.50

0.25
FAA Full-Scale Panel Tests
CVP1
CVP2 (Multiple Cracks)
0.00
0.00

0.25

Boeing Full-Scale Barrel Tests


Test 1
Test 2 (Multiple Cracks)

0.50

0.75

1.00

Normalized Cycles
FIGURE 44. COMPARISON OF FATIGUE CRACK GROWTH DATA SHOWING EFFECT
OF MULTIPLE CRACKS ON LEAD CRACK GROWTH
48

12

P an el

S tren gth (p si)

CVP1

1 1 .1 4

CVP2

9 .1 6

10

Applied
Pressure (psi)

6
4
2
0

Post Fatigue Crack Length, 2ao ~ 25 in

CVP1
Right Crack Length
Left Crack Length

CVP2 (Multiple Cracks)


Right Crack Length
Left Crack Length

Frames
F3 and F5
9

10

12

11

F1

F2

13

14

20

15

16

24

18

17

28

32

F3

F4

F5

F6

Saw-Cut Frame F4
After Fatigue
Loading

Frames
F2 and F6

12

16

S7
S6
S5
S4
S3
S2
S1

36

40

Half Lead Crack Length, a (in)

FIGURE 45. CRACK EXTENSION DURING RESIDUAL STRENGTH TESTS FOR


PANELS CVP1 AND CVP2
Post Fatigue Crack Length, 2ao ~ 25 in

10

S7
S6
S5
S4
S3
S2
S1

Crack Tip Position


Link-Up Position

F1

F2

F4

F5

F6

Saw-Cut Frame F4
After Fatigue
Loading

Frame F5

F3

Applied
Pressure (psi)
8

9R

7
12

10R

14

11R

16

12R

18

13R

20

14R

15R

22

16R

24

17R

26

18R

28

Crack-Tip Position (in)

FIGURE 46. CRACK TIP POSITION OF LEAD CRACK AND MULTIPLE CRACKS AS A
FUNCTION OF APPLIED PRESSURE FOR RESIDUAL STRENGTH TEST OF CVP2

49

Manufacturing Flaws

Tab Failure
Overload Region

Fatigue Crack

Region of Fatigue Crack


Extension

Saw-Cut Scratches

Stop Drill Hole

Load Transfer Slot

FIGURE 47. PHOTOGRAPHS OF TAB FAILURE AFTER FIRST RESIDUAL STRENGTH


ATTEMPT FOR PANEL CVP3

Bearing Failures

Repair from First


Premature Failure

FIGURE 48. PHOTOGRAPHS OF TAB FAILURE AFTER SECOND RESIDUAL


STRENGTH ATTEMPT FOR PANEL CVP3

50

NAS 6205 Steel Bolts,


= 0.312

Doubler Layers Cold


Bonded Using EA9309.3NA

Pin Hole, =0.5

Original Skin, t=0.063


Original 2024-T3 Doublers, t=0.063
2024-T3 Filler, t=0.063
4130A Steel Doublers, t=0.025
4130A Steel Doublers, t=0.04

NAS 6204 Steel Bolts,


=0.25

FIGURE 49. PHOTOGRAPHS OF REINFORCEMENTS MADE TO ALL TAB ENDS FOR


THE LONGITUDINAL LOAD APPLICATION POINTS FOR PANEL CVP3

Premature Failure, 19.1 psi

First Run
20

Failure Strength, 17.9 psi

Premature Failure, 18.4 psi

Right Crack Length


Left Crack Length

Post Fatigue Crack


Length, 2ao ~ 19 in

S3 Failed

Second Run
Right Crack Length
Left Crack Length

Third Run

15

Applied
Pressure (psi)

S5 Failed

Right Crack Length


Left Crack Length

Saw-Cut
Stringer

10

1st Intact
Stringer (S3, S5)

2nd Intact
Stringer (S2, S6)
S1 S2 S3 S4 S5 S6 S7

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

Half Crack Length, a (in)

FIGURE 50. CRACK EXTENSION, AS A FUNCTION OF APPLIED PRESSURE,


RECORDED FOR RESIDUAL STRENGTH TESTS OF PANEL CVP3

51

25

P a n el

S tren g th (p si)

CV P3

1 9 .1 4 *

CV P4

2 0 .7 5

*Premature Failure at 19.14 psi, CVP3


Post Fatigue Crack
Length, 2ao ~ 19 in

20
Saw-Cut
Stringer

Applied 15
Pressure (psi)

CVP3
Right Crack Length
Left Crack Length

10

CVP4 (Multiple Cracks)


Right Crack Length
Left Crack Length

S1 S2 S3 S4 S5 S6 S7
8

10

11

12

Half Crack Length, a (in)


FIGURE 51. CRACK EXTENSION, AS A FUNCTION OF APPLIED PRESSURE,
RECORDED FOR RESIDUAL STRENGTH TESTS OF PANELS CVP3 AND CVP4
Post Fatigue Crack
Length, 2ao ~ 19 in

21

20

19

Applied
Pressure (psi)
18

17

12L

11L

10L

9L

8L

7L

Crack-Tip Postion
Link-Up Position

S1 S2 S3 S4 S5 S6 S7

Stringer S2

16
-20

-18

-16

-14

Saw-Cut
Stringer

-12

-10

-8

Crack-Tip Position (in)


FIGURE 52. CRACK TIP POSITION OF LEAD CRACK AND MULTIPLE CRACKS AS A
FUNCTION OF APPLIED PRESSURE FOR RESIDUAL STRENGTH TEST OF CVP4

52

25

FAA Full-Scale Panel Tests


Boeing Full-Scale Barrel Test [20]
Boeing Full-Scale Barrel Test [21]
Foster-Miller Panel Tests [22]

20

15

Percent Reduction
of Residual Strength

10

FIGURE 53. COMPARISON OF DATA SHOWING THE EFFECT OF MULTIPLE CRACKS


ON THE RESIDUAL STRENGTH

F1

F2

F3

F4

F5

F6

Skin Crack
2a ~ 68 in

Frame 5: Fractured

Frame 3: Fractured
Frame 4: Saw-Cut

FIGURE 54. PHOTOGRAPHS OF THE FINAL STATE OF DAMAGE SHOWING CRACK


BULGING AND DAMAGED FRAMES IN PANEL CVP1

53

F1

6000

F2

F3

F4

F5

F6

Crack Initiation
Initiation Site:
Site: Frame
Frame
Crack
CVP1
Outer Flange/Stringer
Flange/Stringer
Outer
Connection Hi-Lok
Hi-Lok
Connection
Frame Stress
~ 52.03
ksi
Frame
Crack
Net
Section
Stress
~
68.6
ksi
Strain Gage
Ftu ~ 77 ksi
Fty ~ 66 ksi

5000

CVP2
Strain
Crack Length

4000

Frame
Strain ()

Crack
Length (in)
20

F5

2000
1000

10

Stringer

30

3000

33"
"

40

CVP1
Strain
Crack Length

10

Frame Strain at Failure


()
CVP1
CVP2
4958
5219

12

Applied Pressure (psi)

FIGURE 55. STRAIN IN FRAME F5 PRIOR TO FAILURE OF PANELS CVP1 AND CVP2
Crack Path Along Original Rivet Line
Crack Path
Changes Rivet
Lines

Doubler Fractured at
Load Transfer Slot

Total
Total Crack
Crack Length,
Length, 2a
2a ~~ 68
68 in
in

FIGURE 56. PHOTOGRAPHS OF THE FINAL STATE OF DAMAGE IN PANEL CVP3


SHOWING SKIN FAILURE

54

Stringer 1

Skin Crack
2a ~ 68 in
Stringer 5

S1 S2 S3 S4 S5 S6 S7

Stringer 4

Stringer Splice Fractured


and Rivets Sheared
(Similar failure for
Stringers 2, 6 and 7)

Stringer Splice Fractured at


Hat Hi-Lok (Similar failure
for Stringer 3)
Saw-Cut Stringer
and Intercoastal

FIGURE
RE 57. PHOTOGRAPHS OF THE FINAL STATE OF DAMAGE IN PANEL CVP3
SHOWING THE SUBSTRUCTURE FAILURE
Crack Initiation
Initiation Site:
Site: Skin
Skin
Crack
to
Stringer
Splice
Hat
to Stringer Splice Hat
Connection Hi-Lok
Hi-Lok
Connection

5000

S1 S2 S3 S4 S5 S6 S7
CVP3
CVP4

4000

Stringer 3000
Strain ()

Stringer Strain at Failure


()
()
CVP3*
CVP4
3710
3992

2000

1000

*Premature Failure at 19.14 psi, CVP3


0

10

15

20

25

Applied Pressure (psi)

FIGURE 58. STRAIN IN STRINGER S5 PRIOR OF FAILURE OF PANELS


CVP3 AND CVP4

55

TABLE 1. TEST MATRIX


Specimen
CVP1
CVP2
CVP3
CVP4

Joint Configuration
Longitudinal Lap Joint
Longitudinal Lap Joint
Circumferential Butt Joint
Circumferential Butt Joint

Initial Damage
Lead Crack only
Lead Crack with Multiple Cracks
Lead Crack only
Lead Crack with Multiple Cracks

Date Completed
August 1999
February 2000
July 2000
September 2000

TABLE 2. SEQUENCE OF LOADING CONDITIONS APPLIED TO


PANELS CVP1 AND CVP2
Load
Condition
1a
1b
1c
2
3

Test Type
Quasi-Static Loading, Strain Survey
Quasi-Static Loading, Strain Survey
Quasi-Static Loading, Strain Survey
Cyclic Fatigue Crack Growth
Quasi-Static, Residual Strength

Maximum Load
Pressure
Hoop
Frame
Long.
(psi)
(lb/in)
(lb/in)
(lb/in)
10.1
554.6
111.9
0
0
0
0
333.3
10.1
554.6
111.9
333.3
10.1
554.6
111.9
333.3
Internal pressurization with reactive hoop
and frame loads plus longitudinal stress 50%
less than hoop stress

TABLE 3. SEQUENCE OF LOADING CONDITIONS APPLIED TO


PANELS CVP3 AND CVP4
Load
Condition
1a
1b
1c
2
3

Test Type
Quasi-Static Loading, Strain Survey
Quasi-Static Loading, Strain Survey
Quasi-Static Loading, Strain Survey
Cyclic Fatigue Crack Growth
Quasi-Static, Residual Strength

56

Maximum Load
Pressure
Hoop
Frame
Long.
(psi)
(lb/in)
(lb/in)
(lb/in)
8.8
483.2
97.6
0
0
0
0
875.7
8.8
483.2
97.6
875.7
8.8
483.2
97.6
875.7
Internal pressurization with reactive hoop
and frame load plus longitudinal stress 50%
higher than hoop stress

TABLE 4. STRESS-INTENSITY FACTOR RANGE CALCULATIONS FOR


PANELS CVP1 AND CVP2
CVP2 Multiple Cracks
( ksi in )

CVP1 Baseline
( ksi in )
a, in
3.56
3.84
4.13
4.29
4.69
5.04
5.36
5.71
5.76
6.16
6.47
6.75
7.15
7.77
8.46
8.65
9.24
9.96
10.13
10.73
11.34
11.70
12.21
12.86
13.18

K1
30.19
31.68
33.30
34.11
38.13
39.52
40.91
42.23
42.46
47.09
48.07
49.14
50.56
55.41
58.06
58.43
63.13
65.54
65.78
70.57
72.26
72.93
77.37
78.40
78.90

K2
0.75
1.08
1.56
1.95
2.42
2.72
3.27
4.34
4.41
4.74
5.19
5.55
6.49
7.23
7.96
8.51
9.15
9.77
10.20
10.85
11.31
11.84
12.43
12.76
13.40

k1
0.24
0.13
0.29
0.32
0.63
0.46
0.62
0.88
0.89
0.04
0.87
0.17
0.77
0.97
0.85
0.19
0.97
1.72
0.79
0.78
2.29
1.57
0.08
3.17
2.53

k2
9.76
9.89
9.35
8.38
12.45
13.08
13.01
11.86
11.66
15.36
15.52
15.17
13.85
16.88
16.26
14.98
18.44
17.36
16.18
19.98
16.98
15.58
21.66
17.95
16.62

57

K1
30.78
32.79
36.57
44.39
38.47
40.09
42.09
47.33
51.97
47.68
49.04
50.86
59.91
56.50
62.62
69.44
64.37
70.26
78.54
71.67
74.39
83.55
78.54
80.93
91.15

K2
0.73
1.05
1.62
2.46
2.41
2.71
3.29
4.76
5.32
4.94
5.22
5.64
7.48
7.28
8.47
9.96
9.26
10.38
12.05
11.03
11.57
13.44
12.65
13.09
15.34

k1
0.30
0.03
0.02
0.66
0.68
0.44
0.88
0.34
0.03
0.33
0.89
0.32
1.06
1.03
0.34
0.92
0.86
1.20
0.48
0.47
2.07
0.53
0.44
2.95
1.52

k2
9.76
9.90
9.40
8.81
12.46
13.07
12.99
12.06
12.20
16.01
15.53
15.11
13.83
16.88
16.14
14.99
18.90
17.26
16.13
18.96
16.96
15.60
20.03
17.87
16.62

TABLE 5. STRESS-INTENSITY FACTOR RANGE CALCULATIONS FOR


PANELS CVP3 AND CVP4

a, in
3.47
3.85
4.13
4.22
4.69
5.21
5.68
6.14
7.08
8.48
8.76

K1
27.51
28.67
29.46
29.71
31.67
33.03
33.98
35.70
37.18
35.29
34.68

CVP3, Baseline
( ksi in )
K2
k1
1.49
5.57
1.46
5.22
1.80
5.19
1.75
5.25
1.41
5.24
1.34
5.29
1.42
5.37
0.34
5.30
0.38
4.81
0.09
4.23
0.08
4.55

k2
6.64
5.81
5.46
5.20
5.49
5.31
5.40
5.98
5.11
3.22
1.84

58

K1
27.69
29.07
30.79
33.24
31.76
33.23
35.08
35.57
37.22
35.69
37.17

CVP4, Multiple Cracks


ksi in
K2
k1
1.49
5.61
1.46
5.26
1.86
5.25
1.98
5.55
1.40
5.25
1.31
5.30
1.41
5.34
0.38
5.29
0.38
4.81
0.14
4.23
0.19
4.39

k2
6.68
5.83
5.47
4.95
5.49
5.31
5.42
5.95
5.11
3.21
1.78

APPENDIX APANEL ENGINEERING DRAWINGS


Detailed engineering drawings for the four panels tested are presented in this appendix. Panels
CVP1, CVP2, CVP3, and CVP4 are cross-referenced in the accompanied engineering drawings
numbered ZB128403 as configurations 1, 501, 505, and 507, respectively. The selected
panel configurations represent generic fuselage structure from a narrow-body aircraft fabricated
according to original equipment manufacturing (OEM) specifications. It was decided in this
program to test panels that were generic instead of aircraft specific, since the purpose of this
study is to provide experimental data to support and verify analysis methodologies to assess the
effects of multiple cracks applicable to all aircraft types. The panel size was selected so that the
test section will contain large damage such as a two-bay crack with central frame severed. The
test section of the panel was sized in order to minimize the effect of the test fixture attachment
points along the perimeter.
Typical panel dimensions are 120 in the longitudinal direction, 68 in the circumferential
direction, with a radius of 66. For all four panels, the skin was 2024-T3 aluminum with a
thickness of 0.063. Each panel had six frames with a 19 spacing and seven stringers with a
7.5 spacing. The frames and shear clips were 7075-T6 aluminum with thickness of 0.071 and
0.063, respectively. The stringers were also 7075-T6 aluminum with a thickness of 0.063,
except for S4 where the thickness is 0.071. The edges of the curved panels, where loads are
applied, were reinforced by bonding six layers of 0.045~0.065-inch-thick aluminum alloy
doublers to the skin to ensure a uniform load transfer. Along the perimeter of the panel,
reinforcing doublers with a length of 112 on the longitudinal sides and 56 on the hoop sides
were added. Holes with a diameter of 0.5 were spaced approximately 4 apart on the
longitudinal sides and 3.5 apart on the hoop sides to attach the whiffle tree assemblies which
apply the load. There were 28 load application points on each longitudinal side and 16 load
application points on each hoop side. Doublers were also added to the frame ends where they
attach to the frame loaders.

A-1

A-2

A-3

A-4

A-5

A-6

A-7

A-8

A-9

A-10

A-11

A-12

A-13

A-14

A-15

A-16

A-17

A-18

A-19

A-20

A-21

A-22

A-23

A-24

A-25

A-26

A-27

A-28

A-29

A-30

A-31

A-32

A-33

A-34

A-35

A-36

A-37

A-38

A-39

A-40

A-41

A-42

A-43

A-44

A-45

A-46

A-47

A-48

APPENDIX BLOCATION OF STRAIN GAGES


Strain gages were placed on the all four panels to monitor the strain distribution and to ensure
proper load introduction. The type and location of the strain gages used are provided in the
tables and figures of this appendix. All strain gages were 350 Ohms with a Constantan foil alloy.
A three conductor, Teflon-coated twisted cable was used for connection to the strain gages.
Boeing Aircraft Company, Long Beach, CA, installed all strain gages to panels CVP1 and CVP3.
The Federal Aviation Administration William J. Hughes Technical Center, Atlantic City
International Airport, NJ installed all strain gages to panels CVP2 and CVP4.
The strain gage, coating, cable, and adhesive types for each panel are listed in table B-1. A full
description of the Micro-Measurement (MM) products is provided in MM Catalog A-110-8 and
MM Catalog 500. These catalogs can be obtained from:
Micro-Measurements Division
Measurements Group
P.O. Box 27777
Raleigh, North Carolina 27611
Phone: (919) 365-3800
The location of the strain gages for the longitudinal lap joint panels, CVP1 and CVP2, is
provided in table B-2 and figures B-1 through B-4. In these panels, 20 axial strain gages were
located on both the inner and outer flanges of the frames. The stringers were instrumented with
eight axial strain gages on the flange and hat section. The skin was instrumented with eight
strain gage rosettes. At one location on the skin, two back-to-back 45 strain gage rosettes
(gages 31 and 32) were installed to provide a measure of bending of the skin.
The location of the strain gages for the circumferential lap joint panels, CVP3 and CVP4, is
provided in table B-3 and figures B-5 through B-11. In these panels, nine axial strain gages were
located on both the inner and outer flanges of the frames. The stringers were instrumented with
22 axial strain gages on the flange and hat section. The skin was instrumented with nine strain
gage rosettes (45o) in the skin and 31 axial strain gages in the frames and stringers. At two
locations on the skin, namely at gages 36 and 37 and at gages 39 and 40, two back-to-back 45
strain gage rosettes were installed to provide a measure of bending of the skin.

B-1

TABLE B-1. GENERAL STRAIN GAGE INFORMATION


Panel

CVP1

CVP2

CVP3

CVP4

No. Gages Axial


Gage No. Axial
Micro-Measurement
Part No., Axial
No. Gages, Rosette
Gage No. Rosette
Micro-Measurement
Part No., Axial
Micro-Measurement
Part No., Coatings
Micro-Measurement
Part No., Cable
Micro-Measurement
Part No., Adhesive

28
1-28
EA-13-062AQ-350

28
1-28
CEA-13-062UW-350

31
1-31
EA-13-062AQ-350

31
1-31
CEA-13-062UW-350

8
29-36
EA-13-120WR-350

8
29-36
CEA-13-125UR-350

9
32-40
EA-13-120WR-350

9
32-40
CEA-13-125UR-350

3140 RTV

M Coat J

3140 RTV

M Coat J

330-FFE

330-FTE

330-FFE

330-FTE

M-Bond AE-10

M-Bond 200

M-Bond AE-10

M-Bond 200

B-2

TABLE B-2. STRAIN GAGE LOCATIONS FOR PANELS CVP1 AND CVP2
Strain Gage No.
(View)
1 (C)

Location
Name and P/N
Outside of Frame Flange F2

2 (C)

Inside of Frame Flange F2

3 (C)

Outside of Frame Flange F3

4 (C)

Inside of Frame Flange F3

5 (C)

Outside of Frame Flange F4

6 (C)

Inside of Frame Flange F4

7 (C)

Outside of Frame Flange F5

8 (C)

Inside of Frame Flange F5

9 (C)

Outside of Frame Flange F3

10 (C)

Inside of Frame Flange F3

11 (C)

Outside of Frame Flange F4

12 (C)

Inside of Frame Flange F4

13 (C)

Outside of Frame Flange F5

14 (C)

Inside of Frame Flange F5

15 (C)

Outside of Frame Flange F3

16 (C)

Inside of Frame Flange F3

17 (C)

Outside of Frame Flange F4

18 (C)

Inside of Frame Flange F4

19 (C)

Outside of Frame Flange F5

B-3

Dimensional
Midway Between L3 and
Center of Flange (0.46)
Midway Between L3 and
Center of Flange (0.39)
Midway Between L3 and
Center of Flange (0.46)
Midway Between L3 and
Center of Flange (0.39)
Midway Between L3 and
Center of Flange (0.46)
Midway Between L3 and
Center of Flange (0.39)
Midway Between L3 and
Center of Flange (0.46)
Midway Between L3 and
Center of Flange (0.39)
Midway Between L4 and
Center of Flange (0.46)
Midway Between L4 and
Center of Flange (0.39)
Midway Between L4 and
Center of Flange (0.46)
Midway Between L4 and
Center of Flange (0.39)
Midway Between L4 and
Center of Flange (0.46)
Midway Between L4 and
Center of Flange (0.39)
Midway Between L6 and
Center of Flange (0.46)
Midway Between L6 and
Center of Flange (0.39)
Midway Between L6 and
Center of Flange (0.46)
Midway Between L6 and
Center of Flange (0.39)
Midway Between L6 and
Center of Flange (0.46)

L4 (3.75),
L4 (3.75),
L4 (3.75),
L4 (3.75),
L4 (3.75),
L4 (3.75),
L4 (3.75),
L4 (3.75),
L5 (3.75),
L5 (3.75),
L5 (3.75),
L5 (3.75),
L5 (3.75),
L5 (3.75),
L7 (3.75),
L7 (3.75),
L7 (3.75),
L7 (3.75),
L7 (3.75),

TABLE B-2. STRAIN GAGE LOCATIONS FOR PANELS CVP1 AND CVP2 (Continued)
Strain Gage No.
(View)
20 (C)

Location
Name and P/N
Inside of Frame Flange F5

21 (D)

Outside of Longeron Flange L2

22 (D)

Inside of Longeron Hat L2

23 (D)

Outside of Longeron Flange L3

24 (D)

Inside of Longeron Hat L3

25 (D)

Outside of Longeron Flange L4

26 (D)

Inside of Longeron Hat L4

27 (D)

Outside of Longeron Flange L5

28 (D)

Inside of Longeron Hat L5

29L (E)
29-45,
29T
30L (E)
30-45,
30T
31L (E)
31-45,
31T
32L (E)
32-45,
32T
33L (E)
33-45
33T
34L (E)
34-45
34T
35L (E)
35-45
35T
36L (E)
36-45
36T

Exterior Surface of Skin


Exterior Surface of Skin
Interior Surface of Skin
Exterior Surface of Skin
Exterior Surface of Skin
Exterior Surface of Skin
Exterior Surface of Skin
Exterior Surface of Skin

B-4

Dimensional
Midway Between L6 and L7 (3.75),
Center of Flange (0.39)
Aft of Frame F3 (8.88),
Center of Flange (0.37)
Aft of Frame F3 (8.88),
Center of Hat (0.35)
Aft of Frame F3 (8.88),
Center of Flange (0.37)
Aft of Frame F3 (8.88),
Center of Hat (0.35)
Aft of Frame F3 (9.09),
Center of Flange (0.37)
Aft of Frame F3 (9.09),
Center of Hat (0.38)
Aft of Frame F3 (8.88),
Center of Flange (0.37)
Aft of Frame F3 (8.88),
Center of Hat (0.35)
Midway Between Frames F1 and F2
(9.50) and Longerons L3 and L4
(3.75)
Midway Between Frames F2 and F3
(9.50) and Longerons L3 and L4
(3.75)
Midway Between Frames F3 and F4
(9.50) and Longerons L3 and L4
(3.75)
Midway Between Frames F3 and F4
(9.50) and Longerons L3 and L4
(3.75)
Midway Between Frames F4 and F5
(9.50) and Longerons L3 and L4
(3.75)
Midway Between Frames F5 and F6
(9.50) and Longerons L3 and L4
(3.75)
Midway Between Frames F3 and F4
(9.50) and Longerons L4 and L5
(3.75)
Midway Between Frames F3 and F4
(9.50) and Longerons L5 and L6
(3.75)

TABLE B-3. STRAIN GAGE LOCATIONS FOR PANELS CVP3 AND CVP4
Strain Gage No.
(View)
1 (F)

Location
Name and P/N
Outside of Frame Flange F3

2 (F)

Outside of Frame Flange F3

3 (F)

Outside of Frame Flange F1

4 (F)

Outside of Frame Flange F2

5 (F)

Outside of Frame Flange F3

6 (F)

Inside of Frame Flange F3

7 (F)

Outside of Frame Flange F4

8 (F)

Inside of Frame Flange F3

9 (F)

Outside of Frame Flange F3

10 (M)

Outside of Longeron Flange L1

11 (G)

Outside of Splice Flange L2

12 (G)

Inside of Splice Hat L2

13 (H)

Outside of Longeron Flange L3

14 (H)

Inside of Longeron Hat L3

15 (G)

Outside of Splice Flange L3

16 (G)

Inside of Splice Hat L3

17 (M)

Inside of Longeron Hat L4

18 (M)

Outside of Longeron Flange L4

19 (M)

Outside of Longeron Flange L4

B-5

Dimensional
Midway Between L2 and L3 (3.75),
Center of Flange (0.46)
Midway Between L3 and L4 (3.75),
Center of Flange (0.46)
Midway Between L4 and L5 (3.75),
Center of Flange (0.46)
Midway Between L4 and L5 (3.75),
Center of Flange (0.46)
Midway Between L4 and L5 (3.75),
Center of Flange (0.46)
Midway Between L4 and L5 (3.75),
Center of Flange (0.39)
Midway Between L4 and L5 (3.75),
Center of Flange (0.46)
Midway Between L5 and L6 (3.75),
Center of Flange (0.39)
Midway Between L4 and L5 (3.75),
Center of Flange (0.46)
FWD. of F2 (8.87),
on Center of Flange (0.37)
FWD. of CL Sym. (2.25),
on Center of Flange (0.43)
FWD. of CL Sym. (2.25),
on Center of Hat (0.26)
FWD. of CL Sym. (7.50),
on Center of Flange (0.37)
FWD. of CL Sym. (7.50),
on Center of Hat (0.35)
FWD. of CL Sym. (2.25),
on Center of Flange (0.43)
FWD. of CL Sym. (2.25),
on Center of Hat (0.26)
FWD. of F2 (8.87),
on Center of Hat (0.35)
FWD. of F2 (8.87),
on Center of Flange (0.37)
FWD. of F3 (9.12),
on Center of Flange (0.37)

TABLE B-3. STRAIN GAGE LOCATIONS FOR PANELS CVP3 AND CVP4 (Continued)
Strain Gage No.
(View)
20 (M)

Location
Name and P/N
Inside of Longeron Hat L4

21 (H)

Inside of Longeron Hat L4

22 (H)

Outside of Longeron Flange L4

23 (M)

Outside of Longeron Flange L4

24 (M)

Inside of Longeron Hat L4

25 (H)

Inside of Longeron Hat L5

26 (H)

Outside of Longeron Flange L5

27 (G)

Inside of Splice Hat L5

28 (G)

Outside of Splice Flange L5

29 (G)

Inside of Splice Hat L6

30 (G)

Outside of Splice Flange L6

31 (M)

Outside of Longeron Flange L7

32L (J)
32-45
32T
33L (J)
33-45
33T
34L (L)
34-45
34T
35L (L)
35-45
35T
36L (K)
36-45
36T

Exterior Surface of Skin


Exterior Surface of Skin
Exterior Surface of Skin
Interior Surface of Skin
Exterior Surface of Skin

B-6

Dimensional
FWD. of F3 (9.12),
on Center of Hat (0.35)
FWD. of CL Sym. (7.50),
on Center of Hat (0.35)
FWD. of CL Sym. (7.50),
on Center of Flange (0.37)
Aft of F4 (9.12),
on Center of Flange (0.37)
Aft of F4 (9.12),
on Center of Hat (0.35)
FWD. of CL Sym. (7.50),
on Center of Hat (0.35)
FWD. of CL Sym. (7.50),
on Center of Flange (0.37)
FWD. of CL Sym. (2.25),
on Center of Flange (0.26)
FWD. of CL Sym. (2.25),
on Center of Flange (0.43)
FWD. of CL Sym. (2.25),
on Center of Hat (0.26)
FWD. of CL Sym. (2.25),
on Center of Flange (0.43)
FWD. of F2 (8.87),
on Center of Flange (0.37)
FWD. of CL Sym. (6.25),
Midway Between Longerons L2 and
L3 (3.75)
FWD. of CL Sym. (6.25),
Midway Between Longerons L3 and
L4 (3.75)
Midway Between Frames F2 and F3
(9.50) and Longerons L4 and L5
(3.75)
Midway Between Frames F2 and F3
(9.50) and Longerons L4 and L5
(3.75)
FWD. of CL Sym. (6.25),
Midway Between Longerons L4 and
L5(3.75)

TABLE B-3. STRAIN GAGE LOCATIONS FOR PANELS CVP3 AND CVP4 (Continued)
Strain Gage No.
(View)
37L (K)
37-45
37T
38L (L)
38-45
38T
39L (K)
39-45
39T
40L (K)
40-45
40T

Location
Name
Interior Surface of Skin

Dimensional
FWD. of CL Sym. (6.25),
Midway Between Longerons L4 and
L5 (3.75)
Midway Between Frames F4 and F5
(9.50) and Longerons L4 and L5
(3.75)
FWD. of CL Sym. (6.25),
Midway Between Longerons L5 and
L6 (3.75)
FWD. of CL Sym. (6.25),
Midway Between Longerons L5 and
L6 (3.75)

Exterior Surface of Skin


Exterior Surface of Skin
Interior Surface of Skin

B-7

FIGURE B-1. SECTION VIEWS FOR PANELS CVP1 AND CVP2

B-8

FIGURE B-2. PLACEMENT OF AXIAL GAGES AT THE INNER AND OUTER CAP OF
THE FRAMES IN PANELS CVP1 AND CVP2

B-9

FIGURE B-3. PLACEMENT OF AXIAL GAGES AT THE CAP AND FLANGE OF THE
STRINGERS (LONGERONS) OF PANELS CVP1 AND CVP2

B-10

FIGURE B-4. PLACEMENT OF ROSETTE GAGES AT THE SKIN MID-BAY LOCATION


IN PANELS CVP1 AND CVP2

B-11

FIGURE B-5. SECTION VIEWS FOR PANELS CVP3 AND CVP4


B-12

FIGURE B-6. PLACEMENT OF AXIAL GAGES AT THE INNER AND OUTER CAP OF
THE FRAMES IN PANELS CVP3 AND CVP4

B-13

FIGURE B-7. PLACEMENT OF AXIAL GAGES AT THE CAP AND FLANGE OF


THE STRINGERS (LONGERONS) SPLICE REGION OF THE BUTT JOINT OF
PANELS CVP3 AND CVP4

B-14

FIGURE B-8. PLACEMENT OF AXIAL GAGES AT THE CAP AND FLANGE OF THE
STRINGERS (LONGERONS) NEAR THE BUTT JOINT OF PANELS CVP3 AND CVP4

B-15

FIGURE B-9. PLACEMENT OF ROSETTE GAGES AT THE SKIN BUTT JOINT


LOCATION IN PANELS CVP3 AND CVP4

B-16

FIGURE B-9. PLACEMENT OF ROSETTE GAGES AT THE SKIN BUTT JOINT


LOCATION IN PANELS CVP3 AND CVP4 (Continued)

B-17

FIGURE B-10. PLACEMENT OF ROSETTE GAGES AT THE SKIN MID-BAY LOCATION


IN PANELS CVP3 AND CVP4

B-18

FIGURE B-11. PLACEMENT OF AXIAL GAGES AT THE CAP AND FLANGE OF


THE STRINGERS (LONGERONS) OF PANELS CVP3 AND CVP4

B-19/B-20

APPENDIX CBOEING FULL-SCALE STRAIN SURVEY TEST RESULTS


To help verify test results generated using the FASTER facility, results from a full-scale test
conducted on an aft fuselage section of an actual narrow-body aircraft by Boeing Aircraft
Company, in Long Beach, CA, were compared with results from the FASTER facility. The aft
fuselage test article is shown in figure C-1. The test article was mounted on a strong-back fixture
and pressurized quasi-statically from 0 to 7.8 psi for three tests, tests 1 to 3. A section of aircraft,
from frame station 1269 to 1288 and stringer L4 to L5, was instrumented with strain gages as
shown in figure C-2. In this section, the aft fuselage test article closely resembles the four
curved panels in this test program, having similar radius, skin thickness, and substructure details.
A 45 rosette gage was placed near a skin mid-bay, location A, and uniaxial gages were placed in
the cap and flange of stringer L4, locations B and C, and the inner and outer frame cap at frame
station 1269, locations E and F. The strain gage data from the three tests are listed in the tables
C-1 through C-3 of this appendix.
TABLE C-1. STRAIN GAGE RESULTS FROM TEST 1, ALL STRAIN GAGE DATA IN
E
C
B
Frame Outer
D
Stringer Stringer
A
Cap
Flange
Frame Inner Cap
Cap
Skin Mid-Bay
Pressure
(psi)
SK1A SK1B SK1C
L4C
L4F
FCL2 FCL3 FCU1 FCU2 FCU3
0.00
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
1.02
66
46
21
24
10
50
47
29
31
31
1.99
130
90
41
51
19
104
98
63
68
69
3.00
199
134
57
79
30
163
154
100
107
110
3.99
269
181
77
104
37
216
204
136
146
150
4.99
341
228
97
129
44
272
256
171
184
190
6.00
415
279
123
155
51
324
305
205
221
229
6.99
488
326
140
185
63
384
361
242
262
271
7.77
546
362
153
207
72
431
405
271
293
304
TABLE C-2. STRAIN GAGE RESULTS FROM TEST 2, ALL STRAIN GAGE DATA IN
E
C
B
Frame Outer
D
Stringer Stringer
A
Cap
Flange
Frame Inner Cap
Cap
Skin Mid-Bay
Pressure
(psi)
SK1A SK1B SK1C
L4C
L4F
FCL2 FCL3 FCU1 FCU2 FCU3
0.00
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
1.00
64
44
19
24
9
54
50
31
33
34
1.99
131
88
38
49
16
108
101
66
71
73
3.02
204
136
58
75
24
166
156
105
113
115
4.00
275
181
75
101
32
222
209
140
150
155
5.01
347
227
93
126
39
278
261
176
189
195
5.99
419
274
113
152
46
333
314
213
230
236
7.00
493
322
131
178
52
389
366
249
268
278
7.77
550
360
148
197
57
430
403
276
297
307

C-1

TABLE C-3. STRAIN GAGE RESULTS FROM TEST 3, ALL STRAIN GAGE DATA IN

Pressure
(psi)
0.00
1.00
2.01
3.00
4.01
5.01
6.01
7.00
7.77

A
Skin Mid-Bay
SK1A SK1B SK1C
0
0
0
64
42
15
131
87
34
202
133
53
273
179
72
346
227
91
419
275
111
492
322
130
549
359
144

B
Strin.
Cap
L4C
0
24
49
75
99
125
152
179
199

C
Strin.
Flange
L4F
0
10
17
25
32
38
46
54
62

D
Frame Inner Cap
FCL2 FCL3 FCU1
0
0
0
58
55
33
113
107
70
168
159
108
225
212
145
280
264
183
335
316
220
393
369
258
437
411
287

FIGURE C-1. BOEING AFT FUSELAGE TEST ARTICLE

C-2

E
Frame Outer
Cap
FCU2 FCU3
0
0
35
36
75
76
116
118
155
160
196
201
236
243
276
287
308
319

FIGURE C-2. LOCATION OF STRAIN GAGES IN TEST ARTICLE

C-3/C-4

APPENDIX DANALYSIS OF FULL-SCALE PANELS


SUMMARY
Analysis to support the full-scale testing of four curved fuselage panels was conducted using the
Airframe Computational Modeling (ACM) facility. Emphasis was placed on assessing the effect
of multiple cracking on the fatigue crack growth behavior for two joint configurations: a
longitudinal lap joint and a circumferential butt joint. Geometric nonlinear finite element
analyses were conducted on the two joint configurations to determine strain distributions and
fracture parameters governing crack formation and growth. Comparisons with strain gage data
verified the finite element models. Fatigue crack growth predictions were made using a cycleby-cycle crack growth algorithm and the corresponding mixed mode stress-intensity factor (SIF)
ranges calculated using the Modified Crack Closure Integral (MCCI) method. Results include
comparisons of strain distributions and fatigue crack growth characteristics for the two joint
configurations.
DESCRIPTION OF PANELS
Four panels were tested in this study: (1) panel CVP1 contains a longitudinal lap splice with a
lead crack, (2) panel CVP2 has the same configuration and lead crack as CVP1 with the addition
of multiple small cracks emanating from rivet holes ahead of the lead crack, (3) panel CVP3 has
a circumferential butt joint with a lead crack, and (4) panel CVP4 has the same configuration and
lead crack as panel CVP3, with the addition of multiple small cracks emanating from rivet holes
ahead of the lead crack.
The panel configuration represents a generic fuselage structure from a narrow-body aircraft
fabricated according to original equipment manufacturing (OEM) specifications. Figures D-1
and D-2 show a schematic of the longitudinal lap joint and the circumferential butt joint panels,
respectively, including the dimensions and location of the strain gages. Details of the panel
configurations and locations of the strain gages can be found in appendices A and B,
respectively, of this report. A brief description is provided herein.
For the longitudinal lap joint panels CVP1 and CVP2, a lap joint was located along stringer S4 as
shown in figure D-1. The joint consisted of two layers of the 2024-T3 panel skin with a
thickness of 0.063 and two layers of 2024-T3 finger doublers with a thickness of 0.025. Four
rows of fasteners, A, B, C, and D were used to connect the skin and doublers. A crack-like slit
representing a lead crack was placed symmetrically across frame F4, machined in the skin along
the critical fastener row A in the longitudinal lap splice. The total length of the lead crack was
7.0. For panel CVP2, additional small cracks were machined in the fasteners ahead of the lead
crack in row A.
For panels CVP3 and CVP4, a circumferential butt joint was located between frames F3 and F4
as shown in figure D-2. The joint consisted of two layers of the 2024-T3 panel skin with a
thickness of 0.063, a 2024-T3 finger doubler with a thickness of 0.025, and a tapered doubler
with a maximum thickness of 0.08, which tapered to a thickness of 0.025 along the edge.
Eight rows of fasteners, A through H, were used to connect the skin and doublers. A crack-like
slit representing a lead crack was placed symmetrically across stringer S4, machined in the skin
D-1

along the critical fastener row A in the circumferential butt joint. Stringer S4 was cut to simulate
a broken stringer. The total length of the lead crack was 7.0. For panel CVP4, additional small
cracks were machined in the fasteners ahead of the lead crack in row A.
These panels were subjected to a sequence of three load conditions: (1) strain survey under
quasi-static loading, (2) fatigue test loading under constant-amplitude loading, and (3) residual
strength test under quasi-static loading up to fracture. Geometric nonlinear finite element
analyses were conducted to support the full-scale testing of the four fuselage panels for the strain
survey and the fatigue crack growth tests.
DESCRIPTION OF AIRFRAME COMPUTATIONAL MODELING FACILITY
Analysis to support the full-scale testing of four curved fuselage panels was conducted using the
Airframe Computational Modeling (ACM) facility. With advances in commuter technology,
computational modeling offers a cost-effective supplement to full-scale testing which can be
extremely expensive. The ACM facility has an in-house capability, at the Federal Aviation
Administration William J. Hughes Technical Center, Atlantic City International Airport, NJ, to
conduct high fidelity modeling and analysis of aircraft structures. The facility consists of three
UNIX-based Silicon Graphics Incorporated (SGI) computers interfaced in a local area network
(LAN) and running under IRIX 6.5 operating system. Two workstations are equipped with dual
250-MHz R10000 processors, 512 Mbytes of main memory, and 36 GBytes of hard disk space.
The third computer, a high-end server, is equipped with four 400-MHz MIPS R12000
processors, 1 Gbyte of main memory, and 180 GBytes of hard disk space.
Several commercial and government-developed software tools are used in the ACM facility. The
commercial tools include PATRAN, a pre- and postprocessor used for model development and
data reduction, and ABAQUS, a general-purpose finite element analysis package. The
government developed software tools tailored for fracture mechanics studies, including finite
element alternating method (FEAM), FRANC2D, and STAGS. In addition, a probabilistic-based
analysis tool, Transport Risk Assessment Containing Multiple Site Damage (TRACMSD), is
available to assess the effect of a variety of factors on the overall risk of aircraft under conditions
of aging. The ACM facility allows the FAA to develop and evaluate highly sophisticated
methods, which may be used by industry for airframe designs and maintenance and inspection
procedures. The ACM facility was used in this study to conduct analysis to support the full-scale
testing of the four curved panels.
ANALYTICAL PROCEDURE
The strain distributions and fracture parameters governing crack formation and growth were
determined for each panel using geometric nonlinear finite element analyses. The mixed mode
stress-intensity factors calculated using the MCCI method were used in a cycle-by-cycle crack
growth analysis program to predict the fatigue crack growth in the panels tested.
DESCRIPTION OF FINITE ELEMENT MODELS.
Geometric nonlinear finite element analyses were conducted using the commercial finite element
code ABAQUS 5.8 [D-1] in the ACM facility. Analyses of the strain survey and fatigue crack
D-2

growth were conducted for panels tested. As shown in figures D-3 through D-6, the finite
element models contained the major geometric details of the panels including the cross-section
properties and dimensions of the substructure (frames, stringers, shear-clip, and intercostals), the
finger doublers, the load attachment doublers, and reaction links. Table D-1 lists the components
of the model and the corresponding thickness, and material properties.
Figures D-3 and D-4 show the global view of typical finite element models for the longitudinal
lap joint and circumferential butt joint panels, respectively. Models were developed for each of
the four panels tested using general-purpose, two-dimensional shell elements with each node
having six degrees of freedom. The shell elements used account for finite membrane strains and
are suitable for large-strain analysis. Reduced integration was used to form the element stiffness.
In general, four-node shell elements were used throughout to model the skin, doublers, frames,
shear clip, stringers, and intercostals, except near the crack tips. In the immediate vicinity of the
crack tips, eight-node shell elements were used in forming an orthogonal mesh, where the size of
the elements were at least 1/40 of the lead crack length, as shown in figures D-5 and D-6, for the
longitudinal lap and circumferential butt joint panels, respectively. Skin, stringer, shear-clip,
frame, and finger doublers were modeled with a uniform thickness. Tapered doublers and
attachment doublers were modeled using shell elements with increased stepped uniform
thickness in the ranges specified in table D-1.
At the end of each frame, stainless steel reaction links, 1 wide, 0.5 thick, and 4 long are
attached in order to prevent rigid motion in the radial direction, as shown in figures D-5 and D-6.
These reaction links are modeled as grounded springs fixed on one end and provide a stiffness in
the radial direction. The value of stiffness used is based on the stainless steel properties and the
dimensions of the link.
Beam elements were used to model the fasteners that connected the substructures with the skin
and the substructures to one another. To simplify the global panel modeling, the fastener holes
were not modeled. Figure D-7 shows a schematic cross section of a lap joint with four layers
with thicknesses of t1 through t4 and the corresponding finite element representation. The layers
were modeled using shell elements having the same thickness and mid-plane location. A single
fastener that connects all four layers was modeled using three beams, designated a, b, and
c, aligned sequentially connecting each layer. The length of each beam was the distance
between the mid-planes of two adjacent shells. For example, for beam element a, the length
was (t1 + t2)/2.
For the strain survey analysis, the elements used to calculate values of strain were approximately
the same size and at the same location as the actual strain gages. The average characteristic
length of the elements used to calculate the strain was 0.125. As illustrated in figure D-8, the
strain gages were categorized in seven groups, according to similar gage locations with common
structural details and the measured strain directions: (1) frame outer cap location measuring
strains in the hoop direction; (2) frame inner cap location measuring strains in the hoop direction;
(3) stringer cap location measuring strains in the longitudinal direction; (4) stringer flange
location measuring strains in the longitudinal direction; (5) skin mid-bay location measuring
strains in the hoop direction; (6) skin mid-bay location measuring strains in the longitudinal
direction; and (7) skin mid-bay location measuring strains in the 45 direction.

D-3

MATERIAL PROPERTIES.
Mechanical Properties: Table D-1 lists the mechanical properties used for the shell elements to
model components including the skin, doublers, frames, shear-clip, stringers, and intercostals.
Mechanical properties were referenced from MIL-HDBK-5H [D-2].
Fastener Shear Stiffness: The empirical equation developed by Swift [D-3], shown below, was
used to calculate the fastener shear stiffness of the beam elements as:
k shear =

E' d
d
d
A + B +
t1 t 2

(1)

where E' is the effective modulus, d is the fastener diameter, and t1 and t2 are the thickness of the
two layers, and A and B are empirical constants based on the fastener material. Tables D-2 and
D-3 show the properties and data used to model fasteners in the longitudinal lap joint and
circumferential butt joint panels, respectively. Values of the fastener shear stiffness for the beam
elements connecting the layers in each of the fastener rows (see figures D-1 and D-2) are listed
along with the beam elements connecting the skin to stringer and skin to shear clip designated Y
and Z, respectively.
Reaction Link Stiffness: The value of stiffness used for the grounded spring elements is based
on the stainless steel properties and the dimensions of the link by:
k link =

EtW
30 10 6 (0.5)(1.0 )
=
= 3,750,000 lb/in
L
4 .0

(2)

where E is the link modulus of elasticity, and t, W, and L are the link thickness, width, and gage
length, respectively.
Fatigue Crack Growth Properties: Three sets of fatigue crack growth data [D-4 through D-6] for
2024-T3 aluminum were compiled, as shown in figure D-9, with varying R-ratios and used in the
fatigue crack growth analysis. The data shown by the black symbols generated by Phillips [D-4]
is in the region of slow crack growth and near the threshold conditions. The data shown by the
open symbols (generated by Hudson [D-5]) is in the straight line Paris region, and the data
shown by the gray symbols (by Dubensky [D-6]) is in the rapid unstable crack growth region.
For a given stress-intensity factors (SIF) range, the crack growth rate increases with increase in
the R-ratio.
CRACK CONFIGURATIONS.
The crack configurations of the panels were simulated using pairs of coincident nodes along the
shared edges of two rows of elements, as shown in the exploded view in figure D-10. In the
immediate vicinity of the crack tips, eight-node shell elements were used in forming an
orthogonal mesh where the size of the elements were at least 1/40 of the lead crack length, as

D-4

shown in figures D-5 and D-6, for the longitudinal lap and circumferential butt joint panels,
respectively. For the fatigue crack growth analysis, the lead crack length was increased in
separate finite element runs from the initial length to the final length. Tables D-4 through D-7
describe the crack length, the number of nodes, the number of elements for each element type,
and the crack tip element size for the finite element runs conducted for each panel. The number
of finite element runs conducted was 26 and 11 for each of the longitudinal lap joint panels and
the circumferential butt joint panels, respectively. Typical finite element models for the
longitudinal lap joint panels consist of 62,600 elements and 11,4600 nodes and for the
circumferential butt joint panels, 33,000 elements and 42,800 nodes.
TEST CONDITIONS.
The load conditions for the strain survey and fatigue crack growth tests are specified in tables
D-8 and D-9 for the longitudinal lap joint and circumferential butt joint panels, respectively. For
each type of panel, three quasi-static loadings were applied to assess the strain distribution and
reproducibility of the strain data. In load condition 1a, each panel was subjected to an internal
pressure, and the hoop and frame loads were applied as reactive loads to balance the internal
pressure. In load condition 1b, load was applied in the longitudinal direction along the edges of
the panels only. Load condition 1c is the superposition of load conditions 1a and 1b. For the
hoop load, 16.8% was applied on the six frames and the remaining load was applied on 28
loading points along the edge of the panel. The longitudinal load was applied on 16 loading
points along the edge of the panel. No load was applied directly on the stringers.
For longitudinal lap joint panels CVP1 and CVP2, load condition 1c simulates the cylindrical
pressurization that a section of the fuselage along the neutral axis would experience. Therefore,
the average hoop stress should be twice as much as the longitudinal stress. For these two panels,
a maximum internal pressure of 10.1 psi was used, resulting in a maximum load of 2218.4 lb. for
each loading point along the edge in the hoop direction and a maximum load of 2090.5 lb. for
each frame. The corresponding maximum load applied on each loading point along the
longitudinal edges was 1166.6 lb.
For circumferential butt joint panels CVP3 and CVP4, load condition 1c simulates a fuselage
down-bending condition that a fuselage section along the crown of the aircraft would experience,
where the longitudinal stress is 50% higher than the hoop stress. For these two panels, a
maximum internal pressure of 8.8 psi was used, resulting in a maximum load of 1927.3 lb. for
each loading point along the edge in the hoop direction and a maximum load of 1816.2 lb. for
each frame. The corresponding maximum load applied on each loading point along the
longitudinal edges was 3065.0 lb.
In load condition 2, the same loads as in load condition 1c were applied at constant-amplitude
and a frequency of 0.2 Hz with an R-ratio (minimum to maximum load) of 0.1 for all load
components except for the longitudinal load, which was 0.3.
MODEL BOUNDARY CONDITIONS.
For the hoop, frame, and longitudinal loads, nodal point forces (listed in tables D-8 and D-9)
were applied at the load application points in the actual test, as shown by the arrows in figures
D-5

D-3 and D-4, for the longitudinal lap and circumferential butt joint panels, respectively. Internal
pressure was applied to the inner surface of the skin elements. For the hoop load, 28 nodal
forces were applied along each edge; for the longitudinal load, 16 nodal forces were applied in
each end; and for the frame load, 12 nodal forces were applied to the ends of the frames. For the
strain survey analysis, the loads were applied incrementally in a ramp function up to the
maximum values for load conditions 1a, 1b, and 1c specified in tables D-8 and D-9. For the
fatigue crack growth analysis, load condition 2 (specified in tables D-8 and D-9) was applied
incrementally in a ramp function in two steps, each up to the minimum and maximum applied
loads as shown schematically in figure D-11. In this figure, time can be regarded as a dummy
variable denoting the value in the applied load.
To eliminate rigid-body motion, two node points located in the middle of each end were fixed in
the hoop direction and two nodes located in the middle of each edge were fixed in the
longitudinal direction, as shown in figures D-3 and D-4.
THE MODIFIED CRACK CLOSURE INTEGRAL (MCCI) METHOD
For fatigue crack growth predictions, the corresponding mixed mode SIF were calculated using
the MCCI method [D-7 through D-9]. In the MCCI approach, it is assumed that the energy
released during crack extension is the same as the work that would be needed to close the crack
and that the energy released can be related to the four components of SIF. The four components
of SIF are the Mode I SIF caused by tensile load, K1, the Mode II SIF cause by in-plane shear
load, K2, the SIF due to symmetric bending loads, k1, and the SIF due to out-of-plane shear and
twist loads, k2, as shown in figure D-12.
The MCCI method approximates the rate of work needed to close a crack using the local crack
tip displacements and forces. The displacements and forces at the nodes of the four elements
surrounding the crack tip were obtained from the finite element results for each crack length, as
shown in figure D-12. The work (Wi) done to close a crack of length a for each nodal degree of
freedom (DOF) is given by [D-9]:

Wi =

)]

1
Fi Close u itop u ibot , i = 1,L,6
2ta

(3)

where t is the thickness of the panel, F is the force needed to close the crack surfaces, u is the
displacement component on each surface of the crack, and i denotes the DOF. The total amount
of work done to close a crack of length a is numerically equal to the total amount of strain
energy released during a crack growth increment of a, and the components of strain energy
release rate:
G1 = W2 + W6
G2 = W1
G3 = W3
G 4 = W4
G5 = W5
D-6

(4)
(5)
(6)
(7)
(8)

The strain energy release rates can be related to the stress-intensity factors as:
K 12
G1 =
E

(9)

K 22
E

(10)

1 +

3 +

(11)

G2 =
G4 =

k12
3E

G3 + G5 =

k 22
3E

1 +

3 +

(12)

where E = 10500 ksi and = 0.33 are the modulus of elasticity and Poisons ratio of the panel
skin material, and K1, K2, k1, and k2 are the SIF described earlier. Only the Mode I SIF, K1, was
used to predict the fatigue crack growth behavior because, as will be shown, it was found to be
the dominant SIF.
CRACK GROWTH ALGORITHM.
The SIF range and the crack growth data for 2024-T3 aluminum were used in a cycle-by-cycle
crack growth analysis program to predict the fatigue crack growth in panels tested. The
algorithm used is illustrated in figure D-13. All parameters are initialized in step 1, including the
counter i, the initial cycle number, and crack length. The algorithm then enters a loop in step 2
where, for a given crack length, ai, the SIF range, (K)i, is determined from linear interpolation
of tabular SIF versus crack length data obtained from the finite element analysis. For the
calculated SIF, (K)i, and given R-ratio, the corresponding crack growth rate, (da dN )i , is
determined in step 3 from experimental tabular data at various R-ratios using linear interpolation.
In step 4, the crack length, ai+1, and cycle, Ni+1, are updated, assuming the incremental crack
extension, ai, is equal to the crack growth rate, (da dN )i , in a cycle-by-cycle analysis with Ni
equal to 1. A check is made in step 5 to terminate the algorithm in step 9 if the updated crack
length, ai+1, is greater than or equal to the final crack length, afinal. If not, a check is made in step
6 to determine if linkup occurred between the lead crack and multiple-site damage (MSD) or
between the lead crack and rivet hole. If no linkup occurs, the increment counter is increased in
step 8 and the algorithm returns to step 2. If a linkup event occurs, then step 7 increases the
crack length. For the case of MSD linkup, the crack length, ai+1, is instantaneously increased by
the length of the two MSD cracks, 2amsd, and the diameter of the rivet hole, driv. For the case of
rivet hole linkup, the crack length, ai+1, is instantaneously increased by the diameter of the rivet
hole, driv. The increment counter is increased in step 8 and the algorithm returns to step 2. This
process is repeated until the crack length is equal to or greater than the final crack length where
the algorithm terminates at step 9.

D-7

RESULTS
Results from the analysis to study the strain distribution and fatigue crack growth for both joint
configurations are presented.
STRAIN DISTRIBUTIONS.
The strain distributions were predicted at equal load increments up to the maximum values for
load conditions 1a through 1c in table D-8 for the longitudinal lap joint panels and for load
conditions 1a through 1c in table D-9 for the circumferential butt joint panels. A preliminary
analysis revealed that small multiple cracks had no effect on the calculated strains at the strain
gage locations for both joint configurations. Therefore, only one analysis was conducted for
each joint configuration for the strain distribution calculation.
The predicted strains at the strain gage locations are provided in tables D-10 through D-12 for
the longitudinal lap joint panels and in tables D-13 through D-15 for the circumferential butt
joint panels. The locations of strain gages are shown schematically in figures D-1 and D-2. For
each loading condition, the applied loads and calculated strains at equal load increments up to the
maximum loads are listed. Ten load increments were used for the longitudinal lap joint panels,
and five load increments were used for the circumferential butt joint panels. The pressure
applied to the inner surface of the skin is in units of psi, the frame loads applied to each of the 12
frame ends are in units of lbs., the hoop loads applied at the 28 locations along each side of the
panel are in units of lbs., and the longitudinal load applied at the 16 locations along each end of
the panel are in units of lbs. The strains calculated at the gage locations are in units of .
The measured and predicted strain data were categorized in seven groups, as illustrated in
figure D-8, according to similar gage locations in common structural details and the measured
strain directions. Comparisons between the measured and predicted strains of the seven groups
for each load condition are shown in figures D-14 through D-34 for longitudinal lap panels,
CVP1 and CVP2, and in figures D-35 through D-55 for the circumferential butt joint panels
CVP3 and CVP4. For the longitudinal lap joint panel, results for load conditions 1a, 1b, and 1c
are shown in figures D-14 through D-20, figures D-21 through D-27, and figures D-28 through
D-34, respectively. For the circumferential butt joint panels, results for load conditions 1a, 1b,
and 1c are shown in figures D-35 through D-41, figures D-42 through D-48, and figures D-49
through D-55, respectively. For each panel, four sets of experimental results are plotted, two
using air and two using water as the pressurization media.
As shown in figures D-14 through D-55, there was more scatter in the experiments for strains
measured farthest from the skin: group 2, frame inner cap, and group 4, stringer flange. In
general, good agreement was obtained between experiments and analysis for strains measured in
the principle loading direction for gages closest to the skin; group 1, frame outer cap; group 3,
stringer cap; group 5, skin hoop; group 6, skin longitudinal; and group 7, skin 45.
The strain at the maximum load predicted by finite element analysis was compared with the
experimental data. For load condition 1a, each panel was subjected to an internal pressure, while
hoop and frame loads were applied as reactive loads from the internal pressure. Even though
load was not applied in the longitudinal direction, longitudinal strain still developed in the skin
D-8

and stringers, as the result of Poissons effect and difference in stiffness between the skin and
stringers. The magnitude of the longitudinal strain, however, was in general much smaller
compared to that in the hoop direction.
Table D-16 shows the comparison for panel CVP1 subjected to loading condition 1a. The test
results obtained from two air runs and two water runs were averaged first, and then compared
with that of analysis. The standard deviation of the test results for each gage is also listed in the
table, serving as an indication of the consistency of the test data. In addition, according to their
locations and directions, the gages were grouped into seven groups, two for frame gages, two for
stringer gages, and three for skin gages. For each group, a group percentage error, defined by the
following equation, was also calculated

Group % Error =

(e a )
(e )

ave
i

ave 2
i

100%

(12)

where eiave is the averaged experimental data of the i th gage and ai is the corresponding analysis
result.
As indicated in table D-16, for strain gages located in the substructure, good agreement (a 13.2%
group error) was obtained between the measurement and predictions for frame gages located at
outer cap region, group 1, which is closest to the skin. For the gages located at the frame inner
cap region, group 2, that is farthest from the skin, the agreement was not as good. This may be
attributed to the experimental data being less consistent, as indicated by their relatively high
standard deviations. The agreement for gages located at stringers was relatively poor (93.7% for
stringer hat gages, group 3 and 26.8% for stringer flange gages, group 4). However, the
magnitude of strain generally was much smaller since the measurement was in the direction
normal to the loading direction.
Also shown in table D-16, for strain gages located on the skin, an excellent agreement, i.e., a
9.0% group error was obtained between measurement and prediction for strain component in the
hoop direction, group 5, measuring strain in the principle loading direction. A good agreement
was also obtained for the 45-degree strain component (a 12.6% group error). The agreement was
not as good for the longitudinal strain component, group 7 (a 39.3% group error), but the
magnitude of strain in that direction was much smaller because it is normal to the loading
direction. It should be noted that the high percentage error for the longitudinal strain component,
group 6, was mainly due to gage SG35L, which has unusually low experimental results.
Table D-17 shows the comparison for panel CVP1 subjected to loading condition 1b,
longitudinal load applied on the edges of the skin only. Load was not applied directly on the
stringers, although they tended to deform with the skin in the longitudinal direction. The hoop
strain on the skin and frames was the result of Poissons effect and differences in stiffness
between the skin and frames. Only two test results using water as the pressure media were
recorded. For the substructure, excellent agreement (a 2.2% group error) was obtained for gages
located at the stringer hat region (closest to the skin). For the gages located at the stringer flange

D-9

region (farthest from the skin), the agreement was not as good (a 35.0% group error). For the
gages located at frames, which were aligned in the direction normal to the loading, the agreement,
as expected, was relatively poor (35.4% for outer cap gages and 26.5% for inner cap gages). For
strain gages located on the skin, an excellent agreement (a 7.5% group error) was obtained
between measurement and prediction for strain component in the longitudinal (loading)
direction. The agreement was almost as good for the hoop strain (a 8.1% group error) and was
fair for the 45-degree strain (a 16.6% group error).
Table D-18 shows the comparison for panel CVP1 subjected to loading condition 1c, a
cylindrical pressurization of a fuselage along the neutral axis. Therefore, the hoop direction can
be considered as the primary loading direction, while the longitudinal direction is considered the
secondary loading direction. For the skin gages, excellent agreement was obtained for the strain
components in the primary loading (hoop) direction (10.3%) and 45-degree direction (7.8%). In
the secondary loading direction, the agreement was not as good (17.2%), but the magnitude of
strain was small. For the substructure, the comparison for the frame gage locations (in the
primary loading direction) was better than those on the stringers, and the comparison for gages
located closest to the skin also fared better than those that were farthest from the skin.
In summary, for panel CVP1, excellent agreement was obtained between measured and predicted
strain for skin mid-bay gages in the primary loading direction, with the average percentage error
ranging from 7.5% to 10.3%. In the direction normal to the primary loading, the percentage
error ranged from 8.1% to 39.3%, but the magnitude of strain was generally much smaller. For
the substructure, the gages located closest to the skin and aligned in the direction of primary
loading also compared very well with average percentage error ranging from 2.2% to 13.2%.
Gages that were aligned normal to the primary loading direction or located farthest from the skin
typically compared poorly.
A similar trend was observed for panel CVP2 subjected to the same load conditions as CVP1.
The results of comparison are listed in tables D-19 through D-22.
For the circumferential butt joint panels CVP3 and CVP4, the comparisons for load conditions
1a, 1b, and 1c, as shown in table D-9, are given in tables D-23 through D-27. It is noted that for
these two panels, load condition 1c simulates a fuselage down-bending condition that a fuselage
section along the crown of the aircraft would experience. Therefore, the longitudinal stress is
50% higher than the hoop stress. Consequently, the longitudinal direction was considered as the
primary loading direction, while the hoop direction is considered the secondary loading direction.
For panel CVP3, the average percentage error for skin mid-bay gage locations in the primary
loading direction ranged from 10.9% to 16.9%. For gages on substructure that aligned in the
primary loading direction and located closest to the skin, the average percentage error ranged
from 11.9% to 12.1%. For panel CVP4, the corresponding average percentage errors were from
10.1% to 15.0 % and from 7.7% to 38.9%, respectively.
Table D-28 summaries the group percentage errors for all four panels subjected to the three load
conditions. In general, good agreement was obtained between experiments and analysis for
strains measured in the principle loading direction for gages closest to the skin: group 1, frame
outer cap; group 3, stringer cap; group 5, skin hoop; group 6, skin longitudinal; and group 7, skin

D-10

45. The agreement was not as good for strains measured in the secondary loading direction,
particularly for the gages located farthest from the skin: group 2, frame inner cap and group 4,
the stringer flange.
DEFORMATION FIELDS.
Numerical simulations of the deformation process at several crack lengths are shown in
figure D-56 for the longitudinal lap joint panels CVP1 and CVP2. In this figure, the displaced
meshes are shown at the maximum applied load for load condition 2 in table D-8. The
displacements have been scaled by 25. The inset shows the local crack-tip deformation in each
of the two panels. As indicated, crack-bulging deformation occurred. As the crack length
increased, the distance between the crack edges increased indicating Mode I crack deformation.
Mode III crack deformation also occur where out-of-plane (bulging) deflection of one of the
crack faces occurred opposite to the lap joint. There was little deflection of the crack face
reinforced by the lap joint.
For the circumferential butt joint panels CVP3 and CVP4, the numerical simulation of the
deformation process is shown in figure D-57, at several crack lengths. In this figure the
displacement meshes are shown at the maximum applied load for load condition 2 in table D-9.
The displacements have been scaled by 40. The inset shows the local crack-tip deformation in
each of the two panels. Unlike the longitudinal lap joint panel, little crack-bulging deformation
occurred for the circumferential butt joint panels. As the shown in the figure, as the crack length
increased, the distance between the crack edges increased, indicating primarily Mode I crack
deformation.
STRESS-INTENSITY FACTOR SOLUTIONS.
The predicted SIF ranges for the lead crack in panels CVP1 and CVP2 are listed in table D-29
and shown in figure D-58. The numbers inside the circles along the x axis represent the location
of rivets. As shown in the figure, K1, which governs Mode I crack growth, is the dominant SIF
range. The next highest SIF range, k2, which would cause Mode III crack growth, was not
significant. Thus, only the Mode I SIF was used to predict the crack growth. As the lead crack
tip approached the rivet directly ahead, the SIF increased more for CVP2 compared to CVP1 due
to the small cracks at the rivet hole.
The predicted stress-intensity factor ranges for the lead crack in panels CVP3 and CVP4 are
listed in table D-30 and shown in figure D-59. The numbers inside the circles along the x axis
represent the location of rivets. As shown in the figure, K1, which governs Mode I crack
growth, is the dominant SIF range. The next highest SIF ranges, k1 and k2, which would
cause crack-bulging deflections, were not significant. Thus, as for the longitudinal lap joint
panels, the Mode I SIF was used to predict the crack growth. As the lead crack tip approached
the rivet directly ahead, the SIF increased more for CVP4 compared to CVP3 due to the small
cracks at the rivet hole. In both panels, for crack lengths longer than the stringer spacing of 7.5,
the SIF ranges decreased slightly due to the stiffening of stringers bridging the crack.

D-11

FATIGUE CRACK GROWTH.


The half length of the lead crack, as a function of number of fatigue cycles, is shown in
figure D-60 for panels CVP1 and CVP2. The initial half-crack length prior to loading was 3.5.
In the figure, the circular and square symbols represent the measured crack lengths at the left and
the right crack tips, respectively, for each panel. The numbers inside the circles along the y axis
represent the location of rivets. For panel CVP1, indicated by the open symbols, the vertical
jumps indicate crack extension across a rivet hole. When this happened, the crack length
increased instantaneously by the diameter of the rivet hole. The rate of crack growth increased
as the crack tip approached the rivet hole. The horizontal segments shown in the plot indicate
the number of cycles before the crack reformed on the opposite side of the rivet hole. As the
crack length increased, the delay in crack reformation (incubation period) decreased due to the
larger crack driving force. For panel CVP2, which contained multiple cracks, the vertical jumps
in the experimental data indicate linkup of the lead crack and a small multiple crack. When this
happened, the crack length increased instantaneously by the diameter of the rivet hole plus the
lengths of the small cracks at that rivet. There was no crack reformation. The length of the lead
crack front instantaneously grew the length of the small cracks located in the rivets directly
ahead. As a result, the number of cycles needed to grow the lead crack to the final length
(~12.5inches) in panel CVP2 was approximately 37% less than that in panel CVP1.
The Mode I SIF range, K1, (figure D-58) and crack growth data for 2024-T3 aluminum
(figure D-9) were used in a cycle-by-cycle crack growth analysis program to predict the fatigue
crack growth in panels CVP1 and CVP2, also shown in figure D-60. For panel CVP1, crack
growth across rivet hole, indicated by the vertical jumps in the curve, was modeled by
instantaneously increasing the length of the crack by the diameter of the rivet hole when the lead
crack reached the rivet. For panel CVP2, crack growth at the rivet was modeled by
instantaneously increasing the length of the crack by the diameter of the rivet plus the length of
the small cracks at the rivet when the lead crack reached the first small crack. It is important to
note that only K1 was used to predict crack growth since it was the dominant SIF. There were
indications of Mode III loading as indicated by k2 values shown in figure D-58 and
crack-bulging deflection observed during the test. Mode III crack growth was not included in the
crack growth analysis due to the lack of experimental crack growth data. Good agreement was
obtained between experiments and predictions relying on K1. For CVP2, the growth of the
small multiple crack in the rivet ahead of the lead crack was not modeled for in the analysis.
The fatigue crack growth behavior of panels CVP3 and CVP4 is shown in figure D-61. The
initial half-crack length prior to loading was approximately 3.5. In the figure, the circular and
square symbols represent the measured crack lengths of the left and the right crack and CVP4
tips, respectively, from both panels. The numbers inside the circles along the y axis indicates the
locations of the rivets. For panel CVP3, crack growth across a rivet hole is indicated by a
vertical jump in the data, where the crack length instantaneously increased by a length equal to
the hole diameter. The horizontal segments shown in the plot indicate the incubation period or
the number of cycles for the crack to reform on the opposite side of the rivet hole. For panel
CVP4, which contained multiple cracks, the vertical jumps in the experimental data indicate the
point when the lead crack and small multiple crack linked up. When this happened, the crack
length increased instantaneously by the diameter of the rivet hole plus the lengths of the small

D-12

cracks at that rivet. There was no crack reformation required. The small crack at the rivet hole
on the opposite side became the new lead crack front. As a result, the number of cycles to grow
the lead crack to the third rivet hole in panel CVP4 was approximately 27%, less than that in
panel CVP3. At the third rivet hole on either side, 5R and 5L, the crack had just reached the first
intact stringers (S3 and S5). The additional stiffness added by the stringers increased the
incubation period for panel CVP3 and decreased the subsequent crack growth rate for both
panels.
The Mode I SIF range, K1, (figure D-59) and the crack growth data for 2024-T3 aluminum
(figure 9) were used in a cycle-by-cycle crack growth analysis program to predict the fatigue
crack growth in panels CVP3 and CVP4, also shown in figure D-61. The analysis based on K1
was in good agreement with the test data for crack growth in both panels until the crack reached
the intact stringer. Little crack bulging was observed during the test, indicating that the crack
growth was primarily due to Mode I loading.
CONCLUDING REMARKS
Geometric nonlinear finite element analyses were conducted to determine strain distributions and
fracture parameters governing crack formation and growth. In general, for the strain
distributions, good agreement was obtained between experiments and analysis for strains
measured in the principle loading direction for gages closest to the skin. The agreement was not
as good for strains measured in the secondary loading direction, particularly for the gages located
farthest from the skin.
For fatigue crack growth predictions, the corresponding mixed mode stress-intensity factors were
calculated using the Modified Crack Closure Integral (MCCI) method. The Mode I stressintensity factor (SIF) range was used in a cycle-by-cycle crack growth analysis program to
predict the fatigue crack growth in the panels tested. Reasonable agreement was obtained
between experimental fatigue crack growth data and predictions relying on the Mode I SIF
calculated using finite element analyses. The Mode I SIF was dominate compared to the other
modes. The number of cycles to grow a fatigue crack to a predetermined length was reduced by
approximately 37% due to the presence of multiple cracks for the longitudinal lap joint panels
and 27% for the circumferential butt joint panels.
REFERENCES
D-1.

ABAQUS Version 5.8, Hibbitt, Karlsson, and Sorensen (HKS), 1080 Main Street,
Pawtucket, RI 02860, USA, 1998.

D-2.

Metallic Materials and Elements for Aerospace Vehicle Structures, MIL-HDBK-5H,


Change Notice 1, October 2001.

D-3.

Swift, T., Development of the Fail-Safe Design Features of the DC-10, American
Society for Testing and Materials Special Technical Publication 486, 1970, pp. 164-214.

D-4.

Hudson, C.M., Effect of Stress Ratio on Fatigue Crack Growth in 7075-T6 and 2024-T3
Aluminum Alloy Specimens, NASA TN D-5390, 1969.
D-13

D-5.

Phillips, E.P., The Influence of Crack Closure on Fatigue Crack Growth Thresholds in
2024-T3 Aluminum Alloys, ASTM STP 982, 1988, pp. 505-515.

D-6.

Dubensky, R.G., Fatigue Crack Propagation in 2024-T3 and 7075-T6 Aluminum Alloys
at High Stress, NASA CR-1732, 1971.

D-7.

Rybicki, E.F. and Kanninen, M.F., A Finite Element Calculation of Stress-Intensity


Factors by a Modified Crack Closure Integral, Engineering Fracture Mechanics, Vol. 9,
1977, pp. 931-938.

D-8.

Potyondy, D.O., Ph.D. Thesis, School of Civil and Environmental Engineering, Cornell
University 1993.

D-9.

Viz, M.J., Potyondy, D.O., and Zehnder, A.T., Computation of Membrane and Bending
Stress-Intensity Factors for Thin, Cracked Plates, International Journal of Fracture,
Vol. 72, 1995, pp. 21-38.

D-14

TABLE D-1. MECHANICAL PROPERTIES REFERENCED FROM MIL-HDBK-5H [D-2]


Component
Skin
Stringer
Frame
Shear-Clip
Intercostal
Finger Doublers
Attachment Doublers
Tapered Doublers

Material
2024-T3
7075-T3
7075-T3
7075-T3
7075-T3
2024-T3
2024-T3
2024-T3

Thickness (in)
0.063
0.071
0.071
0.063
0.040
0.025
0.125-0.50
0.025-0.08

Modulus of
Elasticity (ksi)
10500
10300
10300
10300
10300
10500
10500
10500

Poissons
Ratio
0.33
0.33
0.33
0.33
0.33
0.33
0.33
0.33

TABLE D-2. PROPERTIES USED TO MODEL FASTENERS FOR CVP1 AND CVP2

Fastener
Row
A

Fastener Type
MS20470AD5

Fastener
Diameter,
d (in)
0.15625

MS20470AD6

0.1875

MS20470AD6

0.1875

MS20470AD6

0.1875

NAS1097KE6

0.1875

NAS1097KE6

0.1875

NAS1097KE6

0.1875

NAS1097KE6

0.1875

MS20470AD5

0.15625

NAS1097AD6

0.1875

NAS1097AD6

0.1875

Fastener
Material,
A, B
Aluminum
5.0, 0.8
Aluminum
5.0, 0.8
Aluminum
5.0, 0.8
Aluminum
5.0, 0.8
Aluminum
5.0, 0.8
Aluminum
5.0, 0.8
Aluminum
5.0, 0.8
Aluminum
5.0, 0.8
Aluminum
5.0, 0.8
Aluminum
5.0, 0.8
Aluminum
5.0, 0.8

Effective
Modulus
E (KSI)
10500
10500
10500
10500
10500
10500
10500
10500
10500
10500
10500

D-15

Layer1/
Layer 2
Outer Skin
Outer Doubler
Outer Skin
Outer Doubler
Outer Doubler
Inner Skin
Inner Skin
Inner Doubler
Outer Skin
Outer Doubler
Outer Doubler
Inner Skin
Inner Skin
Inner Doubler
Inner Doubler
Stringer
Inner Skin
Inner Doubler
Skin
Stringer
Skin
Shear Clip

Layer
Thick.
(in),
t1 /t2
0.063
0.025
0.063
0.025
0.025
0.063
0.063
0.025
0.063
0.025
0.025
0.063
0.063
0.025
0.025
0.071
0.063
0.025
0.063
0.071
0.063
0.063

Shear
Stiffness,
kshear (lb/in)
136899.8
147130.8
147130.8
147130.8
147130.8
147130.8
147130.8
150140.9
136899.8
207375.9
201676.8

TABLE D-3. PROPERTIES USED TO MODEL FASTENERS FOR CVP3 AND CVP4

Fastener
Row
A, H

Fastener Type
MS20470AD5

Fastener
Diameter,
d (in)
0.15625

B, G

NAS1097AD6

0.1875

B, G

NAS1097AD6

0.1875

C, F

NAS1097AD6

0.1875

C, F

NAS1097AD6

0.1875

D, E

HLT 435-6

0.1875

D, E

HLT 435-6

0.1875

NAS1097AD6

0.1875

NAS1097AD6

0.1875

Fastener
Material,
A, B
Aluminum
5.0, 0.8
Aluminum
5.0, 0.8
Aluminum
5.0, 0.8
Aluminum
5.0, 0.8
Aluminum
5.0, 0.8
Titanium
4.0, 0.82
Titanium
4.0, 0.82
Aluminum
5.0, 0.8
Aluminum
5.0, 0.8

Effective
Modulus
E (KSI)
10500
10500
10500
10500
10500
10500
10500
10500
10500

D-16

Layer1/
Layer 2
Top Skin
Finger Doubler
Top Skin
Finger Doubler
Finger Doubler
Tapper Doubler
Top Skin
Finger Doubler
Finger Doubler
Tapper Doubler
Top Skin
Finger Doubler
Finger Doubler
Tapper Doubler
Skin
Stringer
Skin
Shear Clip

Layer
Thick.
(in),
t1 /t2
0.063
0.025
0.063
0.025
0.025
0.0525
0.063
0.025
0.025
0.080
0.063
0.025
0.025
0.080
0.063
0.071
0.063
0.063

Shear
Stiffness,
kshear (lb/in)
136899.8
147130.8
142074.7
147130.8
152912.6
156368.2
163085.7
187613.8
182936.9

TABLE D-4. FINITE ELEMENT MODEL INFORMATION FOR CVP1


Finite Element
Run

Crack Length,
a(in)

Number of Shell
Elements

Number of Beam
Elements

Total Number
of Nodes

Crack Tip Element


Dimension (in by in)

cvp1_1_1
cvp1_1_2
cvp1_1_3
cvp1_1_4
cvp1_1_5
cvp1_2_1
cvp1_2_2
cvp1_2_3
cvp1_2_4
cvp1_2_5
cvp1_3_1
cvp1_3_2
cvp1_3_3
cvp1_3_4
cvp1_4_1
cvp1_4_3
cvp1_4_4
cvp1_5_1
cvp1_5_3
cvp1_5_4
cvp1_6_1
cvp1_6_3
cvp1_6_4
cvp1_7_1
cvp1_7_3
cvp1_7_4

3.563
3.844
4.125
4.219
4.289
4.714
5.036
5.357
5.705
5.759
6.188
6.469
6.750
7.149
7.768
8.464
8.652
9.241
9.964
10.125
10.734
11.344
11.695
12.214
12.857
13.179

61396
61396
61432
56356
56356
61396
61432
61432
58748
58748
62156
61432
61432
59948

2099
2099
2099
2099
2099
2099
2099
2099
2099
2099
2099
2099
2099
2099

116952
116964
117092
101928
101912
117062
117208
117220
109288
109268
119478
117344
117356
112952

0.0938 x 0.0939
0.0938 x 0.0939
0.0469 x 0.0470
0.0234 x 0.0235
0.0234 x 0.0235
0.0268 x 0.0235
0.1070 x 0.0939
0.1070 x 0.0939
0.0268 x 0.0235
0.0268 x 0.0235
0.0234 x 0.0235
0.0937 x 0.0939
0.0937 x 0.0939
0.0234 x 0.0235

61432
59948

2099
2099

117456
113016

0.1070 x 0.0939
0.0268 x 0.0235

61432
59948

2099
2099

117545
113068

0.1070 x 0.0939
0.0268 x 0.0235

61432
59348

2099
2099

117632
111324

0.0937 x 0.0939
0.0234 x 0.0235

61432
59348

2099
2099

117772
111384

0.1070 x 0.0939
0.0268 x 0.0235

D-17

TABLE D-5. FINITE ELEMENT MODEL INFORMATION FOR CVP2


Finite Element
Run

Crack Length,
a(in)

Number of Shell
Elements

Number of Beam
Elements

Total Number
of Nodes

Crack Tip Element


Dimension (in by in)

cvp2_1_1
cvp2_1_2
cvp2_1_3
cvp2_1_4
cvp2_1_5
cvp2_2_1
cvp2_2_2
cvp2_2_3
cvp2_2_4
cvp2_2_5
cvp2_3_1
cvp2_3_2
cvp2_3_3
cvp2_3_4
cvp2_4_1
cvp2_4_3
cvp2_4_4
cvp2_5_1
cvp2_5_3
cvp2_5_4
cvp2_6_1
cvp2_6_3
cvp2_6_4
cvp2_7_1
cvp2_7_3
cvp2_7_4

3.563
3.844
4.125
4.219
4.289
4.714
5.036
5.357
5.705
5.759
6.188
6.469
6.750
7.149
7.768
8.464
8.652
9.241
9.964
10.125
10.734
11.344
11.695
12.214
12.857
13.179

61396
61396
61432
56356
56356
61432
61432
61432
58748
58748
61432
61432
61432
59948
61432
61432
59948
61432
61432
59948
61432
61432
59348
61432
61432
59348

2099
2099
2099
2099
2099
2099
2099
2099
2099
2099
2099
2099
2099
2099
2099
2099
2099
2099
2099
2099
2099
2099
2099
2099
2099
2099

117010
117022
117150
101982
101966
117232
117262
117274
109341
109322
117350
117382
117394
113030
117462
117494
113086
117550
117582
113118
117662
117694
111386
117794
117834
111446

0.0938 x 0.0939
0.0938 x 0.0939
0.0469 x 0.0470
0.0234 x 0.0235
0.0234 x 0.0235
0.0268 x 0.0235
0.1070 x 0.0939
0.1070 x 0.0939
0.0268 x 0.0235
0.0268 x 0.0235
0.0234 x 0.0235
0.0937 x 0.0939
0.0937 x 0.0939
0.0234 x 0.0235
0.0536 x 0.0470
0.1070 x 0.0939
0.0268 x 0.0235
0.0536 x 0.0470
0.1070 x 0.0939
0.0268 x 0.0235
0.0469 x 0.0470
0.0937 x 0.0939
0.0234 x 0.0235
0.0268 x 0.0235
0.1070 x 0.0939
0.0268 x 0.0235

TABLE D-6. FINITE ELEMENT MODEL INFORMATION FOR CVP3


Finite Element
Run

Crack Length,
a(in)

Number of Shell
Elements

Number of Beam
Elements

Total Number
of Nodes

Crack Tip Element


Dimension (in by in)

cvp3_1_1
cvp3_1_3
cvp3_1_4
cvp3_1_5
cvp3_2_1
cvp3_2_3
cvp3_2_5
cvp3_3_1
cvp3_3_3
cvp3_3_6
cvp3_3_9

3.474
3.849
4.131
4.224
4.693
5.209
5.677
6.140
7.080
8.480
8.760

28850
28850
28850
28850
31826
31826
31826
31826
31826
31826
31826

2335
2335
2335
2335
2329
2329
2329
2325
2327
2327
2327

36990
37006
37018
37022
45978
46022
46070
46102
46182
46302
46326

01097 x 0.0938
01097 x 0.0938
01094 x 0.0938
01094 x 0.0938
0.0547 x 0.0469
0.0547 x 0.0469
0.0547 x 0.0469
0.0554 x 0.0469
0.0548 x 0.0471
0.0550 x 0.0469
0.0551 x 0.0469

D-18

TABLE D-7. FINITE ELEMENT MODEL INFORMATION FOR CVP4


Finite Element
Run

Crack Length,
a(in)

Number of Shell
Elements

Number of Beam
Elements

Total Number of
Nodes

Crack Tip Element


Dimension (in by in)

cvp4_1_1
cvp4_1_3
cvp4_1_4
cvp4_1_5
cvp4_2_1
cvp4_2_3
cvp4_2_5
cvp4_3_1
cvp4_3_3
cvp4_3_6
cvp4_3_9

3.474
3.849
4.131
4.224
4.693
5.209
5.677
6.140
7.080
8.480
8.760

28850
28850
28850
29338
31826
31826
31826
31826
31826
31826
31826

2335
2335
2335
2335
2329
2329
2329
2327
2327
2327
2327

37004
37020
37032
38547
46000
46044
46092
46124
46204
46324
46348

0.1097 x 0.0938
0.1097 x 0.0938
0.1094 x 0.0938
0.0547 x 0.0469
0.0547 x 0.0469
0.0547 x 0.0469
0.0548 x 0.0469
0.0554 x 0.0469
0.0548 x 0.0471
0.0550 x 0.0469
0.0551 x 0.0469

TABLE D-8. LOADING SEQUENCE AND CONDITIONS OF PANELS CVP1 AND CVP2
Load
Condition
1a
1b
1c
2

Test
Type
Quasi-Static
Loading, Strain
Survey
Quasi-Static
Loading, Strain
Survey
Quasi-Static
Loading, Strain
Survey
Cyclic Fatigue
Crack Growth

Pressure (psi)

Minimum and Maximum Load


Hoop (lb)
Frame (lb)

Long. (lb)

0 to 10.1

0 to 2218.4

0 to 2090.5

0 to 0

0 to 0

0 to 0

0 to 0

0 to 1166.6

0 to 10.1

0 to 2218.4

0 to 2090.5

0 to 1166.6

1.0 to 10.1

221.8 to 2218.4

209.1 to 2090.5

116.7 to 1166.6

TABLE D-9. LOADING SEQUENCE AND CONDITIONS OF PANELS CVP3 AND CVP4
Load
Condition
1a
1b
1c
2

Test
Type
Quasi-Static
Loading, Strain
Survey
Quasi-Static
Loading, Strain
Survey
Quasi-Static
Loading, Strain
Survey
Cyclic Fatigue
Crack Growth

Minimum to Maximum Load


Hoop (lb)
Frame (lb)

Pressure (psi)

Long. (lb)

0 to 8.8

0 to 1927.3

0 to 1816.2

0 to 0

0 to 0

0 to 0

0 to 0

0 to 3065.0

0 to 8.8

0 to 1927.3

0 to 1816.2

0 to 3065.0

0.9 to 8.8

192.7 to 1927.3

181.6 to 1816.2

919.5 to 3065.0

D-19

TABLE D-10. FINITE ELEMENT PREDICTIONS OF STRAIN FOR LONGITUDINAL LAP


JOINT PANELS CVP1 AND CVP2, LOAD CONDITION 1a
Increment
Pressure (psi)
Frame Load (lb.)
Hoop Load (lb.)
Long. Load (lb.)
SG01
SG02
SG03
SG04
SG05
SG06
SG07
SG08
SG09
SG10
SG11
SG12
SG13
SG14
SG15
SG16
SG17
SG18
SG19
SG20
SG21
SG22
SG23
SG24
SG25
SG26
SG27
SG28
SG29T
SG29-45
SG29L
SG30T
SG30-45
SG30L
SG31T
SG31-45
SG31L
SG32T
SG32-45
SG32L
SG33T
SG33-45
SG33L
SG34T
SG34-45
SG34L
SG35T
SG35-45
SG35L
SG36T
SG36-45
SG36L
SG37T
SG37-45
SG37L

1
1.01
209.05
221.84
0.00
55.45
57.40
63.25
53.84
61.49
66.45
55.00
52.96
62.43
65.10
45.52
92.01
55.83
64.68
71.77
42.43
76.29
43.03
70.27
41.66
-27.75
-4.38
-31.07
-6.18
-30.49
-13.80
-23.89
-7.78
123.15
58.41
-5.94
121.75
57.42
-8.83
57.61
23.79
-15.47
122.79
58.33
-13.44
122.61
52.90
-13.51
123.09
58.94
-6.32
58.56
20.36
-20.93
110.08
42.70
-15.92
107.31
45.83
-18.77

2
2.02
418.09
443.69
0.00
113.47
115.54
128.86
108.38
125.15
133.01
112.84
106.43
128.34
126.23
96.02
176.50
115.72
125.32
144.58
86.10
153.19
87.16
141.81
84.63
-57.45
-7.25
-64.67
-10.77
-58.32
-28.00
-47.14
-16.71
224.75
104.27
-15.97
223.80
103.28
-20.63
134.74
56.40
-32.15
225.32
103.87
-30.61
225.23
94.29
-30.55
224.72
104.67
-16.44
135.85
52.35
-37.62
209.24
79.43
-33.92
206.83
88.78
-35.39

3
3.03
627.14
665.53
0.00
173.10
174.30
195.83
163.82
190.26
200.04
172.43
160.68
196.48
185.05
149.34
257.00
178.13
183.62
217.91
130.43
230.44
131.87
214.01
128.32
-88.23
-9.32
-99.39
-14.66
-85.40
-42.35
-70.12
-26.19
317.37
144.82
-27.77
317.23
144.02
-33.81
219.97
92.39
-49.75
319.88
144.22
-49.29
319.98
131.23
-49.07
317.34
144.84
-28.23
221.89
89.97
-52.12
303.35
113.58
-52.75
301.60
129.92
-50.86

4.04
836.18
887.38
0.00
233.88
233.56
263.71
220.02
256.38
267.51
233.23
215.57
266.05
242.50
204.37
335.24
242.18
240.54
291.59
175.14
307.94
176.95
286.65
172.46
-119.64
-10.94
-134.61
-18.23
-112.24
-56.78
-93.10
-35.91
405.89
182.87
-40.42
406.57
182.30
-47.67
308.92
129.78
-67.98
411.12
182.31
-68.61
411.47
166.36
-68.26
405.85
182.44
-40.85
312.00
130.36
-65.39
394.86
146.50
-71.90
393.47
169.96
-65.63

5.05
1045.23
1109.22
0.00
295.52
293.19
332.26
276.81
323.28
335.36
294.95
270.96
336.56
299.11
260.50
412.14
307.33
296.60
365.54
220.08
385.68
222.26
359.65
216.90
-151.41
-12.33
-170.04
-21.66
-139.01
-71.27
-116.19
-45.72
492.45
219.66
-53.54
493.91
219.34
-61.89
399.68
167.74
-86.68
501.03
219.42
-88.21
501.64
200.79
-87.75
492.38
218.81
-53.91
403.97
172.16
-77.89
484.93
178.82
-91.17
483.48
209.31
-79.92

D-20

6.06
1254.28
1331.06
0.00
357.88
353.12
401.34
334.07
390.81
403.52
357.39
326.76
407.73
355.19
317.40
488.24
373.27
352.12
439.73
265.18
463.63
267.72
432.94
261.54
-183.38
-13.58
-205.55
-25.05
-165.74
-85.80
-139.48
-55.53
578.10
255.80
-66.90
580.27
255.76
-76.28
491.37
205.91
-105.72
590.48
256.14
-107.91
591.36
235.01
-107.37
578.01
254.60
-67.23
496.68
214.67
-89.91
574.18
210.87
-110.44
572.29
248.24
-93.88

7.07
1463.32
1552.91
0.00
420.83
413.31
470.84
391.72
458.86
471.97
420.43
382.89
479.38
410.92
374.86
563.82
439.80
407.29
514.16
310.38
541.77
313.30
506.49
306.32
-215.45
-14.79
-241.05
-28.46
-192.45
-100.38
-163.00
-65.31
663.36
291.60
-80.41
666.17
291.86
-90.77
583.55
244.13
-125.02
679.90
292.74
-127.63
681.06
269.27
-127.04
663.24
290.16
-80.70
589.58
257.54
-101.57
662.94
242.80
-129.67
660.31
286.90
-107.59

8.08
1672.37
1774.75
0.00
484.28
473.72
540.71
449.72
527.36
540.66
483.98
439.33
551.38
466.44
432.76
639.09
506.79
462.23
588.77
355.65
620.10
358.95
580.27
351.20
-247.56
-15.98
-276.51
-31.90
-219.14
-114.99
-186.76
-75.02
748.50
327.22
-94.00
751.88
327.82
-105.28
675.98
282.32
-144.53
769.50
329.38
-147.32
770.91
303.65
-146.70
748.35
325.66
-94.25
682.41
300.56
-112.99
751.43
274.72
-148.82
747.78
325.40
-121.10

9.09
1881.41
1996.60
0.00
548.18
534.32
610.91
508.00
596.27
609.59
547.99
496.03
623.66
521.82
491.01
714.19
574.15
517.04
663.58
400.97
698.60
404.67
654.25
396.16
-279.66
-17.20
-311.89
-35.40
-245.83
-129.63
-210.77
-84.66
833.68
362.77
-107.64
837.55
363.73
-119.80
768.56
320.45
-164.21
859.33
366.11
-166.96
860.99
338.20
-166.35
833.51
361.19
-107.86
775.01
343.62
-124.20
839.78
306.67
-167.89
834.89
363.80
-134.45

10
10.10
2090.46
2218.44
0.00
612.45
595.11
681.39
566.54
665.56
678.72
612.43
552.98
696.16
577.12
549.57
789.20
641.82
571.77
738.56
446.34
777.26
450.42
728.41
441.19
-311.72
-18.47
-347.18
-38.96
-272.52
-144.31
-235.02
-94.20
918.95
398.28
-121.29
923.26
399.65
-134.30
861.23
358.52
-184.03
949.44
402.98
-186.55
951.31
372.93
-185.96
918.78
396.82
-121.50
867.34
386.69
-135.25
928.04
338.70
-186.88
921.75
402.16
-147.68

TABLE D-11. FINITE ELEMENT PREDICTIONS OF STRAIN FOR LONGITUDINAL LAP


JOINT PANELS CVP1 AND CVP2, LOAD CONDITION 1b
Increment
Pressure (psi)
Frame Load (lb.)
Hoop Load (lb.)
Long. Load (lb.)
SG01
SG02
SG03
SG04
SG05
SG06
SG07
SG08
SG09
SG10
SG11
SG12
SG13
SG14
SG15
SG16
SG17
SG18
SG19
SG20
SG21
SG22
SG23
SG24
SG25
SG26
SG27
SG28
SG29T
SG29-45
SG29L
SG30T
SG30-45
SG30L
SG31T
SG31-45
SG31L
SG32T
SG32-45
SG32L
SG33T
SG33-45
SG33L
SG34T
SG34-45
SG34L
SG35T
SG35-45
SG35L
SG36T
SG36-45
SG36L
SG37T
SG37-45
SG37L

1
0.00
0.00
0.00
116.66
-1.76
-2.63
-19.21
-3.88
-19.15
-4.25
0.42
-3.99
-19.02
-2.87
-19.97
-2.52
0.27
-2.40
-7.31
-2.08
-7.18
-2.11
-2.54
-1.25
26.11
26.30
31.33
31.79
31.56
33.72
29.99
31.53
-14.68
7.28
34.93
-12.28
10.88
34.85
-7.41
14.07
35.07
-11.79
11.60
34.62
-12.05
11.44
34.68
-14.92
12.77
34.88
-13.57
11.03
35.47
-9.68
10.63
31.16
-10.43
10.17
30.72

2
0.00
0.00
0.00
233.31
-3.52
-5.33
-38.22
-7.79
-38.08
-8.49
0.86
-8.02
-37.86
-5.74
-39.69
-5.09
0.54
-4.78
-14.60
-4.25
-14.33
-4.34
-5.07
-2.54
52.16
52.55
62.57
63.53
63.13
67.37
59.89
63.00
-29.25
14.75
69.97
-24.46
21.82
69.67
-14.90
28.04
70.03
-23.51
23.19
69.16
-24.01
22.89
69.31
-29.69
25.57
69.87
-27.05
22.05
70.82
-19.33
21.26
62.27
-20.80
20.32
61.34

3
0.00
0.00
0.00
349.97
-5.28
-8.14
-57.07
-11.73
-56.82
-12.78
1.31
-12.11
-56.53
-8.67
-59.19
-7.77
0.81
-7.23
-21.86
-6.46
-21.45
-6.59
-7.59
-3.84
78.16
78.75
93.73
95.20
94.65
100.94
89.70
94.39
-43.72
22.37
105.07
-36.57
32.81
104.44
-22.45
41.91
104.87
-35.18
34.74
103.62
-35.90
34.32
103.91
-44.35
38.41
104.94
-40.40
33.09
106.04
-28.96
31.88
93.30
-31.13
30.44
91.87

4
0.00
0.00
0.00
466.62
-7.03
-11.07
-75.75
-15.73
-75.38
-17.12
1.74
-16.25
-75.03
-11.65
-78.47
-10.55
1.09
-9.77
-29.07
-8.68
-28.52
-8.86
-10.11
-5.16
104.09
104.90
124.81
126.81
126.12
134.44
119.44
125.72
-58.10
30.13
140.24
-48.62
43.85
139.16
-30.05
55.68
139.60
-46.80
46.27
138.01
-47.73
45.74
138.45
-58.89
51.28
140.09
-53.61
44.14
141.15
-38.58
42.48
124.28
-41.40
40.55
122.32

5
0.00
0.00
0.00
583.28
-8.77
-14.11
-94.27
-19.77
-93.76
-21.53
2.17
-20.47
-93.36
-14.69
-97.54
-13.44
1.38
-12.41
-36.24
-10.92
-35.55
-11.14
-12.64
-6.49
129.96
130.99
155.81
158.36
157.55
167.86
149.10
156.99
-72.39
38.02
175.47
-60.60
54.93
173.84
-37.71
69.38
174.22
-58.38
57.78
172.31
-59.49
57.14
172.95
-73.33
64.18
175.29
-66.70
55.20
176.14
-48.18
53.07
155.19
-51.63
50.63
152.68

D-21

6
0.00
0.00
0.00
699.93
-10.50
-17.26
-112.63
-23.86
-111.98
-26.00
2.60
-24.74
-111.52
-17.80
-116.40
-16.42
1.68
-15.13
-43.37
-13.16
-42.54
-13.43
-15.16
-7.84
155.77
157.03
186.73
189.84
188.91
201.21
178.68
188.19
-86.61
46.01
210.74
-72.52
66.05
208.47
-45.41
82.98
208.72
-69.91
69.25
206.53
-71.20
68.52
207.39
-87.68
77.09
210.55
-79.67
66.27
211.03
-57.77
63.65
186.03
-61.81
60.69
182.95

7
0.00
0.00
0.00
816.59
-12.22
-20.51
-130.84
-27.99
-130.03
-30.52
3.02
-29.08
-129.52
-20.96
-135.06
-19.49
1.99
-17.94
-50.44
-15.41
-49.48
-15.73
-17.69
-9.19
181.53
183.02
217.58
221.27
220.22
234.48
208.19
219.33
-100.76
54.11
246.05
-84.39
77.20
243.03
-53.17
96.51
243.13
-81.40
80.70
240.68
-82.85
79.88
241.77
-101.94
90.01
245.84
-92.51
77.35
245.81
-67.33
74.21
216.81
-71.93
70.74
213.14

8
0.00
0.00
0.00
933.24
-13.92
-23.87
-148.88
-32.17
-147.91
-35.09
3.45
-33.47
-147.35
-24.17
-153.53
-22.66
2.32
-20.83
-57.48
-17.66
-56.38
-18.03
-20.22
-10.57
207.23
208.97
248.34
252.63
251.48
267.67
237.63
250.40
-114.83
62.31
281.39
-96.20
88.38
277.55
-60.97
109.95
277.43
-92.84
92.13
274.74
-94.45
91.23
276.11
-116.12
102.95
281.18
-105.24
88.44
280.49
-76.88
84.76
247.52
-82.01
80.77
243.25

9
0.00
0.00
0.00
1049.90
-15.61
-27.32
-166.78
-36.38
-165.64
-39.72
3.87
-37.92
-165.02
-27.43
-171.81
-25.90
2.65
-23.79
-64.47
-19.93
-63.24
-20.34
-22.74
-11.95
232.88
234.86
279.04
283.93
282.68
300.79
267.00
281.42
-128.85
70.60
316.75
-107.95
99.59
312.00
-68.82
123.32
311.63
-104.23
103.53
308.72
-105.99
102.55
310.38
-130.22
115.89
316.53
-117.85
99.54
315.06
-86.41
95.29
278.17
-92.05
90.77
273.28

10
0.00
0.00
0.00
1166.55
-17.28
-30.86
-184.53
-40.63
-183.20
-44.39
4.30
-42.42
-182.54
-30.74
-189.91
-29.22
2.99
-26.83
-71.42
-22.20
-70.06
-22.66
-25.27
-13.35
258.47
260.71
309.66
315.17
313.83
333.85
296.30
312.37
-142.80
78.97
352.13
-119.66
110.83
346.40
-76.71
136.60
345.73
-115.57
114.91
342.63
-117.47
113.86
344.59
-144.26
128.82
351.91
-130.36
110.64
349.54
-95.91
105.80
308.75
-102.03
100.77
303.23

TABLE D-12. FINITE ELEMENT PREDICTIONS OF STRAIN FOR LONGITUDINAL LAP


JOINT PANELS CVP1 AND CVP2, LOAD CONDITION 1c
Increment
Pressure (psi)
Frame Load (lb.)
Hoop Load (lb.)
Long. Load (lb.)
SG01
SG02
SG03
SG04
SG05
SG06
SG07
SG08
SG09
SG10
SG11
SG12
SG13
SG14
SG15
SG16
SG17
SG18
SG19
SG20
SG21
SG22
SG23
SG24
SG25
SG26
SG27
SG28
SG29T
SG29-45
SG29L
SG30T
SG30-45
SG30L
SG31T
SG31-45
SG31L
SG32T
SG32-45
SG32L
SG33T
SG33-45
SG33L
SG34T
SG34-45
SG34L
SG35T
SG35-45
SG35L
SG36T
SG36-45
SG36L
SG37T
SG37-45
SG37L

1
1.01
209.05
221.84
116.66
53.12
54.68
43.69
49.98
41.99
62.08
54.78
49.01
43.23
61.94
25.68
88.81
55.68
61.95
64.24
40.41
68.85
40.94
67.54
40.39
-1.49
21.74
0.47
25.31
1.25
19.75
6.15
23.50
108.90
65.71
28.68
109.49
68.25
25.80
50.61
37.87
19.33
110.91
69.64
20.90
110.53
64.27
20.92
108.71
71.84
28.29
46.86
32.30
14.42
100.24
53.23
15.03
97.48
56.34
11.97

2
2.02
418.09
443.69
233.31
107.75
109.85
89.28
100.65
85.71
124.13
111.23
98.56
89.68
119.60
56.52
169.33
114.51
119.53
129.15
82.04
137.90
82.93
136.04
82.03
-4.70
44.65
-1.28
51.66
5.30
38.75
12.89
45.44
197.99
119.71
53.10
200.00
125.26
48.31
120.38
84.09
36.98
202.34
126.59
37.73
201.92
117.35
38.04
197.81
131.21
52.64
114.24
76.86
32.48
189.83
100.61
27.72
187.83
110.01
25.85

3
3.03
627.14
665.53
349.97
163.09
165.40
135.85
152.16
130.52
186.48
168.42
148.88
138.10
174.77
90.17
245.48
175.01
174.58
194.27
124.36
206.97
125.52
204.91
124.33
-8.80
68.05
-3.90
78.28
10.18
57.30
19.84
66.53
279.70
169.29
75.71
282.59
177.49
69.23
197.59
133.19
53.39
286.63
178.63
52.84
286.26
166.29
53.54
279.57
185.71
75.30
190.84
126.95
52.11
274.76
145.56
39.44
273.76
161.90
40.55

4
4.04
836.18
887.38
466.62
218.79
221.24
183.04
204.34
176.07
249.11
225.93
199.85
187.74
228.45
125.51
319.15
236.37
228.12
259.50
167.11
276.04
168.49
273.98
167.04
-13.36
91.61
-6.85
104.87
15.33
75.50
26.72
87.12
358.47
217.07
97.43
361.59
227.49
89.26
277.96
183.27
68.91
368.16
228.59
67.10
367.88
213.57
68.21
358.39
238.06
97.09
271.60
179.57
72.46
357.37
189.37
50.69
356.91
212.60
55.64

5
5.05
1045.23
1109.22
583.28
274.68
277.29
230.66
257.05
222.21
311.98
283.58
251.32
238.16
281.19
161.94
391.31
298.15
280.73
324.80
210.13
345.12
211.73
343.18
210.02
-18.14
115.18
-9.88
131.27
20.62
93.38
33.42
107.38
436.08
264.12
118.64
438.87
276.38
108.76
359.70
233.59
83.75
448.66
277.63
80.87
448.50
260.17
82.43
436.04
289.41
118.39
354.17
233.31
93.10
438.72
232.61
61.70
438.28
262.51
70.93

D-22

6
6.06
1254.28
1331.06
699.93
330.68
333.48
278.65
310.17
268.84
375.03
341.28
303.21
289.15
333.32
199.16
462.51
360.10
332.74
390.16
253.36
414.21
255.16
412.49
253.19
-23.01
138.65
-12.88
157.43
26.01
110.98
39.88
127.40
513.31
310.91
139.54
515.32
324.69
127.88
442.03
283.86
98.03
528.88
326.28
94.32
528.83
306.50
96.35
513.31
340.25
139.38
437.43
287.49
113.85
519.35
275.52
72.57
518.45
311.89
86.30

7
7.07
1463.32
1552.91
816.59
386.73
389.79
326.96
363.62
315.89
438.23
398.98
355.44
340.55
385.03
236.97
533.06
422.10
384.36
455.58
296.74
483.33
298.73
481.86
296.49
-27.89
161.98
-15.79
183.32
31.50
128.32
46.08
147.24
590.49
357.65
160.22
591.38
372.68
146.73
524.58
333.94
111.85
609.13
374.77
107.53
609.18
352.73
110.06
590.52
390.83
160.15
520.82
341.79
134.61
599.54
318.26
83.35
597.79
360.87
101.68

8
8.08
1672.37
1774.75
933.24
442.82
446.20
375.54
417.35
363.33
501.56
456.65
407.97
392.27
436.45
275.26
603.18
484.07
435.73
521.06
340.24
552.47
342.42
551.29
339.90
-32.73
185.13
-18.58
208.93
37.09
145.42
52.02
166.92
667.75
404.45
180.74
667.24
420.48
165.35
607.15
383.80
125.27
689.53
423.20
120.55
689.67
398.94
123.60
667.82
441.25
180.75
604.06
396.02
155.31
679.46
360.89
94.06
676.55
409.57
117.05

9
9.09
1881.41
1996.60
1049.90
498.93
502.69
424.39
471.31
411.14
564.99
514.30
460.76
444.25
487.67
313.97
672.99
545.97
486.92
586.60
383.84
621.64
386.20
620.78
383.40
-37.49
208.10
-21.23
234.26
42.77
162.28
57.70
186.47
745.16
451.32
201.13
743.04
468.18
183.80
689.67
433.42
138.35
770.11
471.62
133.41
770.34
445.14
137.00
745.26
491.56
201.21
687.03
450.09
175.92
759.20
403.44
104.73
754.88
458.03
132.36

10
10.10
2090.46
2218.44
1166.55
555.07
559.25
473.50
525.47
459.30
628.50
571.91
513.79
496.47
538.75
353.05
742.58
607.77
538.01
652.19
427.52
690.84
430.05
690.30
426.97
-42.15
230.85
-23.73
259.30
48.55
178.93
63.15
205.89
822.70
498.29
221.40
818.81
515.80
202.08
772.10
482.81
151.11
850.87
520.04
146.13
851.17
491.35
150.27
822.84
541.79
221.55
769.68
503.98
196.43
838.81
445.94
115.34
832.88
506.33
147.61

TABLE D-13. FINITE ELEMENT PREDICTIONS OF STRAIN FOR CIRCUMFERENTIAL


BUTT JOINT PANELS CVP3 AND CVP4, LOAD CONDITION 1a
Increment
Pressure (psi)
Frame Load (lb.)
Hoop Load (lb.)
Long. Load (lb.)
SG01
SG02
SG03
SG04
SG05
SG06
SG07
SG08
SG09
SG10
SG11
SG12
SG13
SG14
SG15
SG16
SG17
SG18
SG19
SG20
SG21
SG22
SG23
SG24
SG25
SG26
SG27
SG28
SG29
SG30
SG31

1
1.76
363.23
385.47
0.00
123.78
128.15
102.51
125.52
127.77
77.48
133.61
121.47
80.61
-50.88
-14.20
-2.07
-11.99
-14.63
-2.53
-21.17
-32.91
-31.08
-53.02
-14.17
-22.42
30.24
-65.86
-13.80
-14.81
-12.11
-21.13
-2.65
-12.02
-9.58
-50.95

2
3
4
5
3.52
5.28
7.04
8.80
726.46 1089.69 1452.92 1816.15
770.94 1156.40 1541.87 1927.34
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
244.85 364.43 483.12 601.27
252.10 373.77 494.14 613.71
199.80 294.07 386.53 477.87
246.89 365.89 483.46 600.14
251.44 372.83 492.90 612.16
158.24 241.01 325.18 410.39
262.76 389.39 514.46 638.55
239.98 356.91 472.94 588.45
164.14 249.32 335.56 422.54
-103.10 -155.11 -206.42 -256.89
-27.78 -41.13 -54.33 -67.39
-3.63 -4.87 -5.85 -6.62
-23.54 -35.56 -48.19 -61.43
-29.96 -45.13 -59.83 -73.97
-2.34 -0.39
2.91
7.29
-44.27 -68.85 -94.61 -121.34
-66.46 -100.59 -135.24 -170.36
-64.48 -99.37 -135.38 -172.33
-111.46 -172.32 -234.52 -297.57
-27.01 -39.47 -51.86 -64.27
-45.96 -69.73 -93.40 -116.86
61.30 92.34 123.08 153.42
-136.20 -208.01 -280.27 -352.58
-26.51 -39.28 -52.37 -65.82
-30.25 -45.48 -60.21 -74.36
-23.75 -35.84 -48.54 -61.85
-44.18 -68.69 -94.37 -121.01
-2.61 -0.82
2.30
6.48
-25.45 -40.04 -55.56 -71.88
-17.00 -23.04 -28.01 -32.09
-103.19 -155.16 -206.41 -256.79

Increment
Pressure (psi)
Frame Load (lb.)
Hoop Load (lb.)
Long. Load (lb.)
SG32T
SG32-45
SG32L
SG33T
SG33-45
SG33L
SG34T
SG34-45
SG34L
SG35T
SG35-45
SG35L
SG36T
SG36-45
SG36L
SG37T
SG37-45
SG37L
SG38T
SG38-45
SG38L
SG39T
SG39-45
SG39L
SG40T
SG40-45
SG40L

D-23

1
1.76
363.23
385.47
0.00
185.95
88.64
-7.29
183.74
85.84
-8.09
183.19
76.93
-32.52
123.93
47.69
-29.83
182.64
82.98
-6.44
112.66
20.59
-81.65
183.73
76.08
-30.81
186.50
87.78
-5.48
108.07
15.50
-82.19

2
3
4
5
3.52
5.28
7.04
8.80
726.46 1089.69 1452.92 1816.15
770.94 1156.40 1541.87 1927.34
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
353.96 510.69 659.75 803.32
167.02 239.03 306.76 371.44
-19.37 -34.32 -51.19 -69.40
351.54 509.50 660.79 807.23
161.50 230.86 295.98 358.03
-21.21 -37.49 -55.90 -75.84
347.61 505.22 660.02 813.61
145.50 211.34 276.23 340.88
-63.14 -92.61 -121.32 -149.49
264.28 411.29 561.52 713.52
103.92 163.57 224.87 287.11
-59.25 -88.76 -118.44 -148.23
349.41 506.37 656.66 802.11
156.34 223.75 287.11 347.56
-18.36 -33.70 -51.35 -70.67
232.49 355.51 479.92 604.81
50.48 85.72 124.31 165.15
-151.06 -212.63 -268.69 -320.60
347.91 505.26 659.93 813.55
143.32 207.65 270.93 333.84
-59.71 -87.48 -114.53 -141.11
354.70 511.47 660.52 804.09
165.26 236.41 303.33 367.29
-16.00 -29.60 -45.25 -62.34
223.52 342.39 462.83 583.91
41.68 74.12 110.55 149.70
-150.61 -210.25 -263.82 -312.90

TABLE D-14. FINITE ELEMENT PREDICTIONS OF STRAIN FOR CIRCUMFERENTIAL


BUTT JOINT PANELS CVP3 AND CVP4, LOAD CONDITION 1b
Increment
1
2
3
4
5
Pressure (psi)
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
Frame Load (lb.)
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
Hoop Load (lb.)
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
Long. Load (lb.) 613.00 1226.00 1839.00 2452.00 3065.00
SG01
-96.93 -188.39 -275.40 -358.66 -438.70
SG02
-134.01 -259.64 -378.78 -492.66 -602.16
SG03
208.32 405.77 593.82 773.29 944.74
SG04
-7.90 -16.90 -26.53 -36.71 -47.46
SG05
-132.55 -256.78 -374.52 -487.03 -595.19
SG06
-22.92 -45.98 -69.51 -93.52 -117.94
SG07
-139.70 -271.42 -396.61 -516.36 -631.49
SG08
-94.91 -184.30 -269.23 -350.43 -428.42
SG09
-24.92 -49.35 -73.76 -98.32 -123.10
SG10
58.42 118.87 181.23 245.44 311.44
SG11
69.98 137.37 203.56 269.06 334.11
SG12
140.16 276.14 408.35 537.42 663.85
SG13
235.24 462.86 684.56 901.45 1114.30
SG14
231.11 454.54 673.27 888.69 1101.48
SG15
103.26 207.97 313.94 421.00 528.98
SG16
249.93 484.15 706.20 918.61 1123.20
SG17
179.28 359.43 539.50 719.07 897.93
SG18
113.03 228.25 344.98 462.83 581.58
SG19
132.81 267.70 403.93 540.95 678.39
SG20
140.39 280.43 419.48 557.24 693.62
SG21
85.01 172.77 262.15 352.34 442.75
SG22
15.06 28.46 41.29 54.07 67.04
SG23
163.06 326.40 489.53 652.13 814.00
SG24
169.20 337.25 503.91 669.05 832.63
SG25
230.43 453.70 672.56 888.29 1101.55
SG26
235.27 462.89 684.58 901.45 1114.28
SG27
249.60 483.53 705.32 917.49 1121.83
SG28
103.13 207.69 313.52 420.42 528.27
SG29
184.68 361.18 530.93 695.03 854.34
SG30
72.38 144.82 217.85 291.66 366.26
SG31
58.46 118.97 181.37 245.64 311.68

Increment
Pressure (psi)
Frame Load (lb.)
Hoop Load (lb.)
Long. Load (lb.)
SG32T
SG32-45
SG32L
SG33T
SG33-45
SG33L
SG34T
SG34-45
SG34L
SG35T
SG35-45
SG35L
SG36T
SG36-45
SG36L
SG37T
SG37-45
SG37L
SG38T
SG38-45
SG38L
SG39T
SG39-45
SG39L
SG40T
SG40-45
SG40L

D-24

1
2
3
4
5
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00
613.00 1226.00 1839.00 2452.00 3065.00
15.50 17.51
9.92 -4.46 -23.69
76.40 152.18 227.21 301.40 374.66
122.78 256.41 396.85 541.51 688.72
27.58 20.54 -5.27 -41.96 -85.38
13.49 17.46 16.96 14.00
9.48
163.14 345.95 538.36 735.18 933.71
-72.45 -141.36 -207.19 -270.40 -331.35
31.16 65.48 101.58 138.69 176.37
179.22 358.94 538.00 715.89 892.34
-30.46 -65.23 -103.18 -143.60 -185.97
58.52 114.88 169.01 220.98 270.95
188.23 374.79 559.29 741.58 921.66
25.18 13.90 -16.84 -58.81 -107.78
12.08 16.64 17.92 17.31 15.37
163.88 346.80 539.51 736.91 936.28
-73.99 -143.82 -212.55 -281.23 -350.20
-33.92 -57.92 -78.23 -97.18 -115.80
207.72 420.24 631.49 840.03 1045.55
-72.08 -141.37 -208.12 -272.61 -335.14
66.89 134.79 203.36 272.38 341.66
181.49 362.70 542.94 721.88 899.34
10.61
8.27 -3.21 -21.17 -43.77
71.05 141.96 212.63 282.93 352.71
122.76 256.34 396.69 541.28 688.52
-21.04 -44.13 -68.23 -93.05 -118.50
90.93 176.53 258.66 338.13 415.44
179.00 354.03 525.51 693.70 858.94

TABLE D-15. FINITE ELEMENT PREDICTIONS OF STRAIN FOR CIRCUMFERENTIAL


BUTT JOINT PANELS CVP3 AND CVP4, LOAD CONDITION 1c
Increment
Pressure (psi)
Frame Load (lb.)
Hoop Load (lb.)
Long. Load (lb.)
SG01
SG02
SG03
SG04
SG05
SG06
SG07
SG08
SG09
SG10
SG11
SG12
SG13
SG14
SG15
SG16
SG17
SG18
SG19
SG20
SG21
SG22
SG23
SG24
SG25
SG26
SG27
SG28
SG29
SG30
SG31

1.00
2.00
3.00
4.00
5.00
1.76
3.52
5.28
7.04
8.80
363.23 726.46 1089.69 1452.92 1816.15
385.47 770.94 1156.40 1541.87 1927.34
613.00 1226.00 1839.00 2452.00 3065.00
24.41 47.68 71.00 94.99 119.98
-8.42 -16.75 -23.74 -28.83 -31.75
302.88 577.92 832.30 1070.15 1294.30
112.07 210.96 301.58 386.47 467.19
-7.32 -14.49 -20.32 -24.30 -26.16
55.77 115.50 176.77 238.76 301.17
-8.45 -17.32 -25.10 -31.11 -35.03
24.13 46.91 69.66 93.02 117.32
56.84 117.95 180.91 244.86 309.45
14.59 39.67 72.63 111.65 155.42
56.28 112.00 168.09 224.66 281.66
136.64 267.62 393.91 516.52 636.14
220.02 429.63 631.66 827.75 1018.95
213.98 416.91 613.84 806.78 996.74
100.93 206.63 315.56 426.69 539.32
225.79 430.86 621.40 801.18 972.67
145.61 290.42 434.08 576.57 717.97
83.22 167.54 252.58 338.23 424.53
84.96 172.22 261.05 350.95 441.61
124.40 246.89 366.86 484.35 599.58
63.86 130.44 198.35 266.66 334.87
43.17 82.31 118.82 153.63 187.31
100.86 202.39 305.07 408.62 512.74
152.60 301.58 447.25 590.02 730.27
213.33 416.29 613.54 806.96 997.49
219.90 429.38 631.26 827.22 1018.30
225.49 430.32 620.64 800.25 971.59
100.66 206.04 314.62 425.38 537.62
170.48 328.71 477.91 620.15 756.87
63.53 130.77 201.03 273.68 348.26
14.60 39.75 72.78 111.86 155.69

Increment
Pressure (psi)
Frame Load (lb.)
Hoop Load (lb.)
Long. Load (lb.)
SG32T
SG32-45
SG32L
SG33T
SG33-45
SG33L
SG34T
SG34-45
SG34L
SG35T
SG35-45
SG35L
SG36T
SG36-45
SG36L
SG37T
SG37-45
SG37L
SG38T
SG38-45
SG38L
SG39T
SG39-45
SG39L
SG40T
SG40-45
SG40L

D-25

1.00
2.00
3.00
4.00
5.00
1.76
3.52
5.28
7.04
8.80
363.23 726.46 1089.69 1452.92 1816.15
385.47 770.94 1156.40 1541.87 1927.34
613.00 1226.00 1839.00 2452.00 3065.00
186.67 330.19 452.09 561.67 663.60
155.07 291.06 418.61 541.53 661.46
110.07 221.42 335.35 451.26 568.41
188.76 312.96 409.27 491.11 564.49
84.72 140.21 184.45 223.10 258.49
147.69 302.98 461.97 622.00 781.69
119.68 229.85 335.74 439.29 541.33
112.85 222.64 330.26 436.09 540.36
146.70 294.37 441.07 586.19 729.56
86.69 180.65 277.28 374.80 472.46
102.48 208.21 314.12 419.14 522.92
157.20 311.41 462.41 610.42 755.72
184.99 304.11 395.32 472.23 540.91
81.29 136.81 182.94 224.50 263.41
148.76 303.59 462.39 622.77 783.32
45.54 103.67 163.49 222.69 280.88
-2.04 20.51 50.66 83.60 117.58
141.50 307.70 478.46 648.76 817.13
118.49 225.05 327.05 426.83 525.30
146.14 286.06 422.93 557.79 691.12
150.16 300.14 448.68 595.42 740.29
182.16 321.48 439.78 546.27 645.50
148.98 279.72 402.88 522.10 638.86
111.57 223.76 338.18 454.40 571.81
88.00 179.75 271.09 361.08 449.62
112.71 234.09 356.75 478.55 598.84
109.05 236.51 368.96 502.07 634.26

TABLE D-16. COMPARISON OF MEASURED AND PREDICTED STRAINS FOR CVP1,


LOAD CONDITION 1a

Gage

Air-1

SG2
SG4
SG6
SG8
SG10
SG12
SG14
SG16
SG18
SG20

596.65
594.59
651.48
582.27
955.44
615.64
567.95
554.30
543.65

CVP1- Load Condition 1a


Experiment
Analysis % Error Remarks
Air-2 Water-1 Water-2 Average Stdev
Group 1: Frame Outer Cap (Closest to Skin)
Loading direction
586.13 599.27 589.35 592.85 6.14 595.11
-0.4%
582.74 600.85 591.52 592.42 7.54 566.76
4.3%
642.05 662.21 640.67 649.10 9.97 678.71
-4.6%
579.41 600.06 589.08 587.70 9.18 553.13
5.9%
Gage damaged
940.31 962.89 936.90 948.89 12.33 789.50 16.8%
612.54 631.67 623.96 620.95 8.62 571.78
7.9%
569.31 555.42 555.34 562.00 7.67 446.24 20.6%
541.27 554.73 556.25 551.64 6.96 450.36 18.4%
543.35 541.25 534.16 540.60 4.43 441.17 18.4%

Group % Error
SG1
SG3
SG5
SG7
SG9
SG11
SG13
SG15
SG17
SG19

877.51
788.96
778.01
784.00
816.82
639.92
777.88
573.49
528.92
581.98

13.2%
Group 2:
810.10
724.58
721.53
761.95
758.21
584.88
753.29
546.19
496.85
574.02

Frame Inner Cap (Farthest From Skin)


748.91 760.80 799.33 58.47 612.56
676.49 690.93 720.24 50.05 681.50
712.75 703.82 729.03 33.45 665.74
731.68 714.51 748.03 30.97 612.46
710.06 716.74 750.46 49.10 696.28
582.23 577.13 596.04 29.43 549.66
716.97 703.51 737.91 33.94 641.88
523.39 526.83 542.48 22.98 738.31
540.86 520.32 521.74 18.60 777.05
550.78 538.61 561.35 20.13 728.21

Group % Error
SG22
SG24
SG26
SG28

-21.12
-61.57
-44.60
-66.93

Loading direction
23.4%
5.4%
8.7%
18.1%
7.2%
7.8%
13.0%
-36.1%
-48.9%
-29.7%
21.1%

Group 3: Stringer Hat (Closest to Skin)


Negligible strain
-23.62
-7.45 -18.66 -17.71 7.13 -18.50
-4.4%
-63.83 -59.80 -70.80 -64.00 4.82 -38.98 39.1%
-45.92 -54.85 -56.85 -50.55 6.19 -144.30 -185.4%
-69.11 -62.05 -72.01 -67.53 4.20 -94.19 -39.5%

Group % Error

93.7%

Group 4: Stringer Flange (Farthest From Skin)


SG21 -297.71 -297.78 -287.00 -298.85 -295.33 5.58 -311.68
SG23 -232.94 -230.06 -225.17 -236.11 -231.07 4.65 -347.12
SG25 -254.82 -241.56 -252.24 -237.33 -246.49 8.38 -272.95
SG27
Group % Error

-5.5%
-50.2%
-10.7%
Gage damaged
26.8%

D-26

TABLE D-16. COMPARISON OF MEASURED AND PREDICTED STRAINS FOR CVP1,


LOAD CONDITION 1a (Continued)

Gage

Air-1

SG29T
SG30T
SG31T
SG32T
SG33T
SG34T
SG35T
SG36T

893.74
809.69
826.65
872.29
890.19
806.93
954.68
866.26

CVP1- Load Condition 1a (Continued)


Experiment
Analysis % Error Remarks
Air-2 Water-1 Water-2 Average Stdev
Group 5: Skin, Hoop Direction
Loading direction
895.52 904.65 889.43 895.84 6.41 918.95 -2.6%
811.27 813.02 797.79 807.94 6.90 923.26 -14.3%
828.51 851.69 837.64 836.13 11.44 861.29 -3.0% Opposite Gage 32
872.45 883.91 862.05 872.68 8.93 949.45 -8.8%
890.26 897.64 877.86 888.99 8.20 951.31 -7.0%
805.60 808.02 794.04 803.65 6.48 918.77 -14.3%
957.56 962.99 948.49 955.93 6.04 867.29
9.3%
865.26 873.13 865.50 867.53 3.75 928.05 -7.0%

Group % Error
SG29L
SG30L
SG31L
SG32L
SG33L
SG34L
SG35L
SG36L

-110.55
-98.74
-147.66
-153.10
-146.98
-146.15
-34.68
-115.74

9.0%
Group 6: Skin, Longitudinal Direction
-114.60 -120.21 -111.24 -114.15 4.41
-98.59 -106.75 -94.69 -99.69 5.07
-148.28 -164.20 -150.28 -152.60 7.81
-152.94 -172.03 -153.73 -157.95 9.39
-144.42 -159.00 -136.80 -146.80 9.21
-136.22 -145.46 -138.54 -141.59 4.96
-36.81 -34.32 -35.70 -35.38 1.12
-117.39 -116.44 -122.31 -117.97 2.97

Group % Error
SG29-45
SG30-45
SG31-45
SG32-45
SG33-45
SG34-45
SG35-45
SG36-45

398.32
340.19
361.81
367.79
371.40
353.25
489.54
382.83

-121.29
-134.31
-184.07
-186.50
-185.98
-121.51
-135.25
-186.88

Negligible strain
-6.3%
-34.7%
-20.6% Opposite Gage 32
-18.1%
-26.7%
14.2%
-282.3%
-58.4%
39.3%

Group 7: Skin, 45-degree Direction


402.29 406.93 408.32 403.96 4.56
344.83 348.15 351.74 346.23 4.91
374.40 382.88 379.29 374.59 9.20
380.62 381.24 378.21 376.96 6.26
384.85 370.22 373.76 375.06 6.69
366.83 349.79 348.76 354.66 8.34
501.91 497.88 490.11 494.86 6.04
392.19 389.52 381.62 386.54 5.13

Group % Error

398.26
1.4%
399.65 -15.4%
358.53
4.3% Opposite Gage 32
402.99 -6.9%
372.93
0.6%
396.84 -11.9%
386.66 21.9%
338.69 12.4%
12.6%

D-27

TABLE D-17. COMPARISON OF MEASURED AND PREDICTED STRAINS FOR CVP1,


LOAD CONDITION 1b

Gage

CVP1 - Load Condition 1b


Experiment
Analysis % Error Remarks
Water-1 Water-2 Average Stdev

SG2
SG4
SG6
SG8
SG10
SG12
SG14
SG16
SG18
SG20

Group 1: Frame Outer Cap (Closest to Skin)


-38.19 -31.59 -34.89 4.66 -30.92
-48.11 -44.11 -46.11 2.82 -40.66
-60.77 -57.22 -58.99 2.51 -44.46
-44.23 -42.40 -43.31 1.29 -42.46
-65.51 -63.77 -64.64 1.23 -29.27
-42.76 -39.41 -41.09 2.38 -26.89
-38.09 -40.76 -39.43 1.89 -22.14
-36.78 -36.55 -36.67 0.16 -22.60
-9.67 -17.09 -13.38 5.25 -13.35

Group % Error
SG1
SG3
SG5
SG7
SG9
SG11
SG13
SG15
SG17
SG19

35.4%

Group 2: Frame Inner Cap (Farthest From Skin)


-36.31 -41.38 -38.84 3.59 -17.28 55.5%
-182.02 -227.36 -204.69 32.06 -184.54
9.8%
-112.54 -184.28 -148.41 50.73 -183.22 -23.5%
109.19 -10.13
49.53 84.37
4.28 91.4%
-194.87 -229.22 -212.04 24.28 -182.53 13.9%
-106.08 -187.87 -146.98 57.83 -189.91 -29.2%
107.89 -16.16
45.86 87.72
2.99 93.5%
-66.26 -77.92 -72.09 8.25 -71.38
1.0%
-37.28 -61.01 -49.14 16.78 -70.03 -42.5%
38.78 -27.08
5.85 46.57 -25.28 532.0%

Group % Error
SG22
SG24
SG26
SG28

26.5%

Group 3: Stringer Hat (Closest to Skin)


267.17 259.34 263.26 5.54 260.70
317.34 313.98 315.66 2.37 315.17
329.83 320.57 325.20 6.55 333.84
317.75 326.37 322.06 6.09 312.37

Group % Error
SG21
SG23
SG25
SG27

Negligible strain
11.4%
11.8%
24.6%
2.0%
Gage damaged
54.7%
34.6%
43.8%
38.4%
0.2%

1.0%
0.2%
-2.7%
3.0%
2.2%

Group 4: Stringer Flange (Farthest From Skin)


268.60 267.37 267.99 0.87 258.47
3.6%
309.69 310.49 310.09 0.57 309.66
0.1%
558.68 550.87 554.78 5.52 313.78 43.4%
Gage damaged

Group % Error

35.0%

D-28

TABLE D-17. COMPARISON OF MEASURED AND PREDICTED STRAINS FOR CVP1,


LOAD CONDITION 1b (Continued)

Gage
SG29T
SG30T
SG31T
SG32T
SG33T
SG34T
SG35T
SG36T

CVP1 - Load Condition 1b (Continued)


Experiment
Analysis % Error Remarks
Water-1 Water-2 Average Stdev
Group 5: Skin, Hoop Direction
-130.06
-120.46 -125.26 6.79 -142.81 -14.0%
-129.01
-121.21 -125.11 5.52 -119.69 4.3%
-76.97
-70.93
-73.95 4.27 -76.69 -3.7% Opposite Gage 32
-120.58
-108.96 -114.77 8.21 -115.60 -0.7%
-117.19
-113.08 -115.14 2.91 -117.50 -2.1%
-150.42
-161.63 -156.02 7.93 -144.27 7.5%
-137.00
-141.95 -139.47 3.50 -130.32 6.6%
-114.52
-106.25 -110.39 5.85 -95.92 13.1%

Group % Error
SG29L
SG30L
SG31L
SG32L
SG33L
SG34L
SG35L
SG36L

8.1%
Group 6:
314.79
337.90
335.55
338.53
344.03
354.61
303.60
302.06

Skin, Longitudinal Strain


311.66
313.23 2.21
330.81
334.35 5.01
329.82
332.68 4.05
330.39
334.46 5.75
340.68
342.35 2.37
359.87
357.24 3.72
290.71
297.16 9.11
290.20
296.13 8.38

Group 7:
75.78
131.43
140.53
126.51
142.26
162.57
96.15
88.09

Skin, 45-degree Direction


84.12
79.95 5.89
133.67
132.55 1.58
148.02
144.28 5.30
140.41
133.46 9.82
149.30
145.78 4.97
166.47
164.52 2.75
99.47
97.81 2.35
94.86
91.47 4.79

352.12
346.39
345.73
342.62
344.58
351.90
349.55
308.75

Group % Error
SG29-45
SG30-45
SG31-45
SG32-45
SG33-45
SG34-45
SG35-45
SG36-45

Loading direction
-12.4%
-3.6%
-3.9% Opposite Gage 32
-2.4%
-0.7%
1.5%
-17.6%
-4.3%
7.5%

Group % Error

78.94
110.82
136.61
114.89
113.83
128.83
110.66
105.80

1.3%
16.4%
5.3% Opposite Gage 32
13.9%
21.9%
21.7%
-13.1%
-15.7%
16.6%

D-29

TABLE D-18. COMPARISON OF MEASURED AND PREDICTED STRAINS FOR CVP1,


LOAD CONDITION 1c

Gage

Air-1

SG2
SG4
SG6
SG8
SG10
SG12
SG14
SG16
SG18
SG20

543.75
531.29
579.94
542.78
861.89
575.51
508.91
525.01
520.07

CVP1- Load Condition 1c


Experiment
Analysis % Error Remarks
Air-2 Water-1 Water-2 Average Stdev
Group 1: Frame Outer Cap (Closest to Skin)
Primary loading direction
544.92 545.29 548.37 545.58 1.97 559.26 -2.5%
531.73 533.59 536.83 533.36 2.52 525.71
1.4%
579.70 577.45 574.70 577.95 2.44 628.48 -8.7%
542.68 551.59 553.69 547.69 5.79 513.93
6.2%
Gage damaged
861.15 862.78 859.56 861.35 1.36 742.86 13.8%
575.43 585.52 592.28 582.19 8.23 538.01
7.6%
516.43 513.00 521.42 514.94 5.30 427.48 17.0%
525.31 526.14 535.54 528.00 5.05 430.07 18.5%
525.35 522.19 537.44 526.26 7.76 426.98 18.9%

Group % Error
SG1
SG3
SG5
SG7
SG9
SG11
SG13
SG15
SG17
SG19

769.04
587.02
645.33
811.29
617.55
531.05
815.01
511.01
502.77
574.83

12.3%

Group 2:
799.62
624.64
681.07
861.36
660.12
564.63
869.35
547.69
506.56
614.41

Frame Inner Cap (Farthest From Skin)


Primary loading direction
693.95 767.52 757.53 44.89 555.17 26.7%
488.28 580.48 570.11 57.92 473.59 16.9%
580.31 640.53 636.81 41.78 459.47 27.8%
723.79 804.59 800.26 56.92 571.93 28.5%
520.84 622.89 605.35 59.44 496.58 18.0%
460.42 533.93 522.51 44.09 353.11 32.4%
722.61 820.03 806.75 61.22 607.81 24.7%
468.63 544.01 517.84 36.72 651.97 -25.9%
485.68 530.29 506.33 18.38 690.65 -36.4%
535.27 620.58 586.27 39.58 690.08 -17.7%

Group % Error
SG22
SG24
SG26
SG28

229.04
248.76
275.61
239.15

26.0%
Group 3: Stringer Hat (Closest to Skin)
230.54 239.31 233.63 233.13 4.54
250.98 238.79 240.32 244.71 6.06
279.57 266.62 265.59 271.85 6.84
240.41 231.85 226.85 234.57 6.38

Group % Error
Group 4:
SG21 -22.71 -22.42
SG23 80.71 80.41
SG25 210.51 243.88
SG27
-

230.82
259.27
178.94
205.91

1.0%
-5.9%
34.2%
12.2%
19.9%

Stringer Flange (Farthest From Skin)


-22.00 -26.34 -23.37 2.00 -42.11 -80.2%
71.58
67.89
75.15 6.43 -23.68 131.5%
171.16 213.86 209.85 29.84
48.09 77.1%
Gage damaged

Group % Error

85.0%

D-30

TABLE D-18. COMPARISON OF MEASURED AND PREDICTED STRAINS FOR CVP1,


LOAD CONDITION 1c (Continued)

Gage

CVP1- Load Condition 1c (Continued)


Experiment
Analysis % Error Remarks
Air-1 Air-2 Water-1 Water-2 Average Stdev

SG29T
SG30T
SG31T
SG32T
SG33T
SG34T
SG35T
SG36T

Group 5: Skin, Hoop Direction


820.74 818.22 815.28 811.56 816.45 3.95
708.66 706.45 699.56 695.65 702.58 6.03
734.94 729.97 738.27 734.78 734.49 3.42
776.50 773.22 766.63 762.76 769.78 6.22
788.18 784.36 775.11 771.09 779.69 7.93
718.06 714.74 704.37 699.95 709.28 8.53
863.29 861.61 858.16 851.40 858.62 5.26
781.30 778.30 784.20 781.56 781.34 2.41

822.70
818.80
772.18
850.87
851.17
822.84
769.64
838.82

Group % Error
SG29L
SG30L
SG31L
SG32L
SG33L
SG34L
SG35L
SG36L

10.3%

Group 6: Skin, Longitudinal Direction


213.29 216.86 220.62 228.91 219.92 6.70
222.60 225.44 228.54 232.34 227.23 4.18
180.64 184.21 183.13 188.13 184.03 3.12
176.76 181.16 180.73 186.33 181.25 3.93
187.08 190.09 200.08 207.64 196.22 9.42
201.93 205.60 211.11 217.27 208.98 6.69
243.79 246.08 249.32 250.18 247.34 2.95
165.87 168.23 155.92 154.96 161.25 6.78

Group % Error
SG29-45
SG30-45
SG31-45
SG32-45
SG33-45
SG34-45
SG35-45
SG36-45

Primary loading direction


-0.8%
-16.5%
-5.1% Opposite Gage 32
-10.5%
-9.2%
-16.0%
10.4%
-7.4%

221.39
202.06
151.08
146.16
150.25
221.54
196.44
115.33

Secondary loading direction


-0.7%
11.1%
17.9% Opposite Gage 32
19.4%
23.4%
-6.0%
20.6%
28.5%
17.2%

Group 7: Skin, 45-degree Direction


499.85 496.14 499.16 504.67 499.96 3.53
477.88 474.72 474.75 477.10 476.11 1.62
500.48 500.69 508.99 502.21 503.09 4.01
514.39 513.36 521.03 511.38 515.04 4.18
518.74 520.08 509.51 511.89 515.06 5.15
547.50 551.08 530.77 530.72 540.02 10.81
603.69 605.67 595.48 594.82 599.92 5.57
485.02 486.71 476.88 476.06 481.17 5.48

Group % Error

498.26 0.3%
515.80 -8.3%
482.83 4.0% Opposite Gage 32
520.04 -1.0%
491.34 4.6%
541.80 -0.3%
503.96 16.0%
445.94 7.3%
7.8%

D-31

TABLE D-19. COMPARISON OF MEASURED AND PREDICTED STRAINS FOR CVP2,


LOAD CONDITION 1a

Gage

Air-1

Air-2

CVP2 - Load Condition 1a


Experiment
Analysis
Water-1 Water-2 Average Stdev

% Error Remarks

Group 1: Frame Outer Cap (Closest to Skin)


SG2
620.05 625.67 621.52 616.66 620.97 3.73 595.11
SG4
616.58 617.18 609.07 602.11 611.24 7.12 566.76
SG6
714.61 718.77 718.82 711.92 716.03 3.38 678.71
SG8
617.09 613.09 618.58 611.02 614.95 3.49 553.13
SG10 624.45 624.81 617.08 609.58 618.98 7.21 577.18
SG12 1055.03 1058.84 1069.63 1054.73 1059.56 6.97 789.50
SG14 632.70 632.98 636.88 622.01 631.14 6.38 571.78
SG16 574.97 581.54 565.01 545.82 566.84 15.57 446.24
SG18 532.29 535.96 531.94 476.33 519.13 28.59 450.36
SG20 581.36 584.22 591.36 570.72 581.92 8.57 441.17

4.2%
7.3%
5.2%
10.1%
6.8%
25.5%
9.4%
21.3%
13.2%
24.2%

Group % Error

16.7%

SG1
SG3
SG5
SG7
SG9
SG11
SG13
SG15
SG17
SG19

829.85
851.03
781.36
823.11
687.96
870.92
559.54
697.88
579.80

Group 2:
953.91
951.31
908.98
918.01
801.18
918.37
592.62
730.95
597.55

Frame Inner Cap (Farthest From Skin)


870.32 847.45 875.38 54.91 612.56
865.11 823.28 872.68 55.23 681.50
811.24 757.37 814.74 66.58 665.74
837.61 793.32 843.01 53.29 696.28
695.83 610.84 698.95 78.20 549.66
861.75 802.98 863.50 47.37 641.88
527.41 525.83 551.35 31.59 738.31
687.14 526.22 660.55 91.47 777.05
630.05 558.96 591.59 30.10 728.21

Group % Error
SG22
SG24
SG26
SG28

Loading direction

Loading direction
30.0%
21.9%
18.3%
Gage damaged
17.4%
21.4%
25.7%
-33.9%
-17.6%
-23.1%
23.5%

Group 3: Stringer Hat (Closest to Skin)


-9.92
-7.31
6.22
10.31
-0.18 9.95 -18.50 -10465.9% Negligible strain
-34.43 -42.61 -16.52 -11.69 -26.31 14.62 -38.98
-48.2%
253.28 -318.64 -46.87 -16.27 -32.12 233.82 -144.30
-349.2% Large Stdev
-54.39 -63.96 -46.37 -51.41 -54.03 7.40 -94.19
-74.3%

Group % Error
SG21 -319.58
SG23 -229.61
SG25 -76.21
SG27 -228.79

177.9%
Group 4: Stringer Flange (Farthest From Skin)
-325.50 -296.33 -310.72 -313.03 12.68 -311.68
-243.56 -218.54 -228.41 -230.03 10.30 -347.12
-85.80 -123.55 -103.65 -97.30 20.87 -272.95
-239.83 -245.74 -221.35 -233.93 10.94 -235.05

Group % Error

0.4%
-50.9%
-180.5%
-0.5%
45.5%

D-32

TABLE D-19. COMPARISON OF MEASURED AND PREDICTED STRAINS FOR CVP2,


LOAD CONDITION 1a (Continued)

Gage

Air-1

CVP2 - Load Condition 1a (Continued)


Experiment
Analysis % Error Remarks
Air-2 Water-1 Water-2 Average Stdev

SG29T
SG30T
SG31T
SG32T
SG33T
SG34T
SG35T
SG36T
SG37T

807.94
817.00
832.92
874.50
865.50
771.42
807.02
820.29
830.04

Group 5: Skin, Hoop Direction


807.38 787.12 788.57 797.75 11.46
818.99 796.32 794.00 806.58 13.24
825.13 821.24 804.79 821.02 11.86
874.79 855.03 852.76 864.27 12.02
861.11 842.68 839.96 852.31 12.87
770.59 747.88 749.38 759.82 12.94
809.99 788.87 777.11 795.75 15.54
816.58 789.42 793.90 805.05 15.64
831.07 819.60 805.48 821.55 11.90

918.95
923.26
820.94
949.45
951.31
918.77
867.29
928.05
921.76

Group % Error
SG29L
SG30L
SG31L
SG32L
SG33L
SG34L
SG35L
SG36L
SG37L

-96.86
-81.39
-89.62
-144.55
-171.27
-134.94
-28.30
-93.73
-64.66

13.0%
Group 6: Skin, Longitudinal Direction
-99.84 -98.93 -110.02 -101.41 5.87
-86.66 -88.81 -79.07 -83.98 4.52
-92.44 -70.07 -64.01 -79.03 14.11
-153.85 -158.24 -146.19 -150.71 6.45
-164.81 -165.45 -161.79 -165.83 3.96
-126.66 -136.35 -130.06 -132.00 4.47
-45.16 -75.28 -26.70 -43.86 22.55
-98.34 -78.85 -78.42 -87.33 10.22
-67.83 -47.31 -40.07 -54.97 13.41

Negligible strain
-121.29 -19.6%
-134.31 -59.9%
-150.16 -90.0% Opposite Gage 37
-186.50 -23.8%
-185.98 -12.2%
-121.51
7.9%
-135.25 -208.4%
-186.88 -114.0%
-147.72 -168.7%

Group % Error
SG29-45
SG30-45
SG31-45
SG32-45
SG33-45
SG34-45
SG35-45
SG36-45
SG37-45

360.36
363.12
371.85
376.13
362.91
317.27
369.44
407.24
386.55

Loading direction
-15.2%
-14.5%
0.0% Opposite Gage 37
-9.9%
-11.6%
-20.9%
-9.0%
-15.3%
-12.2%

59.4%
Group 7: Skin, 45-degree Direction
346.06 357.43 343.25 351.77 8.39
356.85 348.55 366.88 358.85 8.02
357.44 363.63 372.06 366.24 7.06
365.45 342.81 356.00 360.10 14.16
365.27 368.87 360.99 364.51 3.39
326.80 320.12 305.97 317.54 8.68
362.61 334.93 356.39 355.84 14.92
399.89 417.99 415.98 410.27 8.35
377.89 365.41 389.31 379.79 10.75

Group % Error

398.26
399.65
346.16
402.99
372.93
396.84
386.66
338.69
402.15

-13.2%
-11.4%
5.5% Opposite Gage 37
-11.9%
-2.3%
-25.0% Questionable gage
-8.7%
17.4%
-5.9%
12.6%

D-33

TABLE D-20. COMPARISON OF MEASURED AND PREDICTED STRAINS FOR CVP2,


LOAD CONDITION 1b
CVP2 - Load Condition 1b
Experiment
Analysis % Error Remarks
Water-1 Water-2 Average Stdev

Gage

Air-1

Air-2

SG2
SG4
SG6
SG8
SG10
SG12
SG14
SG16
SG18
SG20

-19.49
-53.46
-61.34
-32.50
-63.40
-78.38
-39.26
-40.75
-30.86
-27.40

Group 1: Frame Outer Cap (Closest to Skin)


-23.10 -20.03 -24.93 -21.89
2.58
-69.28 -54.65 -64.65 -60.51
7.71
-62.71 -63.65 -71.63 -64.83
4.63
-37.75 -25.22 -33.11 -32.15
5.18
-64.10 -56.92 -73.12 -64.38
6.66
-82.55 -79.22 -92.74 -83.22
6.60
-46.56 -35.99 -45.86 -41.92
5.14
-23.76 -29.61 -52.78 -36.72 12.82
-28.63 -39.02 -51.97 -37.62 10.56
-28.76 -27.96 -25.34 -27.37
1.46

Negligible strain
-30.92
-40.66
-44.46
-42.46
-30.77
-29.27
-26.89
-22.14
-22.60
-13.35

Group % Error
SG1
SG3
SG5
SG7
SG9
SG11
SG13
SG15
SG17
SG19

142.64
-28.23
-3.50
-44.10
5.16
108.44
-36.24
-1.87
16.25

47.9%
Group 2: Frame Inner Cap (Farthest From Skin)
83.47
32.41 133.63
98.04 50.91
-17.28
-140.90 -208.33 -80.14 -114.40 77.73 -184.54
-1.97 -194.42 -12.26 -53.04 94.37 -183.22
-105.41 -200.05 -87.88 -109.36 65.73 -182.53
-3.06 -199.26 -17.54 -53.67 97.51 -189.91
36.77 -65.49 187.86
66.90 107.69
2.99
-5.16 -47.41 -64.27 -38.27 24.90
-71.38
2.22 -81.55 -56.42 -34.41 41.26
-70.03
2.74 -21.36
50.15
11.95 29.85
-25.28

Group % Error
260.70
315.17
333.84
312.37

Group % Error
271.23
335.08
289.47
317.62

Negligible strain
117.6%
-61.3%
-245.4%
Gage damaged
-66.9%
-253.8%
95.5%
-86.5%
-103.5%
311.6%
118.5%

Group 3: Stringer Hat (Closest to Skin)


SG22 281.59 303.81 268.83 305.87 290.02 17.90
SG24 356.51 371.73 339.48 384.31 363.01 19.37
SG26
5.20 48.93 321.34 365.64 185.28 184.45
SG28 346.00 350.87 318.59 362.24 344.42 18.52

SG21
SG23
SG25
SG27

-41.3%
32.8%
31.4%
-32.1%
52.2%
64.8%
35.9%
39.7%
39.9%
51.2%

10.1%
13.2%
-80.2% Large Stdev
9.3%
26.7%

Group 4: Stringer Flange (Farthest From Skin)


281.40 263.30 285.18 275.28
9.92 258.47
343.55 327.06 354.70 340.10 11.84 309.66
296.77 280.85 216.64 270.93 36.78 313.78
321.96 298.47 337.01 318.77 15.88 296.30

Group % Error

6.1%
8.9%
-15.8%
7.0%
9.8%

D-34

TABLE D-20. COMPARISON OF MEASURED AND PREDICTED STRAINS FOR CVP2,


LOAD CONDITION 1b (Continued)

Gage
SG29T
SG30T
SG31T
SG32T
SG33T
SG34T
SG35T
SG36T
SG37T

Air-1
-156.19
-134.17
-94.74
-130.42
-138.49
-176.60
-114.37
-107.68
-105.68

CVP2 - Load Condition 1b (Continued)


Experiment
Analysis % Error Remarks
Air-2 Water-1 Water-2 Average Stdev
Group 5: Skin, Hoop Direction
-159.80 -169.27 -181.60 -166.71 11.35
-142.56 -153.65 -163.69 -148.52 12.88
-99.23 -58.32 -105.69 -89.50 21.26
-134.50 -135.91 -159.88 -140.18 13.34
-142.38 -141.22 -147.86 -142.49 3.94
-180.58 -190.39 -167.05 -178.65 9.67
-116.00 -120.33 -132.81 -120.88 8.34
-110.53 -98.75 -134.74 -112.93 15.38
-110.91 -112.39 -129.16 -114.53 10.17

-142.81
-119.69
-72.28
-115.60
-117.50
-144.27
-130.32
-95.92
-102.03

Group % Error
SG29L
SG30L
SG31L
SG32L
SG33L
SG34L
SG35L
SG36L
SG37L

355.19
374.55
319.75
384.58
362.41
339.41
374.39
319.19
322.79

16.5%
Group 6: Skin, Longitudinal Direction
356.04 354.00 370.00 358.81 7.51
385.55 361.20 401.92 380.81 17.24
339.11 304.06 347.46 327.60 19.52
398.20 366.03 414.70 390.88 20.64
371.30 334.81 371.71 360.06 17.37
344.40 315.16 337.77 334.19 13.00
381.34 350.09 400.96 376.69 21.00
330.42 303.02 341.75 323.60 16.52
343.38 305.96 350.89 330.76 20.36

352.12
346.39
300.07
342.62
344.58
351.90
349.55
308.75
303.23

Group % Error
SG29-45
SG30-45
SG31-45
SG32-45
SG33-45
SG34-45
SG35-45
SG36-45
SG37-45

137.11
108.15
96.44
103.53
95.33
24.38
121.24
94.72
86.58

14.3%
19.4%
19.2% Opposite Gage 37
17.5%
17.5%
19.2%
-7.8%
15.1%
10.9%
Loading direction
1.9%
9.0%
8.4% Opposite Gage 37
12.3%
4.3%
-5.3%
7.2%
4.6%
8.3%
7.6%

Group 7: Skin, 45-degree Direction


159.17 121.49 147.22 141.25 15.96
132.77 90.10 131.21 115.56 20.36
88.91 91.66 103.90
95.23 6.57
91.62 79.03 106.74
95.23 12.60
98.32 93.81 101.93
97.35 3.58
25.16 32.30 40.42
30.57 7.47
117.03 111.95 144.37 123.65 14.33
98.03 114.21 126.07 108.26 14.61
81.26 59.84 88.69
79.09 13.21

Group % Error

78.94
110.82
114.37
114.89
113.83
128.83
110.66
105.80
100.77

44.1%
4.1%
-20.1% Opposite Gage 37
-20.6%
-16.9%
-321.5% Questionable gage
10.5%
2.3%
-27.4%
40.0%

D-35

TABLE D-21. COMPARISON OF MEASURED AND PREDICTED STRAINS FOR CVP2,


LOAD CONDITION 1c

Gage

Air-1

CVP2 - Load Condition 1c


Experiment
Analysis % Error Remarks
Air-2 Water-1 Water-2 Average Stdev

SG2
SG4
SG6
SG8
SG10
SG12
SG14
SG16
SG18
SG20

579.98
553.07
637.36
571.61
557.94
959.66
580.50
540.10
497.14
557.41

Group 1: Frame Outer Cap (Closest to Skin)


586.49 591.92 589.19 586.90 5.12 559.26
557.42 565.94 567.61 561.01 6.92 525.71
638.54 658.56 659.98 648.61 12.33 628.48
575.27 602.10 597.42 586.60 15.39 513.93
559.38 562.67 565.44 561.35 3.37 538.80
962.17 979.46 983.76 971.26 12.12 742.86
579.57 608.39 600.40 592.22 14.44 538.01
528.85 537.34 530.13 534.10 5.47 427.48
488.46 491.19 493.07 492.46 3.65 430.07
546.90 543.07 551.79 549.79 6.21 426.98

Group % Error
SG1
SG3
SG5
SG7
SG9
SG11
SG13
SG15
SG17
SG19

15.6%

Group 2:
876.17 898.59
733.30 740.54
681.88 668.39
723.13 715.81
608.06 573.74
871.88 807.36
525.25 487.40
662.64 602.36
579.73 532.71

Frame Inner Cap (Farthest From Skin)


Primary loading direction
807.80 859.26 860.46 38.62 555.17 35.5%
685.05 707.24 716.53 25.40 473.59 33.9%
699.98 687.03 684.32 13.07 459.47 32.9%
Gage damaged
663.33 687.11 697.35 27.49 496.58 28.8%
582.48 580.81 586.27 15.01 353.11 39.8%
808.85 795.67 820.94 34.47 607.81 26.0%
494.77 495.97 500.85 16.70 651.97 -30.2%
611.77 617.50 623.57 26.78 690.65 -10.8%
542.87 543.99 549.82 20.57 690.08 -25.5%

Group % Error
SG22
SG24
SG26
SG28

264.49
306.58
173.34
262.23

30.6%
Group 3: Stringer Hat (Closest to Skin)
262.02 258.65 254.08 259.81 4.51
300.00 293.25 295.38 298.80 5.90
261.24 322.65 289.42 261.66 64.01
264.86 269.97 255.33 263.10 6.09

Group % Error
SG21 -33.01
SG23 103.10
SG25 195.74
SG27 75.89

Primary loading direction


4.7%
6.3%
3.1%
12.4%
4.0%
23.5%
9.2%
20.0%
12.7%
22.3%

230.82
259.27
178.94
205.91

11.2%
13.2%
31.6% Large Stdev
21.7%
20.6%

Group 4:
-35.01
97.20
195.79
77.90

Stringer Flange (Farthest From Skin)


-40.08 -36.47 -36.14 2.98 -42.11 -16.5%
84.43
79.38
91.02 11.00 -23.68 126.0%
185.93 162.99 185.11 15.46
48.09 74.0%
66.99
68.00
72.19 5.51
63.12 12.6%

Group % Error

80.8%

D-36

TABLE D-21. COMPARISON OF MEASURED AND PREDICTED STRAINS FOR CVP2,


LOAD CONDITION 1c (Continued)

Gage
SG29T
SG30T
SG31T
SG32T
SG33T
SG34T
SG35T
SG36T
SG37T

CVP2 - Load Condition 1c (Continued)


Experiment
Analysis % Error Remarks
Air-1 Air-2 Water-1 Water-2 Average Stdev
Group 5: Skin, Hoop Direction
724.40 726.61 724.09 737.12 728.06 6.15
708.14 712.39 718.88 721.67 715.27 6.14
740.72 744.17 749.94 745.57 745.10 3.82
768.09 772.78 779.45 785.94 776.56 7.80
753.80 758.65 761.85 765.70 760.00 5.04
687.90 688.52 683.65 693.18 688.31 3.90
711.01 711.90 705.40 709.34 709.41 2.88
721.76 722.37 727.97 728.76 725.22 3.66
729.96 735.29 752.11 744.74 740.53 9.85

822.70
818.80
735.44
850.87
851.17
822.84
769.64
838.82
832.89

Group % Error
SG29L
SG30L
SG31L
SG32L
SG33L
SG34L
SG35L
SG36L
SG37L

12.6%

Group 6: Skin, Longitudinal Direction


252.24 250.79 265.07 236.07 251.04 11.87
278.90 273.92 264.47 261.84 269.78 7.99
223.87 218.78 206.40 221.29 217.58 7.74
224.89 220.84 206.04 194.97 211.69 13.78
195.85 189.66 181.62 174.01 185.29 9.51
204.16 206.11 194.92 184.56 197.44 9.88
304.38 304.39 295.91 295.29 299.99 5.08
205.42 209.67 203.95 210.64 207.42 3.24
243.16 237.48 226.94 238.56 236.54 6.86

Group % Error
SG29-45
SG30-45
SG31-45
SG32-45
SG33-45
SG34-45
SG35-45
SG36-45
SG37-45

Primary loading direction


-13.0%
-14.5%
1.3% Opposite Gage 37
-9.6%
-12.0%
-19.5%
-8.5%
-15.7%
-12.5%

221.39
202.06
142.44
146.16
150.25
221.54
196.44
115.33
147.57

Secondary loading direction


11.8%
25.1%
34.5% Opposite Gage 37
31.0%
18.9%
-12.2%
34.5%
44.4%
37.6%
30.1%

Group 7: Skin, 45-degree Direction


546.34 537.76 514.42 514.76 528.32 16.24
498.50 496.20 475.55 486.02 489.07 10.52
473.58 473.75 454.80 470.88 468.25 9.07
485.07 486.84 466.73 465.91 476.14 11.37
491.84 489.11 499.86 500.04 495.21 5.59
406.69 414.51 409.40 410.91 410.38 3.26
497.37 491.06 483.83 489.63 490.47 5.56
507.63 502.82 521.87 519.80 513.03 9.26
478.74 479.51 464.67 479.07 475.50 7.23

Group % Error

498.26 5.7%
515.80 -5.5%
451.02 3.7% Opposite Gage 37
520.04 -9.2%
491.34 0.8%
541.80 -32.0% questionable gage
503.96 -2.7%
445.94 13.1%
506.32 -6.5%
11.3%

D-37

TABLE D-22. COMPARISON OF MEASURED AND PREDICTED STRAINS FOR CVP3,


LOAD CONDITION 1a

Gage
SG6
SG9

CVP3 - Load Condition 1a


Experiment
Analysis % Error Remarks
Air-1 Air-2 Water-1 Water-2 Average Stdev
Group 1: Frame Outer Cap (Closest to Skin)
Loading direction
445.18 441.21 469.51 462.70 454.65 13.62 410.33
9.7%
483.24 476.35 501.05 491.73 488.09 10.69 422.34
13.5%

Group % Error
SG1
SG2
SG3
SG4
SG5
SG7
SG8

328.39
377.86
421.35
482.46
397.36
405.24
381.07

Group % Error
SG12
-7.14
SG14 -69.24
SG16 -31.80
SG17
SG20 -20.43
SG21 -108.17
SG24 -16.21
SG25 -79.95
SG27 -24.30
SG29 -10.68

11.9%
Group 2:
276.12
307.18
348.87
409.17
327.36
321.41
330.22

Frame Inner Cap (Farthest From Skin)


409.39 414.21 357.03 66.78 601.41
473.21 457.82 404.02 76.91 613.67
644.97 539.44 488.66 130.49 477.95
613.15 529.65 508.60 85.52 600.18
482.80 454.74 415.57 68.72 612.17
496.61 521.20 436.12 91.30 638.60
428.06 399.63 384.74 41.17 588.46

Loading direction
-68.4%
-51.9%
2.2%
-18.0%
-47.3%
-46.4%
-52.9%

42.4%
Group 3: Stringer Hat (Closest to Skin)
Negligible strain
-6.05
13.83
23.53
6.04 15.13
-6.55 208.4%
-68.25 -55.31 -69.18 -65.50 6.80 -73.91 -12.8%
-32.26 -12.54 -12.83 -22.36 11.17 -121.32 -442.7%
Gage damaged
-27.15 -27.51 -28.20 -25.82 3.62 -64.30 -149.0%
-108.64 -100.97 -111.37 -107.29 4.44 -116.91
-9.0%
-21.44 -14.59
8.13 -11.03 13.10 -65.80 -496.6%
-77.65 -66.38 -73.00 -74.24 5.99 -74.32
-0.1%
-22.69
-6.02
-5.34 -14.59 10.31 -120.99 -729.5%
-10.25
13.29
19.68
3.01 15.78 -71.85 2488.8%

Group % Error

117.4%

-159.68
-136.86
-25.05
-2.86
-200.71
-297.60
38.90
-310.86
-15.96
-20.20
-87.70
-148.10

Group 4: Stringer Flange (Farthest From Skin)


-162.96 -126.20 -113.58 -140.61 24.50 -256.93 -82.7%
-139.47 -143.85 -137.18 -139.34 3.22 -67.39
51.6%
-37.31 -34.64 -21.01 -29.50 7.73 -61.40 -108.1%
-11.08 -26.71 -21.94 -15.65 10.74
7.32 146.8%
-191.10 -209.54 -219.59 -205.24 12.18 -172.44
16.0%
-293.43 -305.38 -319.95 -304.09 11.68 -297.51
2.2%
24.80
26.52
41.60
32.96 8.53 153.49 -365.7%
-307.90 -308.57 -288.91 -304.06 10.18 -352.61 -16.0%
-20.54 -29.34 -10.13 -18.99 8.11 -61.80 -225.4%
-16.35 -48.00 -28.72 -28.32 14.11
6.51 123.0%
-86.31 -52.87 -49.14 -69.00 20.85 -32.10
53.5%
-154.92 -121.55 -103.96 -132.13 23.66 -257.95 -95.2%

Group % Error

44.8%

SG10
SG11
SG13
SG15
SG18
SG19
SG22
SG23
SG26
SG28
SG30
SG31

D-38

TABLE D-22. COMPARISON OF MEASURED AND PREDICTED STRAINS FOR CVP3,


LOAD CONDITION 1a (Continued)

Gage

Air-1

SG32T
SG33T
SG34T
SG35T
SG36T
SG37T
SG38T
SG39T
SG40T

684.70
672.96
803.45
652.85
762.12
452.89
766.41
717.92
526.05

CVP3 - Load Condition 1a (Continued)


Experiment
Analysis
Air-2 Water-1 Water-2 Average Stdev
Group 5: Skin, Hoop Direction
693.69 682.65 678.91 684.99 6.28 803.29
688.69 682.42 672.27 679.08 7.90 807.21
805.16 790.05 771.36 792.50 15.63 813.62
661.03 636.16 639.57 647.40 11.59 713.55
767.95 764.18 750.88 761.28 7.34 802.08
467.93 416.90 414.00 437.93 26.70 604.89
769.08 759.20 736.50 757.80 14.80 813.54
719.64 712.96 701.16 712.92 8.34 804.06
532.30 522.19 501.65 520.55 13.27 583.99

Group % Error
SG32L
SG33L
SG34L
SG35L
SG36L
SG37L
SG38L
SG39L
SG40L

-13.33
-33.44
-108.51
-102.27
-31.07
-150.66
-95.98
-15.94
-160.01

349.69
280.97
354.24
305.01
340.42
185.47
325.31
409.46
217.65

Loading direction
-17.3%
-18.9%
-2.7%
-10.2% Opposite Gage 34
-5.4%
-38.1% Opposite Gage 36
-7.4%
-12.8%
-12.2% Opposite Gage 39
14.0%

Group 6: Skin, Longitudinal Direction


-18.54
3.20
-2.50
-7.79 9.92
-45.33 -22.19 -25.84 -31.70 10.22
-109.95 -104.84 -81.93 -101.31 13.09
-106.77 -98.28 -78.73 -96.51 12.35
-34.13 -19.77 -13.49 -24.62 9.66
-150.70 -143.18 -136.62 -145.29 6.77
-95.44 -97.36 -78.11 -91.72 9.11
-15.96
-2.81
7.01
-6.92 11.16
-156.74 -149.61 -152.59 -154.74 4.57

Group % Error
SG32-45
SG33-45
SG34-45
SG35-45
SG36-45
SG37-45
SG38-45
SG39-45
SG40-45

% Error Remarks

-69.32
-75.76
-149.49
-148.23
-70.58
-320.67
-141.09
-62.24
-313.00

Negligible strain
-789.8%
-139.0%
-47.6%
-53.6% Opposite Gage 34
-186.7%
-120.7% Opposite Gage 36
-53.8%
-799.0%
-102.3% Opposite Gage 39
99.6%

Group 7: Skin, 45-degree Direction


348.18 342.51 365.45 351.46 9.82
278.37 275.95 270.77 276.51 4.35
352.97 349.85 362.02 354.77 5.17
303.52 311.37 314.05 308.49 5.03
332.76 325.56 332.88 332.90 6.07
185.99 177.00 178.15 181.65 4.74
327.50 316.81 313.02 320.66 6.87
414.10 404.04 423.54 412.78 8.27
223.50 208.74 213.94 215.96 6.22

Group % Error

371.47 -5.7%
358.06 -29.5%
340.89
3.9%
287.12
6.9% Opposite Gage 34
347.59 -4.4%
165.16
9.1% Opposite Gage 36
333.85 -4.1%
367.34 11.0%
149.71 30.7% Opposite Gage 39
12.9%

D-39

TABLE D-23. COMPARISON OF MEASURED AND PREDICTED STRAINS FOR CVP3,


LOAD CONDITION 1b

Air-2

CVP3 - Load Condition 1b


Experiment
Analysis % Error Remarks
Water-1 Water-2 Average Stdev

Gage

Air-1

SG6
SG9

Group 1: Frame Outer Cap (Closest to Skin)


-212.15 -195.05 -202.13 -194.90 -201.06
8.13 -117.89
-150.26 -146.58 -159.96 -157.41 -153.55
6.20 -122.97

Group % Error
SG1
SG2
SG3
SG4
SG5
SG7
SG8

-199.76
-262.11
755.96
-14.97
-260.83
-376.25
-187.21

35.0%
Group 2:
-231.96
-310.42
762.56
-10.77
-292.82
-365.94
-186.42

Frame Inner Cap (Farthest From Skin)


-230.24 -282.13 -236.02 34.11 -438.79
-334.72 -409.52 -329.19 61.47 -602.18
662.97 532.39 678.47 107.48 944.82
-84.78 -211.26 -80.45 93.58
-47.49
-337.36 -424.15 -328.79 70.90 -595.22
-312.35 -436.87 -372.85 51.05 -631.57
-238.48 -308.92 -230.26 57.82 -428.45

Group % Error

-85.9%
-82.9%
-39.3%
41.0%
-81.0%
-69.4%
-86.1%
62.6%

Group 3: Stringer Hat (Closest to Skin)


SG12 823.22 817.43 822.37 810.53 818.39
5.83
SG14 1011.40 1050.13 1041.56 1017.80 1030.22 18.56
SG16 1020.41 998.39 1002.76 990.82 1003.10 12.55
SG17
SG20 800.77 827.06 833.35 811.19 818.09 14.84
SG21 513.62 504.26 513.03 484.78 503.92 13.46
SG24 888.54 905.30 909.80 893.09 899.18 10.01
SG25 1052.49 1048.81 1046.46 1027.66 1043.86 11.08
SG27 964.45 936.12 942.69 941.59 946.21 12.49
SG29 807.42 790.23 799.00 796.36 798.25
7.13
Group % Error
SG10 358.94
SG11 364.53
SG13 1094.75
SG15 563.90
SG18 629.82
SG19 589.71
SG22 -128.60
SG23 755.40
SG26 1085.30
SG28 485.98
SG30 329.30
SG31 361.27

41.4%
19.9%

664.24 18.8%
1101.55 -6.9%
1123.43 -12.0%
Gage damaged
693.62 15.2%
442.76 12.1%
832.61
7.4%
1101.58 -5.5%
1122.08 -18.6%
854.52 -7.0%
12.1%

Group 4: Stringer Flange (Farthest From Skin)


356.12 369.57 355.77 360.10
6.47 311.50 13.5%
369.63 372.46 361.00 366.91
5.12 333.86
9.0%
1080.29 1098.28 1079.01 1088.08
9.86 1114.43 -2.4%
568.36 571.54 562.94 566.69
4.01 529.26
6.6%
629.46 635.53 618.93 628.44
6.92 581.59
7.5%
674.01 674.34 650.57 647.16 39.88 678.33 -4.8%
161.75 159.10 118.77
77.76 138.97
66.98 13.9%
795.38 801.44 778.65 782.72 20.60 813.96 -4.0%
1072.27 1079.17 1072.64 1077.35
6.18 1114.38 -3.4%
493.08 489.50 488.47 489.26
2.95 528.55 -8.0%
338.54 196.47 186.31 262.66 82.48 366.40 -39.5%
369.40 376.15 362.32 367.29
6.93 311.74 15.1%

Group % Error

7.4%

D-40

TABLE D-23. COMPARISON OF MEASURED AND PREDICTED STRAINS FOR CVP3,


LOAD CONDITION 1b (Continued)

Gage

Air-1

CVP3 - Load Condition 1b (Continued)


Experiment
Analysis % Error Remarks
Air-2 Water-1 Water-2 Average Stdev

SG32T
SG33T
SG34T
SG35T
SG36T
SG37T
SG38T
SG39T
SG40T

-276.96
-414.72
-352.17
-183.52
-402.93
-418.07
-360.35
-279.38
-158.72

Group 5: Skin, Hoop Direction


-278.08 -281.48 -266.37 -275.72 6.52
-425.75 -423.66 -410.89 -418.76 7.10
-343.88 -347.59 -334.89 -344.63 7.33
-205.99 -202.70 -177.63 -192.46 14.00
-416.97 -414.69 -406.61 -410.30 6.63
-401.72 -401.25 -384.32 -401.34 13.78
-353.23 -357.03 -355.22 -356.46 3.02
-281.54 -279.54 -264.33 -276.20 7.97
-149.25 -149.54 -145.77 -150.82 5.54

Group % Error
SG32L
SG33L
SG34L
SG35L
SG36L
SG37L
SG38L
SG39L
SG40L

844.46
1067.39
875.16
850.73
1076.61
965.84
898.61
851.83
808.81

-23.56
-85.36
-331.34
-186.00
-107.74
-350.24
-335.14
-43.72
-118.49

91.5%
79.6%
3.9%
3.4% Opposite Gage 34
73.7%
12.7% Opposite Gage 36
6.0%
84.2%
21.4% Opposite Gage 39
58.1%

Group 6: Skin, Longitudinal Direction


Loading direction
849.46 840.93 815.88 837.68 14.95 688.49 17.8%
1059.53 1056.25 1030.56 1053.43 15.95 933.70 11.4%
884.03 888.28 871.50 879.74 7.75 892.35 -1.4%
857.62 863.73 848.20 855.07 7.01 921.66 -7.8% Opposite Gage 34
1075.79 1068.50 1052.38 1068.32 11.23 936.28 12.4%
977.50 978.30 971.82 973.37 5.79 1045.55 -7.4% Opposite Gage 36
911.76 909.97 903.88 906.06 6.00 899.34
0.7%
842.83 844.38 833.65 843.17 7.47 688.39 18.4%
810.75 811.07 798.28 807.23 6.05 858.77 -6.4% Opposite Gage 39

Group % Error

10.9%

Group 7: Skin, 45-degree Direction


SG32-45 321.29 328.52 323.80 332.24 326.46 4.88 374.64 -14.8%
SG33-45 -110.97 -105.68 -105.82 -102.45 -106.23 3.52
9.48 108.9%
SG34-45 144.00 160.87 162.85 165.31 158.26 9.68 176.38 -11.5%
SG35-45 184.61 182.77 189.61 198.31 188.83 6.95 270.94 -43.5% Opposite Gage 34
SG36-45 -109.32 -92.42 -97.22 -111.76 -102.68 9.34
15.39 115.0%
SG37-45 -256.59 -187.01 -188.86 -193.68 -206.54 33.49 -115.84 43.9% Opposite Gage 36
SG38-45 305.25 313.99 321.26 302.38 310.72 8.59 341.68 -10.0%
SG39-45 245.78 263.42 262.19 268.68 260.02 9.90 352.71 -35.6%
SG40-45 352.05 374.88 373.07 371.00 367.75 10.59 415.36 -12.9% Opposite Gage 39
Group % Error

32.7%

D-41

TABLE D-24. COMPARISON OF MEASURED AND PREDICTED STRAINS FOR CVP3,


LOAD CONDITION 1c
CVP3 - Load Condition 1c
Experiment
Analysis % Error Remarks
Air-2 Water-1 Water-2 Average Stdev

Gage

Air-1

SG6
SG9

Group 1: Frame Outer Cap (Closest to Skin)


Secondary loading direction
258.32 246.40 265.09 274.00 260.95 11.63 301.19 -15.4%
321.97 303.36 322.40 330.44 319.54 11.47 309.44
3.2%

Group % Error
SG1
SG2
SG3
SG4
SG5
SG7
SG8

10.1%

Group 2: Frame Inner Cap (Farthest From Skin)


49.32 12.44 22.32 28.45
28.13 15.59 120.02
-39.40 -103.59 -68.27 -89.62 -75.22 27.95 -31.80
1142.93 1041.25 993.98 923.95 1025.53 91.91 1294.43
436.88 352.11 328.91 266.89 346.20 70.35 467.23
-30.59 -109.91 -57.95 -88.13 -71.65 34.68 -26.18
-20.92 -88.45
-7.44 -63.34 -45.04 37.48 -35.06
77.34
-2.45 50.29 35.40
40.15 33.28 117.30

Group % Error

29.8%

Group 3: Stringer Hat (Closest to Skin)


SG12 836.44 808.29 800.77 793.71 809.80 18.73
SG14 954.65 938.30 916.50 902.87 928.08 22.95
SG16 1024.26 978.50 957.22 945.78 976.44 34.64
SG17
SG20 779.08 771.02 757.06 740.53 761.92 16.92
SG21 390.41 383.14 374.02 347.25 373.71 18.87
SG24 910.39 865.81 845.23 838.20 864.91 32.51
SG25 964.14 953.09 932.08 906.09 938.85 25.57
SG27 950.31 917.90 900.36 884.34 913.23 28.27
SG29 794.38 773.87 773.62 759.03 775.23 14.53
Group % Error
SG10
SG11
SG13
SG15
SG18
SG19
SG22
SG23
SG26
SG28
SG30
SG31

Group 4:
276.02 274.29
264.03 261.39
1080.08 1048.25
569.58 566.44
454.26 464.61
464.33 461.58
229.11 208.41
586.99 554.49
1084.98 1051.49
476.14 476.36
264.46 271.96
310.06 289.52

Secondary loading direction


-326.6%
57.7%
-26.2%
-35.0%
63.5%
22.2%
-192.2%

636.60
996.80
972.90
599.55
334.84
730.27
997.52
971.81
757.04

21.4%
-7.4%
0.4%
Gage damaged
21.3%
10.4%
15.6%
-6.2%
-6.4%
2.3%
11.9%

Stringer Flange (Farthest From Skin)


302.99 291.10 286.10 13.56 155.45 45.7%
252.96 241.87 255.06 9.98 281.44 -10.3%
1029.64 1026.94 1046.23 24.48 1019.14
2.6%
547.13 542.00 556.29 13.76 539.64
3.0%
450.32 434.36 450.89 12.56 424.46
5.9%
442.33 418.30 446.64 21.27 441.61
1.1%
215.18 217.80 217.63 8.62 187.30 13.9%
537.95 525.74 551.29 26.55 512.68
7.0%
1028.29 1015.45 1045.05 30.51 1018.47
2.5%
448.85 442.71 461.02 17.77 537.95 -16.7%
152.71 141.49 207.66 70.14 348.43 -67.8%
319.72 308.69 307.00 12.64 155.72 49.3%

Group % Error

13.8%

D-42

TABLE D-24. COMPARISON OF MEASURED AND PREDICTED STRAINS FOR CVP3,


LOAD CONDITION 1c (Continued)

Gage

Air-1

CVP3 - Load Condition 1c (Continued)


Experiment
Analysis % Error Remarks
Air-2 Water-1 Water-2 Average Stdev

SG32T
SG33T
SG34T
SG35T
SG36T
SG37T
SG38T
SG39T
SG40T

383.15
215.84
512.69
396.73
292.44
65.08
442.99
401.08
336.89

Group 5: Skin, Hoop Direction


391.52 390.33 411.49 394.12 12.15
229.88 235.96 254.97 234.16 16.23
513.63 508.26 525.07 514.91 7.17
403.32 350.83 428.74 394.91 32.46
299.69 307.82 325.56 306.38 14.25
80.76 58.81 69.53
68.55 9.25
457.07 449.34 463.59 453.25 8.98
410.00 410.28 430.63 413.00 12.51
345.52 341.68 342.16 341.56 3.55

663.65
564.47
541.33
472.46
540.87
280.91
525.27
645.50
449.72

Group % Error
SG32L
SG33L
SG34L
SG35L
SG36L
SG37L
SG38L
SG39L
SG40L

805.37
1007.90
756.43
739.22
1004.92
851.25
839.83
807.57
696.26

54.2%
Group 6: Skin, Longitudinal Direction
789.80 769.10 750.38 778.66 24.00
985.76 960.36 939.71 973.43 29.71
758.49 737.23 720.69 743.21 17.81
735.41 718.71 702.01 723.84 17.06
999.91 965.00 944.30 978.53 28.92
843.95 823.63 803.63 830.62 21.45
809.01 774.06 767.29 797.55 33.60
795.28 778.72 764.57 786.54 18.82
691.06 677.77 648.94 678.51 21.19

Group % Error
SG32-45
SG33-45
SG34-45
SG35-45
SG36-45
SG37-45
SG38-45
SG39-45
SG40-45

660.27
108.41
569.59
493.51
193.03
-11.71
682.62
700.01
643.70

Secondary loading direction


-68.4%
-141.1%
-5.1%
-19.6% Opposite Gage 34
-76.5%
-309.8% Opposite Gage 36
-15.9%
-56.3%
-31.7% Opposite Gage 39
Primary loading direction

568.22
781.72
729.56
755.72
783.37
817.08
740.31
571.72
634.03

27.0%
19.7%
1.8%
-4.4% Opposite Gage 34
19.9%
1.6% Opposite Gage 36
7.2%
27.3%
6.6% Opposite Gage 39
16.9%

Group 7: Skin, 45-degree Direction


655.63 631.57 646.54 648.50 12.65
121.63 114.47 114.60 114.78 5.40
555.96 531.24 540.38 549.29 16.95
480.51 470.67 473.63 479.58 10.16
179.45 177.22 187.68 184.35 7.33
-24.50 -17.31
-9.01 -15.63 6.85
647.02 635.01 639.40 651.01 21.65
664.10 640.18 653.30 664.40 25.68
606.67 582.26 573.83 601.62 31.32

Group % Error

661.42 -2.0%
258.49 -125.2%
540.37
1.6%
522.93 -9.0% Opposite Gage 34
263.43 -42.9%
117.54 851.9% Opposite Gage 36
691.13 -6.2%
638.87
3.8%
598.79
0.5% Opposite Gage 39
14.8%

D-43

TABLE D-25. COMPARISON OF MEASURED AND PREDICTED STRAINS FOR CVP4,


LOAD CONDITION 1a

Air-2

CVP4 - Load Condition 1a


Experiment
Analysis % Error Remarks
Water-1 Water-2 Water-3 Average Stdev

Gage

Air-1

SG6
SG9

Group 1: Frame Outer Cap (Closest to Skin)


440.62 439.04 416.63 440.76 437.50 434.91 10.31
473.30 471.61 454.64 462.26 462.11 464.79 7.67

Loading direction
410.33
422.34

Group % Error
SG1
SG2
SG3
SG4
SG5
SG7
SG8

688.74
835.98
1019.69
860.00
2659.74
656.44

7.7%
Group 2: Frame Inner Cap (Farthest From Skin)
745.80 658.59 619.54 679.43 678.42 46.12
884.33 772.17 679.97 770.95 788.68 77.12
1015.79 896.52 634.68 842.74 881.88 157.94
859.85 790.64 594.22 734.56 767.85 110.38
1014.47 744.26 633.93 770.78 1164.63 847.26
687.12 579.67 528.72 606.45 611.68 62.51

601.41
613.67
477.95
600.18
612.17
588.46

Group % Error
Stringer Hat (Closest to Skin)
-39.99 -39.90 -36.40 5.40
236.61 745.37
94.19 406.90
-77.04 -72.32 -69.17 5.51
-40.72 -49.34 -39.82 6.78
-14.62 -17.29
-8.01 7.77
-174.48 -176.76 -164.10 10.98
-42.23 -38.86 -34.51 6.39
-165.31 -163.01 -149.16 13.75
-67.65 -67.28 -61.73 5.88
-64.10 -70.38 -66.75 3.16

-6.55 82.0%
-73.91 178.5%
-121.32 -75.4%
-170.45 -328.0%
-64.30 -702.3%
-116.91 28.8%
-65.80 -90.7%
-74.32 50.2%
-120.99 -96.0%
-71.85
-7.6%

Group % Error
-103.32
-73.25
30.68
-27.01
-243.02
-348.57
-344.66
5.93
-13.65
-37.38
-169.87

Loading direction
11.4%
22.2%
45.8%
21.8%
47.4%
Gage damaged
3.8%
35.7%

Group 3:
SG12 -30.84 -30.19 -41.07
SG14 -234.92 -108.12 -167.97
SG16 -63.77 -64.81 -67.93
SG17 -42.24 -34.93 -31.89
SG20
-3.64
1.37
-5.88
SG21 -157.66 -159.94 -151.64
SG24 -35.40 -27.79 -28.27
SG25 -140.12 -137.68 -139.67
SG27 -61.74 -57.86 -54.13
SG29 -68.73 -67.66 -62.86

SG10
SG11
SG13
SG15
SG18
SG19
SG22
SG23
SG26
SG28
SG30
SG31

5.7%
9.1%

92.5%
Group 4: Stringer Flange (Farthest From Skin)
-129.21 -129.05 -165.97 -143.17 -134.14 22.88
-78.66 -79.51 -93.05 -82.41 -81.38 7.32
43.61
32.29 10.90 21.56
27.81 12.28
-33.64 -33.15 -44.62 -36.54 -34.99 6.40
-239.68 -1537.38 278.65 -333.64 -415.02 672.28
-341.18 -345.02 -352.23 -352.99 -348.00 4.96
-337.58 -331.59 -347.53 -348.43 -341.96 7.19
26.06
-5.74
-5.39
-1.00
3.97 13.21
-12.84 -21.00 -10.89 -23.51 -16.38 5.53
-37.90 -38.17 -35.85 -43.35 -38.53 2.84
-168.01 -173.38 -162.74 -171.82 -169.16 4.12

Group % Error

-256.93
-67.39
-61.40
7.32
-172.44
-297.51
-352.61
-61.80
6.51
-32.10
-257.95

-91.5%
17.2%
320.8%
120.9%
58.4%
14.5%
Gage damaged
-3.1%
1656.7%
139.7%
16.7%
-52.5%
46.1%

D-44

TABLE D-25. COMPARISON OF MEASURED AND PREDICTED STRAINS FOR CVP4,


LOAD CONDITION 1a (Continued)

Gage

Air-1

CVP4 - Load Condition 1a (Continued)


Experiment
Analysis % Error Remarks
Air-2 Water-1 Water-2 Water-3 Average Stdev

SG32T
SG33T
SG34T
SG35T
SG36T
SG37T
SG38T
SG39T
SG40T

774.92
804.45
746.79
703.26
746.86
459.27
796.39
775.12
451.17

772.07
800.49
742.23
695.36
744.22
444.31
790.67
768.36
439.32

Group 5: Skin, Hoop Direction


792.78 809.24 791.77 788.16
806.68 835.49 823.14 814.05
727.59 733.87 753.74 740.84
704.37 742.17 710.56 711.14
743.50 760.73 762.14 751.49
452.09 482.53 462.82 460.21
793.14 792.70 801.76 794.93
780.13 796.14 785.20 780.99
439.04 466.31 452.59 449.68

15.11
14.77
10.34
18.17
9.18
14.36
4.33
10.51
11.27

803.29
807.21
813.62
713.55
802.08
604.89
813.54
804.06
583.99

Group % Error
SG32L
SG33L
SG34L
SG35L
SG36L
SG37L
SG38L
SG39L
SG40L

41.53
14.22
-97.65
-100.51
-13.49
-179.28
-107.51
2.66
-166.23

10.3%
Group 6: Skin, Longitudinal Direction
46.36 29.59 27.09 29.23
34.76 8.61
21.02 13.69 -19.69
-3.79
5.09 16.61
-93.51 -63.98 -112.58 -116.06 -96.76 20.67
-95.97 -64.63 -115.45 -118.12 -98.94 21.38
-11.17 -11.26 -50.10 -42.93 -25.79 19.11
-184.36 -259.57 -187.22 -201.53 -202.39 33.01
-94.68 -97.74 -110.14 -111.09 -104.23 7.52
12.66 12.41
-4.90
-5.86
3.40 8.97
-160.90 -160.39 -155.36 -167.10 -162.00 4.79

-69.32
-75.76
-149.49
-148.23
-70.58
-320.67
-141.09
-62.24
-313.00

Group % Error
SG32-45
SG33-45
SG34-45
SG35-45
SG36-45
SG37-45
SG38-45
SG39-45
SG40-45

425.30
420.32
322.46
307.00
336.84
175.46
350.31
422.21
152.77

Loading direction
-1.9%
0.8%
-9.8%
-0.3% Opposite Gage 34
-6.7%
-31.4% Opposite Gage 36
-2.3%
-3.0%
-29.9% Opposite Gage 39

299.4%
1587.7%
-54.5%
-49.8% Opposite Gage 34
-173.7%
-58.4% Opposite Gage 36
-35.4%
1933.2%
-93.2% Opposite Gage 39
82.2%

Group 7:
434.40 436.13
425.03 402.49
323.99 352.20
305.17 349.26
331.94 318.81
160.96 206.00
345.13 345.70
422.75 428.99
149.08 145.05

Skin, 45-degree Direction


429.39 426.01 430.25
420.39 417.23 417.09
324.03 336.74 331.88
328.08 318.70 321.64
331.33 339.95 331.77
233.79 191.44 193.53
351.73 352.51 349.08
450.41 438.85 432.64
177.09 166.16 158.03

Group % Error

4.88
8.63
12.74
18.02
8.07
28.14
3.44
11.98
13.28

371.47
358.06
340.89
287.12
347.59
165.16
333.85
367.34
149.71

13.7%
14.2%
-2.7%
10.7% Opposite Gage 34
-4.8%
14.7% Opposite Gage 36
4.4%
15.1%
5.3% Opposite Gage 39
11.5%

D-45

TABLE D-26. COMPARISON OF MEASURED AND PREDICTED STRAINS FOR CVP4,


LOAD CONDITION 1b

Air-2

CVP4 - Load Condition 1b


Experiment
Water-1 Water-2 Water-3 Average Stdev

Gage

Air-1

SG6
SG9

Group 1: Frame Outer Cap (Closest to Skin)


-147.39 -146.64 -136.29 -135.86 -149.96 -143.23
6.64
-154.46 -155.82 -146.22 -142.41 -160.90 -151.96
7.50

Analysis % Error Remarks

-117.89
-122.97

Group % Error
SG1
SG2
SG3
SG4
SG5
SG7
SG8

-349.18
-580.73
390.09
-43.31
-792.82
-381.59

18.4%
Group 2: Frame Inner Cap Farthest From Skin)
-309.88 -309.61 -333.88 -427.83 -346.08 48.69
-538.51 -525.64 -533.15 -704.79 -576.56 74.81
408.72 384.69 333.64 307.18 364.86 42.59
28.41
55.09 -63.99 -106.17 -25.99 66.53
-542.37 -518.85 -510.96 -679.75 -608.95 123.47
-375.19 -341.43 -337.07 -493.04 -385.66 63.19

-438.79 -26.8%
-602.18
-4.4%
944.82 -159.0%
-47.49 -82.7%
-595.22
2.3%
Gage damaged
-428.45 -11.1%

Group % Error

56.1%

Group 3: Stringer Hat (Closest to Skin)


SG12 756.21 754.25 725.77 735.25 762.55 746.81 15.55
SG14 1086.31 1145.14 1104.93 1115.95 991.15 1088.70 58.55
SG16 759.18 755.74 754.90 741.76 764.69 755.25
8.47
SG17 927.92 918.92 886.74 936.42 927.07 919.41 19.29
SG20 834.51 831.83 787.27 812.74 835.84 820.44 20.76
SG21 466.48 468.12 418.75 451.74 467.38 454.49 21.10
SG24 912.11 909.89 880.30 893.26 908.88 900.89 13.72
SG25 1137.48 1140.09 1078.21 1105.47 1134.73 1119.20 26.83
SG27 723.81 723.49 680.27 710.77 728.83 713.44 19.71
SG29 537.89 536.43 527.40 537.08 537.45 535.25
4.42

664.24
1101.55
1123.43
898.03
693.62
442.76
832.61
1101.58
1122.08
854.52

Group % Error
SG10 343.62
SG11 453.86
SG13 1037.70
SG15 492.02
SG18 635.46
SG19 859.88
SG22
SG23 912.33
SG26 1022.48
SG28 485.50
SG30 393.06
SG31 347.00

17.7%
19.1%

11.1%
-1.2%
-48.7%
2.3%
15.5%
2.6%
7.6%
1.6%
-57.3%
-59.6%
25.1%

Group 4: Stringer Flange (Farthest From Skin)


346.18 334.73 348.30 345.18 343.60
5.24 311.50
449.79 444.55 447.71 456.98 450.58
4.92 333.86
1032.00 1013.97 1017.87 1034.55 1027.22 10.60 1114.43
492.47 465.85 483.15 499.67 486.63 13.01 529.26
630.08 603.08 605.64 634.94 621.84 16.12 581.59
857.75 824.27 681.34 862.06 817.06 77.44 678.33
902.63 884.74 852.32 905.49 891.50 24.15 813.96
1024.34 995.27 987.34 1021.15 1010.11 17.44 1114.38
484.24 476.83 477.36 487.56 482.30
4.90 528.55
396.48 375.02 407.10 396.10 393.55 11.64 366.40
333.05 327.30 334.62 318.19 332.03 10.56 311.74

Group % Error

9.3%
25.9%
-8.5%
-8.8%
6.5%
17.0%
Gage damaged
8.7%
-10.3%
-9.6%
6.9%
6.1%
11.4%

D-46

TABLE D-26. COMPARISON OF MEASURED AND PREDICTED STRAINS FOR CVP4,


LOAD CONDITION 1b (Continued)

Gage

Air-1

CVP4 - Load Condition 1b (Continued)


Experiment
Analysis % Error Remarks
Air-2 Water-1 Water-2 Water-3 Average Stdev

SG32T
SG33T
SG34T
SG35T
SG36T
SG37T
SG38T
SG39T
SG40T

-229.53
-543.47
-348.90
-222.14
-469.51
-289.57
-339.20
-244.61
-154.11

-232.37
-549.69
-346.55
-225.64
-474.57
-289.98
-343.11
-247.44
-160.04

Group 5: Skin, Hoop Direction


-232.72 -239.19 -216.65 -230.09
-550.67 -574.90 -522.38 -548.22
-336.39 -359.83 -345.48 -347.43
-212.69 -216.41 -197.59 -214.90
-467.03 -487.34 -456.10 -470.91
-289.65 -277.52 -273.25 -283.99
-339.93 -355.44 -330.81 -341.70
-245.10 -250.05 -222.57 -241.95
-155.42 -151.81 -146.92 -153.66

8.30
18.77
8.40
10.89
11.40
8.01
8.93
11.05
4.82

-23.56 89.8%
-85.36 84.4%
-331.34
4.6%
-186.00 13.4% Opposite Gage 34
-107.74 77.1%
-350.24 -23.3% Opposite Gage 36
-335.14
1.9%
-43.72 81.9%
-118.49 22.9% Opposite Gage 39

Group % Error
SG32L
SG33L
SG34L
SG35L
SG36L
SG37L
SG38L
SG39L
SG40L

870.46
881.86
916.48
909.04
1032.30
963.59
936.09
852.97
833.72

65.2%
Group 6: Skin, Longitudinal Direction
870.06 838.29 841.60 877.82 859.65
878.14 839.31 849.66 883.65 866.52
909.65 872.94 894.67 917.45 902.24
903.23 865.91 885.91 911.38 895.09
1030.15 1003.81 1006.08 1037.75 1022.02
986.88 949.07 966.82 998.29 972.93
934.67 907.47 922.47 936.98 927.54
851.42 840.82 843.76 856.09 849.01
830.87 811.52 822.14 832.93 826.24

Group % Error
SG32-45 390.22
SG33-45 -249.98
SG34-45 227.77
SG35-45 288.68
SG36-45 -67.66
SG37-45 -72.61
SG38-45 332.15
SG39-45 356.86
SG40-45 385.41

18.29 688.49
20.55 933.70
18.74 892.35
19.12 921.66
15.85 936.28
19.57 1045.55
12.66 899.34
6.45 688.39
9.43 858.77

Loading direction
19.9%
-7.8%
1.1%
-3.0% Opposite Gage 34
8.4%
-7.5% Opposite Gage 36
3.0%
18.9%
-3.9% Opposite Gage 39
10.1%

Group 7: Skin, 45-degree Direction


396.44 373.03 369.57 421.15 390.08
-250.65 -293.06 -276.47 -226.80 -259.39
232.64 224.30 209.54 220.92 223.04
292.68 280.71 275.63 292.81 286.10
-74.22 -81.39 -80.93 -78.33 -76.50
-75.67 -86.60 -62.99 -77.02 -74.98
326.01 339.76 327.15 315.55 328.13
356.23 364.36 354.63 362.79 358.98
382.44 383.87 382.83 381.70 383.25

Group % Error

20.72 374.64
4.0%
25.75
9.48 103.7%
8.70 176.38 20.9%
7.64 270.94
5.3% Opposite Gage 34
5.71
15.39 120.1%
8.50 -115.84 -54.5% Opposite Gage 36
8.88 341.68 -4.1%
4.32 352.71
1.7%
1.44 415.36 -8.4% Opposite Gage 39
34.0%

D-47

TABLE D-27. COMPARISON OF MEASURED AND PREDICTED STRAINS FOR CVP4,


LOAD CONDITION 1c
CVP4 - Load Condition 1c
Experiment
Analysis % Error Remarks
Air-2 Water-1 Water-2 Water-3 Average Stdev

Gage

Air-1

SG8
SG9

Group 1: Frame Outer Cap (Closest to Skin)


283.50 280.95 262.82
287.39 292.33 281.40 11.24
322.94 318.52 292.74
316.86 327.29 315.67 13.45

Secondary loading direction


301.19
309.44

Group % Error
SG1
SG2
SG3
SG4
SG5
SG7
SG8

290.56
209.58
1356.40
668.13
261.42
263.16

4.9%
Group 2: Frame Inner Cap (Farthest From Skin)
Secondary loading direction
247.64 163.36
196.33 239.60 227.50 49.03 120.02 47.2%
153.70 22.91
61.01 146.70 118.78 75.45 -31.80 126.8%
1304.94 1014.86 1009.97 1276.34 1192.50 166.89 1294.43 -8.5%
624.63 445.71
460.15 626.31 564.98 103.89 467.23 17.3%
357.20 183.61 -17754.56 617.63 -3266.94 8100.48 -26.18 99.2%
Gage damaged
206.17 103.10
129.16 216.06 183.53 65.83 -35.06 119.1%

Group % Error
SG12
SG14
SG16
SG17
SG20
SG21
SG24
SG25
SG27
SG29

698.40
545.46
653.34
836.02
787.94
317.05
830.99
979.79
624.30
447.90

92.1%
697.60
251.39
651.25
834.50
785.29
317.56
828.51
972.15
619.43
446.20

Group 3: Stringer Hat (Closest to Skin)


658.27
695.01 705.84 691.03 18.75
470.62
944.78 -47.38 432.98 367.33
629.60
645.82 658.47 647.70 11.09
813.42
819.51 834.69 827.63 10.43
750.57
764.20 786.50 774.90 16.73
287.59
297.16 313.50 306.57 13.48
813.41
820.05 837.13 826.02
9.34
934.64
942.73 965.22 958.90 19.37
605.45
611.66 622.28 616.63
7.88
442.56
447.80 451.86 447.27
3.36

Group % Error
SG10 317.74
SG11 367.18
SG13 1026.82
SG15 420.63
SG18 422.92
SG19 525.67
SG22
SG23 581.10
SG26 1001.15
SG28 437.24
SG30 335.64
SG31 258.56

-7.0%
2.0%

636.60
996.80
972.90
717.99
599.55
334.84
730.27
997.52
971.81
757.04

7.9%
-130.2% Large stdev
-50.2%
13.2%
22.6%
-9.2%
11.6%
-4.0%
-57.6%
-69.3%
38.9%

Group 4: Stringer Flange (Farthest From Skin)


296.90 278.44
309.20 324.17 305.29 18.15 155.45 49.1%
369.86 356.43
364.35 372.40 366.04
6.15 281.44 23.1%
1022.51 996.63 1014.65 1034.19 1018.96 14.35 1019.14
0.0%
423.53 407.98
414.69 423.25 418.02
6.64 539.64 -29.1%
426.67 159.73
396.61 454.10 372.01 120.40 424.46 -14.1%
528.97 502.87
515.02 531.85 520.88 11.91 441.61 15.2%
Gage damaged
587.14 576.04
585.77 594.85 584.98
7.03 512.68 12.4%
991.71 955.76
977.89 996.18 984.54 18.27 1018.47 -3.4%
439.43 425.05
445.07 437.79 436.92
7.32 537.95 -23.1%
338.20 328.69
342.16 336.01 336.14
4.90 348.43 -3.7%
263.16 248.51
279.06 260.59 261.98 11.05 155.72 40.6%

Group % Error

15.2%

D-48

TABLE D-27. COMPARISON OF MEASURED AND PREDICTED STRAINS FOR CVP4,


LOAD CONDITION 1c (Continued)

Gage

Air-1

CVP4 - Load Condition 1c (Continued)


Experiment
Analysis %Error Remarks
Air-2 Water-1 Water-2 Water-3 Average Stdev

SG32T
SG33T
SG34T
SG35T
SG36T
SG37T
SG38T
SG39T
SG40T

467.57
313.98
461.29
422.05
282.33
149.97
498.39
474.17
283.83

466.72
324.71
461.56
428.87
282.92
154.02
499.14
478.60
290.42

Group 5: Skin, Hoop Direction


496.85 488.55 473.30 478.60
371.91 337.94 324.59 334.62
473.08 451.69 464.11 462.35
449.84 460.24 427.50 437.70
310.08 290.30 284.61 290.05
184.02 177.86 154.25 164.02
504.69 493.58 499.75 499.11
484.61 491.22 481.03 481.92
283.07 302.28 285.72 289.06

13.44
22.51
7.64
16.45
11.64
15.69
3.96
6.43
7.92

Group % Error
SG32L
SG33L
SG34L
SG35L
SG36L
SG37L
SG38L
SG39L
SG40L

814.17
842.50
781.07
772.60
937.87
765.55
794.50
783.76
675.05

719.39
175.90
558.00
539.02
236.81
49.36
700.24
706.65
539.82

Secondary loading direction


-38.7%
-68.7%
-17.1%
-7.9% Opposite Gage 34
-86.5%
-71.3% Opposite Gage 36
-5.2%
-33.9%
-55.6% Opposite Gage 39
39.7%

Group 6: Skin, Longitudinal Direction


813.32 773.78 791.25 818.51 802.21
830.91 767.97 796.56 829.86 813.56
778.57 744.58 752.23 774.74 766.24
770.59 740.47 743.85 766.43 758.79
935.84 917.09 896.11 931.20 923.62
764.66 761.03 752.94 760.06 760.85
793.51 778.56 781.63 796.13 788.87
778.10 771.61 764.39 783.71 776.31
670.82 656.26 674.69 674.76 670.31

19.11
30.71
16.66
15.39
17.39
4.99
8.13
8.33
8.05

Group % Error
SG32-45
SG33-45
SG34-45
SG35-45
SG36-45
SG37-45
SG38-45
SG39-45
SG40-45

663.65
564.47
541.33
472.46
540.87
280.91
525.27
645.50
449.72

Primary loading direction


568.22 29.2%
781.72 3.9%
729.56 4.8%
755.72 0.4% Opposite Gage 34
783.37 15.2%
817.08 -7.4% Opposite Gage 36
740.31 6.2%
571.72 26.4%
634.03 5.4% Opposite Gage 39
15.0%

713.17
177.66
555.00
539.60
239.92
54.17
701.61
701.55
538.04

Group 7:
712.03
179.71
555.45
555.63
276.05
127.19
715.22
708.41
531.32

Skin, 45-degree Direction


716.87 730.26 718.35
172.32 184.56 178.03
546.95 551.31 553.34
545.35 530.85 542.09
233.25 237.02 244.61
88.87
65.30
76.98
703.04 700.54 704.13
719.06 707.06 708.55
556.96 538.28 540.89

Group % Error

7.28
4.55
4.30
9.17
17.73
31.95
6.30
6.43
9.56

661.42 7.9%
258.49 -45.2%
540.37 2.3%
522.93 3.5% Opposite Gage 34
263.43 -7.7%
117.54 -52.7% Opposite Gage 36
691.13 1.8%
638.87 9.8%
598.79 -10.7% Opposite Gage 39
9.1%

D-49

TABLE D-28. SUMMARY OF GROUP PERCENTAGE ERRORS BETWEEN THE


MEASURED AND PREDICTED STRAINS
CVP1
Load Condition 1a
Load Condition 1b
Load Condition 1c
% Error Remarks
% Error Remarks
% Error Remarks
1. Frame Outer Cap (Closest to skin)
13.2% Loading direction 35.4%
12.3% Primary loading direction
2. Frame Inner Cap (Farthest from skin) 21.1% Loading direction 26.5%
26.0% Primary loading direction
3. Stringer Hat (Closest to skin)
93.7%
2.2%
19.9%
4. Stringer Flange (Farthest from skin) 26.8%
35.0%
85.0%
5. Skin, Hoop Direction
9.0% Loading direction 8.1%
10.3% Primary loading direction
6. Skin, Longitudinal Direction
39.3%
7.5% Loading direction 17.2% Secondary loading direction
7. Skin, 45-degree Direction
12.6%
16.6%
7.8%
CVP2
Gage Group
Load Condition 1a
Load Condition 1b
Load Condition 1c
% Error Remarks
% Error Remarks
% Error Remarks
1. Frame Outer Cap (Closest to skin)
16.7% Loading direction 47.9%
15.6% Primary loading direction
2. Frame Inner Cap (Farthest from skin) 23.5% Loading direction 118.5%
30.6% Primary loading direction
3. Stringer Hat (Closest to skin)
177.9%
26.7%
20.6%
4. Stringer Flange (Farthest from skin) 45.5%
9.8%
80.8%
5. Skin, Hoop Direction
13.0% Loading direction 16.5%
12.6% Primary loading direction
6. Skin, Longitudinal Direction
59.4%
7.6% Loading direction 30.1% Secondary loading direction
7. Skin, 45-degree Direction
12.6%
40.0%
11.3%
CVP3
Gage Group
Load Condition 1a
Load Condition 1b
Load Condition 1c
% Error Remarks
% Error Remarks
% Error Remarks
1. Frame Outer Cap (Closest to skin)
11.9% Loading direction 35.0%
10.1% Secondary loading direction
2. Frame Inner Cap (Farthest from skin) 42.4% Loading direction 62.6%
29.8% Secondary loading direction
3. Stringer Hat (Closest to skin)
117.4%
12.1%
11.9%
4. Stringer Flange (Farthest from skin) 44.8%
7.4%
13.8%
5. Skin, Hoop Direction
14.0% Loading direction 58.1%
54.2% Secondary loading direction
6. Skin, Longitudinal Direction
99.6%
10.9% Loading direction 16.9% Primary loading direction
7. Skin, 45-degree Direction
12.9%
32.7%
14.8%
CVP4
Gage Group
Load Condition 1a
Load Condition 1b
Load Condition 1c
% Error Remarks
% Error Remarks
% Error Remarks
1. Frame Outer Cap (Closest to skin)
7.7% Loading direction 18.4%
4.9% Secondary loading direction
2. Frame Inner Cap (Farthest from skin) 35.7% Loading direction 56.1%
92.1% Secondary loading direction
3. Stringer Hat (Closest to skin)
92.5%
25.1%
38.9%
4. Stringer Flange (Farthest from skin) 46.1%
11.4%
15.2%
5. Skin, Hoop Direction
10.3% Loading direction 65.2%
39.7% Secondary loading direction
6. Skin, Longitudinal Direction
82.2%
10.1% Loading direction 15.0% Primary loading direction
7. Skin, 45-degree Direction
11.5%
34.0%
9.1%
Gage Group

D-50

TABLE D-29. STRESS-INTENSITY FACTOR RANGE CALCULATIONS FOR PANELS


CVP1 AND CVP2

a, in
3.56
3.84
4.13
4.29
4.69
5.04
5.36
5.71
5.76
6.16
6.47
6.75
7.15
7.77
8.46
8.65
9.24
9.96
10.13
10.73
11.34
11.70
12.21
12.86
13.18

K1
30.19
31.68
33.30
34.11
38.13
39.52
40.91
42.23
42.46
47.09
48.07
49.14
50.56
55.41
58.06
58.43
63.13
65.54
65.78
70.57
72.26
72.93
77.37
78.40
78.90

CVP1 Baseline
( ksi in )
K2
k1
0.75
0.24
1.08
0.13
1.56
0.29
1.95
0.32
2.42
0.63
2.72
0.46
3.27
0.62
4.34
0.88
4.41
0.89
4.74
0.04
5.19
0.87
5.55
0.17
6.49
0.77
7.23
0.97
7.96
0.85
8.51
0.19
9.15
0.97
9.77
1.72
10.20
0.79
10.85
0.78
11.31
2.29
11.84
1.57
12.43
0.08
12.76
3.17
13.40
2.53

k2
9.76
9.89
9.35
8.38
12.45
13.08
13.01
11.86
11.66
15.36
15.52
15.17
13.85
16.88
16.26
14.98
18.44
17.36
16.18
19.98
16.98
15.58
21.66
17.95
16.62

D-51

K1
30.78
32.79
36.57
44.39
38.47
40.09
42.09
47.33
51.97
47.68
49.04
50.86
59.91
56.50
62.62
69.44
64.37
70.26
78.54
71.67
74.39
83.55
78.54
80.93
91.15

CVP2 Multiple Cracks


( ksi in )
K2
k1
0.73
0.30
1.05
0.03
1.62
0.02
2.46
0.66
2.41
0.68
2.71
0.44
3.29
0.88
4.76
0.34
5.32
0.03
4.94
0.33
5.22
0.89
5.64
0.32
7.48
1.06
7.28
1.03
8.47
0.34
9.96
0.92
9.26
0.86
10.38
1.20
12.05
0.48
11.03
0.47
11.57
2.07
13.44
0.53
12.65
0.44
13.09
2.95
15.34
1.52

k2
9.76
9.90
9.40
8.81
12.46
13.07
12.99
12.06
12.20
16.01
15.53
15.11
13.83
16.88
16.14
14.99
18.90
17.26
16.13
18.96
16.96
15.60
20.03
17.87
16.62

TABLE D-30. STRESS-INTENSITY FACTOR RANGE CALCULATIONS FOR PANELS


CVP3 AND CVP4

a, in
3.47
3.85
4.13
4.22
4.69
5.21
5.68
6.14
7.08
8.48
8.76

K1
27.51
28.67
29.46
29.71
31.67
33.03
33.98
35.70
37.18
35.29
34.68

CVP3, Baseline
( ksi in )
K2
k1
1.49
5.57
1.46
5.22
1.80
5.19
1.75
5.25
1.41
5.24
1.34
5.29
1.42
5.37
0.34
5.30
0.38
4.81
0.09
4.23
0.08
4.55

k2
6.64
5.81
5.46
5.20
5.49
5.31
5.40
5.98
5.11
3.22
1.84

D-52

K1
27.69
29.07
30.79
33.24
31.76
33.23
35.08
35.57
37.22
35.69
37.17

CVP4, Multiple Cracks


ksi in
K2
k1
1.49
5.61
1.46
5.26
1.86
5.25
1.98
5.55
1.40
5.25
1.31
5.30
1.41
5.34
0.38
5.29
0.38
4.81
0.14
4.23
0.19
4.39

k2
6.68
5.83
5.47
4.95
5.49
5.31
5.42
5.95
5.11
3.21
1.78

A
F1

F2

F3

F4

S1
S2
S3

29 2

S4
S5

Attachment Doublers (Not to scale)


0.5
0.325 0.1525
View A-A

F6
34

22
21
24
23 31,32
30 4 3
6 5
26
25
10 9
12
11
35
28
27
36

0.25
8 7

33

View B-B

34
56 68

14 13

20

18 17

0.025
Fastener Row A:
MS20470AD5

3.5

7.5

19

0.063

S6
16 15

F5

S7
19

A (2 : 1)
60
112
120

0.063
Fastener Row B:
MS20470AD6

Outer Skin
AA

Outer Finger
Doubler

0.025

1.5

A
0.875

1.250

0.813

0.875

0.071
C (2 : 1)
Fastener Row D:
MS20470AD5

AA

Inner Skin

Fastener Row C:
NAS1097AD6

C
Stinger

B (2 : 1)

AA-AA
D (2 : 1)

Inner Finger Doubler

FIGURE D-1. CVP1 AND CVP2 PENAL CONFIGURATION AND STRAIN GAGE
LOCATIONS
A
F1

F2

S1

F3

10

S2
S3
19

17

S4
3

18

S5
S6
S7

31
19

20

F4

5 22 36,37
25
27
28
8 26
9 39,40 29
30

F5

F6

Attachment Doublers (Not to scale)


0.5
0.325 0.1525
View A-A

34

11
12
1 13 32
15
16
33
14
2
21

34, 35 6

23
7 24

56 68

0.25

38

B
7.5

View B-B

3.5

0.063

0.025

60
112
120

Fastener Rows
A and H:
MS20470AD5

AA
1.500

Skin
Finger
Doubler

A (2 : 1)
Fastener Rows
B, C, F and G:
NAS1097AD6

C
D
E

Tapered
Doubler

0.75

CL
0.75

0.08

0.625

0.75

H
Skin

B (2 : 1)

0.625

AA

0.875

AA-AA

Fastener Rows
D and E:
HLT-435-6
Hi-Lok Pin

D (2 : 1)

FIGURE D-2. CVP3 AND CVP4 PENAL CONFIGURATION AND STRAIN GAGE
LOCATIONS

D-53

Fixed Long.
Direction

Skin
Full Assembly

Load Attachment Doubler

Fixed Hoop
Direction

Longitudinal
Load

Hoop Load
Stringer
Detail

Substructure
Reaction
Link Detail

Typical Mesh:
Elements: 62600
Nodes: 114600
Rivet Stiffness:
k shear =

E' d
d d
5 + 0.8 +
t ts

Frame Load
Frame - Shear Clip
Detail

FIGURE D-3. FINITE ELEMENT MODEL OF CVP1 AND CVP2, SHOWING


FULL ASSEMBLY AND SUBSTRUCTURE COMPONENTS
Full Assembly

Fixed Long.
Direction

Skin
Load Attachment Doubler

Fixed Hoop
Direction
Hoop Load
Longitudinal
Load

Stringer
Detail

Substructure

Typical Mesh:
Elements: 33,000
Nodes: 42,800
Rivet Stiffness:
kshear =

E' d
d d
5 + 0.8 +
t ts

Reaction
Link Detail

Frame - Shear Clip


Detail

Frame Load

FIGURE D-4. FINITE ELEMENT MODEL OF CVP3 AND CVP4, SHOWING


FULL ASSEMBLY AND SUBSTRUCTURE COMPONENTS

D-54

Attachment Doublers
0.5

0.325

Crack Area, CVP1


0.25

0.1525

View A-A

Finger Doubler

View B-B

A
4-noded elements

8-noded elements

Frame and Shear-Clip


Full Assembly

Crack Area, CVP2

Stringer

Reaction Link
Nodal
Load

Grounded spring
elements

4-noded elements

8-noded elements

4-noded elements

FIGURE D-5. FINITE ELEMENT MODEL OF CVP1 AND CVP2, SHOWING DETAILED
MESHES OF FINGER DOUBLERS, FRAMES, STRINGERS, AND CRACK REGION
Crack Area, CVP3

Attachment Doublers
0.5

0.325

0.25

0.1525

Finger Doubler

View A-A

View B-B

A
A

Full Assembly

8-noded elements

4-noded elements

Frame and Shear-Clip

Crack Area, CVP4

Stringer
Reaction Link
Nodal
Load
4-noded elements

8-noded elements

4-noded elements

Grounded spring
elements

FIGURE D-6. FINITE ELEMENT MODEL OF CVP3 AND CVP4, SHOWING DETAILED
MESHES OF FINGER DOUBLERS, FRAMES, STRINGERS, AND CRACK REGION
D-55

Layer 1: Outer Skin

Layer 3: Inner Skin

Layer 2: Outer Doubler


Layer 4: Inner Doubler

Lap Joint Connecting


Four Layers
Beam Length

Layer
Thickness

t2

Shell (layer)
mid-plane

t1
t3

t4

t1 + t2

CL
CL

CL
CL

2
t2 + t3
2
t3 + t4

Finite Element Representation:


3 Beam Elements

Detail of Single Fastener

FIGURE D-7. SCHEMATIC OF LAP JOINT AND CORRESPONDING FINITE


ELEMENT REPRESENTATION

Skin Gages

Frame Gages

Stringer Gages

1
3
7

5
2

F1

Group

Component

Direction

Frame Outer Cap

Hoop

S2

F2

F3

F4

F5

F6

S1

Frame Inner Cap

Hoop

S3

Stringer Cap

Longitudinal

S4

Stringer Flange

Longitudinal

S5

Skin

Hoop

S6

Skin

Longitudinal

Skin

45

22

29

21
24
23 31,32
30 4 3
6 5
26
25
10 9
35 12 11
28
27
36
16 15

18 17

33

8 7

34

14 13

20

19

S7

FIGURE D-8. GROUPING OF STRAIN GAGES ACCORDING TO LOCATION AND


MEASURE DIRECTION

D-56

1e+0
1e-1
1e-2
1e-3

da/dN
(in/cycle)

1e-4
1e-5

R = -1.0
R=0
R = 0.33
R = 0.5
R=0
R = 0.33
R = 0.5
R = -1.0
R=0
R = 0.5

Hudson [4]

Dubensky [5]

Phillips [6]

1e-6
1e-7
1e-8
1e-9
1e-10
1e-11
1

10

100

K ksi*sqrt(in)

FIGURE D-9. FATIGUE CRACK GROWTH DATA FOR 2024-T3 ALUMINUM WITH
VARIOUS R-RATIOS
Crack Surfaces
Coincident Nodes

Crack-Tip Node

Element Row B
Element Row A

Shared Edge

FIGURE D-10. FINITE ELEMENT MESH IN THE VICINITY OF A CRACK TIPS


USED IN THE FATIGUE CRACK GROWTH ANALYSIS
D-57

Maximum

Load, P

Minimum
t
Step 1

Step 2

Time, t
FIGURE D-11. RAMP FUNCTION USED IN THE FATIGUE CRACK GROWTH
ANALYSIS

u~ top =

top
i

i =1

KI

KII

~ bot

uibot

~
F close =

close

i =1

i =1

2
5
k1

k2

4
6

1
D.O.F

FIGURE D-12. DEFINITION OF FOUR STRESS-INTENSITY FACTORS AND


CRACK TIP ELEMENTS AND NODES FOR THE MCCI METHOD

D-58

Initialization
i=0
Ni =0

Step 1

SIF

Step 2

Step 3

Step 4

Stop

ai +1 a f

Step 6
Check for Link-Up
ai +1 alink up

Rate Calculation
da
R=0
R=1
R=-1
dN
da

dN i

(K )i

Step 9

Check for Final Length

Increment Count
i=i+1

(K )i
(a)i

Step 5

Step 8

K calculation

Step 7
Increase Length for Link-up
For MSD: ai +1 = ai +1 + 2amsd + d riv
For no MSD: ai +1 = ai +1 + d riv

Update Crack Length


a da

N i dN i
N i +1 = N i + 1
da
ai +1 = ai +

dN i

C
L

alink-up

driv
amsd amsd

FIGURE D-13. ALGORITHM FOR THE CYCLE-BY-CYCLE CRACK GROWTH


ANALYSIS

D-59

Load Cond. 1a
Pressure
Hoop Load
Frame Load
Long. Load

Max. Load
10.1 psi
554.6 lb/in
111.9 lb/in
0 lb/in

1200

800

Strain
()

CVP2 (Multiple Cracks)

CVP1

600
400

Air, Run 1
Air, Run 2
Water, Run 1
Water, Run 2

Air, Run 1
Air, Run 2
Water, Run 1
Water, Run 2

Strain Gage 02

1000

200
0
-200

Analysis (CVP1 and CVP2)

1200

800

Strain
()

600

600

400

400

200

200

0
0

10

-200

12

Load Step

10

12

1200

Strain Gage 08

1000

Strain Gage 10

1000

800

800

Strain
()

600

600

400

400

200

200

-200

Load Step

1200

Strain
()

12

Strain Gage 06

1000

800

-200

10

1200

Strain Gage 04

1000

Strain
()

Load Step

10

12

Load Step

-200

10

Load Step

FIGURE D-14. MEASURED AND PREDICTED STRAINS FOR GROUP 1 GAGES IN


FRAME OUTER CAPS OF CVP1 AND CVP2, LOAD CONDITION 1a

D-60

12

Load Cond. 1a
Pressure
Hoop Load
Frame Load
Long. Load

Max. Load
10.1 psi
554.6 lb/in
111.9 lb/in
0 lb/in

CVP1

1200

800

Strain
()

CVP2 (Multiple Cracks)

600
400

Air, Run 1
Air, Run 2
Water, Run 1
Water, Run 2

Air, Run 1
Air, Run 2
Water, Run 1
Water, Run 2

200
0
-200

Analysis (CVP1 and CVP2)

10

12

Strain Gage 16

1000

800

800

Strain
()

600

600

400

400

200

200

0
0

10

-200

12

Load Step

10

12

10

12

1200

Strain Gage 18

1000

Strain Gage 20

1000

800

800

Strain
()

600

600

400

400

200

200

-200

Load Step

1200

Strain
()

1200

Strain Gage 14

1000

-200

Load Step

1200

Strain
()

Strain Gage 12

1000

10

12

Load Step

-200

Load Step

FIGURE D-14. MEASURED AND PREDICTED STRAINS FOR GROUP 1 GAGES IN


FRAME OUTER CAPS OF CVP1 AND CVP2, LOAD CONDITION 1a (Continued)

D-61

Load Cond. 1a
Pressure
Hoop Load
Frame Load
Long. Load
CVP1

Max. Load
10.1 psi
554.6 lb/in
111.9 lb/in
0 lb/in

1200

800

Strain
()

CVP2 (Multiple Cracks)


Air, Run 1
Air, Run 2
Water, Run 1
Water, Run 2

Air, Run 1
Air, Run 2
Water, Run 1
Water, Run 2

600
400
200
0
-200

Analysis (CVP1 and CVP2)

10

12

10

12

10

12

800

Strain
()

600
400

600
400

200

200

0
0

10

-200

12

Load Step

Load Step

1200

1200

Strain Gage 07

1000

Strain Gage 09

1000

800

800

Strain
()

600

600

400

400

200

200

-200

Strain Gage 05

1000

800

Strain
()

1200

Strain Gage 03

1000

-200

Load Step

1200

Strain
()

Strain Gage 01

1000

10

12

Load Step

-200

Load Step

FIGURE D-15. MEASURED AND PREDICTED STRAINS FOR GROUP 2 GAGES IN


FRAME INNER CAPS OF CVP1 AND CVP2, LOAD CONDITION 1a
D-62

Load Cond. 1a
Pressure
Hoop Load
Frame Load
Long. Load

Max. Load
10.1 psi
554.6 lb/in
111.9 lb/in
0 lb/in

CVP1

1200

800

Strain
()

CVP2 (Multiple Cracks)

600
400

Air, Run 1
Air, Run 2
Water, Run 1
Water, Run 2

Air, Run 1
Air, Run 2
Water, Run 1
Water, Run 2

200
0
-200

Analysis (CVP1 and CVP2)

10

12

10

12

Strain Gage 15

1000

800

800

Strain
()

600

600

400

400

200

200

0
0

10

-200

12

Load Step

Load Step

1200

1200

Strain Gage 17

1000

800

Strain
()

600

600

400

400

200

200

-200

Strain Gage 19

1000

800

Strain
()

1200

Strain Gage 13

1000

-200

Load Step

1200

Strain
()

Strain Gage 11

1000

10

12

Load Step

-200

10

Load Step

FIGURE D-15. MEASURED AND PREDICTED STRAINS FOR GROUP 2 GAGES IN


FRAME INNER CAPS OF CVP1 AND CVP2, LOAD CONDITION 1a (Continued)
D-63

12

Load Cond. 1a
Pressure
Hoop Load
Frame Load
Long. Load
CVP1

Max. Load
10.1 psi
554.6 lb/in
111.9 lb/in
0 lb/in
CVP2 (Multiple Cracks)
Air, Run 1
Air, Run 2
Water, Run 1
Water, Run 2

Air, Run 1
Air, Run 2
Water, Run 1
Water, Run 2

Analysis (CVP1 and CVP2)

600

600

Strain Gage 22

Strain Gage 24

400

Strain
()

400

200

Strain
()

200
0

-200

-200

-400

-400

-600

10

-600

12

Load Step

600

12

Strain
()

200
0

-200

-200

-400

-400

Strain Gage 28

400

200

-600

10

600

Strain Gage 26

400

Strain
()

Load Step

10

12

Load Step

-600

10

Load Step

FIGURE D-16. MEASURED AND PREDICTED STRAINS FOR GROUP 3 GAGES IN


STRINGER HATS OF CVP1 AND CVP2, LOAD CONDITION 1a
D-64

12

Load Cond. 1a
Pressure
Hoop Load
Frame Load
Long. Load

Max. Load
10.1 psi
554.6 lb/in
111.9 lb/in
0 lb/in

CVP1

CVP2 (Multiple Cracks)


Air, Run 1
Air, Run 2
Water, Run 1
Water, Run 2

Air, Run 1
Air, Run 2
Water, Run 1
Water, Run 2

Analysis (CVP1 and CVP2)

400

400

Strain Gage 21

300
200

Strain
()

200

Strain
()

100
0

100
0

-100

-100

-200

-200

-300

-300

-400

Strain Gage 23

300

10

-400

12

Load Step

400

400

Strain Gage 25

300

12

200

Strain
()

100
0

100
0

-100

-100

-200

-200

-300

-300

-400

10

Strain Gage 27

300

200

Strain
()

Load Step

10

12

Load Step

-400

10

Load Step

FIGURE D-17. MEASURED AND PREDICTED STRAINS FOR GROUP 4 GAGES IN


STRINGER FLANGES OF CVP1 AND CVP2, LOAD CONDITION 1a
D-65

12

Load Cond. 1a
Pressure
Hoop Load
Frame Load
Long. Load
CVP1

Max. Load
10.1 psi
554.6 lb/in
111.9 lb/in
0 lb/in
CVP2 (Multiple Cracks)
Air, Run 1
Air, Run 2
Water, Run 1
Water, Run 2

Air, Run 1
Air, Run 2
Water, Run 1
Water, Run 2

Analysis (CVP1 and CVP2)

1000

1000

Strain Gage 29T

800

Strain
()

600

Strain
()

400

600
400

200

200

-200

Strain Gage 30T

800

10

-200

12

Load Step

1000

Strain Gage 31T

12

Strain
()

400

600
400

200

200

Strain Gage 32T

800

600

-200

10

1000

800

Strain
()

Load Step

10

12

Load Step

-200

10

Load Step

FIGURE D-18. MEASURED AND PREDICTED HOOP STRAIN FOR GROUP 5 GAGES
IN SKIN MID-BAY OF CVP1 AND CVP2, LOAD CONDITION 1a
D-66

12

Load Cond. 1a
Pressure
Hoop Load
Frame Load
Long. Load
CVP1

Max. Load
10.1 psi
554.6 lb/in
111.9 lb/in
0 lb/in

1000

600

Strain ()400

CVP2 (Multiple Cracks)


Air, Run 1
Air, Run 2
Water, Run 1
Water, Run 2

Air, Run 1
Air, Run 2
Water, Run 1
Water, Run 2

Strain Gage 33T

800

200
0
-200

1000

Strain
()

400

10

12

400

200

200

10

-200

12

Load Step

1000

1000

Strain Gage 36T

800

Strain
()

400

600
400

200

200

Strain Gage 37T

800

600

-200

12

600

Load Step

Strain
()

10

Strain Gage 35T

800

600

-200

1000

Strain Gage 34T

800

Strain
()

Load Step

Analysis (CVP1 and CVP2)

10

12

Load Step

-200

10

Load Step

FIGURE D-18. MEASURED AND PREDICTED HOOP STRAIN FOR GROUP 5 GAGES
IN SKIN MID-BAY OF CVP1 AND CVP2, LOAD CONDITION 1a (Continued)
D-67

12

Load Cond. 1a
Pressure
Hoop Load
Frame Load
Long. Load
CVP1

Max. Load
10.1 psi
554.6 lb/in
111.9 lb/in
0 lb/in
CVP2 (Multiple Cracks)
Air, Run 1
Air, Run 2
Water, Run 1
Water, Run 2

Air, Run 1
Air, Run 2
Water, Run 1
Water, Run 2

Analysis (CVP1 and CVP2)

600

600

Strain Gage 29L

400

Strain
()

Strain
()

200

200

-200

-200

-400

Strain Gage 30L

400

10

-400

12

Load Step

600

Strain Gage 31L

10

12

Strain
()

10

12

200

-200

-200

Strain Gage 32L

400

200

-400

600

400

Strain
()

Load Step

10

12

Load Step

-400

Load Step

FIGURE D-19. MEASURED AND PREDICTED LONGITUDINAL STRAINS FOR


GROUP 6 GAGES IN SKIN MID-BAY OF CVP1 AND CVP2, LOAD CONDITION 1a
D-68

Load Cond. 1a
Pressure
Hoop Load
Frame Load
Long. Load
CVP1

Max. Load
10.1 psi
554.6 lb/in
111.9 lb/in
0 lb/in

600

Strain
()

CVP2 (Multiple Cracks)

-200
-400

Analysis (CVP1 and CVP2)

Strain Gage 34L


Strain
()

200

12

200

-200

-200

10

-400

12

10

12

10

12

Load Step

600

600

Strain Gage 36L

400

Strain
()

200

-200

-200

Strain Gage 37L

400

200

-400

10

Strain Gage 35L

400

Load Step

Strain
()

600

400

-400

Load Step

600

Strain
()

200
0

Air, Run 1
Air, Run 2
Water, Run 1
Water, Run 2

Air, Run 1
Air, Run 2
Water, Run 1
Water, Run 2

Strain Gage 33L

400

10

12

Load Step

-400

Load Step

FIGURE D-19. MEASURED AND PREDICTED LONGITUDINAL STRAINS FOR GROUP 6


GAGES IN SKIN MID-BAY OF CVP1 AND CVP2, LOAD CONDITION 1a (Continued)
D-69

Load Cond. 1a
Pressure
Hoop Load
Frame Load
Long. Load
CVP1

Max. Load
10.1 psi
554.6 lb/in
111.9 lb/in
0 lb/in
CVP2 (Multiple Cracks)
Air, Run 1
Air, Run 2
Water, Run 1
Water, Run 2

Air, Run 1
Air, Run 2
Water, Run 1
Water, Run 2

Analysis (CVP1 and CVP2)

1000

1000

Strain Gage 29-45

800

Strain
()

600

Strain
()

400

600
400

200

200

-200

Strain Gage 30-45

800

10

-200

12

Load Step

1000

Strain Gage 31-45

10

12

Strain
()

400

600
400

200

200

Strain Gage 32-45

800

600

-200

1000

800

Strain
()

Load Step

10

12

Load Step

-200

10

12

Load Step

FIGURE D-20. MEASURED AND PREDICTED 45 STRAINS FOR GROUP 7 GAGES IN


SKIN MID-BAY OF CVP1 AND CVP2, LOAD CONDITION 1a
D-70

Load Cond. 1a
Pressure
Hoop Load
Frame Load
Long. Load
CVP1

Max. Load
10.1 psi
554.6 lb/in
111.9 lb/in
0 lb/in

1000

600

Strain
()

CVP2 (Multiple Cracks)


Air, Run 1
Air, Run 2
Water, Run 1
Water, Run 2

Air, Run 1
Air, Run 2
Water, Run 1
Water, Run 2

400
200
0
-200

Analysis (CVP1 and CVP2)

600

10

12

10

12

600

Strain
()

400

400

200

200

10

-200

12

Load Step

1000

1000

Strain Gage 36-45

800

Strain
()

400

600
400

200

200

Strain Gage 37-45

800

600

-200

Strain Gage 35-45

800

Load Step

Strain
()

1000

Strain Gage 34-45

800

-200

Load Step

1000

Strain
()

Strain Gage 33-45

800

10

12

Load Step

-200

10

12

Load Step

FIGURE D-20. MEASURED AND PREDICTED 45 STRAINS FOR GROUP 7 GAGES IN


SKIN MID-BAY OF CVP1 AND CVP2, LOAD CONDITION 1a (Continued)

D-71

Load Cond. 1b
Pressure
Hoop Load
Frame Load
Long. Load
CVP1

Max. Load
0 psi
0 lb/in
0 lb/in
333.3 lb/in

600

Strain Gage 02
400

Strain
()

CVP2 (Multiple Cracks)

200
0

Air, Run 1
Air, Run 2
Water, Run 1
Water, Run 2

Air, Run 1
Air, Run 2
Water, Run 1
Water, Run 2

-200
-400

Analysis (CVP1 and CVP2)

Strain Gage 04
Strain
()

200

12

200

-200

-200

10

-400

12

10

12

Load Step

600

600

Strain Gage 10

Strain Gage 08
400

400

Strain
()

200

200

-200

-200

-400

10

Strain Gage 06

400

Load Step

Strain
()

600

400

-400

Load Step

600

Strain
()

10

12

Load Step

-400

10

Load Step

FIGURE D-21. MEASURED AND PREDICTED STRAINS FOR GROUP 1 GAGES IN


FRAME OUTER CAPS OF CVP1 AND CVP2, LOAD CONDITION 1b
D-72

12

Load Cond. 1b
Pressure
Hoop Load
Frame Load
Long. Load
CVP1

Max. Load
0 psi
0 lb/in
0 lb/in
333.3 lb/in

600

Strain Gage 12
400

CVP2 (Multiple Cracks)

Strain
()

Air, Run 1
Air, Run 2
Water, Run 1
Water, Run 2

Air, Run 1
Air, Run 2
Water, Run 1
Water, Run 2

200
0
-200

Analysis (CVP1 and CVP2)

-400

10

12

Load Step

600

600

Strain Gage 14
400

Strain
()

Strain
()

200

200

-200

-200

-400

Strain Gage 16

400

10

-400

12

Load Step

10

12

10

12

Strain Gage 20

Strain Gage 18
400

400

Strain
()

200

200

-200

-200

-400

600

600

Strain
()

Load Step

10

12

-400

Load Step

Load Step

FIGURE D-21. MEASURED AND PREDICTED STRAINS FOR GROUP 1 GAGES IN


FRAME OUTER CAPS OF CVP1 AND CVP2, LOAD CONDITION 1b (Continued)
D-73

Load Cond. 1b
Pressure
Hoop Load
Frame Load
Long. Load
CVP1

Max. Load
0 psi
0 lb/in
0 lb/in
333.3 lb/in

600

Strain Gage 01
400

Strain
()

CVP2 (Multiple Cracks)

Air, Run 1
Air, Run 2
Water, Run 1
Water, Run 2

Air, Run 1
Air, Run 2
Water, Run 1
Water, Run 2

200

-200
-400

Analysis (CVP1 and CVP2)

10

12

Load Step

600
600

Strain Gage 05
Strain Gage 03

400

Strain
()

400

Strain
()

200

200
0

0
-200
-200
-400
-400

10

12

Load Step

600

10

12

10

12

Strain Gage 09

Strain Gage 07

400

Strain
()

200

200

-200

-200

-400

600

400

Strain
()

Load Step

10

12

Load Step

-400

Load Step

FIGURE D-22. MEASURED AND PREDICTED STRAINS FOR GROUP 2 GAGES IN


FRAME INNER CAPS OF CVP1 AND CVP2, LOAD CONDITION 1b
D-74

Load Cond. 1b
Pressure
Hoop Load
Frame Load
Long. Load
CVP1

Max. Load
0 psi
0 lb/in
0 lb/in
333.3 lb/in

600

Strain Gage 11
400

CVP2 (Multiple Cracks)

Strain
()

Air, Run 1
Air, Run 2
Water, Run 1
Water, Run 2

Air, Run 1
Air, Run 2
Water, Run 1
Water, Run 2

200
0
-200

Analysis (CVP1 and CVP2)

-400

10

12

Load Step

600

600

Strain Gage 13

Strain Gage 15
400

400

Strain
()

Strain
()

200

200

-200

-200

-400

10

-400

12

600

Strain Gage 17

10

12

10

12

Strain Gage 19
400

Strain
()

200

200

-200

-200

-400

600

400

Strain
()

Load Step

Load Step

10

12

Load Step

-400

Load Step

FIGURE D-22. MEASURED AND PREDICTED STRAINS FOR GROUP 2 GAGES IN


FRAME INNER CAPS OF CVP1 AND CVP2, LOAD CONDITION 1b (Continued)
D-75

Load Cond. 1b
Pressure
Hoop Load
Frame Load
Long. Load
CVP1

Max. Load
0 psi
0 lb/in
0 lb/in
333.3 lb/in
CVP2 (Multiple Cracks)
Air, Run 1
Air, Run 2
Water, Run 1
Water, Run 2

Air, Run 1
Air, Run 2
Water, Run 1
Water, Run 2

Analysis (CVP1 and CVP2)

800

800

Strain Gage 22

Strain Gage 24

600

Strain
()

600

Strain
()

400

400

200

200

-200

10

-200

12

Load Step

10

12

10

12

Strain Gage 28

Strain Gage 26
600

600

Strain
()

400

400

200

200

-200

800

800

Strain
()

Load Step

10

12

-200

Load Step

Load Step

FIGURE D-23. MEASURED AND PREDICTED STRAINS FOR GROUP 3 GAGES IN


STRINGER HATS OF CVP1 AND CVP2, LOAD CONDITION 1b
D-76

Load Cond. 1b
Pressure
Hoop Load
Frame Load
Long. Load
CVP1

Max. Load
0 psi
0 lb/in
0 lb/in
333.3 lb/in
CVP2 (Multiple Cracks)
Air, Run 1
Air, Run 2
Water, Run 1
Water, Run 2

Air, Run 1
Air, Run 2
Water, Run 1
Water, Run 2

Analysis (CVP1 and CVP2)

800

800

Strain Gage 21

Strain Gage 23

600

Strain
()

600

Strain
()

400

400

200

200

-200

10

-200

12

Load Step

10

12

Strain Gage 27

Strain Gage 25
600

600

Strain
()

400

400

200

200

-200

800

800

Strain
()

Load Step

10

12

-200

10

Load Step

Load Step

FIGURE D-24. MEASURED AND PREDICTED STRAINS FOR GROUP 4 GAGES IN


STRINGER FLANGES OF CVP1 AND CVP2, LOAD CONDITION 1b
D-77

12

Load Cond. 1b
Pressure
Hoop Load
Frame Load
Long. Load
CVP1

Max. Load
0 psi
0 lb/in
0 lb/in
333.3 lb/in
CVP2 (Multiple Cracks)
Air, Run 1
Air, Run 2
Water, Run 1
Water, Run 2

Air, Run 1
Air, Run 2
Water, Run 1
Water, Run 2

Analysis (CVP1 and CVP2)

600

600

Strain Gage 29T

Strain Gage 30T

400

Strain
()

400

Strain
()

200

200

-200

-200

-400

10

-400

12

Load Step

600

10

12

10

12

Strain Gage 32T

400

400

Strain
()

200

200

-200

-200

-400

600

Strain Gage 31T


Strain
()

Load Step

10

12

Load Step

-400

Load Step

FIGURE D-25. MEASURED AND PREDICTED HOOP STRAINS FOR GROUP 5


GAGES IN SKIN MID-BAY OF CVP1 AND CVP2, LOAD CONDITION 1b
D-78

Load Cond. 1b
Pressure
Hoop Load
Frame Load
Long. Load
CVP1

Max. Load
0 psi
0 lb/in
0 lb/in
333.3 lb/in

600

Strain Gage 33T


400

Strain
()

CVP2 (Multiple Cracks)

200
0

Air, Run 1
Air, Run 2
Water, Run 1
Water, Run 2

Air, Run 1
Air, Run 2
Water, Run 1
Water, Run 2

-200
-400

Analysis (CVP1 and CVP2)

10

12

600

Strain Gage 34T

Strain Gage 35T

400

400

Strain
()

200

200

-200

-200

-400

Load Step

600

Strain
()

10

-400

12

Load Step

10

12

Load Step

600
600

Strain Gage 37T

Strain Gage 36T

400

400

Strain
()

Strain
()

200

200
0

0
-200
-200
-400
-400

10

12

Load Step

10

Load Step

FIGURE D-25. MEASURED AND PREDICTED HOOP STRAINS FOR GROUP 5


GAGES IN SKIN MID-BAY OF CVP1 AND CVP2, LOAD CONDITION 1b (Continued)
D-79

12

Load Cond. 1b
Pressure
Hoop Load
Frame Load
Long. Load
CVP1

Max. Load
0 psi
0 lb/in
0 lb/in
333.3 lb/in
CVP2 (Multiple Cracks)
Air, Run 1
Air, Run 2
Water, Run 1
Water, Run 2

Air, Run 1
Air, Run 2
Water, Run 1
Water, Run 2

Analysis (CVP1 and CVP2)

800

800

Strain Gage 30L

Strain Gage 29L


600

600

Strain
()

Strain
()

400

400

200

200

-200

10

-200

12

800
600

10

12

10

12

Strain Gage 32L

600

Strain
()

400

400

200

200

-200

800

Strain Gage 31L


Strain
()

Load Step

Load Step

10

12

Load Step

-200

Load Step

FIGURE D-26. MEASURED AND PREDICTED LONGITUDINAL STRAINS FOR


GROUP 6 GAGES IN SKIN MID-BAY OF CVP1 AND CVP2, LOAD CONDITION 1b
D-80

Load Cond. 1b
Pressure
Hoop Load
Frame Load
Long. Load
CVP1

Max. Load
0 psi
0 lb/in
0 lb/in
333.3 lb/in

800

Strain Gage 33L


600

Strain
()

CVP2 (Multiple Cracks)

200

Air, Run 1
Air, Run 2
Water, Run 1
Water, Run 2

Air, Run 1
Air, Run 2
Water, Run 1
Water, Run 2

400

0
-200

Analysis (CVP1 and CVP2)

12

Strain Gage 35L

600

600

Strain
()

400

400

200

200

-200

10

-200

12

10

12

10

12

Load Step

Load Step

800

800

Strain Gage 37L

Strain Gage 36L


600

600

Strain
()

400

400

200

200

-200

10

800

Strain Gage 34L

Strain
()

Load Step

800

Strain
()

10

12

Load Step

-200

Load Step

FIGURE D-26. MEASURED AND PREDICTED LONGITUDINAL STRAINS FOR GROUP


6 GAGES IN SKIN MID-BAY OF CVP1 AND CVP2, LOAD CONDITION 1b (Continued)
D-81

Load Cond. 1b
Pressure
Hoop Load
Frame Load
Long. Load
CVP1

Max. Load
0 psi
0 lb/in
0 lb/in
333.3 lb/in
CVP2 (Multiple Cracks)
Air, Run 1
Air, Run 2
Water, Run 1
Water, Run 2

Air, Run 1
Air, Run 2
Water, Run 1
Water, Run 2

Analysis (CVP1 and CVP2)

800

800

Strain Gage 30-45

Strain Gage 29-45


600

Strain
()

600

Strain
()

400

400

200

200

-200

10

-200

12

Load Step

800

Strain Gage 31-45

10

12

10

12

Strain Gage 32-45


600

Strain
()

400

400

200

200

-200

800

600

Strain
()

Load Step

10

12

Load Step

-200

Load Step

FIGURE D-27. MEASURED AND PREDICTED 45 STRAINS FOR GROUP 7 GAGES IN


SKIN MID-BAY OF CVP1 AND CVP2, LOAD CONDITION 1b
D-82

Load Cond. 1b
Pressure
Hoop Load
Frame Load
Long. Load
CVP1

Max. Load
0 psi
0 lb/in
0 lb/in
333.3 lb/in

800

Strain Gage 33-45


600

Strain
()

CVP2 (Multiple Cracks)

200

Air, Run 1
Air, Run 2
Water, Run 1
Water, Run 2

Air, Run 1
Air, Run 2
Water, Run 1
Water, Run 2

400

0
-200

Analysis (CVP1 and CVP2)

Strain Gage 34-45


Strain
()

400

10

12

10

12

10

12

400

200

200

10

-200

12

Load Step

800

800

Strain Gage 36-45

Strain Gage 37-45

600

600

Strain
()

400

400

200

200

-200

Strain Gage 35-45

600

Load Step

Strain
()

800

600

-200

Load Step

800

Strain
()

10

12

Load Step

-200

Load Step

FIGURE D-27. MEASURED AND PREDICTED 45 STRAINS FOR GROUP 7 GAGES IN


SKIN MID-BAY OF CVP1 AND CVP2, LOAD CONDITION 1b (Continued)
D-83

Load Cond. 1c
Pressure
Hoop Load
Frame Load
Long. Load

Max. Load
10.1 psi
554.6 lb/in
111.9 lb/in
333.3 lb/in

CVP1

1200

800

Strain
()

CVP2 (Multiple Cracks)

600
400

Air, Run 1
Air, Run 2
Water, Run 1
Water, Run 2

Air, Run 1
Air, Run 2
Water, Run 1
Water, Run 2

200
0
-200

Analysis (CVP1 and CVP2)

1200

1200

10

12

800

Strain
()

600

600

400

400

200

200

-200

Strain Gage 06

1000

800

Strain
()

Load Step

Strain Gage 04

1000

Strain Gage 02

1000

10

-200

12

Load Step

1200

1200

Strain Gage 08

1000

10

12

10

12

Strain Gage 10

1000
800

800

Strain
()

600

Strain ()

600

400

400

200

200

-200

Load Step

-200
0

10

12

Load Step

Load Step

FIGURE D-28. MEASURED AND PREDICTED STRAINS FOR GROUP 1 GAGES IN


FRAME OUTER CAPS OF CVP1 AND CVP2, LOAD CONDITION 1c
D-84

Load Cond. 1c
Pressure
Hoop Load
Frame Load
Long. Load

Max. Load
10.1 psi
554.6 lb/in
111.9 lb/in
333.3 lb/in

CVP1

1200

800

Strain
()

CVP2 (Multiple Cracks)

200
0
-200

Analysis (CVP1 and CVP2)

1200

12

600

400

400

200

200

0
0

1200

10

-200

12

10

12

10

12

Load Step

1200

Strain Gage 18

1000

Strain Gage 20

1000

800

800

Strain
()

600

600

400

400

200

200

-200

10

800

Strain
()

Load Step

Strain
()

Strain Gage 16

1000

600

-200

1200

800

Strain
()

Load Step

Strain Gage 14

1000

600
400

Air, Run 1
Air, Run 2
Water, Run 1
Water, Run 2

Air, Run 1
Air, Run 2
Water, Run 1
Water, Run 2

Strain Gage 12

1000

10

12

Load Step

-200

Load Step

FIGURE D-28. MEASURED AND PREDICTED STRAINS FOR GROUP 1 GAGES IN


FRAME OUTER CAPS OF CVP1 AND CVP2, LOAD CONDITION 1c (Continued)
D-85

Load Cond. 1c
Pressure
Hoop Load
Frame Load
Long. Load

Max. Load
10.1 psi
554.6 lb/in
111.9 lb/in
333.3 lb/in

CVP1

1200

800

Strain
()

CVP2 (Multiple Cracks)

600
400

Air, Run 1
Air, Run 2
Water, Run 1
Water, Run 2

Air, Run 1
Air, Run 2
Water, Run 1
Water, Run 2

Strain Gage 01

1000

200
0
-200

Analysis (CVP1 and CVP2)

10

12

Load Step

1200

Strain Gage 05

1200

Strain Gage 03

1000

1000
800

800

Strain
()

Strain
()

600

600
400

400
200
200
0
0
-200
-200

10

12

Load Step

1200

1200

Strain Gage 07

1000

10

12

10

12

800

Strain
()

600

600

400

400

200

200

-200

Strain Gage 09

1000

800

Strain
()

Load Step

10

12

Load Step

-200

Load Step

FIGURE D-29. MEASURED AND PREDICTED STRAINS FOR GROUP 2 GAGES IN


FRAME INNER CAPS OF CVP1 AND CVP2, LOAD CONDITION 1c
D-86

Load Cond. 1c
Pressure
Hoop Load
Frame Load
Long. Load

Max. Load
10.1 psi
554.6 lb/in
111.9 lb/in
333.3 lb/in

CVP1

1200

800

Strain
()

CVP2 (Multiple Cracks)

600
400

Air, Run 1
Air, Run 2
Water, Run 1
Water, Run 2

Air, Run 1
Air, Run 2
Water, Run 1
Water, Run 2

200
0
-200

Analysis (CVP1 and CVP2)

1200

1200

400

400

200

200

0
0

10

10

12

-200

12

1200

Strain Gage 17

1000

10

12

10

12

Load Step

1200

Strain Gage 19

1000

800

800

Strain
()

600

600

400

400

200

200

-200

600

Load Step

Strain
()

800

Strain
()

600

-200

Strain Gage 15

1000

800

Strain
()

Load Step

Strain Gage 13

1000

Strain Gage 11

1000

10

12

Load Step

-200

Load Step

FIGURE D-29. MEASURED AND PREDICTED STRAINS FOR GROUP 2 GAGES IN


FRAME INNER CAPS OF CVP1 AND CVP2, LOAD CONDITION 1c (Continued)

D-87

Load Cond. 1c
Pressure
Hoop Load
Frame Load
Long. Load
CVP1

Max. Load
10.1 psi
554.6 lb/in
111.9 lb/in
333.3 lb/in
CVP2 (Multiple Cracks)
Air, Run 1
Air, Run 2
Water, Run 1
Water, Run 2

Air, Run 1
Air, Run 2
Water, Run 1
Water, Run 2

Analysis (CVP1 and CVP2)

800

800

Strain Gage 22

Strain Gage 24

600

Strain
()

600

Strain
()

400

400

200

200

-200

10

-200

12

Load Step

10

12

Strain Gage 28

Strain Gage 26
600

600

Strain
()

400

400

200

200

-200

800

800

Strain
()

Load Step

10

12

-200

10

Load Step

Load Step

FIGURE D-30. MEASURED AND PREDICTED STRAINS FOR GROUP 3 GAGES IN


STRINGER HATS OF CVP1 AND CVP2, LOAD CONDITION 1c
D-88

12

Load Cond. 1c
Pressure
Hoop Load
Frame Load
Long. Load

Max. Load
10.1 psi
554.6 lb/in
111.9 lb/in
333.3 lb/in

CVP1

CVP2 (Multiple Cracks)


Air, Run 1
Air, Run 2
Water, Run 1
Water, Run 2

Air, Run 1
Air, Run 2
Water, Run 1
Water, Run 2

Analysis (CVP1 and CVP2)

800

800

Strain Gage 23

Strain Gage 21
600

600

Strain
()

Strain
()

400

400

200

200

-200

10

-200

12

800
600

10

12

Strain Gage 27

600

Strain
()

400

400

200

200

-200

800

Strain Gage 25
Strain
()

Load Step

Load Step

10

12

Load Step

-200

10

Load Step

FIGURE D-31. MEASURED AND PREDICTED STRAINS FOR GROUP 4 GAGES IN


STRINGER FLANGES OF CVP1 AND CVP2, LOAD CONDITION 1c
D-89

12

Load Cond. 1c
Pressure
Hoop Load
Frame Load
Long. Load

Max. Load
10.1 psi
554.6 lb/in
111.9 lb/in
333.3 lb/in

CVP1

CVP2 (Multiple Cracks)


Air, Run 1
Air, Run 2
Water, Run 1
Water, Run 2

Air, Run 1
Air, Run 2
Water, Run 1
Water, Run 2

Analysis (CVP1 and CVP2)

1000

1000

Strain Gage 29T

800

Strain
()

600

Strain
()

400

600
400

200

200

-200

Strain Gage 30T

800

10

-200

12

Load Step

1000

600

Strain
()

400

10

12

400
200

-200

-200

12

600

200

10

Strain Gage 32T

800

1000

Strain Gage 31T

800

Strain
()

Load Step

10

12

Load Step

Load Step

FIGURE D-32. MEASURED AND PREDICTED HOOP STRAINS FOR GROUP 5


GAGES IN SKIN MID-BAY OF CVP1 AND CVP2, LOAD CONDITION 1c
D-90

Load Cond. 1c
Pressure
Hoop Load
Frame Load
Long. Load

Max. Load
10.1 psi
554.6 lb/in
111.9 lb/in
333.3 lb/in

CVP1

1000

Strain
()

CVP2 (Multiple Cracks)


Air, Run 1
Air, Run 2
Water, Run 1
Water, Run 2

Air, Run 1
Air, Run 2
Water, Run 1
Water, Run 2

600
400
200
0
-200

Analysis (CVP1 and CVP2)

600

Strain
()

400

12

600
400

200

200

10

-200

12

10

12

10

12

Load Step

1000

1000

Strain Gage 36T

800

Strain
()

400

600
400

200

200

Strain Gage 37T

800

600

-200

10

Strain Gage 35T

800

Load Step

Strain
()

1000

Strain Gage 34T

800

-200

Load Step

1000

Strain
()

Strain Gage 33T

800

10

12

Load Step

-200

Load Step

FIGURE D-32. MEASURED AND PREDICTED HOOP STRAINS FOR GROUP 5


GAGES IN SKIN MID-BAY OF CVP1 AND CVP2, LOAD CONDITION 1c (Continued)
D-91

Load Cond. 1c
Pressure
Hoop Load
Frame Load
Long. Load

Max. Load
10.1 psi
554.6 lb/in
111.9 lb/in
333.3 lb/in

CVP1

CVP2 (Multiple Cracks)


Air, Run 1
Air, Run 2
Water, Run 1
Water, Run 2

Air, Run 1
Air, Run 2
Water, Run 1
Water, Run 2

Analysis (CVP1 and CVP2)

1000

1000

Strain Gage 29L

800

Strain
()

600

Strain
()

400

600
400

200

200

-200

Strain Gage 30L

800

10

-200

12

Load Step

1000

1000

Strain Gage 31L

800

Strain
()

Strain
()

400

Strain Gage 32L

400
200

12

600

200

10

800

600

-200

Load Step

10

12

Load Step

-200

10

Load Step

FIGURE D-33. MEASURED AND PREDICTED LONGITUDINAL STRAINS FOR


GROUP 6 GAGES IN SKIN MID-BAY OF CVP1 AND CVP2, LOAD CONDITION 1c
D-92

12

Load Cond. 1c
Pressure
Hoop Load
Frame Load
Long. Load

Max. Load
10.1 psi
554.6 lb/in
111.9 lb/in
333.3 lb/in

CVP1

1000

Strain
()

CVP2 (Multiple Cracks)


Air, Run 1
Air, Run 2
Water, Run 1
Water, Run 2

Air, Run 1
Air, Run 2
Water, Run 1
Water, Run 2

600
400
200
0
-200

Analysis (CVP1 and CVP2)

1000

Strain Gage 34L

800

Strain
()

400

10

-200

12

10

12

10

12

Load Step

1000

1000

Strain Gage 36L

800

Strain
()

400

600
400

200

200

Strain Gage 37L

800

600

-200

Strain Gage 35L

Load Step

Strain
()

400
200

600

200

800

600

-200

Load Step

1000

Strain
()

Strain Gage 33L

800

10

12

Load Step

-200

10

12

Load Step

FIGURE D-33. MEASURED AND PREDICTED LONGITUDINAL STRAINS FOR GROUP


6 GAGES IN SKIN MID-BAY OF CVP1 AND CVP2, LOAD CONDITION 1c (Continued)

D-93

Load Cond. 1c
Pressure
Hoop Load
Frame Load
Long. Load

Max. Load
10.1 psi
554.6 lb/in
111.9 lb/in
333.3 lb/in

CVP1

CVP2 (Multiple Cracks)


Air, Run 1
Air, Run 2
Water, Run 1
Water, Run 2

Air, Run 1
Air, Run 2
Water, Run 1
Water, Run 2

Analysis (CVP1 and CVP2)

1000

1000

Strain Gage 30-45

Strain Gage 29-45


800

Strain
()

800

600

Strain
()

400

600
400

200

200

-200

10

-200

12

Load Step

1000

Strain Gage 31-45

10

12

Strain
()

400

600
400

200

200

Strain Gage 32-45

800

600

-200

1000

800

Strain
()

Load Step

10

12

Load Step

-200

10

12

Load Step

FIGURE D-34. MEASURED AND PREDICTED 45 STRAINS FOR GROUP 7 GAGES IN


SKIN MID-BAY OF CVP1 AND CVP2, LOAD CONDITION 1c
D-94

Load Cond. 1c
Pressure
Hoop Load
Frame Load
Long. Load

Max. Load
10.1 psi
554.6 lb/in
111.9 lb/in
333.3 lb/in

CVP1

1000

600

Strain
()

CVP2 (Multiple Cracks)

400

Air, Run 1
Air, Run 2
Water, Run 1
Water, Run 2

Air, Run 1
Air, Run 2
Water, Run 1
Water, Run 2

Strain Gage 33-45

800

200
0
-200

Analysis (CVP1 and CVP2)

10

12

Load Step

1000
1000

Strain Gage 34-45

Strain Gage 35-45

800

800

Strain
()

Strain
()

600

600
400

400
200
200
0
0
-200
-200

10

12

Load Step

1000

10

12

Strain Gage 37-45


800

600

Strain
()

400

600
400

200

200

-200

1000

Strain Gage 36-45

800

Strain
()

Load Step

10

12

Load Step

-200

10

12

Load Step

FIGURE D-34. MEASURED AND PREDICTED 45 STRAINS FOR GROUP 7 GAGES IN


SKIN MID-BAY OF CVP1 AND CVP2, LOAD CONDITION 1c (Continued)
D-95

CVP3

CVP4 (Multiple Cracks)


Air, Run 1
Air, Run 1
Air, Run 2
Air, Run 2
Water, Run 1
Water, Run 1
Water, Run 2
Water, Run 2
Water, Run 3
Analysis (CVP3 and CVP4)

Max.
8.8
483.2
97.6
0

Load Cond. 1a
Pressur
Hoop Load
Frame
Long. Load
1200

1200

Strain Gage 06

1000
800

Strain
()

800

Strain
()

600

600

400

400

200

200

-200

Strain Gage 09

1000

10

-200

12

Load Step

10

12

Load Step

FIGURE D-35. MEASURED AND PREDICTED STRAINS FOR GROUP 1 GAGES IN


FRAME OUTER CAPS OF CVP3 AND CVP4, LOAD CONDITION 1a

CVP3

CVP4 (Multiple Cracks)


Air, Run 1
Air, Run 1
Air, Run 2
Air, Run 2
Water, Run 1
Water, Run 1
Water, Run 2
Water, Run 2
Water, Run 3
Analysis (CVP3 and CVP4)

Max.
8.8
483.2
97.6
0

Load Cond. 1a
Pressur
Hoop Load
Frame
Long. Load
1200

1200

Strain Gage 01

1000
800

Strain
()

800

Strain
()

600

600

400

400

200

200

-200

Strain Gage 02

1000

10

12

Load Step

-200

10

Load Step

FIGURE D-36. MEASURED AND PREDICTED STRAINS FOR GROUP 2 GAGES IN


FRAME INNER CAPS OF CVP3 AND CVP4, LOAD CONDITION 1a
D-96

12

Load Cond. 1a
Pressure
Hoop Load
Frame Load
Long. Load

Max. Load
8.8
483.2 lb/in
97.6 lb/in
0 lb/in

1200

800

Strain
()

CVP4 (Multiple Cracks)


Air, Run 1
Air, Run 1
Air, Run 2
Air, Run 2
Water, Run 1
Water, Run 1
Water, Run 2
Water, Run 2
Water, Run 3
Analysis (CVP3 and CVP4)
CVP3

1200

200
0
-200

12

10

12

800

Strain
()

600

400

400

200

200

0
0

1200

10

-200

12

Load Step

1200

Strain Gage 07

1000

Strain Gage 08

1000

800

800

Strain
()

600

600

400

400

200

200

-200

10

Strain Gage 05

1000

Load Step

Strain
()

1200

600

-200

Load Step

800

Strain
()

600
400

Strain Gage 04

1000

Strain Gage 03

1000

10

12

Load Step

-200

10

Load Step

FIGURE D-36. MEASURED AND PREDICTED STRAINS FOR GROUP 2 GAGES IN


FRAME INNER CAPS OF CVP3 AND CVP4, LOAD CONDITION 1a (Continued)
D-97

12

Load Cond. 1a
Pressure
Hoop Load
Frame Load
Long. Load

Max. Load
8.8
483.2 lb/in
97.6 lb/in
0 lb/in

600

Strain Gage 12

400

Strain
()

CVP3

CVP4 (Multiple Cracks)


Air, Run 1
Air, Run 1
Air, Run 2
Air, Run 2
Water, Run 1
Water, Run 1
Water, Run 2
Water, Run 2
Water, Run 3
Analysis (CVP3 and CVP4)

200
0
-200
-400
-600

10

12

10

12

600

Strain Gage 14
400

Strain Gage 16

400

200

Strain
()

200
0

-200

-200

-400

-400

-600

Load Step

600

Strain
()

10

-600

12

Load Step

Load Step

600
600

Strain Gage 17

400

Strain
()

Strain Gage 20

400

Strain
()

200

200
0

0
-200
-200
-400
-400
-600
-600

10

12

Load Step

10

Load Step

FIGURE D-37. MEASURED AND PREDICTED STRAINS FOR GROUP 3 GAGES IN


STRINGER HATS OF CVP3 AND CVP4, LOAD CONDITION 1a
D-98

12

Load Cond. 1a
Pressure
Hoop Load
Frame Load
Long. Load

Max. Load
8.8
483.2 lb/in
97.6 lb/in
0 lb/in

600

Strain Gage 21

400

Strain
()

CVP3

CVP4 (Multiple Cracks)


Air, Run 1
Air, Run 1
Air, Run 2
Air, Run 2
Water, Run 1
Water, Run 1
Water, Run 2
Water, Run 2
Water, Run 3
Analysis (CVP3 and CVP4)

200
0
-200
-400
-600

400
200

Strain
()

12

10

12

200
0

-200

-200

-400

-400

10

-600

12

Load Step

600

600

Strain Gage 27

Strain Gage 29

400

400

200

Strain
()

200
0

-200

-200

-400

-400

-600

10

Strain Gage 25

400

Load Step

Strain
()

600

Strain Gage 24

-600

Load Step

600

Strain
()

10

12

Load Step

-600

10

Load Step

FIGURE D-37. MEASURED AND PREDICTED STRAINS FOR GROUP 3 GAGES IN


STRINGER HATS OF CVP3 AND CVP4, LOAD CONDITION 1a (Continued)
D-99

12

CVP3

CVP4 (Multiple Cracks)


Air, Run 1
Air, Run 1
Air, Run 2
Air, Run 2
Water, Run 1
Water, Run 1
Water, Run 2
Water, Run 2
Water, Run 3
Analysis (CVP3 and CVP4)

Max.
8.8
483.2
97.6
0

Load Cond. 1a
Pressur
Hoop Load
Frame
Long. Load

600

600

Strain Gage 10

400

Strain
()

200

Strain
()

200
0

-200

-200

-400

-400

-600

Strain Gage 11

400

10

-600

12

Load Step
600

Strain
()

10

12

10

12

-200

-200

-400

-400

10

-600

12

Load Step

600

600

Strain Gage 18

400

Strain
()

200
0

-200

-200

-400

-400

Strain Gage 19

400

200

-600

12

200

Load Step

Strain
()

10

Strain Gage 15

400

200

-600

600

Strain Gage 13

400

Strain
()

Load Step

10

12

Load Step

-600

Load Step

FIGURE D-38. MEASURED AND PREDICTED STRAINS FOR GROUP 4 GAGES IN


STRINGER FLANGES OF CVP3 AND CVP4, LOAD CONDITION 1a
D-100

CVP3

CVP4 (Multiple Cracks)


Air, Run 1
Air, Run 1
Air, Run 2
Air, Run 2
Water, Run 1
Water, Run 1
Water, Run 2
Water, Run 2
Water, Run 3
Analysis (CVP3 and CVP4)

Max.
8.8
483.2
97.6
0

Load Cond. 1a
Pressur
Hoop Load
Frame
Long. Load

600

600

Strain Gage 22

Strain Gage 23

400

Strain
()

400

200

Strain
()

200
0

-200

-200

-400

-400

-600

10

-600

12

Load Step
600

Strain
()

10

12

10

12

-200

-200

-400

-400

10

-600

12

Load Step

600

600

Strain Gage 30

400

Strain
()

200
0

-200

-200

-400

-400

Strain Gage 31

400

200

-600

12

200

Load Step

Strain
()

10

Strain Gage 28

400

200

-600

600

Strain Gage 26

400

Strain
()

Load Step

10

12

Load Step

-600

Load Step

FIGURE D-38. MEASURED AND PREDICTED STRAINS FOR GROUP 4 GAGES IN


STRINGER FLANGES OF CVP3 AND CVP4, LOAD CONDITION 1a (Continued)
D-101

Load Cond. 1a
Pressure
Hoop Load
Frame Load
Long. Load

Max. Load
8.8
483.2 lb/in
97.6 lb/in
0 lb/in

CVP3

CVP4 (Multiple Cracks)


Air, Run 1
Air, Run 1
Air, Run 2
Air, Run 2
Water, Run 1
Water, Run 1
Water, Run 2
Water, Run 2
Water, Run 3
Analysis (CVP3 and CVP4)

1000

1000

Strain Gage 32T

800

Strain
()

600

Strain
()

400

600
400

200

200

-200

Strain Gage 33T

800

10

-200

12

Load Step

1000

1000

Strain Gage 34T


600

Strain
()

400

12

10

12

Strain Gage 35T

400
200

10

600

200

-200

800

800

Strain
()

Load Step

10

12

Load Step

-200

Load Step

FIGURE D-39. MEASURED AND PREDICTED HOOP STRAINS FOR GROUP 5


GAGES IN SKIN MID-BAY OF CVP3 AND CVP4, LOAD CONDITION 1a
D-102

Load Cond. 1a
Pressure
Hoop Load
Frame Load
Long. Load

Max. Load
8.8
483.2 lb/in
97.6 lb/in
0 lb/in

1000

Strain
()

CVP3

CVP4 (Multiple Cracks)


Air, Run 1
Air, Run 1
Air, Run 2
Air, Run 2
Water, Run 1
Water, Run 1
Water, Run 2
Water, Run 2
Water, Run 3
Analysis (CVP3 and CVP4)

600
400
200
0
-200

12

10

12

Strain Gage 38T

600

Strain
()

400

600
400

200

200

1000

10

-200

12

Load Step

1000

Strain Gage 39T

800

Strain Gage 40T

800

600

Strain
()

400

600
400

200

200

-200

10

800

Load Step

Strain
()

1000

Strain Gage 37T

800

-200

Load Step

1000

Strain
()

Strain Gage 36T

800

10

12

Load Step

-200

10

Load Step

FIGURE D-39. MEASURED AND PREDICTED HOOP STRAINS FOR GROUP 5


GAGES IN SKIN MID-BAY OF CVP3 AND CVP4, LOAD CONDITION 1a (Continued)
D-103

12

Load Cond. 1a
Pressure
Hoop Load
Frame Load
Long. Load

Max. Load
8.8
483.2 lb/in
97.6 lb/in
0 lb/in

CVP3

CVP4 (Multiple Cracks)


Air, Run 1
Air, Run 1
Air, Run 2
Air, Run 2
Water, Run 1
Water, Run 1
Water, Run 2
Water, Run 2
Water, Run 3
Analysis (CVP3 and CVP4)

400

400

Strain Gage 33L

Strain Gage 32L


200

Strain
()

200

Strain
()

-200

-200

-400

-400

-600

10

-600

12

Load Step

400

400

200

12

200

Strain
()

-200

-200

-400

-400

-600

10

Strain Gage 35L

Strain Gage 34L


Strain
()

Load Step

10

12

Load Step

-600

10

Load Step

FIGURE D-40. MEASURED AND PREDICTED LONGITUDINAL STRAINS FOR


GROUP 6 GAGES IN SKIN MID-BAY OF CVP3 AND CVP4, LOAD CONDITION 1a
D-104

12

Load Cond. 1a
Pressure
Hoop Load
Frame Load
Long. Load

Max. Load
8.8
483.2 lb/in
97.6 lb/in
0 lb/in

400

Strain Gage 36L


200

Strain
()

CVP3

CVP4 (Multiple Cracks)


Air, Run 1
Air, Run 1
Air, Run 2
Air, Run 2
Water, Run 1
Water, Run 1
Water, Run 2
Water, Run 2
Water, Run 3
Analysis (CVP3 and CVP4)

400

-200
-400
-600

400

Strain Gage 37L

Strain
()

10

12

10

12

-200

-200

-400

-400

10

-600

12

Load Step

400

400

Strain Gage 40L

Strain Gage 39L


200

200

Strain
()

-200

-200

-400

-400

-600

Strain Gage 38L

Load Step

Strain
()

200

-600

Load Step

200

Strain
()

10

12

Load Step

-600

10

12

Load Step

FIGURE D-40. MEASURED AND PREDICTED LONGITUDINAL STRAINS FOR GROUP


6 GAGES IN SKIN MID-BAY OF CVP3 AND CVP4, LOAD CONDITION 1a (Continued)
D-105

Load Cond. 1a
Pressure
Hoop Load
Frame Load
Long. Load

Max. Load
8.8
483.2 lb/in
97.6 lb/in
0 lb/in

CVP3

CVP4 (Multiple Cracks)


Air, Run 1
Air, Run 1
Air, Run 2
Air, Run 2
Water, Run 1
Water, Run 1
Water, Run 2
Water, Run 2
Water, Run 3
Analysis (CVP3 and CVP4)

800

800

Strain Gage 32-45

Strain Gage 33-45

600

Strain
()

600

Strain
()

400

400

200

200

-200

10

-200

12

Load Step

800

Strain Gage 34-45

12

Strain Gage 35-45


600

Strain
()

400

400

200

200

-200

10

800

600

Strain
()

Load Step

10

12

Load Step

-200

10

Load Step

FIGURE D-41. MEASURED AND PREDICTED 45 STRAINS FOR GROUP 7 GAGES IN


SKIN MID-BAY OF CVP3 AND CVP4, LOAD CONDITION 1a
D-106

12

Load Cond. 1a
Pressure
Hoop Load
Frame Load
Long. Load

Max. Load
8.8
483.2 lb/in
97.6 lb/in
0 lb/in

800

Strain Gage 36-45

600

Strain
()

CVP3

CVP4 (Multiple Cracks)


Air, Run 1
Air, Run 1
Air, Run 2
Air, Run 2
Water, Run 1
Water, Run 1
Water, Run 2
Water, Run 2
Water, Run 3
Analysis (CVP3 and CVP4)

400
200
0
-200

10

12

10

12

800

Strain Gage 38-45

Strain Gage 37-45


600

600

Strain
()

400

400

200

200

-200

Load Step

800

Strain
()

10

-200

12

Load Step

Load Step

800
800

Strain Gage 40-45

Strain Gage 39-45

600

600

Strain
()

Strain
()

400

400
200

200
0
0
-200
-200

10

12

Load Step

10

12

Load Step

FIGURE D-41. MEASURED AND PREDICTED 45 STRAINS FOR GROUP 7 GAGES IN


SKIN MID-BAY OF CVP3 AND CVP4, LOAD CONDITION 1a (Continued)
D-107

CVP3

Load Cond. 1b
Pressure
Hoop Load
Frame Load
Long. Load
1000

CVP4 (Multiple Cracks)


Air, Run 1
Air, Run 1
Air, Run 2
Air, Run 2
Water, Run 1
Water, Run 1
Water, Run 2
Water, Run 2
Water, Run 3
Analysis (CVP3 and CVP4)

Max. Load
0
0 lb/in
0 lb/in
875.7 lb/in

1000

Strain Gage 06

800
600

Strain
()

600

400

Strain
()

200
0

400
200
0

-200

-200

-400

-400

-600

-600

-800

Strain Gage 09

800

10

-800

12

Load Step

10

12

Load Step

FIGURE D-42. MEASURED AND PREDICTED STRAINS FOR GROUP 1 GAGES IN


FRAME OUTER CAPS OF CVP3 AND CVP4, LOAD CONDITION 1b

CVP3

Load Cond. 1b
Pressure
Hoop Load
Frame Load
Long. Load
1000

CVP4 (Multiple Cracks)


Air, Run 1
Air, Run 1
Air, Run 2
Air, Run 2
Water, Run 1
Water, Run 1
Water, Run 2
Water, Run 2
Water, Run 3
Analysis (CVP3 and CVP4)

Max. Load
0
0 lb/in
0 lb/in
875.7 lb/in

1000

Strain Gage 01

800
600

Strain
()

600

400

Strain
()

200
0

400
200
0

-200

-200

-400

-400

-600

-600

-800

Strain Gage 02

800

10

12

Load Step

-800

10

Load Step

FIGURE D-43. MEASURED AND PREDICTED STRAINS FOR GROUP 2 GAGES IN


FRAME INNER CAPS OF CVP3 AND CVP4, LOAD CONDITION 1b
D-108

12

Load Cond. 1b
Pressure
Hoop Load
Frame Load
Long. Load

Max. Load
0
0 lb/in
0 lb/in
875.7 lb/in

1000
600

Strain
()

CVP3

CVP4 (Multiple Cracks)


Air, Run 1
Air, Run 1
Air, Run 2
Air, Run 2
Water, Run 1
Water, Run 1
Water, Run 2
Water, Run 2
Water, Run 3
Analysis (CVP3 and CVP4)

1000

200
0
-400
-600
-800

1000

Strain
()

200
0

10

12

10

12

400
200
0

-200

-200

-400

-400

-600

-600
0

1000

10

-800

12

Load Step

1000

Strain Gage 07

800

Strain Gage 08

800

600

600

400

Strain
()

200
0

400
200
0

-200

-200

-400

-400

-600

-600

-800

600

Load Step

Strain
()

Strain Gage 05

800

400

-800

Load Step

600

Strain
()

400

-200

Strain Gage 04

800

Strain Gage 03

800

10

12

Load Step

-800

10

12

Load Step

FIGURE D-43. MEASURED AND PREDICTED STRAINS FOR GROUP 2 GAGES IN


FRAME INNER CAPS OF CVP3 AND CVP4, LOAD CONDITION 1b (Continued)

D-109

Load Cond. 1b
Pressure
Hoop Load
Frame Load
Long. Load

Max. Load
0
0 lb/in
0 lb/in
875.7 lb/in

1200

800

Strain
()

CVP3

CVP4 (Multiple Cracks)


Air, Run 1
Air, Run 1
Air, Run 2
Air, Run 2
Water, Run 1
Water, Run 1
Water, Run 2
Water, Run 2
Water, Run 3
Analysis (CVP3 and CVP4)

1200

200
0
-200

1200

10

12

10

12

600

400

400

200

200

0
0

1200

10

-200

12

Load Step

1200

Strain Gage 17

1000

Strain Gage 20

1000

800

800

Strain
()

600

600

400

400

200

200

-200

800

Strain
()

Load Step

Strain
()

Strain Gage 16

1000

600

-200

Load Step

800

Strain
()

600
400

Strain Gage 14

1000

Strain Gage 12

1000

10

12

Load Step

-200

10

12

Load Step

FIGURE D-44. MEASURED AND PREDICTED STRAINS FOR GROUP 3 GAGES IN


STRINGER HATS OF CVP3 AND CVP4, LOAD CONDITION 1b
D-110

Load Cond. 1b
Pressure
Hoop Load
Frame Load
Long. Load

Max. Load
0
0 lb/in
0 lb/in
875.7 lb/in

1200

800

Strain
()

CVP3

CVP4 (Multiple Cracks)


Air, Run 1
Air, Run 1
Air, Run 2
Air, Run 2
Water, Run 1
Water, Run 1
Water, Run 2
Water, Run 2
Water, Run 3
Analysis (CVP3 and CVP4)

1200

200
0
-200

12

10

12

800

Strain
()

600

400

400

200

200

0
0

1200

10

-200

12

Load Step

1200

Strain Gage 27

1000

Strain Gage 29

1000

800

800

Strain
()

600

600

400

400

200

200

-200

10

Strain Gage 25

1000

Load Step

Strain
()

1200

600

-200

Load Step

800

Strain
()

600
400

Strain Gage 24

1000

Strain Gage 21

1000

10

12

Load Step

-200

10

Load Step

FIGURE D-44. MEASURED AND PREDICTED STRAINS FOR GROUP 3 GAGES IN


STRINGER HATS OF CVP3 AND CVP4, LOAD CONDITION 1b (Continued)

D-111

12

CVP3

Load Cond. 1b
Pressure
Hoop Load
Frame Load
Long. Load

1200

CVP4 (Multiple Cracks)


Air, Run 1
Air, Run 1
Air, Run 2
Air, Run 2
Water, Run 1
Water, Run 1
Water, Run 2
Water, Run 2
Water, Run 3
Analysis (CVP3 and CVP4)

Max. Load
0
0 lb/in
0 lb/in
875.7 lb/in

1200

Strain Gage 10

1000
800

Strain
()

800

Strain
()

600

600

400

400

200

200

-200

Strain Gage 11

1000

10

-200

12

Load Step
1200

600

10

12

10

12

600

400

400

200

200

0
0

1200

10

-200

12

Load Step
1200

Strain Gage 18

1000

Strain Gage 19

1000

800

800

Strain
()

600

600

400

400

200

200

-200

12

800

Strain
()

Load Step

Strain
()

10

Strain Gage 15

1000

800

-200

1200

Strain Gage 13

1000

Strain
()

Load Step

10

12

Load Step

-200

Load Step

FIGURE D-45. MEASURED AND PREDICTED STRAINS FOR GROUP 4 GAGES IN


STRINGER FLANGES OF CVP3 AND CVP4, LOAD CONDITION 1b
D-112

CVP3

Load Cond. 1b
Pressure
Hoop Load
Frame Load
Long. Load

1200

CVP4 (Multiple Cracks)


Air, Run 1
Air, Run 1
Air, Run 2
Air, Run 2
Water, Run 1
Water, Run 1
Water, Run 2
Water, Run 2
Water, Run 3
Analysis (CVP3 and CVP4)

Max. Load
0
0 lb/in
0 lb/in
875.7 lb/in

1200

Strain Gage 22

1000
800

Strain
()

800

Strain
()

600

600

400

400

200

200

-200

Strain Gage 23

1000

10

-200

12

Load Step
1200

400

400

200

200

0
0

1200

10

-200

12

10

12

10

12

Load Step
1200

Strain Gage 30

1000

Strain Gage 31

1000

800

800

Strain
()

600

600

400

400

200

200

-200

600

Load Step

Strain
()

12

800

Strain
()

600

-200

10

Strain Gage 28

1000

800

Strain
()

1200

Strain Gage 26

1000

Load Step

10

12

Load Step

-200

Load Step

FIGURE D-45. MEASURED AND PREDICTED STRAINS FOR GROUP 4 GAGES IN


STRINGER FLANGES OF CVP3 AND CVP4, LOAD CONDITION 1b (Continued)
D-113

Load Cond. 1b
Pressure
Hoop Load
Frame Load
Long. Load

Max. Load
0
0 lb/in
0 lb/in
875.7 lb/in

CVP3

CVP4 (Multiple Cracks)


Air, Run 1
Air, Run 1
Air, Run 2
Air, Run 2
Water, Run 1
Water, Run 1
Water, Run 2
Water, Run 2
Water, Run 3
Analysis (CVP3 and CVP4)

400

400

Strain Gage 32T

Strain Gage 33T

200

Strain
()

200

Strain
()

-200

0
-200

-400

-400

-600

-600

-800

10

-800

12

Load Step

400

Strain
()

-200

-200
-400

-600

-600

12

-400

10

Strain Gage 35T

200

-800

400

Strain Gage 34T

200

Strain
()

Load Step

10

12

Load Step

-800

10

Load Step

FIGURE D-46. MEASURED AND PREDICTED HOOP STRAINS FOR GROUP 5


GAGES IN SKIN MID-BAY OF CVP3 AND CVP4, LOAD CONDITION 1b
D-114

12

Load Cond. 1b
Pressure
Hoop Load
Frame Load
Long. Load

Max. Load
0
0 lb/in
0 lb/in
875.7 lb/in

400

Strain
()

CVP3

CVP4 (Multiple Cracks)


Air, Run 1
Air, Run 1
Air, Run 2
Air, Run 2
Water, Run 1
Water, Run 1
Water, Run 2
Water, Run 2
Water, Run 3
Analysis (CVP3 and CVP4)

400

0
-200
-400
-600
-800

12

10

12

Strain Gage 38T

Strain
()

-200

0
-200

-400

-400

-600

-600

400

10

-800

12

Load Step

400

Strain Gage 39T

Strain Gage 40T

200

200

Strain
()

-200

0
-200

-400

-400

-600

-600

-800

10

200

Load Step

Strain
()

400

Strain Gage 37T

-800

Load Step

200

Strain
()

Strain Gage 36T

200

10

12

Load Step

-800

10

12

Load Step

FIGURE D-46. MEASURED AND PREDICTED HOOP STRAINS FOR GROUP 5


GAGES IN SKIN MID-BAY OF CVP3 AND CVP4, LOAD CONDITION 1b (Continued)
D-115

Load Cond. 1b
Pressure
Hoop Load
Frame Load
Long. Load

Max. Load
0
0 lb/in
0 lb/in
875.7 lb/in

CVP3

CVP4 (Multiple Cracks)


Air, Run 1
Air, Run 1
Air, Run 2
Air, Run 2
Water, Run 1
Water, Run 1
Water, Run 2
Water, Run 2
Water, Run 3
Analysis (CVP3 and CVP4)

1200

1200

Strain Gage 32L

1000
800

Strain
()

800

Strain
()

600

600

400

400

200

200

-200

Strain Gage 33L

1000

10

-200

12

Load Step

1200

1200

Strain Gage 34L

1000

12

800

Strain
()

600

600

400

400

200

200

-200

10

Strain Gage 35L

1000

800

Strain
()

Load Step

10

12

Load Step

-200

10

Load Step

FIGURE D-47. MEASURED AND PREDICTED LONGITUDINAL STRAINS FOR


GROUP 6 GAGES IN SKIN MID-BAY OF CVP3 AND CVP4, LOAD CONDITION 1b
D-116

12

Load Cond. 1b
Pressure
Hoop Load
Frame Load
Long. Load

Max. Load
0
0 lb/in
0 lb/in
875.7 lb/in

1200

800

Strain
()

CVP3

CVP4 (Multiple Cracks)


Air, Run 1
Air, Run 1
Air, Run 2
Air, Run 2
Water, Run 1
Water, Run 1
Water, Run 2
Water, Run 2
Water, Run 3
Analysis (CVP3 and CVP4)

1200

200
0
-200

1200

10

12

10

12

800

Strain
()

600

400

400

200

200

0
0

10

-200

12

Load Step

1200

Load Step

1200

Strain Gage 39L

1000

800

Strain
()

600

600

400

400

200

200

-200

Strain Gage 40L

1000

800

Strain
()

Strain Gage 38L

1000

600

-200

Load Step

800

Strain
()

600
400

Strain Gage 37L

1000

Strain Gage 36L

1000

10

12

Load Step

-200

10

12

Load Step

FIGURE D-47. MEASURED AND PREDICTED LONGITUDINAL STRAINS FOR GROUP 6


GAGES IN SKIN MID-BAY OF CVP3 AND CVP4, LOAD CONDITION 1b (Continued)
D-117

Load Cond. 1b
Pressure
Hoop Load
Frame Load
Long. Load

Max. Load
0
0 lb/in
0 lb/in
875.7 lb/in

CVP3

CVP4 (Multiple Cracks)


Air, Run 1
Air, Run 1
Air, Run 2
Air, Run 2
Water, Run 1
Water, Run 1
Water, Run 2
Water, Run 2
Water, Run 3
Analysis (CVP3 and CVP4)

800

800

Strain Gage 32-45

600

Strain
()

400

Strain
()

200

400
200

-200

-200

-400

Strain Gage 33-45

600

10

-400

12

Load Step

800

12

Strain Gage 35-45

600

600

400

Strain
()

200

400
200

-200

-200

-400

10

800

Strain Gage 34-45

Strain
()

Load Step

10

12

Load Step

-400

10

12

Load Step

FIGURE D-48. MEASURED AND PREDICTED 45 STRAINS FOR GROUP 7 GAGES IN


SKIN MID-BAY OF CVP3 AND CVP4, LOAD CONDITION 1b
D-118

Load Cond. 1b
Pressure
Hoop Load
Frame Load
Long. Load

Max. Load
0
0 lb/in
0 lb/in
875.7 lb/in

800

Strain Gage 36-45


600

Strain
()

CVP3

CVP4 (Multiple Cracks)


Air, Run 1
Air, Run 1
Air, Run 2
Air, Run 2
Water, Run 1
Water, Run 1
Water, Run 2
Water, Run 2
Water, Run 3
Analysis (CVP3 and CVP4)

400
200
0
-200
-400

800

600
400

Strain
()

200

10

12

10

12

400
200

-200

-200

10

-400

12

Load Step

800

800

Strain Gage 39-45


600

Strain Gage 40-45

600

400

Strain
()

200

400
200

-200

-200

-400

600

Load Step

Strain
()

Strain Gage 38-45

Strain Gage 37-45

-400

Load Step

800

Strain
()

10

12

Load Step

-400

10

12

Load Step

FIGURE D-48. MEASURED AND PREDICTED 45 STRAINS FOR GROUP 7 GAGES IN


SKIN MID-BAY OF CVP3 AND CVP4, LOAD CONDITION 1b (Continued)
D-119

CVP3

Load Cond. 1c
Pressure
Hoop Load
Frame Load
Long. Load
1400

CVP4 (Multiple Cracks)


Air, Run 1
Air, Run 1
Air, Run 2
Air, Run 2
Water, Run 1
Water, Run 1
Water, Run 2
Water, Run 2
Water, Run 3
Analysis (CVP3 and CVP4)

Max. Load
8.8
483.2 lb/in
97.6 lb/in
875.7 lb/in

1400

Strain Gage 06

1200
1000

Strain
()

1000

Strain
()

800
600

800
600

400

400

200

200

-200

Strain Gage 09

1200

10

-200

12

Load Step

10

12

Load Step

FIGURE D-49. MEASURED AND PREDICTED STRAINS FOR GROUP 1 GAGES IN


FRAME OUTER CAPS OF CVP3 AND CVP4, LOAD CONDITION 1c

CVP3

Load Cond. 1c
Pressure
Hoop Load
Frame Load
Long. Load
1400

CVP4 (Multiple Cracks)


Air, Run 1
Air, Run 1
Air, Run 2
Air, Run 2
Water, Run 1
Water, Run 1
Water, Run 2
Water, Run 2
Water, Run 3
Analysis (CVP3 and CVP4)

Max. Load
8.8
483.2 lb/in
97.6 lb/in
875.7 lb/in

1400

Strain Gage 01

1200
1000

Strain
()

1000

Strain
()

800
600

800
600

400

400

200

200

-200

Strain Gage 02

1200

10

12

Load Step

-200

10

Load Step

FIGURE D-50. MEASURED AND PREDICTED STRAINS FOR GROUP 2 GAGES IN


FRAME INNER CAPS OF CVP3 AND CVP4, LOAD CONDITION 1c
D-120

12

Load Cond. 1c
Pressure
Hoop Load
Frame Load
Long. Load

Max. Load
8.8
483.2 lb/in
97.6 lb/in
875.7 lb/in

1400

1000

Strain
()

CVP3

CVP4 (Multiple Cracks)


Air, Run 1
Air, Run 1
Air, Run 2
Air, Run 2
Water, Run 1
Water, Run 1
Water, Run 2
Water, Run 2
Water, Run 3
Analysis (CVP3 and CVP4)

1400

600

200
0
-200

10

12

10

12

1000

Strain
()

600

800
600

400

400

200

200

0
0

10

-200

12

1400

Strain Gage 07

1200

Load Step

1400

Strain Gage 08

1200

1000

1000

Strain
()

800
600

800
600

400

400

200

200

-200

Strain Gage 05

1200

Load Step

Strain
()

1400

800

-200

Load Step

1000

Strain
()

800

400

Strain Gage 04

1200

Strain Gage 03

1200

10

12

Load Step

-200

10

Load Step

FIGURE D-50. MEASURED AND PREDICTED STRAINS FOR GROUP 2 GAGES IN


FRAME INNER CAPS OF CVP3 AND CVP4, LOAD CONDITION 1c (Continued)
D-121

12

Load Cond. 1c
Pressure
Hoop Load
Frame Load
Long. Load

Max. Load
8.8
483.2 lb/in
97.6 lb/in
875.7 lb/in

1200

800

Strain
()

CVP3

CVP4 (Multiple Cracks)


Air, Run 1
Air, Run 1
Air, Run 2
Air, Run 2
Water, Run 1
Water, Run 1
Water, Run 2
Water, Run 2
Water, Run 3
Analysis (CVP3 and CVP4)

1200

200
0
-200

1200

12

10

12

600

400

400

200

200

0
0

1200

10

-200

12

Load Step

1200

Strain Gage 17

1000

Strain Gage 20

1000

800

800

Strain
()

600

600

400

400

200

200

-200

10

800

Strain
()

Load Step

Strain
()

Strain Gage 16

1000

600

-200

Load Step

800

Strain
()

600
400

Strain Gage 14

1000

Strain Gage 12

1000

10

12

Load Step

-200

10

Load Step

FIGURE D-51. MEASURED AND PREDICTED STRAINS FOR GROUP 3 GAGES IN


STRINGER HATS OF CVP3 AND CVP4, LOAD CONDITION 1c
D-122

12

Load Cond. 1c
Pressure
Hoop Load
Frame Load
Long. Load

Max. Load
8.8
483.2 lb/in
97.6 lb/in
875.7 lb/in

1200

800

Strain
()

CVP3

CVP4 (Multiple Cracks)


Air, Run 1
Air, Run 1
Air, Run 2
Air, Run 2
Water, Run 1
Water, Run 1
Water, Run 2
Water, Run 2
Water, Run 3
Analysis (CVP3 and CVP4)

1200

200
0
-200

1200

12

10

12

600

400

400

200

200

0
0

1200

10

-200

12

Load Step

1200

Strain Gage 27

1000

Strain Gage 29

1000

800

800

Strain
()

600

600

400

400

200

200

-200

10

800

Strain
()

Load Step

Strain
()

Strain Gage 25

1000

600

-200

Load Step

800

Strain
()

600
400

Strain Gage 24

1000

Strain Gage 21

1000

10

12

Load Step

-200

10

Load Step

FIGURE D-51. MEASURED AND PREDICTED STRAINS FOR GROUP 3 GAGES IN


STRINGER HATS OF CVP3 AND CVP4, LOAD CONDITION 1c (Continued)
D-123

12

CVP3

Load Cond. 1c
Pressure
Hoop Load
Frame Load
Long. Load

1200

CVP4 (Multiple Cracks)


Air, Run 1
Air, Run 1
Air, Run 2
Air, Run 2
Water, Run 1
Water, Run 1
Water, Run 2
Water, Run 2
Water, Run 3
Analysis (CVP3 and CVP4)

Max. Load
8.8
483.2 lb/in
97.6 lb/in
875.7 lb/in

1200

Strain Gage 10

1000
800

Strain
()

800

Strain
()

600

600

400

400

200

200

-200

Strain Gage 11

1000

10

-200

12

Load Step
1200

400

400

200

200

0
0

1200

10

-200

12

10

12

10

12

1200

Strain Gage 18

1000

800

800

Strain
()

600

400

200

200

0
2

10

12

Load Step

Strain Gage 19

600

400

Load Step

1000

-200

600

Load Step

Strain
()

12

800

Strain
()

600

-200

10

Strain Gage 15

1000

800

Strain
()

1200

Strain Gage 13

1000

Load Step

-200

Load Step

FIGURE D-52. MEASURED AND PREDICTED STRAINS FOR GROUP 4 GAGES IN


STRINGER FLANGES OF CVP3 AND CVP4, LOAD CONDITION 1c
D-124

CVP3

Load Cond. 1c
Pressure
Hoop Load
Frame Load
Long. Load

CVP4 (Multiple Cracks)


Air, Run 1
Air, Run 1
Air, Run 2
Air, Run 2
Water, Run 1
Water, Run 1
Water, Run 2
Water, Run 2
Water, Run 3
Analysis (CVP3 and CVP4)

Max. Load
8.8
483.2 lb/in
97.6 lb/in
875.7 lb/in

1200

1200

Strain Gage 22

1000
800

Strain
()

800

Strain
()

600

600

400

400

200

200

-200

Strain Gage 23

1000

10

-200

12

Load Step
1200

1200

Strain Gage 26

1000

400

400

200

200

0
0

1200

10

-200

12

10

12

10

12

Load Step
1200

Strain Gage 30

1000

Strain Gage 31

1000

800

800

Strain
()

600

600

400

400

200

200

-200

12

600

Load Step

Strain
()

10

800

Strain
()

600

-200

Strain Gage 28

1000

800

Strain
()

Load Step

10

12

Load Step

-200

Load Step

FIGURE D-52. MEASURED AND PREDICTED STRAINS FOR GROUP 4 GAGES IN


STRINGER FLANGES OF CVP3 AND CVP4, LOAD CONDITION 1c (Continued)
D-125

Load Cond. 1c
Pressure
Hoop Load
Frame Load
Long. Load

Max. Load
8.8
483.2 lb/in
97.6 lb/in
875.7 lb/in

CVP3

CVP4 (Multiple Cracks)


Air, Run 1
Air, Run 1
Air, Run 2
Air, Run 2
Water, Run 1
Water, Run 1
Water, Run 2
Water, Run 2
Water, Run 3
Analysis (CVP3 and CVP4)

1000

1000

Strain Gage 32T

800

Strain
()

600

Strain
()

400

600
400

200

200

-200

Strain Gage 33T

800

10

-200

12

Load Step

1000

10

12

Strain Gage 35T


800

600

Strain
()

400

600
400

200

200

-200

1000

Strain Gage 34T

800

Strain
()

Load Step

10

12

Load Step

-200

10

Load Step

FIGURE D-53. MEASURED AND PREDICTED HOOP STRAINS FOR GROUP 5


GAGES IN SKIN MID-BAY OF CVP3 AND CVP4, LOAD CONDITION 1c
D-126

12

Load Cond. 1c
Pressure
Hoop Load
Frame Load
Long. Load

Max. Load
8.8
483.2 lb/in
97.6 lb/in
875.7 lb/in

1000

Strain Gage 36T


800

Strain
()

CVP3

CVP4 (Multiple Cracks)


Air, Run 1
Air, Run 1
Air, Run 2
Air, Run 2
Water, Run 1
Water, Run 1
Water, Run 2
Water, Run 2
Water, Run 3
Analysis (CVP3 and CVP4)

1000

400
200
0
-200

10

12

10

12

Strain Gage 38T


Strain
()

400

600
400

200

200

1000

10

-200

12

Load Step

1000

Strain Gage 39T

Strain Gage 40T

800

800

600

Strain
()

400

600
400

200

200

-200

800

Load Step

Strain
()

1000

Strain Gage 37T

600

-200

Load Step

800

Strain
()

600

10

12

Load Step

-200

10

12

Load Step

FIGURE D-53. MEASURED AND PREDICTED HOOP STRAINS FOR GROUP 5 GAGES
IN SKIN MID-BAY OF CVP3 AND CVP4, LOAD CONDITION 1c (Continued)
D-127

Load Cond. 1c
Pressure
Hoop Load
Frame Load
Long. Load

Max. Load
8.8
483.2 lb/in
97.6 lb/in
875.7 lb/in

CVP3

CVP4 (Multiple Cracks)


Air, Run 1
Air, Run 1
Air, Run 2
Air, Run 2
Water, Run 1
Water, Run 1
Water, Run 2
Water, Run 2
Water, Run 3
Analysis (CVP3 and CVP4)

1200

1200

Strain Gage 32L

1000
800

Strain
()

800

Strain
()

600

600

400

400

200

200

-200

Strain Gage 33L

1000

10

-200

12

Load Step

1200

1200

Strain Gage 34L

1000

10

12

800

Strain
()

600

600

400

400

200

200

-200

Strain Gage 35L

1000

800

Strain
()

Load Step

10

12

Load Step

-200

10

Load Step

FIGURE D-54. MEASURED AND PREDICTED LONGITUDINAL STRAINS FOR


GROUP 6 GAGES IN SKIN MID-BAY OF CVP3 AND CVP4, LOAD CONDITION 1c
D-128

12

Load Cond. 1c
Pressure
Hoop Load
Frame Load
Long. Load

Max. Load
8.8
483.2 lb/in
97.6 lb/in
875.7 lb/in

1200

800

Strain
()

CVP3

CVP4 (Multiple Cracks)


Air, Run 1
Air, Run 1
Air, Run 2
Air, Run 2
Water, Run 1
Water, Run 1
Water, Run 2
Water, Run 2
Water, Run 3
Analysis (CVP3 and CVP4)

1200

200
0
-200

1200

10

12

10

12

800

Strain
()

600

400

400

200

200

0
0

1200

10

-200

12

Load Step

1200

Strain Gage 39L

1000

Strain Gage 40L

1000

800

800

Strain
()

600

600

400

400

200

200

-200

Strain Gage 38L

Load Step

Strain
()

1000

600

-200

Load Step

800

Strain
()

600
400

Strain Gage 37L

1000

Strain Gage 36L

1000

10

12

Load Step

-200

10

12

Load Step

FIGURE D-54. MEASURED AND PREDICTED LONGITUDINAL STRAINS FOR GROUP 6


GAGES IN SKIN MID-BAY OF CVP3 AND CVP4, LOAD CONDITION 1c (Continued)
D-129

Load Cond. 1c
Pressure
Hoop Load
Frame Load
Long. Load

Max. Load
8.8
483.2 lb/in
97.6 lb/in
875.7 lb/in

CVP3

CVP4 (Multiple Cracks)


Air, Run 1
Air, Run 1
Air, Run 2
Air, Run 2
Water, Run 1
Water, Run 1
Water, Run 2
Water, Run 2
Water, Run 3
Analysis (CVP3 and CVP4)

1000

1000

Strain Gage 32-45


800

Strain
()

600

Strain
()

400

600
400

200

200

-200

Strain Gage 33-45

800

10

-200

12

Load Step

1000
800

10

12

10

12

Strain Gage 35-45

800

600

Strain
()

400

600
400

200

200

-200

1000

Strain Gage 34-45


Strain
()

Load Step

10

12

Load Step

-200

Load Step

FIGURE D-55. MEASURED AND PREDICTED 45 STRAINS FOR GROUP 7 GAGES IN


SKIN MID-BAY OF CVP3 AND CVP4, LOAD CONDITION 1c
D-130

Load Cond. 1c
Pressure
Hoop Load
Frame Load
Long. Load

Max. Load
8.8
483.2 lb/in
97.6 lb/in
875.7 lb/in

1000

Strain
()

CVP3

CVP4 (Multiple Cracks)


Air, Run 1
Air, Run 1
Air, Run 2
Air, Run 2
Water, Run 1
Water, Run 1
Water, Run 2
Water, Run 2
Water, Run 3
Analysis (CVP3 and CVP4)

600
400
200
0
-200

10

12

Strain
()

400

10

12

600
400

200

200

Strain Gage 38-45

800

600

10

-200

12

Load Step

Load Step

1000

1000

Strain Gage 40-45

Strain Gage 39-45


800

Strain
()

1000

Strain Gage 37-45

800

-200

Load Step

1000

Strain
()

Strain Gage 36-45

800

800

600

Strain
()

400

600
400

200

200

-200

10

12

Load Step

-200

10

Load Step

FIGURE D-55. MEASURED AND PREDICTED 45 STRAINS FOR GROUP 7 GAGES IN


SKIN MID-BAY OF CVP3 AND CVP4, LOAD CONDITION 1c (Continued)
D-131

12

a = 4.2 in

CVP1

CVP2

a = 7.1 in

CVP1

CVP2

a = 10.1 in

CVP1

CVP2

a = 13.2 in

CVP1

CVP2

FIGURE D-56. FINITE ELEMENT SIMULATIONS OF DEFORMATION PROCESSES AT


CRACK TIPS FOR CVP1 AND CVP2 DISPLACEMENTS SCALED BY 25
D-132

a = 3.8 in

CVP3

CVP4

a = 5.2 in

CVP3

CVP4

a = 8.5 in

CVP3

CVP4

FIGURE D-57. FINITE ELEMENT SIMULATIONS OF DEFORMATION PROCESSES AT


CRACK TIPS FOR CVP3 AND CVP4 DISPLACEMENTS SCALED BY 40

D-133

CVP1
K1

100

80

Stress-Intensity
Factor Range
ksi in

CVP2 (Multiple Cracks)


K1

K2
k1

K2
k1

k2

k2

Initial Crack
Length, ao ~ 3.5 in
F1

60

F2

F3

F4

F5

F6

S7
S6
S5
S4
S3
S2
S1

40

20

10

12

14

Half Crack Length, a (in)


FIGURE D-58. MIXED-MODE STRESS-INTENSITY FACTOR RANGES AS A FUNCTION
OF HALF CRACK LENGTH FOR PANELS CVP1 AND CVP2
CVP3
K1

50

40

Initial Crack
Length, 2ao ~ 7 in

CVP4 (Multiple Cracks)


K1

K2

K2

k1

k1

k2

k2

Stress-Intensity 30
Factor Range
ksi in

1st Intact
Stringer (S3, S5)

20

S1 S2 S3 S4 S5 S6 S7

10

Saw-Cut
Stringer

10

Half Crack Length, a (in)


FIGURE D-59. MIXED-MODE STRESS-INTENSITY FACTOR RANGES AS A FUNCTION
OF HALF CRACK LENGTH FOR PANELS CVP3 AND CVP4

D-134

Initial Crack
Length, ao ~ 3.5 in

Frequency = 0.2 Hz
R = 0.1
Load Cond. 2

Max. Load

Pressure

14

12

10

F1

Hoop Load

554.6 lb/in

Frame Load

111.9 lb/in

Long. Load

333.3 lb/in

F2

F3

F4

F5

F6

S7

10.1 psi

S6
S5
S4
S3
S2
S1

CVP1
Right Crack Length
Left Crack Length
Analysis - KI

Lead Crack
Half Length (in) 6

CVP2 (Multiple Cracks)


Right Crack Length
Left Crack Length
Analysis - KI

64

3000

6000

9000

Number of Cycles

FIGURE D-60. HALF LENGTH OF THE LEAD CRACK AS A FUNCTION OF NUMBER


OF FATIGUE CYCLES FOR PANELS CVP1 AND CVP2
Frequency = 0.2 Hz
R = 0.1
Load Cond. 2
Pressure

10
9

Max. Load
8.8 psi

Hoop Load

483.2 lb/in

Frame Load

97.6 lb/in

Long. Load

875.7 lb/in

Initial Crack
Length, 2ao ~ 7 in

Intact
Stringer (S3, S5)

8
5

Half Crack
Length, a (in)

7
6

CVP3
Right Crack Length
Left Crack Length
Analysis - K1

CVP4 (Multiple Cracks)


Right Crack Length, CVP4
Left Crack Length, CVP4
Analysis - K1

4
3

S1 S2 S3 S4 S5 S6 S7

4000

8000

12000

16000

Number of Cycles

20000

24000

Saw-Cut
Stringer, S4

FIGURE D-61. HALF LENGTH OF THE LEAD CRACK AS A FUNCTION OF NUMBER


OF FATIGUE CYCLES FOR PANELS CVP3 AND CVP4
D-135/D-136

APPENDIX ERAW STRAIN GAGE DATA


SUMMARY.
The strain distribution was measured and predicted at ten equal load increments up to the
maximum values for load sequences 1a through 1c in tables E-1 and E-2 for the longitudinal lap
joint and circumferential butt joint panels, respectively. In general, for each panel, the strain
survey test was repeated twice using water and twice using air to determine the repeatability of
the results and the effect of the pressurizing media. For panel CVP1, load condition 1b was
conducted twice only using water.
The raw data from the strain survey for the strain gages in each panel is provided in the tables of
this appendix. In these tables, for each test condition (1a, 1b, and 1c) and run (Air 1 and 2,
Water 1 and 2), applied loads and strains were measured at each gage at each of the ten equal
load increments up to the maximum loads listed. For the applied loads, the pressure is in units of
psi, the 12 frame load assemblies, frames 1-12, are in units of lbs., the 14 hoop load assemblies,
hoops 1-14, are in units of lbs., and the 8 longitudinal load assembles, long. 1-8, are in units
of lbs. The strains measured at the gages are in units of .
For all tests, the applied loads were within 2% of the prescribed values listed in table E-1 and
E-2. Valid strain readings were obtained from all gages in CVP1, tables E-3 through E-12. For
CVP2, tables E-13 through E-24, bad strain readings were obtained for gages 7 and 26; for
CVP3, tables E-25 through E-36, bad strain readings were obtained for gage 17; and for CVP4,
tables E-37 through E-48, bad strain readings were obtained for gages 7 and 22. These gages
short-circuited due to moisture absorption during panel pressurization using water. Apparently,
the coating of these gages was not sufficient to protect the gages from the environment.
TABLE E-1. LOADING CONDITIONS OF PANELS CVP1 AND CVP2 FOR
THE STRAIN SURVEY
Load
Condition
1a
1b
1c

Pressure (psi)
10.1
0
10.1

Maximum Load
Hoop (lb.)
Frame (lb.)
8874
2089
0
0
8874
2089

Long. (lb.)
0
4667
4667

TABLE E-2. LOADING CONDITIONS OF PANELS CVP3 AND CVP4 FOR


THE STRAIN SURVEY
Load
Condition
1a
1b
1c

Pressure (psi)
8.8
0
8.8

Maximum Load
Hoop (lb.)
Frame (lb.)
7731
1822
0
0
7731
1822

E-1

Long. (lb.)
0
12260
12260

TABLE E-3. CVP1, AIR 1, LOAD CONDITION 1a


Load Step
Pressure
Frame-1
Frame-2
Frame-3
Frame-4
Frame-5
Frame-6
Frame-7
Frame-8
Frame-9
Frame-10
Frame-11
Frame-12
Hoop-1
Hoop-2
Hoop-3
Hoop-4
Hoop-5
Hoop-6
Hoop-7
Hoop-8
Hoop-9
Hoop-10
Hoop-11
Hoop-12
Hoop-13
Hoop-14
Long-1
Long-2
Long-3
Long-4
Long-5
Long-6
Long-7
Long-8
SG1
SG2
SG3
SG4
SG5
SG6
SG7
SG8
SG9
SG10

0.00
0.01
-12.26
-91.70
-12.19
3.53
36.05
-17.20
-80.41
-40.96
27.35
29.97
-54.76
-45.96
17.07
16.59
51.59
-30.01
-16.17
186.80
-50.80
5.81
9.75
-1.13
-39.94
44.86
76.73
-67.07
2.74
-1.46
10.28
-18.09
-48.59
-28.79
85.01
-48.48
-97.46
8.06
-74.91
5.13
-24.99
3.30
-10.16
8.78
-67.58
463.35

1.00
1.00
214.37
202.82
192.44
213.32
208.19
190.24
189.50
206.30
196.53
198.11
225.91
217.10
910.35
900.40
880.40
892.05
764.98
900.23
894.19
871.58
874.63
887.03
899.85
888.31
907.53
902.15
-10.99
108.13
-1.24
-15.56
-1.41
26.49
157.31
17.97
-196.03
50.20
-167.83
57.86
-200.18
47.42
-228.65
54.13
-162.92
1593.65

2.00
2.03
412.52
407.85
554.02
423.92
417.38
427.25
420.62
423.40
415.47
415.30
414.23
444.70
1807.35
1795.26
1769.54
1812.25
1789.06
1792.50
1791.74
1788.78
1773.75
1787.53
1782.06
1786.99
1760.22
1781.56
-7.24
11.79
-14.05
-18.09
-37.15
-28.79
-35.10
32.74
-163.27
102.61
-148.95
110.98
-156.64
104.57
-172.99
112.18
-131.35
6315.49

3.00
3.07
624.79
620.18
617.31
619.33
621.72
625.51
622.67
630.39
627.67
674.01
624.72
636.19
2648.63
2690.11
2655.14
2656.23
2672.99
2681.05
2751.31
2669.17
2663.94
2659.21
2664.45
2646.94
2620.51
2676.07
5.24
-18.32
-19.17
91.79
31.47
130.80
-24.07
-16.49
-141.63
154.27
-132.59
167.55
-118.00
161.70
-122.67
169.69
-123.44
4973.32

4.00
4.04
825.34
862.31
838.88
825.43
822.94
824.26
838.93
837.80
838.42
805.74
830.75
829.80
3547.13
3562.52
3543.94
3535.18
3549.09
3550.62
3542.70
3541.81
3551.96
3543.21
3546.48
3551.01
3547.18
3540.40
-7.24
34.67
7.72
-5.46
-22.86
-13.71
103.39
8.13
-58.45
209.42
-70.34
221.57
-60.28
218.83
-82.85
223.10
-49.41
5092.95

5.00
5.06
1043.59
1058.06
1042.00
1045.79
1041.90
1062.41
1065.95
1059.42
1096.81
1058.43
1064.13
1020.42
4425.91
4443.00
4463.61
4422.28
4446.45
4433.93
4433.30
4466.94
4458.89
4449.68
4431.07
4440.96
4430.07
4457.62
-7.24
-12.30
17.97
141.03
60.06
-26.28
35.98
-18.95
33.52
269.10
13.59
281.21
34.60
283.60
5.49
282.07
38.20
5435.31

E-2

6.00
6.06
1279.62
1278.67
1283.46
1271.89
1249.34
1270.62
1243.55
1266.08
1270.21
1265.17
1269.34
1280.74
5334.58
5312.61
5321.35
5313.26
5315.96
5326.74
5305.84
5273.35
5287.19
5317.73
5309.77
5323.15
5327.44
5337.21
31.47
-15.92
17.97
-7.99
100.11
51.64
206.38
-2.95
149.71
331.11
111.12
341.55
107.30
345.58
85.69
338.95
133.56
5018.59

7.00
7.05
1464.69
1460.01
1455.26
1469.38
1438.50
1442.19
1451.10
1457.91
1454.71
1451.90
1451.56
1455.24
6199.47
6186.68
6192.22
6180.88
6186.28
6164.47
6188.27
6167.92
6173.12
6201.47
6167.55
6197.30
6164.86
6186.37
2.74
3.36
-21.73
-28.19
-52.88
83.04
89.91
-0.49
196.44
386.09
155.38
397.59
154.99
407.30
142.27
395.34
178.20
5784.11

8.00
8.10
1668.99
1676.50
1670.20
1674.07
1659.02
1686.87
1687.53
1673.43
1722.71
1658.89
1672.07
1669.16
7122.46
7105.48
7109.76
7162.43
7122.53
7131.25
7120.48
7130.30
7111.26
7122.69
7122.55
7117.17
7122.17
7133.67
7.74
51.53
1.32
-20.61
-47.16
-23.77
21.28
19.20
313.35
450.04
268.88
461.14
273.87
479.09
258.54
458.45
297.79
6184.11

9.00
9.09
1904.09
1899.61
1891.87
1890.61
1881.05
1890.82
1904.88
1880.21
1894.46
1907.07
1924.81
1875.97
8000.89
7976.40
8000.68
7998.98
7997.11
7995.59
7990.66
8011.49
8004.07
8007.86
8007.58
8000.16
8020.34
8028.97
8.99
-14.71
14.13
17.27
14.31
-23.77
9.02
4.44
378.00
507.16
325.23
519.32
331.33
543.68
321.68
514.64
352.69
6413.93

10.00
10.10
2098.13
2081.36
2079.47
2086.75
2091.29
2091.56
2081.34
2077.11
2071.95
2095.45
2106.88
2110.94
8909.92
8879.50
8876.52
8907.05
8872.58
8892.48
8885.45
8883.68
8889.83
8876.92
8887.33
8896.37
8909.49
8900.31
2.74
-15.91
-34.53
-0.41
128.68
22.73
-27.75
-20.18
474.51
569.76
413.16
580.79
419.17
612.84
405.13
574.49
447.61
5956.13

TABLE E3. CVP1, AIR 1, LOAD CONDITION 1a (Continued)


SG11
SG12
SG13
SG14
SG15
SG16
SG17
SG18
SG19
SG20
SG21
SG22
SG23
SG24
SG25
SG26
SG27
SG28
SG29T
SG29-45
SG29L
SG30T
SG30-45
SG30L
SG31T
SG31-45
SG31L
SG32T
SG32-45
SG32L
SG33T
SG33-45
SG33L
SG34T
SG34-45
SG34L
SG35T
SG35-45
SG35L
SG36T
SG36-45
SG36L

-31.76
35.01
25.69
22.16
-49.75
-119.00
-49.93
281.67
33.65
84.75
8.28
9.53
68.94
-14.68
1574.13
535.12
2140.69
-11.63
14.27
34.88
-64.23
25.05
7.05
6.73
96.38
99.91
105.06
11.22
8.04
-0.18
14.02
3.99
4.95
22.96
41.59
10.68
16.34
18.65
25.72
0.92
20.53
40.14

-212.99
118.25
-181.45
82.11
-79.49
-102.16
-87.94
313.60
-37.52
105.54
-8.47
22.54
71.14
-11.38
1575.20
535.36
602.48
-14.58
132.66
91.00
-61.99
104.94
58.14
17.59
180.95
139.94
100.30
102.06
56.45
1.60
95.61
46.92
9.31
105.52
98.82
13.80
80.77
54.04
31.81
105.31
66.64
25.84

-183.10
202.67
-131.79
151.28
-19.66
-34.43
-51.78
362.02
1.66
147.49
-45.30
12.83
43.47
-26.06
1550.68
522.44
1048.64
-30.03
247.81
147.51
-72.76
194.21
98.79
8.06
252.49
171.37
77.95
206.54
102.70
-18.88
198.46
92.85
-9.63
204.58
144.39
-12.01
174.30
104.84
24.95
212.48
117.07
9.40

-157.01
285.85
-80.02
217.67
-9.21
-1.65
-12.49
412.50
52.24
198.05
-72.91
11.18
24.57
-31.01
1536.36
521.28
136.25
-30.03
352.28
198.86
-82.77
276.47
139.15
3.57
328.97
205.41
66.94
299.06
143.80
-28.54
291.40
131.00
-18.58
290.33
183.18
-22.47
267.28
153.51
26.82
307.70
161.43
2.15

-111.65
370.37
-36.46
278.63
45.04
59.14
26.81
461.18
99.69
249.17
-100.71
8.98
3.30
-37.43
1515.58
516.70
2595.56
-35.18
445.43
243.54
-89.22
355.28
174.66
-3.53
404.60
243.04
53.18
386.10
186.74
-42.15
379.19
174.67
-31.19
368.86
232.43
-26.96
359.82
205.58
22.88
396.54
203.37
-10.77

-38.00
462.65
50.19
342.86
115.08
118.08
72.69
513.33
163.66
305.56
-134.37
5.86
-22.92
-44.40
1490.26
512.93
438.19
-41.06
541.58
290.81
-100.55
438.20
213.10
-12.05
482.66
278.93
38.87
476.72
227.44
-57.21
470.91
213.07
-45.91
453.58
269.03
-44.38
457.40
258.24
20.41
487.47
247.50
-20.34

E-3

26.81
555.11
129.45
403.60
171.89
175.43
124.50
567.26
219.63
357.70
-161.30
8.43
-42.18
-44.96
1471.39
514.73
599.30
-44.75
630.15
327.71
-109.46
516.60
243.22
-18.97
560.09
309.82
30.26
560.25
258.94
-65.57
555.55
250.61
-51.66
529.00
307.15
-47.28
549.59
304.89
21.24
571.88
286.45
-28.28

58.40
647.76
180.52
461.72
205.48
228.72
162.87
619.75
259.36
407.90
-191.49
6.23
-64.56
-51.75
1446.92
509.23
32.79
-52.11
718.00
364.84
-119.89
596.33
277.59
-28.59
644.44
348.69
15.22
646.20
297.86
-81.19
643.90
289.15
-67.95
610.15
339.64
-66.72
644.80
354.40
18.26
658.15
323.40
-41.16

163.63
751.32
298.98
529.33
287.65
288.97
240.18
683.88
339.38
468.41
-223.71
1.83
-92.43
-60.56
1414.91
502.25
397.73
-63.15
808.78
409.07
-131.20
681.18
314.20
-40.00
730.62
385.55
-3.30
737.47
334.05
-100.48
737.01
325.80
-87.08
694.83
375.19
-85.89
745.41
403.91
11.12
747.72
360.39
-55.23

207.51
846.59
360.83
587.53
323.77
340.95
282.02
735.70
386.07
520.58
-250.76
-0.92
-113.33
-67.16
1390.12
498.17
860.63
-69.77
894.71
447.66
-144.45
760.10
348.58
-51.00
816.35
424.02
-18.52
822.42
371.11
-116.42
824.54
361.64
-102.89
773.66
407.83
-101.88
838.20
452.64
8.51
831.17
397.43
-66.40

282.95
947.15
446.16
648.65
395.62
399.13
348.45
795.58
455.73
577.16
-280.92
-3.48
-137.70
-73.94
1361.29
490.41
594.49
-74.91
981.72
481.44
-157.61
842.30
378.32
-63.54
901.70
458.63
-35.21
910.10
405.23
-134.13
914.07
394.67
-119.40
854.35
438.89
-118.33
933.85
498.42
2.79
916.06
433.14
-78.67

TABLE E-4. CVP1, AIR 1, LOAD CONDITION 1c


Load Step
Pressure
Frame-1
Frame-2
Frame-3
Frame-4
Frame-5
Frame-6
Frame-7
Frame-8
Frame-9
Frame-10
Frame-11
Frame-12
Hoop-1
Hoop-2
Hoop-3
Hoop-4
Hoop-5
Hoop-6
Hoop-7
Hoop-8
Hoop-9
Hoop-10
Hoop-11
Hoop-12
Hoop-13
Hoop-14
Long-1
Long-2
Long-3
Long-4
Long-5
Long-6
Long-7
Long-8
SG1
SG2
SG3
SG4
SG5
SG6
SG7
SG8
SG9
SG10

0.00
-0.01
18.69
3.79
68.43
20.71
-24.39
3.17
75.39
40.72
14.13
-24.83
42.04
25.23
5.93
3.70
-47.80
-30.01
49.24
225.90
24.00
-8.98
-101.30
11.56
144.67
35.60
24.82
29.83
-4.75
114.15
-47.34
56.42
55.77
-28.79
2.89
42.58
-99.68
15.39
-61.34
15.57
-14.10
13.55
11.72
20.35
-51.81
5607.23

1.00
1.01
206.26
210.29
215.24
206.92
187.99
205.99
224.55
217.23
207.62
205.60
206.18
224.63
884.18
879.97
885.54
689.28
1302.92
808.79
864.83
915.70
958.10
901.26
940.19
875.07
885.02
886.97
474.68
467.02
471.27
537.56
520.40
467.53
540.91
464.67
-206.33
52.77
-179.62
60.07
-197.29
47.98
-216.25
56.20
-175.44
5679.15

2.00
2.03
411.63
415.63
415.84
416.12
483.76
404.30
416.63
421.14
402.70
409.59
418.80
419.94
1773.92
1778.69
1767.77
1756.48
1779.72
1786.91
1786.26
1781.56
1764.83
1773.21
1771.16
1764.93
1767.81
1796.65
1313.41
1001.53
929.52
928.86
936.23
942.31
947.61
928.41
-167.14
99.88
-196.72
104.03
-182.61
94.33
-183.03
103.22
-184.65
5856.62

3.00
3.03
632.16
627.57
628.11
618.09
642.90
636.25
626.69
615.48
635.16
624.66
637.24
621.19
2657.92
2642.24
2678.22
2672.96
2652.44
2654.97
2649.15
2654.11
2652.76
2649.88
2643.88
2661.50
2664.74
2660.89
1398.85
1398.23
1392.25
1409.21
1405.62
1397.63
1402.76
1387.88
-85.21
151.91
-139.40
155.30
-120.11
146.88
-107.85
155.62
-122.72
5477.32

4.00
4.03
846.95
835.43
826.10
817.75
832.51
826.93
834.79
844.00
835.94
839.49
819.97
816.99
3523.34
3527.89
3546.07
3533.68
3547.57
3541.66
3555.82
3549.56
3537.75
3543.57
3552.38
3521.71
3451.13
3563.11
1876.75
1886.91
1870.89
1869.87
1869.96
1863.52
1879.23
1879.83
5.86
203.95
-60.61
206.94
-33.55
199.44
10.99
208.71
-45.74
5530.16

5.00
5.04
1043.93
1047.94
1042.35
1042.68
1047.41
1054.31
1052.63
1047.84
1034.42
1029.63
1044.35
1046.81
4421.75
4424.15
4415.25
4453.43
4410.50
4418.59
4443.80
4444.75
4431.58
4429.74
4444.00
4433.55
4422.66
4435.25
2577.16
2442.10
2319.08
2330.81
2324.58
2327.18
2353.52
2327.76
110.12
257.79
17.08
258.93
50.12
254.54
111.50
262.51
40.78
5200.09

E-4

6.00
6.06
1256.16
1256.73
1270.38
1269.09
1265.52
1249.19
1253.25
1268.89
1246.87
1259.37
1241.66
1264.53
5316.00
5318.14
5347.97
5333.71
5325.31
5324.88
5327.74
5325.14
5321.78
5310.48
5335.61
5308.32
5320.02
5337.21
2800.92
2803.67
2803.40
2793.29
2800.93
2797.39
2777.84
2801.82
185.96
312.73
90.71
313.65
136.15
312.55
224.44
318.95
113.51
5840.92

7.00
7.08
1469.55
1468.44
1475.53
1458.74
1477.89
1458.80
1466.57
1463.03
1444.27
1450.14
1442.96
1458.67
6209.37
6202.03
6212.36
6207.53
6226.14
6211.66
6219.90
6227.72
6211.97
6223.84
6223.54
6197.92
6224.80
6224.26
3261.99
3268.91
3262.20
3259.65
3265.93
3261.42
3256.18
3251.35
265.34
367.95
143.81
366.64
187.86
370.49
285.28
372.70
173.79
5362.08

8.00
8.07
1683.16
1671.64
1677.49
1665.84
1678.39
1663.57
1651.93
1667.11
1669.13
1673.24
1667.66
1680.09
7103.89
7079.70
7092.01
7086.21
7094.50
7095.86
7105.88
7085.92
7102.16
7093.70
7083.78
7087.52
7085.09
7118.76
3752.01
3723.49
3743.03
3711.10
3738.48
3730.71
3744.53
3719.55
346.33
422.92
202.40
419.75
247.87
429.28
359.80
426.25
233.31
5972.00

9.00
9.09
1883.61
1898.06
1883.48
1892.52
1889.87
1887.62
1881.09
1882.26
1891.31
1867.80
1882.84
1898.79
7984.97
7999.29
7987.28
7994.20
7984.83
8001.97
7989.63
7988.50
7994.17
7985.31
7990.17
7999.36
7982.46
7975.99
4205.21
4189.56
4192.50
4190.98
4198.82
4206.93
4196.76
4198.24
409.00
476.42
247.21
473.04
300.56
488.80
424.62
480.26
282.91
5682.09

10.00
10.10
2085.73
2060.16
2091.13
2089.85
2090.94
2104.79
2093.72
2089.49
2103.70
2099.22
2091.95
2085.33
8865.34
8888.71
8897.82
8892.18
8883.79
8879.43
8883.62
8877.17
8885.25
8870.56
8878.98
8882.43
8895.54
8863.92
4674.65
4655.63
4668.85
4646.87
4664.88
4668.07
4656.35
4656.02
466.31
530.98
287.95
526.10
350.97
548.99
489.94
535.04
324.03
5319.72

TABLE E-4. CVP1, AIR 1, LOAD CONDITION 1c (Continued)


SG11
SG12
SG13
SG14
SG15
SG16
SG17
SG18
SG19
SG20
SG21
SG22
SG23
SG24
SG25
SG26
SG27
SG28
SG29T
SG29-45
SG29L
SG30T
SG30-45
SG30L
SG31T
SG31-45
SG31L
SG32T
SG32-45
SG32L
SG33T
SG33-45
SG33L
SG34T
SG34-45
SG34L
SG35T
SG35-45
SG35L
SG36T
SG36-45
SG36L
SG37T
SG37-45
SG37L

-33.61
62.03
48.23
37.05
-38.54
-110.24
-47.93
285.51
44.52
89.93
11.05
11.55
68.59
-15.05
1586.37
539.68
606.65
-7.95
6.95
22.80
-62.46
19.57
-4.72
6.69
98.79
96.23
104.54
10.31
3.84
-3.34
10.59
-4.77
0.64
23.61
34.46
0.64
6.92
8.30
26.69
-0.37
14.03
42.44
-66.94
35.00
10.83

-217.08
130.24
-169.35
86.34
-83.22
-99.99
-81.71
313.48
-39.55
105.19
14.36
48.93
100.87
18.54
1622.98
571.43
2752.89
20.75
121.71
87.90
-50.02
90.34
69.79
51.37
176.90
158.03
132.60
91.50
72.91
31.20
84.86
61.75
38.08
92.98
111.35
38.38
65.90
61.01
60.28
96.53
70.27
54.72
11.63
65.68
32.01

-217.47
199.02
-131.57
145.75
-60.17
-63.73
-56.19
356.97
13.80
153.58
14.92
75.33
117.39
48.64
1654.98
605.98
335.76
53.87
221.48
144.46
-26.32
160.03
119.88
86.80
239.41
208.71
159.03
174.95
133.78
59.48
169.42
121.63
65.61
171.54
175.66
59.71
141.61
121.49
92.20
185.76
128.55
77.78
81.96
106.84
56.71

-171.35
276.07
-59.78
205.01
0.78
-10.62
-29.38
396.86
58.50
197.15
7.18
94.20
123.98
71.02
1676.15
634.18
1237.13
78.15
316.08
211.38
-2.93
234.62
173.62
110.16
301.91
254.07
176.99
258.41
189.32
78.76
251.34
179.42
89.23
244.88
235.07
82.68
226.50
186.85
117.18
271.83
190.60
96.06
156.81
154.32
83.83

-94.76
352.07
55.29
264.37
52.33
40.65
25.16
447.47
124.72
245.33
4.05
118.39
132.05
99.28
1698.41
664.82
6854.88
106.86
403.38
265.13
22.06
303.93
224.71
137.20
365.08
300.83
199.91
336.66
243.04
101.49
330.66
236.71
112.36
317.41
296.56
104.14
310.90
247.31
143.36
352.80
244.00
116.82
231.36
206.02
110.10

-18.73
433.63
159.62
323.88
125.55
93.20
86.48
501.65
200.67
301.39
4.42
144.95
142.85
128.08
1722.15
697.42
490.36
134.08
487.16
312.94
49.74
372.65
270.69
165.73
433.57
348.29
222.81
413.41
293.45
124.75
409.06
289.49
135.14
388.71
352.66
127.10
396.09
305.96
171.86
432.25
292.75
137.02
303.25
254.54
137.18

E-5

56.19
519.48
274.05
385.02
168.97
146.47
138.79
555.00
271.82
354.87
-2.21
163.99
147.42
150.27
1741.11
722.48
587.15
158.35
571.28
365.22
66.02
444.10
319.31
184.91
505.80
396.29
238.56
491.79
343.85
140.04
488.19
340.55
152.06
460.91
407.28
144.33
482.31
366.61
194.96
510.04
342.76
154.60
376.84
300.59
160.44

97.34
605.40
333.61
441.21
232.06
199.97
186.56
607.78
314.92
403.67
-4.42
188.22
156.07
175.63
1763.35
750.33
924.09
178.25
654.31
416.34
88.36
515.87
367.77
207.58
580.31
447.90
257.13
569.96
395.45
158.67
567.28
394.25
172.09
532.39
463.22
166.64
570.38
429.21
219.67
589.09
392.98
170.49
450.48
348.95
186.23

145.45
693.70
408.55
497.63
278.80
247.77
236.51
658.94
370.10
456.08
-5.34
212.23
165.06
200.58
1784.51
777.67
1095.12
201.80
733.92
464.97
108.64
585.91
413.77
229.21
654.71
497.41
275.47
645.83
446.25
176.31
644.45
444.39
191.08
602.86
515.96
187.19
655.51
488.44
244.15
665.84
439.65
187.26
523.19
401.60
212.12

186.41
783.09
475.70
553.88
326.32
298.86
286.64
713.04
427.12
510.34
-7.00
232.75
172.39
223.34
1803.83
803.72
4536.32
229.77
814.63
513.27
128.68
658.14
461.15
248.82
731.90
549.13
290.70
724.27
499.24
190.42
724.00
494.48
206.77
675.35
569.67
206.31
742.71
548.40
266.77
743.51
486.03
200.60
595.01
448.34
231.67

221.10
872.17
538.91
609.69
362.17
346.07
327.18
763.57
471.41
559.93
-8.84
256.00
181.00
248.09
1824.80
830.06
868.52
248.88
894.16
563.11
150.08
729.20
509.90
270.38
809.02
601.88
307.36
802.26
550.35
206.76
803.46
545.99
223.54
748.08
622.57
225.04
829.36
609.03
289.81
820.73
533.10
215.61
668.51
490.58
255.77

TABLE E-5. CVP1, AIR 2, LOAD CONDITION 1a


Load Step
Pressure
Frame-1
Frame-2
Frame-3
Frame-4
Frame-5
Frame-6
Frame-7
Frame-8
Frame-9
Frame-10
Frame-11
Frame-12
Hoop-1
Hoop-2
Hoop-3
Hoop-4
Hoop-5
Hoop-6
Hoop-7
Hoop-8
Hoop-9
Hoop-10
Hoop-11
Hoop-12
Hoop-13
Hoop-14
Long-1
Long-2
Long-3
Long-4
Long-5
Long-6
Long-7
Long-8
SG1
SG2
SG3
SG4
SG5
SG6
SG7
SG8
SG9
SG10

0.00
0.02
9.50
41.49
-103.78
6.35
-47.39
-7.66
83.17
22.67
-14.55
14.41
-36.24
-25.25
-38.64
27.64
9.00
14.61
58.59
-8.82
36.77
28.00
244.56
4.31
-34.41
-116.36
24.82
-52.16
-3.50
-5.07
20.53
40.00
1.45
-18.74
103.39
-22.64
-182.69
8.80
-104.87
11.17
-77.45
5.68
-46.87
47.19
-106.37
6261.91

1.00
1.02
206.90
205.73
202.15
209.29
185.18
201.52
218.67
202.75
219.12
198.00
215.62
218.73
884.35
874.62
839.58
1109.55
854.68
855.52
894.19
908.40
894.48
894.11
892.28
880.72
870.27
879.61
2.74
-15.91
-19.17
22.32
-65.75
3.88
-25.30
-5.41
-212.18
55.33
-170.24
62.08
-187.93
51.64
-214.39
91.04
-172.30
6259.82

2.00
2.04
420.22
426.06
405.52
416.11
395.76
411.05
437.32
410.83
413.21
442.32
396.79
392.29
1783.21
1789.73
1810.36
1808.53
1802.15
1816.72
1799.03
1788.78
1788.32
1787.53
1979.58
1772.17
1752.81
1796.47
0.25
3.36
-19.17
159.97
-61.46
-26.28
-35.10
16.74
-186.03
105.38
-172.13
114.67
-161.94
106.06
-182.09
144.49
-175.48
7083.16

3.00
3.05
614.65
622.09
620.95
628.15
616.73
610.47
615.01
612.41
598.92
604.37
627.43
612.92
2658.18
2666.44
2671.38
2667.65
2678.87
2677.59
2676.78
2668.91
2665.50
2660.75
2653.11
2683.74
2627.66
2690.71
-3.50
82.83
-6.36
156.17
68.63
20.21
31.08
-5.41
-130.47
158.50
-131.87
166.84
-97.96
161.34
-126.89
197.69
-126.21
6965.77

4.00
4.04
827.89
837.07
837.99
831.43
846.19
847.16
833.54
818.65
824.22
843.41
810.26
822.66
3573.13
3529.38
3554.59
3533.32
3547.22
3537.58
3540.87
3519.27
3529.77
3533.80
3531.36
3521.01
3554.24
3540.04
-2.25
134.63
3.88
-24.40
127.25
78.01
-22.84
1.97
-28.77
215.12
-48.49
222.51
-19.13
218.85
-55.21
252.16
-39.68
7925.05

5.00
5.05
1062.64
1058.15
1076.44
1059.69
1047.18
1064.24
1052.49
1044.25
1076.17
1051.86
1035.72
1088.18
4429.18
4431.51
4431.22
4432.99
4444.14
4442.80
4425.56
4407.76
4429.76
4438.80
4495.68
4440.96
4430.07
4457.62
1.49
-2.67
-2.52
-28.19
197.30
-37.59
72.75
-16.48
41.23
272.45
14.51
280.54
41.10
280.91
24.53
311.85
31.23
9034.62

E-6

6.00
6.06
1251.99
1249.06
1230.19
1240.79
1257.89
1224.70
1237.42
1239.29
1244.79
1253.87
1268.40
1271.11
5341.47
5319.45
5342.11
5318.31
5339.72
5318.76
5310.78
5308.75
5305.62
5330.63
5321.10
5328.97
5318.43
5343.06
2.74
-1.46
-33.25
-28.19
-19.99
162.17
24.95
0.74
112.88
329.65
80.44
338.44
105.05
342.47
90.64
368.50
96.81
7452.39

7.00
7.06
1406.03
1449.49
1472.31
1460.66
1464.28
1469.24
1463.67
1479.07
1467.45
1466.18
1462.18
1474.77
6190.18
6236.40
6224.16
6229.22
6218.04
6199.86
6195.56
6204.91
6156.74
6223.21
6202.62
6212.13
6164.86
6216.18
1.49
-8.69
25.65
109.46
70.07
134.56
-13.04
8.13
188.70
386.19
149.10
395.31
176.47
405.75
165.49
425.12
167.51
8996.29

8.00
8.08
1675.71
1678.03
1675.20
1703.20
1674.38
1671.50
1655.66
1674.28
1664.18
1694.19
1669.63
1675.18
7115.03
7088.91
7113.31
7088.07
7103.84
7097.72
7082.17
7077.10
7089.82
7114.03
7093.44
7108.34
7098.50
7117.34
-4.75
-12.30
-26.85
-18.09
-30.01
85.55
108.29
-12.79
299.76
449.44
246.82
455.96
271.92
473.37
268.04
485.84
272.60
8499.62

9.00
9.08
1869.98
1870.39
1866.47
1868.53
1967.65
1877.60
1864.41
1881.08
1874.38
1873.51
1866.49
1880.30
7988.15
8007.94
7988.44
7980.65
7969.36
7993.99
7992.71
7988.50
7990.53
7978.06
7964.32
7984.53
7982.46
7975.99
2.74
-9.89
-39.65
130.91
-28.57
-32.56
131.56
6.90
378.84
509.51
315.41
515.08
342.19
539.45
336.98
543.07
339.20
8690.10

10.00
10.08
2096.62
2107.60
2083.12
2074.89
2079.42
2093.51
2092.91
2095.56
2087.12
2089.79
2045.54
2079.30
8870.91
8861.09
8851.67
8845.70
8870.71
8858.94
8883.62
8891.08
8867.98
8869.67
8861.48
8859.30
8864.99
8863.04
-3.50
-5.07
-34.53
-7.99
-24.28
-35.07
4.12
-10.33
440.20
566.63
375.08
572.91
403.78
606.07
400.31
601.55
405.49
7681.41

TABLE E-5. CVP1, AIR 2, LOAD CONDITION 1a (Continued)


SG11
SG12
SG13
SG14
SG15
SG16
SG17
SG18
SG19
SG20
SG21
SG22
SG23
SG24
SG25
SG26
SG27
SG28
SG29T
SG29-45
SG29L
SG30T
SG30-45
SG30L
SG31T
SG31-45
SG31L
SG32T
SG32-45
SG32L
SG33T
SG33-45
SG33L
SG34T
SG34-45
SG34L
SG35T
SG35-45
SG35L
SG36T
SG36-45
SG36L

-88.70
46.30
-9.53
30.09
-72.40
-118.48
-61.70
292.07
6.25
83.31
5.52
13.56
69.87
-16.15
1645.24
538.58
1783.29
11.92
3.48
29.16
-69.88
13.72
3.62
4.90
97.46
105.95
105.27
-0.73
16.08
-7.15
0.18
-0.46
1.38
11.92
36.06
6.97
3.11
15.08
21.10
-3.30
21.59
35.20

-204.75
129.86
-167.77
87.06
-85.09
-96.31
-78.03
323.34
-39.91
102.24
-19.52
15.39
60.15
-22.75
1629.81
529.17
1518.60
3.08
128.84
89.31
-73.35
99.65
50.08
7.06
177.11
136.79
91.33
97.03
60.66
-14.16
90.67
39.95
-5.37
100.67
82.29
-9.72
73.17
44.65
20.69
103.48
59.81
13.79

-191.22
208.76
-132.77
152.60
-71.64
-54.40
-40.41
374.20
0.74
144.21
-49.36
8.62
40.54
-31.20
1613.56
523.83
1259.98
-1.33
240.54
147.63
-79.50
184.92
97.39
4.54
250.07
174.02
76.86
196.09
110.94
-27.08
189.97
85.99
-18.13
194.16
131.72
-20.41
162.88
95.32
20.14
206.30
107.01
3.80

-139.58
289.54
-77.09
214.03
-16.73
2.56
7.90
426.66
51.32
194.57
-76.60
11.73
23.47
-31.75
1599.80
524.27
1821.50
0.14
341.89
193.80
-83.70
266.80
133.85
3.57
321.30
208.78
68.78
287.73
154.60
-34.04
281.35
129.82
-24.09
279.40
178.57
-26.60
255.90
147.24
22.29
300.96
154.25
-3.57

-72.54
372.79
-3.66
275.22
41.06
60.80
48.29
474.38
115.52
249.38
-106.43
10.45
1.28
-35.97
1579.38
521.89
1337.98
-7.95
435.41
236.88
-89.78
346.17
167.25
-2.11
393.50
239.13
56.67
374.78
191.14
-45.41
369.33
169.09
-35.60
361.24
216.05
-40.95
348.41
194.37
20.46
389.25
195.05
-13.15

-19.65
462.83
74.98
339.72
98.24
123.23
99.88
529.02
174.18
302.31
-139.74
3.12
-24.76
-46.79
1553.65
514.50
664.08
-16.05
532.73
283.73
-105.97
429.88
203.80
-15.07
475.97
275.68
39.06
465.27
230.59
-63.04
461.29
210.82
-51.56
443.22
258.87
-49.75
447.65
246.37
15.74
479.87
238.07
-26.12

E-7

25.53
553.69
137.15
400.08
143.11
181.29
131.29
577.11
222.21
354.94
-167.92
2.93
-44.93
-51.02
1534.49
512.71
11269.7
-16.79
623.01
323.96
-115.82
510.02
240.01
-22.64
557.39
314.59
27.14
551.63
270.27
-75.37
548.95
249.97
-61.75
523.27
290.88
-63.60
542.49
300.67
14.01
566.38
282.23
-35.61

82.81
646.81
208.97
459.25
195.91
236.00
180.28
630.26
273.47
407.64
-197.34
0.55
-67.84
-57.80
1511.01
509.31
13292.2
-23.41
710.90
363.90
-126.60
589.63
275.20
-31.61
639.18
352.66
13.02
637.46
308.40
-90.34
636.62
288.54
-76.65
603.61
327.06
-80.60
636.98
350.85
11.58
651.06
320.77
-45.96

168.03
745.33
313.15
523.78
275.52
295.17
247.13
691.33
345.97
465.23
-227.74
0.37
-91.51
-61.66
1484.86
506.06
9066.53
-30.77
799.36
401.38
-137.77
671.24
306.15
-41.97
722.11
388.26
-1.47
724.56
344.43
-104.82
725.21
327.01
-89.36
682.43
366.31
-87.48
733.48
400.57
7.37
737.94
359.21
-58.98

219.88
842.76
384.53
584.22
312.59
345.99
292.57
743.62
412.67
526.63
-257.09
-0.73
-114.46
-67.36
1460.83
500.15
8665.02
-39.61
886.37
439.69
-149.67
752.28
341.76
-51.29
807.80
429.47
-15.59
811.48
384.19
-120.39
814.34
366.47
-105.40
762.89
405.75
-101.87
829.15
450.39
4.40
823.17
396.45
-70.00

269.08
940.06
444.87
643.16
365.68
403.65
349.10
801.50
453.47
573.29
-285.79
-6.05
-137.75
-76.90
1432.35
492.21
90.53
-49.17
973.23
479.16
-162.15
834.51
375.41
-64.11
895.37
466.47
-34.67
899.38
420.52
-139.90
904.99
399.93
-124.30
844.80
436.14
-122.36
925.25
497.11
-3.11
908.83
430.57
-85.12

TABLE E-6. CVP1, AIR 2, LOAD CONDITION 1c


Load Step
Pressure
Frame-1
Frame-2
Frame-3
Frame-4
Frame-5
Frame-6
Frame-7
Frame-8
Frame-9
Frame-10
Frame-11
Frame-12
Hoop-1
Hoop-2
Hoop-3
Hoop-4
Hoop-5
Hoop-6
Hoop-7
Hoop-8
Hoop-9
Hoop-10
Hoop-11
Hoop-12
Hoop-13
Hoop-14
Long-1
Long-2
Long-3
Long-4
Long-5
Long-6
Long-7
Long-8
SG1
SG2
SG3
SG4
SG5
SG6
SG7
SG8
SG9
SG10

0.00
0.02
25.65
-77.76
-73.96
-5.06
29.18
13.37
-47.22
-6.07
-54.16
76.92
-12.03
37.53
-47.92
25.80
10.77
3.45
-25.51
4.22
34.95
-38.58
144.46
16.99
-54.71
-51.51
32.24
-29.80
2.74
-1.46
-1.24
58.94
-2.84
139.58
-37.55
6.90
-182.71
11.91
-127.84
14.65
-114.40
6.59
-102.00
49.03
-130.08
8704.65

1.00
1.00
222.10
203.67
210.44
191.75
207.31
235.23
220.03
207.55
222.21
288.90
213.63
225.27
882.41
870.85
873.21
912.41
940.55
874.06
859.44
893.60
885.38
874.17
871.98
882.57
877.69
887.06
474.68
463.41
469.99
522.41
639.06
457.48
451.45
462.21
-170.43
56.81
-167.33
58.79
-186.51
46.16
-191.59
90.60
-172.52
8361.12

2.00
2.02
419.94
437.91
412.11
415.83
447.23
426.10
417.97
419.04
412.76
421.26
421.83
431.65
1770.03
1793.24
1765.82
1760.02
1772.07
1766.25
1780.61
1788.78
1757.37
1774.84
1796.83
1779.58
1797.30
1811.38
947.67
944.94
932.08
925.07
919.08
923.46
935.36
937.03
-132.50
102.44
-163.29
104.03
-152.45
92.68
-133.54
139.49
-158.56
9243.42

3.00
3.02
631.03
643.79
613.27
627.30
640.04
653.85
622.45
631.90
615.13
616.98
602.66
603.08
2650.22
2676.96
2658.43
2655.97
2648.43
2658.43
2678.07
2676.30
2658.22
2662.56
2664.18
2668.91
2664.74
2675.80
1402.04
1403.70
1390.42
1417.48
1399.34
1402.10
1403.43
1384.87
-56.26
154.10
-121.77
153.47
-93.93
143.58
-70.40
190.15
-111.14
9521.40

4.00
4.04
831.25
821.34
827.60
834.79
846.11
836.88
826.41
837.34
844.91
831.11
838.78
829.33
3541.56
3538.59
3543.94
3538.90
3526.67
3541.31
3544.52
3549.21
3541.04
3541.40
3540.95
3528.77
3554.60
3540.40
1875.69
1938.89
1872.36
1873.84
1854.42
1858.68
1863.48
1884.94
29.69
206.37
-59.70
204.05
-34.48
195.45
2.93
241.18
-47.04
10589.9

5.00
5.05
1061.91
1040.03
1029.38
1034.83
1049.90
1044.87
1036.52
1042.07
1035.56
1046.24
1025.13
1032.37
4410.61
4392.85
4406.38
4416.26
4414.24
4424.18
4421.92
4429.51
4416.58
4411.18
4417.71
4455.35
4399.97
4434.81
2328.71
2331.30
2344.69
2310.60
2336.02
2333.46
2343.71
2326.53
138.18
262.06
25.72
258.25
53.84
251.47
102.92
294.67
41.16
9875.42

E-8

6.00
6.05
1248.22
1253.93
1255.60
1262.87
1247.21
1249.87
1261.05
1247.42
1244.29
1234.45
1273.03
1261.98
5334.04
5328.65
5345.66
5312.73
5321.04
5328.07
5318.08
5338.87
5327.99
5323.91
5310.56
5329.50
5341.20
5336.14
2802.86
2787.46
2811.80
2793.99
2800.37
2798.09
2807.92
2808.64
234.58
317.77
106.72
312.46
140.45
308.99
217.18
350.33
124.57
9128.92

7.00
7.08
1462.87
1456.48
1472.31
1464.12
1459.11
1470.89
1472.46
1451.70
1474.65
1462.92
1467.38
1469.78
6215.56
6184.22
6204.02
6241.60
6208.08
6210.41
6224.13
6204.29
6210.73
6215.35
6200.15
6204.10
6216.15
6223.01
3265.09
3250.19
3252.59
3284.26
3263.85
3259.51
3272.69
3280.23
302.14
371.94
159.22
365.14
199.60
366.97
292.02
403.67
184.24
7999.85

8.00
8.07
1665.65
1673.08
1656.60
1669.00
1669.47
1666.68
1674.95
1688.40
1676.74
1675.59
1653.06
1672.07
7088.33
7075.31
7087.76
7094.80
7101.26
7087.70
7088.75
7091.90
7084.36
7085.04
7093.44
7086.10
7091.09
7109.89
3728.42
3741.64
3722.71
3736.50
3735.93
3720.80
3739.73
3730.74
382.43
426.22
228.66
418.10
280.10
426.35
404.11
459.96
255.36
7139.72

9.00
9.10
1862.74
1880.48
1897.01
1871.63
1886.21
1867.04
1877.81
1892.75
1884.49
1883.46
1881.31
1874.74
7977.80
7990.33
7989.24
7985.17
7970.15
7992.92
7978.92
7972.91
7986.09
7991.76
8017.06
7991.15
7974.24
7997.55
4184.41
4198.41
4196.76
4193.92
4200.67
4199.81
4188.60
4220.81
420.14
478.21
247.92
470.61
310.83
485.82
448.93
513.27
277.37
6279.63

10.00
10.08
2095.94
2091.27
2080.73
2089.72
2087.36
2087.77
2066.74
2095.23
2078.04
2106.68
2089.23
2080.69
8858.88
8862.05
8866.76
8874.56
8854.88
8852.47
8869.97
8861.49
8864.34
8869.67
8857.79
8881.54
8872.41
8870.49
4669.19
4676.84
4663.27
4659.03
4665.84
4667.60
4673.04
4666.63
520.60
535.06
326.00
524.68
385.79
545.20
529.17
567.93
360.44
6453.47

TABLE E-6. CVP1, AIR 2, LOAD CONDITION 1c (Continued)


SG11
SG12
SG13
SG14
SG15
SG16
SG17
SG18
SG19
SG20
SG21
SG22
SG23
SG24
SG25
SG26
SG27
SG28
SG29T
SG29-45
SG29L
SG30T
SG30-45
SG30L
SG31T
SG31-45
SG31L
SG32T
SG32-45
SG32L
SG33T
SG33-45
SG33L
SG34T
SG34-45
SG34L
SG35T
SG35-45
SG35L
SG36T
SG36-45
SG36L

-132.43
53.37
-68.26
30.19
-75.67
-113.92
-69.42
294.20
-11.96
81.85
5.71
13.20
69.51
-19.09
1659.39
538.64
1205.65
15.60
1.28
30.63
-72.54
11.70
2.02
3.80
101.55
106.83
103.45
-3.16
16.45
-10.40
-3.90
-10.09
-1.51
4.72
11.96
-8.99
-0.50
10.32
19.27
-3.66
19.39
35.84

-206.26
127.46
-145.36
87.72
-84.65
-100.55
-75.66
320.98
-34.40
100.97
10.31
47.47
97.21
16.33
1696.74
572.40
3138.44
50.93
112.02
84.25
-57.30
83.21
62.19
47.11
166.10
154.24
133.72
79.68
77.49
26.07
74.61
53.54
34.92
85.15
98.89
28.98
55.46
53.73
55.02
87.75
68.67
52.66

-186.24
197.37
-84.06
149.24
-50.14
-62.45
-36.54
367.06
20.42
145.67
9.21
72.40
112.62
45.15
1731.51
604.88
1398.38
78.90
212.14
149.63
-29.75
153.81
117.82
81.85
228.04
207.51
158.11
165.14
142.73
52.19
160.21
116.12
62.08
162.18
167.64
54.85
133.23
117.37
84.37
178.06
127.90
73.29

-140.31
271.71
-20.43
208.99
-2.20
-11.90
0.92
412.27
71.19
194.02
4.23
94.57
121.59
70.10
1758.20
633.63
2640.65
107.59
307.30
210.32
-8.01
226.57
168.62
107.14
291.87
254.07
177.90
247.23
199.19
72.76
242.63
172.67
85.10
235.84
227.88
77.13
217.48
179.24
110.22
264.69
184.60
91.25

-91.66
347.51
52.83
265.61
50.23
39.56
39.30
458.11
126.76
243.35
1.10
120.25
131.34
98.75
1787.99
665.69
3658.38
133.38
394.31
260.97
17.85
295.94
217.93
135.53
356.63
301.99
201.05
325.18
253.33
96.42
321.01
230.11
108.94
307.38
288.46
99.25
302.03
239.48
136.57
345.36
236.76
110.70

-17.08
430.46
159.42
325.82
117.46
95.05
81.17
507.12
205.12
297.04
-3.68
141.68
138.11
123.70
1814.86
695.35
812.85
159.13
479.93
314.65
39.45
367.23
264.42
158.75
425.40
346.53
220.29
403.59
300.64
116.21
399.61
278.81
129.67
379.25
344.57
120.34
387.28
298.50
163.75
424.83
287.85
131.23

E-9

61.16
514.32
272.90
385.69
174.61
147.61
142.32
561.86
267.49
347.25
-5.52
165.33
145.27
149.03
1838.23
723.25
1044.16
184.89
563.77
364.78
59.82
437.28
312.49
181.30
496.19
395.31
238.82
480.94
352.54
134.86
478.07
332.99
149.26
450.78
400.62
139.83
473.62
359.57
187.28
502.87
337.82
148.05

110.18
601.58
352.58
442.81
236.94
200.50
194.62
616.02
336.59
404.37
-9.21
187.28
152.75
172.67
1861.77
749.89
2294.31
209.14
646.55
412.27
79.52
508.87
358.25
202.29
571.22
445.47
256.56
558.91
403.26
151.88
557.33
384.85
168.04
522.62
456.99
161.21
561.58
420.55
212.05
581.89
386.52
164.38

177.04
689.66
457.38
500.93
291.45
252.16
249.91
669.16
396.40
454.98
-11.23
212.59
161.57
199.85
1887.72
779.69
2425.16
233.45
725.50
462.49
104.01
578.59
407.72
226.55
644.12
497.96
276.94
634.65
456.12
171.46
634.55
438.56
187.96
593.05
511.97
182.65
646.77
482.39
237.06
657.97
435.47
181.81

192.45
778.24
502.13
556.02
318.59
299.93
282.94
719.38
434.07
505.14
-10.31
234.20
171.28
223.13
1912.18
805.66
2746.00
253.29
807.23
512.07
123.86
650.76
456.11
247.29
723.95
552.01
292.87
713.57
508.69
187.11
714.94
489.20
204.28
666.43
563.93
201.06
735.03
543.94
261.34
736.66
482.78
196.27

258.58
867.49
586.74
611.95
385.30
350.50
348.33
775.56
504.01
560.36
-12.70
256.95
178.26
247.75
1932.05
831.98
2919.70
277.61
883.82
559.14
146.16
720.32
501.38
268.39
796.27
601.21
309.59
788.96
558.82
203.07
791.45
538.70
221.27
736.10
616.95
222.04
819.05
602.13
283.84
811.29
527.61
211.42

TABLE E-7. CVP1, WATER 1, LOAD CONDITION 1a


Load Step
Pressure
Frame-1
Frame-2
Frame-3
Frame-4
Frame-5
Frame-6
Frame-7
Frame-8
Frame-9
Frame-10
Frame-11
Frame-12
Hoop-1
Hoop-2
Hoop-3
Hoop-4
Hoop-5
Hoop-6
Hoop-7
Hoop-8
Hoop-9
Hoop-10
Hoop-11
Hoop-12
Hoop-13
Hoop-14
Long-1
Long-2
Long-3
Long-4
Long-5
Long-6
Long-7
Long-8
SG1
SG2
SG3
SG4
SG5
SG6
SG7
SG8
SG9
SG10

0.00
0.01
4.33
67.51
199.98
56.33
66.47
-67.06
-208.34
44.65
-27.21
-13.54
-4.43
62.53
37.49
-53.36
156.27
66.65
23.07
371.12
-65.37
-16.38
384.72
-26.50
87.42
-18.15
-19.68
-7.44
-6.00
-31.57
0.04
-26.93
-20.00
6.39
4.12
49.96
205.38
15.02
249.00
8.61
262.42
8.06
342.15
16.60
271.84
3277.73

1.00
1.01
222.62
207.67
207.52
209.51
202.65
196.66
228.89
212.96
243.41
191.00
232.46
209.96
901.16
885.76
882.26
858.67
963.17
872.37
890.63
915.79
890.84
892.29
888.59
886.28
959.27
916.88
-1.00
98.50
-11.49
-43.35
35.76
57.91
-0.78
80.73
38.15
50.44
16.73
51.51
34.36
46.38
71.66
56.71
41.19
28278.1

2.00
1.96
427.83
426.67
406.28
406.47
405.08
411.94
408.67
428.68
413.68
396.46
402.70
444.75
1753.32
1750.89
1756.95
1780.47
1744.04
1727.13
1769.67
1759.02
1742.63
1783.73
1759.73
1771.99
1752.63
1759.03
-2.25
-18.32
-10.20
79.13
8.59
-2.40
-4.46
-7.87
89.83
100.64
56.04
106.08
76.47
100.22
97.45
108.70
78.11
18831.0

3.00
3.03
626.41
635.66
673.87
626.12
642.31
640.79
631.58
632.41
654.05
629.55
628.53
620.90
2696.65
2673.28
2686.82
2659.69
2685.80
2701.27
2670.78
2683.43
2668.87
2669.55
2673.14
2668.65
2679.30
2675.53
-2.25
32.26
-3.80
50.10
34.33
1.36
-5.69
8.13
148.64
158.72
114.26
166.50
112.03
157.90
147.43
167.91
139.10
13092.5

4.00
4.09
820.57
852.35
840.96
849.96
826.80
838.12
837.82
847.02
858.33
856.29
836.29
837.37
3586.12
3580.93
3577.66
3583.51
3586.46
3587.87
3548.17
3571.40
3568.34
3563.15
3566.79
3551.01
3591.68
3577.67
2.74
-13.50
-8.92
-34.51
110.10
-6.17
29.86
0.74
217.92
217.37
178.56
226.58
182.22
218.89
219.59
227.37
203.77
12758.4

5.00
5.04
1013.93
1031.56
1050.22
1040.23
1043.23
1048.52
1041.84
1035.33
1061.86
1029.17
1043.93
1016.95
4425.91
4395.13
4426.34
4429.71
4424.03
4420.90
4449.72
4428.63
4402.96
4424.79
4426.06
4417.40
4399.09
4396.67
-7.24
25.03
73.02
-39.55
-17.14
2.62
5.34
-7.87
307.27
270.58
256.68
280.51
273.62
275.93
316.57
283.75
283.96
35893.0

E-10

6.00
6.04
1271.95
1250.04
1268.97
1262.48
1258.90
1256.33
1265.60
1253.68
1226.18
1244.16
1242.01
1266.53
5326.08
5329.96
5329.16
5338.23
5346.66
5325.68
5333.97
5338.87
5318.89
5345.65
5327.17
5336.91
5348.62
5343.60
0.25
127.40
-11.49
-40.82
-2.84
-1.15
0.44
-7.87
409.92
333.50
351.53
342.10
364.78
342.84
414.55
345.81
383.40
5015.66

7.00
7.09
1454.84
1465.78
1466.01
1456.09
1452.80
1449.35
1471.10
1452.06
1447.14
1468.44
1464.29
1435.56
6214.95
6218.61
6219.46
6250.29
6229.88
6222.83
6221.72
6270.86
6232.57
6244.33
6231.53
6226.33
6216.15
6230.47
2.74
10.58
62.78
-33.24
12.88
6.39
70.29
-0.49
441.25
389.17
378.13
399.76
396.94
405.08
446.41
402.50
414.80
17051.9

8.00
8.06
1670.20
1698.50
1683.45
1675.27
1665.40
1671.20
1672.16
1682.16
1668.64
1660.74
1680.81
1724.59
7108.75
7101.08
7101.95
7091.08
7105.00
7108.90
7100.41
7108.11
7107.62
7115.45
7094.86
7109.76
7099.92
7111.31
0.25
-33.98
5.16
-38.29
-20.00
0.11
-6.91
84.42
531.05
448.52
459.48
458.34
480.52
469.71
527.90
460.92
500.04
24541.3

9.00
9.09
1868.20
1885.99
1873.27
1878.82
1876.15
1869.02
1885.26
1888.15
1865.86
1890.91
1863.26
1870.11
7951.54
7973.51
7969.53
7997.92
7986.70
7998.25
8011.53
7987.70
7976.99
7970.02
7978.29
7998.56
7952.00
7945.38
-13.49
120.19
41.02
-39.56
-14.28
5.13
-3.24
-2.95
611.98
510.76
530.32
520.00
548.25
540.53
593.37
521.91
573.64
24445.3

10.00
10.15
2105.03
2107.51
2096.61
2086.77
2115.47
2120.32
2097.83
2093.59
2107.96
2101.60
2106.00
2117.16
8936.95
8893.41
8928.87
8917.39
8924.11
8951.27
8917.44
8935.47
8938.98
8913.17
8933.48
8903.78
8931.74
8922.67
1.49
74.40
-3.80
-15.56
11.45
10.16
55.58
-7.87
674.89
576.84
590.66
586.58
618.42
617.54
669.62
587.86
636.74
10814.6

TABLE E-7. CVP1, WATER 1, LOAD CONDITION 1a (Continued)


SG11
SG12
SG13
SG14
SG15
SG16
SG17
SG18
SG19
SG20
SG21
SG22
SG23
SG24
SG25
SG26
SG27
SG28
SG29T
SG29-45
SG29L
SG30T
SG30-45
SG30L
SG31T
SG31-45
SG31T
SG32T
SG32-45
SG32L
SG33T
SG33-45
SG33L
SG34T
SG34-45
SG34L
SG35T
SG35-45
SG35L
SG36T
SG36-45
SG36L

258.53
29.06
373.25
26.28
67.49
-100.15
38.00
276.33
166.44
98.19
2.95
6.96
58.87
-10.83
1257.43
546.66
2492.21
-95.54
1.28
11.90
-48.28
24.69
5.64
15.72
70.32
90.18
118.66
6.51
-26.13
13.75
15.17
8.03
15.74
33.42
50.18
17.52
50.33
47.31
44.67
3.48
20.99
40.24

27.21
116.04
111.04
78.99
-5.27
-90.18
-33.08
293.25
75.85
117.62
-17.88
4.04
60.03
-13.96
1250.84
542.56
17296.1
-93.41
117.42
73.73
-49.88
96.09
44.58
23.80
160.45
126.55
108.31
94.33
15.91
15.27
91.22
58.18
18.37
107.52
100.26
13.22
67.79
56.21
51.08
91.67
65.93
42.52

55.49
197.98
134.04
141.40
17.01
-48.36
1.65
340.06
101.40
156.01
-44.76
2.38
39.26
-21.85
1233.46
536.23
1528.36
-98.52
225.76
130.30
-58.51
176.35
88.66
19.99
228.61
157.86
94.31
186.69
61.79
4.22
181.71
100.05
7.39
192.78
147.52
6.65
147.34
100.94
50.65
191.31
110.01
26.96

80.82
285.80
186.15
210.64
77.60
15.02
40.59
396.71
156.57
206.57
-76.61
4.77
16.14
-27.17
1210.76
533.37
2504.10
-99.24
334.45
183.49
-62.71
263.20
131.58
16.77
304.45
191.07
84.38
283.94
107.11
-4.26
278.84
148.53
-1.74
283.08
197.63
-4.04
242.81
152.77
50.59
296.62
159.46
11.18

141.81
373.56
257.99
277.84
126.37
74.18
95.50
454.26
210.66
260.09
-107.37
2.20
-9.17
-34.88
1178.56
524.19
8171.85
-107.33
435.86
233.12
-73.28
347.88
168.47
6.97
382.94
221.06
67.87
377.61
143.48
-19.43
371.24
187.57
-12.66
367.46
236.67
-13.03
341.29
201.01
48.39
392.81
203.34
-0.50

224.12
459.85
350.39
338.20
179.56
125.40
151.66
505.10
272.17
308.93
-137.33
0.18
-31.21
-41.15
1152.55
518.42
3723.29
-117.01
520.54
280.63
-80.90
420.14
205.78
2.02
456.12
257.10
53.98
458.67
181.66
-33.12
452.31
224.67
-20.94
443.57
267.30
-27.54
430.90
246.12
45.14
473.67
240.28
-7.39

E-11

301.92
554.52
445.52
405.39
240.72
187.52
213.92
562.12
337.36
367.07
-162.77
2.38
-52.64
-43.13
1126.26
514.36
5327.91
-113.20
612.21
316.45
-88.91
501.24
237.40
-6.87
537.63
294.96
43.28
545.59
221.66
-44.67
541.26
262.40
-34.23
523.22
302.25
-40.35
525.18
296.09
42.02
562.90
280.26
-20.07

321.70
648.16
479.10
465.39
281.99
240.17
251.48
616.01
377.79
419.29
-193.04
-0.55
-74.49
-52.32
1100.58
508.88
1749.63
-125.76
705.47
364.07
-102.96
583.58
277.24
-15.54
626.31
336.54
28.62
635.09
261.06
-59.22
631.87
302.57
-46.91
604.30
341.15
-51.15
625.22
349.41
39.93
652.37
322.56
-31.18

394.58
741.89
557.26
526.40
334.39
294.12
310.91
672.29
431.66
471.49
-223.32
-2.20
-99.10
-60.05
1072.38
501.32
2985.54
-135.37
789.93
395.97
-116.86
661.53
307.13
-28.16
708.75
372.43
10.64
718.54
296.24
-77.72
717.72
338.10
-64.55
682.25
373.07
-69.11
718.21
397.04
35.36
734.68
358.67
-44.26

448.89
844.30
623.51
588.80
401.22
348.11
372.21
729.17
493.04
527.70
-252.56
-2.20
-122.02
-64.81
1051.18
497.55
3101.10
-138.29
877.67
438.08
-125.36
743.36
343.24
-38.79
797.03
411.25
-7.89
808.25
334.58
-98.15
809.45
372.92
-84.78
764.49
407.43
-86.02
815.11
445.76
31.83
821.22
393.96
-55.67

497.88
953.90
697.59
655.56
441.30
405.81
420.31
785.10
544.30
584.45
-278.22
-1.28
-142.50
-69.37
1030.60
493.08
3837.13
-143.38
973.86
475.08
-145.38
833.14
376.98
-56.64
894.73
454.14
-30.26
905.16
373.34
-123.16
907.65
408.79
-108.82
850.31
443.93
-102.58
917.00
499.62
27.24
912.22
434.97
-69.25

TABLE E-8. CVP1, WATER 1, LOAD CONDITION 1b


Load Step
Pressure
Frame-1
Frame-2
Frame-3
Frame-4
Frame-5
Frame-6
Frame-7
Frame-8
Frame-9
Frame-10
Frame-11
Frame-12
Hoop-1
Hoop-2
Hoop-3
Hoop-4
Hoop-5
Hoop-6
Hoop-7
Hoop-8
Hoop-9
Hoop-10
Hoop-11
Hoop-12
Hoop-13
Hoop-14
Long-1
Long-2
Long-3
Long-4
Long-5
Long-6
Long-7
Long-8
SG1
SG2
SG3
SG4
SG5
SG6
SG7
SG8
SG9
SG10

0.00
0.09
28.98
50.82
193.61
24.14
58.41
6.29
152.40
121.12
160.38
-76.53
75.55
47.76
2.22
-95.71
149.19
142.86
99.69
-3.23
-103.69
20.61
-101.28
-26.50
139.10
59.68
69.31
-14.89
-15.99
50.33
0.04
137.25
15.74
12.67
-2.01
75.82
184.62
16.32
196.62
9.34
196.15
9.89
243.10
13.22
220.75
14978.5

1.00
0.02
10.55
37.32
192.44
138.41
129.64
-118.69
46.10
-38.47
-27.68
85.84
-133.55
87.99
78.34
-64.40
150.93
-28.14
13.73
-49.78
-28.89
20.61
47.98
24.24
-67.64
-105.26
32.24
164.01
454.75
458.63
475.16
374.69
664.86
461.30
283.57
472.10
202.65
13.02
203.29
0.92
211.60
0.00
286.24
6.45
224.12
23165.8

2.00
-0.02
-29.98
8.52
-242.63
82.33
-204.27
33.34
-189.17
32.83
-18.33
-120.07
6.04
81.76
89.50
-79.15
135.00
111.27
-44.20
253.84
-41.67
-8.98
166.29
-4.75
-99.01
-45.94
24.82
74.55
946.61
917.43
941.23
906.31
945.00
921.14
924.51
891.68
240.17
9.72
228.96
-2.93
240.71
-6.96
350.64
2.97
239.68
20950.0

3.00
-0.03
-4.13
-252.12
117.79
80.62
-111.09
-15.86
19.27
-25.69
-37.53
-216.47
-154.67
-89.45
4.07
82.88
76.44
163.33
8.13
-55.39
-74.51
-8.98
78.92
-39.18
179.71
-83.01
-41.92
89.46
1389.97
1406.53
1447.18
1481.06
1392.61
1412.57
1402.62
1402.51
247.45
6.42
218.07
-10.08
235.22
-11.72
361.74
-2.65
243.30
12444.8

4.00
0.00
2.49
-69.89
38.56
70.01
43.92
2.48
-41.32
-15.67
-140.70
7.06
83.52
17.49
28.22
-44.17
-47.80
310.19
8.13
69.42
-36.20
20.61
-39.39
24.24
122.49
-90.42
17.40
-37.25
1869.45
1859.39
1862.12
1854.90
1854.42
1829.78
1847.55
1867.72
225.92
3.48
181.95
-12.46
207.69
-16.68
363.35
-5.22
198.91
22631.7

5.00
0.03
-0.41
26.28
-10.70
48.15
137.64
62.36
74.76
-47.71
-173.08
59.38
46.85
121.96
20.79
-27.60
88.86
100.12
-59.15
235.21
-7.01
72.39
291.89
0.68
-65.78
-64.48
-4.84
104.36
2315.21
2312.26
2320.59
2272.94
2330.54
2322.38
2332.92
2348.92
201.51
1.47
138.20
-15.94
180.55
-21.62
380.17
-9.15
158.64
16631.6

E-12

6.00
0.03
-5.36
2.17
137.11
50.09
41.24
-56.30
90.44
-25.15
-73.47
-55.81
150.24
84.09
-33.07
57.10
32.07
-28.15
-23.64
171.87
76.91
79.79
-103.11
33.30
-17.79
-16.30
-79.01
-37.26
2797.46
2803.95
2813.93
2830.20
2786.91
2785.11
2833.28
2825.48
190.23
-3.67
105.62
-22.53
155.47
-29.31
363.87
-15.73
124.57
11761.1

7.00
0.00
11.61
-36.36
121.43
13.63
3.02
30.13
-99.25
55.55
95.47
-166.22
-15.71
44.07
-12.64
-69.94
56.91
-2.12
-59.14
-3.23
-47.14
72.39
-101.28
9.74
-80.55
59.68
-79.00
-14.89
3308.20
3273.73
3281.41
3317.75
3303.11
3286.56
3286.83
3304.27
200.33
-7.15
92.77
-28.39
138.36
-36.64
352.36
-21.31
113.37
10208.2

8.00
0.04
-5.38
7.38
-1.92
122.47
110.24
-12.19
78.49
66.20
101.12
80.33
-12.12
113.61
98.80
64.47
28.52
25.76
-42.33
-92.65
9.41
-68.17
266.43
-2.94
-4.87
46.72
24.82
-52.16
3708.68
3734.70
3745.96
3774.62
3737.43
3759.98
3722.84
3746.99
193.56
-11.37
78.15
-32.27
136.67
-42.54
359.32
-24.54
92.70
35488.0

9.00
-0.01
0.87
93.54
-96.91
-33.32
-16.36
39.96
41.68
-153.07
2.65
59.03
-175.02
-136.12
69.07
-27.59
32.06
-70.90
23.08
-103.81
-61.73
42.80
138.99
22.43
-51.02
154.19
-93.83
0.01
4159.43
4189.98
4208.28
4212.87
4210.68
4199.81
4211.89
4212.20
207.21
-15.95
79.77
-36.65
132.34
-48.20
394.32
-29.93
92.65
24749.9

10.00
0.01
13.92
-13.16
56.80
2.15
122.66
66.36
-140.22
-42.21
106.34
-40.15
-33.98
-116.39
-14.50
-16.55
-38.92
-57.89
-18.03
192.35
177.23
5.81
2.47
6.12
246.18
-12.59
-41.93
96.92
4676.83
4673.42
4665.94
4638.95
4658.66
4631.30
4660.96
4628.64
204.22
-19.27
72.27
-42.18
143.87
-53.18
438.19
-32.24
86.27
31567.1

TABLE E-8. CVP1, WATER 1, LOAD CONDITION 1b (Continued)


SG11
SG12
SG13
SG14
SG15
SG16
SG17
SG18
SG19
SG20
SG21
SG22
SG23
SG24
SG25
SG26
SG27
SG28
SG29T
SG29-45
SG29L
SG30T
SG30-45
SG30L
SG31T
SG31-45
SG31T
SG32T
SG32-45
SG32L
SG33T
SG33-45
SG33L
SG34T
SG34-45
SG34L
SG35T
SG35-45
SG35L
SG36T
SG36-45
SG36L

194.40
34.31
279.29
23.55
62.17
-104.80
21.49
276.34
134.90
96.05
2.95
8.43
58.35
-10.65
1276.10
543.63
6588.50
-83.07
11.54
19.65
-49.17
32.75
8.76
12.01
73.98
87.42
113.40
18.34
-15.54
11.28
18.70
8.72
16.85
35.28
54.42
16.75
45.13
44.12
42.50
9.16
27.79
39.30

209.53
20.46
320.49
14.94
54.39
-113.26
21.13
269.64
147.46
94.05
29.30
37.60
98.01
29.20
1326.01
585.11
4023.14
-44.79
-15.02
8.84
-36.68
6.04
21.00
57.00
64.09
105.85
155.65
-5.96
-5.85
52.51
-0.96
20.43
51.20
24.32
64.11
43.32
36.53
55.79
77.56
-14.48
32.39
80.45

233.72
10.50
376.63
9.67
34.20
-136.68
29.21
267.72
139.87
78.93
57.84
66.19
134.86
67.75
1373.47
622.75
3526.04
-6.49
-33.33
12.41
-13.51
-10.06
34.20
93.21
53.52
122.01
193.41
-23.38
7.68
88.48
-16.41
32.27
89.28
3.76
79.18
86.48
27.31
68.06
108.45
-34.09
33.71
112.07

227.61
3.26
390.48
5.68
82.88
-126.03
29.94
265.24
156.22
87.01
84.17
88.73
166.57
99.31
1420.49
654.38
1715.83
25.17
-49.98
20.01
16.85
-21.40
53.40
124.95
41.87
138.91
224.37
-31.21
27.78
117.97
-28.19
52.45
122.35
-12.93
101.99
123.25
19.24
87.45
131.87
-39.94
52.23
136.94

200.51
1.74
395.36
4.90
51.31
-136.52
18.56
261.26
160.70
89.07
106.13
114.44
196.01
130.02
1467.64
685.86
4903.68
53.17
-56.78
26.62
43.18
-30.19
62.32
156.83
39.45
149.74
256.21
-40.81
35.48
151.63
-36.68
64.36
156.05
-22.62
119.45
156.16
-0.82
87.25
161.74
-49.31
54.59
165.24

175.68
-1.70
413.88
2.43
34.48
-139.99
8.64
255.96
177.43
95.32
137.81
148.54
233.79
170.59
1526.03
726.73
1423.34
95.14
-65.56
32.20
74.96
-44.28
77.07
197.76
35.78
171.88
298.76
-54.14
55.95
193.98
-47.32
88.96
197.07
-33.58
144.61
195.92
-23.87
98.66
198.27
-61.03
69.72
202.10

E-13

148.22
-10.96
394.71
-4.99
35.56
-139.37
1.47
251.71
164.10
89.75
165.36
172.66
264.67
200.97
1580.64
758.85
1639.06
126.74
-80.72
42.76
106.82
-56.33
92.11
229.46
27.65
185.32
330.53
-65.89
67.25
225.96
-60.86
102.40
231.62
-52.73
162.37
234.03
-36.04
109.76
227.29
-72.18
80.91
231.56

133.91
-19.95
381.37
-11.32
35.38
-143.60
-0.92
248.34
153.26
85.90
194.11
199.99
296.61
232.93
1636.74
791.96
904.43
160.62
-96.29
48.40
137.13
-71.33
105.04
263.04
18.52
199.97
364.50
-80.93
80.79
260.35
-76.63
116.54
266.19
-73.65
177.55
271.25
-45.53
123.25
256.15
-85.19
90.92
259.86

134.23
-22.21
389.50
-14.31
24.22
-149.06
-3.86
245.01
166.30
89.49
216.06
224.59
322.98
260.36
1689.40
821.23
1299.86
182.88
-103.90
62.84
169.11
-81.29
122.86
296.10
12.85
215.64
394.61
-88.58
95.50
292.17
-83.50
133.24
299.35
-83.27
192.36
303.66
-63.69
131.72
286.70
-93.90
102.80
291.88

128.83
-33.72
424.97
-19.89
12.89
-158.47
-4.59
241.44
171.19
82.82
246.90
251.26
355.67
292.00
1748.57
853.68
3027.63
215.20
-123.08
66.80
200.48
-96.44
135.32
327.23
1.51
229.80
427.45
-104.17
106.43
323.21
-100.01
144.47
331.93
-103.97
206.48
339.25
-68.42
147.16
314.27
-108.52
108.72
318.47

140.68
-38.83
468.30
-21.46
21.52
-154.99
-2.02
238.93
188.05
83.97
270.47
277.10
384.35
323.60
1807.65
886.90
1527.17
249.23
-136.53
71.28
234.65
-109.68
142.23
362.57
-8.03
236.41
460.95
-114.37
114.73
357.35
-107.64
152.55
364.52
-113.39
218.81
371.00
-83.18
148.08
346.08
-118.85
110.80
349.18

TABLE E-9. CVP1, WATER 1, LOAD CONDITION 1c


Load Step
Pressure
Frame-1
Frame-2
Frame-3
Frame-4
Frame-5
Frame-6
Frame-7
Frame-8
Frame-9
Frame-10
Frame-11
Frame-12
Hoop-1
Hoop-2
Hoop-3
Hoop-4
Hoop-5
Hoop-6
Hoop-7
Hoop-8
Hoop-9
Hoop-10
Hoop-11
Hoop-12
Hoop-13
Hoop-14
Long-1
Long-2
Long-3
Long-4
Long-5
Long-6
Long-7
Long-8
SG1
SG2
SG3
SG4
SG5
SG6
SG7
SG8
SG9
SG10

0.00
0.01
-28.40
83.15
148.50
63.23
-14.62
16.15
65.72
-161.75
-204.98
12.46
-127.78
80.00
54.21
-64.42
51.58
-46.74
-29.24
-74.01
-58.08
35.41
171.77
-2.94
-78.71
-114.52
24.82
82.01
0.25
90.09
3.88
-31.99
17.18
7.65
5.34
11.82
111.39
6.42
146.40
2.38
162.04
4.77
225.72
8.11
172.75
40190.2

1.00
1.01
212.10
216.18
214.20
228.29
235.25
213.46
218.36
217.93
213.55
204.57
206.87
230.51
899.12
854.28
835.94
743.26
1482.44
747.40
843.02
937.90
925.34
901.26
899.58
882.48
907.26
894.43
459.70
467.02
458.47
440.32
388.87
468.79
365.66
465.90
42.37
52.27
-3.31
49.67
4.35
48.03
67.81
55.20
23.90
27943.1

2.00
2.00
412.13
403.94
428.37
416.62
410.07
416.74
412.05
423.45
415.45
415.34
405.90
408.40
1779.31
1769.30
1762.27
1771.18
1773.94
1784.87
1758.72
1773.81
1786.32
1771.04
1774.50
1831.29
1767.46
1773.93
932.97
930.77
934.92
931.66
933.65
932.54
930.74
927.46
46.40
96.64
-6.25
99.52
22.36
95.31
90.16
102.84
14.16
24488.0

3.00
3.02
636.46
640.57
654.72
634.45
642.02
633.74
634.11
624.61
626.94
645.85
631.03
621.71
2659.51
2662.23
2660.20
2642.96
2670.86
2684.51
2659.83
2676.57
2667.59
2670.08
2666.29
2676.59
2672.42
2668.61
1402.60
1406.67
1401.22
1407.95
1398.47
1400.15
1403.99
1421.11
143.75
149.61
71.30
152.64
90.92
146.05
201.35
156.68
93.75
21895.0

4.00
4.03
832.98
826.54
834.48
831.34
851.29
833.52
832.07
846.45
820.96
853.99
820.69
847.12
3560.84
3533.77
3546.42
3556.34
3562.88
3558.78
3536.11
3556.61
3550.14
3555.90
3550.18
3551.01
3554.60
3540.40
1860.71
1897.94
1876.20
1878.89
1867.29
1862.45
1869.61
1870.18
265.68
203.15
167.78
204.32
188.80
196.08
319.34
209.25
193.19
19771.2

5.00
5.05
1052.87
1050.02
1077.00
1041.29
1046.01
1047.82
1056.80
1043.39
1033.42
1068.23
1029.81
1042.35
4452.35
4439.76
4435.66
4424.58
4428.21
4441.83
4441.04
4430.39
4437.49
4441.06
4448.13
4433.99
4445.35
4458.06
2349.93
2324.07
2358.78
2334.59
2336.02
2333.46
2347.39
2338.84
340.49
257.79
220.34
256.73
253.47
249.77
401.06
263.15
246.32
23554.8

E-14

6.00
6.06
1248.44
1262.86
1257.54
1244.13
1262.96
1248.37
1250.04
1251.91
1255.83
1250.99
1262.20
1261.31
5321.58
5318.14
5312.47
5309.55
5325.31
5319.29
5300.37
5368.99
5310.32
5302.70
5309.24
5330.03
5304.66
5314.32
2796.90
2791.35
2791.60
2799.32
2793.50
2793.35
2798.40
2797.84
402.81
311.09
257.57
308.16
297.47
305.41
462.07
317.14
291.66
30875.8

7.00
7.05
1465.41
1460.74
1464.56
1466.66
1458.20
1458.17
1464.54
1461.01
1454.37
1465.34
1457.98
1453.17
6227.33
6214.30
6241.91
6197.61
6208.70
6211.04
6210.16
6212.92
6210.15
6209.34
6214.31
6205.33
6209.97
6216.80
3269.16
3266.18
3265.72
3251.75
3271.32
3259.84
3261.99
3262.10
497.81
367.62
331.71
363.38
380.66
366.13
561.00
373.61
369.11
19859.3

8.00
8.08
1664.77
1670.47
1679.74
1690.53
1670.32
1664.10
1677.26
1666.60
1663.39
1665.84
1655.30
1674.39
7094.61
7125.73
7097.34
7110.38
7109.45
7105.17
7109.53
7122.20
7121.47
7114.74
7105.22
7109.05
7128.88
7110.60
3756.50
3755.55
3745.06
3734.58
3740.66
3737.74
3734.25
3723.98
534.37
420.70
355.35
416.80
419.37
424.68
617.13
429.40
394.03
17126.8

9.00
9.08
1897.64
1882.66
1888.88
1885.87
1879.76
1898.08
1909.06
1896.44
1900.41
1866.49
1891.74
1894.00
8020.51
7982.96
7996.34
7981.45
7988.84
8004.10
8011.75
8003.29
8005.10
7992.56
8006.78
7999.36
8012.12
7998.35
4196.47
4214.85
4198.90
4188.45
4195.96
4198.13
4197.99
4182.24
597.56
475.28
397.57
470.07
469.79
484.18
677.14
484.80
440.12
20320.3

10.00
10.10
2098.75
2080.23
2073.22
2101.16
2116.06
2081.98
2087.92
2090.58
2097.81
2095.14
2096.42
2089.88
8869.14
8859.32
8896.04
8877.39
8880.15
8853.45
8867.26
8868.89
8869.80
8869.67
8863.33
8881.54
8879.82
8863.04
4628.13
4662.58
4658.26
4671.79
4670.10
4665.23
4673.21
4654.48
662.73
530.83
441.97
524.84
521.26
544.47
735.17
540.80
486.58
29618.1

TABLE E-9. CVP1, WATER 1, LOAD CONDITION 1c (Continued)


SG11
SG12
SG13
SG14
SG15
SG16
SG17
SG18
SG19
SG20
SG21
SG22
SG23
SG24
SG25
SG26
SG27
SG28
SG29T
SG29-45
SG29L
SG30T
SG30-45
SG30L
SG31T
SG31-45
SG31T
SG32T
SG32-45
SG32L
SG33T
SG33-45
SG33L
SG34T
SG34-45
SG34L
SG35T
SG35-45
SG35L
SG36T
SG36-45
SG36L

165.52
32.59
254.40
16.92
51.86
-118.10
6.25
268.97
118.63
86.00
12.17
18.17
72.73
-1.10
1367.71
546.69
1018.66
-82.40
-0.55
8.80
-49.26
17.03
4.59
17.53
77.35
94.34
116.63
5.55
-17.93
14.68
8.86
11.53
16.03
30.99
49.19
11.62
40.63
43.15
44.46
-7.34
25.94
51.82

-3.86
115.77
106.69
79.90
8.49
-98.79
-37.31
289.49
73.46
113.20
11.79
33.20
91.41
18.92
1390.41
569.01
2588.42
-42.58
113.03
82.30
-43.28
88.04
57.79
49.67
157.01
142.11
132.72
91.03
42.25
38.11
88.15
70.25
37.70
103.94
114.16
35.02
64.68
64.14
69.59
82.87
67.54
66.88

6.25
191.46
131.39
138.20
18.25
-62.31
-9.00
332.67
98.12
150.00
13.27
59.98
112.70
50.69
1425.99
605.68
3362.18
0.88
210.64
147.08
-18.82
154.46
117.03
85.90
219.02
187.38
160.79
169.61
99.31
68.14
164.50
127.82
71.21
172.16
178.85
66.77
131.40
118.92
104.77
170.49
129.46
93.71

65.05
269.31
248.65
202.29
82.12
-9.89
42.81
387.19
184.79
203.71
5.71
83.99
122.58
79.69
1443.74
636.40
2782.12
26.65
304.18
203.30
6.69
225.98
170.33
114.81
280.86
231.33
182.78
251.23
153.04
91.92
245.62
184.11
96.68
246.86
240.90
87.82
213.03
176.64
131.36
258.80
185.30
111.85

157.85
344.44
364.98
260.86
143.06
42.69
106.57
441.78
251.61
253.02
-2.76
106.73
129.19
103.93
1467.67
671.10
16052.8
58.32
386.96
251.31
34.02
290.20
216.96
143.29
341.95
276.98
207.92
324.03
204.24
117.14
317.83
239.70
123.76
311.09
300.64
117.32
290.61
234.80
161.31
339.45
233.33
123.91

212.43
421.55
447.48
320.48
190.57
93.08
154.52
493.06
305.90
303.44
-5.71
131.85
131.02
126.15
1487.19
702.13
22501.8
83.36
473.22
306.01
57.01
359.73
266.02
169.65
411.63
325.05
229.21
401.60
255.99
139.15
396.51
291.85
148.05
381.83
356.81
141.05
376.11
296.08
189.52
420.82
285.02
142.02

E-15

248.73
506.02
512.54
378.97
241.33
146.28
199.43
544.97
364.40
359.53
-9.22
153.73
135.85
147.33
1506.01
729.22
1767.97
98.12
555.85
356.18
77.73
429.25
313.55
191.83
485.76
376.76
246.74
478.26
308.41
156.22
474.10
344.82
165.97
452.06
412.68
161.03
461.85
357.32
214.89
500.57
333.72
154.92

318.28
593.38
610.37
439.45
295.25
197.89
256.31
598.61
426.83
413.11
-9.76
177.88
144.42
172.79
1523.08
755.19
557.24
126.07
635.65
404.41
101.01
498.25
359.46
214.45
557.08
425.79
265.91
552.52
359.11
174.95
550.20
393.20
185.23
520.65
462.26
182.62
545.38
414.79
238.85
577.90
379.96
169.77

341.36
682.92
662.49
497.83
328.15
246.77
297.77
651.13
466.31
462.89
-9.58
203.88
155.40
199.20
1535.66
779.27
4551.00
150.34
718.29
455.67
123.92
570.41
408.85
238.47
635.07
480.19
284.39
631.61
413.34
193.34
628.94
445.12
207.13
592.97
514.06
203.09
634.20
475.79
264.22
656.77
427.81
187.06

377.89
773.42
726.02
556.06
374.41
299.13
342.56
702.79
523.85
517.30
-10.87
227.14
163.64
223.04
1551.70
804.15
6913.54
173.15
798.22
504.44
144.33
641.33
455.97
259.12
711.58
532.05
301.06
708.17
465.58
209.46
707.16
494.72
225.38
664.77
565.07
221.55
720.62
534.26
287.77
733.66
473.34
203.55

416.76
864.09
781.19
612.02
419.54
349.94
391.69
756.33
567.12
566.99
-14.19
250.78
170.18
245.98
1568.81
829.14
3148.81
193.16
876.64
552.73
163.99
712.07
502.39
278.57
789.17
583.64
315.22
785.90
516.94
223.09
785.45
543.84
241.38
736.38
617.76
241.12
808.96
593.19
309.42
809.72
520.57
219.33

TABLE E-10. CVP1, WATER 2, LOAD CONDITION 1a


Load Step
Pressure
Frame-1
Frame-2
Frame-3
Frame-4
Frame-5
Frame-6
Frame-7
Frame-8
Frame-9
Frame-10
Frame-11
Frame-12
Hoop-1
Hoop-2
Hoop-3
Hoop-4
Hoop-5
Hoop-6
Hoop-7
Hoop-8
Hoop-9
Hoop-10
Hoop-11
Hoop-12
Hoop-13
Hoop-14
Long-1
Long-2
Long-3
Long-4
Long-5
Long-6
Long-7
Long-8
SG1
SG2
SG3
SG4
SG5
SG6
SG7
SG8
SG9
SG10

0.00
-0.02
8.33
0.27
-87.77
98.26
-112.41
-136.07
-212.39
23.39
55.86
90.89
-121.70
106.88
-1.50
-60.74
168.72
-54.18
-49.80
125.31
109.75
42.80
62.55
-2.94
20.97
33.74
-116.09
7.47
-29.72
-26.75
-5.08
-28.19
-21.43
-9.95
-8.14
6.90
160.32
13.39
225.21
6.97
256.50
8.25
293.99
10.80
233.91
30050.1

1.00
0.98
199.64
224.42
191.51
205.47
210.68
202.95
187.21
205.74
206.36
218.21
213.59
219.97
886.21
859.89
821.83
765.64
1405.97
764.24
837.64
893.60
885.38
881.42
873.82
897.40
788.69
872.15
-3.50
-17.12
-2.52
-23.14
-15.71
0.11
-8.14
1.97
55.02
57.96
29.96
55.91
60.11
55.91
93.47
60.19
51.67
25113.4

2.00
2.03
402.10
399.08
390.90
413.49
425.91
405.08
415.76
404.77
414.03
406.99
406.07
410.41
1796.21
1775.00
1774.87
1771.35
1768.51
1773.87
1771.67
1766.59
1771.93
1776.66
1772.83
1764.75
1760.22
1796.47
-1.00
8.17
3.88
3.38
-30.01
169.74
23.73
-14.02
41.63
107.45
28.30
112.16
62.48
110.69
83.00
114.27
45.78
18962.3

3.00
3.03
648.83
621.79
644.72
627.87
621.63
622.14
619.53
627.25
613.93
633.00
638.69
639.93
2660.04
2688.54
2674.93
2667.65
2658.31
2655.24
2684.08
2654.91
2660.83
2659.74
2657.59
2677.13
2650.70
2669.15
1.50
15.40
-1.24
139.79
-31.44
227.58
-3.24
22.90
160.75
165.70
131.36
171.10
156.83
169.45
182.43
172.41
152.16
16002.6

4.00
4.02
831.08
814.19
846.33
843.24
825.23
838.46
831.39
838.88
818.51
832.65
860.65
822.22
3523.34
3524.21
3533.64
3533.68
3549.44
3545.38
3566.77
3527.02
3531.94
3537.78
3533.56
3551.01
3532.35
3532.94
-4.75
115.37
-7.64
-28.19
-30.01
-20.00
-9.36
5.67
351.57
223.80
306.99
224.59
302.02
220.93
323.83
223.05
324.90
16029.7

5.00
5.03
1040.67
1020.31
1037.40
1029.07
1028.61
1029.05
1019.20
1024.75
1033.67
1037.53
1038.63
1046.09
4414.23
4420.39
4429.44
4445.92
4423.48
4405.45
4414.56
4393.40
4410.18
4421.12
4433.36
4411.75
4393.43
4405.88
5.24
15.40
23.09
100.63
1.45
171.01
172.04
-20.18
424.97
280.86
376.70
283.45
377.15
280.71
411.83
282.21
396.64
15680.5

E-16

6.00
6.03
1239.44
1267.62
1228.00
1254.08
1248.76
1251.47
1244.87
1251.90
1229.58
1257.87
1255.52
1243.98
5295.04
5282.62
5313.72
5307.16
5306.09
5303.86
5319.91
5488.99
5271.86
5289.79
5297.91
5309.38
5276.58
5308.45
1.49
-23.14
76.86
-21.88
-14.28
3.88
-5.69
-7.87
539.37
341.18
487.87
344.29
494.57
346.67
543.54
343.79
511.34
15105.5

7.00
7.08
1473.12
1484.20
1458.50
1472.65
1452.13
1484.39
1490.99
1468.50
1484.71
1495.22
1480.50
1526.44
6212.47
6236.40
6236.58
6223.64
6231.13
6225.94
6226.58
6243.14
6228.97
6231.71
6218.63
6220.78
6218.01
6239.79
3.99
21.42
-5.08
139.78
5.74
-4.92
-14.27
4.44
576.84
401.42
522.31
406.32
531.79
411.64
572.92
404.88
549.27
12510.8

8.00
8.06
1677.14
1663.80
1656.05
1666.71
1670.63
1664.46
1656.83
1668.57
1637.41
1666.08
1672.52
1669.42
7096.02
7088.48
7081.00
7104.36
7079.09
7069.33
7089.06
7085.92
7063.93
7093.70
7067.17
7065.28
7085.09
7066.58
-3.50
-7.48
-11.49
-25.67
-32.87
-13.72
-14.27
-2.95
636.11
458.65
571.79
463.34
579.93
475.25
615.30
461.24
602.07
18748.1

9.00
9.09
1882.15
1872.26
1890.60
1889.34
1914.28
1891.27
1899.42
1904.02
1885.43
1879.24
1889.02
1872.22
8003.54
7986.40
8003.26
7988.62
7997.91
8003.84
7980.51
8011.49
8004.07
7986.11
7990.97
7992.74
8005.50
7984.24
-3.50
-21.94
5.16
84.21
98.67
-6.18
-11.82
15.51
695.69
518.78
620.66
523.25
635.93
543.04
675.75
521.63
654.08
16148.8

10.00
10.08
2077.76
2081.62
2096.94
2087.04
2063.98
2078.31
2069.70
2074.10
2081.05
2080.37
2075.22
2059.46
8833.76
8864.77
8865.87
8856.86
8852.02
8853.35
8878.15
8876.29
8866.16
8855.17
8850.41
8859.30
8857.57
8885.40
-6.00
-21.94
17.97
134.74
25.76
-8.69
-16.72
-7.87
766.58
577.30
684.69
581.74
701.93
609.61
736.49
580.10
719.98
21291.2

TABLE E-10. CVP1, WATER 2, LOAD CONDITION 1a (Continued)


SG11
SG12
SG13
SG14
SG15
SG16
SG17
SG18
SG19
SG20
SG21
SG22
SG23
SG24
SG25
SG26
SG27
SG28
SG29T
SG29-45
SG29L
SG30T
SG30-45
SG30L
SG31T
SG31-45
SG31L
SG32T
SG32-45
SG32L
SG33T
SG33-45
SG33L
SG34T
SG34-45
SG34L
SG35T
SG35-45
SG35L
SG36T
SG36-45
SG36L

241.75
28.45
329.63
20.59
43.12
-126.12
31.25
269.55
146.38
81.55
6.45
14.49
61.68
-10.29
1372.69
542.98
2300.89
-61.74
-2.56
13.24
-54.14
21.42
5.64
6.61
63.97
83.47
105.93
4.40
-12.80
-0.09
10.96
-9.32
2.57
29.83
39.77
8.08
65.05
51.07
33.68
-4.77
26.80
42.85

47.79
123.47
138.00
85.91
-2.80
-97.14
-15.62
295.91
96.29
115.04
-15.11
10.09
51.21
-19.84
1358.19
531.91
1367.32
-63.21
119.99
79.64
-61.38
100.85
38.25
7.57
152.47
118.62
90.50
98.96
32.01
-4.68
96.31
45.18
-3.21
112.43
95.53
2.89
76.73
52.95
33.86
90.57
61.34
32.25

38.23
208.36
126.74
150.88
16.46
-47.83
2.39
343.15
116.70
153.12
-40.72
15.59
40.38
-19.10
1351.29
532.54
925.47
-53.62
233.70
134.56
-65.44
184.09
88.91
11.14
227.21
154.60
83.69
194.45
81.56
-8.53
188.33
92.69
-3.90
199.08
144.03
-0.14
159.39
102.25
38.25
194.30
119.86
28.39

121.80
292.24
226.77
218.72
85.54
12.27
62.63
399.00
186.58
204.38
-69.99
12.28
18.71
-24.60
1333.63
528.47
2295.97
-52.87
334.85
186.21
-72.69
266.34
127.93
4.77
296.27
184.72
70.26
286.17
123.39
-21.17
278.50
132.30
-13.22
283.15
183.76
-13.35
249.93
151.28
37.04
288.41
166.86
19.35

256.46
370.02
371.10
274.85
162.04
76.20
132.07
456.27
261.65
253.31
-121.38
-2.02
-9.54
-31.39
1337.86
536.36
743.18
-58.02
417.05
219.73
-70.81
334.57
160.65
7.56
360.01
216.13
68.80
362.06
158.66
-24.29
355.14
172.08
-16.75
355.75
232.11
-18.71
328.95
194.84
42.31
374.52
197.67
-2.89

323.76
454.44
459.49
340.38
216.50
131.37
184.63
510.26
327.77
307.46
-147.74
-2.20
-34.68
-38.19
1321.93
537.75
833.02
-61.71
510.34
265.44
-80.49
412.76
199.15
1.38
437.04
251.63
58.72
447.21
199.10
-34.43
440.85
210.03
-22.86
431.10
269.75
-18.31
422.31
246.15
43.87
461.83
240.55
-11.74

E-17

431.25
551.72
590.15
407.79
283.62
189.63
259.04
568.83
410.77
365.23
-176.11
-0.55
-59.82
-43.70
1287.88
526.37
6739.95
-66.87
595.67
309.05
-90.56
488.32
234.31
-7.24
512.99
288.87
42.02
529.72
238.05
-51.66
525.39
250.10
-40.94
510.69
301.89
-43.08
513.35
293.49
37.09
544.67
276.09
-22.74

453.21
644.70
617.89
473.59
331.19
246.74
298.48
625.48
450.07
419.98
-205.92
-3.12
-83.65
-52.32
1255.60
514.70
1169.69
-77.16
693.13
351.21
-104.09
576.75
272.17
-20.67
605.33
328.07
23.85
623.66
276.75
-68.80
620.44
288.04
-53.46
596.44
335.11
-59.17
618.51
345.52
30.31
638.19
319.64
-34.52

490.36
740.89
660.11
532.11
378.99
301.00
341.86
679.43
495.01
473.01
-234.67
-5.13
-106.41
-61.14
1229.41
507.41
1180.65
-87.48
779.62
390.08
-116.83
654.75
302.36
-32.46
691.11
362.78
7.16
707.69
308.95
-85.67
706.13
321.57
-68.75
673.56
365.81
-73.12
712.22
391.05
25.37
722.55
354.76
-48.10

528.76
840.18
717.67
594.05
420.57
354.12
383.93
733.50
537.89
527.10
-261.56
-5.13
-126.59
-66.28
1208.98
504.47
1190.76
-91.89
868.79
430.16
-129.88
737.07
338.94
-41.58
782.09
406.62
-7.52
796.61
350.45
-101.81
797.45
360.49
-84.50
755.02
402.71
-87.53
809.25
443.51
23.95
809.78
394.42
-58.27

580.99
936.27
775.72
652.60
470.50
405.58
441.23
789.22
582.11
575.35
-290.97
-7.52
-149.96
-73.65
1186.45
498.80
1140.12
-100.77
953.58
469.10
-142.20
816.79
373.84
-53.11
867.74
445.88
-25.70
882.59
387.72
-120.33
885.27
395.66
-101.43
833.46
436.81
-101.88
903.12
491.58
18.55
893.33
430.41
-71.23

TABLE E-11. CVP1, WATER 2, LOAD CONDITION 1b


Load Step
Pressure
Frame-1
Frame-2
Frame-3
Frame-4
Frame-5
Frame-6
Frame-7
Frame-8
Frame-9
Frame-10
Frame-11
Frame-12
Hoop-1
Hoop-2
Hoop-3
Hoop-4
Hoop-5
Hoop-6
Hoop-7
Hoop-8
Hoop-9
Hoop-10
Hoop-11
Hoop-12
Hoop-13
Hoop-14
Long-1
Long-2
Long-3
Long-4
Long-5
Long-6
Long-7
Long-8
SG1
SG2
SG3
SG4
SG5
SG6
SG7
SG8
SG9
SG10

0.00
-0.02
-19.95
27.33
-26.70
9.62
-142.47
70.40
-17.00
-46.45
-178.92
-178.70
-0.82
-48.04
-7.07
-66.27
145.67
265.60
-34.86
-79.61
18.53
94.58
-124.95
-4.75
246.16
-97.83
-86.42
29.83
5.24
-12.30
2.60
154.95
151.59
197.42
-11.82
-53.41
294.28
18.33
329.14
7.33
332.25
5.13
381.82
8.10
339.70
18858.3

1.00
0.01
11.81
80.28
-225.04
-134.43
-146.87
45.59
75.23
-55.85
-73.22
-129.55
99.83
-54.00
7.79
-27.60
-47.80
-39.30
-21.77
250.11
45.90
-38.58
75.30
-19.25
-28.87
24.48
-86.43
-7.44
479.72
481.52
461.08
449.21
504.72
478.89
395.11
489.33
231.42
12.84
256.57
1.28
284.10
-2.02
370.13
2.33
258.29
21997.1

2.00
0.02
-11.32
53.48
174.09
33.78
88.75
-121.57
122.54
34.48
0.88
-27.15
49.85
112.85
15.22
-64.43
138.57
-57.90
-4.95
214.74
-38.03
57.60
46.16
-8.38
-39.95
-5.18
24.82
-52.16
927.98
936.80
951.57
932.93
929.36
925.00
935.64
942.23
248.84
11.55
265.03
-4.95
294.13
-6.05
397.43
-0.78
275.39
23501.3

3.00
0.00
13.33
-13.77
232.98
32.59
104.81
-131.19
-81.81
-2.77
-171.23
40.62
150.34
85.80
-49.79
108.67
-95.72
196.81
4.39
-72.16
18.53
94.59
195.44
-12.00
-41.79
-71.90
84.15
0.01
1382.62
1427.14
1383.29
1414.26
1425.64
1410.20
1418.70
1434.65
241.82
8.80
234.65
-9.53
261.41
-11.18
394.06
-4.16
252.36
15559.3

4.00
0.01
3.37
-42.92
211.04
91.58
-24.20
-98.58
39.27
52.83
-181.17
97.95
118.66
60.37
15.22
-58.90
-10.53
61.09
-14.30
41.48
69.62
64.99
7.93
53.23
-69.48
-88.57
61.89
-14.89
1879.44
1858.19
1855.71
1871.32
1888.74
1864.97
1869.61
1866.48
223.19
4.03
186.75
-15.40
213.39
-17.60
373.83
-10.39
201.51
23688.8

5.00
-0.01
6.52
-187.48
-38.08
-0.09
-34.86
-119.18
7.70
98.75
125.25
69.84
60.66
-78.57
0.36
75.52
-49.58
-13.28
112.79
-87.06
-79.99
-1.59
55.26
85.86
-54.71
-107.11
61.90
29.83
2338.93
2305.04
2312.91
2344.93
2327.68
2343.75
2339.05
2312.00
227.41
2.02
182.16
-19.43
208.90
-24.01
371.82
-14.28
194.15
24549.7

E-18

6.00
-0.03
26.44
-7.55
-282.52
-159.44
-180.54
77.10
-185.93
55.01
147.18
-204.64
102.32
-62.00
-51.64
95.76
44.49
27.62
-31.11
115.98
-78.15
35.40
-75.80
-1.13
-71.32
169.02
-79.00
-74.52
2800.64
2793.76
2808.24
2796.80
2806.37
2785.81
2798.40
2805.23
218.99
-3.85
168.02
-23.83
200.72
-30.61
382.30
-19.00
169.17
26088.9

7.00
-0.01
-0.43
1.87
81.98
-27.73
118.63
18.28
-42.31
-35.59
106.02
111.10
-135.71
9.58
-31.22
1.86
115.49
3.45
77.28
-42.35
20.36
5.81
-57.60
-6.57
-21.49
0.38
32.24
-22.35
3275.73
3268.91
3245.55
3243.23
3293.10
3262.68
3303.99
3263.65
205.91
-5.50
137.83
-28.59
174.23
-35.73
372.66
-22.74
150.18
21319.3

8.00
0.00
5.59
37.50
190.95
-11.36
-134.13
-35.23
68.66
-98.56
-137.47
-84.46
110.33
72.57
-57.21
101.29
85.31
-52.32
-6.82
140.21
-90.93
28.01
22.50
75.00
-71.34
119.02
24.82
-59.63
3750.26
3743.51
3784.76
3788.89
3743.52
3744.02
3750.18
3747.37
210.60
-9.54
124.66
-34.28
177.21
-41.25
396.31
-26.37
139.22
30482.2

9.00
0.00
7.57
56.87
-105.69
-155.91
-101.09
-121.57
-5.15
73.85
-140.70
-20.49
137.67
105.69
20.79
3.70
-60.22
75.95
15.60
67.56
-21.60
42.81
-106.77
51.43
57.90
-75.61
61.91
29.83
4201.89
4192.39
4177.55
4193.92
4223.55
4217.40
4191.05
4177.74
225.82
-9.35
95.72
-35.91
129.12
-46.90
368.15
-31.24
106.40
10402.3

10.00
0.00
1.19
-29.49
35.53
77.32
18.46
-109.20
61.03
-44.21
25.78
-114.47
82.52
96.05
-5.21
-60.75
158.11
23.91
34.30
-46.08
-43.50
-23.78
-46.69
22.43
212.98
-32.98
-130.93
22.38
4669.81
4641.37
4694.59
4684.89
4683.44
4689.58
4682.26
4643.87
203.10
-14.48
64.85
-41.22
119.97
-51.84
376.21
-34.95
77.73
11316.3

TABLE E-11. CVP1, WATER 2, LOAD CONDITION 1b (Continued)


SG11
SG12
SG13
SG14
SG15
SG16
SG17
SG18
SG19
SG20
SG21
SG22
SG23
SG24
SG25
SG26
SG27
SG28
SG29T
SG29-45
SG29L
SG30T
SG30-45
SG30L
SG31T
SG31-45
SG31L
SG32T
SG32-45
SG32L
SG33T
SG33-45
SG33L
SG34T
SG34-45
SG34L
SG35T
SG35-45
SG35L
SG36T
SG36-45
SG36L

329.85
15.18
418.97
16.13
76.71
-117.82
70.00
282.66
165.47
79.68
-1.84
7.52
58.36
-11.38
1433.99
552.13
1532.71
-39.63
-11.72
4.21
-53.07
22.32
0.09
7.93
50.96
79.59
113.96
-6.42
-10.61
3.58
-1.74
-16.85
13.63
19.96
33.15
12.30
87.02
63.99
39.25
-11.36
24.40
39.39

274.20
11.97
410.85
11.92
39.85
-135.97
47.41
275.53
170.64
80.42
26.72
39.43
98.37
30.30
1483.47
592.39
2463.26
1.61
-28.57
5.82
-38.65
2.38
19.85
55.67
51.61
102.49
155.64
-21.14
7.50
47.14
-11.51
3.49
50.32
19.36
58.46
46.94
55.31
64.18
76.82
-27.50
26.51
81.04

283.39
8.53
441.06
10.54
80.48
-121.68
48.69
273.10
197.15
90.36
52.51
67.67
130.12
63.91
1525.63
625.26
3460.57
33.28
-40.48
12.74
-15.20
-6.04
36.09
88.46
39.41
116.21
188.49
-27.65
24.69
79.55
-19.44
24.24
85.03
5.83
79.83
84.11
44.09
78.67
102.05
-33.18
43.07
108.51

257.79
5.14
438.82
7.97
88.49
-122.57
44.46
271.16
199.68
92.37
82.35
97.55
163.49
98.23
1572.44
659.10
3923.41
70.09
-53.47
15.34
14.06
-18.30
48.37
122.50
33.89
132.47
224.05
-39.61
39.31
114.97
-32.60
42.13
120.45
-11.06
98.29
119.84
27.99
88.98
131.02
-43.07
54.48
136.14

206.04
0.18
414.29
1.74
72.88
-131.77
18.93
262.48
180.96
84.66
110.75
126.74
196.03
131.50
1625.94
692.17
2020.05
102.52
-63.74
22.73
42.91
-33.13
61.91
158.77
28.49
147.97
258.07
-50.94
54.13
150.87
-44.02
57.66
155.47
-25.60
115.98
155.35
6.55
93.36
161.39
-56.28
61.43
168.52

200.34
-8.81
414.65
-2.06
60.72
-139.65
21.68
261.15
184.09
84.48
136.92
151.32
225.39
159.97
1674.18
721.92
2237.73
129.78
-79.68
29.19
71.58
-48.13
74.93
190.41
19.50
162.47
288.18
-63.14
67.30
180.17
-55.49
69.37
185.45
-44.37
129.37
189.91
-2.34
104.46
187.00
-69.11
66.98
194.71

E-19

188.96
-17.25
420.24
-7.38
33.62
-154.01
14.70
255.67
166.44
71.79
163.47
175.92
255.70
189.38
1727.56
752.29
2135.36
160.73
-94.89
38.77
101.86
-60.22
87.97
220.84
11.84
174.14
319.78
-76.72
76.09
212.01
-70.17
78.98
220.28
-62.96
143.32
225.91
-14.81
112.92
214.64
-84.15
73.13
223.21

165.75
-20.18
416.40
-9.12
56.26
-142.37
9.74
253.39
179.09
81.70
189.95
204.10
288.11
223.11
1780.43
785.30
2470.73
196.03
-102.92
41.23
133.75
-69.90
99.08
255.53
4.45
187.02
354.37
-83.44
91.42
246.89
-78.91
98.55
256.52
-76.11
166.07
263.88
-32.08
121.60
244.90
-89.63
86.32
252.68

167.49
-26.94
436.10
-13.71
62.71
-141.16
7.72
249.53
177.70
73.09
216.03
230.26
318.18
254.08
1837.49
818.39
2632.34
228.55
-116.16
56.60
166.30
-81.28
117.89
288.96
-4.18
204.74
387.23
-94.99
109.03
280.04
-91.10
114.49
290.59
-91.06
182.48
298.44
-44.24
136.12
274.21
-99.57
101.37
283.31

121.25
-33.75
405.51
-17.82
24.66
-158.08
-3.49
246.48
161.55
73.03
244.59
257.21
350.94
288.21
1898.59
851.69
3040.57
266.65
-126.14
61.92
196.83
-93.84
125.59
322.51
-7.52
220.21
423.06
-108.21
121.01
315.38
-103.04
129.86
324.87
-109.52
197.10
334.39
-60.83
142.56
306.18
-111.95
103.35
311.74

111.14
-39.62
415.41
-20.98
25.67
-156.16
-7.35
243.09
173.15
77.26
270.20
279.94
381.03
317.76
1955.08
883.07
2170.46
296.09
-138.22
73.37
230.25
-105.73
142.14
355.20
-15.36
236.22
454.25
-116.46
137.46
346.36
-111.79
145.47
358.14
-124.15
214.10
371.18
-73.84
155.72
333.88
-119.83
118.26
340.21

TABLE E-12. CVP1, WATER 2, LOAD CONDITION 1c


Load Step
Pressure
Frame-1
Frame-2
Frame-3
Frame-4
Frame-5
Frame-6
Frame-7
Frame-8
Frame-9
Frame-10
Frame-11
Frame-12
Hoop-1
Hoop-2
Hoop-3
Hoop-4
Hoop-5
Hoop-6
Hoop-7
Hoop-8
Hoop-9
Hoop-10
Hoop-11
Hoop-12
Hoop-13
Hoop-14
Long-1
Long-2
Long-3
Long-4
Long-5
Long-6
Long-7
Long-8
SG1
SG2
SG3
SG4
SG5
SG6
SG7
SG8
SG9
SG10

0.00
0.02
9.39
50.05
52.28
-48.93
35.31
72.06
82.88
105.02
53.17
24.46
-65.26
-13.44
-68.35
-62.58
95.96
176.34
138.94
88.05
-63.56
50.21
15.22
58.69
56.06
198.73
-79.02
-7.44
-19.73
-1.46
51.26
110.72
-2.84
145.86
66.62
-26.33
93.85
10.08
180.78
8.24
210.67
11.72
276.57
11.21
194.24
15357.2

1.00
1.03
224.52
220.05
200.82
218.31
211.46
247.74
205.31
213.49
292.83
189.81
207.55
224.34
890.01
880.24
896.46
955.35
849.16
907.77
888.80
878.80
887.20
886.86
888.59
899.25
885.10
916.88
477.18
469.43
445.66
484.52
713.40
463.76
309.28
476.98
31.90
55.91
-17.27
49.83
24.00
49.83
57.70
54.40
1.65
12512.8

2.00
2.03
411.72
426.15
409.07
393.81
425.20
429.87
406.40
407.47
406.29
387.31
423.97
416.58
1764.81
1771.50
1748.42
1756.66
1757.47
1801.99
1770.02
1789.32
1774.28
1782.63
1777.05
1780.11
1790.42
1797.01
914.34
935.68
920.92
921.65
932.32
925.09
933.28
915.24
52.06
101.00
3.31
100.57
31.46
97.09
95.79
102.70
18.93
11966.8

3.00
3.01
624.48
645.85
637.64
627.63
642.10
618.55
619.27
626.99
618.86
710.22
621.57
643.11
2647.30
2657.50
2643.25
2658.62
2652.97
2642.46
2684.35
2669.44
2658.75
2652.22
2648.10
2684.27
2665.27
2653.97
1391.36
1393.42
1392.25
1382.68
1395.61
1391.35
1386.83
1380.50
150.86
152.13
84.88
154.25
111.17
148.75
200.93
156.81
92.98
14606.9

4.00
4.03
843.16
833.35
832.62
838.09
823.53
829.98
829.65
842.31
827.25
825.75
843.69
842.97
3558.63
3524.21
3554.94
3550.41
3532.62
3543.52
3557.65
3550.27
3547.56
3547.90
3551.24
3552.07
3563.08
3534.00
1856.96
1895.53
1854.43
1875.11
1855.85
1867.48
1873.29
1865.25
316.68
205.92
217.24
199.76
231.92
192.25
346.31
202.91
233.84
19084.2

5.00
5.06
1051.91
1040.38
1048.58
1052.40
1045.06
1050.26
1048.82
1062.96
1049.78
1058.53
1049.03
1053.37
4470.92
4450.81
4471.16
4452.46
4450.63
4449.28
4433.75
4459.99
4446.59
4477.31
4453.67
4456.23
4452.77
4472.97
2342.44
2336.12
2335.73
2351.01
2336.02
2328.43
2353.52
2326.53
428.64
260.15
309.63
254.50
332.49
247.91
472.28
260.75
330.84
16001.4

E-20

6.00
6.07
1245.63
1254.82
1246.15
1248.22
1246.35
1262.56
1246.07
1241.05
1244.85
1229.80
1239.64
1259.05
5319.72
5314.45
5321.35
5311.40
5336.52
5326.74
5331.38
5325.67
5322.31
5332.76
5328.76
5338.51
5313.14
5315.38
2782.89
2813.95
2800.28
2881.12
2806.09
2808.14
2803.02
2806.18
502.26
315.03
362.07
308.80
393.12
304.96
546.22
316.63
382.93
25443.2

7.00
7.07
1450.91
1480.90
1448.38
1455.60
1454.04
1457.40
1463.86
1468.93
1458.97
1468.10
1482.62
1469.79
6218.66
6207.56
6221.23
6198.23
6214.93
6217.24
6219.90
6212.92
6208.33
6209.34
6210.62
6220.16
6224.80
6231.71
3278.82
3287.53
3284.60
3253.95
3270.99
3279.62
3277.59
3270.39
555.25
369.30
397.36
362.50
436.08
362.69
607.42
371.68
421.17
22431.9

8.00
8.08
1645.72
1668.63
1665.92
1661.12
1685.75
1674.19
1661.47
1674.93
1675.32
1658.67
1668.56
1667.19
7095.31
7098.82
7130.00
7101.79
7097.07
7122.65
7099.29
7094.02
7099.23
7101.66
7115.87
7103.06
7085.80
7104.56
3737.02
3742.76
3721.26
3742.67
3742.77
3730.71
3738.40
3726.93
638.01
426.98
468.76
419.23
514.72
424.54
708.24
429.94
504.17
16160.0

9.00
9.08
1889.39
1862.17
1896.11
1886.24
1871.50
1889.95
1863.25
1867.87
1876.69
1856.85
1889.05
1877.40
7961.89
7972.71
7981.16
7969.23
7982.16
7967.64
7985.19
7958.91
7988.71
7985.31
7984.63
7984.53
7967.62
7998.35
4200.22
4184.74
4204.02
4217.50
4194.53
4195.62
4210.24
4213.01
681.58
478.81
492.78
470.67
550.34
481.30
754.88
483.47
528.19
18159.9

10.00
10.10
2098.39
2114.63
2100.32
2080.11
2100.18
2074.84
2098.96
2079.23
2095.02
2088.95
2078.51
2094.04
8865.34
8864.77
8848.12
8860.57
8881.93
8881.30
8876.33
8868.00
8867.09
8883.28
8867.98
8873.24
8908.60
8869.61
4679.33
4685.47
4673.63
4655.37
4662.95
4662.72
4662.18
4656.95
751.42
535.27
544.78
525.44
602.23
542.31
812.03
539.51
584.43
17444.0

TABLE E-12. CVP1, WATER 2, LOAD CONDITION 1c (Continued)


SG11
SG12
SG13
SG14
SG15
SG16
SG17
SG18
SG19
SG20
SG21
SG22
SG23
SG24
SG25
SG26
SG27
SG28
SG29T
SG29-45
SG29L
SG30T
SG30-45
SG30L
SG31T
SG31-45
SG31L
SG32T
SG32-45
SG32L
SG33T
SG33-45
SG33L
SG34T
SG34-45
SG34L
SG35T
SG35-45
SG35L
SG36T
SG36-45
SG36L

203.00
35.45
310.80
24.33
51.02
-120.53
22.41
277.30
140.39
82.41
4.97
12.47
61.46
-13.03
1496.31
538.01
1774.45
-31.52
1.10
20.79
-55.71
27.07
6.23
4.68
64.33
81.99
104.39
11.23
-0.73
-1.83
13.93
-6.01
6.33
30.91
39.60
11.70
53.83
43.75
28.66
-2.02
25.95
39.75

7.90
115.71
98.34
80.78
-2.80
-99.84
-27.92
295.21
64.59
103.03
13.63
41.07
90.27
18.18
1533.82
572.58
1773.16
11.19
109.67
83.59
-43.58
87.08
56.11
50.84
146.61
137.45
133.02
86.12
59.05
35.98
84.03
58.19
35.89
101.00
104.98
30.64
63.82
61.96
67.04
79.53
74.52
71.11

10.29
190.95
145.07
142.35
23.38
-62.46
2.76
341.59
117.39
148.82
14.55
72.05
109.34
51.03
1568.45
607.21
1634.98
42.10
208.89
146.00
-19.50
155.12
116.88
86.82
209.01
186.55
160.53
166.04
118.27
65.27
162.08
122.43
68.98
171.25
178.07
64.54
132.53
118.40
98.85
167.84
132.01
93.02

83.40
268.03
252.84
205.62
75.45
-11.36
59.51
394.55
190.44
195.92
9.58
92.95
116.49
75.08
1591.08
634.00
22844.9
73.76
300.43
203.66
3.39
226.09
169.41
111.66
267.84
226.40
178.14
247.12
168.17
84.42
241.33
175.94
91.78
241.92
234.32
84.72
212.55
173.84
123.03
253.23
185.89
110.30

193.71
337.64
397.70
257.17
147.48
44.71
114.66
448.70
258.99
243.11
-15.29
103.44
131.04
105.78
1655.79
682.55
1454.00
106.20
376.74
244.37
34.99
282.36
215.24
150.73
326.71
279.39
217.30
311.04
224.56
121.92
306.13
233.99
130.57
300.89
301.72
121.10
281.70
236.11
163.71
330.31
233.99
122.64

287.56
416.97
526.35
321.23
214.57
100.04
182.43
503.70
345.26
300.10
-18.61
126.15
125.14
124.49
1681.22
713.44
1338.47
126.79
462.18
303.19
62.72
352.01
270.44
178.48
395.03
329.97
238.18
389.27
279.73
143.26
385.47
289.61
152.99
372.66
359.29
144.34
368.10
297.71
190.19
413.82
283.52
134.17

E-21

336.69
501.51
598.15
381.01
264.32
148.62
228.22
554.12
400.18
352.42
-20.64
151.49
131.40
148.20
1701.44
740.57
1352.34
147.44
544.87
354.56
83.53
421.81
318.18
199.89
467.41
378.30
254.38
466.19
328.98
160.07
462.58
337.78
171.52
442.15
408.43
164.01
454.20
355.20
213.36
491.26
331.97
152.22

369.58
587.16
660.49
440.23
302.57
198.28
272.14
607.02
447.49
403.40
-19.35
176.98
142.05
173.55
1721.88
767.75
1398.30
168.06
626.38
403.03
105.92
491.53
364.04
222.08
542.73
427.66
272.91
542.67
378.17
178.36
539.98
387.64
191.63
511.71
459.56
186.12
540.17
413.00
238.14
569.71
378.90
168.91

441.35
679.55
769.25
502.83
385.72
257.60
352.18
668.17
544.57
467.90
-22.84
200.78
146.42
197.01
1729.82
784.67
1077.84
191.59
708.65
453.43
126.36
564.06
410.04
241.93
617.75
476.38
287.72
621.04
429.29
192.90
618.91
439.10
209.03
584.27
513.56
205.13
627.76
473.82
259.30
648.58
425.65
182.54

460.42
767.17
812.61
559.05
411.26
301.91
381.91
715.16
573.96
512.38
-21.00
225.15
157.79
221.96
1750.81
809.74
916.19
217.34
786.58
503.21
147.50
632.43
457.44
264.33
693.86
527.88
306.04
695.04
479.70
211.36
694.40
488.39
231.04
653.14
562.01
225.89
711.76
532.11
284.82
722.92
472.75
200.40

500.65
858.16
873.47
616.60
469.62
356.69
434.26
769.64
633.21
568.86
-22.29
248.61
164.94
245.64
1768.29
834.89
744.72
237.22
866.78
553.68
170.30
705.42
504.56
284.86
772.37
579.98
322.37
774.61
530.34
226.62
774.71
539.47
247.93
726.03
615.55
245.80
799.59
592.46
307.81
801.17
520.12
215.99

TABLE E-13. CVP2, AIR 1, LOAD CONDITION 1a


Load Step
0.00
1.00
Pressure
0.03
1.01
Frame-1
9.49
176.05
Frame-2
493.82 209.90
Frame-3
56.75 196.39
Frame-4
19.49 198.46
Frame-5
71.82 207.93
Frame-6
18.96 263.99
Frame-7
58.16 252.40
Frame-8
-9.86 206.54
Frame-9
-74.29 269.44
Frame-10
-24.05 214.82
Frame-11
42.33 201.33
Frame-12
-42.05 196.91
Hoop-1
49.72 880.39
Hoop-2
-70.50 870.95
Hoop-3
23.21 882.75
Hoop-4
12.79 915.70
Hoop-5
171.64 897.68
Hoop-6
-73.51 872.46
Hoop-7
321.94 893.60
Hoop-8
95.85 890.38
Hoop-9
-20.51 889.81
Hoop-10
29.39 881.90
Hoop-11
-91.46 875.81
Hoop-12
-37.82 918.97
Hoop-13
37.84 875.66
Hoop-14
90.25 859.81
Long-1
118.31 120.69
Long-2
26.89 -37.52
Long-3
-7.72 -46.25
Long-4
1.75
82.51
Long-5
379.99 296.07
Long-6
-31.41 -37.53
Long-7
100.44 104.05
Long-8
20.21
58.37
SG1
62.18 -27.01
SG2
15.48
63.54
SG3
116.71 39.81
SG4
15.80
67.21
SG5
38.81 -33.24
SG6
22.36
76.35
SG7
####### #######
SG8
-52.71
6.91
SG9
49.62 -28.09
SG10
3.72
63.86

2.00
2.04
423.10
434.71
433.37
425.24
422.97
416.79
442.68
413.81
433.03
417.00
402.02
418.08
1822.98
1832.10
1789.48
1794.38
1795.00
1786.85
1799.25
1766.19
1756.95
1767.27
1767.88
1765.06
1780.56
1762.91
79.17
-48.47
49.46
-39.86
272.14
-3.30
113.69
17.75
38.05
124.00
87.03
126.08
5.76
138.80
#######
65.80
15.48
126.96

3.00
3.02
643.32
632.39
636.77
644.13
654.24
646.80
557.97
623.62
593.88
623.43
622.21
612.36
2685.07
2755.67
2721.12
2680.82
2707.26
2694.20
2714.40
2633.94
2543.61
2633.87
2567.13
2630.81
2603.19
2650.51
0.82
-13.22
-36.30
64.16
270.89
85.94
105.25
-26.57
144.93
184.67
192.91
186.82
112.75
205.66
#######
128.35
108.88
188.01

4.00
4.04
832.49
847.44
828.09
825.04
835.44
834.24
838.30
829.65
819.00
829.54
828.46
828.82
3542.59
3515.73
3518.56
3536.77
3532.91
3552.63
3489.87
3568.61
3610.24
3537.31
3529.22
3541.68
3530.33
3487.01
-2.74
12.30
-45.00
77.62
267.29
76.16
106.45
-19.19
185.12
242.89
254.55
245.57
172.35
272.19
#######
188.73
178.30
252.05

5.00
5.04
1048.36
1059.86
1035.72
1049.92
1039.93
1046.34
1037.28
1037.01
1034.98
1021.48
1037.76
1034.50
4415.79
4437.56
4430.99
4423.29
4428.84
4436.05
4428.83
4429.00
4431.34
4470.74
4426.12
4429.64
4412.28
4322.81
-0.36
-8.35
-46.24
104.53
299.63
-42.41
107.65
54.67
258.10
302.84
334.43
306.60
261.16
343.31
#######
251.29
254.72
313.49

E-22

6.00
6.05
1254.45
1253.74
1250.77
1261.55
1262.23
1241.99
1229.54
1237.66
1251.15
1248.04
1257.35
1252.46
5304.65
5324.19
5323.24
5310.78
5373.13
5333.37
5348.65
5319.17
5283.63
5267.25
5179.66
5303.14
5309.41
5314.36
-21.72
-21.72
-42.51
13.99
321.21
-41.19
113.65
-17.95
338.20
364.00
416.81
367.14
346.41
414.34
#######
313.07
333.85
374.67

7.00
7.06
1457.43
1458.40
1462.73
1478.71
1460.72
1446.48
1458.49
1471.53
1453.88
1457.89
1470.69
1438.08
6193.94
6200.42
6193.13
6191.32
6195.67
6194.18
6194.05
6201.37
6191.51
6162.49
6166.57
6242.64
6191.10
6231.29
2.01
-1.06
3.47
-44.75
334.43
48.05
117.27
12.82
424.98
426.23
499.83
428.52
413.29
485.08
#######
374.30
416.33
437.01

8.00
8.07
1655.31
1656.17
1676.46
1680.41
1659.27
1577.98
1684.95
1666.77
1791.91
1649.75
1671.42
1648.88
7060.06
7079.16
7068.99
7061.46
7051.74
7079.71
7098.59
7077.45
7084.31
7109.53
7036.81
7064.95
7066.60
7082.86
6.76
-3.49
54.42
119.22
372.80
7.71
167.75
0.51
491.84
486.97
568.23
488.09
492.22
557.26
#######
435.37
487.18
498.78

9.00
9.08
1872.60
1838.75
1859.76
1875.68
1856.56
1861.10
1897.58
1886.05
1866.46
1831.23
1868.72
1878.64
7972.29
7959.89
7962.57
7959.52
7880.62
7959.88
7961.30
7960.26
7936.60
8084.86
7911.95
7975.47
7956.32
7941.22
-3.92
-12.00
2.22
-15.38
369.20
8.93
160.54
9.13
605.94
552.04
678.56
553.00
566.22
629.31
#######
498.68
586.69
562.62

10.00
10.10
2093.19
2071.60
2087.54
2086.32
2091.67
2067.64
2074.54
2097.22
2067.15
2047.65
2093.55
2074.33
8852.58
8865.21
8822.11
8836.53
8849.25
8848.58
8863.48
8866.04
8815.16
8880.46
8865.36
8849.86
8854.34
8859.65
-5.11
7.44
2.22
-19.05
385.98
27.27
165.35
1.74
699.32
616.13
775.71
616.88
654.20
703.12
#######
559.72
677.27
625.85

TABLE E-13. CVP2, AIR 1, LOAD CONDITION 1a (Continued)


SG11
SG12
SG13
SG14
SG15
SG16
SG17
SG18
SG19
SG20
SG21
SG22
SG23
SG24
SG25
SG26
SG27
SG28
SG29T
SG29-45
SG29L
SG30T
SG30-45
SG30L
SG31T
SG31-45
SG31L
SG32T
SG32-45
SG32L
SG33T
SG33-45
SG33L
SG34T
SG34-45
SG34L
SG35T
SG35-45
SG35L
SG36T
SG36-45
SG36L
SG37T
SG37-45
SG37L

31.04
33.70
104.83
30.92
-52.13
-19.81
-393.79
-2.14
-340.28
30.08
24.42
54.24
-34.24
32.63
229.54
24852.0
-141.91
48.26
7.85
31.20
26.62
15.24
8.90
10.56
18.63
35.96
40.27
1.55
58.50
38.86
-5.31
19.35
13.91
19.49
-13.13
19.14
0.27
34.07
32.66
-8.48
-8.71
6.98
-64.60
33.79
22.30

-60.45
117.64
-35.34
92.01
-68.53
22.56
-420.08
31.12
-379.70
59.48
-14.06
43.36
-56.98
15.79
220.70
24833.4
-179.17
38.66
82.32
40.11
5.68
86.52
23.38
-8.25
113.45
13.58
66.23
82.04
77.25
16.57
45.89
32.45
-3.60
51.93
3.48
10.53
33.42
27.58
6.97
66.29
13.99
-9.25
18.79
58.47
2.76

-21.65
208.88
-23.69
153.05
-33.99
76.03
-377.57
75.09
-353.81
111.61
-50.32
40.45
-79.07
13.12
218.40
24777.6
-205.60
37.92
163.34
70.85
-1.89
165.08
60.42
-13.77
197.47
2.44
103.72
165.64
119.17
8.09
112.24
59.62
-11.75
113.98
33.19
1.36
85.96
51.59
-1.77
145.98
57.29
-13.91
105.78
101.12
-5.09

78.88
300.45
90.89
217.89
10.74
126.87
-302.77
125.46
-283.44
172.03
-89.17
37.95
-106.36
9.52
209.40
24831.0
-234.03
34.96
242.57
108.40
-10.48
243.70
94.02
-22.68
273.13
-8.76
136.45
248.48
157.93
-4.94
186.76
93.34
-25.82
182.99
62.75
-10.51
148.44
79.04
-8.74
225.19
97.18
-22.72
188.80
140.51
-13.36

137.31
395.32
187.52
283.00
70.80
184.23
-231.49
179.61
-211.24
234.89
-122.48
37.08
-127.54
7.63
202.70
24848.2
-260.48
32.74
322.78
143.52
-19.49
323.97
129.40
-28.77
360.11
-17.12
171.35
333.64
192.45
-16.78
266.49
126.42
-41.01
257.29
90.83
-23.92
220.11
109.14
-13.25
307.00
135.93
-30.46
272.69
176.81
-18.98

213.76
503.26
281.15
347.13
113.64
236.23
-172.65
230.41
-165.18
288.68
-154.86
35.14
-150.69
3.48
196.21
24859.9
-282.33
28.31
402.68
174.82
-30.55
404.25
163.24
-38.01
443.62
-27.15
207.58
419.06
227.32
-30.99
347.80
157.30
-58.43
330.88
118.45
-37.05
293.62
140.22
-16.04
387.21
173.63
-39.04
355.77
214.72
-26.31

E-23

290.02
609.52
370.20
408.87
161.28
291.58
-107.04
282.64
-110.41
345.18
-187.57
36.42
-172.24
2.83
190.88
24825.5
-303.33
25.34
481.74
215.58
-38.81
483.79
204.74
-43.05
524.28
-33.13
246.92
503.96
267.70
-42.82
431.24
192.52
-75.04
405.97
149.43
-49.84
370.04
181.62
-15.76
466.95
219.60
-45.69
437.09
255.93
-29.79

353.27
716.11
451.88
472.11
226.31
352.55
-29.06
337.82
-51.07
404.29
-216.88
35.79
-192.51
1.12
185.11
24847.3
-325.22
19.44
562.23
252.77
-46.54
565.41
241.27
-49.34
608.20
-40.81
286.61
590.94
306.96
-55.47
517.55
229.86
-89.80
482.72
183.33
-62.30
450.59
218.11
-15.90
549.46
259.83
-55.13
519.39
296.65
-35.09

416.18
819.94
521.66
535.59
284.24
412.03
49.96
393.40
7.39
463.96
-250.17
33.94
-217.35
-5.89
175.83
24853.6
-349.90
12.78
644.55
287.20
-56.43
648.92
273.46
-58.48
692.36
-52.51
313.32
681.29
337.17
-72.83
607.95
266.06
-111.50
562.04
213.30
-76.73
535.51
251.73
-22.27
631.89
300.68
-65.48
604.01
325.62
-44.24

481.89
927.80
608.62
597.51
340.94
469.01
108.86
444.58
59.19
519.60
-281.44
31.77
-241.38
-9.99
166.35
24924.2
-372.91
4.65
725.02
321.19
-68.36
731.17
309.25
-70.17
775.27
-61.98
357.14
768.67
378.91
-88.22
696.14
303.69
-127.52
640.24
247.27
-91.16
619.49
289.63
-26.13
714.48
336.72
-76.90
686.44
369.90
-51.53

558.99
1033.44
712.28
662.22
400.38
527.32
182.79
497.55
128.92
580.73
-313.98
31.08
-266.21
-13.45
156.89
25004.1
-395.79
-0.52
807.54
359.51
-78.25
814.24
347.98
-78.51
858.09
-71.08
396.13
858.66
419.68
-104.39
787.13
344.40
-144.32
720.38
281.83
-104.74
706.05
333.45
-29.19
798.85
381.20
-86.91
770.29
410.52
-57.98

TABLE E-14. CVP2, AIR 1, LOAD CONDITION 1b


Load Step
0.00
1.00
Pressure
0.05
0.04
Frame-1
30.80
31.64
Frame-2
113.96 -52.03
Frame-3
110.58 137.17
Frame-4
318.37 258.88
Frame-5
-8.62
54.33
Frame-6
165.56 186.81
Frame-7
-137.57 31.69
Frame-8
-91.85 -12.21
Frame-9
69.47
0.12
Frame-10
21.36
47.64
Frame-11
-72.18 39.98
Frame-12
67.57
52.45
Hoop-1
-20.11 -23.79
Hoop-2
45.14
23.46
Hoop-3
-13.62 16.20
Hoop-4
33.14 -100.07
Hoop-5
-14.40 180.78
Hoop-6
-80.90 129.72
Hoop-7
-143.71 312.84
Hoop-8
66.43
22.28
Hoop-9
70.17
99.17
Hoop-10
-113.31 123.31
Hoop-11
41.20
30.14
Hoop-12
-50.77 23.26
Hoop-13
-43.72 -36.30
Hoop-14
60.66
53.25
Long-1
2.01
486.17
Long-2
-35.10 478.93
Long-3
-69.87 443.37
Long-4
31.12 423.86
Long-5
329.67 694.02
Long-6
41.94 412.31
Long-7
101.66 450.17
Long-8
2.97
436.23
SG1
54.82 120.80
SG2
13.27
12.07
SG3
91.10 155.85
SG4
13.13
12.30
SG5
11.15
31.22
SG6
21.63
16.66
SG7
####### #######
SG8
-54.20 -53.45
SG9
37.45
88.03
SG10
4.45
-1.63

2.00
0.06
-3.97
-352.04
-28.76
-56.04
22.11
83.71
-18.82
-36.87
31.01
10.93
8.91
34.61
-1.73
19.85
116.18
92.35
-50.89
-34.71
-140.07
7.56
-35.01
119.69
177.52
63.96
30.42
-50.34
922.86
950.42
935.48
952.42
1060.84
953.81
948.92
950.73
132.41
8.57
117.47
5.53
0.60
10.76
#######
-59.34
56.28
-7.91

3.00
0.09
21.04
45.09
-177.19
475.83
197.28
-17.35
90.52
-39.50
14.45
-5.48
63.78
-14.71
-29.30
34.30
-57.48
-113.02
350.43
-18.09
-132.77
117.92
-15.07
31.20
37.51
-30.41
-36.30
-35.55
1396.48
1403.83
1423.99
1416.28
1527.31
1402.55
1403.35
1384.13
114.71
5.53
61.57
-3.63
-16.67
3.21
#######
-60.82
6.62
-15.84

4.00
0.11
-1.95
6.29
74.47
-86.77
-70.74
87.28
-63.56
-62.65
-5.47
112.55
22.33
81.38
51.56
7.20
-59.23
-0.16
-34.47
9.63
318.32
-21.86
445.48
-75.36
-39.86
-58.17
-43.71
260.41
1869.01
1913.23
1831.81
1842.29
2032.24
1814.71
1841.05
1832.38
143.27
4.84
72.08
-9.67
15.01
0.81
#######
-65.23
23.05
-20.27

5.00
0.12
0.32
-34.85
66.44
56.87
100.62
-12.39
-71.45
-36.11
1090.86
34.07
38.25
-26.85
14.80
-72.31
137.22
-63.06
166.17
22.56
13.33
73.78
200.72
-109.68
63.31
8.45
0.77
-28.15
2334.05
2349.33
2354.85
2323.00
2450.44
2374.42
2340.87
2338.13
134.25
2.99
60.65
-13.54
-9.58
-6.93
#######
-65.97
6.80
-25.07

E-24

6.00
0.11
-5.13
56.95
105.63
-79.60
3.71
-70.38
-49.43
-65.75
-123.76
-30.01
26.06
-87.76
-32.97
59.59
-34.67
-81.55
-1.64
-77.19
157.58
-36.58
122.75
-97.04
-28.81
1.05
-21.48
260.44
2764.85
2794.13
2787.35
2779.41
2964.75
2787.62
2820.45
2786.20
150.65
0.14
44.23
-20.91
-24.86
-14.85
#######
-68.91
-5.93
-32.63

7.00
0.10
-12.35
60.08
69.26
-57.53
-38.03
71.95
57.03
-2.38
-47.35
-7.96
-26.69
-101.93
-9.08
9.00
-106.60
-111.17
144.30
-21.78
-156.51
-21.86
-24.14
-22.98
89.09
-56.32
8.18
-42.94
3188.85
3257.49
3281.07
3281.44
3459.03
3285.50
3279.92
3297.39
153.59
-2.81
42.20
-26.25
-28.36
-21.29
#######
-72.59
-7.04
-38.35

8.00
0.10
4.19
-555.74
-103.02
-37.52
-12.83
-42.47
-15.29
32.07
60.81
69.54
-8.03
3.58
-16.43
131.85
151.24
-138.90
-50.88
-1.46
-74.31
22.28
-15.07
25.78
-104.34
60.26
67.49
23.65
3448.78
3724.21
3723.55
3737.90
3787.56
3725.64
3730.69
3744.28
171.85
-4.10
35.56
-30.40
-24.17
-27.19
######
-76.27
-25.50
-46.65

9.00
0.10
3.06
56.51
-14.91
7.89
-34.67
2.24
-51.58
83.60
-33.48
62.55
-6.47
25.96
0.10
28.88
81.09
-88.96
-38.11
-128.93
-21.36
-7.15
256.96
51.07
85.42
-21.16
-80.80
201.26
3862.63
4169.85
4161.89
4242.89
4218.77
4227.70
4203.89
4273.22
202.97
-5.16
41.65
-36.98
0.05
-31.24
#######
-79.21
-9.62
-51.08

10.00
0.09
8.33
1125.26
-86.88
16.62
-56.99
80.49
-34.16
68.30
80.09
81.68
-28.25
-8.44
14.80
77.66
-64.49
158.94
-83.71
65.05
-161.97
-7.15
322.22
-77.17
89.10
-69.28
-43.72
16.25
4370.57
4558.75
4804.42
4687.07
4747.48
4715.47
4678.66
4707.75
216.45
-7.47
47.74
-41.08
-9.99
-38.25
#######
-83.64
-15.35
-58.83

TABLE E-14. CVP2, AIR 1, LOAD CONDITION 1b (Continued)


SG11
SG12
SG13
SG14
SG15
SG16
SG17
SG18
SG19
SG20
SG21
SG22
SG23
SG24
SG25
SG26
SG27
SG28
SG29T
SG29-45
SG29L
SG30T
SG30-45
SG30L
SG31T
SG31-45
SG31L
SG32T
SG32-45
SG32L
SG33T
SG33-45
SG33L
SG34T
SG34-45
SG34L
SG35T
SG35-45
SG35L
SG36T
SG36-45
SG36L
SG37T
SG37-45
SG37L

6.59
30.94
39.41
27.15
-35.47
-11.02
-389.98
0.22
-356.94
27.88
22.02
50.98
-38.26
26.68
225.42
25112.5
-147.77
33.49
12.41
29.22
21.52
18.89
-0.99
3.06
21.99
30.86
30.42
5.87
42.38
30.98
-3.99
10.86
8.14
13.25
-16.94
16.68
6.83
22.28
23.60
-2.76
-19.85
0.08
-64.11
22.09
17.52

27.40
26.97
123.83
26.09
-17.41
-16.46
-399.96
-6.52
-323.29
30.83
47.18
75.72
-6.43
61.46
252.88
25048.2
-113.90
72.66
-9.20
40.53
56.40
5.30
12.43
44.56
14.40
60.91
48.19
-8.03
65.01
70.05
-15.24
25.25
40.56
4.73
-12.34
39.07
-5.31
49.87
64.64
-16.01
4.43
36.02
-74.80
36.68
48.03

-1.95
17.87
65.71
19.04
-25.60
-21.29
-394.79
-4.58
-327.68
29.72
74.38
102.81
27.14
94.86
281.01
25101.2
-86.41
103.71
-23.94
52.17
88.31
-6.94
16.33
78.89
9.55
91.00
50.28
-18.59
63.52
104.78
-30.82
29.48
76.19
-24.08
-16.10
73.89
-15.59
49.18
96.84
-24.06
4.34
61.80
-84.29
36.68
78.67

-25.75
8.87
71.33
16.14
-48.91
-30.13
-405.82
-8.79
-315.70
32.49
105.65
138.59
65.42
138.41
314.67
25101.2
-53.98
141.42
-42.02
69.09
124.91
-25.11
37.49
123.40
-1.43
130.43
57.82
-33.88
71.50
150.76
-44.32
38.63
115.09
-41.76
-13.32
106.62
-31.26
63.85
140.99
-38.98
22.61
98.16
-93.88
45.78
118.88

3.45
5.03
77.26
11.94
-26.34
-23.22
-401.39
-11.42
-323.44
25.65
135.61
174.95
104.33
182.49
348.47
25107.5
-16.38
185.76
-57.68
93.24
163.91
-39.35
58.42
168.94
-10.51
170.68
72.60
-47.97
89.48
197.12
-59.70
53.16
154.57
-57.31
-12.62
138.40
-43.81
83.87
185.68
-47.30
38.27
138.43
-105.59
58.74
160.01

-15.23
-3.78
83.58
10.29
-34.72
-27.00
-399.64
-12.34
-312.93
28.61
161.16
198.70
134.27
212.59
373.78
25051.2
11.20
214.61
-74.42
102.57
198.53
-50.00
66.18
200.97
-22.80
196.89
81.35
-55.88
100.81
229.10
-71.19
58.88
188.92
-77.28
-9.51
173.24
-52.69
93.35
216.65
-56.09
45.36
163.99
-109.46
71.52
186.95

E-25

-26.17
-12.74
72.34
4.11
-33.76
-29.90
-408.13
-17.65
-329.20
19.18
192.43
230.69
172.78
254.11
406.97
25010.0
47.65
255.27
-89.90
123.95
234.39
-65.42
85.63
242.28
-33.55
234.36
98.70
-74.43
116.58
274.49
-90.34
68.31
230.51
-99.48
-6.59
210.02
-68.22
111.14
261.40
-71.25
57.20
202.73
-123.37
86.53
224.66

-31.06
-21.42
87.67
0.98
-30.39
-31.65
-409.24
-20.93
-324.50
18.07
217.75
253.97
203.43
285.26
433.68
25001.6
77.49
287.03
-107.08
133.25
271.20
-77.69
92.44
276.63
-42.72
261.04
103.90
-84.56
123.43
308.01
-102.95
76.94
264.21
-116.74
-4.36
242.59
-77.93
118.47
294.97
-80.87
64.56
232.03
-131.68
92.05
251.56

-25.34
-28.95
94.26
-3.81
-59.97
-45.10
-406.79
-23.94
-322.82
15.12
242.57
283.08
235.59
320.17
461.57
25077.6
107.66
321.06
-120.16
149.17
305.50
-91.24
97.09
311.88
-49.66
293.58
114.09
-99.17
130.86
345.73
-116.65
84.43
299.64
-134.44
-4.36
276.27
-89.52
128.14
331.44
-92.13
69.60
261.47
-144.91
98.29
284.04

4.79
-34.44
120.18
-7.82
-42.41
-41.60
-387.41
-22.55
-312.62
14.38
270.11
311.35
269.00
356.30
490.07
25033.9
138.55
354.30
-135.16
160.98
340.34
-104.28
110.60
351.30
-57.29
326.23
119.58
-111.49
138.47
384.80
-128.79
94.18
334.48
-149.01
-1.39
309.47
-99.79
139.85
369.55
-101.15
80.04
293.87
-156.77
101.35
317.10

-14.82
-44.28
143.03
-10.86
-60.34
-52.38
-407.76
-30.40
-308.58
11.98
297.33
339.82
302.83
392.13
519.76
25092.3
171.36
388.34
-152.00
169.99
375.36
-119.13
119.33
389.54
-68.97
358.13
128.88
-124.79
149.78
423.68
-141.87
108.07
370.77
-164.92
3.48
343.50
-111.70
153.78
406.21
-112.82
93.04
325.52
-166.63
111.20
349.19

TABLE E-15. CVP2, AIR 1, LOAD CONDITION 1c


Load Step
0.00
1.00
Pressure
-0.05
1.02
Frame-1
-14.47 214.70
Frame-2
12.52 248.90
Frame-3
-28.86 195.42
Frame-4
9.28
225.07
Frame-5
56.42 206.97
Frame-6
-87.68 256.23
Frame-7
30.53 289.12
Frame-8
-58.12 184.71
Frame-9
-139.09 198.49
Frame-10
10.32 217.08
Frame-11
40.81 239.07
Frame-12
-24.89 244.16
Hoop-1
7.46
885.73
Hoop-2
-70.51 912.33
Hoop-3
-41.69 917.65
Hoop-4
234.82 954.37
Hoop-5
-74.60 904.80
Hoop-6
-114.16 922.16
Hoop-7
46.21 975.59
Hoop-8
29.64 838.88
Hoop-9
-25.95 862.61
Hoop-10
-71.75 860.23
Hoop-11
-93.30 757.89
Hoop-12
217.57 869.00
Hoop-13
-80.79 846.00
Hoop-14
53.25 874.60
Long-1
175.30 594.16
Long-2
25.68 459.49
Long-3
30.81 448.34
Long-4
-21.50 404.29
Long-5
347.65 636.48
Long-6
136.08 433.09
Long-7
118.49 454.97
Long-8
-4.41 431.31
SG1
98.86
66.62
SG2
21.33
70.51
SG3
165.81 102.54
SG4
23.45
71.32
SG5
48.95
21.09
SG6
24.58
81.70
SG7
####### #######
SG8
-46.83 10.59
SG9
94.86
26.19
SG10
9.07
64.98

2.00
2.01
418.54
360.56
411.67
422.39
427.01
425.93
439.73
422.92
409.06
420.94
434.73
422.02
1762.34
1779.70
1766.68
1762.93
1787.70
1781.31
1813.86
1780.55
1783.80
1792.20
1802.54
1846.14
1772.79
1784.75
934.92
940.89
923.23
958.73
953.14
936.88
931.08
922.60
107.71
124.78
115.44
120.37
45.17
135.86
#######
65.06
43.36
119.03

3.00
3.03
622.91
632.65
630.15
632.31
642.42
628.35
622.01
623.92
625.60
627.18
620.80
631.69
2666.42
2645.18
2675.24
2663.90
2675.98
2658.83
2664.82
2670.19
2655.51
2662.24
2656.88
2667.29
2654.56
2679.57
1404.93
1394.24
1420.40
1394.39
1412.36
1400.25
1390.27
1397.81
224.37
182.84
204.00
174.54
114.38
194.26
#######
120.27
129.93
176.59

4.00
4.04
840.60
822.60
825.86
853.84
829.76
859.21
848.42
829.44
785.65
836.22
850.25
832.07
3544.78
3564.86
3564.52
3570.42
3582.51
3547.44
3543.18
3560.54
3569.63
3489.64
3557.99
3548.38
3551.87
3575.10
1885.63
1884.06
1867.86
1872.88
1899.15
1858.72
1857.87
1911.17
372.15
245.12
347.12
233.38
236.55
258.90
#######
179.87
262.82
236.53

5.00
5.06
1028.35
1025.80
1048.39
1040.24
1042.32
1038.47
1030.79
1032.24
1030.19
1028.77
1039.79
1036.64
4444.75
4437.12
4435.81
4439.50
4428.40
4430.07
4424.74
4466.23
4433.60
4442.28
4404.45
4422.68
4375.65
4582.26
2318.62
2305.58
2287.74
2316.88
2308.97
2324.30
2358.90
2333.21
423.23
300.35
381.84
284.63
282.11
319.54
#######
235.84
304.38
290.24

E-26

6.00
6.05
1257.24
1253.10
1246.69
1240.22
1252.96
1254.93
1249.58
1228.43
1217.37
1266.35
1251.65
1255.29
5325.92
5310.80
5354.12
5324.80
5334.07
5334.43
5335.11
5312.35
5271.46
5303.90
5294.42
5311.07
5324.77
5322.29
2800.73
2789.55
2767.74
2785.81
2782.80
2801.35
2806.30
2791.41
522.57
359.01
474.27
340.55
367.94
385.13
#######
291.04
391.33
346.33

7.00
7.06
1459.70
1471.12
1466.70
1449.95
1459.55
1445.30
1483.25
1461.85
1452.79
1446.47
1478.07
1466.40
6215.99
6211.26
6200.15
6206.12
6248.56
6208.96
6272.56
6201.99
6192.13
6206.45
6198.51
6191.45
6199.13
6209.71
3269.56
3262.35
3264.91
3247.17
3289.98
3270.83
3289.53
3262.92
576.81
415.27
512.14
394.02
410.99
448.00
#######
349.97
429.40
400.06

8.00
8.09
1680.62
1666.10
1682.78
1676.44
1667.38
1687.78
1645.47
1692.72
1668.23
1648.16
1717.19
1683.62
7125.09
7114.20
7118.81
7104.72
7127.23
7134.00
7022.59
7114.23
7091.57
7058.96
7357.38
7131.58
7162.99
7393.65
3775.18
3687.75
3903.77
3715.87
3749.19
3735.42
3770.36
3750.43
706.69
477.52
603.04
451.14
469.33
511.15
#######
404.41
522.21
458.51

9.00
9.08
1847.43
1834.20
1844.98
1860.83
1865.85
1878.74
1848.65
1888.79
1820.41
1976.89
1866.33
1864.11
7946.81
7969.14
7962.73
7991.23
7926.46
7961.99
7976.14
7974.98
7874.95
7969.26
7956.17
7975.47
7897.01
7896.82
4175.94
4172.28
4145.73
4158.46
4199.59
4198.36
4184.66
4198.13
752.76
530.98
658.01
505.78
525.60
574.34
#######
460.35
566.88
509.80

10.00
10.09
2091.14
2208.53
2107.81
2096.33
2075.80
2097.90
2104.01
2083.64
2074.30
2066.78
2078.55
2121.21
8888.38
8844.41
8903.69
8852.22
8892.10
8875.34
8895.42
8910.18
8969.31
8880.46
8817.45
8849.86
8846.92
8867.05
4672.95
4655.69
4700.96
4662.31
4662.09
4646.72
4660.36
4666.83
866.66
590.70
753.02
562.89
625.47
640.67
#######
522.18
669.33
569.58

TABLE E-15. CVP2, AIR 1, LOAD CONDITION 1c (Continued)


SG11
SG12
SG13
SG14
SG15
SG16
SG17
SG18
SG19
SG20
SG21
SG22
SG23
SG24
SG25
SG26
SG27
SG28
SG29T
SG29-45
SG29L
SG30T
SG30-45
SG30L
SG31T
SG31-45
SG31L
SG32T
SG32-45
SG32L
SG33T
SG33-45
SG33L
SG34T
SG34-45
SG34L
SG35T
SG35-45
SG35L
SG36T
SG36-45
SG36L
SG37T
SG37-45
SG37L

57.53
38.00
122.36
34.75
-38.59
-20.65
-371.07
-1.17
-330.92
29.91
15.73
42.39
-40.51
25.11
233.04
25115.9
-135.01
55.66
0.93
31.07
25.89
11.79
7.46
9.48
12.72
24.87
41.03
-6.91
67.05
38.48
-15.71
2.40
9.25
7.62
-31.98
15.74
-21.58
28.55
49.12
-15.83
-26.24
-1.46
-66.94
35.00
10.83

-12.97
121.90
16.98
95.43
-48.27
18.14
-410.29
26.46
-353.47
62.07
8.33
68.48
-28.07
51.64
252.68
25186.1
-143.94
83.02
64.94
61.26
37.04
73.26
41.49
32.87
97.26
42.52
69.54
68.23
95.07
54.86
33.04
34.55
18.99
35.09
-6.63
26.59
10.55
40.40
56.23
54.62
25.04
21.66
11.63
65.68
32.01

16.97
201.86
22.00
150.93
-15.52
69.03
-364.88
68.58
-330.31
111.05
4.63
92.98
-11.78
83.98
275.35
25071.7
-140.37
114.06
130.71
105.40
62.95
133.55
79.46
63.70
177.32
64.34
113.02
137.37
135.13
81.89
86.50
69.38
44.56
82.19
30.45
50.66
56.25
70.82
77.88
121.11
77.75
47.35
81.96
106.84
56.71

82.08
283.44
114.62
211.00
41.55
124.12
-296.02
118.27
-265.71
169.09
-3.14
121.65
-0.39
119.96
293.07
25060.0
-140.83
141.42
203.04
158.77
86.55
203.79
126.62
93.88
249.56
88.49
157.72
211.40
182.61
110.11
151.15
115.04
69.90
142.28
65.08
73.47
115.30
109.89
104.42
193.83
127.63
69.12
156.81
154.32
83.83

200.04
373.81
261.78
273.02
112.29
180.43
-207.75
169.61
-184.59
228.77
-11.47
150.21
7.77
154.26
310.81
25010.4
-139.62
173.93
273.71
214.63
114.87
274.48
176.54
124.66
319.35
112.30
205.74
286.60
234.72
135.55
220.02
164.58
93.46
206.26
101.27
94.79
178.89
155.44
131.92
265.55
180.93
91.86
231.36
206.02
110.10

239.65
466.74
334.03
329.07
150.86
232.22
-157.05
216.37
-140.03
280.74
-13.69
177.83
21.51
188.05
334.92
25010.0
-130.02
205.00
345.51
271.45
136.85
342.88
230.54
154.81
394.61
137.16
254.09
360.47
282.41
162.21
289.45
211.23
116.39
270.84
139.20
117.93
243.26
203.02
168.04
334.53
230.78
116.48
303.25
254.54
137.18

E-27

316.47
563.70
438.16
388.50
210.23
287.35
-79.83
268.28
-70.85
338.96
-20.35
203.87
28.85
218.13
354.44
25048.2
-123.92
229.39
416.76
325.38
164.02
413.60
279.37
183.34
467.08
158.29
298.60
436.92
329.71
182.73
363.90
259.54
133.81
338.89
179.72
136.93
313.15
252.63
196.95
406.79
282.80
136.20
376.84
300.59
160.44

348.81
661.46
508.03
445.43
241.90
336.99
-31.97
315.61
-25.16
392.79
-20.35
230.94
43.24
249.70
377.45
25150.8
-112.94
258.25
490.16
379.44
189.73
485.01
330.00
212.59
545.25
182.14
348.16
514.34
378.72
207.42
440.74
310.98
153.02
408.70
222.35
157.34
385.12
306.17
231.78
478.86
335.74
159.39
450.48
348.95
186.23

407.09
759.79
566.74
502.10
307.65
394.07
40.87
367.31
29.22
448.76
-19.24
258.02
56.38
282.53
397.30
25192.4
-103.46
284.10
563.46
434.39
215.53
556.33
382.84
242.33
620.23
206.41
401.43
591.85
431.55
231.47
517.54
362.65
175.08
477.97
263.68
180.41
457.80
360.21
263.22
552.00
390.94
179.46
523.19
401.60
212.12

453.05
852.82
652.22
558.67
351.46
445.29
106.87
416.82
81.75
502.18
-27.56
281.79
60.71
307.62
412.45
25239.4
-99.21
304.06
635.46
487.21
238.71
627.27
425.87
263.78
690.38
224.29
445.57
668.85
477.93
248.05
594.81
411.05
191.48
548.02
305.50
198.43
531.22
404.99
288.50
624.21
433.45
194.57
595.01
448.34
231.67

542.93
951.16
764.41
619.89
418.85
503.65
178.45
466.52
153.89
561.32
-29.41
308.33
70.91
337.33
429.85
25110.0
-91.26
329.93
708.81
542.67
264.16
698.73
476.69
291.37
765.69
246.49
488.54
747.39
523.19
270.15
673.39
458.15
209.88
620.02
346.11
217.19
606.97
454.41
316.71
698.04
483.93
215.36
668.51
490.58
255.77

TABLE E-16. CVP2, AIR 2, LOAD CONDITION 1a


Load Step
0.00
1.00
Pressure
-0.03
1.01
Frame-1
0.99
183.22
Frame-2
-55.26 246.67
Frame-3
-42.64 200.10
Frame-4
45.45 210.80
Frame-5
49.48 228.92
Frame-6
-23.24 281.25
Frame-7
-3.83 250.68
Frame-8
-2.94 211.71
Frame-9
30.27 276.42
Frame-10
-99.78 221.70
Frame-11
-23.46 201.33
Frame-12
-9.21 209.01
Hoop-1
35.02 883.98
Hoop-2
-41.59 888.93
Hoop-3
88.11 942.30
Hoop-4
-61.21 904.51
Hoop-5
20.25 839.22
Hoop-6
63.20 861.29
Hoop-7
-132.76 882.55
Hoop-8
103.20 831.53
Hoop-9
-38.64 855.35
Hoop-10
31.20 889.12
Hoop-11
-61.98 1032.41
Hoop-12
-74.83 992.99
Hoop-13
-58.55 801.51
Hoop-14
112.45 1030.00
Long-1
44.74 134.93
Long-2
70.65
19.60
Long-3
-12.69 -12.69
Long-4
40.91
16.43
Long-5
335.66 348.82
Long-6
82.29
16.26
Long-7
111.27 113.67
Long-8
-1.95
58.37
SG1
152.14 32.33
SG2
18.94
69.17
SG3
211.95 86.12
SG4
21.43
71.50
SG5
48.91
9.44
SG6
21.63
86.31
SG7
####### #######
SG8
-49.04 10.59
SG9
138.25 21.39
SG10
7.96
70.70

2.00
2.02
405.19
303.66
417.24
398.68
510.25
382.18
381.55
430.19
409.47
469.54
416.46
432.79
1773.54
1750.97
1761.59
1761.26
1780.58
1768.55
1810.39
1802.80
1890.98
1781.54
1880.10
1787.10
1780.38
1762.73
18.63
65.79
42.00
-15.38
316.51
-46.09
116.09
4.20
44.32
125.03
113.80
127.84
63.50
149.14
#######
67.27
41.51
130.67

3.00
3.06
629.21
625.16
631.26
631.73
622.86
634.49
543.58
610.96
554.98
617.66
618.10
646.37
2675.88
2685.20
2719.37
2697.47
2723.68
2649.86
2701.62
2619.49
2643.61
2657.62
2633.72
2668.09
2647.94
2665.57
10.32
-18.08
-40.04
-17.83
300.89
89.62
111.27
-6.88
105.14
185.21
154.20
188.70
88.23
213.63
#######
130.59
80.47
194.69

4.00
4.07
820.09
848.88
836.31
836.77
857.53
842.32
882.85
825.97
848.50
839.64
843.37
847.63
3572.35
3563.05
3596.09
3566.72
3562.44
3565.92
3570.57
3561.25
3626.56
3568.01
3571.60
3556.49
3530.33
3575.81
-2.74
-4.71
-31.34
-14.16
242.14
67.61
111.27
-31.50
182.94
244.41
256.81
248.98
202.91
282.20
#######
193.92
182.21
258.01

5.00
5.06
1057.72
1045.00
1053.62
1059.29
1054.49
1050.44
1136.12
1049.72
1098.49
1042.80
1046.82
1036.90
4451.15
4447.04
4487.56
4425.59
4454.82
4453.12
4427.45
4443.71
4440.41
4450.87
4424.28
4429.64
4449.35
4522.60
7.94
6.23
85.49
23.78
332.03
39.49
113.67
11.59
290.57
306.32
367.30
309.39
300.19
351.27
#######
253.53
290.01
321.09

E-28

6.00
6.07
1264.62
1262.30
1262.61
1242.43
1282.78
1257.07
1215.60
1258.16
1216.14
1347.74
1248.67
1252.32
5349.81
5336.10
5340.09
5356.25
5332.25
5327.04
5331.46
5327.60
5315.52
5326.11
5333.65
5326.41
5288.23
5300.62
-1.55
41.48
2.22
25.00
334.46
30.94
120.89
-6.88
390.84
368.58
475.42
372.55
387.41
423.68
#######
316.10
384.17
382.35

7.00
7.10
1471.92
1457.44
1458.25
1460.46
1470.07
1447.06
1454.24
1465.56
1451.41
1457.08
1468.08
1452.87
6220.91
6232.38
6231.21
6231.41
6220.62
6224.98
6215.38
6238.77
6282.80
6228.13
6274.05
6228.46
6258.44
6209.71
2.01
3.80
9.68
-12.94
350.09
-16.75
125.71
-9.34
492.77
433.15
565.64
434.05
483.47
497.38
#######
379.42
482.20
447.67

8.00
8.07
1684.41
1718.54
1676.27
1657.82
1709.12
1662.70
1683.31
1672.01
1666.38
1670.49
1681.65
1674.90
7086.49
7094.33
7083.73
7093.62
7083.45
7100.75
7141.30
7122.30
7108.60
7103.02
7245.72
7110.08
7104.39
7179.78
2.01
-15.65
90.47
9.09
366.84
103.07
144.93
2.97
581.79
493.79
647.75
494.03
570.32
568.32
#######
438.31
555.86
506.53

9.00
9.11
1872.50
1878.65
1892.26
1873.86
1878.90
1876.23
1863.67
1893.47
1888.01
1859.32
1870.86
1870.56
7975.17
7978.97
7968.79
8056.78
7991.09
7968.32
8009.81
7969.21
7976.28
7985.31
7937.49
7984.47
7980.16
8039.02
15.07
-10.79
27.08
9.09
400.41
0.37
160.56
11.59
635.36
554.38
701.18
554.05
623.99
638.64
#######
500.10
606.39
566.44

10.00
10.11
2107.76
2114.13
2108.91
2116.42
2097.64
2087.05
2086.10
2095.00
2094.59
2083.31
2121.79
2098.05
8912.28
8905.85
8894.92
8907.73
8893.92
8890.12
8884.46
8880.75
8916.72
8887.68
9088.31
8864.66
8884.00
8830.05
5.57
-8.36
25.84
-5.59
365.67
7.71
173.80
18.98
773.12
621.72
837.78
620.44
745.26
714.62
#######
560.52
741.77
633.48

TABLE E-16. CVP2, AIR 2, LOAD CONDITION 1a (Continued)


SG11
SG12
SG13
SG14
SG15
SG16
SG17
SG18
SG19
SG20
SG21
SG22
SG23
SG24
SG25
SG26
SG27
SG28
SG29T
SG29-45
SG29L
SG30T
SG30-45
SG30L
SG31T
SG31-45
SG31L
SG32T
SG32-45
SG32L
SG33T
SG33-45
SG33L
SG34T
SG34-45
SG34L
SG35T
SG35-45
SG35L
SG36T
SG36-45
SG36L
SG37T
SG37-45
SG37L

59.75
33.52
142.96
33.32
-19.30
-16.87
-365.61
-4.03
-321.38
28.98
15.92
46.45
-35.35
31.94
218.42
24168.1
-144.54
62.32
2.51
36.73
29.56
13.14
-0.66
8.58
8.44
31.79
36.75
-8.68
61.49
38.28
-15.90
6.02
14.10
10.83
-23.07
17.51
-7.68
24.93
32.34
-14.57
-20.46
-0.34
-73.70
27.85
17.01

-18.79
129.38
3.26
97.87
-45.65
25.83
-400.78
28.03
-362.49
58.93
-9.62
40.59
-48.64
23.22
214.83
24168.1
-181.59
54.93
72.57
43.73
8.14
77.51
20.46
-3.73
107.46
15.63
62.71
73.02
81.15
21.51
36.29
35.15
-2.86
43.14
-1.62
3.31
27.47
18.38
0.88
62.06
14.41
-10.04
11.40
53.97
3.82

37.46
219.61
76.03
163.01
-18.84
77.65
-346.27
73.43
-286.41
127.88
-45.89
37.45
-71.97
18.56
206.04
24168.1
-214.54
50.49
151.46
70.72
2.66
153.97
46.41
-10.94
195.30
3.74
97.50
156.26
116.22
8.28
107.68
63.90
-19.91
110.45
23.91
-12.75
83.46
38.91
-18.27
143.91
60.28
-20.02
95.28
90.44
-4.77

56.52
311.27
89.71
224.52
10.51
127.95
-303.94
121.61
-284.56
168.00
-82.15
37.77
-94.94
16.53
199.41
24103.3
-243.18
48.27
238.43
109.45
-12.81
238.71
87.08
-21.60
279.94
-4.67
136.43
243.64
157.22
-2.37
184.11
98.23
-32.25
180.93
58.12
-22.25
150.98
65.02
-27.19
226.07
99.06
-27.06
183.67
134.26
-10.48

170.24
410.59
230.72
289.92
69.34
183.71
-222.12
173.73
-204.44
230.50
-113.07
38.84
-115.48
17.23
194.27
23949.8
-267.37
49.76
316.94
144.89
-19.78
316.46
120.84
-24.90
362.56
-10.85
171.29
326.78
192.11
-11.65
261.37
129.83
-43.95
254.74
87.88
-33.57
221.08
95.46
-31.20
303.86
139.12
-31.21
265.25
171.22
-13.92

256.98
512.32
324.99
352.51
134.29
243.25
-145.24
227.85
-146.70
287.60
-145.07
40.87
-138.44
16.12
189.00
23932.7
-289.57
46.79
395.89
178.59
-26.79
396.21
157.82
-28.96
441.11
-17.63
203.60
411.57
227.90
-24.08
342.52
163.45
-58.53
328.49
117.77
-45.67
295.88
129.46
-33.98
383.16
181.53
-37.08
347.85
207.31
-18.14

E-29

341.61
618.66
430.28
416.08
191.73
300.56
-53.57
283.09
-68.27
351.93
-181.89
37.91
-167.59
8.83
177.91
23847.4
-318.44
38.66
477.10
213.28
-36.36
479.87
191.48
-41.55
522.95
-30.17
242.44
500.25
267.04
-42.83
428.46
198.24
-78.42
405.72
151.84
-59.68
375.45
166.62
-41.32
465.70
222.18
-49.02
433.13
249.60
-28.40

425.04
728.19
525.35
481.60
263.28
364.22
18.48
337.97
-12.03
410.17
-213.90
36.80
-191.57
3.89
169.11
23915.0
-343.34
32.01
559.38
249.22
-47.74
562.97
231.17
-50.13
607.95
-39.69
278.07
588.65
302.85
-59.01
516.51
234.80
-97.01
483.74
184.24
-73.00
457.80
203.41
-45.04
548.52
263.48
-60.07
516.91
286.35
-35.18

494.63
833.74
605.12
542.46
300.17
414.89
72.91
387.85
45.69
468.21
-242.77
37.22
-211.40
2.56
164.18
23879.7
-361.50
28.31
637.95
281.49
-57.91
642.10
266.08
-56.03
688.82
-46.24
313.74
673.06
339.39
-69.67
600.56
273.92
-109.82
558.69
219.79
-82.73
537.65
241.13
-44.67
626.50
304.09
-65.43
597.31
323.39
-39.41

534.81
939.44
651.30
603.35
342.29
469.66
123.35
439.17
77.50
518.44
-274.38
38.55
-234.58
-2.15
155.65
23868.5
-382.99
18.70
721.04
320.46
-69.47
726.57
305.32
-66.07
772.91
-54.50
351.99
763.61
377.20
-86.83
691.32
311.46
-126.90
638.69
250.59
-97.06
624.64
280.87
-50.75
711.62
344.37
-78.29
680.98
363.22
-45.21

645.24
1047.54
768.73
669.16
432.43
535.39
220.71
497.05
149.10
580.05
-309.94
33.66
-264.26
-10.41
141.03
23797.3
-412.23
8.35
801.86
351.47
-79.98
809.27
334.88
-78.80
856.55
-67.88
384.91
853.16
411.74
-106.77
780.62
350.10
-144.85
717.84
284.41
-110.30
710.17
314.16
-59.17
795.21
378.86
-92.38
764.79
397.74
-56.31

TABLE E-17. CVP2, AIR 2, LOAD CONDITION 1b


Load Step
0.00
1.00
Pressure
-0.06
0.02
Frame-1
43.75 -21.47
Frame-2
-19.11
0.37
Frame-3
-15.45 43.07
Frame-4
-37.60 -4.60
Frame-5
-78.49 -29.93
Frame-6
-81.20 -23.45
Frame-7
43.93
42.22
Frame-8
62.01 -61.94
Frame-9
-45.28 22.97
Frame-10
66.77
65.06
Frame-11
20.16 -56.24
Frame-12
-30.46 37.07
Hoop-1
-67.89 58.91
Hoop-2
-81.34 27.07
Hoop-3
-57.47 -43.45
Hoop-4
245.90 240.37
Hoop-5
-76.42 100.52
Hoop-6
44.73 159.28
Hoop-7
33.42 -138.25
Hoop-8
-21.86 -51.29
Hoop-9
374.77 342.17
Hoop-10
-102.45 -41.05
Hoop-11
48.56
30.14
Hoop-12
112.08 169.46
Hoop-13
-36.30 156.47
Hoop-14
-5.95 -57.74
Long-1
-30.04 468.46
Long-2
-38.75 463.23
Long-3
7.20
475.78
Long-4
2.97
470.45
Long-5
270.95 724.14
Long-6
-42.42 477.19
Long-7
101.67 485.12
Long-8
5.44
470.79
SG1
126.89 132.03
SG2
19.45
18.48
SG3
229.48 176.86
SG4
25.89
20.22
SG5
69.81
42.50
SG6
25.32
23.47
SG7
####### #######
SG8
-46.10 -47.56
SG9
149.33 104.82
SG10
9.99
6.11

2.00
-0.01
-19.89
-83.24
-34.28
43.52
23.40
61.41
54.44
-13.57
-22.32
-98.36
86.17
54.50
-32.97
220.40
-78.52
108.99
49.44
-73.51
139.33
-73.37
278.75
72.75
81.75
45.47
104.59
-5.95
958.75
950.71
958.13
958.83
1088.74
943.09
925.16
928.85
194.15
15.48
220.97
16.08
44.62
15.92
#######
-51.98
142.12
-1.45

3.00
0.00
-17.64
51.12
-33.76
-19.74
4.95
66.98
25.55
-21.78
-14.89
-10.15
-59.01
13.40
27.67
-56.05
-20.64
94.20
20.25
-29.17
9.68
-29.22
-54.98
117.92
262.34
199.11
0.77
-5.95
1421.41
1423.27
1432.69
1396.70
1510.52
1436.78
1397.34
1414.90
193.43
12.53
181.32
9.49
15.06
9.47
#######
-56.40
102.99
-8.65

4.00
-0.01
-9.05
1604.54
0.54
497.41
4.93
24.53
56.71
9.35
-13.02
58.88
-38.52
-81.58
-77.07
93.92
-43.44
-92.66
399.64
-31.02
163.07
88.49
-18.70
-50.08
13.56
54.72
149.05
-5.95
1914.31
1890.32
1874.26
1837.58
2028.84
1835.68
1836.42
1838.72
192.12
8.89
168.21
0.74
50.19
5.97
#######
-59.34
98.37
-15.10

5.00
0.01
-25.48
-43.67
20.20
-20.69
-4.63
-17.18
12.54
-38.23
-26.32
-107.53
-65.04
67.79
150.79
140.90
-78.52
34.99
120.57
-31.02
-161.97
-43.94
-15.07
121.52
302.85
4.75
297.37
-42.95
2331.90
2310.67
2331.47
2370.96
2438.69
2388.11
2379.57
2335.90
252.02
11.06
195.33
0.60
20.86
-1.03
#######
-63.02
116.64
-18.24

E-30

6.00
0.00
35.60
49.21
110.25
-28.51
30.67
85.53
-43.50
57.25
93.09
-67.12
50.85
27.07
27.67
-47.02
-43.45
-100.08
-16.23
168.54
42.56
-43.94
71.98
74.55
240.20
245.36
-103.04
-42.95
2819.10
2831.44
2785.70
2801.06
2939.26
2811.69
2811.67
2810.44
225.32
5.62
157.15
-9.90
31.45
-7.48
#######
-65.24
86.56
-27.47

7.00
0.00
5.71
10.37
87.33
-80.84
-59.65
3.41
44.39
19.42
-44.69
144.71
59.36
49.60
-60.54
52.37
145.99
-127.81
27.55
-69.81
-138.23
-29.22
97.37
49.27
-91.47
32.51
37.84
90.26
3205.47
3312.18
3295.98
3308.36
3496.20
3252.49
3297.95
3288.77
223.45
2.44
111.94
-20.26
20.40
-14.85
#######
-72.59
52.95
-34.48

8.00
0.00
7.17
55.29
-50.23
-25.94
-65.09
-27.42
11.05
-98.25
-31.34
-91.79
-30.93
-54.78
9.29
-72.31
-46.95
-125.97
-49.06
-18.09
276.32
22.28
48.40
-88.02
-102.52
-63.73
45.26
216.06
3736.01
3731.50
3660.16
3673.04
3953.02
3709.74
3727.09
3692.57
207.79
-1.11
82.97
-27.86
23.16
-22.22
#######
-74.07
22.50
-43.15

9.00
0.00
-7.61
5.63
84.35
-39.00
-17.78
66.68
21.80
-8.31
2.25
30.87
21.91
47.69
-58.70
70.43
-13.62
5.39
-118.37
-101.22
115.59
-51.29
44.78
128.74
-89.62
-39.67
-36.31
238.26
4113.45
4164.19
4180.95
4180.90
4437.41
4197.56
4194.69
4182.55
245.80
-1.38
101.81
-32.48
30.67
-26.46
#######
-78.50
45.76
-46.66

10.00
0.00
19.62
163.41
63.43
-66.92
-78.50
47.69
28.23
-60.42
12.23
-84.95
-19.13
-56.55
31.34
-21.71
21.46
-94.51
-50.88
-43.95
-90.76
-51.29
242.45
83.59
-50.93
-54.48
-36.31
275.26
4467.59
4573.03
4662.43
4703.92
4821.57
4704.19
4686.80
4701.31
261.44
-3.18
97.01
-38.00
26.85
-32.91
#######
-82.17
42.99
-52.56

TABLE E-17. CVP2, AIR 2, LOAD CONDITION 1b (Continued)


SG11
SG12
SG13
SG14
SG15
SG16
SG17
SG18
SG19
SG20
SG21
SG22
SG23
SG24
SG25
SG26
SG27
SG28
SG29T
SG29-45
SG29L
SG30T
SG30-45
SG30L
SG31T
SG31-45
SG31L
SG32T
SG32-45
SG32L
SG33T
SG33-45
SG33L
SG34T
SG34-45
SG34L
SG35T
SG35-45
SG35L
SG36T
SG36-45
SG36L
SG37T
SG37-45
SG37L

79.45
39.16
179.34
38.11
-19.20
-16.41
-368.43
-3.61
-320.96
28.43
10.37
36.57
-35.86
28.99
218.93
24591.7
-149.11
53.45
4.18
26.67
24.68
15.71
-6.65
4.48
11.05
23.94
37.87
-6.08
62.42
33.94
-13.60
4.26
9.11
14.18
-26.36
11.60
-6.85
22.51
28.58
-10.06
-25.78
-8.92
-69.88
29.43
8.42

43.50
36.98
119.58
35.80
-23.53
-17.79
-379.84
-3.75
-328.48
28.61
37.00
66.57
-4.50
61.27
246.78
24413.2
-121.14
84.48
-13.20
37.19
50.92
2.91
3.38
40.31
14.12
54.82
44.88
-14.07
65.37
68.27
-25.73
15.17
41.81
-11.04
-29.75
38.64
-17.68
30.96
61.61
-17.08
-10.16
20.17
-76.98
31.84
40.41

46.87
26.00
162.75
29.59
-7.55
-20.83
-380.07
-8.69
-302.25
29.72
66.06
98.11
31.06
101.32
278.11
24480.4
-84.52
126.63
-30.58
54.44
88.13
-10.72
15.08
83.89
2.11
91.56
57.40
-30.12
80.22
112.48
-42.72
28.13
82.90
-26.50
-23.34
71.05
-30.28
48.62
106.37
-30.10
1.92
59.14
-91.27
42.02
77.79

15.64
17.04
133.61
24.20
-21.37
-26.78
-390.12
-11.97
-305.65
27.51
94.93
123.51
64.18
134.18
306.04
24503.5
-55.70
159.92
-48.30
65.67
122.83
-25.21
25.75
119.64
-4.55
120.64
69.31
-42.49
91.36
148.21
-57.65
42.12
118.59
-50.75
-20.84
105.56
-41.63
61.63
141.38
-40.06
14.27
88.57
-100.40
52.81
107.66

36.40
11.87
177.53
22.08
-10.31
-23.73
-407.80
-22.60
-289.85
27.87
123.23
161.12
100.05
176.42
338.01
24465.7
-20.49
196.86
-67.07
90.52
158.91
-40.10
47.52
160.70
-19.63
161.22
81.12
-56.44
104.15
191.81
-72.56
56.19
159.43
-65.88
-23.11
139.35
-54.04
75.33
182.07
-53.07
25.13
123.48
-111.09
67.30
148.60

21.08
3.19
153.81
17.20
-14.83
-30.13
-392.11
-19.23
-294.71
24.91
148.76
183.05
129.80
206.13
362.45
24409.8
7.37
227.17
-76.32
101.13
190.96
-49.68
48.26
192.15
-22.38
187.41
91.30
-67.32
110.64
225.16
-86.25
62.36
193.20
-87.94
-18.05
174.45
-62.87
83.97
215.81
-59.58
32.77
153.22
-121.69
71.94
175.25

E-31

20.57
-6.42
189.52
13.51
-8.65
-29.17
-405.35
-26.20
-281.83
24.18
178.75
214.32
166.29
245.46
394.21
24365.2
41.33
266.38
-98.60
117.75
232.46
-67.66
65.54
235.70
-34.62
222.50
99.73
-81.83
122.52
267.81
-99.58
78.68
230.77
-101.77
-10.95
206.78
-75.20
100.51
256.22
-71.58
47.27
189.27
-132.64
81.29
210.98

10.47
-15.79
150.82
6.19
-19.80
-33.59
-403.74
-28.28
-297.48
17.89
208.89
251.97
203.91
287.51
426.77
24430.4
75.18
300.36
-114.53
141.10
268.81
-83.12
82.80
275.95
-46.44
262.46
105.35
-97.59
126.22
311.20
-116.93
82.15
271.37
-125.27
-18.52
243.78
-88.73
105.89
296.63
-85.80
49.69
221.47
-146.16
86.39
251.40

15.13
-24.79
167.58
1.67
-41.13
-43.54
-400.60
-30.54
-298.87
13.09
241.09
285.39
242.09
329.58
459.91
24415.7
109.83
342.50
-132.34
160.02
303.88
-100.82
106.05
318.43
-58.83
301.05
124.05
-114.93
144.96
356.98
-132.79
98.45
312.26
-142.30
-8.91
278.46
-104.12
128.14
340.73
-100.87
70.85
260.95
-157.75
105.68
290.26

21.36
-31.17
183.65
-1.88
-16.26
-37.10
-400.92
-33.64
-289.31
13.46
264.82
310.01
271.76
360.65
485.47
24500.0
139.19
372.89
-146.40
171.14
339.34
-110.79
112.99
353.40
-67.40
328.43
128.35
-123.09
152.78
390.21
-143.74
107.72
345.22
-158.44
-6.08
312.09
-111.30
136.34
373.34
-106.66
75.44
288.94
-165.83
109.55
318.10

21.86
-38.97
177.27
-6.81
-16.95
-40.69
-395.29
-35.02
-295.11
9.57
290.70
337.13
303.65
394.39
513.14
24485.8
169.90
404.64
-159.87
179.28
371.22
-123.86
118.41
388.50
-74.52
358.77
132.38
-135.82
155.73
426.48
-157.13
111.89
378.87
-176.02
-5.33
346.09
-122.12
143.02
407.69
-116.83
82.38
319.49
-177.63
110.94
348.76

TABLE E-18. CVP2, AIR 2, LOAD CONDITION 1c


Load Step
0.00
1.00
Pressure
-0.03
1.00
Frame-1
-27.09 281.69
Frame-2
-340.76 253.91
Frame-3
-56.89 208.99
Frame-4
-24.03 242.14
Frame-5
-23.50 208.51
Frame-6
-20.37 257.80
Frame-7
43.62 292.41
Frame-8
99.56 193.16
Frame-9
-76.93 262.84
Frame-10
-62.68 318.52
Frame-11
-29.31 215.29
Frame-12
-84.36 238.80
Hoop-1
-51.35 928.26
Hoop-2
-9.07 907.18
Hoop-3
219.68 944.24
Hoop-4
101.60 1032.37
Hoop-5
346.78 945.21
Hoop-6
-116.01 976.02
Hoop-7
168.57 1027.02
Hoop-8
-29.22 868.40
Hoop-9
-40.46 811.91
Hoop-10
-24.79 851.28
Hoop-11
295.45 1084.11
Hoop-12
63.97 832.07
Hoop-13
23.01 771.93
Hoop-14
75.45 845.09
Long-1
44.74 455.41
Long-2
-120.19 630.96
Long-3
37.03 468.32
Long-4
-8.04 493.70
Long-5
275.74 624.62
Long-6
98.19 472.30
Long-7
101.67 458.67
Long-8
-10.57 467.10
SG1
163.96 126.90
SG2
27.05
71.34
SG3
251.83 201.45
SG4
31.93
75.70
SG5
66.92
91.33
SG6
29.01
87.24
SG7
####### #######
SG8
-43.16 12.80
SG9
162.45 108.54
SG10
15.90
67.38

2.00
2.01
424.33
474.13
403.72
454.05
403.49
453.73
476.62
382.33
413.28
440.60
425.29
400.26
1742.47
1736.69
1723.17
1580.09
1691.37
1781.66
1785.00
1795.81
1757.13
1769.25
1723.83
1735.62
1877.15
1711.27
927.89
917.89
888.52
920.89
953.24
930.86
920.36
916.54
57.96
119.13
94.98
120.06
2.58
134.95
#######
59.18
25.64
119.41

3.00
3.05
629.15
637.25
629.49
626.50
653.86
685.39
633.70
632.16
623.54
638.86
640.67
631.34
2666.42
2661.44
2745.40
2671.30
2710.64
2712.41
2736.04
2641.56
2614.59
2650.39
2653.99
2653.28
2640.53
2813.58
1402.42
1377.09
1402.86
1416.28
1409.82
1400.11
1422.58
1422.29
272.66
186.39
267.27
179.19
179.11
200.71
#######
123.21
183.10
180.84

4.00
4.06
837.58
824.80
836.58
828.42
804.31
810.34
993.48
845.29
929.11
815.92
820.09
858.39
3539.98
3542.08
3575.76
3523.03
3499.30
3513.04
3416.03
3568.97
3556.19
3525.01
3516.67
3542.04
3530.68
3546.57
1942.79
1839.27
1941.39
1826.56
1918.52
1862.58
1793.14
1848.57
337.94
241.02
297.38
228.87
187.05
255.45
#######
174.76
222.07
236.03

5.00
5.06
1040.32
1056.99
1036.28
1043.60
1047.41
1053.66
1023.81
1056.25
1038.82
1044.18
1051.54
1053.84
4440.12
4438.01
4422.66
4458.89
4535.08
4480.84
4469.45
4422.53
4410.46
4422.85
4417.79
4445.33
4420.58
4427.29
2329.76
2309.69
2326.73
2332.03
2338.21
2329.66
2348.55
2334.90
434.70
300.15
398.11
285.81
297.71
320.86
#######
234.39
314.38
292.67

E-32

6.00
6.06
1264.33
1255.05
1258.90
1269.73
1272.14
1248.31
1229.39
1251.28
1258.00
1256.50
1245.33
1260.97
5338.79
5328.87
5331.32
5317.40
5341.37
5332.58
5316.85
5333.89
5325.34
5325.05
5363.90
5340.15
5331.66
5351.36
2789.77
2912.02
2901.68
2798.99
2788.52
2793.73
2774.77
2791.13
527.34
357.96
467.03
340.33
355.98
383.40
#######
288.92
380.36
347.54

7.00
7.07
1441.24
1455.98
1465.46
1471.12
1468.66
1461.04
1432.00
1460.56
1437.55
1453.79
1427.71
1454.74
6204.99
6164.33
6226.57
6248.69
6250.43
6207.12
6248.88
6188.51
6175.23
6186.02
6196.07
6200.09
6200.37
6144.34
3258.55
3223.13
3270.80
3259.08
3275.26
3268.06
3251.95
3241.66
634.94
419.69
563.85
398.90
437.23
449.70
#######
349.27
474.31
406.75

8.00
8.09
1666.41
1716.06
1680.63
1669.11
1665.22
1697.53
1732.39
1688.35
1751.03
1702.33
1682.41
1713.81
7104.87
7126.85
7136.36
7076.96
7183.78
7128.46
7172.35
7086.22
7134.70
7110.95
7157.99
7118.19
7171.84
7247.10
3770.81
3804.81
3745.05
3754.18
3712.39
3727.23
3740.68
3745.88
751.89
480.25
664.30
456.12
540.08
516.83
#######
408.95
574.44
464.18

9.00
9.09
1879.44
1840.46
1871.72
1839.43
1872.04
1825.36
1778.61
1875.60
1894.28
1851.77
1919.33
1878.53
7976.77
7985.99
7991.43
7951.07
7947.08
7969.92
8044.29
8020.72
7856.57
7920.28
8129.13
7969.66
8039.49
7883.60
4164.90
4141.51
4279.57
4247.41
4201.63
4197.98
4255.22
4202.66
816.59
537.22
702.13
509.43
559.51
577.65
#######
461.96
611.18
516.97

10.00
10.13
2110.14
2093.96
2094.11
2099.84
2112.10
2111.44
1976.52
2092.22
2056.91
2102.90
2058.09
2076.24
8910.44
8987.18
8912.46
8794.86
8893.92
8910.44
8939.25
8881.64
8904.92
8881.34
8888.36
8872.95
8877.47
8838.33
4668.92
4672.24
4658.23
4659.39
4690.40
4671.93
4668.30
4689.76
883.15
594.07
761.95
565.90
620.00
642.39
#######
522.97
664.79
571.66

TABLE E-18. CVP2, AIR 2, LOAD CONDITION 1c (Continued)


SG11
SG12
SG13
SG14
SG15
SG16
SG17
SG18
SG19
SG20
SG21
SG22
SG23
SG24
SG25
SG26
SG27
SG28
SG29T
SG29-45
SG29L
SG30T
SG30-45
SG30L
SG31T
SG31-45
SG31L
SG32T
SG32-45
SG32L
SG33T
SG33-45
SG33L
SG34T
SG34-45
SG34L
SG35T
SG35-45
SG35L
SG36T
SG36-45
SG36L
SG37T
SG37-45
SG37L

76.05
44.98
165.36
40.61
-29.94
-18.16
-375.53
-6.76
-331.21
25.84
9.26
33.02
-46.20
17.00
212.14
23761.5
-150.05
57.15
4.74
21.06
15.67
17.30
-5.35
-1.75
9.37
16.37
38.24
-3.75
70.59
24.47
-11.71
4.82
2.64
11.39
-23.44
10.34
-12.33
21.59
22.17
-13.88
-23.40
-8.83
-65.14
33.11
1.41

55.00
127.69
112.94
99.81
-27.41
21.41
-383.79
24.84
-320.76
63.93
9.26
65.20
-24.61
54.65
239.35
23767.4
-149.87
94.12
58.30
64.05
47.82
70.00
28.03
35.32
88.52
42.06
65.04
64.89
98.97
55.26
29.47
44.31
27.19
33.46
-4.08
27.43
16.50
34.36
38.85
53.23
28.40
21.99
7.21
62.48
30.99

-21.56
202.30
13.71
147.72
-21.65
66.46
-365.06
66.55
-332.01
106.07
9.63
96.13
0.07
91.92
268.38
23806.2
-144.54
127.38
126.49
106.99
60.77
127.63
71.11
65.93
179.01
70.06
119.03
128.55
136.99
88.41
75.73
77.61
57.05
76.42
25.58
50.53
56.49
60.65
65.67
116.56
74.36
49.68
73.69
107.64
61.78

142.98
290.28
216.31
214.50
55.69
126.61
-270.91
115.87
-223.17
173.16
-2.96
124.79
0.85
126.05
282.07
23839.1
-148.41
156.20
200.34
162.25
85.34
201.13
124.16
96.29
241.60
93.14
160.14
206.61
193.19
115.24
147.06
126.60
75.96
141.91
62.38
71.42
118.37
106.45
90.24
191.46
130.42
70.05
152.76
159.06
87.87

153.06
370.74
217.71
267.00
99.46
178.81
-219.84
162.26
-207.75
216.62
-6.10
152.04
15.24
158.36
303.60
23879.7
-142.65
186.53
269.58
213.69
112.01
268.41
169.66
127.14
319.74
115.86
200.57
279.64
233.28
139.53
213.34
162.48
95.07
203.88
92.70
87.49
179.53
144.32
118.65
260.53
175.98
92.44
224.89
197.60
112.90

253.79
468.03
362.98
328.64
144.33
229.29
-157.61
208.82
-131.90
277.07
-11.47
176.83
22.99
189.73
324.83
23906.2
-134.56
217.59
340.15
267.81
137.24
337.55
221.65
156.29
393.06
137.87
250.95
353.95
286.34
164.39
284.45
212.55
115.42
269.33
135.08
110.64
244.27
195.61
152.25
329.17
229.13
118.17
298.26
249.60
136.96

E-33

304.57
565.99
426.82
385.16
191.59
280.67
-96.10
258.39
-83.82
329.45
-11.66
204.76
36.65
222.07
348.38
23955.1
-125.16
247.21
409.68
322.14
170.81
407.79
269.94
188.30
468.76
161.45
298.27
430.35
333.71
188.90
358.69
260.12
134.46
337.36
175.55
130.12
312.73
245.64
184.92
400.35
282.93
141.79
371.88
296.78
162.58

377.82
665.13
525.40
445.20
252.29
337.81
-27.63
309.18
-25.35
385.99
-20.35
229.99
41.17
250.10
364.64
23970.4
-121.08
269.37
483.80
375.39
188.58
479.73
322.00
211.62
540.09
181.88
347.87
507.56
383.96
207.64
434.48
309.02
151.68
405.39
215.68
150.65
384.09
294.49
212.51
473.18
331.34
159.12
445.13
348.14
184.99

474.05
764.08
651.68
506.72
313.78
392.49
65.44
362.80
57.17
447.60
-20.91
260.17
52.38
283.16
384.07
24002.2
-113.56
297.50
556.80
435.22
217.22
551.50
376.45
241.36
613.38
207.07
397.22
585.24
435.58
232.53
512.14
362.53
173.41
475.08
259.49
173.85
458.08
347.31
243.86
546.35
386.63
180.92
517.95
398.28
211.95

477.74
856.77
673.98
560.03
359.67
446.44
95.54
406.60
83.81
496.22
-24.80
282.52
61.75
309.93
402.99
24022.8
-103.72
319.68
630.45
478.49
238.04
622.84
418.06
265.23
687.70
225.84
441.14
663.14
480.11
252.07
589.39
409.31
192.70
544.55
300.20
196.72
531.52
392.10
274.64
618.44
429.24
199.99
591.66
442.20
232.34

523.60
954.77
746.62
617.51
388.21
494.53
141.27
455.29
130.04
550.10
-27.38
308.27
71.56
337.55
421.01
24029.8
-94.51
345.49
706.47
537.94
262.56
697.12
469.50
290.74
765.21
246.65
488.22
744.67
529.92
271.76
671.67
461.58
208.64
619.57
346.70
212.74
609.35
444.42
302.93
694.58
480.62
219.11
666.90
489.88
254.77

TABLE E-19. CVP2, WATER 1, LOAD CONDITION 1a


Load Step
0.00
1.00
2.00
3.00
4.00
5.00
6.00
7.00
8.00
9.00
10.00
Pressure
0.02
1.02
2.06
3.08
4.17
5.07
6.04
7.08
8.02
9.06
10.05
Frame-1
-172.91 158.93 465.84 616.31 759.48 1044.99 1247.88 1442.25 1664.90 1844.26 2158.95
Frame-2
-70.78 244.75 529.99 594.79 836.54 1030.45 1254.05 1441.36 1684.87 1841.39 2169.15
Frame-3
-39.20 206.78 465.64 640.71 827.33 1034.07 1252.81 1468.18 1675.74 1883.02 2153.10
Frame-4
-108.02 193.30 533.45 584.26 808.79 998.20 1275.58 1466.87 1677.84 1898.94 2150.33
Frame-5
42.63 187.33 365.72 575.44 831.35 960.66 1250.47 1474.84 1687.84 1876.47 2209.28
Frame-6
-1279.20 185.00 541.12 559.63 832.29 1028.40 1278.73 1495.02 1710.56 1918.85 2168.99
Frame-7
-107.27 209.22 326.82 603.27 844.37 1075.03 1164.41 1429.22 1705.16 1840.87 2157.97
Frame-8
129.52 228.81 415.08 589.69 818.49 1055.80 1229.38 1464.65 1668.04 1893.07 2066.99
Frame-9
-144.16 215.25 481.47 648.60 872.56 1062.82 1309.02 1434.74 1688.39 1875.28 2093.96
Frame-10 -996.96 188.87 485.42 577.45 866.60 1088.49 1310.35 1454.45 1671.68 1852.03 2084.56
Frame-11 121.82 219.83 416.73 592.08 791.71 1052.76 1296.62 1441.88 1664.38 1838.45 2102.91
Frame-12
-26.56 203.71 381.32 567.94 793.50 1110.48 1354.82 1406.97 1580.93 1897.79 2135.57
Hoop-1
22.66 897.17 1742.11 2705.80 3578.01 4461.35 5299.65 6273.46 7065.38 8049.19 8763.13
Hoop-2
-104.71 932.21 1645.61 2557.00 3481.50 4290.46 5235.77 6301.69 7037.00 8078.45 8850.89
Hoop-3
756.04 784.10 1676.53 2933.19 3877.91 4556.18 5296.74 6070.17 7127.73 8052.79 8860.49
Hoop-4
343.16 1229.16 2235.15 2874.38 3506.45 4294.06 5441.41 6388.53 7119.23 7551.00 8865.49
Hoop-5
40.82 859.63 1700.15 2545.42 3303.62 4649.12 5251.44 6159.70 6956.70 7885.81 8858.94
Hoop-6
-68.46 792.27 1987.11 2767.60 3531.80 4672.93 5484.33 6199.21 6925.18 8148.86 8600.62
Hoop-7
234.35 1024.89 1744.05 2765.64 3566.66 4407.97 5116.86 6057.21 6930.00 7715.91 8701.13
Hoop-8
375.58 964.06 1787.94 2670.67 3774.46 4399.35 5481.23 6378.13 7011.45 7958.88 8739.42
Hoop-9
94.83 1102.97 1739.40 2731.22 3386.13 4611.51 5551.30 6303.23 7212.36 8115.61 8700.28
Hoop-10
-32.31 505.87 1795.34 2759.73 3641.41 4327.32 5236.25 6109.82 7172.45 8001.68 9093.29
Hoop-11
4.04
925.15 1901.53 3008.70 3841.77 4436.42 5280.69 6440.76 7065.98 7908.22 8767.48
Hoop-12
676.27 591.15 1773.59 3327.97 4038.95 4504.86 5245.57 6310.91 6940.76 7953.32 8857.14
Hoop-13
-165.93 1116.62 2206.41 2591.92 3652.42 4267.38 5253.91 6194.91 6944.38 8003.02 8745.18
Hoop-14
690.47 853.25 1637.52 2695.56 3428.39 4338.11 5359.68 6224.81 6773.01 7903.56 8858.81
Long-1
211.35
7.22
-11.77 -20.08
6.03
15.52
3.66
14.34
-5.84
4.84
10.78
Long-2
195.20 -87.95 42.08
91.90 -60.00 -61.22 84.60
66.37
78.52
91.90
50.57
Long-3
-58.16 143.16 77.31 342.03 277.37 304.71 -4.71 139.44 -22.11 -13.41 110.84
Long-4
-47.47 -20.55 205.83 -49.91 49.20 -43.79 -19.32 -41.35 -46.23 77.34
67.54
Long-5
418.09 319.75 397.70 353.35 305.36 314.95 277.79 348.52 252.59 311.39 396.43
Long-6
100.07 -19.73 -25.85 65.84 -14.84 -18.51 175.85 -16.06 -16.06 164.86
8.38
Long-7
128.56 51.63 105.72 111.73 118.93 110.52 73.26 118.93 120.12 117.74 122.52
Long-8
-31.50 102.67 20.21
37.44
79.28
65.75 -51.19 75.59 -52.41 -19.19 145.74
SG1
608.89 298.99 339.31 410.48 437.52 586.96 662.02 757.85 802.63 906.47 1005.34
SG2
26.35
67.41 128.26 191.95 245.60 311.76 371.41 437.21 492.96 561.39 623.07
SG3
692.74 381.99 423.26 470.53 499.26 652.16 731.73 820.65 889.08 968.87 1062.67
SG4
26.53
72.59 135.77 194.05 249.15 314.51 373.68 439.17 496.93 556.26 618.29
SG5
409.53 204.14 247.81 296.86 322.38 465.18 551.97 618.22 697.78 761.94 852.10
SG6
24.20
71.55 140.07 203.27 262.01 336.79 404.43 477.94 549.23 623.16 699.74
SG7
####### ####### ####### ####### ####### ####### ####### ####### ####### ####### #######
SG8
-60.80 -5.61
60.63 118.05 176.91 248.30 307.94 369.04 430.86 492.00 551.57
SG9
597.96 286.63 324.62 377.44 406.01 544.80 631.06 715.04 773.56 856.89 950.20
SG10
8.14
60.35 128.04 191.15 249.05 315.27 379.87 445.73 502.55 562.38 622.28

E-34

TABLE E-19. CVP2, WATER 1, LOAD CONDITION 1a (Continued)


SG11
SG12
SG13
SG14
SG15
SG16
SG17
SG18
SG19
SG20
SG21
SG22
SG23
SG24
SG25
SG26
SG27
SG28
SG29T
SG29-45
SG29L
SG30T
SG30-45
SG30L
SG31T
SG31-45
SG31L
SG32T
SG32-45
SG32L
SG33T
SG33-45
SG33L
SG34T
SG34-45
SG34L
SG35T
SG35-45
SG35L
SG36T
SG36-45
SG36L
SG37T
SG37-45
SG37L

432.66
25.90
548.40
24.19
164.32
0.49
-224.29
-12.16
185.67
84.42
7.40
74.13
-21.10
21.97
190.88
619.31
27.32
88.91
18.92
70.89
10.93
41.34
19.16
2.21
-47.23
36.28
27.90
7.82
96.34
35.51
-0.32
10.48
16.94
45.27
-3.01
22.02
32.16
50.42
36.84
3.42
28.06
21.75
-64.23
56.18
16.68

205.07
110.34
312.81
85.46
35.15
23.20
-281.04
22.39
108.19
112.15
-23.86
72.75
-34.70
16.21
196.70
617.72
-2.89
90.40
70.28
45.35
-18.98
72.40
18.88
-5.71
70.29
26.49
60.37
57.81
99.32
29.79
32.90
17.12
1.10
56.77
-16.33
-0.41
23.75
34.45
21.42
57.40
28.85
58.25
-1.68
67.52
8.56

251.87
206.62
294.45
152.51
78.34
77.72
-205.88
79.46
108.18
158.52
-63.82
62.59
-66.56
0.71
188.62
610.31
-37.11
84.48
151.36
72.88
-29.57
153.37
50.67
-22.30
163.74
5.17
98.03
149.80
139.55
7.30
102.05
46.19
-18.60
112.05
17.40
-14.10
77.16
55.30
1.48
140.56
20.65
105.51
92.50
109.97
-9.92

295.59
294.59
341.36
214.48
126.62
133.78
-174.34
118.44
166.45
223.04
-97.86
49.95
-85.29
-4.04
189.61
615.52
-58.32
88.92
224.49
91.76
-32.17
224.79
79.35
-24.14
257.45
-8.76
138.22
230.62
175.73
-5.53
171.09
80.24
-30.85
174.10
47.62
-24.53
137.47
81.91
-1.59
215.75
17.06
141.97
174.14
146.36
-21.67

308.66
379.08
398.88
278.62
164.51
191.28
-131.50
169.97
223.21
284.01
-130.59
58.76
-113.63
-6.49
178.73
615.09
-103.99
75.61
305.93
122.72
-44.20
303.59
109.60
-29.00
345.33
-13.17
173.59
311.12
207.80
-6.12
244.09
118.22
-30.06
247.38
71.56
-39.79
206.26
108.19
-1.07
303.41
-2.51
177.15
261.01
182.54
-25.19

443.18
484.74
558.53
349.96
220.69
240.42
-54.39
218.54
285.72
334.09
-157.05
73.25
-130.60
4.49
168.19
609.94
-119.65
82.26
377.64
160.13
-50.37
375.17
146.96
-35.97
409.70
-8.52
204.65
390.71
238.96
-24.86
322.19
143.90
-58.88
315.04
104.55
-54.87
279.34
145.39
-21.66
369.00
4.94
236.15
331.56
218.68
-16.70

E-35

529.22
588.48
658.79
413.65
282.84
303.81
34.49
279.53
368.79
400.84
-187.22
75.89
-154.04
3.62
156.83
605.59
-144.93
79.31
453.21
211.80
-57.44
453.76
188.75
-45.88
485.84
-14.70
240.16
471.37
274.59
-34.93
401.46
178.70
-72.16
385.95
138.53
-66.47
355.15
172.72
-32.67
445.05
-2.42
271.74
410.39
257.54
-19.67

585.14
700.90
724.00
477.54
341.20
362.67
101.55
333.28
419.09
459.43
-218.11
68.28
-177.10
-4.04
145.23
596.95
-171.95
70.44
537.47
232.89
-70.25
539.83
214.23
-59.83
579.16
-27.66
282.80
561.99
307.24
-55.45
490.39
216.55
-89.49
465.35
167.17
-81.74
438.23
206.34
-42.29
529.76
-13.70
312.11
497.74
298.51
-31.14

641.24
805.78
809.47
538.39
372.65
413.93
156.79
383.16
479.20
516.17
-249.38
64.21
-197.71
-6.67
129.90
585.36
-198.46
58.61
613.32
263.77
-82.98
617.17
240.55
-73.32
661.96
-35.46
313.03
646.84
322.63
-80.71
573.39
252.03
-109.75
537.44
203.28
-95.61
516.20
230.50
-56.00
607.31
-28.24
340.92
573.56
326.90
-38.61

700.55
915.94
877.34
601.00
439.39
473.89
241.41
439.54
539.00
574.63
-275.12
66.58
-213.92
-8.10
117.58
591.49
-216.08
62.31
695.61
308.27
-91.07
699.85
288.10
-76.53
748.10
-37.32
356.50
732.88
378.50
-83.28
663.56
300.36
-120.52
616.81
242.79
-105.82
599.25
276.78
-50.34
687.63
-29.03
392.93
658.46
367.45
-42.24

770.79
1030.20
948.91
662.71
489.41
528.19
293.63
488.64
606.63
636.68
-306.36
63.57
-241.84
-12.39
104.72
585.55
-240.17
54.92
774.83
341.34
-101.09
779.08
322.74
-82.47
829.43
-53.94
390.27
824.82
415.19
-108.13
752.56
335.35
-139.75
694.75
265.74
-121.45
682.13
313.73
-52.28
769.76
-40.59
436.29
748.63
402.07
-50.03

TABLE E-20. CVP2, WATER 1, LOAD CONDITION 1b


Load Step
0.00
1.00
2.00
3.00
4.00
5.00
6.00
7.00
8.00
9.00
10.00
Pressure
-0.05
0.11
0.02
0.00
-0.02
-0.02
0.06
-0.01
0.01
0.00
-0.02
Frame-1
-21.23 -49.25 236.19 89.38
99.35 354.15 -133.72 78.10 382.72 17.63
44.33
Frame-2
96.05 -90.10 220.36 -1382.23 110.03 -472.17 -432.58 236.31 2114.54 72.79 645.32
Frame-3
-140.28 -219.79 -120.64 -570.68 -143.70 -52.83 -1115.68 126.87 -46.69 39.14
65.76
Frame-4
-1573.22 -1227.15 -120.87 47.65 -368.17 226.49 34.65 429.41 710.20 198.22 273.21
Frame-5
46.19 125.14 212.65 -455.46 -580.04 287.69 106.06 -92.37 2084.73 -27.00 -134.83
Frame-6
-609.84 99.12 430.03 -991.65 133.90 181.36 66.89 -116.34 1398.13 189.11 512.66
Frame-7
-107.15 -42.02 217.42 25.75
-3.89
87.66 138.59 -88.58 -21.65 -105.86 -1308.70
Frame-8
-70.04 -120.31 -0.47 157.45 124.38 136.70 -29.33 53.52 -34.53 106.83 140.75
Frame-9
-220.95 70.42 148.06 -0.77
40.70 197.97 -57.31 232.35 198.99 153.80 93.91
Frame-10
5.29 -170.68 -219.55 -44.39 -53.35 187.96 44.30 -51.91 200.94 -151.84 -128.25
Frame-11 633.18 -924.38 -114.25 161.19 -82.77 51.17 116.16 153.81 -665.48 30.20
16.24
Frame-12
-35.13 -166.79 -112.18 164.05 -95.74 414.72 203.03 -78.72 140.69 104.55 -22.23
Hoop-1
683.99 -63.69 502.22
6.13 -148.21 9.81 -161.06 406.72 55.74 386.47 261.53
Hoop-2
-122.76 121.10 -130.01 -37.87 184.35 283.74 278.27 63.31 648.73 -66.78 -41.48
Hoop-3
21.26 1203.22 521.10 493.04 799.96 45.82 689.40 -41.88 165.09 343.97 -61.16
Hoop-4
280.24 -69.32 13.92 108.26 69.42 -87.83 435.65 972.24 -122.98 289.55 -98.92
Hoop-5
6.17 1264.47 349.05 -54.02 -97.79 927.29 -163.43 20.76 -77.73 -154.33 622.62
Hoop-6
485.61 -219.92 -74.01 -201.47 151.35 -197.79 -197.75 295.47 -179.32 -144.20 -120.19
Hoop-7
-222.06 475.34 364.01 953.78 -189.24 351.26 668.87 -258.65 811.44 842.40 75.52
Hoop-8
-146.72 -117.27 -73.14 353.48 552.12 -124.62 22.49 309.37 -14.29 15.13 -131.99
Hoop-9
1142.97 352.27 -48.41 -86.48 -44.79 -6.71 111.14 -48.41 887.20 794.73 -37.53
Hoop-10
-109.98 1368.99 -5.22 411.92 -126.22 276.48 1233.55 253.03 -43.15 -144.28 1123.51
Hoop-11
-124.93 -137.79 645.14 -152.53 315.38 1184.79 269.30 431.44
9.57
993.31 -108.33
Hoop-12
78.58 444.91 393.15 -119.42 71.17 -136.07 98.91
4.55 -112.03 -89.82 124.83
Hoop-13
390.13 493.83 1035.07 1049.79 -47.31 -91.78 93.54 108.37 397.50 -136.27 264.06
Hoop-14
1016.12 -115.99 -167.80 -152.98 209.55 76.36
76.36 742.26 -27.22 609.08 -49.41
Long-1
142.50 619.54 1369.51 1579.71 1853.67 2269.01 2803.91 3122.53 3845.70 4229.38 4289.90
Long-2
-63.65 114.98 1179.48 1376.48 2160.13 2258.56 2745.57 3086.41 3783.23 4067.96 4719.30
Long-3
123.28 359.39 1083.87 1436.94 1787.23 2371.29 2755.00 3557.16 3583.79 3995.47 4465.20
Long-4
-45.02 741.71 653.61 1051.36 2154.87 2289.46 2543.69 3390.96 3588.47 4231.18 4680.21
Long-5
312.55 487.57 818.43 1348.41 1890.11 2333.65 2887.18 3179.09 3438.55 3869.25 4559.73
Long-6
238.19 669.68 1384.76 1345.77 1829.69 2224.51 2452.85 3287.07 3921.98 4073.94 4518.88
Long-7
60.04 477.07 1333.97 1159.83 2112.76 2515.37 3167.64 3479.58 3720.43 4325.32 4520.01
Long-8
209.75 347.61 1279.36 1755.88 2027.72 2273.89 2549.35 3267.52 3730.85 4219.87 4819.29
SG1
775.43 655.02 731.05 681.26 709.82 724.31 718.30 833.59 707.54 778.49 715.76
SG2
35.25
29.90
31.28
20.14
15.21
15.53
18.15
21.70
8.94
10.60
5.44
SG3
822.57 815.67 762.28 721.84 717.05 766.60 716.86 738.56 620.87 678.79 599.78
SG4
25.06
34.87
21.97
9.77
2.77
5.12
1.25
-7.41 -17.77 -20.31 -26.66
SG5
509.80 562.37 453.58 458.00 434.61 500.91 456.02 418.59 368.00 414.96 336.29
SG6
18.13
33.97
13.34
6.34
-3.24
-1.03
-2.87 -19.27 -27.37 -28.29 -37.13
SG7
####### ####### ####### ####### ####### ####### ####### ####### ####### ####### #######
SG8
-64.50 -46.09 -66.69 -70.39 -77.01 -72.59 -69.65 -82.15 -82.89 -83.63 -88.03
SG9
724.90 693.26 640.59 615.43 610.45 639.55 608.79 627.55 513.48 571.07 493.86
SG10
-0.16
7.59
-9.75 -17.87 -23.04 -29.12 -25.07 -36.69 -46.46 -49.41 -56.42

E-36

TABLE E-20. CVP2, WATER 1, LOAD CONDITION 1b (Continued)


SG11
SG12
SG13
SG14
SG15
SG16
SG17
SG18
SG19
SG20
SG21
SG22
SG23
SG24
SG25
SG26
SG27
SG28
SG29T
SG29-45
SG29L
SG30T
SG30-45
SG30L
SG31T
SG31-45
SG31L
SG32T
SG32-45
SG32L
SG33T
SG33-45
SG33L
SG34T
SG34-45
SG34L
SG35T
SG35-45
SG35L
SG36T
SG36-45
SG36L
SG37T
SG37-45
SG37L

544.41
9.10
656.46
18.35
190.66
-4.62
-164.80
-7.49
229.36
92.75
12.40
86.20
-14.97
35.63
194.28
636.72
42.94
111.85
30.59
67.89
3.68
30.56
14.38
19.47
-62.74
49.90
10.28
-1.10
91.35
50.32
6.83
7.14
18.38
55.24
3.39
22.45
39.23
71.05
59.76
0.45
46.29
43.15
-78.67
38.07
30.75

572.22
33.01
735.23
36.63
156.51
-9.13
-184.17
-9.76
244.69
96.25
8.51
77.32
-18.15
23.36
195.04
629.30
40.35
104.44
16.36
44.10
6.10
41.77
-1.87
10.04
-37.69
35.87
14.47
17.82
92.27
36.89
16.52
26.92
21.50
42.48
15.13
30.87
35.70
49.91
45.16
5.56
36.08
26.51
-67.08
36.39
15.89

470.67
6.33
615.44
16.27
152.72
-18.02
-217.97
-19.27
218.03
87.93
69.74
133.49
54.94
100.19
252.56
701.49
96.69
169.48
-20.73
69.73
75.66
12.30
28.16
84.72
-63.65
106.12
61.01
-23.42
125.46
119.95
-32.50
50.28
103.14
-10.16
6.82
99.43
9.89
86.83
123.08
-15.27
97.68
55.64
-94.79
81.27
87.85

481.10
-2.17
696.07
10.56
165.51
-15.21
-203.11
-16.41
245.82
83.51
86.41
161.16
77.09
129.37
272.08
726.45
117.27
194.65
-36.63
85.51
94.16
-2.46
42.28
113.31
-74.61
134.47
57.68
-38.81
124.74
149.97
-41.45
39.42
120.91
-0.43
-3.94
93.91
1.15
92.79
152.15
-27.08
119.80
56.35
-106.30
77.43
116.47

463.94
-11.96
670.64
3.56
149.57
-24.65
-207.86
-22.00
244.71
81.85
115.09
187.29
114.21
167.01
305.64
763.96
154.41
231.61
-56.80
116.30
146.14
-17.40
50.44
155.99
-90.66
166.42
53.30
-51.83
122.88
192.20
-58.67
32.87
165.67
-33.11
-18.42
149.73
-14.56
90.28
192.34
-47.03
154.94
50.19
-114.62
76.64
149.57

516.30
-16.76
750.89
8.99
150.94
-29.49
-186.75
-23.84
275.76
87.75
129.69
188.43
128.31
176.41
316.29
776.39
170.19
245.63
-72.69
99.32
165.86
-29.50
40.88
178.23
-89.31
171.09
53.90
-49.78
134.93
203.82
-50.62
69.74
174.97
-37.94
15.78
170.94
-9.12
113.92
206.59
-39.77
173.01
85.94
-116.89
75.84
154.90

E-37

466.89
-14.68
711.73
8.95
155.74
-22.72
-216.82
-26.61
254.14
79.26
158.20
227.27
166.46
218.31
348.96
813.61
199.41
281.14
-83.81
129.65
201.09
-42.30
62.19
217.81
-86.80
209.98
66.05
-63.27
141.06
246.27
-70.96
71.70
213.74
-61.17
13.93
207.55
-28.75
113.28
244.16
-49.96
202.72
77.00
-128.25
79.93
193.64

449.68
-33.33
668.74
-4.04
156.23
-31.19
-208.16
-27.95
248.01
75.92
193.70
265.74
212.33
269.03
388.47
861.88
244.65
326.21
-100.90
140.81
238.96
-64.06
78.38
266.02
-110.53
255.24
80.69
-87.63
153.10
300.90
-95.46
68.86
263.14
-93.19
-7.00
245.85
-46.13
134.45
297.62
-73.48
245.39
100.25
-144.94
96.93
239.58

389.70
-42.52
689.92
-9.43
120.45
-37.55
-237.19
-34.05
250.60
70.93
226.26
308.07
253.23
316.81
425.11
904.90
278.19
369.08
-123.03
167.10
281.14
-82.97
97.08
308.22
-108.16
301.95
110.27
-114.36
167.20
352.40
-118.05
88.69
308.18
-102.68
16.57
274.47
-68.08
145.78
345.86
-85.80
288.27
104.17
-165.59
114.86
285.78

430.67
-46.35
731.55
-8.60
158.58
-31.01
-233.18
-38.11
262.07
69.82
248.09
317.86
275.09
335.45
441.64
923.28
298.84
389.04
-137.57
166.82
306.96
-91.66
94.44
334.58
-121.70
315.70
103.20
-114.27
171.47
372.73
-123.27
96.49
329.37
-119.76
17.41
305.76
-67.84
152.84
365.56
-86.12
303.84
110.46
-166.99
113.80
300.77

356.27
-56.92
649.70
-13.44
125.59
-40.12
-252.26
-44.34
235.78
66.86
266.94
340.12
301.66
359.58
465.58
946.54
324.99
413.39
-156.20
172.83
347.56
-108.32
98.75
364.48
-116.99
338.56
109.42
-127.69
173.86
399.52
-134.79
102.24
352.39
-138.09
15.55
324.48
-79.92
165.45
391.45
-96.67
329.11
133.01
-180.04
110.44
322.38

TABLE E-21. CVP2, WATER 1, LOAD CONDITION 1c


Load Step
0.00
1.00
Pressure
0.04
0.91
Frame-1
36.24 154.75
Frame-2
37.77 233.43
Frame-3
174.36 206.12
Frame-4
-941.61 216.68
Frame-5
421.25 205.54
Frame-6
149.62 216.81
Frame-7
67.61 231.29
Frame-8
68.44 211.28
Frame-9
27.78 249.57
Frame-10 104.20 176.50
Frame-11
38.03 235.07
Frame-12
71.21 220.60
Hoop-1
-161.06 818.26
Hoop-2
-66.77 775.13
Hoop-3
419.34 433.41
Hoop-4
-24.92 870.41
Hoop-5
1403.07 1186.17
Hoop-6
-59.22 784.96
Hoop-7
-251.30 657.98
Hoop-8
522.70 772.81
Hoop-9
-52.04 747.58
Hoop-10
359.58 865.26
Hoop-11
-132.28 809.09
Hoop-12
6.40
937.18
Hoop-13
871.97 745.94
Hoop-14
-153.00 653.48
Long-1
-3.46 193.56
Long-2
536.60 91.91
Long-3
-45.72 757.20
Long-4
-29.11 435.91
Long-5
441.97 642.34
Long-6
18.16 184.44
Long-7
114.11 471.16
Long-8
-37.64 255.35
SG1
683.77 432.04
SG2
16.26
54.69
SG3
824.34 493.96
SG4
10.28
45.88
SG5
539.82 266.66
SG6
14.44
50.73
SG7
####### #######
SG8
-71.11 -24.01
SG9
711.91 392.76
SG10
-12.33 29.91

2.00
2.05
456.06
504.46
397.56
356.44
487.04
404.15
384.03
398.23
453.91
423.80
425.59
412.81
1799.42
1869.96
2020.61
2004.37
1631.18
1669.78
1592.85
1868.86
1806.49
1714.07
1663.88
1818.00
1909.87
1829.89
1128.51
383.50
1132.22
884.77
881.87
877.39
1238.91
612.18
494.32
124.40
485.84
111.79
254.60
121.84
#######
42.24
393.32
107.95

3.00
3.08
662.74
669.44
657.80
663.49
653.01
744.66
618.94
472.80
626.09
556.96
597.34
658.05
2662.99
2668.50
2709.86
2342.89
2668.93
2765.20
2535.02
2803.08
3139.19
2678.46
2669.74
2602.59
2777.26
2702.96
1630.58
1217.15
1114.94
1582.26
1264.36
1571.78
1562.32
1479.99
450.65
178.31
442.86
164.39
276.15
182.45
#######
105.53
366.92
166.80

4.00
4.04
813.31
803.76
815.84
793.69
845.56
883.99
883.03
893.29
864.31
800.22
813.18
787.26
3641.96
3529.93
3365.45
3446.91
3520.30
3487.12
3741.58
3383.87
3376.39
3660.54
3430.23
3616.28
3681.34
3597.86
2100.71
1952.53
1953.94
1710.90
1830.36
2048.70
2067.29
2007.00
561.77
238.30
523.84
221.73
337.29
241.58
#######
163.68
433.56
222.33

5.00
5.02
1068.21
1076.38
1021.20
1036.95
989.08
939.35
1146.49
1118.61
1042.60
1118.60
1079.12
1016.15
4557.34
4339.66
4267.25
4091.01
4521.92
4760.21
4435.80
4487.62
4160.02
4542.23
4309.31
4401.24
4734.44
4574.87
2288.95
2439.38
2142.42
1748.49
1931.87
2110.62
2587.22
2412.74
685.06
299.07
641.71
281.33
441.80
306.61
#######
222.56
545.41
283.21

E-38

6.00
6.00
1255.10
1224.78
1241.16
1220.75
1254.25
1291.05
1274.87
1241.65
1272.52
1243.42
1254.66
1209.73
5233.50
5385.72
5247.63
5025.19
5342.63
5550.83
4983.57
5274.72
5302.34
5228.50
5401.75
5171.03
5394.25
5558.92
2653.49
2991.31
2572.60
3056.60
3022.93
2777.02
2776.17
2696.07
753.43
356.62
688.01
334.76
495.11
367.41
#######
279.24
596.54
339.29

7.00
7.07
1571.65
1493.71
1478.72
1487.80
1442.29
1451.13
1481.39
1490.97
1443.93
1408.46
1425.48
1388.44
6188.94
6316.15
5886.02
6264.59
6152.40
6206.60
6115.64
6150.09
6049.38
6254.29
6166.27
6140.67
6283.87
6143.43
3310.90
3251.36
3437.51
3269.49
3443.69
3433.42
3350.64
3134.26
816.61
416.60
735.75
390.29
530.39
434.18
#######
339.66
636.17
394.34

8.00
8.13
1691.15
1694.14
1694.97
1673.11
1690.01
1688.64
1691.85
1646.11
1563.49
1627.37
1684.82
1650.65
7362.30
7233.21
6823.63
6931.70
7131.08
7227.40
7080.84
7150.51
7253.34
7251.19
7240.28
6866.05
7217.98
7075.68
3873.77
3444.92
3782.11
3870.63
3674.22
4024.23
3293.28
3735.29
905.46
480.98
810.68
449.49
601.09
503.91
#######
402.89
708.77
451.82

9.00
9.15
1851.34
1845.20
1883.16
1881.91
1881.87
1895.06
1898.46
1907.57
1893.66
1885.48
1901.53
1900.32
8097.77
8086.48
8025.53
7986.56
8133.06
8242.26
7821.04
8041.40
8088.22
8089.98
8038.77
8051.15
8063.94
7971.74
4215.14
4399.71
4368.28
4088.03
4118.59
4342.86
4328.92
4361.42
978.99
537.00
882.63
506.28
695.20
572.44
#######
463.25
784.45
507.72

10.00
10.13
2091.28
2067.99
2049.58
2023.99
1970.72
1998.49
2110.79
2193.70
2144.05
2099.38
2068.16
2109.02
8865.96
8867.12
8700.88
8793.26
9039.48
8933.06
9122.92
9153.19
8767.30
8965.05
8957.18
8918.14
8910.06
8786.57
4515.37
4931.96
4738.59
4641.06
4619.67
4539.66
4967.09
4628.51
1043.59
592.54
941.57
561.23
771.89
638.46
#######
525.13
843.04
561.09

TABLE E-21. CVP2, WATER 1, LOAD CONDITION 1c (Continued)


SG11
SG12
SG13
SG14
SG15
SG16
SG17
SG18
SG19
SG20
SG21
SG22
SG23
SG24
SG25
SG26
SG27
SG28
SG29T
SG29-45
SG29L
SG30T
SG30-45
SG30L
SG31T
SG31-45
SG31L
SG32T
SG32-45
SG32L
SG33T
SG33-45
SG33L
SG34T
SG34-45
SG34L
SG35T
SG35-45
SG35L
SG36T
SG36-45
SG36L
SG37T
SG37-45
SG37L

577.02
8.54
723.81
20.92
169.08
-9.32
-162.75
-11.74
239.88
92.56
-4.62
66.06
-33.87
14.41
156.33
606.69
11.75
87.44
17.15
79.94
30.95
34.30
16.56
15.65
-49.70
27.60
22.70
2.25
102.65
39.06
8.52
20.00
17.03
59.93
-4.59
16.95
44.25
72.11
37.68
-6.43
8.53
34.39
-59.26
41.70
3.68

277.50
82.36
423.56
68.97
76.78
13.53
-248.04
16.29
166.45
113.07
-14.43
71.88
-20.36
31.94
184.08
633.72
6.86
124.40
50.99
40.15
6.33
39.85
10.90
43.14
65.55
32.43
59.90
28.61
105.07
73.00
9.46
29.57
40.92
40.06
-12.99
21.51
12.73
53.07
49.20
33.27
50.25
72.00
-14.14
49.03
12.27

254.89
188.68
365.77
139.31
98.66
70.45
-238.53
61.96
181.06
170.74
-13.13
114.85
2.37
75.30
212.39
671.04
13.93
157.67
125.44
90.92
25.51
112.15
66.22
64.83
148.86
63.31
116.69
108.16
154.03
98.85
61.08
62.59
68.64
72.50
19.87
56.99
51.78
65.61
65.24
106.91
81.33
105.98
71.44
109.89
51.50

289.31
272.98
440.32
204.76
134.22
127.47
-158.09
115.67
225.64
226.00
-3.88
157.87
27.41
124.19
254.05
-850.70
-148.07
203.50
186.05
160.38
71.86
177.20
120.38
92.93
226.87
102.51
168.12
183.57
204.11
121.35
123.89
102.72
85.40
128.30
53.79
70.86
104.88
109.69
102.04
174.14
119.97
171.29
62.56
161.46
95.75

331.94
356.45
515.85
261.51
169.08
173.52
-129.43
151.51
279.09
275.90
-3.33
191.47
43.09
163.67
278.45
-805.11
-137.03
241.20
246.19
212.45
117.79
241.13
176.22
132.16
295.20
132.27
228.34
253.22
266.80
152.52
188.17
164.44
110.65
186.24
101.82
95.53
160.67
169.93
138.65
238.67
152.74
239.95
135.26
224.55
128.16

443.22
454.46
640.00
326.64
235.08
231.37
-36.25
207.67
346.78
331.53
-14.06
213.82
40.42
186.00
286.05
-782.68
-144.97
254.50
315.35
264.75
138.51
311.75
221.75
149.37
362.82
148.43
268.15
329.14
306.87
163.18
257.71
192.86
120.71
249.12
120.67
108.05
225.76
207.27
151.48
310.04
160.66
285.59
208.89
268.83
147.10

E-39

476.63
548.96
683.10
382.10
280.72
281.52
13.40
252.37
393.20
383.84
-18.87
238.88
50.15
216.26
307.82
-745.91
-127.74
288.51
384.09
320.34
164.93
379.51
268.16
178.51
436.78
169.00
307.63
403.35
348.23
185.47
329.00
246.64
140.74
315.54
167.91
120.39
291.03
252.60
183.36
378.15
189.00
336.40
281.87
308.64
169.94

497.39
646.09
728.93
439.77
319.89
335.79
56.15
302.12
426.39
433.83
-19.98
265.70
68.15
246.94
333.85
-705.79
-117.84
317.40
462.13
361.12
185.78
453.85
314.92
208.63
517.73
190.03
358.77
479.00
398.76
219.26
408.13
305.87
162.85
384.35
220.17
147.51
364.71
306.17
215.51
453.47
211.92
388.12
359.95
358.56
193.24

561.70
751.68
828.26
505.45
373.58
393.20
129.24
356.19
500.66
497.32
-29.60
287.53
66.43
270.69
343.96
-682.66
-118.46
337.29
544.07
407.92
196.56
531.75
360.85
229.01
599.97
205.36
398.55
566.12
440.41
228.29
494.29
349.52
169.10
465.31
261.56
146.78
441.95
354.41
243.44
531.95
227.68
439.79
441.04
398.40
210.75

643.27
853.01
925.70
568.51
422.81
446.17
192.56
404.96
563.36
554.98
-27.56
317.67
78.88
305.93
365.96
-649.02
-108.71
365.38
612.25
470.98
241.66
603.67
411.53
257.11
672.20
231.18
449.61
645.68
492.72
249.01
569.76
400.60
196.44
529.30
296.98
187.47
514.57
402.35
279.59
606.01
246.42
493.95
513.83
451.41
237.73

702.39
948.81
1014.22
628.69
477.21
499.59
259.96
452.66
606.14
602.17
-30.89
342.54
88.11
333.64
385.06
-619.48
-101.61
396.47
683.20
522.08
268.67
674.21
457.43
283.49
744.42
251.41
493.00
722.60
538.03
269.36
647.04
454.24
215.28
598.01
338.22
209.09
587.53
452.00
308.53
677.21
267.46
544.21
585.90
495.46
259.53

TABLE E-22. CVP2, WATER 2, LOAD CONDITION 1a


Load Step
0.00
1.00
Pressure
0.01
0.98
Frame-1
-175.05 212.92
Frame-2
147.73 314.81
Frame-3
-101.39 217.70
Frame-4
312.20 231.82
Frame-5
35.31 189.65
Frame-6
-111.28 272.28
Frame-7
-88.44 332.23
Frame-8
22.67 327.64
Frame-9
-27.41 276.95
Frame-10
-27.67 136.21
Frame-11
-25.47 254.47
Frame-12 -128.72 178.46
Hoop-1
-80.24 924.82
Hoop-2
95.83 634.21
Hoop-3
771.98 864.85
Hoop-4
321.03 324.70
Hoop-5
-106.92 775.82
Hoop-6
844.15 770.18
Hoop-7
-207.52 1466.86
Hoop-8
-43.72 552.12
Hoop-9
105.71 994.18
Hoop-10
272.90 1230.06
Hoop-11
77.73 348.54
Hoop-12
480.12 496.77
Hoop-13
723.70 664.39
Hoop-14
-79.01 934.63
Long-1
6.03
33.33
Long-2
-51.50 43.29
Long-3
155.59 240.12
Long-4
49.20
10.04
Long-5
314.95 276.62
Long-6
12.05 251.66
Long-7
13.17
17.98
Long-8
155.60 209.78
SG1
632.72 191.16
SG2
22.12
49.39
SG3
757.19 287.51
SG4
17.92
47.16
SG5
486.46 167.89
SG6
15.00
49.99
SG7
####### #######
SG8
-71.11 -21.06
SG9
639.73 188.60
SG10
-8.09
33.60

2.00
2.07
479.34
498.45
322.92
353.89
506.92
355.72
369.11
357.50
449.32
364.12
351.63
401.31
1869.06
1851.71
1587.26
2076.31
1959.27
1941.13
1654.77
2000.87
1856.89
1753.45
1215.98
2061.85
1739.01
1910.90
13.15
96.74
144.39
260.84
266.97
67.05
52.82
288.50
307.52
122.49
349.96
117.38
206.35
127.21
#######
43.72
250.69
112.95

3.00
3.08
614.74
806.94
524.16
822.31
610.09
547.90
663.73
534.78
695.88
615.51
561.80
677.08
2528.86
2796.78
2690.57
3047.69
2612.39
2427.15
2345.13
2545.62
2818.26
2427.43
3021.60
2706.22
2436.23
2843.54
4.84
339.72
-38.26
125.03
257.36
205.14
129.72
154.34
374.99
180.10
413.80
178.33
247.51
192.44
#######
105.56
316.59
179.56

4.00
4.13
815.77
994.05
806.21
1146.12
920.51
731.65
743.68
759.18
849.00
886.48
855.35
745.99
3676.87
3701.54
3688.12
2823.57
3485.65
3897.16
3770.79
3516.27
3856.83
3926.00
3638.38
3727.30
3555.33
3782.81
38.07
67.58
-15.90
100.57
245.40
106.16
62.44
188.81
466.31
246.55
533.06
245.91
376.70
267.93
#######
179.87
421.74
245.20

5.00
5.15
1028.96
1101.28
1121.01
1028.71
1011.90
1109.19
875.17
1093.62
994.90
1002.34
1018.62
1015.36
4448.05
4560.97
4382.13
4430.50
4444.43
4384.35
4664.93
4685.76
4328.22
4585.11
4518.87
4393.40
4748.79
4677.99
45.19
74.88
135.71
229.05
352.11
103.73
118.93
209.75
511.88
309.24
556.18
302.59
392.53
337.23
#######
239.52
470.89
312.02

E-40

6.00
6.20
1304.92
1242.36
1311.27
1217.21
1167.92
1146.08
1308.11
1242.15
1212.44
1348.95
1246.08
1123.92
5224.31
5264.67
5470.37
5271.22
5455.71
5517.58
5587.95
5443.36
5044.36
5394.11
5242.79
5429.55
5453.01
5299.43
44.00
110.11
143.15
103.02
326.91
172.16
116.51
74.35
539.11
369.38
607.96
369.07
433.19
412.91
#######
302.79
498.34
373.97

7.00
6.98
1506.37
1340.84
1588.76
1522.43
1570.11
1380.17
1491.82
1479.03
1520.62
1300.08
1501.97
1359.08
6271.58
6373.86
5998.22
5700.53
6088.57
6243.52
6084.60
6407.55
5619.65
5885.88
6262.06
6214.69
6024.40
6224.81
32.14
8.05
-61.88
-59.70
330.53
-35.62
123.74
-63.49
689.55
429.78
724.80
418.12
541.16
473.19
#######
353.61
625.58
430.46

8.00
8.03
1661.44
1712.68
1691.16
1636.46
1746.48
1671.44
1615.75
1781.81
1751.40
1709.72
1693.24
1684.87
7238.48
7060.89
7056.16
6877.37
7318.18
6977.35
6822.73
6980.63
6953.47
7004.88
6773.52
7124.40
7083.83
6867.83
26.20
-15.04
182.93
-41.35
396.47
-33.18
126.14
145.75
783.73
493.01
834.93
482.42
635.23
550.39
#######
420.60
711.24
490.06

9.00
9.08
1890.08
1845.96
1844.58
1848.27
1853.37
1885.86
1892.27
1804.99
1979.71
1913.73
1853.34
1866.39
8014.51
7843.80
7860.03
8126.59
7948.06
8077.05
7971.80
8040.60
8109.17
7619.61
7923.75
7746.87
7870.38
8207.71
21.46
10.48
-33.29
-22.99
403.62
-29.51
124.93
-68.41
820.22
552.36
878.10
541.70
699.32
623.72
#######
481.70
762.93
549.28

10.00
10.03
2068.65
2111.03
2052.83
2085.79
2098.11
2103.77
2083.50
2095.86
2133.64
2037.67
2109.34
2098.84
8914.74
8866.26
8677.23
8986.69
8847.11
8886.05
8671.05
8937.14
8926.03
8211.15
8877.13
8774.84
8803.61
8902.31
30.95
67.60
102.17
-40.13
456.45
-14.84
136.97
-67.19
961.49
614.90
994.43
604.23
788.91
692.87
#######
540.64
877.47
611.34

TABLE E-22. CVP2, WATER 2, LOAD CONDITION 1a (Continued)


SG11
SG12
SG13
SG14
SG15
SG16
SG17
SG18
SG19
SG20
SG21
SG22
SG23
SG24
SG25
SG26
SG27
SG28
SG29T
SG29-45
SG29L
SG30T
SG30-45
SG30L
SG31T
SG31-45
SG31L
SG32T
SG32-45
SG32L
SG33T
SG33-45
SG33L
SG34T
SG34-45
SG34L
SG35T
SG35-45
SG35L
SG36T
SG36-45
SG36L
SG37T
SG37-45
SG37L

501.91
9.33
618.26
19.31
137.58
-10.28
-310.53
-23.89
193.27
79.44
-19.61
19.63
-44.38
-6.90
165.72
-876.81
-168.76
131.79
18.45
25.87
20.87
39.25
-13.52
-13.91
-38.11
-2.44
14.42
-4.91
105.62
18.15
-5.45
5.65
3.80
42.15
-11.09
7.46
30.40
50.01
31.13
-22.24
-30.24
-21.13
-75.91
26.59
-14.70

155.18
83.51
324.70
67.81
-10.72
8.32
-409.34
7.61
92.28
95.14
-24.60
44.27
-23.86
27.46
201.79
-839.22
-173.36
171.69
47.26
40.57
28.16
43.26
8.81
19.99
74.29
20.40
54.27
23.44
120.26
58.59
4.24
19.86
23.13
43.36
-6.63
2.29
-0.75
40.34
49.66
20.58
12.82
14.85
-25.91
42.57
11.57

193.16
198.65
261.84
148.92
25.16
66.83
-359.19
58.10
127.45
163.38
-66.98
39.39
-57.91
9.38
179.98
-863.19
-217.72
146.61
138.49
70.54
9.49
135.71
38.10
-7.50
167.65
1.83
89.27
125.29
145.71
29.80
78.74
35.15
2.59
97.42
-5.20
-15.82
63.51
40.49
1.71
113.21
58.55
-8.27
75.50
86.22
-4.21

268.10
283.98
248.48
212.68
65.24
123.95
-188.91
138.61
130.97
204.42
-105.10
25.86
-90.10
-8.29
169.71
-880.85
-257.87
128.12
213.01
116.12
8.75
216.57
69.62
-26.41
250.42
-21.25
116.10
216.35
179.66
0.59
158.75
68.27
-27.32
159.98
30.22
-29.89
136.01
62.00
-32.03
201.66
100.32
-33.17
166.22
120.70
-24.41

379.74
389.37
462.80
288.69
139.79
181.35
-132.52
191.23
261.33
283.85
-133.94
31.49
-110.37
-3.12
157.29
-874.79
-283.13
139.19
299.69
130.89
-14.94
298.62
104.93
-33.57
339.51
-22.36
167.14
303.48
227.67
-9.87
240.96
113.54
-45.66
240.98
80.20
-49.90
207.95
106.07
-28.82
279.82
157.35
-21.69
251.26
170.80
-24.03

364.83
495.60
470.40
345.61
226.86
250.18
-170.29
211.38
261.91
324.54
-160.41
43.31
-124.17
6.98
160.07
-865.87
-294.85
140.68
378.74
172.08
-23.91
378.15
150.06
-36.07
419.09
-18.04
207.72
388.65
259.04
-20.33
319.15
144.30
-53.72
312.45
101.09
-57.40
279.63
133.90
-24.59
358.20
185.19
-26.17
331.44
213.89
-15.63

E-41

389.34
608.89
517.69
411.72
241.30
297.87
-130.82
261.61
296.47
378.29
-197.76
39.70
-152.29
-4.04
148.45
-872.95
-320.32
130.32
462.83
201.87
-35.89
465.58
184.71
-52.20
504.83
-33.83
254.80
479.55
309.46
-41.05
409.31
189.66
-75.33
390.84
137.05
-70.57
362.87
175.69
-37.41
444.26
232.16
-39.13
420.57
265.02
-28.72

495.31
696.30
639.51
464.78
317.42
354.88
-24.49
317.98
407.67
449.87
-224.43
35.09
-174.67
-7.78
133.55
-876.35
-345.57
124.41
526.46
232.96
-47.08
529.28
215.46
-59.37
571.07
-42.94
275.57
544.51
330.46
-46.38
477.12
212.99
-91.69
451.81
157.07
-83.47
426.05
203.76
-44.85
507.54
265.60
-45.89
485.23
286.23
-35.78

566.56
810.90
701.96
530.38
342.38
401.35
17.65
361.58
448.36
505.69
-260.32
35.78
-203.54
-10.50
118.77
-882.60
-370.93
113.32
611.39
258.79
-58.88
611.63
242.75
-63.80
658.26
-52.83
304.69
640.25
359.39
-70.65
569.35
246.11
-113.95
533.54
191.37
-100.74
511.18
236.65
-49.03
594.87
307.78
-61.37
571.94
317.13
-43.17

622.85
919.40
792.23
596.26
391.58
455.28
89.56
417.93
488.50
554.49
-291.03
40.17
-223.83
-7.23
110.67
-883.15
-390.57
109.63
693.75
319.35
-66.36
694.02
294.37
-68.42
738.79
-53.15
348.03
731.16
403.36
-85.45
659.79
292.61
-125.51
613.00
223.53
-111.36
595.62
280.13
-44.43
679.07
357.66
-68.78
654.18
363.96
-40.61

700.80
1022.88
865.45
654.69
456.43
512.17
154.33
467.30
548.49
611.85
-319.93
38.47
-245.67
-10.22
100.14
-884.53
-411.35
103.72
769.97
345.68
-74.96
775.36
328.33
-81.45
819.21
-60.27
388.30
814.61
436.98
-97.89
744.62
325.90
-139.12
687.45
253.73
-123.05
675.57
315.09
-45.46
756.70
397.09
-75.17
733.34
403.45
-46.93

TABLE E-23. CVP2, WATER 2, LOAD CONDITION 1b


Load Step
0.00
1.00
2.00
Pressure
-0.10
-0.04
-0.04
Frame-1
-77.39 -308.77 22.48
Frame-2
-61.46 -385.20 -652.19
Frame-3
-131.00 81.17 267.10
Frame-4
92.75 -47.49 342.70
Frame-5
-96.34 -141.79 -34.23
Frame-6
143.20 -112.25 12.28
Frame-7
-101.08 -222.58 -30.83
Frame-8
37.59 -27.03 -102.23
Frame-9
-49.17 780.43 214.02
Frame-10 -107.45 -1293.00 45.42
Frame-11 158.72 -449.82 -49.96
Frame-12 -937.06 -50.71 -152.20
Hoop-1
336.76 379.08 -72.87
Hoop-2
202.36 -50.51 498.66
Hoop-3
-5.04 -13.81 198.38
Hoop-4
-8.27 446.74 208.14
Hoop-5
905.04 -179.84 -134.25
Hoop-6
293.50 1233.71 755.33
Hoop-7
-54.11 60.90 -165.49
Hoop-8
-117.28 235.79 588.85
Hoop-9
568.08 -73.79 -62.91
Hoop-10
296.37 563.60 16.45
Hoop-11
-1.48 -80.69 -14.38
Hoop-12
-69.47 966.69 567.03
Hoop-13
849.73 -32.48 12.00
Hoop-14
653.48 357.49 964.13
Long-1
6.03
696.74 415.47
Long-2
-16.26 344.69 1331.51
Long-3
-65.60 627.87 816.78
Long-4
154.40 198.48 657.35
Long-5
398.82 623.09 1035.50
Long-6
-33.17 680.75 787.10
Long-7
11.97 318.46 1218.72
Long-8
27.59 487.98 463.36
SG1
538.87 515.89 511.09
SG2
27.04
22.25
17.42
SG3
624.31 590.43 525.32
SG4
24.32
20.13
9.63
SG5
349.73 343.18 257.09
SG6
22.92
21.44
8.92
SG7
####### ####### #######
SG8
-61.54 -60.81 -70.38
SG9
517.30 473.61 430.60
SG10
1.69
-7.17
-9.75

3.00
0.06
-32.12
-62.46
456.33
-27.41
-38.86
294.44
-219.79
-136.15
-306.87
37.32
-68.36
-84.16
101.67
75.95
258.03
287.70
-88.67
-27.83
382.27
0.42
354.12
-26.90
85.10
1207.35
-39.90
98.56
1339.85
1687.43
1021.74
1024.34
1462.16
1328.53
1083.99
1377.83
379.11
11.15
390.25
7.33
151.04
6.52
#######
-70.37
288.63
-15.28

4.00
-0.09
76.13
-810.13
75.18
87.82
150.62
43.23
152.15
-17.47
13.68
292.04
-25.73
-25.58
-63.68
812.90
536.78
-37.87
-33.95
520.70
-150.87
412.32
-37.53
294.54
969.27
-13.95
19.41
683.00
1928.24
1875.59
1334.76
1968.70
1834.78
1714.62
1774.87
1938.91
653.18
19.95
641.34
6.68
341.89
3.94
#######
-72.59
536.74
-15.10

5.00
0.05
401.16
46.28
74.63
273.55
-34.41
57.71
-22.55
-19.94
-56.52
-166.71
223.55
-107.50
59.41
-59.54
10.74
-0.88
197.65
-96.17
931.78
279.95
747.58
310.82
-14.38
-1.00
34.24
68.97
2404.29
2240.33
2342.71
1943.20
2301.28
2201.29
2432.44
2032.65
293.27
-1.34
281.45
-12.66
118.00
-10.98
#######
-72.59
194.15
-34.10

E-42

6.00
-0.01
85.37
179.36
32.84
55.70
-47.14
28.35
90.68
-264.84
-1.29
6.74
-3.47
-90.71
-78.39
175.32
973.59
71.27
155.72
22.05
248.98
294.60
997.61
-37.72
-93.58
58.20
308.48
520.19
2796.79
2927.83
2788.55
3034.28
2830.85
2986.97
2887.65
2681.04
533.63
8.11
459.32
-12.71
212.17
-15.40
#######
-77.01
373.60
-30.42

7.00
-0.02
40.71
-98.57
106.77
157.53
151.39
74.37
507.61
57.16
73.76
-53.44
-77.78
23.51
-113.29
570.92
438.63
-71.17
1062.05
-153.42
358.50
0.42
1137.42
-135.25
309.85
631.86
219.58
9.78
3466.35
3326.70
3305.78
3442.01
3117.63
3576.44
3466.01
3472.74
557.66
7.51
503.87
-12.38
268.11
-16.50
#######
-76.26
401.03
-35.94

8.00
0.11
-149.14
-57.08
30.77
38.19
125.14
58.37
-94.35
-107.19
-116.90
50.79
20.86
-103.45
241.29
-59.54
61.60
-48.97
-63.13
-33.37
513.68
301.99
-55.66
-8.84
683.75
-58.36
-62.13
-12.42
3893.17
3650.79
3484.38
3806.24
3764.58
3662.86
3535.37
3995.45
291.98
-6.50
187.19
-30.21
40.24
-29.58
#######
-90.99
102.79
-52.37

9.00
0.09
-4.22
-32.53
271.30
-42.58
49.47
-39.82
30.14
-12.04
108.57
-3.84
34.93
-21.71
-36.13
827.52
417.63
-13.83
-137.91
-72.16
597.73
66.62
-13.96
38.12
9.57
-21.36
212.16
586.89
4389.14
4169.62
4487.12
3998.31
4342.32
4138.31
4409.00
4214.52
404.76
-0.42
218.36
-36.34
83.01
-34.19
#######
-98.35
132.69
-56.61

10.00
-0.11
76.96
-435.74
-1.21
7.61
-65.95
54.29
-81.60
144.86
-17.26
65.27
155.90
-80.43
171.48
52.46
-34.85
-41.57
855.98
-116.48
743.73
-21.65
912.49
-43.15
-51.22
24.90
56.47
372.28
4536.73
4704.72
4660.31
4676.54
4670.01
4727.90
4417.86
4613.74
580.75
-3.50
457.80
-36.20
236.65
-43.03
#######
-89.52
351.23
-63.99

TABLE E-23. CVP2, WATER 2, LOAD CONDITION 1b (Continued)


SG11
SG12
SG13
SG14
SG15
SG16
SG17
SG18
SG19
SG20
SG21
SG22
SG23
SG24
SG25
SG26
SG27
SG28
SG29T
SG29-45
SG29L
SG30T
SG30-45
SG30L
SG31T
SG31-45
SG31L
SG32T
SG32-45
SG32L
SG33T
SG33-45
SG33L
SG34T
SG34-45
SG34L
SG35T
SG35-45
SG35L
SG36T
SG36-45
SG36L
SG37T
SG37-45
SG37L

371.58
30.56
496.64
31.98
112.93
-9.50
-323.37
-13.03
154.97
81.09
-2.77
37.99
-31.10
10.44
197.09
-877.27
-163.20
127.35
25.79
46.50
23.28
33.59
-5.67
-9.67
-23.82
15.44
21.21
0.90
99.31
20.32
3.02
5.19
-3.09
42.80
-9.42
3.45
14.87
39.46
16.07
-16.94
-2.75
-3.93
-71.91
29.14
2.80

358.15
27.70
515.29
30.00
111.69
-14.24
-338.35
-14.10
170.89
81.47
25.35
62.60
6.20
45.50
225.56
-841.51
-132.04
165.06
0.47
37.28
43.39
21.22
1.85
30.36
-23.21
44.46
46.23
-9.70
120.09
57.02
-13.45
29.62
36.59
19.81
-0.32
20.72
7.24
59.25
54.87
-20.99
12.73
28.93
-79.87
49.59
31.35

286.17
17.27
439.77
20.19
112.94
-9.32
-349.85
-14.93
155.72
76.11
53.28
96.30
45.07
89.87
237.67
-800.88
-98.14
201.28
-28.03
86.24
108.55
6.88
27.51
73.84
-38.71
83.70
54.14
-28.07
125.84
104.18
-37.59
18.84
81.73
-11.51
-23.90
77.56
-10.84
61.99
96.60
-39.63
5.92
60.02
-88.94
60.55
72.58

171.88
14.40
318.35
17.05
59.55
-18.80
-378.93
-12.71
119.46
70.74
73.26
111.15
68.36
106.47
265.35
-784.62
-83.67
216.78
-40.48
76.96
123.17
-6.47
18.88
93.25
-16.18
99.76
72.45
-34.81
127.87
121.93
-50.66
34.86
97.13
-29.14
-15.17
74.62
-19.12
65.65
113.09
-36.23
15.15
75.58
-96.32
64.26
88.27

359.44
3.74
525.98
16.00
141.86
-11.94
-326.63
-21.16
186.43
72.04
101.76
134.47
95.34
138.77
254.93
-753.26
-50.83
248.59
-45.45
103.40
144.87
-12.36
28.90
128.15
-61.47
127.44
46.65
-39.51
129.92
156.07
-54.81
35.75
133.29
-42.51
-16.75
118.06
-19.86
68.49
147.30
-50.14
8.35
106.87
-103.68
56.14
117.76

133.05
-6.00
433.32
10.93
32.84
-27.92
-409.79
-26.01
155.72
69.27
136.72
183.40
150.17
199.28
350.40
-695.90
-7.00
303.29
-81.52
98.53
187.83
-53.83
45.61
188.36
-34.52
182.66
83.53
-75.63
141.60
221.98
-80.60
49.91
181.35
-56.61
-4.41
156.19
-55.71
91.34
210.82
-69.43
38.73
157.21
-127.40
69.24
172.49

E-43

242.79
-13.25
470.40
4.25
95.68
-20.88
-362.48
-26.61
169.98
65.40
164.86
218.78
183.20
238.24
376.13
-660.67
29.22
335.85
-90.36
139.39
232.02
-53.23
68.41
224.64
-65.90
219.50
86.23
-82.10
152.19
261.66
-95.19
46.90
224.09
-83.70
-15.22
197.31
-59.67
96.46
246.49
-82.55
30.44
186.13
-134.49
81.93
210.12

287.25
-15.56
554.11
8.16
90.82
-25.94
-372.42
-35.94
203.05
73.51
193.31
237.70
212.03
263.28
398.51
-634.80
55.35
361.65
-109.91
132.64
264.34
-65.22
67.23
254.82
-74.40
241.19
97.42
-89.80
164.40
288.44
-102.09
67.60
254.31
-98.76
-0.04
232.04
-68.25
109.35
274.13
-91.55
46.33
211.22
-143.06
92.41
231.57

51.99
-29.64
290.34
-7.59
0.10
-41.42
-430.61
-33.12
120.21
60.95
223.67
264.91
255.95
304.27
427.32
-594.60
88.25
406.04
-127.44
141.46
293.44
-94.13
77.64
296.62
-53.19
277.02
118.17
-112.78
167.02
334.84
-130.85
82.05
293.14
-126.14
-9.60
254.27
-92.25
120.14
319.28
-100.49
66.28
253.70
-156.34
98.79
267.58

79.85
-37.58
264.36
-15.19
-19.94
-52.56
-450.82
-47.07
93.95
47.83
258.64
314.07
303.08
359.80
398.87
-543.85
132.55
453.35
-141.11
177.53
339.93
-109.96
108.87
350.84
-73.67
329.35
133.71
-133.47
184.26
393.84
-151.55
98.31
347.58
-156.81
-10.21
313.53
-109.83
137.05
374.20
-123.36
71.50
297.38
-172.80
115.47
320.37

257.57
-52.07
596.71
-11.55
62.60
-48.46
-387.87
-50.67
202.89
57.26
272.33
324.18
312.76
375.12
419.31
-528.96
153.24
469.61
-165.09
183.19
375.83
-118.98
109.48
374.75
-107.41
341.93
127.29
-144.12
198.73
411.40
-147.46
98.44
356.11
-138.01
14.67
314.37
-107.50
163.61
393.72
-132.24
96.57
314.58
-186.34
116.58
333.60

TABLE E-24. CVP2, WATER 1, LOAD CONDITION 1c


Load Step
0.00
1.00
Pressure
0.11
1.07
Frame-1
660.51 165.10
Frame-2
674.69 249.32
Frame-3
221.49 204.31
Frame-4
-120.19 227.06
Frame-5
644.66 217.68
Frame-6
401.60 243.60
Frame-7
840.26 219.03
Frame-8
651.27 193.85
Frame-9
2748.67 281.13
Frame-10 227.41 272.72
Frame-11 607.33 249.61
Frame-12 492.49 253.38
Hoop-1
-23.27 1027.72
Hoop-2
113.88 863.65
Hoop-3
724.47 840.30
Hoop-4
393.10 946.25
Hoop-5
-57.66 1239.06
Hoop-6
988.05 1158.10
Hoop-7
-172.79 783.97
Hoop-8
868.44 883.15
Hoop-9
684.12 937.97
Hoop-10
-117.19 1293.27
Hoop-11
136.68 1321.23
Hoop-12
-63.92 716.98
Hoop-13
560.60 1175.93
Hoop-14
535.09 327.93
Long-1
-3.46 657.51
Long-2
51.79 202.47
Long-3
115.81 775.69
Long-4
1.48
275.55
Long-5
276.56 672.18
Long-6
-23.40 322.53
Long-7
22.78 382.13
Long-8
-45.03 638.09
SG1
682.36 347.49
SG2
16.40
51.75
SG3
801.91 448.81
SG4
0.05
44.92
SG5
532.69 235.43
SG6
10.21
53.32
SG7
####### #######
SG8
-71.86 -21.80
SG9
704.22 330.78
SG10
-14.36 31.39

2.00
2.24
460.14
567.96
387.77
450.20
332.46
402.60
355.90
299.53
431.08
480.05
372.00
388.17
2190.79
2310.79
2069.72
1516.01
2005.06
2007.83
1841.17
2052.56
2098.21
2349.54
2126.07
1758.61
2280.32
1800.12
499.63
1247.41
515.92
577.70
768.00
609.72
1027.41
713.10
383.94
119.52
398.59
107.00
169.66
124.24
#######
42.97
292.17
105.00

3.00
3.12
576.09
439.59
595.45
612.96
593.82
665.91
656.08
620.09
698.70
614.75
640.45
723.04
2637.01
2675.46
2627.17
2779.18
2668.66
3093.70
2604.15
2788.09
2451.75
2855.16
2562.63
2417.31
2562.01
2569.52
1334.97
1652.02
1338.49
1615.14
1506.36
1426.17
1649.89
1237.39
330.50
169.74
332.73
150.43
225.73
176.92
#######
98.17
240.11
150.56

4.00
4.02
859.98
650.98
943.02
857.64
852.62
816.28
769.44
809.04
829.47
789.98
850.56
716.43
3840.38
3325.80
3223.41
3609.68
3551.30
3612.72
3571.78
3325.36
3443.81
3810.81
3375.31
3631.45
3948.60
3627.82
1879.97
1920.93
1953.94
1453.94
2085.71
1893.44
2061.28
1696.79
533.39
237.52
484.55
211.18
303.40
237.53
#######
154.85
400.33
216.24

5.00
5.07
938.83
883.36
1026.09
1005.70
971.62
1066.37
1072.59
1060.25
917.28
1110.16
1055.45
1066.51
4643.70
4545.62
4272.51
4745.86
4148.04
4496.06
4559.96
4568.08
4527.65
3904.33
4638.60
4245.38
4526.41
4322.88
2381.98
2363.30
1999.93
2275.00
2381.84
2201.51
2269.22
2526.47
572.65
294.47
523.10
271.98
338.44
302.38
#######
214.47
424.88
275.27

E-44

6.00
6.00
1218.89
1238.64
1321.78
1272.42
1249.03
1294.40
1266.37
1258.98
1316.24
1314.13
1285.23
1296.32
5165.52
5371.27
5049.45
5561.65
5183.96
5406.75
5073.04
5392.95
4994.60
5864.79
4436.87
5438.04
5179.77
5248.69
2797.98
2908.39
2761.21
2957.20
2875.20
2666.74
3278.20
2729.03
675.54
348.68
616.32
323.32
445.80
363.57
#######
270.43
524.61
328.99

7.00
7.11
1414.63
1562.98
1452.65
1439.24
1414.40
1396.40
1352.00
1409.86
1394.97
1523.62
1443.77
1415.94
6342.65
6519.65
5950.32
5945.82
6624.11
6466.41
6359.68
6400.19
6286.91
6001.46
6184.69
6177.68
6120.78
6365.39
3489.25
3226.17
3112.24
3078.93
3424.85
3221.06
3239.19
3106.26
792.84
416.00
705.13
387.16
512.06
436.39
#######
334.51
591.12
389.18

8.00
8.17
1667.56
1640.87
1659.42
1637.43
1614.63
1685.64
1811.86
1659.31
1674.66
1578.59
1679.05
1688.16
7061.00
7291.01
7235.74
7449.61
7085.49
6904.17
7057.10
7156.44
7231.95
6996.96
7693.77
7034.88
6964.53
7296.19
3671.28
3599.76
3844.72
3631.29
3865.27
3601.75
3887.47
3588.08
864.45
477.52
759.11
440.96
571.46
504.70
#######
396.31
671.00
452.79

9.00
9.18
1892.49
1812.06
1831.46
1823.11
1828.20
1845.52
1912.60
1863.17
1857.48
1865.17
1862.85
1907.63
8127.39
7846.39
8076.54
8229.14
8030.93
8112.95
8109.54
7776.56
7961.29
8429.53
8309.60
7910.50
8049.11
7897.74
4219.47
4280.19
4109.39
4185.49
4300.37
4127.31
3990.81
4325.29
919.19
533.00
815.75
497.67
635.60
572.13
#######
452.99
712.16
501.87

10.00
10.14
2130.27
2088.23
2088.43
2090.61
2071.89
2035.20
2076.59
2181.90
2228.06
2118.57
2132.68
2162.89
8946.87
8789.46
8806.13
8761.90
9176.28
9064.28
9048.06
9291.13
8671.26
8537.05
9522.79
8649.89
8292.95
9065.97
4581.82
4608.72
4739.84
4724.26
4665.22
4841.58
4596.93
4578.04
987.01
584.98
866.30
550.18
706.32
633.85
#######
514.09
762.19
550.57

TABLE E-24. CVP2, WATER 1, LOAD CONDITION 1c (Continued)


SG11
SG12
SG13
SG14
SG15
SG16
SG17
SG18
SG19
SG20
SG21
SG22
SG23
SG24
SG25
SG26
SG27
SG28
SG29T
SG29-45
SG29L
SG30T
SG30-45
SG30L
SG31T
SG31-45
SG31L
SG32T
SG32-45
SG32L
SG33T
SG33-45
SG33L
SG34T
SG34-45
SG34L
SG35T
SG35-45
SG35L
SG36T
SG36-45
SG36L
SG37T
SG37-45
SG37L

570.62
5.50
717.44
20.88
187.80
4.32
-250.23
-12.71
245.64
91.46
-19.42
34.54
-38.76
18.05
151.65
-864.58
-168.59
139.20
25.47
60.61
36.89
24.49
9.69
25.23
-44.58
18.97
12.10
-13.33
108.23
56.04
-11.34
-1.45
23.93
48.63
-23.67
10.71
38.54
57.26
49.12
-19.69
-26.05
-19.92
-70.94
27.76
3.78

233.56
89.06
363.69
73.54
30.27
13.07
-372.45
12.00
128.55
108.46
-26.27
33.61
-26.36
25.76
179.68
-842.88
-181.02
157.68
51.13
30.33
30.02
39.53
1.20
49.04
87.76
11.68
56.14
29.35
122.70
75.77
2.12
30.87
41.07
34.66
-17.22
9.74
8.50
42.35
46.19
31.88
20.56
1.06
-12.94
40.16
-2.17

169.22
197.45
193.81
146.58
37.17
65.48
-343.43
60.26
79.71
144.86
-31.26
68.97
-9.06
58.51
205.03
-814.85
-180.63
182.80
123.35
115.78
77.67
117.80
56.98
72.42
182.23
40.70
105.06
110.81
161.08
103.78
62.54
63.15
65.05
75.34
11.42
37.48
54.90
63.89
58.92
109.84
75.18
29.21
74.28
89.96
31.49

207.01
265.64
326.30
198.96
62.78
110.47
-314.17
96.65
167.56
204.56
-14.98
123.67
28.80
120.13
259.16
-757.12
-147.38
240.46
175.18
168.17
102.51
174.17
118.20
105.10
230.78
92.75
156.82
176.92
218.21
135.16
119.61
113.31
92.81
124.30
53.33
68.76
99.90
115.50
108.13
162.85
145.75
78.25
133.31
150.96
87.44

293.56
350.91
440.14
259.16
180.14
181.35
-234.05
145.78
253.01
266.85
-17.20
149.75
34.98
151.68
270.90
-727.89
-145.48
273.72
242.01
206.33
119.05
243.10
170.65
118.20
296.68
115.18
220.02
248.43
278.86
143.05
183.23
169.08
104.69
180.66
97.88
85.10
157.97
167.14
130.89
229.14
202.33
100.30
200.61
215.35
112.28

322.53
452.61
507.37
319.64
181.89
219.62
-193.67
190.30
273.72
308.06
-23.31
178.37
41.85
183.79
284.02
-702.89
-141.05
297.38
317.49
262.24
134.65
318.14
214.83
136.31
366.59
138.36
263.97
326.59
318.92
160.61
254.42
196.81
122.76
248.80
114.08
95.86
223.20
198.17
155.34
300.14
234.49
121.13
276.06
264.55
139.44

E-45

417.80
543.75
610.96
376.10
261.13
277.77
-112.92
239.09
352.36
367.98
-22.20
213.05
56.56
219.97
307.44
-668.76
-128.27
329.93
380.65
314.85
168.39
379.64
262.11
174.99
431.52
166.51
298.55
395.67
356.43
188.85
320.51
240.82
148.53
303.05
153.40
135.90
283.62
242.41
191.69
364.10
286.95
149.40
342.09
300.50
169.49

467.49
652.83
682.87
441.70
282.81
325.25
-71.94
287.90
399.20
424.03
-28.86
234.36
64.69
246.01
320.87
-639.03
-123.89
352.15
463.66
375.96
183.50
459.37
324.62
198.12
516.90
186.41
365.98
478.35
415.64
212.94
406.67
309.13
159.87
384.96
205.96
136.20
362.85
310.63
218.11
444.21
356.95
170.53
424.61
367.35
190.69

520.97
754.48
733.10
501.64
368.27
392.37
15.80
343.48
445.03
481.29
-33.85
248.41
65.42
264.81
325.48
-617.09
-124.43
363.94
542.59
414.31
205.59
534.84
358.56
223.70
603.19
202.23
396.59
565.90
447.50
223.38
490.29
348.90
172.89
457.49
246.04
161.04
441.72
343.49
239.28
525.96
385.53
177.23
504.95
394.17
206.50

567.85
852.91
803.10
560.92
389.92
435.99
63.94
391.14
494.60
534.52
-37.19
274.63
71.14
291.38
347.49
-590.06
-117.32
389.08
615.24
471.81
236.62
608.36
407.62
248.32
680.04
219.04
446.31
646.53
500.74
239.36
572.31
411.14
184.31
533.77
297.24
167.84
516.58
405.73
270.05
600.45
453.07
195.78
581.06
445.37
225.91

625.80
945.21
908.47
618.60
437.45
487.43
123.07
439.73
561.93
591.45
-39.59
305.38
84.93
331.98
372.35
-553.47
-100.87
426.78
685.43
522.22
262.77
676.17
460.40
280.19
742.19
250.62
494.68
720.42
551.20
266.40
643.70
459.40
214.72
598.75
334.55
198.34
584.88
454.41
312.48
665.68
507.80
229.77
648.04
496.85
258.50

TABLE E-25. CVP3, AIR 1 LOAD CONDITION 1a


Load Step
Pressure
Frame-1
Frame-2
Frame-3
Frame-4
Frame-5
Frame-6
Frame-7
Frame-8
Frame-9
Frame-10
Frame-11
Frame-12
Hoop-1
Hoop-2
Hoop-3
Hoop-4
Hoop-5
Hoop-6
Hoop-7
Hoop-8
Hoop-9
Hoop-10
Hoop-11
Hoop-12
Hoop-13
Hoop-14
Long-1
Long-2
Long-3
Long-4
Long-5
Long-6
Long-7
Long-8
SG1
SG2
SG3
SG4
SG5
SG6
SG7
SG8
SG9
SG10
SG11

0.00
-0.01
-34.94
-38.75
-48.53
11.48
22.09
16.51
27.23
-33.03
43.19
-2.05
-13.84
16.96
45.47
36.28
-73.01
5.60
-70.94
-41.42
59.09
10.42
-245.47
40.08
-85.18
242.19
-32.30
-25.41
9.41
24.61
-7.40
-15.12
29.48
-52.16
-2.52
11.33
-27.68
26.57
427.80
338.59
53.48
17.16
238.98
47.70
20.41
3.98
7.67

1.00
0.89
190.83
160.93
179.28
168.67
181.26
179.17
182.08
147.46
179.37
175.07
184.55
185.19
768.14
771.11
760.53
772.19
787.30
768.37
791.41
760.81
768.85
767.14
794.54
781.65
761.77
773.57
12.95
29.47
-7.40
-12.67
-7.72
-2.01
-1.32
17.49
-108.01
-74.14
340.09
207.75
-45.96
48.98
79.79
-25.42
51.82
-1.30
-8.50

2.00
1.76
378.58
369.12
379.54
379.18
373.07
372.35
352.85
386.89
364.75
352.59
358.06
345.16
1540.31
1547.31
1546.52
1547.88
1554.08
1553.97
1552.81
1555.33
1552.76
1564.72
1558.09
1539.79
1541.00
1550.35
5.87
30.69
-3.67
2.03
-10.12
-2.01
5.89
-5.90
-132.40
-100.09
359.55
213.43
-64.24
89.69
69.58
-29.04
94.81
-10.85
-26.33

3.00
2.64
542.26
540.88
538.63
538.00
537.32
540.04
537.36
548.82
564.09
580.01
539.93
539.69
2367.47
2326.97
2335.86
2375.26
2324.35
2324.62
2319.53
2305.48
2334.62
2327.71
2349.07
2325.49
2320.00
2319.51
5.87
30.69
-2.42
-10.22
23.48
10.23
-6.12
-7.13
-109.83
-72.52
414.21
263.05
-34.45
132.77
99.39
-0.70
141.83
-22.88
-43.41

4.00
3.52
735.18
723.03
726.87
751.95
715.34
714.52
737.40
726.27
730.29
709.32
708.33
744.63
3088.47
3069.18
3087.08
3067.95
3091.44
3082.80
3094.02
3085.21
3085.79
3085.43
3097.78
3022.39
3091.74
3088.82
3.50
27.04
-1.18
-5.32
10.28
1.66
-6.12
1.48
-86.19
-44.24
472.82
312.45
-0.87
176.24
129.76
37.36
190.15
-39.18
-61.61

5.00
4.40
912.58
906.88
915.08
919.33
903.68
905.94
915.01
905.40
901.68
904.01
908.83
906.29
3850.07
3851.27
3885.82
3842.25
3855.03
3855.92
3866.83
3879.65
3860.55
3857.62
3863.10
3860.15
3841.22
3865.53
8.23
25.83
0.07
0.80
-64.12
2.89
37.13
-12.06
-45.29
7.31
515.09
369.56
55.92
222.48
199.68
91.31
241.43
-54.01
-79.07

E-46

6.00
5.28
1087.25
1074.10
1097.14
1089.17
1096.20
1116.75
1115.82
1088.78
1107.05
1115.01
1103.34
1117.18
4612.28
4648.42
4657.10
4635.70
4646.63
4637.05
4636.62
4652.03
4637.13
4653.31
4650.54
4646.01
4650.05
4642.24
3.50
28.26
-2.42
21.62
-62.92
2.89
32.33
1.48
-11.18
47.30
556.90
423.39
97.75
267.20
255.04
129.68
289.91
-66.63
-92.11

7.00
6.17
1271.65
1285.89
1311.21
1267.01
1272.59
1259.03
1265.15
1279.25
1260.31
1238.39
1274.33
1266.02
5417.33
5402.72
5390.22
5579.68
5398.56
5392.83
5408.74
5424.40
5395.56
5405.61
5399.26
5402.22
5399.53
5396.76
3.51
30.69
2.56
-2.87
-35.32
0.44
41.95
-7.13
13.39
80.49
588.97
463.41
136.55
311.91
282.72
169.22
339.11
-84.02
-106.06

8.00
7.04
1458.09
1468.44
1456.95
1441.72
1445.84
1455.98
1465.90
1441.91
1448.15
1449.33
1458.66
1433.61
6198.30
6194.79
6191.62
6203.13
6197.82
6200.23
6198.97
6160.62
6187.27
6194.69
6183.63
6151.63
6194.15
6122.30
4.69
27.04
2.56
9.37
136.28
-4.45
-9.73
-9.60
68.78
138.84
649.61
527.73
190.55
356.69
338.67
214.12
387.27
-102.71
-120.41

9.00
7.92
1627.97
1656.88
1642.82
1646.40
1652.53
1629.80
1650.68
1638.54
1618.09
1661.53
1623.92
1642.26
6966.25
6975.86
6980.58
6959.77
6995.79
6982.29
6967.82
6955.14
6869.56
6990.47
6998.82
6982.05
6995.64
6965.67
7.05
28.26
3.80
6.92
-18.52
1.66
37.14
12.57
97.57
170.94
688.71
572.29
224.96
401.07
369.86
248.74
435.40
-115.66
-130.88

10.00
8.80
1812.27
1823.36
1824.19
1810.35
1818.46
1833.16
1787.09
1814.37
1815.79
1785.77
1839.79
1830.00
7748.17
7723.77
7744.41
7723.04
7729.58
7736.31
7761.97
7734.17
7445.86
7698.66
7721.02
7744.97
7714.74
7734.28
7.05
25.83
-4.91
-10.22
-34.12
4.11
-13.33
8.87
113.17
185.81
715.96
600.77
240.61
444.02
381.99
267.22
480.46
-134.45
-142.65

TABLE E-25. CVP3, AIR 1 LOAD CONDITION 1a (Continued)


SG12
SG13
SG14
SG15
SG16
SG17
SG18
SG19
SG20
SG21
SG22
SG23
SG24
SG25
SG26
SG27
SG28
SG29
SG30
SG31
SG32-T
SG32-45
SG32-L
SG33-T
SG33-45
SG33-T
SG34-T
SG34-45
SG34-L
SG35-T
SG35-45
SG35-L
SG36-T
SG36-45
SG36-L
SG37-T
SG37-45
SG37-L
SG38-T
SG38-45
SG38-L
SG39-T
SG39-45
SG39-L
SG40-T
SG40-45
SG40-L

-20.19
-13.19
-31.62
4.96
153.61
33909.4
14.75
22.14
81.40
31.12
-47.49
-16.23
3.43
6.58
41.02
28.37
-18.61
39.26
-30.80
-22.92
10.59
-23.44
9.37
27.17
-22.00
38.43
7.00
2.84
32.93
46.91
59.59
76.52
0.67
25.18
29.59
418.69
129.57
89.52
36.92
-12.65
-2.90
-13.27
-4.03
45.81
38.47
45.86
50.09

-15.42
-24.57
-32.17
17.02
151.60
34007.0
3.10
0.98
81.04
23.95
-47.45
-36.43
-2.81
2.26
34.96
27.18
-9.78
38.53
-35.35
-28.94
93.66
11.47
7.13
111.63
5.03
19.54
97.62
48.35
27.99
113.40
93.57
70.46
100.55
53.12
12.51
458.17
158.95
89.52
103.00
21.13
-15.24
78.61
47.13
44.53
95.05
67.59
33.46

-17.71
-37.13
-42.08
17.62
145.37
34315.9
-14.11
-28.11
77.72
13.27
-52.59
-65.82
-9.61
-4.55
23.93
24.29
-11.99
36.51
-46.79
-37.98
175.53
42.39
-3.88
192.73
29.17
9.64
189.51
88.91
18.63
174.19
119.83
61.27
195.47
91.38
6.95
495.78
179.51
70.64
184.85
55.84
-32.09
165.18
95.53
45.17
146.54
85.12
12.26

-18.17
-45.47
-50.47
15.97
141.32
34630.2
-32.74
-58.29
74.77
2.95
-54.24
-96.10
-14.20
-12.56
16.94
21.16
-14.20
33.93
-57.81
-48.45
253.53
77.16
-7.96
268.81
57.26
4.68
278.63
127.45
7.44
231.80
145.16
51.16
283.57
125.77
2.45
532.55
194.72
53.23
265.40
89.07
-45.71
247.13
139.60
45.67
195.28
99.73
-8.21

-15.74
-50.88
-55.33
13.95
139.82
34792.6
-52.25
-88.29
74.23
-6.44
-52.91
-127.15
-17.32
-19.65
13.08
19.92
-19.35
33.38
-69.66
-68.61
329.16
115.24
-3.97
341.82
87.01
4.87
364.32
164.04
-1.55
291.28
172.72
43.45
369.16
160.78
0.11
570.90
211.63
37.65
345.08
123.60
-57.65
325.84
183.61
48.01
243.53
115.25
-27.03

-14.68
-55.33
-61.44
10.93
138.14
34390.0
-72.26
-118.68
72.02
-16.38
-49.43
-160.03
-17.32
-27.94
10.32
17.85
-25.24
32.10
-81.52
-83.27
400.86
149.81
-1.49
412.36
114.33
5.97
448.19
201.83
-12.74
352.94
201.76
33.53
450.54
198.00
-2.69
610.54
230.37
21.52
422.76
160.34
-68.03
401.07
229.14
48.70
293.14
135.70
-46.04

E-47

-17.62
-57.39
-71.84
11.38
132.76
34621.9
-92.49
-149.77
67.78
-29.83
-46.67
-191.60
-20.81
-37.65
7.75
14.08
-28.18
30.08
-90.10
-95.75
472.44
186.26
-5.44
481.77
143.10
0.46
530.33
236.09
-24.84
418.14
230.39
21.58
530.18
233.12
-6.55
653.50
246.13
3.01
499.61
192.28
-79.26
475.68
270.31
46.55
345.39
155.24
-64.32

-17.53
-62.29
-76.97
11.29
130.09
34650.8
-111.16
-178.10
66.12
-39.21
-43.91
-222.61
-21.91
-45.15
7.01
11.96
-28.91
28.60
-97.99
-109.88
540.57
220.56
-5.07
548.96
170.99
-2.29
609.87
270.35
-35.48
483.43
260.67
11.65
606.87
270.25
-7.70
698.92
263.18
-11.47
575.72
226.04
-87.65
548.06
311.65
44.44
399.24
178.45
-79.68

-18.17
-62.48
-84.36
9.37
126.35
34766.1
-132.33
-209.22
66.13
-50.27
-35.83
-255.69
-23.56
-52.15
7.20
10.22
-31.86
29.71
-106.96
-125.00
607.16
255.12
-6.26
613.46
200.20
-4.49
688.81
307.23
-45.02
547.90
292.28
2.83
679.27
303.16
-8.85
744.44
281.01
-26.14
652.13
253.98
-96.70
616.89
350.95
44.53
450.63
199.61
-94.11

-18.72
-62.02
-91.20
11.61
123.55
35257.5
-152.61
-238.12
64.10
-60.58
-30.46
-284.15
-23.56
-60.20
6.09
7.55
-31.12
28.06
-114.63
-138.36
672.41
289.12
-8.69
678.50
228.29
-8.53
767.50
342.80
-56.40
616.12
324.79
-8.01
752.53
334.91
-14.22
793.74
303.21
-39.70
727.93
289.24
-105.70
686.59
390.99
41.19
505.31
224.47
-108.92

-21.25
-65.51
-97.72
12.44
120.35
36031.9
-172.91
-266.86
60.79
-72.00
-29.45
-313.93
-26.32
-68.31
3.70
4.75
-31.12
26.41
-121.72
-155.46
738.06
323.84
-13.83
744.44
254.39
-16.23
845.17
376.39
-67.78
684.78
356.41
-19.22
824.03
365.03
-19.32
844.32
323.80
-52.91
803.99
319.02
-114.66
754.70
429.11
37.03
560.39
248.00
-122.80

TABLE E-26. CVP3, AIR 1 LOAD CONDITION 1b


Load Step
Pressure
Frame-1
Frame-2
Frame-3
Frame-4
Frame-5
Frame-6
Frame-7
Frame-8
Frame-9
Frame-10
Frame-11
Frame-12
Hoop-1
Hoop-2
Hoop-3
Hoop-4
Hoop-5
Hoop-6
Hoop-7
Hoop-8
Hoop-9
Hoop-10
Hoop-11
Hoop-12
Hoop-13
Hoop-14
Long-1
Long-2
Long-3
Long-4
Long-5
Long-6
Long-7
Long-8
SG1
SG2
SG3
SG4
SG5
SG6
SG7
SG8
SG9
SG10
SG11

0.00
-0.01
-6.90
-8.73
12.01
3.34
7.04
-23.77
22.63
1.97
-55.69
5.41
-16.65
-4.96
16.04
-10.67
30.53
-81.43
301.58
36.24
37.17
-33.71
347.79
-126.28
471.69
197.72
-54.56
-40.20
3.50
17.32
2.56
-1.65
27.08
-2.01
-3.72
-0.98
15.23
84.00
456.89
398.22
113.71
25.87
300.46
93.74
27.94
6.69
4.73

1.00
-0.02
8.75
-8.59
31.04
-1.68
34.79
-28.69
1.84
7.02
15.71
22.52
12.03
5.30
-9.70
34.47
-76.50
51.88
-16.15
12.20
-85.18
32.49
-240.05
85.29
-192.15
134.72
12.22
11.57
1234.77
1221.36
1205.84
1227.68
1230.55
1230.84
1221.79
1219.03
-16.68
38.31
599.98
412.48
71.12
7.76
247.91
66.48
12.33
41.80
40.37

2.00
-0.02
3.32
1.57
46.22
4.95
-27.58
25.39
14.47
-21.68
31.97
36.86
-6.02
-2.78
10.53
65.16
-81.77
-25.88
-69.10
1.11
-48.66
-41.07
311.53
-90.12
82.63
201.44
-32.31
-18.02
2437.95
2475.47
2477.81
2490.31
2458.27
2463.94
2463.17
2484.83
-25.48
20.70
736.74
449.25
54.53
-11.31
239.62
57.59
-2.74
76.27
78.59

3.00
-0.03
-3.20
764.76
-71.81
10.49
14.20
18.99
-4.50
-6.21
-20.41
33.39
-24.62
-9.73
14.21
9.19
-123.90
51.90
-12.50
137.94
163.20
17.78
-143.89
14.76
-205.06
561.01
-32.31
-25.41
3704.39
3702.34
3652.23
3607.97
3709.50
3667.19
3663.21
3646.73
-32.27
0.52
855.31
477.44
29.06
-31.35
219.65
33.61
-21.11
112.97
114.62

4.00
-0.02
-8.98
-23.01
16.81
1.26
36.01
-32.56
34.20
13.54
-0.39
44.53
3.23
-7.19
-13.38
-12.47
139.33
-53.65
-112.93
6.66
11.60
-4.29
273.40
11.15
-127.59
-189.62
27.06
4.17
4874.27
4907.60
4881.64
4935.25
4903.37
4895.15
4898.34
4911.06
-39.79
-17.45
957.85
480.23
10.27
-49.55
172.04
22.48
-34.89
155.20
151.17

5.00
-0.03
8.68
19.13
0.09
-1.75
14.02
25.61
39.93
3.77
-1.57
-47.89
8.87
5.49
23.40
-28.72
-2.81
-31.43
-111.10
-32.17
75.52
3.07
-5.99
32.84
-111.00
88.37
-10.04
-10.62
6140.39
6137.77
6137.80
6139.47
6137.46
6146.96
6144.89
6136.60
-60.88
-54.69
1062.31
495.18
-29.78
-68.98
145.43
-5.82
-52.71
192.98
189.39

E-48

6.00
-0.04
0.53
902.30
-20.04
-8.19
-2.78
-18.06
-38.59
-0.67
-39.25
-4.12
26.54
-2.45
-6.02
-32.33
83.17
-44.40
55.07
-82.09
77.34
10.42
52.07
0.30
-182.93
219.98
-24.88
-18.02
7340.80
7356.26
7345.96
7331.94
7344.38
7345.44
7354.64
7344.18
-77.93
-81.98
1161.81
509.76
-57.92
-85.72
122.53
-26.71
-68.32
228.42
226.88

7.00
-0.03
11.06
428.13
28.20
2.35
-12.93
-36.57
-33.27
2.92
32.45
9.81
-15.64
1.17
16.04
-21.50
39.30
-74.02
-85.53
26.99
84.64
3.07
-9.62
27.42
-168.17
105.06
4.80
-18.02
8603.81
8594.19
8585.20
8588.08
8602.93
8590.39
8595.65
8534.52
-105.08
-124.26
1237.81
507.51
-98.06
-103.18
83.32
-49.56
-83.38
265.42
264.91

8.00
-0.02
-17.72
-125.66
-7.34
-9.21
18.63
6.37
10.08
1.49
-9.11
-26.07
-28.92
-15.83
5.01
-17.89
-39.67
51.90
228.56
-15.53
31.69
3.07
115.58
-5.13
-99.94
342.30
-2.62
-3.22
9817.06
9817.32
9776.90
9797.45
9826.46
9803.31
9817.21
9644.58
-109.85
-119.46
1302.93
508.89
-95.78
-125.29
58.50
-52.08
-95.89
302.77
300.96

9.00
-0.02
3.54
64.35
-23.92
1.72
-35.99
27.31
27.86
-3.13
-38.20
24.41
13.90
0.29
25.23
-19.69
-74.74
-42.54
-105.60
-17.38
-21.27
-19.00
131.89
-5.13
-153.41
82.81
-17.46
-18.01
11022.3
10994.6
11001.3
11037.8
11038.3
11045.9
10952.6
10752.5
-161.19
-170.95
1350.17
466.02
-139.49
-160.08
-27.11
-84.63
-113.70
336.53
338.23

10.00
-0.03
3.95
-296.69
-33.80
2.13
42.06
10.76
-0.89
-14.64
23.38
12.90
38.16
11.20
28.92
-3.45
-97.57
-27.73
-83.71
161.96
18.90
-11.64
-232.77
-43.10
322.33
188.45
-32.30
-32.81
12034.0
12020.0
12067.7
12223.0
12193.8
12262.9
11851.3
11658.5
-162.48
-180.12
1409.47
477.71
-152.78
-176.45
-42.50
-95.58
-126.19
367.70
369.65

TABLE E-26. CVP3, AIR 1 LOAD CONDITION 1b (Continued)


SG12
SG13
SG14
SG15
SG16
SG17
SG18
SG19
SG20
SG21
SG22
SG23
SG24
SG25
SG26
SG27
SG28
SG29
SG30
SG31
SG32-T
SG32-45
SG32-L
SG33-T
SG33-45
SG33-T
SG34-T
SG34-45
SG34-L
SG35-T
SG35-45
SG35-L
SG36-T
SG36-45
SG36-L
SG37-T
SG37-45
SG37-L
SG38-T
SG38-45
SG38-L
SG39-T
SG39-45
SG39-L
SG40-T
SG40-45
SG40-L

-33.56
-17.69
-30.89
4.28
145.93
42396.7
14.71
34.85
81.23
9.03
-22.79
-16.42
-1.71
1.15
31.28
11.23
-33.33
27.14
-28.28
-20.26
11.92
-31.20
1.30
26.39
-22.97
34.40
13.33
0.73
28.91
41.00
54.64
74.33
-4.66
23.17
34.69
417.54
136.02
86.60
48.50
-13.76
-10.01
-12.36
-8.44
38.49
41.44
42.39
49.18

59.42
95.08
96.05
64.16
255.96
46586.4
83.58
140.66
190.17
104.04
89.95
89.89
110.85
112.86
144.88
104.08
15.97
110.89
3.83
12.11
-15.28
9.13
101.77
-18.64
-0.80
148.12
-24.45
31.11
135.10
9.61
83.64
177.58
-47.61
51.00
152.23
392.14
161.87
187.94
9.03
27.19
99.57
-40.23
22.19
127.45
28.07
83.65
128.67

147.01
207.47
216.61
126.19
360.38
46268.7
151.03
238.21
296.37
186.53
198.65
186.10
213.31
222.31
255.54
195.14
67.47
195.75
37.26
47.42
-42.02
36.84
193.75
-63.25
13.38
260.38
-61.55
64.57
240.01
-21.26
115.41
279.75
-91.49
77.47
267.33
363.57
184.26
289.30
-26.76
60.98
201.03
-68.83
49.47
217.02
12.71
120.55
207.82

233.18
312.73
334.53
183.26
462.79
46169.1
214.26
328.64
395.47
266.13
291.70
279.06
316.75
329.33
360.76
284.41
117.52
277.91
71.49
74.98
-68.95
81.30
282.58
-107.88
38.86
367.02
-97.06
85.30
339.86
-49.81
135.09
376.48
-135.03
89.23
380.68
335.94
191.82
390.00
-64.39
87.07
302.83
-95.81
65.64
302.52
-0.56
148.29
287.29

326.50
426.39
459.38
245.79
571.89
45737.8
281.79
418.43
495.38
333.50
373.47
371.40
417.72
437.93
475.62
376.51
169.75
359.81
107.27
108.87
-100.31
108.96
382.01
-156.62
42.16
483.84
-133.78
118.39
438.70
-77.47
167.21
473.30
-182.57
103.85
496.04
300.50
202.27
493.53
-104.21
128.37
402.29
-125.15
97.55
387.67
-15.88
190.28
365.32

409.97
535.68
572.66
304.85
674.76
45281.8
348.43
504.20
587.79
387.83
452.18
463.58
517.62
547.67
583.72
468.82
220.52
442.11
140.57
145.55
-127.06
147.08
466.39
-203.25
43.95
593.17
-168.45
141.40
534.27
-104.31
189.43
565.73
-230.35
102.29
609.92
263.08
197.13
596.18
-140.36
159.23
500.92
-154.12
123.13
474.90
-31.43
227.19
446.51

E-49

491.42
642.22
676.95
362.81
773.65
44619.8
412.31
585.56
674.12
434.78
526.91
549.52
609.99
651.88
687.96
557.08
274.23
519.44
176.07
181.23
-154.39
181.63
550.04
-247.13
36.01
695.90
-201.24
160.88
623.79
-128.81
207.98
653.21
-275.89
95.41
717.92
227.86
188.87
695.34
-175.05
191.36
592.11
-181.27
148.66
557.34
-43.09
264.57
525.54

574.89
751.15
777.85
421.69
874.09
44396.2
475.63
667.28
760.45
482.66
602.36
636.37
704.56
757.20
796.79
653.30
321.32
599.54
210.06
218.66
-183.33
217.55
636.84
-292.16
25.59
799.00
-234.85
179.62
712.94
-152.72
227.27
739.77
-319.95
84.54
821.52
193.33
178.04
791.76
-210.66
222.03
685.73
-210.34
178.88
643.02
-58.32
305.83
606.30

657.14
864.74
870.76
479.15
974.12
43906.3
538.47
701.95
830.29
532.99
448.00
697.77
786.36
863.15
907.55
756.35
365.51
681.53
243.02
254.87
-210.51
247.21
719.14
-329.19
20.73
904.75
-271.97
182.58
795.75
-161.59
239.60
820.16
-362.67
49.32
932.19
148.49
129.97
888.08
-246.47
253.27
768.78
-237.14
194.93
728.22
-72.46
333.79
688.24

749.82
986.42
982.58
533.58
1093.77
44231.4
604.13
716.24
904.02
595.36
295.90
757.20
872.77
979.06
1026.96
868.44
417.71
771.48
273.13
291.85
-242.50
274.53
815.18
-368.13
-15.58
1034.72
-315.37
188.77
887.85
-168.67
261.22
909.12
-389.31
50.41
1051.19
84.90
70.48
992.19
-289.36
285.90
861.51
-267.25
223.63
823.59
-95.21
372.50
780.16

813.36
1078.29
1057.06
581.08
1178.85
43722.4
657.55
769.80
970.47
634.03
302.37
822.75
947.70
1066.52
1121.45
952.66
460.39
842.38
303.62
326.34
-263.70
305.31
879.57
-403.52
-26.41
1117.09
-342.84
200.52
959.66
-187.40
273.00
979.41
-422.77
31.56
1137.45
50.01
42.04
1069.28
-317.66
305.76
938.69
-291.99
241.84
897.36
-111.00
398.28
849.87

TABLE E-27. CVP3, AIR 1 LOAD CONDITION 1c


Load Step
Pressure
Frame-1
Frame-2
Frame-3
Frame-4
Frame-5
Frame-6
Frame-7
Frame-8
Frame-9
Frame-10
Frame-11
Frame-12
Hoop-1
Hoop-2
Hoop-3
Hoop-4
Hoop-5
Hoop-6
Hoop-7
Hoop-8
Hoop-9
Hoop-10
Hoop-11
Hoop-12
Hoop-13
Hoop-14
Long-1
Long-2
Long-3
Long-4
Long-5
Long-6
Long-7
Long-8
SG1
SG2
SG3
SG4
SG5
SG6
SG7
SG8
SG9
SG10
SG11

0.00
-0.02
-8.39
-51.95
36.27
27.71
40.06
47.82
21.01
38.23
14.18
50.28
-19.90
-1.40
1.33
38.08
-29.14
-44.40
45.94
-13.68
55.44
-33.71
-13.25
-15.98
43.90
-4.29
-10.04
4.18
10.59
31.90
1.31
2.03
30.68
-17.91
-1.32
-3.44
-26.40
21.80
386.90
313.09
42.71
16.75
219.08
33.88
16.92
6.78
8.40

1.00
0.88
176.45
181.16
173.54
190.48
172.03
170.10
181.81
197.12
175.59
173.08
175.85
167.62
770.05
783.82
767.62
794.49
626.68
772.15
786.01
760.73
765.14
776.10
770.49
759.33
746.85
773.49
1221.91
1215.41
1229.61
1216.78
1215.08
1199.16
1229.13
1206.84
-105.08
-80.92
476.86
238.69
-58.29
33.21
67.93
-37.15
36.76
36.25
27.33

2.00
1.75
373.92
383.52
364.60
365.89
370.13
369.46
351.75
373.75
375.84
365.27
360.38
333.68
1538.78
1545.82
1527.52
1542.64
1545.26
1545.04
1551.29
1540.31
1537.93
1537.28
1539.34
1546.89
1533.27
1535.25
2443.86
2466.96
2436.74
2440.11
2451.07
2449.26
2445.15
2428.20
-127.66
-104.93
656.53
310.50
-71.22
54.86
51.63
-34.27
66.53
66.98
46.81

3.00
2.64
546.43
571.15
547.94
545.63
563.94
542.47
536.42
565.10
570.11
584.24
540.72
531.83
2318.53
2331.28
2340.08
2305.60
2325.05
2310.53
2322.05
2305.25
2325.32
2327.48
2323.02
2310.44
2282.67
2319.28
3684.32
3674.40
3672.14
3686.33
3678.30
3685.54
3678.83
3671.35
-139.57
-128.91
784.07
357.96
-92.30
76.12
36.79
-41.55
94.82
94.84
67.02

4.00
3.52
724.53
727.92
726.55
717.15
713.30
726.08
714.62
725.88
712.45
724.42
718.09
723.48
3101.66
3091.16
3080.37
3073.81
3080.79
3079.41
3087.02
3099.92
3091.24
3089.05
3097.78
3081.70
3076.90
3088.82
4891.78
4911.01
4905.02
4900.72
4905.55
4908.36
4906.53
4898.49
-141.01
-130.94
963.99
434.62
-89.44
99.58
23.68
-28.35
126.76
123.74
91.45

5.00
4.40
892.66
916.32
912.40
913.19
904.43
906.69
912.50
913.23
918.32
913.56
901.31
915.87
3870.69
3853.46
3889.72
3848.19
3870.02
3860.00
3854.44
3864.17
3852.53
3853.23
3864.17
3866.79
3892.38
3872.15
6126.79
6122.58
6119.77
6132.74
6130.85
6130.45
6123.85
6133.52
-101.77
-89.13
1140.70
533.96
-45.64
127.46
64.22
14.10
163.70
155.15
114.79

E-50

6.00
5.27
1112.71
1103.25
1096.78
1083.62
1087.20
1087.53
1086.08
1093.49
1066.45
1197.20
1099.53
1104.61
4627.00
4644.80
4627.27
4613.47
4637.50
4638.90
4618.35
4659.38
4638.94
4646.08
4628.41
4623.77
4598.11
4671.83
7365.88
7340.72
7256.58
7371.37
7353.05
7354.25
7346.50
7365.35
-87.64
-88.07
1258.98
576.26
-46.50
152.39
64.99
21.42
195.10
185.11
140.50

7.00
6.15
1250.70
1280.36
1278.33
1263.27
1255.05
1267.28
1303.30
1267.45
1264.01
1248.98
1259.42
1271.45
5420.46
5398.57
5403.71
5408.77
5412.63
5407.09
5406.37
5409.69
5404.63
5405.61
5412.17
5409.63
5488.57
5418.95
8583.43
8542.81
8373.28
8586.49
8580.99
8575.35
8570.07
8573.54
-102.86
-101.60
1370.59
615.68
-52.09
178.79
56.66
30.94
228.53
215.54
166.96

8.00
7.05
1450.42
1443.32
1463.03
1444.38
1460.58
1450.10
1477.34
1420.64
1468.47
1443.55
1452.97
1429.55
6174.40
6178.54
6184.60
6179.06
6190.52
6172.50
6173.40
6190.04
6138.28
6187.46
6192.86
6166.45
6149.62
6181.48
9775.54
9783.06
9618.59
9819.25
9804.65
9804.29
9794.16
9810.53
-98.12
-111.80
1460.65
643.68
-63.06
203.77
57.77
33.38
259.99
241.53
194.56

9.00
7.92
1622.65
1646.30
1632.37
1629.01
1642.03
1639.84
1642.21
1628.35
1623.46
1634.12
1656.21
1649.31
6967.64
6950.17
6932.84
6959.31
6958.14
6962.65
6946.60
6939.73
6819.89
6953.60
6963.08
6944.29
6965.26
6787.44
10983.2
10989.5
10901.4
11025.3
11035.7
11033.4
11037.7
10922.1
-100.86
-129.12
1559.82
671.49
-83.35
228.51
35.09
23.21
288.44
266.43
221.73

10.00
8.80
1836.71
1825.43
1819.37
1827.92
1813.61
1792.74
1813.10
1835.20
1821.20
1820.38
1823.04
1828.44
7751.08
7762.72
7752.41
7794.49
7739.76
7680.07
7680.83
7550.27
7511.18
7749.30
7678.61
7744.97
7699.89
7512.37
12013.9
11992.1
11943.3
12285.4
11506.2
12508.7
13556.2
11689.4
-97.38
-141.93
1638.74
698.70
-97.06
256.41
27.63
25.64
321.54
289.46
249.87

TABLE E-27. CVP3, AIR 1 LOAD CONDITION 1c (Continued)


SG12
SG13
SG14
SG15
SG16
SG17
SG18
SG19
SG20
SG21
SG22
SG23
SG24
SG25
SG26
SG27
SG28
SG29
SG30
SG31
SG32-T
SG32-45
SG32-L
SG33-T
SG33-45
SG33-T
SG34-T
SG34-45
SG34-L
SG35-T
SG35-45
SG35-L
SG36-T
SG36-45
SG36-L
SG37-T
SG37-45
SG37-L
SG38-T
SG38-45
SG38-L
SG39-T
SG39-45
SG39-L
SG40-T
SG40-45
SG40-L

-22.30
-11.00
-20.89
10.33
152.89
30908.8
14.85
20.30
81.04
24.50
-42.86
-18.99
3.43
5.80
41.02
21.76
-12.73
34.85
-29.80
-20.90
11.37
-16.15
9.60
28.96
-18.56
36.79
12.60
8.56
31.29
44.39
61.24
75.24
7.46
26.84
27.61
405.11
128.48
86.78
42.07
-9.90
-5.93
-5.20
0.01
43.71
36.88
42.03
44.79

70.44
89.95
94.87
80.94
257.59
31903.3
70.56
94.48
185.22
102.58
49.55
58.87
102.60
109.00
143.61
111.22
40.99
115.86
-4.53
7.06
70.94
53.68
100.91
71.92
26.74
131.99
67.90
84.56
129.06
81.14
124.79
169.52
66.77
83.30
130.06
418.87
174.92
180.26
75.47
61.53
83.38
58.81
75.83
130.08
78.46
99.36
105.29

156.97
188.92
202.50
139.12
359.30
32633.6
121.66
156.17
283.57
173.33
112.44
122.61
196.66
211.51
239.99
200.85
87.36
197.65
19.36
37.33
122.21
116.51
184.50
106.46
71.05
237.89
121.67
145.96
221.92
111.68
172.21
260.54
115.44
138.70
241.51
428.04
203.41
264.08
121.56
129.32
166.07
114.03
139.87
217.31
114.49
146.11
167.43

245.07
291.46
309.12
196.66
462.51
33310.1
173.60
215.80
378.17
239.24
171.09
185.96
293.06
313.87
340.90
292.78
130.77
280.48
43.29
66.81
171.06
183.12
270.93
137.34
110.61
344.64
176.33
210.63
310.33
143.60
224.72
347.26
158.58
189.70
350.37
436.80
232.39
353.88
167.25
197.44
252.52
164.64
210.77
302.98
150.58
203.61
233.20

334.09
400.68
418.34
256.40
571.19
33915.3
223.35
267.65
468.46
292.22
196.31
247.06
387.75
422.06
450.21
390.95
182.98
364.74
68.86
98.66
214.43
250.65
360.97
161.73
137.94
459.58
228.01
271.45
397.39
177.20
274.81
432.27
192.33
223.46
467.02
436.30
238.58
446.55
211.81
266.07
340.17
209.36
280.29
391.70
183.40
262.09
302.70

420.16
511.66
522.12
312.01
677.01
34824.9
269.31
314.06
550.42
334.05
222.14
301.62
478.69
524.47
560.55
487.44
228.61
446.70
93.53
131.69
252.83
317.11
446.90
183.55
154.67
568.04
279.58
327.40
476.67
211.45
319.09
509.87
222.46
247.29
577.04
433.68
229.43
531.65
256.43
332.02
423.68
250.46
347.23
476.74
214.41
319.73
370.62

E-51

504.55
624.01
620.85
369.75
781.04
35524.6
315.54
360.60
630.06
372.87
246.87
356.86
568.24
624.94
671.89
583.82
279.35
527.29
120.25
163.36
290.53
382.49
530.03
205.43
165.48
671.62
330.90
384.75
554.76
250.19
368.64
586.07
252.36
266.44
679.83
436.94
225.74
616.83
300.82
398.09
506.92
290.41
417.26
559.98
248.13
383.31
441.94

587.00
726.69
717.24
427.88
882.20
35962.9
360.87
406.61
706.63
411.91
264.09
413.41
655.65
721.96
777.22
677.82
328.65
604.80
146.98
194.44
330.68
448.45
611.24
227.60
175.76
772.87
382.44
440.84
630.33
291.48
416.94
659.76
282.47
284.56
781.03
445.52
224.82
704.62
346.51
464.93
589.48
331.86
485.82
640.11
283.40
446.63
511.16

669.08
835.22
811.32
484.83
981.46
36332.1
408.68
454.55
785.56
450.30
288.21
468.40
743.93
817.67
885.86
770.88
373.60
683.92
173.47
223.64
367.84
512.23
690.34
248.25
184.98
872.46
433.15
497.04
706.40
332.65
466.62
733.96
309.70
301.91
881.12
453.40
224.13
790.92
391.92
530.03
671.02
370.81
554.07
719.80
316.99
510.22
581.57

749.09
938.01
898.56
540.36
1079.28
35910.6
453.06
499.60
859.66
486.90
307.88
526.20
829.43
907.99
989.64
863.29
420.65
760.64
201.98
256.13
406.87
577.69
764.19
270.90
195.06
964.65
484.65
550.71
778.97
374.92
515.05
804.46
339.05
317.02
974.71
465.83
223.37
874.25
438.31
595.35
749.84
411.85
619.00
795.89
353.13
572.00
650.90

835.12
1050.33
987.45
596.55
1185.20
36396.8
493.49
543.64
931.36
521.02
334.60
599.34
934.94
996.84
1102.44
961.03
466.32
840.45
227.17
284.77
441.76
646.94
841.87
289.84
196.91
1060.51
535.51
612.19
846.75
416.03
570.02
871.62
366.08
334.80
1065.00
475.47
226.70
953.16
476.54
676.95
844.24
447.84
701.73
874.29
384.71
650.94
720.03

TABLE E-28. CVP3, AIR 2 LOAD CONDITION 1a


Load Step
Pressure
Frame-1
Frame-2
Frame-3
Frame-4
Frame-5
Frame-6
Frame-7
Frame-8
Frame-9
Frame-10
Frame-11
Frame-12
Hoop-1
Hoop-2
Hoop-3
Hoop-4
Hoop-5
Hoop-6
Hoop-7
Hoop-8
Hoop-9
Hoop-10
Hoop-11
Hoop-12
Hoop-13
Hoop-14
Long-1
Long-2
Long-3
Long-4
Long-5
Long-6
Long-7
Long-8
SG1
SG2
SG3
SG4
SG5
SG6
SG7
SG8
SG9
SG10
SG11

0.00
1.00
2.00
0.01
0.87
1.75
-10.67 178.52 355.46
-33.36 171.07 373.58
87.18 185.91 392.53
9.91
182.21 368.09
-1.91 196.53 355.08
-36.00 178.97 358.05
8.30
178.63 355.60
-33.01 183.61 344.89
34.51 153.16 384.97
3.14
175.07 365.68
-23.99 184.61 359.09
-21.06 173.06 290.85
30.75 757.26 1597.63
-30.53 764.04 1603.60
-48.44 799.29 1538.05
-51.80 805.68 1513.01
106.19 460.54 1539.78
-24.78 824.00 1543.19
22.56 778.78 1549.47
3.07
753.45 1518.39
64.77 765.22 1541.72
-61.19 756.28 1537.44
512.31 746.59 1528.43
-45.07 776.09 1532.22
-24.88 761.77 1474.06
-10.62 766.17 1542.80
30.66
40.11
27.12
36.76
36.77
34.33
12.51
0.07
-9.89
0.80
13.05
-4.10
-47.32 135.09 108.68
-19.13 -16.69 -9.34
4.69
-2.52
-1.32
-12.06 -15.75 -13.29
-13.38 -103.24 -95.53
49.13 -66.43 -55.79
452.58 365.42 393.10
362.70 227.96 247.65
76.48 -39.50 -24.24
20.09
50.08
91.88
263.94 94.08 117.34
67.35 -18.78 -0.65
21.88
50.54
95.17
7.46
2.65
-8.46
6.20
-11.26 -31.65

3.00
2.63
530.78
557.08
568.38
538.57
551.70
544.04
546.69
544.37
528.15
553.18
535.60
536.94
2316.69
2325.86
2297.96
2333.38
2306.79
2308.68
2329.36
2305.48
2316.48
2313.24
2321.40
2325.49
2312.58
2304.72
23.57
30.69
2.56
-7.77
-62.91
-0.78
7.09
15.03
-93.70
-46.98
443.58
284.46
-7.74
135.88
129.11
22.75
143.11
-21.22
-47.45

4.00
3.52
726.81
751.07
721.96
733.23
755.27
736.83
729.07
733.44
730.57
728.54
725.53
737.99
3075.91
3092.96
3078.61
3099.74
3088.10
3097.90
3245.91
3084.90
3090.93
3094.16
3075.35
3081.39
3098.85
3081.12
15.31
35.55
-8.64
2.03
-61.72
-2.01
10.70
5.18
-44.01
12.08
537.49
375.11
53.95
181.58
189.46
77.71
194.22
-37.34
-65.10

5.00
4.40
921.12
903.34
913.29
907.20
903.62
922.85
899.50
919.16
913.89
947.05
898.67
909.74
3845.33
3964.00
3846.23
3859.69
3857.63
3864.09
3865.78
3923.40
3836.58
3853.61
3838.74
3837.52
3974.39
3865.14
7.05
41.62
-1.18
-2.87
89.47
-48.48
-0.11
-12.06
-23.47
38.68
576.36
419.26
86.11
225.21
220.59
112.27
241.78
-46.93
-79.80

E-52

6.00
5.27
1098.49
1108.00
1089.47
1098.69
1109.18
1090.51
1088.89
1096.30
1088.47
1093.26
1097.23
1098.78
4644.46
4663.73
4650.91
4645.88
4649.35
4658.31
4611.95
4637.32
4655.27
4653.31
4650.54
4631.18
4635.21
4657.04
4.69
34.34
5.05
8.15
84.69
-0.78
-6.12
-8.37
10.64
80.69
626.48
472.35
131.29
270.87
263.74
155.04
291.19
-64.75
-94.31

7.00
6.16
1253.69
1264.28
1274.44
1259.37
1263.22
1275.29
1250.98
1258.19
1272.10
1251.77
1282.43
1265.62
5398.39
5382.32
5391.43
5380.99
5398.02
5386.75
5377.15
5395.52
5399.73
5398.92
5394.27
5387.93
5385.23
5404.70
2.32
37.98
-3.67
-1.65
-24.52
-14.24
-3.72
-9.60
25.13
94.99
631.80
489.22
149.03
313.04
288.93
180.46
337.67
-81.37
-108.65

8.00
7.04
1455.21
1449.89
1466.10
1457.80
1468.83
1451.45
1462.53
1464.37
1458.70
1482.12
1458.74
1490.77
6135.78
6183.95
6168.81
6188.32
6177.73
6178.05
6184.36
6189.42
6121.33
6143.44
6164.57
6195.49
6245.47
6180.87
4.69
40.41
2.56
9.37
46.27
-8.12
7.09
-2.21
64.01
139.75
683.76
545.15
195.13
358.52
333.77
222.22
386.90
-94.49
-122.61

9.00
7.92
1640.61
1643.56
1622.81
1634.91
1646.21
1630.38
1634.33
1625.64
1622.45
1638.29
1631.55
1670.80
6951.79
6959.90
6973.90
6960.00
6947.88
6950.40
6938.17
6947.78
6742.54
6976.00
6960.09
6937.57
6958.54
6958.27
5.87
39.20
-4.91
-2.87
-6.52
7.78
4.69
3.95
85.10
162.87
711.48
578.52
219.65
402.35
350.90
247.22
433.57
-111.66
-134.37

10.00
8.82
1815.09
1843.60
1818.41
1818.34
1814.38
1803.64
1827.37
1828.80
1809.51
1822.58
1826.85
1841.04
7757.37
7718.35
7744.41
7728.60
7749.67
7734.46
7738.23
7726.82
7395.06
7742.06
7745.00
7730.15
7685.05
7571.55
4.69
34.33
-3.67
-9.00
-50.92
7.78
2.29
-5.90
110.79
182.88
722.01
599.67
237.04
445.49
368.98
265.89
478.25
-134.54
-147.43

TABLE E-28. CVP3, AIR 2 LOAD CONDITION 1a (Continued)


SG12
SG13
SG14
SG15
SG16
SG17
SG18
SG19
SG20
SG21
SG22
SG23
SG24
SG25
SG26
SG27
SG28
SG29
SG30
SG31
SG32-T
SG32-45
SG32-L
SG33-T
SG33-45
SG33-T
SG34-T
SG34-45
SG34-L
SG35-T
SG35-45
SG35-L
SG36-T
SG36-45
SG36-L
SG37-T
SG37-45
SG37-L
SG38-T
SG38-45
SG38-L
SG39-T
SG39-45
SG39-L
SG40-T
SG40-45
SG40-L

-11.19 -3.76
-4.86
-6.00
-5.27
-1.23 -15.85 -26.67 -35.15 -40.89
-39.28 -36.80 -46.29 -53.95 -60.43
6.84
16.47
14.27
15.23
10.83
168.18 169.21 163.97 159.70 157.58
-1066.93 -1157.51 -1291.25 -1232.42 -1337.86
5.48
-7.46 -24.34 -43.16 -64.69
23.43
0.42
-29.94 -59.57 -91.98
83.42
81.77
79.19
76.43
75.52
30.39
25.97
14.00
3.87
-5.70
-42.81 -45.61 -49.33 -51.16 -48.79
-16.05 -35.33 -67.46 -97.39 -130.46
5.27
2.15
-4.65
-9.42 -11.63
4.79
1.57
-6.03 -13.48 -20.62
46.72
39.37
29.07
22.82
20.07
38.49
40.05
36.46
33.66
32.29
0.52
7.88
2.73
1.99
-3.90
45.50
47.16
44.77
42.20
42.20
-31.90 -38.66 -49.36 -59.92 -72.20
-27.15 -31.23 -37.61 -54.46 -70.64
10.64
92.33 172.35 252.53 327.41
-21.61 19.04
47.30
83.95 120.44
14.14
13.78
6.03
0.07
3.60
27.99 109.74 189.04 267.25 340.38
-23.70
6.45
30.59
59.19
88.67
38.07
20.64
14.77
8.17
7.80
6.64
95.78 187.11 276.62 363.44
14.02
56.33
95.87 133.55 172.31
35.14
29.27
19.91
9.64
-0.45
41.27 106.15 165.18 225.46 283.33
62.52
94.12 119.63 145.53 173.11
77.80
70.46
61.45
51.53
42.53
6.73
103.85 197.29 287.80 373.60
27.02
54.31
92.47 127.33 164.56
29.68
14.57
9.93
5.02
4.88
399.98 442.67 480.28 521.23 559.20
128.47 158.22 175.82 192.15 206.47
84.75
87.51
67.34
51.58
33.80
40.41 103.00 185.75 265.40 345.04
-10.63 21.13
57.12
91.64 123.40
-5.24 -12.86 -31.67 -44.66 -56.31
-10.52 79.90 166.08 248.78 327.09
-3.29
51.08
95.98 140.93 185.20
49.61
48.97
50.25
50.52
53.91
32.32
87.59 138.15 188.61 236.32
38.74
65.04
78.18
94.24 108.86
46.26
30.91
10.25 -10.22 -29.77

-6.28
-45.33
-68.63
9.50
153.35
23894.4
-77.26
-121.24
71.46
-17.12
-47.77
-162.22
-15.12
-29.09
15.84
29.76
-5.37
40.36
-82.16
-81.84
400.18
155.94
1.53
412.09
116.57
2.30
445.76
206.39
-12.00
347.07
199.54
31.68
456.74
202.75
1.76
601.58
219.34
15.65
422.35
158.49
-67.24
402.87
228.38
52.95
287.64
129.48
-47.31

E-53

-6.42
-50.33
-74.73
7.99
150.09
27604.6
-96.44
-151.24
70.18
-27.80
-45.20
-193.62
-17.69
-36.78
13.63
27.41
-9.05
39.63
-91.62
-98.19
471.34
189.24
1.40
482.55
144.38
-0.64
527.02
242.14
-22.28
411.44
229.84
21.94
535.87
237.06
-0.40
646.30
236.77
0.07
499.80
191.18
-77.70
477.14
269.99
52.59
339.96
149.60
-63.77

-6.24
-54.04
-80.10
7.72
147.43
28054.8
-114.93
-179.41
68.15
-38.30
-42.26
-224.47
-19.34
-44.32
12.90
25.76
-11.25
39.26
-100.44
-117.01
540.62
224.71
-0.07
551.13
172.48
-5.04
607.18
277.53
-32.73
477.93
260.69
11.47
611.89
270.14
-3.93
693.12
256.59
-14.04
576.15
223.86
-87.07
548.49
312.65
51.31
392.00
172.02
-80.21

-5.00
-54.78
-85.51
6.48
146.01
27481.0
-135.77
-208.12
66.49
-47.69
-37.48
-254.58
-19.71
-50.63
12.90
24.84
-12.73
39.26
-107.93
-130.93
608.21
261.87
-0.76
617.82
202.40
-8.16
686.06
311.26
-42.27
544.23
290.08
1.91
685.51
301.01
-5.72
740.82
274.76
-27.42
651.76
256.37
-94.36
618.18
351.87
50.57
445.57
193.93
-93.91

-6.97
-59.27
-93.08
6.43
141.98
28084.2
-156.01
-237.02
62.44
-58.92
-35.97
-283.96
-21.91
-59.01
10.14
21.39
-11.25
37.98
-115.04
-144.47
674.79
293.66
-5.16
684.93
227.92
-14.40
764.93
346.47
-54.74
612.96
322.22
-10.03
758.77
332.38
-11.46
791.26
296.42
-40.99
727.93
289.05
-104.09
688.05
392.10
46.50
501.21
219.54
-108.37

-10.05
-62.99
-102.40
5.38
137.09
28802.1
-176.58
-267.05
57.85
-72.00
-34.64
-314.66
-25.22
-67.94
7.01
17.94
-11.99
35.04
-122.96
-162.49
742.45
328.61
-10.16
752.89
254.75
-21.74
844.62
382.62
-67.23
682.95
355.68
-22.53
832.66
364.12
-17.16
842.62
318.48
-56.76
805.83
320.85
-113.33
757.45
433.10
42.16
557.79
245.99
-122.80

TABLE E-29. CVP3, AIR 2 LOAD CONDITION 1b


Load Step
Pressure
Frame-1
Frame-2
Frame-3
Frame-4
Frame-5
Frame-6
Frame-7
Frame-8
Frame-9
Frame-10
Frame-11
Frame-12
Hoop-1
Hoop-2
Hoop-3
Hoop-4
Hoop-5
Hoop-6
Hoop-7
Hoop-8
Hoop-9
Hoop-10
Hoop-11
Hoop-12
Hoop-13
Hoop-14
Long-1
Long-2
Long-3
Long-4
Long-5
Long-6
Long-7
Long-8
SG1
SG2
SG3
SG4
SG5
SG6
SG7
SG8
SG9
SG10
SG11

0.00
0.00
13.11
49.70
-74.45
4.41
21.92
6.15
-35.31
-21.50
-49.80
-0.85
-7.59
-7.78
39.94
-26.91
-62.46
-38.83
-49.01
-34.01
190.53
-19.00
345.97
-43.10
217.23
-232.24
86.41
159.50
100.32
35.55
-23.58
-29.81
-37.72
-42.37
-4.92
-12.06
-23.65
35.74
438.86
348.81
65.12
19.27
234.97
59.48
21.14
18.76
7.12

1.00
-0.01
9.42
23.38
-64.39
-16.52
4.42
0.84
-21.72
42.00
-18.62
-26.87
-24.68
0.67
-11.54
11.00
18.25
25.96
-58.14
-22.92
-66.92
-11.64
-4.18
20.19
-133.14
10.54
-2.62
-18.02
1211.28
1219.05
1222.14
1264.54
1205.48
1228.52
1212.30
1222.84
-25.85
25.29
582.97
381.35
53.16
2.12
215.23
50.73
7.92
43.46
41.29

2.00
-0.02
25.29
-24.92
52.68
13.16
-26.27
30.10
3.06
-17.58
-0.52
20.29
20.02
-5.59
6.85
-3.45
-73.01
5.60
-85.55
1.11
-8.49
17.78
-33.21
-52.15
176.70
-35.80
-32.31
-25.42
2434.65
2459.92
2448.19
2445.25
2435.71
2461.74
2463.42
2448.14
-30.26
13.55
717.68
416.55
40.43
-17.96
203.82
42.08
-7.33
77.35
76.22

3.00
-0.03
19.01
-20.84
-65.12
-3.47
3.67
-27.03
43.03
20.64
53.91
44.74
-21.94
10.33
-9.70
12.81
177.95
113.01
-23.46
-41.42
-24.93
-11.64
-36.84
-111.82
512.31
-58.04
-24.88
-10.62
3669.71
3672.70
3697.76
3728.71
3664.63
3688.72
3685.58
3684.40
-18.88
20.52
853.11
473.73
43.40
-36.44
202.70
38.23
-21.48
114.12
111.86

4.00
-0.03
8.22
-69.97
82.00
-10.83
-1.97
25.18
20.35
-22.68
-52.82
-0.31
-20.50
-3.80
6.85
32.66
-9.83
-62.91
151.85
-63.60
13.43
25.14
13.97
32.85
-136.84
14.25
41.90
18.97
4917.27
4892.29
4918.22
4917.37
4917.06
4898.08
4904.83
4889.38
-38.69
-9.20
958.40
473.40
12.51
-61.05
148.64
16.84
-39.48
157.03
150.62

5.00
-0.03
-0.28
22.26
6.61
6.52
-3.58
4.89
13.44
-2.04
15.23
34.11
-23.93
3.11
-13.38
9.20
58.63
-25.89
-78.26
4.81
44.49
-26.36
-5.99
-28.64
174.85
-22.83
-10.04
-18.02
6128.59
6136.56
6142.78
6135.80
6137.46
6127.39
6140.08
6132.91
-57.75
-38.55
1049.54
485.50
-18.83
-82.04
114.64
-6.28
-54.90
192.22
188.46

E-54

6.00
-0.03
3.30
-21.06
68.51
1.48
1.73
-27.25
39.76
32.86
33.15
-25.68
-20.07
-5.06
-4.18
29.05
25.27
150.03
-74.58
-26.62
-17.62
-11.64
-7.80
-21.40
62.34
-8.00
-2.62
-10.62
7335.92
7375.48
7323.27
7367.21
7336.99
7369.66
7370.06
7368.55
-76.47
-63.50
1154.58
504.40
-41.79
-101.13
84.84
-20.75
-68.33
228.26
225.62

7.00
-0.01
-8.82
-8.94
-19.07
-2.03
-0.06
25.31
-1.86
3.32
-14.21
-15.63
18.54
6.77
-9.70
50.72
4.21
33.38
42.29
47.33
-21.28
-4.29
-11.43
-61.20
296.58
-8.00
-2.62
-3.22
8474.49
8565.54
8433.85
8578.78
8581.85
8576.21
8575.74
8574.39
-97.38
-90.84
1225.27
497.98
-69.47
-120.39
55.98
-41.68
-84.13
263.29
262.92

8.00
-0.02
4.41
-33.83
-36.77
4.32
6.29
4.41
-26.66
-30.07
25.21
-30.08
0.97
4.36
-0.51
-17.89
12.98
127.80
-16.15
-26.62
88.29
3.07
-4.18
-41.30
241.22
-4.29
-2.62
-10.62
9640.94
9813.44
9660.90
9791.08
9808.25
9809.18
9794.16
9657.86
-121.40
-121.46
1291.05
487.43
-95.86
-138.94
14.25
-56.61
-97.71
299.12
300.19

9.00
-0.03
-0.48
8.14
42.45
2.87
-7.23
-15.67
-19.57
23.49
62.02
6.27
13.04
14.92
6.85
-25.11
-41.42
90.78
128.11
-63.60
66.39
3.07
52.07
5.72
255.98
-24.68
-2.62
-3.22
10811.0
10961.8
10844.5
10999.8
11017.9
11014.1
10951.4
10821.5
-144.15
-149.18
1346.45
484.91
-119.66
-156.75
-13.46
-68.38
-110.95
335.69
337.35

10.00
-0.04
-9.90
-32.65
67.39
10.68
10.94
27.70
19.54
-6.27
-25.73
-8.00
31.18
-2.89
-9.70
7.39
105.99
-57.36
53.24
-43.26
-32.23
10.42
13.97
23.81
-153.42
12.39
12.22
26.37
11827.4
12105.1
11960.6
12285.5
12265.8
12270.2
11927.0
11853.0
-179.53
-197.87
1410.20
471.07
-165.43
-176.58
-64.90
-96.54
-126.37
367.06
371.49

TABLE E-29. CVP3, AIR 2 LOAD CONDITION 1b (Continued)


SG12
SG13
SG14
SG15
SG16
SG17
SG18
SG19
SG20
SG21
SG22
SG23
SG24
SG25
SG26
SG27
SG28
SG29
SG30
SG31
SG32-T
SG32-45
SG32-L
SG33-T
SG33-45
SG33-T
SG34-T
SG34-45
SG34-L
SG35-T
SG35-45
SG35-L
SG36-T
SG36-45
SG36-L
SG37-T
SG37-45
SG37-L
SG38-T
SG38-45
SG38-L
SG39-T
SG39-45
SG39-L
SG40-T
SG40-45
SG40-L

-4.17
3.90
-33.78
9.96
175.40
-263.80
3.60
23.43
85.82
35.36
-40.79
-14.95
7.47
6.31
48.19
39.64
-2.42
47.34
-32.09
-26.96
9.68
-16.38
20.06
27.40
-19.80
40.09
7.32
10.72
35.87
44.39
63.26
79.83
7.65
27.85
30.23
401.58
129.95
87.87
39.50
-10.82
-3.17
-7.77
0.56
50.71
33.64
41.11
47.72

79.71
112.05
79.27
66.78
278.31
-358.68
71.25
120.25
187.80
115.28
54.19
83.84
112.15
110.84
158.87
128.64
43.93
127.80
0.34
7.29
-15.88
14.04
110.22
-14.88
-4.06
150.89
-27.48
41.11
136.40
12.27
92.28
177.60
-34.22
54.31
143.79
374.43
149.22
181.73
3.71
30.87
98.02
-35.65
27.15
134.88
20.42
78.55
123.02

165.70
223.08
194.47
126.18
383.05
-341.10
137.45
209.56
290.20
196.72
127.10
175.69
213.37
220.35
267.57
222.00
90.30
212.35
33.32
40.68
-42.40
46.71
200.64
-58.77
15.13
261.92
-64.82
67.16
239.72
-16.31
117.83
278.18
-77.01
73.27
260.85
345.47
159.72
280.95
-31.35
60.08
198.48
-63.72
47.14
223.86
5.14
109.42
203.45

249.11
330.34
303.98
182.35
484.01
-408.74
202.01
291.09
384.24
266.68
178.89
262.72
310.69
324.36
371.60
311.91
140.33
292.61
67.31
72.50
-69.82
76.12
288.22
-102.97
27.71
370.51
-99.76
92.09
335.46
-43.06
142.07
370.97
-119.97
87.26
372.69
314.43
165.02
377.17
-67.88
94.23
295.76
-91.96
68.81
305.77
-5.67
143.57
280.22

347.53
449.32
431.82
245.79
601.14
-483.00
271.10
369.84
483.23
336.82
202.07
350.47
412.21
443.64
490.14
415.13
193.30
380.94
103.50
106.48
-101.69
115.89
389.72
-151.61
35.32
493.93
-140.84
111.05
439.07
-66.37
165.19
471.46
-168.80
86.28
499.99
274.00
151.79
487.48
-108.61
126.35
396.97
-123.13
88.64
399.71
-22.95
175.14
367.37

431.46
561.85
544.17
305.56
706.97
-284.36
336.64
439.18
570.80
389.26
215.87
434.16
507.47
552.95
600.02
513.40
240.36
462.82
136.51
142.42
-129.47
147.76
476.20
-194.28
26.88
605.95
-176.59
131.30
531.10
-87.19
188.13
560.53
-212.89
81.05
614.08
231.60
134.34
587.68
-145.31
158.29
492.61
-152.09
117.24
486.02
-37.36
215.50
449.07

E-55

516.59
672.73
655.37
363.03
812.56
-312.37
400.69
507.38
655.41
439.62
230.11
515.23
601.23
660.97
710.27
610.65
290.45
542.83
170.58
180.20
-158.81
180.59
565.09
-237.47
15.41
715.97
-211.34
147.87
621.46
-108.73
206.54
648.13
-255.35
71.52
724.79
190.32
114.18
685.88
-181.86
194.50
585.69
-180.46
144.87
570.99
-51.27
254.78
530.27

595.61
779.28
759.21
419.35
911.22
-644.88
462.46
573.28
736.96
487.50
244.16
593.10
689.39
765.93
816.54
704.90
339.75
622.38
204.48
217.72
-185.27
212.34
647.41
-278.74
2.87
819.99
-246.15
165.02
709.16
-128.32
226.37
733.04
-295.84
59.96
830.79
150.83
93.80
783.77
-216.18
223.89
675.10
-208.80
169.44
655.67
-65.63
291.10
611.91

677.09
889.41
863.15
477.45
1010.70
-1009.66
525.93
641.33
819.53
536.80
262.37
673.10
780.59
870.43
924.37
798.38
390.49
701.12
238.40
254.66
-213.56
245.58
731.54
-322.00
-9.98
925.39
-280.61
178.34
797.68
-148.54
241.96
818.43
-337.44
49.36
937.60
110.09
73.97
881.58
-251.95
254.53
767.14
-236.88
197.02
739.91
-79.72
330.54
694.15

755.41
994.77
959.93
531.79
1104.33
18.66
586.93
706.19
897.67
583.45
278.61
749.01
865.70
969.40
1027.61
886.73
438.36
776.33
271.82
291.38
-239.91
276.76
812.15
-363.53
-22.74
1024.92
-313.16
191.74
881.79
-168.19
257.05
900.30
-377.23
37.57
1038.91
70.84
53.42
975.53
-284.47
284.86
852.87
-264.14
220.14
820.73
-95.62
363.37
771.93

831.55
1093.14
1053.94
584.38
1194.07
-154.20
646.72
769.80
973.60
632.01
295.53
825.33
952.10
1067.81
1129.17
973.62
486.88
851.75
305.42
329.19
-266.95
310.04
893.14
-404.48
-34.77
1123.88
-344.45
207.86
963.70
-189.15
274.28
980.51
-416.62
28.99
1138.73
32.63
38.37
1069.10
-318.76
314.95
941.08
-290.89
250.70
901.71
-111.55
403.80
851.23

TABLE E-30. CVP3, AIR 2 LOAD CONDITION 1c


Load Step
Pressure
Frame-1
Frame-2
Frame-3
Frame-4
Frame-5
Frame-6
Frame-7
Frame-8
Frame-9
Frame-10
Frame-11
Frame-12
Hoop-1
Hoop-2
Hoop-3
Hoop-4
Hoop-5
Hoop-6
Hoop-7
Hoop-8
Hoop-9
Hoop-10
Hoop-11
Hoop-12
Hoop-13
Hoop-14
Long-1
Long-2
Long-3
Long-4
Long-5
Long-6
Long-7
Long-8
SG1
SG2
SG3
SG4
SG5
SG6
SG7
SG8
SG9
SG10
SG11

0.00
0.00
1.60
-3.61
44.50
-7.11
-20.67
-25.59
22.21
-25.99
-40.38
-26.00
-10.33
1.56
12.37
-35.95
21.76
44.49
-32.59
-6.29
51.78
-19.00
1.27
-64.81
220.94
-2.44
4.80
-3.22
79.06
44.05
3.80
-1.65
13.88
0.44
1.09
-7.13
-33.01
13.73
392.82
314.91
34.70
15.92
202.89
31.09
15.27
13.48
2.89

1.00
0.88
183.05
184.33
181.84
179.85
178.64
273.43
172.83
179.53
194.39
186.48
187.36
170.70
771.89
778.41
788.68
851.90
637.63
803.58
778.71
760.73
772.40
776.10
772.33
776.01
776.53
766.09
1217.07
1228.65
1200.86
1239.92
1225.75
1221.06
1229.00
1226.41
-86.35
-50.10
538.80
297.86
-22.31
35.22
99.29
-3.95
40.24
37.11
23.65

2.00
1.75
367.86
363.50
363.71
358.10
364.05
370.28
375.09
366.08
368.06
376.54
366.40
374.40
1538.78
1538.59
1564.38
1722.27
1559.87
1563.53
1628.00
1533.26
1552.76
1557.49
1537.80
1539.79
1548.42
1550.35
2448.82
2463.56
2474.32
2446.47
2452.52
2462.96
2452.61
2450.60
-82.52
-44.05
721.76
381.86
-7.47
57.78
108.15
18.12
72.03
70.54
41.84

3.00
2.64
539.03
548.05
538.84
546.83
546.16
550.44
530.81
540.56
555.71
564.86
550.43
548.68
2349.56
2318.41
2313.52
2323.89
2304.73
2302.90
2309.03
2349.85
2320.34
2311.67
2308.73
2310.90
2357.34
2312.34
3688.23
3663.83
3679.97
3681.80
3669.07
3681.01
3669.59
3659.41
-110.77
-80.47
846.13
416.83
-34.83
80.71
87.36
17.30
103.82
102.46
64.08

4.00
3.52
735.41
733.68
727.09
733.22
722.47
741.91
737.94
738.86
732.58
728.80
730.87
712.31
3081.74
3100.18
3083.88
3103.44
3102.71
3088.65
3092.50
3077.55
3096.37
3086.93
3103.01
3073.98
3098.85
3103.31
4903.10
4904.45
4903.28
4899.00
4900.26
4907.87
4902.43
4896.77
-130.40
-110.42
962.53
452.04
-61.68
101.43
53.42
5.44
131.38
133.22
88.16

5.00
4.39
922.23
907.93
916.12
923.83
920.26
935.86
926.26
918.37
927.02
929.03
908.05
915.85
3870.30
3910.85
3877.04
3871.88
3876.94
3859.62
3883.27
3835.52
3871.44
3864.85
3872.32
3882.39
4026.73
3865.53
6128.59
6137.77
6078.07
6132.13
6141.06
6143.29
6140.08
6132.91
-110.76
-90.37
1115.73
532.50
-39.77
127.65
72.42
28.84
164.62
167.73
113.51

E-56

6.00
5.29
1079.84
1085.74
1098.34
1088.64
1083.61
1083.96
1099.79
1084.82
1092.58
1078.33
1094.36
1069.96
4641.71
4632.16
4648.33
4613.47
4635.67
4640.75
4634.79
4725.59
4635.32
4646.08
4633.94
4631.18
4635.21
4634.84
7340.64
7381.55
7273.49
7346.39
7357.39
7358.65
7360.45
7363.62
-121.58
-113.30
1216.15
555.78
-59.84
150.39
56.75
26.00
194.56
191.28
139.78

7.00
6.16
1282.31
1284.46
1289.23
1281.13
1274.64
1274.66
1289.89
1302.26
1276.62
1287.23
1266.53
1285.67
5413.65
5409.94
5428.82
5405.60
5418.65
5418.72
5414.22
5329.84
5407.53
5413.93
5418.79
5410.71
5422.87
5405.24
8457.96
8569.18
8428.87
8587.35
8577.05
8588.44
8590.16
8576.86
-104.51
-103.02
1347.46
614.77
-51.45
176.41
67.60
37.95
226.32
220.50
165.12

8.00
7.03
1509.19
1452.20
1468.41
1468.73
1452.17
1463.96
1482.94
1546.74
1472.34
1485.30
1453.46
1455.90
6204.44
6211.66
6183.46
6198.20
6213.05
6200.85
6177.67
6189.42
6105.00
6172.37
6192.24
6173.25
6171.26
6173.47
9700.40
9805.40
9723.67
9796.47
9806.28
9812.11
9810.23
9806.10
-108.00
-116.22
1439.06
640.80
-64.37
200.80
64.72
35.57
255.90
252.86
194.34

9.00
7.93
1614.04
1623.71
1632.37
1642.80
1652.38
1621.16
1622.95
1628.04
1616.17
1630.36
1630.51
1638.62
6962.12
6955.59
6952.14
6951.90
6947.19
6964.50
6963.04
6844.79
6717.14
6961.53
6958.25
6944.98
6958.54
6817.71
10872.3
11026.1
10942.7
11022.9
11035.8
11036.0
11040.2
11023.2
-108.00
-137.41
1515.43
654.74
-88.93
225.55
43.38
27.78
286.20
276.96
220.06

10.00
8.81
1818.19
1813.69
1806.05
1812.82
1815.76
1820.30
1797.62
1804.23
1826.47
1825.56
1816.26
1830.19
7701.42
7728.42
7726.08
7759.31
7739.76
7731.84
7717.36
7566.50
7389.28
7743.61
7731.79
7716.86
7731.12
7432.48
11892.4
12089.3
12076.4
12247.5
12259.8
12259.2
12142.1
11951.6
-111.14
-159.13
1592.29
672.84
-115.26
251.27
13.70
12.81
315.11
296.67
245.28

TABLE E-30. CVP3, AIR 2 LOAD CONDITION 1c (Continued)


SG12
SG13
SG14
SG15
SG16
SG17
SG18
SG19
SG20
SG21
SG22
SG23
SG24
SG25
SG26
SG27
SG28
SG29
SG30
SG31
SG32-T
SG32-45
SG32-L
SG33-T
SG33-45
SG33-T
SG34-T
SG34-45
SG34-L
SG35-T
SG35-45
SG35-L
SG36-T
SG36-45
SG36-L
SG37-T
SG37-45
SG37-L
SG38-T
SG38-45
SG38-L
SG39-T
SG39-45
SG39-L
SG40-T
SG40-45
SG40-L

-11.61 81.03
-7.88
94.06
-25.85 89.62
5.65
73.64
168.35 274.13
-1672.58 -1686.05
4.66
58.25
19.57
92.80
80.12 184.08
24.69 102.74
-47.13 48.62
-16.97 60.88
6.55
107.35
6.40
111.05
43.79 147.81
34.36 125.81
2.73
56.43
43.49 125.94
-31.59 -6.83
-28.39
1.55
15.68
71.80
-10.41 57.75
11.90 105.52
34.15
71.36
-16.04 27.93
33.30 135.27
11.22
65.87
12.37
88.03
30.92 128.30
44.40
73.51
61.98 121.09
71.57 166.36
14.07
67.49
24.82
83.70
26.19 132.88
401.21 410.95
126.84 173.78
87.33 179.49
39.87
73.25
-8.98
61.34
-5.47
85.34
-2.45
56.78
2.77
79.26
47.15 136.41
33.78
72.07
39.47
97.16
43.70 105.10

169.61
196.40
198.47
130.51
376.83
10963.9
113.79
156.88
284.44
174.95
121.05
122.59
200.84
212.20
246.92
214.60
102.06
206.24
17.93
31.95
120.12
119.83
193.77
103.00
73.70
242.61
118.34
147.49
223.53
102.07
165.56
258.65
115.05
136.47
244.58
418.96
198.05
261.65
119.88
129.66
167.32
111.26
138.28
222.67
107.02
139.00
166.53

257.70
298.80
305.36
189.69
479.89
8526.36
163.78
215.43
377.80
238.14
178.48
184.49
296.36
313.13
347.70
306.02
149.90
287.28
39.29
56.71
170.51
188.30
278.95
135.42
113.32
348.13
174.49
211.55
311.43
136.26
216.64
344.32
159.87
184.88
352.62
428.13
223.03
349.30
168.54
196.89
252.02
163.36
207.74
308.24
140.61
191.58
228.47

344.76
406.26
412.14
250.77
585.61
6960.18
214.40
266.42
465.24
287.12
197.54
242.89
387.09
417.72
452.32
402.80
199.94
369.59
65.29
85.00
215.48
256.39
365.54
163.24
139.62
457.65
226.77
269.67
396.73
174.16
265.31
426.66
197.69
217.36
465.83
431.11
224.68
438.39
213.69
264.11
336.98
210.32
275.16
393.29
177.41
249.10
297.19

431.87
516.80
517.49
308.52
692.78
19563.4
264.72
313.70
547.84
329.08
218.24
298.50
478.32
522.44
560.92
501.87
247.74
451.48
91.33
117.18
254.61
324.03
453.14
184.84
155.77
567.31
278.29
325.38
477.95
210.76
310.65
505.64
228.52
239.08
577.41
431.30
216.58
526.52
258.45
330.00
422.49
251.74
342.50
479.12
211.20
308.63
368.29

E-57

519.84
627.74
623.06
368.50
801.15
19610.5
314.19
362.84
631.23
371.25
239.64
356.71
569.59
626.47
672.15
601.81
297.04
533.96
118.01
143.21
292.53
391.43
541.09
207.33
166.60
675.36
329.65
381.48
559.77
249.57
359.68
585.03
258.45
257.84
684.86
436.44
213.83
617.44
303.60
398.68
507.48
293.37
413.31
564.84
245.74
373.30
441.43

599.71
732.55
714.31
423.85
898.75
23359.5
356.47
406.98
706.08
407.49
259.96
411.02
655.28
721.41
777.59
694.00
340.42
610.31
144.73
171.62
330.64
455.24
619.72
228.70
175.95
774.34
380.43
438.46
634.55
289.00
408.86
657.74
286.88
274.37
783.97
442.72
210.32
700.95
348.71
464.01
588.01
332.77
480.63
644.60
278.64
434.26
509.93

681.25
838.72
808.04
482.54
996.48
23877.3
404.74
455.56
783.19
446.16
279.93
467.02
741.21
816.22
882.92
784.88
388.24
687.27
173.90
205.41
369.19
519.46
698.27
250.41
185.86
872.10
430.31
492.91
710.66
330.89
457.16
731.24
314.42
289.88
883.33
452.86
208.30
786.92
394.04
529.37
668.22
373.30
545.28
723.32
313.96
494.78
580.36

759.48
942.86
897.00
537.74
1089.26
24136.2
451.54
501.57
857.74
482.06
305.14
523.02
827.88
907.16
988.62
872.95
439.74
763.13
201.68
232.82
406.51
588.09
773.28
272.44
198.16
964.92
482.22
546.07
783.11
371.81
503.62
801.44
342.69
304.37
977.91
463.49
205.92
869.76
439.92
591.07
748.48
411.99
610.30
799.84
347.13
554.96
649.01

827.77
1034.20
971.49
588.48
1170.72
25479.9
492.02
540.88
924.36
513.10
322.89
574.00
905.37
987.08
1083.32
952.57
484.72
832.55
228.36
258.96
448.49
648.96
837.46
299.57
207.93
1046.20
534.96
602.47
848.58
416.49
552.76
865.01
375.26
320.35
1062.24
480.28
207.24
942.71
488.28
651.24
821.29
454.45
673.44
869.11
383.97
614.12
711.88

TABLE E-31. CVP3, WATER 1, LOAD CONDITION 1a


Load Step
Pressure
Frame-1
Frame-2
Frame-3
Frame-4
Frame-5
Frame-6
Frame-7
Frame-8
Frame-9
Frame-10
Frame-11
Frame-12
Hoop-1
Hoop-2
Hoop-3
Hoop-4
Hoop-5
Hoop-6
Hoop-7
Hoop-8
Hoop-9
Hoop-10
Hoop-11
Hoop-12
Hoop-13
Hoop-14
Long-1
Long-2
Long-3
Long-4
Long-5
Long-6
Long-7
Long-8
SG1
SG2
SG3
SG4
SG5
SG6
SG7
SG8
SG9
SG10
SG11

0.00
-0.05
-207.76
-134.99
-225.85
-99.46
-218.34
123.01
-193.73
-217.70
-91.73
-38.67
82.29
-222.22
4.90
7.19
57.91
-40.07
52.21
-189.88
52.06
-28.49
0.65
-74.23
-62.63
-105.99
15.10
255.03
41.60
0.01
-0.85
14.20
-17.38
20.21
-27.48
-25.75
202.66
333.65
784.73
731.27
355.98
21.19
596.73
292.42
60.83
40.66
17.59

1.00
0.88
198.55
208.66
180.12
176.40
190.72
181.73
175.12
174.93
172.28
311.02
184.54
186.83
755.01
777.98
943.91
752.28
769.70
741.73
864.59
670.11
762.48
753.77
768.82
768.57
786.60
765.29
2.65
0.01
-3.34
11.75
-1.79
-11.58
-26.28
19.79
65.84
161.75
608.24
540.14
187.32
54.84
441.36
173.21
90.58
26.51
-2.81

2.00
1.78
392.91
322.78
385.22
341.80
304.62
367.75
305.57
313.82
350.05
406.93
355.57
315.00
1519.67
1539.58
1540.27
1542.63
1550.93
1556.74
1465.17
1523.15
1551.52
1558.27
1550.50
1463.40
1506.18
1578.74
3.83
2.44
-4.58
6.85
-34.18
-22.59
-20.27
25.94
51.90
132.95
594.84
506.36
158.73
94.08
368.27
162.58
133.01
22.98
-21.36

3.00
2.68
547.37
553.03
541.98
555.18
533.82
546.70
547.99
543.95
541.77
549.31
555.37
540.01
2315.89
2333.99
2324.66
2316.63
2337.95
2316.61
2266.88
2273.46
2291.81
2272.60
2308.44
2264.08
2478.22
2311.08
5.01
-1.21
-0.85
15.42
-4.19
11.65
55.40
-30.68
77.39
165.97
635.78
553.89
196.85
139.92
404.36
201.18
182.97
14.03
-41.39

4.00
3.49
693.27
701.53
729.75
720.34
721.65
729.31
742.22
781.02
733.34
717.58
714.87
730.42
3078.56
3075.59
3055.95
3054.99
3051.47
3059.39
3102.83
3368.94
3160.43
3017.21
3095.42
3056.89
3064.02
3065.14
-24.49
-1.21
-2.10
4.40
-34.17
18.98
18.16
-29.44
131.12
242.45
718.20
647.95
281.62
186.13
500.49
277.56
236.06
1.27
-54.25

5.00
4.49
898.86
938.36
921.95
903.90
907.23
932.96
909.96
910.67
902.00
909.29
912.06
913.38
3863.91
3866.54
3858.04
3869.87
3844.12
3863.78
3877.32
3876.73
3860.98
3867.29
3870.11
3872.55
3902.68
3842.00
-6.79
2.44
-3.34
6.85
-34.18
7.98
68.62
16.10
149.27
251.44
762.07
677.84
288.22
233.07
500.12
291.43
286.20
-16.68
-74.46

E-58

6.00
5.24
1081.08
1104.30
1094.46
1093.33
1090.01
1093.79
1095.89
1105.02
1107.71
1070.99
1117.74
1097.14
4637.45
4618.82
4611.99
4633.99
4621.39
4624.88
4632.78
4634.25
4622.88
4624.86
4673.99
4606.37
4592.65
4633.35
-20.95
3.65
0.39
4.40
-17.38
22.65
16.96
-29.44
230.16
358.23
911.77
814.88
397.82
280.22
606.44
375.76
336.20
-22.37
-88.62

7.00
6.18
1262.80
1282.19
1276.64
1258.16
1274.08
1275.75
1274.31
1314.22
1320.19
1378.41
1291.77
1252.74
5425.33
5421.30
5406.00
5408.84
5423.86
5413.33
5417.09
5413.82
5392.05
5413.17
5396.75
5421.72
5401.33
5402.50
8.56
3.65
20.30
9.30
-17.38
7.98
-21.48
18.56
261.50
384.97
918.65
839.00
423.85
327.50
647.78
404.57
387.23
-37.70
-102.94

8.00
7.00
1471.60
1428.12
1461.86
1450.06
1436.93
1443.95
1438.37
1452.27
1455.05
1442.48
1445.31
1438.80
6260.68
6178.29
6148.73
6151.90
6147.49
6155.25
6153.59
6149.27
6137.63
6150.85
6145.31
6140.72
6158.07
6134.68
6.19
1.22
2.88
16.64
-7.79
18.99
-25.08
16.10
313.15
449.63
1019.78
917.66
490.24
373.45
704.79
460.11
436.37
-48.62
-117.43

9.00
7.91
1662.58
1657.03
1632.70
1634.50
1642.34
1638.48
1635.40
1659.42
1639.22
1637.64
1664.78
1633.82
6962.91
6979.68
6953.94
6962.69
6952.52
6959.25
6945.95
6980.32
6970.28
7004.24
6978.69
6941.25
6966.75
6992.59
-0.89
-2.42
5.37
17.87
-4.19
14.09
98.65
-3.60
337.41
478.70
1048.07
957.45
521.95
421.56
747.62
491.20
486.79
-58.18
-128.85

10.00
8.84
1810.62
1891.25
1837.96
1832.83
1821.99
1833.13
1819.84
1835.04
1842.06
1844.32
1856.60
1833.50
7767.03
7769.22
7765.19
7761.30
7785.72
7762.18
7914.37
7693.71
7641.49
7763.62
7756.76
7741.77
7775.43
7717.38
-2.07
-2.42
12.83
10.52
1.81
20.21
-19.08
12.41
366.02
504.75
1096.34
996.69
545.37
468.14
764.65
512.27
535.29
-76.26
-142.81

TABLE E-31. CVP3, WATER 1, LOAD CONDITION 1a (Continued)


SG12
SG13
SG14
SG15
SG16
SG17
SG18
SG19
SG20
SG21
SG22
SG23
SG24
SG25
SG26
SG27
SG28
SG29
SG30
SG31
SG32-T
SG32-45
SG32-L
SG33-T
SG33-45
SG33-T
SG34-T
SG34-45
SG34-L
SG35-T
SG35-45
SG35-L
SG36-T
SG36-45
SG36-L
SG37-T
SG37-45
SG37-L
SG38-T
SG38-45
SG38-L
SG39-T
SG39-45
SG39-L
SG40-T
SG40-45
SG40-L

-4.77
0.74
-16.76
10.47
189.33
24171.0
25.35
33.00
138.65
95.58
-15.53
-9.26
23.08
27.62
48.75
52.47
-84.83
40.36
663.41
-10.98
-36.53
-39.50
4.24
-18.23
-19.02
52.38
-19.09
-34.75
28.54
17.73
54.63
84.06
-36.24
34.77
44.79
527.10
143.35
97.22
24.26
-67.38
-19.05
-53.25
-45.91
36.06
57.01
62.45
84.97

-7.52
-20.35
-27.72
19.13
179.50
23977.3
11.72
2.63
130.91
82.68
-28.62
-40.84
6.74
18.09
29.07
46.07
-83.35
33.93
655.30
-16.03
45.94
-12.84
-14.19
54.61
-11.49
7.98
68.44
9.76
18.99
99.67
95.95
72.66
45.28
47.98
6.12
590.47
187.38
104.36
88.49
-38.73
-45.57
40.28
6.99
26.68
119.77
89.29
67.25

-5.13
-25.20
-37.58
21.06
175.38
23803.8
-5.12
-25.16
126.67
66.66
-23.43
-71.32
-2.81
5.89
26.87
41.84
-85.56
27.87
645.93
-28.29
130.46
18.35
-24.65
139.57
12.24
-8.71
156.66
51.60
8.91
164.13
127.16
62.37
147.17
85.59
-5.03
615.92
203.90
82.18
164.28
-6.59
-64.80
127.57
54.84
23.43
170.06
104.45
43.87

-2.06
-28.00
-39.28
19.13
178.82
23912.6
-23.56
-52.77
127.04
62.80
-16.63
-91.33
8.94
6.54
29.99
48.69
-86.30
33.75
639.00
-39.77
207.24
66.01
-24.47
215.94
49.50
-7.24
244.34
88.13
1.94
224.23
150.48
56.67
237.68
122.83
1.39
648.89
215.28
70.27
241.73
24.25
-61.63
208.26
104.93
33.00
217.61
124.71
30.35

-4.08
-31.71
-50.79
15.55
174.10
23747.9
-43.62
-84.60
123.73
49.35
-15.35
-129.70
1.60
-2.39
27.78
46.39
-93.65
31.36
629.49
-48.86
276.98
89.68
-26.80
284.74
70.43
-9.81
321.55
124.52
-9.25
638.31
178.40
46.75
316.62
161.45
-0.44
677.87
228.67
49.01
314.40
55.28
-78.93
278.49
147.87
34.96
259.31
139.83
10.06

-0.31
-37.81
-57.89
12.62
172.81
23839.1
-65.41
-119.39
118.57
37.02
-14.93
-162.57
-2.63
-11.18
23.01
44.46
-98.80
29.89
621.69
-68.70
358.16
135.74
-24.24
367.44
105.31
-14.94
413.81
163.66
-22.27
968.76
210.53
34.44
410.80
199.38
-4.71
724.10
244.46
30.50
401.02
88.52
-92.75
364.86
196.63
33.77
316.92
161.42
-11.13

E-59

-4.44
-44.97
-66.71
6.11
167.65
23897.4
-87.35
-150.14
116.19
27.26
-14.93
-195.64
-7.04
-16.89
19.70
43.87
-103.96
31.36
617.75
-70.63
418.59
160.53
-24.70
427.56
131.21
-15.68
482.45
190.81
-31.82
768.95
232.23
25.25
476.75
225.87
-3.29
719.63
252.74
14.00
467.86
112.40
-103.86
427.62
226.59
35.06
360.75
171.42
-25.19

2.08
-42.12
-68.85
5.19
170.61
23918.5
-106.89
-179.02
115.45
17.32
-6.94
-225.92
-4.83
-22.78
18.59
44.88
-110.57
33.20
610.85
-87.02
490.57
197.85
-20.80
499.62
157.96
-14.94
565.49
232.04
-41.35
744.84
270.22
16.61
558.40
264.70
-5.49
788.20
277.31
1.17
547.83
151.13
-111.79
502.03
275.93
34.92
416.12
200.12
-40.73

4.64
-46.05
-71.36
2.07
170.72
23996.1
-126.92
-208.61
114.13
9.40
-4.37
-255.61
-5.75
-30.05
14.55
45.28
-117.17
36.50
606.55
-92.23
552.32
228.58
-18.18
560.14
182.52
-13.66
637.44
265.16
-49.59
684.83
300.82
9.26
627.85
293.21
-6.32
842.51
294.13
-10.01
617.81
180.29
-120.62
567.94
311.45
35.18
464.31
217.81
-54.25

4.60
-49.09
-76.65
1.07
169.19
23953.8
-148.05
-237.54
110.29
0.38
-1.89
-283.75
-4.28
-35.85
11.79
44.00
-119.40
38.71
602.30
-108.14
621.56
264.78
-21.81
628.96
212.11
-19.53
718.45
298.40
-61.34
828.33
332.10
-1.76
703.80
324.37
-9.49
890.60
313.83
-23.39
694.64
213.74
-127.12
639.20
350.82
33.68
521.02
241.72
-66.31

5.47
-53.90
-82.75
-0.36
167.27
23962.6
-170.35
-268.83
106.43
-10.86
-0.10
-312.39
-6.12
-41.74
9.40
42.85
-120.87
39.81
599.14
-125.54
689.37
302.81
-23.87
698.08
241.12
-24.48
800.07
334.51
-72.90
959.40
366.26
-13.34
778.52
355.24
-13.07
928.07
335.67
-35.48
774.47
245.32
-135.61
710.72
390.82
31.99
578.69
267.30
-79.10

TABLE E-32. CVP3, WATER 1, LOAD CONDITION 1b


Load Step
Pressure
Frame-1
Frame-2
Frame-3
Frame-4
Frame-5
Frame-6
Frame-7
Frame-8
Frame-9
Frame-10
Frame-11
Frame-12
Hoop-1
Hoop-2
Hoop-3
Hoop-4
Hoop-5
Hoop-6
Hoop-7
Hoop-8
Hoop-9
Hoop-10
Hoop-11
Hoop-12
Hoop-13
Hoop-14
Long-1
Long-2
Long-3
Long-4
Long-5
Long-6
Long-7
Long-8
SG1
SG2
SG3
SG4
SG5
SG6
SG7
SG8
SG9
SG10
SG11

0.00
0.02
-31.40
-146.36
11.60
13.30
53.24
72.59
37.74
73.88
158.55
142.77
114.88
34.45
-66.80
-0.03
112.30
232.07
-104.79
-66.05
-101.31
59.76
-30.19
-76.04
-134.54
-55.97
104.13
-85.15
-20.95
1.22
9.10
5.63
-1.79
21.43
-27.48
-13.44
26.42
98.48
479.79
449.47
119.88
27.89
299.97
123.13
56.23
24.59
8.03

1.00
0.01
101.56
-38.28
138.94
-86.34
39.79
-15.36
-55.06
74.10
-87.21
-111.85
30.50
15.64
17.77
166.01
-29.80
-40.06
-108.42
183.46
31.98
-6.43
105.85
-43.49
226.81
97.82
-66.50
107.13
1273.68
1203.69
1362.54
1207.65
1221.72
1192.77
1216.89
1142.20
35.21
108.55
709.32
542.10
128.84
12.07
319.51
130.38
43.36
57.31
48.82

2.00
-0.01
105.34
-91.83
39.77
76.05
-128.95
-11.57
-92.78
-11.80
117.02
53.62
127.17
-81.06
8.58
14.41
-129.81
24.72
203.75
4.19
126.93
22.98
-100.93
-77.84
247.09
-85.61
-59.09
158.90
2418.91
2454.01
2452.75
2408.94
2464.91
2435.52
2442.52
2368.47
26.78
91.86
811.92
547.60
110.83
-7.64
308.24
114.17
27.57
97.47
82.44

3.00
0.00
-150.72
-87.79
-54.07
-35.46
-100.80
-97.66
4.35
23.30
620.16
81.85
70.29
-44.05
-19.00
-16.28
177.22
-40.07
-124.87
91.07
31.99
8.28
82.28
-45.31
-105.04
8.89
15.10
-33.37
3688.27
3685.14
3708.68
3665.57
3667.53
3663.85
3674.38
3698.40
7.71
56.65
919.02
548.94
72.63
-29.55
249.38
86.71
11.59
133.10
121.76

4.00
0.00
72.78
35.19
74.23
-111.70
43.74
46.29
-15.12
107.13
-151.46
-58.15
61.31
41.90
-33.70
-41.55
12.30
-23.41
141.66
-43.86
-93.99
-13.79
-32.00
14.36
-58.95
-5.94
52.19
55.37
4905.01
4857.24
4894.18
4883.51
4903.03
4908.56
4910.34
4858.96
4.96
53.72
1046.15
582.55
69.93
-48.77
231.26
84.75
-1.08
171.45
157.05

5.00
0.01
4.96
-142.71
126.78
99.69
-1.77
54.13
13.56
73.82
-134.63
-32.93
42.08
-100.53
-31.86
16.21
28.09
183.92
165.39
242.62
-55.65
8.28
-120.89
177.08
-151.14
477.71
-44.25
99.75
6153.04
6152.63
6136.28
6110.63
6173.94
6102.52
6122.89
6080.44
5.88
52.61
1144.99
608.17
67.31
-67.92
244.93
80.12
-14.31
210.81
195.25

E-60

6.00
0.00
-128.50
153.57
-11.35
91.94
-87.17
78.77
-107.57
-5.92
13.09
-141.95
31.42
33.82
-15.32
66.76
168.44
-43.77
-73.75
-91.93
139.71
8.28
-137.21
102.94
1.90
21.85
-36.83
-33.37
7346.74
7367.84
7359.74
7379.37
7358.44
7363.73
7357.03
7364.70
-47.66
-26.98
1185.32
569.36
-16.44
-93.44
163.84
17.94
-36.90
244.87
232.14

7.00
0.00
34.47
-57.34
156.19
-89.71
67.47
-55.99
22.41
-61.95
-59.39
117.11
3.43
10.39
-18.99
12.60
250.88
-30.81
-126.69
357.21
-68.43
-43.20
332.62
-144.75
481.27
90.42
-96.19
33.19
8558.43
8554.16
8523.71
8511.25
8561.21
8575.06
8530.18
8571.66
-55.18
-34.87
1267.67
581.70
-23.87
-110.36
167.61
13.13
-48.84
281.84
269.45

8.00
-0.01
86.40
7.22
122.13
-32.56
78.08
12.20
114.05
84.73
-135.81
-6.52
-13.14
-53.25
-18.99
-25.30
-152.60
309.79
-139.46
65.18
-28.27
0.92
60.51
-88.69
1.90
-102.29
96.70
84.95
9823.88
9826.22
9646.16
9834.84
9843.84
9822.58
9837.35
9840.91
-90.75
-89.30
1329.34
555.85
-75.82
-132.27
113.99
-18.32
-65.92
323.34
306.93

9.00
0.00
34.93
17.86
185.82
10.74
81.74
-58.95
-119.80
-19.87
53.04
140.26
44.78
-83.96
-18.99
43.29
-26.30
-34.51
33.96
233.38
-48.35
52.40
-137.21
37.86
-110.56
-143.05
81.86
25.79
10976.8
10952.0
10801.6
11034.2
11118.8
11023.1
11122.4
10953.3
-107.63
-119.39
1360.86
525.47
-109.05
-151.49
85.19
-44.65
-82.82
356.37
342.24

10.00
-0.01
-50.00
22.51
-135.61
72.25
-46.48
-44.19
74.17
48.32
-195.38
-94.59
55.98
-86.37
-18.99
32.46
-31.56
200.58
41.26
-10.60
46.59
30.34
-21.12
-79.66
-34.98
51.51
74.45
-40.77
12133.5
12154.6
12080.5
12290.3
12062.9
12335.2
12310.5
12208.7
-137.52
-153.14
1426.95
524.01
-138.97
-170.38
46.86
-64.07
-98.07
392.73
381.92

TABLE E-32. CVP3, WATER 1, LOAD CONDITION 1b (Continued)


SG12
SG13
SG14
SG15
SG16
SG17
SG18
SG19
SG20
SG21
SG22
SG23
SG24
SG25
SG26
SG27
SG28
SG29
SG30
SG31
SG32-T
SG32-45
SG32-L
SG33-T
SG33-45
SG33-T
SG34-T
SG34-45
SG34-L
SG35-T
SG35-45
SG35-L
SG36-T
SG36-45
SG36-L
SG37-T
SG37-45
SG37-L
SG38-T
SG38-45
SG38-L
SG39-T
SG39-45
SG39-L
SG40-T
SG40-45
SG40-L

-1.23
-18.56
-16.03
10.42
186.95
24376.9
24.99
30.79
124.85
88.58
-34.59
-17.34
8.94
23.48
32.20
51.41
-89.98
47.16
643.84
-13.83
-12.53
-23.17
-6.54
0.91
-23.84
16.79
-6.07
-35.76
16.98
57.15
70.43
70.64
-22.47
22.80
12.83
504.68
170.33
105.29
34.17
-65.91
-33.55
-24.83
-22.21
28.24
79.31
82.36
82.05

90.76
109.55
111.31
76.48
303.88
24504.4
94.31
137.52
241.68
185.59
76.90
96.68
130.30
147.41
158.28
156.97
-38.47
142.29
670.07
22.39
-40.91
12.52
92.54
-48.56
-3.69
144.07
-44.39
4.67
130.50
18.05
105.67
183.08
-72.21
54.94
146.33
468.54
191.58
214.68
-4.73
-33.40
86.44
-58.01
12.64
132.98
55.46
123.42
170.65

178.94
217.81
227.59
133.33
408.98
24628.0
157.63
224.38
341.98
265.87
145.50
187.74
230.18
251.37
264.15
246.46
8.61
220.89
694.41
52.51
-70.03
46.37
184.79
-93.07
16.27
252.83
-84.83
24.65
231.55
-5.89
128.99
280.28
-114.06
69.67
258.13
439.60
198.01
310.53
-41.07
1.12
183.81
-85.33
26.78
214.71
41.61
148.27
246.15

274.08
335.59
347.90
196.25
520.27
24783.4
224.13
308.51
442.69
341.75
200.35
279.74
334.68
360.57
379.25
343.06
60.85
305.59
717.26
85.81
-99.53
82.11
281.56
-138.20
29.26
367.87
-122.58
52.29
332.46
-30.67
158.93
378.61
-158.13
87.51
373.63
406.26
206.83
414.30
-83.64
37.29
288.63
-113.03
57.55
301.04
27.52
190.59
325.94

360.84
447.12
462.00
253.86
626.63
24824.2
286.89
376.65
532.01
399.80
210.29
360.93
429.47
469.23
488.67
439.49
108.68
388.47
738.74
119.61
-127.97
114.60
370.14
-182.46
31.74
482.37
-157.72
70.67
426.78
-53.98
178.60
469.80
-203.82
85.69
491.31
366.13
191.44
514.79
-119.44
69.43
382.79
-141.65
77.02
387.67
11.29
220.34
405.95

441.74
557.82
568.84
310.69
727.50
24942.3
352.80
444.34
617.36
449.10
223.08
438.38
518.30
574.68
596.90
533.45
158.70
468.15
760.43
160.51
-154.93
145.42
451.99
-224.67
26.92
588.53
-194.11
81.76
518.26
-73.24
193.09
557.96
-247.22
73.30
600.49
324.82
166.09
610.78
-153.01
100.09
470.72
-169.14
92.03
470.37
-2.02
246.65
484.38

E-61

527.35
668.25
681.66
371.14
834.59
25057.9
418.42
515.09
703.73
502.77
237.09
525.12
615.86
685.37
705.94
633.62
205.74
551.98
779.61
199.04
-183.14
174.47
540.70
-265.74
12.14
699.18
-230.10
109.10
608.75
-92.90
224.63
647.14
-287.55
70.53
710.18
284.96
155.60
714.19
-192.25
135.68
569.49
-197.44
132.37
558.40
-16.56
299.01
569.46

604.98
777.03
780.63
427.11
931.94
25095.7
479.39
578.81
783.30
548.29
248.45
598.79
700.75
786.31
814.27
725.42
253.58
629.17
799.39
233.40
-209.90
206.59
620.07
-307.07
0.53
801.22
-264.56
122.81
695.19
-112.36
241.36
730.62
-328.70
56.37
814.38
244.46
130.84
807.73
-225.66
161.58
654.71
-225.74
153.41
639.23
-32.19
330.07
646.81

695.69
893.63
892.51
485.24
1039.10
25275.2
544.55
650.95
872.00
605.92
275.13
685.08
797.87
896.21
927.13
824.51
304.34
712.18
818.77
270.45
-241.99
246.08
713.24
-352.82
-8.97
912.00
-299.81
136.28
788.91
-134.84
256.05
821.02
-371.84
45.31
926.40
202.96
112.13
911.64
-263.65
199.58
751.48
-255.08
181.55
728.78
-48.37
369.65
733.52

773.43
999.52
987.62
538.47
1132.34
25404.2
605.72
714.88
950.50
654.22
291.23
761.53
884.07
996.45
1032.18
915.24
353.66
791.60
838.60
308.91
-270.08
277.62
792.54
-394.21
-20.44
1011.51
-333.13
150.32
873.36
-153.34
272.79
903.79
-411.48
32.70
1027.50
164.01
91.22
1005.94
-296.52
226.96
837.46
-282.29
206.04
812.05
-63.87
404.55
815.08

851.29
1104.58
1082.82
596.98
1225.12
25571.9
669.41
780.95
1029.64
704.12
306.38
840.85
973.31
1095.13
1134.57
1003.49
402.95
865.99
856.14
348.30
-295.81
307.21
871.41
-435.38
-36.46
1112.21
-366.47
167.32
957.55
-173.99
292.25
986.11
-451.04
24.49
1127.78
125.39
76.35
1099.78
-333.41
262.40
926.85
-308.65
235.43
892.37
-77.02
445.90
891.63

TABLE E-33. CVP3, WATER 1, LOAD CONDITION 1c


Load Step
Pressure
Frame-1
Frame-2
Frame-3
Frame-4
Frame-5
Frame-6
Frame-7
Frame-8
Frame-9
Frame-10
Frame-11
Frame-12
Hoop-1
Hoop-2
Hoop-3
Hoop-4
Hoop-5
Hoop-6
Hoop-7
Hoop-8
Hoop-9
Hoop-10
Hoop-11
Hoop-12
Hoop-13
Hoop-14
Long-1
Long-2
Long-3
Long-4
Long-5
Long-6
Long-7
Long-8
SG1
SG2
SG3
SG4
SG5
SG6
SG7
SG8
SG9
SG10
SG11

0.00
0.86
183.72
183.23
165.36
183.96
158.60
170.56
247.97
190.93
193.67
182.39
207.10
183.86
753.10
752.63
754.35
735.55
762.32
734.26
742.18
802.56
746.23
721.30
733.87
753.82
742.17
765.37
1259.64
1246.32
1385.07
1218.79
1206.25
1189.23
1214.60
1201.40
51.54
142.67
838.62
618.62
166.33
37.42
395.15
150.86
73.68
64.06
38.17

1.00
1.72
414.37
380.84
392.91
375.34
379.58
368.67
337.37
426.52
364.69
306.13
380.20
383.20
1547.25
1516.12
1566.58
1588.91
1622.12
1560.44
1569.23
1508.44
1531.57
1538.38
1541.28
1530.11
1550.69
1541.77
2442.03
2454.74
2462.22
2429.27
2447.62
2458.27
2434.82
2423.38
72.98
165.95
1017.68
697.57
190.60
66.02
398.82
172.73
108.20
102.29
55.06

2.00
2.65
541.30
543.40
551.40
540.49
543.27
547.57
545.11
537.63
547.52
536.10
549.22
537.10
2306.47
2308.49
2310.39
2316.40
2312.15
2310.84
2323.25
2383.77
2319.02
2321.42
2323.19
2323.38
2315.01
2340.66
3677.20
3682.23
3613.61
3640.59
3686.26
3684.15
3677.52
3663.44
54.64
136.04
1121.82
716.38
169.74
91.13
381.43
181.09
144.74
136.42
74.35

3.00
3.55
717.37
722.47
726.27
728.96
728.57
741.05
868.29
703.87
733.80
797.11
737.01
741.16
3097.25
3077.70
3077.31
3108.99
3090.12
3089.27
3086.71
3030.67
3075.18
3085.91
3086.20
3079.13
3071.44
3079.93
4871.96
4910.68
4911.60
4885.96
4904.23
4900.00
4905.54
4922.96
76.83
143.39
1295.02
776.04
170.35
114.42
387.28
184.31
174.87
166.73
95.11

4.00
4.41
897.26
920.98
899.81
891.93
898.69
890.81
887.40
901.91
884.21
902.24
934.13
911.43
3860.23
3859.32
3863.30
3851.36
3855.07
3861.93
3871.84
3920.47
3860.59
3866.90
3867.88
3864.75
3857.78
3856.41
6112.30
6138.66
6042.37
6127.16
6121.74
6128.81
6128.28
6131.53
86.18
154.75
1429.23
841.04
186.92
141.72
408.63
206.32
209.38
200.35
119.35

5.00
5.24
1093.92
1072.06
1084.94
1099.28
1089.06
1109.85
1100.03
1104.00
1073.51
1111.28
1089.67
1073.63
4652.62
4651.77
4652.80
4649.27
4641.93
4641.98
4644.19
4597.47
4642.84
4718.88
4633.43
4606.37
4607.49
4618.55
7260.14
7493.70
7199.99
7317.67
7359.18
7370.58
7355.36
7380.21
87.28
150.90
1525.95
873.48
186.78
167.76
415.54
218.04
242.81
232.66
145.07

E-62

6.00
6.12
1288.53
1262.87
1286.88
1285.62
1280.86
1272.42
1354.76
1284.46
1258.45
1388.24
1274.59
1260.83
5414.51
5414.26
5423.67
5407.22
5414.93
5413.55
5437.37
5302.44
5356.51
5433.77
5403.04
5413.23
5385.42
5423.61
8545.45
8554.16
8268.67
8637.34
8582.81
8573.84
8573.43
8579.05
116.27
167.80
1646.86
929.21
200.10
196.03
433.49
235.84
276.47
265.67
168.43

7.00
7.03
1452.73
1445.62
1451.62
1462.21
1443.91
1457.53
1441.89
1460.95
1456.93
1452.88
1455.44
1449.27
6163.25
6190.92
6176.80
6181.52
6176.69
6184.82
6173.68
6347.84
6141.26
6201.47
6187.72
6162.95
6172.91
6186.45
9557.67
9765.99
9586.84
9812.07
9808.40
9808.41
9793.45
9783.54
86.56
131.85
1708.17
930.13
173.07
223.35
410.31
231.86
309.35
289.40
195.25

8.00
7.04
1471.48
1448.92
1451.42
1446.50
1448.90
1462.41
1424.41
1464.14
1449.75
1462.96
1466.98
1455.96
6180.41
6193.35
6189.70
6213.61
6182.79
6170.65
6183.42
6282.28
6152.76
6173.16
6177.28
6230.29
6166.11
6187.07
9581.73
9757.96
9594.88
9794.20
9806.43
9804.00
9804.70
9797.58
83.44
127.45
1706.70
927.01
168.44
223.72
403.03
228.01
309.72
288.67
194.52

9.00
7.88
1629.09
1644.04
1640.53
1644.07
1639.84
1634.42
1623.25
1640.39
1633.80
1627.22
1641.11
1578.35
6929.37
6923.31
6943.05
6941.87
6928.35
6931.06
6905.34
6950.91
6972.10
6910.22
6949.19
6985.72
6974.17
6955.61
10735.9
10871.7
10705.6
11023.1
11040.7
11027.9
11009.4
11015.9
84.18
121.40
1784.90
953.41
163.40
249.94
413.52
233.78
341.68
322.82
221.53

10.00
8.78
1836.61
1814.85
1821.00
1817.46
1806.60
1818.17
1778.11
1879.42
1808.37
1818.11
1797.20
1810.58
7670.36
7724.87
7736.14
7728.75
7729.90
7740.77
7732.56
7502.49
7652.37
7734.69
7729.11
7734.36
7723.50
7584.25
11962.3
12072.0
12132.8
12307.4
12263.3
12261.8
12206.0
12158.3
85.46
101.77
1872.09
971.38
138.11
274.51
384.21
217.94
369.05
349.49
248.72

TABLE E-33. CVP3, WATER 1, LOAD CONDITION 1c (Continued)


SG12
SG13
SG14
SG15
SG16
SG17
SG18
SG19
SG20
SG21
SG22
SG23
SG24
SG25
SG26
SG27
SG28
SG29
SG30
SG31
SG32-T
SG32-45
SG32-L
SG33-T
SG33-45
SG33-T
SG34-T
SG34-45
SG34-L
SG35-T
SG35-45
SG35-L
SG36-T
SG36-45
SG36-L
SG37-T
SG37-45
SG37-L
SG38-T
SG38-45
SG38-L
SG39-T
SG39-45
SG39-L
SG40-T
SG40-45
SG40-L

91.05
101.68
123.38
84.60
303.91
23747.9
87.48
114.90
249.62
185.61
76.96
76.67
130.13
149.22
146.90
149.54
-32.59
125.95
683.73
29.24
11.69
27.62
94.75
6.28
12.14
139.87
21.45
41.88
134.36
251.06
127.71
186.96
-3.92
77.84
140.70
494.63
210.32
218.36
46.83
-2.55
76.86
8.37
42.30
128.83
100.23
134.02
155.14

178.85
201.49
226.31
140.02
404.30
23698.4
131.84
169.54
341.25
250.77
147.94
136.51
224.30
243.82
245.22
238.96
10.08
204.92
696.80
54.35
65.12
92.88
176.40
43.50
57.44
239.26
76.14
107.32
220.55
224.66
178.38
271.46
50.23
132.40
247.38
493.57
232.50
294.03
89.95
58.22
159.95
62.64
107.91
210.50
135.18
180.37
213.58

268.75
308.94
332.84
197.31
509.25
23799.0
180.82
223.44
433.40
311.31
205.04
198.18
321.76
343.38
354.55
334.30
54.95
290.10
708.35
79.96
115.97
163.78
260.09
78.23
96.89
344.68
132.06
170.41
306.53
236.93
230.69
356.12
98.68
183.43
356.29
499.80
252.85
377.75
134.53
125.77
247.74
113.97
183.19
297.46
166.16
236.82
275.75

356.45
418.98
439.85
254.00
615.69
24036.7
230.21
270.39
521.78
359.58
232.06
254.93
413.60
448.15
463.58
433.66
102.04
375.90
723.62
112.10
160.11
231.96
346.73
104.81
124.39
456.05
183.24
230.36
393.31
271.18
281.21
440.50
136.69
215.09
470.64
504.26
251.04
466.30
179.86
190.96
331.37
160.38
247.85
384.80
199.45
289.34
344.75

441.20
523.61
543.10
310.08
719.06
24043.1
275.28
314.89
601.04
400.23
254.21
310.16
501.49
548.79
567.74
529.29
146.16
457.59
738.56
144.78
199.97
298.02
429.94
128.34
139.94
560.17
234.38
282.58
470.29
287.52
326.34
515.96
168.98
235.48
575.68
503.52
245.14
552.02
223.33
253.90
412.17
201.98
312.92
468.04
232.45
345.74
413.45

523.54
629.57
638.05
366.00
818.92
24457.9
321.34
359.97
678.70
436.31
272.07
362.48
585.94
644.32
672.86
622.26
189.56
535.82
753.85
177.37
238.38
358.93
509.99
151.06
149.30
659.93
283.16
334.63
544.93
317.75
372.06
588.90
199.63
252.35
672.72
507.64
241.29
634.29
266.45
317.24
489.89
242.13
377.56
546.60
265.43
404.01
480.18

E-63

601.18
733.47
724.94
416.70
912.41
24556.9
361.61
398.88
749.70
469.54
296.69
413.78
668.32
735.03
774.65
711.10
233.00
611.97
767.87
208.49
276.06
425.42
584.42
174.45
162.36
752.33
335.67
385.66
615.29
353.87
416.02
657.00
229.78
267.04
766.89
512.06
236.56
714.15
312.20
378.81
565.39
283.44
439.30
623.00
298.47
458.22
545.58

682.90
835.78
818.49
474.47
1010.05
24542.2
408.59
446.73
827.73
509.68
318.00
469.78
754.25
830.03
879.06
802.16
277.88
690.40
782.43
238.52
315.89
486.07
663.79
197.99
168.79
851.74
387.40
442.31
690.67
392.18
467.81
730.32
260.26
288.13
863.86
514.90
241.34
799.38
357.52
449.32
644.87
323.97
510.57
703.00
334.19
525.69
617.15

683.27
835.78
818.86
474.47
1010.23
24612.8
408.41
446.54
827.37
508.95
317.36
469.78
754.62
830.03
878.33
802.34
278.62
690.03
782.38
237.74
317.63
488.45
663.24
199.60
169.89
851.38
389.23
442.49
690.49
393.33
467.99
730.32
261.91
288.09
864.05
525.12
241.15
799.38
359.17
450.24
645.28
325.80
511.21
702.72
335.63
525.95
616.84

758.93
933.69
901.59
527.29
1098.97
24418.6
450.44
488.32
896.75
543.01
335.18
521.74
836.33
915.45
976.67
886.00
322.76
762.77
797.08
269.23
354.31
548.82
734.22
221.58
177.78
939.24
438.02
493.64
757.80
431.54
514.63
796.11
289.45
302.90
952.94
528.89
240.79
878.01
402.67
510.10
719.62
363.03
572.79
774.98
367.94
583.87
681.95

834.77
1034.36
986.33
581.94
1187.17
24459.8
499.45
535.25
972.22
580.57
359.19
577.00
918.41
1004.55
1078.51
971.31
370.58
837.71
815.77
304.91
392.17
609.01
805.57
244.99
187.70
1027.65
487.54
545.70
831.54
477.37
561.28
867.96
318.64
315.75
1044.40
538.10
238.95
958.65
448.73
570.14
793.77
404.48
630.69
849.31
404.59
639.56
751.21

TABLE E-34. CVP3, WATER 2, LOAD CONDITION 1a


Load Step
Pressure
Frame-1
Frame-2
Frame-3
Frame-4
Frame-5
Frame-6
Frame-7
Frame-8
Frame-9
Frame-10
Frame-11
Frame-12
Hoop-1
Hoop-2
Hoop-3
Hoop-4
Hoop-5
Hoop-6
Hoop-7
Hoop-8
Hoop-9
Hoop-10
Hoop-11
Hoop-12
Hoop-13
Hoop-14
Long-1
Long-2
Long-3
Long-4
Long-5
Long-6
Long-7
Long-8
SG1
SG2
SG3
SG4
SG5
SG6
SG7
SG8
SG9
SG10
SG11

0.00
0.06
-41.22
71.44
-126.91
-75.82
-161.89
-10.22
-123.75
3.73
29.99
-202.90
-43.90
34.91
-57.60
140.75
-101.73
58.04
117.93
118.78
-99.47
-65.25
-126.31
-50.72
390.85
120.05
-44.24
47.97
9.73
1.22
2.88
19.09
21.00
-5.47
74.62
5.02
200.98
324.08
754.36
730.09
339.54
20.41
584.03
280.49
61.19
12.28
14.46

1.00
0.90
263.02
178.17
173.98
184.04
163.86
179.00
192.66
187.30
296.53
146.04
210.15
176.79
784.35
716.53
726.28
672.61
1233.30
641.85
736.71
817.27
829.68
775.54
772.59
757.53
771.84
772.76
-20.95
1.22
7.86
14.20
-36.58
11.65
-33.49
-1.14
92.42
195.48
663.80
609.20
222.95
54.10
448.97
204.73
96.08
11.69
-3.17

2.00
1.79
366.16
370.55
349.98
368.47
367.55
361.70
366.58
359.30
359.55
509.23
371.43
345.14
1525.19
1528.76
1549.04
1650.00
1563.71
1549.35
1538.19
1603.88
1544.11
1525.57
1559.56
1537.37
1565.37
1534.22
12.10
-2.42
10.34
28.89
58.19
17.76
116.67
-14.67
123.41
211.99
665.82
601.87
229.86
92.24
443.65
210.37
133.91
12.05
-24.85

3.00
2.62
554.71
560.36
552.76
536.66
558.41
554.06
560.62
570.35
563.17
536.12
561.17
547.47
2341.40
2306.69
2322.67
2316.40
2319.46
2344.11
2325.08
2236.68
2324.46
2328.65
2313.97
2323.38
2359.52
2333.27
-24.50
1.22
4.12
15.42
-28.18
28.77
-25.08
11.17
174.01
295.80
803.48
732.22
328.69
141.92
531.94
302.12
190.67
5.22
-43.77

4.00
3.52
711.33
709.38
723.69
734.97
713.87
716.47
724.03
737.00
723.72
730.38
708.73
693.15
3082.24
3075.59
3068.23
3077.21
3066.08
3087.11
3082.75
3104.20
3073.37
3078.68
3084.36
3079.13
3071.44
3079.93
-18.59
1.22
7.86
20.32
-16.18
26.32
59.01
29.64
191.45
314.91
811.63
752.46
352.18
187.41
565.16
332.41
239.00
-8.33
-61.78

5.00
4.34
929.51
934.30
914.82
922.48
915.45
914.28
919.71
915.27
915.04
1061.95
901.77
917.88
3834.49
3821.42
3852.78
3880.98
3862.37
3869.32
3820.72
3884.09
3822.88
3843.79
3835.08
3857.73
3917.52
3871.58
-22.13
-2.42
12.83
15.42
10.21
37.33
-27.48
46.87
272.87
407.53
892.04
852.39
442.77
234.53
673.61
403.66
289.14
-7.27
-75.38

E-64

6.00
5.36
1098.69
1077.09
1091.34
1109.26
1083.54
1105.76
1087.39
1160.21
1113.34
1122.74
1100.53
1114.64
4696.74
4649.97
4666.84
4647.41
4654.71
4658.61
4810.35
4633.78
4633.31
4646.09
4649.56
4635.55
4673.80
4677.25
-7.97
1.22
10.34
21.54
33.00
21.43
-26.28
59.17
276.35
412.85
932.97
868.16
452.35
284.41
678.00
421.74
342.78
-28.57
-93.39

7.00
6.17
1290.45
1273.57
1278.45
1259.96
1267.26
1336.99
1301.58
1332.87
1325.12
1273.09
1276.28
1281.85
5535.10
5435.20
5551.08
5397.19
5381.32
5373.97
5584.53
5524.14
5451.91
5499.95
5457.59
5429.13
5445.85
5439.48
16.81
6.08
10.34
19.09
121.76
29.99
3.75
117.01
346.00
506.16
1042.64
981.55
551.59
334.25
777.95
504.80
398.21
-33.25
-103.30

8.00
7.03
1427.83
1451.79
1471.42
1461.42
1453.48
1449.95
1574.73
1442.22
1479.84
1458.25
1411.62
1470.24
6170.60
6187.31
6206.62
6175.97
6171.22
6182.97
6177.33
6171.95
6136.43
6173.16
6180.96
6193.22
6188.37
6187.07
-30.39
4.87
11.59
16.64
180.54
58.11
60.20
174.86
338.88
494.66
1051.92
985.87
543.07
376.46
774.00
507.87
443.07
-45.42
-115.07

9.00
7.84
1626.81
1627.78
1640.00
1636.61
1639.27
1635.65
1650.30
1636.45
1636.72
1609.50
1639.01
1605.50
6889.38
6882.22
6932.89
6962.69
6959.82
6940.77
6876.58
6854.61
6677.55
6931.23
6906.10
6955.37
6936.38
6836.60
13.28
1.22
5.37
10.52
274.13
104.58
109.46
231.49
379.96
537.21
1098.55
1028.96
583.58
421.01
817.41
543.40
489.55
-56.75
-128.11

10.00
8.68
1830.97
1810.76
1824.01
1825.60
1806.10
1804.33
1807.86
1862.69
1827.84
1932.23
1808.10
1850.77
7714.78
7721.52
7706.52
7719.80
7817.80
7726.28
7908.10
7642.23
7338.54
7662.37
7679.33
7741.77
7627.05
7465.92
-38.65
0.01
12.83
12.97
350.87
143.70
161.10
272.08
467.47
618.16
1162.73
1097.46
648.76
465.80
905.62
584.49
534.42
-73.84
-143.19

TABLE E-34. CVP3, WATER 2, LOAD CONDITION 1a (Continued)


SG12
SG13
SG14
SG15
SG16
SG17
SG18
SG19
SG20
SG21
SG22
SG23
SG24
SG25
SG26
SG27
SG28
SG29
SG30
SG31
SG32-T
SG32-45
SG32-L
SG33-T
SG33-45
SG33-T
SG34-T
SG34-45
SG34-L
SG35-T
SG35-45
SG35-L
SG36-T
SG36-45
SG36-L
SG37-T
SG37-45
SG37-L
SG38-T
SG38-45
SG38-L
SG39-T
SG39-45
SG39-L
SG40-T
SG40-45
SG40-L

-16.24
12.02
-13.83
17.80
191.10
22309.2
33.98
39.07
143.42
100.91
-8.18
-19.36
16.84
23.80
42.12
49.01
-78.20
32.46
673.08
-23.93
-21.28
-34.50
8.55
-4.00
-12.09
63.38
-18.31
-36.81
21.56
52.37
66.01
86.62
-20.63
35.41
37.35
432.72
136.55
84.75
31.60
-59.29
-18.91
-39.49
-48.84
26.36
62.80
53.69
74.01

-13.62
-10.17
-12.72
20.92
189.80
22386.4
22.14
16.07
140.28
96.30
-19.52
-43.95
7.29
21.49
24.47
48.82
-77.46
32.64
656.43
-25.81
44.83
-17.15
-4.24
63.42
-4.38
38.06
60.92
4.62
21.01
121.17
100.71
83.49
39.40
47.79
20.72
512.69
179.84
108.93
90.68
-28.81
-39.60
44.67
2.40
25.58
117.60
79.98
60.86

-10.32
-6.23
-23.18
19.68
189.52
22439.4
5.39
-10.07
138.25
83.78
-10.43
-65.25
14.45
18.73
31.46
53.28
-74.52
28.23
657.63
-33.06
130.72
31.37
-17.08
139.92
25.96
32.74
150.23
44.12
14.41
179.20
126.23
77.25
137.79
80.90
17.28
502.05
189.93
89.69
160.60
1.48
-39.79
127.56