Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
ABSTRACT
This study aimed to determine the factors limiting agricultural production and the farmer problems in
Erzurum, Kars, Agri and Ardahan provinces of Eastern Anatolia. Farmer conversation meetings were
held in total of 147 villages chosen from four type of villages (mountain, plain, mountain-plain passage
and valley) in 41 districts for informal survey in 1998. At these meetings, farmers were asked about the
problems they faced during agricultural production activities. Questionnaires for formal surveys were
prepared according to the results of the first survey. Stratified random sampling method was used to
determine sample size of villages and farms. Formal survey study was conducted between March-July
1999 resulting in 1116 questionnaires through face-to-face farmer interviews in 76 villages. The results of
the survey revealed that the problems related to agronomy, animal health, animal diseases, input, credit
and socio-economic structure were ranked the first priority respectively. Problems were also classified
according to the responsible institutions. It was determined that 24, 37 and 39 percent of the problems
could be solved by research, regulation and extension, respectively.
INTRODUCTION
Agricultural research strategies have not taken into account the farmer participation to
the research and extension studies (down-up) by near past in the world and by recent in
Turkey. Agricultural development was considered as a production increase and the
series of technology transfer studies to provide higher welfare. Whereas, as mentioned
by Mannion (1994), these strategies, also called green revolution, provided
heterogeneous benefit distribution among regions and the communities but the majority,
except farmers having favorable conditions has not benefited much from these green
revolution types of studies.
Adams (1982) stated that agricultural extension studies should be started after a survey
study with which the objectives and the problems of the farmers related to farm
management is determined and that reasonable solutions may be found. Also, it is
International Soil Congress (ISC) on
“Natural Resource Management
for Sustainable Development”
June 7-10, 2004 Erzurum-Turkey, pp. F1-F9
agreed that identification and definition studies are the first step of the research studies
(Norman and Collinson, 1987).
Although many survey studies have been conducted by different institutions in Erzurum
Province, especially by the College of Agriculture at Ataturk University, they were
limited in both subjects examined and the sample size. That is, a detailed survey study
in Erzurum province has not been conducted except Farming Systems Research (FSR)
study carried out by Eastern Anatolia Agricultural Research Institute (EAARI), which
was criticized that it did not represent the province as a whole.
Material
Methods
In determination of the sample size, stratified random sampling method was used (Cicek
and Erkan, 1996). Stratification was made in determination of both village and farm
numbers. In order to ensure selected villages to represent the whole study area, villages
of the all districts including central districts of the provinces in the study area, in total of
41, were categorized into four groups namely mountain, plain, mountain-plain transition
and valley villages. The sample size of the farmers to be interviewed was calculated by
using previously estimated population parameters. To determine the sample size,
following formula of the stratified random sampling method was used.
n
N i xS i 2
2 2 2
N xD N i xS i
Where; D: d/Z,
Ni : number of units in ith layer, d: a certain deviation from the mean,
Si : standard deviation of ith layer, Z: table value of t-distribution
n : minimum sample size
N: Number of total units,
2
International Soil Congress (ISC) on
“Natural Resource Management
for Sustainable Development”
June 7-10, 2004 Erzurum-Turkey, pp. F1-F9
Deviation of sample mean ( x ) from that of population (µ) was taken 10% and 5% in
determination of sample villages and farms respectively. Sample sizes of villages being
72 and farms being 996 were calculated in 95% and 99% confidence levels,
respectively.
In 1998, informal surveys were conducted in total 147 villages in four village type in 41
districts in the study area. Farmers were asked about the problems they faced in farming
and the answers were used in preparation of questionnaire forms of formal survey. The
questionnaire forms were given the last shape by reviewing and reorganizing according
to the suggestions by the departments in the research institute. A valuable extension
work during informal survey was also performed and the farmers were introduced some
new varieties and technologies generated by Eastern Anatolia Agricultural Research
Institute (EAARI) and they were enlightened on the subjects of their interests.
Studies in the villages where sufficient number of farmers were not obtained or the
villages where it was not possible to go, were performed in the villages of the same
group. Formal survey studies were started on 8th of March, 1999 and ended in 14th of
July, 1999, resulting in 1146 completed questionnaires through face to face farmer
interviews in 76 villages.
Village Groups
Mountain Plain Transition Valley Total
Province NV NQ NV NQ NV NQ NV NQ NV NQ
s
Erzurum 17 232 5 86 7 98 7 82 36 498
Kars 5 67 5 87 1 16 4 42 15 212
Agri 2 28 11 191 2 32 3 43 18 294
Ardahan 2 29 1 20 2 34 2 29 7 112
TOTAL 26 356 22 384 12 180 16 196 76 1116
NV: Number of village NQ: Number of questionnaire
Data from questionnaires were processed in the computer by the year 2000 and 30
questionnaires were eliminated due to their lacking of relevant data. SPSSWIN and MS
EXCEL software packages were used to analyze the data (Figure 1)
3
International Soil Congress (ISC) on
“Natural Resource Management
for Sustainable Development”
June 7-10, 2004 Erzurum-Turkey, pp. F1-F9
Natural factors, namely physical and biological, and socio-economic factors, grouped
into endogenous and exogenous, affect the agricultural production (Maxwell, 1986,
cited in Kara, 1996). In accordance to this reality, questions to elicit the factors having
effects on agricultural production were included in the questionnaires, along with those
to be reported directly by the interviewees and production customs. Farmer problems
and the factors affecting agricultural production were scored according to 1-5 Likert
Scale from minimum to maximum importance. In the light of the study findings, the
reasons were investigated and possible solutions were suggested. In prioritization of the
problems, following method (Woolley, 1989 cited in Uzunlu et all., 1993) was used.
1- In the first stage, problems were identified and each problem was given a rough
priority according to the number of farmers affected by this problem.
2- In the second stage, the importance of the crops grown for farmers and the severity
of the problems were taken into consideration
3- In the third stage, the reasons of the problems were identified.
4- In the fourth stage, possible suggestions to be proposed were investigated for each
problem, and finally
5- In the fifth stage, the list of the solutions for each problem was formed.
RESULTS
4
International Soil Congress (ISC) on
“Natural Resource Management
for Sustainable Development”
June 7-10, 2004 Erzurum-Turkey, pp. F1-F9
The most significant problem related to crop farming is the low yield in all products.
The factors bring about low yield are either related to incorrect or imperfect applications
or arising from socio-economic factors and the problems concerned with input supply.
Insufficient and expensive veterinary services were the most important problem.
Moreover, untimely and superficial vaccinations were determined to be another
important problem. Also, foot and mouth disease epidemics despite of vaccinations are
other important issues to be focused on. The leading reason of the insufficient
veterinary service is the lack of staff working in the provincial and district directorates
of agriculture in the study area; insufficient infrastructure and lack of communication
between farmers and the institutions.
The most important extension related problems were lack of on-farm applications, lack
of technical knowledge of the extension officers, ignorant farmers on some crop
farming. In addition, lack of communication of extension officers with farmers,
insufficient number of officers in regional agricultural institutions and lack of extension
work were also important problems.
Lack of water in meadows for animals, insufficiency of the graze lands and lack of
quality bulls for inseminations were reported to be the most striking animal husbandry
related problems. Moreover, problems, such as no artificial insemination activities,
roughage deficit, unsuitable animal houses for animal keeping and early drying of the
graze lands were the important problems in this context. On the other hand, the study
revealed that contrary to the assumptions, the rate of the farmers who were against to
artificial insemination due to religious beliefs or delusions was found to be very low.
Insufficient rainfall, the higher proportion of rain fed lands, short vegetation period,
infertility of the lands, insufficient irrigation water, extreme cold weather in spring and
fall, etc. were determined to be the most important problems related to environment and
climate.
5
International Soil Congress (ISC) on
“Natural Resource Management
for Sustainable Development”
June 7-10, 2004 Erzurum-Turkey, pp. F1-F9
DISCUSSION
The measures to be taken in achieving the higher yields are increasing registered variety
use, introducing winter varieties of wheat, barley and vetch, emphasis on extension,
introducing low cost tillage systems. Farmers do not tillage the soil adequately before
sowing due to high cultivation costs or they do not know the importance of good soil
preparation before sowing. Inadequate tillage brings about more seed use and low yield.
Farmers should be organized to obtain the inputs at low prices. By means of
development of early maturing varieties, plant growth will be completed before the
extreme and unfavorable weather conditions, along with that harvesting time will move
to an earlier time and so green sowing, not practiced due to the delay of previous
harvest, will be possible. This will also help increase the yield.
Among the infrastructural problems, over fragmentation comes first and this causes the
difficulties in planning, ineffective use of production factors, waste of labor, work and
time. For this reason, it is necessary to give priority to land reform studies in order to
increase the size of farms to an optimum level.
An important proportion of the applications and factors resulting in low yield are valid
for the pastures as well. In addition, another leading reason for low yield in pastures is
the over grazing because of high roughage deficit in the region. Pastures are heavily
grazed in the spring and in autumn. So, increasing the roughage production and
rehabilitation of the graze lands should be considered together to solve this problem.
Although a significant increase in literacy was achieved, this is just limited to primary
school with 67,6 percent. The proportion of the farmers graduated from advanced
schools is very low with 11,1 percent. Thus, present education level of the farmers is
not sufficient to follow up and adopt the technological innovations (Kara, 2000). Higher
education is also important with regard to effective management of the existing
resources (Karagolge,1976). Education level of the farmers, especially in the study area,
is very low when compared to the farmers of developed countries (Turkdogan, 1973).
Extension workers usually move to other provinces after they have a certain degree of
experience. Required measures to restraint the staff in the region should be taken, along
with a special emphasis on the training the trainees. The cooperation between extension
services and research institutes, in reality, is not tight. People in extension service
institution are not aware of the study results carried out in research institutes most of the
time. This cooperation should be improved and promoted with the legislative
regulations to be put into action. On-farm research and farmer participation to such
research studies should also be promoted and given high priority.
6
International Soil Congress (ISC) on
“Natural Resource Management
for Sustainable Development”
June 7-10, 2004 Erzurum-Turkey, pp. F1-F9
Moreover, farmers should be categorized for the service fees. Such services should be
provided to small farmers for free while big farms should be charged. The quality of
services makes farmers to be willing to pay reasonable fees determined for the services.
In putting the problems in order according to their possible reasons and solutions, the
scores given by the farmers to them were used in scoring their solutions and so, total
scores of the type of solutions (i.e. research, extension and policy measures) were
obtained. In enumeration with the consideration of these total scores, it was determined
that extension and policy measures came first and second respectively, while research
was the last (Table 3, 4, 5).
7
International Soil Congress (ISC) on
“Natural Resource Management
for Sustainable Development”
June 7-10, 2004 Erzurum-Turkey, pp. F1-F9
In conclusion, the first step in solving the farmer problems should be acceleration of the
technology transfer studies. There have been a lot of research studies on the shelves
waiting to be conveyed to the farmers. Special emphasis should be given to extension
while structural deficiencies of the farms and agricultural institutions should be
eliminated.
REFERENCES
8
International Soil Congress (ISC) on
“Natural Resource Management
for Sustainable Development”
June 7-10, 2004 Erzurum-Turkey, pp. F1-F9