0 Bewertungen0% fanden dieses Dokument nützlich (0 Abstimmungen)
35 Ansichten9 Seiten
The document discusses the origins of World War 1 and who was responsible. It provides context around the assassination of Archduke Franz Ferdinand and the subsequent actions taken by Austria-Hungary, Germany, Russia, France and other European powers. A timeline of events from June 1914 to August 1914 outlines the series of diplomatic exchanges, military mobilizations and declarations of war that ultimately led the major European countries into World War 1. Additional details are provided on German naval strength compared to the Triple Entente powers of Britain, France and Russia in an attempt to argue that Germany did not pose a military threat to the region.
The document discusses the origins of World War 1 and who was responsible. It provides context around the assassination of Archduke Franz Ferdinand and the subsequent actions taken by Austria-Hungary, Germany, Russia, France and other European powers. A timeline of events from June 1914 to August 1914 outlines the series of diplomatic exchanges, military mobilizations and declarations of war that ultimately led the major European countries into World War 1. Additional details are provided on German naval strength compared to the Triple Entente powers of Britain, France and Russia in an attempt to argue that Germany did not pose a military threat to the region.
The document discusses the origins of World War 1 and who was responsible. It provides context around the assassination of Archduke Franz Ferdinand and the subsequent actions taken by Austria-Hungary, Germany, Russia, France and other European powers. A timeline of events from June 1914 to August 1914 outlines the series of diplomatic exchanges, military mobilizations and declarations of war that ultimately led the major European countries into World War 1. Additional details are provided on German naval strength compared to the Triple Entente powers of Britain, France and Russia in an attempt to argue that Germany did not pose a military threat to the region.
knew that French troops were approaching the Belgian boarder to use it as a launching pad into Germany. German Military Commanders realized this several years before the beginning of the war, hence the shlifen plan was created in order to stop the French from using Belgium as a position to invade Germany Under German Kaiser Wilhelm starting about 1900 German foreign policy lost all balance and was mostly run by the Prussian military that had united Germany 1870. In the years 1900-1912 Germany almost started 2 wars (especially with France) in the '1st and 2nd Moroccan Crisis', started a military arms race with the rest of Europe, started a naval battleship race with Britain, stomped all over Africa to try and grab the other countries colonies, and sided with the Dutch 'Boers' against the British in the British Boer War in South Africa Britain Can be shown as responsible because they were afraid that Germany would over take them, so they wanted to crush Germany Britain was Jealous that Germany became the largest economy in 1900, and that Britain fell to third BEHIND the USA and Germany
France Can be shown as responsible because they were competitive with Germany since the beginning of German creation, they were jealous because they were no longer the powerful France that they once were, but rather were becoming a fourth rate European power in a position between Britain and Germany
Russia, bound by treaty to Serbia, announced mobilisation of its vast army in her defence, a slow process that would take around six They bragged they were the best and the strongest, everyone else weak, and that their military would defeat anybody when Germany decided to attack. They made the other powers afraid, nervous, kept them on the edge of their seats. When war came 1914 as you said, Germany didn't actually cause 'that' particular incident, but with everyone else so rattled it didn't take much to set the powder keg off. weeks to complete. Once the Russian military machine gets going, it cant be stopped
Austria 1. They issued an ultimatum to Serbia after the assassination of the archduke Ferdinand, an ultimatum designed to be rejected and give them a pretext for war. This ultimatum was designed to lead to war as it was given a time period of 24H 2. They asked for Germany to back them up in the case their dispute with Serbia caused problems with Russia, thus obligating Germany to declare war on Russia if it came to Serbia's defence. 3. They declared war on Serbia after the ultimatum was rejected.
The Kaiser wanted to have the largest navy in the world to challenge Britain's navy. The Kaiser thought that if Britain had to challenge Germany it would losesupport from its colonies because it wouldn't have enough ships to supply the colonies with supplies or to get supplies from the colonies. This naval race led to extreme militarism and the war monger wanted to use the weapons that e had amassed. Germany So what was Germanys fault for the war? Lets look at our opponents GREAT POINTS One by one: Apparently, Germany, a new nation, with a great history, desired to become better for its people, to become a great nation in the center of Europe. Because of these moderate ambitions of greatness, something that everynation strives for, Germany is made to be the bad guy in these debates. In reality, Germany was cornered by Russia, France, and Britain Germany wanted peace with Britain, only to be laughed at when the Kaiser desired a strong
relation between the two nations, the Kaiser, although he may have wanted a strong navy, only wanted it to be able to defend German ports and shipping, which was essential to German economy The chancellor of Germany and the man responsible for the Triple Alliance was Otto von Bismarck. Bismarck wanted to prevent a war on two fronts, which is why he targeted these two countries specifically. Germany formed triple alliance before triple entente was formed
Timeline of Events June 28, 1914: Serbian irredentists assassinate Archduke Franz Ferdinand of the Austro- Hungarian Empire. June 2829: Anti-Serb pogrom in Sarajevo July 23: Austria-Hungary, following their own secret enquiry, sends an ultimatum to Serbia, containing several very severe demands. In particular, they gave only forty-eight hours to comply. Whilst both Great Britain and Russia sympathised with many of the demands, both agreed the timescale was far too short. Both nevertheless advised Serbia to comply. July 24: Germany officially declares support for Austria's position. July 24: Sir Edward Grey, speaking for the British government, asks that Germany, France, Italy and Great Britain, "who had no direct interests in Serbia, should act together for the sake of peace simultaneously."[29] July 25: The Serbian government replies to Austria, and agrees to most of the demands. However, certain demands brought into question her survival as an independent nation. On these points they asked that the Hague Tribunal arbitrate July 25: Russia enters a period preparatory to war and mobilization begins on all frontiers. Government decides on a partial mobilization in principle to begin on July 29. July 25: Serbia mobilizes its army; responds to Austro-Hungarian dmarche with less than full acceptance; Austria-Hungary breaks diplomatic relations with Serbia. July 26: Serbia reservists accidentally violate Austro-Hungarian border at Temes-Kubin.[30] July 26: Russia having agreed to stand aside whilst others conferred, a meeting is organised to take place between ambassadors from Great Britain, Germany, Italy and France to discuss the crisis. Germany declines the invitation. July 27: Sir Edward Grey meets the German ambassador independently. A telegram to Berlin after the meeting states, "Other issues might be raised that would supersede the dispute between Austria and Serbia ... as long as Germany would work to keep peace I would keep closely in touch." July 28: Austria-Hungary, having failed to accept Serbia's response of the 25th, declares war on Serbia. Mobilisation against Serbia begins. July 29: Russian general mobilization is ordered, and then changed to partial mobilization. July 29: Sir Edward Grey appeals to Germany to intervene to maintain peace. July 29: The British Ambassador in Berlin, Sir Edward Goschen, is informed by the German Chancellor that Germany is contemplating war with France, and furthermore, wishes to send its army through Belgium. He tries to secure Britain's neutrality in such an action. July 30: Russian general mobilization is reordered at 5:00 P.M. July 31: Austrian general mobilization is ordered. July 31: Germany sends an ultimatum to Russia, demanding that they halt military preparations within twelve hours. July 31: Both France and Germany are asked by Britain to declare their support for the ongoing neutrality of Belgium. France agrees to this. Germany does not respond. July 31: Gemany asks France, whether it would stay neutral in case of a war Germany vs. Russia August 1 (3 A.M.): King George V of Great Britain personally telegraphs Tsar Nicholas II of Russia. August 1: French general mobilization is ordered. August 1: German general mobilization is ordered. August 1: Germany declares war against Russia. August 1: The Tsar responds to the king's telegram, stating, "I would gladly have accepted your proposals had not the German ambassador this afternoon presented a note to my Government declaring war." August 2: Germany and The Ottoman Empire sign a secret treaty.[31] entrenching the Ottoman- German Alliance August 3: Germany, after France declines (See Note) its demand to remain neutral,[32] declares war on France. Germany states to Belgium that she would "treat her as an enemy" if she did not allow free passage of German troops across her lands. August 3: Britain, expecting German naval attack on the northern French coast, states that Britain would give "... all the protection in its powers." August 4: Germany implements the Alfred von Schlieffen Plan (modified). August 4 (midnight): Having failed to receive notice from Germany assuring the neutrality of Belgium, Britain declares war on Germany. August 6: Austria-Hungary declares war on Russia. August 23: Japan, honouring the Anglo-Japanese Alliance, declares war on Germany. August 25: Japan declares war on Austria-Hungary
.The naval strength of the powers in 1914 Country Personnel Large Naval Vessels (Dreadnoughts) Tonnage Russia 54,000 4 328,000 France 68,000 10 731,000 Britain 209,000 29 2,205,000 TOTAL 331,000 43 3,264,000 Germany 79,000 17 1,019,000 Austria- Hungary 16,000 4 249,000 TOTAL 95,000 21 1,268,000 (Source: Ferguson 1999, p. 85)
So let me get this straight, Britain France and Russia were afraid that german military might was dangerous and unstabalizing, but they fail to admit that there was no german navel strength compared to the triple entant. Compared to Germany, they had 5 times the number of navel personnel than Germany They had 4 times the number of navel vessels, and carried 3 times the amount of tonnage Where was the threat?
1. Germany was not trying to escalate the war to a world war --Bethmann Hollweg went against the blank check and urged Austria to isolate the war in Belgrade, and to halt in Belgrade in other words, do not go further south than Belgrade --that message was sent in a telegram --Occurred after Grey said the Bethmann that if the war in Europe escalated to a continental war then England would join on the July 29th --Strachan agrees that neither Bethmann nor the Kaiser nor Hollweg --Were going into the war because they needed to protect austria (origins of the war 87-88) 2. Triple Entente - (we dont have pages for this) - 3. Germany was justified in going through Belgium because of self defense (Pg 250) ^Why were they justified in going through a sovereign nation? - Russias mobilization forced Germany to act, despite the previous peace attempts - before a German soldier even passed the German frontier, French aeroplanes flew overhead via through Belgium, a supposedly neutral country, yet Belgium did not warn Germany of the impeding threat
4. Triple Entente -The resolution is, be it resolved that Germanys actions on the international stage were not the primary cause of World War 1 -One of the key differentiators about whether or not Germany caused the war was the prominence of the Entente -The alliance system was a cause for war, but the entente was created before the alliance, and Germany assumed correctly that its rivals were attempting to cut it off. Therefore the alliance can be considered reactionary to the entente -The Triple Entente wasnt even created to avoid war, as England was acting more out of self- interest than any commitment to Belgium, and in fact Britain elected to mobilize against Germany before it decided to honour any commitment to France (Page 100) -British diplomacy was unsustainable if it let the Entente fall apart (Page 100) -Additionally, by joining the Entente Britain was better able to manage its increasingly hostile relationship with Germany -It gave Britain military power on the continent through the militaries of its allies -In joining, it committed Russia to a rivalry with Germany as well as relieve Britain of its main competitor in Central Asia -If Britain did not support France and Russia, it would be forced into an Anglo-German alliance. -Neutrality was no longer an option for France because of its imperial consequences (Page 95), which was, of course, an important factor for the British -For these reasons, England, too, was a primary instigator of what made the conflict into a world affair
Days to Remember: The British Empire in the Great War (Illustrated): The Causes of the War; A Bird's-Eye View of the War; The Turn at the Marne; The Western Front; Behind the Lines; Victory
Days to Remember - The British Empire in the Great War (Illustrated Edition): The Causes of the War; A Bird's-Eye View of the War; The Western Front; Behind the Lines; Victory
THE GREAT WAR COLLECTION – The Battle of Jutland, The Battle of the Somme & Nelson's History of the War (9 Books in One Volume): Selected Works from the Acclaimed War Correspondent about World War I Greatest Battles & Strategies , Including His Personal Perspective and Experience During the War
Letters from Mesopotamia - In 1915 and January, 1916, from Robert Palmer, who was Killed in the Battle of Um El Hannah, June 21, 1916 Aged 27 Years (WWI Centenary Series)
United States v. Gerard Valmore Brown, A/K/A Blackie, A/K/A Gerald Kennedy, United States of America v. Melvin Sanders, A/K/A Pops, United States of America v. Andre Simpson, 76 F.3d 376, 4th Cir. (1996)