0 Bewertungen0% fanden dieses Dokument nützlich (0 Abstimmungen)
19 Ansichten11 Seiten
Cu concentrations in all samples were below the threshold level of metal contamination, contained in Surat Keputusan Direktur Jendral Badan Pemeriksa Obat dan Makanan No 03725 / B / SK / VII / 89. The concentration of Zn is still below the threshold also.
Cu concentrations in all samples were below the threshold level of metal contamination, contained in Surat Keputusan Direktur Jendral Badan Pemeriksa Obat dan Makanan No 03725 / B / SK / VII / 89. The concentration of Zn is still below the threshold also.
Cu concentrations in all samples were below the threshold level of metal contamination, contained in Surat Keputusan Direktur Jendral Badan Pemeriksa Obat dan Makanan No 03725 / B / SK / VII / 89. The concentration of Zn is still below the threshold also.
STREET FOODS WITH ATOMIC ABSORPTION SPECTROPHOTOMETRY (AAS) METHOD
ANALISA LOGAM Zn DAN Cu PADA JAJANAN ANAK SEKOLAH DASAR DI BANDUNG DENGAN METODE SPEKTROFOTOMETRI SERAPAN ATOM (SSA)
Elya Hilda Handayani 1 Katharina Oginawati 2 dan Muhayatun Santoso 3 Environmental Engineering Study Program Faculty of Civil and Environmental Engineering - Institut Teknologi Bandung Jl. Ganesha 10 1 ella_ikan@yahoo.com , 2 katharina.oginawati@ftsl.itb.ac.id, 3 hayat@bdg.centrin.net.id
Abstract : Metal elements are needed by body for metabolic processes. For examples are Cu and Zn. These metals present in food naturally. However, food can be contaminated by metals from the environment. Excess consumption of metal elements can cause disease for consumers. Primary school childrens foods are one of the problems of metal contamination that need attention. There are some sellers who put hazardous materials into the food or the foods sanitation is neglected in food processes. Thus the analysis carried out by first doing sampling at four primary schools in Bandung to check the concentration of Cu and Zn metals in these foods. The number of samples taken is 6 pieces per location. From laboratory analysis using atomic absorption spectrophotometry method the results show that Cu concentrations in all samples were below the threshold level of metal contamination, contained in Surat Keputusan Direktur Jendral Badan Pemeriksa Obat dan Makanan No 03725/B/SK/VII/89. The concentration of Zn is still below the threshold also.
Key words : Cu, Zn, street foods, primary school children, AAS
Abstrak : Unsur logam dibutuhkan oleh tubuh untuk proses metabolisme. Diantaranya adalah logam Cu dan Zn. Logam-logam ini terdapat di dalam makanan secara alami. Namun, makanan dapat pula terkontaminasi oleh logam dari lingkungan. Kelebihan mengkonsumsi unsur logam-logam ini dapat menimbulkan penyakit pada konsumen. Jajanan anak sekolah dasar merupakan salah satu permasalahan mengenai cemaran logam yang perlu diperhatikan. Jajanan yang sebagian besar di buat sendiri oleh pejualnya tidak semuanya memenuhi persyaratan yang ada. Terdapat beberapa pedagang yang memasukan bahan-bahan berbahaya ke dalam makanan ataupun pengolahan makanan yang tidak memenuhi sanitasi makanan. Maka dilakukan analisis dengan terlebih dahulu melakukan pengambilan sampel di empat sekolah dasar yang ada di Bandung untuk memeriksa konsentrasi logam Cu dan Zn di dalam jajanan tersebut. Jumlah sampel yang diambil adalah 6 buah per lokasi. Dari hasil analisa laboratorium dengan menggunakan metode spektrofotometri serapan atom di dapatkan hasil bahwa konsentrasi Cu di semua sampel berada di bawah ambang batas cemaran logam, yang terdapat di dalam Surat Keputusan Direktur Jendral Badan Pemeriksa Obat dan Makanan No 03725/B/SK/VII/89. Begitupula dengan konsentrasi Zn yang masih berada di bawah ambang batas.
Kata Kunci : Cu, Zn, jajanan, anak SD, SSA
EM 1-2
INTRODUCTION
School age children is an investment because they are the future generation. The quality of the nation in the future is determined by the quality of children today. Efforts to improve the quality of human resources must be done early, systematic and sustainable. The development of school-age children depends on optimal nutrition and quality of the nutrition itself. During the growth processes, the provision of nutrition or food intake in children could not always be implemented perfectly (Cahyadi, 2009). Problem that often arises is that feeding does not fulfill the nutritional needs and does not notice the food hygiene. This problem can give bad effect, such as the child's body system disorders and can cause loss of quality of mind in the long run. Often, it escaped the attention of adults, either due to ignorance or indifference. Currently, children consume more food that is not feasible consumption, such as foods that is sold on the roadside. Behavior of school children consume more street foods than meals made at home caused by the activities of school children today are spending more time outside the home, especially in schools, than at home. Foods which is sold by street vendors or called street food according to the FAO the definition is foods and beverages prepared and sold by street vendors in the streets and in crowded places other public or eaten directly consumed without processing or further preparation. Foods consumed by children, especially in Indonesia contain substances that are dangerous to consume because it can cause disease. Hazardous substances are present in food due to contamination. Contaminations in foods are caused by many things, such as improper handling during production, storage, provision, and presentment of foods. The substance of contaminants that can contaminate one food is heavy metal elements (Februhartanty). Heavy metals are toxic to most living creatures, although some are needed in small amounts. Metals can be distributed to the human body and some will be accumulated. If this situation continues, in the long term the amount heavy metals will harm human health (Supriyanto, 2007). Some of heavy metals are used in a variety of daily necessities and it will pollute directly or indirectly, to the environment and if already exceed the set limit it will be dangerous for life. Apart from water and soil contaminated with industrial waste, metal contamination in food may also occur due to contamination during processing or preparation. Like air pollution due to motor vehicle hit the roadside in food or snacks. Cu and Zn are metals needed by the body (Supriyanto, 2007). Therefore, these metals in the body are needed by human in a certain amount. However, if people consume food with excess Cu and Zn concentrations it can cause disease. The high concentration of Cu and Zn in foods can occur due to contamination of the environment. Foods which are sold by vendors are generally not well prepared and clean. Most sellers have low knowledge about the safe handling by foods, they also have less access to clean water and washing facilities and trash. Contamination in the foods that sold by street vendors could be from raw materials, unhealthy foods seller or maker, or equipment which are not clean, as well as time and storage temperature is not right.
METHODOLOGY
The samples are taken from primary schools in Bandung, which have been selected to analysis the concentration of Cu and Zn using atomic absorption spectrophotometry method. Atomic Absorption Spectrophotometry method is a method of analysis for the determination of metallic elements and metalloids based on the absorption of radiation by free atoms of these elements. This AAS method can detect 67 elements, including Cu and Zn in the sample. The advantage of this method is specific, low detection limit, from the same solution can be
Refining Processing questionnaire Decide sampling location measured several different elements, concentration ranges can be determined very broad (sub mg / L to percent), and others. (Susanto) Before analyze using the preparations are refining and drying (freeze dry). using a mixer and adding water. So are dried or the water content removed by freeze dry flour. The purpose of refining and freeze dry homogeneous. So the analysis can First thing to do using AAS dissolving process can be performed multiple times depending on the concentration of elements in it. In this dissolving process, sample with amount of 500 mg, then amount of 6.5 and 1 ml and 2.5 ml digestion to dissolve it all. After the sample concentrations can be measured Basic analysis using AAS technique is that by measuring the amount of absorption by the atom analit, then the analit obtained through comparison with the standard. In this study, the technique is used Flame AAS, with the basic principal is how to make Gas mixtures used in this FAAS are air C. The principal of this metho absorbance from standard solutions to obtain the sample concentration. So the scale of the AAS absorbance will be calibrated by a standard series of known concentration. the analysis by AAS is the calibration curve. From this calibration sample will be known. AAS calibration process is crucial because it can directly a results of the analysis. Factor standard AAS and AAS instruments. More research methodology can be seen in
The sampling conducted in four elementary schools located in different regions. The location of the selected schools spread throughout the city of Bandung ( done to see the difference of metal content in these areas, because of differences i and the neighborhood. Schools
EM 1-3 Laboratory Analysis AAS Method Sample Preparation Refining Freeze Dry Sampling Processing questionnaire Interview with the seller Initial Survey Decide sampling location Distribute questionnaire measured several different elements, concentration ranges can be determined very broad (sub L to percent), and others. (Susanto) using these methods, the samples first must be prepared refining and drying (freeze dry). Refining is done by destroying food samples water. So in the end it will become a thick liquid. Then the samples are dried or the water content removed by freeze drying. Samples will be dry as a powder or efining and freeze drying food samples is to make the samples So the analysis can be done more accurately. First thing to do using AAS method is the dilution of samples or called digest. This dissolving process can be performed multiple times depending on the concentration of elements in it. In this dissolving process, samples, that already dried, inserted into a vessel 500 mg, then it dissolved by adding nitric acid and perchloric acid with amount of 6.5 and 1 ml and 2.5 ml aquadest. Then the sample is inserted into the microwav igestion to dissolve it all. After the sample turn into a homogenous solution concentrations can be measured using AAS method. Basic analysis using AAS technique is that by measuring the amount of absorption by analit concentration can be set. Determination of concentration analit obtained through comparison with the standard. In this study, the technique is used Flame with the basic principal is how to make formation of atoms using a gas mixture flame. s used in this FAAS are air-acetylene flame with a temperature of 1900 of this method is to compare between samples a standard solutions to obtain the sample concentration. So the scale of the calibrated by a standard series of known concentration. the analysis by AAS is the calibration curve. From this calibration the absorbance from AAS calibration process is crucial because it can directly a Factor that may affect the calibration process is the solution of the standard AAS and AAS instruments. More research methodology can be seen in Figure 1.Research Methodology
sampling conducted in four elementary schools located in different regions. The selected schools spread throughout the city of Bandung (Figure. 2 metal content in these areas, because of differences i and the neighborhood. Schools for sampling locations are as follows measured several different elements, concentration ranges can be determined very broad (sub se methods, the samples first must be prepared. The Refining is done by destroying food samples . Then the samples Samples will be dry as a powder or s is to make the samples or called digest. This dissolving process can be performed multiple times depending on the concentration of ready dried, inserted into a vessel ric acid and perchloric acid with is inserted into the microwave solution, thee metal Basic analysis using AAS technique is that by measuring the amount of absorption by concentration can be set. Determination of concentration analit obtained through comparison with the standard. In this study, the technique is used Flame formation of atoms using a gas mixture flame. acetylene flame with a temperature of 1900 - 2200 d is to compare between samples absorbance with standard solutions to obtain the sample concentration. So the scale of the calibrated by a standard series of known concentration. The result of the absorbance from AAS calibration process is crucial because it can directly affect the that may affect the calibration process is the solution of the standard AAS and AAS instruments. More research methodology can be seen in Figure 1. sampling conducted in four elementary schools located in different regions. The Figure. 2). This is metal content in these areas, because of differences in activity EM 1-4
1. Sekolah Dasar Percobaan Negeri Setiabudi 2. Sekolah Dasar Negeri Soka 1 3. Sekolah Dasar Negeri Sindanglaya 2 4. Sekolah Dasar Negeri Pelesiran
Figure 2. Sampling location From these schools the samples which are taken are foods which are consumed by school students often. It is known from previously distributed questionnaires to determine the most widely snacks chosen by the students. From each school selected five to six kinds of snacks consumed the most. The selected foods are sold outside the school and are sold inside the school. But most of the samples which been taken are sold outside the school, because this is what snacks consumed more frequently by the school students. Examples of snacks are taken as shown in Figure 3.
Figure 3.Types of foods as sample
The method used to analyzing the laboratory data using statistical analysis was also performed. The method used is 2n factorial method to test the variance of the data. With this method will be seen the influence of the factors that have determined the concentration of metals in foods. There are three factors chosen, the use of sauces, cooking utensils, and food materials in form roots. These three factors will be divided into two levels, which are low and high level. SDPN Setiabudi SDN Soka 1 1 SDN Pelesiran SDN Sindanglaya 2 EM 1-5
For the use of sauces factor, low-level is not using sauces and high levels are using sauces. For the cook utensils, while low levels are not attached directly to the cookware and for high levels are foods attached directly to the cookware. And for food materials from roots are high level and other that are not are low level. The end result of this analysis will be seen whether low-level and high level influence each other or not. Moreover, it can be seen the interaction between the factors that influence each other or not. If the result was accepted then the hypothesis suggests that there is no influence between the two levels, or between factors. While if the result was rejected then the hypothesis indicates that there is a difference between the level of data or factors. Replikat used in this analysis are two. It is because the measurement of the samples done twice (simplo and duplo).
RESULTS AND DISCUSSION
The number of samples taken from the four school consists of 24 pieces, 6 kinds of foods from each school. From all of the snacks that have been taken to sampled and examined by Atomic Absorption Spectrophotometry method, gaining Cu and Zn concentrations in the food in dry weight. To get the actual concentrations in food should be sought in the heavy metal concentration in wet weight of food. Cu concentration in the food samples are shown in Table 1 below
Table 1. The concentration of Cu in foods School Food The concentration of Cu (mg/kg) Standard value (mg/kg) SDPN Setiabudi Bakwan 0,29 10 Martabak 0,30 10 Kentang 4,11 10 Creepes 0,39 10 Mie 0,46 10 Cakwe 0,31 10 Average 0,98 SDN Sindanglaya 2 Telur 0,46 30 Cireng 1,53 10 Cilok 0,26 10 Cakwe 0,16 10 Baso tahu 0,56 10 Average 0,59 SDN Pelesiran Batagor 1,43 10 Agar 0,00 2 Pisang 0,89 5 Cakwe 0,99 10 Sosis 0,53 20 Telur 0,79 30 Average 0,77 SDN Soka Bacil 0,35 10 EM 1-6
School Food The concentration of Cu (mg/kg) Standard value lumpia Basah 0,48 5 mie 0,26 10 cimol 0,09 10 kue 0,87 10 chiki 0,57 30 biting 1,93 30 Average 0,65
As can be seen in the table above, the concentration of Cu find in snacks having a low concentration. Only kentang and cireng have high Cu concentrations although still below the quality standards set by the government. Cus quality standards are different for each kind of food. In Surat Keputusan Direktur Jenderal Badan Pemeriksa Obat dan Makanan No 03725/B/SK/VII/89 tentang Batasan Maksimum Cemaran Logam dalam Makanan, foods are divided into fruit, meat, vegetables, flour, and others. For these foods measurement, quality standard of reference that been used is based on the main components of its food. For example in batagor the main component is flour, so the standard value that is used is for flour, which is 30 mg/kg. Therefore, the maximum limit values are different for each food. From the average concentration of Cu in each school, it is obtained the results that the average Cu concentration is greatest in SDPN Setiabudi, in the amount of 0.98 mg / kg. This is because the value of Cu concentration in kentang is big. The amount of this Cu concentration can be caused due to the use of cooking utensils made of Cu that easy to peel. Quality of cookware that is used by food vendors on the street is generally not good. The food vendors select cooking equipments that are cheap but easy to peel. As a result, the contamination of food in food processes happen because of cookware. Based on observations at the time of sampling, the condition of the cooking utensils already not good or has flaking. . The amount of Cu concentration in kentang can also be caused because the potato is a kind of roots plants. While Cu on the plants will concentrate in the roots. Therefore, the concentration of Cu on kentang tends to be large compared to the others. In addition to factors mentioned previously, Cu can also enter the food through the water used for cooking. Cu could contain in the water if the pipe had rotted. Besides SDPN Setiabudi, SDN plesiran have big average of Cu concentration quite the same from each other. This can be caused by school building construction. So there are lots of dust and particulates floating around the location. Dust and particulates can contaminate food with heavy metals. Therefore, the concentration of Cu in SD Plesirans foods tend to be large and evenly on each type of snacks. Exposure to Cu in a long time can cause symptoms such as irritation of the nose, throat, mouth and eyes, headaches, stomach pain, loss of balance, nausea, vomiting and diarrhea. Exposure to large doses of Cu can cause damage to liver, kidney, and even cause death. There are currently no scientific evidence that Cu is carcinogenic. The results showed that long exposure and high doses of Cu can reduce the level of intelligence of children in times of growth, coughing, and bleeding nose. Cu can also cause skin allergies. Cu repeated exposure can cause thickening of the skin and cause a greenish color of the skin and hair causing irritation of the nose. In addition to measuring the concentration of Cu, Zn metal is also measured in the food court and obtained the following data (Table 2)
EM 1-7
Table 2 The concentration of Zn in foods
School Food The concentration of Cu (mg/kg) Standard value (mg/kg) SDPN Setiabudi Bakwan 0,29 10 Martabak 0,30 10 Kentang 4,11 10 Creepes 0,39 10 Mie 0,46 10 Cakwe 0,31 10 Average 0,98 SDN Sindanglaya 2 Telur 0,46 30 Cireng 1,53 10 Cilok 0,26 10 Cakwe 0,16 10 Baso tahu 0,56 10 Average 0,59 SDN Pelesiran Batagor 1,43 10 Agar 0,00 2 Pisang 0,89 5 Cakwe 0,99 10 Sosis 0,53 20 Telur 0,79 30 Average 0,77 SDN Soka Bacil 0,35 10 lumpia Basah 0,48 5 mie 0,26 10 cimol 0,09 10 kue 0,87 10 chiki 0,57 30 biting 1,93 30 Average 0,65
Based on Surat Keputusan Direktur Jenderal Badan Pemeriksa Obat dan Makanan No 03725/B/SK/VII/89 tentang Batasan Maksimum Cemaran Logam dalam Makanan, the maximum limit of Zn contamination in food is of 40 mg / kg. Zn found in every humans consumptions of food, because Zn is one of the metals the body needs for metabolic processes. However, like other metals, Zn dose needed are little. If human excess the consumption it will caused Zn poisoning. From the data measurement, biting has the greatest concentration, in the amount of 22.43 mg / kg. Although not exceed the maximum limit of metal contamination in food by the government, but the concentration of Zn in biting is quite high compared to other foods. When viewed the average Zn concentrations found in food at each school, the average values are highest in the SD plesiran. Besides Zn concentration, the average of Cu concentrations in EM 1-8
SD Pelesiran tend to be large too. This can be caused due to the use of food containing Zn and in conditions that are not good. Thus contaminate the cooked food using the cooking utensil. As mentioned literature, contaminations from cooking utensils are more likely to occur than directly consuming Zn contained in the food. Also because of the construction of schools that produce dust and particulates that pollute snacks. SDPN Setiabudi also has a big average concentration of Zn. Besides kentang, mie also causes the average concentration becomes large. The amount of Zn and Cu concentrations in kentang showed that food from roots contain more metals. Plants absorb the metals from the soil and accumulate in roots. Therefore, the concentration of metals in potatoes tends to be large. Zn is not toxic, but in a state as ions, free Zn has a high toxicity. Consumption of excess Zn can lead to deficiency of another components. Zn toxicity can be acute and chronic. Symptoms of acute toxicity can be a stomach pain, diarrhea, nausea and vomiting. In the drinking water will lead to a sense of rough and can cause symptoms of vomiting. Other health disorders are caused stomach ulcers, stomatitis and letargia. Zn toxicity is rare because consumption Zn, because the digestive disturbances and diarrhea equipment caused by drink or food contaminated Zn coated equipment. To see which factors affecting metal contamination in the foods, conducted 2n factorial statistical analysis. Factors that are considered can affect the metal contamination of foods is the addition of sauce, use of cooking utensils, and food material from roots. As mentioned earlier, these factors can cause Cu and Zn metals into the food. From the results of statistical analysis in 2n factorial get the following conclusion (Table 3 and Table 4)
Table 3. The results of 2n factorial method for Cu Source of Variance F-theory f table (p=5%) Hypothesis Replikat 0,0295 5,59 diterima Main Effect The use of sauce (A) 1903,95 5,59 ditolak Cooking utensils (B) 1514,03 5,59 ditolak Roots plant (C ) 2004,54 5,59 ditolak Interaction 2 Factor AB 5,818 5,59 ditolak AC 60,42 5,59 ditolak BC 840,68 5,59 ditolak Interaction 3 factor ABC 2400,59 5,59 ditolak Error 1 5,59 diterima Total
a. The measurement of Cu done twice (simplo and the duplicate), the data that was obtained did not have the significant difference. This showed the used AAS are accurate. b. The use of sauce in foods influenced the Cu concentration inside foods. The foods that was added sauce had the concentration of metal higher compare with foods that was not added sauce. c. The use of the cooking utensil influenced the Cu concentration in foods. Foods that was directly touching with the cooking utensil had the higher concentration of Cu. EM 1-9
d. The food materials using roots of plants, have higher Cu concentration compare with the other that are not. e. The interaction between the use of sauce and foods that was directly touching with the cooking utensil had the influence on the Cu concentration in foods. f. The interaction between the use of sauce and the use of the food materials using roots of plants gave the influence on the Cu concentration in foods. g. The interaction between foods that was directly touching with the cooking utensil and the use of the food materials using roots of plants gave the influence on the concentration h. The three interactions between the use of sauce, foods that was directly touching with the cooking utensil, and the use of the food materials using roots of plants had the influence on the Cu concentration in foods. This proved that the three factors could affect the concentration of Cu in foods.
Table 4. The results of 2n factorial method for Zn
Source of Variance F-theory f table (p=5%) Hypothesis Replikat 4,348 5,59 diterima Main Effect The use of sauce (A) 166,20 5,59 ditolak Cooking utensils (B) 3,02 5,59 diterima Roots plant (C ) 2302,19 5,59 ditolak Interaction 2 Factor AB 73,12 5,59 ditolak AC 266,99 5,59 ditolak BC 461,65 5,59 ditolak Interaction 3 factor ABC 26,047 5,59 ditolak Error 1 5,59 diterima Total
a. The measurement of Zn done twice (simplo and the duplicate), the data that was obtained did not have the significant difference. This showed the used AAS are accurate. b. The use of sauce in foods influenced the Zn concentration inside foods. The foods that was added sauce had the concentration of metal higher compare with foods that was not added sauce. c. The use of the cooking utensil did not influence the Zn concentration in foods. Foods that were directly touching with the cooking utensil and that was not touching directly had the same concentration. This showed that Zn could contaminate food although not directly touching with the cooking utensil, like through oil or water. d. The food materials using roots of plants, have higher Zn concentration compare with the other that are not. e. The interaction between the use of sauce and foods that was directly touching with the cooking utensil had the influence on the Zn concentration in foods. EM 1-10
f. The interaction between the use of sauce and the use of the food materials using roots of plants gave the influence on the Zn concentration in foods. g. The interaction between foods that was directly touching with the cooking utensil and the use of the food materials using roots of plants gave the influence on the concentration h. The three interactions between the use of sauce, foods that was directly touching with the cooking utensil, and the use of the food materials using roots of plants had the influence on the Zn concentration in foods. This proved that the three factors could affect the concentration of Zn in foods.
From the analysis used 2n factorial method was obtained results that Cu contamination and Zn in foods was affected by the use of sauce, the cooking utensil, and the food materials using roots of plants. Although from results there are no foods having metal that through quality standard, but the contamination of metal that was caused by many factors, including the use of sauce, the cooking utensil, and his foodstuff kind, still happen. Therefore, the consumers must pay attention in consuming food, in order to prevent the poisoning of metals that could cause a loss to the consumer, especially children.
CONCLUSION
The results of the analysis are that all foods have small concentration of Cu, under the quality standard from government. Although kentang and cireng had the concentration that was quite big compared with other foods, its still under standard value. Whereas for Zn, the concentration in some foods are bigger, like in cakwe, kentang, batagor, kue, and telur, that was above 10 mg/kg. However, foods still safe because the concentration under the threshold that was determined by the government. The use of sauce, the cooking utensil and the food materials using roots of plants influenced the Cu and Zn concentration in foods.
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT
This final project is partially funded by BATAN in Bandung
REFFERENCES
Anonim. 1989. Surat Keputusan Direktur Jenderal Badan Pemeriksa Obat dan Makanan No 03725/B/SK/VII/89 tentang Batasan Maksimum Cemaran Logam dalam Makanan. Anonim. Essentiality, Deficiencies, and Toxicities of the Elements. Pages 129 143 Cahyadi. 2009. Gizi Buruk dan Kemiskinan. Harian Pikiran Rakyat. 5 Mei 2009 Emami. 2004. Heavy Metals Content of Canned Tuna Fish. Food Chemistry 93 Pages 293- 296 Februhartanty. 2004. Amankah makanan jajanan anak sekolah di Indonesia?. http://www.gizi.net/cgi-bin/berita/fullnews.cgi?newsid1097726693,98302, diakses tanggal 3 Januari 2010. Harjoto, Ratnawati, Muhayatun. Analysis of Cesium and Zinc in Food Samples. BATAN Iwasaki, et al,. 2009. Effects of heavy metals on riverine benthic macroinvertebrate assemblages with reference to potential food availability for drift-feeding fishes. Setac Press EM 1-11
Kuzmina, Ushakova. 2008. Process of exotrophy in fish. Effect of heavy metals Zn and Cu. Pleiades Publishing. Pandey, Pandey. 2009. Accumulation of heavy metals in dietary vegetables and cultivated soil horizon in organic farming system in relation to atmospheric deposition in a seasonally dry tropical region of India. Springer Science Sudjana. 2005. Metoda Statistika. Bandung : Penerbit Tarsito. Supriyanto, Samin, Zainul, 2007. Analisis Cemaran Logam Berat Pb, Cu, dan Cd pada Ikan Tawar dengan Metode Spektrofotometrinyala Serapan Atom (SSA). Surtipanti, et al. 1994. Toxic Heavy Metals and Other Trace Elements in Foodstuff from 12 Different Countries. IAES Cordinated Research Program. Humana Press Inc Wei-Yang, Yu-Lan, Sheng Su. 2008. Copper and Zinc in a paddy field and their potential ecological impacts affected by wastewater from a lead/zinc mine, P. R. China. Springer Science Widowati, et al. 2008. Efek Toksik Logam. Penerbit Andi. Yogyakarta