2000 S C M R 1321 -Dismissal From Service---Regular Inquiry Not Held---Service Tribunal Had Rightly Concluded That Dismissal of Civil Servant From Service and Subsequent Reduction in Punishment Were Violative of Dictum
0 Bewertungen0% fanden dieses Dokument nützlich (0 Abstimmungen)
184 Ansichten1 Seite
Petitioners versus Muhammad SIDDIQUE KHAN---Respondent civil Petition for leave to Appeal No. 874-L of 1998, decided on 30th November, 1999. (On appeal from the judgment / order dated 31-3-1998 passed by the Punjab service Tribunal, Lahore in Appeal No. 1680 / 94)
Petitioners versus Muhammad SIDDIQUE KHAN---Respondent civil Petition for leave to Appeal No. 874-L of 1998, decided on 30th November, 1999. (On appeal from the judgment / order dated 31-3-1998 passed by the Punjab service Tribunal, Lahore in Appeal No. 1680 / 94)
0 Bewertungen0% fanden dieses Dokument nützlich (0 Abstimmungen)
184 Ansichten1 Seite
2000 S C M R 1321 -Dismissal From Service---Regular Inquiry Not Held---Service Tribunal Had Rightly Concluded That Dismissal of Civil Servant From Service and Subsequent Reduction in Punishment Were Violative of Dictum
Petitioners versus Muhammad SIDDIQUE KHAN---Respondent civil Petition for leave to Appeal No. 874-L of 1998, decided on 30th November, 1999. (On appeal from the judgment / order dated 31-3-1998 passed by the Punjab service Tribunal, Lahore in Appeal No. 1680 / 94)
Present: Sh. Riaz Ahmed and Ch. Muhammad Arif, JJ PROVINCE OF PUNJAB through Additional Chief Secretary, Government of Punjab and another---Petitioners versus MUHAMMAD SIDDIQUE KHAN---Respondent Civil Petition for Leave to Appeal No. 874-L of 1998, decided on 30th November, 1999. (On appeal from the judgment/order dated 31-3-1998 passed by the Punjab Service Tribunal, Lahore in Appeal No. 1680/94). Constitution of Pakistan (1973)--- ----Art. 212(3)---Dismissal from service---Regular inquiry not held---Service Tribunal had rightly concluded that dismissal of civil servant from service and subsequent reduction in punishment were violative of dictum laid down by Supreme Court in the case of Lal Muhammad and another 1980 SCMR 850 and thus both the orders were set aside---Petition for leave to appeal filed by the Department against the judgment of Service Tribunal being without merit, was dismissed in circumstances. Lal Muhammad and another v. Government of Sindh 1980 SCMR 850 ref. Muhammad Sharif Butt, Advocate Supreme Court with Rao M. Yousaf Khan, Advocate-on- Record for Petitioners. Nemo for Respondent. Date of hearing: 30th November, 1999. ORDER SH. RIAZ AHMED, J.---The Province of the Punjab through the Additional Chief Secretary, Government of the Punjab and another seek (leave to appeal against the judgment and order dated 31-3-1998 delivered by the Punjab Service Tribunal whereby it was held that major penalty could not have been awarded to the respondent without holding a regular inquiry and thus the order impugned date4 1-8-1994 dismissing the respondent from service and the order dated 4-9-1994 whereby the punishment of dismissal was reduced and the petitioner was demoted and reinstated were set aside. In fact it was conceded by the contesting department before the Tribunal that without holding regular inquiry the major penalties were imposed upon the respondent. In view of the dictum laid down by this Court in the case reported as Lal Muhammad and another v. Government of Sindh (1980 SCMR 850) the Tribunal rightly concluded that the dismissal of the respondent from service and the subsequent reduction in the punishment were violative of the said dictum and thus both the orders were set aside. 2. After hearing the learned counsel at length, we do not find any merit in this petition. The Tribunal had rightly acted in setting aside both the orders by placing reliance upon the law laid down by this Court. The petition is dismissed. Q.M.H./M.A.K./P-6/S Petition dismissed.
1996 P L C CS 433 - Statutory Rules National Bank of Pakistan (Staff) Services Rules Were First Promulgated in Year 1973 and Subsequently in Year 1980 Rules of 1980
1994 P L C CS 1717 Show Cause Notice Was Issued To Such Employee by The Registrar, Supreme Court Who Was Incompetent Authority in Respect of Officer of BPS 18
1998 P L C CS 221 - Constitutional Petition - Employee of Statutory Body - Termination of Service Without Show-Cause Notice and Without Affording Opportunity of Being Heard
1996 S C M R 1185 - Rule of Good Governance Demand That The Benefit of Such Judgment by Service Tribunal-Supreme Court Be Extended To Other Civil Servants Who May Not Be Parties To The Litigation
1996 S C M 8413 - IRREGULAR Appointment Service Tribunal Having Re Instated Civil Servant Could Not Be Deemed To Have Committed Any Illegality or Irregularity