Sie sind auf Seite 1von 3

Plaintiffs' Lawyers Take Aim at GM for Recall

Attorneys Known for Large Civil Settlements Line Up to Sue Over Company's
Handling of Defective Ignition Switches

By Ashby Jones
June 8, 2014

Of all the problems haunting General Motors Co. GM +1.61% over its handling of
defective ignition switches, the one with plaintiffs' lawyers is just beginning.

The company's size and self-confessed failures in an internal report released last week
are attracting lawyers who forged some of the biggest civil settlements ever, from the
landmark tobacco litigation to the Exxon Valdez disaster to Toyota Motor Corp.'s
7203.TO +0.15% unintended-acceleration problems.

More than 80 ignition-switch-related civil lawsuits have been filed against GM, most
seeking alleged economic damages, such as repair costs and declines in resale value on
about 2.6 million cars recalled since February. The average depreciation claim alone
might total $500 to $1,000 per car, according to lawyers who have filed suits against

The company also will have to fight suits claiming the defective ignition switches caused
serious injuries and deaths. While just a handful of cases are under way, plaintiffs'
lawyer Bob Hilliard of Corpus Christi, Texas, said he has signed up several hundred such
clients. GM has attributed at least 54 crashes and 13 deaths to switch-related air bag
failures, and said last week that it can't rule out the possibility that the death toll could

Chief Executive Mary Barra said Thursday that she wouldn't "speculate on anything
involving litigation." She said the company would "do the right thing by victims."
Company spokesman Greg Martin said the CEO's "remarks last week regarding the
Valukas report stand on their own," declining further comment. GM also is being
scrutinized by regulators, prosecutors and lawmakers.

It is common for bad headlines and deep pockets to lure plaintiffs' lawyersand a pile of
lawsuits. In 2012, BP BP +0.73% PLC agreed to pay at least $7.8 billion to end litigation
over the Deepwater Horizon oil spill. Toyota settled for about $1.1 billion with owners of
about 16 million cars affected by unintended-acceleration problems. Plaintiffs' lawyers
collected about $227 million in fees and costs.

Some legal experts said GM could face an unusually long, steep and costly fight in the
wake of the 315-page, company-funded report by former U.S. Attorney Anton Valukas.
"This is a big case, and it could be enormously expensive for GM," said Elizabeth Burch,
a University of Georgia law professor.

Ms. Barra said the report demonstrated a "pattern of incompetence and neglect" in the
auto maker's 11-year failure to recall cars equipped with a defective ignition switch. Mr.
Valukas said the company's "search for root cause became a basis for doing nothing to
resolve the problem for years."

One section of the report detailed an outside law firm's concerns about the company's
legal exposure. In 2010, King & Spalding LLP advised GM to settle a wrongful-death suit
filed in Tennessee, concluding that a "seven-figure verdict remains probable" even
though "Nashville area jurisdictions are not 'judicial hellholes.' "

The law firm also warned that "facts and circumstances surrounding the
investigationcould provide fertile ground for laying the foundation for an award for
punitive damages, resulting in a significantly larger verdict."

"There's a lot of shocking material in this report that we're no question going to use,"
said Steve Berman, a Seattle lawyer who represented 13 states in the tobacco litigation
that led to a $206 billion settlement in 1998. He also was co-lead counsel in the Toyota
economic-loss cases.

In a sign of the intense interest in GM by plaintiffs' lawyers, more than a dozen lawyers
with clients in ignition-switch cases made pitches last month to seven federal judges in
Chicago. The judges will decide where to combine suits that seek damages for alleged
economic losses. A decision is expected soon.

Talking fast while a countdown light changed from green to yellow to red, one lawyer at
the meeting said Florida is quick, while another said New York has an edge because it
hosted the auto maker's bankruptcy case. Someone else noted that Oklahoma would be
a short flight for everyone.

Mark Robinson, the Newport Beach, Calif., lawyer who won a $127 million jury verdict
in 1978 against Ford Motor Co. F +2.40% over a fuel-tank design flaw on the Pinto,
urged judges to assign the consolidated cases to U.S. District Judge James Selna in
Santa Ana, Calif. Judge Selna handled the Toyota litigation.

Mr. Robinson is hoping to be a major force in the GM ignition-switch suits. Also
maneuvering for influence is Elizabeth Cabraser of San Francisco, a leader in litigation
over the Exxon Valdez oil spill in 1989, breast implants and the drugs Vioxx and Fen-
Phen. The two lawyers are co-lead counsel for plaintiffs in personal-injury cases against

Messrs. Berman and Robinson hope to be part of a small group of lawyers steering the
litigation against GM. GM's defense team includes lawyers at King & Spalding and
Kirkland & Ellis LLP.

The defense strategy by GM includes a compensation program that will be launched in
August and led by Kenneth Feinberg, the lawyer who managed the U.S. government's
September 11 Victim Compensation Fund.

GM hasn't said how much money it will put into the fund. Victims and their families
who file claims could get a check from the company, but they likely would have to agree
not to seek damages from GM in court.

Some plaintiffs' lawyers said they are willing to consider the compensation fund once
GM discloses more details. "We'll pursue the avenue by which our clients are going to be
best served," said Adam Levitt, a lawyer in Chicago.

GM lawyers are trying to use the auto maker's bankruptcy in 2009 to insulate the
company from depreciation-related claims before then. Plaintiffs' lawyers claim that
would violate constitutional due-process rights, since GM allegedly knew about the
ignition-switch problems but kept them secret for years.

U.S. Bankruptcy Judge Robert Gerber in New York is expected to rule by the end of

The auto maker's possible exposure to death and injury claims could get clearer when a
Georgia state-court judge rules on a request to nullify a settlement reached by GM last

Marietta, Ga., lawyer Lance Cooper said the case should be reopened because it is clear
GM knew about the defective ignition switches long before 26-year-old Brooke Melton
died while driving her Chevrolet Cobalt in 2012. Mr. Cooper sued GM on behalf of her

Terms of the settlement weren't disclosed, and a hearing date hasn't been announced.