Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
i
[(R
i
-R
f
)*
i
]
/
2
ei
[[(R
i
-R
f
)*
i
]
/
2
ei
]
i
2
/
2
ei
(
i
2
/
2
ei
) C
i
Meghna Pet Industries 0.1214 0.2338 0.2338 1.9259 1.9259 0.0022
Fine Foods Limited 0.1205 0.6594 0.8932 5.4733 7.3993 0.0081
Bata Shoe 0.1048 0.8938 1.7870 8.5323 15.9316 0.0150
Beach Hatchery Ltd. 0.1025 0.5653 2.3523 5.5169 21.4485 0.0189
Bd.Thai Aluminium 0.0855 0.2508 2.6031 2.9326 24.3811 0.0204
Al-Haj Textile 0.0815 0.1896 2.7927 2.3263 26.7074 0.0215
Pharma Aids 0.0790 0.3603 3.1530 4.5599 31.2673 0.0235
Kohinoor Chemicals 0.0782 0.0631 3.2161 0.8067 32.0740 0.0238
Aftab Automobiles 0.0776 0.3160 3.5322 4.0738 36.1477 0.0254
BATBC 0.0751 1.0056 4.5377 13.3970 49.5448 0.0297
Lankabangla Finance
Ltd. 0.0689 0.4906 5.0283 7.1193 56.6641 0.0315
Janata Insurance 0.0686 0.5834 5.6117 8.5073 65.1714 0.0334
Bd. Welding Electrodes 0.0684 0.6549 6.2666 9.5821 74.7535 0.0352
Purabi Gen. Insurance 0.0668 0.5532 6.8198 8.2825 83.0360 0.0367
IDLC 0.0587 0.2926 7.1125 4.9879 88.0239 0.0372
Hakkani Pulp & Paper 0.0577 0.4325 7.5449 7.4942 95.5181 0.0380
United Insurance 0.0576 0.2227 7.7677 3.8686 99.3866 0.0384
CMC Kamal 0.0572 0.6889 8.4566 12.0493 111.4360 0.0394
BEXIMCO 0.0557 0.5676 9.0241 10.1821 121.6181 0.0402
Olympic Industries 0.0542 0.8677 9.8918 16.0001 137.6182 0.0411
Savar Refractories 0.0534 0.2565 10.1483 4.8050 142.4232 0.0413
Karnaphuli Insurance 0.0530 0.3965 10.5447 7.4860 149.9092 0.0417
Prime Finance & Invest. 0.0527 0.2944 10.8391 5.5805 155.4897 0.0419
Rahim Textile 0.0523 0.3848 11.2239 7.3533 162.8430 0.0422
Legacy Footwear 0.0520 0.8010 12.0249 15.4111 178.2541 0.0427
Stylecraft 0.0508 0.2141 12.2390 4.2169 182.4710 0.0429
Ambee Pharma 0.0489 0.6488 12.8878 13.2681 195.7391 0.0431
Kay & Que 0.0481 0.2002 13.0881 4.1604 199.8996 0.0432
Padma Oil Co. 0.0447 0.7619 13.8500 17.0465 216.9461 0.0433
Dutch-Bangla Bank 0.0445 0.2395 14.0894 5.3769 222.3230 0.0433
Beximco Synthetics 0.0442 0.1979 14.2873 4.4787 226.8017 0.0433
Green Delta Insurance 0.0442 0.2222 14.5095 5.0298 231.8315 0.0433
National Tea Co. Ltd. 0.0437 0.2874 14.7970 6.5808 238.4123 0.0433*
From the table 2 it can be seen that among 235 companies the optimum portfolio
consists of investing in 33 companies for which (R
i
- R
f
) /
i
is greater than a particular
cut off point C*. Here, the cut-off rate is 0.0433.
Sarker
84
Table 3: Result of Weights amount invested in Portfolio from Selected
Companies (July 2007 to June 2012)
No. Name of Company
Weight of
Securities (%)
Mean
Return Beta
1 Bata Shoe 15.91% 6.00% 0.4828
2 BATBC 12.67% 4.63% 0.4916
3 Fine Foods Limited 10.38% 8.12% 0.5959
4 Meghna Pet Industries 7.55% 4.48% 0.2918
5 Beach Hatchery Ltd. 5.15% 10.46% 0.9293
6 Lankabangla Finance Ltd. 5.10% 4.54% 0.5228
7 Aftab Automobiles 3.60% 5.34% 0.5675
8 Bd.Thai Aluminium 3.30% 5.64% 0.5501
9 Olympic Industries 3.13% 5.36% 0.8162
10 Bd. Welding Electrodes 2.90% 9.23% 1.2134
11 Janata Insurance 2.71% 8.91% 1.1629
12 Hakkani Pulp & Paper 2.46% 4.65% 0.6428
13 Purabi Gen. Insurance 2.41% 8.82% 1.1802
14 Legacy Footwear 2.33% 5.28% 0.8362
15 BEXIMCO 2.20% 5.64% 0.8432
16 CMC Kamal 1.99% 7.95% 1.2257
17 Kohinoor Chemicals 1.83% 2.70% 0.2250
18 IDLC 1.78% 4.63% 0.6300
19 Pharma Aids 1.77% 11.60% 1.3496
20 Karnaphuli Insurance 1.46% 4.76% 0.7215
21 Al-Haj Textile 1.29% 9.18% 1.0114
22 United Insurance 1.27% 4.60% 0.6369
23 Rahim Textile 1.25% 4.99% 0.7737
24 Prime Finance & Invest. 1.19% 4.36% 0.6480
25 Savar Refractories 1.09% 4.39% 0.6473
26 Ambee Pharma 1.07% 5.87% 1.0079
27 Stylecraft 1.02% 3.22% 0.4505
28 Kay & Que 0.54% 3.54% 0.5416
29 Padma Oil Co. 0.28% 6.35% 1.2112
30 Green Delta Insurance 0.12% 3.31% 0.5376
31 Beximco Synthetics 0.10% 3.36% 0.5471
32 Dutch-Bangla Bank 0.08% 6.16% 1.1724
33 National Tea Company Limited 0.07% 3.12% 0.4991
Beta on a Portfolio,
p
0.6545
Alpha on a Portfolio,
p
0.0531
Portfolio Return 6.17%
Portfolio Risk 8.76%
Table 2 and 3 clearly explain the results of empirical analysis. Only those securities
are desirable in the portfolio, which have positive excess return over risk free return.
If short sale is not allowed, it is seen that the optimum portfolio consists of only 33
securities with the largest investment in Bata Shoe Company (Bangladesh) Ltd. And
the smallest in National Tea Company Limited. Portfolio return and portfolio risk have
found out respectively 6.17% and 8.76%. The result shows that portfolio beta is
significantly lower than the market beta and portfolio return is much higher than the
Sarker
85
portfolio variance. The results are almost similar to the earlier results (e.g. Paudel
and Koirala, 2006; Singh, 2007; Kumar, 2011; and Elton et al., 1976). All the
securities which have excess return to beta ratio more than the cut-off point are
included in the portfolio. Such portfolio is the optimum portfolio and the securities
included in the portfolio are the efficient securities.
The study that follows 164 stocks needs 494 numbers of inputs as against 13694 for
Markowitz Model. So, it can be stated that implementation of Markowitz model is
much more time-consuming and more complex by the number of estimates required.
And the framework of Sharpe's single index model for optimal portfolio construction
is very simple and useful. The results are almost similar to the earlier results (e.g.
Meenakshi and Sarita, 2012).
5. Conclusion
Risk and return play an important role in making any investment decisions. This
study aims at analyzing the opportunity that are available for investors as per as
returns are concerned and the investment of risk thereof while investing in equity of
firms listed in the Dhaka stock exchange. Sharpe's single-index model was applied
by using the monthly closing prices of 164 companies listed in DSE and DSE all
share price index for the period from July 2007 to June 2012. From the empirical
analysis, it can be said that data coverage of this paper is moreover satisfactory to
make an investment decision because it covers 69.79% of data. Out of 164
companies taken for the study, 7 companies are showing negative returns and the
other 157 companies are showing positive returns. Out of 164 companies, 61
companies where market beta is above 1, show that the investments in these stocks
are outperforming than the market. The study shows that portfolio beta is
significantly lower than the market beta and portfolio return is much higher than the
portfolio variance. And the framework of Sharpe's single index model for optimal
portfolio construction is very simple and useful. The results are almost similar to the
earlier results (e.g. Paudel and Koirala, 2006; Singh, 2007; Kumar, 2011; Elton et al.,
1976; and Meenakshi and Sarita, 2012). From this empirical analysis, to some extent
one can able to forecast individual securitys return through the market movement
and can make use of it.
5.1 Limitations of the Research
This paper attempts to construct an optimal portfolio by using Sharpe's single-index
model and thereby helps to make investment decisions. The current study however
has some limitations. This study did not take into consideration the companies that
are not listed on the DSE and the companies that are listed and traded but stopped
operations. This study used monthly data rather than daily data. This study has
successfully constructed an optimal portfolio consisting of 33 securities among
various sectors; future research may concentrate on portfolio selection models and
the development of new portfolio selection models and policies.
Sarker
86
References
Bowen, PA 1984, A hypothesis: Portfolio theory is elegant but useless, The
Investment Analysts Journal, 24(2), pp. 17-21.
Briec, W & Kerstens, K 2009, Multi-horizon Markowitz portfolio performance
appraisals: A general approach Omega, 37, pp. 50 62.
Chitnis, A 2010, Performance Evaluation of Two Optimal Portfolios by Sharpes
Ratio, Global Journal of Finance and Management, Vol. 2, No. 1, pp. 35 - 46
Dutt, D 1998, Valuation of common stock an overview, The Management
Accountant, November
Dhaka Stock Exchange, http://www.dsebd.org, Dhaka Stock Exchange Library.
Elton, EJ, Gruber, MJ & Padberg, MW 1976, Simple Criteria for Optimal Portfolio
Selection, The Journal of Finance, Vol. 31, Issue 5, pp. 1341-1357.
Frankfuter, GM, Herbert, F & Seagle, JP 1976, Performance of the Sharpe portfolio
Selection model: a comparison, Journal of Financial & Quantitative Analysis,
11(2), pp. 195-204.
Haugen, R 2001, Modern Investment Theory, 5
th
Edition, Upper Saddle River, New
Jersey: Prentice- Hall, Inc.
Jobson, JD & Korkie, B 1980, Estimation for Markowitz Efficient Portfolios, Journal
of the American Statistical Association, 75 (371), Sep., pp. 544-554.
Kamal, JB 2012, Optimal Portfolio Selection in Ex Ante Stock Price Bubble and
Furthermore Bubble Burst Scenario from Dhaka Stock Exchange with
Relevance to Sharpes Single Index Model, Financial Assets and Investing,
Vol.3,No. 3, pp. 29-42.
Kumar, MA 2011, Construction of an optimal portfolio: an application to sharpe's
single index model, Siddhant- A Journal of Decision Making, Vol. 11, Issue: 2,
pp. 21-30.
Markowitz, H 1952, Portfolio Selection, Journal of Finance, 7(1), pp. 77- 91.
Markowitz, H 1959, Portfolio Selection, John T. Wiley & Sons, Inc., New York.
Meenakshi, R & Sarita, B 2012, Optimal portfolio selection with or without the
procedure of short sales, Asian Journal of Research in Business Economics
and Management, Vol. 2, Issue: 7, pp. 220-234.
Michaud, RO 1989, The Markowitz optimization enigma: Is optimized optimal?,
Financial Analysts Journal, 45(1), pp. 31-42.
Nanda, SR, Mahanty, B & Tiwari, MK 2010, Clustering Indian Stock Market Data for
Portfolio Management, Expert Systems with Applications, 37, pp. 8793-8799.
Omet, G 1995, On the Performance of Alternative Portfolio Selection Models,
Dirasat (The Humanities), 22(3), pp. 125-135.
Paudel, R & Koirala, S 2006, Application of Markowitz and Sharpe Models in
Nepalese Stock Market, The Journal of Nepalese Business Studies, 3(1), pp.
18-35.
Saravanan, A & Natarahan, P 2012, Optimal Portfolio Construction with Nifty
Stocks, Advances In Management, Vol. 5(8) Aug., pp. 4-53.
Sharpe, WF 1963, A Simplified Model for Portfolio Analysis, Management Science,
9, pp. 277-293.
Sharpe, WF 1964, Capital Asset Prices: A Theory of Market Equilibrium under
Conditions of Risk, The Journal of Finance, Vol. 19, No. 3, pp. 425-442.
Singh, S 2007, Portfolio Risk Diversification in Indian Stock Market: A Evidence from
S&P CNX Nifty, Thesis submitted to University of Business school, Panjab
University.
Sarker
87
Terol, AB. Gladish, BP, & Ibias, JA 2006, Selecting the optimum portfolio using fuz
compromise programming and Sharpes single-index model, Applied
Mathematics and Computation, 182, pp. 644664.
Varian, H 1993, A Portfolio of Nobel Laureates: Markowitz, Miller and Sharpe, The
Journal of Economic Perspectives, 7(1), pp. 159-169.