ITEM CODE: 120L & 121L

Sr.
No.

A.
1.
i)

DESCRIPTION

ITEM NAME: CHILLED WATER PACKAGE

ITB REQUIREMENT

NAME OF BIDDER
M/s Thermax Ltd.
M/s Voltas Ltd.
Ref. W/VS/223734/06
Dated 23.05.11

Ref.- EM&RBG/108/SAM/R-3
Dt: 21-05-2011

SCOPE OF SUPPLY
Supply Items
Motors for Following Pumps
Chilled Water Pump
Steam Condensate Pump
De-superheating Pump

Required
Required
Required

TECHNICALCOMPARATIVE STATEMENT (ELECTRICAL)

Confirmed

Confirmed

Confirmed
Confirmed
Confirmed

Confirmed
Confirmed
Confirmed

REMARKS

ITEM CODE: 120L & 121L

Sr.
No.

ii)

2.

DESCRIPTION

ITEM NAME: CHILLED WATER PACKAGE

ITB REQUIREMENT

NAME OF BIDDER
M/s Thermax Ltd.
M/s Voltas Ltd.
Ref. W/VS/223734/06
Dated 23.05.11

Ref.- EM&RBG/108/SAM/R-3
Dt: 21-05-2011

PLC based Control Panel with motor

starters with internal Power & Control
Cables for VAM motors

Required

Confirmed

Confirmed

Spares for 2 years operation and

commissioning

Required

Confirmed

Confirmed

B.
TECHNICALCOMPARATIVE STATEMENT (ELECTRICAL)

REMARKS

ITEM CODE: 120L & 121L

Sr.
No.

DESCRIPTION

ITEM NAME: CHILLED WATER PACKAGE

ITB REQUIREMENT

NAME OF BIDDER
M/s Thermax Ltd.
M/s Voltas Ltd.
Ref. W/VS/223734/06
Dated 23.05.11

1.
Motor
i). ) Rated Voltage with %
ii). ) Rated Frequency with %
On each VAM
iii). ) Rated
i) Soln. Pump
Output
ii) Refrigerant Pump
(KW)
iii) Purge Pump
Chilled Water Pump

Ref.- EM&RBG/108/SAM/R-3
Dt: 21-05-2011

415V10%
50Hz 5%

Confirmed
Confirmed

Confirmed
Confirmed

Vendor Data

15 x 2 (SESF)
+
22 x 3 (DESF)

17 x 2 (SESF)
+
17 x 4 (DESF)

Vendor Data

132 (2+1)

-- (3+1)

TECHNICALCOMPARATIVE STATEMENT (ELECTRICAL)

REMARKS

ITEM CODE: 120L & 121L

Sr.
No.

DESCRIPTION

ITB REQUIREMENT

NAME OF BIDDER
M/s Thermax Ltd.
M/s Voltas Ltd.
Ref. W/VS/223734/06
Dated 23.05.11

Steam Condensate Pump

De-superheating Pump

iv).
v).
vi).
vii).
viii).

ITEM NAME: CHILLED WATER PACKAGE

) Explosion proof protection

DUTY Class
) Degree of protection
) Efficiency class
) Insulation Class

Vendor Data
Vendor Data

Safe area
S1
IP-55
Eff1
Class F, with temp rise
limited to Class B

TECHNICALCOMPARATIVE STATEMENT (ELECTRICAL)

18.5 (1+1)
7.5 (1+1)
Confirmed
Confirmed
Confirmed
Confirmed
Confirmed

Ref.- EM&RBG/108/SAM/R-3
Dt: 21-05-2011

-- (1+1)
-- (1+1)
Confirmed
Confirmed
Confirmed
Confirmed
Confirmed

REMARKS

ITEM CODE: 120L & 121L

Sr.
No.

DESCRIPTION

ITEM NAME: CHILLED WATER PACKAGE

ITB REQUIREMENT

NAME OF BIDDER
M/s Thermax Ltd.
M/s Voltas Ltd.
Ref. W/VS/223734/06
Dated 23.05.11

Ref.- EM&RBG/108/SAM/R-3
Dt: 21-05-2011

ix). ) Design Temp. Reference

x). ) Type of Start
xi). ) Make
xii).
SPECIAL REQUIREMENT

500C
DOL
As per ITB
Vendor

Confirmed
Confirmed
Confirmed
NOTE-1

Confirmed
Confirmed
Confirmed
NOTE-1

Motor Spares
Bearing set (1set)
Cooling fan (1 Set)

Required
Required, if applicable

Confirmed
Confirmed

Confirmed
Confirmed

C.
1.
2.

TECHNICALCOMPARATIVE STATEMENT (ELECTRICAL)

REMARKS

ITEM CODE: 120L & 121L

Sr.
No.

2.

DESCRIPTION

ITEM NAME: CHILLED WATER PACKAGE

ITB REQUIREMENT

NAME OF BIDDER
M/s Thermax Ltd.
M/s Voltas Ltd.
Ref. W/VS/223734/06
Dated 23.05.11

Grease nipple & plug (1No.)

Ref.- EM&RBG/108/SAM/R-3
Dt: 21-05-2011

Required, if applicable

Confirmed

Confirmed

E.
F.

DOCUMENTATION
COMPLIANCE TO ELECTRICAL
SPECIFICATION (1075-TS-0809) AND ITS
ATTACHMENTS

Required
Required

Confirmed
Confirmed

Confirmed
Confirmed

G.

TECHNICAL SUITABILITY

YES/NO

YES (NOTE2)

YES (NOTE2)

TECHNICALCOMPARATIVE STATEMENT (ELECTRICAL)

REMARKS

ITEM CODE: 120L & 121L

Sr.
No.

DESCRIPTION

ITEM NAME: CHILLED WATER PACKAGE

ITB REQUIREMENT

NAME OF BIDDER
M/s Thermax Ltd.
M/s Voltas Ltd.
Ref. W/VS/223734/06
Dated 23.05.11

REMARKS

Ref.- EM&RBG/108/SAM/R-3
Dt: 21-05-2011

NOTE:

1. M/s Thermax & M/s Voltas had taken deviation on canned motor specification and they shall supply canned motor as per their manufacturer standards.
However they guaranteed the successful operation & performance of these canned motors.

2. M/s Thermax & M/s Voltas confirmed that each Motor Data sheet/technical particulars shall be furnished as per Specifications before commencement of
manufacturing for review/approval in the event of order. M/s. Thermax & M/s Voltas agreed to PDILs specification except the deviation which is mutually
agreed & applicable only for canned motors. Both vendors confirm to the PDILs specification as per MOM. M/s. Thermax & M/s Voltas agreed to provide

TECHNICALCOMPARATIVE STATEMENT (ELECTRICAL)

ITEM CODE: 120L & 121L

Sr.
No.

DESCRIPTION

ITEM NAME: CHILLED WATER PACKAGE

ITB REQUIREMENT

NAME OF BIDDER
M/s Thermax Ltd.
M/s Voltas Ltd.
Ref. W/VS/223734/06
Dated 23.05.11

REMARKS

Ref.- EM&RBG/108/SAM/R-3
Dt: 21-05-2011

technical particulars and specification sheet for PDILs approval before manufacturing. Both vendors also confirmed that any changes required to conform to
the enquiry specification shall be carried out without any price implication.
3. Both vendors shall submit electrical load list on priority once the LOI is placed on selected bidder for further detailing by PDIL.

TECHNICALCOMPARATIVE STATEMENT (ELECTRICAL)