Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
Contemporary garment manufacturing asks for the appli- important to be familiar with the loads the fabrics are
cation of new technologies and usage of increasingly more exposed to and the deformations that are the response of
demanding fabrics. The fabrics often present serious prob- the fabric mechanical properties to the loads. It is thus pos-
lems in manufacturing, primarily due to the complex prop- sible, knowing the fabric mechanical properties at a partic-
erties dictated by ever-changing fashion trends. Fabrics are ular load level, to predict its reaction behavior, investigate
key components of the garment to be made, and differ by interactions of the parameters and their correlations, as
mass, raw material content and construction parameters. well as to predict potential problems in the garment manu-
Fabrics exhibit even more diversity when their mechanical facturing processes.1
properties are investigated in relation to load–deformation The investigations described here present the continua-
behavior. tion of the development of the system for predicting seam
Loads occurring in fabric processing result in complex appearance quality. The impact of fabric mechanical prop-
mechanisms of non-linear behavior, determined by the erty parameters on the seam appearance quality is investi-
inhomogeneity of the fabric structure. A high degree of gated, as it is the basis of a prediction system. This system
deformation is often the result of even quite low loads. Fab-
rics are exposed to various levels of load in transforming
them from a two-dimensional form into the three-dimen- 1
Corresponding author: tel.: +38622207970; +38622207960;
sional (3-D) form of an article of clothing. It is extremely fax: +38622207990; e-mail: daniela.z-pavlinic@uni-mb.si
Textile Research Journal Vol 76(3): 235–242 DOI: 10.1177/0040517506061533 www.trj.sagepub.com © 2006 SAGE Publications
TRJ 236 Textile Research Journal 76(3)
is aimed at offering predictions for the behavior of a new, the technique used in re-shaping the fabric into an article
carefully selected fabric, for which mechanical properties of clothing, as well as upon sewing processing parameters.
have been previously determined. Having proper informa- The fabric to be sewn is affected by the technology-deter-
tion on the behavior of the fabric selected in processing, mined forces of the sewing machine on one hand, and on the
potential problems can be eliminated in advance, which forces depending on the process of processing the fabric.
will also contribute to the final appearance of the garment Fabric behavior in sewing, i.e. its resistance to the loads at
manufactured [1]. the point of sewing, sewing needle penetration force and
To establish attributes that impact the quality of the the force originating at the toothed feed element, is prima-
seam made, as well as further predictions of seam puckering rily affected by fabric elongation, surface and longitudinal
and flotation of the work-piece, we applied methods of compression properties of the fabric processed [5].
machine learning from learning examples. We primarily used On the other hand, the work-piece is exposed, in process-
the methods of regression trees and k-nearest neighbors ing the fabric into a 3-D shape, to more or less intensive ten-
(k-NN), i.e. the distance weighted k-nearest neighbors [2]. sion, bending and shear loads, as well as to compression.
Regression trees induced from data define mappings from Fabric behavior in processing depends upon its formability,
the attributes’ values to possible predictions. On the other bending rigidity, fabric elasticity and relaxation ability, shrink-
hand, the method of distance-weighted k-NN respects the ability, shear rigidity, shear hysteresis and geometrical
importance of the distance of the query point to the nearest roughness. Formability is a specific fabric property, defined
examples. This means that nearer examples are more impor- as the ability of the fabric to be re-shaped from a plane into
tant for the prediction of the class value than those faraway the 3-D form of an article of clothing. It is based on the max-
in the attribute space. The k-NN method has proved to be imum longitudinal compression that the fabric can stand
more adequate for our prediction task. Predictions are thus before buckling occurs [6]. Tension properties at low loads
made by the distance weighted k-NN. We used an imple- were used to describe longitudinal compression [4, 7]. They
mentation of k-NN included in the Orange software pack- define fabric formability (F in mm2) as a ratio of fabric
age, developed by the Artificial Intelligence Laboratory, elasticity (EL = EMT/LT in %), bending rigidity by a length
Faculty of Computer and Information Science, University unit (B in cN cm2/cm), shear rigidity (G in cN/cm °) and
of Ljubljana, Slovenia [3]. During the study a high degree of shear hysteresis (2HG5 in cN/cm) at the shear angle ± 5°
correlation was found between the important attributes (equation (1)):
selected by the above machine learning methods, and the
attributes suggested for this prediction task by an expert in EMT G
the field of garment engineering. F = ------------------- ⋅ B ⋅ ---------------- (1)
F m ⋅ LT 2HG5
turing aperture. It depends upon the elastic properties of ric extension in the area of the seam, which is reflected as a
the warp and weft yarns, since, due to abrasion forces in gain in longitudinal length. Seam flotation is a deformation
the interlocking area of the needle and catcher thread, the of the seam that occurs because of the interaction of the
work-piece compacts in the area of the puncturing aper- shear load (affecting the fabric through the sewing thread)
ture at the moment of tightening the stitch. The deforma- and fabric extension in the area of the seam [10, 11].
tion created in this way, which is reduced in the direction
of the stitch center, can cause additional tension in warp or
weft yarns. During repeated puncturing, the sewing needle Statistical methods
must make its way between individual warp and weft yarns, Fabrics respond in different manners to the loads occurring
and the yarns are again pushed aside. As in sewing needle in garment manufacturing processes. It is extremely impor-
puncturing the puncturing point is changed at each stitch tant to have an understanding of the interactions of the
formed, in principle by the stitch length, namely 2 to 5 mm, fabric mechanical properties, to be able to study and
the same system of the warp and weft threads is established understand properly the key parameters of these proper-
at the distance of the technologically determined puncturing ties. Fabric behavior in sewing is, from the point of view of
point, e.g. stitch length. Due to repetitious pushing of the the aesthetics of seam appearance, reflected in its smooth-
warp and weft yarns, construction deformation occurs in ness. The seam that is not smooth is either puckered or
the textile surface. If the tension caused is higher than the floated [11]. The degree of correlation between seam
margin of elasticity they are seen as plastic deformation of puckering and flotation can be measured by the Pearson’s
the fabric [9]. The deformation is reflected as seam puckering correlation coefficient, as shown in equation (2) [12]:
and has a detrimental impact on the quality of the seam,
as well as on the appearance of the article of clothing as a
∑ X – X Y – Y -
n
whole (Figure 1). i=1 i i
The fabrics in plain weave are more prone to seam r = ---------------------------------------------------------- (2)
( n – 1 )S x S y
puckering, due to higher density of warp and weft yarns,
which cause higher values of shear properties, primarily
where Xi and Yi are the values of variables X and Y in
shear hysteresis (2HG) at the shear angle ± 0.5°.
experiment i, X and Y are their average values, Sx and Sy
are their standard deviations and n is number of samples.
Seam Flotation
Investigations of the seam flotation, from the point of view
of fabric mechanical properties, are affected by the values of
Machine Learning Methods
bending and shear properties, the formability of the fabric Machine learning is an area of artificial intelligence that
in question, as well as by extension. Low bending rigidity is includes procedures that, from a number of learning exam-
detrimental to the seam appearance because of the resist- ples from a problem domain, discover new knowledge on
ance the fabric offers to the bending. However, too low the topic. This knowledge, represented by a formal model,
formability prevents the fabric from adapting to the forces is obtained from a kind of analysis and generalization of
occurring within it. The seam, as a joining element, causes the learning examples. The knowledge can be used to proc-
fabric shearing deformation in the area of the seam, due to ess new, previously unseen, examples. Often such discov-
the mass of the thread interlocked in the stitch. The shear ered knowledge itself is of interest to domain experts.
deformation of the fabric caused in this way results in fab- Procedures of machine learning can be used to discover
TRJ 238 Textile Research Journal 76(3)
previously unknown regularities within a set of given data. expert was conducted using the Spearman’s rank-correla-
This is often referred to as data mining, or KDD – knowl- tion coefficient [12]:
edge discovery in data bases. In this way the rules, previously
unknown to the expert in the field, but quite meaningful, N
∑
2
can be discovered and statistically verified for validity. A 6 Di
model thus obtained can also be tested on some other i=1
ρ = 1– -------------------------
- (3)
examples that differ from those used for inducing the
N N 2 – 1
model. The validity of induced models is typically meas-
ured by their classification accuracy, sensitivity, etc. Other
qualities of a model are also of interest: its interpretability
where Di is the difference between the two ranks of the
from the expert’s point of view, its brevity, etc.
corresponding values of two variables and N is the number
In attribute-value machine learning, each learning exam-
of pairs of values.
ple is described in terms of values of attributes and the class
To assess the predictive accuracy of the induced regres-
it belongs to. Class can be categorical (in classification prob-
sion trees and the k-NN classifiers, standard ten-fold cross
lems) or numerical (in regression problems). In the case
validation was used. Examples were randomly divided into
presented here, the learning examples are the individual
ten folds and each method was tried for ten times, where the
fabrics; the attributes are the measured parameters of
examples from nine folds were used for learning and the
mechanical properties, while the associated classes are the
remaining fold was used for testing. The accuracy of the
various responses of the fabrics behavior. The task of
models induced was measured by the root of mean squared
machine learning is to find a model, i.e. function, which
error (RMSE), a standard measure for the evaluation of
could be used to predict the response of new fabrics. Two
regression models (equation (4)):
methods of machine learning have been used for the pur-
pose in our study: regression tree learning, and learning by
the k-nearest neighbors method (k-NN). The classification N 2
x i – p i
trees method was also used in preliminary experiments, as
well as naive Bayesian classifier and locally weighted regres- ∑i=1
sion, which all proved to yield significantly less accurate RMSE = ------------------------------ (4)
N
results than regression trees and k-NN.
Modeling by regression trees is based on recursive parti- where the pi is a predicted value; the xi is the corresponding
tioning of the example set into ever-smaller subsets, until measured value; and N is the number of examples.
the variance in the class values obtained in the subsets is All the experiments were conducted using the compo-
below a specified threshold [13]. The division is based on nent-based machine learning system Orange [3]. It includes
the values of attributes, chosen by heuristic that is supposed a range of preprocessing algorithms (feature subset selec-
to lead to smaller and (according to the holy grail of machine tion, categorization, and feature utility estimation for
learning, the Ockham’s principle) more accurate trees. The predictive tasks), modeling techniques (classification and
induced regression trees can be shown to a domain expert, regression trees, naive Bayesian classifier, k-NN, majority
who can then decide whether they agree with the existing classifier, support vector machines, linear and logistic regres-
theoretical knowledge. sion, ensemble methods), validation procedures (cross-val-
K-nearest neighbors method (k-NN) predicts the outcome idation, random sampling, leave-one-out) and visualization
for an example by computing the average outcome over k methods.
learning examples most similar to the query example, the
so-called “nearest neighbors” [2]. Neighbors’ influence can
also be weighted with regard to their distance from the query
example. Unfortunately, k-NN models cannot be visualized, Methodology
which makes their interpretation very difficult. In order to
gain some insight into such k-NN models, we conducted a The research described here was aimed at investigating the
series of tests in which k-NN selected the most appropriate impact of parameters of fabric mechanical properties on
attribute subset for predicting a specific response. Using seam puckering and flotation of work-piece components in
such a randomized procedure, we were able to statistically the area of the seam. The aim was to construct predictive
assess the importance of individual attributes by counting models that can be used to predict the quality of the seams
the number of trials in which they were selected. To evalu- for a new randomly selected fabric, provided its mechani-
ate the compliance of the model with the expectations cal properties are known.
made by experts, we compared the attribute selections by
k-NN with those made by a domain expert. Statistical com-
parison of the attribute rankings by k-NN and a human
Predicting Seam Appearance Quality D. Z. Pavlinic et al. 239 TRJ
Table 3 Number of trials (out of 30) in which the attributes were selected. The attributes that were used in less than four
times are omitted for the sake of claritya.
Responses EMT-1 EMT-2 RT-1 RT-2 a G-2 2HG-2 2HG5-2 EL-1 EL-2 B-1 B-2
s1 19 29 30 9
s7 28 18 11 28 14 28
a
Justification for this threshold is that if the probability of the attribute to be chosen at random is 0.5, the probability that an attribute is
chosen in four or more trials is less than p = 0.05. Therefore, attributes occurring in less than four trials can be considered statistically
insignificant.
Predicting Seam Appearance Quality D. Z. Pavlinic et al. 241 TRJ
Table 4 Spearman’s rank-correlation coefficient. resenting one of the key criteria for assessing the quality of
garment appearance, is a proper basis for constructing the
Responses Spearman’s rank-correlation coefficient system for predicting garment appearance quality. Using k-
NN, the software package Orange enables successful deter-
s1 0.943
s7 0.815 mination of the mechanical property parameters that impact
seam puckering and work-piece component flotation in the
area of the seam. The selection of important attributes is
appropriate and can be used to find the attributes that specific for a particular response of fabric behavior, and
affect fabric behavior in sewing processes. can be used to predict the degree of seam puckering and
work-piece component flotation, so that the proper fabric
can be selected just by knowing its mechanical property
Conclusion parameters. Such an approach to solving the problem of
seam puckering and work-piece component flotation, even
The results obtained in constructing a model for predicting before the actual process of garment manufacture has started,
seam quality using machine learning, indicate that in solv- is of considerable importance in the process of designing
ing these problems the k-NN algorithm is more appropri- high-quality garments. It offers, apart from savings in the
ate for the purpose than regression trees. Despite the fact amount of the fabric to be used, clear criteria for the required
that regression trees offer, in principle, the formation of fabric quality parameters.
more complex models for prediction, and that the interac-
tions among the attributes can be more clearly seen, the
trees yield poor results. The k-NN method uses learning
examples by memorizing them, and each new example Literature Cited
which is given its class, makes its own contribution in addi-
tion to the previous learning examples. Spearman’s rank- 1. Zavec, P., D., and Geršak, J., Evaluation of Garment Appear-
correlation coefficient showed relatively high correlation ance Quality, Tekstil 53(10), 497–509 (2004).
between the ranks of the attributes selected by the experts 2. Hastie, T., Tibshirani, R., and Friedman, J., “The Elements of
and the k-NN. The results also confirm the conjectured Statistical Learning,” Springer Verlag, New York, 2001.
impact of the mechanical property parameters on seam 3. Demšar, J., and Zupan, B., “Orange,” http://magix.fri.uni-lj.si/
orange/, 2004.
puckering and flotation of the work-piece components in
4. Geršak, J., Investigations of the Impact of Fabric Mechanical
the area of the seam. It was confirmed that fabric elasticity
Properties on Garment Appearance, Tekstil 52(8), 368–379
had the most prominent impact on seam puckering. Seam (2003).
puckering was most noticeable with inelastic fabrics, where 5. Zavec, D., and Geršak, J., The Influence of Mechanical and
the tension in warp and weft threads were higher than with Physical Properties of Fabrics on Their Behaviour in Garment
elastic fabrics, due to the fact that they were pushed aside Manufacturing Processes, in “International Conference Inno-
as each sewing needle penetration. Work-piece component vation and Modeling of Garment Manufacturing Processes,
flotation in the area of the seam occurred because of inad- IMCEP 2000,” University of Maribor, Faculty of Mechanical
equate shear and bending properties, expressed as shear Engineering, Maribor, pp. 249–257, 2000.
and bending rigidity and the level of associated hysteresis. 6. Lindberg, J., Westerberg, L., and Svennson, R., Wool Fabrics
as Garment Construction Materials, J. Textile Inst. 51(2),
In making predictions of work-piece component flotation
1475–1493 (1960).
in the area of the seam, using the k-NN method (k = 30),
7. Morooka, H., and Niwa, M., Physical Properties of Fabrics
the above parameters of mechanical properties, namely Relating to Making-up and Good Appearance, J. Text. Machin.
shear hysteresis 2HG and bending rigidity B weftwise, were Soc. Japan 24(4), 105–114 (1978).
the most frequently selected ones in the course of 30 repe- 8. Kawabata, S., “The Standardization and Analysis of Hand
titions. The parameter of tensile resilience, RT, was also Evaluation, The Hand Evaluation and Standardization Com-
frequently selected in learning (28 times out of 30 repeti- mittee,” 2nd Edn, The Textile Machinery Society of Japan,
tions). It denotes the ratio between the reversible and the Osaka, 1980.
energy needed for the deformation, and has a serious 9. Geršak, J., The Impact of Technical-Technological Parame-
impact on the seam appearance. Elastic fabrics exhibit ters of Sewing on Seam Quality, in “Proceedings Clothing
Engineering 1992,” Technical Faculty, Department of Mechan-
lower relaxation values, meaning that work-piece compo-
ical Engineering, Institute for Textile and Garment Manu-
nents made of such fabrics can more readily compensate
facture Processes, Maribor, Slovenia, pp. 49–63, 1992, (in
for the loads in the area of the seam, which makes these Slovene).
fabrics more flexible in the end-use products, namely arti- 10. Geršak, J., “Expertise with the Analysis of Fabric Mechanical
cles of clothing. and Physical Properties:[for] Mura European Fashion Design,”
Investigation of the mechanical property parameters of Murska Sobota, University of Maribor, Faculty of Mechanical
the fabrics analyzed and their impact on seam quality, rep- Engineering, Maribor, Slovenia, 1998, (in Slovene).
TRJ 242 Textile Research Journal 76(3)
11. Geršak, J., Development of the System for Qualitative Predic- 13. Breiman, L., Friedman, J. H., Olshen, R. A., and Stone, C. J.,
tion of Garment Appearance Quality, Int. J. Clothing Sci. “Classification and Regression Trees,” Wadsworth Int. Group,
Technol. 14(3/4), 169–180 (2002). Belmont, CA, 1984.
12. Zar, J. H., “Biostatistical Analysis,” Prentice Hall, Englewood 14. AATCC, “Test Method 88B: Smoothness of Seams in Fabrics
Cliffs, New Jersey, 1998. after Repeated Home Laundering,” AATCC, Research Trian-
gle Park, NC, 1996.