Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
The stress-strain curve for sisal fibres has been experimentally determined. Ultimate ten-
sile strength (UTS), initial modulus (YM), average modulus (AM) and per cent elongation
at break of fibres have been measured as function of fibre diameter, test length and test
speed. UTS, YM, AM and per cent elongation lie in the range 530 to 630 MN m -2, 17 to
22 G N m -2, 9.8 to 16.5 G N m -2 and 3.64 to 5.12 respectively for fibres of diameters
ranging between 100 and 300 #m. No significant variation of mechanical properties with
change in diameter of the fibres was observed. However, with increase in test length of
the fibres, the UTS and per cent elongation are found to decrease while YM and AM
increased in the test length ranging from 15 to 65 mm. With the increase in speed of
testing from 1 to 50 mm min -~, YM and UTS are found to increase whereas per cent
elongation and AM do not show any significant variation. At a test speed of 500 mm min -~
the UTS value decreases sharply. The above results are explained in terms of the internal
structure of the fibre such as the cell structure, microfibrillar angle, defects, etc. Scanning
electron microscope (SEM) studies of the fractured tips of the sisal fibres reveal that the
failure of the fibre is due to the uncoiling of microfibrils accompanied by decohesion and
finally tearing of cell walls. The tendency of uncoiling seems to decrease with increasing
speed of testing.
3926
T A B L E I Properties of sisal fibres
References Diameter Density Size of Moisture Major chemical Micro- UTS YM % elongation TM FR
o f fibre (g cm-a) cells content constituents fibrillar (MNm -2) (GN m -2) (GN m -2) (N m -2)
(,*m) (ram) at 65% r.h. angle
(%) Cellulose Lignin
(%) (%) (deg)
60
r
r'O
400
300
'E 600
~- zoo Correlotion coefficient
400 x = -0.81
1oo zoo
30
I 2 3 4 ~-- 25
'E
--~'Elongotion(%)
20
Figure 1 Typical stress-strain curve of a sisal fibre of
T~icient
~ = +05)9
diameter 200#m and 50ram long tested at 10mm min -~.
"g 10
IK
cells begins following decohesion o f cellulosic and
non-cellulosic molecules mainly through weak
links and imperfections. This is indicated in the I I I
3.3. Effect of diameter/denier of the fibre that the variations are significant. A regression
Table II shows the mechanical parameters o f sisal analysis shows a linear relationship between UTS
fibres of 50ram length tested at 1 0 m m m i n -1. (o in M N m -2) and test length (L in m) in the
The mechanical parameters do not show any range studied. The regression equation is given by
appreciable change with increase in diameter of
o = 7 9 6 - - 2367.9L, (1)
the fibre investigated as has been observed in the
case of banana fibre [18]. with correlation coefficient 3 , = - - 0 . 8 1 and the
slope having significance level at 1%.
3.4. Effect of test length Since the standard deviations (SD) in mean
Sisal fibres o f different test lengthshaving diameter strengths of the fibre, at particular gauge lengths,
2 0 0 # m were tested at a speed o f 10ram min -1. were observed to be high and variant, a further
Table III lists the observed variation o f mechanical test was carried out, namely coefficient o f vari-
parameters with test lengths. Fig. 2 shows the vari- ation (CV = standard deviation/mean) of UTS
ation o f UTS and YM with test lengths. It can be values at different gauge lengths, to verify the
seen from Table III that both UTS and per cent observed linear variation of the mean UTS values.
elongation decrease with test length as observed Table IV shows the variation o f CV with test
in the case o f banana [18] and coir [19] fibres, lengths. The regression equation is given by
whereas YM and AM increase with test length.
Test o f significance using Student's t-test shows C V x 10 -2 = 5 . 3 6 x 10 - 2 + 0 . 1 7 • t0-2L,
TABLE II Variation of mechanical properties with fibre diameter (test length: 50 mm; speed of testing: 10 mm nrin -~)
Diameter *Initial *Ultimate *% elongation Average
(mm) modulus tensile at break modulus
(GN m-~) strength (GN m-~)
(MN m -s)
0.10-0.30 17.0-22.0 530.0-630.0 3.64-5.12 9.8-16.5
*No systematic and significant variation was observed with diameter.
3928
TABLE III Variation of mechanical properties with test length (diameter of fibre: 200/~m; speed of testing:
10 mm min -1)
Test length Initial modulus Ultimate tensile % elongation Average
(ram) (GN m-2) strength at break modulus
(MNm-2) (GN m-2)
Mean SD Men SD Men SD Mean SD
15 14.15 1.50 793.80 59.70 8.15 1.07 9.74 1.02
25 17.26 1.62 757.10 72.25 5.70 1.44 13.28 1.55
35 19.71 1.53 728.10 85.70 4.65 1.30 15.64 2.12
50 22.52 2.53 630.10 90.00 3.98 0.62 15.83 1.93
65 25,36 2.20 620.81 98.70 3.50 0.35 17.87 1.57
having correlation coefficient 3" = + 0 . 9 7 at 1% from the sisal leaves. Effects due to factors (a) to
significance level. Thus it shows that there exists a (d) as well as chemical constituents on the vari-
linear relationship between the test length and the ation of observed mechanical parameters can be
ultimate strength of sisal fibre. neglected. Hence, in the following paragraphs, we
shall explain the observed properties o f the fibres
3.5. Effect of test speed in terms of structural variations.
Table V lists values of UTS, YM, per cent elonga- Fig. 3 shows both transverse and longitudinal
tion and average modulus of sisal fibres of diameter sections of sisal fibre indicating that sisal fibre is
200/lm and length 5 0 m m tested at different a multicelhilar fibre as other vegetable fibres
speeds. Only the YM and UTS values show signifi- having mainly compactly arranged sclerenchyma
cant variation and these increase with increase in cells (strengthening cells). The celIs have diameter
test speed from 1 to 5 0 m m min -1. However, at (d) of 25/~m and a mean length (l) of 2.5 mm with
5 0 0 m m min -1, UTS decreases sharply. Such be- a lid ratio of 100 [20] for fibres of diameter 50 to
haviour is also observed in banana fibres [18]. 300/am in contrast to cell diameter of 18 to 30 #m
and mean length o f 2.7 to 5.5 mm and lid ratio of
3.6. Fracture studies 150 in the case of banana fibre [18] of diameter
Figs. 4 and 5 show SEM pictures of the fractured 80 to 250#m. The cell walls of sisal fibre appear
tips at test speeds 10 mm min -1 and 500 mm min -I to be thicker (8 to 25/lm) with varying lumen size
respectively. It is clear from these figures that the of 8 to 12#m in contrast to thinner (1.25/lm) but
fracture mode in sisal fibres depends on the speed uniform cell walls and lumen size of 12.5#m in
of testing as observed in the case of banana fibre banana fibre. These comparative structural differ-
[18]. ences between sisal and banana fibres indicate sisal
fibre to be weaker than banana fibre.
4. Discussion
As reported earlier [ 18], the mechanical properties 4.1. S t r e s s - s t r a i n c u r v e
of plant fibres depend on (a) source, (b) age, Sisal fibre, having both crystalline and non-crystal-
(c) species, (d) processing parameters and (e) inter- line components, is expected to behave like a
nal structure including chemical constituents. In viscoelastic material when subjected to tension.
the present study, the sisal fibres used were sup- Fhe applied stress is shared initially between crys-
plied from one locality and are extracted manually talline and non-crystalline components in a natural
fibre which is also basically a fibre-reinforced com-
TABLE IV Coefficient of variation (SD/Mean) of UTS posite on a microscale. The extent to which the
(from Table IIl) at different gauge lengths fibre resists the deformation in the low strain
Test length Coefficient of variation region is called the initial modulus of the fibre.
(ram) (SD/Mean) of UTS (X 10 -2) The effective modulus ( E J may then be calculated
15 7.5 for the fibre following the equation due to
25 9.5 McLaughlin [21] :
35 11.7
50 14.2 Ef = WeE e cosZ0 + WneEnc, (2)
65 15.8 where E e and Erie are the modulus values of crys-
3929
TABLE V Variation of mechanical parameters with test speed (diameter of fibre: 200 #m; test length: 50 mm)
Speed of Initial modulus UTS *% elongation *Averagemodulus
testing (GN m -2) (MN m -2) (GN m-2)
(mm min -1) Mean SD Mean SD
1 8.41 1.42 481.00 78.80
2 20.00 1.64 608.80 95.40
10 22.12 2.53 630.12 90.00 3.16-4.12 11.70-22.10
50 34.16 1.75 759.70 58.10
500 - - 441.60 150.70
*No systematic significant variation was observed with speed of testing.
talline and non-crystalline regions and are assumed It can easily be seen that higher cellulose content
to be 45 GN m -2 and 3 GN m -2 respectively for the and smaller microfibrillar angle are mainly respon-
vegetable fibres [19]. We and Wne are the weight sible for the higher strength and modulus and
fractions of the crystalline and non-crystalline smaller elongation. This is in conformity with
components which have values o f 0.67 and 0.12 earlier studies made in the case o f other plant
respectively for sisal fibre [2]. The microfibrillar fibres [ 18, 2 1 , 2 4 ] .
angle (0) of sisal fibre is found to be 23.14 ~ [19].
The modulus value (E~) calculated using the above 4.2. Effect of diameter/denier
values in Equation 2 is 26 GN m -2, which is of the In sisal fibres the microfibrillar angle and number
same order as observed in the present investigation. of strengthening cells did not show any appreciable
As the applied stress increases the viscoelastic variation within the range of fibre diameter used in
nature o f the fibre becomes clearer. Several visco- the present study. Hence, no appreciable change in
elastic models have been proposed [22] to explain values of YM, UTS and per cent elongation were
the behaviour o f viscoelastic materials. These observed in the diameter range of the sisal fibres
models essentially consists o f a dashpot (represent- studied.
ing amorphous regions) and a spring (representing
crystalline regions) in series and parallel combina- 4.3. Effect of test length
tions. Fig. 6 represents the calculated stress-strain The observed decrease in the values of UTS and
behaviour of such a simple two element model of per cent elongation at break and increase in YM
Maxwell [23] which qualitatively fits well with the and AM with increasing test length of the fibre
observed stress-strain curve of sisal fibre shown in may be understood as follows: with increase in
Fig. 1 and thus confirming the viscoelastic nature test length the number o f weak links or imperfec-
of the fibres. tions increases, thus resulting in reduction in UTS
The different structural and chemical parameters and per cent elongation values [25] (see Appen-
of sisal, banana and coir are shown in Table VI. dix). On the other hand, with increase in test
Figure 3 (a) Photomicrograph of cross-section of sisal fibre. (b) Scanning electron micrograph showing longitudinal
section.
3930
Figure 4 Fractured tips of sisal fibre tested at 10 mm rain -~ showing (a) bonding material between the cells remaining
intact; (b) uncoiling of fibrils (cf) and pull-out of the cells (pc).
length of the fibre, a higher resistance is offered by is shown in Table VI by the correlation coefficient
the fibre to the applied stress which results in and significance level of the slope, respectively,
lower elongation initially. This probably accounts calculated from the experimental observation.
for the higher modulus of the fibres at longer test
lengths. The reason for such behaviour, unlike 4.4. Effect of speed of testing
metals, is due to the multicellular structure, visco- The observed variation in the strength values can
elastic nature and non-uniform structural inhomo- be explained from the viscoelastic model of cellu-
geneity of the natural fibres. lose fibres (Section 4.1). A mathematical analysis
From the plot o f UTS against test length, an of the model [221 shows that for any type of
estimate of density of weak links in the fibre can rapid mechanical test, the fibre behaves like an
be made using linear equation derived relating UTS elastic body, i.e., the crystalline region (represented
(a) and test length (L) of the fibre (Appendix) by a spring in the model) mainly shares the applied
given by: load which results in higher values of both modu-
lus and UTS. When the speed of testing decreases,
o L = r o L L + OLo. (3) the applied load will be shared increasingly by the
The slope m g is usually negative and expressed as amorphous region (represented by the dashpot in
MN m -3 when a is expressed as MN m -2 and L in the model). However, for a very slow mechanical
m. Table VII lists the values of the slopes for sisal, test the fibre behaves like a viscous liquid and the
banana and coir, indicating the degree of flaw den- major portion of the applied load is shared by the
sity along the length of the fibres. The extent of amorphous regions and thus results in low modulus
such relationships and the significance of the slope and UTS values.
Figure 5 Fractured tips of sisal fibre tested at 500 mm min -1 showing (a) decohesion of the cells through the bonding
material; (b) relatively little uncoiling of fibrils and pull-out of the cells.
3931
T A B L E VI Comparison of structure and properties of some natural fibres
Fibre Diameter Density Cellulose Cell length Cell wall MicrofibriUar YM UTS %
(~m) (gcm -3) (%)/ (/)/Cell thickness angle (GN m -2) (MN m -2) elongation
Lignin(%) breadth (d) (#m) (deg)
content ratio
Sisal 100-300 1.450 70/12 100 12.5 20-25 17-22 530-630 3.64-5.12
Banana 50-250 1.350 83/5 150 1.25 11-12 27-33 711-789 2.4-3.6
Coir 100-450 1.150 37/42 35 8.00 30-45 3-6 106-175 17-47
However, at very high strain rate (500mm develops cracks which results in failure. Thus
min-1), the sudden fall in UTS value may be due relatively lesser amounts of uncoiling, tearing of
to the presence of imperfections in the fibre which cell walls and pull-out of the micro fibrils are
quickly respond to the applied stress at this large expected, as observed in Fig. 5b. On the other
strain rate and thus causing an immature failure. hand, a considerable amount of separation of cells
The large SD observed in this case may also be due by breaking through the bonding material is
to irregular response of the imperfections to the evident in Fig. 5a, as expected.
applied stress.
5. Conclusions
4.5. Fracture studies 1. The stress-strain curve for sisal fibre is charac-
It has been reported [26] that fracture mode in terized by an initial linear region followed by a
natural fibres can be of two distinct types, namely curvature indicating the increased rate of strain
intracellular and intercellular. The intracellular produced with increase in stress. This is in accord-
fracture is generally observed in fibres having large ance with the viscoelastic nature of the fibre.
elongation and tested at low speed. Such a fracture 2. The values of experimentally observed elastic
is accompanied by tearing of cell walls as well as modulus, UTS, average modulus and per cent
pull-out of the fibrils. The intercellular fracture is elongation are in the range of 17 to 22 G N m -2,
commonly observed in low elongation fibres tested 530 to 630MNm -2, 98 to 165MNm -2 and 3.64
at high speed. Intercellular fracture occurs mainly to 5.12% respectively for fibres in the 100 to
with separation of bonding material between the 300/1m diameter range, indicating little variation
cells and very little pull-out of the fibrils. in mechanical properties with variation in diameter
Sisal fibre is found to have a mixed mode of of the fibre.
fracture. At low strain rate (2 mm rain -1) the frac- 3. Values of UTS and per cent elongation of
ture mode appears to be mostly intracellular in sisal fibre decreased from 793.8MNm -2 and
nature. The pull-out and uncoiling of the fibils can 8.15% for 15 mm test length of 625.6 MN m -2 and
be clearly seen in Fig. 4b without any separation
of cells near the periphery of the fibre or breaking
=oiI~I
any bonding material between the cells (Fig. 4a).
However, at a much higher speed of testing,
5 0 0 m m m i n -1, the fracture mode appears to be
intercellular (Fig. 5). This can be understood since
at this high speed the major contribution is from
the Crystalline fraction, and the fibre takes up a
comparatively higher stress. The amorphous frac-
tion, being unable to stand this stress level.
3932
3.50% for 6 5 m m test length o f the fibre. Also Equation A2 then becomes:
b o t h initial modulus and average modulus in-
creased with decrease over the test lengths men- eL = go + a in
tioned above.
4. Values of initial modulus and UTS increased
Assuming A L / L o < 1, we obtain from first ap-
from 8.41 GN m -2 and 481.0 MN m -2 respectively
proximation
at a test speed of l m m m i n -1 to 3 4 . 1 6 G N m -2
and 7 5 9 M N m -2 respectively at a test speed o f
o L = -- AL + ao,
5 0 m m min -1. These results confirm the visco- Lo
elastic nature o f the fibre. or
5. Fracture studies reveal that sisal fibre has a o~
aL = - - L + a 0 - - a (puttingAL=L--Lo)
mixed mode o f fracture. At low speed the fracture L0
mode is mainly intracellular whereas at high speed
or
the fracture mode is essentially intercellular. t t
oL = aLoL + OLo. (A3)
Acknowledgement
The authors thank Sri K. Sukumaran and K . K . ao and aLo have the same dimension, that is
Ravikumar for their help in mechanical testing, MN m -z, while c~0 has dimension MN m -3.
Mr Peter Koshy and Mr S. G. K. Pillai for their From Equation A3, a plot o f e L against L gives
help in SEM and optical microscopic work respec- a straight line to a first approximation. The slope
tively. Thanks are due to Mr Suresh Kumar and Mr o f the line gives an estimate o f the density o f flaws
C. S. Bhatt for the helpful discussions on statistical along the fibre. However, absence o f any variation
analysis, and Dr B. C. Pal for his valuable sugges- as expected b y Equation A3 should mean that the
tions. flaws are regularly distributed in the range studied
and the average distance between the flaws is very
Appendix small compared to the test lengths.
In natural fibres, since the flaws or weak links are
irregularly spaced in the fibre, the strength will References
depend upon the length of the fibre used for the 1. Report of Khadi and Village Industries Commission,
Bombay, "All India Seminar on Fibre Industry",
tensile test [25].
organized by KVIC, Trivandrum, March (1980).
If a fibre having length L and strength a is now 2. K.P. SRINIVASA SHETTY, idem.
changed in length by d L , a corresponding change 3. A. R. PATEL, Eastern Economist (India) July 24
in strength da will be observed. The incremental (1981) p. 152.
changes can be retated by the equation given 4. S.K. KALLAPUR, "Bark and Leaf Fibres of India"
(Directorate of Publicity, KVIC, Irla Road, Vile
below:
Parle, Bombay, 1962).
dL 5. "FAO Production Year Book" (Food and Agricul-
da = a L (A1) ture Organisation, Rome, 1965), Vol. 19, p. 155.
6. N. G E O P A U L , U. C H A T T E R J E E and S.S.
where dL represents the probability of having an BHATTACHARYA, Text. Trends (July 1972) 1.
7. R.G. BOSE, Sci. Cult. 17 (1951-52) 435.
imperfection introduced or reduced, L represents
8. K.G. SATYANARAYANA, A. G. KULKARNI and
the probability o f already having an imperfection P. K. ROHATGI, J. Scient. Ind. Res. 40 (1981) 222.
in L and a represents a measure of the frequency 9. R.R. NORTON (ed.), "Composite Materials:
o f occurrence o f weak links in the fibre. Integrating Engineering Applications of Composites", Vol. 3
Equation A1 we obtain: (Academic Press Inc., New York, 1974).
10. D.G. SWIFT and R. B. L. SMITH, Composites 10
L (1979) 145.
OL = O"0 + O~ I n L o (A2) 11. T. PARAMASIVAN and A. P. J. ABDUL KALAM,
Fibre Sci. Teehnol. 7 (1974) 85.
where ao is the strength of the fibre of length Lo 12. K.C. DHYANI and N. GEO PAUL, Jute Bull. 37
taken as standard. Equation A2 predicts the gen- (1974) 1.
13. H.R. MAUERSBERGER (ed.), "Textile Fibres"
eral nature of variation o f strength with test
(John Wiley & Sons Inc., New York, 1974).
lengths in any range. 14. A.C. CHAKRAVORTY, Text. Res. J. 39 (1969)
In a particular range we can write L = Lo + s 878.
3933
15. A.C. CHAKRAVORTY and N. GEO PAUL, Ind. 23. J . M . G . COWIE, "Polymers: Chemistry and Physics
Text. J. (March 1977) 97. of Modern Materials" (Intertext Books, Aylesbury,
16. N. GEO PAUL and S. S. BHATTACHARYA, Text. Bucks, 1973) p. 228.
Trends (April 1974) 1. 24. K. G. SATYANARAYANA, C. K. S. PILLAI, K.
17. H.P. STOUT and J. A. JENKINS, Ann. Sei. Textiles, SUKUMARAN, S . G . K . PILLAI, P.K. ROHATGI
Belges N4-12 (1955) 231. and KALYANI VIJAYAN, J. Mater. Sci. 17 (1982)
18. A.G. KULKARNI, K. G. SATYANARAYANA, P. K. 2453.
ROHATGI and KALYANI VIJAYAN, J. Mater. Sei. 25. E. OTT, H.M. SPURLIN and M.W. GRAFFIN
19 (1983) 2290. (eds.), "Cellulose and Cellulose Derivatives - Part
19. A.G. KULKARNI, K.G. SATYANARAYANA, III", 2nd edn (Interscience Publishers Inc., New
K. SUKUMARAN and P. K. ROHATGI, ibid. 16 York, 1955) p. 1337.
(1981) 905. 26. P.S. MUKHERJEE, K.G. SATYANARAYANA,
20. K.G. SATYANARAYANA, (MISS) MANGALA- K. SUKUMARAN and P. KOSHY, Proceedings of
KUMARI, P. KOSHY and A. G. KULKARNI, Bull. the 16th Annual Conference of Electron Microscopic
Eleetr. Mierose. Soe. Ind. 7 (1983) 1. Society of India, held at Madurai (India), Nov.
21. E.C. McLAUGHLIN and R. A. TAIT, J. Mater. Sei. 24-26, 1983.
15 (1980) 89.
22. TURNER ALFREY JR, "Mechanical Behaviour of
High Polymers" (Interscience Publishers Inc., New R e c e i v e d 14 S e p t e m b e r 1 9 8 3
York, 1948). and accepted 23 January 1 9 8 4
3934