Beruflich Dokumente
Kultur Dokumente
EDITORIAL
EXECUTIVE EDITOR Stephen Pizzello
SENIOR EDITOR Rachael K. Bosley
ASSOCIATE EDITOR Jon D. Witmer
TECHNICAL EDITOR Christopher Probst
CONTRIBUTING WRITERS
Benjamin B, Douglas Bankston, Robert S. Birchard,
John Calhoun, Michael Goldman, Simon Gray,
David Heuring, Jay Holben, Noah Kadner,
Jean Oppenheimer, Iain Stasukevich,
Patricia Thomson
ART DEPARTMENT
CREATIVE DIRECTOR Marion Kramer
ADVERTISING
ADVERTISING SALES DIRECTOR Angie Gollmann
323-936-3769 FAX 323-936-9188
e-mail: gollmann@pacbell.net
ADVERTISING SALES DIRECTOR Sanja Pearce
323-952-2114 FAX 323-952-2140
e-mail: sanja@ascmag.com
CLASSIFIEDS/ADVERTISING COORDINATOR Diella Peru
323-952-2124 FAX 323-952-2140
e-mail: diella@ascmag.com
American Cinematographer (ISSN 0002-7928), established 1920 and in its 94th year of publication, is published
monthly in Hollywood by ASC Holding Corp., 1782 N. Orange Dr., Hollywood, CA 90028, U.S.A.,
(800) 448-0145, (323) 969-4333, Fax (323) 876-4973, direct line for subscription inquiries (323) 969-4344.
Subscriptions: U.S. $50; Canada/Mexico $70; all other foreign countries $95 a year (remit international
Money Order or other exchange payable in U.S. $). Advertising: Rate card upon request from Hollywood
office. Article Reprints: Requests for high-quality article reprints (or electronic reprints) should be made to
Sheridan Reprints at (800) 635-7181 ext. 8065 or by e-mail hrobinson@tsp.sheridan.com.
Copyright 2014 ASC Holding Corp. (All rights reserved.) Periodicals postage paid at Los Angeles, CA
and at additional mailing offices. Printed in the USA.
POSTMASTER: Send address change to American Cinematographer, P.O. Box 2230, Hollywood, CA 90078.
6
One Look. All Speeds
The Cooke Look
NEW
T2.8
T1.4
T2.0
CookeOpticsLimited
British Optical Innovation and Quality Since 1893.
cookeoptics.com
T: +44 (0)116 264 0700
Canada, South America, USA:
T: +1-973-335-4460
OFFICERS - 2013/2014
Richard Crudo
President
Owen Roizman
Vice President
Kees van Oostrum
Vice President
Lowell Peterson
Vice President
Victor J. Kemper
Treasurer
Frederic Goodich
Secretary
Isidore Mankofsky
Sergeant At Arms
MEMBERS OF THE
BOARD
Curtis Clark
Richard Crudo
Dean Cundey
George Spiro Dibie
Richard Edlund
Fred Elmes
Victor J. Kemper
Francis Kenny
Matthew Leonetti
Stephen Lighthill
Michael OShea
Lowell Peterson
Owen Roizman
Rodney Taylor
Haskell Wexler
ALTERNATES
Isidore Mankofsky
Kenneth Zunder
Steven Fierberg
Karl Walter Lindenlaub
Sol Negrin
MUSEUM CURATOR
Steve Gainer
American Society of Cine ma tog ra phers
The ASC is not a labor union or a guild, but
an educational, cultural and pro fes sion al
or ga ni za tion. Membership is by invitation
to those who are actively en gaged as
di rec tors of photography and have
dem on strated out stand ing ability. ASC
membership has be come one of the highest
honors that can be bestowed upon a
pro fes sional cin e ma tog ra pher a mark
of prestige and excellence.
Backstage Equipment, nc. 8052 Lankershim Bl. North Hollywood, CA 91605 (818) 504-6026 Fax (818) 504-6180 backstaged@aol.com www.backstageweb.com
Come visit our showroom or call for our latest Magliner product catalog
We are the largest retailer specializing in Magliner customized products and accessories for the Film and Television Industry in the world
New York Showroom C.W..H. 364 W. 36th St. New York, NY 10018 (877)-Mr-CASTER (877-672-2783) backstage@cwih.com www.cwih.com
e are the largest retailer specializing in Magline WWe
Come visit our showroom or call for our latest Magliner product catalog
e are the largest retailer specializing in Magliner customized products and accessories for the Film and T
Come visit our showroom or call for our latest Magliner product catalog
elevision Industry in the world m and TTe
Come visit our showroom or call for our latest Magliner product catalog
o
E n 2 h o H h tt rr oo NN
h
. l B m i h s r e k n a L 55 00 8 . c n e , t n e mm p i u q E ee
N
g a t s k c a B
. t S tt 66 33 . WW 4 6 3 . H . . W . C m o o rr w oo hh S k r o YYo w e N
T
9 4 C a b
c
0 8 1 6 - 4 0 55 8) 8 1 88 (( x Fa F
6
6 2 0 6 - 4 0 5 ) 8 1 8 ( 5 0 6 1 9 AA
8
C , w d o o w yy
Y
l l o
c a b ) 3 8 7 2 - 2 7 6 - 77 ( 7 8 ( RR E T SS AA CC M - r M - ( ) 7 7 8 11 00 00 11 YY NN , k r o YYo w ee NN
o
b m o c . b e w e g a t s k c a b . m w w w m oo a c . l o a @@ d
m
e g a t s k c a
w o cc . h i w c . w c w w m o c . h i w c @ e g a t s k c
NEW! WORKSHOPS AND
8-WEEK FILM INTENSIVES
PHOTO CHRISTIAN TYLER RANDOLPH
WWW.MAINEMEDIA.EDU/INTENSIVE
8
A numbers of cinematographers have made the leap to
the directors chair, but ASC member Wally Pfister was
particularly well prepped to make his feature debut with
the sci-fi thriller Transcendence. His resume as a director
of photography includes a long string of complex
productions (including the Dark Knight trilogy and
Inception), but also lower-key dramas that demonstrate
his versatility (Laurel Canyon, Moneyball). On Transcen-
dence, Pfister recruited Jess Hall, BSC to help him make
the transition. I saw that Jess could be a collaborator
thematically and conceptually as well as visually, he
tells David Heuring (Second Life, page 30), adding, I
will always think about what the camera is doing its
instinctual by now. But certainly, having Jess lead this terrific crew enabled me to spend
more time focused on the actors and all the other concerns of a director.
Daniel Landin, BSC employed some very unique strategies while collaborating
with director Jonathan Glazer on another sci-fi project, Under the Skin (Alien Ways,
page 44). In her role as an extraterrestrial who preys on Scottish men, actress Scarlett
Johansson was required to drive around Glasgow in a van rigged with hidden cameras
that recorded her attempts to lure unsuspecting non-actors into the passenger seat. To
facilitate this approach, Landin employed new camera technology, as he explains in a
detailed Q&A with Iain Stasukevich: We shot about 60 percent of the movie with an
Alexa Plus, but the decision to go digital was really driven by the development of the
One-Cam, a small digital camera specifically invented for our film by Tom Debenham,
Louis Mustill and Arron Smith [at One of Us in London]. We used One-Cams to shoot
the driving scenes with Scarlett in such a way that we could hide the cameras whilst
shooting simultaneous reverses.
Connoisseurs of black-and-white imagery should certainly seek out Ida, the
Polish drama that won the inaugural Spotlight Award at this years ASC Awards cere-
mony. The honor is intended to call attention to great cinematography in non-main-
stream movies a description that aptly summarizes the stunning compositions and
artful lighting achieved by Lukasz Zal, PSC and Ryszard Lenczewski, PSC. (Zal, who
began the project as Lenczewskis camera operator, stepped up and shot most of the
picture when the cinematographer fell ill after one day of shooting.) In Benjamin
Bergerys coverage (Divine Purpose, page 54), Zal and director Pawel Pawlikowski
explain their aesthetic choices, with Zal noting, We wanted to build essential frames
that would have strong impact and speak about the space beyond the frame.
Other ASC Award winners and nominees appear in our annual pictorial on the
Societys awards-season events (A Festive Focus, page 71), while our coverage of the
Academys Scientific and Technical Awards (ASC Shines at Sci-Tech Awards, page 64)
spotlights several members and associates who were honored for their industry impact:
Peter Anderson, ASC, who received the prestigious Gordon E. Sawyer Award, and the
team that spearheaded the ASC Color Decision List: Curtis Clark, ASC; associate
members Lou Levinson, Joshua Pines and David Reisner; and David Register. Needless
to say, everyone at the ASC is extremely proud of their influential achievements.
Stephen Pizzello
Executive Editor
Editors Note
P
h
o
t
o
b
y
O
w
e
n
R
o
i
z
m
a
n
,
A
S
C
.
10
Now you can get incredible quality uncompressed SDI and HDMI video
capture and playback using removable solid state disks! HyperDeck
Shuttle is the perfect quality broadcast deck you can hold in your
hand. HyperDeck Shuttle lets you bypass camera compression for the
highest quality on set recording, and is perfect for digital signage or instant
replay and program recording with live production switchers. Video is
recorded to QuickTime
10 bit format
so you can use the media in Mac
and Windows
video software!
Use Cameras, Switchers and Monitors
With SDI and HDMI inputs and outputs,
HyperDeck Shuttle works with virtually every
camera, switcher or monitor! Plug into
televisions or video projectors for instant on set
preview or get exciting live action replay with
ATEM production switchers. Even use it for digital signage. Just press play
twice for loop playback! Imagine using pristine uncompressed recording
on your next live event!
Learn more today at www.blackmagicdesign.com/hyperdeckshuttle
HyperDeck Shuttle
$
345
FREE UPDATE
NOW WITH
Details surrounding the February death of second camera assistant Sarah Jones in Georgia
have been well documented, but something important has been lost in the reportage. The
facts, as theyve been related, describe a horrible and preventable tragedy. The public
outpouring of grief by individuals and groups connected to the camera department was
remarkable, but the fact that it came almost exclusively from us uncovered a dark secret
most of us have known for quite some time: This industry is in trouble, and I dont mean
economically, but spiritually.
From time to time, the late ASC legend William A. Fraker liked to hold court in the
Clubhouse bar and expound upon the early days of his career. Those were the good days,
he was fond of saying. You could feel the romance when you went to work. His emotion
was palpable, and those of us lucky enough to be there believed his every word. But look
a little deeper, and his sentiment becomes more than a nostalgic reference to the era of
highballs and unfiltered cigarettes. He was really talking about the feeling of family and
community that infused the movie business of his day.
According to Fraker, filmmaking collaborators showed a genuine caring for one
another that extended well beyond the workplace. Though a similar ethic may exist in
isolated pockets today, it bears no relation to its predecessor. There is no question that in
the 1940s and 50s, and even up to the 70s, society had a sharper understanding of what
was really lasting and meaningful in life. On the soundstages of 2014, its likely those
notions of warmth and common decency will prevail only as long as they can generate cold, hard cash.
I am by no means suggesting the past was rampant with peace, love and understanding. There were plenty of things wrong
with our culture then, and there was no way for Fraker to know it was already beginning to unravel. But if were honest, his gauzy
recollections force us to confront uncomfortable truths about how we think of and treat one another, even in the smallest of ways.
Have we lost our humanity? Just open a newspaper. For a view closer to home, consider the disdain with which so many
people deal with each other on the road, in the supermarket, at the ballpark and, dare I say, on set. Its almost as if narcissism
and a sense of entitlement have drained some people of the ability to see anyone as being like themselves. Those who make motion
pictures for a living work long and hard at jobs we love, sometimes making significant sacrifices along the way. But were not curing
cancer. Were not even curing a hangnail. Twisted individuals for whom money, power, ego and prestige are the ultimate goals,
however, treat the obsessive pursuit of these superficial rewards as being tantamount to conquering a fatal disease. As sad as this
reality is, it becomes frightening when you realize how pervasive the attitude has become.
I cant imagine that anyone associated with Midnight Rider wished for Sarah Jones to be killed while doing her job. Unless
theyre followed by corresponding action, good intentions mean nothing, and thats especially true in this case. The only people who
really know what attitudes led to this tragedy are those who were with her at the location that day. But if you think a certain loss
of humanity didnt play a primary role in what happened, you might be beyond saving yourself.
Will we just make note of Sarahs passing, bow our heads for a moment and then carry on? Or will we use it and I mean
really use it to effect genuine change in how we regard one another? Our behavior is the only thing in our lives over which we
have total control, and its vital to realize were all living on borrowed time. Our journey through this world goes by very quickly.
As directors of photography, we have always been responsible for the safety of our crews, and it is incumbent upon us to
find ways to be more decent and caring not only to them, but also to everyone we know. It wont always be easy; at times, it will
run counter to initial impulses. But if our example proves worthy, it might make a start toward curing the spiritual sickness I have
described. It would also stand as the most profound tribute any of us could offer to the memory of Sarah Jones.
Richard P. Crudo
ASC President
Presidents Desk
12 May 2014 American Cinematographer
P
h
o
t
o
b
y
D
o
u
g
l
a
s
K
i
r
k
l
a
n
d
.
A Cardboard Drama with Heart
By Mark Dillon
Movie characters that are superficially rendered are often
derided as cardboard, but the 11-minute silent movie Me + Her,
directed by Joseph Oxford and shot by Bradley Stonesifer, wrings the
gamut of emotions from actors and sets that actually are cardboard.
The short tells the story of Jack, a cardboard man grieving the
death of his mate, Jill. He contemplates ending it all with a lit match,
but then instead hops into a recycling bin bound for a box factory,
where he follows Jills body down a chute and into a shredder. Their
intertwined remains are scattered where a special tree once stood,
and a new one sprouts in its place.
Oxford reveals that the character of Jack was conceived for a
music video in 2007. I threw together available materials and came
up with a neat little puppet, he explains. These little cardboard
characters were going to strum guitars and bang on drums a
pretty straightforward performance video but then things fell
through with the band. However, I really liked the character design
and started to imagine what the rules of a cardboard world would
be, and how these characters would fit in.
Oxford wrote Me + Her in early 2009, and spent the next two
years building sets and characters in between gigs as a production
assistant and art director. He met Stonesifer while working on
projects directed by Lee Toland Krieger, and on the set of one such
project, the feature The Vicious Kind, he approached the cine-
matographer with his concept. Joey told me about this crazy world
he was coming up with, and I was all for it, Stonesifer recalls. We
figured out the visual style and general approach gradually, long
before getting anything on camera. The cinematographer and his
wife, Emily Bloom, became the projects lead producers through
their company, Island Creek Pictures.
Preproduction on Me + Her began in earnest in April 2013,
and the shoot (18 days of photography scheduled over six months)
took place in Los Angeles at The Escarpment studio and the Allen
Box Co. Because of limited storage space, the filmmakers had to
build and tear down sets on a regular basis. Sixteen puppeteers
manipulated the 15"-tall figures with rods, using wires to achieve
nuances such as the blinking of eyes. A through-line for the whole
movie was that it should look and feel handmade, which is why I
decided to leave the rods in frame, says Oxford.
After testing several cameras, including a Panasonic AG-
HPX500, an Arri Alexa, and Canon C300 and 5D Mark II cameras,
Stonesifer opted for a Passive Micro Four Thirds model Blackmagic
Cinema Camera. The Panasonic has a macro capability, so it would
have helped us get extremely close to the puppets and achieve vary-
ing focal lengths throughout the zoom, but its massive, and the
image quality wasnt what we wanted, explains the cinematogra-
pher. With both of the Canons, the sensor size was too large and
would have required more light for the depth-of-field we wanted.
And, based on our limited money, crew and equipment, we decided
moving an Alexa around 15-inch puppets was too daunting. The
Corrugated
constructs Jack
and Jill picnic
at magic hour
before Jill
suffers a tragic
fate in the short
film
Me + Her.
I
14 May 2014 American Cinematographer
P
h
o
t
o
s
a
n
d
f
r
a
m
e
g
r
a
b
s
c
o
u
r
t
e
s
y
o
f
t
h
e
f
i
l
m
m
a
k
e
r
s
.
Short Takes
image quality wasnt worth the sacrifice of
time and options. The comparatively light-
weight Blackmagic, he continues, rendered
images that held up on the big screen and
had an aesthetic Joey and I both liked.
Stonesifer used an MFT-to-PL-mount
lens adapter for most of the shoot, employ-
ing Arri/Zeiss Ultra Prime lenses, mainly a
20mm. With the [2.5K] sensor crop factor
of 1.6, when we put a 20mm lens on it, the
field of view was equivalent to what I was
used to seeing with a Super 35 32mm
lens, he notes. He occasionally used Canon
CN-E15.5-47mm and CN-E30-105mm
zoom lenses, which held up extremely well
beside the Ultra Primes. They were great for
moving a little quicker toward the end of
the shoot.
He used an EF model Blackmagic
Cinema Camera for a POV shot captured
with a Canon 100mm Macro IS USM lens:
Jack sees a recycling symbol on his bath-
room sink and gets the idea to go to the box
factory.
Stonesifer typically shot between a
T5.6 and T8. If youre shooting a human 6
feet away on a 50mm lens at T2 or T2.8,
youll have 4 to 6 inches of focus, he says.
If you want the same perceived focus on a
puppet 10 inches away, you have to stop
down substantially. He adds that he used
no lens filtration. We wanted to see the
texture of the cardboard.
Several tools were employed to
achieve the small-scale moves, including a
Dana dolly, 3' and 4' sliders, a VZQuickJib
and a 19' JimmyJib arm. Some shots were
handheld. In the box factory, the chute Jack
slides down was a 4'x4' set that was 14' tall
and featured removable side panels. To
maneuver in such a small space, the crew
used a Blackmagic Pocket Cinema Camera
and Super 16 Zeiss Super Speed prime
lenses. The full-sized Blackmagic cameras
captured in CinemaDNG raw to built-in SSD
recorders, and the Pocket captured in
ProRes 4:2:2 to SDXC cards. (The final
aspect ratio was 2.40:1.) Camera assistant
James Gustafson served as a part-time DIT.
We had the Pocket camera on a
monopod, out of which we ran a BNC
cable, explains Stonesifer. We were
converting the cameras HDMI signal to
HD-SDI for monitoring. We had a wireless
follow focus so the camera assistant could
16 May 2014 American Cinematographer
Top to bottom:
Jills death spurs
Jack to drastic
action;
puppeteers
maneuver the
actors in the
cardboard
hospital;
cinematographer
Bradley
Stonesifer (left)
supervises the
lighting over
Jacks home; a
recycling truck
rumbles past
Jack.
pull focus from the monitor. The cine-
matographer operated on that segment;
otherwise, he pulled focus and allowed
crew volunteers to operate the camera.
Stonesifer notes that the Blackmagic
Cinema Cameras 2.5K sensor helped with
the productions limited lighting budget,
because the largest instrument he needed
was a 5K Fresnel, which served as a sun
source.
The box-factory set was 24' long,
with fog machines blowing smoke out of
the stacks and a haze machine for interior
atmosphere. We had 750-watt Source
Four Lekos on dimmers outside the factory,
blasting through the windows to create a
strong edgelight, Stonesifer explains. For
the interior, we had a daylight-balanced
4-foot 4-bank Kino Flo gelled with Lee 245
[ Plus Green] overhead to give us an indus-
trial-looking fill. Then, we had Dedolights
raking the interior walls, creating a sconce
effect as a downlight, along with a LitePan-
els 1-by-1 LED. The mix of colors helped to
create contrast. Its a moody finale, dark and
gritty.
Most of the picture was created in-
camera, but Oxford animated the time-
lapse growth of a tree, and students at the
Pastilla Institute of Design extended a few
sets digitally, removed rafters from back-
grounds and added a city to the back-
ground of the final shot.
Aaron Peak of Hollywood DI served
as the projects colorist, on-line editor and
post coordinator. The goal of the final
grade was to accentuate the texture of the
cardboard pieces, bring depth and life to the
set pieces, and unify the images, says Peak,
who worked on a DaVinci Resolve. He ran
some image sequences through Adobe
Lightroom processing in search of that
unique and magical look, particularly for
the flashbacks showing Jack and Jills happy
life together.
Me + Her received its premiere at the
2014 Sundance Film Festival.
18 May 2014 American Cinematographer
Top and middle: Jack surreptitiously searches for Jills body. Bottom: Director Joseph Oxford (facing
camera) and the puppeteers block a romantic magic-hour setup.
t he r t of f i l m opt i c s
zoom lenses capture the dream.
Recognized around the world for their superior design and outstanding performance.
Available in 28-340mm, 19.5-94mm, 24-290mm, 15-40mm, 28-76mm and 45-120mm.
optimo
angenieux@tccus.com www.angenieux.com
20 May 2014 American Cinematographer
Road Work
By Jon D. Witmer
Written and directed by Steven Knight, Locke unfolds nearly
in real time as its title character (played by Tom Hardy) navigates a
veritable minefield of phone calls over the course of an 85-minute
nighttime drive. As Locke strives to keep a key business endeavor on
schedule, he also reveals to his wife that he has been unfaithful a
confession that threatens to destroy their life together. Although
Hardy is the only actor to appear onscreen, both sides of each conver-
sation are heard.
Locke is the first collaboration between Knight and cine-
matographer Haris Zambarloukos, BSC, who elected to shoot with
digital cameras in order to capture the nighttime driving along open
roads in and around London, England. Zambarloukos recalls that he
was sent the script by Locke producer Guy Heeley, a former assistant
director with whom he had worked on the features Sleuth (AC Nov.
07) and Death Defying Acts. Speaking with AC while enjoying a bit
of a break in Cyprus, Zambarloukos enthuses, I read the script,
which is probably one of the best Ill ever get to read, and I was like,
Please, sign me up!
American Cinematographer: Was it at all daunting to be
limited to one characters car, at night, for almost 90 minutes?
Zambarloukos: Oh, hugely daunting, but also liberating.
When we started talking about it, Steve asked, Do you ever drive at
night and get fascinated by color and light and the pulse of what
could possibly be going on behind each car windshield? We started
talking about [the film] as a kind of visual poem. More than anything
technical about how to shoot it, for me it was about, How can I be
a good servant to this human story?
How much prep time did you and Knight have
together?
Zambarloukos: Two to three weeks. It was quite intense.
First of all, Steve says, I want to do the whole performance every
night while driving from Birmingham to London. Thats the route
Locke takes along the M1, which is a very important highway in the
U.K, and it takes about an hour and a half. But then we were told
youre not allowed to film on a motorway in England anymore, so
we had to find permission from a road that could double for the
M1. We were both quite devastated that we couldnt do the Birm-
ingham-to-London route, but in retrospect, I was very lucky because
half or three-quarters of that route would have had no streetlights
whatsoever!
How many shooting days did you have?
Zambarloukos: We had eight nights to shoot. We had five
nights with Tom, and we needed to spend one shooting him getting
into the car and driving off from the construction site. In the end,
we decided to do three nights on a low-loader [process trailer] and
one night of Tom driving the real car, with us inside with two
cameras, so we could look through the windshield at the road. We
also did a couple of days of drive-bys and POVs, anything we could
do without Tom. We worked out that we could do two perfor-
mances every night, so I can actually tell producers I did 79 pages in
one day, because thats how long the script was! Tom put his entire
self into it, so he would be exhausted by 2 or 3 a.m., giving us about
four hours of shooting [each night]. Another reason for finishing by
Production Slate
U
n
i
t
p
h
o
t
o
g
r
a
p
h
y
b
y
K
e
r
r
y
B
r
o
w
n
.
P
h
o
t
o
s
a
n
d
f
r
a
m
e
g
r
a
b
s
c
o
u
r
t
e
s
y
o
f
A
2
4
.
Ivan Locke (Tom Hardy) weighs the consequences of his path as he drives from Birmingham to London in the feature Locke.
I
22 May 2014 American Cinematographer
2 or 3 in the morning was that after that,
the road emptied out. We couldnt afford
more picture cars, so almost everything you
see is a happy accident. We asked our police
escort to overtake twice, and we also had a
couple of vans for the rest of the crew. I was
on a walkie-talkie, and I would sometimes
ask the driver to come closer or put his
beam lights on to give us a [lens] flare.
Why did you choose a Red Epic?
Zambarloukos: I did a bit of Red
footage for the night-car work on Jack
Ryan: Shadow Recruit, so I went into Locke
with a little homework already done. Red
was definitely the right decision for Locke,
and I picked the Epic for its size its very
small and its great resolution. We shot
with three cameras [simultaneously], and
we predominantly rigged them to Lockes
car and not to the frame of the low-loader.
That made it feel a bit more like Tom was
driving. We recorded in 5K [at 5:1 compres-
sion to 256GB Red SSD cards], and we got
about 26 minutes per card. We did have a
problem with one card, and I dont know
what Red did with it its all black magic to
me but they managed to recover about
80 percent of the footage. It happens rarely,
but that is one of the challenges of digital.
I wanted all the dreamy nightscapes
you can create with Scope, so I used Panav-
ision C Series anamorphic lenses, which I
think soften digital in a way that seems very
filmic. I also picked the C Series based on
their bokeh as well as their resolution; that
was based on an assumption that they
would work well with out-of-focus lights
but still give sharp eyes, which they did. We
predominantly worked at 800 ASA, some-
times at 1,280, so I didnt really need a very
fast stop. To my eyes, T2.8-T4 is the
optimum for an anamorphic lens, in partic-
ular the C Series.
Did you favor any particular focal
lengths?
Zambarloukos: We stuck within
what I would say is [the range of] normal
human vision, 35mm to 100mm. We also
used a specialty lens. I really wanted to play
with focus, and I had [previously] asked Jim
Budd at Panavision U.K. if we could make
an anamorphic Lensbaby. He said, Youre
absolutely crazy, that cant be done, but
about a year later, he called me up and said,
Ive made it. Id say it was around 50mm,
but it was never locked off. We actually
undid the screws and some of the things
that hold it together and were constantly
having it mobile. Some of the extremely
weird, distorted, out-of-focus shots were
done on this Lensbaby with an anamorphic
element added on the back, a Jim Budd
Special.
Steve pushed me to get a lot of
reflections. Usually, you have to compromise
the composition to get the best reflections
off windshields, but Ive always been
intrigued by the two-way mirrors used in
3-D rigs, so I started experimenting with
putting a two-way mirror in front of the lens
and having it angled in a way that we could
Top: Lockes journey takes him away from a record-setting concrete pour he was to supervise,
and which he strives to keep on schedule via mobile phone. Bottom: 1st AC Ashley Bond (left)
and cinematographer Haris Zambarloukos, BSC ready one of the productions three
Red Epic cameras.
15, 20, 32 ... Introducing the 73 Hydrascope
Equipment that works in any environment
weather resistant and tough
LOCATIONS: California: 888 883 6559
New Mexico, Texas, Louisiana, Ohio & Florida: 888 758 4826
UK: +44 1 92 326 5953
TELESCOPING CRANES
With Stabilized Remote Camera Systems
CHAPMAN/LEONARD
Studio Equipment, Inc.
DOLLIES...
Super PeeWee IV
Part of the PeeWee series
Time Saving Camera Support for all your needs!
Hustler IV
Pedestals, Mobile Cranes, Arms & Bases
www.chapman-leonard.com
Ask about our Sound Stage in Florida
CHAPMAN/LEONARD
Studio Equipment, Inc.
24 May 2014 American Cinematographer
get better reflections from streetlights and
cars. That could be [anywhere between] 15
degrees or 65 degrees, and it only worked
if [the frame line was] within the wind-
screen or one of the side windows of the
car. If you saw off the car, it didnt work, so
what he sees. By amplifying the reflections,
you do that. If you start analyzing it, you see
that the reflections are going in the wrong
direction, but that was a risk we were will-
ing to take. We were quite abstract and
unapologetic about it.
How did you handle the two
sides of the phone conversations?
Zambarloukos: The mechanics of it
ended up being that we would shoot for
these four nights with Tom while our other
actors were in a couple of rooms in a hotel.
They would call in, and their [side of the]
conversations would be recorded live in the
hotel. What you hear is the actual voice
performances of Tom and the other actors
interacting live.
Where were you while filming?
Zambarloukos: We were allowed
only 12 people on the low-loader, so my
operator, Simon Baker, was on one camera,
with Shaun Cobley on focus; Ashley Bond,
my B-camera focus puller, manned and
focused the second camera; and the third
camera was locked off. I stayed on the truck
[that pulled the low-loader] with my gaffer,
Julian White, and we played with a small
dimmer [a GrandMA2 Command Wing
and PC laptop that sent a signal via a
LumenRadio wireless DMX transmitter/
receiver system] to control the LED lights we
had rigged to the car to augment what we
saw happening on the street.
What LEDs did you rig to the car?
Zambarloukos: We rigged four
Martin Stagebar [RGBAW] fixtures outside
we only used them when we felt it was
right. We had two of them, and my key
grip, Malcolm Huse, pretty much jerry-
rigged them with Cardellini Clamps. From a
story point, I was trying to say, I want to
look at Tom Hardy, but I also want to see
To help capture the play of light reflected on the cars windshield, Zambarloukos frequently employed
two-way mirrors rigged at varying angles in front of the cameras. With the effect, Zambarloukos notes,
I was trying to say, I want to look at Tom Hardy, but I also want to see what he sees.
26 May 2014 American Cinematographer
the vehicle, two on each side [from scaffold
box attached to the roof rack]. Then, we
had individual strips of warm and cool
LiteGear LiteRibbon LED strips positioned
discretely within the vehicle, one strip above
the sunshade and some behind the driver's
seat. I didnt need a lot of light because I
didnt want to burn out the effect of the
streetlights, but I did need to augment
within that surrounding. I chose RGB LEDs
so we could be quite specific [when match-
ing existing streetlights]. They were DMX-
able, and they worked off a 5K generator,
which was plenty for us. [The LiteRibbon
was battery-powered.] Chris Craig, who is
my usual dimmer-board operator, rigged
the dimmer for us. We programmed in
what the buttons and levers would do, and
we set certain chases, certain color
schemes, so if we were in a sodium-vapor
area, we could [tune the LEDs to] a sodium-
vapor look. Wed listen to [the dialogue],
and sometimes wed [base the lighting on]
what was happening on the road, and
sometimes wed go with what we were
hearing. We improvised. I think thats the
best way to do anything: know your script,
do a lot of testing, figure out a lot of things
in advance and then let go. Its like being a
jazz musician who knows his scales, chords
and what mode hes in, and then lets go.
Only through practice, rehearsal and
Top: One of two
BMW SUVs was
rigged on a
process trailer for
three nights of
shooting.
Zambarloukos
requested a
picture car with a
sunroof, which
really made a
difference, he
says. You see a
lot more
movement [of
light] because of
the sunroof.
Middle: Hardy
takes the wheel.
Bottom: Bond
and
Zambarloukos
prepare to shoot.
28 May 2014 American Cinematographer
preparation can you let yourself go and
improvise.
The film is bookended with
crane shots. The first reveals the
construction site and introduces Locke
as he gets into his car, and the last
moves off his car as he exits the motor-
way. What crane did you use for those
shots?
Zambarloukos: We used a 30-foot
Technocrane. Panavision and Panalux really
went out on a limb and helped us out with
this project. For as long as I can remember,
all the way back to my student projects, the
[parties] that have always donated time,
equipment and knowledge are the rental
companies. I believe theyve been sponsor-
ing the film industry for years, and they
should be thanked and praised for that. A
film like Locke was made with a lot of help.
People like Hugh Whittaker at Panavision
basically said, Youre lucky youre doing it in
eight days and in January, because [at that
time], you can pretty much have what you
want!
Did you work with a digital-
imaging technician?
Zambarloukos: Yes, Sophie Bagga-
ley from The Digital Orchard. She was back
at base camp, and she would download the
cards so we could re-use them. We made a
basic LUT, and I switched from RedColor3 to
raw to keep an eye on things, but I didnt
spend time grading on set.
Were you watching dailies
during production?
Zambarloukos: Absolutely. Justine
Wright is a superb editor. We sent her a lot
of footage, but she was very diligent and
could work in the daytime. Then, while we
were setting up [to shoot at night], I would
watch footage in the DIT trailer, and Justine
would come in and tell us how many angles
we had on everything, what seemed to
work and what we might need. Having her
check everything in the day with fresh eyes
was hugely helpful.
What was your goal in the final
grade?
Zambarloukos: It was mostly just
fine-tuning. We transcoded the 5K footage
to 2K DPX files, and we graded and did final
outputs at 2K. [Colorist] Rob Pizzey at
Company 3 in London set it up, and when
he had to leave for another project, I
finished the grade with [colorist] Trevor
Brown. Things transposed very quickly from
shot to shot. Certain performances repre-
sented the dominant mood Steve ended up
favoring, so you can pretty much count on
your two hands the number of shots that
actually made it into the film. That made it
a very quick grade to do. With a DI, I used
to work very hard on each shot until it was
perfect, slowly moving through a reel. But
what Ive started to do is go back to the way
I worked on a film print: I do a rough pass
as quickly as we can over the entire film,
then go back to the beginning and fine-
tune. That way, youre observing the mood
of the film as a complete picture. I find I do
a better grade this way, going from broad
strokes to the fine brush strokes.
TECHNICAL SPECS
2.40:1
Digital Capture
Red Epic MX
Panavision C Series
Top: The production utilized a 30' Technocrane for shots that bookend the film. Bottom: Zambarloukos
confers with director Steven Knight. The cinematographer recalls that he and Knight discussed Locke as
a kind of visual poem. More than anything technical about how to shoot it, for me it was about, How
can I be a good servant to this human story?
With Transcendence,
Jess Hall, BSC, envisions a
contemporary sci-fi tale for first-time
director Wally Pfister, ASC.
By David Heuring
|
Second
Li
f
e
30 May 2014 American Cinematographer
www.theasc.com May 2014 31
I
ts late January in a sound designers
dark room in Hollywood, and direc-
tor and ASC member Wally Pfister
is reacting to a series of provisional
sound effects that were created for a
scene in Transcendence that depicts the
growth of nanotechnology fibrous,
plant-like tendrils that spread over the
ground and up the support posts of solar
panels. Pfister asks for less insect-like
sound elements, and then approves of a
low-frequency rumble derived from a
rocket-engine roar. You know I love
the low frequencies, he says with a
smile, referring to his affinity for bass
guitar.
Transcendence, Pfisters feature-
directing debut, tells the tale of a termi-
nally ill scientist, Will Caster ( Johnny
Depp), whose consciousness makes the
leap from his dying body to a computer
and, eventually, the Web. His partner,
Evelyn (Rebecca Hall), and colleagues,
including Joseph (Morgan Freeman)
and Max (Paul Bettany), discover that
U
n
i
t
p
h
o
t
o
s
b
y
P
e
t
e
r
M
o
u
n
t
a
i
n
,
c
o
u
r
t
e
s
y
o
f
A
l
c
o
n
E
n
t
e
r
t
a
i
n
m
e
n
t
a
n
d
W
a
r
n
e
r
B
r
o
s
.
Opposite page: Artificial intelligence researcher Will Caster (Johnny Depp) communicates with his
wife and fellow academic, Evelyn (Rebecca Hall), after his consciousness is transferred from his body
to a computer. This page, top: Caster is questioned by an audience member during a conference
presentation. Bottom: Cinematographer Jess Hall, BSC meters a scene.
32 May 2014 American Cinematographer
with the transition, Caster gains terrify-
ing omnipotence. The science-fiction
tale unfolds not in a distant future, but
rather in the present day.
Pfister tapped English cine-
matographer Jess Hall, BSC to shoot
the picture. A graduate of Central Saint
Martins College in London, Hall has
shot such features as The Spectacular
Now, Hot Fuzz and Brideshead Revisited
(2008). Pfister says that in Hall, he saw
a cinematographer with a similar
aesthetic. I saw that Jess could be a
collaborator thematically and conceptu-
ally as well as visually. I knew we could
make the images strong.
In their earliest conversations,
Pfister and Hall focused on the more
intimate, less techy aspects of the script.
Hall observes, This isnt an out-and-
out technological sci-fi movie, and
Wally and I talked a lot about how to
create images that would feel tactile, not
sterile. Theres a very strong, dramatic
human element to this film, even
Second Life
Top: Evelyn comforts Caster as he begins succumbing to the terminal effects of radiation poisoning.
Bottom: Casters image appears on a monitor in a data-storage facility after he succeeds in transporting
his consciousness to the digital realm.
www.theasc.com May 2014 33
though Will, the protagonist, ceases to
exist in human form as we enter the
second act.
I also think its important that
the story is rooted in technological
development that is happening now,
continues Hall. Elements of the story
required a futuristic palette, but one
grounded in reality. Im a great admirer
of photojournalism, particularly The
Magnum Group, and Wally began his
career as a news cameraman. I think we
both connected with the idea of captur-
ing a palpable, tangible realism.
The dichotomy of organic vs.
synthetic guided the entire production,
which shot for about eight weeks in
Albuquerque, N.M., and four weeks in
Los Angeles. The main sets were built
at I-25 Studios in New Mexico under
the direction of production designer
Chris Seagers. Although Pfister
prepped for many months, his main
prep with Hall was about six weeks.
From the beginning, Pfister
Evelyn communicates with Caster from her apartment (top) and the data facility (bottom). All but a few
of the projections were captured in-camera. That was incredibly beneficial for the actors, and it also
meant that we were composing complete shots, says Hall. Finding ways to achieve these effects in
camera was a great challenge, but the results were visually exciting.
intended to shoot 35mm anamorphic
and finish with photochemical color
timing. As weve become more reliant
on technology, I think weve lost sight of
the fact that some technology can over-
complicate things and can cost a lot
more, and thats my analogy with digital
vs. film, says Pfister. Theres nothing
wrong with 35mm film; it didnt need
replacing. People simply thought that
digital capture was a cheaper way of
doing it. However, digital is more
complicated and, in some cases, it
requires a more expensive process.
Certainly, its not as reliable as film.
Also, film is higher resolution,
he adds. To capture all the resolution of
an anamorphic 35mm image, you need
a scan somewhere between 8K and 12K.
So while everyone brags about 4K
cameras and scans, were shooting on,
effectively, a 10K camera. Why replace
that with an inferior technology?
Hall chose two Kodak Vision3
negatives, 500T 5219 and 250D 5207,
which intercut really well, he says.
Between them, they dealt with every
extreme from harsh desert to a
completely black set, which was Evelyns
apartment. He avoided special process-
ing, noting, The locations and the
palette of the film are so diverse that I
didnt want to overcomplicate the
processing.
The productions A and B
cameras were Panaflex Millennium
XL2s, and Hall and his team also used
an Arri 235, an Arri 435 and a Vision
Research Phantom Flex. (The latter two
were for specific effects shots.) The
Panavision lens package comprised C
Series, E Series and High Speed
anamorphic primes, as well as some
Close Focus lenses, a T1.8 100mm and
a T2.8 25mm. The 25mm was used for
34 May 2014 American Cinematographer
Second Life
Top: Evelyn walks
the futuristic floor
of the Brightwood
Data Center, a set
built at I-25
Studios in New
Mexico. Production
designer Chris
Seagers designed
the set to facilitate
the use of multiple
projections on
glass, Perspex and
other materials
that would add
layers and depth
to the visual
design. Bottom:
Director Wally
Pfister, ASC
(center) works
through a scene
with actor Clifton
Collins Jr.,
A-camera operator
Scott Sakamoto
(at camera) and
visual-effects
supervisor Nathan
McGuinness (right).
www.theasc.com May 2014 35
POV shots of the machine [Casters
embodiment as artificial intelligence] as
seen through its surveillance devices,
and we also used it for some spectacular
desert vistas, one of which was captured
in a real storm, Hall notes.
As for camerawork, he continues,
The general analogy for our approach
was, The camera should find its own
place. By that I mean the camera
should find a point of view from which
to inhabit a scene, a perspective that
served the narrative without imposing
itself in a self-conscious display. In this
respect, Wally and I responded to the
actors, watching the rehearsal process
intensely, often from opposing angles.
During that process, I tried to feel the
inherent rhythm of a scene, its heart-
beat, and then to find a sequence of
shots to best express that. That might
involve any number of techniques from
a slow tracking shot to vigorous hand-
held, but they all derived from a moti-
vation to serve the narrative, to support
and capture the performance.
At the conceptual center of our
visual approach was the conflict
between the organic and the synthetic,
he adds. We allowed the tension and
potential incompatibility of these two
forces to inhabit our images in many
respects, from the choice of locations
and materials to decisions about
composition, color and contrast.
At the heart of the story is Wills
subterranean research facility, the
Brightwood Data Center, whose associ-
ated spaces include Evelyns apartment,
an incubating room and a data-storage
room. All of these sets were designed to
facilitate the use of multiple projections
on glass, Perspex and other materials
that would add layers and depth. The
projection concept also encompasses
Casters virtual presence as a live feed. A
separate booth was built for Depp so
that he and the other actors could inter-
act live during the shoot.
All but a few of the projections
were captured in-camera. That was
incredibly beneficial for the actors, and
Top: Casters colleague, Joseph (Morgan
Freeman), and an FBI investigator (Cillian
Murphy) are equally astounded by the
scientists digital reincarnation. Here he
appears on a monitor in the data centers
mainframe storage room. The filmmakers
used a variety of lighting tools, including
LiteGear LiteRibbon and Kino Flo Tubes, to
illuminate the shelving on the walls.
Bottom: Hall within a hall.
36 May 2014 American Cinematographer
it also meant that we were composing
complete shots, says Hall. Ive always
been inspired by the work of [artist] Bill
Viola, who projects imagery on various
materials, and Wally let me run with
that idea. In testing, we found a material
called Clearview that allowed us to
project onto glass whilst allowing the
material to remain reflective and semi-
transparent. We also found a type of
black Perspex that worked well. It was all
about getting the right balance with the
existing lighting. Finding ways to
achieve these effects in camera was a
great challenge, but the results were
visually exciting, and the integration of
projections into the initial photographic
process gave the film a distinct quality.
Because we were shooting film
and not doing a DI, we really had to
have a theory worked out, and that
meant color balancing all the projectors
and being really careful to maintain that
balance, Hall continues. It was quite
precise work. We mostly used Barco
HDF-W26 DLP projectors and Barco
HD20 FLM DLP projectors. All the
graphic material running through them
was controlled through a Dataton
Watchout system that enabled us to
manipulate multiple layers of projec-
tions quickly. It also gave us almost infi-
nite flexibility with the layering,
Second Life
Top left: Caster
emerges from
Brightwood amid
a field of solar
panels that
power the facility.
Top right: Depp
and Pfister confer
on the location.
Bottom: A wire
rig helps facilitate
an explosive
stunt performed
by Hall.
38 May 2014 American Cinematographer
resolution and positioning of the various
elements. However, ultimately, monitor-
ing the color balance of the projectors
and their material was done the old-
fashioned way, using a color-tempera-
ture meter, and finally by eye, utilizing
the knowledge of the process I had
gained during testing.
Two key environments featuring
the projections presented different chal-
lenges: an all-white lab, which is the
central room in Brightwood, and
Evelyns all-black apartment. The latter,
Hall explains, was partly a design deci-
sion [in that] it worked as a nice coun-
terpoint to the all-white lab. However, it
also has a meaning and a purpose within
the story. Its darkness presents a void
from within which Will reproduces
elements of his and Evelyns shared past
in the form of projections. Images from
their shared consciousness, dreams and
memories appear from within its dark-
ness alongside data monitoring the
activities within the facility and tracking
the world at large. So, the main chal-
lenge was about how to get light into the
set and a good quality of light onto the
actors without polluting the many
projections or creating reflections in the
multiple panes of glass, reflective floor
and ceiling it had a low [10'], black,
reflective ceiling and a highly reflective
black epoxy resin floor. Balancing all the
elements without destroying the mood
of the space was tricky.
Second Life
Top: Pfister (right)
surveys a scene
while perched
atop a Chapman
crane. Middle and
bottom: The
director and crew
coordinate
carnage for a fiery
action sequence.
The perfect interview.
Perfect for an interview.
. Enlighten your images with the outstanding Spectra LED lights
Spectra LED lights offer a range of power levels and beam angles for all
situations. The controllable output ensures accurate exposure and reproduction
of skin tones and color. Flicker-free technology gives peace of mind when
shooting in variable conditions and the long battery life or mains power option
make Spectra the essential choice for the videographer and photographer alike.
manfrotto.us
The apartment set has no
windows, and its walls consist largely of
back projections we created using
Stewart Filmscreen 150 RP material,
says Hall. There were 8-by-4-foot
panels of glass dividing the room into
various sections, and those also featured
projections.
I realized we had to bring light
in through the ceiling, he continues.
There were projectors coming through
the ceiling to project onto the glass, and
there was also significant rigging to
suspend the projectors above the ceiling
that limited our lighting options. Chris
Seagers and I collaborated to design
recessed apertures in the ceiling that
could accommodate lighting and
resemble practical fixtures if seen on
camera, and we cut various diffusion
panels and attached them with Velcro so
we could quickly exchange panels
depending on the size of frame; wed
bring the larger, thicker panels of diffu-
sion lower in frame for closer shots to
make the light spread more and soften
its quality further. It was problem solv-
ing, really a collaboration involving
Chris ingenious design, a lot of engi-
neering help from key grip Ray Garcia,
and thorough planning of our intended
shooting angles for the respective
scenes, says Hall.
The ceiling in the all-white lab
plays as a compositional element, and
was built with four 120' lines of light
that gaffer Cory Geryak created with
Par Bars: Par cans every 1
1
2' aimed
straight down from above through milk
Plexiglas and Lee 129 diffusion.
Tungsten sources meant consistent
color temperature, but the light was a bit
warm after passing through the Plexi
and the 129, so Geryak used Lee
CTB gels to bring it back to white.
Custom light boxes using Par cans and
2Ks were integrated into the ceiling
design; these illuminated the various
booths and cubicles where the
nanotechnology experiments take place.
Smaller panels also served as architec-
tural accents, and 1K Babies were posi-
tioned to shoot through narrow gaps
between the walls and the ceiling to
create hot lines of overexposed light.
The Par Bars were the most
cost-effective way to rig it, continues
Geryak, a longtime collaborator of
Pfisters who had also worked with Hall
on several commercials. We needed a
consistent color across the entire ceiling,
and that would not have been achiev-
able with Kino Flos. It required a lot of
channels and Socapex connections to
control because we wanted the ability to
shut off [some lights] to give more
modeling and create more contrast in
closer shots, as well as the ability to
create brownouts and flickers when the
data center is being destroyed later in
the story.
The data center is connected to a
mainframe storage room that features
multiple glass shelves running the
length of the space, creating a kind of
infinite corridor. The edges of the glass
40 May 2014 American Cinematographer
shelves emit light, created with
LiteGear LiteRibbon firing through
from behind. Some were turned off,
fracturing the lines in interesting ways.
Semi-reflective plastic and glass
elements were lit from behind with 4'
Kino Flo tubes gelled with Deep
Amber, a color that echoes the original
hard drives of the experimental project
Will developed at the university, says
Hall.
Casters terminal illness is the
result of a terrorist attack by Rift, an
anti-technology resistance movement.
A Craftsman-style bungalow in
Hollywood served as Rifts headquar-
ters, and Hall and his crew took a
simple approach to the location, which
presented many equipment restrictions
and a less-than-ideal sun path.
Cables were run from the house
to trees on the opposite side of the
Arrimaxes bounced into a 12-by-12
bleached muslin and then diffused
through a 12-by-12 Light Soft Frost to
sculpt the faces a little more. We added
some tungsten light inside the house to
add color contrast.
Hall says that in general, his
approach was to light so that Pfister
could change shooting direction
quickly and efficiently. An example is
the schoolhouse, a derelict building in
Albuquerque whose main room was
about 70'x40'. We needed to be able to
create different times of day in there
very quickly, says Hall. We had 18Ks
on cherry pickers coming through
windows on one side for hard daylight.
We also built a scaffolding structure so
we could black out quickly and shoot
night scenes. We built some structure
into the ceiling so we could light
quickly or tear it out for wider shots,
garden. Using a pulley system, various
textiles could be reeled over to cover the
scenes, which frequently involved inte-
rior/exterior transitions. At one point,
for a long dialogue scene, we created
dusk during the day by tenting with a
60-by-60-foot black silk that diffused
the daylight, says Hall. We effectively
turned harsh sunlight into soft, ambient
dusk light. This was also achieved by
shooting tungsten stock in daylight. I
used CTS to balance the daylight units,
which were predominantly lighting
faces, to around 4,600K, and that kept
the skin tones from becoming too blue.
As the sun path changed
throughout the day, I kept the ambient
light consistent by lighting through the
black silk with 18K Arrimaxes situated
on the roof, Hall continues. The light
was still quite toppy, so I added a
daylight-balanced book light, two 4K
Second Life
Armed troops burst through the doors of an Internet caf while executing a raid.
and there we used EB lights, strip lights
that Cory designed, and layers of hori-
zontal Chimeras that allowed us to
quickly get a backlight anywhere in the
room. It was all about being ready to
move fast and change direction quickly
whilst maintaining the quality of the
lighting.
Regarding exposure, Hall says, A
photochemical finish requires precision
and consistency. I knew we were going
to have very limited manipulation of
color and contrast in post. Changes in
exposure would equate to changes in
contrast and saturation on the print, and
I wanted shots to cut perfectly within a
scene. We did print dailies, which are
such a great and absolute register of
what youre doing with exposure. In
testing, I developed a set of lights that I
was very happy with, and then I tried to
maintain that.
There was definitely some very
low-light work, but because Wally and I
are not big fans of grain, we didnt want
to underexpose to the point of milky
blacks and grain, the cinematographer
continues. We found the point beyond
which we felt the film stock fell apart,
and we didnt underexpose below that.
But within those limits, I used under-
and overexposure as a musician
uses fortissimo and pianissimo, tech-
niques to implement a desired emotion
or mood. During testing, we also
found exactly where we liked to put
each actors skin tone in terms of expo-
sure, and that was rarely at key. On inte-
riors, we liked to work around T2.8-T4,
and on exteriors, between T5.6-T11,
depending on the focal length. But on
darker scenes, I was often underexpos-
ing the key light by 2 stops. I overex-
posed some of the sets that featured a lot
of white because we found they looked
better that way the whites became
cleaner.
For the visual effects, Pfister says
he asked for a very photographic
aesthetic from visual-effects supervisor
Nathan McGuinness and his team at
Double Negative, which employed an
all-4K workflow. Finished effects shots
were recorded back to 35mm film with
an Arrilaser and merged with the film
workflow. Nathans approach was to
interrupt the natural freedom of the
photography as little as possible, says
Hall. We tried to keep the lighting
integrated, to avoid the use of green-
screen, and to not restrict the use of
camera moves. Nathan did a great job of
making sure that the shots came out of
the digital platform with the right kind
of contrast and color so that they would
integrate smoothly with the rest of the
picture.
McGuinness emphasizes the
importance of designing the right
workflow. Of course, design and
conception are important, but before
our artists could do their work, we had
to create a pipeline in our facility that
would preserve the integrity of the piece
of film itself, from its origin all the way
to print. We had to make sure that what
we saw in that film was what we gave
back once we were finished with it.
When youre doing a full film finish, the
color timing doesnt have the same flex-
ibility of a digital grading system, so I
had to be very careful about the color
management. One very important
consideration was the organic molding
of that digital creation as it is transposed
to film that amazing little bit of
magic that occurs when you go back to
negative.
Hall says he relished the chance
to do a traditional photochemical
finish. I am increasingly aware of the
subtle shifts that occur in the image
within the DI process, and I have been
dissatisfied with some results, so I
grabbed this opportunity when Wally
Second Life
Pfister consults
with Depp in
the virtual
world.
42
suggested it. I just thought it was a great
chance to do something very pure.
The picture workflow chiefly
involved FotoKem in Burbank and
Technicolor in Hollywood. FotoKem
processed the productions negative and
created print dailies (timed by Don
Capoferri), and Technicolor then
scanned those to create HD dailies,
which were graded by colorist Stephen
P. Arkle, one of Pfisters longtime
collaborators. FotoKem colorist (and
ASC associate member) Mato Der
Avanessian supervised the photochemi-
cal timing of the IP and 35mm release
prints. The IP was then scanned at 4K
at Technicolor for the final digital
outputs and for a stereoscopic conver-
sion by Stereo D. Technicolor created a
4K DCP for standard exhibition and a
4K DCP (timed at 22-footlamberts) for
Imax exhibition, and Arkle did the 3-D
color mapping on the 4K DCP for
stereoscopic exhibition. Show prints
were made from the original cut nega-
tive, and about 200 release prints were
made from an IN, all on Kodak Vision
2383, according to Pfister.
Looking back on the experience
of making Transcendence, Geryak says
that Pfisters wealth of experience as a
cinematographer made for a very effi-
cient shoot and a great-looking picture.
Often, directors are so focused on
performance or coverage that time-of-
day becomes secondary, but Wally knew
how to schedule our days around the
light, even as he was concentrating on
directing, says Geryak. When the
look of the movie is important to the
director, it shows.
Cinematographers never stop
thinking in images, Pfister says. Even
when Im directing, I will always think
about what the camera is doing its
instinctual by now. But certainly, having
Jess lead this terrific crew enabled me to
spend more time focused on the actors
and all the other concerns of a director.
I did feel the need to put the camera on
my shoulder every now and again just
for the fun of it, because shooting action
is so much damn fun! Aside from that,
it was Jess baby, and I just helped out
where I could.
TECHNICAL SPECS
2.40:1
35mm Anamorphic and
Digital Capture
Panaflex Millennium XL;
Arri 235, 435;
Vision Research Phantom Flex
Panavision C Series, E Series,
High Speed, Close Focus
43
D
irected by Jonathan Glazer and shot by Daniel Landin,
BSC, Under the Skin is a hallucinatory journey in which
an alien being (played by Scarlett Johansson) masquer-
ades as a human and cruises the Scottish countryside in
a van, picking up strangers from the side of the road in order
to harvest their muscle fiber for her extraterrestrial employers.
In time, she becomes comfortable in her human skin, and
soon finds herself preyed upon by her quarry.
In depicting an alien adrift in the human world, the film-
makers went to great lengths to hide their own presence. The
result is an immersive drama that reflects upon the best and
worst aspects of humankind.
American Cinematographer: The production notes
describe Under the Skin as existential science fiction, which
brings to mind films like Solaris and 2001: A Space Odyssey.
Did you look to other films or filmmakers for inspiration?
Daniel Landin, BSC: Reflecting back on our discussions
in prep a long time ago! Jonathan and I were inspired by
Akira Kurosawas Ran and Dersu Uzala and Mikls Jancss My
Way Home, and more generally by Andrei Tarkovskys Andrei
Rublev and Mirror and Sergei Paradjanovs Shadow of Forgotten
Ancestors. Fundamentally, though, our greatest inspiration came
from the fantastic landscape, both rural and urban, in which we
were filming. Jonathan wanted to put an alien character in a very
real environment, and putting a Hollywood star in a city like
Glasgow was the nearest thing to an alien we could get!
Alien Ways
44 May 2014 American Cinematographer
Daniel Landin, BSC goes
undercover to create other-
worldly ambience for the eerie
sci-fi drama Under the Skin.
By Iain Stasukevich
|
www.theasc.com May 2014 45
Glasgow is an energetic city and has its
own intense pride. Although there has
been prolonged industrial decline and
hard times, there is still vitality and a
direct engagement [that is] less
common in London. People are less
guarded, and we were able to work with
a lot of non-actors who werent aware of
the film industry and had little desire to
engage with it. We wanted to be very
discreet about getting in, shooting and
leaving without affecting that too much.
Would you say the story is told
from the aliens perspective, or is it
more of an objective experience?
Landin: One of the challenges
was to capture her gaze, which is devoid
of subjectivity because she has none. At
the beginning of the film, she doesnt
have any emotional connection to the
landscape or her human body, and she
doesnt react to beauty or violence, and
we wanted our cameras to convey that
objectivity. Then, as the film progresses,
human emotion starts to corrupt her
vision, and also ours. She starts to learn
how to see more like a human, a condi-
tion which can only lead to her demise.
We understand you used a new
camera, the One-Cam, along with an
Arri Alexa. Tell us more about those
choices.
Landin: We shot about 60
percent of the movie with an Alexa Plus
[capturing in ArriRaw to a Codex
recorder], but the decision to go digital
was really driven by the development of
the One-Cam, a small digital camera
specifically invented for our film by Tom
Debenham, Louis Mustill and Arron
Smith [at One of Us in London] after
we had tested all the other compact
cameras. The One-Cam has a Super
16-sized [1" diagonal] 2.7K CCD
sensor, which we cropped at 1.85:1,
though its native ratio is more like
1.66:1. Once we had a prototype, we
shot extensive tests for resolution and
lens options. Our first AC, Nathan
Mann, then worked with Movietech,
our camera-rental house, to take the
basic unit and make it more roadworthy.
Tom also designed a custom look-up
table for us in the interest of being truer
to the way the One-Cam saw things
and replicating monitoring/rushes/edit.
Preserving saturated reds was an impor-
tant part of this decision. We used One-
Cams to shoot the driving scenes with
Scarlett in such a way that we could hide
the cameras whilst shooting simultane-
ous reverses. Whilst testing, we were so
pleased with the One-Cam image that
we considered shooting the entire film
on it, but there wasnt enough time to
make it rugged enough for general
shooting in our more hostile environ-
ments.
Tell us more about your hidden-
camera setups in the van.
Landin: Jonathan didnt want to
stage and restage action for the camera,
so it was crucial to put the cameras in
the right places so that things would
unfold naturally. Production designer
Chris Oddy redesigned the vans dash-
board so we could conceal eight One-
Cams in it. The cameras were small
enough to be in each others shots, so we
had a front-
3
4 camera both for driver
and passenger, two cameras concealed
behind the headrests, one wide two-
shot mounted in the center of the dash-
board, one camera shooting from
behind the steering wheel on a medium U
n
i
t
p
h
o
t
o
g
r
a
p
h
y
b
y
N
i
a
l
l
O
B
r
i
e
n
.
A
d
d
i
t
i
o
n
a
l
p
h
o
t
o
s
b
y
D
a
n
i
e
l
L
a
n
d
i
n
.
A
l
l
i
m
a
g
e
s
c
o
u
r
t
e
s
y
o
f
A
2
4
.
Opposite page:
An emotionless
extraterrestrial
(Scarlett
Johansson) takes
the form of a
human female in
Under the Skin.
This page, top:
While cruising the
Scottish
countryside
seeking men to
seduce and
process, the
alien meets a
disfigured recluse
starved for
physical contact.
Bottom:
Cinematographer
Daniel Landin, BSC
surveys a seaside
setup.
46 May 2014 American Cinematographer
close-up of the driver and the equivalent
on the passenger, and one camera with a
6mm PL-mounted Zeiss Super Speed
Super 16 lens shooting through an 18-
inch optical flat set into the metal parti-
tion separating the cabin from the rear.
We also had a ninth One-Cam that
could be rigged outside or used for other
angles.
Did you run all the cameras at
the same time?
Landin: They were all going at
once, with a [2336x1752 uncompressed
12-bit] raw data feed to the back of the
van. There were six of us in the back:
Jonathan, me, assistant director Nick
Heckstall Smith, sound mixer Nigel
Albermaniche, DIT Mark Purvis and
One-Cam tech Arron Smith. We were
able to shoot 26 minutes of continuous
takes on each camera.
How were the One-Cams
configured?
Landin: The camera is the size of
a big box of matches, and on most of
them I used C-mount Super 16
Schneider Cinegon and Xeno/
Xenoplan lenses in 16mm, 25mm,
35mm and 50mm focal lengths to
complement the Zeiss Super Speeds we
used on the Alexa. For some One-Cam
shots, I used Kowa [8mm, 12.5mm,
16mm, 25mm and 50mm] lenses,
though we found during testing that
they had a lower resolution and
performed substantially less well wide
open. In spite of the One-Cams size, its
image quality was in many ways more
cinematic than that of the Alexa.
How so?
Landin: Tom Debenham de-
signed the cameras color interpretation
with a more filmic curve than that of
the Alexa, which is essentially an excel-
lent image gatherer to which one can
apply a look later. So, in a sense, using
the One-Cam was more like shooting
reversal [stock] than negative.
What was your overall approach
to lighting?
Landin: We pursued a very natu-
ralistic kind of light, working with a soft
palette of overcast skies and urban
sodium. The light in Scotland from
October to December was very mono-
chromatic, with the low sun generally
obscured by fast-moving clouds.
Constant moisture in the air puts a
shine on everything, but in the muted
light, the asphalt looks stark and lunar
rather than slick.
Did you rig any lights inside the
van?
Landin: A few, but we always
kept the light level low enough to use as
much available light as possible. My
Alien Ways
Top: The aliens
resolve is reflected
in the stony
expressions she
adopts between
encounters.
Bottom: The
huntress mimes
human charm as
she entices her
victims. Most of
the men who play
the aliens pickups
were unaware they
were being shot
with hidden
cameras positioned
strategically
in the van.
www.theasc.com May 2014 47
gaffer, John Colley, worked with Steve
Howard at Panalux to design ultra-slim,
lightweight LED panels in 5-by-20-
inch sections of tungsten and daylight,
and 10-by-2-inch RGB batons to simu-
late traffic lights. Picture-car coordina-
tor Terry Smith rewired the interior
cabin light, and everything was fed back
to dimmers that I could control live at
the rear of the van. Our aim was to be
able to shoot continuously on all
cameras and adjust lighting levels with-
out having to interrupt performances
by anyone traveling with Scarlett. All
the lighting, video and computing
equipment drew a substantial amount of
power, which required the van to tow a
small, silent generator. That gave
Scarlett another challenge, along with
driving on the wrong side of the road,
acting and improvising with non-actors!
Were her passengers really
unaware they were being filmed?
Landin: Many of them. They
were guys Scarlett picked up on the side
of the road and lured in, and they only
found out what was going on after
theyd climbed out of the van and
production chased them down to have
them sign release forms!
Was one of your goals to make
the alien look as seductive as possible?
Landin: The seduction is all
Scarletts performance. Using a beguil-
ing light on her would have been
counter to our principles. The camera
was allowed to linger on her actions and
absorb them without passing judgment,
although I cant swear there was never
any flattering light on her, of course.
The goal was not to just show up and
switch the camera on, but to create a
cinematic representation of reality. We
wanted to use what was found but shape
and author it to drive our story.
Were you always working incog-
nito?
Landin: When we had control
over a location, like the beach or the
forest, we didnt need to hide the
camera. When we went into the public-
housing estate or the mall, we tried to
disguise our presence so our non-actors
would remain unaffected by the shoot.
The public-housing estate where the
alien gets attacked by a group of guys
was located in a fairly derelict part of
town, and the streetlights had been
vandalized. Because we were filming
from all angles as Scarlett drove into the
location, we couldnt have a whole elec-
trical department on the side of the
road. John Colley developed some
covert sodium lights with practical-elec-
trical expert Joe McGee, and these were
After being
lured to a
desolate
location, the
men are trapped
in a mysterious
liquid substance
so their muscle
can be
harvested.
48 May 2014 American Cinematographer
wired to the top of the destroyed lamp-
posts. Most of the lighting ended up
being in shot, so it had to look like it was
practical.
What were your lens stop and
ISO rating for the night scenes?
Landin: At night, we mostly
worked wide open on the One-Cams,
rating them at 800 ISO, which was
pushing them about a third of a stop.
We had to set our light levels to the
existing lamps, and Glasgow is not a
brightly lit city in general. The C-
mount lenses in particular were difficult
in that respect because they were slower
than the Super Speeds, and all of them
were rendered in f-stops rather than T-
stops. The Schneiders were generally
f1.8 and the Kowas f1.6, but the Kowas
lost resolution wide open.
How did you shoot the mall
scenes without being noticed?
Landin: We got permission to
shoot at the Buchanan Galleries and
were there at the busiest time of day on
a Saturday. We prepped the One-Cams
in a back room and had a number of
operators, including me, operating
cameras that were hidden in mop buck-
Alien Ways
www.theasc.com May 2014 49
ets, safety cones and shopping bags.
Our A-camera operator, Stuart Howell,
had a jacket over his arm concealing a
handheld One-Cam with a 16mm
prime lens and a Kenyon KS-6 gyrosta-
bilizer. He was able to follow Scarlett
through the crowd of people, who were
completely unaware of our presence.
Tell us about the locations you
used for the scenes that show the
aliens native environment.
Landin: We chose derelict
Victorian buildings in secluded areas for
the transitional moments where we go
from hard reality to an alien space. One
of the principles of these locations is
that the aliens allure allows her to
engage these men even though their
common sense and the viewers
might be telling them, Dont go in
there! The mens drive for what shes
offering outweighs the danger they
sense. You see that particularly with her
last victim; she has to work harder to
draw him into her web.
How did you create the alien
environment?
Landin: On Stage 8 at Elstree
Studios, Chris Oddy laid an 80-foot-
Opposite page, top and middle: Inside the van, the crew rigged compact cameras in hidden
positions to capture the interactions between Johansson and her passengers from a variety
of angles. The pictured setup shows two One-Cams with PL adapters and 16mm Zeiss Super
Speed lenses rigged to shoot through an 18" optical flat mounted in the vans steel partition;
one camera was equipped with a 6mm lens to capture a wide over-the-shoulder angle, and
the other with a 25mm trained on the rearview mirror. During filming, these cameras were
shrouded in black cloth. Other cameras, mounted in the vans dashboard and other spots,
were equipped with 1" and 1.3" Schneider C-mount lenses and 1" Kowa SWIR lenses. This
page, top: The filmmakers monitored the action from the back of the van. Both pages,
bottom: Manning the mobile base with Landin, were (from left) 1st AD Nick Hextall-Smith,
production sound mixer Nigel Albermaniche, director Jonathan Glazer, DIT Mark Purvis and
One-Cam engineer Arron Smith.
50 May 2014 American Cinematographer
long black glass floor in panel sections,
into which was sunk an 8-foot-deep
tank filled with black, Methocel-based
liquid. The liquids surface was at the
same height as the black glass, so the
men were able to step from one panel to
the other. They were then lowered 7 feet
on hydraulics into the liquid by Asylum
[Models & Effects] a very frighten-
ing descent! Jonathan was very specific
that he didnt want to do a lot of CGI,
that everything should be done in-
camera if possible. So the wide shots of
Scarlett and the men were done in two
passes: one with Scarlett walking back-
ward on glass, and one with the men
walking forward into the black liquid.
We kept the camera in one position so
we could maintain the same perspective,
and then the screen was split in the edit.
How did you light those scenes?
Landin: We used two overhead
light boxes, with 36 double-black-
skirted 4.8K space lights in each truss
frame, to toplight the actors. These were
kept at 8-foot centers, with egg crates on
the bottom to keep the light from
spilling sideways. They were all
programmed so that when necessary,
the toplight could move with the actor
so it wouldnt be in the back of the shot
as the camera moved. The shots in the
liquid were done by underwater special-
ist Mark Silk at the Underwater Studio
in Basildon. It was important that those
sequences didnt feel like they were
actually filmed in water; the substance
beneath the surface is more like an
unknown gas. For The Swimmer,
prosthetic-effects artists at Asylum
made a wig of steel wire so his hair
wouldnt sway in the water. We filmed
at 25 fps, 33 fps and 50 fps, creating a
similar toplight with underwater Kino
Flos so we wouldnt get a ripple effect in
the lighting.
Once the alien leaves Glasgow
for the Highlands, the films scope
broadens, but the environments, such
as the castle and the Quiet Mans
home, become more solitary.
Landin: Our location manager,
Eugene Strange, really strove to get to
the right locations rather than ones that
were just handy for the unit. In a lot of
cases, the local crewmembers were
going to places theyd never been before!
Jonathan felt very strongly that we
should let the actors react to their envi-
ronments, so our approach with the
Quiet Mans home was very much
driven by the kind of man who would
have lived there. It was a very small
house, and one of our conditions was
that we wouldnt alter a place any more
than we had to. The house possessed
certain qualities that we wouldnt have
necessarily chosen on our own, so the
limitations ended up informing our
visual style.
In what ways?
Landin: We were inspired by the
practicals, even though they werent
always the only sources for filming. We
were emulating what we found in the
kitchen, the living room and the
bedroom. Authenticity triumphed over
beauty in a good way. In the living-
room scene when theyre watching TV,
we could have really played with the TV
Alien Ways
Top: Vehicle supervisor Ben Dillon (seated) prepares for a shot with Purvis and A-camera
operator Stuart Howell. All of the motorcycle POVs were shot with One-Cams mounted to the
bikes handlebars or rear fenders. They were very small and didnt compromise the rider in any
way, says Landin. Bottom: For scenes shot at the Buchanan Galleries shopping center, the crew
operated One-Cams hidden in shopping bags, mop buckets and safety cones. Pictured (from left)
are 2nd AC Simon Surtees, Howell, Smith and One-Cam technical supervisor Louis Mustill.
effect, but instead we looked at the way
the room was actually lit. It had a stark
overhead source, so we just put a small
1K Rifa exactly where that fixture was.
For the bedroom scene thats lit with an
electric-bar fire, we first looked at how
the heater lit the room, and then we
worked out a gel package that was the
same color and tone as that light. What
you see, exposure wise, is 30 percent the
heater and 70 percent a single 2-foot
Kino Flo tube gelled with Flame Red
and CTO.
As the story unfolds, the alien
encounters increasingly hostile envi-
ronments, such as the castle and the
forest. Were they equally hostile in
terms of logistics?
Landin: Tantallon Castle was
chosen specifically because its old and
dramatic, but not very pretty. In a way,
the weight of that historical architecture
is informing the alien about mankind.
The location itself was incredibly hostile
toward filming! Rather than bring in
any lighting, we had to be careful about
where we put the actors. One scene was
filmed in a narrow 15th-century stone
staircase, and Stuart had to shoot with a
handheld Alexa while walking back-
ward down this incredibly tight spiral.
That was one of the scenes where we
were losing light on a very short day.
The forest in Drimsynie was also a
hostile place to film because it was dark,
cold and muddy. Again, we had short
daylight hours, and the amount of light
that actually penetrated the forest was
very minimal, even at midday. In fact,
Alien Ways
After meeting a kind man who provides her with shelter, the extraterrestrial begins to
experience emotional stirrings.
52
during the scouting period, after wed
earmarked the areas we wanted to work
in, our greensman, Roger Holdman,
removed the tops of the trees to give us
enough daylight for a proper exposure.
We had lights with us, but nearly all of
our work was done in natural daylight,
so we prepped and wrapped in the dark-
ness to maximize our shooting time.
The Alexa was generally set at 800 ISO,
and wed increase that to 1,600 as we
began to lose the light. But even in the
daytime, we were wide open.
What was your focus in the final
grade? Were there any surprises with
the One-Cam?
Landin: The One-Cam image
was a little less sharp than that of the
Alexa particularly with the lenses we
used but in a way that we liked. The
highlights fell off in what felt like a
more filmic way; they didnt feel like
they were clipping even as the camera
was moving past a streetlamp. We had
to get [the look] right on the day
because there wasnt a wealth of [image
information] we could plunder in post.
The One-Cam has its limits, but it got
us action we could never have got other-
wise and drove the films entire visual
style. We did the grading at One of Us.
First, Tom Debenham who also
served as our second-unit director and
visual effects co-supervisor [with
Dominic Parker] did an initial pass
on the Alexa footage to bring it into
line with the One-Cam footage, using
a combination of proprietary tools to
generate LUTs and then doing the color
correction in [Baselight] Truelight.
Then, colorist John Claude did the final
grade. The final output was 2K.
Ive always felt that cinema is
defined by the impact of the whole, not
by technical definitions. Each medium
has its own character, and, as a cine-
matographer, I should be open to all
options, including rejecting those on the
shelf. Filmmakers should be able to use
whatever it takes to create that epic and
intoxicating feeling you get when you sit
in the cinema. A low-resolution, pixel-
ridden image can achieve as much as
65mm if the emotional effect is the
same. Under the Skin offered us all the
rare opportunity to work with a director
who demanded we stretch our ideas
about cinema beyond the confines of
what we already knew, and pushed us
beyond the comfort zone of conven-
tional filmmaking.
53
TECHNICAL SPECS
1.85:1
Digital Capture
Arri Alexa Plus;
One of Us One-Cam
Zeiss Super Speed;
Schneider Cinegon,
Xeno/Xenoplan; Kowa
54 May 2014 American Cinematographer
Ida, an ASC Award winner
shot by Lukasz Zal, PSC, and
Ryszard Lenczewski, PSC, tells
its story with artful
black-and-white images.
By Benjamin B
|
P
awel Pawlikowskis Ida has captured some notable awards
for its cinematographers, PSC members Lukasz Zal and
Ryszard Lenczewski, including Camerimages Golden
Frog and the inaugural ASC Spotlight Award (created to
recognize outstanding cinematography in a non-mainstream
fiction or documentary feature). Set in the early 1960s, the
black-and-white drama focuses on Ida (Agata
Trzebuchowska), a young novice in a Polish convent who is
preparing to take her vows to become a nun. The Mother
Superior sends Ida out into the world to meet her aunt,
Wanda (Agata Kulesza), who sent people to their deaths as a
judge during the Stalinist era, and who now leads a dissolute
life. When they meet, Wanda abruptly informs Ida that she is
Divine Purpose
www.theasc.com May 2014 55
F
r
a
m
e
p
u
l
l
s
a
n
d
p
h
o
t
o
s
c
o
u
r
t
e
s
y
o
f
M
u
s
i
c
B
o
x
F
i
l
m
s
.
Jewish, and that her parents died during
the war in mysterious circumstances.
The two women set out to inves-
tigate the deaths with the hope of find-
ing the couples graves so they can pay
their respects. Their journey takes them
to the Polish countryside, where they
gradually uncover anti-Semitism and
war crimes, and over the course of their
travels, the two women become very
close.
Though Ida is centered on the
unlikely bond between a disenchanted
Stalinist judge and her innocent niece,
the film is above all about identity and
faith, says Pawlikowski. What was
great about making the film was that I
managed to put a lot of themes into it,
and then managed to lose them in the
story. Thats how I think art should
work; it shouldnt be explanatory or
didactic or illustrative. Ida is a film that
tries to hover above the ground some-
how. Its set in a certain historical time
and place, but I wanted it to be about
universal things about the spirit and
the mind. I wanted it to be a spiritual
journey, or about the lack of one.
With a laugh, the director
concedes that a black-and-white Polish-
language film about a Jewish nun was
not an easy sell. In the end, he secured
modest funding from Polish and other
European sources. It was kind of liber-
ating not to expect anything commer-
cially or critically to be able to do
what I wanted to, but with little money,
he says.
For the cinematography,
Pawlikowski turned to Lenczewski,
who had shot his first three features.
Lenczewski spent months prepping Ida,
scouting locations and taking thousands
of stills, but he fell ill after one day of
shooting, so Pawlikowski asked Zal, the
camera operator, to take his place. (Zal
and Lenczewski share a long history.
Zal was Lenczewskis teaching assistant
at the National Film School in Ldz,
and worked as his operator on several
films.) Lenczewski returned to Ida
briefly to shoot a few scenes, notably the
first nightclub scene and the discovery
of a grave in the woods, but Zal shot
Opposite page:
Novitiates prepare
to take their vows
in Ida. This page,
top and middle:
Ida (Agata
Trzebuchowska,
right) learns that
she has an aunt
and leaves the
convent to meet
her. Bottom:
Director Pawel
Pawlikowski (left)
and
cinematographer
Lukasz Zal, PSC
on set.
56 May 2014 American Cinematographer
most of the picture. Lukasz replaced
me perfectly, notes Lenczewski. He is
a talented, sensitive guy.
Inspired by his familys old photo
albums, Pawlikowski wanted to frame
Ida in 1.33:1, which led him to choose
an Arri Alexa with a 4:3 sensor. (The
monochrome Alexa had not yet been
introduced, so the picture was shot in
color and desaturated in post.) The
filmmakers used Arri/Zeiss Ultra
Prime lenses and captured in ArriRaw
to a Codex recorder. The equipment
was provided by Panavision Poland.
Zal says the main challenge with
the Alexa was to find the right density
for darkness to be just on the edge of
visibility and achieve the proper effect
on set. He adds, The Alexa performs
great at its maximum latitude and with
high underexposure, when the picture is
almost about to break. It looks less digi-
tal that way.
Pawlikowski recounts that he set
out to make an anti-film, without
using camera moves or conventional
cinematic techniques. At the root of
Ida was a desire to make a film with
nothing but the essentials, he says.
Maybe its my midlife crisis, but I feel
Ive been seeing too many similar films
that have little to say, and that use the
same old bag of tricks, where camera-
men are hired because of a style they
used on a previous film. There are very
few films where the form has some-
thing to do with the content, possibly
because there is often little content.
Idas form was designed to be as
unadorned as possible. Almost all the
shots are locked off, so the few shots
that feature moves have that much
more impact. There is no traditional
coverage. Zal describes the approach as
creating scenes with posters wide,
static frames that enclose the characters
and convey the story and mood. Some
scenes unfold in single long takes,
whereas others are broken down into
two or three austere shots. When
Wanda tells Ida she is Jewish, there are
just three shots: a lengthy wide shot, a
shot of Ida, and a close-up of a family
photo.
Divine Purpose
Ida and her aunt,
Wanda (Agata
Kulesza), pause
on their journey
for a moment of
prayer. Part of
the filmmakers
strategy was to
frame the
characters with
wide, static
compositions
that would
convey the story
and mood.
www.theasc.com May 2014 57
I wanted the viewer early on to
get used to the fact that hes not going to
be guided to look at one thing, then
another, explains Pawlikowski. There
are a lot of wide shots, so the eye has to
get used to that. You have to really
watch the film. Because the photogra-
phy is strong, each image is really felt.
Some viewers think its just a lot of
pretty shots, but theres a lot of emotion
in each composition. My ideal viewer
realizes the images are as emotional as
the performances, and as charged.
Reducing the number of shots
required more work on each shot and
more takes. There is often something
happening in the background or fore-
ground, or in the sky, and when you put
everything in one shot, it all has to work
together you cant cut your way out of
trouble, says Pawlikowski. So, I often
shaped the scene as we went along.
Ida is marked by compositions
that feature a lot of sky room tall,
empty spaces above the characters. Zal
notes, We eliminated color and camera
moves, so composition and lighting was
all we had left! We wanted to build
essential frames that would have strong
emotional impact and speak about the
space beyond the frame. In the scene
where Ida is waiting in the bus station,
for example, we feel a kind of isolation,
an emptiness, that she is somehow lost
in the frame. This tension in the frame
speaks about the souls of our characters
and their world.
Pawlikowski adds, When you
analyze the framing intellectually, you
Top and middle:
Photoflex
Octodomes light
a close-up of Ida
in bed. Bottom:
The crew
positions a
diffusion frame
to soften the
light for another
bedtime scene.
I wanted to find a
proper contrast
between the
characters and their
environments.
58 May 2014 American Cinematographer
can say its about the missing millions,
or the lack of God, or even the presence
of God and Im pleased to look at it
that way, but it didnt start out like that.
[The framing] wasnt decided intellec-
tually; it just felt right somehow. We
started by asking, How can we make
this format more interesting? And then,
after you do it a few times, you realize
there is something happening that
suggests meaning. At times, it looked
kind of ridiculous, but when youre
halfway through the shoot and youve
been composing like this, you just have
to stick to it. It paid off in the end.
The monochrome imagery
required great finesse in adjusting
contrast, and in modulating the frame
with subtle areas of light and shadow.
Zal reports that he estimated exposure
using the Alexas false-color and Log C
settings. Ida is marked by less contrast in
exteriors than in interiors. The gray
exteriors with gentle contrast, says Zal,
were greatly helped by shooting in the
bleak Polish winter, with its consistently
soft light. The filmmakers avoided what
Divine Purpose
Clockwise from
top: Ida
watches her
aunt leave their
hotel; bare
lightbulbs
enhance the
ambience as
Wanda relaxes
to music in a
nightclub; the
pair grow closer
as they flip
through family
photographs.
www.theasc.com May 2014 59
little sunlight there was, but they some-
times used large HMIs bounced on
large frames on one side of frame, and
large negative fill on the other, to add
some direction to the diffused light.
Zal says he wanted to create
lighting that was very simple and
natural, like the other elements in this
movie. I wanted to find a proper
contrast between the characters and
their environments. He notes that
when he and Pawlikowski felt the image
was too beautiful, they stepped back to
simpler setups.
Zal perceived his frequent reduc-
tion of light in the frame as following
the directors desire to strip down to the
essentials. It was important to subtract
lighting, like Pawel was subtracting
other levels, and create an uncluttered
look. He often used negative fill to
create contrast in the image. With a
chuckle, he admits that his approach
often led to a forest of stands and flags
to cut light from a big soft source and
modulate areas of shadows in the static
frame.
For day interiors, Zal often used
6K and 4K HMI units outside (on tall
stands or cherry pickers), putting them
through 4x4-meter silk butterflies or,
depending on available space, large
frames of Lee 250 diffusion. In the
convent chapel, he added large frames
of black cloth to create a contrast with
these soft sources coming through the
Top: A handsome
saxophone player
(Dawid Ogrodnik)
leads the
nightclubs band.
Middle: A closer
view of the
location shows the
diffused lighting
deployed for the
scene. Bottom: Ida
and the musician
share a moment
outside the club.
A film that works is
like a table with four
even legs: the
structure, acting,
photography and
sound are all equal.
60 May 2014 American Cinematographer
large windows; holes were cut in the
cloth to create spots of light in the
background. For closer shots, he would
usually add a large (200x120-centime-
ter) vertical frame of 250 very close to
the actor. Zal notes that the chapel
setup was inspired by his visit to the
location on a sunny day. The sun was
just amazing that day, so I took some
pictures and copied that [lighting]
when we shot.
While working on convent day
interiors, Zal used diffusion and flags to
lend some texture and differentiation
to the large expanses of flat walls.
Another technique he employed was to
cut holes in black cloth to let spots of
light shine through, as seen in the
convents kitchen, adding a little smoke
to soften the image.
Zal frequently used Dedolight
Octodomes as soft sources for night
interiors. In the convent dining room,
for example, he created three soft pools
of light with Octodomes above the
frame, using the white tablecloth as fill.
For other night interiors, he created
gradations of shadows and vignetting
on the background walls with small
Octodomes suspended above the frame,
as in the scene where Ida stands by the
stove and is transfixed by a young nun
washing herself. To convey the sensual-
ity of the moment, the filmmakers
stoked a big fire in the stove to create
flickering light on Idas face. In a similar
Divine Purpose
Top and bottom
left: Octodomes
bounce fill light
off a white
tablecloth for a
dinner sequence
in the convent.
Bottom right:
Smoke and a
beam of light
aimed through
black cloth
enhance the look
of a scene in the
convents
kitchen.
www.theasc.com May 2014 61
realistic vein, Zal used half a dozen
candles to create authentic candlelight
on Ida as she prays at night.
In the hotel room Wanda and Ida
share, Zal spent time with the produc-
tion designer twisting and turning the
sheer curtains on the window to create a
wispy reflection on the wall from the
HMIs outside.
When Ida goes to a nightclub at
the end of the film, Zal used a couple of
old tungsten Fresnels, one as a backlight
in frame. Those Fresnels were probably
built in the Sixties! he jokes. He added
smoke for atmosphere. For the shot of
Ida entranced by the music, Zal lit her
with a Compact Kino Flo bounced off
polystyrene and further diffused by 250,
adding the two Fresnels in the back-
ground, a Dedolight to rake the wall
behind her, and an Octodome fill on the
side. He balanced the units with a
dimmer, tweaking the effect a bit differ-
ently for every take. I just couldnt help
myself, he chuckles.
Zal recalls that one of the most
difficult scenes was a night exterior on
the last day of the shoot, when Ida
stands in the darkness before a statue
of Christ. We were shooting from
the balcony of the monastery, and we
couldnt use any cherry pickers in that
area, so I decided to shoot it at dusk and
use skylight as a fill. For a side-back-key
light, we created a wall of Grid Cloth
butterflies [2x6x6-meter and 4x4-
meter] about 50 meters from her and
bounced all our HMIs off it, tilting the
fixtures down to match the falling
daylight. Then, the crew quickly moved
to the ground, and we added a frame of
250 diffusion on one side for her close-
up. The whole crew was working extre-
mely fast, and we managed to do it
because of their extraordinary efforts.
During their prep for Ida, the
filmmakers conducted tests at DI
Factory in Warsaw to devise a workflow
that would progress from the color
ArriRaw footage to the final black-and-
white DCP and film print. Technical
director Kamil Rutkowski explains that
he used several tools, including Visual
Basic and Microsoft Excel, to create
Top and middle:
Flags and
diffusion frames
shape the light
for a sequence in
the convents
chapel. Bottom:
On the opposite
side of the
chapel, Zal
positioned large
frames of black
cloth to create
contrast with
the soft sources
coming through
the large
windows.
three custom look-up tables for the
production. For previewing on set, he
created a Rec 709 LUT, which was also
baked into the editing dailies. (Zal
alternated between this LUT and the
Alexas built-in DCI P3 viewing LUT
when checking shots on his monitor.)
After the shoot, the ArriRaw footage
was ingested using Arris ADA-3
deBayering process to create a color file.
The grading was done on a Nucoda
Film Master, and a second custom
LUT, for RGB color space, was applied
to the color file to output a black-and-
white image. The transfer to mono-
chrome was not done until the final
delivery to 35mm and DCP, which
required a LUT for P3 color space. The
full Alexa camera resolution of
2880x2160 was scaled down to
1998x1080 in the DCP. The workflow
Rutkowski devised included a Kodak
Vision 2242 color intermediate printed
onto Kodak Black-and-White Print
Film 2302 with high printing lights.
In the final grade, for which
footage was projected at 2K onto DI
Factorys 26'-wide screen, colorist
Micha Herman worked with the
underlying color levels to adjust the
projected black-and-white image. He
likens his technique to creating virtual
color filters for the monochrome image,
in the same way cinematographers in
the past used color filters to alter black-
and-white 35mm negative. Noting that
Pawlikowski and Zal were both closely
involved in the DI, Herman says the
three of them had spirited discussions
about contrast, often comparing differ-
ent ways of rendering a scene. In the
Divine Purpose
Many of the
compositions in
Ida feature
abundant sky
room.
Pawlikowski
says this
framing was
initially
designed to
maximize the
impact of the
movies 1.33:1
aspect ratio, but
concedes that
the strategy
suggests
meaning to
some viewers.
62
end, the filmmakers opted for an overall
increase in contrast. Pawlikowski recalls,
We had never done a film like this
before, so we were groping, and finally, it
didnt feel dynamic enough, so we put
the contrast back in.
Hermans main focus was the
actors faces, and he sometimes
augmented the underlying greens and
yellows to output a brighter, more
glamorous skin tone that he compares
to silky paper. He also used color keys
to give some exteriors, like the forest,
less solid, smokier blacks. Pawlikowski
and Zal wanted a film look, so Herman
used Nucodas virtual-grain function to
add minute film grain with varying
degrees of opacity. Zal adds that the
grain helped deteriorate a digital
image that was too clean.
Looking back at the 39-day
shoot, Zal is thankful for Pawlikowskis
understanding of the time required for
lighting. When there was a hard scene
for lighting, Pawel never asked me to
work faster; he was always very
patient. His first feature as a director of
photography was a dream come true,
he adds. Pawel was very collaborative,
and the images are a result of this close
collaboration.
A film that works is like a table
with four even legs: the structure,
acting, photography and sound are all
equal, notes Pawlikowski. Therefore,
my work with the cinematographer is
a bit like my work with actors: I try
to establish the rules of the game, and
then I let them join the game and
express themselves. Its all about the
collaboration. With Lukasz, I had the
kind of complicity I had with Ryszard
on previous films, and shooting became
a fun game. Sometimes it was more
me, sometimes it was more Lukasz, but
we were always going in the same
direction.
63
TECHNICAL SPECS
1.33:1
Digital Capture
Arri Alexa
Arri/Zeiss Ultra Prime
64 May 2014 American Cinematographer
Prominent Society members share
spotlight with fellow honorees at
Academys Scientific and
Technical Awards.
By Jay Holben
|
S
hortly after the ASC Awards wrapped in February, the
Society enjoyed another evening of celebration at the
Academy of Motion Picture Arts & Sciences Scientific and
Technical Achievement Awards ceremony, where five
members of the ASC Technology Committee received a
Technical Achievement Award for the creation of the ASC
Color Decision List and ASC member Peter Anderson
received the Gordon E. Sawyer Award, which recognizes an
individual whose technological contributions have brought
credit to the industry. Charles Tad Marburg received the John
A. Bonner Medal of Commendation, which honors outstand-
ing service and dedication in upholding AMPAS standards.
Front row (from left): Actress/co-host Kristen Bell; Peter Anderson, ASC; Charles Tad Marburg; AMPAS President Cheryl Boone Isaacs; Sci-Tech Awards
Committee Chairman Richard Edlund, ASC; and actor/co-host Michael B. Jordan. Second row (from left): Jeremy Selan, Andre Gauthier, Jan Sperling, Etienne
Brandt, Gifford Hooper, Philip George and Robert Lanciault. Third row (from left): Ronald D. Henderson, Dan Piponi, Ian Sachs, Olivier Maury, Tony Postiau,
Emmanuel Prvinaire, Yves Boudreault and Benoit Sevigny. Fourth row (from left): Chris Perry, Peter Huang, Thomas Lokovic, Areito Echevarria, Peter Hillman,
Martin Hill, Nick McKenzie, Jon Allitt and Jim Hourihan. Fifth row (from left): Greg Humphreys, ASC associate Joshua Pines, Colin Doncaster, Janne Kontkanen,
David Cardwell, Csaba Kohegyi, Pat Hanrahan, Tibor Madjar, David Register and Curtis Clark, ASC. Back row (from left): Matt Pharr, Joe Mancewicz, Hans
Rijpkema, Johannes Saam, Chris Cooper, Eric Veach, Andrew Camenisch, Ofer Alon, Florian Kainz, Jeffery Yost, Philip Hubbard, ASC associate Lou Levinson and
ASC associate David Reisner.
ASC Shines at
Sci-Tech Awards
www.theasc.com May 2014 65
P
h
o
t
o
s
b
y
J
o
r
d
a
n
M
u
r
p
h
,
A
a
r
o
n
P
o
o
l
e
,
T
o
d
d
W
a
w
r
y
c
h
u
k
a
n
d
M
i
c
h
a
e
l
Y
a
d
a
,
c
o
u
r
t
e
s
y
o
f
A
M
P
A
S
.
Sharing the Technical
Achievement Award for the ASC
CDL were Curtis Clark, ASC, who
chairs the Societys Technology
Committee; ASC associate members
Lou Levinson, Joshua Pines and
David Reisner; and David Register.
Pines, the vice president of imaging
R&D at Technicolor, accepted the
award with characteristically dry
humor. After apologizing for lacking
the time to thank everyone who
contributed to the ASC CDL, he
pulled out a 5'-long flip card of his
thank-you list. Its an honor to be here
competing at the Winter Olympics for
geeks, he joked. Producing a line of
color-timing punch tape, he explained,
This was the method used for describ-
ing color-correction information in the
fabulous days of film, and cinematogra-
phers lamented no longer having a
similar mechanism to accurately and
repeatedly describe their creative looks
as things went downhill I mean, as
things went digital.
Once the audiences laughter
subsided, Pines continued, So, we
came together under the auspices of the
ASC [and] created the CDL, which
allows cinematographers to have their
creative visions passed from the set to
dailies [and] all the way through post,
including editing, visual effects and final
color correction.
Speaking to AC more recently,
Clark said, The ASC CDL provides a
much-needed, easy-to-use, cross-plat-
form tool for crafting and managing
creative photographic looks that are
initially generated on set by the cine-
matographer and subsequently applied
to dailies, editorial and VFX. Its perva-
sive adoption throughout an array of
digital motion-picture production and
postproduction workflows is evidence
of its intrinsic value.
Noting that the ASC CDL had
also recently received a Prime Time
Emmy Engineering Award, Clark
continued, The Academy Technical
Achievement Award [recognizes] an
accomplishment that could only have
been achieved with the dedication and
enthusiastic support of members of the
ASC Technology Committee, a unique
industry forum that has definitively
reaffirmed the vital role of the ASC [as]
originally envisioned by its 15 founders
in 1919. As we address the impact of
the digital-imaging revolution on cine-
matography, we take our inspiration
from their vision, which provided the
foundation for past decades of ASC
leadership in advancing the art of cine-
matography.
The Gordon E. Sawyer Award
was presented to Peter Anderson, ASC
by his friend and colleague Douglas
Trumbull, the 2011 recipient of the
same prize. I love Peter dearly, and Im
honored to speak at this occasion, said
Trumbull. Peter somehow ended up at
my company [to work on] Steven
Top: Co-hosts Kristen Bell and Michael B. Jordan welcome the audience. Bottom: ASC associate
member Joshua Pines (at podium) makes light of his thank-you list while accepting the Technical
Achievement Award for the ASC CDL on behalf of fellow honorees (from left) Curtis Clark, ASC;
David Reisner; David Register; and Lou Levinson.
66 May 2014 American Cinematographer