In Re: Civil Case for the Recovery of Ownership

of an Unregistered Parcel of Land

FACT CHART
irect !"a#ination
$itness %a#e: !L&!R 'A(O
))) Plaintiff*People ))) efendant* Acc+sed ))) Others
eter#ination of Personal Circ+#stances
,- For the record, please state your name Sir
.- Where do you reside?
/- Please state your age
0- Please state your Civil Status
1- Please state your occupation
To prove that the defendant2s clan was iss+ed
a Certificate of Ancestral o#ain of Title
,- Mr. Witness, may we know what school you graduated?
.- What course did you take?
/- When did you graduate Mr. Witness?
0- Ater graduation, did you immediately search or an employment?
1- And why is it so Mr. Witness?
3- !n what particular course in graduate school Mr. Witness?
4- !n what school have you enrolled or you master"s degree?
5- #ave you completed your master"s degree?
6- When then did you graduate Mr. Witness?
,7- Ater earning your master"s degree, have you sought or an employment?
,,- And were you immediately employed Mr. Witness?
,.- Where then were you employed?
,/- When were employed $y the %ational Commission o !ndigenous People or the %C!P or
$revity?
,0- May we know what your position upon hiring was?
,1- &ut you said that you are the Administrative 'icer o the Community (elineation )eam o
the %C!P, how is that so Mr. Witness?
,3- When were you promoted in the position o Administrative 'icer o the Community
(elineation )eam then Mr. Witness?
,4- &eore we go to the unctions o your oice, may we irst know the unctions o the %ational
Commission o !ndigenous People?
,5- What then are its powers?
,6- %ow we go to your oice Mr. Witness, may we know the unctions o your oice namely the
Community (elineation )eam?
.7- #ow a$out the unctions o your position as the Administrative 'icer o the Community
(elineation )eam then Mr. Witness?
.,- *ou mentioned that one o the %C!P"s powers would $e the issuance o a Certiicate o
Ancestral (omain o )itle or a Certiicate o Ancestral +and )itle, may we know the relationship
o your oice in the issuance o aorementioned titles?
..- For the record, are you stating that the application or the issuance o a Certiicate o
Ancestral (omain o )itle or Certiicate o Ancestral +and )itle shall $e su$mitted to your
oice, which shall $e su$-ected to a review also $y your oice?
./- What is the purpose o the review Mr. Witness?
.0- Who conducts the review Mr. Witness?
.1- #ow do you conduct the review Mr. Witness?
.3- Since you mentioned that you personally conduct the review, then or the record, all
applications or the issuance o CA()"s or CA+)"s shall $e personally reviewed $y you?
.4- )hen do you know the deendant Mr. Witness?
.5- When have you met the deendant Mr. Witness?
.6- #ow are you related to him Mr. Witness?
/7- Who is this !nauna .uang/ey Mr. Witness?
/,- Since the deendant is among the grand children o the applicant !nuana .uang/ey, is the
deendant allowed to in0uire as to the status o the application o his grandmother !nuana .uang/
ey?
/.- When did the applicant !nauna .uang/ey iled their application Mr. Witness?
//- Can you please state to the court the total land area o the community $eing sought or the
issuance o a CA() or a CA+) $y !nauna .unag/ey Mr. Witness?
/0- Can you please state to the court what were su$mitted $y !nauna .uang/ey upon application
Mr. Witness, i you remem$er?
/1- Were the documents su$mitted complete and suicient?
/3- (id you review these documents Mr. Witness?
/4- When was the review conducted, i you remem$er?
/5- Ater the review, what happens ne1t regarding the application Mr. Witness?
/6- What is the purpose or the su$mission o the application with the supporting documents to
the (2%3?
07- What were the indings o the (2%3 regarding the community o !nauna .uang/ey Mr.
Witness?
0,- 4pon the inding that the land or the community is appropriate or titling, what happens ne1t
Mr. Witness?
0.- What is this Work and Financial Plan Mr. Witness?
0/- What are the contents o these Work and Financial Plan?
00- Who issues this Work and Financial Plan Mr. Witness?
01- Was the community o deendant, led $y !nanua .uang/ey given these Work and Financial
Plan?
03- When was it given, i you remem$er?
04- Ater the issuance o a Work and Financial Plan, what happens to the application Mr.
Witness?
05- What is this %otice o (elineation Activities Mr. Witness?
06- )o whom are these %otices sent to Mr. Witness?
17- Who issue these %otices Mr. Witness?
1,- Were the notices sent with regards to the application o deendant"s grandmother !nuana
.uang/ey?
1.- When were the notices sent, i you remem$er?
1/- What is re0uired to happen ne1t ater the issuance o the %otices Mr. Witness?
10- #ow is the validation o the +ist o 2lders or 3epresentatives done Mr. Witness?
11- Where should this +ist i 2lders or representatives $e $ased rom Mr. Witness?
13- Who conducts the validation o the +ist o 2lders or 3epresentatives Mr. Witness?
14- With regards to the application o deendant"s grandmother, did the latter su$mit the +ist o
2lders or 3epresentatives?
15- Was the validation conducted Mr. Witness?
16- When was the validation conducted, i you remem$er?
37- May we know who these 2lders or 3epresentatives are?
3,- Were they positively validated to $e the same 2lders or 3epresentatives included in the +ist
which was su$mitted $y the deendant"s grandmother?
3.- Ater the validation, what happens ne1t to the application Mr. Witness?
3/- Who conducts the 'cular !nspection Witness?
30- What is the purpose o the 'cular !nspection?
31- Was an 'cular !nspection conducted in the community o the deendant Mr. Witness?
33- When was the 'cular !nspection conducted, i you remem$er?
34- Ater the 'cular !nspection, what happens ne1t to the application Mr. Witness?
35- What is this Social Preparation Accomplishment 3eport?
36- Who prepares the Social Accomplishment 3eport Mr. Witness?
47- With regard to the application o the deendant"s grandmother, was the Social
Accomplishment 3eport in their avor su$mitted to the 3egional 3eview &ody?
4,- When was the report su$mitted to the 3egional 3eview &ody, i you remem$er?
4.- What does the 3egional 3eview &ody empowered to do on every application or the issuance
o a CA() or a CA+)?
4/- What happens when the 3egional 3eview &ody would issue a Work 'rder?
40- What happens however o the 3egional 3eview &ody would issue a Survey 'rder?
41- With respect to the community o the deendant, what was issued in their avor $y the
3egional 3eview &oard?
43- What happens ne1t Mr. Witness?
44- Who issues the Survey Plan Mr. Witness?
45- With respect to the community o the deendant, was a Survey Plan issued $y the (irector o
the Ancestral (omains 'ice?
46- When was it issued, i you remem$er?
57- Ater the issuance o a Survey Plan, what is re0uired ne1t or purposes o titling?
5,- Ater the Survey Plan has $een endorsed to your oice, what transpires ne1t Mr. Witness?
5.- What is the purpose o showing the Survey Plan to the applicant Mr. Witness?
5/- Was the survey Plan regarding the community o the deendant shown to !nauna .uang/ey
and the other elders?
50- What is re0uired to transpire ne1t Mr. Witness?
51- Who causes the pu$lication o the application or the issuance o CA() or CA+) Mr.
Witness?
53- With regards to the deendant"s community, what particular title was $eing applied or $y the
deedant"s grandmother, !nauna .uang/ey?
54- When was !nauna .uang/ey"s application pu$lished, i you remem$er?
55- !n what newspaper was the application o !nanua .uang/ey pu$lished, i you remem$er?
56- Ater the pu$lication, what transpires ne1t Mr. Witness?
67- Who conducts these deli$erations Mr. Witness?
6,- #ow are the deli$erations conducted $y the Commissioners o the %C!P?
6.- With regards to the deendant"s community, were deli$erations conducted $y the
Commissioners?
6/- When was it conducted, i you remem$er?
60- What happens i the Commissioners o the %C!P came out with an unavora$le decision Mr.
Witness?
61- #ow a$out i a avora$le decision was decided $y the Commissioners, what happens ne1t?
63- ! it was a avora$le decision, what does the Ancestral (omains 'ice do ne1t?
64- With regards to the community o the deendant, what was the decision o the
Commissioners o the %C!P?
65- Since a avora$le decision came up, when was the decision endorsed to the Ancestral
(omains 'ice, i you remem$er?
66- When was the Certiicate o Ancestral (omain o )itle prepared $y the Ancestral (omains
'ice, i you remem$er?
,77- Ater the preparation $y the Ancestral (omains 'ice o the CA() or CA+), what
transpires ne1t Mr. Witness?
,7,- With regards to the deendant"s community, when was the CA() signed $y the
Commissioners o the %C!P, i you remem$er?